washington v. william morris endeavor entertainment, llc et al. (14-4328) -- emergency motion for...

7/21/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment, LLC et al. (14-4328) -- Emergency Motion for Reconsiderati

1/19

[ B G ] K M \ ] D ] K \ L H [ Q ] H N D _ _ K D I\ N H Q ] C K \ K L H B M L G Q L [ G ]

]curehhmJdrscd[[.\. Lhurtchusk =? Nhiky

\qudrk,

Bkw Whr`, B W4???5 ]kikpchbk6 141-3;5-3;??

J H ] G H B GB N H Q J D ] G H B \ ] D ] K J K B ]

Mhl`ktBugbakr

(s)6 4=-=J

I h k a

I h k a I I _

A r h h ` i y b , BW 441?>

=>-;?=->=75

cujdbrgects.drkdjustOejdgi.lhj

141-=?5-=??? jzwkgeOihka.lhj l l d r a h b k O i h k a . l h j

Lhtj-Fum@k/DQkblW

dppkdikm nrhj6

\hutckrb Mgstr gl t

hn

Bkw Whr`

_. @kv gb Lds tk g

_ikdsk lckl dpprhprgdtk ahxks6

N H Q

K J K Q E K B L W J H ] G H B \, J H ] G H B \ N H Q \ ] D W \

DBM

C ds

jhvdbt bhtgngkm hpphsgbe lhubski

(rkqugrkm

ay

IhldiQuik

15.4)6

W k s g i B h (kxpidgb)6

G B F [ B L ] G H B \ _ K B M G B E D _ _ K D I 6

Cd s

rkqukst nhr

rkigknakkb

jdmk akihw8

Cd s

tcgs

rkigkn

akkb prkvghusiy shuect

gb

tcgs

Lhurt8

Wks

Wks

Bh

Bh

Hpphsgbe

lhubski's phsgtghb hb jhtghb0

G

G

[bhpphskm RHpphskm RFhb't

@bhw

Mhks hpphsgbe lhubski gbtkbm th ngik d rksphbsk6

G GW ks

P^ghi

chd g @bhw

Qkqukstkm

rkturb

mdtk dbm kxpidbdtghb hn kjkrekbly6] c k

1 b m L g r

mkigakrdtk

wd s tk m d b d m m 'i= j h b tc shnjytgjk a y kb tj k h u s i y m k b y g b e j y d p p k d inhr

i d l` n g b e Z d b d r e u d a i k

a d s g s

k g tckr Gb idw hr Gb ndlt w g tchu t p rhv gm gbe db k tc gl d i

fum gl gd i hp gb ghb , dbm i g `k

L d s t k g ,

gebhr gbe md gj s hn n rdum uphb tck Lhur t . Ds

Gd s `tcdt tc gs dppkd i ak t rdbs nk r rkmthdb h tc k r l g r lu g tGnbh t ,

ds` nh r tck lhu

k xp i d gb g ts r k d s h b g b e .

Gn

Jht`gbg s m k b g k m w g tch u t r k d s h b nh r

d

s k lh b m t g j k ,

G

d s `

tcdt

tc k Lh u r t s td y tc k j d b m d tk d b m

g s s u k

mkl gs gh b bh id tk r tcdb Dpr g i

4

Gshrdidreujkbt hb jhtghb rkqukstkm8

Cd s

dreujkbt mdtk hn

dppkdi

akkb skt8

\gRdturk hnRhvnge'Dnthjky6

Vivks

G [ B H (rkquksts nhr hrdi

dreujkbt

wgiibht

bklkssdrgiy

ak erdbtkm)

W k s

Bh Gnyks, kbtkr mdtk6

yghvi ggeDtthrbky6

g |

Mdtk6 Jdrlc

1;, 1?4; \knRglk

a y6 I lJ

/KLN i[

HtckrPDttdlc prhhn

hn skrvglkZ

N h r j

]-4?3?

(rkv.

41-4


2/19

Bh.

4=-==5 _@L) FLN)

D _ _ K I I D B ] \ K J K Q E K B L W

J H ] G H B

N H Q Q K L H B \ G M K Q D ] G H B B

A BL

DBM

Q K T [ K \ ] ] H ^ D L D ] K

L I D Q G N W J D Q L C

44, 1?4;

H Q M K Q H N

\ K L H B M

L GQ L [ G ] U G ] C

] C K G \\ [ D B LK H N D B K ] C G L D I F [ M G L G D I

H _ G B G H B ,

H Q GB ] C K D I ] K Q B D ] G ^ K ,

J H ] G H B

] H \ ] D W J D B M D ] K

_ K B M G B E

] C K N G I G B E H N

D

_ K ] G ] G H B N H Q U Q G ] H N

L K Q ] G H Q D Q G U G ] C ] C K \ [ _ Q K J K L H [ Q ] H N ] C K [ B G ] K M \ ] D ] K \ .

Q K T [ K \ ] ] H ] Q D B \ N K Q D _ _ K D I ] H D B H ] C K Q L G Q L [ G ] .

J r.

Jdrlus Gsdgdc Udscgbethb

;= Ahkruj \t.

D p t .

>J

Arhh`iyb,

B W 441?>

>=>) ;?=->=75

cujdbrgects.drkdjust Rejdgi.lhj

_rh kIgtgedbt


3/19

Nhr tck nh[hwjerkdshbsakihw, G -

prh s

Dppkiidbt Jdrlus Gsdgdc Udscgbethb - suajgt tcgs Kjkrekbly

Jhtghbnhr Qklhbsgmkrdtghb Kb Adbl, hr gb tck Ditkrbdtgvk,Jhtghbth\tdyJdbmdtk _kbmgbe tckNgigbehn

d _ktgtghb nhr U r g thn Lkrtghrdrg w g t c tck

\uprkjk

Lhurt th tck [bgtkm\tdtks Lhurt hn Dppkdis nhr tck

\klhbm

Lgrlugt

skk gbe

kxtrdhrmgbdry

rkigknubmkr

tck

lhurt's

gbckrkbt

phwkrs pursudbt

th Nkm. Q. Dpp. _.

15(a),

=? dbm =4 th lhrrklt tck ikediiy krrhbkhus mklgsghbs rkbmkrkm ay \klhbm Lgrlugtfumeks Mkbbgs

Fdlhas, Idurd ]dyihr \wdgb, Qdyjhbm F. Ihcgkr, Ekrdrm K. Iyblc,_ktkr U.

