the role of the public health nurse in disaster
TRANSCRIPT
The Role of the Public Health Nurse
In Disaster
Preparedness, Response, and Recovery
APositionPaper
AssociationofPublicHealthNursesPublicHealthPreparednessCommittee
January2014
*Thisisthe2ndeditionofanAssociationofPublicHealthNurses(APHN)PositionPaper,firstpublishedin2007underAPHN’spreviousname:AssociationofStateandTerritorialDirectorsofNursing(ASTDN).The1steditionwassupportedbyASTHO'sCooperativeAgreementtoImprovetheNation'sPublicHealthInfrastructurewithStatePublicHealthAgencies/Systems,awardnumberU50/CCU313903-8-4,fromtheCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention(seereferences).**Thisdocumentisbasedonupdatedinformationwithinputfromthefirsteditionauthors,externalreviewers,andtheQuadCouncilmembers,acoordinatingorganizationoffournursingorganizationsfocusedonpublic/communityhealthnursing:ACHNE,ANA,APHA,andAPHN.***ReferencelinksupdatedinOctober2015
2
ExecutiveSummaryNosinglediscipline,agency,organizationorjurisdictioncanorshouldclaimsoleresponsibilityforthecomplexarrayofchallengesassociatedwithdisasters,whethercausedbynature,humans,orsomecombinationofboth.Eachentity,though,mustunderstanditsrespectiverole.PublichealthnursesplayanintegralroleinmeetingtheNationalPreparednessGoal.Indisasterpreparedness,response,andrecoveryoperations,publichealthnursesmustbeabletodowhattheydobest--populationbasedpracticeintheircommunities.Sometimes,though,thereisconfusionastowhatapublichealthnurseshouldandcandoinpreparedness,response,andrecoveryoperations.Thispositionpaperprovidespracticalguidanceacrossthedisasterlifecycleaswellasprovidingrespectiveresourcelinkages.Itisdesignedtoinformpublichealthnursesabouthowtoconducttheircriticalworkinadisasterwhilehelpingotherstounderstandthatwork.
Acknowledgements
TheAssociationofPublicHealthNurses(APHN)recognizesthatpublichealthnursespossessabroadrangeofpopulationbasedknowledge,skills,andnursingexpertisewhenitcomestodisasterpreparedness,response,andrecovery.Theoriginalpositionpaperontheroleofpublichealthnursesindisasterwaspublishedin2007(undertheAPHN’spreviousname:AssociationofStateandTerritorialDirectorsofNursing(ASTDN)byitsPreparednessCommitteemembershipatthetime.Usingthisprevioustemplate,the2013APHNPublicHealthPreparednessCommitteereviewedcurrentkeynationaldisasterdocuments,analyzedpublichealthandnursingdisasterrolesinrecentdisasters,analyzedthecurrentstateofcompetencyresearchandapplicablepracticemodels,andheldfocusgroupsfornursingandpublichealthinput.Theresultisthe2013TheRoleofPublicHealthNursesinEmergencyandDisasterPreparedness,Response,andRecovery.PositionPaperSubcommittee:
• SharonA.R.Stanley,PhD,RN,RS,FAANPreviousChiefNurse,AmericanRedCross,NationalHeadquarters,WashingtonD.C.andVisitingProfessor,CollegeofNursingandHealth,WrightStateUniversity,Dayton,OH-CommitteeCo-Chair
• SandraCole,RN,BA,ProgramManager,BureauofHealthEmergencyManagement,NewMexicoDepartmentofHealth,SantaFe,NM-CommitteeCo-Chair
• JudyMcGill,RN,MS,PublicHealthNurseCoordinator,OfficeofCommunityHealthSystemsandHealthPromotion,WestVirginiaDepartmentofHealth,Charleston,WV
• ClairMillet,MN,APRN,PHCNS-BC,DirectorofPublicHealthNursing,LouisianaDepartmentofHealth&HospitalsOfficeofPublicHealth,BatonRouge,LA
• DarleneMorse,RN,MEd,CHES,PublicHealthNurseProgramManager,BureauofInfectiousDiseaseControl,NewHampshireDepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,Concord,NH
Wethankallmembersofthe2012–2014PublicHealthPreparednessCommitteefortheirguidanceandinsight.WealsothankthemembersoftheQuadCouncilandothercolleagueswhoreviewedandofferedsuggestionsregardingthepaper.Aspecialthanksisdeliveredtoourtwoexternalreviewerswhoprovidedtheirexpertreviewforthefinalversion:KristineQureshi,PhD,RN,FAAN,andTenerGoodwinVeenema,PhD,RN,MPH,FNAP,FAAN.
