third edition labour relations - · pdf file1.4 the major theories of labour relations 7 the...

14
THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS in SOUTH AFRICA Editors *^^ ROBERT VENTER ANDREW LEVY MARINDA CONRADIE MAGGIE HOLTZHAUSEN B 370559 OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS SOUTHERN AFRICA

Upload: doanthuan

Post on 10-Mar-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

THIRD EDITION

LABOURRELATIONSin SOUTH AFRICA

Editors *^^ROBERT VENTER ANDREW LEVY

MARINDA CONRADIE MAGGIE HOLTZHAUSEN

B 370559

OXFORDUNIVERSITY PRESS

SOUTHERN AFRICA

Page 2: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

CONTENTS

Foreword xxi

Acknowledgements and dedications xx

1 An introduction to labour relations l

1.1 Introduction 3

1.2 Defining labour relations 4

1.3 The origins of labour relations 4

1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7

The unitarist approach 7

The pluralist approach 8

The Marxist approach 8

1.5 The parties to the employment

relationship and their respective roles 9

The secondary employment relationship 9

The primary employment relationship l i

The role of the employer 11

The role of the employee 12

Power and conflict within the primary

employment relationship 14

Power and exploitation 15

Conflict 16

1.6 The environment for labour relations in

South Africa 18

The micro-environment 18

Organisational culture 19

Leadership , 19

Communication 19

The nature of the workforce 20

Policies and procedures 20

The macro-environment 20

The economy 21

Government policy 21

Inflation and unemployment 21

Globalisation and retaining the

competitive edge 22

Technology 22

The socio-political environment 23

The legal framework 24

The social environment 26

Racial and gender imbalances 26

Education and training 27

Poverty, the standard of living and the

N. _ _ Human Development Index (HDI) 29

Healthcare 31

Chapter summary 33

Discussion questions 33

Experiential exercises 33

2 The historical development of

South African labour relations 35

2.1 Introduction 37

2.2 The origins of South African labour law 38

2.3 The industrial era - the introductionof the colour bar 38

2.4 Towards an industrial conciliation

mechanism 40

The 1909 Act 40

The First World War 41

The Rand Rebellion 41

2.5 The 1930s to the 1970s 42

The Nationalist era: 1950-1970 43

The uprisings during the seventies 44

2.6 The Wiehahn Commission: Towards the

deracialisation of South African labour

relations 45

The government's response to the

Wiehahn Commission 46

2.7 The eighties: Government reforms 47

The period following the 1981

amendments: 1982-1989 47

2.8 The nineties: An ethos of change 48

2.9 1994 and beyond: The shaping of anew dispensation 49

VIII

Page 3: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

The role of Nedlac 49

Towards a new labour dispensation 51

The Mbeki years 51

Chapter summary 53

Discussion questions 54

3 Comparative labour relations 55

3.1 Introduction 56

3.2 Globalisation 57

3.3 International and regional bodies 58

The International Labour Organisation 58

Southern African Development Council 59

The Non-aligned Movement and theAfrican Union 60

The New Partnership for Africa's

Development 60

3.4 Some international comparisons 60

Australia 60

Labour legislation 61

Collective bargaining and bargaining

structures ' 62

Workplace representation 62

Trade unions and industrial action 63

Other basic conditions of employment 63

Japan 64

Labour legislation 64

Trade unions . 66Disputes and industrial action 66

Collective bargaining 66

Workers' representation in theenterprise 66

Other basic conditions of

employment 67

3.5 Some comments about Africa 67

General labour-related challengesfacing the African continent 68

Discrimination at work in Africa 68

The quest for decent workopportunities 68

HIV/Aids 69

Implementing labour standards at the

workplace 69

Strong tripartism and social dialogue 69

Child labour 70

Closing the skills gap 70

Some African countries 71

Mozambique 71v Zambia 71

Nigeria 71

Ghana 72

Chapter summary 72

Review questions 72

Experiential exercises 72

4 Participants in South Africa's labour

relations system 73

4.1 Introduction 75

4.2 The state 75

4.3 Employees and trade unions 77

Definition of a trade union 77

Trade union representativeness

and access to the workplace 77

Types of trade unions 78

Craft unions 78

Industrial unions 79

General unions 79

White-collar unions 80

Trade union federations 80

Why workers join trade unions 80

Trade union objectives 80

Economic (including social welfare)

objectives 81

Job security 82

Working conditions and job regulation 82

Individual development andsocialisation 82Socio-political goals 82

Page 4: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Trade union structure and organisation 82

