those who knock on europe’s door must repent? bilateral border disputes and eu enlargement

Upload: transformeurope

Post on 04-Jun-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    1/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door MustRepent?Bll Bd D d EU El

    Adw Gdd d Adw Tyl

    N. 54 | N 2013

    WORKING PAPER

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    2/21

    2 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    KFG Working Paper Series

    Edited by the Kolleg-ForschergruppeT Tafmav Pw f E

    T KFG W P S d l f Kll-F y

    ll d l. I d x wll d d

    x l d xl d E d E U.

    All KFG W P ll KFG w www.f. dd

    l [email protected].

    Cy f : Adw Gdd d Adw Tyl

    Edl d d: Ad B d Fl B

    Gdd, Adw/Tyl, Adw 2013: T W K E D M R? Bll Bd D d

    EU El, KFG W P S, N. 54, N 2013, Kll-F (KFG) T TfPw f E F U Bl.

    ISSN 1868-6834 (P)

    ISSN 1868-7601 (I)

    T l fdd y G R Fd (DFG).

    F U Bl

    Kll-F

    T Tf Pw f E:

    T E U d D f Id

    I. 26

    14195 Bl

    Gy

    P: +49 (0)30- 838 57033

    Fx: +49 (0)30- 838 57096

    [email protected]

    www.f.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    3/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 3

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent?

    Bilaal Bd Di ad EU Elagm

    Adw Gdd ad Adw Tayl

    Abstract

    T xl ld f wd d EU l; ly ll d

    w M S d l, w f , ,

    l l d. A w w ly f - Ily d Sl,

    Sl d C, d G d Md - EU f w d lwy w

    wd wd . T q l

    l w ld l y flly l

    f . O l EU f w x f d

    ld d f d. W l w dy

    l, l lly dlz wy ld dl EU ly. I

    C f d ld llly d-y.

    T A

    Adw Gdd Pf f Pl Uy f Sld. H w-

    xly f B, E d EU l, w l

    f l f . R l ld Migraon and

    Mobility in the EU(w C Bwll) d The EU and South East Europe:

    The Dynamics of Mul-Level Governance and Europeanisaon (w Adw

    Tyl d Cl L). H w V Fllw Kll-FT Tf Pw f E J/Jly 2012. F Fy 2013,

    wll ld f 5-y E R Cl dd

    j l .

    C: .dd@ld..

    Adw Tayl Pf f Pl Uy f Sld. H w l -

    ESRC fdd j dl f l-ll

    S E E. I y w fd Ez

    f W Bl d f ;

    State Failure(Pl Mll) d j

    EU l -ld W Bl. H l w l f

    d Ud Kd.

    C: .j.yl@ld..

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    4/21

    4 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    Contents

    1. Id 52. Bd d E I 6

    3. Ily - Sl 7

    4. C - Sl 10

    5. FYROM - G 12

    6. Cl 16

    Rf 18

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    5/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 5

    Those who knock on Europes door such as Ljubljana must make a gesture of repentance.

    (Gianfranco Fini in Corriere della Sera 1994: 5)

    1. Id

    Sd f l f l w E C f

    M S d l y. El , d l d

    d l d l w, xl l. Cl

    l M S collecvelyw y l d ( )

    dd y fy EU lly, d w fy -

    l, l . M S , f, d ll l . A

    ld f ll d w M S d l, w

    f , , l l d. T d

    xly d w x , w Ily d Sl, Sl d C, d

    G d Md.

    W w EU f w d lwy w wd wd

    d q l l w

    ld l y flly l f . E

    d dl f y wl E d -

    zd ld, l d fzzy (f xl, R 1993; F/My 1999; C

    l. 2004). Hw, d dy d fy w l w d/d d

    /-, w w yy dly f f f. T x

    : w Ily d Sl y Dlz, I d F;

    P By w C d Sl; d, d w G d Md. T

    d w f lx f Bl l fd y E , d

    y xl l w E d

    (H 1966). T l d f l EU d y Lx

    d Slf w w : x f l ll f

    f f E d f w f dd (2009:791-92). T f w d d f d l d

    ld ly w l, l d l l d

    (Bzl/R 2012). Hw, , w d xd . I Ily-Sl

    w d f f f E d, C-

    Sl d, EU, wl ll l w dw d l, d

    G-Md w EU flly l.

