theoretical explanations for cosmic...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Theoretical Explanations for
Cosmic Acceleration
Physics Colloquium, University of Guelph, 17 October 2006
Eanna Flanagan, Cornell
![Page 2: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating, which according to general relativity implies the existence of a form of matter with negative pressure (dark energy).
• Negative pressure in general relativity
• Acceleration: observational pillars
• Why the new physics required is puzzling
• Survey of (i) frameworks (ii) models (iii) theoretical problems (iv) potential new observational channels
• Can we avoid dark energy by modifying gravity?
Outline
![Page 3: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The Hot Big Bang
Image credit: Wayne Hu and Martin White
![Page 4: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Constituents of the Universe today
Dark matter: we don’t know what this is, but there are several well-motivated ideas (particles).
Dark energy: we don’t know what this is (not particles), many ideas but few compelling ones.
![Page 5: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Observations show that on scales larger than about 10 million light years, the Universe is homogeneous and isotropic
The Large-scale Universe
Image credit: Stephen Landy
![Page 6: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Observations show that on scales larger than about 10 million light years, the Universe is homogeneous and isotropic
The Large-scale Universe
Fluctuations in the temperature of the 3K cosmic microwave background, 1 in 100,000
![Page 7: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Characterizing sources of gravity
![Page 8: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Characterizing sources of gravity (cont)Examples:
![Page 9: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Dynamics of the Expanding Universe
• Uniform expansion with scale factor a(t)
• Concentric spherical shells labeled by r, size a(t)r
• First law of thermodynamics:dE = !pdV
d(!c2r3a3) = !pd(r3a3)
p = wc2! =" ! # 1a3(1+w)
![Page 10: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Dynamics of the Expanding Universe
• Uniform expansion with scale factor a(t)
• Concentric spherical shells labeled by r, size a(t)r
• First law of thermodynamics:dE = !pdV
d(!c2r3a3) = !pd(r3a3)
p = wc2! =" ! # 1a3(1+w)
• Newton’s second law:
a(t)r = !G
!43!r3a3"
"
[ra]2
a
a= !4!G
3[" ]
![Page 11: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Dynamics of the Expanding Universe
• Uniform expansion with scale factor a(t)
• Concentric spherical shells labeled by r, size a(t)r
• First law of thermodynamics:dE = !pdV
d(!c2r3a3) = !pd(r3a3)
p = wc2! =" ! # 1a3(1+w)
• Newton’s second law:Correction due to general relativity
a(t)r = !G
!43!r3a3"
"
[ra]2
a
a= !4!G
3!" + 3pc!2
"
![Page 12: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Dynamics of the Expanding Universe
• Uniform expansion with scale factor a(t)
• Concentric spherical shells labeled by r, size a(t)r
• First law of thermodynamics:dE = !pdV
d(!c2r3a3) = !pd(r3a3)
p = wc2! =" ! # 1a3(1+w)
• Newton’s second law:Correction due to general relativity
a(t)r = !G
!43!r3a3"
"
[ra]2
a
a= !4!G
3!" + 3pc!2
"• Acceleration if p < !1
3c2!
![Page 13: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Analog of dark energy
![Page 14: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration • By combining first law of thermodynamics and acceleration equation:
a2 =8!G
3"a2 ! k, k = 0,±1
• Rewrite as:1
H20
a2
a2=
!M
a3+
!!
a3(1+w)+
!R
a4+
!k
a2,
1 = !M + !! + !R + !k
![Page 15: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration • By combining first law of thermodynamics and acceleration equation:
a2 =8!G
3"a2 ! k, k = 0,±1
• Rewrite as:1
H20
a2
a2=
!M
a3+
!!
a3(1+w)+
!R
a4+
!k
a2,
1 = !M + !! + !R + !k
• Cosmic microwave background (standard yardstick)
!R ! 10!4, |!k| " 0.05
![Page 16: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration • By combining first law of thermodynamics and acceleration equation:
a2 =8!G
3"a2 ! k, k = 0,±1
• Rewrite as:1
H20
a2
a2=
!M
a3+
!!
a3(1+w)+
!R
a4+
!k
a2,
1 = !M + !! + !R + !k
• Cosmic microwave background (standard yardstick)
!R ! 10!4, |!k| " 0.05
• Infer a(t) from brightness and redshifts of standard candles (Type Ia supernova)
![Page 17: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration (cont.)
![Page 18: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration (cont.)
![Page 19: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration (cont.)
No Big Bang
1 2 0 1 2 3
expands forever
-1
0
1
2
3
2
3
closed
recollapses eventually
Supernovae
CMB
Clusters
open
flat
Knop et al. (2003)Spergel et al. (2003)Allen et al. (2002)
Supernova Cosmology Project
!
!"
M
![Page 20: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Evidence for acceleration (cont.)
!M
–1.5
–1
–0.5
0
–1.5
–1
–0.5
0
–1.5
–1
–0.5
0
0 0.5–2
w
2dFGRS
w
w
Combined
With limits from;2dFGRS (Hawkins et al. 2002)and CMB (Bennet et al. 2003,� � Spergel et al. 2003)
Supernova Cosmology ProjectKnop et al. (2003)
Assuming constant w
w = –1.05 (statistical)+0.15–0.20
–0.09 (systematic)+
SNe
CMB
![Page 21: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Simplest model: Cosmological constant
• The case , constant energy density • Puzzle: expect quantum loops to generate a much larger
energy density, • Unknown higher energy physics can in principle cancel out this
contribution, but it requires exquisite fine tuning.• String theory predicts a multiverse with huge number of
different vacua, each with its own . Anthropic principle could explain smallness of our
• Problem: life might still evolve if were 1000 times larger.
w = !1 !! ! (10!3 eV)4
!! ! E4cuto"
!!
