water saving measures of using the groasis waterboxx in organic gardening in desert regions

Upload: u8x58

Post on 01-Jun-2018

247 views

Category:

Documents


6 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    1/22

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx©

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques

    Final report

    Diego Schiavon, student number #7937

     Potential adoption of water-saving measures by members

    of the cooperative

    This report has been prepared by Diego Schiavon for the management

    board of the La Primavera agricultural cooperative.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    2/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page i

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Copyright and Disclaimer Notice

    AquaPro, Groasis and waterboxx are registeredtrademarks of AquaPro BV.

    All pictures and illustrations of the Groasis

    waterboxx shown in this report are subject to

    the copyright and usage restrictions of

    AquaPro BV.

    The La Primavera logo is a registered

    trademark of Cooperativa Agricola La

    Primavera Scarl.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    3/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page i i

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Executive summary

    This report presents the Groasis waterboxx and can be used by the members of the management board to

    form an opinion about the device. It consists of ten sections, covering the history of the device, its

    components and usage, some suggestions about the installation, the available test results and a concluding

    evaluation

    The first three sections present the historical background of the waterboxx from the prototype stage to the

     present, a physical description of the device and a general explanation of the principles used to design it.

    Drawings of the device and graphical illustrations of its usage are included as well.

    The fourth section lists the single components of the device and their function, and provides some

    graphical illustration of how the waterboxx is to be assembled. The fifth section expands on the previous

    one, lists the different steps necessary to install a waterboxx, provides some brief suggestions about

     planting materials and strategies, and concludes with instructions about removing the device.

    Section 6 describes the data collection techniques and experiment designs to be used when testing the

    waterboxx, with some practical suggestions about the experiment setup. Section 7 lists some of the

    species used in the past for test purposes, and the countries where these tests have taken place. The

    evidence gathered from the tests is briefly evaluated in section 8.

    Section 9 evaluates the compatibility with organic regulations, both at a national and supernational level,

    and concludes that the waterboxx is most likely to be suitable for organic farming, although the

    cooperative technical service and the certifying agency should be contacted to confirm this.

    Finally, a general evaluation and a recommendation is presented in the conclusion.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    4/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page i i i

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Table of contents

    Introduction

    1 About the waterboxx

    2 A short description

    3 Waterboxx: the concept4 The components

    5 Using the waterboxx

    5.1 Soil preparation

    5.2 Orientation

    5.3 Laying the paperboard

    5.4 Planting the seedlings

    5.5 Placing the water tank 

    5.6 Mounting the waterboxx

    5.7 Final preparations

    5.8 Removing the waterboxx

    6 Logging procedure

    7 Experiments

    8 Test results

    9 Suitability for organic farming

    10 Conclusion

    References

    Addenda

    Item I: International Groasis waterboxx plantings 2010/2011

    Item II: the AquaPro pricelist

    1

    2

    3

    45

    6

    6

    6

    6

    7

    7

    7

    7

    8

    9

    10

    10

    11

    12

    13

    I

    II

    IV

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    5/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 1

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    This report has been requested by the management board to establish whether the cooperative should use

    the waterboxx©, a device to farm without irrigation. The wateboxx has recently received media attention

    as a device that makes it possible to farm marginal, arid lands: this is of importance in the light of

    increased competition on the market and lower food prices.

    The present report is a collection of available information about the Groasis waterboxx, its history,

    components, usage and applications. The members of the management board should use this report to

    form an opinion about the product. An assessment of this product is provided in the concluding section.

    As described in the report, the waterboxx is a device that could prove useful on the chalk- and sulphate-

    rich fields of our Southern members, as well as improve water drainage on our peach, apple and pear

    fields in the North. However too few test results have been published, and therefore it is the

    recommendation of this report that this product should not be used until more data become available.

    The Cooperative could discuss the possibility of carrying out their own tests with the support of theTechnical Service.

    Introduction

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    6/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 2

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Pieter Hoff (1953) is a

    Dutch inventor and

     businessman. He has a

    wide agronomical

     background,

    accumulated while

    running his family

    nursery garden. In

    2003 he decided to

    sell his company and

    focus on developing a

    strategy to fight

    desertification. In the

     prologue to his 2008 book "CO2, a gift from

    heaven", he writes that he was motivated byfrustration at the pitiful state of the Italian

    Apennines around Naples, once lush with

    vegetation and now abandoned to erosion1.

