vishwanath vs the state of uttar pradesh on 3 september

8/17/2019 Vishwanath vs the State of Uttar Pradesh on 3 September

1/8

Vishwanath vs The State Of Uttar Pradesh on 3 September, 1959

Equiva ent !itations" 19#$ %&' #(, 19#$ S)' *1+ # #

-en!h" .an!hoo, /0 0

PETITIONER:

VISHWANATH

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

03/09/1959

BENCH:

WANCHOO, .N.

BENCH:

WANCHOO, .N.

IMAM, S!ED JAFFER

CITATION:

19"0 AIR "# 19"0 SCR $1% "&"

ACT:

C'()(*+ T'(+ -R( 2 P'( + 4 424*64-W 4* 47 4* s 6+8s(* 4+ -W 4 4')4'4 + 86 ( * (6 (s * P8*(s + 4 ( 4s '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64 6+8s4 4+

2 + 86 '-- H8s +* 's 8s4- W(24>s ' 4' s + (* 8s +* +* =( (* ()-I2 ;' 46 4 < '( 2 ;'( + 4

424*64-I* (+* P4*+ C 4, 1?"0 $@ V 2 1?"0%, ss. 9#, 99 +* 100.

HEADNOTE:


2/8

T 4 '4 + ( *s 4 44* *4 G +* (s (24 4'4 s '+(*4 +* s 4 4* ( 4 ( 4'2+ 4' B +* 4' ' 4' V, 4 +;;4 +* . G, ( '44 4's, 4* 4 8+' 4' 2 B +* 4 4* (*s( 4 +* 6+)4 8 '+ (* (s '4 86 +* (24 4 (* (). S 46+8 2 4 ' +* G s +' 4 ;8 (* 4'. A (s 4 +;;4 +* s 8 4 (s2+ 4' + G +s + +)+* +* 4'48; * B '4; (4 + 4 s 8 4 4+ 4*. T 4+;;4 +* = 8 + =*(24 2' ) (s ; 6=4 +* s + 4 G *64. T 4 =*(24 ;4*4 '+ 4

4 4+' 2 G +* 4 (4 . B +* 4 +;;4 +* 4'4

"

'(4 2 ' 4 )8' 4' 2 G B +s +6 8( 4 +* 4 +;;4 +* +s 6 * (6 4 8* 4' S.30& P+' II I* (+* P4*+ C 4 +* s4* 4*64 '44


3/8

G '+= ;8' (* S4ss( *s T'(+ N . #1 2 1953. S. P. S(* + +* S. D. S4= '(, 2 ' 4+;;4 +* . G. C. M+ 8' +* C. P. + $2 ' G. N. D(=s ( %, 2 ' 4 '4s; * 4* .

1959. S4; 4) 4' 3. T 4 J8 )4* 2 4 C 8' +s 4 ( 4'4 <

WANCHOO J.-T (s (s +* +;;4+ < s;46(+ 4+ 4 + +(*s 4 8 )4* 2 4 A + + + H( C 8' (* + 6'()(*+ )+ 4'. T 4 2+6 s 2 4 6+s4, +s 2 8* < 4H( C 8' , +'4 * * 4' (* (s;8 4 +* 4

"&?

84s ( * + (s '+(s4 (* (s +;;4+ (s 4 4' 4 +;;4 +* + 47644 4 4 '(2 ;'( + 4 424*64 2 ;4's *. T 4 '4 4 +* 2+6 s 2 ' 8' ;8'; s4s +'4 4s4. G ;+464+s4 +s )+''(4 4 s(s 4' 2 4 +;;4 +* . T 4 +;;4 +* +* (s 2+ 4'

B+ '( 4'4 ( (* (* + '+( +< 8+' 4' + G '+= ;8'. G ;+ >s s(s 4' +s )+''(4 *4 B+*+'s(, +s + s ( (* (* +* 4' '+( +< 8+' 4' *4+' s 8+' 4'. G ;+ +s=4 B+*+'s(>s

s *s 4 ; () (* '(* (* +6= (s (24. B+*+'s( + s +''( 4 +* 4* + 2 8' 2 4) 4* B+ '(>s 8+' 4' '(* +6= 4 (' . O* '4+6 (* 4 ; +64, B+*+'s(

+* (s s *s s 8 s( 4 ( 4 G ;+ 4* (*. I* 4 )4+* ()4, B+ '( 6+)4 8+* +s +s=4 < B+*+'s( 4 4 (' ( 4' 8s +* . B+ '( +s * + '44+ 4

( +* +s=4 B+*+'s( * (* 4'24'4 (* 4' ;4 ; 4>s +22+('s. W ( 4 B+ '( +*B+*+'s( 4'4 + =(* , G ;+ 6+)4 8 2 4 8+' 4' '+ (* (s '4 86 +* (24 4 (* (). T 4 (' 6+8 2 4 ' +s s 4 +s 4(* +=4* 8 +* + 8 - 2- +' 2 4 4 44* 4' +* G ;+ . -T 4 +;;4 +* +s + s 4'4 +* s 8 4

