virginia: and number vgobvirginia: exhibit a before the virginia gas and oil board application ofcnx...

12
VIRGINIA: 100002223 BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBER VGOB 09-0421-2500 ELECTIONS: UNIT P-80 (herein Subject Drilling Unit) REPORT OF BOARD FINDINGS AND ORDER This Supplemental Order is entered by the Board sua sponre in the form authorized by the Board at hearings held on February 15, 1994 and June 16, 1992; and this Supplemental Order is being recorded for the purpose of supplementing the Order previously in the captioned matter on October 8, 2009 which was recorded at Document ¹090003362 in the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Buchanan County, Virginia, on October 29, 2009, (herein "Board Order" ) and completing the record regarding elections. Findinus: The Board finds that: The Board Order directed CNX GAS COMPANY LLC (herein ADesignated Operator) to mail copies of the Board Order to all Respondents whose interests, if any, were pooled by the said Board Order; The Designated Operator filed its aflldavit of elections disclosing that it had mailed a true and correct copy of the Board's Order to all Respondents whose interests, if any, were pooled by said Board Order; The Board Order required each Respondent whose interests, if any, were pooled by the terms of said Board Order to make an election within thirty (30) days afier the date of mailing or recording, as applicable, of said Order; the affidavit of elections filed herein and annexed hereto as Exhibit A states: (i) whether each Respondent has made or failed to make a timely election; (ii) the nature of any election(s) made; and (iii) whether, by reason of a failure to elect or to timely elect one or more Respondents are deemed, under the terms of the Board's Order, to have leased all their rights, title, interests, estates and claims in Subject Drilling Unit to the Applicant; That the atfidavit of elections annexed hereto with the Exhibits submitted therewith identifies the Respondent(s) making a timely election, if any; identifies the Respondent(s), if any, who are deemed to have leased; identifies the conflicting interests and claims which require escrow; identifies the interests and claims, if any, requiring escrow under Virginia Code section 45,1-361.21.D4 and identifies the Respondents, if any, who may be dismissed by reason of having leased or entered into a voluntary agreement with the Applicant. The afiidavit of elections indicates whether or not the escrow of funds is required with regard to Unit P- 80; Order; By this Order, the Board orders the Designated Operator to tender, consistent with and in accordance with the findings set forth at paragraph 2. above and the annexed affidavit of elections with Exhibits thereto, any funds subject to escrow and instructs the Escrow Agent, First Bank & Trust Company PO Box 3860 Kingsport, TN 37664, Attn: Debbie Davis or any successor named by the Board to establish interest bearing escrow account(s), IRS Tax Identification Number 54-1629506, in accordance with the information set forth in the affidavit of elections with Exhibits thereto, to receive funds and account to the Board therefore.

Upload: others

Post on 31-May-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

VIRGINIA:100002223

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBERVGOB 09-0421-2500

ELECTIONS: UNIT P-80(herein Subject Drilling Unit)

REPORT OF BOARD

FINDINGS AND ORDER

This Supplemental Order is entered by the Board sua sponre in the form authorized by the Board athearings held on February 15, 1994 and June 16, 1992; and this Supplemental Order is being recorded forthe purpose of supplementing the Order previously in the captioned matter on October 8, 2009 which wasrecorded at Document ¹090003362 in the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Buchanan County,Virginia, on October 29, 2009, (herein "Board Order" ) and completing the record regarding elections.

