volume 57 issue 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · association of new zealand 2 concrete || volume 57 issue 2...

28
READING CONCRETE CAN CONTRIBUTE TO YOUR SKILLS MAINTENANCE VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Designs for a National Earthquake Museum VUW ARCHITECTURE STUDENTS PROPOSE MEMORIAL STRUCTURE The Benefits of Concrete Roads NEW RESEARCH SHOWS RIGID PAVEMENTS TO BE 25% CHEAPER Maori Concrete Motifs WHITIREIA CAMPUS REDEVELOPMENT COMBINES SHAPE, TEXTURE AND COLOUR concrete

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jun-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

readinG concrete can contribute to your skills maintenance

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Designs for a National Earthquake Museum VUW ARCHITECTURE STUDENTS PROPOSE MEMORIAL STRUCTURE

The Benefits of Concrete Roads NEW RESEARCH SHOWS RIGID PAVEMENTS TO BE 25% CHEAPER

Maori Concrete Motifs WHITIREIA CAMPUS REDEVELOPMENT COMBINES SHAPE, TExTURE AND COLOUR

concrete

Page 2: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

UPFRONTPrime Minister John Key recently announced Saturday 20 September as the date of the general election.

Almost immediately political parties began positioning themselves in relation to key issues through various ‘policy’ announcements.

Of particular interest, or should that be concern, to the concrete industry is the Labour party’s Forestry and Wood Products Economic Upgrade policy package.

Announced mid-March by David Cunliffe at the ForestWood conference in Wellington, the policy package is part of Labour’s plan to transition New Zealand to a “modern, high value economy.”

However, the material specific nature of the policies is so overt that if implemented they would create an inappropriate commercial advantage for one construction material over another.

The Pro-Wood Government Procurement Strategy component is particularly alarming. It stipulates that “all government-funded project proposals for new buildings up to four storeys high shall require a build-in-wood option at the initial concept / request-for-proposals stage (with indicative sketches and price estimates).”

Sound familiar? It is the same flawed policy floated, but shelved, by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry several years ago, one which CCANZ vocally opposed.

Now, as then, it is completely inappropriate to mandate that decision makers in the construction process must consider wood as a structural option. Such preferential treatment of one industry over another would set a disappointing precedent.

Government should not be picking winners when it comes to the selection of construction materials, which should stand or fall on their own technical, cost, aesthetic and sustainability credentials.

Building environment rating tools, such as the Green Star rating tool, have gained traction over recent years, and offer a far more objective assessment of the benefits of construction materials.

To suggest that timber is a more sustainable option and as such should be the preferred material for government buildings is too simplistic. I do not dispute that wood has sustainable properties, or that forestry is important to New Zealand’s Kyoto obligations. However, this does not outweigh or negate the sustainability of other construction materials such as concrete.

In addition, the policy does a huge dis-service to the hardworking men and women in the cement and concrete industries. Favouring a single construction material during the design phase of a government building could seriously impact on their livelihoods and jobs.

My sentiments are shared by the steel industry. Metals NZ believe the policy undermines the technical expertise of structural engineers, architects and quantity surveyors, who are the best people to evaluate the most suitable building materials based on the desired product performance and commercial outcomes for a particular project.

On his blog, ACT leader Jamie Whyte refers to Labour’s policies as “forced consumption”, and believes they are “not merely a path to national economic decline. They appeal to immoral and anti-social urges: vote for me and I will prey on others for your benefit.”

In a withering attack, Economic Development Minister Steven Joyce called the policy “classic 70s ‘government knows best’ interventionism,” and asked the question “what next, supplementary minimum prices for wood?”

In short, this policy does not create a level playing field for the use of construction materials in government buildings. In fact, materials other than wood will be considerably disadvantaged by this policy.

The wide-reaching implications of this policy are extremely concerning and it should in no circumstances be adopted.

Rob Gaimster CCANZ, CEO

concreteMAGAZINE

Editor/Advertising:

Adam Leach

+64 4 915 0383

[email protected]

Subscriptions:

Angelique Van Schaik

+64 4 499 8820

[email protected]

concrete is published quarterly

by CCANZ (Cement & Concrete

Association of New Zealand)

PO Box 448

Level 6, 142 Featherston St

Wellington

NEW ZEALAND

Tel: +64 4 499 8820

Fax: +64 4 499 7760.

Email: [email protected]

Website: www.ccanz.org.nz

ISSN: 1174-8540

ISSN: 1179-9374 (online)

Disclaimer: The views expressed in concrete

are not necessarily those of the Cement &

Concrete Association of New Zealand. While

the information contained in the magazine

is printed in good faith, its contents are

not intended to replace the services of

professional consultants on particular projects.

The Association accepts no legal responsibility

of any kind for the correctness of the contents

of this magazine, including advertisements.

© Copyright 2014 CCANZ (Cement &

Concrete Association of New Zealand)

THE MAGAZINE OF THE CEMENT AND CONCRETE

ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND

Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year architecture student at VUW.2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 3: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

www.reseneconstruction.co.nz 0800 50 70 40

Many older brick and masonry buildings now must be structurally upgraded or face an early retirement at the hands of the demolition contractors. Other buildings, such as those damaged by earthquakes need to be strengthened as part of their reinstatement to safe habitable buildings.

The SEISMOLOCK GRC Plaster is formulated to provide a strong bond to the surface of a masonry wall while the embedded layers of fibreglass mesh provide the tensile strength to resist in-plane shear loads and face loads on brick and masonry walls.

Strengthening existing brick and masonry buildings against earthquake loads

NEWSBASE ISOLATION 201As part of the Concrete Futures project CCANZ, along with the New Zealand Concrete Society, held the Base Isolation 201 seminar series in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch during December 2013.

Dr Alistair Russell (CCANZ Manager – Structural Performance & Engineering Systems) and Professor Ian Buckle

Ian Buckle, a Foundation Professor at the University of Nevada in Reno, was the principal speaker, with Barry Davidson, a well-known New Zealand based structural engineering researcher and practitioner, co-presenting.

As with the Base Isolation 101 seminar series held in March 2013, at which Ronald Mayes, Simpson Gumpertz & Heger’s base isolation project engineer, spoke alongside Ian Buckle, the 201 series sought to reacquaint New Zealand designers with what base isolation has to offer, and how to go about getting it.

Specifically, attendees gained a more advanced understanding of base isolation than given in the introductory series, and left being able to determine with confidence the properties of a base isolation system to meet required levels of seismic performance, and design/specify corresponding isolation hardware.

NEW BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING STANDARDNZS 3917:2013 Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering - Fixed Term has been published. NZS 3917 is the final in a suite of three standards which includes NZS 3910:2013 and NZS 3916:2013.

