us mag apologises to zaha hadid for qatar 'error' | online news | building

8/11/2019 US mag apologises to Zaha Hadid for Qatar 'error' | Online News | Building

1/3

Tuesday26 August 2014

US mag apologises to Zaha Hadid for Qatar 'error'

26 August 2014 | By Dave Rogers

New York Review of Books posts statement on website

The New York Review of Books has apologised for an error it made about Zaha Hadid when its architecture critic

criticised her attitude towards the plioght of construction workers in Qatar during a recent book review.

Hadid claimed critic Martin Filler falsely implied she was indifferent to the alleged difficult working conditions of migrant

workers on high-profile construction projects in the Middle East, including her own.

She also claimed Filler used large portions of his June 5 review of Rowan Moores Why We Build: Power and Desire in

Architecture to question her success and fault her personality, although she was not a prominent character in the book.

In her complaint, Hadid pointed to a passage where Filler said she unashamedly disavowed any responsibility, let alone

concern for an estimated one thousand laborers who have perished while building the Al Wakrah stadium she

designed for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar.

Hadid began action over comments made about her attitude towards construction workers in Qatar

But in a statementposted on the magazines website, Filler wrote: In my review of Rowan Moores Why We Build: Power

and Desire in Architecture[NYR, June 5], I quoted comments by the architect Zaha Hadid, who designed the Al Wakrah

stadium in Qatar, when she was asked in London in February 2014 about revelations a week earlier in the Guardian that

hundreds of migrant laborers had died while working on construction projects in Qatar. I wrote that an estimated one

thousand laborershave perished while constructing her project thus far.

This site uses cookies

By continuing to browse the site you areagreeing to our use of cookies. Read our Cookie

Policy to find out more.

I AGREE

ag apologises to Zaha Hadid for Qatar 'error' | Online News | Building http://www.building.co.uk/news/us-mag-apologises-to-zaha-hadid

8/26/14 1


2/3

Source:

0

Follow @buildingnews 50.2K followers

Related Company

Resources

However, work did not begin on the site for the Al Wakrah stadium until two months after Ms. Hadid made those

comments; and construction is not scheduled to begin until 2015. There have been no worker deaths on the Al Wakrah

project and Ms. Hadids comments about Qatar that I quoted in the review had nothing to do with the Al Wakrah site or

any of her projects.

I regret the error.

At the time, legal action was filed at the New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan, Oren Warshavsky, a partner at

Baker & Hostetler, which is representing Hadid, said that Fillers review was a personal attack disguised as a book

review and has exposed Ms Hadid to public ridicule and contempt, depriving her of confidence and injuring her goodname and reputation.

In a statement released after Fillers apology, Warshavsky said: We are in receipt of Mr Fillers retraction issued today

and aware of the New York Review of Books plan to post it on their website. Ms Hadid together with counsel are

reviewing it now and will respond after further careful consideration.

Magazine editor Robert Silvers told the Guardian that it had posted the statement on its website independently, not as a

result of consultation with Hadid or her lawyers.

He added: We have done this entirely on our own. This letter contains the facts that should be made public and the

regret that we thought was appropriate.

This story first appeared on Building Design here.

LATEST CASE STUDIES

Related company resources

Desktop Site | Mobile Site

0LikeLike

Jaga heats

BREEAM

Excellent

Humberside PoliceHQ

Read More

Sika concrete

repair system

specified for Forth

Road Bridge

Read More

Load bearing frame

for St Georges

Grove

Read More




I AGREE


8/26/14 1


3/3




I AGREE


8/26/14 1

us mag apologises to zaha hadid for qatar 'error' | online news | building

Documents