verification of real-time igs products and their influence on precise point positioning ·...

27
Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning Tomasz HADAŚ , Jan KAPLON, Karina WILGAN, Jaroslaw BOSY, Jan SIERNY Wroclaw University of Environmental and Life Sciences, Poland GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 1/25

Upload: others

Post on 13-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Verification of real-time IGS products andtheir influence on Precise Point Positioning

Tomasz HADAŚ, Jan KAPLON, Karina WILGAN,Jaroslaw BOSY, Jan SIERNY

Wroclaw University of Environmental and Life Sciences, Poland

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 1/25

Page 2: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

RTIGS projectMotivationMethodology

Presentation plan

1 Introduction

RTIGS project

Motivation

Methodology

2 RTIGS current status

Accuracy

Latency

Quality degradation over time

3 Short-time predictions

Prediction of orbit corrections

Prediction of clock corrections

4 Conclusions

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 2/25

Page 3: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

RTIGS projectMotivationMethodology

RTIGS project

Target combination product performances are:

Satellite Clock Accuracy: 0.3 ns

Station Clock Accuracy: 0.3 ns

Orbit Accuracy: At the level of the IGS Ultra predictions (5cm)

Latency (when available in RT): 10 s

Update interval in stream:

orbit corrections: 60s

clock corrections: 5s

code biases: 5s

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 3/25

Page 4: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

RTIGS projectMotivationMethodology

Beginner difficulties

1 Lack of documentation on how to apply corrections:

high standardization (Ntrip, RTCM),

few papers and presentations about RTIGS (with bugs).

2 Poor quality verification (until recently):

only target accuracy provided,

PPP monitor scenarios,

AC combination results (Number, RMS and sigma).

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 4/25

Page 5: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

RTIGS projectMotivationMethodology

Beginner difficulties

1 Lack of documentation on how to apply corrections:

high standardization (Ntrip, RTCM),

few papers and presentations about RTIGS (with bugs).

2 Poor quality verification (until recently):

only target accuracy provided,

PPP monitor scenarios,

AC combination results (Number, RMS and sigma).

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 4/25

Page 6: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

RTIGS projectMotivationMethodology

RTIGS project verification methodology (1)

1 Record navigation data and time-series of real-time correction (5 days)

2 Apply clock and orbit corrections, recalculate APC to CoM

3 Compare results with IGS Final orbits/clocks

4 Compute statistics for residuals for each satellite

5 Analyze outliers

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 5/25

Page 7: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS orbit quality (1)

Average STD < 0.050 m, avarage bias ± 0.025 m

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 6/25

Page 8: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS orbit quality (2)

Poor quality over Pacific Ocean and Southern Ocean

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 7/25

Page 9: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS clocks quality (1)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 8/25

Page 10: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS Rubidium clocks quality (1)

Repeatable outliers for PRN: 19 (IIR), 21 (IIR), 31(IIM)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 9/25

Page 11: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS Rubidium clocks quality (2)

Random nature of outliers for the remaining 4 satellites

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 10/25

Page 12: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS Cesium clocks quality (1)

Repeatable outliers for PRN: 3 (IIA) and 24 (IIF)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 11/25

Page 13: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

RTIGS Cesium clocks quality (2)

Single cases of outlying long-arcs for remaining satellites

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 12/25

Page 14: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

Latency - overview

Isolated cases of missing data for 30min, more few-minutes gaps

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 13/25

Page 15: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

Latency - uncommon cases

1) Two close in time cases of data gap (2 & 3 messages) for individual satelllite.2) Few minutes of repeatable uncommon clock correction latency + data gaps.

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 14/25

Page 16: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

Metodology

Simulated data transfer interruptions for various time-periods

Difference between real-time corrections and delayed data as a measure ofquality degradation over time

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 15/25

Page 17: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

Delayed orbit corrections

After 1 min. 95% of corrections degrades < 2 cm; 4min. < 5cmCorrection for satellites with Cesium clocks degrades slightly faster.

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 16/25

Page 18: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

AccuracyLatencyQuality degradation over time

Delayed clock corrections

After 10 sec. 95% of corrections degrades < 2 cm, 30 sec. < 5cmCorrection for satellites with Cesium clocks degrades significantly faster.

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 17/25

Page 19: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

In field measurements

Real-time in-field kinematic PPP:

continous positioning in changing conditions:

environmental (troposphere, ionosphere),

spatial (terrain, horizon obstracles);

rely on availiable orbits and clocks;

require constant Ntrip connection.

In case of interruption in Internet connection (eg. outside the GSM range) -- is it possible to continue measurements?

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 18/25

Page 20: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Methodology

By using the data from the past - predict the corrections:

how to fit the model?

what accuracy is required?

how much past data is needed?

how far one can predict?

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 19/25

Page 21: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Polynomial fit

Polynomials of degree 3 and 4 fited into 2-hour time series of orbit correctiondata (PRN 1: IIF,Rb)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 20/25

Page 22: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Polynomial fit

3-deg polynomials: mean=0.000m, StdDev=0.030m, range=(-0.119 : +0.108)4-deg polynomials: mean=0.000m, StdDev=0.007m, range=(-0.035 : +0.031)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 21/25

Page 23: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Results of polynomial orbit predictions (PRN1: IIF, Rb)

Slower degradation: 2cm after 5min.; 5cm after 10min., (for: deg=3, multi=3)(instead of: 2cm after 1min.; 5cm after 4min.)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 22/25

Page 24: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Results of polynomial orbit predictions (PRN8: IIA, Cs)

Slower degradation: 2cm after 4min.; 5cm after 7min., (for: deg=3, multi=3)(instead of: 2cm after 1min.; 5cm after 4min.)

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 23/25

Page 25: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Clock corrections

None of the prediction method improved the results for clocks.

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 24/25

Page 26: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Prediction of orbit correctionsPrediction of clock corrections

Clock corrections

None of the prediction method improved the results for clocks.

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 24/25

Page 27: Verification of real-time IGS products and their influence on Precise Point Positioning · 2013-06-25 · Introduction RTIGS current status Short-time predictions Conclusions Verification

IntroductionRTIGS current status

Short-time predictionsConclusions

Conclusions

1 IGS provides real-time corrections for broadcast orbits and clocks;

2 In general, RTIGS products meet the target accuracy:

RMS=5cm for each orbit component, RMS=9cm for clocks,

there are interruptions in data transmission as well as outliers,

the correction (especially for clocks) degrades very fast,

users should be careful and aware of imperfections;

3 In case of interruptions in data transmission:

it is possible to extend the lifetime of orbit corrections by 3-deg. polynomialprediction,

clock prediction methods gives worse results;

4 “Guide to use RTIGS products” wolud be helpful:

may encourage the scientific community to take advantage of them.

GNSS PPP Workshop: Reaching Full Potential, 12-14 June 2013, Ottawa 25/25