    The Groasis waterboxx is the result of his

    research, culminated in 2004 with a prototype: a

    round, donut-shaped plastic box with a 20-inch

    radius; once filled with water, it sequestrates more

    water from the atmosphere in the form of

    condense and drips it down to the seedlings planted in its middle. It allows plants to grow

    under extremely harsh conditions on desert soils

    and even rocks.

    Mr. Hoff extensively tested his invention on arid

    soils, first in his native Holland, and then in the

    Moroccan Sahara, in Zaragoza (Spain) and

    California (USA). The testing phase lasted four

    years, from 2005 until 2010, and resulted in

    improvements on the prototype design. Further

    testing was conducted starting in 2010 in Spain,

    Morocco, Kenya and California. In total, over

    15,000 waterboxxes with trees will have been

    tested in 20 research and demonstration areas2.

    The test in Morocco was conducted with the

    support of the University of Oujda, Morocco. The

    results are presented on Mr. Hoff's company

    website, www.groasis.com. He claims that after

    four years, 88,2% of the trees planted with a

    waterboxx were in good condition, with 11,8%alive but "weak". Of the control group, consisting

    of trees irrigated weekly but without the

    waterboxx, 89,5% died, and 10,5% were alive and

    in good condition3. Mr. Hoff also claims that

     plants survive once the waterboxx is removed4.

    The waterboxx project attracted media attention

    ever since the testing phase: the first articles in the

    national press appeared in 20075 and the invention

    was soon mentioned in newspapers in the English-

    speaking world and beyond. In 2008, the

    waterboxx was awarded the prestigious Dutch

    BètaDragon Award and 10,000EUR 6. Finally, in

     November 2010 the American magazine Popular

    Science awarded it the 2010 Grand Award of

    Green Tech and the Overall Award of Popular

    Science7. Petrus Hoff was invited to present hisinvention at the PopTech 2010 conference in

    Camden, Maine. The appearance in Popular

    Science greatly increased the popularity of the

    waterboxx.

    The project also attracted public funding: the

    Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, the Dutch

    Province of Brabant and the EU EFRO-

    Programme OP Zuid 2007-2013 contributed part

    of the money to make the latest innovations possible8.

    The Groasis waterboxx is the means to a much

    more grandiose end: stopping climate warming

    and feeding the world not through government

    regulation, but by planting trees on marginal, non-

     productive lands. Mr. Hoff's views are laid out in

    his 2008 book, "CO2: a gift from heaven", where

    he calls for a global effort to reafforest 2 billion ha

    worldwide9.

    1 About the Groasis waterboxx

    Fig. 1 Petrus (Pieter) Hoff, inventorof the Groasis waterboxx.

    Fig. 2 A waterboxx installed on arid soil in Oman

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    7/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 3

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    The waterboxx is a circular water tank made of

     plastic with a radius and height of 25 cm. It is

    covered by a corrugated plastic sheet slanting

    inwards towards the center, where a tubular

    opening allows for the planting of one or two

    seedlings. The sheet covers a circular tank to be

    filled with water.

    Along the tubular

    opening are two

    small pipes: the

     plastic sheet is

    supposed to

    sequestrate water

    from the atmospherein the form of

    condense, which

    then slides towards

    the central tubular

    opening and reaches the water tank through the

    small pipes.

    The tubular opening can accomodate one, two or

    three plants, depending on the model. The model

    with a double opening is more recent, and arosefrom the need to reduce the economical damage if

    the only plant dies. AquaPro, the company

     producing the waterboxx, recommends to cut the

    smaller of the two plants.

    On the bottom of the water tank there is a wick,

    whose purpose is to drip small quantities of water

    into the soil; the waterboxx can also be installed

    without the overflow pipe.

    Optionally, the device can be provided with two

    wind protectors to anchor it to the soil and prevent

    it from being blown away by strong winds. Two

    nails are necessary for each anchoring pin.

    The waterboxx is available in polypropylene or in

    a biodegradable product called Ecopur: the former

    can be re-used several times, while the latter is to

     be used only once and then left to decompose,

     particularly in remote regions and extremely poorsoils.

