what is dbi-tlc? why implement dbi? collab 2017/dbi inte… · – adkins & gavin, 2012; ennis...

8
2/16/17 Lembke, 2016 1 Data-Based Instruction for Beginning Writers: Tools, Learning, and Collaborative Support Erica Lembke, Kim Moore, Alex Smith, Erica Mason, Sara Eldred, Carol Garman University of Missouri [email protected] dbitlc.missouri.edu/ DBI Team University of Missouri: Carol Garman, Kim Moore, Abby Carlisle, Apryl Poch, Alex Smith, Erica M ason University of Minnesota: Kristen McMaster, Dana Brandes, Pyung-Gang Jung, Mike Herriges, Jaehyun Shin, Kyle Wagner DBI-TLC is a $1.5 million Professional Development Grant funded by the InsHtute for EducaHon Sciences, US Department of EducaHon Acknowledgements What is DBI-TLC? DBI = Data-Based Instruc0on TLC = Tools, Learning, and Collabora0ve Support Development ac0vi0es/partnerships with 2 school districts To support teachers’ use of Data-Based decision making (DBI) To improve outcomes for students, focusing on early wri0ng development Why Implement DBI? Some students do not respond to research- based intervenHons. These students require more intensive, individualized instrucHon. DBI provides a framework to individualize instrucHon. When teachers use DBI correctly, student achievement can improve. Why WriHng? Proficient wriHng is essenHal to learning in school and to later vocaHonal success. Learning to write is criHcal to Overall literacy development Students’ ability to communicate what they know IntegraHng knowledge and thinking criHcally InstrucHonal Strategies supported by Research Picture Word Prompt Sentence InstrucHon & Frequency Building Datchuk, Kubina, & Mason, 2015 Self-Regulated Strategy Development Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 Expressive WriHng Program White et al, 2014 Self-Monitoring Carr & Punzo, 1993; Mooney et al., 2005 *Hier & McCurdy, 2016 (NASP PresentaHon)

Upload: others

Post on 22-Aug-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 1

Data-BasedInstructionforBeginningWriters:Tools,Learning,andCollaborativeSupport

EricaLembke,KimMoore,AlexSmith,EricaMason,SaraEldred,CarolGarman

[email protected]

dbitlc.missouri.edu/

• DBITeam– UniversityofMissouri:

• CarolGarman,KimMoore,AbbyCarlisle,AprylPoch,AlexSmith,Erica Mason

– UniversityofMinnesota:• Kristen McMaster, DanaBrandes,Pyung-GangJung,MikeHerriges, JaehyunShin,KyleWagner

• DBI-TLCisa$1.5millionProfessionalDevelopmentGrantfundedby theInsHtuteforEducaHonSciences,USDepartmentofEducaHon

Acknowledgements

WhatisDBI-TLC?

• DBI=Data-BasedInstruc0on• TLC=Tools,Learning,andCollabora0veSupport

• Developmentac0vi0es/partnershipswith2schooldistricts

• Tosupportteachers’useofData-Baseddecisionmaking(DBI)

• Toimproveoutcomesforstudents,focusingonearlywri0ngdevelopment

WhyImplementDBI?

• Somestudentsdonotrespondtoresearch-basedintervenHons.

• Thesestudentsrequiremoreintensive,individualizedinstrucHon.

• DBIprovidesaframeworktoindividualizeinstrucHon.

• WhenteachersuseDBIcorrectly,studentachievementcanimprove.

WhyWriHng?

• ProficientwriHngisessenHaltolearninginschoolandtolatervocaHonalsuccess.

• LearningtowriteiscriHcalto– Overallliteracydevelopment– Students’abilitytocommunicatewhattheyknow– IntegraHngknowledgeandthinkingcriHcally

InstrucHonalStrategiessupportedbyResearch

• PictureWordPromptSentenceInstrucHon&FrequencyBuilding– Datchuk,Kubina,&Mason,2015

• Self-RegulatedStrategyDevelopment– Adkins&Gavin,2012;Ennisetal.,2013,2015;Laneetal.,2008;Masonetal.,2008,2013

• ExpressiveWriHngProgram– Whiteetal,2014

• Self-Monitoring– Carr&Punzo,1993;Mooneyetal.,2005*Hier&McCurdy,2016(NASPPresentaHon)

Page 2: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 2

Andthat’swhereDBIcomesin!

• Inthisproject,weprovide– Toolsforassessingyoungwriters’performanceandprogress

– ToolsforprovidingearlywriHngintervenHon– AprocessforsystemaHcdecision-makingtoindividualizeinstrucHonforstrugglingwriters

WhatComponentsofWriHngareAddressedwithDBI?

