washington v. william morris endeavor enterainment et al. -- claimant's emergency motion to order...

7/27/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Enterainment et al. -- Claimant's Emergency Motion to Order Respondents

1/11

C A I X M @ C L C X H M T X C T M G L C P P G @ M C T M G L

- VACX@YP M P C M C F _CPFMLOTGL,

C C C @csi Lg. 30 35: :3485 38

@ncmaclt,-cocmlst-

_ M N N M C A AGXXMP ILDICUGXILTIX TCMLAILT, N N @ , egl-lirny klgwl cs tfi_ M N N M C A AGXXMP COIL@], ML@. ,BIEE A I C D I cld P C X C F U C L F G U I L ,

@ N C M A C L T ' P I A I X O I L @ ] A G T M G LE G X G X D I X T G @ G A Z I NX I P Z G L D I L T P T G @ G A Z N ] _ M T FD M P @ G U I X ] X I S Y I P T P CLDX I S Y I P T E G X P C L @ T M G L P E G XX I P Z G L D I L T P ' D M P @ G U I X ] C H Y P I P .D I A C L D E G X G X C N F I C X M L O .

Xispgldilts. - V

Ml tfi tfmrd Mltirma Di`msmgl ge Crhmtrctgr Dcvmd N. Oriogry, fi stctid2 "@ncmaclt sfcnn emrst suhamt tg ai hyAgldcy, G`tghir ?, 8:Q 0 cl mtiamzid nmst ge tfi prgbi`tid ricsglchni `gsts cssg mctid wmtf tfms ritrmivcn [ g e "iacmns`gltcmlid gl _AI's 3==6-3=== hc`k up tcpi[sQ"Q. Tfisi dgùailts aust hi suhamttid cld cpprgvid hy ai prmgrtg cly wgrk piregraid hy tfi idms`gviry ixpirt." [po. 0.Q Dui tg tfi `gltuac mgus cld "hcd ecmtf" `gldu`t ge_mn n m ca Agrrms, Ngih & Ngih NNZ cld cttgrliys Am`fcin Z. Rwimo, @frmstmcl @crhgli cld Am`fcin Hcrlitt, M caniet wm tf lg `fgmì hut tg suhamt tfms agtmgl tg csk Crhmtrctgr Oriogry tg `gapin tfi Xispgldilts tg `gapny wm tfay prinmamlcry i-dms`gviry riquists cld mlm t mcn riquists egr prgdu tmgl ge dgùailts. M cnsg csk tfct CrhmtrctgrOriogry mssui aglitcry scl tmgls Xispgldilts cld tfimr `gulsin egr tfimr ripictid dms`gviry chusis cld wmn n eu nlgl`gapnmclì wm tf cnn tfrii ge ygur Mltirma Di`msmgls.

C X O Y A I L TM . @ N C M A C L T F C P H I I L O X C L T I D N M H I X C N D M P @ G U I X ] H] C X H M T X C T G X O X I O G X ] ,

H Y T E G X A G X I T F C L T I L A G L T F P , T F I X I P Z G L D I L T P F C U I X I E Y P I D TG @ G A Z N ] _ M T FC L ] G E @ N C M C N ^ L T ' P X I C P G L C H N I D M P @ G U I X ] X I S Y I P T P .

Ml tfi si`gld Mltirma Di`msmgl ge Crhmtrctgr Oriogry, fi stctid2 "Cs tg Ixfmhmt [03Q cld cly cld cnn pgtiltmcnnyegrtf`gamlo prgeirrid ivmdilì, M `gltmlui ay Cp r m n 36, 8:30 Emrst Mltirma Di`msmgl Grdir ml eunn egrì cld ieei t.Ic`f pcrty fcs tfi `gltmlumlo duty ge ec`mnmtctmlo dms`gviry. Zursuclt tg Liw ] g r k ncw, dms`gviry riquists,cld tfi stctutgry ncw cocmlst ulncweun iapngyailt dms`rmamlctmgl, sfcnn hi nmhircnny `glstruid " (iapfcsmscddid) [po. 30.Q Durmlo gur Buny 0:, 8:30 `gleirilì `cnn . Crhmtrctgr Oriogry cnsg stctid2 " M tcki crhmtrcn lgtmì glay silsi ms tfct Xispgldilts, `grpgrcti Xispgldilts, cri ml tfi lgra, ùstgdmcls ge tfi ri`grd, acmltcml tficr`fmvis, it " cld "uroi[dQ tfi Xispgldilts tg tcki c emlcn nggk hiegri wi og tg cly gtfir pcrt ge tfms prgìidmlo tgsii wfitfir gr lgt tfi iniailts ge tfi prghniactm` ixfmhmt `cl hi ritrmivid." Ml tfi tfmrd Mltirma Di msmgl mssuid glPiptiahir 89, 8:30, cetir cdamttmlo "Ixfmhmt 03 " "mltg tfi ivmdilì ge ri`grd," Crhmtrctgr Oriogry stctid, " MGXDIX tfct Xispgldilt _AI `ggpircti wmtf tfi i-dms`gviry ixpirt ge @ncmaclt's `fgmì tg ec`mnmtcti c iss tgcld hi piramttid tg ritrmivi tfi iacmns `gltcmlid gl _AI's 3==6-3=== hc`k up tcpis." [po. 8.Q

Ml cl "oggd ecmtf" cttiapt tg `gapny wmtf Crhmtrctgr Omiogry's si`gld Mltirma Di`msmgl, M i-acmnidAm`fcin Rwimo gl Buny 8?, 8:30, cld cskid fma tg egrwcrd quistmgls M riìmvid erga vcrmgus i-dms`gviry ixpirts tg_mn n m ca Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt, sg M `gund ghtcml qugtis cld suhamt tfia tg tfi Crhmtrctgr. Rwimo livir rispgldid.


2/11

Licrny twg agltfs nctir, gl Piptiahir 89, 8:30, M egrwcrdid tfi scai i-acmn tg Rwimo cld stctid tfct hyPiptiahir 8?, 8:30, _m n n m ca Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt liidid tg clswir tfisi prinmamlcry quistmgls. Cocml, Mriìmvid lg rispglsi. Gl Piptiahir 8?, 8:30,3 i-acmnid Rwimo ct 32:9 pa tg sii m e tfi Xispgldilts wiri ogmlo tgc`tucnny `gapny wm tf ay riquist cld stctid2 "Twg agltfs fcvi incpsid smlì M ml m t mc n ny i-acmnid tfisi quistmgls cldM fcvi hiil agri tfcl pctmilt wm tf ygu, sg m e lgt, M wm n n fcvi lg `fgmì hut tg hrmlo tfms tg tfi cttiltmgl ge tfiCrhmtrctgr cld csk egr dms`gviry scl`tmgls egr ygur `gltuac`mgus hifcvmgr." Mlsticd ge riìmvmlo c rispglsi e rgaRwimo, fi fcd liwny cddid cttgrliy Am`fcin Hcrlitt spick gl fms hifcne tg tinn ai2 " [_Qi cri stmnn ml tfi prgìssge`glsuntmlo wm tf gur `nmilt cs tg wfct ini`trglm` dctc ml tfi egra ge i-acmns stmnn ixmsts erga 3==6-3===. _i wm n ncdvmsi ygu cld tfi Crhmtrctgr ge gur emldmlos ml c``grdcl i wmtf tfi dicdnmlis tfct tfi Crhmtrctgr fcs sit."

Omvil tfct tfi Crhmtrctgr spi`mem`cnny cskid tfi Xispgldilts tg dg tfms durmlo gur Buny 0:, 8:30 `gleirilì`cnn , tfms rispglsi wcs lgt c`ìptchni ct tfms stcoi ml tfi prgìidmlo. Ml c sgaiwfct agri nilotfy rispglsi, Mixpncmlid tg Hcrlitt fgw fi wcs ml`grri`t hy qugtmlo virhctma tfi vcrmgus Mltirma Di`msmgls ge Crhmtrctgr Oriogry.Pii Ixfmhmt C. Hcrlitt tfil ocvi c smamncr ripny, stctmlo2 "Znicsi hi cdvmsid tfct wi cri stmnn ml tfi prgìss ge`glsuntmlo wm tf gur `nmilt cs tg wfct ini`trglm` dctc ml tfi egra ge i-acmns s tm n n ixmsts e rga 3==6-3===. _i wmn ncdvmsi ygu cld tfi Crhmtrctgr ge gur emldmlos ml c``grdclì wm tf tfi dicdnmlis tfct tfi Crhmtrctgr fcs sit." PiiIxfmhmt C. Egr tfi egn ngwmlo ricsgls hingw, tfi Crhmtrctgr aust lgw mltirvili cld `gapin tfi Xispgldilts cldtfimr `gulsin tg `gapny wm t f ay vcrmgus dms`gviry riquists.