Shop stewards 84

Shop steward committees 85

Local branch committees 86

Regional branch committees 86

National Committee and National

Executive Council 86

National congress 86

Trade union recognition and access to

the workplace 87

Recognition of a new union 87

Organisational rights of representative

unions 88

The registration of trade unions 90

The effect of registration of atrade union or employers'organisation 92

Freedom of association and the

closed shop 93

Trade union growth in South Africa 94

South African trade unions and trade

union federations 95

Congress of South African Trade Unions 95

Federation of Unions of South Africa 96

National Council of Trade Unions 96

South African Confederation of TradeUnions 96

4.4 Employers and employers'

organisations , 96

Umbrella employers' organisations 98

Business Unity South Africa 98

Chambers of Commerce and Industry

South Africa 98

National chambers of commerce 98

South African Chamber of Business 99

National African Federation ofChambers of Commerce 99Afrikaanse Handelsinstituut 100

Employers' organisations at theindustry level 100

Chapter summary

Discussion questions

Experiential exercises

101

101

102

5 An introduction to labour economics 103

5.1 Introduction 104

5.2 Neo-classical micro-economic models. of wage determination 106

5.3 Elasticity of the demand and supply oflabour 108

5.4 The marginal product of labour 109

5.5 The supply of labour: The backward-bending supply curve Hi

5.6 The distribution of earnings, wagestructures, and the economic effectsof trade unions 113

The occupational or 'skill' differential 113

Inter-industry differentials 114

Union versus non-union differentials • 115

Geographic or regional differentials \ i i 6

Discriminatory differentials 116

5.7 Employment, unemployment andtechnological progress 116

Frictional unemployment 117

Seasonal unemployment 117

Deficient demand (cyclical

unemployment) 118

Structural unemployment 118

'Hard-core'unemployment 119

5.8 Unions, wage bargaining, and inflation 119

5.9 Governments and labour market policy 123

Chapter summary 123

Discussion questions 124

Experiential exercises 124

6 Contemporary issues in theSouth African labour market 125

6.1 Introduction 126

Page 5: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

6.2 Minimum wage regulation inSouth Africa 126

Direct contract between buyer andseller of labour - 127

Minimum wage levels set on asectoral basis by a statutorywage-fixing body 127

Statutory backed collective bargainingwith extension of the agreement tonon-participative parties 127