Findinus: The Board finds that:

The Board Order directed CNX GAS COMPANY LLC (herein ADesignated Operator) to mail copies ofthe Board Order to all Respondents whose interests, if any, were pooled by the said Board Order;

The Designated Operator filed its aflldavit of elections disclosing that it had mailed a true and correctcopy of the Board's Order to all Respondents whose interests, if any, were pooled by said Board Order;

The Board Order required each Respondent whose interests, if any, were pooled by the terms of saidBoard Order to make an election within thirty (30) days afier the date of mailing or recording, asapplicable, of said Order; the affidavit of elections filed herein and annexed hereto as Exhibit A states: (i)whether each Respondent has made or failed to make a timely election; (ii) the nature of any election(s)made; and (iii) whether, by reason of a failure to elect or to timely elect one or more Respondents aredeemed, under the terms of the Board's Order, to have leased all their rights, title, interests, estates andclaims in Subject Drilling Unit to the Applicant;

That the atfidavit of elections annexed hereto with the Exhibits submitted therewith identifies theRespondent(s) making a timely election, if any; identifies the Respondent(s), if any, who are deemed tohave leased; identifies the conflicting interests and claims which require escrow; identifies the interests andclaims, if any, requiring escrow under Virginia Code section 45,1-361.21.D4 and identifies theRespondents, if any, who may be dismissed by reason of having leased or entered into a voluntaryagreement with the Applicant.

The afiidavit of elections indicates whether or not the escrow of funds is required with regard to Unit P-80;

Order; By this Order, the Board orders the Designated Operator to tender, consistent with and inaccordance with the findings set forth at paragraph 2. above and the annexed affidavit of elections withExhibits thereto, any funds subject to escrow and instructs the Escrow Agent, First Bank & Trust CompanyPO Box 3860 Kingsport, TN 37664, Attn: Debbie Davis or any successor named by the Board to establishinterest bearing escrow account(s), IRS Tax Identification Number 54-1629506, in accordance with theinformation set forth in the affidavit of elections with Exhibits thereto, to receive funds and account to theBoard therefore.

Page 2: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

Mailina of Order and Filina of Affidavi: The Designated Operator under the captioned Order or shallfile an affidavit with the Secretary of the Board within ten (10) days after the date of receipt of this Orderstating that a true and correct copy of this Order was mailed to each Respondent whose interests or claimsare subject to escrow and whose address is known within seven seven (7) days fiom the date of receipt ofthis Order.

Conclusion: Therefore, the findings and all terms and provisions set forth above be and hereby aregranted and IT IS SO ORDERED.

Effective Date; This Order shall be effective on the date of its execution.

DONE AND EXECUTED this~ day of M~M, 2010, by a majority of theVirginia Gas and Oil Board.

IHDONE AND PERPORNED THIE~dy d y f / J J4,2DID Eyd d ffd B d.

David E. Asbury, Jr.,Principal Executive to the Staff of the Boar

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL

Acknowledged on this ~ day of , 2010, personally before me anotary public in and for the Commonwealth of Vipgnia, appEared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworndid depose and say that he is Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, and appeared David E. AsburyJro being duly sworn did depose and say that he is Principal Executive to the Staff of the Virginia Gas andOil Board that they executed the same and were authorized to do so.

p~Diane J. Davis, Notatyy

174394

My commission expires: September 30, 2013

Page 3: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

VIRGINIA:Exhibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

Application of CNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling of Interests in CBM Unit P-80VGOB 09-0421-2500 in the Rocklick District of Buchanan County, Virginia

AFFIDAVIT OF CNX GAS COMPANY LLC (herein ADesignated Operator) REGARDINGELECTIONS, ESCROW AND SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER

Anita D. Duty, being first duly sworn on oath, deposes and says:

That your affiant is employed by CNX Land Resources, Inc., as a Pooling Supervisor and is dulyauthorized to make this affidavit on behalf of CNX GAS COMPANY LLC, the designated operator,

That the Order entered on October 8, 2009, by the Virginia Gas and Oil Board (hereinafter "Board")regarding the captioned CBM Unit required the Applicant to mail a true and correct copy of said Order toeach person pooled by the Order;