• Textgenera*on– Turningideasintotext(words,

sentences,passages)– IncludesideageneraHon,word

choice,content,textstructure,genre

TextGenera0on

Transcrip0on

ConstrainedbyAJenKonandMemory

SelfRegula0on

SimpleViewofWriHng

• Transcrip*on– TranslaHngsounds,words,

sentences,andpassagesintoprint– IncludeshandwriHngortyping,

spelling,andmechanics

• Self-regula*on– WhatwritersdotomeettheirwriHng

goals– Includesgoalsehng,planning,

organizing,self-monitoring,self-evaluaHng,revising,andself-rewarding

EightStepsofDBI ObjecHves

• Inthissession,youwilllearnto:– Selectresearch-basedwriHngintervenHonsbasedonastudent’sindividualneeds

– DevelopabasicWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)– IncorporateaddiHonalskill-basedmini-lessonsintoyourinstrucHonasneeded

Step3:ImplementHigh-QualityInstruc0on

a.  Identify research-based instructional methods (see Writing Intervention Toolkit)

b.  Determine amount ofwriting instruction

c.  Develop a Writing Instructional Plan

d.  Implement the intervention withfidelity

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

• IdenHfyresearch-basedinstrucHonalmethodstoimplementbasedonstudentstrengthsandneeds.– DeterminethefocusandcontentofinstrucHon– SeeSelecKngResearch-BasedWriKngIntervenKonsintheWriHngIntervenHonToolkit.

Page 3: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 3

PurposeoftheDiagnosKcChecklist

• TohelpteachersselectwriHngintervenHonsthat:– Arebasedonsoundresearch,– AddressspecificwriHngdifficulHes,and– AlignwithcriHcallanguageandwriHngstandards

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

WriHngComponents

• ThediagnosKcchecklistisorganizedaroundthesethreecomponents.– TranscripHon– TextGeneraHon– SelfRegulaHon

TextGenera0on

Transcrip0on

ConstrainedbyAJenKonandMemory

SelfRegula0on

SimpleViewofWriHng

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

RevisiHngMolly’sCase

Mollyisathird-gradestudentwhoreceivesspecialeducaHonservicesfocusedonwrikenlanguage,includingreadingandwrikenexpression.ShewasidenHfiedforspecialeducaHonattheendofhersecond-gradeyear.HerIEPteamdeterminedshewouldreceivedailysmall-groupinstrucHoninreadingandwriHngbythespecialeducaHonteacher,Mrs.Lewis.

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

QuesHonstoConsider

• Thinkabout:– ThewriHngprocess(whathappensduringwriHng)– ThewriHngproduct(theresultofwriHng)

• UsethediagnosHcchecklistto– IdenHfystudentstrengthsandweaknesses– SelectanintervenHonthatmatchesthestudent’sneed

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

SampleFromTable OneofMolly’sCBMBaselinePrompts

ˆ ˆˆ ˆˆ ˆ ˆ

ˆ

ˆ ˆˆ

ˆˆ ˆ

ˆ

Page 4: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 4

HandwriHng:DoesMolly…

?aaa

aaa

So, Molly appears to have relative strengths in handwriting.

Spelling:DoesMolly…

X

?

a?

?

X

aa

So, Molly appears to have a mix of strengths and weaknesses in spelling, but I need to know more…

WemightwanttogathersomemoreinformaHon…

• CollectaddiHonalsamples• UseDiagnosHcTools– SamplesareinGooglefolder– YoumayhaveotherdiagnosHctoolsyouliketouse

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

DiagnosHcExample:WordsTheirWaySpellingInventory

TextGeneraHon:DoesMolly…

Xa

?

(kind of)

X

?

So, Molly appears to have a mix of strengths and weaknesses in text generation, but I need to know more…

WemightwanttogathersomemoreinformaHon…

• CollectaddiHonalsamples• UseDiagnosHcTools

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

Page 5: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 5

DiagnosHcExample:BeginningWritersConHnuum(from6+1Traits)

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

HowdoesMrs.Lewisdecidewhattodo?

• ArerconsideringMolly’sstrengthsandweaknesses,shedecidestofocusherinstrucHonon– Spellingwordswithlongvowelsandconsonantblends

– SentenceconstrucHon(usingcapsandpunctuaHon)

– Sentencecombining(tomakemorecomplexsentences)

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

MatchinganIntervenHontoStudent’sNeeds

Step3a:IdenHfyResearch-BasedInstrucHonalMethods

Summary:Step3a

• TheSelecKngResearch-BasedIntervenKonstoolisdesignedtohelpteachersselectwriHngintervenHonsthat:– Arebasedonsoundresearch,– AddressspecificwriHngdifficulHes,and– AlignwithcriHcallanguageandwriHngstandards

• ThisshouldhelpyouselectintervenHonsthathaveevidenceofefficacywithbeginningwriters.

Applyit!

