what we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · what we learn from the dead:...

27
What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer # , Claudia A. Szentiks*, Guido Fritsch , Oliver Krone*, Ines Lesniak*, Kristin Mühldorfer*, Gudrun Wibbelt*, Gabriela Galateanu , Anne Berger # , Christian C. Voigt # , Sven Kühlmann # , Thomas B. Hildebrandt , Alex D. Greenwood* * Department of Wildlife Diseases, Department of Reproduction Management, # Department of Evolutionary Ecology Leibniz Institute for Zoo & Wildlife Research (IZW) Berlin, Germany; www.izw-berlin.de

Upload: others

Post on 17-Feb-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

What we learn f rom t he dead: post -mort em wolf research and monit oring in Germany

Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szent iks*, Guido Frit sch‡, Ol iver

Krone*, Ines Lesniak*, Krist in Mühldorfer*, Gudrun Wibbelt *,

Gabriela Galat eanu‡, Anne Berger#, Christ ian C. Voigt #, Sven

Kühlmann#, Thomas B. Hildebrandt ‡, Alex D. Greenwood*

* Depart ment of Wildl i fe Diseases, ‡ Depart ment of Reproduct ion Management , # Depart ment of Evolut ionary Ecology

Leibniz Inst it ut e for Zoo & Wildl i fe Research (IZW)

Berl in, Germany; www. izw-berl in.de

Page 2: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Underst and: Int erdiscipl inary research on evolut ionary adapt at ions of

wildl i fe and it s l imit s, part icularly diseases, and t he relat ionship

bet ween wildl i fe and it s habit at and environment

Mission of t he IZW

Improve: cont ribut e t o t he scient if ic basis of biological conservat ion

in order t o assist t he prot ect ion of t hreat ened wildl i fe

To underst and and – where appropriat e – improve t he

adapt abil i t y of wildl i fe t o (ant hropogenic) global change

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW © B. Wachter, IZW

Page 3: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Research on wolf healt h & causes of deat h

Init iat ed a research & monit oring programme on healt h of German

wolves

Post mor t em invest igat ions since 1999

Collect evidence for forensic invest igat ion

Wide range of diagnost ic met hods

Programme combines bot h invasive and non-invasive met hods

o virology o bacteriology o electron microscopy o toxicology

o computed tomography o necropsy o histology o parasitology

o stable isotope ecology o morphology

Page 4: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Healt h monit oring of wolves: aims

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Cause of death

Car accidents Natural causes Illegal killing

Page 5: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Healt h monit oring of wolves: aims

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Cause of death

assessment of health and condition

Body condition, nutritional state Infectious diseases (viruses, bacteria…) Parasite load Environmental pollutants

Car accidents Natural causes Illegal killing

Page 6: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Healt h monit oring of wolves: aims

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Cause of death

assessment of health and condition

Body condition, nutritional state Infectious diseases (viruses, bacteria…) Parasite load Environmental pollutants

Stable isotope analysis

Geographical origin Diet over a longer period

Car accidents Natural causes Illegal killing

Page 7: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

assessment of health and condition

Body condition, nutritional state Infectious diseases (viruses, bacteria…) Parasite load Environmental pollutants

stable isotope analysis

Geographical origin Diet over a longer period

cause of death

development of diagnostics

Fast morphological separation of wolves from domestic dogs

Healt h monit oring of wolves: aims

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Car accidents Natural causes Illegal killing

Page 8: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

1. Del ivery of / col lect ing wolf bodies

From f reshly dead t o rot t en t o bones and bit s of skelet on

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW © C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 9: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

1. Del ivery of / col lect ing wolf bodies

2. Comput ed t omography

First assessment

Locat ion of bul let (f ragment s)

Fract ures

Unusual sof t t issue present at ion

Bone densit y

From f reshly dead t o rot t en t o bones and bit s of skelet on

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

© G. Fritsch, IZW

Page 10: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

3. Necropsy / dissection

Ident it y: sex, age (cat egory), body measurement s, body mass

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 11: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Ext ernal examinat ion

Document at ion and col lect ion of forensic evidence and t races

o f ibres

o car paint part icles

o ent ry point s of bul let s

o DNA

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

3. Necropsy / dissection

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 12: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Collect ion (and ident if icat ion) of ect o-parasit es

♀ Ixodes r icinus ♂ Dermacent or

ret iculat us

♂ Chaet opsyl la

t r ichosa

Lipopt ena

cervi

© J. Steinberg, IZW © J. Steinberg, IZW © J. Steinberg,

IZW © J. Steinberg, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

3. Necropsy / dissection

Page 13: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Dissect ion

Int ernal examinat ion

Ext ract ion of organs

diagnost ics

Ext ract ion & col lect ion of proj ect i les

Ext ract ion of samples

shot pel let s

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

3. Necropsy / dissection

bul let

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 14: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

histology bacteriology virology parasitology toxicology electron microscopy stable isotope analysis

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

4. Lab processing

Page 15: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Infect ious disease diagnost ics

o Parvovirus

o Coronavirus

o Canine Dist emper Virus

o Canines Adenovirus-1 (HCC)

o Rabies Virus

o Pseudorabies Virus (AK)

o Polyomaviruses

o Herpesviruses

o Brucel la

o Francisel la t ularensis

o Lept ospira

o Int est inal parasit es

o Tr ichinel la

o Dirof i lar ia

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Process

4. Lab processing

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 16: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Current ly 103 dead wolves

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 17: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Causes of deat h: t raf f ic accident s

Bite wounds

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

area of lost skin

due t o t raf f ic

accident

Page 18: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Causes of deat h: nat ural causes

Natural causes

o Fights (wolves wild boar)

o Canine distemper

o septicaemia

o Mange & starvation

(cachexia)

Bite wounds

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s Purulent myocardit is

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 19: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

© G. Frisch, IZW

Projectile particles

© C.A. Szentiks,

IZW

© C.A. Szentiks,

IZW © C.A.

Szentiks, IZW

Causes of deat h: i l legal ki l l ing

© C.A. Szentiks,

IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 20: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Result s: cause of deat h

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 21: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Cause of death vs health status

Cause of death

Underlying diseases

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 22: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Det ect ed diseases / infect ions which were not fat al

o Canine dist emper virus infect ion

Enamel hypoplasia © C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 23: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Det ect ed diseases / infect ions which were not fat al

• Mange

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 24: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Det ect ed diseases / infect ions which were not fat al

o Infection with trichinae, Echinococcus multilocularis, other endoparasites such as Sarcocystis, helminths, protozoans

Sarcosporidiosis

H&E

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

t ape worms

© C.A. Szentiks, IZW

Page 25: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Not det ect ed

o Rabies

o Pseudo rabies

o Parvovirosis

o Hepat it is cont agiosa canis

Healt h monit oring of wolves: Result s

Page 26: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

Most wolves are healthy: few have underlying diseases

Most die from encountering people (traffic accidents; illegal killing)

Research into and monitoring of health should be intensified

o Identify potential wolf-driven risks of infections in wildlife & domestic animals

o Risk of zoonotic infection for humans

o Exposure to environmental toxins

An intensification of health research and monitoring of German wolves

o would address concerns of various stakeholder groups

o would contribute to a German and central European integrated

conservation management plan

o would assist in preparing responses if health issues arise

Research on healt h of wolves: summary

Page 27: What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and ... · What we learn from the dead: post-mortem wolf research and monitoring in Germany Heribert Hofer#, Claudia A. Szentiks*,

© M.L. East, IZW