    2 A short description

    Fig. 3 A drawing of the waterboxxas shown on the AquaPro website.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    8/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 4

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    The waterboxx is a work of bio-mimicry: an

    imitation of how nature works. Mr. Hoff observed

    that while humans cultivate by plowing the soil,

    under natural conditions the seeds are first

    dispersed (for example by animals) and then

    germinate directly in the topsoil, i.e. the top ~10cm

    soil layer. Plowing destroys the capillary canals

     present in the soil, but in nature they stay intact and

    help retain the humidity necessary for the seed to

    germinate.

    Zoochory, or seed transportation by animals,

     provides another lesson on how to protect a

    growing seedling: a seed ingested by an animal and

    then excreted with the feces can use the water andnutrients in the feces to grow. The feces also

     prevent evaporation and keep the water stored in

    the subsoil capillary canals.

    Finally, many plants survive in extremely arid

    conditions by absorbing morning dew and

    occasional fog, like Tillandsia spp. and some

    lichens and pine seedlings10.

    The waterboxx design takes the points above intoaccount: the seed is sown on the topsoil without

    damaging the subsoil capillaries, and the

    waterboxx is put on top of it. The waterboxx,

     basically a round hollow plastic tank, prevents

    water evaporation just like animal feces do in

    nature; finally, the water tank creates a temperature

    differential that causes water vapour condensation.

    The waterboxx tank, filled with water, will staycooler in the morning when the outside air

    temperature starts to rise. The difference between

    the lower inside temperature and the higher outside

    temperature causes the atmospheric water vapor to

    condense on the outside cover of the waterboxx.

    From there, it drips through internal tubes to the

    inside water tank and is then conveyed to the

    underneath soil by means of a wick. The system is

    able to collect rainwater in a similar way.

    The waterboxx has the advantage of stabilizing soil

    temperature: the water present in the tank and the

    water regularly dripped into the soil can buffer

    temperature fluctuations because of water's high

    specific heat capacity, i.e. the high amount of

    energy necessary to alter water temperature. Mr.

    Hoff claims the soil temperature below thewaterboxx is about 25°C11. This is a very important

    feature for a product to be used in desert areas,

    where daily temperature excursion can run in the

    dozens of Celsius degrees and plants may not be

    able to survive.

    Temperature regulation is not limited to the soil,

     but extends to the plant micro-climate as well. The

    young plants are surrounded by the waterboxx

    water tank: the inside water absorbs heat during the

    day and releases it during the night, stabilizing air

    temperature around the plant. And as long as the

     plant is smaller than the waterboxx height, it is

     protected from strong and dry winds as well.

    By completely surrounding the plants, the

    waterboxx also has the advantage of preventing

    weed growth and of protecting the plant from

    damage by rodents12. Labor costs for weeding are

    also reduced.

    3 Waterboxx: the concept

    Fig. 4 The wick drips approximately of 50 ml per day in the soilunder the waterboxx.

    Fig. 5 The primary root reaches water 2 meters underground.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    9/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 5

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    The waterboxx consists of seven different

    components:

    Water tank: the water

    tank is the main body of

    the device. It is circular

    or elliptical in shape and

    delimited by 25cm-high

    edges. In the center, a

    tubular duct opens to

    uncover a small portion

    of the underlying ground. The mid-plate and the

    cover sheet can be secured to the tank structure.

    Additionally, two openings at the bottom of the

    tank can accommodate the wind protectors, and ahole can accommodate the wick;

    Wick: the wick is a cotton

     pipe of 25cm of length. It

    must be inserted in the

    hole at the bottom of the

    water tank, with about half

    the length inside the tank

    and half outside. It drips

    water collected in the tankfrom the atmosphere into

    the underlying soil;

    Mid-plate: the mid plate is a plastic disc slightly

    smaller in radius than the water tank. It has an 8-

    shaped hole allowing for the central opening in the

    waterboxx, and a further hole to let water inside

    from the top opening in the cover sheet. The mid-

     plate needs to be secured

    to the water tank. It

    separates the water from

    the outside air: the shaft is

    cooler than the outside in

    the morning, and causes

    water vapor condensation

    on the plastic cover sheet;