(s 2+ 4'


4/8

"&9

+ G ;+ +s + +)+* . B+ '(, 4'48; * '4; (4 + (2 G ;+ +s + +)+* 4s 8 4 4+ 4* $ )+' %. O* (s 4 +;;4 +* = 8 + =*(24 2' ) (s ; 6=4 +*

s + 4 G ;+ *64. T 4 =*(24 ;4*4 '+ 4 (* 4 4+' +* G ;+ 24 *s4*s4 4ss. S 4;s 4'4 +=4* '4 ( 4 G ;+ 8 ( 8 s8664ss. T 4'48; *, G ;+ +s +=4* 4 s;( + < B+ '( +* 4 +;;4 +* +* B+*+'s( +* (s s *s +*s )4 4's, 8 G ;+ (4 < 4 ()4 4< '4+6 4 4 s;( + .

O* 4s4 2+6 s 4 S4ss( *s J8 4 +s 2 ;(*( * + B+ '( + )4'4 < +s=44 +;;4 +* 4+ G ;+ 6 8 * + 4 '4+ (s4 + 4 +;;4 +* 8 +=4 8

+ =*(24 2' ) (s ; 6=4 +* s + G ;+ . B+ '( +s, 4'42 '4, +6 8( 4 2 + 4 )4* .

T 4 S4ss( *s J8 4 +s 28' 4' 2 ;(*( * + 4 +;;4 +* + 4 '( 2 ;'( + 4424*64 2 ;4's *, +* + (s '( 47 4* 4 4 4* 4 6+8s(* 2 4+ +s (

+' s4 * +66 8* 2 +* +ss+8 * (s s(s 4' (6 +s ( (* 4* + 86 4'. H4 +s 28' 4' 2 ;(*( * + ) '4 +') +* 4 6('68)s +*64s 2 4 6+s4 '4 8('4 +s * 6+8s4 +* 4'42 '4 4 +;;4 +* +s + s +6 8( 4 . T 4 S + 4 4*+;;4+ 4 4 H( C 8' + +(*s 4 +6 8( + 2 +668s4 . T 4 H( C 8'8; 4 4 +6 8( + 2 B+ '(. T 4 +6 8( + 2 - 4 +;;4 +* +s s4 +s( 4 * 4

' 8* + 4 6+s4 +s * 6 4'4 < 4 2(2 6 +8s4 2 s. 100 +* 4 '( 2

-;'( + 4 424*64 2 ;4's * (* (s 6+s4 ( * 47 4* 4 8* +'< 6+8s(* 2 4+ 4 +ss+( +* +* 4'42 '4 ( +s 47644 4 . T 4 H( C 8' '4 (4 * +*

4+' (4' 46(s( * 2 ( s * (* E);4' ' . R+) S+('( ' 8s ();'(s *)4* . H4 +;; (4 2 ' + 64' (2(6+ 4 4*+ 4 () +;;4+ (sC 8' 8 (s +s '428s4 . T 4'48; * 4 +;; (4 (s C 8' 2 ' s;46(+ 4+ 4 (6 +s '+* 4 +* + (s 4 )+ 4' +s 6 )4 8; 42 '4 8s.

T 4 )+(* 84s ( * 4'42 '4 + 2+ s 2 ' 6 *s( 4'+ ( * (* (s +;;4+ (s 4 4' 446(s( * (* R+) $1% I. .R. 19&? A . 1"5.

"50

S+(s 6+s4 $1% (s 6 ''46 . I +;;4+'s + 2 8' 4' ( C 8' s + 4 +=4* + (4 (6 (s (224'4* * + +=4* (* R+) S+(s 6+s4 $1-%, *+)4 < J+ + s(* . (*E);4' ' $ % D+' + =+' . E);4' ' +' . T 4 S + 4 $&% +* D+


5/8

+ 86 (* +s (s +* 224*64 8* 4' + C 4 +* * )4'4 < 4 +6 2 + 86 ( * +s42(*4 (* s. 3" 4'4 2. M4'4 + 86 ( * (s * +* 224*64 +* , 4'42 '4, 6+**( 4 '(s4 2 +*< '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64 +* 4 47 4* 4 '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64( 4* < s. 100 * < +'(s4s (2 4 224*64 (6 66+s( *s 4 474'6(s4 2 4 '( (s 2

4 O2 4 =(* s )4* ( *4 (* s.

100.

