tichmic a l iiemorandujfconnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a...

12
I r I TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJf TO : Michael NU1pinak1, Jt.PX ftOKJ David Bn•ley, PM DA'l'ZI Pebruary 23, 1U3 U1 Lin...ltU IVitcb COrp, PudbiUty ltudy {18) R ..pon•• CCI LyMa Jenninql ... DA Gary X.nnat'C. ... I.inaaa•tar Ma011i David.aon - D!P Letlia lfhita - D!P Al aait.h - MUr'tha, CUllina, Riohtar ' Pinn.y on February 11, 1193 a aea ti09 waa bald. at Linau•tar to clbcuaa t.ha oo.a.ntl ot tha AcJenoy on t.ha 11. bong tha it... diJcuaaK vaa tba need tor ..bdona control on tba exbtin9 air atripper an4 on tP propoaed. toil vapor extract i on (l'n) 1y1tu. Tb• A;anoy advieed that an OSWD. Diraotiva dated Juna 15, lilt, apeciti&l air dhoharv• liw.ita tor o1one praaur1or1 (Chlorinated hyVocarbona •.ant other) in oaona nonatt&inaent ar..a to 3 ll:l/hr' or 15 ll:I/4&Y or 10 tpy . In ad41tion, 40 c:nt 214 Subpart U liaita ut.lion• to 10 partl per aillion 'by weight in air without traatuftt. 'l'ba PI pl'opoalld that no oft-;&1 traatw.ant be included on tha ubtint' tntaria Ruaval Traatuftt lyatea (IRTI) air atripper. controh Kau included tor the propoaed IVZ ayat... 'l'he AV•noY requaatecl that ruaa i O'Neill datanine tha actual aM propoaed rataa of ..i .. iona troa the air atrippar and the lVI ayata, caloulata the ooet of aontroll, and evaluate the need tor controla. The A;engy a11o raqu..ted olarirication of the coat tor uialion control• (carbon filtration) davelope,d in the S&Mitivi ty Al\alyda ahovn ot tha rs . Rather than aod.ity tha text of the PI, and to maintain the tchadule aatablbhacl by · the ArJanay, the intorution qanarated waa to be ..) · -- 3.1:,. 1/ .... - 2 =

Upload: others

Post on 06-Dec-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r I

TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJf

TO Michael NU1pinak1 JtPX

ftOKJ David Bnbullley PM

DAlZI Pebruary 23 1U3

U1 LinltU IVitcb COrp PudbiUty ltudy 18) Rponbullbull

CCI LyMa Jenninql DA Gary XnnatC Iinaaabulltar Ma011i Davidaon - DP Letlia lfhita - DP Al aaith - MUrtha CUllina Riohtar Pinny

on February 11 1193 a aeati09 waa bald at Linaubulltar to clbcuaa tha ooantl ot tha AcJenoy on tha 11 bong tha it diJcuaaK vaa tba need tor bdona control on tba exbtin9 air atripper an4 on tP propoaed toil vapor extracti on (ln) 1y1tu Tbbull Aanoy advieed that an OSWD Diraotiva dated Juna 15 lilt apecitiampl air

dhoharvbull liwita tor o1one praaur1or1 (Chlorinated hyVocarbona

bullant other) in oaona nonattampinaent ara to 3 lllhr or 15 llI4ampY

or 10 tpy In ad41tion 40 cnt 214 Subpart U liaita utlionbull to 10 partl per aillion (PJIII~ by weight in air without traatuftt

lba PI plopoalld that no oft-amp1 traatwant be included on tha ubtint tntaria Ruaval Traatuftt lyatea (IRTI) air atripper controh Kau included tor the propoaed IVZ ayat lhe AVbullnoY requaatecl that ruaa i ONeill datanine tha actual aM propoaed rataa of i iona troa the air atrippar and the lVI ayata caloulata the ooet of aontroll and evaluate the need tor controla The Aengy a11o raquted olarirication of the coat tor uialion controlbull (carbon filtration) daveloped in the SampMitivity Alalyda ahovn in~ ot tha rs

Rather than aodity tha text of the PI and to maintain the tchadule aatablbhacl by middotthe ArJanay the intorution qanarated waa to be

)

middot-shy

31 1

-2 =

~middotmiddot

I r -

r

Teohnicd Meaoranduar Michael lfalipinaki RPM Pabruary 23 1113 Pa9a 2

oswn Diraativa naso-21 indicataa that voc controb abould ba requind tor aourcaa with tao111tybullw14a aabdcna in axcaaa ot 3 pouncla per hour in obullona nonattampinaant arua Tbua oontrola would not apacifically be required by thia Giraative rbamp 41raot1va 1110 atataa that ita control lavh ara not intandad to preclude or rapheamp ltata propola for aora atringent hvela of control in punuit of Clean Air Act oala aa part ot liP ravtaiona 111 nonattainnt araaabull

Connecticut r equlltiona would thuat ora conatituta a ora l tringant lavel a ot control for ~ entire f acility 1n thi a ca btlcaua controb would M r~~qUired for tlla aoll gaa aptu btlyon4 thoaa iapoaed by any other federal ARAAa i n tha abeenca of l Ute

r evulationa 1amprther oontrola on tha air atrippint ayatua ara not varrantcS by any state or Peder ll JJtUa

suraquopart AA Mta etndarcle or attectect proae11 vente ociated vith diltillation traotionatian thin-ua evaporat ion aol vant uuaation or air or at ltripping operationbull aanav1n9 haaamprdaua vaataa vith 019ampni a oancentratiana of at let 10 ppv All vanta to which the atanc1arda apply auat aithu reduce total orqani o n i aaion trobull all aff aotad vanta to laaa than 3 pauMa par hour and 3 1 tona par year or i natall oont rol davicampl to r educe arvania

bullbullhaiona trOll all affactad vents by 95 percent

U can be a aan froa ~ neither thamp Interibull Raoval lraablant lyataa amptripper nor the faciltiy water aupply atr1ppar (coabinad contact waatavatar at 10 ppaw or qraatar and thua tha atanctard 1a

no~ applicable to ~ha aaurcaa Purthanora their abdon rataamp

13-1 0 1 SSI1I Ucl6i E0 E6 EZ B3J

I r -

rAONdUlnc

J

rechnical xaorandua Michaal lfalipinaki RPM Pabruary 23 1tiiJ Pa9a 3

ara vall below tha rata r~tqU1te4 by tha atan4ard of l pounda par hoU and would tharafora be in ooapliana evan if the atandard van daued nlavant and appropriate