    Bd -ll dl dy lx l d ll d y y:

    y fy d-d (Wl 1993) d l-xl (Ll 1998),

    w l d, w ly l d, d d

    d (Bw 2001: 119). T EU l f d, d f dd l-,

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    6/21

    6 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    z d d w d. Bd y

    dly . T d xd x f d d d-

    , d Wl -y wll j f dy d d dl

    (Nw 2001: 147).

    2. Bd ad Ea Iga

    I Al, Gd Wwll, G f , d Bl

    l lly l : T l f ,

    dy, f E U, w w fd f f ydy. T wy

    dw f l d f q, ld Bl. I E, d

    l (D Wll 2013). Wwll ly d y f

    EU d.

    F d My (1999) w w EU d d -,

    E d y dl f y. Udl f EU -

    (R 1993). F d My (1999), dw S (1996), dfy -ll, l/

    ll, l d ll d d, d, ld d, d

    d w EU ld d l d, - d

    lly (F/My 1999: 217). T w w fzzy d. C l.

    (2004) f E l d, w w d

    Yl -. I y dl, y dy f -

    lx d l. F xl, w d y dld d

    -dld d EU -dl, dl (All 2004).

    I l, w wld x d w yy w d d d d

    f f. T l w f l d y -

    f d d y (Ml 2002; Gdd/Tyl 2013). E

    l d ( M S) d d (l ) d f l w

    z l. F d d d, dy , w -l d d d, l d. Hy w EU l

    dy l dly -EU d f l f -

    f l . F l y lly ld, l w EU

    d l (Klly 2004; S 2012). E y ll dy d f EU -

    (, f xl, EU f Nl P Pz) l - ,

    ll dy l - . T EU l , lly,

    l f. El ld d lld y

    l d EU . T lly d

    ly f d l d l -EU ly d l, w

    y EU.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    7/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 7

    Dz l. (2006) dfy f EU d d. T , compulsory impact, w

    l dl f l (Slf/Sdl 2004) w

    w yy d dly f d d -

    (Dz l. 2006: 575). T w yy d l wld f w ld x d d ld f f d

    f d w d ly . If EU ( wll ) l l, w

    ?

    O w EU x l d . Enablingl

    l d EU d jfy dlly ll . T j

    f d l dd d f EU jfy d l

    dd. D wd f xd f l (Dz l. 2006: 578)? Ay -

    l l , f, l l d y xly -:

    connecve (Dz l. 2006: 581). T EU y l, l l. T

    w y idexe ll, l EU f f

    d f f f ly, w EU dlz .

    EU x-d x f l d EU , d

    lf dy, l f fl - . E w EU

    l, f, construcve (Dz l. 2006: 584). Sl d l

    y-wd d f dwd y d dy. T EU

    l ( d y H 1966), l d

    ly, lz ly . T w l: , f f

    l, d ly ; d d, x-ddy

    w d x . T EU , f f,

    l -fl. R EU d l (Vd

    2005) ( l lz) d d l . T

    lly y dd d l

    w. A ly q l d l l, ll d-

    ll x d dd f EU d l . T, w d

    xd . I Ily-Sl , d (Ily) d ly; C-Sl

    EU, d f ll, w l fl l; d lly, G-Md d f ld , d l d f EU

    d f d .

    3. Ialy - Slvia

    Bw Ily d Sl l 199 ld d d 29 d d ll ly

    w l f d [d] d y f ll y w xll x-

    l f x (Kl/G 2001: 130). T Ily-Sl d l ddd

    w d l d. F xl, Czz (2007) d f f d

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    8/21

    8 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    d f d Ily l d f

    d d qly f l f d Cld W. W Il

    ll y f w fl ly -f f Il l.

    A d f Sd Wld W d 350,000 Il d Dlz, F d I (y

    w d dd , le foibe); y d w lzd y T. T - d

    -f Il l d ldly l le foibe, d l f

    l l dy (Fy 10) d y 2004 lw.

    T Ty f P (Fy 1947) dd Yl Z, ld f Pl, y f F d

    f I l, w f y f T d UN . I 1954 Yl -

    d T Il l. Ud Ty f O (N 1975) w Ily d Yl,

    Ily d l l I l d w ld y f -

    l (T 1980, Ud 1982 d Ljlj 1988) d ld (Kl/G 2001). T

    - f Yl d Sl dl f dd d dy EU , ld

    y Ily, f l d d P d d y Ty f

    O. L w q f y f Il d w. Al 68 f

    Sl f 1991 d y f ld y -Sl z. I 1992 -d-

    d ld R w dl f ld z

    d l .