Cdii

dbm Mkbby Lcgb,

Qkpuacldb

dpphgbtkm nkmkrdi mgstrglt fumek _.

@kvgbLdstkg

hn tck \hutckrb Mgstrglt hn Bkw

Whr`

dbm tck

prgvdtgzkm, qudsg-fumglgdi nhruj `bhwb ds tck DjkrgldbDragtrdtghbDsshlgdtghb

( DDD ).

_rhlkmurdi

Cgsthry

_rhlkmurdiiy dbm suastdbtgvkiy, tcgs

ldsk

gs hbk hn d`gbm.' HbMklkjakr11, 1?4?,4 suajgttkm d mktdgikm,

3?-pdekLhjpidgbtw g tctck \hutckrb Mgstrglth nBkwWhr`,diikegbe lidgjs hnsystkjgl mgspdrdtk trkdtjkbt,

mgspdrdtkgjpdlt, prk dbm phst-cgrgbe gbmgvgmuditrkdtjkbtdbm rktdigdtghb gb vghidtghb hn \kltghb 4734,]gtik

^ G G BW\CQI dbm BWLCQI dedgbst jy nhrjkr kjpihykr dbm himkst tdikbt

dekbly

gb Chiiywhhm -

Ugi i g dj Jhrrgs Dekbly (bhw `bhwb ds U g i i g dj Jhrrgs Kbmkdvhr Kbtkrtdgbjkbt) - dbm twh hn tck

lhjpdby's Cujdb Qkshurlks pkrshbbki, Fknn Jkdmk dbm \drdcUgbgdrs`g (bhw `bhwb ds \drdc ^db

Chvkb.1

Hb Nkarudry 1;, 1?44,U g i i g djJhrrgs dbm tckgrlhubskijhvkm th mgsjgss jy lhjpidgbt, hr gb tck

ditkrbdtgvk,

shuect

th lhjpki dragtrdtghb

pursudbt

th twh jdbmdthry,

prk-mgsputk

dragtrdtghbderkkjkbtsG

sgebkm ds d lhbmgtghb hn kjpihyjkbt. Hb Jdrlc 14, 1?44, G suajgttkm db hpphsgtghbdi

Jhtghb,

rdgsgbe

ublhbslghbdagigty

dreujkbts adskm

hb tck

lhjpdby's

lkbtury-pius pdttkrb dbm lhbtgbugbe prdltglk hn

kxliumgbe qudigngkm

Dnggldb

Djkrgldbs

nrhj

gts Dekbt, Lhhrmgbdthr dbm Dekbt ]rdgbkk phsgtghbs. Hb Fuiy

1?, 1?44, Qkpuaigldb dpphgbtkm nkmkrdi fumek kbnhrlkm

Ug i i gdjJhrrgs'

dragtrdtghbderkkjkbtdbm

pursudbt

]ck hbiy gdwnuggy dpphgbtkm dragtrdthr gb tcgs

ldsk

- MdvgmI. Erkehry hn tck DjkrgldbDragtrdtghb Dsshlgdtghb -

stdtkm tcrhuechut cgs mklgsghbs6 Gb jy

tcgrty ykdrs

ds db

Dragtrdthr

hn Idahr & Kjpihyjkbt Mgsputks, tcgsldsk

prkskbts

tck jhst kxtkbsgvk

Jh t g h b

prdltglk tcdt G cdvk kblhubtkrkm

PDragtrdthr

Erkehry _drtgdi

Ngbdi Dwdrm,

< Z

R

G ngikmd lhjpidgbtwg tctck KKHL hb

Fubk


4/19

th tck Mkikedtghb _rhvgsghb lhbtdgbkm gb tck sklhbmdragcdtghb derkkjkbt G sgebkm, lhbliumkm tcdt tck

gssuk

hn

dragtrdagigty

cdm th ak mklgmkm ay tck dragtrdthr.

Aktwkkb \kptkjakr1?44 dbmFubk1?41,4

jdmk

nhurdttkjptsthcdvk

Ldstki's

Fuiy 1?, 1?44 \tdy

Hrmkr vdldtkm, aut tck pdbki

fumeks

Ekrdrm K. Iyblc,

_ktkr

U.

Cd i i

dbm Mkbby Lcgb lhbliumkm tcdt tcky

mgm

bhtcdvk

furgsmgltghb

th

mklgmk

db gbtkrihluthry

dppkdi

dbm mkbgkm jy

dppkdi

ds jhht. Hb

Fxjk

4;,

1?41,4 ngikmd Mkjdbm nhr

Dragtrdtghb

wg t ctck Djkrgldb

Dragtrdtghb

Dsshlgdtghb.Dntkrahtc

pdrtgks

lhuim

bht jutudiiy

derkk

hb db dragtrdthr, tck D DD dpphgbtkm Mdvgm I. Erkehry hb Dueust 4, 1?41. Gb tck 4>

jhbtcs tcdt Dragtrdthr Erkehry prksgmkm hvkr tck

ldsk,

ck

gssukm tcrkkGbtkrgj

Mklgsghbs dbm hb Mklkjakr

45, 1?4


5/19

fustglkwhuimak mhbk gb tcgs dltghbdaskbtrklusdi hn tck ubmkrsgebkm. Hb Dp r g i 4?, 1?4=,4 suajgttkm d

,

1?4=,4

ngikm dJhtghbskk gbe th

Jhmgny

Ikwgs' Ngbdi

Dwdrm

muk th tck bujkrhus ndltudi krrhrs dbm

gbdllurdlgks lhbtdgbkm gbtck

Dwdrm.

Hb Fuiy11 ,

1?4=,

ck mkbgkmjyJhtghbaklduskpursudbt thDDDKjpihyjkbt

Quik=?,

tck dragtrdthr

PwdsZ

bht kjphwkrkm th rkmktkrjgbk tck jkrgts ditchuec G

sgjpiy

ds km

cgj trutcnui.

-


6/19

lhbtrdvkbkm puaigl

phigly.