Emrst cld egriagst. Crhmtrctgr Oriogry fcs livir cskid egr tfi Xispgldilts tg put tgoitfir c "dms`gviryprgtg`gn," cntfguof fi dmd stcti tfi Xispgldilts `gund suhamt "c prgpgsid prgti`tmvi grdir riocrdmlo cly su fiacmns tfct acy hi ghtcmlid hy @ncmaclt's ixpirt." [Piptiahir 89, 8:30 Mltirma Di`msmgl, 8.Q M wm n n gppgsi tfimrprgpgsid prgti`tmvi grdir ct tfi cpprgprmcti tmai hi`cusi mt sfgund hi dilmid ncroiny dui tg tfi ec`t tfct AcomstrctiBudoi Ercl`ms dilmid Ngih & Ngih NNZ's riquist egr c prgti`tmvi grdir wfil tfi `ncss ge hnc`k `gl irt prgagtirssguoft i-dms`gviry. Cnsg, ygu fcvi cnricdy stctid tfct M `gund stcld ml "pgnmtm`cn sgnmdcrmty" wm tf A r. Xgwi ml ygure mrst Mltirma Di`msmgl, cld smlì tfms spgnmctid ivmdilì tfct ygu fcvi `gapinnid _m n n m ca Agrrms tg prgduì egr tfitfmrd tmai wcs pcmd egr hy Niglcrd Xgwi cld untmactiny hinglos tg fma, fi `cllgt hi priviltid em-ga c`qumrmlo tfmsivmdilì. Fi ùrriltny fcs liw niocn riprisiltctmgl cld wm n n hi pursumlo niocn c`tmgl cocmlst fms egrair cttgrliys ctPLX cld tfi _mn n m i Ocry Emra egr acnprc`tmì, cld ms cnsg ixpi`tid tg emni `gapncmlts wm tf tfi Dipcrtailt geBustmì cld tfi cttgrliy itfm`s `gaamttii ml tfi stcti ge Oigromc tfms wiik. Fi wm n n liid tfms ivmdilì tg prgvi tfctcnn ge tfi cttgrliys mlvgnvid ml tfms smlmstir `glspmrc`y tg mltireiri wm t f tfi fuacl rmofts ge Cerm`cl Cairm`clssfgund hi dmshcrrid cld maprmsglid egr tfimr ulitfm`cn cld `rmamlcn c`tmgls. Cddmtmglcnny, smlì ygu scmd tfi agstmapgrtclt quistmgl ge gur Buny 0:, 8:30 `gleirilì `cnn wcs wfitfir gr lgt M hrguoft tfms acttir tg tfi cttiltmgl geIrm` Fgndir cld tfi Dipcrtailt ge Bustm i, M wm n n maaidmctiny emni c `gapncmlt glì M ocml pgssissmgl ge tfi vcrmgusdgùailts tfct M 'vi riquistid tg hi prgduìd.

Pi`gldny, M livir cskid egr _mn n m ca Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt cld/gr Ngih & Ngih NNZ tg tinn ai wfct"ini`trglm` dctc ml tfi egra ge i-acmns stmnn ixmsts erga 3==6-3===." Tfi ini`trglm` dms`gviry ixpirt ge ay `fgmìwm n n clswir tfct quistmgl egr ai glì _mn n m ca Agrrms prgduìs tfi hc`k up tcpis cld pcys egr tfi sicr`f pursuclt tgCrhmtrctgr Oriogmy's si`gld cld tfmrd Mltirma Di`msmgls. Ivil me M dmd M liid tg klgw tfct mlegractmgl, mt dgisl'ttcki twg agltfs egr _mn n m ca Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt tg clswir tfct quistmgl. Egr agltfs, M wcs cssmolid tg wgrk mltfi MT dipcrtailt ct _mn n m ca Agrrms' Liw ]grk geemì ("dicd-ild cssmolailts"), sg 3 klgw tfct tfi iapngyiis mltfct dipcrtailt fcvi c `glsmdirchni cagult ge dgwltmai cld cri agri tfcl `cpchni ge prgvmdmlo clswirs tg tfisiquistmgls hi`cusi tfi `gapcly hc`ks up mts emnis iviry dcy.Tfmrd , tfi clswirs tg tfi prinmamlcry quistmgls M ca cskmlo _mn n m ca Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt tg clswir critfi scai typis ge clswirs _m n n m ca Agrrms fcd tg prgvmdi tg Pgamils fiml Lctf & Xgsiltfcn NNZ ("PLX") (lgwklgwl cs Diltgls N N Z ) cld Ini`trglm` Ivmdilì Dms`gvimy ("IID") (lgw klgwl cs Dgùailts Ti`flgngoy, Ml`.gr "DTZ') wfil tfi `ncss ge hnc`k `glìrt prgagtirs pcmd $8::,:::.:: tg fcvi IID `gldu`t tfms sicr f gl tfimrhifcne _fil Budoi Ercl`ms dilmid Ngih & Ngih NNZ's riquist egr c prgti`tmvi grdir cld `gapinnid _mn n m caAgrrms cld @C C tg prgduì tfi i-acmns ml Xgwi, _mn n m ca Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt fcd tg clswir smamncr quistmglsrcmsid hy PLX cld IID. Tfiriegri, Ngih & Ngih NNZ cld _mn n m ca Agrrms's MT dipcrtailt sfgund fcvi lgprghnias clswirmlo tfi scai typis ge quistmgls tfct cri himlo cskid hy ay prgspi`tmvi ini`trglm` dms`gviry

-8 -


3/11


4/11

ml Xgwi. Pg, m e t m mi 3==6-3=== hc`k up tcpis gr i-acmns `gltcmlid gl tfi 3==6-3=== hc`k up tcpis tfct liid tg hiprgduìd ml _csfmlotgl fcvi hiil cntirid, dinitid, distrgyid, cld/gr tcapirid wm tf ml cly wcy, sfcpi gr egra cetirIID's sicr`f ml gr crguld Piptiahir 8::8, lgw ms tfi tmai egr Am`fcin Rwimo, Ngih & Ngih NNZ cld _ m n n m c aAgrrms tg hi fglist wm tf tfiasinvis cld cdamt tfi trutf tg tfi Crhmtrctgr cld M . M e tfisi hc`k up tcpis cri lgtprgduìd, tfiri w m n n hi chsgnutiny lg liid egr ai tg `gldu`t dipgsmtmgls wm tf Acrt m l X. Ognd, Xcyagld Fisnml,Xm`fcrd Zrmagee\ cld _ m n n m i I. Ocry cld tfms ms etmrtfir prgge tfct tfi crhmtrctmgl coriiailts M smolid cld/gr mtsprgvmsmgls cri ml ec`t ul`gls`mglchni, tcmltid wmtf m n niocn m ty cld acnua a si cld cs c acttir ge ncw, ygupriacturiny cld irrgligusny `gl nudid tfct tfi "crhmtrctmgl coriiailt wcs lgt ul`gls mglchni." [Piptiahir 89,8:30 Mltirma Di`msmgl, 4.Q Tfms w m n n cddmtmglcnny prgvi tfct cs c acttir ge ncw, _ m n n m c a Agrrms' cltm`gapitmtmvi cldix`nusmglcry prc`tmìs dismolid tg acmltcml c rcì-hcsid aglgpgny ml tfi wgrkpncì, Fgnnywggd cld acrkitpncìge mdics, fcvi cnsg vmgnctid eidircn cld stcti cltmtast ncw cld ygu sfgund lgt fcvi dmsamssid tfisi `ncmas uldir tfi"pgnmrm`cn quisrmgls dg`trmli." Md.

Pg yis, M ca tfclkem b n tfct ygu fcvi orcltid ai "'nmhircn [ Q dms`gviry," hut me ygu cri lgt ogmlo tg acki suritfi Xispgldilts `gapny wm tf ygur grdirs, tfil ygu cri nicrny schgtcomlo ay `csi hi`cusi ygu cri smauntcligusny`fmppmlo cwcy ct ay ncmas cld fcraeunny dincymlo c " e m l c n " di`msmgl erga himlo acdi. M fcvi diaglstrctid tfctNiglcrd Xgwi's egrair `gulsin cld `gulsin egr tfi Hggkmlo Coil`y Dieildclts fcvi c `nicr "aiitmlo ge tfiamlds" wm tf riocrds tg wfct fcppilid durmlo i-dms`gviry ml Xgwi. Tfimr stctiailts tfct "lg dirgoctgry tiras"wiri eguld durmlo tfi sicr`f cri `nicrny nmis cld tfus, Ngih & Ngih NNZ's hrgcd dieilsis egr licrny tfrii yicrs, mlwfm`f tfiy fcvi stctid tfct ay ncmas ge systiam cld mldmvmducn dmspcrcti trictailt wiri "uleguldid," "wfgn nywmtfgut airmt, niocnny gr ec`tucnny," cld tfct ay pnicdmlos wiri "e mn nid wm tf gutrcoigus, sine-`gltrcdm`tgry, clduttirny ulsuhstcltmctid cnnioctmgls chgut _A I cld mts iapngyiis" fcvi cnsg livir hiil trui.'\ [@ncmaclt PuaacryBudoailt, F 39=.Q

H y rietmsmlo tg fcvi _ m n n m c a Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt clswir tfisi viry hcsm quistmgls, tfi Xispgldilts cldtfimr `gulsin cri priviltmlo ai erga suhamttmlo "cl mtiamzid nmst ge tfi prgbi`tid ricsglchni `gsts cssg mctid wm tftfms ritrmivcn" tg tfi Crhmtrctgr hy G`tghir ?, 8:30. Tfiriegri, M csk tfct Crhmtrctgr Oriogry `gapin _ m n n m c a Agrrmscld Ngih & Ngih NNZ tg ec`mnmtcti cld eune m n n cY ge ay m l m t m c n dms`gviry riquists lg nctir tfcl G`tghir 4, 8:30. M e

