unep-psi webinar series "making inclusive insurance work" - session 6: health insurance...
TRANSCRIPT
Making inclusive insurance work series
Health Part 2:
Health insurance for the emerging
consumer
Interfacing with the webinar system
Tell us what you think. Type your questions/ comments here even while the presentation is going on. These will only be visible to the staff.
Polls will also be opened during the webinar – participate by clicking on your answers
Hide/unhide the control panel
The UNEP PSI and ILO webinar series
Making inclusive insurance work - A webinar series by the International Labour Organization’s Impact Insurance Facility and UN Environment’s
Principles for Sustainable Insurance (PSI) Initiative
As part of the global agenda of insuring for sustainable development, the Impact Insurance Facility (www.impactinsurance.org) and the PSI Initiative (www.unepfi.org/psi) are organizing a seven-part webinar series with the
theme, “Making inclusive insurance work”.
Today’s session will focus on “Health insurance for the emerging consumer”
Evolution so far… and promise of PPP models
Private or community-based health insurer (CBHI)
SubstituteHMI services a population that is a) ineligible for public coverage or b) does not receive effective public coverage
Reform designs underway
No reform in place
Maturity (e.g. time, political commitment, management capacity, infrastructure, resources)
Government
Pro
vid
er o
f co
vera
ge
GOAL:Universal Health Coverage
FoundationCBHI is at the origin of health social protection; government decides to scale and exerts regulatory authority over CBHIs
PartnershipGovernment outsources specific pieces of the insurance value chain to private partners (insurer, bank, MNO and other organized groups)
SupplementHMI provides products covering additional benefits to public scheme (e.g. telemedicine, outpatient benefits, lost wages, travel, etc.)
Prim
ary
Pro
vid
er
Seco
nd
ary
Pro
vid
er
Making inclusive insurance work:
Health insurance for the emerging
consumer
Presenter:Sanjay Pande
Finsall Networks
Presenter:Walter Bacareza
PhilHealth
Facilitator:Lisa Morgan
Impact Insurance Facility
6
Presenter:Lorenzo ChanPioneer Group
Health insurance for the
emerging consumer
Product
Development
Flexibility &
Outstanding Service
to MFIs
Lorenzo O. Chan, Jr.
Pioneer group of insurance companies,
Philippines
Source: psa.gov.ph
US$158 – US$316 monthly
Mostly daily wage earners
US$5.30- US$10.50 a day
US$316 monthly – US$631
Mostly daily, weekly wage earners
with some bi-monthly salaried
US$10.50 – US$21 a day
Source: psa.gov.ph
2015
relevant
BENEFIT
DESCRIPTION
AMOUNT
Personal Accident 5,000
Daily Sickness
Hospital Benefit
(DSHB) /
Daily Accident Hospital
Benefit (DAHB)
200/day
Maximum of 15 days per year of
combined DSHB and DAHB
CARD CARE
Affordability
Simplicity
Accessibility
To Buy & To Claim
The $5 CARD Care could
be loaned
$7 MediCash applicable
for Salary Deduction
Cash assistance
P200/day or US$4/day for
CARD Care (max 15 days)
income assistance while
hospitalised
P10,000 or US$200 medical
cash assistance for MediCash
To Buy To ClaimAffordability
Affordability
Medical cash assistance,
P3,000 or US$60, 3 months
cover
$1 - $2 versions were
also created – shorter
cover period but matches
their wallet
same concept as shampoo sachets
To Buy To Claim
Relevant
Easy to graspSimplicity
To Buy To Claim
Simple triggers, forms and
requirements
PRODUCT COMPARISON – CLAIMS REQUIREMENTS
BRAND X
Hospital Admission &
Discharge
Philhealth Deduction
Hospital O.R.
Doctor’s Diagnosis- Dengue
Hemorrhagic Fever
Laboratory Results as basis
for diagnosis
Doctor’s Diagnosis- All strains
(CSMR)
Laboratory Results as basis
for diagnosis
Accessibility
CARD network, moms
Malls
TelCo redemption
Clinics
Speedy Payouts through
Banks
Pawnshops
CARD offices
To Buy To Claim
Affordability
Simplicity
Accessibility
To Buy & To Claim
Thank you
Lorenzo O. Chan, Jr.