That within seven (7) days of receipt of an executed copy of the Order referred to at paragraph 2, above,your affiant caused a true and correct copy of said Order to be mailed via the United States Postal Serviceto each Respondent named in the captioned Application, whose address was known, and to all persons, ifany, who were added as Respondents at the hearing held in the captioned matter; that proof of such mailinghas previously been tendered to the Division of Gas and Oil, the Office of the Gas and Oil Inspector, atLebanon, Virginia;

That the Order of the Board in the captioned matter required all persons pooled thereby to tender theirwritten elections to the Unit Operator within thirty (30) days of the date the Order was recorded in thecounties identified above; that said Order was recorded on October 29, 2009;

That the designated operator CNX GAS COMPANY LLC has established procedures to review all mailreceived and all written documents received other than by mail to ascertain whether parties whose interestshave been pooled have made a written election, in a timely fashion, as required by the captioned Order;that said procedures were followed to identify the elections, if any, made with regard to the Subject Unit;that the following persons delivered, by mail or otherwise, written elections the Unit Operator, within thethirty day elections period:

Reual FL & Dorothy Ratliff —Carried Operator (I/3 Interest in Tr. 1A, IB,1C,ID)

That Respondents identified in Exhibit B-3 hereto are, having failed to make any election, deemed tohave leased their coalbed methane rights, interests and claims to Applicant, all as provided in the Board'sOrder of October 8, 2009;

See attached Exhibit B-3

That the rights, interests and claims of the following persons are subject to escrow under the Board'sOrder pooling the captioned Unit, Board Regulations and the Code of Virginia:

See attached Exhibit E

Page 4: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

That after the pooling hearing held in the captioned matter, the following persons have leased or enteredinto a voluntary agreement with the Designated Operator:

See attached Exhibit B-2

That to the extent any of said persons listed in Exhibit B-2 have rights, interests and claims which aresubject to escrow, they should be dismissed as respondents; the Operator requests that the followingpersons be dismissed as Respondents:

Malcolm Lee & Lore Lee Daniels, Billy C. & Nell Woodrum, Randy & Peggy JeanShortridge

That the persons identified in Exhibit EE attached hereto have entered into royalty split agreements thatallow the Applicant/Designated Operator to pay them directly without the need to escrow funds whichwould otherwise be in conflict.

None

That pursuant to the provisions of VAC 25-160-70.A.IO. and C. and VAC 25-160-80 the annexedsupplemental order sets forth the interests and claims that require escrow of funds pursuant to VirginiaCode sections 45.1-361.21.D.and 45.1-361.22.A.3,and 4.

Dated at Bluefield, West Virginia, this ~day of kJVKL'010.

U~,L). t. WSTATE OF WEST VIRGINIACOUNTY OF MERCER

Taken, subscribed and sworn to before me by Anita D. Duty as a Pooling Supervisor for CNX LandResources, Inc., on behalf of the corporate Designated Operator, this ~ day of

, 2010.

Notary

My commission expires: itC3/D3 I Pep''7I

III

IIIiI

OFFICIAL SEALNOTARY PUBLIC

STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA

RHONDA L CARTWRIGHT IICNX GAS COMPANY LLC2403 'OHN NASH BLVD.BLUEFIELD, WV 24201 I

MY commission expire ~ October 23, 201TI

I

Page 5: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

PROPER1V LINES SHOWN ON THIS PLAT WERE TAK

FROM DEED DESCRIPTIONS AND CHAIN DF TITLE

AND DOES NOT REPRESENT A CURRENT FIELD SUR

I

TO OTHER88'ADIUS DF PBB2688'ADIUS

/iNI360 144.22E 937,914.30

I

'

1CI

I

I

I)