    T l y d f Cl Azl C

    (Al 1993 My 1994) d d y , -ld Bl l

    l f 1994, w ldd f -f M Sl Il-Allz

    Nzl (MSI-AN). I O, Il f M d w ll

    ld: f y d fl y f xl.

    M d Ed, EU dd (L

    Rl 1994).

    T w l x EU wld w Ily -

    ld w dz f -f d f f MSI AN

    (Jy 1995). T ld w d dld y y ldGf F y f T O 1994. T I q w lly

    f AN w l T d ld f MSI. T d-

    l f AN w d y f w E dy:

    l l dd f l d d d l-

    w EU. T MSI-AN d l wld fd f w

    Sl l d f Sl w d d f y .

    Hw, C dll S (1994) w, F ld f y l y,

    d ld f l w l

    ld. F w l dly, f xl y U. S. d w

    lly dly f l-l. T U. S. w l y f Yl

    wd EU. T dl f F w dy/f d ll/l

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    9/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 9

    d, w w fd w dl : E l? T Sl

    w f ld MSI l d d ly -

    y, AN.

    F l w d w y lly T (O 1994). Idd y ll

    f l wd f d-l , w wd- wd y : Triesni:

    d y l fd f Sl? T w wd dd N!. El dy,

    F d dld AN d w f d dy (w ll ld f d-

    y) d , F d l f l dy w wll

    , z ld d 1994 w Il d Sl f

    d Aql d d Pl. F d w

    E d f ; Sl d z ld I d

    Dlz w Il d y l f (le foibe) w w w

    f l ld y T fllw (C dll S 1994).

    T fll f Bl (D 1994) dd

    ld y L D, w dd d Sl l ll

    l d wy f . T d w - w ll

    ld ly jy . T dl : Ily wld

    l Sl wl Sl wld f x-Il

    y. T d ly f AN w F Pl

    dd f f d Pl. F w ly

    l f fl l Pl w Ud-Sy f F A, S All,

    d (4 M 1995) Il wld l f l w

    Sl. D d A Ty w Sl d EU J 1996 x-Y-

    l y wd EU. T EU lyd y l . T Sl

    (A 1995) w d y S F M J Sl d S EU dy.

    I qd Sl wld, w f y f f , z

    f EU z y y Sl w dly xdd EU z

    d dd f l y Sl y, ldd I l f. T

    q f f y w l .

    I My 1996 D w ld y -l ld y R Pd. T

    Ud-Sy f F A w P F f -l Ol T . I

    y, Per Passione, F (2003) w Pd d ld y Pd Cl x-

    d l fl Sl . Ud Pd, Il d l

    wld d l f f y f d wl F d f

    Sl y wld Sl . T ld d

    f Il . T w l Il . Sl

    w ly d y G wl Sl w l

    f E Bl wd j EU d NATO.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    10/21

    10 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    I f wd wd. T w lly ld l l f

    f le foibe f Il l d dz f -f

    d F. F q f l d d ll ly d

    E. T f D d Pd w y l f US, d w l ly -E, w -d y l

    x f d y .

    4. Caa - Slvia

    I ly-1990 C d Sl d ( w , -

    f d S-dd fd) f dd ll l w

    , ylzd y d By f P (Bl R 2004) d y f y

    d d ql () lzd d l l d ll ld

    (RFE/RL Nw 2009). T d d w d ly xlly y

    Yl -, w dd d f 668 w d wfl yl

    f l l d d fdly l w EU (A 2002; /

    Aly 2007).

    D l d f Sl dd dl d x l d-

    (u possides juris) fllw y Sl dld y lf (S

    2010: 93-111). C, f Al 15 f UN C Lw f S, ld

    d ld qd f w Sl zd d

    l f ex aequo et bono(d d d f qy d ) w

    d w l f lw f f w y d f d ql.