(M`t .Bh. >4)

n

jy jhtghbskk gbe th lhrrklt tcgs jgsldrrgdek h n

fustglk

wds

bhterdbtkm, G ds`km Ldstkg gb tck ditkjdtgvk, th rksthrk jy GN_

stdtus

sh tcdt G

lhuim

suajgt jy dppkdi gb

lhbsgmkrdaik ehhm ndgm g th tck dppkiidtk lhurt. G gbliumkm db upmdtkm, bhtdrgzkmDn n gmdv g t mktdgigbe tcgs

gbnhrjdtghb ds dbkxcgagtth jy Hlthakr ? Nrdum [phb tck LhurtJ h t g h b. kk

Kxcgagt

D.Hb Hlthakr 11, 1?4=, _.@kv gbLdstkg gssukm d twhpdekHrmkr, mkbygbe tck kbtgrkJh t g hb ds

akgbe wgtchut

jkrgt dbm

rknggsgbe

th rksthrk jygb

nhrj p upkrgsstdtus adskm

hb d stdtkjkbt jdmk gb tck

nhhtbhtk

h n

jyJh t gh b . kkKxcgagtA.

Hb

Bhvkjakr

1 4 ,

1?4=,4 ngikmdb Kxpkmgtkm

Jh t g hb

th Qksthrk Gb Nhrjd _dupkrgs \tdtus, \uspkbm

Ng i gbe

Gbfubltghb

dbm Qkjhvk D i i _rkfumglk _kbmgbe Ehhm Ndgtc Dppkdi, Hr Gb tckDitkjdtgvk,

^gtgdtk

D i iHrmkrs Qkbmkrkm Ay _.

@kvgb

Ldstkg dbm tck D D D Muk th Nrdum [phb tck Lhurt dbm Nrdum [phb

tck Lhurt, Ay tck Lhurt pursudbt th Nkm. Q. Dpp. _. 3,R 1=,R & => dbm

Ihldi

Quiks 1=.4,R=>.1 dbm =>.


7/19

Lcgb ak mgsqudigngkm.' Qkedrmikss hn wch mklgmks dby dspklthn tcgs dppkdi, G ds` tcdt tck ngbmkr hn

rkjdgb

gjpdrtgdi dbm gbmkpkbmkbt. 4 dish ds` tck dppkiidtk lhurtgssukdb ktcgldi dbm hafkltgvk

fumglgdi

hpgbghb wcglc

mgslusskstck dreujkbts hnahtcpdrtgks

akldusk

tcgs

Jht ghb

- ig`ktck idst tcrkk

tcdt wkrk suajgttkm th _.

@kvgb

Ldstkg - mkjhbstrdtks tcdt mkspgtk tck

stdtkjkbts

dbm fumejkbts hn _.

@kvgb

Ldstkg, tck Djkrgldb

Dragtrdtghb

Dsshlgdtghb,][email protected],Ihka & IhkaII_ , Jglcdki

_.

Vwkge,

LcrgstgdbLdrahbk, ktl., jy dppkdi,

g n

bkkm ak suajgttkm,

whuim

bht ak

nrgvhihus

dbm

whuim

dltudiiyak jdmk gb kxtrkjk ehhm

ndgtc. '

Hb Jdrlc 44 ,

1?4;, pdbki fumeks Mkbbgs

Fdlhas,

Qdyjhbm F. Ihcgkr, Fr. dbm

mgstrglt

fumek Idurd

]dyihr \wdgb mkbgkm jy dppkdi gb twh skbtkblks, krrhbkhusiy lhbliumgbe tcdt jy dppkdi idl`PkmZ db

dreudaik

adsgs

kgtckr gb idw hr gb ndlt.

kk

Kxcgagt

L .

Ig`kLdstkg, tck \klhbm

Lgrlugt

jdmk bh jkbtghb hn

jylidgjs hn nrdum uphb tck Lhurt.

Dppkiidtk Qkvgkw hn Jhtghb _ursudbtNkm.Q. Dpp. _. 15(a), =? & =4.

_ursudbt th Nkm. Q. Dpp. _. 15(a), D pdrty dmvkrskiy dnnkltkm ay tck lhurt's...dltghb jdy

ngik

djhtghb th

rklhbsgmkr, vdldtk, hr

jhmgny

tcdtdltghb. _ursudbt th Nkm. Q.

Dpp.

_=?(d)(1),d

Jh t ghb

nhr rklhbsgmkrdtghb

just stdtk

wgtc

pdrtgluidrgtykdlc phgbt hnidwhr ndlt tcdt tck pktgtghbkr akigkvks tck lhurt cds hvkrihh`km

hrjgsdpprkckbmkm dbm just dreuk gb supphrt

h n

tck

pktgtghb.

_ursudbt th NQD_


8/19

\gblktck gblkptghbhn

tgbsldsk

nkmkrdi fumek_. @kvgb Ldstkgcds gssukm ngvk,hbk-sgmkmHrmkrs.\gblkG'j

igjgtkm th 4;pdeks Gnhlushb twh pdrtgluidr

drkds

thschwwcy

Ldstkg

dbm tck

\klhbmLgrlugt's

lhbliusghbs

drk krrhbkhus6 '

P_. @kvgb

Ldstkg

Krrkm Ay Mktkrjgbgbe

Dragtrdthr

_drtgdi Ngbdi Dwdrm Uds Bht QkvgkwdaikZ Gb

Ldstki's

\kptkjakr

;, 1?4=

Hrmkr,

ck

lhbliumkm tcdt Erkehry's

_drtgdiNgbdiDwdrm wds bht

rkvgkwdaik

ay

rkiygbe hbiy hb hbk ldsk- Jglcdkis v. Jdrgnhruj \cgppgbe, \.D., >1= N.1m =44, =4= (1m Lgr. 473?).'-R

Fdjks

Edgtgscds puacsckmtwh gbnhrjdtgvk dbm kxtrkjkiy gbsgectnggi idw drtglikshbtcgs thpgl,dbm gt gs

likdrtcdt

Jglcdkis

gs bht

lhbtrhiigbe.

G t gs wkii

skttikm

tcdt

bhb-njdi

dragcdi mklgsghbs dbm

gbtkrihluthry

dragtgdi

dwdrms (k.e.,

Gbtkrgj Mklgsghbs dbm _drtgdiNgbdiDwdrms )cdvk akkbmkkjkmrkvgkwdaik ay tck

nkmkrdi

lhurtsgblk

Jglcdkis. \kk k.e..

]rdmk

& ]rdbsphrt. Gbl. v.Bdturdi_ktrhikuj Lcdrtkrkrs.Gbl.. 7

Dj .

Qkv.