I

II

I/ I

jI

I

jI

I

I

L/

2A

N 360,082.85E 939,509.57

7

/

/

N 35B,545.12E 937,853.45

EXHIBIT A

NORA FIELDUNIT PBO

FORCE POOLINGI/GOB 09—0121 —2500

CODpany CNX Gas Companv LLC

Tract No. ElevatIonBUCHANAN District ROCKLICK

This plat is a new plat an updated plat X or afiTIMOTHY E. BORN

Pg/Na. 035686For m DGO-G0-7Rev, 9/91 L i censed gof egs i ona I Eng i neer ep

'e

U Name and Number UNIT PBD

Quadrangle HA@40

Gcale: 1" = 4INE'ate '3 f/?jTD I

Page 6: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

CNX GAS CQIIPANY LLCUNff:PSO

Tract Identlffcatlons

Bull Creek Coal Company (Joseph Ragiff 259.59Acre Tract) -All Minerals except Oil, Gas snd CBMIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. —Coal In and Below the P-6 Seam LeasedRapoca Energy- Coal in Splashdam Seam Leased (Subleased from Penn Virginia Resource Partners)Rapoca Energy —Coal In Hsgy and Above Seams LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Corporagon- Coal in Kennedy Seam LeasedCNX Gss Company.LLC —CBM LeasedReual H. Rafillf, st sl- All Mlnerah sxoept CoalChesapeake Appahrchla LLC-Oil and Gss LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC -CBM Leased (1/3)CNX Gas Company LLC- Surfaoe12.33 Acres 20,9906%

Bull Creek Coal Company (Joseph Ratliff 269.59Acre Tract) -All Minerals except Oil, Gas and CBMIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. —Coal In and Below Ihs P-6 Seam LeasedRapocs Energy- Coal in Spisshdam Seam Leased (SuMsassd fiom Penn Virginia Resource Partners)Rapoca Energy —Coal In Hagy and Above Seams LssssdJewsll Smokshss Coal Corporsgon- Coal In Kennedy Seam LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC—CBM LeasedBull Cmek Coal Company, et al -All Minsrakr except CosiChesapeake Appahrchia LLC -Oil and Gas LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM Leased (1/3)Apphrchian Power Company, Inc. -Surface16 16Acres 275111%

Bull Creek Coal Company (Joseph Ratirff 259.59 Acre Trad) —All Minerals except Oil, Gss and CBMIskmd Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. —Coal In and Below tha P-6 Seam LeasedRapoca Energy- Coal In Splashdsm Seam Leased (Subleased from Penn Vfiglnia Resource Partners)Rapoca Energy —Coal in Hagy and Above Seams LeasedJewsll Smokeless Coal Corporsgon —Coal in Kennedy Seam LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedBgly C. Woodrum, et al —All Mlrwals except CoalChesapeake Appalachia LLC-Oil and Gas LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC- CBM Leased (1/3)Billy C. Woodrum, et ux —Surface4.63Acres '2227%Bull Creek Coal Company (Joseph Ratliff 259.59 Acre Tract) —All Minerals except Oil, Gas and CBM'lskmd Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. —Coal In and Below the PA Seam LeasedRapoca Energy- Coal in Splsshdam Seam Leased (Subleased from Penn Virginia Resource Psrlners)Rapoca Energy —Coal in Hagy snd Above Seams LeasedJewsll Smokeless Coal Corporation —Coal in Kennedy Seam LeasedCNX Gss Company LLC —CBM Le'asedReual H. Rsfirff, et al - All Nfrnerals except CoalChesapeake Appalachia LLC —Oil and Gaia Leased

-GNX-Gas-Gempany-LLG-GBM-Leased(4/3)- ——Commonwealth of Virginia —Surface0.60Acres 1.0215%

Page 1 of 3

Page 7: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

CNX GAS COINPA NY LLCUNIT PSO

Tract Identifications

1E. Bull Creek Coal Company (Joseph Rstliff 259.59Acre Tract) -All Minerals except Oil, Gas and CBMIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. —Coal In and Below the P-6 Seam LeasedRapoca Energy- Coal in Splashdam Seam Leased (Subkrased from Penn Virginh Resource Partners)Rapoca Energy- Coal in Hagy and Above Seams LeasedJeweil Smokeless Coal Corporation —Coal in Kennedy Seam LeasedCNX Gss Company LLC —CBM LeasedEddie William Wilson, et al —All Minerals except CoalChesapeake Appalachhr LLC- Oil and Gas Leased (1/3)CNX Gas Company LLC —Oil and Gss Leased (2/3)CNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedEddkr William Wthon, et ux —Surface0.76Acres 12938%