In tha pruabla to 1lbpart AA (D Vol II bulla 120 p aampUa) KPA

canddared facilitiea that aana9a vary low concentration Orqanio vaataa and vroun4water r-ediation ayat fpeoitically 1

aonoludinv that 7aoilitiaa with orqania bullbulliiona froa procaaa vanta that do not exoc thua abaion ratabull will not hava to inatall controla or anitor nbdona troa atrecua proeaaa vente The quantity ot abdoM and tha riak aoo iated with air

atrippra trt inq atraau with concentration- below 10 ppaw aay M

relatively nall thu a inbhin9 tha pot ential huJII ot datarrinc) shycontrol until a later tiaa -iii ror the aoil vapor aamptraction ayata SUbpart AA doae not appear to = apply beoaua it b not cma of tha lbted proaaaaa and HcauH = U bull~middot would 1M in vapor pllaaa at ita point ot 9anaration It

Mould be notS howavezo that conceptual daain inolud~ carbon aclaorption that will r~ voce to non-datact lavala

ottGee piegbemt Bltea

In tht r1 lite altunatiwa vera davel~ by coal)ininq source control (IC) and lliqration XampnampIJnt (KPI) tachnoloCJilbull to adctrbull

xlth aoil and CJZOundvatar contaaintion Ihlll ampltarnativaa a4ctrbull tha contuination lgtOth outdde of and below tha pr041lction

facility for attactivenaaa implaaantaJIility amprut coat Because

than b an operatinCJ qroundwatar traataant 1yatam the axiatinCJ

middot---shy

r -I

lachnical orandwa Michael tfalipinaki RPM February 23 1tt3 4

air atrippinq ayatu vaa ratainS for all tour lite Altrnativaa 1ha tour eite alternativebull ara

IAbulll No Action (Qround-Watu Collaction and Traatant)

IA-2 Containaent (Ground-Water Collection and rraataant)

Ubulll Vaeuua Ektraction (oround-Watar Collection and Traatunt)

Ubull4 Ai~ IPU9inq (Ground-Water COllection and Traatant)

Tha praUainary daaiqna davaloped in tha 11 ~ car~n

Uozoption tor offbullqu trutaent on tha ava ayatu lacauaa lloth

shy2 the rata and aaaa of uiaaiona ara very low in tha air atrippiJ9 ayatu and Hoaua tha ryat have bean pnittad ~ tha Cl DIP = Vithout -~aaion oontrale no eaiaaion11 oontroh coat aatiutaa = vwa 4evelopecl in tha ra excapt in tU lanaitivity Analyaia

U1LJ attaobed auaarhaa tha bulliaaicma froa the ayat that

an CNZTently operatinq at tha aita lfotal bullbeiona fro the two exbtinq air aUippera one to trut tha plant vatu aupply tha other h part of u Interb aaova1 Trtaent ayeta (IJlH) ara

OOat lbhl 0 17 lbday and toUl bulluch leea than the CIWD Action Liaita ot 3 lbhr and 15 lbfday

To aval-ampta tha potnthl dboharge at voca troa tba propoaed aoil

vapor extraction ayat (lVI) analytical 4ata troa tiva Of ~middot

anitorinq vella irlatall~ in tba Jonbull 1 area vera uuinad and the

Yorat oaae -iaaion rate wae eatbatad tor thaaa tiva vaUa

Tbia worat ca nta would H ona that would ba axpactad to axiat

-

- r -

TAitl 1

V0C DIIIIIOlfl

IRlS AIR ITIIPPIR- Zata~ xgs (YS~lll Z1IDLLmllll ~ lbbr lbdaY

Jan IS 4511 15200 ooa on Dec llov

92 9715 710

IJUO tuso

003 ooa

on ou

Oo~ lept

IUl 1510

92410 77040

003 0 02

011 0

~Iy 17706 30657

40320 40101

ooa 004

0 60 104

Avenge 0021 066

PACILIlY WAlD SUPPLY STkiPPD

Total infllant VOCbull prior to IMI atartllp in rune 1112

r eb U lOU U9l

April U 2101 ucr1

JW1 U U32 Wl1

Avrage aH4 1Jo9l

Total voe laiaaiona (2500 gpcl) bull 005 lbday

Total intluent VOCbull attar IJllll atartup 1n rune 1112

Aamp9 U 670 1Jo9l

Oct 12 11

Deo ta 270 U9l

468 U9l

TCgtUl VOC llliooiono (2500 9cent) bull 0 01 lbday

-j~ middot-shyd

- r -

J

1achnical Meaorandua Michael Ralipinalti UK Pabruary 2J 1993bullbull9bull 5 for approxiaataly 10 daya (baaS on intorution davalopad durinq the bencbbullacal8 taatinq) than Hqin to ctaclina at a rata aiJlilar to other lVI ayatua

lVI DIIIIIONS

1AllJQ yos bheipn Bftt (lbbrl

DWbulllt 0 301

DWmiddot2t QQOIi

DWoo3t 0 003

OW-4t 0024

ow-st ~

TOTAL 0 404 r-AVDAGI oou -ii = The nlll lilted above are located nur the ori9inal aourca of = HlMH of VOCe Canaequently virtuelly all 01har nlla will

diaabaqe VOC at a lowv rata lf hypotlaatically all or tba pnpoeed 40 vapor axtracrtion walla 41110ba19ed VOC at tha above aqraqa rata oontimaolampaly frGa~ tartup tha total rata would lie

only 32 ~hr 1be In yta bullbull outlined in Ula r1 would howvu inclwa bull bulliaaiou conUol to reduce tha rata of 4habarga to a non-dataot l aval

coaraquoininq all tha 411ollartaa without a1111ona contlol would raault in a poibla worat caaa acenario of a total dboharqa of

voca of 333 lbbr (77 5 lltday) or thb total 1511 percent wOuld or i 9inata troa thbull vz bullYbullta (cludnq tha Urat rev weeki ot opratiotl) an4 1bullbullbull than one ~rcent would bull the reult ot air 1t1 ippinq Conaequently it would be neceary to bullpend at lea1t