    Cover sheet:  the cover sheet is a corrugated,

    round plastic sheet that slopes inwards towards the

    center at an angle of 45 degrees. It has an 8-shaped

    opening in the middle, a simple compass shape foreasier orientation, two smaller holes to secure the

    siphons and a round hole from which water can be

    added to the tank. The corrugation pattern allows

    the condense droplets to easily flow downwards

    towards the siphons,

    from where they reach

    the tank and, through the

    wick, ultimately the

    ground. The cover sheet

    also doubles as a

    growing surface for

    climbing plants like

    tomatoes or pumpkins;

    Wind protectors: the wind protectors are small

     plastic plaques shaped like the AquaPro logo (see

    Fig. 5 and 8). The can be clicked into place at the bottom of the water tank and need to be nailed into

    the ground to prevent wind damage. They are

    optional and need to be ordered separately.

    Alternatively, some rocks or heavy material can be

    used to hold down the water tank;

    Siphons: the siphons are two small pipes to be

    inserted next to the central opening on the cover

    sheet. They gather the water from the cover sheet

    and convey it to the underlying tank;

    Cap: this is is a round plastic

    cap sealing the water tank and

    the whole waterboxx. When

    open, water can be poured into

    the inside. Otherwise it should

    always be kept closed to

     prevent evaporation.

    Additionally, the installation set consists of a

    paperboard to be laid on top of the seedlings (see

    Fig. 11 on the following page). This is the first

     protection against evaporation and can have one,

    two or three holes, depending on the number of

    seedlings to be used per box.

    4 The components

    Fig. 5 The water tank, the main body of the waterboxx.

    Fig. 6 The cotton wick at the bottom of the tank.

    Fig. 7 The mid plate mountedon the tank.

    Fig. 8 The cover sheet mountedon top of the mid-plate.

    Fig. 9 The cap and thesiphons.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    10/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 6

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    A number of variables have to be taken into

    account while designing a waterboxx installation,

    such as climate, temperature, rainfall, soil or

    growing medium, wind and sun exposure.

    Installing the waterboxx requires the following

    steps:

    It is crucial that the waterboxx is levelled

    horizontally and to guarantee efficient collection of

    the condensed water. The underlying soil must be

    horizontal as well and free from rubble. Aquapro

    suggests to dig a hole with a diameter of 60 cm and

    a depth of maximum 10 cm; the dug up earth will be used later on in the installation to protect the

    waterboxx from the wind blowing underneath the

    water tank.

    Some rocky terrains have developed no soil at all,

    or what there is is too hard for water to penetrate,

    as in the case of a hardpan developing on top of

    limestone soils. In these cases digging a hole can

     prove hard or impossible, and Mr. Hoff suggests to

    use a capillary drill instead.

    A capillary drill is an automatically balanced drill

    that can be connected to a tractor lift. It can drill a

    horizontally levelled, 60cm-diameter hole within

    30 seconds. The capillary drill can break through

    the hardpan but still leave the subsoil capillary

    canals intact. Initially developed in the mining

    industry, it has been adapted by Mr. Hoff for

    agriculture. It is still at a prototype stage and can

     be rented from AquaPro at a fee. Note that thiscould indeed prove useful on the hard Apulian clay

    soils.

    The use of the capillary drill has the added

    advantage of requiring little manpower in areas

    where providing for workers is hard or impossible,

    like deserts and remote regions. Finally, the drill

    allows to exactly calculate the time and cost of

     preparing the soil, thus making budgets more

    consistent.

    The waterboxx has an 8-shaped central opening

    where two small trees can be sown or planted. It is

    important that the two plants receive the most

    sunlight when it is least damaging, i.e. in the

    morning and evening, and the least during theafternoon heat. Care must be given to installing the

    device with the holes in a East-West direction: a

    compass shape on the cover sheet helps

    determining North and South.

    AquaPro supplies paperboard sheets with one, two

    or three holes. As explained above, the paperboard

    is a first barrier against evaporation and covers that part of the soil not directly supporting the water

    tank.

    The paperboard should be laid on top of the

     planting soil with the holes oriented in a East-West

    direction; the holes in the paper should be used as

    marker for the planting holes, to be dug with with a

    small shovel or a hollow awl. The hole depth

    depends on the plant species: ideal planting depth

    is usually 2-3 times the seed size13.