Pioneer group of insurance companies,
Philippines
Finsall.
medical insurance. products, riders, add-ons,
conveniences, enablers that
low-income households
in India
have worked well for
Finsall.
22
an overviewIndia is still a low-density, low-penetration scenario
$262
GLOBAL NON-LIFE INSURANCE SECTOR
Insurance density
0.72%
Insurance penetration
INDIAN NON-LIFE INSURANCE SECTOR
$3
Insurance density
0.22%Medical Insurance penetration
INDIAN MEDICAL INSURANCE
Medical Insurance density
2.8%
Insurance penetration
$12
2015-16 data
Finsall.
2015-16 data
23
medical insuranceit is micro-insurance all the way
TOTAL POPULATION
1.27Bn
INSURED POPULATION
Out of 0.36 Bn, 76% lives are insured under
Mass segment(Mass : low –ticket, no-frills medical insurances ,
fully or partly subsidized by the governments)
0.36Bn
Mass segment accounts for 10% of total
Medical Insurance premium of US$ 3.7 Bn
Finsall.
24
typical product for low-income
Individuals / HouseholdsCORE
ADD-
ONs
In-patient cover
Pre & Post hospitalization
Maternity cover
Day-care procedures
Medex following accidents
low sums-insured, policy sub-limits, limited family-size, predominantly for medical-management, caters only to low-end surgical procedures
Eye treatment
Dental treatment
Neo-natal cover
Domiciliary treatment
Emergency ambulance
Travel expenses
Premium
subsidy
Finsall.
25
new initiatives to supplement the core
Outpatient
Cover
Top-up
Cover
Long-tail
Cover
Mostly in mass policies
Limited availability, otherwise
Extremely popular among low-income : IR 71% vs. 4%
Recognizes alternative branches of medicine
Acknowledges inadequacy of the underlying insurance
Addresses higher-end surgeries
Cheaper premiums as underlying sum insured acts as deductible
Requiring outpatient treatment over longer duration
e.g., Diabetes / Renal problems
products / riders / add-ons / conveniences / enablers that have worked well
Finsall.
26
new initiatives to supplement the core
Senior
Citizens
Cover
Medical
Wallet
Premium
Financing
*
Covers those who were otherwise excluded
(Annual +) period of insurance
Age > 60 and < 80. If uninterrupted, renewable up to 90 years
Health check-up
Second opinion from doctors in an insurer’s panel
Allows limited carry-forward of un-utilized sum insured
In addition to NCB
Financial enablement to buy or buy adequately
No collateral security or surety
Insurer & intermediary neutral
Low interest rate , minimal documentation
Targets economically marginalized
products / riders / add-ons / conveniences / enablers that have worked well
* Still a low-key initiative. A major initiative by Finsall in the pipeline
Finsall.
27
new initiatives to supplement the core
Extended
Family
Cover
Wellness
Linkages
HIV- AIDS
Typically, policies limit coverage to self + spouse + children + parents
About 19 relationships are covered
Affords a floater facility over larger family at lower costs
Insured member can draw from a bigger family pool
Health check-ups at intervals
Simple mobile Apps to monitor lifestyles
Measureable lifestyle-linked premium and T&Cs
Covers those who were otherwise universally excluded
Laudable, though limited, initiative by some insurers
Supplements free ART & paediatric ART by the Government
OIs and adverse effect of ART are covered
products / riders / add-ons / conveniences / enablers that have worked well
Finsall.
28
new initiatives to supplement the core
Medical
Insurance
Mutuals
village medical depots
Managed by trained Village Health Volunteers
Dispenses basic OTC medicines for routine ailments
Under supervision of Mobile Health Post
mobile health posts
Scheduled visits by qualified doctors to assigned villages
Basic investigations , medication and recommends tests
Connected to telemedicine personnel
Referrals to city OPDs for serious problems
referral OPD
A network of private clinics, specialists and investigation facilities
Cashless treatment for the members of a Mutual
products / riders / add-ons / conveniences / enablers that have worked well
MAXIMIZINGYOUR PHILHEALTH BENEFITS
THROUGH SUSTAINABLE
PARTNERSHIP
WALTER R. BACAREZA
VICE-PRESIDENT, PRO III
last line of
Hospitals operations
first line of
PCB – Primary Care Benefit – P500 MCP – Birthing Facilities – P8,000 NCP – New Born Care/New Born Screening – P1,750
TBDOTS – TB Directly Observed Treatment - P4,000
Animal Bite Treatment – P3,000
Malaria Treatment – P600 Family Planning
IUD – P2,000
Implants – P3,000 *
can work for you?