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 2: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r -

r

Teohnicd Meaoranduar Michael lfalipinaki RPM Pabruary 23 1113 Pa9a 2

oswn Diraativa naso-21 indicataa that voc controb abould ba requind tor aourcaa with tao111tybullw14a aabdcna in axcaaa ot 3 pouncla per hour in obullona nonattampinaant arua Tbua oontrola would not apacifically be required by thia Giraative rbamp 41raot1va 1110 atataa that ita control lavh ara not intandad to preclude or rapheamp ltata propola for aora atringent hvela of control in punuit of Clean Air Act oala aa part ot liP ravtaiona 111 nonattainnt araaabull

Connecticut r equlltiona would thuat ora conatituta a ora l tringant lavel a ot control for ~ entire f acility 1n thi a ca btlcaua controb would M r~~qUired for tlla aoll gaa aptu btlyon4 thoaa iapoaed by any other federal ARAAa i n tha abeenca of l Ute

r evulationa 1amprther oontrola on tha air atrippint ayatua ara not varrantcS by any state or Peder ll JJtUa

suraquopart AA Mta etndarcle or attectect proae11 vente ociated vith diltillation traotionatian thin-ua evaporat ion aol vant uuaation or air or at ltripping operationbull aanav1n9 haaamprdaua vaataa vith 019ampni a oancentratiana of at let 10 ppv All vanta to which the atanc1arda apply auat aithu reduce total orqani o n i aaion trobull all aff aotad vanta to laaa than 3 pauMa par hour and 3 1 tona par year or i natall oont rol davicampl to r educe arvania

bullbullhaiona trOll all affactad vents by 95 percent

U can be a aan froa ~ neither thamp Interibull Raoval lraablant lyataa amptripper nor the faciltiy water aupply atr1ppar (coabinad contact waatavatar at 10 ppaw or qraatar and thua tha atanctard 1a

no~ applicable to ~ha aaurcaa Purthanora their abdon rataamp

13-1 0 1 SSI1I Ucl6i E0 E6 EZ B3J

I r -

rAONdUlnc

J

rechnical xaorandua Michaal lfalipinaki RPM Pabruary 23 1tiiJ Pa9a 3

ara vall below tha rata r~tqU1te4 by tha atan4ard of l pounda par hoU and would tharafora be in ooapliana evan if the atandard van daued nlavant and appropriate

In tha pruabla to 1lbpart AA (D Vol II bulla 120 p aampUa) KPA

canddared facilitiea that aana9a vary low concentration Orqanio vaataa and vroun4water r-ediation ayat fpeoitically 1

aonoludinv that 7aoilitiaa with orqania bullbulliiona froa procaaa vanta that do not exoc thua abaion ratabull will not hava to inatall controla or anitor nbdona troa atrecua proeaaa vente The quantity ot abdoM and tha riak aoo iated with air

atrippra trt inq atraau with concentration- below 10 ppaw aay M

relatively nall thu a inbhin9 tha pot ential huJII ot datarrinc) shycontrol until a later tiaa -iii ror the aoil vapor aamptraction ayata SUbpart AA doae not appear to = apply beoaua it b not cma of tha lbted proaaaaa and HcauH = U bull~middot would 1M in vapor pllaaa at ita point ot 9anaration It

Mould be notS howavezo that conceptual daain inolud~ carbon aclaorption that will r~ voce to non-datact lavala

ottGee piegbemt Bltea

In tht r1 lite altunatiwa vera davel~ by coal)ininq source control (IC) and lliqration XampnampIJnt (KPI) tachnoloCJilbull to adctrbull

xlth aoil and CJZOundvatar contaaintion Ihlll ampltarnativaa a4ctrbull tha contuination lgtOth outdde of and below tha pr041lction

facility for attactivenaaa implaaantaJIility amprut coat Because

than b an operatinCJ qroundwatar traataant 1yatam the axiatinCJ

middot---shy

r -I

lachnical orandwa Michael tfalipinaki RPM February 23 1tt3 4

air atrippinq ayatu vaa ratainS for all tour lite Altrnativaa 1ha tour eite alternativebull ara

IAbulll No Action (Qround-Watu Collaction and Traatant)

IA-2 Containaent (Ground-Water Collection and rraataant)

Ubulll Vaeuua Ektraction (oround-Watar Collection and Traatunt)

Ubull4 Ai~ IPU9inq (Ground-Water COllection and Traatant)

Tha praUainary daaiqna davaloped in tha 11 ~ car~n

Uozoption tor offbullqu trutaent on tha ava ayatu lacauaa lloth

shy2 the rata and aaaa of uiaaiona ara very low in tha air atrippiJ9 ayatu and Hoaua tha ryat have bean pnittad ~ tha Cl DIP = Vithout -~aaion oontrale no eaiaaion11 oontroh coat aatiutaa = vwa 4evelopecl in tha ra excapt in tU lanaitivity Analyaia

