turning data into knowledge · probability of failure score x x x score based on asset age, use,...

44
TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE PNWS-AWWA 2017 Annual Conference Presented to : The Water Information Technology Group Date: May 5 th , 2017 2:45 – 3:45 session Presented by: Barry Buchanan, P.E. Buchanan & Associates 1

Upload: others

Post on 03-Sep-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE PNWS-AWWA 2017 Annual Conference Presented to : The Water Information Technology Group Date: May 5th, 2017 2:45 – 3:45 session Presented by: Barry Buchanan, P.E. Buchanan & Associates

1

Page 2: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

AGENDA The End Game Risk Based Prioritization Output

2

Page 3: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Turning Data into Knowledge

3

WISDOM

Knowledge + Engagement

KNOWLEDGE

Information + Judgement

INFORMATION

Data +

Purpose

DATA

Operational History +

Needs

OPERATIONS

PLANNING

STRATEGIC THINKING

Page 4: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

AIM

4

MAXIMIZE: Asset Utilization; and Asset Availability OPTIMIZE: Asset New, Upgrade, Replacement, Replenishment Decision Making. MINIMIZE: Asset Downtime; Asset Whole of Life Cost; and Accidents.

All at a TOLERABLE RISK

Page 5: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Definitions

5

OPTIMIZED INFRASTRUCTURE

WORK

Page 6: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Definitions

6

INFRASTRUCTURE WORK

Underpinned by Social, Environmental, and Fiscal Result Oriented Governance & Support Systems

Planning

Project Management

Financial Stewardship

(4 yr Work Plan & Budget)

Operational Management

Monitor, Account, & Report Reliability

Centered Maintenance

Optimized Programmatic Operation

LEVELS of SERVICE

Commission IQ, OQ, OT, PT

Funding Identification

Acquire, Renew, Replenish Assets (or not)

Optimized Decision Making

Review Performance and

Improve

ASSET KNOWLEDGE

Disposal

Plan & Design

Acquisition Construct

Funding Allocation

(C/OIP)

Funding Confirmation

(Budget)

Page 7: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

7

Most Likely Driver … Failure Mode

Capacity Compliance Efficiency Condition

Demand Capability

Operability Timeliness, Quality, Effectiveness O&M Structural Degradation

Mortality, Physical Failure

Descriptors

Strategic Asset Management Plan 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, … years

Asset Management Service Plans: – O&M Plan 1 through 5 years Risk Based, Reliability Centered Maintenance: -

Preventative, Condition Assessed, Monitored, Predictive Maintenance Backlog (Poorest

Condition, Highest Risk)

Reactive Maintenance (Failed Asset)

Just in Time: Capital Work Just in Time: Project Based Planned Maintenance Routine Planned

Maintenance

Activity Acquire New

Upgrade Replacement Refurbishment

Replenishment Acquire,

Renewal, or Replenish

Repair

Renewal

Urgency 5+ years 1-5 years 3-12 months 4-12 weeks Daily, Weekly, Monthly Overdue Immediate

Work Type Capital PROJECTS Maintenance PROJECTS Operation’s PROGRAMS Emergency PROJECTS

MAINTAINING a STATE of GOOD REPAIR

OPTIMIZE minimize

Page 8: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

8

Optimized Operations Asset Operations

Formalized Policies, Processes, Practices, & Procedures (P4s) … SOPs, O&M manuals, plans/specs

Training & Innovation Personnel Information Management System (PIMS)

Instrumentation & Automation Site Control and Data Acquisition system (SCADA)

Data consistency/standardization Financial Information Management System (FIMS) Laboratory Information Management System

(LIMS)

monitor control report

OPERATIONS PLANNING STRATEGIC THINKING

Page 9: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

9

Optimized Maintenance

Asset Maintenance Centralize Maintenance Planning & Management Formalize standard maintenance P4s Provide the tools for appropriate record keeping for all

maintenance groups Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) Geographic Information System (GIS)

Page 10: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

10

Optimized CAPEX Implementation

Asset Creation/Acquisition Formalized PMO P4s Standardized commissioning process

Pre-commissioning Physical Commissioning

Installation Qualifications Operations Qualifications Operations Transfer Performance Testing

Post Commissioning Warranty Period Project Closeout

administration construction commissioning

• Asset Register Development

• Asset On-Boarding

Finalized: • Asset Register • O&Ms • SOPs

Intradepartmental quality communication

Page 11: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

11

Optimized Decision Making

RISK Optimized Operational

Needs (Program)

RISK Prioritized Maintenance Needs (Projects)

RISK Prioritized Capital

Needs (Projects)

Page 12: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Aim to deliver an optimized Expenditure profile for all work activities

12

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

Deferred Renewal

Works Program

$

Opt

imis

ed P

rogr

am

Renewal

Maintenance

Operating (including inspections)

Financial Plan Limit

Page 13: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Where is the data? CENTRALIZED SYSTEMS or

13

FINANCIAL INFORMATION

SYSTEM

APP

DATABASE

LABORATORY INFORMATION

SYSTEMS

APP

DATABASE

APP

DATABASE

REPORTING SYSTEM

APP

DATABASE

AMI NETWORKS

AUTOMATIC, HANDHELD, TOUCH, or

DIRECT

APP

DATABASE

CMMS

APP

DATABASE

GIS

MOBILE GIS INSPECTION

DATA COLLECTION

MOBILE GPS NETWORK MAPPING DATA COLLECTION

APP

DATABASE

CUSTOMER INFORMATION

SYSTEM

APP

Database

DOCUMENT MANAGEMENT

SYSTEM

APP

DATABASE

APP

DATABASE

HUMAN RESOURCES

INTERFACE REPORT

DATA WAREHOUSE

• DATA STANDARDS • DATA FLOW • DATA PROCESSES • DATA INDEXING • DATA PLANNING

APP

DATABASE

ASSET MANAGEMENT

SYSTEMS

SCADA

APP

DATABASE

SECURITY

METER READING

Page 14: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Disparate Data Bases Example

14

MARIS

Manages and tracks what is happening on live railroads and integrates with Maximo

Experience and Expert Judgement

AREG MaximoTrack maintenance

Costs for departments using MaximoRSS to subcomponent level

“Maintenance Asset”Linear Assets, Structures

Tracking maintenance activities via work orders (labor and parts)

NOT in MaximoUseful Life

Remaining LifeRenewal Cost

Maintenance cost reporting

Track Dept Not Using Maximo

Using XLSAREG

Turnouts

TrackSignals

TrackSignals

Work Planning XLS

Work Planning XLS

Peoplesoft Finance

“Capital Asset” > $5,000Track costs as per chart of accounts

AREGAsset Register

Includes Fixed Assets not in MaximoMaintenance costs as per chart of accounts /

budget Capital Costs added to asset register

There is now a link between Maximo

and peoplesoftStarting to do reconciliation

reportOBIEE reporting

tool

Spare Parts Sitting in Various Location

(expensed in finance system)

Datastream All moved to Maximo except

Structuresinspections

Asset Register Structures Buildings

ComsElevatorsEscalators

Train ControlFare Collection

AREG Structures

BridgesTunnels

XLS

AREG Buildings

XLSBeing Uploaded to

Maximo

AREG Grounds

XLSBeing Uploaded to

Maximo

AREG Wayside Signals

Track PlansCAD

AREG - CADDistribution

Piping

AREG - CADPower Distribution

Cables and Conduits

AREG - CADFire Protection Piping sprinkler

heads etc

AREG - CADDomestic Water

Piping

AREG - CADSewer Piping

AREG - CADLinear Assets

etc

Local knowledge not recordedEg test equipment

Police dept inventory

New Buildings

CAD / GIS / BIM

Proposal Stage

Knowledge Management Strategy Question

What do we do about existing buildings at what

level of detail

IT assets register XLS

Real Estate Asset Register

XLS

CNI list List of projects

No validation between hours in peoplesoft (paid) and hours in Maximo (allocated to

assets)

Document Management

Systemfusion

GISARC - ESRI

Policies and Procedures Register

MP s via intranet

CMSRollong stock

workflow

Capital Renewal Program

CNI funded and unfunded projectsXLS spreadsheetsLocal knowledge

RIMEX

Customer Service

Requests18th floor log

Database

Will be maximopsr

Plasser trackinspection

Risk Management

SystemMaximo failure coding

Risk Register

Rimex has risk

InspectionsMaximo –

maintenance related

Capital Upgrade/Expansion

ProgramCIP

Word/xlsXls srtp financial model

Xls inspectionsEg track

Paper based inspection

system

Document Management

SystemPIM

No single dms

FTA grants managed by spreadsheet and

peoplesoft

Annual certificationXLS, DOCS,

Local knowledge

Warranty maintenance not yet done

Term LITECapital

Reinvestment Need

Age Based Model

City of Salem - Asset Management Systems8/7/2009

Product Department Contact Primary Purpose WebsiteAlloy IT Craig Cole PC asset tracking, order tracking, help deks http://www.alloy-software.com/Hansen PW Ron Williams Water tracking and billing http://www.hansen.com/Amanda CD and others Kelly Marshall (?) Permitting http://www.csdcsystems.com/silverstripe/index.phpFleet Faster Fleet Jim Young Tracking of fleet assets and billing http://www.ccgsystems.com/MaintStar Facilities Ty Godfrey Work Order tracking http://www.mainstar.com/Yardi UD Dianne Majors Commercial property leases http://www.yardi.com/USHome/UsHome.aspMCM WVCC - Radio Shops Darren Rice Tracking and programing City radios http://www.mcmtechnology.com/FullCourts Courts Case management System http://www.justicesystems.com/LaserFiche City-wide Paul Bagdriwicz Document management system http://www.laserfiche.com/Downtown Core Inventory UD Todd Klocke Downtown business inventory http://gisapps/CoreInventory/Default.aspx Personal DBs All Most individuals Hold day to day work informationSpread Sheet All Most individuals Hold day to day work informationESRI GIS PW MappingWater Models PW Keith Garlinghouse Analysis

BART

City of Silverton • Spread Sheets • FIMS • LIMS • ESRI-GIS • others

Page 15: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Common Fields

High

(Bus

ines

s Cr

itica

l - o

ps n

eeds

)

Med

ium

(dec

isio

n m

akin

g)

Low

(Oth

er a

naly

sis)

GIS

CMM

S

CIS

FIS

Oth

er

Prim

ary

Seco

ndar

y

Terti

ary

Attributes Field DescriptionAsset ID x x x x x x x Unique asset identification numberAssetName x x x Name of the asset used by staffs/systemsAsset Description x x x Textural entry to ensure clarityAsset Location x x x Site where asset is storedOwner x x x Owner of the assetStatus x x x Status of the asset i.e. Active or abn, etcAccepted Date x x x Date asset acceptedDate of Installation x x x x x x Asset installation dateWarranty Date x x x Date warranty period beginsWarranty Period x x x Duration of warrantyRehab Date x x x Date of rehabilitationRehab Type x x x Type of rehabilitationDrawing Number x x x Drawing number as shown on the as-built drawingMaintainedBy x x x Maintenance group/department/source (for example, WUD/City/Private)Expected Life x x x Expected life of an asset based on manufacturer or by industry standardLifecycle Status x x x Current statusRemaining Useful Life x x x What is the remaining life of the assetLifecycle Cost x x x Lifecycle cost of an assetOriginal Value x x x Original cost including outfittingReplacement Value x x x Replacement value based on today’s estimateOriginal Funding Source x x x Original funding source for this assetMaintenance Funding Source x x x Examples include gas tax, general, Parks Department, Department of Utility Services (DUS)

Work Order History* x xThis includes a work order number, the date it was created, the person / group it was assigned to, the time the staff arrived on site, equipment cost, labor cost, reinstatement cost, completion time and the work order close date.

Failure Mode x x x Select failure modes from the selection list that includes condition, level of service, financial and mortality.Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF)Consequence Of Failure Score x x x Score based on proximity analysis and industry standard analysis (COF)Redundancy x x x Redundancy is the availablility of a replacement for an asset’s service deliveryRisk Score x x x Risk Score = POF x COFReliability x x x Information, which contributes to better maintenance performance eg. Information necessary for RCM (failure modes, effects and criticality analysisCapacity x x x Planning information defining service limitCondition x x x Condition of the assetFinancial Efficiency x x x Ratings that can be used to assess the financial efficiency failure modeFunctionality x x x Asset functionality / level of service is a measure of the asset to meet all of the required levels of service intended for the assetGPS Coordinates x x xGeneral Comments x x x Information which will help individualize this asset from similar assetsReference Documents x x x x Available documentation pertaining to asset

Future Data LocationPriorityPurpose of

Data

Asset Register Data Model

15

Dat

a A

ttrib

ute

Nam

es

Dat

a Co

llect

ion

Prio

rity

(Hig

h, M

ediu

m, L

ow)

App

licab

le A

pplic

atio

n D

ata

Base

(s)

(GIS

, FIS

, LIS

, CM

MS,

PIS

, AM

S, A

MI,

DCS

, SCA

DA

, …)

AM

App

licat

ion

Leve

l (Pr

imar

y, S

econ

dary

, Ter

tiary

)

Attribute Description

ASSET

1o

Asset Categories

Hierarchical structure

Location/plan spatial

Primary physical attributes

2o

Detailed Attribute data

Condition

Performance

Maintenance

Operations

Fault/Failure

Residual life

Work/Resources

3o

Issue Risk

Residual Risk

Cost history

Intervention options

Management strategies

Optimized renewal data

Life cycle data

Page 16: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Key ODM Data

LEVEL of SERVICE Rules Regulations Directives Codes Agreements Demand

ASSET REGISTER Basic Asset Data Installed Date Growth Rate Replacement Cost Work History - Faults & Failures

Capacity Condition Compliance Efficiency

Remaining life Failure Curves

Cost History

RISK REGISTER (Issue Risk) Probability of Failure Consequence of failure

Social Economic Environmental O&M

Risk modifiers: Redundancy Environment

Risk Tolerances

MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES Intervention Strategies Maintenance Strategies

SOLUTION IDENTIFICATION Unit Cost (OpEx & CapEx) Interest/discount Rates Residual Risk Study Period

16

Page 17: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Data Health Check

17

Centralized

Standardized Dataflow Data processing Data indexing Data planning Taxonomy

Nomenclature

Classification

Accessible Accurate Repeatable Stable

Transparent

Answerable

Evidence Based

Page 18: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

18

Data Issues: • Incomplete data • Faceted Data mixed with Hierarchical Data • Incorrect data • Placeholder data, erroneous data • Wrong type of data; mixed data types • Disparate data bases

City Area Basin

Iden

tific

atio

n

Iden

tific

atio

n

Num

ber

Num

ber

Star

t M

H

Stre

et A

ddre

ss

Rim

Ele

v.

Out

let I

E.

End

MH

Stre

et A

ddre

ss

Rim

Ele

v.

Inle

t IE

Mat

eria

l

Date

Inst

alle

d

Diam

eter

Leng

th

Land

Use

Typ

e

Tota

l Num

ber o

f Lot

s

Num

ber L

ots

Ope

ratio

nal

Expe

cted

Life

Age

Base

Rem

aini

ng L

ife

Name Name # # # Name ft ft # Name ft ft Yr in ft # # Yrs Yrs Yrs

DO NOT REMOVE OR MOVE THIS LINE15" 141 2 9-24 S WATER ST 260.13 249.33 9-23 S WATER ST 256.91 243.78 CONC 1982 15 394.0 COMMERCIAL 8 8 65 33 32

15" 141 1 9-25 S WATER ST 262.76 254.33 9-24 S WATER ST 260.13 249.33 CONC 1982 15 391.7 COMMERCIAL 8 7 65 33 32

30" 494 1 9-09 N WATER ST 226.36 215.81 9-08 N WATER ST 224.27 215.68 CONC 1982 30 202.6 SINGLE FAMILY 1 1 65 33 32

15" 134 2 9-311 S WATER ST 267.98 260.53 9-26 S WATER ST 265.69 257.99 CONC 1982 15 277.5 SINGLE FAMILY 5 5 65 33 32

15" 134 1 9-27 S WATER ST 268.28 263.29 9-311 S WATER ST 267.98 263.2 CONC 1982 15 46.7 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 65 33 32

15" 134 3 9-26 S WATER ST 265.69 257.99 9-25 S WATER ST 262.76 254.49 CONC 1982 15 386.0 SINGLE FAMILY 8 8 65 33 32

30" 496 3 9-05 ASTE TREATMENT PLA 223.84 214.19 9-04 ASTE TREATMENT PLA 220.93 213.98 DI 1982 30 301.3 SINGLE FAMILY 1 1 85 33 52

15" 130 1 9-28 S WATER ST 271.54 264.48 9-27 S WATER ST 268.28 263.29 CONC 1982 15 397.1 SINGLE FAMILY 9 9 65 33 32

30" 496 1 9-07 N WATER ST 222.92 215.45 9-06 PINE ST 226.46 214.76 DI 1982 30 865.9 SINGLE FAMILY 2 2 85 33 52

30" 494 2 9-08 N WATER ST 224.27 215.68 9-07 N WATER ST 222.92 215.45 CONC 1982 30 236.1 SINGLE FAMILY 4 4 65 33 32

30" 496 4 9-04 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 220.93 213.98 WWTP WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 213.9 DI 1984 30 100.0 GOVERNMENT 0 0 85 31 54