3
TableofContents
Acknowledgements…..…………………………………………………………………………………………..…. 2
Introduction….…………………………………………………………………………………………….…………… 4
PrinciplesforPHNpracticeindisaster………………………………………………………… 5
Vision...……………………………………………………….……………..………………………………… 5
Purposeanduse……………………………….………………………………………………………….. 5
PHNRoleinDisaster….………………………………………………………………..……………………..……. 5
DefinitionandscopeofPHNpractice...…………………………….……………….…….…… 5
Puttingitalltogether..……………………………….…………………………………..…….……… 6
Linkingcomponentsofthenursingprocesswiththedisastercycle…..……..…. 6
CompetencyforDisasterPractice…….…………………………...……………………………………...… 9
PublicHealthPreparednessandResponseCoreCompetencies…..…….……….… 9
ICNFrameworkofDisasterNursingCompetencies…….………………….….….……… 10
LeadershipPlanningandPolicyDevelopment..…………..………………………………………….... 11
Leadershipcollaboration…..………………………………………………………………………….. 11
Metaleadership(crisisleadership)………………..…….…..…………………………………… 12
LegalandEthicalIssues…..………………………………..………………………………………………………. 13
Licensure,geographicboundaries,anddutytorespond…….…………………………. 13
GoodSamaritanLaw..………………………………………….………………………………………… 13
Existingprotections…..…………………………………………………………………………………… 13
Summary ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 14
RecommendedReadingandKeyDocuments………………………………………………...…..….. 15
References …………………………………………………………………………………………………..…..…. 17
4
The Role of Public Health Nurses
In Disaster Preparedness, Response, and Recovery
APositionPaper
IntroductionPreparingfor,respondingto,andrecoveringfromdisastersisapublichealthprioritythatmustbeaddressedinanenvironmentofconstrainedresources.FlorenceNightingaledemonstratedtotheworldtheimportantroleofnursesonthefrontlinesofwar-relateddisaster,andnursescontinuetogrowthesecapabilitiesinthe21stCentury.Publichealthwasaffordedtheopportunitytogreatlyincreasecapacityacrossthedisastercycleinthecommunitysectorwithdedicatedresourcesintheearly2000s.Itwasatimeofsolidgrowthforpublichealthandpublichealthnursingintermsofassuringcommunityresilienceatthelocal,state,andnationalsectors.Publichealthmustnow,morethanever,expertlyengageitsinternalandexternalpartners,aswellasitscommunities.Nosinglediscipline,agency,organizationorjurisdictioncanorshouldclaimsoleresponsibilityforthecomplexarrayofchallengesassociatedwiththedisaster,whethercausedbynature,humans,orsomecombinationofboth.Publichealthnurses(PHNs)playanintegralroleinmeetingtheNationalPreparednessGoal,apartoftheNationalPreparednessSystem:“Asecureandresilientnationwiththecapabilitiesrequiredacrossthewholecommunitytoprevent,protectagainst,mitigate,respondtoandrecoverfromthethreatsandhazardsthatposethegreatestrisk(FEMA,2013).“Nursingand,specifically,publichealthnursingpracticemustremainaconstantacrossthenationalplanningframeworkanditsdisastercycleofpreparedness(prevention,protection,mitigation),response,andrecovery.TherecognitionofPHNs’population-basedskillsintimesofdisasterisanextremelyimportantpartofournationalcapacityforresponse.Publichealthnursesshouldnotbesimplyviewedasacutecare(i.e.,hospital)replacementsorfirstresponderextenders(e.g.,triagepersonnel)inamasscasualtyenvironment.ThisisnottosaythatPHNscannotdothesefunctionsifeducated.Indeed,allhealthprofessionalsmaybecalledupontoexpandinnon-routinepracticeareasduringacatastrophicresponse.Aboveall,though,indisasterpreparedness,response,andrecovery,PHNsarebetterusedforservicestheydobest,namelypopulationbasedpracticelikerapidneedsassessmentsofcommunitiesimpactedbytheincident,population-basedtriage,massdispensingofpreventiveorcurativetherapies,communityeducation,providingcareormanagingsheltersfordisplacedpopulationsand,ofcourse,provisionofongoingcontinuityinessentialpublichealthservices.Publichealthnursespossesstheskillsandknowledgetodevelopdisasterpoliciesandcomprehensiveplans,andtoconductandevaluatepreparednessandresponsedrills,exercisesandtrainings.Theyareintegralmembersinresponseoperationsandcommandcenters,in
5
leadershipandmanagementroles,aswellasinthefieldwheretheyprovidefrontlinepopulationhealthandcorepublichealthservices.ThePHNisalsoadeptincollaboratingwithotherexperts,includingenvironmentalists,epidemiologists,laboratorians,biostatisticians,physicians,socialworkers,andothernurses.Interprofessionalpracticeisrequiredtoenhancepreparedness,response,andrecoveryatthelocal,regional,state,nationalandgloballevels.Strongsystemsandmodelsareneededtomaximizethecollaborationoffirstresponders,healthcareprofessionals,andvolunteers.PrinciplesforPHNpracticeindisaster1.Publichealthnursingrolesindisastersareconsistentwiththescopeofpublichealthnursingpracticeandarearticulatedspecificallyinthosestandardsandscope(ANA,2013).2.ThecomponentsofthenursingprocessalignwiththeNationalPlanningFrameworkphasesofpreparedness(prevention,protection,mitigation),response,andrecovery(ANA,2010;FEMA,2013).3.CompetenciesprovideaframeworkfordefiningPHNroleandstandardsofpracticeacrossthedisastercycleandthesecompetenciesincludethosefrompublichealthnursing,disasternursing,disasterpublichealth,andcompetenciesspecifictopublichealthnursespracticeindisasters(ASPH,2010;ICN2009;QuadCouncil,2011).4.Publichealthnursesbringleadership,policy,planning,andpracticeexpertisetodisasterpreparedness,response,andrecovery.VisionPublichealthnurseswhounderstandtheirdisasterrolesinlightoftheirscopeofpracticeandtheNationalPlanningFrameworkswillbereadyforpracticeacrossthedisastercycle,advocatingforandworkingbesidethewholecommunity.PurposeandusePublichealthnursingpracticefocusesonpopulationhealththroughcontinuoussurveillanceandassessmentofthemultipledeterminantsofhealthwiththeintenttopromotehealthandwellness,preventdisease,disability,andprematuredeath,andimproveneighborhoodqualityoflife(ANA,2013:2).Thispositionpapertargetsthefollowingaudiences:1)publichealthnursesatlocal,regional,andstatelevels;2)disasterpartnersinordertobettercoordinateefforts;and3)stakeholderswhoneedtounderstandPHNpracticeindisastersituations.