1F. Bull Creek Coal Company (Joseph Rstglf 259.59Acre Tract) —All Minerals except Oil, Gas and CBMIsland Cmek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. —Coal In and Below the P-6 Seam LeasedRapoca Energy- Coal In Splashdsm Seam Leased (Subleased from Penn Virginia Resource Partners)Rapoca Energy- Coal In Hsgy and Above Seams LeasedJewell Smokehss Coal Corporagon -Coal in Kennedy Seam teasedCNX Gas Company LLC- CBM LeasedRandy Shorlridge, et al-All Minerals except CoalChesapeake Appshrchhr LLC-Oil and Gas l.eased (1/3)CNX Gas Company LLC —CBM Leased (1/3)Randy Shorlridge, et ux- Surface1,33Acres 2Z642%

Bul Cmek Coal Company (Joseph Rstglf 259.59Acre Tract) —All Minerals except Oil, Gas and CBMIshmd Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy Inc. -Coal In and Below the P-6 Seam LeasedRapoca Energy- Coal in Splashdsm Seam Leased (Subleased fmm Penn Vlrglnla Resource Partners)Rapoca Energy- Coal in Hagy and Abave Seams LeasedJewsll Smokshrss Coal Corporagon —Coal In Kennedy Seam LeasedCNX Gss Company LLC —CBM LeasedSteven L Roars et el~ Minerahr except CoalChesapeake Appalachia LLC -Oil and Gas Leased (1/3)CNX Gas Company LLC -Oil and Gas Leased (2/3)CNX Gas Company LLC- CBM leased

-Steven-L;Rosrk;-et ux- Surface0.06Acres 0.1021%

AGIN LLC (31.80Acre Tract)-AIIMinerakr except Oll, Gas and CBMAlpha Land and Reserves LLC —All Coal LeasedRange Rerxxrrcss-Pine Mounhln, Inc. -All Minerah except CoalCNX Ges Company LLC —Olf, Gas and CBM Leased15.37Acies 26.1662%

.26.2C2D.

Jeny D. RsSY, et ux- SurfaceJohnny P Rstiiff,~.—.Surface...Commonwealth of Virginia —SurfaceJerry D. Rstlilf, et ux- Surface

Page 2cf 3March 9, 2909

'7

Page 8: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

CNX GAS COMPANY LLCUNIT P80

Tract Idsntiffcations

3.

3A,3B.3C.

AGIN LLC (77.20 Acre Tract) —All Coal except the Blair, Eagle, Splsshdam and Hagy Coal Seams

Alpha Land and Reserves LLC- All Coal Leased except the Blair, Eagle, Splashdam and Hagy

Coal SeamsWellmore Coal Company, LLC- Blair, Eagle, Splashdam and Hagy Coal SeamsMoffvation Coal Company- Blair, Eagle, Splashdam and Hagy Coal Seams LeasedRange Resources-Pins Mountain, Inc. —All Minerals except CoalCNX Gas Company LLC —Dil, Gas and CBM Leased7.30Acres 12.4276%

David F. Ratliff, et ux- SurfaceJeny D. Ratliif, et ux- SurfaceCommonwealth of Virginia - Surface

Page 3 of 3March 9, 2009

Page 9: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

Exhibit B-2Unit P4)0

Docket ¹VGOB 094)421-2600List of Respondents to be Dismissed

(58.74 Acre Unit)