Voluntary collective bargaining at

plant or enterprise level 128

6.3 Labour market flexibility 129

Wage flexibility 131

Numerical flexibility 131

Functional flexibility 131

Work time flexibility 132

6.4 Grey labour markets 132

6.5 Outsourcing 135

Outsourcing to a labour- broker 135

Casualisation and short-termcontracts 136

Outsourcing the function to a serviceprovider 136

Extra-legal employment 136

6.6 The 'apartheid wage gap' argument 137

6.7 Labour market discrimination andequality legislation 138

6.8 Labour market effects of discrimination 139

6.9 Labour productivity, efficiency andglobalisation 141

6.10 Employment and the formal andinformal sectors 143

6.11 The historical legacy of apartheid onSouth African labour markets andunemployment 145

6.12 Broad and narrow definitions ofunemployment 149

6.13 Is South African unemployment a functionof lack of sufficiently skilled labour? 153

Chapter summary 155

Discussion questions

Experiential exercise

157

157

7 The South African labour legislative

framework 159

7.1 Introduction 165

7.2 The contract of employment 166

: Capacity to contract 166

- 'Age 166

Insanity 168

The influence of drugs and alcohol 168

The contract must be legal 169

Possibility of performance 169

Intention 169

Agreement 169

Misrepresentation 170

Mistake 171

Undue influence \ 172

Duress \l73

Duration of the contract 174

Fixed-term contracts 174

Indefinite-period contracts 174

Methods of concluding a contract of

employment 174

A written contract 174

A verbal contract 176

Tacit contracts 176

Duties of the employer 177

Receiving the employee into service 177

Expecting only reasonable and agreed

hours of work 177

Remunerating the employee 178

' Provision of safe working conditions 178

Leave 178

Compliance with statutory

requirements 179

Duties of the employee 179

To supply services 179

To perform competently 179

Page 6: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

To show loyalty 180

7b show reasonable respect and

obedience 180

To maintain levels of good conduct 180

Termination of contract of employment 180

On expiry 181

Completion of the specified task or

project 182

By notice duly given 182

By summary termination 183

By repudiation 183

Through mutual agreement 183

By dismissal 183

Bydeath 184

By insolvency 184

By sickness and disability 184

By state action 185

Due to operational requirements 185

7.3 The Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 185

Chapter 1: Purpose, application andinterpretation of the Act 185

Chapter 2: Freedom of association and

general protection . 186

Chapter 3: Collective bargaining 186

Part A: Organisational rights 186

Access 186

Deduction of union dues 187

Election of trade union representatives 187

Leave for trade union activities 188

Disclosure of information 188

Exercising organisational rights 189

Part B: Collective agreements 189

Agency-shop agreements 190

Closed-shop agreements 190

Part C: Bargaining councils 191

Powers and functions 191

Extension of bargaining council

agreements 193

Public service bargaining councils 193

Part E: Statutory councils 193

Establishment of statutory councils 193

Powers and functions of statutory

councils

Ministerial determinations

Part F: General provisions concerning

councils

Representivity of a council

Effect of registration of a council

Dispute resolution functions of

councils

Accounting records and audits

Admission of parties to councils

Changing the constitution and

registered scope of councils

Winding-up, sequestration, and

cancellation of councils

Disputes about demarcation between

sectors and areas

Chapter 4: Strikes and lockouts x

Definitions of strike and lockout

194

194

195

195

195

195

196

196

196

196

196

197

197

Limitations on the right to strike and

lockout 197

Procedural requirements 198

Effect of procedural strikes and lockouts 198

Replacement labour during strikes or

lockouts 199

Strikes and lockouts not in compliance

with the Act 199

Picketing 200

Essential services and maintenance

services 200

, Socio-economic protest action 200

Chapter 5: Workplace forums 201

Establishment of workplace forums 201

Composition and functioning of a

workplace forum 202

Specific matters for consultation 202

Specific matters for jointdecision-making 203

Page 7: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Disclosure of information 203

Dissolution of a workplace forum 204

Disputes about workplace forums 204

Chapter 6: Trade unions and employers'