    A l d l Jly 2001 w Sl d C , Jz D

    d I R, fld D- R A d 3.6 y 12 d

    ( 80 f P By) f Sl d w y d

    EU wll lz ll l w w l d ylz-

    w l Bl. Hw, ly, Sl (f xl, Sl

    Nl Py d Sl D Py) d d , J J,w f f y Sl, d l

    f l l: 1918 l f C A, 1945 l f T d Gz, 1954

    l f Sl y f M R () (Bl R 2001). Sl l

    d D- R A C dd d d R

    f d C Sl, d fd Il C

    f J T H (ICJ). M w xd y C 2003 dl f d -

    ll z Ad. C l w xl z d dw

    f EU d . C l w d N d

    ( C P Py d Py f Hl R) dld dl l-

    l z d Sl y. O y, D Py f Rd P, d

    l f f Idd S f C d w wdd l f

    f fl dfd Sl y (Bl R 2003).

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    11/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 11

    I 2007 C d Sl , I Sd d Jz J, d l f

    d H. T -lld Bld A jyd C , w

    Sl l , d j wd d f . I

    2007 Sl d C l ll d d (f w P By w ly ) w f j d yl f ll

    -ll , d C EU w Sl f , D

    Rl, l . A Sl w w f d d ll l-

    w Sl Nl Py ld y Z Jl d , Dj Rl ( f

    Sl D U) d D M ( f ) f .

    T w w wl Sl (ld ld f Sl Pl Py) w

    d y C d l J J ( ). T P M, A

    R, dld - 2004 l (w R l) C w l

    f EU.

    T EU, f y f l, d w ll . C w -

    d y C d d ( l w dl; w

    ) C d w dd , w Sl d fl

    l C d ld . Oll R, l -

    , w ld f Cy f , wd d C w

    ll d d ll d l (Bl I 2008).

    T C d Sl d, S M d Dl T, lld f dl, w T

    D- R A l wy fwd d ly f l -

    . T C jd f f d-y . I 2007 Sl d

    d f ICJ qly d , d f-

    wd F , ld EU Pdy, d l. Szy d

    Sl d C -jd d d fl

    w l. T l dd -dy d f Sl d d

    Szy C f P R (COREPER). Of EU ly

    Sl d F l d w d. Sl d

    ld d l ll , w d, EU -

    w wll - EU f d d. Sly,

    F C Sl d.

    O 19 D 2008 Sl ld f w w C. T

    EU d d zd Sl -E

    . S C l, ld d, d Sl ll ly d

    EU l f d l C w ll,

    EU l q (Bl I 2008). Jd l df f Sl

    , 23 J d 23 Jly Sl ld l f f w C.

    I Jy Sl d l C NATO. T x-ly Py f

    Sl N d I f 25 J d 5,000 f fd C

    , w l M ddl 40,000 dd l f-

    d. T fld dlly (ly f 2,500 w d) d C jd NATO Al

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    12/21

    12 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    2009. Al l w C d, ly lwd d Sl

    d fqly wld l d w ld.

    W R , d l d x ll, w dld ly l wy fwd w l w ld y d w

    w d f ld (C w ll ICJ). Nl, ly

    2009 w w d w EU ll , -

    ld w f d-y . N w d w Sd

    d P M Sl, f C ICJ d l

    E-ll l. R fd y fl EU l dd C wld fl

    d: I f E C ll ()

    w E , l dly d w C j

    EU (Bl I 2009). R d - l f ll x dl j -

    jd d d ld , d d l .

    Sl d C w wy fwd ll w d l I Sd

    1 Jly 2009. H w dd y Jd K. A w l y, d (

    11 S Ljlj) ld l dl f d K fd Swd

    Pdy C wld jd d (lly F l)

    d P d Sl wld ld, wld l d EU

    . T l f w ld Z (26 O); 2 N

    C l d , w w d Sl 4 N

    2009 (RFE/RL Nw: N 4, 2009). D Sl l

    (, , d f, y d df) fd d l

    y 51.4 48.5 J 2010. T l (25 My 2011) d -

    l d f l ll x ( w jly ld f l f y

    w , w wld l ) d d- l w d

    w UN. I w xd y l d d wld d.

    N E C, EU, w y , d

    ll , C wld d d , ld

    ll l f f dl f d ly l w w

    wll f W Bl [] w w dl ld ld (CEC 2012, 1).

    5. FYROM - G

    Md dld dd f Yl (S 1991); ld

    Rl f Md d d G d d f .