U1LJ attaobed auaarhaa tha bulliaaicma froa the ayat that

an CNZTently operatinq at tha aita lfotal bullbeiona fro the two exbtinq air aUippera one to trut tha plant vatu aupply tha other h part of u Interb aaova1 Trtaent ayeta (IJlH) ara

OOat lbhl 0 17 lbday and toUl bulluch leea than the CIWD Action Liaita ot 3 lbhr and 15 lbfday

To aval-ampta tha potnthl dboharge at voca troa tba propoaed aoil

vapor extraction ayat (lVI) analytical 4ata troa tiva Of ~middot

anitorinq vella irlatall~ in tba Jonbull 1 area vera uuinad and the

Yorat oaae -iaaion rate wae eatbatad tor thaaa tiva vaUa

Tbia worat ca nta would H ona that would ba axpactad to axiat

-

- r -

TAitl 1

V0C DIIIIIOlfl

IRlS AIR ITIIPPIR- Zata~ xgs (YS~lll Z1IDLLmllll ~ lbbr lbdaY

Jan IS 4511 15200 ooa on Dec llov

92 9715 710

IJUO tuso

003 ooa

on ou

Oo~ lept

IUl 1510

92410 77040

003 0 02

011 0

~Iy 17706 30657

40320 40101

ooa 004

0 60 104

Avenge 0021 066

PACILIlY WAlD SUPPLY STkiPPD

Total infllant VOCbull prior to IMI atartllp in rune 1112

r eb U lOU U9l

April U 2101 ucr1

JW1 U U32 Wl1

Avrage aH4 1Jo9l

Total voe laiaaiona (2500 gpcl) bull 005 lbday

Total intluent VOCbull attar IJllll atartup 1n rune 1112

Aamp9 U 670 1Jo9l

Oct 12 11

Deo ta 270 U9l

468 U9l

TCgtUl VOC llliooiono (2500 9cent) bull 0 01 lbday

-j~ middot-shyd

- r -

J

1achnical Meaorandua Michael Ralipinalti UK Pabruary 2J 1993bullbull9bull 5 for approxiaataly 10 daya (baaS on intorution davalopad durinq the bencbbullacal8 taatinq) than Hqin to ctaclina at a rata aiJlilar to other lVI ayatua

lVI DIIIIIONS

1AllJQ yos bheipn Bftt (lbbrl

DWbulllt 0 301

DWmiddot2t QQOIi

DWoo3t 0 003

OW-4t 0024

ow-st ~

TOTAL 0 404 r-AVDAGI oou -ii = The nlll lilted above are located nur the ori9inal aourca of = HlMH of VOCe Canaequently virtuelly all 01har nlla will

diaabaqe VOC at a lowv rata lf hypotlaatically all or tba pnpoeed 40 vapor axtracrtion walla 41110ba19ed VOC at tha above aqraqa rata oontimaolampaly frGa~ tartup tha total rata would lie

only 32 ~hr 1be In yta bullbull outlined in Ula r1 would howvu inclwa bull bulliaaiou conUol to reduce tha rata of 4habarga to a non-dataot l aval

coaraquoininq all tha 411ollartaa without a1111ona contlol would raault in a poibla worat caaa acenario of a total dboharqa of

voca of 333 lbbr (77 5 lltday) or thb total 1511 percent wOuld or i 9inata troa thbull vz bullYbullta (cludnq tha Urat rev weeki ot opratiotl) an4 1bullbullbull than one ~rcent would bull the reult ot air 1t1 ippinq Conaequently it would be neceary to bullpend at lea1t

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 3: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r -

rAONdUlnc

J

rechnical xaorandua Michaal lfalipinaki RPM Pabruary 23 1tiiJ Pa9a 3

ara vall below tha rata r~tqU1te4 by tha atan4ard of l pounda par hoU and would tharafora be in ooapliana evan if the atandard van daued nlavant and appropriate

In tha pruabla to 1lbpart AA (D Vol II bulla 120 p aampUa) KPA

canddared facilitiea that aana9a vary low concentration Orqanio vaataa and vroun4water r-ediation ayat fpeoitically 1

aonoludinv that 7aoilitiaa with orqania bullbulliiona froa procaaa vanta that do not exoc thua abaion ratabull will not hava to inatall controla or anitor nbdona troa atrecua proeaaa vente The quantity ot abdoM and tha riak aoo iated with air

atrippra trt inq atraau with concentration- below 10 ppaw aay M

relatively nall thu a inbhin9 tha pot ential huJII ot datarrinc) shycontrol until a later tiaa -iii ror the aoil vapor aamptraction ayata SUbpart AA doae not appear to = apply beoaua it b not cma of tha lbted proaaaaa and HcauH = U bull~middot would 1M in vapor pllaaa at ita point ot 9anaration It

Mould be notS howavezo that conceptual daain inolud~ carbon aclaorption that will r~ voce to non-datact lavala

ottGee piegbemt Bltea

In tht r1 lite altunatiwa vera davel~ by coal)ininq source control (IC) and lliqration XampnampIJnt (KPI) tachnoloCJilbull to adctrbull

xlth aoil and CJZOundvatar contaaintion Ihlll ampltarnativaa a4ctrbull tha contuination lgtOth outdde of and below tha pr041lction

facility for attactivenaaa implaaantaJIility amprut coat Because

than b an operatinCJ qroundwatar traataant 1yatam the axiatinCJ

middot---shy

r -I

lachnical orandwa Michael tfalipinaki RPM February 23 1tt3 4

air atrippinq ayatu vaa ratainS for all tour lite Altrnativaa 1ha tour eite alternativebull ara

IAbulll No Action (Qround-Watu Collaction and Traatant)

IA-2 Containaent (Ground-Water Collection and rraataant)

Ubulll Vaeuua Ektraction (oround-Watar Collection and Traatunt)

Ubull4 Ai~ IPU9inq (Ground-Water COllection and Traatant)