How to work on
so
War against
PRO III COMBAT
PLAN
POVERTY
All Senior Citizens are now covered
POC : Point of Care Enrollment
(Gov’t hospital only as of this time)
POS :
POINT OF SERVICE
SIN TAX:
Enrolled 15M families nationwide
All pregnant women eligible for
enrollmentMembership War is Over
2013; in mi
llions)
RegionNo. of Accredited
Collecting LGUS%
VIII 99 49.75%
XII 28 14.07%
IV-A 16 8.04%
IV-B 14 7.04%
II 12 6.03%
X 9 4.52%
VI 8 4.02%
CARAGA 4 2.01%
CAR 3 1.51%
III 2 1.01%
V 2 1.01%
XI 2 1.01%
I 0 0.00%
VII 0 0.00%
NO. OF ACCREDITED COLLECTING LGUS 2016
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CAR I II III IV - A IV - B V VI VII VIII X XI XII
No of Accredited Collecting Agents LGUS 2016
CAR I II III IV - A IV - B V VI VII VIII X XI XII
4.52%4.02
1.51% 1.01 1.01%1.01%0% 0%
49.75%
14.07%
8.04%7.04%6.03%
NO. OF ACCREDITED COLLECTING LGUS 2016
1. Partnership as a local collecting agent –Promote your Province as Collecting Partner by putting up billboards
PROVINCE-PHILHEALTH PARTNERSHIP IN PROMOTING UNIVERSAL HEALTH
COVERAGE
LGU’s WITH PCB PER PRO: CY2013 – 2016*
Note*: PRO III data is 2017, all other data remained constant
PRO W/ PCB % PRO W/ PCB % PRO W/ PCB % PRO W/ PCB %
VIII 143 100% CARAGA 70 96% VIII 143 100% VIII 143 100%
VI 133 100% VIII 136 95% III 126 97% III 126 97%CARAGA 72 99% III 124 95% CARAGA 70 96% CARAGA 70 96%
I 122 98% I 118 94% I 118 94% I 118 94%
IX 69 97% VI 124 93% VI 124 93% VI 124 93%
X 90 97% II 86 92% II 86 92% II 86 92%
II 89 96% XII 44 88% XII 44 88% XII 44 88%
IVB 102 95% CAR 66 86% CAR 66 86% CAR 66 86%
XII 47 94% VII 108 82% VII 108 82% VII 108 82%
XI 46 94% X 73 78% X 73 78% X 73 78%
V 107 94% IVA 73 78% IVA 73 78% IVA 73 78%
VII 122 92% ARMM 91 76% ARMM 91 76% ARMM 91 76%
IVA 86 91% XI 36 73% XI 36 73% XI 36 73%
III 117 90% IVB 70 65% IVB 70 65% IVB 70 65%
ARMM 98 82% V 74 65% V 74 65% V 74 65%
CAR 63 82% IX 38 54% IX 38 54% IX 38 54%
NCR 25 81% NCR 14 45% NCR 14 45% NCR 14 45%
TOTAL 1531 94% TOTAL 1345 82% TOTAL 1354 83% TOTAL 1354 83%
CY 2016*CY 2013 CY 2014 CY 2015
LGU’s WITH MCP PER PRO: CY2013 – 2016*
Note*: PRO III data is 2017, all other data remained constant
PRO W/ MCP % PRO W/ MCP % PRO W/ MCP % PRO W/ MCP %
VIII 132 92% VIII 134 94% VIII 155 108% VIII 155 108%
NCR 28 90% IX 63 89% IX 63 89% III 121 93%IX 58 82% II 68 73% II 68 73% IX 63 89%
V 85 75% VI 94 71% VI 94 71% II 68 73%
VI 88 66% V 79 69% V 79 69% VI 94 71%
X 58 62% IVA 64 68% IVA 64 68% V 79 69%
II 57 61% III 87 67% III 87 67% IVA 64 68%