    T G f y fdl l f l lw d

    d [d] f d ly l, y d l y. Md -

    d f d d l () f f y d f

    G l d l ; dd w d l d

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    13/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 13

    f Md , w w ld ylly fl f y d

    xl f Md (). I G d ly

    f l d l d d [f FYROM] d ld

    NATO d EU (Hll Rl, .d.; l REF/RL 2011). T Md w y l ld dd d f

    d dlz . My Md d FYROM ll d xl -

    f w d l d l d l (RFE/RL 2005).

    Md dd d ly ld f (T 1995). T

    E C (EC) f Bl d Dl Yl (16

    D 1991). T ldd y x-Yl d l

    d ll l l wd Cy S

    d wll d l d Cy S, ld

    d f w l l l (ASIL 1992: 1486). T Dl ld

    d w Bd C ( A C f Yl, d

    f EU Yl) wld Md q f , l

    w llly d. Bd ldd ( fll O 6, dld

    11 Jy 1992) Md f d, xlly d ll -

    l l l, ldd f Md f ly y l

    l S (T 1993: 77-80). EC f G (2 My 1992)

    dld d , l ll d fd. A l

    dd Md w l Md , wl

    l w l G d dd

    f d w A d Sj, w f () x d f f EU

    ly q (R 1993, 53).

    O 30 Jly 1992 Md ld f UN l lld f y lly

    l f l y (Pll 2004). Hw, d 1992 l d,

    IMF d Wld B, ly dd ll f Yl Rl f Md

    (FYROM) w, Jy 1993 ( l f F, S d UK), w d y UN

    Sy Cl jd y G d Md. Ud f EU d NATO,

    C M, G P M, dd FYROM l M, dd Sj . O 7 Al Sy Cl dd Gl Aly FYROM

    d UN w l ddd (UN 1993; 1993). T w

    flly d G jd FYROM d d M d FYROM jd F, w

    lly d d ( f) x Tld. Al UN d w d-

    y, FYROM w dlly d .

    Bll l w flzd y I Ad (13 S 1995). T f

    Mx B l; f y w d (G w Py f P d FYROM

    Py f Sd P) fl dl l w ld, f w d

    ll, Md dd V S l yl d d ,

    l d ll y wld xld y d, f l d d

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    14/21

    14 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    ( d d y G 1993 w d d U.S. ) wld llwd, d

    wld l d UN l d (UN 1995). A ,

    ddd l d f (RFE/RL 2005).

    FYROM d UN ld f G f , A S, df f

    Nw Dy, ld fll f M d df y Pd PASOK

    O 1993. T w PASOK dd d l. T Md l-

    d UN dl 30 28 w 18 VMRO-DPMNE (Il

    Md Rly Py D Py f Md Nl Uy) lld f -

    d w d. N d d dlly d

    l 5 f I Ad ll dl ll d.

    T l l w G wd Md, d lly

    l d y f d (f xl, N Mdj, Vd Md);

    G d l f Rl f Md d

    y ql wll fll dd. T Sj fl ql wld

    ld q f dy; Pd C, f xl, d l Md wll

    y Rl f Md dl w f wld (RFE/RL

    2005). G d l z d FYROM fld. I M 1997, f

    xl, w l d , G f , Td Pl,

    Md Pd, K Gl, d dly dd y f Md d

    ly w f l (Nl 1997).

    Ud I Ad G w FYROM f l z.

    A NATO B (Al 2008) G f - f FYROM w d

    (NATO 2008: 21). W EU, J 2008 EU Cl xd

    FYROM wld l w EU fy dly ld dw

    l d d lly l l

    l (CEC 2008, 6). T, d f l .

    G ly w d y VMRO-DPMNE ly f Azzj (qz). T VMRO-

    DMNPE l f VMRO, z fd 1893. I dd

    -/C d, -NATO d EU , d l, dw lf f Md. A 1990 VMRO-DPMNE w l y fd

    f l w Al d yd 1994 l; 1998 dd l w

    D Py f Al. I 1999 VMRO-DPMNE dd l d. I 2002

    VMRO-DPMNE w dfd d 2004 l dy. Ry 2006 w

    d qz ly, w ld NATO - w

    d VMRO-DPMNE 2008 l, w ll xl (RFE/RL

    2008). I 2008 ly l VMRO-DPMNE ll l lld 48.7 f

    . I D 2006 Sj w d Ald Vl (Alxd G) d

    l f Alxd d f Pl II f Md w d, l l

    f 22 W H Sj 2011 d l f Pl II ld f

    q f Sj 2014 wl . S d, wy d ,

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    15/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 15