15" 102 1 9-32 S WATER ST 282.29 273.75 9-31 S WATER ST 280.17 272.43 CONC 1982 15 256.9 SINGLE FAMILY 4 4 65 33 32

30" 496 2 9-06 PINE ST 226.46 214.71 9-05 PINE ST 223.84 214.19 DI 1982 30 456.0 SINGLE FAMILY 2 2 85 33 52

15" 289 2 9-46 UNKNOWN 231.18 224.28 9-45 UNKNOWN 230.30 224.11 UNKNOWN 1940 15 367.2 COMMERCIAL 0 0 76 75 1

18" 386 1 9-34 PINE ST 229.17 218.35 9-11 N JAMES AVE 231.23 217.74 CONC 1982 18 327.0 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 65 33 32

18" 173 1 9-22 S WATER ST 254.46 242.01 9-21 S WATER ST 252.20 240.28 CONC 1982 18 250.3 COMMERCIAL 4 4 65 33 32

15" 289 1 9-46-A LONE OAKS LP 223.9 9-46 LONE OAKS LP 223.09 CONC 1940 15 323.0 COMMERCIAL 0 0 65 75 0

15" 289 3 9-45 N 1ST ST 230.30 224.11 9-44 N 1ST ST 230.36 220.15 UNKNOWN 1940 15 367.2 COMMERCIAL 4 4 76 75 1

18" 385 1 9-38 N JAMES AVE 229.22 218.41 9-34 PINE ST 229.17 218.35 CONC 1982 18 33.0 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 65 33 32

15" 102 2 9-31 S WATER ST 280.17 272.43 9-30 S WATER ST 278.17 271.04 CONC 1982 15 261.0 SINGLE FAMILY 8 8 65 33 32

18" 384 1 4-36 PINE ST 227.58 216.28 4-35 SHERMAN ST 0 216 UNKNOWN 1940 18 181.5 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 76 75 1

18" 171 1 9-23 S WATER ST 256.91 243.55 9-22 S WATER ST 254.46 242.01 CONC 1982 18 224.2 COMMERCIAL 2 2 65 33 32

15" 100 1 9-33 S WATER ST 282.81 274.04 9-32 S WATER ST 282.29 273.65 CONC 1982 15 61.8 SINGLE FAMILY 1 1 65 33 32

15" 110 1 9-30 S WATER ST 278.17 271.01 9-29 S WATER ST 273.96 266.9 CONC 1982 15 468 SINGLE FAMILY 13 13 65 33 32

15" 285 2 9-396 LONE OAKS LP 0 228.93 9-47 LONE OAKS LP 234.12 228.79 PVC 1993 15 100.0 SINGLE FAMILY 1 1 75 22 53

15" 112 1 9-29 S WATER ST 273.96 266.9 9-28 S WATER ST 271.54 264.48 CONC 1982 15 246.1 SINGLE FAMILY 4 4 65 33 32

18" 325 1 9-41 SCHLADOR ST 227.80 218.79 9-40 SCHLADOR ST 225.34 217.95 UNKNOWN 1940 18 570.0 SINGLE FAMILY 5 0 76 75 1

18" 383 1 4-37 PINE ST 227.56 217.35 4-36 PINE ST 227.58 217.08 UNKNOWN 1940 18 178.0 SINGLE FAMILY 1 1 76 75 1

18" 384 2 4-35 SHERMAN ST 0 216 4-35A SHERMAN ST 0 215.79 UNKNOWN 1940 18 144.5 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 76 75 1

15" 280 1 9-401 MILL ST 252.04 230.1 9-400 TODD CT 244.63 229.45 UNKNOWN 1983 15 369.5 MULTIPLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 4 4 76 32 44

30" 387 1 9-11 N WATER ST 231.23 216.65 9-10 N WATER ST 228.28 216.04 CONC 1982 30 485.2 SINGLE FAMILY 7 7 65 33 32

18" 382 2 4-38 PINE ST 218.03 4-37 PINE ST 227.56 217.35 UNKNOWN 1940 18 457.7 SINGLE FAMILY 5 5 76 75 1

18" 375 6 9-40 N JAMES ST 225.34 218.71 9-39 N JAMES AVE 226.02 218.56 UNKNOWN 1940 18 104.0 SINGLE FAMILY 1 1 76 75 1

30" 389 1 9-10 N WATER ST 228.28 216.04 9-09 N WATER ST 226.36 215.81 CONC 1982 30 219.0 SINGLE FAMILY 4 4 65 33 32

18" 377 1 9-39 N JAMES ST 226.02 218.56 9-38 N JAMES AVE 229.22 218.05 UNKNOWN 1940 18 336.0 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 76 75 1

18" 384 3 4-35A SHERMAN ST 0 216.78 4-39 SHERMAN ST 217.18 UNKNOWN 1940 18 0.0 SINGLE FAMILY 0 0 76 75 1

Segement MH IN Segement MH OUT Segement Description Connections/Laterals Life

Water Wastewater Stormwater

Capacity

Condition

Compliance

Efficency

DATA Quality

Good, 12%

Fair, 32%

Poor, 56%

Good, 6%

Fair, 22%

Poor, 72%

Good, 12%

Fair, 31%

Poor, 57%

Good, 6%

Fair, 22%

Poor, 72%

Good, 11%

Fair, 30%Poor,

59%

Good, 6% Fair,

21%

Poor, 74%

Good, 6%

Fair, 22%

Poor, 72%

Good, 6%

Fair, 22%

Poor, 72%

Good, 6% Fair,

21%

Poor, 74%

Good, 6%Fair, 5%

Poor, 89%

Good, 11%

Fair, 86%

Poor, 2%

Good, 11%

Fair, 86%

Poor, 2%

System Built in 1945, 13% of value said to be install in

1900 or before

Pie represent Good, Fair, Poor data for various

asset classes and failure modes

A red squares indicate a data issue. This is 30

line of 1200

Arrows indicate data confidence

Page 19: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

RISK =

Likelihood x Consequence

a risk approach

Page 20: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

20

LEVELS of SERVICE

Technical

Social

Safety Quality Vision, Mission, Goals, Objectives Rules, Regulations, Standards

Maintenance (Availability)

State Faults Failure

Planning (Forecasting)

Utilization Demand

Operations (Optimization)

Reliability Faults

ASSET FAILURE MODES

MEASURED by: • Subject Matter Experts • or

• Accident Count, KPI • Public Survey, KPI • Internal Survey, KPI • Infringements, KPI

NB: actuals, triggers and limits

• Peak Use vs Ability • Peak Use Trend

• Assessment Measure • Faults Count • Repairable Y/N

• Consistency, KPI • Ops Cost, KPI Efficiency/Value

Condition/Mortality

Compliance/Customer Satisfaction

Capacity/Use

THE ISSUES

Qu 4,5,6

Page 21: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

failure modes

The Prime Modes of Failure Capacity – Capability vs Demand Compliance – Regulatory – Customer Satisfaction Condition – Physical Failure Efficiency – O&M Cost

Causes of Physical Failure • Age • Physical deterioration • Weather

o Drought o Rain/Flood o Lightening Strike o Snow o Wind

• Fuel o Power outage o Petroleum shortage o Diesel shortage o Gas shortage

• Solar interference • Earth Movement

o Earthquake o Settlement o Liquefaction o Landslide

• Fire • Damage

o Malicious o Accidental

• Others

NOTE: Traditional Master Plan Focused on blue, based on likelihood Traditional Facility Plan Focused on gold, based on likelihood Asset Management Plan Focuses on ALL, based on RISK

Page 22: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

remaining life

Failure Mode C.C.C.E.

Modifier

Remaining Life

Likelihood of Failure

Expected life

Date installed

Age + - =

default

Qu 7, 8

Page 23: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

LIK

ELIH

OO

D

LIKELIHOOD

Moderate Likelihood

High Likelihood

Low Likelihood

Imminent Highly probable Probable Possible Improbable Highly improbable

of FAILURE

ƒ(Prime Failure Modes)

Note: Likelihood ≠ Risk likelihood

Page 24: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

ASSET FAILURE MODES

MEASURED by: • Subject Matter Experts • or

• Accident Count, KPI • Public Survey, KPI • Internal Survey, KPI • Infringements, KPI

NB: actuals, triggers and limits

• Peak Use vs Ability • Peak Use Trend

• Assessment Measure • Faults Count • Repairable Y/N

• Consistency, KPI • Ops Cost, KPI Efficiency/Value

Condition/Mortality

Compliance/Customer Satisfaction

Capacity/Use

THE ISSUES

RISK OF

FAILURE

Work PRIORITY

x MODIFIERS

CONSEQUENCE

OF FAILURE (Sum of Impacts)

x

Highest

LIKELIHOOD

OF FAILURE

Page 25: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

what is consequence?

Consequence - synonymous with: • Cost … • Impact/Value … • Criticality … • Importance … • Significance … of the failure

Page 26: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

options

Qu 10

ISSUES

IMPACT $ or #

Political Technology Economic Social Environmental Legal

ISSUES

IMPACT $ or #

H&S Customer Social Environmental Regulatory Economic

ISSUES

IMPACT $ or #

Culture Economic Operations Customer

Triple Bottom Line Plus O&M

Balance Score Card

CHEERS

PESTLE

Economic Social Environmental Operations

ISSUES

IMPACT $ or #

Social

ISSUES

IMPACT $ or #

Reputation Cultural Environmental Economic

SCREE CONSEQUENCE CATEGORY OPTIONS

(Choose one or make up your own)

Page 27: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

triple bottom line + o&m

Social Impacts: customer (satisfaction, fairness, equality), political significance, public response, image change, cultural heritage, community health and safety, security/accidents, accessibility, human diversity Economic Impact: financial cost (capital, operating, maintenance/intervention, repair, renew, refurbish, replace, disposal, carbon footprint, financing), legal cost, income loss, regulatory penalties, insurance change Environmental Impact: air, water, soil, noise, greenhouse gasses, landscape, biodiversity, geology, flora, fauna, architectural heritage, archaeological heritage O&M Impact: quality, quantity, workplace health and safety, security, accidents, permitting

Consequence of Failure

• Social Impact/Breadth $:00 or # • Economic Impact/Breadth $:00 or # • Environmental Impact/Breadth $:00 or # • O&M Impact/Breadth $:00 or # TOTAL $:00 or #

Page 28: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

ƒ(Prime Failure Modes)

0 No Effect Minor Appreciable Major Severe Catastrophic

CONSEQUENCE

ƒ(Impact cost)

Note: Impact Cost ≠ Replacement Cost

LIK

ELIH

OO

D

Highly probable Probable Possible Improbable Highly improbable

Tolerable

Occurrence

Tolerable

Impact

Tolerance Levels

Low RISK

High RISK

basic risk chart

Page 29: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

ƒ(Prime Failure Modes)

0 No Effect Minor Appreciable Major Severe Catastrophic

CONSEQUENCE

ƒ(Impact cost)

Note: Impact Cost ≠ Replacement Cost

LIK

ELIH

OO

D

Highly probable Probable Possible Improbable Highly improbable

of FAILURE

Tolerable

Occurrence

Tolerable

Impact

Low RISK

High RISK

Lines of Equi- Potential Risk

Tolerable

Risk Limit - A

Tolerable

Risk Limit - B

Tolerable

Risk Limit - C

equi-potential risk

of FAILURE

Page 30: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

LIK

ELIH

OO

D

0 No Effect Minor Appreciable Major Severe Catastrophic

Highly probable Probable Possible Improbable Highly improbable

CONSEQUENCE of FAILURE

Lines of Equal Potential Risk

FIX UPON FAILURE

SAMPLE MONITORING Tolerable Risk Limit - A

Tolerable Risk Limit - B

Tolerable Risk Limit -C

ƒ(Prime Failure Modes)

Ƒ(Cost, impact.)

High Risk Urgent Work

Low Risk Do Nothing

Moderate Risk

CONDITION MONITOR

Impact Tolerance - A Impact Tolerance - B

MITIGATE the RISK

Probability Tolerance

PERFORMANCE MONITOR

Impact Tolerance - C

IMMEDIATE ACTION

Moderate Risk

risk matrix

Qu 11

Page 31: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Years Past Current Year Years Future

Mean Time to Failure

Failure Distribution

Installed Infrastructure

Resultant Nessie Curve

Accumulated Infrastructure Replacement Backlog

Future Infrastructure Replacement Requirement

Rep

lace

men

t Cos

t $:0

0

infrastructure replacement profile

Page 32: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Risk Ranked Work Priority

(score)

Money Availability

(dollars) + People

Availability (people) +

Capital/Operating Improvement Plan & Annual Budget (Risk Based Prioritization) =

implementation reality

Asset and Knowledge

Management Plans

Financial Management Plans

Workforce Management Plans

Page 33: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Likelihood of Failure

Remaining Life

Capacity

Compliance

Condition

Efficiency

Consequence of Failure

Impacts of Failure

Social

Environment

Economic

O&M Core AM DATA

Measured/ Surveyed AM DATA

CMMS DATA

NB: We did not apply any modifiers to our calculations

Page 34: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Core AM DATA

Measured/ Surveyed AM DATA

CMMS DATA

• Unique ID • Location

• Town/Area/street/etc. • Land Use

• Make/Model/Type • Material

• Installed Date • Expected Life • Replacement Cost • Demand/Growth Rates • Buffer/Peaking Factors • Special Conditions Affecting Life

• Capability • Capacity • Condition • Compliance

• Regulatory • Customer Satisfaction

• Efficiency

• Size/Dimensions • Installation Details

• Depth • Ground type/condition

• Scheduled Maintenance • Defects/Failures History

• Impacts • Social • Economic • Environmental • Operational

data Defined

Mission, Vision, Goals, & Objectives and Agreed Levels of Service

Page 35: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

data – pipe inventory

The City has a relatively complete GIS inventory of the Wastewater Collection system This provided the pipe inventory: • Length of pipe (205,000 +/- 31,000 ft) • Size: diameter (8” – 21”), segment lengths (5’ – 175’) • Type: (AC, PVC, Clay, Concrete, DI) • Installed Dates (1920’s to present) • Location, Area, Basin • MH #, Rim elevation, In/Out invert elevations • Connections # (possible and current)

But: • It was not complete, about 95%; • There were data gaps, unknowns; and • There were data errors in about 30% of the 1,100 lines

• Size, type, location, dates, connectivity … • Data was inconsistently entered type and/or form (there were no documented data standards)

Qu 12

Page 36: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

data - likelihood

Capacity

Compliance

Condition

Efficiency

DEMAND: Peak WW Flows proportioned to Residential, Commercial, and Industrial Users, then accumulated through the system. Using the City growth rate 2%, 10% buffer determined remaining life. CAPACITY: As new system flow analysis

• Default age & installed expected life

• Historic fault and failure • Delphi analysis – Staff

observation • Soil type • Wastewater strength

• SSO Historic data • Regulatory actions • Customer complaints

No data collected

For each pipe segment: • Established a lowest remaining life • Calculated the highest likelihood of failure; highest probability of failure

Page 37: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

capacity computation

Capacity

Compliance

Condition

Efficiency

To determine utilization and capacity of the wastewater collection system we followed the approach presented by Richard Ludlow and Trevor Lierman in 2015, which they used in their analysis of the Oak Lodge Sanitary District trunk sewers 1. Obtained the water use figures for the winter months 2. Determined the peaking factors: Peak day WWF at the WWTF/the average winter daily water usage, with a modifier

proportionate to the pipe size 3. Established the cumulative flows in the system by summing the flows per connection, given the PF and the water use

for the given connection 4. Determined the sewer capacity using the modified manning formula and the installed system data 5. Given a 2% growth factor and a 10% safety factor we then determined the remaining year of life, in capacity terms,

of the individual pipe segments ... In years.

