venaseal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · outcome...

36
陳燿志 Yiu-Che CHAN MB BS (London) BSc MD (London) FRCS (England) FRCS (General Surgery) FCSHK 香港大學外科學系血管外科 Division of Vascular & Endovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Hong Kong Medical Centre, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong. VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose veins

Upload: others

Post on 23-Jan-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

陳燿志Yiu-Che CHAN

MB BS (London) BSc MD (London) FRCS (England)

FRCS (General Surgery) FCSHK

香港大學外科學系血管外科Division of Vascular & Endovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery,

University of Hong Kong Medical Centre,

Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong.

VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol

may improve outcome

in large diameter varicose veins

Page 2: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Disclosure

Speaker name:

....................Yiu Che CHAN.............................................................

I have the following potential conflicts of interest to report:

Consulting

Employment in industry

Stockholder of a healthcare company

Owner of a healthcare company

Other(s)

I do not have any potential conflict of interestX

Page 3: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Endovenous Cyanoacrylate Glue

Venaseal™ Sapheon Closure System, Sapheon Inc(Santa Rosa, USA) now Medtronic, Gorway, Ireland)

• A new modality for treating varicose veins with medical adhesive without thermal energy– European Conformite Europeen (CE) Mark

approval in September 2011

– United States FDA approved February 2015

– Hong Kong is the first place in Asia

– HKU is first centre in Asia to use this

– Medtronic’s VenaSeal closure system has been granted pre-market approval (PMA) from the US FDA November 2015

• The VenaSeal™ closure system is now commercially available in Europe, Australia, HongKong, Singapore, New Zealand, and Canada, Dubai... 氰基丙烯酸酯

Page 4: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

European J Vasc & Endovasc Surg 2013 Feb;45(2):176-7.

Page 5: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration
Page 6: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

• Local anesthetic infiltration at puncture site

Local anesthetic infiltration at puncture site, head up position and

and ultrasound guided venous micropuncture (4Fr sheath)

Page 7: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Remove air bubbles from syringe, then connect to

white catheter and attach to the gun

Page 8: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Inject cyanoacrylate into catheter

until the black marking near the tip

Gun downward

facing to avoid

air bubbles

Page 9: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Gun downward

pointing to

avoid air

bubbles,

catheter

upward

pointing

Page 10: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Measure sheath - the tip of the sheath

is 4cm from the SFJ (IFU 5cm). Insertion of guidewire beyond the SFJ under u/s

The tip of the sheath is 4cm from the

saphenofemoral junction (IFU 5cm)

Page 11: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

When the catheter reaches the black marking, withdraw the blue

sheath to expose tip of catheter to be 4cm from SFJ (IFU 5cm)- fine

adjustment under ultrasound guidance

Page 12: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Catheter Glue Dispenser gun

Page 13: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Two injections of approximately 0.09 milliliters were given 1 cm apart 4cm from SFJ, followed by

a 3-minutes period of local compression, and then repeated injections every 3 cm with 30-second

hand compression until the entire length of the target vein segment was treated .

Page 14: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

All the patients have pre-operative venous duplex

Page 15: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Post-procedure duplex follow up

Distance from SFJ

Page 16: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Outcome MeasuresPrimary Outcome Measures

• Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration rate

• Cumulative probability of recurrent varicose veins within 24 months after treatment, with serial clinical and duplex examination of patient at 1 week, 3 months, 6 months, (1 year, 2 years).

• Definition of complete closure– Doppler ultrasound examination showing closure along entire treated

target vein segment with any discrete segments of patency

Secondary Outcome Measures at pre-op, 1 week post op, 3 months post op, 6 months post-op.

• Pain Score (at discharge) 0-10

• Quality of life Questionnaires (SF36) assessment of pain, edema, venous claudication, pigmentation, lipodermatosclerosis, ulcer size)

• Venous clinical severity score (VCSS)

• Aberdeen varicose vein questionnaire (AVVQ)

• Ecchymosis score (at 1 week: mild, moderate, severe)

• Side-effects or major events from this treatment modality

Garrett AM. BMJ. 1993; 306: 1440-1444.

Carroll C. Health Technol Assess. 2013; 17: i-xvi, 1-141.

Garrett AM. Qual Health Care. 1993; 2: 5-10.

Page 17: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Chan YC , Law Y, Cheung GC, Ting AC, Cheng SW. Phlebology. 2017 Mar;32(2):99-106.