G b t ' i

Dra. 4, 1??>.

\kk k.e.. Mkdikr Lhjputkr \krvglks, Gbl. v. Mua Ckrrgbe Nhrm. ;=5 N.tc Lgr. 1??3) (lhurt hndppkdis

lhbliumkm tcdt db gbtkrihluthry dragtrdi mklgsghb tcdt wds bhtnjdi jgectbhbktckikssak suafklt th gjjkmgdtkfumglgdi

rkvgkwadskmhb d ngbmgbehn rgpkbkss)0 Dbmrkd Mhrkkb, I t m . v.AugimgbeJdtkrgdi Ihldi[bghb131. 1;? N. \upp. 1m

4?5 (K .M.B.W. 1??(d)(4)(M) hn tck ND D

wcglc stdtks

tcdt

db dppkdi ldb ak td kb nrhj db hrmkr...lhbngrjgbehr mkbygbe lhbngrjdtghb hn db dwdrm hr pdrtgdi dwdrm. (kjpcdsgs

dmmkm)

->-


9/19

]ck ndlts hntcgs

ldsk'R

dbm tckprkvdgigbeidw supphrt tcdt Erkehry's _drtgdiNgbdi

Dwdrm

wds ahtc

r p

dbm

ngbdi

nhr tck

sd`k

hn gjjkmgdtkfumglgdi rkvgkw. \gblk ahtc pdrtgks cdm mgslrkpdblgks w g t c tck

Dwdrmdbm Erkehry, tckhbiypkrshb

w g t c

dutchrgty dbmfurgsmgltghbth rkshivktchsk gssuks,wds _. @kvgb

Ldstkg, aut ck rknuskm th mh sh

akldusk

4wds kbtkrgbe th tck lhurtw g t cd ndvhrdaik

mklgsghb.

4cdvk

stgii

akkbiugdaik th njm hbkldskgbwcglcdb dragtrdthr cds vdldtkm mgk

Dwdrm

hn

dbhtggkr

dragtg-dthr dbm G bhw

tcgslhbstgtutks d

vghidtghb

hn muk

prhlkssakldusk

Ckdtckr

\dbth

hn tck

D D D

gbnhrjkm ahtc pdrtgks tcdttck

rkpidlkjkbt dragtrdthrwhuimbhtvdldtkdby hnErkehry's mklgsghbs. DntkrIkwgs wds dpphgbtkm, tcgswds

tck ngrst

tcgbe

Ihka & Ihka II_ jhvkm nhr Ikwgs th mh. \gblk Erkehry's

Dwdrm

wds rkvgkwdaik ay tck

nkmkrdi lhurt, hbiy tck nkmkrdi lhurt cdmfurgsmgltghb th lhbnbj, jhmgny dbm/hr vdldtkcgs Dwdrm dbm

mktkrjgbk wcktckr hrbhtck schuim ak mgsqudigngkm. \gblk tcgs mgm bht cdppkb, dii mklgsghbs rkbmkrkm ay

\lcbdmkr

I I_

dtthrbky]gjhtcy@ .Ikwgs schuim akvgtgdtkmdbm dii jhbgks rklkgvkm schuim ak pdgm thjk.

P_. @kvgb Ldstki's Hrmkrs Bkvkr Mgsluss

Lidgjs

tcdt Ihka & Ihka

I I _

dbm gts Dtthrbkys Cdvk

Kbedekm gb d _dttkrb hn Nrdum[phb tckLhurt ZHbk hn tckgssukstcdt Ldstkg bkvkr dmmrksskmj

cgs \kptkjakr ;, 1?4= dbm Hlthakr 11, 1?4= Hrmkrs, wkrk jy lidgjs tcdt Ihka & IhkaI I_wkrk kbedegbe

gbd pdttkrb hn nrdum uphb tck Lhurt hb

Ug i i g dj

Jhrrgs'akcdin'R ]cksklidgjs wkrk

gbg t gdi iy

arhuect

thtck \klhbm Lgrlugt's dttkbtghb gb jytcgrmdbm

nhurtcdppkdis

ngikm gb 1?41.

Gb

sujjdry hnQhwk6

Qhwk dbm

Dragnrdthr Mdvgm

I. Erkehry's

Gbtkrgj

Mklgsghbs Qkedrmgbe

Kxcgagt

hn

jy

Hlthakr


10/19

Qhskbtcdi I I _ (bhw bhwbds MkbthbsI I _ ) lhbspgrkm

w g t c

dtthrbkys nhr tckAhh`gbe

Dekbly Mknkbmdbts - Ihka & Ihka II_ dbm

Uk g i

Ehtscdi & Jdbeks II_ - gb db

ublhbslghbdaik slckjkth lhblkdi dby rdlgdi mkrhedthry tkrjs/sjh`gbe eub kvgmkblk

nrhj

akgbe rkvkdikm wkrk truk. Gb

Dragtgdthr

Erkehry's ngrst

Gbtkrgj

Mklgsghb, ck ds`km

ahtc

pdrtgks th suajgt jhrk gbnhbbdtghb dahut Kxcgagt Ai 's dutckbtglgty dbm

rkikvdblk. Gbrksphbsk th tck pdrtgks Fubk 4;, 1?4< suajgssghb. Dragtrdthr Erkehry

dmjgttkm Kxcgagt

? Nrdum [phb tck Lhurt hb

Bhvkjakr 3, 1?41 ds akgbe

nui i

hn

cht

dgr dbm pdrdbhgm suspglghbs.

Mkspgtk lhbliumgbe tcdt dii hn jy ikedi dreujkbts drk

wgtchut

jkrgt, bhbk hn

_ . @kvgbLdstki's

idst tcrkk Hrmkrs mgsluss jy lidgjs hn nrdum uphb tck Lhurt. ' ' Ldstki's Hrmkrs dish bkvkr mgsluss

diikedtghbs tcdt Ihka & Ihka II_

cdvk

lhjjgttkm bujkrhus vghidtghbs ubmkr tck Bkw

Whr`

Quiks hn

_rhnkssghbdi LhbmultR dbm BkwWhr`Fumglgdry Idw 35ds d rksuit

hn

tckgr

cgeciy

ubktcgldi dbm

lrgjgbdi

lhbmult. Ay

rknggsgbe

th dl`bhwikmek jy lidgjs hn dtthrbky jgslhbmult, Ldstkgvghidtkmjy lhbstgtutghbdi

rgect th mukprhlksswckb ck gebhrkm jy Jdrlc 45, 1?4= Jht ghbdbm thimjk th lhbtgbuk dragtrdtgbe tck

ldskdedgbst lhubski tcdt wds kbedegbe gb nrdum.R' ]ck \klhbm

Lgrlugt

cds dish gebhrkm

tcksk

lidgjs.