    wll d q ll d (RFE/RL 2011). A d, w

    x f dy, d f -ld x, d f -

    d (Kz 2009). T Sj 2014 j d qz ly f y

    l f l ll f , lly Al d l y Md w d . T j d w EU f d,

    y ly G, lly (ICG 2011: 23).T

    (f G ) w Md d d w l l w MK

    l d. Jd z w EU l, G d l d d-

    l w y- (OC 2012).

    Aqz ly lly d l yy. I l ld f

    w l d f VMRO-DPMNE, w d d

    Od A d w l w Al y d jdz l ly. T

    fdl Md dy, dly ll f Al, d y l l l

    wld d ll . Al l d l wl x

    dq wy G d VMRO-DPMNE d d d

    ly f wd EU y f w G. Cf

    d fl; ly l d-y . Pl d y

    l fd, w l l l q w-d jy

    55 (64 d Al ) f f EU -

    (ICG 2011: 20-21).

    I N 2008 FYROM d d G ICJ, ll f Al

    11 f I Ad l FYROM NATO . I jd (5 D 2011)

    ICJ fd (y 15 1, ly G jd d ) G d d I Ad

    ld d G ly G w y

    z (ICJ 2011). EU l w Md (Tyl l. 2012) x -

    d f Slz d A P (SAP) d w fly dy

    (16 J) dd ld . A Slz d A A (d

    9 Al 2001) f 1 Al 2004, FYROM W Bl y

    f. O 9 N 2005 C d O FYROM l

    f d dd dd , w E Cl d D. I J 2007 E Pl d l , , d Md,

    EU d l , wy d

    l f d EU (RFE/RL 2007).

    T EU l ll w ld y UN d

    f f l (RFE/RL 2009). T C w d -

    ld ll d EU ll 27 EU f . I

    O 2009 C dd w ld

    y G l w ld. T H Ll A Dl (HLAD) w d y

    E Cl D 2012 f f G . A

    f HLAD l d d UN d l Nw Y (29-30

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    16/21

    16 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    Jy; 8-9 Al) w (CEC 2012: 11-12). I 2009 D D, w d

    f y l w P M Pd, dld, T ld -

    f w f w Sj (). W ll l

    d l (RFE/RL 2009). T . T C wll f wl G y d y f E-z d w

    l d l.

    6. Cli

    I l? T d d x f EU l

    d d l , lly. O fy l EU

    f w x f d ld d f d.

    T d f E f w -

    f d dd d l l.

    Ed f Cl d E E (CEE) l d, l d, W

    Bl w l w dy l l lly dlz

    wy ld dl EU ly. I C f

    d ld llly d-y.

    I ll f d , d l l dy l

    d l j d y ll d f y

    y EU.

    T j f : , l d ll l

    f dy; d, d l l ; d d,

    j l f l, l w l d E . All

    -d EU fldd l, f wd d

    d d d y l d d d. Hw, y l l

    f l-. T f l ly dw EU

    d l w yy d l d f l wld f f d. Nl, w, EU l

    , d ll ld l. T EU

    ly ( Dz l. 2006) xl nonef . A f EU l

    d dx: w yy l l, w ly

    , ly l EU f w ld dlz d-

    l d l y l lll l. A l w l:

    f d, l, w ll w w d w d . W

    d f d (Ily-Sl), l dj (Sl-C) d l

    (G-Md) xld y, , f ; d d, xd -

    y d y EU dd d f EU f.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    17/21

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    18/21

    18 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    Rf

    Ansell, Christopher K.2004: R y d ly, : All, C K./Pl, G- d (d): R Tly: E d Ud S Cd, Cd:

    Cd Uy P, 3-18.Arnaut, Darmir2002: Sy W Wy H S: T C f Tl S Dl

    Bw C d Sl, : Jl f O d Cl Lw 21/8, 1-39.

    ASIL 1992: E Cy: Dl Yl d Gdl Rl f NwS, : Il Ll Ml 31/6, 1485-1487.

