thomas j.i.p. raassen, carrie ngongo, marietta …...fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and...

28
Iatrogenic Urogenital Fistulas Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta Mahendeka GMNHC 2015, Mexico City October 18 - 21

Upload: others

Post on 14-Feb-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

Iatrogenic Urogenital Fistulas

Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta Mahendeka

GMNHC 2015, Mexico City October 18 - 21

Page 2: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

MESSAGE

l Iatrogenic fistulas are a separate group l All cadres of service providers are

involved l Training needs to be improved l Alternatives for CS need to be used

Page 3: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

BACKGROUND

l From June 1994 – September 2012, 5.959

VVF/RVF-repairs l In over 65 hospitals in Eastern Africa and Asia l 805 Iatrogenic Fistulas, which is 13,2%

Page 4: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY

An Iatrogenic Genitourinary Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person

Page 5: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

IATROGENIC FISTULAS

3 Types l Uretero-(cervico)-vaginal fistulas l Vault fistulas

l Vesico-(utero)-cervico-vaginal fistulas

Page 6: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

OPERATIONS

l Caesarean Section (CS)

l CS/Hysterectomy for ruptured uterus

l Hysterectomy for gynecological reasons

Page 7: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

RISK FACTORS

l Prior uterine operations, especially CS l Endometriosis l Cervical myoma l Prior pelvic radiation l Inexperienced operators l Difficult circumstances in our setting

Page 8: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

URETERO-(CERVICO)-VAGINAL FISTULAS

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY

This is a lesion to the distal ureter during CS, CS/hysterectomy for ruptured uterus, or hysterectomy for gynecological reasons

Page 9: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

URETERO-CERVICO- VAGINAL FISTULA

Dr. Kees Waaldijk

Page 10: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

URETERO-(CERVICO)-VAGINAL FISTULAS

l Post CS alone 138 (50,6%) l Post Ruptured Uterus, Repaired 16 (5,8%) l Post Ruptured Uterus, Hysterectomy 57 (20,9%) (Obst) 211 l Post Hysterectomy (Gyn) 62 (22,7%) 62 Total 273

Page 11: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

PRIOR LAPAROTOMY

l C-section x 1 20 l C-section x 2 9 l C-section x 3 2

Total 31 (11,6%)

Page 12: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

OPERATOR l Specialist 26 l Registrar 9 l Medical Officer 145 (53,1%) l AMO/CO 93 (34,1%)

Total 273

Page 13: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VAULT FISTULAS

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY The vault fistula is a connection between

the bladder and the apex of the vagina (vault) and it occurs after total abdominal hysterectomy. It borders on the anterior edge of the vaginal scar

Page 14: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VAULT FISTULA

Page 15: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VAULT FISTULAS 2 GROUPS l Post Total Abdominal Hysterectomy 95

for gynecological indication l Post CS/Hysterectomy for ruptured 86 uterus, obstetric indication

Total 181

Page 16: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

PRIOR LAPAROTOMY

l CS once 20 l CS twice 4 l CS thrice 3 l Others 4 Total 31 (17,1%)

Page 17: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

OPERATOR l Specialist 48 (26,4%) l Registrar 8 l Medical Officer 95 (52,5%) l AMO/CO 30

Total 181

Page 18: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VESICO-UTERO/CERVICO- VAGINAL FISTULAS(VCVF)

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY This fistula is an accidental bladder injury (cut or suture) during a Caesarean Section, which is less than 3 cm

Page 19: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VCVF

Dr. Kees Waaldijk

Page 20: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VCVF 351

l Obstetric Origin 349

l Gynecological 2 Total 351

Page 21: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

VCVF 349

Obstetric l Live birth 210(60%) l Stillbirth 139(40%)

Total 349

Page 22: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

PRIOR LAPAROTOMY

Alive Stillborn Total l CS once 76 32 108 l CS twice 23 7 30 l CS thrice 3 3

Total 102 39 141(40,2%) l  (48,6%) (28,1%)

Page 23: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

OPERATOR

l Specialist 4 l Registrar 5 l Medical Officer 234 (66,7%) l AMO/CO 108 (30,8%)

Total 351

Page 24: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

IATROGENIC FISTULAS

3 TYPES l  Uretero-CVF 273 l  Vault Fistulas 181 l  Vesico-CVF 351

Total 805

Page 25: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

CONCLUSIONS RECOMMENDATIONS

l In my series 13,2% of the women have iatrogenic fistulas

l Iatrogenic fistulas are a separate group l All cadres of service providers are involved l Women with previous CS are at an increased

risk of iatrogenic fistula

l Most operations are performed by Med. Off.

and AMO’s/CO’s

Page 26: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

CONCLUSIONS RECOMMENDATIONS

l Training needs to be better. MO’s/AMO’s must perform CS under supervision, before they are posted to hospitals

l Prevention: Do not use blunt, but sharp dissection between bladder and uterus (Tancer, Hilton)

Page 27: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

CONCLUSIONS RECOMMENDATIONS

l Alternatives for CS need to be used, like

Vac. Extr., Destructive Delivery for dead babies and Symphysiotomy

l Early Detection and Catheter Treatment l Access: Improve the accessibility for

pregnant women to free maternity services

Page 28: Thomas J.I.P. Raassen, Carrie Ngongo, Marietta …...Fistula is a fistula between bladder/ureter and uterus/cervix/ vagina, resulting from surgery performed by a medical person IATROGENIC

Thank you