A review took place in 2011 of key areas of NZS 3910:2003 Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering. It was the first revision in 10 years of the form of contract most commonly used for building and civil engineering construction contracts in New Zealand. During the review, a decision was made by the committee that it should be published as three tailored standards:

• NZS 3910 Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering Construction

• NZS 3916 Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering – Design and Construct

• NZS 3917 Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering – Fixed Term

These three standards supersede NZS 3910:2003. For more information visit the Standards New Zealand website - www.standards.co.nz

NEWS

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 3

Page 4: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NEWS

MBIE VIDEOS ABOUT REPAIRS TO EARTHQUAKE-DAMAGED HOUSESAfter an earthquake floor structures may have been twisted, wrenched or tilted. The Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment (MBIE) has produced three videos to help repair, re-level or restore floor structures ‘right first time’.• Packing house piles• Lifting a wall plate• Jacking up a foundation

These resources are part of MBIE’s continuing support of the residential rebuild in Canterbury, which has included guidance, workshops and builders’ booklets.

Specifically, these videos show one practical approach to the work, and support the guidance document - Repairing and Rebuilding Houses Affected by the Canterbury Earthquakes.

Visit the MBIE website to watch the videos - www.dbh.govt.nz/guidance-information

NEW ZEALAND HOUSING AND CONSTRUCTION QUARTERLY (NZHCQ)The New Zealand Housing and Construction Quarterly (NZHCQ) analyses sector trends in the building, construction and housing sectors.

The NZHCQ report brings together information from Statistics New Zealand, Quotable Value, and the Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment (MBIE) to provide a comprehensive picture of the sector for the quarter.

Visit the MBIE website to download the report - www.dbh.govt.nz/nz-housing-and-construction-quarterly

BUILDING A BETTER NEW ZEALAND 2014 CONFERENCEScheduled for 3-5 September in Auckland, the Building a Better NZ conference will bring together a wide range of industry stakeholders including researchers, leaders, policy makers, innovators, designers and manufacturers to focus on research findings and case studies of best practice.

Aligned strongly with the New Zealand Building Research Strategy the conference will unite local and international speakers to share their knowledge and insights on innovative, high performance and low impact approaches to developing, maintaining and retrofitting the built environment.

Spanning policy, planning and design, through to construction, maintenance, refurbishment, reuse or deconstruction, the focus of the conference will be the future of New Zealand’s built environment and how to transform the building sector to deliver on the needs of future New Zealand.

Visit the conference website for more details - www.buildingabetternewzealand.co.nz

4 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 5: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

www.reseneconstruction.co.nz 0800 50 70 40

Aquapel infused lightweight concrete flooring

super hydrophobic, with steel mesh reinforcing

waterproof when cut

easy handling, cost effective

all weather installation

NEW

PCA LAUNCHES POTHOLE CAMPAIGNTo capitalize on the media attention potholes across North America are currently receiving the Portland Cement Association (PCA) has launched an outreach campaign to get the word out about the need for more infrastructure investment and the need for more durable paving materials: concrete.

The campaign is anchored in a section of PCA’s web site called www.OneBigPothole.com

The name stems from an NPR (National Public radio) interview with outgoing US Secretary of Transportation Ray LaHood covering the challenges involved in gaining approval for transportation funding. LaHood suggested that Americans would be okay with increased funding for repairs because they already know that “America is one big pothole right now.”

In addition to background materials and news feeds about potholes, the site features an interactive map showing social media mentions of potholes.

The campaign kicked off in March 2014 with media interviews of PCA President and CEO Gregory M. Scott, who shared how cities can reduce road maintenance costs by building streets and roads with durable concrete.

Scott was interviewed by national and regional radio and television stations, as he stressed that a concrete road has a useful life that is twice as long as an asphalt road, 30 years compared to 15 for asphalt.

Citing MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) CSHub research, Scott noted that the life-time maintenance costs are four times less for a concrete road when compared to an asphalt road.

NEWS

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 5

Page 6: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

CCANZ rECENtLy COMMiSSiONEd ECONOMiC CONSULtANtS iNfOMEtriCS tO iNVEStigAtE thE high-LEVEL

CASE fOr bUiLdiNg CONCrEtE rOAdS. it WAS fOUNd thAt iN A bASELiNE SCENAriO COMpAriNg thE

ECONOMiCS Of ASphALt ANd CONCrEtE rOAdS, CONCrEtE CAME iN ArOUNd 25% LESS ExpENSiVE.

inFrastructure inVestment

On many occasions CCANZ has taken the opportunity to highlight the range of economic, environmental and safety benefits offered by rigid concrete pavements. As the Government continues to invest heavily in roading these benefits become more compelling.

Sustainable infrastructure development, particularly a modern roading network, is crucial to the country’s ability to secure economic growth. The Government is spending around $12.2 billion in state highways over the next 10 years, including making further progress on the Roads of National Significance.

The emergence of the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) model, used to realise Wiri prison and the soon to begin Transmission Gully, is seen as a way to use private sector innovation and funding sources, as well as increase certainty of project delivery by re-assigning risk.

The current environment is ideally suited for decision makers to embrace innovative and long-lasting roading building techniques that, as demonstrated by the Infometric’s analysis, offer significant cost savings.

economic eVidence

The Infometrics report - The Case for Concrete Roads - indicates that over a 30-year life span concrete roads can yield significant

cost savings compared to those built using alternative materials. The adoption of concrete roads has the potential to cut hundreds of millions of dollars from the cost of major New Zealand roading projects.

The report’s findings took into account historical price trends for the outputs of the Petroleum Products and Non Metallic Mineral Manufacturing (NMMP) industries as proxies for the price trends in bitumen and concrete respectively. Likely future price paths were also examined, with the oil price in US dollars and the US$/NZ$ exchange rate informing bitumen price forecasts. The cost of carbon emissions was also considered.

The price volatility of bitumen compared with concrete was found to be a key factor in why roads constructed using concrete offer cost advantages. The price of concrete is generally stable, while bitumen, closely tied to global oil prices and the US/NZ exchange rate, tends to be unpredictable.

The likely future material prices trends look to further enhance the case for concrete roads. Petroleum Products prices have risen 180% since 1994 and will probably continue to increase annually at 5.8%. This is compared to a rise of just 44% in NMMP prices over the same period, with a projected annual increase of 2%.

To a large extent the Petroleum Products’ price premium reflects

CONCRETE ROADSTHE AFFORDABLE OPTION

6 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 7: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NON-HAZARDOUS PRODUCTS TO SAFELY

REPLACE HARSH ACIDS, SOLVENTS, AND CAUSTICS

INTEGRAL WATERPROOFING OF

CONCRETE SLABS AND STRUCTURES

JOINT-FREE FLOOR SLABS

Call the sole agent on 07 575 5410 or visit: www.demden.co.nz

LEADERS IN CONCRETE TECHNOLOGY

C o n c r e t e s o l u t i o n s

the costs associated with an uncertain overseas supply market. In contrast, the low annual price increase of 2% associated with concrete construction is due to the stable nature of domestic sources.