ThePublicHealthNursingRoleinDisasterPreparedness,Response,andRecoveryDefinitionandscopeofPHNpracticePublichealthnursingis“thepracticeofpromotingandprotectingthehealthofpopulationsusingknowledgefromnursing,social,andpublichealthsciences(AmericanPublicHealthAssociation,PublicHealthNursingSection,2013,p.1).”
6
Societalandpoliticalchangesleadingintothe21stcenturyhaveenhancedtheevolutionofidentifiedthreatstothehealthofthepopulation.Thesethreatshavebeenidentifiedas:(1)re-emergenceofcommunicabledisease;(2)environmentalhazards;(3)physicalorcivicbarrierstohealthylifestyles;(3)overallconcernaboutthestructureandfunctionofthehealthcaresystem;(4)modernpublichealthepidemics,suchaspandemicinfluenza,obesity,etc.;and(5)globalandemergingcriseswithincreasedopportunitiesforexposuretomultiplehealththreats(ANA,2013,pp.1-2).Thesethreatshavecreatedacrucialshifttowardspublichealthall-hazardspreparedness.Duringadisaster,PHNscontinuetoadheretotheeightprinciplesofpublichealthnursingpractice(QuadCouncil,2011)andthecorefunctionsofpublichealth(IOM,2002).PuttingitalltogetherPublichealthnursesworkattheindividual,family,community,andsystemslevelstopromotehealthandpreventdiseasewiththeultimategoalofhealthypeopleinhealthycommunities.Theybringcriticalexpertisetoeachphaseofthedisastercycle:preparedness(prevention,protection,andmitigation),responseandrecovery.Theyhaveauniqueskillsetandanabilitytolinksystemsthatarevitaltothedisastercontinuumtoinclude,butnotlimitedtodiseasesurveillance,diseaseandhealthinvestigation,casefinding,rapidneedsassessment,publichealthtriage,massprophylaxisandtreatment,collaboration,healthteachingandprovidereducation,communityorganizing,outreachandreferral,populationadvocacyandpolicydevelopment.Publichealthnursing’sabilitiesarecriticalforpopulation-basedcareacrossthedisastercycle.Publichealthnursesareknowledgeableaboutthediversecommunityresourcesthatareavailable,aswellaswhatgapsmayexistincommunityservices,before,duringandafteradisaster.Thus,thePHNhasauniqueawarenessofthevulnerablepopulationsinthecommunity,andwhomaybeatheightenedrisk.APHN’sclinicalknowledgeinmultipledeterminantsofhealthandepidemiologyandwell-honedcommunityassessmentskillsserveacrucialroleindisasterpreparedness,response,andrecovery.Resilientcommunitiesareabletorecoverfromadverseevents.Publichealthnurseshelpfurtherresilienceincommunitiesduringdisasterswiththeirdiverseskillsets.Theyassistpopulationstoovercomegreatadversityandstressthatoftenoccurindisaster(s)byfacilitatingindividuals,familiesandcommunitiestouseavailableresourcestorespondto,withstand,andrecover.LinkingcomponentsofthenursingprocesswiththedisastercycleToclarifytherelationshipbetweenPHNpracticeandphasesofadisaster,Table1illustrateshoweachstepofthenursingprocessispracticedduringeachphaseofthedisastercycle.Thistablecanbeusedtoeducateandinformnurses,partners,andstudentsaboutthepotentialroleofPHNsacrossthedisastercycle.
7
Table1:THEDISASTERCYCLELINKEDTOTHENURSINGPROCESS
EXAMPLESOFEACHDISASTERPHASEALIGNEDWITHTHENURSINGPROCESSv
Preparedness,responseandrecoveryfocusesonthepublichealthinfrastructureneededtomonitortheenvironment,
assesspopulationneeds,andallocateresourcesintimesofdisaster.
vBASEDONJAKEWAY,C.,LAROSA,G.,CARY,A.&SCHOENFISCH,S.(2008).THEROLEOFPUBLICHEALTHNURSESINEMERGENCYPREPAREDNESSANDRESPONSE:APOSITIONPAPEROFTHEASSOCIATIONOFSTATEANDTERRITORIALDIRECTORSOFNURSING.PUBLICHEALTHNURSING,25(4),353-361.
DISASTERC
YCLE
DEFINITION*
*DEFINITIONSRETRIEVED
FROM:HTTP://WWW.FEMA.GOV
/MISSION-AREAS
ASSESSMENT PLANNING IMPLEMENTATION EVALUATION
PREPARED
NESS
Preparednessincludesprevention,protectionandmitigation.
Itcomprises“thecapabilitiesnecessarytoavoidand/orpreventadisaster,aswellastoreducethelossoflifeandpropertybylesseningtheimpactofdisasters.”
Eliminationofthreatsbeforeadisasterstrikes.
Assesstheregionforpopulationsatriskforaccessandfunctionalneedsduringtimesofdisaster.
Conductahazardvulnerabilityassessmentforthreatsandhazardsthatposethegreatestrisk.
Developacareplantoaddressaccessandfunctionalneedsofpopulationsduringtimesofdisaster.
Completethisassurancefunctionincollaborationwithstakeholderstoaddressneedssuchasshelteringinplace,evacuation,andmasscasualtysurgecapabilities.
Conducttraining,drillsandexercisesrelatedtothecareofindividuals,familiesandcommunitiesduringdisaster,focusingonpopulationswithaccessandfunctionalneedsinanidentifiedregion.
Evaluatethetraining,drillsandexercisesrelatedtothecareofpopulationswithaccessandfunctionalneedsindisaster,identifyinggapsandremainingneeds.
Evaluateoperationalplansforpreparedness,responseandrecoveryforpopulationswithaccessandfunctionalneeds.
