water10.1007/s11356... · web viewelectronic supplementary material title: spatial and temporal...
TRANSCRIPT
Electronic Supplementary Material
Title: Spatial and temporal trends of metals and arsenic in German freshwater compartments
Journal: Environmental Science and Pollution Research (ESPR)
Authors: Annette Fliedner*, Heinz Rüdel, Burkhard Knopf, Karlheinz Weinfurtner, Martin Paulus, Mathias Ricking, Jan Koschorreck
* Fraunhofer Institute for Molecular Biology and Applied Ecology (Fraunhofer IME), 57392 Schmallenberg, [email protected]
Table S1: Metals and arsenic in suspended particulate matter from the German ESB sampling sites, sampling period: 2005 – 2009 (exceptions: Danube: 2009; Saar: 2006-2009). Concentrations are given as µg/g dry weight. The highest mean value of every element is written in bold letters.
Water Sampling site
Value Arsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel Zinc
Danube D1UIm
Range 6.96 25.38 0.54 148.7 36.68 26.52 171.0Median 6.96 25.38 0.54 148.7 36.68 26.52 171.0Mean n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.SD n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.
D2Kelheim
Range 9.01 23.37 0.34 222.0 41.20 28.13 180.3Median 9.01 23.37 0.34 222.0 41.20 28.13 180.3Mean n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.SD n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.
D3Jochenstein
Range 11.74 19.77 0.25 133.7 37.68 35.88 112.5Median 11.74 19.77 0.25 133.7 37.68 35.88 112.5Mean n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.SD n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.
Elbe E1Prossen
Range 23.48- 38.58 68.05-113.3 1.66-3.06 790.0-1580 69.28-124.0 33.48-69.50 388.0-633.0Median 24.60 71.18 1.90 918.7 82.62 43.82 444.5Mean 27.38 81.05 2.06 1100 89.88 46.71 464.6SD 6.38 18.98 0.57 327.5 21.39 13.54 98.26
E2Zehren
Range 16.67-31.12 33.92-84.80 1.34-6.51 212.8-1039 29.22-87.32 15.65-59.50 229.5-773.8Median 25.15 56.53 3.36 649.7 67.82 35.52 588.5Mean 24.69 61.08 3.81 665.0 62.21 37.13 539.9SD 6.37 19.75 1.90 314.2 21.80 15.61 203.1
E3Barby
Range 14.82-27.95 93.50-122.5 3.12-4.90 1725-2850 80.50-101.3 33.78-45.88 725.5-1075Median 18.36 104.5 3.35 2065 86.67 36.32 867.0Mean 20.80 106.1 3.79 2099 87.90 38.24 863.1SD 5.48 12.38 0.82 455.6 8.02 4.93 135.2
E4Cumlosen
Range 20.30-24.68 49.87-71.85 2.38-8.63 1418-1925 62.12-81.05 19.62-32.92 441.8-640.2Median 20.72 62.23 3.62 1512 66.26 28.94 584.4Mean 22.09 62.15 4.39 1578 68.35 28.05 548.6SD 2.13 8.17 2.44 201.3 7.59 5.38 87.13
Table S1 (cont.): Metals and arsenic in suspended particulate matter from the German ESB sampling sites, sampling period: 2005 – 2009 (exceptions: Danube: 2009; Saar: 2006-2009). Concentrations are given as µg/g dry weight. The highest mean value of every element is written in bold letters.
Water Sampling site
Value Arsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel Zinc
Elbe E5Blankenese
Range 17.65-20.15 39.82-52.60 0.24-5.49 785.2-996.5 40.92-49.80 22.13-27.33 244.3-341.5Median 19.45 44.00 1.47 929.0 42.00 23.35 290.3Mean 19.26 45.77 2.10 903.1 44.01 24.47 297.3SD 0.97 5.29 1.99 80.06 3.68 2.60 43.44
Mulde MUDessau
Range 91.48-111.5 125.8-150.5 9.13-12.33 956.0-1393 61.03-73.72 51.52-82.45 391.5-1043Median 106.3 137.0 10.21 1258 65.45 69.93 739.2Mean 101.9 138.5 10.61 1205 66.09 68.87 760.3SD 9.42 9.56 1.37 186.5 5.13 13.32 265.4
Saale SAWettin
Range 11.60-19.13 66.82-90.97 0.63-10.05 2078-4095 76.78-105.0 42.43-62.08 457.0-712.7Median 12.83 77.63 2.81 2342 86.03 53.88 555.3Mean 14.04 78.02 3.74 2674 89.58 53.13 563.1SD 3.02 8.67 3.65 812.0 11.21 7.18 106.9
Rhine R1Weil
Range 6.70-8.33 19.23-25.48 0.09-0.35 84.07-169.5 28.37-33.07 19.07-28.93 90.75-112.7Median 7.56 24.82 0.16 158.3 31.00 25.08 95.52Mean 7.45 23.37 0.19 135.7 30.81 24.31 98.87SD 0.61 2.59 0.10 39.49 2.24 3.95 8.41
R2Iffezheim
Range 8.07-9.66 24.13-29.03 0.23-0.45 212.7-275.5 40.10-45.37 24.17-34.00 120.3-133.8Median 9.15 28.53 0.29 243.8 42.53 33.30 129.5Mean 9.01 27.35 0.31 243.0 42.73 30.53 127.3SD 0.61 2.18 0.08 24.29 2.02 4.45 5.53
R3Koblenz
Range 7.80-9.63 22.10-29.72 0.19-0.48 199.8-258.3 30.87-38.83 19.52-28.92 117.2-153.0Median 7.99 24.80 0.25 210.7 35.13 22.55 139.0Mean 8.42 25.21 0.29 219.4 35.46 23.76 136.8SD 0.79 2.85 0.11 22.66 3.32 3.58 12.98
R4Bimmen
Range 11.70-12.45 47.05-57.33 0.67-1.70 353.5-552.0 46.47-59.10 26.98-37.15 281.0-588.5Median 11.97 51.12 0.85 391.5 52.95 35.33 284.8Mean 12.04 51.45 0.96 413.4 52.43 33.71 344.1SD 0.35 3.81 0.43 79.05 4.69 4.22 136.6
Table S1 (cont.): Metals and arsenic in suspended particulate matter from the German ESB sampling sites, sampling period: 2005 – 2009 (exceptions: Danube: 2009; Saar: 2006-2009). Concentrations are given as µg/g dry weight. The highest mean value of every element is written in bold letters.