!!
!!
• Puzzle: The Universe has expanded by 35 orders of magnitude. Why are dark energy and matter comparable right now? Seems to require fine tuning of initial conditions.
![Page 22: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Dark energy versus time
![Page 23: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Dynamical models of dark energy
• Typically do not address cosmological constant problem• Can address the cosmic coincidence problem• Typically invoke new fundamental or effective fields
S = !!
d4x"!g
"12(#!)2 + V (!)
#
! =12!2 + V (!), p =
12!2 ! V (!)
!2 ! V (!) =" p # $!
• Like inflation models, but at much lower energy scale• Problem: expect loop corrections to spoil flatness of potential
and small mass of scalar field• One solution: scalar field is the size of compact extra
dimensions (radion), protected by diffeomorphism invariance
Quintessence:
![Page 24: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Modified Gravity vs. Dark Energy
• Evidence for dark energy presumes validity of general relativity. Perhaps, instead, general relativity is modified on large scales.
![Page 25: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Modified Gravity vs. Dark Energy
• Evidence for dark energy presumes validity of general relativity. Perhaps, instead, general relativity is modified on large scales.
• How do we decide if a given a modification of the laws of physics involves a modification of gravity? Perhaps ask which side of the Einstein equation is modified, or which term in action is modified:
Gµ! = 8!GTµ!
S =!
d4x!"g
R
16!G+ Smatter[gµ! ,!matter]
![Page 26: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Modified Gravity vs. Dark Energy
• Evidence for dark energy presumes validity of general relativity. Perhaps, instead, general relativity is modified on large scales.
• How do we decide if a given a modification of the laws of physics involves a modification of gravity? Perhaps ask which side of the Einstein equation is modified, or which term in action is modified:
Gµ! = 8!GTµ!
S =!
d4x!"g
R
16!G+ Smatter[gµ! ,!matter]
• This criterion is in fact ambiguous. Instead, we should ask if there are universal, long-range, 5th forces between macroscopic bodies.
![Page 27: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Modified Gravity vs. Dark Energy
Example:
S =!
d4x!"g
R
16!G+ Smatter[e!(!)gµ" ,!matter]"
!d4x!"g
"12(#")2 " V (")
#
gµ" $ e!(!)gµ" , " $ f("),
S =!
d4x!"g
"A(")R16!G
" 12(#")2 " V (")
#+ Smatter[gµ" ,!matter]
![Page 28: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Modified Gravity vs. Dark Energy
Example:
• In this theory, scalar field both acts like quintessence and mediates 5th forces.
• This mixed character is generic, since loop corrections generate matter couplings.
• Solar system tests of gravity (light bending, perihelion precession) require
• These theories can arise as effective description of extra dimensions• Other possible observational signatures: time evolution of effective
Newton’s constant (fine structure constant for generalized models)
S =!
d4x!"g
R
16!G+ Smatter[e!(!)gµ" ,!matter]"
!d4x!"g
"12(#")2 " V (")
#
gµ" $ e!(!)gµ" , " $ f("),
S =!
d4x!"g
"A(")R16!G
" 12(#")2 " V (")
#+ Smatter[gµ" ,!matter]
|!!(!)| ! 10"2 if V !!(!)! (A.U.)"2
![Page 29: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Modifying gravitational action: a catalog
• Are there successful models that are not “mostly quintessence”?
S[gµ! ,!m] =!
d4x!"g
f(R)16!G
+ Sm[gµ! ,!m]
‣ Equivalent to last model with , ruled out by Solar System!(!) = !/!
6
S[gµ! ,!m] =!
d4x!"g
f(R,Rµ!Rµ! , Rµ!"#Rµ!"#)16!G
+ Sm[gµ! ,!m]
‣ Problems with ghosts/acausality
![Page 30: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Modifying gravitational action: a catalog
‣ Ruled out; predicts modifications of particle physics at energy scale
S[gµ! ,!µ,!m] =!
d4x"#g
f(R)16!G
+ Sm[gµ! ,!m]
!!
H0Mp ! 10!3 eV
S[gµ! ,!µ,!m] =!
d4x"#g
f(R, R)16!G
+ Sm[gµ! ,!m]
‣ Some successful models. Equivalent to tensor bi-scalar model similar to the mixed models discussed earlier.
• Some interesting models based on extra dimensions do not have a simple effective 4-dimensional description, eg DGP model
![Page 31: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
• Probes of the expansion history of the Universe
• Probes of the growth of perturbations
• Precision tests of general relativity
• Specific observational windows (i) Supernovae (ii) Measurements of numbers of clusters using CMBR (iii) Weak gravitational lensing (iv) Baryon acoustic oscillations
Observational probes of dark energy
![Page 32: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Image credit: Max Tegmark
![Page 33: Theoretical Explanations for Cosmic Accelerationhosting.astro.cornell.edu/~flanagan/talks/Guelph/Guelph.pdf · 2006-10-25 · Recent observations show that the expansion of the Universe](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042411/5f297399265b635b1541ae24/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
• The discovery of the acceleration of the Universe requires new fundamental physics
• The dark energy might be a cosmological constant. We may never be able to explain its tiny size.
• The dark energy may be dynamical. Potential observational windows include (i) Probing the expansion history of the Universe (ii) Probing the growth of structure in the Universe (iii) High precision tests of general relativity (iv) Measurements of time evolution in fundamental constants of nature.
Conclusions