8
ASSESSMENT PLANNING IMPLEMENTATION EVALUATION
RESPO
NSE
Responsecomprises“thecapabilitiesnecessarytosavelives,protectpropertyandtheenvironment,andmeetbasichumanneedsafteranincidenthasoccurred.”✜PUBLICHEALTHTRIAGE:F.M.BURKLE,POPULATION-BASEDTRIAGEMANAGEMENT
INRESPONSETOSURGE
CAPACITY
REQUIREMENTSDURING
ALARGE-SCALEBIOEVENTDISASTER.ACADEMICEMERGENCY
MEDICINE2006:13:1120.
Usepublichealth,population-basedtriagetoassesscommunicablediseaseoutbreakimpactandneededresponse(e.g.,influenza).
Populationbasedtriageinvolvingsurveillancetodividetheaffectedpopulationintosusceptible,exposed,infected,removed,andvaccinatedforexpedientandlife-savingtreatment.✜
Collaboratewithresponsepartnerstodevelopplansfortriagealgorithmsthatdetermineappropriatecareandsustenancelogisticsforpopulationsbasedontheirsymptomsandco-morbidconditions(e.g.,chronicdisease).
Identifyandplacepublichealthnursesandothersupportpersonneltoprovidecareaccordingtothedevelopedalgorithms.
Assurethatlogisticsareinplacetosupportcommunitycareduringthecrisisperiod.
Conductongoingrapidneedsassessmentsduringtheresponsephaseinordertomeetpopulationneeds.
Participateinongoingresponseplanningduringtheincident(e.g.,theIncidentManagementSystemanditsPlanning“P”).
Participateinserviceplanningandprovidereal-timeadjustmentonthebasisofreal-timepublichealthresponseevaluation.
Assureneededandnecessarypublichealthnursingcare.
RECO
VERY
Recoverycomprises“thecorecapabilitiesnecessarytoassistcommunitiesaffectedbyanincidenttorecovereffectively.”
Conductongoingrapidneedsassessmentatappropriateintervalstodeterminehealthandcriticalresourcecapacityafteranaturaldisaster(e.g.,earthquake.)
Workwithcommunitystakeholderstoplanforanylong-termhealthconcernsfollowinganincident,gettingaheadofthecurvebyidentifyingkeyresourcesandcriticalcarelogistics.
Participateinthereconstitutionofcriticalservicesandthesustainmentofthehealthandsocialinfrastructure.
Assistthecommunitytofindits“newnormal”post-disaster.
Conductevaluationofthelong-termimpactofdisasterconsequencesonthewholecommunity,promotingpublichealthessentialservicesthroughpublichealthnursing.
9
CompetencyforDisasterPractice
Incompetency-basedpractice,thepublichealthnursemayhaveahardtimedecidingwhichsetofcompetenciestouse.Thechoiceisanimportantone,though,sincecompetenciesservetoinformevidencebasedpractice,standardsdevelopment,andlearningneeds(InternationalCouncilofNursing(ICN),2009).Identifyingcompetenciesisaprocessthatinvolvesthereviewofpeer-reviewedliteratureandeducationaltheory,areviewofexistingcompetencies,thesynthesisofnewcompetencies,areviewbyanexpertpanel,arefiningofnewcompetencies,andthedevelopmentofterminalobjectivesforeachcompetency(Gebbie,Hutton,&Plummer,2012).Eachoftherecommendedcompetencysetsinthissectionfollowedthatprocess.Publichealthnursesareencouragedtostudyandacquirethesecompetencies,thenapplythemtotheirownpracticeinanticipationofdisasterpreparedness,response,orrecovery.PublicHealthPreparednessandResponseCoreCompetencies(ASPH,2010)ThePublicHealthPreparednessandResponseCoreCompetenciesaretobeusedwiththeunderstandingthattheyarepracticedwithinfoundationalpublichealthcompetencies,genericemergencycorecompetencies,andposition-specificorprofessionalcompetencies.Thefourcorecompetenciesspanpreparedness,responseandrecoveryroles.PerformanceGoal:Proficientlyperformassignedprevention,preparedness,response,andrecoveryrole(s)inaccordancewithestablishednational,state,andlocalhealthsecurityandpublichealthpolicies,laws,andsystems.1.ModelLeadership
1.1Solveproblemsunderemergencyconditions.1.2Managebehaviorsassociatedwithemotionalresponsesinselfandothers.1.3Facilitatecollaborationwithinternalandexternalemergencyresponsepartners.1.4Maintainsituationalawareness.1.5Demonstraterespectforallpersonsandcultures.1.6Actwithinthescopeofone'slegalauthority.
2.CommunicateandManageInformation
2.1Manageinformationrelatedtoanemergency.2.2Useprinciplesofcrisisandriskcommunication.2.3Reportinformationpotentiallyrelevanttotheidentificationandcontrolofanemergencythroughthechainofcommand.2.4Collectdataaccordingtoprotocol.2.5Managetherecordingand/ortranscriptionofdataaccordingtoprotocol.
3.PlanforandImprovePractice
10
3.1Contributeexpertisetoacommunityhazardvulnerabilityanalysis(HVA).3.2Contributeexpertisetothedevelopmentofemergencyplans.3.3Participateinimprovingtheorganization’scapacities(including,butnotlimitedtoprograms,plans,policies,laws,andworkforcetraining).3.4Refermattersoutsideofone'sscopeoflegalauthoritythroughthechainofcommand.
4.ProtectWorkerHealthandSafety
4.1Maintainpersonal/familyemergencypreparednessplans.4.2Employprotectivebehaviorsaccordingtochangingconditions,personallimitations,andthreats.4.3Reportunresolvedthreatstophysicalandmentalhealththroughthechainofcommand.