Dmmgtghbdiiy, Ldstkg bhr tck \klhbm

Lgrlugt

rkshivkm tck ktcgldi

gssuks

tcdt wkrk lrkdtkm

nrhj

Lcrgstgdb

Ldrahbk's

ndgiurk th mgslihsk gbnhrjdtghb dahut cgs jdrrgdek th db kxklutgvk nhr tck Djkrgldb

Ditchuec Dragtrdthr

Erkehry wdsubidwnuiiy mgsqudigngkm, cgs mklgsghb th dmjgt tcgs lhblkdikm kvgmkblk gbth tck

kvgmkblk hn rklhrm lhuim bht ak hvkrturbkm ubmkr tck mhltrgbk hnlhiidtkrdiksthppki.

Ditchuec

Ikwgs wdsubidwnuiiy

dpphgbtkm, ck mgm bht

vdldtk

dby hn Erkehry's GbtkrgjMklgsghbs. ]cgslrkdtksdb dmmcghbdi

rkdshb

wcy Ikwgs krrkm

ds d jdttkr hn

idw

gb lhbliumgbe tcdt dragtrdtghb wds tckhbiy nhruj jyldsklhuim ak rkshivkm.

R

_ursudbt th Quik 3.= hn tck Bkw

Whr`

Quiks hn _rhnkssghbdi Lhbmult, d idwykr hr idw

ngrj

scdii bht6 (d) vghidtk hr

dttkjpt th vghidtk tck Quiks hn _rhnkssghbdi Lhbmult,

`bhwgbeiy dssgst

hr gbmulk dbhtckr th mh sh, hr mh sh tcrhuec

tck

dlts

hn dbhtckr0 (a)

kbedek

gb

giikedi

lhbmult tcdt dmvkrskiy rkniklts hb tck idwykr's chbksty, trustwhrtcgbkss hr

ngtbkss ds d idwykr0 (l)

kbedek

gb lhbmult

gbvhivgbe

mgschbksty, nrdum, mklkgt hr jgsrkprkskbtdtghb0 (m)

kbedek

gb

lhbmult tcdt gs prkfumglgdi th tck dmjgbgstrdtghb

h nfustglk

hr (k)

stdtk

hr

gjpiy

db

dagig ty6

(4) th gbniukblk gjprhpkriy

hr uphb grrkikvdbt erhubms dby

trgaubdi,

ikegsidtgvk ahmy hr puaigl

hnnglgdi 0

hr (1) th dlcgkvk rksuits usgbe

jkdbs

tcdt

vghidtk

tcksk

Quiks hr htckr idw.

R'

Gt gs

wk i i

skttikm tcdt d jhtghb th mgsqudigny d idw

ngrj

dbm/hr db dtthrbky nhr purphrtkm vghidtghbs hn prhnkssghbdi

ruiks hn ktcgls, ldb

hbiy

ak mklgmkm ay tck nkmkrdi lhurt, bht dragtrdthrs.R' Agmkrjdbb Gbmustrgks Iglkbsgbe. Gbl. v.

DvjdrB.^..

;5?

B.W.\.1m


11/19

Dragtrdtghb

Dsshlgdtghb,RR ag jy Hlthakr


12/19

purphsks hn

Lhberkss

th kigjgbdtk tck gblhbvkbgkblk, ubndgrbkss dbm cujgigdtghb hn

Pubidwng g i Z

mgslrgjgbdtghb. Ad`kr v. \cgdrt Arhdmldstgbe Lh., ;>? N.1m


13/19

kjpihykm. kk

Kxcgagt

N

Gt thh` 4?4

ykdrs

nhr tck ngrst

Dnrgldb

Djkrgldb Dekbt ]rdgbkk th ak prhjhtkm

th

ngij

Dekbt. ]ckrk cds bkvkr akkb db

Dnrgldb

Djkrgldb tkikvgsghb Dekbt kjpihykm gb tck Bkw Whr`

hnnglk. Gt ldbbht ak mgsputkm tcdt G wds kxtrkjkiy jhrk qudigngkm tcdb dii hn jy

sgjgidriy

sgjdtkm

wcgtk/ Fkwgsc

lhubtkrpdrts gb tck Dekbt ]rdgbkk prherdj, aut tcky dii dmvdblkm dahvk jk. kk

Kxcgagt

E

Gt ldbbht ak mgsputkm tcdt

wcgik wcgtk/

Fkwgsc Dekbt ]rdgbkks wkrk prhjhtkm dt d rdtk hn 4? pkrlkbt,

aidl`s kjpihykm gb tck BkwWhr`

hnnglk

cdvk akkb prhjhtkm dt d rdtk hn zkrh pkrlkbt sgblk 1???.

]cgscgsthrgldi dbm stdtgstgldi kvgmkblk dihbk kstda[sckstcdt G kbtkrkm gbthd lhjpdby tcdt wds

dirkdmy

vghidtgbe

]gmk ^GG hn tck

L g v g i

Qgects Dlt hn 47>=.RR ]ck Dppkiikks cdvk bkvkr prhvgmkm d

ikegtgjdtk,bhb-mgslrgjgbdthry rkdshb hr

ausgbkssfustgngldtghb

th kxpidgb wcy G wds tck

hbiy Dnrgldb

Djkrgldbgb BkwWhr`

Lg ty

mkkjkm

qudigngkm

kbhuec th ak cgrkm dt dby

ikvki

hn tck lhjpdby's Dekbt

]rdgbkk prherdj. Gb d whr`pidlk wckrk hllupdtghbs drk skerkedtkm ayrdlkdbm tck luiturk gs mknjkm dihbe

rdlgdiigbks, gt ldbbht ak mgsputkm tcdt jdbyh njylhiikdeuks cdrahrkm gjpi gl g trdlgdi

agdsks

dbm ds d rksuit,

jdby hn

jy

kvdiudtghbs wkrk tdgbtkm ay rdlgdi agds. Kvkb gb cgs

Jdrlc

4?, 1?4; Qkphrt gssukm gb Lckb-

Hstkr, Jdegstgdtk

Fumek

Nrdblgs wds daik th dl`bhwikmek tck rkdigtgks hnmgslrgjgbdtghb gb tck Djkrgldb

whr`pidlk.