S46 ( * 9# ( 4s 4 '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64 2 ;4's * + +(*s +*< 224*64 +2246 (*4 8)+*


6/8

+ ;4's * < 2 '64 6 );4 s ' < +*< 464( 28 )4+*s (* 864s +* 4' ;4's * 2' ) +*< ; +64. B8 + 86 ( * ;8'4 +* s(); 4 (s * +* 224*64 8* 4' 4 P4*+C 4. O* < + 86 ( * ( 64' +(* (* 4* (s ;8*(s + 4 +s +* 224*64. I2 4 (* 4* ( *(s + 4 ;4's * + 86 4 )+< 4 )8' 4'4 ' s (s; s4 2 +s 4 ;8 (* +* 4'

2 4(* )8' 4'4 , s. 3"& +;; (4s. I2 4 (* 4* ( * (s 6+8s4 s46'4 +* ' * 286 *2(*4)4* , s. 3"5 +;; (4s. I2 4 + 86 4 ;4's * (s + )+* +* 4 (* 4* ( * (s

+ s 4 )+< 4 6 );4 4 ' (s (=4 < 4 6 );4 4 )+''< +*< ;4's * + +(*s4' ( ' )+< 4 2 '64 ' s4 864 ( (6( (* 4'6 8's4 ' (s (=4 < 4 s 2 '64 '

s4 864 , s. 3"" +;; (4s. I2 4 (* 4* ( * (s 6+8s4 '(4 8s 8' ' s (s; s4 2 4;4's * + 86 4 +s ;8 () (* +* 4' 2 4(* s8 46 4 '(4 8s 8' , 's + 4'< ' 4 8**+ 8'+ 8s 2 +*< ;4's *, s. 3"# +;; (4s. I2 4 + 86 4 ;4's * (s +6 ( 8* 4' 4 + 4 2 4* +* 4 (* 4* ( * (s +=4 (s *4s < +*< ) + 4;' ;4' < 2' ) ( s ;4's *, s. 3"9 +;; (4s. I (s s+( + 8* 4ss +* 224*64 8* 4' *4 2

4s4 s46 ( *s (s (=4 < 4 6 ))( 4 , 4 2(2 6 +8s4 2 s. 100 6+* + 4 *+;; (6+ ( *. O* + ; +(* '4+ (* , 4 4', 2 + 6 +8s4 4'4 4s * s44) 4 +*< '4+s * 2 ' (* + 4 ' + 86 (* 8s4 4'4 )4+*s +*< (* ) '4 +* + (s 42(*4 +s + 86 ( * (* s. 3" .

"5

I (s '84 + 4 '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64 2 ;4's * +'(s4s * < (2 +* - 224*64 + +(*s4 8)+* < (s 6 ))( 4 . S46 ( * 100 ( 4s +* 47 4* 4 '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64

2 ;4's * (* 6+s4s 4'4. 4 224*64 (6 66+s( *s 4 474'6(s4 2 4 '( (s 2 +*< 2 4 4s6'(; ( *s 4*8)4'+ 4 4'4(*. E+6 2 4 s(7 6 +8s4s 2 s. 100 + =s 2 +* +ss+8 +* +ss+8 (s +* 224*64 + +(*s 4 8)+* < $s44 s. 35 %. S 42 '4

4 47 4* 4 '( 8* 4' s. 100 +'(s4s 4'4 +s 4 4 224*64 2 +ss+8 +* (s+ss+8 +s 4 2 *4 2 4 s(7


7/8


8/8

(s ; 6=4 . I (s 8*2 ' 8*+ 4 + 4 +* 4 '( (* 4 4+' +* 4'42 '4G ;+ (4 . B8 6 *s( 4'(* + 4 +;;4 +* + ( 4* $1% I. .R. 19&? A . 1"5.

?3

"5&

* < *4 4 ( +* ' (*+'< =*(24 (6 , (2 ( + 44* + ( 4 (s +< ' + ,6 8 * + 4 44* 2+ + , ( 6+** 4 s+( + 4 (*2 (6 4 ) '4 +') +* +s*464ss+'< 2 ' 4 ;8'; s4 2 424*64. As +s 44* ; (* 4 8 (* A) + +* . T 4S + 4 $1%, 4s4 (* s 6+** 4 4( 4 (* 2(*4 + s4 2 s6+ 4s ' (* 4*s6+ 4 >. W4, 4'42 '4, + 4 +;;4+ +* + 4 +;;4 +* + 4 '( 2 ;'( + 4 424*64 2 ;4's * 8* 4' 4 2(2 6 +8s4 2 s. 100 +* ( * 6+8s4 ) '4

+') +* +s *464ss+'< +* +6 8( ().

A;;4+ + 4 .
http://indiankanoon.org/doc/1443323/http://indiankanoon.org/doc/1443323/http://indiankanoon.org/doc/1443323/http://indiankanoon.org/doc/1443323/

vishwanath vs the state of uttar pradesh on 3 september

Documents