volume of sediment in deposited in glacial lake ......seismic reflection profile . dutch island...

27
VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE NARRAGANSETT DURING LATE WISCONSINAN DEGLACIATION: IMPLICATIONS ON SEDIMENT SOURCE? Bryan A. Oakley 1 and Jon C. Boothroyd 2,3 1. Department of Environmental Earth Science, Eastern Connecticut State University, Willimantic, CT, USA 2. State Geologist, Rhode Island Geological Survey 3. Research Professor Emeritus, Department of Geosciences, College of the Environment and Life Sciences, Univ. of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI, USA Northeast meeting of the Geological Society of America March 23rd, 2015 – Talk S2-6 Bretton Woods, New Hampshire

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE NARRAGANSETT DURING

LATE WISCONSINAN DEGLACIATION: IMPLICATIONS ON SEDIMENT SOURCE?

Bryan A. Oakley1 and Jon C. Boothroyd2,3

1. Department of Environmental Earth Science, Eastern Connecticut State University,

Willimantic, CT, USA

2. State Geologist, Rhode Island Geological Survey

3. Research Professor Emeritus, Department of Geosciences, College of the Environment and Life Sciences, Univ. of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI, USA

Northeast meeting of the Geological Society of America March 23rd, 2015 – Talk S2-6

Bretton Woods, New Hampshire

Page 2: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

OUTLINE 1. Determine sediment volume for Glacial

Lake Narragansett

2. Where did all of that sediment come from anyways?

Page 3: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,
Page 4: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,
Page 5: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Oakley and Boothroyd, 2013

Glacial Lake Narragansett

Page 6: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Ice thickness - m

Isostatic depression - m

Distance north of terminal margin - km

Ice sheet profiles and resultant isostatic

depression

Oakley and Boothroyd, QR, 2012

Ice thickness < 350 mm

Page 7: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Delta

Lakefloor

Oakley and Boothroyd; in prep

Stratified Deposits:

Glacial Lake Narragansett

Page 8: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

DETERMINING SEDIMENT VOLUME

1. Measure thickness of stratified deposits below present-day Narragansett Bay using seismic reflection profiles

2. Calculate thickness of stratified deposits graded to Glacial Lake Narragansett using published borehole records and mapped extents

Page 9: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILES

Page 10: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE Dutch Island Delta

Oakley, 2012

Page 11: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF

STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas, Lacustrine Fans)

Previous Slide

Page 12: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

STRATIFIED DEPOSIT

THICKNESS Individual Well Log

Delta Extent from: Boothroyd and

McCandless, 2002

Page 13: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

VOLUME OF SEDIMENT DEPOSITED: GLACIAL LAKE NARRAGANSETT

Page 14: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

VOLUME OF SEDIMENT DEPOSITED: GLACIAL LAKE NARRAGANSETT

Total Volume = ~9 x 109 m3

Page 15: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

VOLUME OF SEDIMENT DEPOSITED: GLACIAL LAKE NARRAGANSETT

Total Volume = ~10 x 109 m3

Page 16: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

CONCLUSION I • Glacial Lakefloor deposits below

Narragansett Bay > 4 x 109 m3

• The volume of stratified deposits (deltas) around GLN > 5 x 109 m3

• Total volume > ~10 x 109 m3

Page 17: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Glacial Lake Narragansett Min age: 19,500 yBP

Max age: >20,400 yBP

Oakley and Boothroyd, 2013 J. of Paleolimnology

Page 18: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Possible Sources of Sediment • IF all older deposits removed during advance

(transported to shelf?), ALL sediment deposited must either be:

- Erosion of bedrock - Mobilized subglacial till - Transported from ‘up ice’

Page 19: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Equivalent excavation of >3 m . m-2 of

sediment/bedrock erosion

(Assuming it ALL went to GL Narragansett)

Narragansett Bay Watershed ~3,000 km2

Page 20: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

1,200 km2

Equivalent excavation of >7.5 m . m-2 of

sediment/bedrock erosion

Bedrock erosion near LIS margin ~ 0.4 – 0.9 m (Colgan et al. 2002) Bedrock ages in NJ ‘about right’ (Biermen et al., 1998) Variable; erosion in valleys, less on uplands (Briner et al., 2006)

Delta

Lakefloor

Page 21: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Assume: Erosion concentrated in valleys with minimal erosion on uplands

Area = 500 km2 for valleys requires incision of ~20 m

Closed depressions

> 50 m VERY localized

Bedrock Valleys Upson and Spencer, 1964)

1 km buffer

Page 22: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Google Earth

Run out and get new ages? Outcrops of Rhode Island Formation (Quartzite (conglomerate))

Page 23: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

http://www.panoramio.com/photo/41494198

Outcrops of Rhode Island Formation (Quartzite (conglomerate))

~10 m

Would a deglacial age represent bedrock erosion or just L. Wisconsinan

uncovering?

Page 24: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

CONCLUSIONS II • Bedrock erosion probably doesn’t account

for all of the sediment deposited in GLN • How much? • < 25%?

• Some older (Illinoian and/or L. Wisconsinan advance deposits probably survived the advance of the LIS and were mobilized during retreat

Page 25: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

Older Stratified Deposits: “Lower Drift” Illinoian/Early Wisconsinan

Block Island, RI

(For more on Block Island, see S2: Posters – booth 36 and 37 Monday 1:30-5:30p)

Page 26: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

CONCLUSIONS II • This implies, at least near the terminal

margin in S. New England, removal of older deposits and erosion down to bedrock during advance of the Laurentide Ice Sheet was likely not as complete as often portrayed.

Page 27: VOLUME OF SEDIMENT IN DEPOSITED IN GLACIAL LAKE ......SEISMIC REFLECTION PROFILE . Dutch Island Delta. Oakley, 2012 . INTERPOLATED THICKNESS OF STRATIFIED DEPOSITS (Lakefloor, Deltas,

QUESTIONS?