Overall the difference in CO2 emissions associated with concrete and asphalt roads was not deemed to be significant over a 30-year horizon. This finding took into account evidence that rigid concrete roads generate less tyre rolling resistance, implying less fuel use, especially by trucks. They may also require less lighting at night due to greater reflectivity.

The report also considered the impact of escalation clauses for the price of bitumen or oil in roading contracts. Such clauses inherently favour asphalt solutions proposed during tendering, and can potentially be seen as type of subsidy for one construction material over another.

scenario testinG

The report concludes by testing a set of scenarios involving different discount rates and expected service lives for an historic SH20 Mt Roskill project. Two different pavement options were

considered - Structural Asphaltic Pavement and Continuously Reinforced Concrete Pavement (with exposed aggregate finish).

In the baseline scenario with a discount rate of 8% and a 30 year service life the concrete option emerged 25.1% cheaper than the asphalt option. Lowering the discount rate by one percentage point raises the cost difference to 26.7%.

tHe comPlete PackaGe

Combined with a host of other advantages, including but not limited to, tailored skid resistance, enhanced driver comfort as well as reduced maintenance and associated traffic disruption, the economic argument presented by Infometrics demonstrates that concrete roads are the ‘complete package’.

With the Christchurch Motorways project, described as the most ambitious ever seen in the South Island’s largest city, gaining momentum, what better time than now to discuss how to deliver the best roading solutions available.

Feel free to contact CCANZ ([email protected]) if you would like to discuss the Association’s work in the area of concrete roads.

A BACKGROUNDER

Concrete Roads

Prepared by Infometrics LtdMay 2013

for Cement and Concrete

Association of New Zealand

The Case for

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 7

Page 8: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

CCANZ APARTMENT DESIGN SEMINARbackGround

Good apartment design is one of the biggest challenges currently facing architects in New Zealand as our population undergoes a demographic transformation.

Add to this rising property prices - particularly in Auckland and Christchurch - the scarcity of land for development, and the relatively slow rate of residential construction, and it is inevitable that apartments will become a long-term housing solution.

However, New Zealand is still relatively inexperienced in terms of apartment design and we need to be aware that there are many design requirements to achieving quality results.

seminar outcome

The seminar will highlight the most important challenges for architects in apartment design, and provide insight into the work of New Zealand practices with a proven record in successful apartment design.

Presentations

CCANZ architect (EU) Ralf Kessel will use the CCANZ Apartment Design Guide (download from www.ccanz.org.nz) to recommend suitable space dimensions, address parking issues, discuss urban design and explore how to deliver enhanced fire safety, sound proofing and durability in apartment buildings.

At the Wellington seminar ANZIA registered architect Allan Wright will use case studies to demonstrate how real-life design challenges were overcome to create well-functioning and attractive apartment buildings. NZIA registered architect Tony Koia will do the same at the Auckland seminar.

nZia cPd eVent (15 points)

Presenters

rALf KESSEL (reg. EU architect) Cement & Concrete Association New Zealand (CCANZ)

Author of the CCANZ Apartment Design Guide.

ALLAN Wright (Wellington Seminar) (reg. ANZIA architect) Architecture +

Designer of many residential multi-unit buildings including the Piermont / Monument Apartments in Wellington.

tONy KOiA (Auckland Seminar) (reg. NZIA architect) Koia Architects

Designer of many outstanding residential multi-unit buildings in Auckland and Queenstown.

WellinGton seminar

Wednesday 21st May, 3.00pm - 4.30pmSchool of Architecture, LT 1Victoria University of Wellington (VUW)139 Vivian Street, WELLINGTON

auckland seminar

Friday 6th June, 3.00pm - 4.30pmConference Centre, LT 423-342University of Auckland22 Symonds Street, AUCKLAND

reGistration

Email: [email protected]: 04 499 8820Cost: Free

Date for Christchurch seminar to be announced.8 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 9: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

UNDER SLAB VAPOUR BARRIER TM

Easy, Reliable installation Life of the building Protection

Longevity and Strength Exceptional Tear and Puncture Resistance

www.canzac.com - Ph: 0800 422 692 - Fax: (03) 3434 237 - Email: [email protected]

Specify With Confidence

Designated trademarks are used under license from Stego Industries, LLC

TM TM

CCANZ UPDATES WEATHERTIGHT CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION CODE OF PRACTICECitEd by thE NZ bUiLdiNg COdE AS ACCEptAbLE SOLUtiON 3 fOr CLAUSE E2 ExtErNAL MOiStUrE

(E2/AS3), thE Code of PraCtiCe for Weathertight ConCrete and ConCrete Masonry ConstruCtion

COVErS thE WEAthErtightNESS Of thE bUiLdiNg ENVELOpE fOr CONCrEtE SLAbS ON thE grOUNd,

CONCrEtE WALLS ANd ASSOCiAtEd MEthOdS Of iNSULAtiON, CONCrEtE fLAt rOOfS ANd dECKS, ANd

CONCrEtE tO tiMbEr CONStrUCtiON jUNCtiONS.

To aid planners and builders the Code of Practice follows the same format as existing weathertightness solutions but offers larger detail drawings.

CCANZ developed the Code of Practice in partnership with building and construction industry representatives, and its acceptance into the NZ Building Code followed wider consultation.

CCANZ Chief Executive Rob Gaimster is delighted with the updated Code of Practice and believes it will offer ongoing benefits to builders and home owners.

“The development of this document and its inclusion as an Acceptable Solution in the New Zealand Building Code will continue to help alleviate uncertainty amongst consent authorities

in the area of weathertight concrete and concrete masonry design and construction.”

“It will allow builders, designers and their clients to choose from a wider range of building materials, and in turn enable the weathertight advantages of concrete and concrete masonry systems to enhance New Zealand’s building stock.”

This latest version includes a new section on wall weathertightness systems for masonry veneer that has been extracted from NZS 4229:2013 Concrete Masonry Buildings Not Requiring Specific Engineering Design.

As of Friday 14 February 2014 the Code of Practice was cited as E2/AS3. Visit the CCANZ website to download a copy - www.ccanz.org.nz

Imag

e: D

ied

eric

k Va

n H

eyni

ngen

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 9

Page 10: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

rENOWNEd fOr bUiLdiNg SOME Of NEW ZEALANd’S fiNESt CONCrEtE hOMES, rOSS bANNAN Of

AUCKLANd bASEd bANNAN CONStrUCtiON rECENtLy tOOK tiME OUt tO ChAt With ConCrete

MAgAZiNE AbOUt hiS pASSiON fOr iN-SitU CONStrUCtiON ANd qUALity fOrMWOrK SyStEMS, AS WELL

AS thE iMpOrtANCE Of gOOd COMMUNiCAtiON ANd prOfESSiONAL dEVELOpMENt.

tHe early years

Ross started out in New Zealand’s residential construction industry in a similar fashion to many others. After completing his apprenticeship with a large commercial company in 1989 he transitioned into traditional timber frame residential construction.