Page 38: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

data - consequence

• Materials, Size, Depth • H&S • Downtime, Work load • Location • Access

• Proximity to streams • Land use type/potential

pollution • Flooding

• Soils type • Street size & surface type • Proximity to other utilities • Proximity to businesses • Traffic impedance

• Proximity to: hospitals, schools, recreation facilities

• Public Health • No. of connections

affected • Political/Public perception

For each pipe segment: • Identify the individual criteria scored • The sum of the scores is the Consequence of Failure

Social

Environment

Economic

O&M

Staff helped develop a scoring system for each criteria, the scores were either applied directly or using GIS

Page 39: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

39

PRIORITZED PIPE SEGMENT LISTPipe Diameter Pipe Length

Inlet Outlet inch diamenter feet

9-24 9-23 S WATER ST 15 394 CONC 445.58 1 98,700.00$ 9-25 9-24 S WATER ST 15 391.7 CONC 419.25 2 91,400.00$ 9-09 9-08 N WATER ST 30 202.55 CONC 413.23 3 71,700.00$ 9-311 9-26 S WATER ST 15 277.5 CONC 368.33 4 61,400.00$ 9-27 9-311 S WATER ST 15 46.7 CONC 356.25 5 7,700.00$ 9-26 9-25 S WATER ST 15 386 CONC 349.67 6 85,400.00$ 9-05 9-04 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 301.33 DI 349.01 7 101,100.00$ 9-28 9-27 S WATER ST 15 397.1 CONC 348.17 8 83,400.00$ 9-07 9-06 N WATER ST 30 865.93 DI 331.88 9 306,400.00$ 9-08 9-07 N WATER ST 30 236.09 CONC 327.14 10 79,200.00$ 9-04 WWTP WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 100 DI 310.14 11 26,900.00$ 9-32 9-31 S WATER ST 15 256.9 CONC 280.08 12 58,400.00$ 9-06 9-05 PINE ST 30 456 DI 278.04 13 169,700.00$ 9-46 9-45 UNKNOWN 15 367.2 UNKNOWN 277.78 14 77,100.00$ 9-34 9-11 PINE ST 18 327 CONC 275.94 15 89,200.00$ 9-22 9-21 S WATER ST 18 250.3 CONC 271.83 16 68,300.00$

9-46-A 9-46 LONE OAKS LP 15 323 CONC 267.12 17 60,700.00$ 9-45 9-44 N 1ST ST 15 367.2 UNKNOWN 266.97 18 83,500.00$ 9-38 9-34 N JAMES AVE 18 33 CONC 265.94 19 8,500.00$ 9-31 9-30 S WATER ST 15 261 CONC 261.42 20 57,700.00$ 4-36 4-35 PINE ST 18 181.5 UNKNOWN 259.94 21 35,600.00$ 9-23 9-22 S WATER ST 18 224.2 CONC 259.46 22 61,100.00$ 9-33 9-32 S WATER ST 15 61.8 CONC 255.67 23 14,000.00$ 9-30 9-29 S WATER ST 15 468 CONC 247.57 24 103,500.00$ 9-396 9-47 LONE OAKS LP 15 100 PVC 242.28 25 18,800.00$ 9-29 9-28 S WATER ST 15 246.1 CONC 238.22 26 54,400.00$ 9-41 9-40 SCHLADOR ST 18 570 UNKNOWN 235.69 27 137,200.00$ 4-37 4-36 PINE ST 18 178 UNKNOWN 235.69 28 45,700.00$ 4-35 4-35A SHERMAN ST 18 144.5 UNKNOWN 233.94 29 28,400.00$ 9-401 9-400 MILL ST 15 369.5 UNKNOWN 229.02 30 110,800.00$ 9-11 9-10 N WATER ST 30 485.22 CONC 225.88 31 207,400.00$ 4-38 4-37 PINE ST 18 457.7 UNKNOWN 225.07 32 89,800.00$ 9-40 9-39 N JAMES ST 18 104 UNKNOWN 222.69 33 24,000.00$ 9-10 9-09 N WATER ST 30 218.96 CONC 222.00 34 85,500.00$ 9-39 9-38 N JAMES ST 18 336 UNKNOWN 220.25 35 84,200.00$

4-35A 4-39 SHERMAN ST 18 0 UNKNOWN 212.76 36 -$ 9-47 9-46 LONE OAKS LP 15 323 CONC 209.30 37 67,900.00$

MainPS 21 W MAIN ST 8 604 PVC 209.01 38 116,000.00$ 5-538 5-121 ALDER ST 8 136 UNKNOWN 208.51 39 26,100.00$ 9-42 9-41 SCHLADOR ST 18 27.5 UNKNOWN 208.25 40 6,900.00$ 9-43 9-42 SCHLADOR ST 18 316.4 UNKNOWN 204.25 41 81,200.00$ 9-44 9-622 N 1ST ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 197.21 42 25,100.00$ 9-399 9-396 LONE OAKS LP 18 206 UNKNOWN 189.65 43 40,400.00$ 9-404 9-403 N CHURCH ST 15 347 UNKNOWN 181.33 44 101,500.00$ 5-120 5-09 SHERMAN ST 12 100 UNKNOWN 179.00 45 18,800.00$ 9-403 9-402 MILL ST 15 268.1 UNKNOWN 174.83 46 82,300.00$ 9-402 9-401 MILL ST 15 266.5 UNKNOWN 174.83 46 85,800.00$ 5-121 5-120 MAPLE ST 12 167 UNKNOWN 172.72 48 36,900.00$ 5-501 5-538 BROOK ST 12 266 UNKNOWN 171.85 49 50,000.00$ 5-503 5-502 S JAMES AVE 12 575.5 UNKNOWN 170.89 50 127,300.00$ 5-504 5-503 McCLAINE ST 12 550 UNKNOWN 167.08 51 103,400.00$ 5-597 5-507 WESTFIELD ST 8 200 UNKNOWN 161.64 52 45,200.00$ 9-405 9-404 N CHURCH ST 15 334.7 UNKNOWN 161.33 53 95,800.00$ 5-505 5-504 WESTFIELD ST 12 174.5 UNKNOWN 158.20 54 32,800.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 156.83 55 19,200.00$ 9-622 9-43 N 1ST ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 153.79 56 25,700.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 153.38 57 160,400.00$ 5-506 5-505 WESTFIELD ST 8 202.5 UNKNOWN 152.73 58 43,500.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 151.64 59 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 150.75 60 19,200.00$ 5-502 5-501 S JAMES AVE 12 676 UNKNOWN 147.43 61 112,100.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 146.26 62 31,700.00$ 2-414 2-413 SILVER CLIFF DR W 8 320 UNKNOWN 145.64 63 73,900.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 145.08 64 30,200.00$ 2-411 9-410 SILVER CLIFF DR W 8 501.48 UNKNOWN 144.64 65 115,800.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 144.53 66 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 144.19 67 30,700.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 142.45 68 19,200.00$ 5-513 5-512 W MAIN ST 8 351 UNKNOWN 142.21 69 59,500.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 141.85 70 26,700.00$ 1-285 1-28 ADAMS ST 8 100 PVC 141.79 71 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 139.93 72 28,300.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 139.00 73 29,000.00$ 9-12 9-11 N WATER ST 21 315.92 CONC 137.28 74 94,700.00$ 1-286 1-285 ADAMS ST 8 100 PVC 137.22 75 19,200.00$ 9-408 9-407 Back of 1351 ESKA WAY 15 267.2 UNKNOWN 136.34 76 76,500.00$ 2-412 2-411 SILVER CLIFF DR W 8 200 UNKNOWN 134.64 77 38,400.00$ 5-507 5-506 WESTFIELD ST 8 497.5 UNKNOWN 134.45 78 95,600.00$ 6-527 6-626 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 134.03 79 19,200.00$ 1-62 1-61 HICKS ST 8 252 UNKNOWN 133.89 80 58,200.00$ 9-18 9-17 N WATER ST 21 383.4 CONC 133.01 81 98,000.00$ 9-21 9-20 N WATER ST 21 228 CONC 132.73 82 65,500.00$ 1-61 9-60 PORTER ST 8 442 UNKNOWN 132.61 83 101,000.00$ 1-824 1-286 ADAMS ST 8 100 PVC 132.50 84 23,100.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 131.74 85 24,800.00$ 2-417 2-415 OAK ST 8 202.05 UNKNOWN 129.91 86 47,900.00$ 5-508 5-597 WESTFIELD ST 8 238 UNKNOWN 129.50 87 45,700.00$ 1-63 1-62 COWING ST 8 397 UNKNOWN 129.30 88 91,700.00$ 9-17 9-16 N WATER ST 21 230.5 CONC 128.55 89 58,900.00$ 9-19 9-18 N WATER ST 21 225.3 CONC 127.83 90 59,800.00$ 9-13 9-12 N WATER ST 21 241 CONC 127.24 91 69,300.00$ 9-14 9-13 N WATER ST 21 72.9 CONC 127.22 92 20,100.00$ 9-16 9-15 N WATER ST 21 412 CONC 125.92 93 86,000.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 125.55 94 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 125.55 94 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 124.40 96 19,200.00$ 9-410 9-409 Back of 1401 ESKA WAY 15 352.49 UNKNOWN 122.86 97 100,900.00$ 9-20 9-19 N WATER ST 21 226 CONC 122.23 98 62,500.00$ 6-528 6-560 S CENTER ST 8 77 UNKNOWN 121.59 99 14,800.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 120.66 100 22,800.00$ 6-528 6-527 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 119.90 101 22,600.00$

ORGardPS 513 OREGON GARDENS 4 100 DI 119.58 102 19,200.00$ 5-509 5-508 WESTFIELD ST 8 18 UNKNOWN 119.36 103 3,500.00$ 2-415 2-414 OAK ST 8 460.59 UNKNOWN 118.66 104 106,400.00$

0 1-252 IKE MOONEY RD 8 45 DI 116.43 105 8,600.00$ 9-15 9-14 N WATER ST 21 347.1 CONC 115.99 106 72,500.00$ 9-400 9-399 UNKNOWN 21 121 UNKNOWN 115.93 107 37,800.00$ 5-512 5-511 WESTFIELD ST 8 325 UNKNOWN 114.93 108 55,100.00$ 2-210 2-209 NORWAY AVE 8 522 UNKNOWN 112.44 109 100,300.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 110.29 110 19,200.00$

2-1392P 2-925 SILVER CLIFF DR W (PVT) 9 100 PVC3034 107.25 111 19,200.00$ 2-413 2-412 SILVER CLIFF DR W 8 300 UNKNOWN 106.88 112 57,600.00$ 9-409 9-408 Back of 1401 ESKA WAY 15 339.56 UNKNOWN 106.70 113 97,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 106.14 114 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 105.99 115 19,200.00$ 9-60 9-59 WESLEY ST 12 251 UNKNOWN 103.65 116 58,000.00$ 7-234 7-53 JERSEY ST 6 315 UNKNOWN 103.13 117 60,500.00$ 9-406 9-405 N CHURCH ST 15 264.4 UNKNOWN 102.24 118 74,100.00$ 9-58 9-25 S WATER ST 12 100 UNKNOWN 101.60 119 22,600.00$ 2-211 2-210 NORWAY AVE 8 331.7 UNKNOWN 101.00 120 63,700.00$

Hobart PS 9-858 ESKA WAY 6 800 PVC 99.46 121 153,700.00$ 6-565 6-564 ROSS AVE 8 136 UNKNOWN 99.28 122 30,700.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 98.88 123 19,200.00$ 2-867 9-861 HOBART RD 8 100 PVC3034 98.65 124 26,700.00$ 9-59 9-58 S WATER ST 12 368.7 UNKNOWN 97.20 125 85,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 96.65 126 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 95.76 127 19,200.00$ 2-208 2-401 N CHURCH ST 8 300 UNKNOWN 95.39 128 57,600.00$ 3-142 3-148 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 93.33 129 24,300.00$ 2-418 2-417 OAK ST 8 263.6 UNKNOWN 91.65 130 62,500.00$ 1-253 1-9-78 WALNUT AVE. 8 251 CONC 91.60 131 48,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 90.58 132 19,200.00$ 2-209 2-208 N CHURCH ST 8 336.3 UNKNOWN 88.12 133 64,600.00$

6-624A 6-624 W MAIN ST 12 295.5 UNKNOWN 88.09 134 55,500.00$ 1-65 1-64 MADISON ST 8 552 UNKNOWN 87.81 135 126,100.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 87.46 136 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 87.31 137 19,200.00$ 6-547 6-525 APPLE AV 8 242.2 UNKNOWN 85.98 138 41,100.00$ 8-99 8-98 B ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 85.94 139 19,200.00$ 6-624 MainPS W MAIN ST 12 44 UNKNOWN 85.42 140 8,300.00$ 7-169 7-21 E MAIN ST 8 100 CLAY 84.60 141 19,200.00$ 8-96 8-95 C ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 83.16 142 19,200.00$ 6-563 6-562 S CENTER ST 8 195 UNKNOWN 82.43 143 37,500.00$ 6-564 6-563 ROSS AVE 8 258 UNKNOWN 80.71 144 58,300.00$ 5-517 5-516 S JAMES AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 80.20 145 19,200.00$ 5-520 5-519 McCLAINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 78.68 146 21,500.00$ 1-66 1-65 MADISON ST 8 643 UNKNOWN 78.24 147 148,500.00$ 5-521 5-520 McCLAINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 78.12 148 19,200.00$ 1-822 1-823 CHEE CHEE CT 8 731 PVC 78.11 149 184,100.00$ 5-522 5-521 McCLAINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 77.70 150 19,200.00$ 7-237 7-236 E MAIN ST 6 194 UNKNOWN 77.38 151 44,300.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 77.20 152 19,200.00$

0 0 N JAMES ST 12 100 UNKNOWN 76.79 153 18,800.00$ 7-166 7-20 OAK ST 8 321 UNKNOWN 76.31 154 61,700.00$ 1-64 1-63 COWING ST 8 197 UNKNOWN 76.30 155 37,800.00$

FloridaPS 3-116 N JAMES AVE 4 100 UNKNOWN 75.83 156 19,200.00$ 530 529 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 75.47 157 19,200.00$

2-212 2-211 NORWAY AVE 8 585 PVC3034 75.40 158 112,400.00$ 2-862 9-861 ESKA WAY 8 400 PVC 74.99 159 108,100.00$ 5-523 5-522 McCLAINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 74.94 160 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 74.09 161 19,200.00$ 3-82 3-81 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 73.69 162 23,700.00$ 1-289 1-253 WALNUT WAY 8 249 CONC 73.51 163 2,200.00$ 5-518 5-517 S JAMES AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 73.45 164 19,200.00$ 7-167 7-166 OAK ST 8 313 UNKNOWN 72.97 165 67,200.00$ 5-510 5-509 WESTFIELD ST 8 452 UNKNOWN 72.74 166 86,800.00$ 8-101 8-100 OAK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 71.08 167 19,200.00$

3-1341 3-1340 N 1ST ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 70.46 168 18,800.00$ 7-170 7-169 E MAIN ST 8 100 CONC 70.17 169 900.00$

3-1333 3-1334 N JAMES ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 68.92 170 19,600.00$ 5-319 AlderPS SILVER ST 6 325 CLAY 68.55 171 62,400.00$ 3-83 3-82 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 66.91 172 23,100.00$ 5-516 5-502 S JAMES AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 66.64 173 19,200.00$ 6-568 6-567 EDGEWOOD DR 8 18.9 UNKNOWN 65.70 174 3,600.00$ 6-625 6-624A W MAIN ST 12 295.5 UNKNOWN 65.59 175 55,500.00$ 7-168 7-167 OAK ST 6 270 UNKNOWN 65.56 176 51,900.00$

0 9-11A N JAMES ST 12 100 UNKNOWN 65.40 177 18,800.00$ 9-11A 9-11 S JAMES ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 65.12 178 23,100.00$ 6-529 6-528 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 64.63 179 21,500.00$

3-1336 3-1335 N JAMES ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 64.29 180 18,800.00$ 8-98 8-274 B ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 64.14 181 19,200.00$

307P-A 3-313 N 2ND ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 63.90 182 19,200.00$ 3-1348 0 JEFFERSON ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 62.87 183 18,800.00$ 8-224 8-223 OAK ST 6 174 UNKNOWN 62.80 184 33,400.00$ 8-155 8-95 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 62.30 185 21,500.00$ 8-220 8-98 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 62.11 186 19,200.00$

5-1131 5-1130 OREGON GARDENS 8 85 PVC 61.14 187 16,300.00$ 6-566 6-565 EDGEWOOD DR 8 164 UNKNOWN 61.11 188 37,100.00$ 9-407 9-406 N CHURCH ST 15 15.9 UNKNOWN 60.83 189 4,500.00$ 7-172 7-22 LEWIS ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 60.82 190 19,200.00$ 3-148 3-1348 N 2ND ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 60.59 191 21,000.00$ 2-934 2-933 OAK ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 60.49 192 19,200.00$

3-1340 3-1339 N 1ST ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 59.83 193 18,800.00$ 5-1122 5-1123 OREGON GARDENS 8 185 PVC 59.61 194 35,500.00$ 5-514 5-513 W MAIN ST 8 300 UNKNOWN 59.23 195 50,900.00$

3-1335 3-1333A N JAMES ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 59.19 196 19,600.00$ 3-85 3-84 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 58.83 197 23,100.00$ 626 625 W MAIN ST 12 145.2 UNKNOWN 58.79 198 27,300.00$

7-163 7-19 HIGH ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 58.37 199 19,200.00$ 6-562 6-561 S CENTER ST 8 200.5 UNKNOWN 58.02 200 1,700.00$ 223 222 OAK ST 6 62 UNKNOWN 57.04 201 11,900.00$

3-1333A 3-1333 N JAMES ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 56.91 202 19,600.00$ 1-192 1-63 COWING ST 8 103.5 UNKNOWN 56.51 203 23,900.00$ 8-97 8-96 B ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 56.11 204 21,500.00$ 5-519 5-518 McCLAINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 56.10 205 21,500.00$ 7-171 7-170 E MAIN ST 8 100 CLAY 55.92 206 17,000.00$ 8-100 8-99 OAK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 55.74 207 19,200.00$ 7-181 7-176 JERSEY ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 55.51 208 19,200.00$ 7-161 7-18 PARK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 54.98 209 19,200.00$ 3-168 3-142 LINCOLN ST 8 220 UNKNOWN 54.90 210 42,300.00$

3-1329 3-1331 WESTERN AV NE 8 100 UNKNOWN 54.38 211 19,200.00$ 6-531 6-530 EUREKA AVE 8 437.1 UNKNOWN 54.25 212 84,000.00$ 271P 3-270 N 2ND ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 53.94 213 19,200.00$ 8-310 8-98 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 53.74 214 19,200.00$ 4-107 4-36 PINE ST 8 220 UNKNOWN 53.71 215 50,300.00$ 7-176 7-175 JERSEY ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 53.36 216 22,600.00$