Ck stdtkm, Hn lhursk, gb dby idrek hredbgzdtghb, tckrk w g i i ak shjk, pkrcdpsjdby, gbstdblks

h n

mgslrgjgbdthrylhbmult, wcktckr ay supkgvgshrs hr ay lh-whr`krs. Cdm tck

ldsk

rkjdgbkm gb tck nkmkrdi

lhurt, Nrdblgs

whuim

cdvk lhbliumkm tcdt skbtkblk ay sdygbe, PU g i i g dj JhrrgsZ cds prkskbtkm PbhZ

kvgmkblk tcdt gttd`ks

stkps

th lhubtkrdlt gbstdblks hnPrdlgdiZagds.

G t

wds likdr

nrhj

tck akegbbgbe, tcdt dragtrdtghb wds db gbdpprhprgdtk

nhrj

th dlcgkvk tck puaigl

phiglyehdis hn]gmk ^ G Gdbm tcdt dldskhn

tcgs

jdebgtumk

whuim

rkdlc tck \uprkjk Lhurt, tckrknhrk, gt mgm

bhtjdttkr wcdt tck mklgsghbs hn tck ihwkr lhurts wkrk. Gt mgm jdttkr, chwkvkr, g n jy dppkdi wds mkbgkm

]ck Dppkiikksbkvkrjkt tckgr ckgectkbkm aurmkb hnprhmultghbdbmpkrsudsghb. Murgbemgslhvkry, tcky rknuskm th

prhmulk dby rkikvdbt mhlujkbts (k.e.

rksujks,

kvdiudtghbs, ktl.) th supphrt tck dreujkbts jdmk dedgbst jk. ]cky

bkvkr prhmulkm tck ubmkriygbe k-jdgis th

Kxcgagt

1 N.


14/19

wgtchut

kxpidbdtghb hr mgslussghb hn jy ikedi

drerubkbts sgblk

G'vk spkbtd lhbsgmkrdaik djhubt hn tgjk

dbm kbkrey stumygbe tck idw dbm dmvdblgbe tckskikedidreujkbtsgb ehhm

ndgtc.

Ucdtjd`kstck dltghbs

h n

tcgs pdbki sh mgsturagbe dbm nrustrdtgbe, gs tcdt tcgs pdbki wds lhjprgskm hn twh gbmgvgmudis hn

Dnrgldb

mkslkbt.

]cky wkrk gb tck

akst

phsgtghb th kxpidgb th jk wcyD I I hn

jy

ikedi

dreujkbtswkrkkrrhbkhus,

pdrtgluidriytchsklhblkrbgbe tck L gv g iQgects Dlt hn 47>=. Wkt, tcky

lchsk

bht th.

\gblk suajgttgbe jy idst pikdmgbe

wgtc

tck

\klhbm

Lgrlugt hb Mklkjakr 4;, 1?4=, d bujakr hn

tcgbescdvk cdppkbkm shlgdiiy tcdt nurtckr supphrt jy lidgjs hngbstgjtghbdigzkmrdlgsjdedgbstUgicdj

JhrrgsdbmChiiywhhm,gb dmmgtghb th lidgjs hn tckkctkidwngrj Ihka & Ihka II_ kbedegbe gb nrdum. Hb

Nkarudry 1;, 1?4;, tck

I Ukk`iy

puaigsckm db gb-mkptc drtglik

tgtikm

Chw

Chiiywhhm@kkps

Jgbhrgtgks

Hut. R'

kk Kxcgagt C

Hbk hn tck jkjhrdaik quhtks

nrhj

tck drtglik gbliumk6 Chiiywhhm's mgvkrsgty

bujakrsdrkshjkhn tck whrst hn dby gbmustry. Hb tcdtsdjkmdy, [ L I DprhnksshrsMr.Mdrbkii Cubt dbm

Mr.

Dbd-Lcrgstgbd Qdjhb

rkikdskm

tckgr dbbudi rkphrt hb Ptck idl` hnZ mgvkrsgty tcrhuechut tck

skejkbts

hn

Chiiywhhm.R kkKxcgagt

G

]cksk

drtgliks dbm rkphrtsauttrkssjy systkjgl

mgspdrdtk

trkdtjkbt,

mgspdrdtk

gjpdlt, prk-cgrgbe gbmgvgmudimgspdrdtktrkdtjkbt dreujkbts, ds wk i iauttrkssjy dbtgtrust dbm lhbspgrdly

lidgjs ay schwgbe tcdt tcgs prhaikj gs gbstgtutghbdigzkm, systkjgl, pkrvdsgvk dbm bht

i gjg tkm

th Ug i i g dj

Jhrrgs.

G

dish

ikdjkm tcdt Ihka & Ihka II_ wds rkprkskbtgbe d Mkbthbs dtthjky

gbvhivgbe

lidgjs hn

dtthrbky nrdum. R' Dbm idstiy, hb PJdrlc 4


15/19

lhjpidgbt diikegbe nrdum, rdl`ktkkrgbe dbm ikedi jdiprdltglk

dedgbst

cgs nhrjkr lhubski

Ugick

Edry dbm tck

Ug i i g kEdry IdwNgrj.

\gblk tcgs

ldsk

gs hn kxtrkjk shlgdi sgebgngldblk dbm

mkdis

w g t cd bujakr hn

gssuks

tcdt drk hnngrst

gjprkssghb nhr tck mgstrglt, dppkiidtk dbm\uprkjkLhurt, gt wds gjphrtdbt nhr tck dppkiidtk lhurt

gssuk

db

ktcgldi

fumglgdi

hpgbghb dbm kxpidgb tck idw th tcgs prh sk bhb-dtthrbky.RR ]ck dlt hn

wrg t gbe

argbes

fumeks

lihskr th tck spklgngl mktdgis dbm rkikvdbt

gssuks

hn d

ldsk,

nhrlgbe tckj th rkl`hb w g t ctck

ldsk

dt cdbm gb

dii gts pdrtgluidrs, rdtckr tcdb skkgbegt ds db

jstdblk

hn

shjk

jhrk ekbkrdi tckhry hr prhaikj. RR G n jy

dppkdi

truiy

idl`PkmZ dbdreudaikadsgskgtckr gb idw hr gb ndlt, tckb chw wds Dragnrdthr Erkehrydaikth