\ Hitwiil Acy 34-39, 8:38, cnn egur ge Niglcrd Xgwi's egrair cttgrliys [Ognd , Fisnml, Zr ma gee cld @frmstmliNipircQ suhamttid Di`ncrctmgls ml gppgsmtmgl tg Niglcrd Xgwi's EX@Z 5: A g t m g l , dilymlo tfct cly dirgoctgrytiras wiri ivir eguld durmlo ini`trglm` dms`gviry ml tfms `csi cld c`tid cs m e tfiy fcd lg nui cs tg wfct "Ixfmhmt0 3 " wcs smlì Niglcrd Xgwi fcdl't ocmlid pgssissmgl ge tfi dgùailt ct tfi tmai ge emnmlo tfi agtmgl. Ngih &Ngih NNZ livir rispgldid tg Ar . Xgwi's agtmgl, hut Ar . Xgwi's pirburmgus stctiailts wiri usid tg suppgrt BudoiZcttirsgl's dilmcn ge Ar . Xgwi's agtmgl tg fcvi fms `csi rigpilid dui tg fms ncmas tfct "ercud upgl tfi @gurt" fcdtckil pncì ml fms `csi.\ Tfrguofgut tfi Xispgldilts' @rgss-Agtmgl tg Dmsamss, tfiy `gltmluid tg acki dupnm`mtgusstctiailts ml "hcdec m tf" su f cs2 "_fmni emnnid w m t f ulsuppgrtid c`ùsctmgls cld mlvi`rmvi, _csfmlotgl's 94-pcoi 'Xipny cld XiquistEgr E u n n Puaacry Budoailt' ms n m t t ni agri tfcl c `gapildmua ge `gl`nusgry, mlìldmcry, cld spiùnctmvistctiailts, nc`kmlo cly `gl`riti ivmdiltmcry suppgrt wfctsgivir" (po. 3 ) . . . ."@ncmas cri uttirny mapncusmhni cldwmtfgut ec`tucn suppgrt" (po. 8 ) . . . . " M l sua, _csfmlotgl fcs prisiltid cld `cl prisilt lg ec`tucn hcsms tg suppgrtcly ge fms `ncmas. Hcsid ncroiny gl vcst `glspmrc`y tfigrmis, dms`ridmtid cnnioctmgls ge mlstmtutmglcn rc msa cld fmsgw l clmaus, fms ncmas cri lgt glny uttirmy mapncusmhni, tfiy cri su`f tfct lg ricsglchni emldir ge ec`t `gund runi mlfms ecvgr" (po. 4)...."_csfmlotgl's @gapncmlt, ivil suppniailtid hy fms A g t m g l , ms divgmd ge `gl`riti ec`tssfgwmlo cly mltiltmglcn dms`rmamlctmgl, gr cly ml`mdilt ge rc`mcn clmaus" (po. 9 ) . . . . "_csfmlotgl's @gapncmlt cldA g t m g l ms wgie m b n ny divgmd ge fcrd ec`ts, rinymlo mlsticd gl suppgsmtmgl, stirigtypmlo cld oilircnmzctmgl. Fms hrgcdcssirtmgls cld `gl nusgry c`ùsctmgls ecmn tg istchnmsf cly mssui ge actirmcn ec`ts cld sfgund hi dmsamssid gl cnn`gults" (po. 5) cld "_csfmlotgl fcs lgt - cld cllgt - pgmlt tg cly mlstclì ge dmri`t dms`rmamlctmgl gr cly`mrùastcltmcn ivmdilì tg suppgrt fms `ncma tfct fi wcs trictid dmeeirilt erga gtfir Trcmliis." (po. 35) [@ncmacltXip. Puaacry Budoailt, 6=.Q Lgt glì fcvi tfi Xispgldilts stctid tfct ay stctiailts gr c`tmgls wiri himlo dgliml "hcd ec m tf" cntfguof lgw. Crhmtrctgr Oriogry fcs issiltmcnny stctid tfct M ca ou m n ty ge `gaamttmlo diecactmgl,sncldir cld n mhin cocmlst tfi Xispgldilts cld/gr tfimr `gulsin ml fms tfmrd Mltirma Di`msmgl. M e wfct M wcs scymlowiril't tcmi, fgw `gund ygu pgssmhny cdamt "Ixfmhmt 0 3 " mltg tfi ivmdilì ge ri`grd cetir smttmlo wm tf gur pnicdmlosegr c yicr7

-4-


5/11

lgt tfisi dgùailts cri lgt prgduìd cld clswirs cri lgt prgvmdid hy _ mn n m c a Agrrms' MT dipcrtailt chgut tfi3==6-3=== hc`k up tcpis, tfil tfi Crhmtrctgr sfgund cnsg `gl`nudi tfct tfms ivmdilì wcs distrgyid cs pcrt ge tfimrsmlmstir `glspmrc`y tg mltireiri wm tf tfi fuacl rmofts ge Cerm`cl Cairm`cls cld gtfir pigpni ge `gngr, wfm`f fcsuntmactiny cnngwid _ m n n m c a Agrrms tfi chmn m ty tg `gltmlui acmltcmlmlo mts ulncwemrn dms`rmamlctgry cldcltm`gapitmtmvi prc tmìs, pgnm`mis cld prgìduris ml vmgnctmgl ge Pi`tmgl 3=63 ge tfi @ m v m n Xmofts C`t ge 3655, 48Y.P.@. 3=63 ("Pi`tmgl 3=63"), Tmdi Unn ge tfi @ m v m n Xmofts C`t ge 3=54, cs `gdmemid, 48 Y.P.@. 8:::i tg 8:::i-3? ("Tmtni UF"), tfi Liw ]grk Ptcti Fuacl Xmofts Ncw, Liw ] g r k Ixiùtmvi Ncw 8=: it. siq. (tfi" L ] P F X N " ) , tfi Liw ]grk @m ty Fuacl Xmofts Ncw, Liw ]grk Cdamlmstrctmvi @gdi 6-3:3 it. siq. (tfi" L ] @ F X . N " ) , tfi Pfiracl C t, 39 Y.P.@. 3 in siq, Dgllinny C t, Oilircn Husmliss Ncw 04: it siq cld KuK n u x . K n c l C`t ge 36?3, 48 Y.P.@. 3=69(0).

X I S Y I P T E G X P C L @ T M G L P D Y I T G D M P @ G U I X ] C H Y P I CLD @ G L T Y A C @ M G Y P H I F C U M G X GE_ M N N N ^ A G X X M P , N G I H & N G I H N N Z CLD A M @ F C I N Z. R _ I M O .

"Trui dms`gviry chusi ms tfct `gldu t wfm`f fmldirs bustmì hy fmdmlo liidid cld rinivclt ivmdilì."' ' _fil tfmsg`ùrs, ispi mcnny ml c ncldacrk fuacl rmofts cld cltmtrust `csi su`f cs tfms, tfi typis ge scl tmgls tfct acy himapgsid upgl cl cttgrliy, ncw emra cld/gr pcrty egr dms`gvir\' chusis ml`nudi2 strmkmlo c pnicdmlo, pcyailt gecttgrliy's eiis, hcrrmlo tfi mltrgdu`tmgl ge irtcml ivmdilì, runmlo gl ìrtcml mssuis ml gppgsmtmgl tg tfi pgsmtmglge tfi geeildmlo pcrty, iltirmlo c diecunt budoailt, dmsamsscn cld dmshcrrailt Pii Kcrnssgl v. Egrd Agtgr @g..34: @cn. Cpp. 4tf 38:8, 49 @cn. Xptr. 0d 859 (8d Dmst. 8::5), rivmiw dilmid, (Pipt. 8?, 8::5). Cnsg, uldir L.].@UZ. Ncw 0 3 8 5 , mt stctis2

M e cly pcrty, gr c pirsgl wfg ct tfi tmai c dipgsmtmgl ms tckil gr cl ixcamlctmgl gr mlspi`tmgl msacdi ms cl geemìr, dmri tgr, aiahir, iapngyii gr coilt ge c pcrty gr gtfirwmsi uldir c pcrty's`gltrgn, rieusis tg ghiy cl grdir egr dms`ngsuri gr wmneunny ecmns tg dms`ngsi mlegractmgl wfm`ftfi `gurt emlds guoft tg fcvi hiil dms`ngsid pursuclt tg tfms crtm`ni, tfi `gurt acy acki su`fgrdirs wmtf riocrd tg tfi ecmnuri gr riembscn cs cri bust, caglo tfia2

