urban environmental biogeochemsitry laboratory chemical and biological impacts of roadway derived...

18
Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S. Lev 1 , R. Casey 1 , E. Landa 2 and J. Snodgrass 1 1 Urban Environmental Biogeochemistry Laboratory, Towson University, Towson, MD 2 U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Division-National Research Program, Reston, VA

Upload: peter-henry

Post on 04-Jan-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering

Stormwater Retention Systems

S. Lev1, R. Casey1, E. Landa2 and J. Snodgrass1

1Urban Environmental Biogeochemistry Laboratory, Towson University, Towson, MD2U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Division-National Research Program, Reston, VA

Page 2: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Roadway DerivedContaminants(trace metals)

Stormwater

Retention BasinSediments

Biota

Soils

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 3: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Baltimore

N

Red Runwatershed

Page 4: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Change in wetland landscape of Red Run Watershed:1987-2000

Study area

Page 5: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

10

7

65

11

8

9

4

3

2

XXXXX

Ow

ing

s Mills B

lvd.

MonitoringStation

Watershed scaletransport and

long term storage

TransportAvailability

StorageAmphibian Bioassay

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 6: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Field Study– Characterize Cu and Zn speciation in

stormwater runoff– Evaluate road dust as a potential source in

runoff and retention pond sediments– Determine potential availability of metals in

pond sediments– Determine storage of Cu and Zn in pond

Laboratory Bioassay– Determine effects of aged tire debris and Zn2+

on wood frog (Rana sylvatica) eggs and larvae

Project Objectives

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 7: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Zn and Cu in Roadway Runoff

Total (Dissolved + Exchangeable) y = 5.1849x + 8.5073

R2 = 0.9046

0

200

400

600

800

0 50 100 150

Cu (mg L-1)

Zn

(mg L-1)

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 8: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

16500 g Zn = 73.3 storms 225 g Zn storm-1

73 storms can occur over a 3-4 year periodIndicates a loss of Zn into surrounding environment

6000 g Cu = 140 storms43 g Cu storm-1

140 storms can occur over a 7-9 year periodIndicates some loss of Cu to surrounding environment

Fate of Zn and Cu in Retention Pond

Lost from system

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 9: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

0.00

50.00

100.00

150.00

200.00

250.00

300.00

350.00

400.00

Soil Tire ZnCl2

mg k

g -1

Zn Accumulation in Tissues

Hatching success was significant between clutches (P<0.0001) and moderately significant between treatments (P=0.0442)

Significant differences in time to metamorphosis between treatments (P=0.0081). Tire and ZnCl2 were slower than soil, but were not significantly different from each other

Accumulation in tissues was significant between treatments (P<0.0001) and all treatments were significantly different from each other

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Wood Frog Bioassay

Page 10: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

10

7

65

11

8

9

4

3

2

XXXXXO

win

gs M

ills Blvd

.

MonitoringStation

Watershed scaletransport and

long term storage

TransportAvailability

StorageAmphibian Bioassay

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 11: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Discharge (cfs)

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Research Objectives

- Evaluate metal storage in retention ponds

- Assess dissolved and particulate bound metal transport out of the watershed

1

10

100

1000

0 5 10 15 20 25

Su

spen

ded

Sed

imen

t (m

g/L

)

natural Zn background(high flow)

anthropogenic Zn dominated(low flow)

Page 12: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 13: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

vary through out soil column

roadway derivedmetals

earthworm mixingand vertical transport

soil weathering

physical processes

chemical processes

Bioaccumulation

ingestion

Earthwormdriven chemcialtransformations

excretion

mortality

abiotic processes

abiotic transformations

Earthworm driventransformations

Earthworm

Soil System

digestion

trophictransfer

organic matterpH, soil moisture

mineralogy

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 14: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Earthworm driven physical weathering

Earthworm driven chemical weathering

To

tal

Zn

(p

pm

)

50

60

70

80

90M

gC

l 2 e

xtra

ctab

le Z

n (

pp

b)

Control 1 Control 2 Worms 1 Worms 2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2.0

RoadwayDust

Soil

Zn-bearingdust particles

Page 15: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

A

B

BA

BA

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

section through earthworm in-situ

Zn

Cu

m-SR-XRF Line Scan

gut

burrow wall

Page 16: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Zn-enriched particles

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

gut

burrow

epidermis

m-SR-XRF Zn Elemental Map

Page 17: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Roadway DerivedContaminants(trace metals)

Stormwater

Retention BasinSediments

Biota

Soils

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

Page 18: Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory Chemical and Biological Impacts of Roadway Derived Contaminants Entering Stormwater Retention Systems S

Urban Environmental Biogeochemsitry Laboratory

FundingMaryland Water Resource Research Center

Patuxent Wildlife Research CenterUSGS

NSF-DMR and NSF CHEMTowson University

PeopleKathy Szlavecz (JHU)

Tony Lanzirotti (BNL-NSLS)Kim Camponelli

Judith SimonWhitney CarrollAmanda Shaw

Stephanie AtueyiLiz Wright

Casey JacksonValerie Schmidt

Rob FloraJeff Klupt