the semilibral “collateral” series in context caroline wazer ans summer seminar 2012

24
The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Upload: hannah-cannon

Post on 03-Jan-2016

226 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context

Caroline WazerANS Summer Seminar

2012

Page 2: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Collateral Series (Crawford 39/1-5)

Also known as:

• la série défective (Zehnacker, Moneta)

• the "struck aes series inscribed ROMA" (Thomsen, ERC)

Page 3: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Background: Republican Weight Standards

Traditional chronology:• "Heavy" libral (289 BC - 245 BC): ~324 g as• "Light" libral (245 BC - 217 BC): ~270 g as• Semilibral (217 BC - 215 BC): ~135 g as• Post-semilibral (215 BC - 212 BC): various• Sextantal (c. 212 BC - 207 BC): ~54 g as• Uncial (c. 207 - 146 BC): ~27 g as

Page 4: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Background: Aes Grave iconography

“The iconography of these pieces is of particular historical interest (compensating for their frequently clumsy artistry), since they represent in its earliest known stage of development the unrivalled Roman instinct for using coins as a medium of communication and propaganda. Messages of religious symbolism, national pride, superstition, and hortatory common sense all find their place right from the start.”

-Thurlow and Vecchi, 1986

Page 5: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Background: The Prow types

Page 6: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Background: The Prow types(Crawford nos. 35, 38, 41, 56, 338-9)

Denomination Deity on obverse Function and/or patronage (after Scheid, p.155-157)

As Janus Beginnings, esp. of commercial enterprises

Semis Saturn (or Jupiter?) Sovereignty; patron of the state

Triens Mars (or Minerva?) War and agricultural bounty; patron god of the city of Rome

Quadrans Hercules Success in heroic activities; patron of entrepreneurs; in S. Italy, patron of farmers

Sextans Mercury Journeys; patron of merchants

Uncia Bellona (or Roma?) War; patroness of Rome

Semuncia Mercury Journeys; patron of merchants

Page 7: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Background: The Prow types

Page 8: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Background: The Second Punic War

• 218: Rome declares war after Hannibal crosses the Ebro

• Winter 218 - 217: Hannibal crosses Alps

• 217: Semilibral standard introduced?

• June 217: The defeat at Lake Trasimene - 15,000 killed on Roman side

• August 216: The defeat at Cannae - up to 75,000 killed on Roman side; Italian allies in Campania and Apulia start to defect

• 213: Hannibal takes most of Southern Italy

Page 9: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Collateral Series

Page 10: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Collateral series types

Denomination Obverse Reverse

Triens Woman with diadem -- Juno? Hercules with centaur, ROMA

Quadrans Hercules (?) wearing a boarskin Bull and snake, ROMA

Sextans She-wolf suckling twins Eagle with flower in beak, ROMA

Uncia Sol with radiate crown Crescent with two stars, ROMA

Semuncia Female bust with mural crown Equestrian with whip, ROMA

Page 11: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Triens

Page 12: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Quadrans

Page 13: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Sextans

Page 14: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Sextans - comparison

Page 15: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Uncia

Page 16: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Semuncia

Page 17: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Collateral Series

Page 18: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Archaeological finds

Green = hoards; blue = single finds

Page 19: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Hoard evidenceHoard (RRCH #) # of

semilibral collateral

# of semilibral Prow series

# of libral aes grave (heavy and light)

# of post- semilibral Prow series

# of other coins

Campana (#49) 1 11 0 0 51

Capua (#56) 7 46 31 0 1

Termoli (#70) 23 192 51 10 1

Mandanici (#71) 1 3 0 0 37

Castagneto (#77) 2 11 2 13 23

Isernia (#78) 15 34 4 5 149

Tortoreto (#101) 1 170 6 13 57

Fontanarosa (#141)

1 0 0 440 2

Page 20: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Collateral Uncia

Triens?, Velecha, c.216 - 211

Hannibalic imitations

Page 21: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Collateral Semuncia

Biunx, Capua, 216 - 211 BC

Hannibalic imitations

Page 22: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Some conclusions about the collateral series

• Its iconography is fundamentally different from that of the Prow series, both in content and in meaning.

• It circulated alongside the Prow series, in both space and time.

• It must have been first minted at the early end of Crawford’s dating-- 217 or early 216-- when cities like Capua were still under Roman control.

Page 23: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Open Questions and Further Research

• Were the two semilibral series actually struck at the same time, or just so close together in time that the obsolete one was still in circulation?

• Why was production of the collateral series stopped?

• How big was the issue of the collateral series?

Page 24: The Semilibral “Collateral” Series in Context Caroline Wazer ANS Summer Seminar 2012

Hercules/Bull Quadrans

Marsic Confederation denarius, Social War (90 - 88 BC)

Denarius of L. Thorius Balbus, 105 BC