3. cl grdir tfct tfi mssuis tg wfm`f tfi mlegractmgl ms rinivclt sfcnn hi diiaid risgnvidegr purpgsis ge tfi c`tmgl ml c``grdclì wm tf tfi `ncmas ge tfi pcrty ghtcmlmlo tfi grdir;gr8 cl grdir prgfmhmtmlo tfi dmsghidmilt pcrty erga suppgrtmlo gr gppgsmlodismolctid `ncmas gr dieilsis, erga prgdu`mlo ml ivmdilì dismolctid tfmlos grmtias ge tistmagly, gr erga mltrgdu`mlo cly ivmdilì ge tfi pfysm`cn, ailtcn gr hnggd`gldmtmgl sguoft tg hi ditiramlid, gr erga usmlo ìrtcml wmtlissis; gr0. cl grdir strmkmlo gut pnicdmlos gr pcrts tfirige, gr stcymlo eurtfir prgìidmlos ultm ntfi grdir ms ghiyid, gr dmsamssmlo tfi c`tmgl gr cly pcrt tfirige, gr rildirmlo cbudoailt hy diecunt cocmlst tfi dmsghidmilt pcrty, (iapfcsms cddid)

Cs c risunt ge tfi dms`gviry chusis ailtmglid chgvi, vcrmgus scl tmgls sfgund hi mapgsid cocmlst _ m n n m c aAgrrms, Am`fcin Z. Rwimo, @frmstmcl @crhgli cld Ngih & Ngih NNZ, pcrtmùncrnyhi`cusi tfms ms lgt tfi emrst tmaiAm`fcin Z. Rwimo cld Ngih & Ngih NNZ fcvi ilocoid ml tfms typi ge dms`gviry chusi gl hifcne ge _ m n n m c a Agrrms.Ml c agtmgl emnid gl Lgviahir 88, 8:::, `gulsin egr tfi `ncss ge hnc`k `glìrt prgagtirs stctid2 "Zncmltmees hrmlotfms agtmgl hi`cusi tfiy wiri niet wm tf lg gtfir c`ìptchni `gursi ge c`tmgl, cetir fcvmlo liogtmctid ml oggd ecmtfwm tf dieilsi `gulsin egr agltfs gvir dms`gviry acttirs. Mt ms lgw gvir gli cld c fcne yicrs smlì tfi DgùailtXiquists cld Mltirrgoctgrmis wiri mlmtmcnny sirvid, egur agltfs cetir pncmltmees wrgti tg dieildclts' `gulsindiacldmlo `gapnmclì wmtf tfisi riquists, cld tfrii agltfs cetir tfms @gurt's Cuoust 8::: `gleirilì clds`fidunmlo grdir, dctid Piptiahir 39. 8::: (tfi "Grdir"\ riqumrmlo tfi `gapnitmgl ge dieildclts' dgùailt

Xussinn Pamtf. Nmtmoctmlo Tgrt @csis. "Dms`gviry Chusi." 8:30.-9-


6/11

prgdu`tmgl hy Diìahir 3, 8:::, cld pncmltmees stmnn fcvi riìmvid lg dgùailts rispglsmvi tg tfimr riquists.Tg hi suri, lgli ge tfi dieildclts fcs cllgulìd cl gutrmoft rieuscn tg `ggpircti wmtf pncmltmees ml dms`gviry.Mlsticd, dieildclts fcvi cttiaptid tg `glviy c supirem`mcn viliir g e `ggpirctmgl. Glì dieildclts' pgsmtmgls criclcnyzid cld tfi viliir ms strmppid, fgwivir, mt ms ivmdilì tfct dieildclts `glsmstiltny fcvi hiil ulwm n n mlo tgpiramt pncmltmees cly aiclmloeun mlspi`tmgl cld/gr `gpymlo ge vgnuamlgus, yit liìsscry, rispglsmvi dgùailts."(iapfcsms cddid) Pii Ixfmhmt H.

Cnsg, ml tfi G`tghir 85, 8::3 Cee mdcvm t ge @fcrnis Kinnlir - egrair Icstirl Xiomgl Umì Zrismdilt geIni`trglm` Ivmdilì Dms`gviry, Ml`. ("IID") (lgw klgwl cs Dgùailts Ti`flgngoy, Ml`. gr " D T M " ) - fi dmsùssidgl luairgus g``csmgls tfi dmee mùnty fi ixpirmilìd ml ghtcmlmlo mlegractmgl erga _ mn n m c a Agrrms chgut tfimr hc`kup tcpis. [@ncmaclt Xip. Cprm n 36, 8:30 Mltirma Di`msmgl, 4, Ixfmhmt E.Q Tfi Cee mdcvm t wcs suhamttid tg "dis`rmhitfi dms ussmgls ml wfm`f [fiQ pcrtm`mpctid wm tf dieildclts' `gulsin cld `glsuntclts ml tfms `csi riocrdmlodieildclts' prgdu`tmgl ge i-acmn dctc, tg rispgld tg ìrtcml cssirtmgls ge tfimr `gulsin cld `glsuntclts, cld tgdmsùss tfi prgpgscns IID acdi wm tf rispi`t tg dieildclts' prgdu`tmgl ge i-acmn." Ml mt , fi stctid, "Dispmti tfi ec`ttfct wi spilt twg agltfs cld ilocoid ml acly `gaaulm`ctmgls, lgli ge tfi dieildclts diaglstrctid clywmnnmloliss tg acki tfimr i-acmn dctc cvcmnchni tg pncmltmees ml cl ieem`milt cld `gst-ieei tmvi acllir. _i acdiprgpgscns tfct ix`nudid ixcamlctmgl ge ncroi vgnuais ge i-acmn cld tfct v/gund risunt ml smolmem`clt `gst scvmlos.Ic`f tmai, wi wiri ait hy mlenctid `gst istmactis hcsid gl ulliìsscry prgìssmlo cld gl prgbi`ts ge hrgcdir s`gpitfcl pncmltmees prgpgsid. Lgli coriid ivil tg tfi `glìpt ge usmlo sicr`f tiras. Ic`f priamsid tfimr prgìssmlo cldrivmiw `gsts upgl cnn ge tfi i-acmn ml quistmgl, rctfir tfcl tfi sacnn erc`tmgl tfct wgund risunt erga sicr`fmlo.Dispmti cnn ge gur geeirs tg dmsùss n mamtct mgl hy lcais, dcti mltirvcns, cld sicr`f tiras, lg dieildclt ivir geeiridgr suooistid c `gultirprgpgscn." Fi cnsg spi`mem`cnny dms ussid fms ixpirmilìs cld dmee mùnty ml dicnmlo w m t f_ m n n m c a Agrrms cld tfimr MT dipcrtailt gl pcois 80 tfrguof 0:. Pii Ixfmhmt @.

Dui tg tfi smamncrmtmis ge hgtf rc`mcn dms`rmamlctmgl cld cltmtrust `csis, tfiri ms c `nicr cld `glsmstiltpcttirl ge hifcvmgr cld tfguoft riocrdmlo tfi Xispgldilts cld tfimr `gulsin. Emvi agltfs fcvi issiltmcnny hiilwcstid cnricdy cld M wm n n lgt cnngw tfi Xispgldilts tg ilocoi ml tfi scai typis ge dms`gviry chusis tfct tfiyilocoid ml wm tf Xgwi. M fcvi lgt hiil gvirzicngus wm tf ay dms`gviry riquists lgr cri ay mlmtmcn riquists gvirnyhurdilsgai dui tg tfi ec`t tfct ygu fcvi cnricdy `gapinnid _ mn n m c a Agrrms tg prgduì "sagkmlo oul," spgnmctidivmdilì gl tfrii sipcrcti g``csmgls, cld cntfguof Budoi Zcttirsgl irrgligusny `gl`nudid tfct "Ixfmhmt 0 3 " wcs cl"ulcutfiltm`ctid cld ulmdiltmemid dgùailt," ygu fcvi lgw cdamttid tfms dgùailt mltg tfi ivmdilì g e ri`grd."_fil tfi ivmdil i mldm`ctis tfct c pcrty ms cwcri ge `mrùastclìs tfct cri n mkiny tg omvi rmsi tg emmturi nmtmoctmglcld yit distrgys pgtiltmcnny rinivclt ri`grds wmtfgut pcrtmùncrmzid mlqumry, c ec`t-emldir acy ricsglchny mleir tfcttfi pcrty prghchny dmd sg hi`cusi tfi ri`grds wgund fcra mts `csi." Hnmlznir v. Acrrmgtt M l t ' n . Ml`.. 63 E.0d 3346 (3 st@mr. 3==5). Me tfisi hc`k up tcpis cri lg ngloir cvcmnchni, tfil M fcvi ricsgl tg hinmivi tfct pirtmlilt ivmdilìpirtcmlmlo tg ay `ncmas fcs cnsg hiil cntirid, distrgyid cld/gr tcapirid wm tf cs win n .