XI 29 59% XI 32 65% XI 32 65% XI 32 65%
IVA 55 59% CAR 49 64% CAR 49 64% CAR 49 64%
III 76 58% XII 31 62% XII 31 62% XII 31 62%
ARMM 65 55% CARAGA 44 60% CARAGA 44 60% CARAGA 44 60%
XII 27 54% X 55 59% X 55 59% X 55 59%
CAR 38 49% IVB 57 53% IVB 57 53% IVB 57 53%
IVB 49 46% ARMM 62 52% ARMM 62 52% ARMM 62 52%
CARAGA 32 44% NCR 16 52% NCR 16 52% NCR 16 52%
I 54 43% I 56 45% I 56 45% I 56 45%
VII 50 38% VII 58 44% VII 58 44% VII 58 44%
TOTAL 981 60% TOTAL 1049 64% TOTAL 1070 66% TOTAL 1104 68%
CY 2013 CY 2014 CY 2015 CY 2016*
LGU’s WITH TB DOTS PER PRO: CY2013 - 2016
PRO
W/
TBDOTS % PRO
W/
TBDOTS
%
PRO
W/
TBDOTS
%
PRO
W/
TBDOTS
%
VI 133 100% VI 126 95% VIII 143 100% VIII 143 100%
VIII 118 83% VIII 132 92% VI 126 95% VI 126 95%
II 77 83% IX 62 87% IX 62 87% IX 62 87%
XII 41 82% II 77 83% II 77 83% II 77 83%
X 69 74% XII 41 82% XII 41 82% XII 41 82%
I 89 71% IVA 76 81% IVA 76 81% IVA 76 81%
IX 50 70% I 90 72% I 90 72% III 103 79%IVA 66 70% CAR 55 71% CAR 55 71% I 90 72%
CAR 54 70% VII 93 70% VII 93 70% CAR 55 71%VII 85 64% CARAGA 48 66% III 88 68% VII 93 70%
ARMM 75 63% V 72 63% CARAGA 48 66% CARAGA 48 66%
V 70 61% X 58 62% V 72 63% V 72 63%
XI 27 55% XI 30 61% X 58 62% X 58 62%
NCR 17 55% III 74 60% XI 30 61% XI 30 61%
CARAGA 34 47% ARMM 66 55% ARMM 66 55% ARMM 66 55%
III 49 38% NCR 16 52% NCR 16 52% NCR 16 52%
IVB 40 37% IVB 51 48% IVB 51 48% IVB 51 48%
TOTAL 1094 67% TOTAL 1167 71% TOTAL 1192 73% TOTAL 1207 74%
CY 2016*CY 2013 CY 2014 CY 2015
Note*: PRO III data is 2017, all other data remained constant
TOP PERFORMING (GOVT) MCP FACILITIES IN REGION 3
No.MUNICIPALITY /
PROVINCEFACILITY NAME
2016 BenefitPayment
1 SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGA BIRTHING STATION 3 - SAN JOSE 3,848,650.00
2 SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGASAN NICOLAS BIRTHING STATION NO. 4 3,686,300.00
3 SAN FERNANDO, PAMPANGA BIRTHING STATION NO. 1 3,093,150.00
4 TALAVERA, NUEVA ECIJA RHU I TALAVERA 1,857,850.00
5 STO. TOMAS, PAMPANGASTO. TOMAS MATERNAL AND CHILD HEALTH CLINIC/BS 1,782,900.00
6 MABALACAT, PAMPANGAMAYOR MIGUEL P. MORALES MD, MEM. BIRTHING STATION 1,364,050.00
7 TALAVERA, NUEVA ECIJA RHU III SAN PASCUAL TALAVERA 1,112,050.00
8 ANGELES, PAMPANGAJUANITA L. NEPOMUCENO BIRTHING CENTER 1,102,400.00
9 MINALIN, PAMPANGA MINALIN RHU & LYING-IN CLINIC 1,038,550.00
10 PILAR, BATAAN PILAR RURAL HEALTH UNIT 1,036,000.00
11 SAN JOSE, NUEVA ECIJA CHO PANGANAKAN NG SAN JOSE 1,011,350.00
BILLBOARDS, FLYERS, ETC.
MCAP
BILLBOARDS, FLYERS, ETC.