Water Sampling site
Value Arsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel Zinc
Saar S1Güdingen
Range 8.78-11.97 43.15-58.78 0.72-1.21 163.2-313.2 49.35-68.33 26.75-35.47 284.3-391.5Median 10.49 51.24 0.86 167.4 51.74 33.22 365.8Mean 10.43 51.10 0.91 202.8 55.29 32.16 351.9SD 1.34 6.41 0.21 73.62 8.80 4.09 47.22
S2Rehlingen
Range 13.58-17.47 54.27-69.22 0.89-1.79 228.3-278.8 69.98-89.38 38.25-47.32 390.2-636.5Median 14.28 66.54 1.10 253.5 70.66 43.77 529.9Mean 14.90 64.14 1.22 253.5 75.17 43.28 521.6SD 1.74 6.72 0.42 20.64 9.48 4.65 101.6
n.d. not determined
Table S2: Metals and arsenic in zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha) from the German ESB sampling sites. Concentrations are given as µg/g dry weight except for mercury (ng/g)
Water Sampling site and period
Value Arsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel
µg/g dw µg/g dw µg/g dw ng/g dw µg/g dw µg/g dwLake Belau B
Lake Belau1997-2009
Range 6.20-7.81 0.10-0.53 0.18-0.56 32.57-76.50 8.59-21.90 6.32-18.97Median 6.66 0.20 0.28 43.02 11.78 11.00Mean 6.99 0.26 0.33 49.74 13.84 11.67SD 0.60 0.18 0.14 16.37 5.07 3.96
Danube D1UIm2003-2009
Range 2.56-3.62 0.45-0.86 0.61-0.88 37.72-60.68 12.67-18.93 7.36-17.70Median 2.90 0.80 0.72 53.78 17.04 14.05Mean 3.03 0.71 0.74 51.69 16.49 13.23SD 0.35 0.17 0.10 7.73 2.12 3.34
D2Kelheim2004-2009
Range 3.06-5.11 0.90-1.61 0.21-0.53 51.82-122.0 17.25-43.97 11.54-29.10Median 3.96 1.14 0.34 102.0 27.08 19.19Mean 3.99 1.18 0.36 92.36 28.44 19.42SD 0.67 0.28 0.12 30.51 9.93 6.14
D3Jochenstein2004-2009
Range 5.71-7.46 2.52-4.08 1.02-1.27 107.0-125.0 18.00-51.75 37.68-54.18Median 6.59 2.60 1.15 113.2 25.48 43.20Mean 6.63 2.92 1.15 114.6 29.34 45.64SD 0.66 0.66 0.11 7.86 12.96 7.67
Table S2 (cont): Metals and arsenic in zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha) from the German ESB sampling sites. Concentrations are given as µg/g dry weight except for mercury (ng/g)
Water Sampling site and period
Value Arsenicµg/g dw
Leadµg/g dw
Cadmiumµg/g dw
Mercuryng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Nickelµg/g dw
Elbe E1Prossen1999-2009
Range 4.40-7.66 2.37-4.98 0.44-1.18 80.23-216.2 13.47-20.28 18.73-28.82Median 6.17 3.40 0.61 120.7 16.60 22.60Mean 6.00 3.55 0.74 140.4 16.36 23.29SD 0.84 0.93 0.28 46.01 2.00 3.68
E2Zehren2000-2009
Range 2.79-5.87 2.02-13.98 0.52-6.40 150.7-271.7 11.80-24.75 5.44-22.45Median 4.59 4.43 0.87 215.8 19.30 12.48Mean 4.58 6.12 1.72 215.2 18.77 12.67SD 1.03 4.13 1.94 38.22 3.38 4.72
E3Barby1998-2009
Range 3.67-6.58 0.78-9.91 0.34-1.00 114.3-335.5 9.41-19.50 8.50-18.92Median 5.61 2.43 0.60 220.7 14.24 14.21Mean 5.57 2.93 0.56 204.0 14.25 14.50SD 0.90 2.40 0.19 70.33 2.49 3.10
E4Cumlosen1998-2009
Range 3.81-6.70 0.99-4.32 0.39-2.07 114.8-314.5 13.27-17.73 8.86-23.05Median 5.95 1.91 0.77 146.3 15.35 17.83Mean 5.56 2.12 0.93 164.1 15.41 17.10SD 1.00 0.94 0.48 59.28 1.38 4.61
E5Blankenese1995-2009
Range 7.04-12.78 2.25-5.26 0.92-2.36 163.6-328.6 19.08-33.07 14.90-42.57Median 9.42 3.79 1.13 244.0 27.20 25.86Mean 9.58 3.82 1.24 246.5 26.79 27.34SD 1.78 0.97 0.40 48.0 4.90 8.60
Table S2 (cont.): Metals and arsenic in zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha) from the German ESB sampling sites. Concentrations are given as µg/g dry weight except for mercury (ng/g)
Water Sampling site and period
Value Arsenicµg/g dw
Leadµg/g dw
Cadmiumµg/g dw
Mercuryng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Nickelµg/g dw
Rhine R1Weil1995-2009
Range 3.09-5.32 0.93-3.46 0.82-1.37 61.67-186.8 18.26-31.97 18.55-37.63Median 4.08 2.08 0.90 156.7 21.83 29.11Mean 4.13 2.12 0.98 140.5 24.11 28.17SD 0.82 1.08 0.20 47.32 5.67 6.58
R2Iffezheim1995-2009
Range 5.52-7.91 1.59-4.06 0.81-2.00 93.85-203.8 21.09-33.58 21.78-63.58Median 6.63 3.36 1.28 148.0 28.63 43.13Mean 6.67 3.00 1.34 148.1 27.98 42.90SD 0.98 1.27 0.57 46.51 5.46 22.10
R3Koblenz1995-2009
Range 3.73-6.13 1.77-6.36 0.66-2.12 54.82-155.8 18.87-42.30 10.02-37.51Median 4.70 3.19 1.00 88.37 27.35 20.66Mean 4.73 3.56 1.16 95.71 26.84 22.24SD 0.86 1.81 0.50 35.15 7.11 9.63
R4Bimmen1995-2009
Range 4.43-7.70 3.25-10.89 1.38-2.91 67.04-197.0 24.17-41.55 17.08-37.38Median 5.28 5.19 2.14 132.7 32.48 25.04Mean 5.46 6.08 2.14 140.2 31.08 27.38SD 0.99 2.72 0.46 36.23 5.75 6.75
Saar S1Güdingen1994-2009
Range 2.25-4.26 1.39-4.64 0.43-1.40 39.74-99.03 16.32-37.18 12.98-33.18Median 2.98 3.03 0.68 65.35 20.30 17.51Mean 2.98 3.13 0.81 69.69 21.43 19.07SD 0.66 0.99 0.31 17.30 5.22 6.28
S2Rehlingen1994-2009
Range 2.24-5.69 2.53-6.44 0.32-0.85 34.56-196.4 19.23-29.36 18.00-32.48Median 3.29 3.32 0.44 57.16 23.36 22.60Mean 3.48 3.63 0.49 70.68 23.25 22.84SD 0.88 1.06 0.17 42.55 3.08 3.97
Table S3: Metals and arsenic in muscle and liver of bream (Abramis brama) from the German ESB sampling sites.