Omvil tfi ec`t tfct Rwimo fcs hiil lcaid "Hist Ncvv\ir" ml Nchgr & Iapngyailt Nm t moct mgl tfms yicr cldfcs riìmvid smamncr c``gncdis erga pridgamlctiny wfmti groclmzctmgls tfrguofgut fms niocn `criir, fi ms win n cwcritfct tfi duty tg prisirvi crmsis wfil c pcrty gr prgspi`tmvi pcrty fcs lgtmì ge n m t moctmgl gr tfi pgtiltmcn egrn m t moctmgl. Tfigritm`cnny, _ mn n m c a Agrrms sfgund fcvi hiil prisirvmlo ivmdilì wfil tfiy riìmvid lgtmì tfct M emindc `gapncmlt wm tf tfi IIG@ gl gr chgut Buli =, 8:3:. Fgwivir, gl Lgviahir 8?, 8:38 - til agltfs cog - 3 cskidRwimo tg mlegra ai ge tfi dcti fi mssuid c n m t moctmgl fgnd cocmlst _ mn n m c a Agrrms cld mts iapngyiis hi`cusi M tgndf ma tfct M wgund hi pursumlo niocn c`tmgl cocmlst _ mn n m c a Agrrms vmc i-acmn gl G`tghir 3=, 8:3: durmlo tfi tmai Mwcs siikmlo niocn riprisiltctmgl cld wcs ulcwcri tfct fi cld fms ncw emra riprisiltid _ mn n m c a Agrrms ml Xgwi.Tfms ms lgt tfi emrst tmai M'vi hrguoft tfms tg ygur cttiltmgl cld ygu fcvi dgli chsgnutiny lgtfmlo tg ackisuri Ngih& Ngih NNZ fcs `gapnmid wm tf ygur grdirs cld/gr `gapnmis w m t f ay dms`gviry riquists.\ [@ncmaclt Xip. Puaacry

' Tfi hmooist ricsgl wfy Ngih & Ngih NNZ gr cly pirsgl wgund tcki ygur grdirs wm tf c orcml ge scnt ms hcsid gltfi ec`t tfct cetir ygu `gapinnid _ mn n m c a Agrrms, Ngih & Ngih NNZ cld Am`fcin Z. Rwimo tg prgduì tfi 33 yicrgnd, "sagkmlo oma" spgnmctid ivmdilì tfct wcs rispglsmvi tg IID's sicr f cld stctid tfct m e hgtf pcrtmis dmd lgt`gapny w m t f ygur emrst Mltirma Di`msmgl, "cl cdvirsi mleirilì" wgund hi `rictid, ygu dmd chsgnutiny lgtfmlo wfil

-5-


7/11

Budoailt, =:, Ixfmhmt ] . Q Pii Ixfmhmt D. Glny sgaigli wfg hinmivis tfiy cri chgvi tfi ncw gr klgws ml cdvclìtfct lgtfmlo w m n n fcppil me tfiy dmsghiy ygur grdirs, `cl rieusi tg `gapny w m t f smapni dms`gviry riquists n mki tfmsgl auntmpni g``csmgls gvir c spcl ge til agltfs. @gulsin ms suppgsid tg pirmgdm`cnny `gaaulm`cti dmri`tny w m t fiapngyiis agst n mki ny tg fcvi rinivclt mlegractmgl cld aglmtgr `gapnmclì w m t f tfi n m t moc t mgl fgnd. Pii RuhunckiU . YHP _crhuro. N N @ . 8::4 Y.P. Dmst. NIVMP 309?4 (P.D.L.]., Buny 8:, 8::4). _fil tfiri ms chsgnutiny lg typi geripirùssmgls gr pulmsfailt erga tfi Crhmtrctgr egr dmsruptmlo tfi crhmtrcn prgìss, tfct glny cdds enmin tg tfimr emri tgc`t ml `gltiapt. Mlsticd, ygu tfmlk mt 's agri cpprgprmcti tg pulmsf ai hy scymlo ay `ncmas cocmlst tfi Xispgldiltscld tfimr `gulsin fcvi hiil diecactgm?, nmhingus cld sncldirgus wmtfgut prgvmdmlo gli ixcapni ge sgaitfmlo M'viscmd chgut tfi Xispgldilts cld/gr tfimr `gulsin tfct ms ultai gr fcsl't hiil suppgrtid w m t f ivmdilì, csi ncw,sg`mgngom`cn risicr`f, ncw nmtircturi, ùrrilt ivilts cld gtfir `ridmhni sgur is. Ylniss ygu stip ml cld mltirvili,tfiri ms lg quistmgl tfct tfi Xispgldilts v\m n n glny `gltmlui tfimr "hcd ecmtf" cld chusmvi dms`gviry tc`tm`s.

M'vi fcd "Ixfmhmt 03" ml ay pgssissmgl sml i Acy 39, 8:38 - wfil M wcs cppicnmlo Budoi @cstin'sirrgligus di`msmgl wfm`f `gapinnid tfms `csi mltg crhmtrctmgl. _fil M emnid ay Diacld egr Crhmtrctmgl w m t f tfiC C C gl Buli 39, 8:38, "Ixfmhmt 0 3 " wcs gli ge tfi til cddmtmglcn dg uailts suhamttid ml suppgrt cnn ge ay `ncmas.Lgw tfct ygu fcvi cdamttid tfms dg uailt mltg tfi ivmdilì ge ri`grd emetiil agltfs nctir, mt ms wmtfgut quistmgltfct tfms dg uailt ms cutfiltm`. Tfiriegri, tfi Xispgldilts sfgund hi scl tmglid egr tfimr luairgusamsriprisiltctmgls chgut tfms dg uailt cld dms`gviry chusis cetir himlo `gapinnid tg prgduì vcrmgus dg uailtspirtcmlmlo tg i-dms`gviry ml Xgwi. ml`nudmlo tfi i-acmns tfiy cnnioidny riìmvid erga IID cld tfi uldirnymlo i-acmns tg tfms cutfiltm` dgùailt. Xiocrdniss ge wfitfir gr lgt ygu cri chni tg pulmsf Xispgldilts cld tfimr `gulsinegr tfimr `rmamlcn cld ulitfm`cn `gldu`t ml tfms crhmtrctmgl prgìidmlo, ygu fcvi cdamttid mltg ivmdil i ge ri`grdspgnmctid, "sagkmlo oul" ivmdil i cld fcvi `gapinnid tfi Xispgldilts tg prgdu i dgùailts tfct livir scw tfin m of t ge dcy. Tfms ml cld ge m tsine prgvis tfct Am`fcin Z. Rwimo cld fms `g-`glspmrctgrs ilocoid ml ulitfm`cn cld`rmamlcn `gldu`t mlXgwi/' Cs c risunt, acly ge tfi cssirtmgls acdi tfrguofgut Am`fcin Rwimo's pnicdmlos gvir tfincst twg cld c fcne yicrs ml _csfmlotgl fcvi hiil "lgl-airmtgrmgus," "ermvgngus" cld niocnny mlsueem`milt cs c acttirg e ncw.' Fi fcs `gltmluid tg "cssirt actirmcn ec`tucn stctiailts tfct [fi klgws criQ ecnsi" cld fcs cdvclìd tfisi

tfi Xispgldilts ecmnid tg prgduì cly ge tfi i-acmns cld gtfir pirtmlilt ivmdilì prgduìd cld/gr riìmvid durmloi-dms`gviry ml Xgwi. Cs c risunt, emvi agltfs fcvi hiil issiltmcnny wcstid ml tfms `csi.\ Am`fcin Rwimo cld Ngih & Ngih NNZ's mltiltmglcn spgnmctmgl ge ivmdil i, ecmnuri tg mssui c n m t moc t mgl fgnd cldgtfir 'hcd ecmtf" tc`tm`s mlvgnvmlo agrcn turpmtudi cri ml dmri`t vmgnctmgl ge tfi Liw ] g r k @gdi ge Zrgeissmglcn@gldu`t, ml`nudmlo, hut lgt n mam tid tg, "iloco[mloQ ml mnniocn `gldu`t tfct cdvirsiny rieni`ts gl tfi ncwyir's fglisty,trustwgrtfmliss gr emtliss cs c ncwyir;" "iloco[mloQ ml `gldu`t mlvgnvmlo dmsfglisty, ercud, diìmt gramsriprisiltctmgl;" "iloco[mloQ ml `gldu t tfct ms pribudm`mcn tg tfi cdamlmstrctmgl ge bustmì;" "klgwmlonycssmst[mloQ c budoi gr budm`mcn geem ir ml `gldu`t tfct ms c vmgnctmgl ge cppnm`chni runis ge budm`mcn `gldu`t gr gtfirncw;" cld "iloco[mloQ ml cly gtfir `gldu`t tfct cdvirsiny rieni`ts gl tfi ncwyir's emtliss cs c ncwyir." Xuni 6.4 (h),(`), (d), (e) cld (f). Tfi ioriomgus cld dmchgnm`cn `gldu`t ge Rwimo cld vcrmgus cttgrliys ml Xgwi sfgwid c hnctclt`gltiapt egr tfi @gurt cld c emadcailtcn dmsriocrd egr tfi budm`mcn prgìss. Ic`f cttgrliy, wmtfgut quistmgl,ilocoid ml ercudunilt `gldu`t w m t f tfi "purpgsi tg di imvi" cld tfimr hifcvmgr `gltcmls iniailts ge "s`miltir,diìmt, mltilt tg amsnicd" cld tfiy "klgwmlo[nyQ ecmn[idQ tg `grri`t [tfimrQ amsriprisiltctmgls." Xuni 3.: ( m) . C ncwyirsfcnn lgt "`gulsin c `nmilt tg ilocoi, gr cssmst c `nmilt, ml `gldu`t tfct tfi ncvv\ir klgws ms mnniocn gr ercudunilt."Xuni 3.8 (d). Tfi Xunis `nicrny stcti tfct c ncwyir sfcnn lgt "suppriss ivmdilì tfct tfi ncwyir gr `nmilt fcs c niocnghnmoctmgl tg rivicn," "`glìcn gr klgwmlony ecmn tg dms`ngsi tfct wfm`f tfi ncwyir ms riqumrid hy ncw tg rivicn,""klgwmlony usi pirburid tistmagly gr ecnsi ivmdilì" gr "klgwmlony ilocoi ml gtfir mnniocn `gldu`t gr `gldu`t`gltrcry tg tfisi Xunis." Xuni 0.4 (c)(3), (0), (4) cld (5). _fil ygu uldirstcld tfisi Xunis, mt's lgt surprmsmlo tfcttfi @gurt ri`golmzis c n mlk hitwiil mltiltmglcn spgnmctmgl ge ivmdil i cld cl mldmvmducn's "hcd ec m tf" - c wgrd tfctfcs cppicrid gl luairgus g` csmgls tfrguofgut ay pnicdmlos tg dis`rmhi tfi c`tmgls ge _ m n n m c a Agrrms, Ngih &Ngih NNZ cld Am`fcin Rwimo. Istchnmsfmlo "hcd ecmtf" `cl hi istchnmsfid w m t f imtfir dmri`t gr `mrùastcltmcnivmdilì wfiri ìrtcml ec`tgrs `glviroi. Tfgrltgl v. H n m t z YPC. Ml`.. 69: E. Pupp. 8d 30?4 (P.D. Oc. 8:33). Ivilm e _ m n n m c a Agrrms "acdi" Ngih & Ngih NNZ cld Am`fcin Rwimo ilocoi ml `rmamlcn c`tmvmty gl tfimr hifcne, cncwyir "ms hguld hy tfisi Xunis lgtwmtfstcldmlo tfct tfi ncvk'yir c tid ct tfi dmri`tmgl ge clgtfir pirsgl." Xuni 9.8(c). Tfimr ulitfm`cn cld `rmamlcn [@ncmaclt's Xip. Puaacm\ Budoailt, 34-39, =?.Q\ Livm/ ]grk Xunis ge Zrgeissmglcn @gldu`t, Xuni 0.3.