Tha praUainary daaiqna davaloped in tha 11 ~ car~n

Uozoption tor offbullqu trutaent on tha ava ayatu lacauaa lloth

shy2 the rata and aaaa of uiaaiona ara very low in tha air atrippiJ9 ayatu and Hoaua tha ryat have bean pnittad ~ tha Cl DIP = Vithout -~aaion oontrale no eaiaaion11 oontroh coat aatiutaa = vwa 4evelopecl in tha ra excapt in tU lanaitivity Analyaia

U1LJ attaobed auaarhaa tha bulliaaicma froa the ayat that

an CNZTently operatinq at tha aita lfotal bullbeiona fro the two exbtinq air aUippera one to trut tha plant vatu aupply tha other h part of u Interb aaova1 Trtaent ayeta (IJlH) ara

OOat lbhl 0 17 lbday and toUl bulluch leea than the CIWD Action Liaita ot 3 lbhr and 15 lbfday

To aval-ampta tha potnthl dboharge at voca troa tba propoaed aoil

vapor extraction ayat (lVI) analytical 4ata troa tiva Of ~middot

anitorinq vella irlatall~ in tba Jonbull 1 area vera uuinad and the

Yorat oaae -iaaion rate wae eatbatad tor thaaa tiva vaUa

Tbia worat ca nta would H ona that would ba axpactad to axiat

-

- r -

TAitl 1

V0C DIIIIIOlfl

IRlS AIR ITIIPPIR- Zata~ xgs (YS~lll Z1IDLLmllll ~ lbbr lbdaY

Jan IS 4511 15200 ooa on Dec llov

92 9715 710

IJUO tuso

003 ooa

on ou

Oo~ lept

IUl 1510

92410 77040

003 0 02

011 0

~Iy 17706 30657

40320 40101

ooa 004

0 60 104

Avenge 0021 066

PACILIlY WAlD SUPPLY STkiPPD

Total infllant VOCbull prior to IMI atartllp in rune 1112

r eb U lOU U9l

April U 2101 ucr1

JW1 U U32 Wl1

Avrage aH4 1Jo9l

Total voe laiaaiona (2500 gpcl) bull 005 lbday

Total intluent VOCbull attar IJllll atartup 1n rune 1112

Aamp9 U 670 1Jo9l

Oct 12 11

Deo ta 270 U9l

468 U9l

TCgtUl VOC llliooiono (2500 9cent) bull 0 01 lbday

-j~ middot-shyd

- r -

J

1achnical Meaorandua Michael Ralipinalti UK Pabruary 2J 1993bullbull9bull 5 for approxiaataly 10 daya (baaS on intorution davalopad durinq the bencbbullacal8 taatinq) than Hqin to ctaclina at a rata aiJlilar to other lVI ayatua

lVI DIIIIIONS

1AllJQ yos bheipn Bftt (lbbrl

DWbulllt 0 301

DWmiddot2t QQOIi

DWoo3t 0 003

OW-4t 0024

ow-st ~

TOTAL 0 404 r-AVDAGI oou -ii = The nlll lilted above are located nur the ori9inal aourca of = HlMH of VOCe Canaequently virtuelly all 01har nlla will

diaabaqe VOC at a lowv rata lf hypotlaatically all or tba pnpoeed 40 vapor axtracrtion walla 41110ba19ed VOC at tha above aqraqa rata oontimaolampaly frGa~ tartup tha total rata would lie

only 32 ~hr 1be In yta bullbull outlined in Ula r1 would howvu inclwa bull bulliaaiou conUol to reduce tha rata of 4habarga to a non-dataot l aval

coaraquoininq all tha 411ollartaa without a1111ona contlol would raault in a poibla worat caaa acenario of a total dboharqa of

voca of 333 lbbr (77 5 lltday) or thb total 1511 percent wOuld or i 9inata troa thbull vz bullYbullta (cludnq tha Urat rev weeki ot opratiotl) an4 1bullbullbull than one ~rcent would bull the reult ot air 1t1 ippinq Conaequently it would be neceary to bullpend at lea1t

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 4: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

r -I

lachnical orandwa Michael tfalipinaki RPM February 23 1tt3 4

air atrippinq ayatu vaa ratainS for all tour lite Altrnativaa 1ha tour eite alternativebull ara

IAbulll No Action (Qround-Watu Collaction and Traatant)

IA-2 Containaent (Ground-Water Collection and rraataant)

Ubulll Vaeuua Ektraction (oround-Watar Collection and Traatunt)

Ubull4 Ai~ IPU9inq (Ground-Water COllection and Traatant)

Tha praUainary daaiqna davaloped in tha 11 ~ car~n

Uozoption tor offbullqu trutaent on tha ava ayatu lacauaa lloth

shy2 the rata and aaaa of uiaaiona ara very low in tha air atrippiJ9 ayatu and Hoaua tha ryat have bean pnittad ~ tha Cl DIP = Vithout -~aaion oontrale no eaiaaion11 oontroh coat aatiutaa = vwa 4evelopecl in tha ra excapt in tU lanaitivity Analyaia

U1LJ attaobed auaarhaa tha bulliaaicma froa the ayat that

an CNZTently operatinq at tha aita lfotal bullbeiona fro the two exbtinq air aUippera one to trut tha plant vatu aupply tha other h part of u Interb aaova1 Trtaent ayeta (IJlH) ara

OOat lbhl 0 17 lbday and toUl bulluch leea than the CIWD Action Liaita ot 3 lbhr and 15 lbfday