Water Sampling site and period
Value Bream muscle Bream liverArsenicµg/g dw
Leadng/g dw
Mercuryng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Leadng/g dw
Cadmiumng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Zincµg/g dw
Lake Belau
B-Lake BelauMuscle: 1997-2011Liver:2003-2009
Range 0.11-0.67 0.50-53.58 106.0-225.8 0.98-1.48 42.26-131.8 113.3-364.5 59.56-128.2 118.3-179.2Median 0.19 28.20 153.78 1.25 46.53 155.8 81.38 124.3Mean 0.24 27.64 156.17 1.23 66.78 197.4 87.62 136.5SD 0.18 22.13 41.30 0.16 43.45 114.0 29.14 28.98
Danube D1- UImMuscle:2004-2011Liver:2004-2010
Range 0.26-0.47 5.13-27.05 322.2-529.5 1.08-1.40 37.08-80.28 228.7-538.0 52.03-104.8 113.2-157.0Median 0.32 16.88 435.4 1.23 62.50 271.3 90.38 132.5Mean 0.34 16.91 447.5 1.24 61.62 321.0 82.48 133.7SD 0.08 7.36 67.69 0.12 12.74 106.5 21.62 17.37
D2-KelheimMuscle:2004-2011Liver:2004-2010
Range 0.31-0.75 7.48-42.92 494.5-1295 1.14-1.26 98.90-169.2 204.8-884.5 81.48-213.2 120.8-201.0Median 0.61 33.60 714.3 1.22 132.8 323.7 123.3 144.2Mean 0.58 28.98 808.1 1.21 127.6 417.0 127.2 150.1SD 0.16 12.65 287.5 0.05 24.76 257.4 41.81 27.19
D3-JochensteinMuscle:2004-2011Liver:2004-2010
Range 0.46-0.92 16.88-73.32 1053-1530 1.10-1.77 111.9-274.0 1207-2183 79.35-159.3 109.7-175.8Median 0.52 28.64 1325 1.27 130.8 1382 108.2 141.5Mean 0.60 35.57 1332 1.36 151.8 1590 114.9 141.3SD 0.17 18.08 159.1 0.24 56.98 373.6 31.20 27.83
Table S3 (cont.): Metals and arsenic in muscle and liver of bream (Abramis brama) from the German ESB sampling sites.
Water Sampling site and period
Value Bream muscle Bream liverArsenicµg/g dw
Lead ng/g dw
Mercuryng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Leadng/g dw
Cadmiumng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Zincµg/g dw
Elbe E1-ProssenMuscle:1993-2011Liver:2002-2010
Range 0.20-0.47 44.60-178.5 824.2-2859 1.08-1.72 142.0-467.0 715.8-3140 61.20-145.3 109.6-172.6Median 0.34 90.48 1592 1.36 310.2 2102 75.68 117.8Mean 0.34 95.56 1658 1.37 303.7 1925 86.67 128.1SD 0.07 36.45 562.5 0.16 106.7 912.4 25.64 22.09
E2-ZehrenMuscle:1993-2011Liver:2002-2010
Range 0.10-0.64 42.24-172.4 958.1-3376 1.21-1.98 258.5-541.3 2352-9070 92.13-157.2 120.0-163.8Median 0.42 104.2 2033 1.38 372.8 5650 126.5 150.2Mean 0.44 112.3 2050 1.44 376.4 5512 126.4 146.7SD 0.13 36.24 601.7 0.19 108.8 1887 23.68 16.60
E3-BarbyMuscle:1993-2011Liver:2002-2010
Range 0.29-0.64 51.36-167.9 1050-4196 1.21-2.46 259.5-542.3 1093-8888 78.37-193.5 134.8-186.7Median 0.40 85.86 1540 1.48 363.2 4640 136.8 169.5Mean 0.42 93.59 1902 1.62 382.1 4875 134.7 158.7SD 0.10 33.47 881.1 0.40 83.42 2330 41.91 19.83
E4-CumlosenMuscle:1993-2011Liver:2002-2010
Range 0.21-0.83 36.44-164.0 1041-3286 1.47-4.55 161.8-303.8 2355-7564 61.37-112.7 108.2-156.5Median 0.31 70.88 1492 2.38 263.00 4068 92.85 140.5Mean 0.34 78.92 1782 2.51 259.6 4249 90.74 137.2SD 0.14 33.77 713.9 0.78 44.43 1647 16.74 16.81
E5BlankeneseMuscle:1993-2011Liver:2002-2010
Range 0.38-0.76 7.86-158.8 351.2-1650 1.28-3.81 74.05-131.8 74.27-249.2 17.93-51.05 64.23-113.5Median 0.52 57.88 577.7 2.04 86.22 133.3 19.67 76.13Mean 0.53 60.18 882.8 2.28 94.86 143.6 25.16 82.04SD 0.10 38.72 469.1 0.88 18.97 52.69 11.22 14.83
Table S3 (cont.): Metals and arsenic in muscle and liver of bream (Abramis brama) from the German ESB sampling sites.