-?-


8/11

dieilsis ml ixtriai "hcd e c m t n m " tg "dincy gr prgnglo tfi risgnutmgl ge n m t moc t mgl. " Xuni 0.3. Ml tfi eidircn `gurt, criprisiltid pcrty wfg smols fms gr fir lcai tg dgùailts emnid ml `gurt hicrs c pirsglcn, lgldiniochnirispglsmhmnmty tg ìrtmey tfi trutf cld ricsglchniliss ge tfi dgùailt cld tfi ecmnuri tg aiit tfct duty acy suhbi`ttfi smolir tg Xuni 33 scl tmgls. Eid. X. @mv. Z. 33. [@ncmaclt Xip. Puaacry Budoailt, 89-85.Q Tfms aicls tfctNgih & Ngih NNZ's mltiltmglcn amsriprisiltctmgls gl hifcne ge _m n n m ca Agrrms eurtfir diaglstrctis tfct tfiy crioum n ty ge pirbury, c vmgnctmgl ge 36 Y.P.@. 3583 . Cnsg, tfi `rmamlcn iniailts ge tfimr c`tmgls `cllgt hi molgrid cswi n n . Yldir tfi Pcrhclis-Gxniy stctuti, 36 Y.P.@ 393= , mt `nicrny stctis2 "_fgivir klgwmlony cntirs, distrgys,autmnctis, `glìcns, `gvirs up, ecnsmemis, gr ackis c ecnsi iltry ml cly ri`grd, dgùailt, gr tclomhni ghbi`t wm t f tfimltilt tg mapidi, ghstru`t, gr mlenuilì tfi mlvistmoctmgl gr prgpir cdamlmstrctmgl ge cly acttir wm tf ml tfiburmsdm`tmgl ge tfi Ylmtid Ptctis gr cly `csi emnid uldir t m t n i 33, gr ml rinctmgl tg gr `gltiapnctmgl ge cly su f acttirgr csi, sfcnn hi emlid uldir tfms t m t ni , maprmsglid lgt agri tfcl 8: yicrs, gr hgtf." Ml Crtfur Cldirsil. NNZ v.Ylmtid Ptctis. 944 Y.P. 5=5 (8::9), tfi Pupriai @gurt acdi mt `nicr tfct tfiri aust hi riqumsmti ùnpchmnmty cld tfcttfi dieildclt aust fcvi mltildid tg "`grrupdy" pirsucdi clgtfir ml grdir tg hi nmchni uldir 36 Y.P.@. 3 9 3 8 . Tfiwgrd "`grruptny" lgracnny aicls "wrglo e n m n , maagrcn, diprcvid gr iv m n " `gldu`t. Tfms cocml suppgrts tfi ec`t tfctti`flm`cnny, Ngih & Ngih NNZ sfgund lgt hi riprisiltmlo _m n n m ca Agrrms ml tfms `csi, cld tfct Rwimo cld fms gtfir`g-`glspmrctgrs sfgund ùrriltny hi ml prmsgl.

M e tfisi hc`k up tcpis cld cddmtmglcn dgùailts tfct M fcvi ml m t mc n ny riquistid cri lgt prgduìd, M csk tfctygu strmki ygur pribudmìd, gli-siltilì di`msmgl ml ygur tf m rd Mltirma Di`msmgl v/fm`f irrgligusny `gl`nudid tfcttfi pri-dmsputi, acldctgry crhmtrctmgl coriiailt M smolid cs c `gldmtmgl ge iapngyailt - smx yicrs cetir tfmsivmdilì wcs `glìcnid - ms "lgt ul`gls mglchni"* cld cnngw tfms `csi tg prgìid hc`k ml tfi Pgutfirl Dmstrm`t geL iw ]gr k sg tfct mt cl hi di mdid hy c bu r y tfct rieni`ts tfi dmvirsmty ge Cairm`c cld lgt tfi gpmlmgls ge wfmtiacnis gvir tfi coi ge 9:. [po. 4.Q M e lgt, 3 csk tfct diecunt budoailt hi orcltid gl cnn `ncmas smlì ygu tgnd us durmlogur Buny 0:, 8:30 `gleirilì `cnn tfct me wi coriid tg lgt fcvi dms`gviry cld cl grcn ficm'mlo chgut "Ixfmhmt 03,"ygu wgund fcvi hiil chni tg mssui c "tfgrguont di`msmgl gl cnn ge tfi mssuis" hy "Nchgr Dcy," wfm`f wcsPiptiahir 8, 8:30. Ml Acncutic v. Puzukm Agtgr @g.. Ntd.. =6? E.8d 3905, 89 Eid. X. Pirv. 0d 95: (33tf @mr.3==0), `gurt riceemraid tfct c Eid. X. @mv. Z. 0?(h)(8)(@) diecunt budoailt scl tmgl riqumris c dinmhircti gr hcdecmtf ecmnuri tg ghiy c dms`gviry grdir Tfi `gurt `gl`nudid tfct " [ m Q l tfms `csi, tfi dieildclts r m `fny disirvid tfiscl`tmgl ge c diecunt budoailt, wfiri tfi dieildclt acluec`turirs ocvi amsnicdmlo clswirs tg mltirrgoctgrmis cldriquists egr prgdu`tmgl ge dgùailts, rieusid tg clswir oilircn quistmgls, ecnsiny dilmid mts cwcriliss geOilircn Agtgrs di msmgls tg lgt acrkit tfi Puzukm Pcaurc, cld ecmnid tg prgduì, dispmti twg `gurt grdirs, tfidipgsmtmgl trcls`rmpt ge twg Puzukm ilomliirs e rga clgtfir `csi." (iapfcsms cddid)

M e diecunt budoailt ms lgt orcltid cld tfi Xispgldilts ecmn tg prgduì tfi 3==6-3=== hc`k up tcpis cldcddmtmglcn dgùailts, M csk tfct M mlsticd hi cnngwid tg `gldu`t c `gltiapgrcry sicr f ge tfi fcrd drmvis ge _m n n m caAgrrms e rga 8::8 cld 8:30 usmlo smamncr sicr f tiras usid ml Xgwi, cs wi n n cs sicr`fmlo egr cly i-acmns pirtcmlmlotg aysine (cld Cer m`cl Cairm`cls ml oilircn) pri cld pgst-fmrmlo.' [@ncmaclt Xip. Puaacry Budoailt, =:-=3.Q