    Fig. 10 The capillary drill mounted on a tractor.

    5 Using the waterboxx

    5.1 Soil preparation

    5.2 Orientation

    5.3 Laying the paperboard

    Fig. 11 A three-hole paperboard on top ofgerminating seed.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    11/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 7

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Mr. Hoff recommends using water-soaked seed for

     planting because it gives the highest planting

    results. Alternatively, he recommends to have

    young plants bred especially for the planting,

    although he admits that the resulting primary rootswill be weaker. He recommends not to transplant

    the young trees in order not to hurt the primary

    roots in the process14.

    The twinboxx variant of the waterboxx allows for

    two or three plants. A number of strategies can be

    used, for example growing a small fruit tree as

    cash crop and a taller hardwood tree as a longer-

    term investment, or two trees of the same species

    of which only the strongest will be kept, or twocereal plants, or again just one climbing plant and a

    support15.

    Before placing the waterboxx on the soil, the wick

    and the wind protectors must be put in place. The

    wick should be inserted in the apposite hole on the

     bottom of the water tank: about half of the cotton

    should stay on the inside, and half on the outside.

    The wind protectors are optional and need to be

    ordered separately; they can be clicked into place

    on the bottom of the water tank.

    The water tank should be placed so that the central

    tubular openings correspond to the holes in the

     paperboard. One should make sure not to damagethe plants, seeds or other planting materials while

     placing the water tank.

    If wind-protectors are in use, they need to be nailed

    into the soil once the water tank is in place. Special

    nails are delivered together with the wind

     protectors. If no wind-protectors are in use, it is

    suggested to put a weight of about 3kg, for

    example stones, in the water tank.

    The isolation plate, or mid-plate, needs to be put in

     place on top of the water tank. The cover sheet

    must be placed immediately on top of the mid-

     plate: it will click into place along the edges of the

    water tank. Both the mid-plate and the cover sheet

    have an 8-shaped opening that will fit exactly on

    top of the similarly shaped relief on the water tank.

    The earth that was first removed when preparing

    the soil should now be added around the bottom of

    the waterboxx to prevent evaporation and the wind

    from blowing underneath the box.

    Once the soil is in place, enough water should be

    added to fill up the water tank (about 16 liters) and

    4 more liters should be poured through the central

    opening onto the ground.

    The final pieces still need to be mounted: the blue

    siphons need to be pushed into the apposite

    openings and clicked in the correct position, and

    the water tank needs to be sealed with the cap.

    A layer of about 3 cm of soil should be added to

    the ground through the central opening for further protection against wind, animals, and evaporation.

    Fig. 12 The bottom of a waterboxx with a mounted wick, ready to be put on top of two seedlings.

    Fig. 13 The blue siphons are to be inserted in the apposite slots.

    5.4 Planting the seedlings

    5.5 Placing the water tank 

    5.6 Mounting the waterboxx

    5.7 Final preparations

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    12/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 8

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    After about one year the plant primary roots should

    have grown deep enough to reach the underground

    water and have become strong enough to survive

    without the help of the waterboxx. This stage

     becomes evident when the trees exhibit a stronggrowth phase. When this happens, the

     polypropylene waterboxx can be removed and used

    for a new planting. Note that AquaPro claims that a

     polypropylene model can be re-used 10-20 times:

    in order to get an idea of the average cost per

     planting, a pricelist is included at Item II of the

    Addenda.

    The soil now laying bare should be protected with

    a layer of paperboard, sand, cloth or hay to preventexcessive evaporation and curb weed growth.

    If the model used has a double opening for two or

    three plants, and more than one plant has suvived,

    this is also the time to cut the weakest of the plants

    and leave the fittest to grow.

    In case the biodegradable, "Ecopur" model is in

    use, there is no need to remove the waterboxx, and

    usually this was not the intention in the first place:

    the device can be left where it is. It will protect the

    trees for longer, decompose and release its

    nutrients in the environment. The decayed

    waterboxx will increase the soil nutrient content.