    Balkan Insight2008: Sl Bl C EU P, 16 O, ://www.l.//l/l-l----, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Insight2008: Bl R Sl V C Bd, 18 D, : ://ld.l-.///w/15675/?l=297, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Insight2009: EU: Sl, C Ud Md, 6 M, : ://ld.l./

    //w/17188/?l=297, d 15 O 2013.Balkan Report2001: Sl d C R Bd A, 3 A, : ://www.fl./

    /l/1341147.l, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Report 2003: N Sl R Nw C Z, 17 O, : ://www.fl.//l/1341040.l, d 15 O 2013.

    Balkan Report2004: Sl d C: T Pl f D, 20 A, : ://www.fl.//l/1340991.l, d 15 O 2013.

    Brzel, Tanja A./Risse, Thomas 2012: F E d: Id, : W EPl 35/1, 1-19.

    Bw, C 2001: Bd d Idy Il Pll Ty, : Al, M/J,

    Dd/Ld, Yf (d): Id, Bd, Od: R Il Rl Ty,M d Ld: Uy f M P, 117-136.

    Caaruzza, Marina 2007: LIl l C Ol, Bl: Il Ml.

    CEC2012: R f C E Pl d Cl. T F YlRl f Md: Il f Rf W T Fw f H Ll A- Dl d P Of Gd Nly Rl. COM(2013) 205 l, S-: E C.

    CEC2010: Bd A A w Sl d C MEMO/12/8, Bl: EC.

    CEC2008: Cl f E U. Pdy Cl, 19-20 J. 11018/08 CONCL2, B-

    l: E C.ernic, Jernej L./Avbely, Matej 2007: T Cd f P By: Sl C T C

    f M Dl, : Jl f Il Lw d Ply 5/2, 1-19.

    Chrisansen, Thomas/Peto, Fabio/Tonra, Ben2004: Fzzy l d fzzy d: T EU N Ad, : C d C 35/4, 389-415.

    Corriere della Sera1994: F: ll Sl , 19 O.

    Deutsche Welle2013: Gy Bl: D l , 23 Fy, : ://www.dw.d/y--l-d-l-/-16623276, d 15 O 2013.

    Diez, Thomas/Steer, Stephan/Albert, Mathias 2006: T E U d d : T -f w f E , : Il Oz 60/3, 563-593.

    Fassino, Piero2003: P P, Ml: Rzzl.

    Friss, Lykke/Murphy, Anna 1999: T EU d Cl d E E: d d, :

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    19/21

    Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? | 19

    Jl f C M Sd 37/2, 211-232.

    Geddes, Andrew/Taylor, Andrew J.2013: Hw EU Cy B S S: M d B-d Sy S-E E, : W E Pl 36/1: 51-70.

    Hellenic Republic.d.: FYROM N I, A: My f F A, : ://www.f.//

    FYROM--/, d 15 O 2013.

    Homan, Stanley1966: O Ol? T F f N-S d C f WE, : Ddl 95/3: 862-915.

    ICG2011: Md: T Y A T C. E R N215, Sj, Il d Bl:Il C G.

    ICJ2011: Al f Ad f 13 S 1995 (T F Yl Rl f M-d . G) Jd 5 D, T H: Il C f J.

    Kelley, Judith G.2004: E Pl E. T Pw f N d I, P, NJ: P- Uy P.

    Klemeni, Mladen/Gosar, Anton2001: T l f Il-C-Sl d dl

    N Ad, : Gjl, 52/2, 129-137.

    Kuzmanovski, Blagoje2009: W I A N? Y Wld A T Q If Y Ld Md-, : RFE/RL, Jy 30, : ://www.fl.//Md__W_T_S_H_G_N_/1376847.l, d 15 O 2013.

    La Repubblica 1994: Cd l ll Sl. R L , 7 O.

    Lavenex, Sandra/Schimmelfennig, Frank2009: EU Rl Byd EU Bd: Tz Exl G-, : Jl f E Pl Ply 16/6, 791-812.

    Linklater, Andrew 1998: T Tf f Pll Cy, Cd: Ply P.

    Mali, Walter2002: Sy B Rl I, : Il Sd Rw 2/2,149-180.

    Naegele, Jolyon 1997: Md: G M V Sl I Rl, : RFE/RL, 9M, : ://www.fl.//l/1083950.l, d 15 O 2013.

