trade unions in the eu - hans böckler stiftung · trade unions in the eu: ... additional divide...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
www.wsi.de
Trade Unions in the EU: National Retreat or Mobilising for Social Europe?
Dr. Heiner Dribbusch WSI, Düsseldorf
WSI Summer School 22 – 26 September 2014, Berlin
![Page 2: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
I. The European trade union landscape
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 2
![Page 3: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The ETUC Foundation in 1973 (17 affiliates in 15 countries,
29 million members)
Today
85 affiliated confederations from 36 countries
10 European trade union federations
representing some 60 million members
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 3
![Page 4: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Organisation of ETUC Congress: every four years (last 2011),
delegates according to size of affiliates
Executive council: meets four times a year; members delegated according to size of affiliates
Steering committee: 21 members elected by EC
Secretariat: day to day business: General secretary, 2 deputy GS, 3 confederal secretaries
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 4
![Page 5: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Staffing and finances
The ETUC has about 50 + staff (plus some 60 staff at ETUI)
Partly financed by affiliation fees (2010: €161 per 1,000 members in the top range and about a quarter of that for CEE unions)
Substantial payments come from the Commission (e.g. €10 million in 2009/2010 for ETUI)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 5
![Page 6: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Different national union landscapes (in brackets number of ETUC affiliates)
One single confederation covering all or almost all employees:
Austria, Ireland, Latvia, Slovakia, UK, close to this: Germany (1), Greece (2, public/private divide), Slovenia (1),
Divisions along manual/non-manual and educational lines:
Denmark (3), Finland (3), Norway (3), Sweden (3), partly Estonia (2)
Divisions along (historical) ideological/religious-lines:
Belgium (3), Cyprus (3), the Czech Republic (1), France (5), Hungary (6), Italy (3), Lithuania (3), Luxembourg (2), Malta (3), the Netherlands (3), Poland (3), Portugal (2), Romania (4), Spain (3), Switzerland (2)
CEE countries: additional divide between unions which are based on former state unions and those which grew from opposition
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 6
![Page 7: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
The largest confederations > 4 million members:
DGB (Germany), 6.1 million members; TUC (UK), 5.9; CGIL (Italy) 5.7
million (of which 3 million pensioners); CISL (Italy) 4.5 million (more than
50% pensioners)
between 1 and 2 million:
UIL (Italy), 2.2 million; LO (Sweden), 1.5 million; TCO (Sweden), 1.2 million;
UGT (Spain), 1.2 million; CCOO (Spain), 1.1 million; LO (Denmark), 1.1
million;
less than 100.000: Bulgarian, Estonian, Lithuanian, Luxembourgian,
Slovakian, Maltese confederations
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 7
![Page 8: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
European Trade Union Federations formerly known as European Industry Federations Associations of unions, organized by sectors ETUFs differ largely in size The biggest are: EPSU, public services, ~ 8 million members, ~ 210 affiliates, 23 staff IndustriALL European Trade Union, manufacturing, ~7.1 million
members, ~200 affiliates, 27 staff Uni Europa – various service sectors; ~ 7 million, ~320 affiliates
ETUFs have in total > 1.500 affiliates huge differences in size, largest are: IG Metall and ver.di with some 2 million members each
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 8
![Page 9: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Union density & bargaining coverage
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe
Source: WSI, based on ICTWSS and national sources Note: data mostly as of 2010; data for Portugal, Spain and Greece are questionable – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is about 32% (incl. public sector)
9
![Page 10: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Bargaining coverage & union density
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 10
![Page 11: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
II. Tasks of unions
“What are we here for”
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 11
![Page 12: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Diminish competition between workers Improving working conditions
(and living conditions) Provide help and advice Organise mutual support Principle: „better together“
Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 12 25/09/2014
![Page 13: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
III. Which interests do unions represent?
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 13
![Page 14: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Members ? Class ? Society ?
Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 14 25/09/2014
![Page 15: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
IV. The levels / arenas of union activity
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 15
![Page 16: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
International Nation state Industry / sector Work place Individual member
Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 16 25/09/2014
![Page 17: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Break
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 17
![Page 18: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
What do unions do at the given level ? Who are their interlocutors /
bargaining opponents ? How would you rank that level of
activity ?
Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 18 25/09/2014
![Page 19: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
5 levels of union action 1) Europe
lobbying, campaigning; acting within supranational insitutions 2) Germany
talking to national government, trans-national campaigns; 3) Industry or economic sector
collective bargaining; acting within the system of collective bargaining
4) Establishment or company collective bargaining; supporting and counseling works councils;
organizing and recruitment 5) Individual member
individual support and counseling; legal advice and legal aid in all workplace or social security related disputes;
Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 19 25/09/2014
![Page 20: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
The nation state as main arena
Trade unions are predominately organised along nation states
Here they usually have a legal status and retain some
institutional powers
tripartite consultation, collective bargaining, industrial action and
workplace representation
However, scope and levels of bargaining differ considerable
between countries (take the examples of France, Germany
and Romania)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 20
![Page 21: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
The nation state as main arena
Trade unions are predominately organised along nation states
Here they usually have a legal status and retain some
institutional powers
tripartite consultation, collective bargaining, industrial action and
workplace representation
However, scope and levels of bargaining differ considerable
between countries (take the examples of France, Germany
and Romania)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 21
![Page 22: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
The European arena I
There is no European collective bargaining
A meaningful transnational coordination of collective
bargaining has to struggle with differing enthusiasm
of national unions
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 22
![Page 23: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
The European arena II
The so-called social dialogue is limited by its largely
voluntaristic character
The European counterparts of the unions
BUSINESSEUROPE (private sector) and CEEP (public
sector) are even less able to make commitments which oblige
their affiliates
Many employers’ associations refuse to enter into a
meaningful dialogue with trade unions, others are not
representative
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 23
![Page 24: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
V. Unions and European Union
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 24
![Page 25: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Key dates 1985-1995: Jacques Delors’ presidencies of European commission
Single European Act (SEA) 1986, Treaty of Maastricht in 1992 (including social chapter)
Delors aim: integrate the unions to give single market additional legitimacy (R.Hyman: ‘social gloss’)
> in exchange for giving the single market their approval unions were promised the institutionalization of ‘social dialogue’ with the ETUC
and the ETUFs as ‘social partners’;
Hope for upward harmonization
1994 directive on European Works Councils
1995 Stability and Growth Pact > staged introduction of Euro
2004 Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe (TCE), 2005 rejected in France and the Netherlands
2007 Lisbon Treaty, replaced TCE
2007/2008 Rulings by European Court of Justice: Viking, Laval, Rüffert, established hierarchy of norms, market
freedom was giving priority before social rights
2010 EU 2020
2011 ‘Six Pack’; Euro Plus Pact
2012 Fiscal Compact
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 25
![Page 26: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
‘Yes but …’ or ‘no, unless …’?
ETUC approved the treaties from Maastricht to Lisbon regarding its partial involvement as an opportunity anxious not be depicted as anti-European
Unions were initially more divided but most critics eventually moved from ‘no, because’ (e.g. CGT) or ‘no unless’ (some Nordic unions) to a ‘yes, but’ or ‘yes, and’ position (early e.g. DGB, Italian confederations)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 26
![Page 27: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Competing logics
Logic of membership and logic of influence
Hyman (2005): balancing the two is difficult
By adapting their strategies to the EU decision making process
and to compromise only for the sake of remaining in the game
unions run the risk of loosing their representative credentials in
the eyes of their constituency
Danger of an ‘elitist embrace’ (Hyman 2005)
‘Europe’ is mainly the business of full-time specialists within trade
unions
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 27
![Page 28: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Progress requires contention
Influence of unions is diluted without a readiness to
say ‘no’ Without the capacity to counteract their role within the
policy-making process runs the danger of being reduced to collective begging
Political considerations shape opposition or support: e.g. unions are often less prepared to oppose social-
democratic than conservative governments Acceptance of the paradigm of competitiveness
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 28
![Page 29: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
VI. Different interests between unions
Three examples
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 29
![Page 30: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Port Package Campaigns
The eventually successful campaign against the directive to deregulate port work (2003-2006) was not supported by Italian unions what was opposed by the other unions was already
practice in Italian ports fear for protectionism by ‚Northern‘ unions and
harbour companies
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 30
![Page 31: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Debate on a European minimum wage
Scandinavian unions are opposed to a European minimum wage fear of loosing their bargaining autonomy fear of creating a wage floor which puts pressure on
higher wages fear of weakening the incentive of workers to join
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 31
![Page 32: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
European citizens‘ initiative
At the latest ETUC congress 2011 in Athens The Swiss unions proposed to launch a European
citizens‘ initiative for a Europe without wage and social dumping
This was successfully opposed by DGB and all French confederations on the grounds of being ineffective and to bureaucratic and proposed a comprehensive campaign instead behind this argument stood scepticism towards the instrument as
such the Swiss unions on the other hand argued with their experience
in such initiatives
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 32
![Page 33: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
VII. ‘Mobilising for social Europe’
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 33
![Page 34: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Mobilising capacities ETUC depends on the good-will of the affiliated
confederations
Some confederations have autonomous mobilising capacities
Other confederations are largely representative bodies which entirely depend on affiliates
ETUFs: dependend on affiliates
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 34
![Page 35: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Mobilising in Europe
► Mobilising in Europe depends on the willingness and capacity of the unions and their leadership to act
► This in turn depends on their activists and members willingness to act
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 35
![Page 36: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Prerequisites of social mobilization
Common interests Shared perception of injustice Shared sense of European vulnerability
framing of conflict is decisive
Perceived effectiveness of collective action Appropriate organisation
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 36
![Page 37: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe
Shared perception of crisis? Eurobarometer survey November 2012 Perception of national economy („rather good“ + „very good“ in %)
75 75 70
65
55 53
44 42 38
31 27
24 20 19 17
12 11 11 9 9 8 7 7 7 6 2 1
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
in %
Quelle: Standard Eurobarometer.
37
![Page 38: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
VII. Is there a chance for joint action?
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 38
![Page 39: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Break
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 39
![Page 40: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe
How to build coalitions and avoid
blockades between: Those who do not want to do rather
nothing Those who are prepared to do something Those who want radical action ?
40
![Page 41: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe
Balance between structural determinism
and voluntarism What is thinkable? (and desirable) Please: neither mysticism nor ‘musticism’
41
![Page 42: Trade Unions in the EU - Hans Böckler Stiftung · Trade Unions in the EU: ... additional divide between unions which are based on former ... – e.g. current PT barg. coverage is](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022051801/5ade22597f8b9a213e8db747/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Thank you for listening!
Dr. Heiner Dribbusch Senior researcher
WSI, Germany [email protected]
25/09/2014 Heiner Dribbusch - Trade Unions in Europe 42