    5.8 Removing the waterboxx

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    13/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 9

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    AquaPro encourages individuals and institutions to

    experiment with the waterboxx and make their

    results public. To this end, a section of the website

    is dedicated to collecting information and making

    it accessible to third parties. Registered users can

    submit their data to the AquaPro database.

    In order to make results comparable, AquaPro

    recommends a standard procedure to gather

    results. Next to information about place, local

    climate conditions, soil quality and species, data

    can be entered about temperature and relative

    humidity.

    In particular, AquaPro recommends to use twoelectronic loggers, one to be exposed to the outside

    air but not to sunlight, for example under a roof,

    and one inside the water tank. The logged data can

    then be uploaded to the website at the address

    http://testform.groasis.com/. Additionally, a soil

    thermometer can be used to log soil temperature.

    Standardized climate information is to be retrieved

    from the National Climatic Data Center website

    (http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/ncdc.html).AquaPro recommends using the Lascar Easylog

    EL-USB-2-LCD logger. A very detailed procedure

    is available on the company website15.

    AquaPro requires a control group of 2-10 saplingsof Cupressus sempervirens  (cypress), wherever in

    the world the planting is taking place.

    6 Logging procedure

    Fig. 14 One of the loggers needs to be inside the waterboxx.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    14/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 10

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    The Groasis website claims that the waterboxx has

     been tested in the United States, the Netherlands,

    Morocco, Spain, France and Kenya. The range of

    species is quite large, ranging from fruits and

    vegetables plants like grapes (Vitis vinifera) and

    squash (Cucurbita pepo), to hardwood species like

    holly (Quercus ilex), bushes and bio-fuel plants

    ( Jatropha spp.).

    AquaPro claims that some of the tested plants have

    medicinal properties: Warburgia ugandensis is

    supposed to cure malaria and  Moringa oleifera is

    supposed to cure AIDS16. However, the

    AgroForestry Tree Database puts these claims17,18 

    into question, and a study by the German GTZquestions  Jatropha's value as a bio-fuel crop19. A

    full list of the species used in 2010/2011 can be

    found in the Addenda at the end of the report.

    The initial tests took place in the Moroccan Sahara

    with the support of Mohammed I University of

    Oujda, Morocco. Plantings have also occurred at

    US vineries in Napa Valley and Sonoma Valley, at

    the Californian Preserve Dos Palmas, Preserve

    Pipes Canyon and Preserve Whitewater, in West-

    Sahara with the cooperation of the University of

    Agadir, and in seven Spanish provinces with the

    cooperation of the University of Valladolid20. The

    website does not specify which provinces.

    The waterboxx was used for landscaping and

    urban landscaping purposes at the Port of Sohar in

    Oman and for regreening purposes at sites owned

     by the Union Minera del Norte, a Spanish coal

    mining company. Further plantings are mentioned

    in Ecuador, Mongolia and India, but the website

    does not expand on these claims21.

    7 Experiments

    The weakest point in the Groasis waterboxx

     project is the lack or peer-reviewed evidence and

     publicly accessible data. Very little detail is

     provided about experiment design and results.

    Whatever results are available are of dubious

    significance: for example, regarding the planting

    for Minera del Norte, Mr. Hoff claims that

    "although Spain had one of its hottest summers in

    2010 the planting experiment showed a result of

    over 95% success ratio"22, with no further

    elaboration.

     No research papers are quoted, and none can be

    found on the JSTOR and IngentaConnect academic

    databases. A search with Google Scholar only

    returns an invitation to test the product.

    The site page dedicated to research turns out to be

     just a commercial for the device23, just like the

     pages supposedly reporting the experiment

    results24. The web page where growth data can be

    logged is only accessible for registered users, and

    all it shows are pictures of "successful" plantings.

    The company left unanswered my emails asking

    for more information.

    While AquaPro is a commercial venture and

    understandably needs to promote its product, the

    lack of presented evidence is a major weakness.

    8 Test results

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    15/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 11

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    9 Suitability for organic farming

    There are no reasons to believe that the adoption of

    the waterboxx would in any way breach the EU

    Regulation 2092/9125, the most important

    regulation in organic farming. If outside inputs are

    kept within the parameters given in the Regulation

    Annexes, no problem should arise. However the

    Technical Service should be contacted, if

    necessary, to confirm this.