Influenced however, by the building technologies he had seen overseas and wanting to give his work a stronger sense of permanence, Ross began to utilise precast concrete.

“I started to wonder why I was building imitation (plastered) concrete homes rather than the genuine article,” says Ross. “I researched how to best employ precast concrete panels to build detailed and bespoke residential homes, and received some invaluable advice from Paul Cane of Formstress and Andrew Sinclair of Wilco Precast.”

“My early precast concrete houses were successful and very satisfying, but I was receiving more and more enquiries from customers wanting in-situ elements within the precast concrete frame,” says Ross.

“With further research, along with attendance at international seminars and some local knowledge gained through CCANZ and various individuals, my understanding of efficient construction

methodologies using in-situ forms grew to the point where I

was confident enough to build complicated cast in-situ concrete

homes for customers.”

WHy (in-situ) concrete?

The durability and weathertight advantages of concrete, combined

with its plastic properties and design flexibility are what attract

Ross to the material.

“I am a firm believer in building homes that withstand the test

of time and reduce as much maintenance as possible,” says

Ross. “The typical timber frame home just seems so flimsy, and

is becoming increasingly problematic to construct with the extra

building envelope requirements and cavity systems. Weathertight

issues are always present.”

“Cast in-situ construction offers greater peace of mind against the

elements, and can be just as affordable as any other building type.

From a design perspective there are an endless range of shapes

and forms, restricted only by the imagination of the qualified and

experienced design/build team and the customer.”

“My motivations for choosing in-situ concrete are very similar

to those of my customers. The low maintenance properties of

IN-SITU CONCRETE HOMESOFFERING STRENGTH, STYLE & COMFORT

10 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 11: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

concrete, along with the scope for architectural flair, are important factors. The desire to be different, to stand out from the mass of timber framed houses, is also an attraction. Concrete offers both permanence and prestige for home owners.”

tHe imPortance oF FormWork and miX desiGn

Always striving for quality outcomes, Ross recently purchased his own GHI metal framed ‘Tritech’ formwork material from Germany, and along with Aden Bolton, set-up Formwork Solutions to make available (for hire or purchase) the range of GHI products.

“The correct formwork makes the difference between good concrete work and great concrete work,” says Ross. “You have to have faith in the form when you and your team are pouring and vibrating the mix through the shuttered forms.”

“Tolerances are generally minimal, so any movement whatsoever can be disastrous. The use of the strong forms allows for externally mounted vibrators that negate the need for plunge vibrators that can potentially damage the form-liner.”

“It is also critical to obtain the correct mix design for the concrete. In this regard, Kevin Mischewski and Stevenson Concrete have been fantastic partners from the start, working very closely with me to develop the correct mix design for each specific requirement,” adds Ross. “It is vital to have the support of your local ready mixed concrete supplier and for them to understand exactly what you are doing.”

“I am very excited about the GHI ‘Circumflex’ formwork panels we recently brought to New Zealand, which can be reduced to a radius of 1000mm. On my current project in Remuera I am making extensive use of them as there are many challenging curves as well as a huge helical staircase. They have literally saved me thousands of dollars by not having to build multiple specific radius shutters. In fact, these are the only curable shuttering products currently in New Zealand from what I understand.”

communication and education / traininG

Ross prides himself on maintaining clear communication channels with both the customer and architect from the outset. He believes

this is key to ensuring the most efficient and effective construction methodologies are selected to bring the design to life, and above all, help keep the customer happy.

“One of Bannan Construction’s many points of difference is that I’m on-site and accessible 99 percent of the time. Customers are a lot more informed now than in the past. They have canvassed options, and want to discuss the various pros and cons.”

“I like to be involved early on in the design process as this allows me to talk over the best construction approach for each individual application,” says Ross. “There are many construction details to iron out early in the project, which directly affect the way the home is designed and which can have a dramatic impact on the budget.”

“At times I do feel that practical in-situ concrete knowledge amongst specifiers in New Zealanders is limited, and that there is a perception that residential concrete construction is too expensive. That is not to say there isn’t a desire amongst specifiers to push the boundaries using in-situ concrete, but a more hands-on appreciation of the appropriate methodology would lead to more efficient and less expensive solutions.”

“For instance, rigid wall insulation may come at an additional cost, but this is more than made up for by the reduction in construction time, plus you have an assurance that it won’t bend during the pour. Similarly, terminating walls at the window can be achieved effectively without the need for capping or compromising weathertightness.”

“So that is why I place a premium on my own professional development, by attending conferences and seminars, as well as actively networking with concrete professionals in New Zealand and overseas. I enjoy sharing my knowledge and experience, and have acted as a consultant on other projects, as well as assisted CCANZ with its weathertight concrete code of practice.”

“At the end of the day, if New Zealand is constructing a better, more resilient residential building stock by utilising the properties of in-situ concrete, then I am happy.”

The following project is an example of Bannan Construction’s work.

09 849 8287p 027 495 2407m 09 849 8284f

[email protected]

www.formworksolutions.co.nzwww.bannanconstruction.co.nz

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 11

Page 12: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

Westmere House

thE hOUSE iS A jOUrNEy frOM StrEEt tO WAtEr, With A NArrOW

pONd by thE ENtrANCE WALKWAy CONtiNUiNg thrOUgh thE

hOUSE, ON tO thE pOOL, ANd LEAdiNg tO thE OpEN SEA bEyONd.

This 900m2 home, which backs onto the upper Waitemata harbour, is in effect a large scale piece of sculpture. Massive in-situ concrete walls stand as monoliths, with the house weaving around them.

The main body of the house includes the well-proportioned double height living room with its cave-like media room behind. The living room is framed by a wall 12m long and 5m high which includes the fireplace and runs through to the outside deck where it holds the barbecue and an outside fireplace. This wall is punctured with openings and manipulated with various shapes to bring some subtle curves to its massive form.

This house is a complex exercise in layering of spaces from the street to the sea. The exposed decorative rough sawn timber finish provides texture without being harsh. The oak floors are warm and the cedar ceilings reassuring without being oppressive. The use of in-situ concrete throughout has led to a low maintenance home that retains its warmth through the colder months and repels the heat during the summer months.

bANNAN CONStrUCtiON CASE StUdy - WEStMErE hOUSE

Project PrinciPals

Architect Ponting Fitzgerald ArchitectsConsultant George DowneyContractor Bannan ConstructionConcrete Stevenson Concrete

12 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 13: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION COURSECCANZ has developed a Concrete Construction Course designed for those responsible for supervising the receipt and placement of fresh concrete on-site - typically this would be the site foreman (or equivalent) and the formwork carpenter.