0 5-508 WESTFIELD ST 4 100 UNKNOWN 53.18 217 19,200.00$ 4-112 4-111 EASEMENT 8 100 UNKNOWN 52.86 218 17,000.00$

5-1130 5-1123 OREGON GARDENS 8 165 PVC 52.55 219 31,700.00$ 3-1332 3-1333 N JAMES ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 52.54 220 19,200.00$ 8-102 8-101 OAK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 52.45 221 19,200.00$ 9-53 9-52 S 3RD ST 12 100 UNKNOWN 52.23 222 18,800.00$ 9-861 Hobart PS HOBART RD 8 100 UNKNOWN 52.12 223 19,200.00$ 8-156 8-95 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 51.96 224 19,200.00$ 5-537 AlderPS BROOK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 51.78 225 19,200.00$ 7-175 7-23 JERSEY ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 51.01 226 19,200.00$ 5-606 5-516 S JAMES AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 50.76 227 19,200.00$

3-1339 3-1338 JEFFERSON ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 50.71 228 18,800.00$ 5-1136 5-1135 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 UNKNOWN 50.69 229 19,200.00$ 5-1137 5-1131 OREGON GARDENS 8 250 PVC 50.49 230 48,000.00$ 3-135 3-83 CHESTER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 50.37 231 22,800.00$ 6-571 6-566 ANDERSON DR 8 287 UNKNOWN 50.06 232 55,100.00$

0 5-538 ALDER ST 4 7 DI 49.94 233 1,300.00$ 3-1331 3-1332 N JAMES ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 49.50 234 19,200.00$ 4-1309 4-1307 0 8 100 UNKNOWN 49.39 235 23,700.00$ CO34 8-34 PINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 49.38 236 19,200.00$ 2-685 2-212 NORWAY AVE 8 190 UNKNOWN 49.33 237 32,200.00$ 3-86 3-85 WHITTIER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 49.07 238 22,600.00$

GrantPS 4-110 GRANT ST 6 100 DI 49.06 239 19,200.00$ 7-162 7-161 PARK ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 48.81 240 19,200.00$ 8-274 8-97 B ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 48.26 241 19,200.00$

5-1132 5-1131 OREGON GARDENS 8 220 PVC 48.07 242 42,300.00$ 9-75 9-74 S WATER ST 15 258 PVC 48.04 243 64,700.00$ 5-589 5-506 WELCH ST 6 192.5 UNKNOWN 48.02 244 43,500.00$ 3-91 3-90 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.86 245 19,200.00$ 8-103 8-102 OAK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.61 246 19,200.00$ 5-511 5-510A WESTFIELD ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.59 247 19,200.00$ CO288 8-288 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.42 248 19,200.00$ 6-553 6-552-A WELCH ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.33 249 22,600.00$ 4-114 4-111 GRANT ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.32 250 22,800.00$ 4-108 4-107 PINE ST 8 195 UNKNOWN 47.13 251 44,600.00$ 6-581 6-530 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 47.10 252 900.00$

5-1133 5-1132 OREGON GARDENS 6 158 PVC 47.07 253 30,400.00$ 3-147 3-142 N 2ND ST 8 434 UNKNOWN 46.97 254 98,100.00$ 3-87 3-86 WHITTIER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 46.79 255 19,200.00$ 7-164 7-163 HIGH ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 46.63 256 900.00$ 1-255 1-254 WALNUT AVE. 8 75 CONC 46.41 257 700.00$

0 3-147 N 2ND ST 9 100 UNKNOWN 46.34 258 19,200.00$ 1-290 1-289 WALNUT WAY 8 130 CONC 46.31 259 22,000.00$ 1-193 1-192 BARGER ST 8 326 UNKNOWN 46.25 260 62,600.00$ 8-225 8-224 OAK ST 6 291.5 UNKNOWN 46.08 261 56,000.00$

5-516A 5-516 BROOK ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 45.61 262 17,000.00$ 7-165 7-164 HIGH ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 45.58 263 21,500.00$ 9-394 9-47 LONE OAKS LP 15 556.7 CONC 45.52 264 104,600.00$ 8-228 8-101 5TH ST 8 165.5 UNKNOWN 45.27 265 31,800.00$ 3-136 3-135 CHESTER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 44.94 266 21,500.00$

0 5-521 McCLAINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 44.90 267 19,200.00$ 9-76 9-75 S WATER ST 15 467 PVC 44.75 268 87,800.00$ 2-420 2-417 N STEELHAMMER RD 8 407.2 UNKNOWN 44.66 269 87,400.00$ 6-549 6-600 JEROME AVE 8 311.8 UNKNOWN 44.60 270 59,900.00$ 9-52 9-51 N 3RD ST 15 440.5 UNKNOWN 44.58 271 102,800.00$

3-1337 3-1336 JEFFERSON ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 44.54 272 18,800.00$ 6-525 6-524A W MAIN ST 8 281 UNKNOWN 44.31 273 54,000.00$

5-1135 5-1134 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 UNKNOWN 44.25 274 19,200.00$ 8-93 8-92 N 1ST ST 10 375 UNKNOWN 44.12 275 84,800.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 44.08 276 19,200.00$ 3-88 3-87 WHITTIER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 44.07 277 19,200.00$ 3-137 3-136 CHESTER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 44.07 277 21,500.00$ 116 60 N JAMES AVE 8 280 UNKNOWN 44.05 279 53,800.00$

7-236 7-235B UNKNOWN 6 50 UNKNOWN 43.94 280 9,600.00$ 3-1334 0 N JAMES ST 18 100 UNKNOWN 43.85 281 19,600.00$ 3-132 3-131 WASHINGTON ST 8 100 AC 43.64 282 22,600.00$ 6-545 6-524 COOLIDGE ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 43.59 283 19,200.00$ 6-600 6-548 JEROME AVE 8 327.05 AC 43.50 284 62,800.00$ 5-607 5-606 S JAMES AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 43.49 285 19,200.00$ 9-77 9-76 S WATER ST 15 350 PVC 43.48 286 65,800.00$ 1-254 1-253 WALNUT AVE. 8 225 CONC 43.36 287 2,000.00$ 7-316 7-54 DRAKE ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 43.30 288 19,200.00$ 3-84 3-83 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 42.83 289 23,100.00$ 9-55 9-54 S 3RD ST 12 443.1 CONC 42.82 290 83,300.00$ 5-515 5-514 W MAIN ST 8 398 UNKNOWN 42.79 291 67,500.00$ 8-288 8-96 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 42.77 292 19,200.00$ 8-154 8-153 B ST 8 276 UNKNOWN 42.77 293 62,400.00$ 3-143 3-168 LINCOLN ST 8 195 UNKNOWN 42.33 294 37,500.00$ 7-298 7-297 JAY ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 42.01 295 19,200.00$ 9-54 9-53 S 3RD ST 12 277.9 UNKNOWN 41.84 296 52,200.00$ 8-102 8-101 OAK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 41.82 297 19,200.00$

307P-B 307P-A N 2ND ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 41.64 298 19,200.00$ 6-558 6-551 CHERRY ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 41.50 299 19,200.00$ 6-542 6-523 W MAIN ST 9 100 UNKNOWN 41.44 300 21,500.00$

7-235B 7-235A UNKNOWN 6 150 UNKNOWN 41.28 301 28,800.00$ 6-544 6-542 FISKE ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 41.21 302 19,200.00$ 8-94 8-93 N 1ST ST 9 220 UNKNOWN 41.20 303 50,300.00$ 3-89 3-88 WHITTIER ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 41.02 304 19,200.00$ 6-543 6-542 W MAIN ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 41.02 304 19,200.00$ 7-241 7-238 RESERVE ST 6 256 UNKNOWN 40.91 306 60,700.00$ 1-259 1-253 WALNUT AVE. 8 170 CONC 40.90 307 1,500.00$ 1-256 1-254 FILBERT WAY 8 143 CONC 40.90 307 1,200.00$ 6-546 6-545 COOLIDGE ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 40.83 309 19,200.00$ 5-505 5-504 WESTFIELD ST 12 174.5 UNKNOWN 40.83 310 32,800.00$ 7-235 7-234 UNKNOWN 6 188.5 UNKNOWN 40.75 311 36,200.00$ 7-173 7-172 LEWIS ST 8 100 CLAY 40.73 312 900.00$

5-1398 5-1397 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 40.49 313 19,200.00$ 5-1395 5-1394 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 40.39 314 19,200.00$ 6-569 6-568 EDGEWOOD DR 8 323 UNKNOWN 40.27 315 62,100.00$

1-1153 9-80 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 53 PVC 40.27 316 12,400.00$ 3-90 3-89 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 40.27 317 19,200.00$

3-1338 3-1337 JEFFERSON ST 15 100 UNKNOWN 40.11 318 18,800.00$ 5-1394 5-1139 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 39.63 319 19,200.00$ 8-221 8-310 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 39.63 320 900.00$

5-1134 5-1133 OREGON GARDENS 6 195 PVC 39.55 321 37,500.00$ 1-194 1-193 BARGER ST 8 218 UNKNOWN 39.55 322 49,800.00$

0 0 FAIRVIEW ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 39.51 323 19,200.00$ 9-74 9-73 S WATER ST 18 470 PVC 39.49 324 120,700.00$ 8-92 8-44 N 1ST ST 10 310 UNKNOWN 39.49 325 59,600.00$

5-1397 5-1396 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 39.09 326 19,200.00$ 5-1396 5-1395 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 39.09 326 19,200.00$ 3-144 3-143 LINCOLN ST 8 388 UNKNOWN 39.08 328 87,700.00$ 4-110 4-108 GRANT ST 8 635 UNKNOWN 39.02 329 122,000.00$ 1-282 1-289 WALNUT WAY 8 132 CONC 38.95 330 1,200.00$ 9-51 9-50 N 3RD ST 15 428.5 UNKNOWN 38.90 331 97,400.00$ 7-845 7-846 KLOSHE CT 9 393.33 PVC 38.89 332 88,900.00$

6-552-A 6-552 WELCH ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 38.86 333 19,200.00$ 1-252 1-1261 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 195 PVC3034 38.85 334 44,300.00$

6-551-A 6-551 WELCH ST 9 100 UNKNOWN 38.82 335 19,200.00$ 3-1330 3-1329 WESTERN AV NE 6 100 UNKNOWN 38.75 336 19,200.00$ 8-124 8-38 PINE ST 8 33 UNKNOWN 38.53 337 6,300.00$ 1-823 1-824 CHEE CHEE CT 8 321 PVC 38.48 338 79,700.00$ 4-283 4-10 PINE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 38.42 339 19,200.00$ 2-421 2-420 N STEELHAMMER RD 8 390 UNKNOWN 38.40 340 83,700.00$ 8-152 8-153 C ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 38.37 341 22,600.00$ 9-78 9-77 S WATER ST 15 324 PVC 38.30 342 73,600.00$ 1-195 1-194 CENTRAL ST 8 200 UNKNOWN 38.17 343 45,200.00$

7-235A 7-235 UNKNOWN 6 96.51 UNKNOWN 38.16 344 18,500.00$ 5-304 5-510A SOUTH ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 37.99 345 19,200.00$ 8-222 8-221 OAK ST 6 164.5 UNKNOWN 37.57 346 35,300.00$ 7-174 7-173 LEWIS ST 8 100 CLAY 37.57 347 17,000.00$ 3-139 3-81 JEFFERSON ST 8 368 AC 37.33 348 79,000.00$

6-555-A 6-554 PHELPS ST 9 206 UNKNOWN 37.24 349 39,600.00$ 6-554 6-553 PHELPS ST 9 100 UNKNOWN 37.24 349 19,200.00$

3-1342 3-1341 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 37.23 351 19,200.00$ 8-157 8-156 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 37.22 352 19,200.00$ 7-243 7-236 E MAIN ST 6 177 UNKNOWN 36.78 353 38,000.00$ 9-50 9-49 N 3RD ST 15 353 UNKNOWN 36.71 354 78,100.00$

307P-C 307P-A N 2ND ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 36.58 355 19,200.00$ 9-48 9-394 LONE OAKS LP 15 556.7 CONC 36.43 356 104,600.00$ 5-590 5-589 WELCH ST 6 192.5 UNKNOWN 36.11 357 43,500.00$ 2-455 2-408 NORWAY AVE 8 235.3 UNKNOWN 35.92 358 45,200.00$ 8-315 8-274 N 3RD ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 35.82 359 19,200.00$ 1-821 1-822 CHEE CHEE CT 8 67 PVC 35.72 360 16,500.00$ 5-592 5-591 FAIRVIEW ST 6 382 UNKNOWN 35.70 361 82,000.00$ CO225 8-225 OAK ST 6 130.1 UNKNOWN 35.40 362 25,000.00$ 6-526 6-550 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 35.38 363 19,200.00$ 5-591 5-590 W CENTER ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 35.34 364 19,200.00$

5-1400 5-1399 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 35.18 365 19,200.00$ 5-1399 5-1398 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 35.18 365 19,200.00$ 3-1343 3-1342 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 34.95 367 19,200.00$ 3-1347 0 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 34.95 367 19,200.00$ 3-1345 3-1341 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 34.95 367 19,200.00$ 5-603 5-537 BROOK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 34.95 367 19,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 34.91 371 19,200.00$ 6-548 6-547 JEROME AVE 8 23.25 UNKNOWN 34.86 372 3,900.00$ 7-186 9-55 S 3RD ST 8 400 CONC 34.80 373 76,900.00$

6-524A 6-624 W MAIN ST 8 0 CLAY 34.69 374 -$ 9-56 9-55 LANE ST 12 539.5 CONC 34.68 375 101,400.00$ 5-318 5-319 SILVER ST 6 20 CLAY 34.59 376 3,800.00$ 5-593 5-592 FAIRVIEW ST 6 365 UNKNOWN 34.40 377 78,400.00$

5-1401 5-1400 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 34.31 378 19,200.00$ 5-1404 5-1403 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 34.30 379 19,200.00$ 8-129 8-124 N JAMES ST 8 298 UNKNOWN 34.10 380 68,100.00$ 7-233 7-52 E MAIN ST 8 263 UNKNOWN 33.87 381 50,500.00$ 550 525 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 33.86 382 19,200.00$

7-612 7-241 RESERVE ST 6 150 CONC 33.79 383 32,200.00$ 1-197 1-195 CENTRAL ST 8 200 UNKNOWN 33.50 384 38,400.00$ 5-151 5-120 MAPLE ST 8 241 UNKNOWN 33.50 384 46,300.00$ 4-115 4-114 FLORIDA DR 6 100 UNKNOWN 33.43 386 17,000.00$

0 0 WESTFIELD ST 4 100 UNKNOWN 33.43 386 19,200.00$ 0 3-141 JEFFERSON ST 8 125 CONC 33.34 388 24,000.00$

5-318A 5-318 SILVER ST 6 100 CLAY 33.32 389 19,200.00$ 3-140 3-139 JEFFERSON ST 8 402 AC 33.17 390 86,300.00$ 2-219 2-211 CHADWICK ST 6 448 CONC 33.16 391 101,300.00$ 6-602 6-558 CHERRY ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 33.14 392 19,200.00$

5-1402 5-1400 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 33.00 393 19,200.00$ 2-213 2-212 OAK ST 8 225 UNKNOWN 32.97 394 50,900.00$

0 906 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 9 50 CONC 32.96 395 9,600.00$ 9-858 9-856 ESKA WAY 10 400 PVC 32.85 396 90,400.00$ 6-551 6-625 WELCH ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 32.67 397 19,200.00$ 9-70 9-33B S WATER ST 18 265 PVC 32.44 398 63,800.00$ 6-532 6-531 EUREKA AVE 8 407.6 UNKNOWN 32.24 399 87,500.00$ 1-68 1-67 S WATER ST 8 289 UNKNOWN 32.23 400 62,100.00$

9-33B 9-33A S WATER ST 18 260 PVC 32.20 401 62,600.00$ 6-567 6-566 EDGEWOOD DR 8 381 UNKNOWN 32.04 402 81,800.00$ 9-56A 9-56 LANE ST 12 0 UNKNOWN 31.96 403 -$ 1327P 1326P SUHS PROPERTY PARKING LOT 9 100 PVC3034 31.95 404 19,200.00$

0 896P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 197 PVC 31.95 404 37,800.00$ 3-1344 3-1343 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 31.91 406 19,200.00$

0 0 FAIRVIEW ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 877P 888P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 72 PVC 31.91 406 13,800.00$ 888P 892P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 112 PVC 31.91 406 21,500.00$ 892P 892A-P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 168 PVC 31.91 406 32,300.00$

0 890P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 18 PVC 31.91 406 3,500.00$ 890P 891P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 108 PVC 31.91 406 20,700.00$ 891P 892A-P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 197 PVC 31.91 406 37,800.00$

892A-P 893P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 273 PVC 31.91 406 52,500.00$ 1326P 1325P SUHS PROPERTY PARKING LOT 9 100 PVC3034 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 1325P 1324P SUHS PROPERTY PARKING LOT 9 100 PVC3034 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 1324P 893P SUHS PROPERTY PARKING LOT 9 100 PVC3034 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 893P 893A-P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 273 PVC 31.91 406 52,500.00$

893A-P 894P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 148 PVC 31.91 406 28,400.00$ 894P 895P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 141 PVC 31.91 406 27,100.00$ 895P 0 SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 9 197 PVC 31.91 406 37,800.00$

0 WWTP1 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 9 297.5 PVC 31.91 406 57,200.00$ 4-22-1/2 Bend 4-22-1/2 Bend On Shops Property south of large building 9 24 PVC3034 31.91 406 4,600.00$ 22-1/2 Bend 4-1316 On Shops Property south of large building 9 17 PVC3034 31.91 406 3,300.00$