     National regulations can be stricter than the

    European one. In particular, the Bio Austria

    General Standard26, the Bio Suisse Standard27  and

    the UK Soil Association Organic Standards28 place

    restrictions on hydroponics and other soil-less

    techniques. While the waterboxx clearly uses soil,similar techniques like bottle-irrigation are

    assimilated to hydroponics: the Technical Service

    should clarify whether this would somehow breach

    national regulations.

    An article from the Dutch magazine

    Groenten&Fruit Actueel shows an organic farmer

    using the waterboxx in a greenhouse29, so we could

    conclude that using the device does not breach

    organic regulations. However the article raises

    more questions: no dew can develop at the almost

    constant temperatures inside a greenhouse, so one

    has to wonder about the added value of the

    waterboxx.

    If the Council is to decide to proceed with our own

    field tests, our certification organization ICEA

    should be contacted for clarifications as well.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    16/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 12

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Mr. Hoff's invention seems to be quite promising: many of our eroding fields in Southern Italy could

     benefit from it, and it could be an improvement over gravitational irrigation for our fruit fields in the

     North. Members planning to upgrade their watering systems to sprinklers or drip-irrigators could combine

    those systems with the waterboxx. The cooperative members could certainly benefit from reduced

    irrigation costs and improved soil quality. However the waterboxx cannot be recommended for extended

    usage at the present stage: too little test results are available.

    Among the good sides of the product are the sound understanding of root growth and the thorough

    troubleshooting and design improvements over the years. Positive reviews in the press and by prize

    committees are encouraging, and the product does not violate any EU and national organic standards,

    although the Technical Service could be contacted for further clarifications on this point.

    What really is missing are peer-reviewed test results and references from the academic and agronomical

    community; without those, the waterboxx should not be introduced. The cooperative should instead wait

    for more conclusive research or carry out its own tests.

    10 Conclusion

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    17/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 13

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    References

    1 Hoff, P. (2009) CO2 , a gift from heaven. 2nd ed. Eburon, Delft, the Netherlands.2-4 AquaPro Holland (2007) AquaPro Project Presentation [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 13 September 2011].

    5 AquaPro Holland (2007) Press Presentation [online] Available at: [[Accessed 16 September 2011].6 Eburon Academic Publishers (2010) Eburon-Auteur wint prestigieuze BètaDragons prijs [online]

    Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

    19 Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ) GmbH (2009) Jatropha Reality Check ,

    GTZ – Regional Energy Advisory Platform (East Africa), Nairobi.

    7 Popular Science (2010) The best of what's new 2010 Grand Awards [online] Available at:

    [Accesses 16 September 2011].8 AquaPro Holland (2010) Technology / Stimulus [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].9 Hoff, P. (2009) CO2 , a gift from heaven (p. 82). 2nd ed. Eburon, Delft, the Netherlands.10 J. L. Andrade Dew deposition on epiphytic bromeliad leaves: an important event in a Mexican tropicaldry deciduous forest , Journal of Tropical Ecology (2003), 19: 479-488.11-12 AquaPro Holland (2010) Technology / Principle [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

    14 AquaPro Holland (2010) Technology / Planting materials [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011]

    17 AgroForestry Tree Database, Warburgia ugandensis [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

    16 AquaPro Holland (2011) International Groasis waterboxx plantings 2010/2011 [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

    15 AquaPro Holland (2010) Manual [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

    13 "Sowing." Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation [online] Available at

    [Accessed September 16 2011].

    18 AgroForestry Tree Database, Moringa oleifera [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

    20 AquaPro Holland (2011) Advanced overview of plantings [online] Available at

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].21 AquaPro Holland (2011) Press / Photo library [online] Available at

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].22 AquaPro Holland (2011) Experience in gravel in Oman and mine spills in Spain [online] Available at

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].23 AquaPro Holland (2011) Technology / Research [online] Available at

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].24 AquaPro Holland (2011) Experimental results [online] Available at

    [Accessed 16 September 2011].

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    18/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page 14

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    28 Soil Association (2011), Soil Association organic standards for producers, revision 16.4 June 2011

    [online] Available at:

    [Accessed 20

    September 2011].