InternationalCouncilofNurses(ICN)FrameworkofDisasterNursingCompetencies(ICNandWorldHealthOrganization,2009)TheInternationalCouncilofNurses(ICN)developeddisasternursingcompetenciestohelpclarifytheroleofthenurseinadisasterandassistinthedevelopmentofdisastereducation.AlthoughthecompetenciesdonotaddressthespecificcompetenciesrequiredforPHNpractice,theyaredesignedtoserveastheunderpinning(ICN,2009,p.7).TheICNdisasternursingcompetenciesspanfourbroadareasofcompetencies:1)mitigationandprevention;2)preparedness;3)response;and4)recovery/rehabilitation.Thecompetencydomainsare:
1. Riskreduction,diseasepreventionandhealthpromotion2. Policydevelopmentandplanning3. Ethicalpractice,legalpracticeandaccountability4. Communicationandinformationsharing5. Educationandpreparedness6. Careofthecommunity7. Careofindividualsandfamily8. Psychologicalcare9. Careofvulnerablepopulations10. Long-termrecoveryofindividuals,familiesandcommunities
Inadditiontothesecompetencysets,genericmodelsandcompetenciesforPHNpracticesuchastheMinnesotaDepartmentofHealthPHNInterventionWheel(2001)ortheQuadCouncilPHNCompetencies(2011)provideappropriatepracticemodels,whetherthatPHNpracticeisdeliveredday-to-dayorinadisaster.BycombiningboththeICNDisasterNursingCompetenciesandthePublicHealthPreparednessandResponseCoreCompetencies,thePHNfindsasolidplatformtoinformpracticeacrossthedisastercycle.BothofthesecompetencysetsarefoundintheRecommendedReadingandKeyDocumentssectionattheendofthispaper.
11
LeadershipPlanningandPolicyDevelopment
“Asprioritypublichealthinitiativesevolvetoaddressemerginghealthtrends,publichealthnursestakeleadershiproles.Theyidentifyevidencebywhichnewpublichealthsystemschangesareimplementedandevaluated,anddevelopoperationalsystemsthatmaybeeffectivelydeployed.Publichealthnursingleadershipultimatelyenhancestheabilityofpublichealthsystemstoaddressthehealthissuesfacingallpeopleandcreatesconditionsinwhichpeoplecanbehealthy(ANA,2013:2).”
The2ndeditionofPublicHealthNursing:ScopeandStandardsofPractice(2013)makesitclearthatPHNsareleaders.Thisisnolesstrueinpublichealthpreparedness,response,andrecovery.LeadershipcollaborationWell-preparedPHNsbringleadershipandmanagementexpertisetoeachphaseofdisastercycle.Asanintegralpartofthehealthcaresysteminfrastructurewithintheircommunityandjurisdictions,PHNshaveestablishedlinkagestocommunityhealth-relatednetworksandresourcesthatarevitaltodevelopingdisasterpreparednessplansandpoliciesatlocal,regional,stateandnationallevels.TheseconnectionsbetweenPHNsandcommunitypartnersmustoccurinordertoaddresscomplexissuessuchasprovidingmasscareduringthechaosofadisaster,prioritizingscarceresources,supervisingspontaneousvolunteersandunlicensedhealthcareworkers,identifyingandplanningforthecareofpopulationswithfunctionalandaccessneeds,aswellasdevelopingandmaintainingeffectivesystemsofvolunteerspreparedtoassistpriortotheincident.Publichealthnursesalsocanusetheirnetworksacrossregionalandstateboundariestoachieveconsistencyintheprotocols,practicestandardsandoperationalguidelinespriortothedisasterincident.LeadershipeffortsinpolicyandplanningPublichealthnursesareleadersinpolicyandplanningtoensurethatthecommunitiestheyservereceiveprioritizedandactionablesolutionstotheirhealthandsocialproblems.AnexampleofthisistheireffortinFunctionalNeedsandSupportServices(FNSS)fordisaster-affectedpopulations(FEMA,2010).Solutionsformeetingshelteringneedsforthosewithaccessandfunctionalneedsarefoundbelow,alignedwitheachpolicyprocessstep(Stanhope,M.,2012;FEMA,2010):
1. Statementofahealthcareproblem–Childrenandadultswithdisabilitieshavethesamerighttoservicesingeneralpopulationsheltersasotherresidents.
2. Statementofpolicyoptionstoaddressthehealthproblem-Historically,resourcegapshaveexistedinplanningforandmeetingaccessandfunctionalneedsingeneralpopulationshelters.Theintentofthisplanningguidanceistoensurethatindividualsare
12
notturnedawayfromgeneralpopulationsheltersandinappropriatelyplacedinotherenvironments(e.g.,“specialneeds”shelters,institutions,nursinghomes,andhotelsandmotelsdisconnectedfromothersupportservices).
3. Adoptionofaparticularpolicyoption- Keyconsiderationsinplanningforshelteroperationsarebroaderthanmedicalservices,toincludeofdietaryneeds,serviceanimals,communication,bathingandtoiletingneeds,quietspace,mentalhealthservices,dentalservices,medication,andtransportationservices.
4. Implementationofapolicyproduct(e.g.,aservice)-FunctionalNeedsSupportServices(FNSS)aredefinedasservicesthatenableindividualstomaintaintheirindependenceinageneralpopulationshelter.FNSSincludes:•reasonablemodificationtopolicies,practices,andprocedures•durablemedicalequipment(DME)•consumablemedicalsupplies(CMS)•personalassistanceservices(PAS)•othergoodsandservicesasneeded
5. Evaluationofthepolicy’sintendedandunintendedconsequencesinsolvingtheoriginalhealthcareproblem.–Ongoingthroughvariousorganizationsandagencies,toincludeRedCross’DisasterHealthServicesandnurses.