2013; in mi
llions)
Accredited Health Care Institutions2014 2015 2016
ABCBENEFIT
PAYMENT/ABCBENEFIT
PAYMENT/ABCBENEFIT
PAYMENT/ABC
DR. EMIGDIO C. CRUZ SR. MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 25 1,056,439.52 1,807,696.00 2,340,498.40
RICARDO P. RODRIGUEZ MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 25 1,014,213.52 2,421,796.32 2,324,723.20
ESCOLASTICA ROMERO DISTRICT HOSPITAL 50 962,122.92 1,703,529.32 2,033,059.36
MABALACAT DISTRICT HOSPITAL 25 982,806.96 1,693,311.20 2,004,157.68
DOMINGO B. FLORES DISTRICT HOSPITAL 25 592,401.28 1,515,876.32 1,910,275.36
DR. ANDRES J. LUCIANO DISTRICT HOSPITAL 25 1,246,846.88 2,191,913.04 1,895,632.72
DIOSDADO P. MACAPAGAL MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 75 720,491.15 1,493,164.13 1,852,593.52
ROMANA PANGAN DISTRICT HOSPITAL 50 775,755.88 1,761,752.36 1,852,134.12
JOSE SONGCO LAPID DISTRICT HOSPITAL 25 688,737.68 1,622,530.48 1,769,494.72
SAN LUIS DISTRICT HOSPITAL 25 877,166.40 1,584,390.80 1,411,726.80 RICARDO P. RODRIGUEZ MEMORIAL HOSPITAL (ANNEX SPECIALTY HOSPITAL) 25 407,112.48 868,350.16 1,015,157.12
BENEFIT PAYMENT (DISTRICT HOSPITALS IN PAMPANGA/ ABC)
2013; in mi
llions)
District Hospitals POC ENROLMENT UTILIZATION
PAID 2016 2016
BULACAN MEDICAL CENTER 14,032,800.00 79,481,024.00
BALIUAG DISTRICT HOSPITAL 6,033,600.00 27,721,860.00
OSPITAL NG LUNGSOD NG SAN JOSE DEL MONTE 3,888,000.00 11,610,170.00
EMILIO G. PEREZ MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 3,316,800.00 12,730,280.00
CALUMPIT DISTRICT HOSPITAL 3,300,000.00 7,965,650.00
ROGACIANO M. MERCADO MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 2,966,400.00 14,450,544.00
SAN MIGUEL DISTRICT HOSPITAL 2,844,000.00 10,481,090.00
GREGORIO DEL PILAR DISTRICT HOSPITAL 1,569,600.00 5,993,430.00
NORZAGARAY MUNICIPAL HOSPITAL 1,176,000.00 3,334,450.00
OSPITAL NG GUIGUINTO 508,800.00 2,416,620.00
BUSTOS COMMUNITY HOSPITAL 2,400.00 10,500.00
Total39,638,400.00 176,195,618.00
444.51 %
POC ENROLMENT 2016/ UTILIZATION 2016 BULACAN
TAT of Good Claims
16
6
109
3
13
18
8
20
45
2
7
11
19
17
12
1415
0
5
10
15
20
25
TAT of Good Claims Ranking per PRO*2016
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
TAT Claims for February 1-28, 2017 per PRO
ARMM
CAR
CARAGA
I
II
III B
IIIA
IVA
IVB
IX
NCR NORTH
NCR SOUTH
V
VI
VII
VIII
X
XI
• Accredit More :
ACP : Accredit Collecting Partner 1M/year
MCP : Maternity Care Package
TBDOTS
ABTC :Animal Bite Treatment Center
OMP: Outpatient Malaria Package
FAMILY PLANNING : IUD/ Implants
PNEUMONIA : Elderly
• PROMOTEOplan Billboard
• SERVEOplan Ipad
• CLAIM1M / Bed
2013; in mi
llions)
End of Presentation
Making inclusive insurance work:
Health insurance for the emerging
consumer
Presenter:Sanjay Pande
Finsall Networks
Presenter:Walter Bacareza
PhilHealth
Facilitator:Lisa Morgan
Impact Insurance Facility
56
Presenter:Lorenzo ChanPioneer Group
Q&A
Our next webinar
Making inclusive insurance work - A webinar series by the International Labour Organization’s Impact Insurance Facility and UN Environment’s
Principles for Sustainable Insurance (PSI) Initiative
The next webinar in the series on “Making inclusive insurance work” will focus on:
Insurance regulation – date to be announced soon!