4-1306 4-1306A RAILWAY AVE 9 3 PVC 31.91 406 600.00$ 4-1306A 4-1305 SILVERTON RD 9 152 PVC 31.91 406 29,200.00$

0 0 SILVERTON RD 9 100 PVC 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 0 0 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 9 100 PVC 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 0 0 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 9 100 PVC 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 0 0 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 9 100 PVC 31.91 406 19,200.00$ 0 2-864 ESKA WAY 8 100 PVC 31.91 406 19,200.00$

6-582 6-532 ROSS AVE 8 436.7 UNKNOWN 31.78 432 93,800.00$ 5-1403 5-1400 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 UNKNOWN 31.69 433 19,200.00$ 7-245 7-244 E MAIN ST 6 80 CONC 31.66 434 15,400.00$ 1-196 1-195 BARGER ST 8 383 UNKNOWN 31.60 435 86,600.00$ 7-299 7-298 JAY ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 31.37 436 23,100.00$ 3-134 3-133 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 31.26 437 17,000.00$

0 9-29 S WATER ST 8 0 CONC 31.06 438 -$ 2-935 2-421 N STEELHAMMER RD 8 115 UNKNOWN 30.98 439 24,700.00$ 6-647 6-569 EDGEWOOD DR 8 210 PVC 30.94 440 40,300.00$ 9-72 9-71 S WATER ST 18 297 PVC 30.90 441 74,400.00$ 6-585 6-533 KEENE AVE 8 114 UNKNOWN 30.82 442 24,500.00$ 9-79 9-78 S WATER ST 15 215 PVC 30.75 443 48,900.00$

1-68A 1-68 S WATER ST 8 324 UNKNOWN 30.73 444 69,600.00$ 1-200 1-199 MADISON ST 8 293 UNKNOWN 30.53 445 67,700.00$ 1-807 1-808 SHELOKUM DR 8 343 PVC3034 30.51 446 77,500.00$ 7-183 7-56 S 1ST ST 8 400 UNKNOWN 30.45 447 76,900.00$ 4-113 4-112 MONTE VISTA ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 30.39 448 19,200.00$

0 0 WESTFIELD ST 4 100 UNKNOWN 30.39 448 19,200.00$ 9-71 9-70 S WATER ST 18 291 PVC 30.25 450 70,100.00$

0 5-660 WESTFIELD ST 2 458 UNKNOWN 30.13 451 88,000.00$ 1-69 1-68A S WATER ST 8 324 UNKNOWN 30.12 452 62,200.00$

1-1261 1-1153 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 40 PVC3034 30.09 453 9,300.00$ 6-572 6-571 ANDERSON DR 8 272 PVC 29.99 454 52,300.00$ 3-141 3-140 JEFFERSON ST 8 270 AC 29.99 455 51,900.00$

5-597A 5-597 W CENTER ST 8 48 UNKNOWN 29.95 456 11,800.00$ 2-250 2-209 N CHURCH ST 6 360 UNKNOWN 29.83 457 69,200.00$ 8-272 8-39 WELL ST 8 400 UNKNOWN 29.82 458 76,900.00$ 9-850 9-410 Back of 1501 ESKA WAY 15 97 PVC 29.80 459 27,200.00$

8-93P-A 8-93 D ST 8 100 CONC 29.74 460 19,200.00$ 307P-D 307P-C N 2ND ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 29.69 461 19,200.00$ 7-611 7-245 AMES ST 6 200 CONC 29.68 462 38,400.00$ 9-79A 9-79 S WATER ST 15 135 PVC 29.65 463 30,700.00$ 7-238 7-237 ROCK ST 6 3 CONC 29.63 464 700.00$

3-1346 3-1345 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 29.63 465 19,200.00$ 0 3-1345 N 1ST ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 29.63 465 19,200.00$

3-133 3-132 WASHINGTON ST 8 343 AC 29.59 467 73,700.00$ 8-266 8-288 D ST 6 100 CONC 29.58 468 19,200.00$ 2-868 2-867 HOBART RD 8 198.79 PVC3034 29.57 469 50,100.00$ 7-247 7-235 5TH ST 6 209.3 CONC 29.55 470 40,200.00$ 1-191 1-62 HICKS ST 8 150 UNKNOWN 29.52 471 28,800.00$ 5-594 5-591 W CENTER ST 6 200 UNKNOWN 29.44 472 38,400.00$ 1-67 1-66 S WATER ST 8 350 UNKNOWN 29.30 473 80,000.00$ 7-297 7-186 S 3RD ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 29.23 474 19,200.00$ 2-456 2-455 LIBERTY ST 8 307.7 UNKNOWN 29.09 475 71,100.00$ 1-199 1-65 MADISON ST 8 130 UNKNOWN 29.00 476 31,600.00$

0 0 FAIRVIEW ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 28.87 477 19,200.00$ 0 4-1322 0 9 100 UNKNOWN 28.87 477 19,200.00$

1-609 1-194 CENTRAL ST 8 0 UNKNOWN 28.85 479 -$ 6-556 6-555 CHERRY ST 6 475 UNKNOWN 28.85 479 91,300.00$ 9-80 9-79A S WATER ST 15 261 PVC 28.83 481 59,300.00$ 9-49 9-48 B ST 15 591.1 CONC 28.78 482 130,700.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 28.74 483 19,200.00$ 8-264 8-220 MILL ST 8 144 CONC 28.70 484 24,400.00$ 1-199 1-66 MADISON ST 8 13 UNKNOWN 28.69 485 3,000.00$ 3-145 3-144 LINCOLN ST 8 354 UNKNOWN 28.66 486 80,000.00$

6-524A 6-524 W MAIN ST 8 281 CLAY 28.61 487 54,000.00$ 7-308 9-55 LANE ST 6 190 PVC3034 28.13 488 36,500.00$

0 4-1301 MONSON RD 9 100 PVC 28.11 489 22,600.00$ 0 0 DAVENPORT LN 3 100 UNKNOWN 28.06 490 19,200.00$

7-239 7-238 ROCK ST 8 346.4 CONC 28.01 491 79,100.00$ 2-454 2-455 NORWAY AVE 8 268.2 UNKNOWN 27.81 492 51,500.00$ 6-573 6-572 ANDERSON DR 8 160 PVC 27.80 493 30,700.00$ PCO 0 Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 UNKNOWN 27.80 494 19,200.00$ 2-214 2-250 N CHURCH ST 6 211 UNKNOWN 27.73 495 40,500.00$ 6-534 6-533 EUREKA AVE 8 171.2 UNKNOWN 27.62 496 38,700.00$ 1-67 1-33 S WATER ST 8 30 PVC 27.59 497 5,800.00$ 9-73 9-72 S WATER ST 18 209 PVC 27.49 498 52,400.00$ 3-269 3-85 N 2ND ST 8 29.7 UNKNOWN 27.48 499 5,700.00$ 7-244 7-243 E MAIN ST 6 276 UNKNOWN 27.40 500 53,000.00$ 8-105 8-104 S CHURCH ST 8 483 UNKNOWN 27.36 501 92,800.00$ 6-626 6-526 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 27.35 502 19,200.00$

0 4-901 COX WAY 9 100 PVC 27.35 502 19,200.00$ 0 6-550 W MAIN ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 27.35 502 19,200.00$ 0 7-612 RESERVE ST 6 100 PVC 27.35 502 19,200.00$

1-811 1-821 SHELOKUM DR 8 218 PVC 26.93 506 53,600.00$ 33A 9-33 S WATER ST 18 30 PVC 26.90 507 5,900.00$

8-104 8-103 S CHURCH ST 8 350 UNKNOWN 26.69 508 67,200.00$ 3-131 3-82 WASHINGTON ST 8 369 AC 26.64 509 84,300.00$ 8-128 8-126 BROWN ST 8 166 UNKNOWN 26.52 510 31,900.00$

0 5-590 FAIRVIEW ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 26.49 511 700.00$ 8-125 8-124 PINE ST 8 487 UNKNOWN 26.46 512 93,600.00$ 6-574 6-573 ANDERSON DR 8 223 PVC 26.38 513 42,800.00$ 7-187 7-297 S 3RD ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 26.30 514 19,200.00$

5-1116 ORGardPS OREGON GARDENS 8 210 PVC 26.25 515 40,300.00$ 5-317 5-318 WILLOW ST 6 210 PVC 26.10 516 40,300.00$ 8-229 8-228 5TH ST 8 244.5 UNKNOWN 26.09 517 47,000.00$ 2-450 2-405 N CHURCH ST 8 468.2 UNKNOWN 26.07 518 90,000.00$ 3-118 3-117 FLORIDA DR 8 200 UNKNOWN 26.04 519 38,400.00$ 2-217 2-214 N CHURCH ST 6 0.08 UNKNOWN 25.96 520 -$ 2-393 2-400 UNKNOWN 8 109 PVC 25.90 521 20,900.00$

CLEANOUT 0 FOSSHOLM ROAD 9 33 PVC 25.83 522 6,300.00$ 4-1301 MonsonPS MONSON RD 9 18 PVC 25.83 522 3,500.00$

0 0 MONSON RD 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$ MonsonPS 9-04 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$

OG1 0 OREGON GARDENS 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$ 0 0 W MAIN ST 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$ 0 0 RAILWAY AVE 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$ 0 0 MONSON RD 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$ 0 0 MONSON RD 9 100 PVC 25.83 522 19,200.00$

6-587 6-586 KEENE AVE 8 242 UNKNOWN 25.80 531 46,500.00$ 6-575 6-574 ANDERSON DR 8 96 PVC 25.67 532 18,400.00$ 8-230 8-229 5TH ST 8 221 UNKNOWN 25.56 533 50,000.00$ 1-291 1-9-75 S SILVER LP 8 365 PVC 25.16 534 70,100.00$ 1-251 1-9-76 FENNE LN (PVT) 8 375 PVC 25.14 535 72,000.00$ 5-660 5-506 WESTFIELD ST 6 325 UNKNOWN 25.13 536 81,800.00$

0 6-536 EUREKA AVE 8 100 PVC 25.07 537 17,000.00$ Monson PS MPSForceMain1 MONSON RD 9 21 DI 25.03 538 4,000.00$

8-130 8-273 BROWN ST 8 325 UNKNOWN 25.03 539 62,400.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 25.01 540 19,200.00$ 6-701 6-587 KEENE AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 24.84 541 19,200.00$ 6-533 6-532 EUREKA AVE 8 192.8 UNKNOWN 24.81 542 41,400.00$ 8-273 8-41 BROWN ST 8 325 UNKNOWN 24.81 543 62,400.00$ 8-231 8-230 5TH ST 8 124 UNKNOWN 24.73 544 26,600.00$ 8-106 8-105 S CHURCH ST 8 152 UNKNOWN 24.73 545 29,200.00$ 1-805 1-807 TILLICUM DR 8 206 PVC 24.40 546 1,800.00$ 7-312 7-248 5TH ST 6 0 UNKNOWN 24.31 547 -$ 2-453 2-454 NORWAY AVE 8 273.5 UNKNOWN 24.28 548 52,500.00$ 1-293 1-9-74 N SILVER LP 8 300 PVC 24.24 549 57,600.00$ 7-185 7-184 S 1ST ST 8 148 CONC 24.23 550 28,400.00$ 8-261 8-262 ROBINSON ST 8 100 CONC 24.05 551 19,200.00$ 3-119 3-118 FLORIDA DR 8 260 UNKNOWN 24.04 552 55,800.00$ 1-190 1-64 COWING ST 8 200 UNKNOWN 23.98 553 38,400.00$ 6-570 6-569 WEIBY AVE 8 451 UNKNOWN 23.83 554 86,700.00$

7-247A 7-247 E MAIN ST 6 199 CONC 23.82 555 38,200.00$ 1-808 1-809 SHELOKUM DR 8 354 PVC 23.75 556 80,900.00$ 3-313 3-270 N 2ND ST 8 327.45 UNKNOWN 23.75 557 62,900.00$ 2-686 2-685 NORWAY AVE 8 210 UNKNOWN 23.61 558 40,300.00$

0 9-16 N WATER ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 23.52 559 19,200.00$ 8-126 8-125 PINE ST 8 55 UNKNOWN 23.45 560 10,600.00$ 7-240 7-239 ROCK ST 8 192 CONC 23.40 561 1,700.00$ 6-583 6-582 HAZEL ST 8 331 UNKNOWN 23.40 562 71,100.00$ 5-539 5-519 PHELPS ST 8 161.5 UNKNOWN 23.28 563 34,700.00$ 4-281 4-07 GRANT ST 8 233 CONC 22.98 564 44,800.00$ 8-153 8-94 C ST 8 140.6 UNKNOWN 22.91 565 32,100.00$ 1-201 1-200 MADISON ST 8 300 UNKNOWN 22.81 566 69,300.00$ 7-182 7-175 S 1ST ST 6 230 CONC 22.80 567 44,200.00$ 1-302 1-291 S SILVER LP 8 119 UNKNOWN 22.75 568 22,900.00$ 8-159 8-97 N 2ND ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 22.59 569 19,200.00$ 1-202 1-201 MADISON ST 8 290 UNKNOWN 22.45 570 66,300.00$

95 94 C ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 22.43 571 19,200.00$ 8-275 8-13 WEBB ST 8 256 PVC 22.41 572 49,200.00$ 6-576 6-575 WEIBY AVE 8 150 UNKNOWN 22.41 573 28,800.00$ 8-160 8-159 N 2ND ST 6 198.5 UNKNOWN 22.29 574 1,300.00$ 2-218 2-217 N CHURCH ST 6 298 UNKNOWN 22.29 575 50,500.00$ 2-924 2-453 BARTLETT ST 8 425.5 UNKNOWN 22.27 576 81,800.00$ 1-295 1-196 BARGER ST 8 81 UNKNOWN 22.18 577 17,400.00$ 2-392 2-393 BRYAN CT 8 126 PVC 22.13 578 29,900.00$ 4-123 4-122 ORCHARD ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 21.98 579 19,200.00$ 2-215 2-214 N CHURCH ST 6 50 UNKNOWN 21.77 580 8,500.00$ 8-227 8-226 DIGERNESS ST 6 146 PVC 21.77 580 28,100.00$ 226 225 DIGERNESS ST 6 50 UNKNOWN 21.77 580 9,600.00$

8-262 8-263 MILL ST 8 269 CONC 21.61 583 51,700.00$ 6-577 6-568 KEENE AVE 8 225 UNKNOWN 21.40 584 43,200.00$ 6-578 6-573 KEENE AVE 8 219 UNKNOWN 21.40 584 42,100.00$ 3-270 3-269 N 2ND ST 8 342.85 UNKNOWN 21.28 586 65,900.00$ 8-260 8-261 ROBINSON ST 8 340 CONC 21.27 587 65,300.00$ 2-452 2-453 NORWAY AVE 6 93.9 UNKNOWN 21.20 588 18,000.00$ 6-579 6-564 ROSS AVE 8 139 UNKNOWN 21.18 589 31,400.00$ 8-232 8-231 KENT ST 6 236.6 UNKNOWN 21.18 590 45,500.00$ 7-246 7-237 ROCK ST 6 75 UNKNOWN 21.11 591 14,400.00$ 3-314 3-313 N 2ND ST 8 75 UNKNOWN 21.03 592 14,400.00$ 6-580 6-579 ASH ST 8 388 UNKNOWN 20.94 593 83,300.00$

0 2-951 IOWA ST 8 100 PVC 20.91 594 900.00$ 4-122 4-37 ORCHARD ST 8 272 UNKNOWN 20.84 595 52,300.00$ 8-263 8-264 MILL ST 8 340 CONC 20.72 596 65,300.00$ 2-692 2-689 SWEDEN CIR 8 375 UNKNOWN 20.61 597 80,500.00$ 2-953 2-952 SPENCER DR (PVT) 8 305 PVC 20.46 598 68,900.00$ 1-629 1-66 SMITH ST 8 250 PVC 20.33 599 53,700.00$ 6-524 6-624 W MAIN ST 8 2 UNKNOWN 20.00 600 400.00$ 8-621 8-622 N 1ST ST 8 285 CONC 19.97 601 54,800.00$ 7-287 7-180 S 2ND ST 6 247.6 UNKNOWN 19.93 602 47,600.00$ 6-599 6-544 FISKE ST 8 250 CONC 19.86 603 48,000.00$ 9-851 9-850 ESKA WAY 15 497 PVC 19.82 604 130,700.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 19.79 605 19,200.00$ 2-936 2-935 S STEELHAMMER RD 8 263 PVC 19.58 606 59,400.00$ 1-810 1-811 SHELOKUM DR 8 156 PVC 19.29 607 37,000.00$ 6-601 6-551 CHERRY ST 6 300 UNKNOWN 19.22 608 57,600.00$ 9-852 9-851 ESKA WAY 10 320 PVC 19.11 609 76,300.00$ 5-301 5-597A W CENTER ST 8 181 UNKNOWN 18.68 610 40,900.00$ 6-586 6-585 KEENE AVE 8 124 UNKNOWN 18.68 611 26,600.00$ 6-651 6-647 EDGEWOOD DR 8 410 PVC 18.64 612 78,800.00$ 6-702 6-701 KEENE AVE 8 274 PVC 18.64 613 52,600.00$ 2-216 2-215 N CHURCH ST 6 282 UNKNOWN 18.62 614 47,800.00$