Building apprentices would also find the course invaluable.

The aim of the course is to promote quality concrete construction.

Built around NZS 3109 Concrete Construction, the curriculum for the 2-day classroom based course will meet both industry needs and the relevant NZQA standards.

The course is comprised of the following 5 modules:

1. Introduction to Concrete

a. Cement manufacture

b. Ready mixed concrete production

c. Constituent materials

d. Applications

2. Properties of Fresh and Hardened Concrete

a. Relevant Standards

b. Fresh & hard concrete tests

3. Reinforcement

a. Reinforcement types

b. Manufacture

c. Handling & installation

4. Formwork

a. Requirements of formwork

b. Formwork materials, systems and design

c. Falsework

d. Construction

5. Site Practice

a. Handling & placing

b. Compaction, finishing & curing

c. Hot & cold weather concreting

d. Control of surface finishes & cracks

The popular CCANZ publication The New Zealand Guide to Concrete Construction is an ideal resource to accompany the course. It can be downloaded in chapters from the CCANZ website – www.ccanz.org.nz/documents.aspx

The course will be rolled-out during july in Auckland, with Wellington and Christchurch dates to be announced.

The registration fee is $1,100+GST.

To register your interest in the Auckland, Wellington or Christchurch course contact CCANZ on (04) 499 8820 or email [email protected]

Queries about the course content can be directed to Alistair Russell (Manager – Structural Performance & Engineering Systems) on (04) 915 0384 or email [email protected]

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 13

Page 14: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

CARVED CONCRETE AT WHITIREIA POLYTECHNICLOCAtEd iN thE gO-AhEAd City Of pOrirUA,

NOrth Of WELLiNgtON, WhitirEiA pOLytEChNiC

iS UNdErgOiNg A StAgEd rE-dEVELOpMENt tO

bUiLd A COMMUNity fOCUSEd fACiLity. thE

rECENtLy COMpLEtEd BuiLding PrograMMe 1

iS A StriKiNg AdditiON tO thE CAMpUS bUiLt

ArOUNd thE pOEtiC USE Of CONCrEtE.

camPus community

With a total footprint of around 3817m2, the $16.5m Building 1 houses the Faculty of Health, administration, classrooms and conference facilities – including laboratories and simulation suites that provide state-of-the-art training facilities to around 1000 nursing and paramedic students. The project progressed throughout 2012-2013 under the direction of CGM + Foster Architects Ltd, GAZE Commercial (Interior Design) and Maycroft Construction.

The aim of this redevelopment was to build a community focused campus - one that is fully interconnected. Flexible ‘learning spaces’ and ‘learning streets’ have been included throughout the building to form a holistic education facility that creates a “campus community” and integrates with the wider community.

This sense of union and collaboration between elements extends to the use of construction materials. Concrete and glass work

14 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 15: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

CARVED CONCRETE AT WHITIREIA POLYTECHNICtogether to create a sense of permeability, an open and light filled environment which completely engages with the learning experience. Similarly, concrete and steel work harmoniously together. The new structure sits on a fully insulated concrete foundation, the first floor and supporting structures are also concrete, while the upper levels and roof structures are in steel.

decoratiVe Precast

Concrete itself, used extensively in (decorative) precast panels and columns, also acts as a conduit, bringing together the internal and external environments, as well as the past with the present. This connection is achieved primarily through the intricate Maori patterns that adorn the building facades and corridors. The carved concrete surfaces, conceived by Whitireia Whakairo tutor James Molnar, have their roots steeped in Maori tradition, but with a modern twist made possible through new technologies.

Conveying historical, environmental, cultural and urban narratives unique to Whitireia and its surroundings, the highly detailed carvings are underpinned by the concept of Korowai - the cloak of knowledge - that wraps the new building. The prominent triangles are a direct reference to the prehistoric connection to Whitireia maunga (mountain); mapped up from the landscape that they represent around the Porirua inlet.

The process of creating the decorative panels and columns involved firstly sketching the design, which was then captured digitally, converted into a vector file, and given depth and texture to become a three dimensional object. This formed the basis of a real time negative mould (formliner) that was created by Christchurch based CNC Routing Ltd. The moulds were then sent to Emmetts Civil Construction Ltd of Whanganui who prepared the precast concrete panels and columns, which after some hands-on finishing where ready to erect on-site.

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 15

Page 16: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

CONCrEtE itSELf, USEd ExtENSiVELy iN (dECOrAtiVE) prECASt pANELS

ANd COLUMNS, ALSO ACtS AS A CONdUit, briNgiNg tOgEthEr thE iNtErNAL

ANd ExtErNAL ENVirONMENtS, AS WELL AS thE pASt With thE prESENt.

As which the patterns, the colours selected to highlight parts of the concrete also have traditional significance, For instance, the conspicuous triangles use a red colour matched to the blood of a shark used in Maori paintings.

sustainable Features

Building 1 also boasts a range of sustainable construction features. From a design perspective the fully accessible and flexible layout allows teaching / learning environments to be customised as required. Natural light and ventilation were utilised wherever possible, as were low VOC materials.

The latest in sustainable systems are also present throughout, with solar hot water heating and grey water recycling, as well as underfloor heating in the floating concrete slab, and very high levels of insulation, such as R5.8 in the ceiling. Building longevity has been ensured through the selection of durable construction materials, as well as leaving the services and structural elements exposed to allow for future reconfiguration.

Now in the post occupancy evaluation period feedback indicates the sustainable and artistic moves throughout the design, linked intrinsically to the use of concrete, have created a successful building for the end users, one which will draw the Whitireia and wider Porirua community together.

16 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 17: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

WHitireia PolytecHnic buildinG ProGramme 1

Client Whitireia PolytechnicArchitect CGM + Foster ArchitectsInterior Design GAZE CommercialContractor Maycroft ConstructionPrecast Concrete Emmetts Civil Construction

.

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 17

Page 18: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NEW ZEALAND’SCONCRETE TRAILBLAZERSAS OUtLiNEd iN thE prEViOUS iSSUE Of ConCrete MAgAZiNE, 2014 iS thE yEAr thE NEW ZEALANd

CONCrEtE SOCiEty (NZCS) CELEbrAtES itS 50th ANNiVErSAry. thrOUghOUt itS ExiStENCE thE SOCiEty

hAS bENEfittEd frOM ANd hELpEd fOStEr thE ViSiON, iNtELLECt, WiSdOM ANd dEtErMiNAtiON Of A

grOUp Of iNdiVidUALS WOrthy Of thE titLE – trAiLbLAZErS.