Water Sampling site and period
Value Bream muscle Bream liverArsenicµg/g dw
Lead ng/g dw
Mercuryng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Leadng/g dw
Cadmiumng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Zincµg/g dw
Mulde MU-DessauMuscle:1995-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.24-0.49 35.72-160.0 916.2-4127 1.54-3.51 198.8-499.2 9440-23167 78.07-144.7 115.7-177.5Median 0.38 72.24 1363 2.36 282.7 12417 111.0 138.5Mean 0.37 78.47 1779 2.33 312.1 13050 110.0 140.3SD 0.06 34.02 992.6 0.62 99.30 3953 20.12 19.24
Saale SA-WettinMuscle:1995-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.16-0.72 40.48-151.2 942.7-1962 0.85-1.50 193.6-718.7 304.2-753.0 96.03-143.2 116.8-171.8Median 0.36 83.75 1552 1.22 308.6 530.7 118.5 128.8Mean 0.42 87.43 1494 1.22 349.4 502.2 118.9 139.6SD 0.19 34.49 293.8 0.19 159.9 143.0 17.41 20.77
Table S3 (cont.): Metals and arsenic in muscle and liver of bream (Abramis brama) from the German ESB sampling sites.
Water Sampling site and period
Value Bream muscle Bream liverArsenicµg/g dw
Leadng/g dw
Mercuryng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Leadng/g dw
Cadmiumng/g dw
Copperµg/g dw
Zincµg/g dw
Rhine R1-WeilMuscle:1995-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.24-0.54 15.82-78.29 364.2-916.3 1.03-2.19 51.08-120.2 42.83-204.4 15.65-60.73 55.50-83.73Median 0.42 32.83 697.9 1.51 59.60 138.4 32.43 68.23Mean 0.40 41.66 689.3 1.50 76.43 130.0 33.96 67.80SD 0.09 21.88 162.2 0.26 27.40 53.98 12.27 10.62
R2-IffezheimMuscle:1995-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.39-0.79 15.85-268.0 688.3-1429 1.02-1.64 164.8-275.0 587.4-1183 81.37-102.17 109.3-129.8Median 0.56 58.62 1023 1.31 186.8 851.2 88.50 124.0Mean 0.58 75.02 1037 1.28 196.3 892.1 91.30 123.5SD 0.12 61.05 164.7 0.20 35.01 215.1 6.96 6.17
R3-KoblenzMuscle:1995-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.32-0.68 27.08-118.5 366.5-878.4 0.93-1.31 100.4-199.3 145.3-1466 40.43-95.62 68.38-107.7Median 0.44 67.20 483.3 1.16 157.4 408.0 62.67 92.15Mean 0.47 65.26 527.1 1.14 150.9 526.0 65.11 91.04SD 0.11 27.34 156.3 0.12 29.10 452.1 16.97 12.48
R4-BimmenMuscle:1995-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.43-0.97 61.86-186.2 560.6-1945 1.00-1.61 137.2-389.8 602.3-3104 52.67-133.7 88.82-145.7Median 0.64 82.89 895.0 1.23 282.50 2352 96.92 123.0Mean 0.69 104.45 984.5 1.23 274.02 2074 99.49 120.4SD 0.18 41.55 349.1 0.19 90.43 1035 29.70 22.34
Saar S1-GüdingenMuscle:1994-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.15-0.56 35.83-255.7 315.5-548.6 1.15-1.67 96.26-170.83 108.8-238.5 34.93-77.50 68.95-114.3Median 0.24 74.46 439.1 1.42 132.7 170.5 44.82 94.40Mean 0.28 85.43 435.4 1.41 131.3 175.6 49.79 95.43SD 0.11 51.27 59.50 0.12 24.55 42.11 14.68 13.25
S2-RehlingenMuscle:1994-2011Liver: 2002-2010
Range 0.30-0.76 30.30-122.2 397.5-633.0 1.04-1.65 119.0-187.2 86.78-230.0 91.22-155.0 111.3-156.5Median 0.51 51.67 521.4 1.26 158.3 166.2 114.6 129.3Mean 0.52 64.84 524.7 1.24 155.3 169.4 119.0 133.9SD 0.15 29.25 65.42 0.14 19.77 50.69 18.51 13.97
Table S4: Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in suspended particulate matter (SPM) from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%. Time span: 2005 – 2009 (5 years). Exception: Saar: 2006 – 2009 (4 years)
Water Sampling site
Parameters SPMArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel Zinc
Elbe E1
Prossen
Yearly trend 9.7% n.s. 6.9% n.s. 10% n.s. 5.7% n.s. 12% n.s. 12% n.s. 8.3% n.s.95%-CI -7.5; 30 -14; 32 -11; 37 -23; 45 -5.0; 31 -11; 40 -8.8; 28r² 0.50 0.25 0.41 0.09 0.61 0.44 0.42p <0.182 <0.397 <0.244 <0.616 <0.117 <0.222 <0.236
E2
Zehren
Yearly trend 1.4% n.s. 7.5% n.s. 16% n.s. 6.2% n.s. 10% n.s. 17% n.s. 15% n.s.95%-CI -26; 39 -27; 58 -37; 118 -48; 116 -30; 73 -27; 90 -29; 86r² 0.01 0.10 0.17 0.02 0.15 0.28 0.21p <0.862 <0.599 <0.497 <0.790 <0.529 <0.359 <0.327
E3
Barby
Yearly trend -11% n.s. -2.2% n.s. -1.5% n.s. -11% n.s. -4.7% n.s. -2.2% n.s. -5.1% n.s.95%-CI -28; 9.9 -14; 12 -23; 26 -19; -2.1 -9.4; 0.3 -15; 13 -18; 10r² 0.51 0.09 0.01 0.83 0.75 0.08 0.30p <0.174 <0.616 <0.831 <0.033 <0.061 <0.649 <0.344
E4
Cumlosen
Yearly trend -3.1% n.s. 0.7% n.s. 2.6% n.s. -4.4% n.s. -2.4% n.s. 4.4% n.s. 0.7% n.s.95%-CI -12; 6.3 -14; 17 -41; 77 -15; 7.0 -13; 9.6 -17; 31 -16; 22r² 0.29 0.01 0.01 0.35 0.12 0.10 0.00p <0.353 <0.870 <0.861 <0.296 <0.562 <0.597 <0.879
E5
Blankenese
Yearly trend 1.5% n.s. 5.7% n.s. 27% n.s. 1.5% n.s. 4.4% n.s. 6.3% n.s. 5.8% n.s.95%-CI -3.8; 7.0 -3.2; 15 -63; 331 -8.2; 13 -0.9; 10 1.1; 12 -7.7;21r² 0.20 0.57 0.11 0.07 0.70 0.83 0.36p <0.454 <0.142 <0.586 <0.661 <0.080 0.033 <0.281