To aval-ampta tha potnthl dboharge at voca troa tba propoaed aoil

vapor extraction ayat (lVI) analytical 4ata troa tiva Of ~middot

anitorinq vella irlatall~ in tba Jonbull 1 area vera uuinad and the

Yorat oaae -iaaion rate wae eatbatad tor thaaa tiva vaUa

Tbia worat ca nta would H ona that would ba axpactad to axiat

-

- r -

TAitl 1

V0C DIIIIIOlfl

IRlS AIR ITIIPPIR- Zata~ xgs (YS~lll Z1IDLLmllll ~ lbbr lbdaY

Jan IS 4511 15200 ooa on Dec llov

92 9715 710

IJUO tuso

003 ooa

on ou

Oo~ lept

IUl 1510

92410 77040

003 0 02

011 0

~Iy 17706 30657

40320 40101

ooa 004

0 60 104

Avenge 0021 066

PACILIlY WAlD SUPPLY STkiPPD

Total infllant VOCbull prior to IMI atartllp in rune 1112

r eb U lOU U9l

April U 2101 ucr1

JW1 U U32 Wl1

Avrage aH4 1Jo9l

Total voe laiaaiona (2500 gpcl) bull 005 lbday

Total intluent VOCbull attar IJllll atartup 1n rune 1112

Aamp9 U 670 1Jo9l

Oct 12 11

Deo ta 270 U9l

468 U9l

TCgtUl VOC llliooiono (2500 9cent) bull 0 01 lbday

-j~ middot-shyd

- r -

J

1achnical Meaorandua Michael Ralipinalti UK Pabruary 2J 1993bullbull9bull 5 for approxiaataly 10 daya (baaS on intorution davalopad durinq the bencbbullacal8 taatinq) than Hqin to ctaclina at a rata aiJlilar to other lVI ayatua

lVI DIIIIIONS

1AllJQ yos bheipn Bftt (lbbrl

DWbulllt 0 301

DWmiddot2t QQOIi

DWoo3t 0 003

OW-4t 0024

ow-st ~

TOTAL 0 404 r-AVDAGI oou -ii = The nlll lilted above are located nur the ori9inal aourca of = HlMH of VOCe Canaequently virtuelly all 01har nlla will

diaabaqe VOC at a lowv rata lf hypotlaatically all or tba pnpoeed 40 vapor axtracrtion walla 41110ba19ed VOC at tha above aqraqa rata oontimaolampaly frGa~ tartup tha total rata would lie

only 32 ~hr 1be In yta bullbull outlined in Ula r1 would howvu inclwa bull bulliaaiou conUol to reduce tha rata of 4habarga to a non-dataot l aval

coaraquoininq all tha 411ollartaa without a1111ona contlol would raault in a poibla worat caaa acenario of a total dboharqa of

voca of 333 lbbr (77 5 lltday) or thb total 1511 percent wOuld or i 9inata troa thbull vz bullYbullta (cludnq tha Urat rev weeki ot opratiotl) an4 1bullbullbull than one ~rcent would bull the reult ot air 1t1 ippinq Conaequently it would be neceary to bullpend at lea1t

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 5: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

- r -

TAitl 1

V0C DIIIIIOlfl

IRlS AIR ITIIPPIR- Zata~ xgs (YS~lll Z1IDLLmllll ~ lbbr lbdaY

Jan IS 4511 15200 ooa on Dec llov

92 9715 710

IJUO tuso

003 ooa

on ou

Oo~ lept

IUl 1510

92410 77040

003 0 02

011 0

~Iy 17706 30657

40320 40101

ooa 004

0 60 104

Avenge 0021 066

PACILIlY WAlD SUPPLY STkiPPD

Total infllant VOCbull prior to IMI atartllp in rune 1112

r eb U lOU U9l

April U 2101 ucr1

JW1 U U32 Wl1

Avrage aH4 1Jo9l

Total voe laiaaiona (2500 gpcl) bull 005 lbday

Total intluent VOCbull attar IJllll atartup 1n rune 1112

Aamp9 U 670 1Jo9l

Oct 12 11

Deo ta 270 U9l

468 U9l

TCgtUl VOC llliooiono (2500 9cent) bull 0 01 lbday

-j~ middot-shyd

- r -

J

1achnical Meaorandua Michael Ralipinalti UK Pabruary 2J 1993bullbull9bull 5 for approxiaataly 10 daya (baaS on intorution davalopad durinq the bencbbullacal8 taatinq) than Hqin to ctaclina at a rata aiJlilar to other lVI ayatua

lVI DIIIIIONS

1AllJQ yos bheipn Bftt (lbbrl

DWbulllt 0 301

DWmiddot2t QQOIi

DWoo3t 0 003

OW-4t 0024

ow-st ~

TOTAL 0 404 r-AVDAGI oou -ii = The nlll lilted above are located nur the ori9inal aourca of = HlMH of VOCe Canaequently virtuelly all 01har nlla will

diaabaqe VOC at a lowv rata lf hypotlaatically all or tba pnpoeed 40 vapor axtracrtion walla 41110ba19ed VOC at tha above aqraqa rata oontimaolampaly frGa~ tartup tha total rata would lie

only 32 ~hr 1be In yta bullbull outlined in Ula r1 would howvu inclwa bull bulliaaiou conUol to reduce tha rata of 4habarga to a non-dataot l aval

coaraquoininq all tha 411ollartaa without a1111ona contlol would raault in a poibla worat caaa acenario of a total dboharqa of

voca of 333 lbbr (77 5 lltday) or thb total 1511 percent wOuld or i 9inata troa thbull vz bullYbullta (cludnq tha Urat rev weeki ot opratiotl) an4 1bullbullbull than one ~rcent would bull the reult ot air 1t1 ippinq Conaequently it would be neceary to bullpend at lea1t

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 6: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