1-1200 1-1201 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 343 PVC3034 18.57 615 75,800.00$ 0 9-29 S WATER ST 8 0 UNKNOWN 18.53 616 -$

2-937 2-936 S STEELHAMMER RD 8 242 PVC 18.52 617 55,300.00$ 5-591 5-590 W CENTER ST 6 100 UNKNOWN 18.52 618 19,200.00$ 2-938 2-937 S STEELHAMMER RD 8 327 PVC3034 18.52 619 73,900.00$

2-686A 2-686 NORWAY AVE 8 127 PVC 18.49 620 24,400.00$ 8-94 0 N 1ST ST 10 220 UNKNOWN 18.42 621 37,300.00$ 8-672 8-46 N 2ND ST 8 343.77 PVC3034 18.38 622 66,000.00$ 8-38 0 PINE ST 18 457.7 UNKNOWN 18.36 623 89,800.00$ 3-138 3-137 MILL ST 8 125 UNKNOWN 18.34 624 24,000.00$

1-1146 1-68A ENSTAD LN 8 453 PVC 18.30 625 87,000.00$ 8-46A 8-46 N 2ND ST 8 181.23 PVC 18.26 626 34,800.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 18.25 627 19,200.00$

1-1150 1-739-73 ENSTAD LN 8 319 PVC 18.24 628 61,300.00$ 1-303 1-292 N SILVER LP 8 90 UNKNOWN 18.20 629 800.00$ 7-395 7-394 LONE OAKS LP 8 309.69 PVC 18.19 630 59,500.00$

1-1201 1-1202 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 277 PVC3034 18.15 631 52,100.00$ 2-949 2-418 IOWA ST 8 117 PVC3034 18.09 632 27,000.00$ 1-809 1-810 SHELOKUM DR 8 119 PVC 18.05 633 27,200.00$

2-694A 2-686 DENMARK LP 8 143 PVC 18.04 634 27,500.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 17.99 635 19,200.00$ 9-856 9-854 ESKA WAY 10 147 PVC 17.88 636 35,000.00$ 2-459 2-458 WALL ST 8 360.2 UNKNOWN 17.87 637 81,400.00$ CO262 8-262 MILL ST 8 240 PVC 17.82 638 46,100.00$

117 FloridaPS N JAMES AVE 8 14 UNKNOWN 17.79 639 2,700.00$ 6-557 6-556 W CENTER ST 6 90 UNKNOWN 17.77 640 19,300.00$

0 0 MILL ST 6 100 PVC 17.75 641 19,200.00$ 1-203 1-202 PEACH ST 8 156 UNKNOWN 17.55 642 30,000.00$

1-1163 1-1161 PIONEER DR 12 476 PVC 17.42 643 89,500.00$ 1-292 1-293 N SILVER LP 8 120 UNKNOWN 17.36 644 23,100.00$ 6-584 6-582 ROSS AVE 8 182 UNKNOWN 17.29 645 41,100.00$

1-1199 1-1200 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 73 PVC3034 17.08 646 16,600.00$ 6-648 6-647 EDGEWOOD DR 8 137 PVC3034 17.05 647 26,300.00$

5-1121 5-1120 OREGON GARDENS 8 201 PVC 17.01 648 45,900.00$ 1-1198 1-1199 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 124 PVC3034 16.94 649 28,900.00$ 2-689 2-685 SWEDEN CIR 8 146 PVC3034 16.93 650 24,800.00$ 8-265 8-263 HILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 16.90 651 19,200.00$ 403-A 8-403 MILL ST 8 12 PVC 16.88 652 2,300.00$ 5-540 5-539 PHELPS ST 8 96.5 UNKNOWN 16.77 653 18,500.00$ 1-820 1-821 CHEE CHEE CT 8 90 PVC 16.61 654 21,900.00$ 1-296 1-295 BARGER ST 6 111 UNKNOWN 16.49 655 21,300.00$ 2-457 2-456 WALL ST 8 394.2 UNKNOWN 16.49 656 90,100.00$ 1-812 1-811 SHELOKUM DR 8 150 PVC 16.49 657 37,200.00$ 2-866 2-865 ESKA WAY 8 284 PVC 16.42 658 61,000.00$ 2-865 2-864 ESKA WAY 8 244 PVC 16.34 659 55,800.00$

1-1256 1-1197 On easement SW side of detention pond 15 205 PVC3034 16.34 660 51,400.00$ 2-458 2-457 WALL ST 8 121.6 UNKNOWN 16.32 661 27,500.00$

1-1255 1-1256 FRONTIER ST. 12 230 PVC3034 16.31 662 56,800.00$ 660A-P 5-660 WESTFIELD ST 6 458 UNKNOWN 16.28 663 88,000.00$ 5-1123 5-1121 OREGON GARDENS 8 115 PVC 16.21 664 26,300.00$ 1-813A 1-813 SHELOKUM DR 8 205 PVC 16.20 665 39,400.00$

588 701 KEENE AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 16.15 666 19,200.00$ 1-825 1-823 CHEE CHEE CT 8 208 PVC 16.12 667 54,700.00$ 6-703 6-702 WEIBY AVE 8 140 PVC 16.01 668 26,900.00$ 1-819 1-820 CHEE CHEE CT 8 133 PVC 15.95 669 31,500.00$

5-510A 5-510 WESTFIELD ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 15.93 670 19,200.00$ 5-1125 5-1124 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 PVC 15.68 671 19,200.00$

0 9-409 Back of 1401 ESKA WAY 8 100 UNKNOWN 15.63 672 19,200.00$ 2-864 2-863 ESKA WAY 8 400 PVC 15.63 673 100,700.00$ 2-863 2-862 ESKA WAY 8 402 PVC 15.63 673 107,200.00$ 3-309 3-138 MILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 15.62 675 19,200.00$ 1-816 1-819 CHIKAMIN LP 8 148 PVC 15.58 676 34,200.00$ 8-922 8-627 N 1ST ST 8 386 PVC 15.56 677 74,200.00$ 2-419 2-418 OAK ST 8 392.5 UNKNOWN 15.55 678 88,700.00$ 2-416 2-933 OAK ST 8 467.5 UNKNOWN 15.51 679 89,800.00$ 6-652 6-651 EDGEWOOD DR 8 225 PVC 15.40 680 43,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 15.40 681 19,200.00$ 2-941 2-939 CRESTVIEW DR 8 303 PVC 15.34 682 69,200.00$ 2-952 2-951 IOWA ST 8 400 PVC 15.30 683 91,400.00$

1-1151 1-1150 ENSTAD LN 8 109 PVC 15.29 684 20,900.00$ 5-541 5-540 PHELPS ST 6 145 UNKNOWN 15.28 685 27,900.00$ 1-188 1-27A KOONS ST 8 120 PVC 15.24 686 23,100.00$ 857 9-856 ESKA WAY 8 0 PVC 15.23 687 -$

1-1152 1-9-73 ENSTAD LN 6 0 PVC 15.13 688 -$ 2-391 2-392 BRYAN CT 8 117 PVC 15.11 689 26,400.00$ 1-964 1-805 TILLICUM DR 8 194 PVC 15.02 690 37,300.00$ 2-933 2-415 OAK ST 8 467.5 UNKNOWN 14.99 691 89,800.00$ 5-117 5-1116 OREGON GARDENS 8 50 PVC 14.91 692 9,600.00$ 8-627 8-621 N 1ST ST 8 34 PVC 14.90 693 6,500.00$ 2-691 2-690 SWEDEN CIR 8 445 UNKNOWN 14.87 694 100,600.00$ 4-206 GrantPS GRANT ST 8 180 PVC 14.86 695 34,600.00$ 6-654 6-653 EDGEWOOD DR 8 323 PVC 14.84 696 62,100.00$

5-1118 5-1117 OREGON GARDENS 8 242 PVC 14.81 697 46,500.00$ 9-1154 9-80 S WATER ST 12 159.74 PVC 14.80 698 36,100.00$ 2-951 2-950 IOWA ST 8 400 PVC 14.74 699 85,900.00$

1-1202 1-252 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 106 PVC3034 14.70 700 17,600.00$ 2-954 2-953 CAMBRIDGE AVE. 8 228 PVC3034 14.66 701 51,500.00$ 2-690 2-689 SWEDEN CIR 8 170 UNKNOWN 14.54 702 38,400.00$

1-1254 1-1255 FRONTIER ST. 12 245 PVC3034 14.53 703 59,600.00$ 1-27A 1-27 KOONS ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 14.52 704 19,200.00$ 1-1164 1-1163 PIONEER DR 12 156 PVC 14.49 705 29,300.00$

906 907 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 8 57 CONC 14.49 706 11,000.00$ 2-697 2-687 SWEDEN CIR 8 264 PVC 14.48 707 61,000.00$

1-1197 1-1198 IKE MOONEY RD. 15 113 PVC3034 14.47 708 26,400.00$ 907 908 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 278 CONC 14.47 709 52,300.00$ 917 918 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 10 CONC 14.47 709 2,700.00$ 918 0 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 210.09 CONC 14.47 709 56,600.00$

2-687 2- 686A NORWAY AVE 8 193.64 PVC 14.45 712 37,200.00$ 5-1128 5-1127 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 PVC 14.41 713 19,200.00$ 2-947 2-941 CRESTVIEW DR 8 438 PVC 14.31 714 100,100.00$ 1-965 1-964 TILLICUM DR 8 123 PVC3034 14.28 715 23,600.00$ 1-204 9-32 TREES CT (PVT) 8 0 UNKNOWN 14.28 716 -$

1-1150A 1-1150 ENSTAD LN 8 187 PVC 14.23 717 35,900.00$ 3-146 3-145 MILL ST 8 127 UNKNOWN 14.21 718 28,700.00$

5-1120 5-1119 OREGON GARDENS 8 92 PVC 14.21 719 17,700.00$ 0 0 UNKNOWN 8 100 PVC 14.17 720 19,200.00$

5-1127 5-1126 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 PVC 14.16 721 19,200.00$ 0 0 N JAMES AVE 4 100 DI 14.10 722 19,200.00$

6-560 6-561 S CENTER ST 8 72.5 UNKNOWN 14.06 723 600.00$ 8-923 8-46A N 2ND ST 8 205 PVC 13.95 724 39,400.00$ 859 9-858 ESKA WAY 8 100 DI 13.83 725 19,200.00$

2-695 2-694 DENMARK LP 8 289.93 PVC 13.82 726 55,700.00$ 2-950 2-949 IOWA ST 8 213 PVC 13.82 727 48,700.00$ 855 9-854 ESKA WAY 8 0 PVC 13.81 728 -$

1-1169 1-1168 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 155 PVC3034 13.75 729 34,300.00$ 2-939 2-938 S STEELHAMMER RD 8 43 PVC 13.67 730 8,300.00$ 6-596 6-601 CHERRY ST 6 314 UNKNOWN 13.61 731 2,100.00$

5-1119 5-1118 OREGON GARDENS 8 120 PVC 13.61 732 20,300.00$ 1-815 1-816 CHIKAMIN LP 8 163 PVC 13.58 733 36,800.00$ 2-386 2-387 MILL ST 8 288 PVC 13.52 734 65,100.00$ 9-853 9-852 ESKA WAY 10 157 PVC 13.45 735 36,100.00$ 2-955 2-954 CAMBRIDGE AVE. 8 106 PVC3034 13.44 736 24,500.00$

5-1129 5-1128 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 PVC 13.40 737 19,200.00$ 0 2-866 ESKA WAY 8 23 PVC 13.35 738 4,400.00$

2-956 2-955 PRINCETON AVE 8 336 PVC3034 13.29 739 76,800.00$ 2-694 2-694A DENMARK LP 8 66.97 PVC 13.20 740 12,900.00$

0 7-316 4TH ST 6 100 PVC 13.16 741 19,200.00$ 6-645 6-640 ANDERSON DR 8 246 PVC 13.16 742 47,300.00$

0 877P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 6 73 PVC 13.15 743 14,000.00$ 5-1124 5-1123 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 PVC 13.14 744 19,200.00$ 6-649 6-648 EDGEWOOD DR 8 170 PVC 13.14 745 32,700.00$ 7-616 7-612 AMES CT 6 20 PVC3034 13.13 746 100.00$ 1-813 1-812 SHELOKUM DR 8 60 PVC 13.05 747 14,900.00$

0 5-589 WELCH ST 6 89 UNKNOWN 12.99 748 17,100.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 12.98 749 19,200.00$ 6-640 6-575 ANDERSON DR 8 225 PVC 12.95 750 43,200.00$ 860 9-858 ESKA WAY 8 100 DI 12.86 751 19,200.00$

0 5-513 W MAIN ST 4 100 DI 12.82 752 19,200.00$ 2-700 2-697 SWEDEN CIR 8 120 PVC 12.79 753 27,700.00$ 2-957 2-955 CAMBRIDGE AVE. 8 316 PVC 12.76 754 71,400.00$

2-1356 2-868 Hobart Road 8 276 PVC3034 12.69 755 67,100.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 12.64 756 19,200.00$ 6-646 6-645 ANDERSON DR 8 112 PVC 12.60 757 21,500.00$

1-1168 1-1164 PIONEER DR 12 123 PVC 12.57 758 25,800.00$ 6-653 6-652 EDGEWOOD DR 8 175 PVC 12.57 759 33,600.00$ 1-817 1-816 CHIKAMIN LP 8 256 PVC 12.55 760 58,500.00$ 4-712 4-711 SHERIDAN ST 8 96.9 PVC 12.53 761 18,600.00$

1-188A 1-188 KOONS ST 8 100 PVC 12.53 762 900.00$ 7-615 7-614 RESERVE ST 8 231 CONC 12.49 763 44,400.00$ 111 GrantPS GRANT ST 8 100 PVC 12.44 764 19,200.00$

2-387 2-388 BOEDIE'S DR 8 212 PVC 12.41 765 47,900.00$ 5-1126 5-1125 OREGON GARDENS 6 100 PVC 12.38 766 19,200.00$ 2-397 2-398 LONE OAKS LP 6 239 UNKNOWN 12.36 767 45,900.00$ 7-847 7-848 KLOSHE CT 8 172 PVC3034 12.29 768 38,900.00$ 7-614 7-613 RESERVE ST 8 315 CONC 12.23 769 60,500.00$

2-1371 2-1375 Sage St and int. w/Monitor Rd 12 163 PVC3034 12.19 770 40,200.00$ 2-925 9-410 SILVER CLIFF DR W (PVT) 8 96.07 PVC 12.19 771 22,800.00$

1-1161 1-1160 PIONEER DR 12 321 PVC 12.11 772 78,100.00$ 2-390 2-391 BRYAN CT 8 154 PVC 12.11 773 33,100.00$ 2-698 2-697 SWEDEN CIR 8 189 PVC 12.08 774 43,200.00$ 803 800 TILLICUM DR 8 132 PVC 12.08 774 29,800.00$

1-1171 1-1170 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 245 PVC3034 12.05 776 58,100.00$ 1-1245 1-1246 PIONEER DR 8 310 PVC3034 12.01 777 70,100.00$ 9-1159 9-1158 S WATER ST 12 50 PVC 11.97 778 13,100.00$

0 0 MILL ST 6 100 PVC 11.87 779 19,200.00$ 2-1382 9-850 SAGE ST 12 154 PVC3034 11.86 780 37,500.00$ 2-961 2-953 BREYONNA WAY 8 220 PVC 11.86 781 42,300.00$ 2-389 2-388 TODD CT 8 128 PVC 11.83 782 27,500.00$ 2-959 2-960 BREYONNA WAY 8 68 PVC 11.81 783 15,500.00$

1-1246 1-1249 PIONEER DR 8 181 PVC3034 11.68 784 41,400.00$ 0 0 MILL ST 6 100 PVC 11.67 785 19,200.00$

800 End Stub RESERVE ST 8 140 PVC 11.67 786 26,900.00$ 2-1293 2-947 CRESTVIEW DR 8 120 PVC 11.65 787 27,400.00$ 2-942 2-941 BREYONNA WAY 8 259 PVC 11.62 788 59,800.00$

2-1361 2-868 Webb Lake Drive 8 366 PVC3034 11.59 789 84,500.00$ 2-388 2-390 BOEDIE'S DR 8 238 PVC 11.57 790 53,800.00$ 9-854 9-853 ESKA WAY 10 173 PVC 11.56 791 40,400.00$ 1-804 1-805 TILLICUM DR 8 290 PVC 11.55 792 67,000.00$

9-1155 9-1154 S WATER ST 12 167.9 PVC 11.48 793 38,800.00$ 1-1285 1-814 SHELOKUM DR 8 80 PVC3034 11.47 794 19,900.00$ 5-927 5-608 S JAMES AVE 6 174 PVC 11.42 795 33,400.00$

1-1149 1-1150A ENSTAD LN 8 70 PVC3034 11.41 796 13,400.00$ 1-1147 1-1146 ENSTAD LN 8 246 PVC 11.39 797 47,300.00$ 9-1158 9-1157 S WATER ST 12 177 PVC 11.38 798 33,300.00$

0 2-417 OAK ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 11.37 799 19,200.00$ 0 2-459 WALL ST 8 0 UNKNOWN 11.37 799 -$

2-960 2-961 BREYONNA WAY 8 207 PVC 11.37 801 44,400.00$ 1-1253 1-1254 Tract betw. Flintlock and Frontier 10 219 PVC3034 11.35 802 52,200.00$ 1-1160 1-1158 PIONEER DR 12 131 PVC 11.25 803 24,600.00$ 2-946 2-947 HILLSDALE LN 8 197 PVC 11.21 804 45,000.00$