Tfms maprgvmdilt di`msmgl sfgund cnsg hi strm kil riocrdniss ge tfi Xispgldilts' dms`gviry chusis hi`cusi ygu crivmgnctmlo ay `glstmtutmglcn rmofts tg dui prgìss. ]gur si gld Mltirma Di`msmgl `ncmaid tfct ygu wiri lgt chni tgacki c " e m l c n " di`msmgl riocrdmlo tfi ilegrìchmnmty ge tfi cmtmtrctmgl coriiailt cld/gr cnn `ncmlrs ultmn cetir hgtfpcrtmis `gldu`tid dms`gviry cld fcd cl grcn ficrmlo riocrdmlo "Ixfmhmt 03" cld i-dms`gviry ml Xgwi. Durmlo cldcetir gur Buny 0:, 8:30 `gleiril i `cn n , M ixprissid tfct lg di`msmgl `gund hi acdi ult m n tfms fcppilid. Limtfir glige tfisi tfmlos fcvi g`ùrrid, filì tfi ricsgl egr tfms Agt mgl . ]gu cnsg `mtid lg `csi ncw tg suppgrt ygur di`msmglcld M wm n n lgt cnngw ygu tg schgtcoi ay csi. M wm n n hi emnmlo c si`gld Agt m gl egr @ncrmem`ctmgl cld Agdmem`ctmgllixt wiik tg cddriss tfi irrgrs `gltcmlid ml ygur tf m rd Mltirma Di`msmgl.' "C si`gld `gltiapgrcry i-acmn sicr f sfgund smauntcligusny hi `gldu`tid ml ay `csi cs wi n n hi`cusi mt wm n ncnngw ai tg enmrtfir istchnmsf pritixt tg tfi Xispgldilts' `ncmas riocrdmlo ay cttmtudi cld wgrk piregraclì, smlìmt ms ghvmgus tfct i-acmns cri c acbgr `gaaulm`ctmvi sgurì egr _m n n m ca Agrrms cld mts cnn-_fmti/"Biwmsf"di`msmglackirs tg `ncldistmliny ixpriss tfimr dms`rmamlctgry hmcsis cld pribudm is chgut Cer m`cl Cairm`cls cldgtfir pigpni ge `gngr. Mt wm n n cnsg diaglstrcti wfct wi cnn klgw2 ivil cetir `gaamttmlo tfisi gdmgus, rcì-hcsid`rmais cocmlst Cer m`cl Cairm`cls ml Xgwi, _m n n m ca Agrrms `gltmluid tg wm n n e u n n y ilocoi ml mts dms`rmamlctgry cld

-6 -


9/11

Pmlì tfi Xispgldilts fcvi crouid tfct "Ixfmhmt 0 3 " ms mmrinivclthi`cusi tfi iapngyiis lcaid gl tfi nmst wiri lgtiapngyid ml tfi Liw ]grk geemì, tfms wm n n cnngw ai tfi chmnmty tg embrtfir prgvi ay `ncmas tfct tfi `gapcly's"ulvcrlmsfid rc`mcn clmaus" tgwcrds Cerm`cl Cairm`cls ms `gapcly-wmdi, systiam`, mlstmtutmglcn cld iahiddidmltg tfi `gri ge tfi `gapcly's "stcti ge amld" - tfi ricsgl wfy tfi `gapcly fcs acmltcmlid mts iapngyailtprc`tmìs, pgnm`mis cld prgìduris tfct fcvi `rictid c oncrmlo dmspcrcti mapc`t cocmlst qucnmemid pigpni ge `gngr ergahimlo fmrid cld/gr prgagtid cs Coilts. Pmlì agst iapngyiis tfct M wgrkidwm t f wgund livir suspi`t tfct tfimr i-acmns `gund hi mlspi`tid gr sicr`fid, tfms ms c ncroi sgurì ge gee ri`grd cld mlegracn `gaaulm`ctmgl hy ay piirscld 3 fcvi ricsgl tg hinmivi tfct M w m n n ul`gvir cddmtmglcn ivmdilì tg suppgrt tfct M wcs c vm`tma ge pri-fmrmlodms`rmamlctmgl cld glì M iltirid tfms mlsmdmgusny dms`rmamlctgry, cnn-_fmti/"Biwmsf" wgrk ilvmrglailt cs tfi glnyCerm`cl Cairm`cl iapngyid ct cly nivin ge tfi Coilt Trcmlii prgorca, tfct M wcs "sit up tg ecmn" hi`cusi ge ayrcì, `gngr cld/gr pirìmvid lctmglcn grmoml.

Ny m lo chgut ay wgrk piregraclì siiaid tg hi tfi og tg strctioy ge acly ge tfi wfmti/"Biwmsf" Coiltscld stcee M wgrkid wm t f hi`cusi Fuacl Xisgurìs cnwcys c`ìptid wfct tfiy scmd cs trutf.'" _fil M trmid tg ixpncmltg Fuacl Xisgurìs fgw acly ge tfisi tfmlos tfct wiri himlo scmd chgut ai wiri ultrui cld acly ge tfiivcnuctmgls omvil hy Coilts dmd lgt rieni`t ay c`tucn wgrk piregraclì hi`cusi M wcs cssmolid agstny "dicd-ildcssmolailts," tfiy pcmd ay gaailts lg cttiltmgl cld `gltmluid tg cssmol ai Pmsypficl tcsks." Mtruny hinmivi tfmswcs cl cttiapt tg iviltucnny acki ai qumt gl ay gwl c``grd. Ml tfi Xispgldilts' agtmgls egr suaacmy budoailt,Am`fcin Rwimo cld Ngih & Ngih NNZ `gltmluid tg cdvclì tfisi nmis hy stctmlo tfrguofgut tfimr Gppgsmtmgl tfct"acly" ge ay smamncrny smtuctid _fmti/"Biwmsf" `gultim"pcrts ml tfi Coilt Trcmlii prgorca "fcd pgst- gnnioiixpirmilì iqucn gr ct nicst ecr supirmgr tg" ai cntfguof agst ge ay smamncrny smtuctid wfmti/"Biwmsf"`gultirpcrts ml tfi Coilt Trcmlii prgorca wiri riìlt `gnnioi orcductis wm t f lg wgrk ixpirmilì ml tfiiltirtcmlailt mldustry, (iapfcsms cddid) [@ncmaclt Xip. Puaacry Budoailt, 05-0?; Aicdi Cee., % 3:.Q Tfiy cnsgtrmid tg dms`ridmt ay wgrk piregracl i hy ecnsiny stctmlo tfct ay mlchmnmty tg cdvcl i chgvi tfi Liw ]grk geemì'soncss ìmnmlo wcs dui tg c `gahmlctmgl ge ay pggr cttmtudi cld "ulivil cld imrctm` piregraclì." [Xis. :pp.Puaacry Budoailt, 38, 35, 0=; Ucl Fgvil, \ 3:.QQ M'a c fcrd wgrkir cld cl gvir-c`fmivir hy lcturi. Ml lg wcy dg

M hinmivi M ca pirei`t, hut cnn ge tfisi stctiailts, cs wi n n cs tfi gtfirs cdvclìd tfrguofgut tfimr pnicdmlos, cridiecactgry cld nmhingus. Hy ixpcldmlo dms`gviry, M `cl embrtfir prgvi tfms ec`t cld diaglstrcti tfct tfimr niocnnymlsueem`milt dieilsis cri pritixtucn.

cltm`gapitmtmvi prc`tmìs wm t f "acnmì cld/gr ri`kniss mldmeeirilì" tg tfi eidircnny prgti`tid rmofts ge Cerm`clCairm`cls. Tfms ixpncmls wfy tfiri `gltmluis tg hi zirg Cerm`cl Cairm`cl Coilts gr @ggrdmlctgrs iapngyid ml tfiL iw ]grk geemì cld wfy M wcs ixtriainy gvirqucnmemid `gapcrid tg ay smamncrny smtuctid _fmti/"Biwmsf"`gultirpcrts wfil M stcrtid tfi Coilt Trcmlii prgorca. Cddmtmglcnny, smlì tfi Xispgldilts fcvi ecmnid tg aiittfimr hurdil ge prgdu`tmgl cld pirsucsmgl hy mltiltmglcnny wmtffgndmlo dgùailts su`f cs tfi risuais ge aysmamncrny smtuctid _fmti,/"Biwmsf" Coilt Trcmliis cld riìltny prgagtid Coilts, ay ivcnuctmgls, bgh dis`rmptmglsegr tfi Coilt pgsmtmgl, tfimr rispglsi tg ay IIG@ `gapncmlt, cld gtfir rinivclt dgùailts, tfi Xispgldiltssfgund hi `gapinnid tg prgduì tfisi dgùailts." [@ncmaclt Xip. Puaacmy Budoailt, =5.Q' Ml tfi Ceemdcvmt ge Biee Aicdi, fi cnsg stctid tfct M "riìmvid agri lioctmvi `gaailts [gvir 8:Q, riocrdmlo [ayQpiregraclì tfcl cly gtfir Coilt trcmlii." [Aicdi Cee. % 88;Xis. Gpp. Puaacry Budoailt, 35.Q Tfms ml nudis tfi"ivcnuctmgl" ge @frms _cnsf, ficd ge Ppi`mcn Pirvmìs, wfg hnctcltny nmid gl ai ml twg i-acmns tg Ucl Fgvil mlwfm`f fi stctid tfct M wcs c "eiw fgurs" ncti tg c trcmlmlo cntfguof M fcvi prgvil wfy fms stctiailts wiri lgt trui.[@ncmaclt Xip. Puaacry Budoailt, 46; @ncmaclt Puaacry Budoailt, 3Q 3:4, Ixfmhmt L; @ncmaclt PGL]@gapncmlt, F T Q 6=-=?.Q" Egrair @GG ge tfi Liw ]grk geemì, @crc Ptiml, cdamttid durmlo gur si gld aiitmlo glCprm n ?, 8:3:, tfct ayivcnuctmgls wiri lgt hcd. Durmlo tfi emrst aiitmlo, sfi stctid tfct 3 wcs pgssmhny tfi prghnia wfil M cnnioid tfct Mwcs himlo sit up tg ecmn hi`cusi ge ay rcì gr tfi `gngr ge ay skml. Fgwivir, prmgr tg tfgsi twg aiitmlos, cnn ge tfiCoilt Trcmliis/Engctirs fcd c aiitmlo wm tf Ptiml, Ucl Fgvil cld Aicdi, ml wfm`f tfiy mlegraid tfi orgup tfct tfieiidhc`k erga Coilts wcs tfct gur piregraclì gvircnn wcs pggr. _i wiri tgnd wi wgund cnn hi omvil c "si`gld`fcl i," cntfguof tfms `gaailt dmdl't ricnny cppny tg aihi`cusi M wcs omvil viry nmttni gppgrtulmtmis tg wgrk wm t fCoilts cld agstny wgrkid wm tf suppgrt stcee gr wm t f tfi Acmnrgga cld tfms dmd lgt `fcloi. [@ncmaclt Xip.Puaacry Budoailt, 49.Q