• UseyourSelecHngResearch-BasedIntervenHonstooltoconsideryourstudent’sstrengthsandneedsintheareasof:– TranscripHon– TextGeneraHon– SelfRegulaHon

• UsethecheckliststoconsiderbothProcessandProduct

• WillyouneedtoadministeraddiHonaldiagnosHcmeasures?

Step3b:DetermineAmountofWriHngInstrucHon

• Determinetheamount(duraHonandfrequency)ofwriHnginstrucHon.– Forexample,youmaydecidetoimplementtheintervenHon3Kmesperweekfor30min.

–Whenpossible,useguidelinesfromresearchtodeterminetheamount.

Page 6: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 6

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

• DevelopWIPbasedonyourselectedinstrucHonalapproaches.BasicWIPtemplates– Skill-BasedMini-lessons

WriHngInstrucHonalPlans(WIPs)

• WriHngInstrucHonPlansaretemplatesthatcanassistyouwithdevelopingaplanfordeliveringandmodifyingwriHnginstrucHonbasedonyourstudent’sneeds.

• ProvideflexibleopHonsfordesigningwriHnginstrucHon

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

WriHngInstrucHonalPlans(WIPs)

• WIPsaredesignedto:– ProvideflexibleopHonsfordesigningwriHnginstrucHon

– Beadjustedforindividualstrengthsandneeds(e.g.,transcripHon,textgeneraHon,etc.)

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

OpHon1:BasicWIPTemplate

ModelingGuidedprac*cewithcorrec*vefeedbackIndependentprac*ce

BasicWIPTemplate Skill-BasedMini-Lessons

• Skill-basedminilessonswerecreatedtoprovideteacherswithefficientandeasytoimplementwriHnglessonsdrawnfromresearch-basedintervenHons.

• Theminilessonscanbe:– DeliveredontheirownforstudentswithspecificwriHngdeficits

– Insertedintoastudent’sWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

Page 7: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 7

Skill-BasedMini-Lessons

• Mini-lessonshavebeendevelopedfor:– TranscripHon– TextGeneraHon

• Forlessonsfocusingonself-regulaHon,usePowerfulWriKngStrategies(Harrisetal.,2008)

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

Mini-LessonQuickSheet• TranscripHon

– TR1:PhonicsWarm-Up– TR2:AlphabetPracHce– TR3:WordBuilding– TR4:WordyStudy– TR5:AlphabetRockets– TR6:WordSort

• TextGeneraHon– TG1.1-1.3:Sentence

ConstrucHon– TG2:SentenceCombining– TG3:WriHngGoals– TG4:RepeatedWriHng

• TranscripHon+TextGeneraHon– TRTG1:WriHngPrompt

SampleTranscripHonMini-Lesson SampleTextGeneraHonMini-Lesson

SampleTextGeneraHonMini-Lesson(conHnued) Self-RegulaHonLessons

• Goalsehng• Self-instrucHons• Self-monitoring• Self-reinforcement• TeacherevaluaHon

Page 8: What is DBI-TLC? Why Implement DBI? Collab 2017/DBI inte… · – Adkins & Gavin, 2012; Ennis et al., 2013, 2015; Lane et al., 2008; Mason et al., 2008, 2013 • Expressive Wring

2/16/17

Lembke,2016 8

IllustraHon:TranscripHonLesson

• Examplelesson--starringDanaandIsaac!– AlphabetPracHce–WordBuilding–WordStudy

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

Yourthoughts…

• WhatdoyouthinkoftheinstrucHon?• Whatevidencedidyouseeofmodeling,guidedpracHcewithcorrecHvefeedback?

• When/howmightindependentpracHceeventuallycomein?

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

PauseandPonder

• HowcouldyouuseaWIPwithyourstudent?–Whenwouldablanktemplatebeuseful?–Whenwouldafilled-intemplatebeuseful?–WhatelsemightyouneedtomakeaWIPtemplateworkforyou?

Step3c:DevelopaWriHngInstrucHonalPlan(WIP)

Step3d:ImplementwithFidelity

• ImplementthecorecomponentsoftheintervenHonwithfidelity(asprescribedbythedevelopers),basedonguidelinesfromresearch.

• WhyisitimportanttoimplementtheintervenHonwithfidelity?

üforUnderstandingDBIStep3–ImplementHigh

QualityInstrucHona.  Identify research-based instructional methods

(see Writing Intervention Toolkit)b.  Determine amount of writing instructionc.  Develop a Writing Instructional Pland.  Implement the intervention with fidelity

To discuss—Which area is most difficult? Least difficult?

Nextsteps…

• Visithkp://dbitlc.missouri.edu/formoreinformaHon

• UsethediagnosHcchecklistforoneormoreofyourstudents

• MatchtointervenHon• ArermatchingtointervenHon,ifyou’dlikemoreinformaHononminilessons,contactErica([email protected])