Meta-leadership(crisisleadership)Nursesarefamiliarwiththeconceptofmeta-research,wheremanyareasofresearcharoundatopicarepulledtogetherforanewlookatacomplexproblemandnewsolutions.Duringadisaster,atypeofleadershipthatisincreasinglycalledforincrisiscomplexityismeta-leadership.Meta-leadershipisnotjustatwo-dimensionalrelationshipbetweenasupervisorandemployeeorincidentcommanderandthechainofcommand;rather,itoccursacrossnumerousentitiesandinmanydirections:up,down,andsideways.Meta-leadershipisdefinedasafive-dimensionalabilitytoworkwithincross-boundaryintegrationofanorganization’scapabilitiesintothecommunity(Rowitz,2013).Inordertodothat,anindividualmustunderstandself,theproblemathand,theirorganization,theirsupervisorsandhowtoleadup(i.e.,satisfythebosswhilemakingsuretherightthinggetsdone),andtheconnectivityofthedefinedcommunity,bothitsorganizationsanditsagencies(Marcusetal.,2009).Thesefivedimensionsofmeta-leadershipalignperfectlyintopublichealthnursingpractice.Metaleaders,likepublichealthnurses,motivate,inspire,andgivetoensurethatthecommunitiestheyservejoininthesolution.Althoughin-depthcoverageofhowtoleadindisastercannotbecoveredinthispositionpaper,theMarcusetal.(2007)materialsincludedintherecommendedreadingsectiontoenablethePHNtodevelopfamiliaritywithmeta-leadershipprinciples.
13
LegalandEthicalIssues
Licensure,geographicboundariesanddutytorespondPublichealthnursesshouldbefamiliarwiththenursepracticeactoftheirstateanditsinformationaboutthepracticeofnursingindisasters.IfanurseislicensedbyaNurseLicensureCompactstate,theycanalreadypracticeacrossstatelinesinmemberstates(NCSBN,2013).Duringlarge-scaledisastersthatcrossstateborders,licensednursesmaybeallowedbyfederaland/orstatelawordeclarationstopracticeinotherstates.Manystateshavenoweliminatedhardcopylicensesasthepapercardscanbetamperedwithanddonotreflectcurrentdisciplinarystatus.Licensureisnowoftenverifiedonlineatstateboardsofnursingsites,evenduringdisasters.TheNationalCouncilofStateBoardsofNursing(NCSBN)providesthecapacityforbulklicenseverificationthroughitsNursysdatabaseonbehalfofresponseorganizations.Nurseswhovolunteertoprovidedisasterservicesshouldclarifytheexpectationsforlicensureandliabilityprotectionwiththeorganizationtheyplantovolunteerin.Priortovolunteering,PHNsmustbefamiliarwiththeiremployer’splansforstaffwhowishtorespondandwhattheirdutyexpectationsaretotheirorganization,bothlegallyandethically.Publichealthnursesalsoneedtoclarifyhowtheyarewrittenintoexistingresponseplansfortheirorganizationandregion.Inadditiontotheemployer,regionalplanningbodiesorstatesmayidentifycertaingroupsofnursesandpre-definetheiruseinresponseandrecovery.Writtenpolicyshouldassureprotectionsandmakecleartheexpectationsoftheregisterednurse,theemployer,andthegovernmentresponsesystemsbeforethedisasteroccurs(ANA,2010).GoodSamaritanLawGoodSamaritanlawsgenerallyprovideliabilityprotectiontoindividualsforsituationswhereemergencycareisrenderedusingreasonableandprudentjudgmentforthecircumstances.MoststateshaveenactedsomeformofGoodSamaritanlaw,butmanydonotexplicitlyrecognizepubliclydeclareddisasters(Courtney,Priest,&Root,2012).TheGoodSamaritanlawappliestosituationsinwhichthecareoraidrenderedwasagood-faitheffortandasavoluntaryact.ThismeansthatGoodSamaritanlawsdonotprotectaproviderworkingasanemployeeorasanorganizationalvolunteer.Also,GoodSamaritanlawsdonotprotectagainstnegligenceorgrossmisconduct.ExistingprotectionsThereiscurrentlynocomprehensivenationallegalprotectionforhealthcareprovidersworkinginthedisastercycle.FederallawssuchastheFederalPublicReadinessandEmergencyPreparednessActandtheFederalVolunteerProtectionActandstatelawssuchasStateVolunteerProtectionActs,ModelStateEmergencyHealthPowersActs,andStatePublicHealthandEmergencyManagementProvisionsareinplace.Somebelievethatthepatchworkofprotectionforhealthcareworkershasbecomemuchstrongerinitsproviderprotections(Courtney,Priest,&Roost,2012).