- r -

J

1achnical Meaorandua Michael Ralipinalti UK Pabruary 2J 1993bullbull9bull 5 for approxiaataly 10 daya (baaS on intorution davalopad durinq the bencbbullacal8 taatinq) than Hqin to ctaclina at a rata aiJlilar to other lVI ayatua

lVI DIIIIIONS

1AllJQ yos bheipn Bftt (lbbrl

DWbulllt 0 301

DWmiddot2t QQOIi

DWoo3t 0 003

OW-4t 0024

ow-st ~

TOTAL 0 404 r-AVDAGI oou -ii = The nlll lilted above are located nur the ori9inal aourca of = HlMH of VOCe Canaequently virtuelly all 01har nlla will

diaabaqe VOC at a lowv rata lf hypotlaatically all or tba pnpoeed 40 vapor axtracrtion walla 41110ba19ed VOC at tha above aqraqa rata oontimaolampaly frGa~ tartup tha total rata would lie

only 32 ~hr 1be In yta bullbull outlined in Ula r1 would howvu inclwa bull bulliaaiou conUol to reduce tha rata of 4habarga to a non-dataot l aval

coaraquoininq all tha 411ollartaa without a1111ona contlol would raault in a poibla worat caaa acenario of a total dboharqa of

voca of 333 lbbr (77 5 lltday) or thb total 1511 percent wOuld or i 9inata troa thbull vz bullYbullta (cludnq tha Urat rev weeki ot opratiotl) an4 1bullbullbull than one ~rcent would bull the reult ot air 1t1 ippinq Conaequently it would be neceary to bullpend at lea1t

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 7: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r I

Technical MaaotandWI Jlliehael KaUpinald 1 RPM Pabt-uary 23 1913 Paga I

UU IOO to raduca the diacharga ot voca tr011 tha aita ~y ltll than ona percent

OVer tiae tha VOC concentration of voce in tha vapor extraction wlh will dacraua Although thl proportion of voca clbcbarqed troa tha air atrippinq ayat will incraaaa tha total volWia (and rate) of voca dhahuvad will dagrqaa A dacraaaa in tha avaraga oonoantration of voca to 007 lbhrwell would reduce tha total dhchar9a to al lbhr A dacraaaa in tha avraqa rate to 0015

lbfhrVIll would redura tha total d iiOhlf91 to 144 lbfday Thua becalH n hdon oontroh ara propoaed tor tha avz ayat u tha net~U9ibh added r a oval that voul d bl aobievad wi th air atripper ott--qae traataant woul d not ba coa t affective

ca1t oC Pct-91bull cqntrple

In l eotion lS 1 of tha r1 it vaa dat uainad that air auippinq would be tha racamaended troundwater traataent teonnol09) Tbh ve done Hoalll there b an esiRint operatJnt air 1trippin9 trutaant eyet ttectively trtinv the qroundvater t r oa tbl qroUWiveter extraction bullYbullta The air ltri ppint technolOCJY however 4ou not 41bulltroy voc It truatu1 thea tro thl 9roundwater to the eir tor ulttte daetruction raquoy the natural envi ronaent W Oxidat ion on the othar hand clebulltroybull voca in Chi

ttaataent procaaa l ncl woul d coaply with SAM bull prefannca tor 1

t ecbnol 09Y that reducea the volWM of oontaainantbull Tharatou one ita ot bullenaitivity b the diCJrle of treataant and rlliduala that aay exbt

In addition to replacinq air bulltripping vitb UVCxi4ation the ethct of 14419 vapor-phue carbon treatment to the exiatinq air

) -middot___

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 8: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r I

fbullACflltUrlnc

Technical ~randum JCichael Malipinaki JtPM Pekmlary 23 Utl Paqe 7

etrippar VII evaluated Alao exu1ne4 waa the ettect or operatinq tbe aouroe control rnadial ayateu tor lO yaare rather than the 10 yaar1 antioipatacl (Coatamp tor the aource control ruediation tor SAbulll an4 ll-4 aued three yearbull of operation aprd over ten yaue to aiaulate the likely interaittent operation of the

ayatabullbulll

~ ot the rs 1a attached ancl 1104itie4 to inolwSbull bullNot Applioablebull to reprent a Xo Action alternative Alae the coetl ot IA-3 and SA-bull in the table have bean bullo41tie4 to include the preant worth ot the annual coat of ott-911 trtaent ratber than

the dbullple annual coat ( inorbullbullbullbull the total coat of both

alternativeamp raquoy f11200 The net preaent worth coet of ad41nq

otf-4JI8 u taent to tbe IJlll air amptripper b bullua I DO and vaa r-developed 11 followe (Alao refer to ~ of the Pl) -iii

Gaa pbue tr~nt equipaant ( includaa aarlxm = oaniatara air hbullater eta toe apprax

1300 ota flow at 50bull haidity) luildinq aod i fication

Duct work

lrd9ht

Inetallation (1na1Udaa aontrole ate )

Contintenciaa (Z5t)

OrAL Capital coat

The Olll ccata vbullrbull oaloulatacl tor tbe a44itional

uscoo uoooo s 000 bull 000

t1o ooo llLQAQ t70 000

powaa labor

aaintananca an4 tar thbull carbon uaa uawptiona inclU4a4 unitora

lN at tha carlton over tha 30 yaar Ute of the ayatea and purchaaa

and rbullqenaration coata at two dallara par pcun4 ot carbon Which

uy ba low) bull Buad an the uaa ot TCE calculated tor tha deep

6 --d middot

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 9: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

r I I

Technical Kaaonndum Michael lfalipina)ti UK rabluary 23 uu Paqa 1

M4roek aquitU in ampaction Jo2 of tha PI (1710 poundl) and a

oar~n uaa rata ot 3 lba of carl)Qn per pound of TCB rnovad 17 ltO polmda of aarDon would be ubullbull to raa41ata tba beclrodC aquifar Tha breakdown of OlM aoata ia bullbull follOVI Tha prant worth coat b bad on a t percent intuaat lata and a so yaar lita Raplacaaant coat tor equipant ara lump aum coati tbat occur in yr u

pteaent Wprth Cgltnu Electricity ($001lcwh) bull 47 700

Lolgtor (1 hroh I 125hr) bull 22 100

xaintenanca (allovanca) f aeoo Camprlgtoll (100 1byr I 11b) 41500 l-li119AM1yda (ott-qoa) lUJAA IUBlOTAL bulluo sao Replaonante bull 15000