lhbliumk tcdt U g i i g dj Jhrrgs Kbmkdvhr Kbtkrtdgbjkbt II_ mgslrgjgbdtkm

dedgbst

PjkZ gb

vghidtghb

hn

pkrtgbkbt nkmkrdi,

stdtk

dbm ihldi idw prhcgagtgbe mgslrgjgbdtghb gb kjpihyjkbt hb tck

adsgs

h nrdlk dbm

dwdrm jk tck

ngg[

edjut

h n

jhbktdry

mdjdeks8

Chw wds ckdish daikth dmjgt lhblkdikm kvgmkblk gbth tck

kvgmkblk hn rklhrm gb jy

ldsk

dbm wcy

cdsb't

tcdt

akkb

jkbtghbkm ay tck mgstrglt hr dppkiidtk lhurt8 Ds

[.\.

Drt gl ik G G G nkmkrdi

fumeks

hn

Dng gldb mkslkbt.

\wdgb dbm Ihcgkr wkrk gb tck

akst

phsgtghb th kxpidgb

wcy

Ug i i g djJhrrgs gs bht, dbm cds bht, vghidtkm nkmkrdi,

stdtk,

dbm ihldi idw

prhcgagtgbe

mgslrgjgbdtghb gb

kjpihyjkbt hb tckadsgshnrdlk dbm wcy tckgr cgsthrgldi pdttkj dbm prdltglk hnrdlk-adskmkxliusghb gs

grrkikvdbt

mkspgtk tckrk

akgbe

zkrhDng gldb

Djkrgldb Dekbt ]rdgbkks, Lhhrmgbdthrs hr Dekbts kjpihykm gb

tck BkwWh r`hnnglk wckb Gakedbwckb Gakedbgb\kptkjakrhn 1??3.

DFgnyd ^. Lurtgb, Ekrdim Ikahvgtz & Igsd \hihjhb. Ktcgldi Fumglgdi HpgbghbUr g t gbe . ]ck Ekhrekthwb Fhujdi hn

Ikedi Ktcgls.

^h i .

14, 1


16/19

]h

mkby jy dppkdi

wgmghut

rkshivgbe tck

gssuk

hn nrdum uphb tck Lhurt

mkjhbsnrdtks

tcdt tck

pdbki gs kbedegbe gb suafkltgvk, gmkhihegldi mklgsghb-jd`gbe.

RR

]cus jy dppkdi schuim ak nrdbsnkrrkm.

Adskm hb dii hn tck ndlts dbm lgrlujstdblks, gt gs likdr tcdt Ihka & Ihka II_ schuim cdvkbkvkr akkb

diihwkm

th

rkprkskbtUg[gdjJhrrgs

gb tcgs

ldsk

dbm drk akgbe ubfustiy kbrglckm

nrhj

tckgr

cgeciy

ubktcgldi

dbmlrgjgbdilhbmult. Ay mkbygbe jy jkrgthrghus dppkdi wgtchut kxpidbdtghb hr mgslussghb

h n

ahtc pdrtgks'

ikedi dreujkbts, tck \klhbm Lgrlugtgs kbedegbe gb nrdum gb hrmkr th mkprgvk jk

h njy

rgects ubmkr tck lhihr

h n idw. @bhwgbe

tcdt tck

\uprkjk

Lhurt

dllkpts ikss

tcdb hbk pkrlkbt hn tck pktgtghbs tcdt drk ngikm

kdlc

ykdr,

tck \klhbm

Lgrlugt

gssukm db gjprhvgmkbt mklgsghb gb hrmkr prkfumglk jy

pktgtghb

nhr dwrg t

h nlkrtghrdrg

w g t ctck\uprkjkLhurt sgblk4 whuimak ehgbe gbth tck\uprkjkLhurt wg tctcrkkwcgtkwdsckm dbm hbk

sgmkm njdi mklgsghbs

nrhj

tck ihwkr lhurts dbm tck DDD dii gb ndvhr hn

Ug[gdj

Jhrrgs. ]cus, nhr d

bujakr hn ubfust

rkdshbs,

tcgs lhuim vkry wk[ ak jy idst

rkdi

hpphrtubgty th lcdiikbek tck

krrhbkhus

mklgsghbs hn_.

@kv gb

Ldstkg dbm tck

D D D

dbm tckdppk[dtklhurt schuim rkshivk tckgssukssuajgttkm.RR

A y

supprkssgbe tck trutc dbm gssugbe d tchuectikss Hrmkr, tck \klhbmLgrlugtcdsmhbkd mgsskrvglk

th hur bdtghb.4cdvk akkbubkjpihykm nhr bkdriy ngvkykdrs.Jy rkputdtghb dbmigvkigchhmcdvk akkbrugbkm.

dji gvgbeakihw tck phvkrty ikvki dbm dj

s t g i i

i gvgbehut hn tck twh

sugtldsks

G jhvkm th BkwWhr w g tc .

\gblk pursgbe tcgs

ldsk

dedgbst

U[igdj Jhrrgs,

G cdvk spkbt jhrk tcdb $1,=??.?? hb vdrghus

lhsts

dsshlgdtkm wg tctcgs

ig t gedtghb

dbm bhw, G'j sh arh`k, tcdt gb hrmkr th suajgt tcgs Jht ghb ,4cdm th ahrrhw

jhbky

nrhj ndjgiy

gb hrmkr th

purlcdsk

gb` sh tcdt

4

lhuim

prgbt

hut tcgs

Jh t gh b

dbm pdy nhr gblrkdskm lhst

h n

tck Jktghldrm sh tcdt

4

lhuim ngikmggs

Jh t gh b

wg tctck

lhgut.R*'

]ck rkdigty gs, G schuimb't ak i gvgbeakihw

tck phvkrty ikvkirgectbhw. Ig`kDragtgdthrErkehry, G akigkvk db

gjpdrtgdi

f g u y whuimcdvkdwdrmkm jk

adl` pdy, nrhbt pdy, lhjpkbsdthry & pubgtgvkmdjdeksdbm rkdshbdaiknkksdbm lhsts,ds d prh sk bhb-

dj

dish

bhw

dwdrk

tcdt igtgedbts drk diihwkm db gbmkpkbmkbt

ldusk

hn dltghb nhr nrdum uphb tck Lhurt pursudbt

th Nkm. Q. Lgv. _. >?(m) - kvkb g tck mgstrglt lhurt

mkbgks

jy Nkm. Q. Lgv. _. >? lidgjs - sh tcgs nurtckr supphrts tcdt

Ldstkg

dauskm

cgs phwkr ay gssugbe d ng i gbe gbfubltghb dedgbst jk th prkvkbt jk

nrhj

pursgbe lidgjs.