Table S4 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in suspended particulate matter (SPM) from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%. Time span: 2005 – 2009 (5 years). Exception: Saar: 2006 – 2009 (4 years)
Water Sampling site
Parameters SPMArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel Zinc
Saale SA
Wettin
Yearly trend -4.5% n.s. -1.9.0% n.s. 12% n.s. -13% n.s. -3.4% n.s. 0.30% -0.8% n.s.95%-CI -23; 19 -13; 11 -; 246 -27; 4.2 -15; 9.9 -15; 19 -21; 23r² 0.14 0.08 0.03 0.67 0.20 0.00 0.00p <0.545 <0.650 <0.758 <0.092 <0.457 <0.911 <0.877
Mulde Mu
Dessau
Yearly trend 3.7% n.s. 1.1% n.s. 7.7% n.s. 5.2% n.s. 4.3% n.s. 13% increase 17% n.s.95%-CI -5.1; 13 -6.9; 9.3 1.7; 14 -10; 23 -0.2; 9.0 7.9; 18 -18; 67r² 0.38% 0.06 0.85 0.26 0.75 0.96 0.39p <0.271 <0.678 <0.029 <0.384 <0.059 <0.007 <0.260
Rhine R1
Weil
Yearly trend -0.5% n.s. 2.1% n.s. 12% n.s. 2.6% n.s. -0.02% n.s. 6.4% n.s. 4.4% n.s.95%-CI -9; 9.3 -10; 16 -34; 88 -29; 49 -8.1; 8.9 -9.0; 24 -1.1; 10r² 0.01 0.08 0.12 0.02 0.00 0.35 0.68p <0.844 <0.647 <0.574 <0.816 <0.942 <0.295 <0.087
R2
Iffezheim
Yearly trend -3.2% n.s. 2.2% n.s. 7.4% n.s. -2.4% n.s. -1.6% n.s. 3.5% n.s. 2.4% n.s.95%-CI -8.2; 2.0 -6.2; 12 -16; 39 -12; 8.7 -6.0; 3.0 -12; 22 -0.20; 5.1r² 0.57 0.18 0.21 0.15 0.29 0.12 0.74p <0.142 <0.482 <0.445 <0.523 <0.353 <0.564 <0.063
R3
Koblenz
Yearly trend 3.1% n.s. 3.4% n.s. 14% n.s. -3.9% n.s. 0.2% n.s. 8.0% n.s. 5.0% n.s.95%-CI -5.6; 13 -7.6; 16 -18; 60 -12; 5.0 -10; 12 -2.4; 20 -2.0; 13r² 0.29 0.23 0.34 0.40 0.00 0.66 0.63p <0.353 <0.414 <0.299 <0.249 <0.909 <0.096 <0.110
R4
Bimmen
Yearly trend -1.0% n.s. -1.3% n.s. 1.7% n.s. -8.9% n.s. -3.4% n.s. 2.1% n.s. 7.3% n.s.95%-CI -3.8; 1.9 -9.0; 7.1 -34; 58 -18; 1.6 -11; 4.8 -12; 18 -25; 54r² 0.28 0.08 0.00 0.71 0.38 0.06 0.11p <0.365 <0.654 <0.877 <0.075 <0.270 <0.683 <0.581
Table S4 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in suspended particulate matter (SPM) from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%. Time span: 2005 – 2009 (5 years). Exception: Saar: 2006 – 2009 (4 years)
Water Sampling site
Parameters SPMArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel Zinc
Saar S1
Güdingen
Yearly trend -2.9% n.s. -2.1% n.s. -14% n.s. -18% decrease -7.2% n.s. 6.6% n.s. 1.0% n.s.95%-CI -27; 31 -27; 31 -34; 10 -47; 28 -29; 21 -16; 36 -27; 40r² 0.08 0.05 0.77 0.64
/Kendall’s tau :***/SD(sm): 0.00
0.42 0.39 0.01
p <0.704 <0.770 <0.128 <0.200 /p<0.042 (tau) (p<0.001 (SD(sm))
<0.353 <0.377 <0.877
S2
Rehlingen
Yearly trend -5.3% n.s. 2.9% n.s. -16% n.s. -1.9% n.s. -7.0% n.s. 8.2% increase -1.9% n.s.95%-CI -23; 16 -20; 31 -52; 48 -18; 17 -22; 10 -0.4; 17 -39; 58r² 0.39 0.12 0.47 0.09 0.62 0.89(Kendall’s
tau: 1.00/SD(sm): 0.00
0.01
p <0.380 <0.656 <0.319 <0.694 <0.215 <0.062 / p<0.042 (tau) / p<0.001 (SD(sm))
<0.850
Table S5: Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in zebra mussels from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Zebra musselArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel
Lake Belau B Period 1997-2009 1999-2009 1997-2009 1997-2009 1997-2009 1997-2009No of values 7 6 7 7 7 7Yearly trend -0.3% n.s. -15% n.s. -7.4% decrease -5.2% n.s. -7.7% decrease -6.2% decrease95%-CI 2.6; 1.9 -25; -3.3 -12; -2.3 -10; 0.4 -10; -4.9 -11; -1.2r² 0.03 0.75 0.73 0.53 0.90 0.67p <0.702 <0.026 0.015 <0.061 <0.001 <0.025
Danube D1
Ulm
Period 2003-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009No of values 7 7 7 7 7 7Yearly trend -2.7% n.s. 8.0% n.s. -3.4% n.s. 4.1% n.s. 2.3% n.s. 5.3% n.s.95%-CI -7.6; 2.6 -3.6; 21 -8.9; 2.4 -3.1; 12 -4.3; 9.5 -8.5; 21r² 0.25 0.38 0.32 0.29 0.14 0.15p <0.249 <0.141 <0.187 <0.208 <0.420 <0.391
D2
Kelheim
Period 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009No of values 6 6 6 6 6 6Yearly trend -4.0% n.s. 12% increase 3.3% n.s. 12% n.s. 21% increase 16% increase95%-CI -14; 6.9 4.8; 20 -20; 34 -11; 40 17; 23 5.1; 30r² 0.22 0.85 0.03 0.30 0.99 0.81p <0.352 <0.010 <0.739 <0.262 <0.001 <0.016
D3
Jochenstein
Period 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009 2004-2009No of values 5 5 5 5 5 5Yearly trend -0.8% n.s. 2.4% n.s. -0.3 n.s. 0.9% n.s. 18% n.s. 7.7% n.s.95%-CI -9; 9.1 -16; 23 -9.4; 9.6 -5.2; 7.5 -2.6; 45 -0.8; 17.4r² 0.03 0.05 0.00 0.07 0.72 0.74p <0.785 <0.706 <0.879 <0.664 <0.072 <0.065
Table S5 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in zebra mussels from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Zebra musselArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel
Elbe E1
Prossen
Period 1999-2009 1999-2009 1999-2009 1999-2009 1999-2009 1999-2009No of values 11 11 11 11 11 11Yearly trend 0.9% n.s. 0.8% n.s. 2.3% n.s. -5.2% n.s. -0.8% n.s. -1.6% n.s.95%-CI -2.3; 4.2 -5.2; 7.1 -5.9; 12 -11; 1.0 -3.4; 1.8 -4.9; 1.8r² 0.04 0.01 0.04 0.28 0.05 0.11p <0.558 <0.767 <0.563 <0.089 <0.498 <0.310
E2
Zehren
Period 2000-2009 2000-2009 2000-2009 2000-2009 2000-2009 2000-2009No of values 10 10 10 10 10 10Yearly trend 1.1% n.s. 20% increase -18% n.s. 0.3% n.s. -0.4% n.s. 5.5% n.s.95%-CI -5.3; 7.8 6.3; 30 -35; -4.3 -4.6; 5.4 -5.4; 5.0 -4.4; 16r² 0.02 0.60 0.52 0.00 0.00 0.16p <0.711 <0.008 <0.018 <0.855 <0.852 <0.244
E3
Barby
Period 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009No of values 12 12 12 12 12 12Yearly trend -0.5% n.s. 7.8% n.s. 3.7% n.s. -7.6% decrease 2.0% n.s. -0.8% n.s.95%-CI -3.8; 2.8 -4.3; 21 -2.4; 10 -11; -3.5 -1.2; 5.3 -5.2; 3.7r² 0.01 0.17 0.15 0.63 0.17 0.02p <0.726 <0.187 <0.207 <0.002 <0.184 <0.687
E4
Cumlosen
Period 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009 1998-2009No of values 10 10 10 10 10 10Yearly trend -0.5% n.s. -1.9% n.s. 5.0% n.s. -3.4% n.s. 0.4% n.s. -1.2% n.s.95%-CI -4.4; 3.7 -9; 6.7 -3.6; 14 -8.6; 2.1 -1.4; 2.2 -7.2; 5.1r² 0.01 0.03 0.18 0.21 0.04 0.03p <0.787 <0.623 <0.223 <0.184 <0.609 <0.661
Table S5 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in zebra mussels from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Zebra musselArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel
Elbe E5
Blankenese
Period 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009No of values 13 12 13 13 13 13Yearly trend -0.1% n.s. 2.2% n.s. -2.3% n.s. -1.8% n.s. 3.0% increase 5.3% increase95%-CI -2.7; 2.4 -1.4; 6.0 -5.6; 1.2 -4.2; 0.7 1.2; 4.8 2.2; 8.5r² 0.00 0.15 0.16 0.19 0.55 0.57p <0.871 <0.206 <0.166 <0.137 <0.004 <0.003
Rhine R1
Weil
Period 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009No of values 6 5 6 6 6 6Yearly trend -2.9% n.s. 2.5% n.s. -2.8% decrease 6.0% n.s. 1.1% n.s. 1.5% n.s.95%-CI -7.2; 1.7 -16; 26 -6.8; 1.4 -4.2; 17 -5.6; 8.2 -5.6; 9.2r² 0.44 0.05 0.47 / Kendall’s
tau: -0.730.39 0.04 0.07
p <0.149 <0.716 <0.133 (p<0.039 (tau))
<0.186 <0.688 <0.607
R2
Iffezheim
Period 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009No of values 4 4 4 4 4 4Yearly trend n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.95%-CI n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.r² n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.p n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d. n.d.
R3
Koblenz
Period 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009No of values 9 8 9 9 9 9Yearly trend -1.1% n.s. -1.0% n.s. -4.2% decrease -3.1% n.s. -2.7% n.s. -6.8% decrease95%-CI -3.8; 1.8 -10; 9.0 -9.1; 0.9 -7.9; 2.0 -5.8; 0.6 -10; -2.8r² 0.10 0.01 0.35/ Kendall’s
tau: -0.560.23 0.35 0.69
p <0.411 <0.789 <0.091 / p<0.037 (tau)
<0.188 <0.090 <0.006
Table S5 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in zebra mussels from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Zebra musselArsenic Lead Cadmium Mercury Copper Nickel
R4
Bimmen
Period 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009 1995-2009No of values 10 9 10 10 10 10Yearly trend -1.8% 6.4% increase 1% n.s. 2.4% n.s. -0.8% n.s. -0.1% n.s.95%-CI -3.9; 0.40 1.3; 12 -2.4; 4.5 -1.9; 6.8 -3.5; 2.0 -4.0; 4.0r² 0.31 0.56 0.05 0.17 0.05 0.00p <0.093 <0.020 <0.521 <0.231 <0.533 <0.915
Saar S1
Güdingen
Period 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009No of values 15 15 15 15 15 15Yearly trend -0.7% n.s. 1.9% n.s. 4.9% increase -1.6% n.s. 2.5% increase 2.6% n.s.95%-CI -3.1; 1.9 -2.4; 6.4 1.1; 8.9 -4.5; 1.4 0.3; 4.8 -0.9; 6.3r² 0.02 0.07 0.38 0.09 0.32 0.17p <0.599 <0.353 <0.014 <0.278 <0.026 <0.127
Rehlingen Period 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009 1994-2009No of values 16 15 16 16 16 16Yearly trend -3.0% decrease -0.1% n.s. 2.6% n.s. -6.8% decrease 0.30% n.s. -0.2% n.s.95%-CI -5.3; -0.6 -3.3; 3.1 -0.8; 6.2 -10; -2.8 -1.2; 1.9 -2.3; 1.8r² 0.33 0.00 0.16 0.47 0.01 0.01p <0.019 <0.883 <0.126 <0.003 0.684 <0.781
Table S6: Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in bream from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Bream muscle Bream liverArsenic Lead Copper Mercury Lead Cadmium Copper Zinc
Lake Belau
B period 1997-2009 1997-2009 1997-2009 1997-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009 2003-2009No of values 8 7 8 8 4 4 4 4Yearly trend 0.4% n.s. -20% n.s. 1.1% n.s. -3.8%
decrease-5.4% n.s. 17% n.s. -11% decrease -6.5% n.s.