capital co8t ~

Total ftaant Worth coat bull22s sao

The atiaate of the cot tor tba an ayu vaa cleveloped 1 1

ZiVOICNtlly beoaua an operational ayta ia not illl plampQI aa b with the axbtint air atzippu Dua to the natura of the aoil and blaS on the raaulta of tba pilot teat oondloted at the aita in Ull it middotwu aeeuud tbampt an air tlov r1te at approxiaately 10 eta pu nll oauld H achbvecl UdncJ an utiatS 40 extraction vella would rewlt in an air dbehute rate of approxibullately 400 oh Aa 11 diacuK above the concentration or voca in the diacharqe troa the lVI eyata will vary with tibull BecauH the exact variation oannot M preclictct it waa aaauaed ~t tha car~n V0amp14 M uaed unironly over the life or tba rae4ia1 attore Althouqh thb will not M tha aa 1~ vill not affect the evaluation of tne sc

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 10: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r I

Technical KUlorandum Michael alipinaki RPM rebruaty 23 1993 Page 9

altarnativaa JMcau lxltb IA-J and IA-4 uaa tha aame taohnolOCJY ancS the coat dithranca vill be intarftally condatent

lha tiaata prepared tor tna Ill aaauaeo one 2000 lb vaaaal would be uaed each year Tbie wu done beceu it b leaa difficult to arrange traneporttion and r otivation of a large volume ot carDcn than for aaveral nell 200 - 400 pound oaniatera Durin9 the

initial oparation of Ule IVZ ayat the rate of carDcn u likely will be hiqhu Thb would nault in a hiqbar t1rat year operatin9

ooat but would have le affect on the l onqar tara OiK con Hcauae the concentration of VOCe in tha vapor Will dacraa

Tlwi coat of baton conuot for the IVI ayatn include the r shyoapital coet or tha carbOn filtua and the annual coat or oar110n -2raphoabullant and revanaration an4 diepoaal rroa ~ the c~rraquoon tiltera coat Uoooo (inol14inq conunencibullbulll lecauaa it = b ant1o1pted that the lVI ayetu YOUol4 be operated = interaittntly tba eetiaatad thraa yHr r cS1at1cn period VII

arlancSed to tan yrl to repreeent the inttnLittent operation A81uaint the u1a ot a ooo pcunde of carbon par year (WhiCh y be

low in the tiret year) the pruant vcrth of the IMUil carbon uee coat b tao 2oo tor a ten year reaediaticn period aakinq the tctal pruant worth coat apprcxiutaly 140 coo bullor 1 30 yaar period the IVB ayata liltaly vauld cu operation attar ten yaar1 If however th 1aaa aaaUIIptiona were applied to a lb year period the total praaent worth coat of tha car1gton ayetara would incraa only a lightly to approxbat ely 842 000

rinally retrring aqdn to ~ it waa nctlld durin tlla maatinq at tinater on 211 that the coat to 1ncraaaa the ruadhtion tiaa to l o yean dacraaaed when ccmpared to raplacinq

_) ~middot-

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 11: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

I r --

1echnicel XOrandUBI Michael bullbulllipinak1 JUK rabnlary 23 un Paqa 10

air atrippinv with UVOX14ation in IAmiddotl (tha 1ft alttrnativa) yenhila it inoruaedi in IA-4 (tha air apuging alternative) Thil ooouza in IA-4 becau the NCJnituda of tha obullM coat for tha air

aparginq option b quater than tha aoat of ehantJing tr011 air atrippincJ to UYOx14at1on Jn IA-3 tha aavnitu4a ot the coat of chent1119 to UVOtllidation ia qraatar than the incruea in 06raquo1 coat for opratint the ayz aratea for 30 yaara TUI TOUl Prant Worth Coat incrnaa to ohan9a to tJVOx14amption ia ampppzOXibullataly tt51000 tTbullhle u- ainua Teblt u-t) lha coat to inoruaa tha ruediation tiae to 30 ynra for IAbull3 ia 617 1 4001 tha coat b bivbar for u-t fiUoo o Mcauaa of higher co oona lbuatora it coati approxiaately f3t 000 lMI to operata tha air atri~

(and IW ayat-) tor 30 yaan than it doaa to convert to a VVOxidation ayat- and operate it tor 30 yearbull which h 1hovn in iiiii 111laY1middot =

_)

J

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569
Page 12: TICHMIC A L IIEMORANDUJfConnecticut requlltiona would, thuatora, conatituta aora l t.ringant lavel a ot' control for ~entire f acility 1n thi a ca.., btlcaua controb would M r~~qU.ired

r

DUPt 10 120111

lABLZ 15-13 IJDfiilIVIlY AlfALYSII

FEAIIBILllY llUDY ltDOJtT LIXDUTD IWIlCII coJUIOMTIOlf

WOODSlOO CONMICTICUT DIICHBIR UU

ID8ITIVIlY COIIDITIOK

Air ltrippinq rouncS-vater treatent

Add vapor pbaaa carbon for ott1bullbull traatant

place air atrippinq vith UYOX141t10n

Incraaaa oouroe reaecliation tba to 30 yeara

Coat aavecl by eliainatinq taaioftl

troa

IIA-1 IIA-2 IL-3 HO-AClIOK COKTAIIIIIIIIr VACiltll

IIXlRAcrtOK

$1173400 $2267 too U 42a lOO

Kat Applicable

U 4n4oo U l~lIOO

Not f2tU 1 l OO u o7t3oo Applicabla

wot bull bull CIWgtqo 3 041 500 Applioalgtl o

ori inal

Not Not 0 200 Applicable Appli-lo

IA-4 lDt

IPUGIHQ

U 4ll 100

2 1563 100

uoet 3oo

t3 2ao ooo

40200

r shy-2 = =

  1. barcode 577569
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 577569