-= -


10/11

Ml tfi aicltmai, gli ge tfi hist wcys tg `gahct dms`gviry chusis ge tfi Xispgldilts cld tfimr `gulsin cttfms stcoi ml tfi crhmtrctmgl ms tg "turl stgliwcnnmlo tg tfi pncmltmees cdvcltcoi hy ackmlo tfi [geeildirQ hicr tfi`gsts ge mts . . . chusi."'\ Dui tg tfimr mltiltmglcn amsriprisiltctmgls, `gltuac`mgus hifcvmgr, ghstru`tmgl ge bustmìcld gtfir dms`gviry chusis, M sfgund hi cwcrdid ricsglchni cttgrliy's eiis mlùrrid erga trymlo tg siùri tfiXispgldilts' `gapnmclì wm t f tfimr dms`gviry ghnmoctmgls cld ackmlo tfi mlstclt agdgl, ml cl cagult iqumvcnilttg wfct Ngih & Ngih NNZ fcs hiil pcmd hy _mn n m ca Agrrms smlì ygu emrst `gapinnid tfia tg prgduì tfisidgùailts ml ygur Cpr m n 36, 8:30 Mltirma Di`msmgl. "Tfi cwcrd ge eiis cld ixpilsis ms tfi amndist ge tfi scl tmglscutfgrmzid hy Xuni 0?," cld c `gurt liid lgt emld tfct c pcmty "ilocoid ml wmn n eu n dmsghidmilì gr orgss lionmoilì"hiegri riqumrmlo c pcmty tg pcy mts cdvirscry's cttgrliy's eiis ml `glli`tmgl wm tf c dms`gvimy-rinctid dmsputi. PiiNcld Gìcl Ngomstm`s. Ml`. v. Cquc Ou n e @grpgrctmgl. 363 E.X.D. 88=, 80= (_ .D .L .] . 3==6) Xctfir, c `gurt acymapgsi cl cpprgprmcti cwcrd ge ixpilsis wfirivir, cs firi, c pcrty ulricsglchny cld ulbustmemchny dincys grgtfirwmsi erustrctis dms`gviry gr ecmns tg `gapny wm tf c dms`gviry-rinctid `gurt grdir. Pii Fgcr v. Pcrc Nii @grp..668 .E.8d 568, 56? (8d. @mr. 36=6) (ceemramlo cwcrd ge ixpilsis cld eiis wfiri p nc ml t m e e cld fms cttgrliy "lioni tidtg rispgld ge tfimr gwl mlmtmctmvi, molgrid dui dctis, liìssmtctid dieildclts' agtmgls tg `gapin, cld dmsghiyid ctnicst twg privmgus `gurt grdirs"); Bgfl H. Fu n n . Ml`. v. _ctirhurv Zitrgniua Zrgds.. Ml`.. 649 E.8d 33?8, 33?? (8d@mr. 3=66) (ceemramlo dmsamsscn ge `gapncmlt cld cwcrd ge cttgrliys' eiis tg tfmrd-pcrty dieildclt wfiri dieildclt"limtfir geeirid c sctmsec`tgmy ixpnclctmgl egr mts ecmnuri tg `gapny wm tf tfi `gurt's grdirs lgr diaglstrctidmrùastclìs tfct wgund acki tfi cwcmd ulbust"); Pii Agrucv. @gapclmcDgamlm`clc di Cmc`mgl @. pgr C .. 3==:

_ N 983:4, ct *8 (P.D.L.]. Cpr. 3=, 3==:) ("Pmlì pncmltmees' ecmnuri tg rispgld embnny tg tfi mltilgoctglis gr tgriquist egr ixtilsmgl ge tmai vv 'cs lgt suhstcltmcnny bustmemid, tfms @gurt cwcrds ricsglchni ixpilsis, ml`nudmlocttgrliy's eiis...."); Ucndcl Ppgrtswicr v. Agltogairy_crd & @g.. Ml`.. 9=3 E.Pupp. 3366, 33=0 (P.D.L.]. 3=64)(cwcrdmlo dieildclts cttgrliy's eiis wfiri p nc ml t m e e ecmnid, "wmtfgut ixùsi," tg prgduì dgùailts hy dctispi`memid ml `gurt grdir). Ml tfi ncst yicr, ay uliapngyailt hiliemts fcvi hiil ixfcustid cld twg agltfs cog, Mwcs tgnd tfct M ca lg ngloir inmomhni egr eggd stcaps hi`cusi tfi Ptcti ge Liw ]grk hinmivis M sfgund hi wgrkmlo -c di`msmgl tfct M'a ml tfi prgìss ge cppicnmlo. M ca lgt ivil chni tg finp suppgrt ay ecamny wfg ms cnngwmlo ai tgnmvi rilt erii hi`cusi M 'a lgt chni tg emld iapngyailt cld M aust hi ristgrid tg c pgsmtmgl tfct tckis mltg c``gulttfi emlcl`mcn ngssis M'vi mlùrrid cs c risunt ge tfi Xispgldilts' `gulsin's dmchgnm`cn cld "hcd ecm tf" `gldu t.

Gli tfmlo ms egr ìrtcml, tfi Xispgldilts `cllgt hi grdirid cld tfil ecmn tg prgduì cly dgùailts cldtclomhni ivmdil i pirtcmlmlo tg i-dms`gviry ml Xgwi. cld tfil ygu orclt tfi Xispgldilts' @rgss-Agtmgl tg Dmsamsscld/gr cwcrd tfia dcacois egr cnnioid diecactmgl, nmhin cld/gr sncldir. [.Cprmn 36, 8:30 Mltirma Di`msmgl, =-3:;Piptiahir 89, 8:30 Mltirma Di`msmgl, 9.Q

@ G L @ N Y P M G L

Tfi Xispgldilts fcvi su`ìidid egr tfi pcst sivircn agltfs ml cvgmdmlo tfi prgdu`tmgl ge cly dgùailts clderustrctmlo tfi Crhmtrctgr's grdirs. Tfimr cttiapts tg stcnn cld mapidi tfi prgsiùtmgl ge tfms `csi aust hi scl tmglid.Egr tfi egriogmlo ricsgls, M rispi`tenmnny csk tfct tfi Crhmtrctgr orclt ay agtmgl ml mts iltmrity. M csk tfct ygu `gapinAm`fcin Z. Rwimo cld Ngih & Ngih NNZ tg `gapny wm t f ay dms`gviry riquists hy G`tghir 4, 8:30. Me tfisiriquists cri lgt orcltid, M csk tfi Crhmtrctgr tg orclt cl grcn ficrmlo hitwiil G tghir 35-36, 8:30 tg dmsùss tfisiacttirs, cs winn cs ay pildmlo Agt mgl egr @ncrmem`ctmgl cld Agdmem`ctmgl tg ygur tfmrd Mltirma Di`msmgl tfct wm n n hiemnid lg nctir tfcl G tghir ?, 8:30, uldir gctf ml grdir tg privilt tfms ncldacrk fuacl rmofts cld cltmtrust `csierga schgtcoid cld fcraen m n ny dincyid cly eurtfir, cs winn cs tg privilt tfms nicr ams`crrmcoi ge bustmì.

Ercl`ms F . Fcri Br. it cn. Eunn Dms`ngsuri2 @gahcttmlo Ptgliwcnnmlo cld Gtfir Dms`gviry Chusis, p. 363 (3==4).-3:-


11/11

Dctid2 Liw ]grk, Liw ]grk Hy2 / \ U U \Piptiahir 0:, 8:30 Acr`us M . _csfmlotgl

Zrg Pi @ncmaclt94 Hgirua Pt. Cpt. 5AHrggknyl, L] 338:5(545) 9:4-54=?fuaclrmoft s.cricaustJoacm 3.`ga

washington v. william morris endeavor enterainment et al. -- claimant's emergency motion to order...

Documents