\kk k.e.

Mkjfdbfu`

v. _ktrhvs`y. 4? N.


17/19

dtthjky

prkvdgigbe pdrty hb stdtuthry lidgjs gb d

ldsk

hn lhbsgmkrdaik prhlkmurdi dbm suastdbtgvk

lhjpikxgty. G dishakigkvk tcdt gb d

skpdrdtk

ldsk db gjpdrtgdi fury whuim dishlhbliumk tcdt Ugiigdj

Jhrrgs, Ihka&Ihka II_, Jglcdki _. Vwkge dbm htckrs

cdvk kbedekm

gb d

pdttkj

hn nrdum uphb tck

Lhurt

gb

hrmkr

th

prkvkbt

db gjpdrtgdi fury nrhj

ckdrgbe

dbm

mklgmgbe

tckjkrgtshn jy

lidgjs.

]cgsldskprkskbtsd

bujakr

h n

gssuks

hn ngrstgjprkssghbdbm gb jy Dppigldtghb thDppkdiGbNhrjd

_dupkrgs, G

gbliumkm

dbujakr hn qukstghbs

tcdt

whuim ak

rdgskm

gb jy dppkdi. kk Kxcgagt D8RG n

tcgs

Jhtghb gsmkbgkmPwgmghutkxpidbdtghbZ,G ds tck

mkbgdi

akgssukmbhidtkr tcdbDprgi dbmtcdttckjdbmdtk

ak stdykm wcgik G

rdgsk

tcksk gssukswgtc tck

\uprkjkLhurt.

G

cdvkgbliumkmshjk

hn tck bhtksG

jdmk

hvkrtck idstwkk`.]cgs

mhlujkbt

w g i i

uitgjdtkiyskrvk

ds tck nhubmdtghb nhr jy pktgtghb th tck \uprkjk

Lhurt

schuimGcdvkth

ngik.

kk Kxcgagt F

Lhbliusghb

Nhr tck nhiihwgberkdshbsmgslusskm dahvkdbm tcrhuechuttckidstngvkpikdmgbessuajgttkmth tck

\hutckrb

Mgstrglt hn Bkw Whr` dbm \klhbmLnrlugt, Gprdy

mgdt

tck dppkiidtk

lhurtvdldtks

tck

Jdrlc

44, 1?4; Hrmkr

gssukmay

pdbki

fumeks

Fdlhas \wdgb

dbm Ihcgkrdbm

usks

gts

gbckrkbt

phwkrsth

kgtckr

trdbsnkrtck dppkdi

thdbhtckrlgrlugt hr

erdbt

tckkxtrdhrmgbdryrkigknrkqugrkmth

lhrrklttcgskxtrkjks jgsldrrgdek

h n

fustglk

hblk

dbm nhr dii.

R

Hbk hn tck jhst gjphrtdbt

gssuks

tcdt

w g i i

ak rdgskm th tck \uprkjk Lhurt lhblkrbs tck

ikedigty

hn rkstrgltgbe

gbmgvgmudi

igtgedbts

h n

kjpihyjkbtmgslrgjgbdtghbldsks

n rhj gblhrphrdtgbe

lidgjs hn systkjgl mgspdrdtk trkdtjkbt dbm

mgspdrdtk gjpdlt th prhvkmgslrgjgbdtghbadskmhb rdlk, lhihr, bdtghbdi

h r g eg b

hr dby htckr prhtkltkm lcdrdltkrgstgl. Gb

tck

Jdrlc

4?, 1?4; Qkphrt dbm Qklhjjkbmdtghb hn JdegstrdtkFumekFdjksL. Nrdblgs gb Lckb-Hstkr v. Ehimjdb

\dlcs, Gbl., LdskBh. 4?->7;?

(\ . M. B. W. ) , rknrgsgbe

th rklhjjkbm

lkrtgngldtghb

hn tck lidsshn whjkb diikegbe

systkjgl mgspdrdtk trkdtjkbt adskm hb ekbmkr, ck stdtkm6 Gb d mgspdrdtk trkdtjkbt lidssdltghb (tchuec bht gb db

gbmgvgmudildsk),tckpidgbtgnnsjdy prkskbt kvgmkblkadskmhb 'pdttkj-hr-prdltglk.' Dish,G w g i i lcdiikbek tck nkmkrdi

lhurt's rknusdi th dppiydbtgmgslrgjgbdtghbidww g t c g btck nrdjkwhr h ntck NkmkrdiDragtrdtghbDlt th mktkrjgbkgssuks

h n ublhbslghbdagigty

dbm lhbtrdlt kbnhrlkdagigty, sgblk tck Lhurt cds rkngfskm th

kxpiglg t iy

rkshivk tcgs

gssuk

dbm tck

\kvkbtc

Lgrlugt

gb H'Qkedb v.DragtrdtghbNhjjs. Gbl. 1=> N.


18/19

Mdtkm6 BkwWhr`,BkwWhr`

Jdrlc1;, 1?4;

Qkspkltnuiiy suajgttkm.

y ^ i u F R R R a

Jdrlus

G

Udscgbethb

;= Ahkruj \t. Dpt. >J

Arhh`iyb,

BW 441?>

>=>)

;?=->=75

cujdbrgects. drkdjust eejdgi.


19/19

[BG]K M \]D]K\ LH[Q] HN D__KDI\ NHQ ] C K \KLHBM LGQL[G]

L D _ ] G H B 6

Jdrlus sdgdc Udscgbethb

y

Ug[gdj Jhrr gs Kbmkdvhr Kbtkr td gbjkbt

I I L 0 Fkn n Jkdmk dbm \dr dc Ugbgdrs` g

LKQ] G N G LD]K HN

\ KQ^ GLK

Mhl`ktBujakr6

4= -=

washington v. william morris endeavor entertainment, llc et al. (14-4328) -- emergency motion for...

Documents