Page 18: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

57 incompetent GSVs in 29 patients

VeClose

6.3/4.9 mm

upper and

mid-thigh

Page 19: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

•Closure rates (n=57)

1 week 100%

1 month 95.3%

6 months 90.3%

12 months 78.5%

< 8mm diameter

>=8mm diameter

Predictors of Recanalisation

(Cox Regression analysis)

*

Page 20: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Chan YC et al. Journal of Vascular Interventional Radiology 2017;28(5):665-671.

Page 21: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

(n=108 legs)

Chan YC et al. Journal of Vascular Interventional

2017;28(5):665-671.

Page 22: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Successful GSV (n=108) Closure over Time

Treatment length <28cm vs >=28cm Competent vs incompetent perforators

(Log-rank test, p=0.116) (Log-rank test, p=0.364)

Successful GSV (n=108) Closure over Time

Simple (C3) vs Complicated C4-6) Varicose Veins Consultants vs Fellows/ Trainees

(Log-rank test, p=0.221) (Log-rank test, p=0.771)

Cox Regression analysis

Page 23: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

< 6.6 mm

≥ 6.6 mm

Log rank: p = 0.010

<6.6 mm >=6.6 mm

n 67 48

1 week 61 98.4% 47 100.0%

1 month 60 98.4% 40 89.3%

6 months 52 96.6% 37 84.8%

12 months 35 94.7% 25 79.5%

24 months 6 78.2% 8 67.9%

Successful GSV (n=108) Closure over Time

Great Saphenous Vein Diameter

Chan YC et al. Journal of Vascular Interventional Radiology 2017;28(5):665-671.

Page 24: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Patterns of

Recanalisation

• All of the recanalisation

were continuous with

the SFJ except for 3

cases with

recanalisation at one-

year Duplex follow up

where

– two cases were from mid

to lower thigh

– one was at mid thigh at

level of perforator

Recanalisation continuous with SFJ 6 months

Recanalisation in mid-thigh with SFJ 12 months

Page 25: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Vascular 2017 April; 25(2): 149-156.

Page 26: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Gibson K. WAVES Study. Vascular 2017 April; 25(2): 149-156.

Page 27: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Normal protocol ‘One extra drop’

since 21st July 2016

SFJ SFJ

Page 28: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Overall closure rates of 173 legs

Page 29: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

< 8 mm, normal protocol

≥ 8 mm, normal protocol

Log Rank: p<0.001

Overall closure rates

Page 30: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

≥ 8 mm, extra-drop

protocol (n=48)

≥ 8 mm, normal protocol

Log Rank: p=0.012

Overall closure rates

Page 31: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

≥ 8 mm, extra-drop

protocol

< 8 mm, normal protocol

Log Rank: p=0.462

Overall closure rates

Page 32: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

No DVT cases

• The mean length of the GSV stump in

closed GSV (for GSV <8mm diameter, n>=8mm

diameter- normal protocol, and n>=8mm diameter-“extra-

drop” protocol ) at 1-week and 6-months

– 2.18, 2.95, 2.07 cm at week 1

– 2.33, 4.59, 2.74 cm at 6 months

– Thombus extension from GSV to deep vein

appeared in 4, 2, and 3 legs respectively,

– The “extra-drop protocol” did not predispose

to development of post-procedure deep vein

thrombosis

Page 33: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

EHIT 3

Week 1 duplex: Thrombus – LMWH - No thrombus 4 days later

Page 34: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

Summary

• Endovenous cyanoacrylate treatment is safe and effective

• A GSV diameter of >=8mm,

and >=6.6mm were

statistically significant

predictors for late

recanalization– with great majority seemed to be from the SFJ

downward

• Our modified “extra-drop”

proctocol have improved the

closure rates for GSV >=8mm

– did not predispose to

development of thrombus

extrusion into the deep vein or

deep vein thrombosis

Page 35: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration
Page 36: VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol may improve outcome in large diameter varicose … · Outcome Measures Primary Outcome Measures • Procedure success rate- saphenous vein obliteration

陳燿志Yiu-Che CHAN

MB BS (London) BSc MD (London) FRCS (England)

FRCS (General Surgery) FCSHK

香港大學外科學系血管外科Division of Vascular & Endovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery,

University of Hong Kong Medical Centre,

Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong.

VenaSeal: slightly modified protocol

may improve outcome

in large diameter varicose veins