14
Disastersinvolveresourceconstraints,undesirableenvironments,andmasscasualtysurgeneeds.Disasterincidentsstressplanningandpreparations,providechallenges,andmayinvolveunforeseensituationsdemandingimmediateresponseinthemiddleofchaos.Evenifthehealthcareproviderhassignificantdemandsplacedonthemtothepointthatthecarebecomesqualitativelydifferentfromthatprovidedinnormalcircumstances,professionalliabilityhasandwillbedecidedagainsttherelevantfactsofthesituation(Courtney,Priest,&Roost,2012).Legalprotectiongaugeswhatareasonablyskillfulandprudentproviderwoulddoinasimilarsituation(i.e.,indisaster).Thereisacontinuedneedforcompetency-basedtrainingandanunderstandingbythePHNoftheprofessionalscopeandstandardsofpracticetoassurepreparationasahealthprofessional.Indeed,mostethicalandlegalconflictscanbeavoidedwithdisastertrainingandfamiliaritywithdisasterplans,toincludehands-ondisasterdrillsthatincludebothmedicalandethicaldecisionmaking(Pou,2013).Publichealthnurseswillneedtheabilitytomakeconsistentjudgmentsanddecisionsbasedondisasterplansandpolicies,sometimesinspiteoftheirpersonalbeliefs.SummaryIfpublichealthnursescannotconveytheirdisasterpracticeexpertisetoothers,theywillmostlikelybeunderused,misused,and/orunabletoparticipateintheleadershipthattheyemployforcommunityadvocacy.Nursesremainthelargesthealthcareprovidergroupavailableforpreparedness,response,andrecovery.Itisimportantthatpublichealthnursesunderstandandpromotetheirdisastercapabilitiesasmembersofthepublichealthandhealthcareteambefore,during,andaftertheincident.Disasterpreparedness,response,andrecoveryisacriticalcomponentofpublichealthnursingpractice.Publichealthnurseswillalwaysbeneededwhounderstandthepopulation-basednatureofadisasterresponseandpossesstheknowledgeandskillstorespondinatimelyandappropriatemannertoanytypeofdisaster.
15
RecommendedReadingandKeyDocuments
AmericanNursesAssociation(ANA).2010.ANAissuesbrief:Whowillbethere?Ethics,thelawandanurse’sdutytorespondindisaster.http://nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/WorkplaceSafety/Healthy-Work-Environment/DPR/Disaster-Preparedness.pdf
ANA.2008.Adaptingstandardsofcareunderextremeconditions:Guidanceforprofessionalsduringdisasters,pandemics,andotherextremeemergencies.http://nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/WorkplaceSafety/Healthy-Work-Environment/DPR/TheLawEthicsofDisasterResponse/AdaptingStandardsofCare.pdf
AssociationforCommunityHealthNursingEducators(ACHNE)TaskForceonDisasterPreparedness.2008.Disasterpreparednesswhitepaperforcommunity/publichealthnursingeducators.http://www.achne.org/files/public/DisasterPreparednessWhitePaper.pdf
AssociationofSchoolsofPublicHealth(ASPH).2010.Publichealthpreparedness&responsecorecompetencymodel.http://www.cdc.gov/phpr/documents/perlcpdfs/preparednesscompetencymodelworkforce-version1_0.pdf
CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention(CDC).2013.2013-2014nationalsnapshotofpublichealthpreparedness.http://www.cdc.gov/phpr/pubs-links/2013/
CDC.2011.Anationalstrategicplanforpublichealthpreparednessandresponse.http://www.cdc.gov/phpr/publications/A_Natl_Strategic_Plan_for_Preparedness.htmCDC.March2011.Publichealthpreparednesscapabilities:Nationalstandardsforstateandlocalplanning.http://www.cdc.gov/phpr/capabilities/dslr_capabilities_july.pdfFederalEmergencyManagementAgency(FEMA).2013.PresidentialPolicyDirective(PPD)8components:Nationalpreparednessgoal,nationalpreparednesssystem,nationalplanningframeworks.https://www.fema.gov/learn-about-presidential-policy-directive-8FEMA.2010.GuidanceonplanningforintegrationofFunctionalNeedsSupportServices(FNSS).http://www.fema.gov/pdf/about/odic/fnss_guidance.pdfFEMAEmergencyManagementInstitute(EMI).2013.Independentstudyprogram(ISP).http://training.fema.gov/IS/NIMS.aspxInternationalCouncilofNurses(ICN)andWorldHealthOrganization(WHO).2009.ICNframeworkofdisasternursingcompetencies.http://www.icn.ch/images/stories/documents/networks/DisasterPreparednessNetwork/Disaster_Nursing_Competencies_lite.pdf
16
InstituteofMedicine(IOM).2013.Crisisstandardsofcare:Atoolkitforindicatorsandtriggers.http://iom.nationalacademies.org/Reports/2013/Crisis-Standards-of-Care-A-Toolkit-for-Indicators-and-Triggers.aspxIOM.2012.Crisisstandardsofcare:Asystemsframeworkforcatastrophicdisasterresponse.http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=13351Marcus,L.J.,Dorn,B.C.,Ashkenazi,I.,Henderson,J.M.,&McNulty,E.2010.Meta-leadership:Aprimer.http://npli.sph.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2013/04/meta-leadership_primer.pdfNationalCommissiononChildrenandDisasters.October2010.2010Reporttothepresidentandcongress,AHRQPublicationNo.10-M037.http://archive.ahrq.gov/prep/nccdreport/nccdreport.pdfQuadCouncilofPublicHealthNursingOrganizations(QuadCouncil).(2011).Corecompetenciesforpublichealthnurses(CCPHN).http://www.phf.org/resourcestools/Pages/Public_Health_Nursing_Competencies.aspxRESOLVE,Inc.2012.Transformingpublichealth:Emergingconceptsfordecisionmakinginachangingpublichealthworld.http://www.rwjf.org/en/research-publications/find-rwjf-research/2012/06/transforming-public-health.htmlTrustforAmerica’sHealth.December2012.Readyornot:Protectingthepublicfromdiseases,disasters,andbioterrorism.http://www.healthyamericans.org/report/101/Veenema,T.G.2012.Disasternursingandemergencypreparedness:Forchemical,biological,andradiologicalterrorismandotherhazards,Thirdedition.NewYork,NewYork:SpringerPublishingCompany.U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices(DHHS).2012.ImplementationplanforthenationalhealthsecuritystrategyoftheUnitedStatesofAmerica.http://www.phe.gov/Preparedness/planning/authority/nhss/ip/Documents/nhss-ip.pdfU.S.DepartmentofHomelandSecurity.(2013)Overviewofthenationalplanningframeworks.http://www.fema.gov/media-library-data/20130726-1914-25045-2057/final_overview_of_national_planning_frameworks_20130501.pdf______________________________________________________________________________
17
References
AmericanNursesAssociation.(2013).Publichealthnursing:Scopeandstandardsof practice,2nded.SilverSpring,Maryland:Author.AmericanNursesAssociation.(2010).Nursing:Scopeandstandardsofpractice,2nded.