organisations 204

Chapter 7: Dispute resolution 205

Part A: The Commission for

Conciliation, Mediation and

Arbitration (CMA) 205

Parts D and E: The Labour Court

and the Labour Appeal Court 205

Chapter 8: Unfair dismissal 205

The basic principles 206

Automatically unfair dismissals 206

Other unfair dismissals 207

Dismissal based on misconduct 207

Dismissal based on incapacity 208

Dismissal based on operational

requirements 208

Disputes about unfair dismissals and

unfair labour practices 212

Onus on dismissal disputes 213

Remedies for unfair dismissal and unfair

labour practices 213

Transfer of contract of employment 213

Chapter 9: General provisions 215

Temporary employment services 215

Contracts of employment r 215

Genera/ duties of employers 215

7.4 The Basic Conditions of EmploymentAct 75 of 1997 215

Chapter 1: Definitions, purpose, and

application of the Act 216

Purpose of the Act (section 2) 216

Application (section 3) 216

Inclusion of provisions in contracts of

employment (section 4) 216

Invalidity of agreements (section 5) 216

Chapter 2: Working time 216

Regulation (section 7) 216

Ordinary hours of work (section 9) 216

Overtime (section 10) 217

Extended ordinary daily hours of work

(section 11) 217

Averaging hours of work (section 12) 217

Determination of hours of work by the

_ Minister (section 13) 217

Meal intervals (section 14) 217

Daily and weekly rest period

(section 15) 217

Pay for work on Sundays (section 16) 218

Night work (section 17) 218

Public holidays (section 18) 218

Exclusions 218

Emergency work , 218

Chapter 3: Leave 218

Annual leave (sections 20 and 21) \ 218

Sick leave (sections 22 to 24) '' 218

Maternity leave (section 25) 219

Protection of employees before and

after the birth of a child (section 26) 219

Family responsibility leave (section 27) 219

Leave in excess of entitlement

(section 19) 219

Exclusions (sections 19, 28, and 36) 219

Chapter 4: Remuneration, deductions,and notice of termination 220

Payment of remuneration and deductions

(sections 32 to 35) 220

Chapter 5: Termination of employment 220

Conditions attached to termination of

employment (sections 36 to 42) 220

Exclusions (section 36) 220

Particulars of employment (section 29) 221

Information about remuneration(section 33) 221

Page 8: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Keeping of records (section 31)

Informing employees of their rights

(section 30)

Certificate of service (section 42)

221

221

221

Chapter 6: Prohibition of employment of

children and forced labour

Prohibition of employment of children

(sections 43 to 48)

221

221

Prohibition of forced labour (section 48)222

Chapter 7: Variation of basic conditions

of employment

Variation of agreement (section 49)

Variation by the Minister (section 50)

Chapter 8: Sectoral determination

Sectoral determination (section 51)

Investigation and report

(sections 53 to 56;

Making sectoral determinations

(section 55)

Period of operation of sectoral

determination (section 56)

. legal effect of sectoral determination

(section 57)

Chapter 9: Employment Conditions

Commission

222

222

223

223

223

223

224

224

224

224

Establishment of Employment Conditions

Commission (section 59)

Composition of the Commission

(section 60)

Public hearings (section 61)

Report by the Commission (section 62)

Chapter 10: Monitoring, enforcement,

and legal proceedings

Appointment of labour inspectors

(section 63)

Functions of labour inspectors

(section 64)

Powers of entry (section 65)

Powers to question and inspect

(section 66)

224

225

225

225

225

225

225

225

225

Co-operation with labour inspectors

(section 67)

Securing an undertaking (section 68)

Compliance order (sections 69 to 71)

Appeals (section 72)

Consolidation of proceedings

(section 74)

Payment of interest (section 75)

v Proof of compliance (section 76)

Jurisdiction (section 77)

Protection of rights of employees

(sections 78 to 81)

Chapter 11: General delegation

(section 85)

Deeming of persons as employees

(section 83)

Regulations (section 86)

Obstruction, undue influence, and fraud

(section 92) x

Codes of good practice (section 87) ^

Transitional provisions - Schedule 3

Application to farm workers (item 3)

Ordinary hours of work (item 5)

Leave (items 5 to 7)

Exemptions (item 8)

Wage determinations (items 9 and 10)

Collective agreements (item 11)

7.5 The Employment Equity Act

55 of 1998

An overview of the Act

Provisions

Elimination of unfair discrimination

' Prohibition of unfair discrimination

' Medical testing

Psychometric testing

Burden of proof

Affirmative action

Duties of designated employers

226

226

226

226

226

226

227

227

227

227

227

228

228

228

228

228

228

229

229

229

229

229

229

230

230

230

230

230

230

231

231

Page 9: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Affirmative action measures