These individuals have made a significant contribution to the concrete industry and wider building and construction sector, as well as to the infrastructure of a New Zealand emerging as a modern and forward thinking nation during the second half of the 20th century.

Outlined below is a small selection of these trailblazers, who along with Bob Norman, Nigel Priestley, Bob Irwin, Lyall Holmes and several others will be acknowledged in a commemorative publication detailing the history, accomplishments and influence of the NZ Concrete Society.

sandy cormack

Perhaps no other individual is more synonymous with the concrete industry in New Zealand than Sandy Cormack.

Wellington born, Sandy was an engineer who became chief executive of Certified Concrete Ltd from its establishment in 1938 until retiring in 1971. He moved to Auckland in 1940 where he remained based until he passed away in June 1985, aged 79.

Sandy was the person who introduced and developed ready mixed concrete to this part of the world, and was deeply committed to pioneering advances in precast / prestressed concrete. He also involved himself in numerous research projects and the formation of the various industry associations that still operate today.

Sandy had a principal role in setting-up the NZ Portland Cement Association (NZPCA) in 1948, and served on the board until 1978. Through his work in introducing quality control to concrete production he also served on many Standards committees.

Sandy Cormack

(Image courtesy of Fletcher Trust Archive)

Bob Park Len McSaveney

David Barnard

18 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 19: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

Sandy was instrumental in establishing the NZ Ready Mixed Concrete Association (NZRMCA), and its plant classification scheme. He was involved with the establishment of the Prestressed Concrete Institute (later to become the Concrete Society), and was its first president. When the NZ Concrete Research Association was founded in 1972, he was chairman of its technical advisory committee and served on its board until 1985.

However, many believe Sandy’s greatest achievement was his influence almost 75 years ago in the creation of the first ready mixed concrete plant in Australasia at Grant Road, Wellington. It was that project which launched New Zealand into high-tech concrete, and it was from there that the formidable drive and talents of Sandy Cormack were to provide huge leadership and service.

ProFessor robert (bob) Park

Renowned in New Zealand and internationally, Professor Bob Park was key in the creation of the seismic design method called capacity design, an important innovation with regard to reinforced concrete structures and a notable development in the history of earthquake resistance.

Born in Fiji, Bob came to New Zealand in 1951 and studied civil engineering at Canterbury University, where in 1956 he joined the academic staff. Then after 6 years overseas, during which time he completed his PhD at the University of Bristol, Bob returned to the University in 1965 where he spent the next 35-years.

Over the course of his career Bob won multiple awards for technical papers, contributed to numerous technical committees, and received honours from an array of professional bodies.

President of the NZ Concrete Society from 1975-76, Bob spent 28-years on Council. In 1995 he was awarded an OBE in the Queen’s Birthday Honours.

Highly respected as one of the most knowledgeable people within the field of concrete and earthquake resistance research, as well as an inspirational teacher, Bob passed away in November 2004.

daVid barnard

David started his career in the United Kingdom in 1952 developing engineering experience in local government, contracting and consultancy before coming to New Zealand in 1974. Described as a “single-minded advocate for concrete” David spent close to 25-years at CCANZ, including in its previous guises of the NZ Portland Cement Association and the NZ Concrete Research Association. David was the NZ Concrete Society president from 1987-88.

Refer to any technical publication or Standard on concrete or concrete masonry produced since the mid-1970s and chances are David either wrote it or was a significant contributor. Tireless in his efforts to implement relevant research and deliver practical training David has prided himself on developing strong relationships across the construction sector and imparting independent advice.

Examples of David’s achievements include the introduction of day-time training for concrete construction workers, the development of the Certificate in Concrete Technology and Construction correspondence course, and an emphasis on durability research that led to a specific chapter on the subject in NZS 3101 Concrete Structures Standard. Although David retired from his role at CCANZ in 1999 he remains busy as a consultant.

len mcsaVeney

NZ Concrete Society president from 1988-89, active within fib, and a staunch supporter of student research, the term “Innovator” is often used to describe Len McSaveney. In fact, a March 2002 issue of Concrete used the parlance of the day - “Change Insurgent” - to describe Len’s role as a promoter of new ideas and technology.

Graduating from Canterbury University in 1964 Len went to work for what is now Holmes Consulting Group. After a time travelling Len moved back to New Zealand in 1974 to work for R.T. Scott Limited, a company later bought by Stresscrete, and in turn by the Fletcher organisation. Len’s long association with Fletchers included roles at Firth Industries and Golden Bay Cement.

Lightweight aggregate in Wellington’s Westpac Stadium, the thousands of concrete power poles across the middle of the North Island, and the uptake of self-compacting concrete all owe a debt to Len’s willingness to embrace change.

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 19

Page 20: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NAtiONAL EArthqUAKE MUSEUM

CCANZ ArChitECt (EU) rALf KESSEL

WAS rECENtLy ASKEd tO hELp

rEViEW thE dESigN prOpOSALS

SUbMittEd by ArChitECtUrE

StUdENtS At ViCtOriA UNiVErSity

Of WELLiNgtON’S SChOOL Of

ArChitECtUrE.

Under the direction of Andrew Charleson (Associate Professor – Architecture) the 3rd year students were faced with a brief to conceive a National Earthquake Museum on a prominent Wellington waterfront site. Using concrete as the primary construction material the museum was to offer a range of functional spaces, while at the same time symbolising the immense power of seismic events to shape landscapes and lives in New Zealand. The following pages showcase a small selection of the many outstanding designs presented by the students.

DESIGN PROPOSALS NATIONAL EARTHQUAKE MUSEUM

jonatHan molloy

This design uses a range of experiential perspectives to illustrate how seismic events impact people in different ways. Governing factors include proximity to the quake, degree of personal loss as well as the environment in which the event is experienced. The museum consists of three exhibition spaces based on three perspective experiences - the observer, the victim and the memorial. Each space is connected by a circulation area that re-orientates users, enhancing their understanding of each experience.

20 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 21: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NAtiONAL EArthqUAKE MUSEUM

Tayler MaTThews

The architectural concept of this Earthquake Museum design seeks to portray the immense force and inevitable collision of the Australasian and Pacific tectonic plates beneath New Zealand. The curving roof emphasizes this opposing movement, as does the interior layout which flows towards the central meeting / memorial point. Exhibition spaces help develop a journey between the symbolic built forms, as do the bridges, which also create fluid light patterns that imply shift.