    NATO2008: NATO Cl B S Dl, 3 Al, Bl: N Al Ty O-.

    Newman, David 2001: Bd, d d : ll, : Al, M/J, Dd/Ld, Yf (d): Id, Bd, Od: R- Il Rl Ty, M d Ld: Uy f M P, 137-152.

    OConnor, Coilin 2012: L B: Md N Pl R G I, : RFE/RL, Jy26, : ://www.fl.//d--l---/24626570.l,

    d 15 O 2013.Phillips, John2004: Md. Wld d Rl Bl, Nw H d Ld: Yl U-

    y P.

    RFE/RL2011: G Cz Md O Alxd T G S, RFE/RL, J 16, : ://www.fl.//d_lxd_____d/24237371.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL2009: Md F A S I M El, RFE/RL, Jy 27, : ://www.fl.//Md_EU_F_A_S_I_M_El/1375434.l, d15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL 2009: G A Cll Md EU A, RFE/RL, O 28, : ://www.fl.//G_A_Cll_Md_O_EU_A/1863435.l, -d 15 O 2013.

    REF/RL2008: Md: Vl M Gl El, RFE/RL, J 1, : ://www.fl./-/l/1144531.l, d 15 O 2013.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    20/21

    20 | KFGWorking Paper No. 54 | November 2013

    RFE/RL2007: Md W EU S I N D, RFE/RL, J 6, : ://www.fl.//l/1143886.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL2005: Md Pd O Fl T Ed N D W G, RFE/RL Nwl,Jy 24, : ://www../w/l/fl/2005/05-01-24.fl.l, d 15O 2013.

    RFE/RL 2005: Nw Dl Md-G N Rw, Bl R, Al 15, : ://www.fl.//l/1340941.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL News2009: Sl/C: A Nw D Bll Rl, 1 A, : ://www.fl.//l/1060066.l, d 15 O 2013.

    RFE/RL News 2009: Sl, C S Bd A Dl, 4 N, : ://www.fl.//Sl_C_S_Bd_A_Dl/1869476.l, d 15 O2013.

    Rich, Rich 1993: R f S: T Cll f Yl d S U, : E J-l f Il Lw 4/2, 36-65.

    Ruggie, John G. 1993: Tly d yd: lz dy l l, :Il Oz 77/1, 139-174.

    Sancin, Vasilka2010: Sl-C Bd D: F D- R P-K A,: E P 2/2, 93-111.

    Schimmelfennig, Frank/Sedelmeier, Ulrich2004: G y Cdly: EU Rl Tf Cdd C f Cl d E E, : Jl f E Pl Ply 11/4:661-679.

    Smith, Michael J.1996: T E U d E: l d f d, :Jl f C M Sd 34/1, 5-28.

    Stroschein, Sherrill 2012: E Sl, Cx, d Dz E E, Cd:Cd Uy P.

    Taylor, Andrew J./Geddes, Andrew/Lees, Charles2012: T E U d S E E. TDy f Ez d Mlll G, Ld: Rld/UACES.

    Turk, Danilo 1993: R f S: A C, : E Jl f Il Lw 4/2, 66-71.

    UN1993: Sy Cl Rl S/RES/817, 7 Al, Nw Y: T Ud N.

    UN1993: Gl Aly Rl A/RES/47/225, 8 Al, Nw Y: T Ud N.

    UN1995: G d F Yl Rl f Md I Ad, 13 S. UN T-y S Vl. 189. I-32193, Nw Y: T Ud N.

    Vd, Mld A. 2005: E Uddd. Dy, L, d I A C,Oxfd: Oxfd Uy P.

    Walker, R.B.J.1993: Id/Od: Il Rl Pll Ty, Cd: Cd U-y P.

  • 8/14/2019 Those Who Knock on Europes Door Must Repent? Bilateral Border Disputes and EU Enlargement

    21/21

    T Kllg-Fg - Eagig Aadmi Exag ad

    Iiv Ra

    T Kll-F (KFG) w fd l-d y G R Fd 2008. I - f KFG d lly l

    w dl w y d dd w ll f d j .

    T Kll-F T Tf Pw f E E Bl-Bd- d lz w - d . I x l f EU - d f d, lyz d f l d xl d :

    Idy d Pl S

    Cl, Cdly d Byd

    C Rl d E Exl Rl