Consultation with employees

Matters for consultation

Disclosure of information

Analysis

Employment equity plan

Report

Publication of report

Successive employment equity plans

Responsibility for monitoring and

implementation

Duty to inform

Income differentials

Commission for Employment Equity

Monitoring, enforcement, and legal

proceedings

General

Implementing employment equity

231

231

232

232

232

232

232

233

233

233

233

233

233

233

234

234

7.6 The Broad-Based Black Empowerment

Act 53 of 2003 236

The strategy for the advancement of

B-BBEE 237

B-BBEE Codes 237

7b whom do the codes apply? 238

How do the codes work? 238

How do the codes apply to small

enterprises? 239

Implications of BEE Codes for the

management of labour relations 240

Industry charters 240

7.7 The Skills Development Act

97 of 1998 240

The National Skills Authority 240

Sectoral Education and Training

Authorities (SETAs) 242

The National Skills Fund 242

Labour centres 242

The Skills Development Planning Unit 242

Offences 242

7.8 The Skills Development Levies

Act 9 of 1999 243

Calculation of a levy 243

Payment of a levy 243

Appointment and powers of inspectors 244

Undertakings and compliance orders 244

Offences 245

Proof of accuracy of statement 245

7.9 The Occupational Health and Safety

Act 85 of 1993 as amended by the

Occupational Health and Safety

Amendment Act 181 of 1993 247

Application of the Act 248

Advisory Council for Occupational

Health and Safety (sections 2 to 6) 248

An employer's duties (sections

8 to 13) 248

An employee's duties (sections

14 and 15) 249

Health and safety representatives \

(sections 17 and 18) 249

Health and safety committees

(sections 19 and 20) 249

Inspectors (sections 28 to 32) 250

7.10 The Compensation for OccupationalInjuries and Diseases Act 130 of1993 as amended by theCompensation for Occupational

Injuries and Diseases Act 61 of 1997 250

Death of an employee (section 54) 252

7.11 The Unemployment Insurance

Act 63 of 2001 as amended by the

Unemployment Insurance Amendment

Act of 2003 252

The Unemployment Insurance Fund 252

Claiming benefits 253

Enforcement 255

The Unemployment Insurance Board 255

7.12 The Unemployment Insurance

Contributions Act 4 of 2002 256

Chapter summary 256

Page 10: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Discussion questions

Experiential exercises

Appendices 1-4

257

257

258

8 Managing labour relations in the

workplace 269

8.1 Introduction 272

8.2 The employment relationship as a

source of rights and obligations 273

8.3 Employee misconduct, discipline and

dismissal 276

8.4 Termination of employment 278

The definition of the term 'dismissal' 278

Automatically unfair dismissals 279

Dismissals based on disciplinary

reasons 281

8.5 Elements of procedural fairness in

respect of terminations 282

Procedure in dismissals for

misconduct 283

Requirements for a fair hearing 284

Representation at a hearing 286

Representation by a fellow employee orshop steward 287

Outside respresentation - friends,

spouses, lawyers and consultants 287

Representation by full-time trade union

officials 288

The right to an interpreter , 288

Additional preparations 288

Administrative preparations 289

Decisions on holding joint orindividual hearings 289

Why should an employer hold

formalised hearings at all? An

alternative approach 290

The outside chairperson 290

Appeal hearings 291

Company offences that are also criminal

offences 292

Employee refusal to attend hearings 292

8.6 Substantive fairness 293

Warnings 295

Types of offences 296

Validity of warnings 296

Completing disciplinary forms 297

Suspension from employment 297

i Suspension on full pay 297

Suspension without pay as a

disciplinary measure 297

Demotions 298

Transfers 298

Resignation to avoid dismissal 298

Constructive dismissal 299

8.7 Common forms of misconduct 299

Misconduct involving acts of

dishonesty, unfair competition, and

similar breaches of the duty of

good faith \ 300

Breach of confidentiality 303

Unfair competition 303

Misconduct relating to assault,

fighting or harassment 304

Acts of misconduct relating to

timekeeping and attendance 306

Negligence as a form of misconduct 309

Misconduct in relation to drink or drugs 310

Internet and computer-related

misconduct 311

Impossibility of performance 312

Is the refusal to work overtime

misconduct? 313

8.8 Poor work performance/incapacity 314

Incapacity resulting from illness 316

8.9 Dismissals based on operational

requirements 317

Fair and valid reason 318

Consultation prior to termination 318

Parties to be consulted 319

Commencement of consultations 319

Page 11: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Prior notification 320