Acres in UnitPercentof Unit

Reason forDismissal

II. OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

Tract ¹1A - 12.22acme

(1) Reual H. Ratliff, et al

(b) Malcolm Lee & Lors Lee DanielsPO Box 1037Grundy, VA 24614

Tract ¹tc - 4.82 acres

12.33 acres

4.11 acres1/3 of 12.33acres

20 9908%

6 9969% Purchased

(1) Billy C. Woodrum, et al

(b) Billy C. & Nell WoodrumRt2 Box 230Grundy, VA 24614

4.83 acres

1 61 acres1/3 of 4.83 acres

8.2227%

2.7409% Purchased

Tract ¹1D - 0 SO acres

(1) Reual H Ratliff, et al

(b) Malcolm Lee & Lore Lee DanielsPO Box 1037Grundy, VA 24614

0.60 acres

0.20 acres1/3 of 0.60 acres

1.0215%

0.3405% Purchased

Tract ¹1F- 1.23acres

(1) Randy Shortridge, et al

(b) Randy 8 Peggy Jean ShortridgeRt2, Box 812Grundy, VA 24614

1.33 acres

0.89 acres2/3 of 1.33acres

2.2642%

1.5095% Leased

Page 1 of 1 Revised 11/12/09

Page 10: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

Exhibit B-3Unit P40

Docket ¹VGOB 094)421-2500List of Unleased Owners/Claimants

(58.74 Acre Unit)

Acres in UnitPercentof Unit Election

COAL OWNERSHIP

Tmct ¹2 - 16.37acres

(1) AGIN LLCc/o Western Pocahontas Properties LPP.O. Box 28271035 Third Avenue, Suite 300Huntington, WV 25727

15.37 acres 26.1662% n/a

Note: Them ls no conhlct, Range Resources. Pine Mountain inc. owns the CBM royaluas

Tract ¹3 - 7.30notes

(1) AGIN LLC

c/o Western Pocahontas Properties LPP.O. Box 28271035 Third Avenue, Suite 300Huntington, WV 25727

7.30 acres 12.4276'/c n/a

Noiei there is no con/her, Range Resources-pine Mountain inc. owns the cBM niyaltles

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

Tract ¹10 .12.33acres

(1) Reusl H. Ratliff, et al

(c) Reual H. & Dorothy RatliffRt. 2, Box 232BGrundy, VA 24614

Tract ¹1B- 16.16acres

12 33 acres

4.11 acres1/3 of 12.33acres

20.9908%

6 9969'/o Carried(Reual & Dorothy Ratliff —1/3 interest)

(1) Bull Creek Coal Company, et al

(b) Reual Herman RatliffRt. 2, Box 232BGrundy, VA 24614

(c) Raley E & Patricia Ellen (Ratliff) Walker204 Park St.Grayson, KY 41143

Tmct ¹1C - 4 63 acres

1616 acres

5.39 acres1/3 of 16.16acres

539 acres1/3 of 16.16acres

27.5111%

9 1704'/c Carried(Renal & Dorothy Ratliff - 1/3 interest)

9.1704%

(1) Reual H. Ratliff, et al

(c) Reual Herman RatliffRt. 2, Box 232BGrundy, VA 24614

Tract ¹10- 0 60 acres

4.83 acres

1.61 ac/es1/3 of 4.83 acres

8 2227 ok

2.7409% Carried(Reual & Dorothy Ratliff —1/3 interest)

(1) Reual H. Ratliff, et al

(c) Reual H. & Dorothy RatliffRt. 2, Box 232BGrundy, VA 24614

0.60 acres

0.20 acresI/3 of 0.60 acres

1.0215%

0.3405'/e Carried(Reual & Dorothy Ratliff - 1/3 interest)

Page 1 of1 Updated 11/1 2/09

Page 11: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

Exhibit EUnit Puig

Docket ¹VGOB 084H214500List of Conflicting Owners/Clalmsnat that require escrow

(58.74Acre Unit)