0 8-922 N 1ST ST 3 100 PVC 11.14 805 19,200.00$ 2-398 2-399 LONE OAKS LP 8 102.3 UNKNOWN 11.07 806 19,700.00$ 6-641 6-640 ANDERSON DR 8 295 PVC 11.06 807 56,700.00$ 5-151 0 MAPLE ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 11.00 808 19,200.00$

2-1377 2-1378 SAGE ST 12 241 PVC3034 10.88 809 55,700.00$ 9-1156 9-1155 S WATER ST 12 201 PVC 10.84 810 46,400.00$

3-81 3-148 N. 2nd and Jefferson 15 38 PVC3034 10.77 811 10,000.00$ 7-617 7-616 AMES CT 6 220 PVC3034 10.77 812 37,300.00$ 2-944 2-943 HILLSDALE LN 8 262 PVC 10.75 813 59,200.00$ 7-613 7-612 RESERVE ST 8 68.2 DI 10.67 814 13,100.00$ 7-248 7-247 5TH ST 6 240.7 CONC 10.63 815 46,200.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 10.61 816 19,200.00$ 1-966 1-965 TILLICUM DR 8 233 PVC3034 10.60 817 56,700.00$

1-1250 1-1253 FLINTLOCK ST. 10 45 PVC3034 10.58 818 10,500.00$ 2-1357 2-1356 Wood Duck St 8 354.49 PVC3034 10.56 819 84,000.00$ 2-958 2-957 CAMBRIDGE AVE. 8 40 PVC3034 10.54 820 8,600.00$

1-1170 1-1169 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 110 PVC 10.50 821 24,900.00$ 8-921 8-922 N 1ST ST 9 100 PVC 10.45 822 19,200.00$

4-1307 4-1306 RAILWAY AVE 12 440 PVC 10.45 823 108,600.00$ 1-1211 1-1212 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 168 PVC3034 10.44 824 39,800.00$ 2-1391 2-1377 Lavender St 8 503 PVC3034 10.44 825 116,200.00$

PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 10.43 826 19,200.00$ 1-1228 1-1250 LAKEVIEW DR. 10 295 PVC3034 10.41 827 68,900.00$ CO265 8-265 HILL ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 10.40 828 19,200.00$ 7-237 7-247A E MAIN ST 6 50 PVC 10.29 829 9,600.00$

6-1142 6-1141 SHADOW RIDGE CT 8 173.3 PVC 10.27 830 29,400.00$ 2-693 2-692 SWEDEN CIR 6 45 UNKNOWN 10.24 831 9,700.00$

0 8-921 N 1ST ST 2 100 PVC 10.23 832 19,200.00$ 1-1196 1-1197 IKE MOONEY RD. 8 313 PVC3034 10.21 833 76,100.00$ 7-848 7-299A JAY ST 8 89 PVC 10.20 834 17,100.00$

1-1191 1-1171 JODI DR. 8 280 PVC3034 10.19 835 63,300.00$ 3-920 3-119 ORCHARD ST 8 270 PVC 10.17 836 51,900.00$

1-1165 1-1164 DIVISION ST. 8 256 PVC 10.15 837 2,200.00$ 6-962 6-549 CHARLES ST 8 138 PVC 10.14 838 26,500.00$

2-1378 2-1382 SAGE ST 12 189 PVC3034 10.11 839 43,600.00$ PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 10.09 840 19,200.00$

1-1237 1-1198 SUN VALLEY AVE. 8 211 PVC3034 10.09 841 48,700.00$ 1-1249 1-1254 FRONTIER ST. 8 95 PVC3034 10.03 842 22,500.00$ 9-1157 9-1156 S WATER ST 12 473 PVC 10.01 843 88,900.00$ 2-696 2-695 DENMARK LP 8 86 PVC 9.98 844 700.00$ 6-536 6-535 EUREKA AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 9.96 845 22,600.00$ 2-688 2-687 NORWAY AVE 8 80 PVC 9.95 846 19,000.00$

1-1212 1-1227 PIONEER DR 10 373 PVC3034 9.95 847 85,700.00$ 0 0 N 1ST ST 4 100 PVC 9.92 848 19,200.00$

1-1166 1-1164 BUCKSKIN PL (PVT) 8 70 PVC3034 9.85 849 13,400.00$ 1-1224 1-1225 PIONEER DR 10 269 PVC3034 9.76 850 60,800.00$ 1-1290 1-817 CHIKAMIN LP 8 56 PVC 9.75 851 13,300.00$ 7-845 0 KLOSHE CT 8 100 UNKNOWN 9.75 852 19,200.00$ 2-945 2-944 HILLSDALE LN 8 117 PVC 9.74 853 26,400.00$ 1-971 1-970 KALAPUYA DR 8 175 PVC3034 9.73 854 43,400.00$

1-1162 1-1161 WAGON WHEEL CT. 8 207 PVC 9.71 855 39,800.00$ 1-1226 1-1212 PIONEER DR 10 123 PVC3034 9.70 856 28,700.00$ 1-1145 1-1146 ENSTAD CT. 8 83 PVC 9.66 857 14,100.00$

802 801 RESERVE ST 8 244 PVC 9.64 858 52,400.00$ 1-1219 1-1225 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 113 PVC3034 9.63 859 25,500.00$ 1-1241 1-1242 MEADOW AVE. 8 142 PVC3034 9.63 859 32,100.00$ 896P 897P SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 10 298 PVC 9.60 861 71,000.00$

5-590-A 5-590 WELCH ST 6 42 UNKNOWN 9.58 862 8,100.00$ 2-1358 2-1357 Wood Duck St 8 367.5 PVC3034 9.55 863 84,900.00$ 2-1362 2-1361 Webb Lake Dr. 8 356 PVC3034 9.55 863 81,300.00$ 1-1284 1-1285 Easement between Yapa St and Shelokum Driv 8 0 PVC3034 9.51 865 -$ 1-967A 1-967 TILLICUM DR 8 316 PVC3034 9.50 866 60,700.00$ 5-521-A tee Trix St to Main on McClaine 6 100 PVC3034 9.39 867 19,200.00$ 1-1144 1-1145 ENSTAD CT. 8 173 PVC 9.39 868 29,300.00$

0 0 MILL ST 6 100 PVC 9.39 869 19,200.00$ 7-618 7-617 AMES CT 6 162 PVC3034 9.38 870 34,800.00$

1-1192 1-1172 RYAN DR. 8 405 PVC3034 9.38 871 92,500.00$ 1-1247 1-1246 PIONEER DR 8 130 PVC3034 9.27 872 29,400.00$ 1-1270 1-1269 SKOOKUM DR 8 299 PVC3034 9.27 873 74,200.00$ 1-1227 1-1228 LAKEVIEW DR. 10 130 PVC3034 9.27 874 29,900.00$

PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 9.26 875 19,200.00$ 1-1286 1-1285 SHELOKUM DR 8 210 PVC3034 9.20 876 53,700.00$ 1-1282 1-1283 YAPA ST 8 385 PVC3034 9.20 877 95,500.00$ 1-188C 1-188B KOONS ST 8 124 PVC 9.17 878 26,600.00$ 1-1248 1-1247 IKE MOONEY RD. 8 252 PVC3034 9.11 879 57,600.00$ 1-1283 1-1284 YAPA ST 8 232 PVC3034 9.11 880 57,600.00$ 2-943 2-942 BREYONNA WAY 8 178 PVC 9.09 881 41,100.00$

1-1271 1-1270 SKOOKUM DR 8 280 PVC3034 9.05 882 71,500.00$ 1-1186 1-1173 RILEY DR. 8 268 PVC3034 9.04 883 65,200.00$ 1-1233 1-1234 SUN VALLEY CT. 8 256 PVC3034 9.03 884 62,900.00$ 4-1306 0 RAILWAY AVE 15 100 PVC 9.00 885 22,100.00$ 2-940 2-939 S STEELHAMMER RD 8 206 PVC 8.98 886 46,600.00$ 7-846 7-847 KLOSHE CT 8 63 PVC 8.91 887 14,200.00$ 7-179 7-619 S 2ND ST 8 421 PVC3034 8.87 888 80,900.00$ 1-963 1-188A CLIFF CT 8 138 PVC 8.80 889 1,200.00$ 6-642 6-641 ANDERSON DR 8 219 PVC 8.76 890 42,100.00$

2-Liberty CO 2-455 LIBERTY ST 8 163 PVC 8.76 891 31,300.00$ 1-1287 1-1286 SHELOKUM DR 8 210 PVC3034 8.76 892 61,400.00$

0 0 MILL ST 6 100 PVC 8.74 893 19,200.00$ 1-188B 1-188A KOONS ST 8 71.75 PVC 8.73 894 12,200.00$ 1-1223 1-1224 PIONEER DR 10 182 PVC3034 8.71 895 41,800.00$

916 915 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 38 PVC 8.67 896 9,000.00$ 915 917 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 82 PVC 8.67 896 32,000.00$

1-1220 1-1222 ELK AV 8 160 PVC3034 8.63 898 30,700.00$ 4-1302 4-1301 MONSON RD 15 350 PVC 8.60 899 95,000.00$

PCO PCO Private Streets within Silver Cliff Estates 6 100 PVC3034 8.55 900 19,200.00$ 1-1275 1-1270 YAPA ST 8 128 PVC3034 8.53 901 32,700.00$ 7-299A 7-299 JAY ST 8 163 PVC 8.52 902 31,300.00$ 1-972 1-971 EASTVIEW LN 8 330 PVC3034 8.51 903 83,100.00$

1-1269 1-1268 SHELOKUM DR 8 140 PVC3034 8.50 904 31,600.00$ 1-967 1-966 TILLICUM DR 8 254 PVC3034 8.47 905 48,800.00$ 1-968 1-969 EAST VIEW LN 8 165 PVC3034 8.44 906 38,100.00$

2-1381 2-1382 ROSEMARY WAY 8 349 PVC3034 8.43 907 80,600.00$ 1-1148 1-1147 DENTON CT 8 135 PVC 8.42 908 25,900.00$ 897P SilvertonHSPS SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 10 228 PVC 8.40 909 43,800.00$

SilvertonHSPS 896 SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 8 100 PVC 8.40 909 19,200.00$ 4-896 4-754 SILVERTON HIGH SCHOOL 8 16 PVC 8.40 909 3,100.00$ 1-970 1-967 KALAPUYA DR 8 100 PVC3034 8.38 912 19,200.00$

1-1234 1-1235 SUN VALLEY AVE. 8 240 PVC3034 8.38 913 59,000.00$ 1-1259 1-290 WALNUT WAY 8 200 PVC3034 8.37 914 33,900.00$ 1-1272 1-1271 Skookum Drive 8 302 PVC3034 8.37 915 73,500.00$ 2-1369 2-1370 Monitor Road 10 25 PVC3034 8.32 916 6,200.00$ 6-643 6-642 LOT 8 265 PVC 8.31 917 50,900.00$

1-1173 1-1172 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 286 PVC3034 8.26 918 67,800.00$ 2-699 2-697 SWEDEN CIR 8 134 PVC 8.24 919 25,700.00$

1-1194 1-1196 IKE MOONEY RD. 8 137 PVC3034 8.16 920 33,700.00$ 1-1274 1-1271 TILLICUM DR 8 143 PVC3034 8.15 921 34,800.00$ 1-1188 1-1189 TRAVIS DR. 8 262 PVC3034 8.13 922 60,500.00$

909 916 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 205 PVC 8.13 923 47,300.00$ 6-1143 6-1142 SHADOW RIDGE CT 8 199.69 PVC 8.12 924 42,900.00$ 6-559 6-547 APPLE AVE 8 100 PVC3034 8.11 925 19,200.00$ 801 800 RESERVE ST 8 100 PVC 8.11 925 21,500.00$

6-650 6-649 EDGEWOOD DR 8 111 PVC 8.10 927 21,300.00$ 1-1225 1-1226 PIONEER DR 10 107 PVC3034 8.10 928 24,200.00$ 2-1370 2-1371 Monitor Road 10 57 PVC3034 8.10 929 14,100.00$ 2-1359 2-1358 Mallard Street 8 103 PVC3034 8.10 930 23,500.00$ 6-644 6-643 LOT 8 225 PVC3034 8.01 931 43,200.00$

4-1305 4-1304 MONSON RD 15 348 PVC 8.00 932 87,200.00$ 4-1304 4-1303 MONSON RD 15 350 PVC 8.00 932 84,700.00$ 4-1303 4-1302 MONSON RD 15 350 PVC 8.00 932 87,700.00$ 6-535 6-534 EUREKA AVE 8 100 UNKNOWN 7.97 935 22,600.00$

1-1232 1-1233 Easement crossing 823 SV Ct 8 202 PVC3034 7.96 936 46,200.00$ 2-1376 2-1377 SAGE ST 12 100 PVC3034 7.94 937 18,800.00$ 1-1236 1-1237 SUN VALLEY AVE. 8 128 PVC3034 7.94 938 28,900.00$ 5-608 5-318A SILVER ST 6 47 PVC 7.93 939 9,000.00$

1-1235 1-1236 SUN VALLEY AVE. 8 147 PVC3034 7.92 940 33,600.00$ 2-1385 2-1387 Lavender St 8 138 PVC3034 7.91 941 31,200.00$ 1-1252 1-1250 FLINTLOCK ST. 8 228 PVC3034 7.86 942 52,100.00$ 6-1141 6-1140 SHADOW RIDGE CT 8 119.77 PVC 7.80 943 1,000.00$ 1-1244 1-1245 PIONEER DR 8 222 PVC3034 7.76 944 50,200.00$ 2-1386 2-1387 Ginko Court 8 231 PVC3034 7.75 945 52,200.00$ 1-60A 9-60 WESLEY ST 6 100 PVC 7.75 946 17,000.00$ 1-1230 1-1228 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 117 PVC3034 7.72 947 26,700.00$ 2-1363 2-1362 Mallard St 6 112 PVC3034 7.69 948 24,100.00$ 1-1273 1-1272 EASTVIEW LN 8 143 PVC3034 7.69 949 33,900.00$ 2-1390 2-1391 Basil St 8 142 PVC3034 7.67 950 27,300.00$ 2-1360 2-1358 Mallard Street 8 179 PVC3034 7.62 951 40,500.00$

910 911 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 0 PVC 7.61 952 -$ 911 912 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 104 PVC 7.60 953 19,500.00$ 912 913 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 52 PVC 7.60 953 9,800.00$ 913 914 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 75 PVC 7.60 953 14,100.00$ 914 916 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 93 PVC 7.60 953 17,500.00$ 908 909 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 32 PVC 7.59 957 6,000.00$

WWTP1 915 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 35 PVC 7.59 957 9,400.00$ 2-1387 2-1391 Lavender St 8 308 PVC3034 7.51 959 71,100.00$ 2-1368 2-1369 Monitor Road 10 295 PVC3034 7.48 960 70,300.00$ 4-753 4-752 SCHEMMEL LN 12 243 PVC 7.48 961 51,000.00$

2-1373 2-1368 THYME LOOP 8 126 PVC3034 7.47 962 28,500.00$ 2-1380 2-1381 ROSEMARY WAY 8 253 PVC3034 7.44 963 57,800.00$ 1-1193 1-1194 IKE MOONEY RD. 8 101 PVC3034 7.40 964 23,300.00$ 2-1388 2-1389 Nettle Court 8 164 PVC3034 7.40 965 37,500.00$ 2-1367 2-1368 Monitor Road 10 183 PVC3034 7.37 966 42,000.00$ 1-1262 9-30 OLSON RD 8 0 PVC3034 7.32 967 -$ 4-754 4-753 PINE ST 12 245 PVC 7.29 968 46,000.00$ 4-751 4-905 SCHEMMEL LN 12 291 PVC 7.29 968 54,700.00$

1-1251 1-1250 FLINTLOCK ST. 8 223 DI 7.29 970 51,000.00$ Cleanout (PrivateCleanout (Private Station Lane (Private) 6 100 PVC3034 7.23 971 19,200.00$ Cleanout (PrivateCleanout (Private Station Lane (Private) 6 100 PVC3034 7.23 971 19,200.00$ Cleanout (PrivateCleanout (Private Station Lane (Private) 6 100 PVC3034 7.23 971 19,200.00$ Cleanout (PrivateCleanout (Private Station Lane (Private) 6 100 PVC3034 7.23 971 19,200.00$

0 0 Station Lane (Private) 6 100 PVC3034 7.23 971 19,200.00$ Cleanout (PrivateCleanout (Private Station Lane (Private) 6 100 PVC3034 7.23 971 19,200.00$

6-1140 6-654 EDGEWOOD DR 8 30.34 PVC 7.20 977 5,100.00$ 4-752 4-751 SCHEMMEL LN 12 177 PVC 7.20 978 37,200.00$ 4-905 4-04 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 12 100 PVC 7.20 978 18,800.00$

1-1258 1-1259 WALNUT WAY 8 85 PVC3034 7.18 980 14,400.00$ 1-969 1-965 PUBLIC WALKWAY 8 130 PVC3034 7.18 981 31,900.00$

1-1278 1-1279 TILLICUM DR 8 166 PVC3034 7.16 982 37,900.00$ 1-1178 1-1176 GROUSE ST. 8 132 PVC3034 7.16 983 30,500.00$ 1-1179 1-1175 BISON ST. 8 137 PVC3034 7.16 983 31,300.00$ 4-904 4-903 APRIL LANE NE 8 166 PVC 7.13 985 31,900.00$