Steps to avoid or minimise dismissals 321

Steps to mitigate the adverse effects

of dismissals (retrenchments) 322

Implementation of agreed or fair

selection criteria 322

Last-in- first-out (UFO) 322

The UFO method of selection and the

'bumping' problem

Using skill levels as the method of

selection

Severance pay

Offer of re-employment

Changes in employment practice and

the operational requirement used in

other contexts

8.10 Grievance procedures

Grievance procedures defined

The need for grievance procedures

Open-door policy

Grievance procedures in different

organisations

Grievance procedures in practice

323

324

324

325

325

327

327

327

328

329

329

Utilisation of the grievance procedure 330

Levels for resolution of disputes 331

Benefits of an effective grievance

procedure 331

8.11 A methodology for making practical

decisions in the field of labour

management ( 331

The 'could I' question 332

The 'should I' question 332

Will I get away with it? 333

Will it come as a surprise? 333

Chapter summary 334

Discussion questions 335

Experiential exercises 336

Appendices 1-9 337

9 Collective bargaining and

organisational rights 367

9.1 Introduction 369

9.2 The duty to bargain 369

9.3 Organisational rights 369

Sufficient representation 370

Majority representation 370

Thirty per cent membership 370

Organisational rights 370

Trade union access to the workplace 371

Deduction of union dues 3714

Trade union representatives 371

Leave for trade union activities 371

Disclosure of information 372

Establishing thresholds of

representativity 373

Exercise of organisational rights \ 373

Disputes about organisational rights 374

9.4 The collective bargaining process 375

Duty to bargain 375

Bargaining content 375

Bargaining conduct 376

Bargaining styles 376

Bargaining levels and structure 376

Bargaining agents 377

Trade unions 377

Employers' organisations 378

Collective agreements 379

The legal effect of collective

agreements 379

Disputes about collective agreements 379

Union security arrangements 381

Agency-shop agreements 382

Closed-shop agreements 382

Bargaining structures 383

Bargaining councils 383

Statutory councils 387

Page 12: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

10

10.1

10.2

10.3

10.4

10.5

10.6

10.7

Workplace forums

Chapter summary

Discussion questions

Experiential exercise

Negotiation

Introduction

Defining negotiation

Distributive bargaining

Integrative bargaining

Intra-organisational bargaining

Attitudinal structuring and buildingrelationships

Internal factors that have animpact on negotiations

Bargaining power

Legitimate power

Referent power

Expert power

Coercive power

Reward power

External factors that have animpact on negotiations

Economic climate

Political conditions

Technology

Bargaining in good faith

The arguments used in wagenegotiations

Affordability

Comparability

Cost of living

ProductivityPublic policy

Negotiating tactics

Manipulation of data

Misleading the opposition

Emotive ploys

Switching roles

388

388

388

389

391

392

393

397

394

394

395

396

396

397

397

398

398

398

399

399

400

400

401

402

403

403

403

404

404

404

405

405

405

406

10.8

10.9

\

11

11.1

11.2

11.3

11.4

Negotiating strategies

Walking away

Dual concerns

Contingent outcomes and the'prisoner's dilemma'

The negotiating process

Preparation

Collection of data and all relevant

information

Establishing positions

Setting out objectives

Establishing the tone of theproceedings

Opening stages

Presenting the argument

Dealing with conflict

The outcome

Contend

Concede

Compromise

Chapter summary

Discussion questions

Experiential exercises

Dispute resolution

Introduction

The concept and nature of labourdisputes

How to minimise disputes in yourorganisation

Dispute resolution under the LabourRelations Act 66 of 1995

The Commission for Conciliation,Mediation and Arbitration as a disputeresolution mechanism

Main functions of the CCMA

Disputes that may be referred to theCCMA

406

406

406

407

407

407

407

408

408

408

409

409

410

411

411

411

412

412

413

413

415

416

417

418

419

419

420

420

Resolution of disputes in terms of theLabour Relations Act 422

Page 13: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

Resolution of disputes through

conciliation

Resolution of disputes through

arbitration

Problems experienced at the CCMA

Reasons for high referral rate to the

CCMA

Dispute referral statistics

Conciliation-Arbitration process

(Con-Arb)