95%-CI -10;13 -39; 3.3 -1.4; 3.7 -7.3; -0.3 -49; 75 -15; 63 -18; -3.6 -16; 4.4r² 0.0 0.5 0.16 0.54 0.07 0.70 0.95 0.77p <0.901 <0.073 <0.331 <0.037 <0.731 <0.166 <0.034 <0.125
Danube D1
Ulm
period 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2010 2004-2010 2004-2010 2004-2010No of values 8 8 8 8 7 7 7 7Yearly trend -2.3% n.s. -0.3% n.s. 0.6% n.s. -1.9% n.s. 6.5% n.s. -3.8% n.s. -8.4% n.s. -4.0% n.s.
95%-CI -10; 6.4 -20; 25 -3.2; 4.5 -7.9; 4.4 -3.7; 17 -17; 12 -18; 2.2 -8.7; 1.0r² 0.07 0.00 0.02 0.09 0.34 0.08 0.46 0.47p <0.539 <0.923 <0.721 <0.483 <0.168 <0.534 <0.092 <0.09
D2
Kelheim
period 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2010 2004-2010 2004-2010 2004-2010No of values 8 7 8 8 7 7 7 7Yearly trend -3.4% n.s. -2.5% n.s. 0.8% n.s. 10% n.s. 3.0% n.s. 13% n.s. 12% n.s. 3.9% n.s.
95%-CI -15; 8.9 -27; 31 -0.6; 2.2 -0.8; 22 -6.5; 14 -14; 46 0.5; 23 -4.1; 13r² 0.08 0.01 0.26 0.46 0.11 0.20 0.59 0.23p <0.508 <0.817 <0.199 <0.063 <0.467 <0.385 <0.043 <0.277
D3
Jochen-stein
Period 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2011 2004-2010 2004-2010 2004-2010 2004-2010No of values 8 8 8 8 7 7 7 7Yearly trend -7.6% n.s. 9.6% n.s. 4.9% n.s. 1.0% n.s. 6.8% n.s. 5.7% n.s. 4.9% n.s. 3.7% n.s.
95%-CI -14; -0.9 -6.9; 30 -0; 10 -3.8; 6.1 -7.8; 23 -4.6; 17 -8.4; 20 -6.0; 14r² 0.56 0.24 0.50 0.04 0.21 0.28 0.14 0.15p <0.032 <0.216 <0.050 <0.645 <0.302 <0.222 <0.413 <0.395
Table S6 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in bream from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Bream muscle Bream liverArsenic Lead Copper Mercury Lead Cadmium Copper Zinc
Elbe E1
Prossen
Period 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 19 18 19 19 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 0.8% n.s. -3.1% n.s. -1.7%
decrease-5.3% decrease
-11% n.s. -13% n.s. -2.0% n.s. -4.6% decrease
95%-CI -1.1; 2.7 -6.2; 0.1 -2.3; -1.0 -6.6; -3.8 -16; -5.2 -24; 0.6 -9.5; 6.7 -7.5; -1.5r² 0.05 0.21 0.63 0.78 0.72 0.42 0.04 0.64p <0.375 <0.055 <0.001 <0.001 <0.004 <0.056 <0.605 <0.01
E2
Zehren
Period 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 19 18 19 19 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 4.2%
increase-3.0% n.s. -1.3%
decrease-4.8% decrease
-6.6% n.s. -10% decrease
-4.2% n.s. -3.7% decrease
95%-CI 1.1; 7.4 -5,9; 0.0 -2.2; -0.3 -6.0; -3.5 -13; 0.4 -17; -3.2 -8.9; 1.0 -5.4; -1.9r² 0.33 0.22 0.32 0.79 0.41 0.62 0.34 0.76p <0.01 <0.049 <0.011 <0.001 <0.06 <0.011 <0.095 0.002
E3
Barby
Period 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 19 18 19 19 9 9 9 9Yearly trend -0.5% n.s. -1.0% n.s. -3.6%
decrease-5.0% decrease
5.2% n.s. 14% n.s. 5.3% n.s. 1.7% n.s.
95%-CI -2.5; 1.4 -4.2; 2.2 -4.6; -2.6 -7.4; -2.6 -0.3; 10 -4.2; 35 -4.1; 16 -2.2; 5.7r² 0.02 0.03 0.76 0.51 0.42 0.31 0.20 0.13p <0.569 <0.508 <0.001 <0.001 <0.059 <0.119 <0.228 <0.344
E4
Cumlosen
Period 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 19 18 19 19 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 2.5% n.s. -4.5%
decrease-4.6% decrease
-3.6% decrease
0.5% n.s. 0.2% n.s. -1.4% n.s. -0.4 n.s.
95%-CI -0.1; 5.3 -7.4; -1.6 -5.7; -3.5 -6.3; -0.9 -6.7; 6.0 -11; 14 -7.5; 5.1 -4.4; 3.8r² 0.19 0.39 0.82 0.32 0.01 0.0 0.04 0.01p <0.058 <0.005 <0.001 <0.011 <0.830 <0.918 <0.620 <0.813
Table S6 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in bream from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Bream muscle Bream liverArsenic Lead Copper Mercury Lead Cadmium Copper Zinc
Elbe E5
Blanke-nese
Period 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 1993-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 19 18 19 19 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 0.3% n.s. -9.3%
decrease-6.0% decrease
-8,4% decrease
0.8% n.s. -5,9% n.s. 4.3% n.s. 1.6% n.s.