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 21

Page 22: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NAtiONAL EArthqUAKE MUSEUM

meGat otHman (beloW)

Focussed on giving architectural expression to the concepts of earthquake, monumental and museum, this stark and jagged structure appears torn upwards from the surrounding land. Combining something sudden and violent that causes great destruction and upheaval (earthquake) with a desire to store and exhibit important objects (museum) on a grand scale (monumental), this design captures and conveys the brutal impact of seismic events in a manner that compels and haunts.

brett nicHolas (riGHt)

Visitors to this contemporary Earthquake Museum follow an upward and gently spiralling path that encourages interaction with the exhibits and facilities. The sense of journey within the tightly packed building leads towards the central memorial, which is nestled within the protective cover of the main structure. Also making use of a rising helix configuration the central memorial offers a quiet and reflective shape in which to commemorate those whose life have been affected by earthquakes.

22 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 23: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NAtiONAL EArthqUAKE MUSEUM

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 23

Page 24: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

WHAT HAPPENS TO REINFORCEMENT IN A CONCRETE BUILDING DURING AN EARTHQUAKE?rEiNfOrCEd CONCrEtE bUiLdiNgS iNhErENtLy rELy ON thE dUCtiLE ChArACtEriStiCS Of StEEL rEiNfOrCiNg tO ENSUrE A prEdiCtAbLE ANd NON-brittLE rESpONSE WhEN SUbjECtEd tO LOAdS. thiS iS ESpECiALLy iMpOrtANt fOr EArthqUAKE LOAdiNg ANd WhErE CApACity dESigN iS UtiLiSEd.

Steel reinforcement generally is designed to behave elastically during service loading, and to yield at ultimate loads. When the yield strain (corresponding to the yield stress) is exceeded, irrecoverable plastic deformation occurs, whereas the elastic portion of strain is recoverable. As deformation increases following yielding, the strain in the bar will increase but the stress remains constant, and this is known as the yield plateau.

As the strain in steel reinforcing increases beyond the yield plateau, strain hardening occurs and the remaining strain capacity becomes less. Following deformation of a steel reinforcing bar, such as during an earthquake, testing can be performed to determine the amount of strain hardening which has occurred in the bar, and in Christchurch this is being correlated to determine the accumulated plastic strain, and thus the percentage of peak strain capacity remaining. When peak strain is reached, the bar will rupture.

As earthquake shaking tends to impose cyclic loads and deformations on structures, the phenomenon of strain hardening should more correctly be referred to as “low-cycle fatigue”.

Insurers are becoming concerned about a trend to cite strain hardening as a reason for demolition of damaged reinforced concrete buildings in Christchurch.

WHat are tHe diFFerent tyPes oF reinForcement used in neW Zealand?

The types of reinforcing steel that can be used in New Zealand are governed by a joint Australian/New Zealand Standard, AS/NZS 4671:2001. This Standard outlines a number of types of reinforcing steel, of which two are most commonly used in New Zealand. These are Grade 300E and Grade 500E and the primary difference between the two types is the yield strength of the steel. Grade 300E reinforcement has a nominal yield strength of 300 MPa and Grade 500E reinforcement has a nominal yield strength of 500 MPa.

Moreover, the strength of Grade 500E reinforcement can be achieved in two distinct processes: Microalloying or the Quenched and In-Line

Tempered (QT) method. Engineers must be aware of significant limitations on the use of QT reinforcement, which because of its non-homogeneous cross-section, may not be cut, rebent, welded or threaded.

Grade 300E Grade 500E

Figure 1: Bar marks identifying Grade 300E and Grade 500E reinforcement

martensite – high strength, hard

pearlite – low strength, ductile

Figure 2: Cross section of a Q+T reinforcing bar

WHat about Historic reinForcement?

Although only two grades of reinforcement are used in New Zealand today, other types of reinforcement have been used in earlier times. While knowledge of these reinforcement types is irrelevant to the designer of new structures, it is vital that engineers understand older reinforcement types when assessing the performance of existing buildings. Some of the more prevalent previous reinforcement types are described below.

Grade 275 Before 1989 New Zealand reinforcement was graded according to the “minimum” yield stress, rather than the lower characteristic yield stress as is used now. The steel used in Grade 300E reinforcement has a minimum yield strength of approximately 275 MPa, so before 1989 this reinforcement was referred to as Grade 275.

CCANZ StrUCtUrAL ENgiNEEr ALiStAir rUSSELL

CONSidErS A SEriES Of qUEStiONS ArOUNd StEEL

rEiNfOrCiNg ANd itS bEhAViOUr dUriNg AN EArthqUAKE

24 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 25: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

Grade 430 Grade 430 reinforcement was the predecessor to Grade 500E. It was a high ductility micro alloy steel with a lower characteristic yield strength of 430 MPa. Grade 430 was withdrawn from New Zealand early in the 2000s to allow alignment of New Zealand and Australian reinforcing steel Standards.

Grade 380 Grade 380 was a high strength, low ductility reinforcing steel used in New Zealand until ~1989. It has much poorer properties than later high strength reinforcement types.

Non-metric Before metrification of reinforcement occurred in 1973 New Zealand used a variety of reinforcement to British and US Standards. Most common amongst these are Grade 40 and Grade 60 bars. These have minimum yield strengths of 40 ksi and 60 ksi respectively, corresponding to metric values of 275 MPa and 414 MPa.

WHat is Hardness testinG oF reinForcement and WHat does it mean?

Measuring the surface hardness of a steel reinforcing bar which has undergone strain hardening, and comparing that value with an equivalently determined hardness value of a bar which has not undergone strain hardening, provided that appropriate boundary conditions are maintained, may be used to provide an estimation of the residual strain of that bar. It is important that the limitations of the test method used are identified and understood.

There is considerable complexity involved in correlating the surface hardness with the reinforcement deterioration due to cyclic loading, and correspondingly, with the expected future performance of the overall building. This is particularly important considering the different types of reinforcement available currently and historically in New Zealand, and why an understanding of the reinforcement characteristics and manufacturing process is valuable.

WHat can be done about buildinGs WHicH HaVe been subjected to loW-cycle FatiGue?

In theory, where some concentrated cracking has occurred, as long as that crack can be opened up, and filled with good quality, high strength epoxy, then any subsequent cracks should be initiated elsewhere, in a non-strain hardened region of the bar.

Strain hardening correlates with some increase in strength, and any further yielding will occur where the strength is the least (or lower). Initial yielding of a reinforcement bar is likely to occur at a location

of lower strength than other areas, and can be because of a minor random imperfection.

At locations of significant imperfections (defects), such as the result of spot welding or notching, highly concentrated deformations can occur leading to bar rupture or fracture. This highlights the importance of understanding the characteristics of reinforcement bars, and the limitations on handling and installation.

Depending on the extent of damage, parts of the building may have to be replaced or retrofitted. The view could be taken that where any strain hardening has taken place, that portion of the building – usually a beam adjacent to a column – needs to be replaced so that it is in the same condition as when it was first constructed, as it may be considered that any strain hardening represents a reduction in total pre-existing capacity.