    27 Bio Suisse (2011) Bio Suisse Standards, Edition of 1.1.2011 [online] Available at: [Accessed September 20 2011].

    26 Bio Austria Verein zur Förderung des Biologischen Landbaus

    (2010), Produktionsrichtlinien Fassung September 2010 [online]

    Available at:

    [Accessed 20 September 2011].

    25  Regulation (EC) 2007/834 of 28 June 2007 on organic production and labelling of organic products

    and repealing Regulation (EEC) No 2092/91, OJ L 189, p. 1 of 20.7.2007.

    29 Visser, P. (2011, September 6) Tomaten plukken in woestijnbestendige teelt. Groenten&Fruit

     ACTUEEL, p. 19.

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    19/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page I

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Addenda

    Item 1: International Groasis waterboxx plantings 2010/2011

    Item 2: the AquaPro pricelist

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    20/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page I I

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    UNITED STATES

    Whitewater (High Desert), Mission Springs

    (Low Desert), Dos Palmas (Salton Sea), CA

    Honey Mesquite -- Prosopis glandulosa

    Screwbean Mesquite -- Prosopis pubescens

    Blue Paloverde -- Parkinsonia florida

    Sugarbush – Rhus ovata

    Velvet Ash – Fraxinus velutina

    California Sycamore – Platanus racemosa

    Holly Leaf Cherry - Prunus ilicifolia

    Wishbone Bush - Mirabilis bigelovii

    Cheesebush - Hymenoclea salsola

    Paperbag Bush - Salazaria mexicanaBeargrass - Nolina parryi

    Joshua Tree - Yucca brevifolia

    Apricot Mallow - Sphaeralcea ambigua

    California-Napa,Sonoma:

    Vines

    Chardonnay – Vitis vinifera

    Zinfandel – Vitis vinifera

    Vegetable

    Squash – Cucurbita pepo

    HOLLAND

    English Oak - Quercus robur 

    Irish Yew - Taxus baccata aurea fastigiata

    MOROCCO

    Argan - Argania spinosa

    SPAIN

    Stone Pine - Pinus pineaMaritime Pine - Pinus pinaster

    Portuguese Oak - Faginea

    Almond - Almendra

    Hawthorn - majuelo

    Poplar - alamo

    Holly Oak - Quercus ilex

    Pine - Pinus spp.

    Cherry - Cerezos

    Juniper - Juniperus spp.

    Scots Pine - Pino silvestreSessile Oak - Roble albar

    Birch - Petrea abedal

    FRANCE

    Maple - Acer monspessulanum

    Boxwood - Buxus serpervirens

    Mastic - Pinus halepensisEvergreen - Pistacier lentiscus

    Mahaleb cherry - Prunus mahaleb

    Laurestine - Viburnum tinus

    KENYA

    Plant resources:

    Biodiesel - Jatropha spp.

     Neem tree - Azadirachta indica

    Prostrate - Prunus africana

    AIDS - Moringa oleiferaMalaria - Warbugia ugandensis

    Acacia species:

    tortilis

    mellifera

    hockii

     seyal 

     xonthophloea

    Trees with timber value:

    Menu oak - Vitex keniensis

    Elegon teak - Olea welwitschii

    African cedar - Junipera procera

    Fruits - climbers and runners:

    Strawberry- Fragaria virginiana

    Passion fruit - Passiflora edulis

    Fruits - trees:

    Orange - Citrus sinesis

    Mango - Fera indicaLemon - Citrus limon

    Pawpaw - Papaya crica

    Avocado - Persea americana

    Oil plants

    Palm oil - Elaeis guineensis

    Rape - Brassica napus 

    Soya - Glycine max

    Date palm - Phoenix dactylifera 

    Item I: International Groasis waterboxx plantings 2010/2011

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    21/22

    ISTC 01 Technical Communication Techniques - Diego Schiavon, #7937 Page I I I

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Vegetables

    Carrots - Daucus carota

    Cabbage - Brassica oleracea

    Tomatoes - Solanum spp.Radish - Raphanus sativus

    Legumes

    Beans - Phaseolus spp. 

    Black beans - Lablab albus

    International Groasis waterboxx plantings 2010/2011 (continued)

  • 8/9/2019 Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in Desert Regions

    22/22

    Report: the Groasis waterboxx

    Item II: the AquaPro pricelist