95%-CI -1.4; 1.9 -14;-4.7 -7.4; -4.6 -10; -6,7 -6.7; 5.4 -16; 4.8 -6,9; 16 -3.6; 7.3r² 0.01 0.52 0.81 0.85 0.01 0.20 0.10 0.07p <0.754 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.751 <0.224 <0.415 <0.495
Saale SA
Wettin
Period 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 17 16 17 17 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 9.1%
increase0.9% n.s. -1.9%
decrease2.9% increase -12% decrease 5.3% n.s. -0.7% n.s. -1.3% n.s.
95%-CI 6.5; 12 -3.6; 5.7 -3.2; -0.6 1.1; 4.7 -18; -5.8 -3.0; 14 -5.4; 4.1 -5.8; 3.4r² 0.79 0.01 0.39 0.44 0.74 0.25 0.02 0.06p <0.001 <0.684 <0.007 <0.004 <0.003 <0.173 <0.727 <0.517
Mulde MU
Dessau
Period 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 17 16 17 17 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 0.3% n.s. -4.8%
decrease-3.7% decrease
-8.1% decrease
1.6% n.s. 3.3% n.s. 1.2% n.s. -0.3% n.s.
95%-CI -1.6; 2.3 -8.4; -1.0 -5.6; -1.7 -10; -5.6 -7.8; 12 -4.2; 12 -4.8; 7.6 -4.5; 4.2r² 0.01 0.34 0.51 0.76 0.02 0.13 0.03 0.0p <0.718 <0.017 <0.001 <0.001 <0.709 <0.345 <0.662 <0.857
Table S6 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in bream from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Bream muscle Bream liverArsenic Lead Copper Mercury Lead Cadmium Copper Zinc
Rhine R1
Weil
Period 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 16 15 16 16 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 3.5%
increase-5.7% decrease
0.3% n.s. -3.3% decrease
0.7% n.s. -1.8% n.s. 7.5% n.s. 2.6% n.s.
95%-CI 1.3; 5.5 -11; -0.2 -1.7; 2.3 -5.6; -1.1 -11; 12 -17; 16 -2.8; 18 -1.9; 7.5r² 0.47 0.28 0.01 0.41 0.0 0.01 0.29 0.21p <0.003 <0.04 <0.741 <0.007 <0.861. <0.795 <0.131 <0.215
R2
Iffezheim
Period 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 17 16 17 17 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 2.0% n.s. -4.8% n.s. -0.6% n.s. -1.3% n.s. -2.4% n.s. -1.0% n.s. -0.5% n.s. -0.8% n.s.
95%-CI 0.0; 4.2 -11; 2.5 -2.3; 1.0 -2.9; 0.3 -7.0; 2.4 -8.6; 7.3 -2.9; 1.9 -2.4; 0.7r² 0.22 0.12 0.04 0.17 0.17 0.01 0.03 0.20p <0.052 <0.177 <0.419 <0.095 <0.277 <0.770 <0.648 <0.220
R3
Koblenz
Period 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 17 16 17 17 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 2.5% n.s. -6.0%
decrease-0.9% n.s. -0.9% n.s. 1.6% n.s. 30%
increase4.8% n.s. 2.8% n.s.
95%-CI 0.6; 4.6 -9.5; -2.1 -1.9; 0.2 -3.7; 1.9 -4.7; 8.4 18; 42 -2.8; 13 -1.2; 7,0r² 0.33 0.43 0.17 0.03 0.05 0.87 0.24 0.28p <0.015 <0.005 <0.096 <0.498 <0.574 <0.001 <0.178 <0.144
R4
Bimmen
Period 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 1995-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 17 16 17 17 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 4.0%
increase-6.6% decrease
-1.6% decrease
-4.0% decrease
-2.8% n.s. -4.3% n.s. -1.3% n.s. -0.8% n.s.
95%-CI 2.1; 6.0 -8.5; -4.5 -3.0; -0.2 -6.7; -1.4 -13; 9.3 -22; 17 -11; 9.7 -6.9; 5.7r² 0.59 0.76 0.30 0.41 0.04 0.04 0.01 0.01p <0.001 <0.001 <0.023 <0.005 <0.591 <0.627 <0.771 0.758
Table S6 (cont.): Time trend analysis of arsenic and metals in bream from the German ESB sites using the PIA programme (Bignert 2007), alpha 5%; power 80%
Water Sampling site
Parameters Bream muscle Bream liverArsenic Lead Copper Mercury Lead Cadmium Copper Zinc
Saar S1
Güdingen
Period 1994-2011 1994-2011 1994-2011 1994-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 18 17 18 18 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 5.5%
increase-6.3% decrease
-0.8% n.s. 0.3% n.s. -2.3% n.s. 6.6% n.s. 3.9% n.s. 2.0% n.s.
95%-CI 3.1; 8.0 -9.5; -2.6 -1.5; 0.0 -1.1; 1.6 -7.8; 3.7 0.6; 13 -4.8; 13 -2.5; 6.6r² 0.60 0.46 0.21 0.01 0.11 0.49 0.13 0.13p <0.001 <0.003 <0.055 <0.684 <0.392 <0.035 <0.342 <0.337
S2
Rehlingen
Period 1994-2011 1994-2011 1994-2011 1994-2011 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010 2002-2010No of values 18 17 18 18 9 9 9 9Yearly trend 3.4%
increase-5.9 decrease
-1.0% n.s. 0.3% n.s. 2.8% n.s. 9.7% increase
1.5% n.s. 1.1% n.s.
95%-CI 1.1; 5.8 -8.8; -3.1 -2.0; -0.1 -1.0; 1.6 -0.7; 6.5 2.5; 17 -3.3; 6.5 -2.2; 4.4r² 0.37 0.55 0.24 0.01 0.34 0.60 0.07 0.08p <0.007 <0.001 <0.037 <0.641 <0.095 <0.015 <0.501 <0.460