If there are enough of these regions in the frame that need replacing, the cost to do this work may tip over so that it becomes less economical to repair than to fully replace the building.

WHat does tHis mean For concrete buildinGs in tHe Future?

The design and construction of “traditional” Concrete Moment Resisting Frame (CMRF) structures will come under greater scrutiny, and this may create opportunities to further the use of new (or less widely used) technologies, which employ damage resistant design philosophies.

Largely as a result of the Christchurch earthquakes, seismic design philosophies in New Zealand are tending towards limiting non-structural damage as much as possible, instead of focussing on just designing for life-safety. The requirements to limit building damage, non-structural damage and building downtime are increasingly being given greater weighting in new structural design, particularly as a result of the cost of repairing and rebuilding many structures in Christchurch.

The New Zealand concrete industry has been at the forefront of such new damage resistant design concepts, with the development of both Base Isolation and PRESSS technologies originating from this country, as well as other emerging technologies, such as non-tearing joints in concrete moment resisting frames. Based on its generally high mass and high stiffness, concrete as a material is naturally well suited to such design methods.

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 25

Page 26: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

APARTMENT DESIGN GUIDE

The CCANZ Apartment Design Guide sets out key considerations, and provides recommendations on size, daylight and

interior climate requirements, along with effective soundproofing and fire protection.

Email [email protected] to request your FREE copy of the Apartment Design Guide

www.ccanz.org.nz

CCANZ LIBRARYLiStEd bELOW iS A SMALL SELECtiON Of rECENtLy

ACqUirEd MAtEriAL by thE CCANZ LibrAry.

EMAiL [email protected] tO bOrrOW.

concrete miX desiGn, Quality control and sPeciFication by ken W. day, james aldred & barry Hudson

Thoroughly revised and updated this fourth edition addresses current industry practices that provide inadequate durability and fail to eliminate problems with underperforming new concrete and defective testing.

Many specifications now require additional criteria in an attempt to improve durability or other properties. This book discusses the trend towards adding performance requirements to existing prescriptive specifications. It also explores the matter of prescription versus performance specification and especially the specification of non-strength-related performance such as durability.

curinG concrete by Peter c. taylor

Curing concrete is often low on the list of priorities, particularly when budgets and timelines are under pressure. Yet the increasing demands being placed on concrete mixtures also mean that they are less forgiving than in the past. Therefore, any activity that will help improve hydration and performance, while reducing the risk of cracking, is becoming

more important. Curing Concrete explains exactly why curing is so important and shows how to best do it.

The author also gives numerous examples of how curing has affected concrete performance in real-world situations. These include examples from hot and cold climates. Written for construction professionals who want to ensure the quality and longevity of their concrete structures, this book demonstrates that curing is well worth the effort and cost.

library QuiZ

To go in the draw to win a copy of Curing Concrete by Peter C. Taylor answer the following simple question:

According to Infometrics research approximately how much cheaper are concrete roads compared to asphalt alternatives?

Email your answer to [email protected]. Entries close Friday 30 May 2014.

Congratulations to David McKay of Trengrove Architects Ltd, who correctly answered the Vol 57 Iss 1 Library Quiz to receive a copy of Tadao Ando: Houses by Philip Jodidio.

26 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2

Page 27: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year

NEWS FROM THE ASSOCIATIONS

NEW ZEALANd CONCrEtE SOCiEty (NZCS)

celebration Publication to mark 50 years

The NZ Concrete Society will celebrate its 50th birthday by producing an anniversary publication, an oral history video and an audio visual timeline scroll.

The theme of the Concrete Industry Conference 2014, to be held at Wairakei Resort, will be looking back at the past 50 years, plus the website and logo will be revamped, there will be a seminar series and articles will be published throughout the year.

Gavin Cormack, son of the Society’s founder, Sandy Cormack, is chairing a steering committee which is sourcing and managing material for the commemorative publication, video and A/V timeline.

Gavin says the 100-page book will tell the stories, in words and photographs, of the Society and concrete’s role in New Zealand over the last five decades.

It will open by placing the Society into the context of the 1960s and discuss the post-WWII environment that led to its formation, the impact of trade unions and other issues of the time like draconian foreign exchange laws and state control of major construction projects.

Among the industry’s trailblazers who will be celebrated are Bob Norman (second President 1966); Morley Sutherland (President 1970-71); J.B.S. (Hans) Huizing; Rob Irwin; and Bob Park.

The book will feature significant structures built in the last half century including the original Newmarket Viaduct (first in-situ cantilever bridge), the Mangaweka Railway Viaduct (first base isolated bridge), the Ngauranga Interchange in Wellington (first push bridge); the Sky Tower (tallest structure); and Victoria University’s Alan MacDiarmid building (first multi-storey PRESSS building).

“Fallibility is part of the pioneering ethic, and there’s much value in exploring failures, lessons learned and the implications for future projects.”

A look to the future will discuss shifting boundaries and the fact there’s always room for improvement in the way concrete is engineered and used.

“Christchurch’s rebuild presents an opportunity to develop new specifications and uses for concrete. The next decade could be, as Gerry Brownlee has intimated, the Society’s finest hour.” Jason Ingham, the NZCS Immediate Past President, is chairing conference organising committee. Already, three keynote speakers have been secured: Professor Hugo Corres Peiretti, Professor Ken Hover and Gavin Cormack.

NZCS Secretary Allan Bluett says the conference partners, CCANZ, Precast NZ and NZRMCA, have agreed the conference theme will be to look back at the last 50 years.

For nostalgic reasons Concrete Industry Conference 2014 will be held in Wairakei Resort, the venue for the first NZCS conference held in August 1965.

CONTACTSNew Zealand ready Mixed Concrete AssociationPh (04) 499 0041Fax (04) 499 7760Executive Officer: Adam LeachPresident: Jeff Burgesswww.nzrmca.org.nz

New Zealand Concrete Masonry AssociationPh (04) 499 8820Fax (04) 499 7760Executive Officer: David BarnardPresident: Mario Fontinhawww.nzcma.org.nz

precast NZ inc.Ph (09) 638 9416Fax (09) 638 9407Executive Director: Rod FulfordPresident: Paul Canewww.precastnz.org.nz

New Zealand Concrete SocietyPh (09) 536 5410Fax (09) 536 5442Email:[email protected]/Manager: Allan BluettPresident: Carl Ashbywww.concretesociety.org.nz

New Zealand Master Concrete placers AssociationPh (07) 575 3214Fax (07) 575 3618Email: [email protected]

Gavin Cormack

Jason Ingham

Wairakei Resort, Taupo9–11 October

VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 || concrete 27

Page 28: VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 - cdn.ymaws.com · ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 2 concrete || VOLUME 57 ISSUE 2 Cover photo: National Earthquake Museum, Wellington. Design by Megat Othman, 3rd year