SilverSpring,Maryland:Author.AmericanPublicHealthAssociation,PublicHealthNursingSection.(2013).Thedefinitionand
practiceofpublichealth2013.Retrievedfromhttp://www.apha.org/~/media/files/pdf/membergroups/nursingdefinition.ashx
AssociationofSchoolsofPublicHealthandCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention PublicHealthPreparednessandResponse.(2010).Publichealthpreparedness& Responsecorecompetencymodel.Retrievedfrom
http://www.cdc.gov/phpr/documents/perlcPDFS/PreparednessCompetencyModelWorkforce-Version1_0.pdf
Brewer,K.(2010).Whowillbethere?Ethics,thelawandanurse’sduty
torespondindisaster(ANAIssueBrief).RetrievedJuly1,2014fromhttp://nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/WorkplaceSafety/Healthy-Work-Environment/DPR/Disaster-Preparedness.pdf
Courtney,B.A.,Priest,C.,&Root,P.(2012).Legalissuesinemergencyresponse.In M.P.Couig&P.W.Kelley,(Eds.),Annualreviewofnursingresearch:Disastersand humanitarianassistance(Volume30,pp.67-88).NewYork,NewYork:Springer PublishingCompany.FederalEmergencyManagementAgency.(2013).PresidentialPolicyDirective 8components:Nationalpreparednessgoal,Nationalpreparednesssystem, Nationalplanningframeworks.Retrievedfrom https://www.fema.gov/learn-about-presidential-policy-directive-8FederalEmergencyManagementAgency.(2010).Guidanceonplanningforintegrationof functionalneedssupportservices(FNSS).Retrievedfrom http://www.fema.gov/pdf/about/odic/fnss_guidance.pdfGebbie,K.M.,Hutton,A.,&Plummer,V.(2012).Updateoncompetenciesandeducation.In M.P.Couig,&P.W.Kelley,(Eds.),Annualreviewofnursingresearch:Disasters andhumanitarianassistance(Volume30,pp.169-192).NewYork,NewYork: SpringerPublishing.
18
InstituteofMedicine.(2002).Thefutureofthepublic'shealthinthe21stcentury.WashingtonDC:DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.Retrievedfromhttp://iom.edu/Reports/2002/The-Future-of-the-Publics-Health-in-the-21st-Century.aspx
InternationalCouncilofNursing&WorldHealthOrganization.(2009).ICNframeworkof disasternursingcompetencies.Geneva,Switzerland:Authors.Retrievedfrom http://www.wpro.who.int/hrh/documents/icn_framework/en/ Jakeway,C.,LaRosa,G.,Cary,A.&Schoenfisch,S.(2008).Theroleofpublichealthnurses
inemergencypreparednessandresponse:ApositionpaperoftheAssociationofStateandTerritorialDirectorsofNursing.PublicHealthNursing,25(4),353-361.Retrievedfromhttp://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1525-1446.2008.00716.x/abstract
Kuntz,S.W.,Frable,P.,Qureshi,K.,&Strong,L.L.(2008).AssociationofCommunityHealth
NursingEducators(ACHNE):Disasterpreparednesswhitepaperforcommunity/publichealthnursingeducators.PublicHealthNursing,25(4),362-369.Retrievedfromhttp://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1525-1446.2008.00717.x/abstract
Marcus,L.J.,Ashkennazi,I.,Dorn,B.C.,&Henderson,J.M.(2007).Nationalpreparedness andthefivedimensionsofmeta-leadership.Retrievedfrom
https://www.medicalreservecorps.gov/File/Promising_Practices_Toolkit/Guidance_Documents/Emergency_Preparedness_Response/Meta_Leadership_One_page_primer_March_2007.pdf
MinnesotaDepartmentofHealth,DivisionofCommunityHealthServices,PublicHealth NursingSection.(2001).Publichealthnursinginterventionwheel.Retrievedfrom http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/opi/cd/phn/docs/0301wheel_manual.pdfNationalCouncilofStateBoardsofNursing.(2013).Nurselicensurecompact.Retrievedfrom
https://www.ncsbn.org/nlc.htm
Pou,A.(2013).Ethicalandlegalchallengesofdisastermedicine:Areyouready?SouthernMedicalJournal,106(1),27-30.Retrievedfromhttp://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/777544
QuadCouncilofPublicHealthNursingOrganizations(QUADCOUNCIL).(2011).Core
competenciesforpublichealthnurses(CCPHN).Retrievedfromhttp://www.phf.org/resourcestools/Pages/Public_Health_Nursing_Competencies.aspx
Rowitz,Louis.(2013).Publichealthleadership:Puttingprinciplesintopractice,3rded. Burlington,Massachusetts:JonesandBartlettLearning,LLC.Stanhope,M.(2012).PublicHealthPolicy.InM.Stanhope&J.Lancaster,(Eds.),Public
19
healthnursing:Population-centeredhealthcareinthecommunity,8thEd(pp.163-183). MarylandHeights,MO:Elsevier-Mosby.U.S.DepartmentofHomelandSecurity.(2013)Overviewofthenationalplanningframeworks.
Retrievedfromhttp://www.fema.gov/media-library-data/20130726-1914-25045-2057/final_overview_of_national_planning_frameworks_20130501.pdf