Acres In UnitPercentof Unit

Tract ¹1¹ 'fz 23 solos

Note: Rebecca Thornbury, Attorney for Dorothy & Renal Ratliff is contestmg ownership1/2 not 1/3 interest Entire tract escrowed by request and approved by the Board

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

12.33 acres 20.9908%

(1) Renal H. Ratliff, et al

(a) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewe8, VA 24651

12.33 acres

4.11 acres1/3 of 12 33 acres

20 9908ok

6.9969%

(b) CNX Gas Company LLC2481 John Nash BlvdBluefield, WV 24701

(c) Revel H. & Dorothy RatliffRt 2, Box 2328Grundy, VA 24614

Tract ¹1B - 1/I 18scone

411 acresI/3 of 12.33acres

4.11 acres1/3 of 12 33 acres

6.99690/o

6 9969'/o

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal CompanyPO. Box 187Tazewe8, VA 24651

16.16 acres 27.5111'/o

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal Company, et al

(b) Renal Herman RatliffRt. 2, Box 2328Grundy, VA 24614

(c) Relay E. 8 Patricia Ellen (Rstliff) Walker204 Hunter Hills Cirde ¹30Bristol, VA 37620

16.16acres

5.39 acme1/3 of 16.16acres

539 acres1/3 of 16.16acres

27 511fok

9 1704'/

9.1704%

Tract ¹1C - 4Jlz scoow

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewea, VA 24651

4.83 acres 8.2227'/o

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Revel H. Ratliff, et al

(b) CNX Gas Company LLC2481 John Nash Blvd.Bluefield, VIN 24701

4.83 acres

1.61 acres1/3 of 4.83 acres

8.2227%

2 7409o/

(c) Reual Herman RstliffRt. 2, Box 232BGrundy, VA 24614

1.61 acres1/3 of 4.83 acres

Page 1 of 2

2.7409%

Updated 11/1 2/09

li

Page 12: VIRGINIA: AND NUMBER VGOBVIRGINIA: Exhibit A BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD Application ofCNX Gas Company LLC for Forced Pooling ofInterests in CBM Unit P-80 VGOB 09-0421-2500in

Exhibit EUnit PGO

Docket QVGOB 094M21 4&00List of ConfgcSng Owners/Claims nh that require escrow

(58.74Acre Unit)

Acres In UnitPercentof Unh

Tract ¹fD 0 aa serac

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

0.60 acres 1.0215%

(1) Renal H. Ratliff, et al

(b) CNX Gas Company LLC2481 John Nash Blvd.Bluefheld, WV 24701

(c) Renal H. & Dorothy RatQIIRt. 2, Box 2328Grundy, VA 24614

Trna/ 61E - 0.76serac

0.60 acres

0.20 acresI/3 of 0.60 acres

0.20 acresI/3 of 0.60 acme

1.021504

0.3405%

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazeweg, VA 24651

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

0.76 acres 1.2938%

(1) Eddie WIIQam Wilson, et al

(b) Eddre WIIQsm & Shirley S. WilsonPO Box 696Vansant, VA 2465B

Tnrcr ¹1P - 1.99serac

0.76 seals

0.51 acme2/3 of 0.76 acres

1.2938%

0.8626%

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

1.33 acres 2.2642'/r

(1) Randy Shorlridge, et el

(b) Randy & Peggy Jean ShortridgeRt2, Box 812Grundy, VA 24614

Tnrer ¹/G a.aa arras

1.33 ec/es

0.89 ec/es2/3 of 1.33acres

2.2642%

1.5095%

COAL OWNERBHIP

(1) Bull Creek Coal CompanyP.O. Box 187Tazewell, VA 24651

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

O.O5 acme 0.1021%

(1) Steven L. Roerk, et sl

(b) Steven & Margamt RoarkPO Box 631Grundy, VA 24614

0.06 acres

o.os ac/es2/3 of 0.06 acres

Page 2 of 2

0 1021%h

O.OM1%

Updated 11/I 2/09