Pre-dismissal arbitration

How to refer a case to the CCMA

Bargaining councils as a dispute

resolution mechanism

The Labour Court as a dispute

resolution mechanism

Functions of the Labour Court

The Labour Appeal Court

The new proposed structure of the

labour courts

Chapter summary

Review questions

Experiential exercises

Appendices 1-19

423

424

426

426

426

428

428

428

429

431

431

432

432

436

436

437

438

Increased productivity

Cost control

12 A Forms of worker participation

Consultation

Collective bargaining

Joint decision-making

Co-management

Self-management

"Financial participation

12.5 Implementing worker participation

Suggestion schemes

Task forces and teams

Dedicated work teams

Job enrichment

Quality circles

Financial participation

Employee Stock-Ownership

Plans (ESOPs)

Workplace forums

Consultation

Joint decision-making

Disclosure of information

Dissolution of workplace forums

475

475

476

476

476

476

477

477

477

477

477

477

478

478

478

479

. 479

\480

483

484

485

486

12 Worker participation in South Africa 469

12.1 Introduction 471

12.2 Defining worker participation 472

12.3 Objectives of worker participation 473

Ethical or moral objectives 473

Socio-political objectives 473

Economic objectives 473

More effective decision-making 473

Increased job satisfaction 474

Better commitment to quality

improvement 474

Management-employee ratio 474

Labour relations 474

Improved communication withinorganisations 475

Disputes relating to workplace forums 486

12.6 Essential ingredients for the success

of worker participation 488

Management commitment 488

Organisational culture 489

Management style 490

The structure of the organisation 490

Ongoing assessment of the

participative process 491

Education and training 491

Incentives and rewards 492

Trade union support 493

Effective engagement by subordinates 493

Chapter summary 493

Discussion questions 494

Experiential exercises 494

Page 14: THIRD EDITION LABOUR RELATIONS - · PDF file1.4 The major theories of labour relations 7 The unitarist approach 7 The pluralist approach 8 ... mechanism 40 The 1909 Act 40 The First

13 Industrial action

13.1 Introduction

13.2 A brief historical examination ofindustrial action in South Africa

13.3 The emerging union movement

13.4 The Industrial Court, the Unfair LabourPractice and the rise of legalism

13.5 Centralised collective bargaining

13.6 The Labour Relations Act

13.7 The seasonal pattern of strike activityin South Africa

13.8 Is South Africa strike prone?

13.9 Developments in the law on strikes

Repression of industrial action

Tolerance of industrial action

The right to strike and recourse tolockout 511

13.10The legal dimensions of industrial

action 511

Types of strike action 512

Go-slows 512

Works-to-rule • ' 513

Work-ins or sit-ins 513

13.11 Lockout 514

13.12 Protected strikes and lockouts under

the 1995 Labour Relations Act 516

The refusal to bargain 516

Secondary (sympathy) strikes 517

Strikes and lockouts in response todismissals for operationalrequirements 518

Limitations on the right to strike orrecourse to lockout 520

Strikes and lockouts in compliancewith the Act 521

497

498

499

502

504

505

506

508

508

509

509

509

Strikes and lockouts not incompliance with the Act(wildcat strikes)

13.13 Specific provisions relating to theright to strike

Picketing

Essential services

Maintenance services

^ Replacement labour

Socio-economic protest action

13.14The practicalities of strikemanagement

Chapter summary

Experiential questions

Appendices 1-3

522

524

524

527

529

530

530

531

531

532

533

14 Labour relations in South Africa:

Some future patterns and predictions 551

14.1 Introduction 553

14.2 Political transition 553

14.3 Economic transition 554

Labour market flexibility and internationalcompetition 554

The changing face of the employment

relationship 555

14.4 Social transition 557

Chapter summary 562

Discussion questions 562

Experiential exercise 562

Glossary

Table of cases

References

Websites

Permissions

Index

563

566

567

573

575

578