1-1257 1-1201 WALNUT WAY 8 144 PVC3034 7.13 986 27,700.00$ 1-1187 1-1188 TRAVIS DR. 8 121 PVC3034 7.02 987 27,600.00$ 2-1352 2-1353 12' W Public Easement bet. 807 and 809 Pintail 8 132 PVC3034 6.96 988 28,300.00$ 1-1231 1-1232 Easement near rear lot 803 Pioneer 8 35 PVC3034 6.96 989 7,900.00$ 2-1365 9-858 Commerce Court 8 100 PVC3034 6.95 990 19,200.00$ 1-1190 1-1189 TRAVIS DR. 8 123 PVC3034 6.94 991 28,100.00$ 1-1279 1-1280 TILLICUM DR 8 252 PVC3034 6.92 992 54,100.00$ 7-180 7-179 S 2ND ST 8 100 PVC3034 6.92 993 19,200.00$

1-1172 1-1171 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 264 PVC3034 6.87 994 59,700.00$ 1-205 1-204 TREES CT (PVT) 8 0 UNKNOWN 6.87 995 -$ 2-962 2-950 IOWA ST 8 400 PVC 6.83 996 76,900.00$

1-1229 1-1230 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 117 PVC3034 6.80 997 26,700.00$ 2-1392 2-211 NORWAY AVE 8 585 PVC3034 6.78 998 112,400.00$ 4-711 4-107 SHERIDAN ST 8 400 PVC3034 6.76 999 76,900.00$

1-1242 1-1244 PIONEER DR 8 180 PVC3034 6.73 1000 41,100.00$ 4-754B 4-754A PINE ST 8 187 PVC 6.71 1001 35,900.00$ 2-1389 2-1390 Basil St 8 101 PVC3034 6.70 1002 19,400.00$ 1-1276 1-1277 EASTVIEW LN 8 345 C900 6.67 1003 81,800.00$ 1-1182 1-1184 AVERY DR. 8 260 PVC3034 6.66 1004 60,000.00$ 1-1280 1-1281 TILLICUM DR 8 138 PVC3034 6.63 1005 31,200.00$ 2-1379 2-1380 ROSEMARY WAY 8 178 PVC3034 6.63 1006 40,200.00$ CO227 8-227 DIGERNESS ST 8 106 PVC 6.62 1007 20,400.00$ 7-177 7-176 S 2ND ST 8 310 PVC3034 6.60 1008 59,600.00$

1-1167 1-1166 BUCKSKIN PL (PVT) 8 173 DI 6.59 1009 33,200.00$ 1-1267 1-1266 On 20' SS-SD Pub. Esmnt on S side Lts 25-32 8 203 PVC3034 6.58 1010 46,400.00$ 1-1266 1-1266A On 20' SS-SD Pub. Esmnt on S side Lts 25-32 8 311 PVC3034 6.58 1010 70,300.00$ 2-1349 2-1350 Portion 12' W SS Pub. Easement across 702 Pin 8 179 PVC3034 6.53 1012 30,300.00$ 4-903 AprilPS APRIL LANE NE 8 24 PVC 6.51 1013 4,600.00$

AprilPS 4-754A APRIL LANE NE 4 360 PVC 6.51 1013 69,200.00$ 1-1222 1-1223 PIONEER DR 10 92 PVC3034 6.48 1015 17,700.00$ 2-1375 2-1376 SAGE ST 12 156 PVC3034 6.47 1016 29,300.00$

0 8-227-A DIGERNESS ST 4 25 PVC 6.45 1017 4,800.00$ 4-901 4-902 COX WAY 8 182 PVC 6.38 1018 30,900.00$ 4-902 4-903 APRIL LANE NE 8 121 PVC 6.38 1018 20,500.00$

1-1181 1-1182 AVERY DR. 8 82 PVC3034 6.26 1020 18,900.00$ 1-1268 1-1267 SHELOKUM DR 8 234 PVC3034 6.23 1021 50,200.00$ 1-1205 1-1207 HAWK DR. 8 211 PVC3034 6.21 1022 55,500.00$ 1-1263 1-1262 OLSON RD 8 141 PVC3034 6.16 1023 27,100.00$ 2-1295 2-1294 Four Oaks Drive 8 212 PVC3034 6.14 1024 48,400.00$ 1-1291 1-1292 12' SS easmnt NW side of 735 Chikamin Loop 8 139 PVC3034 6.11 1025 29,800.00$ 1-1288 1-1287 SHELOKUM DR 8 204 PVC3034 6.06 1026 50,100.00$ 1-1183 1-1182 TRAVIS DR. 8 130 PVC3034 6.05 1027 25,000.00$ 4-754A 4-754 PINE ST 8 164 PVC 5.96 1028 27,800.00$ 1-1264 1-1263 OLSON RD 8 203 PVC3034 5.96 1029 39,000.00$ 6-551 6-625 WELCH ST 8 100 PVC3034 5.96 1030 19,200.00$

0 5-505A WESTFIELD ST NE 6 100 PVC3034 5.90 1031 19,200.00$ 1-1238 1-1239 MEADOW AVE. 8 182 PVC3034 5.89 1032 44,300.00$ 1-1221 1-1222 PIONEER DR 10 58 PVC3034 5.85 1033 11,100.00$ 2-1351 2-1352 Pintail St 8 320 PVC3034 5.80 1034 68,700.00$ 1-1204 1-1205 HAWK DR. 8 289 PVC3034 5.79 1035 66,000.00$ 1-1210 1-1211 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 124 PVC3034 5.78 1036 28,600.00$ 1-1209 1-1210 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 262 PVC3034 5.71 1037 60,500.00$ 1-1208 1-1209 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 188 PVC3034 5.59 1038 43,400.00$ 1-1189 1-1191 JODI DR. 8 268 PVC3034 5.59 1039 61,200.00$ 2-1294 2-1293 Crestview Drive 8 137 PVC3034 5.58 1040 31,600.00$ 1-1292 1-1264 20' Public Easement on NW side 730 Chikamin 8 285 PVC3034 5.58 1041 65,100.00$ 1-1177 1-1176 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 192 PVC3034 5.52 1042 47,400.00$ 1-1277 1-972 EASTVIEW LN 8 189 PVC3034 5.51 1043 43,200.00$ 1328 3-1329 WESTERN AV NE 8 100 PVC3034 5.47 1044 19,200.00$

1-1207 1-1208 LAKEVIEW DR. 8 143 PVC3034 5.46 1045 33,000.00$ 2-1366 2-1365 Commerce Court 8 100 PVC3034 5.42 1046 19,200.00$ 5-1139 5-1138 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 PVC 5.40 1047 19,200.00$ 1-1260 1-1202 VINTAGE LN 8 168.78 PVC3034 5.38 1048 32,400.00$ 1-1243 1-1242 PIONEER DR 8 233 PVC3034 5.35 1049 52,700.00$ 1-1206 1-1205 HAWK DR. 8 137 PVC3034 5.33 1050 36,500.00$ 2-1300 2-1294 Crestview Drive 8 256 PVC3034 5.32 1051 59,100.00$ 2-1384 2-1371 Monitor Road 10 414 PVC3034 5.27 1052 95,100.00$ 2-1354 2-1352 MERGANSER ST 8 221 PVC3034 5.26 1053 50,000.00$ 2-1299 2-1300 Crestview Drive 8 98 PVC3034 5.26 1053 18,800.00$ 1-1289 1-1290 CHIKAMIN LP 8 349 PVC3034 5.22 1055 80,600.00$ 1-1217 1-1216 ELK AVE. 8 105 PVC3034 5.16 1056 24,000.00$ 2-1383 2-1384 Monior Road 10 279 PVC3034 5.13 1057 63,100.00$ 1-1195 1-1194 LITTLEBIT CT. 8 163 PVC3034 5.12 1058 38,600.00$ 1-1203 1-1204 HAWK DR. 8 96 PVC3034 5.09 1059 21,700.00$

2-963 Plug 2-962 IOWA ST 8 44 PVC3034 5.04 1060 8,500.00$ 1-1184 1-1186 RILEY DR. 8 36 PVC3034 5.03 1061 8,200.00$ 2-1374 2-1376 THYME LOOP 8 250 PVC3034 4.99 1062 48,000.00$ 1-1176 1-1175 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 451 PVC3034 4.99 1063 104,200.00$

1-1266A 1-1266 Olson Road SE fork of hammerhead 8 31 PVC3034 4.97 1064 6,000.00$ 2-1297 2-1296 Four Oaks Drive 8 301 PVC3034 4.96 1065 64,600.00$ 1-1240 1-1241 MEADOW AVE. 8 43 PVC3034 4.95 1066 9,700.00$ 5-1138 5-1137 OREGON GARDENS 8 100 PVC 4.95 1067 19,200.00$ 1-1215 1-1216 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 148 PVC3034 4.90 1068 33,800.00$ 2-1296 2-1295 Four Oaks Drive 8 72 PVC3034 4.77 1069 15,500.00$ 2-1350 2-1351 Pintail Street 8 176 PVC3034 4.69 1070 29,800.00$ 1-1216 1-1218 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 88 PVC3034 4.65 1071 20,300.00$ 1-1213 1-1214 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 180 PVC3034 4.63 1072 45,300.00$ 4-1308 4-1307 RAILWAY AVENUE 8 100 PVC 4.58 1073 19,200.00$ 6-552 6-551-A WELCH ST 8 100 UNKNOWN 4.57 1074 19,200.00$

2-1355 2-1354 MERGANSER ST 8 88 PVC3034 4.53 1075 18,900.00$ 4-1321 4-1320 FOSSHOLM ROAD 10 179.52 PVC 4.53 1075 44,300.00$ 4-1320 4-1319 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 218.62 PVC 4.53 1075 54,000.00$ 4-1319 4-1314 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 194.59 PVC 4.53 1075 48,000.00$ 4-1311 4-1310 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 185.62 PVC 4.53 1075 45,800.00$ 4-1310 4-1305 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 18.27 PVC 4.53 1075 4,600.00$ 1-1239 1-1240 MEADOW AVE. 8 403 PVC3034 4.48 1081 93,100.00$ 4-1322 4-1321 FOSSHOLM ROAD 10 400 PVC 4.39 1082 76,900.00$ 1-1174 1-1173 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 163 PVC3034 4.36 1083 39,600.00$ 1-1175 1-1174 IKE MOONEY RD. 12 231 PVC3034 4.35 1084 53,300.00$ 1-1265 1-1264 OLSON RD 8 48 PVC3034 4.23 1085 11,100.00$ 2-1353 2-1356 South SideHobart Road 8 353 PVC3034 4.23 1086 80,700.00$ 2-1298 2-1297 Pioneer Drive 8 122 PVC3034 4.21 1087 26,200.00$ 4-1312 4-1311 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 151.52 PVC 4.21 1087 36,100.00$ 4-1313 4-1312 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 340.7 PVC 3.89 1089 79,500.00$ 1-1185 1-1186 RILEY DR. 8 93 PVC3034 3.87 1090 21,000.00$ 1-1180 1-1181 AVERY DR. 8 65 PVC3034 3.81 1091 14,900.00$ 1-1218 1-1219 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 64 PVC3034 3.80 1092 14,600.00$ 1-1214 1-1215 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 107 PVC3034 3.74 1093 24,700.00$ 2-1372 2-1373 THYME LOOP 8 196 PVC3034 3.63 1094 37,700.00$ 6-555 6-555-A PHELPS ST 8 206 UNKNOWN 3.61 1095 34,900.00$

4-1314 4-1313 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 170 PVC 3.58 1096 32,700.00$ 4-1318 4-1317 On shops property south of large building 6 104 PVC3034 2.34 1097 20,000.00$ 4-1317 4-22-1/2 Bend On Shops Property south of large building 6 48 PVC3034 2.33 1098 9,200.00$ 4-1316 4-1315 Access entry to City Shops 6 178 PVC3034 2.33 1098 34,200.00$ 4-1315 Tee fitting Entry road to City Shops 6 8 PVC3034 2.33 1098 1,500.00$

Buried Stub 4-1316 N and W stub from MH at shops entry at fence 6 12 PVC3034 2.17 1101 100.00$ Buried Stub 4-1316 N and W stub from MH at shops entry at fence 6 12 PVC3034 2.17 1101 100.00$

6-524 6-523 W MAIN ST 8 100 PVC3034 1.40 1103 19,200.00$

Estimated Replacement Cost

ManholeStreet Name Material Work Priority Score Rank

1-1185 1-1186 RILEY DR. 8 93 PVC3034 3.87 1090 21,000.00$ 1-1180 1-1181 AVERY DR. 8 65 PVC3034 3.81 1091 14,900.00$ 1-1218 1-1219 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 64 PVC3034 3.80 1092 14,600.00$ 1-1214 1-1215 CENTENNIAL DR. 8 107 PVC3034 3.74 1093 24,700.00$ 2-1372 2-1373 THYME LOOP 8 196 PVC3034 3.63 1094 37,700.00$ 6-555 6-555-A PHELPS ST 8 206 UNKNOWN 3.61 1095 34,900.00$

4-1314 4-1313 SILVERTON ROAD NE 10 170 PVC 3.58 1096 32,700.00$ 4-1318 4-1317 On shops property south of large building 6 104 PVC3034 2.34 1097 20,000.00$ 4-1317 4-22-1/2 Bend On Shops Property south of large building 6 48 PVC3034 2.33 1098 9,200.00$ 4-1316 4-1315 Access entry to City Shops 6 178 PVC3034 2.33 1098 34,200.00$ 4-1315 Tee fitting Entry road to City Shops 6 8 PVC3034 2.33 1098 1,500.00$

Buried Stub 4-1316 N and W stub from MH at shops entry at fence 6 12 PVC3034 2.17 1101 100.00$ Buried Stub 4-1316 N and W stub from MH at shops entry at fence 6 12 PVC3034 2.17 1101 100.00$

6-524 6-523 W MAIN ST 8 100 PVC3034 1.40 1103 19,200.00$

PRIORITZED PIPE SEGMENT LISTPipe Diameter Pipe Length

Inlet Outlet inch diamenter feet

9-24 9-23 S WATER ST 15 394 CONC 445.58 1 98,700.00$ 9-25 9-24 S WATER ST 15 391.7 CONC 419.25 2 91,400.00$ 9-09 9-08 N WATER ST 30 202.55 CONC 413.23 3 71,700.00$ 9-311 9-26 S WATER ST 15 277.5 CONC 368.33 4 61,400.00$ 9-27 9-311 S WATER ST 15 46.7 CONC 356.25 5 7,700.00$ 9-26 9-25 S WATER ST 15 386 CONC 349.67 6 85,400.00$ 9-05 9-04 WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 301.33 DI 349.01 7 101,100.00$ 9-28 9-27 S WATER ST 15 397.1 CONC 348.17 8 83,400.00$ 9-07 9-06 N WATER ST 30 865.93 DI 331.88 9 306,400.00$ 9-08 9-07 N WATER ST 30 236.09 CONC 327.14 10 79,200.00$ 9-04 WWTP WASTE TREATMENT PLANT 30 100 DI 310.14 11 26,900.00$ 9-32 9-31 S WATER ST 15 256.9 CONC 280.08 12 58,400.00$ 9-06 9-05 PINE ST 30 456 DI 278.04 13 169,700.00$ 9-46 9-45 UNKNOWN 15 367.2 UNKNOWN 277.78 14 77,100.00$ 9-34 9-11 PINE ST 18 327 CONC 275.94 15 89,200.00$ 9-22 9-21 S WATER ST 18 250.3 CONC 271.83 16 68,300.00$

9-46-A 9-46 LONE OAKS LP 15 323 CONC 267.12 17 60,700.00$

Estimated Replacement Cost

ManholeStreet Name Material Work Priority Score Rank

Risk Based Prioritized Asset List:

RISK REGISTER

Page 40: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score
Page 41: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

41

Data Standardization

•Standardize naming conventions for GIS data fields (data dictionary) •Decide to use All

CAPS or not •Spelling

•Verify all wanted info has a field

•Verify fields set up appropriately for calculations •Year field is number •Appropriate use of

text fields •rim values must be a

number field

Data Clean up

•Add New •Update Existing •QA/QC Database •Remove Null and

Unknown values •Perform routine

maintenance and updates on practices and procedures and data

Analysis

•Perform Geoprocessing Analysis (map production)

•Get Risk Scores •establish scoring

criterea •agree on criterea with

operatives •develop calculation

sheets •implement

calculation sheets •truth test •apply to map

Verification

•Verify analysis results •Double Check Database •Clean up if possible

Cartography

•Use Analysis to create Heat Map

Final Product

•Final Risk Evaluation •Planning material to

move forward •apply planning

process

OUTPUT Heat Maps

Prioritized Work List

Page 42: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

resultant nessie curve

Page 43: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

investment strategies

Qu 14 & 15

Page 44: TURNING DATA INTO KNOWLEDGE · Probability Of Failure Score x x x Score based on asset age, use, maintenance and condition. Faster system score (POF) Consequence Of Failure Score

Thank you for listening

• Questions • Ideas • Thoughts • Comments

#+*@#!

2735 Alvarado Terrace S, Salem OR 97302 phone: 360 901 1564 e-mail [email protected]

Qu 16