the role of extrinsic motivation in learning english …
TRANSCRIPT
THE ROLE OF EXTRINSIC MOTIVATION IN LEARNING ENGLISH
AS A SECOND LANGUAGE AMONG INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE STUDENTS
A Thesis
Presented to the faculty of the Department of Graduate and Professional Studies in
Education
California State University, Sacramento
Submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of
MASTER OF ARTS
in
Education
(Curriculum & Instruction)
by
Xiangqiu Huo
SUMMER 2018
ii
© 2018
Xiangqiu Huo
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
iii
THE ROLE OF EXTRINSIC MOTIVATION IN LEARNING ENGLISH
AS A SECOND LANGUAGE AMONG INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE STUDENTS
A Thesis
by
Xiangqiu Huo Approved by: __________________________________, Committee Chair Rachael A Gonzales, Ed.D. __________________________________, Second Reader Elva Duran, Ph.D. ____________________________ Date
iv
Student: Xiangqiu Huo
I certify that this student has met the requirements for format contained in the University
format manual, and that this thesis is suitable for shelving in the Library and credit is to
be awarded for the thesis.
__________________________, Graduate Coordinator ___________________ Albert Lozano, Ph.D. Date Department of Graduate and Professional Studies in Education
v
Abstract
of
THE ROLE OF EXTRINSIC MOTIVATION IN LEARNING ENGLISH
AS A SECOND LANGUAGE AMONG INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE STUDENTS
by
Xiangqiu Huo
Motivation is one of the cornerstones closely linked to a college student’s learning
ability and academic performance. Cherry (2018) defines extrinsic motivation as one’s
psychological behavior that is compelled by external rewards such as grades, praise,
money, and fame. This type of motivation arises from outside the individual, as opposed
to intrinsic motivation, which originates from inside the individual. From my personal
experience and experiences witnessed amongst my international student peers, the
English as a Second Language (ESL) curriculum we took was no simple walk in the park.
With sufficient extrinsic and intrinsic motivators to stimulate our education environment,
we have noticed our increased ability to have better comprehension, concentration and
understanding of the fundamentals of the English language. Teaching English to
Speakers of Other Languages (TESOL) can also be enhanced through extrinsic and
intrinsic motivation to accelerate ESL student’s ability to master new language skills.
This thesis provides an extensive review of literature related to the topic of extrinsic
motivation and its relationship with educators and international college students.
Moreover, the thesis will also explore how extrinsic motivation is a more effective
vi
motivator compared to intrinsic motivation and how it has specifically contributed to the
success of international students in the learning of English as a second language. Lastly,
this thesis discusses various ways educators can leverage extrinsic motivation to improve
the effectiveness of how well their students master English as a second language.
_______________________, Committee Chair Rachael A Gonzales, Ed.D. _______________________ Date
vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to take this opportunity to thank and show appreciation to my Master’s
advisor Dr. Gonzales, Department Chair of Graduate and Professional Studies Dr.
Lozano, Coordinator of International Student and Scholar Services Mr. Shigenaga, and
Masters of Education Technology Professor Dr..Chia-Jung Chung. They took their
precious time from their busy schedule to make this research process successful. I would
also like to thank my family for their support both financially and emotionally in the
successful completion of my research. Thank you all!
viii
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page
Acknowledgements .................................................................................................... vii
List of Tables ................................................................................................................ x
Chapter
1. THE PROBLEM……………………………………………………………….... 1
Introduction ........................................................................................................... 1
Statement of the Problem ...................................................................................... 2
Purpose of the Study ............................................................................................ 3
Methodology of Research .................................................................................... 3
Definition of Terms .............................................................................................. 3
Limitations of Research ....................................................................................... 4
2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE ................................................................................. 5
Theories of Motivation .......................................................................................... 6
Self-determination Theory .................................................................................... 6
Benefits of Extrinsic Motivation ........................................................................... 9
Impact of Extrinsic Motivation on the Learning English as a Second Language 12
Impact of Teaching Strategies on Extrinsic Motivation ..................................... 16
Theory of Multiple Intelligence ..................................................................... 17
Universal Design and How It Relates to Motivation ..................................... 18
Technology and Extrinsic Motivation ................................................................. 22
Motivation and Use of Incentives ....................................................................... 23
ix
Conclusion .......................................................................................................... 24
3. METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................... 25
Framing the Research Questions ......................................................................... 25
The Investigative Process: The Systematic Review Methodology ..................... 27
Identifying Relevant Sources .............................................................................. 27
Assessing the Quality of Studies ......................................................................... 27
Summarizing the Documentation ........................................................................ 29
Interpreting the Findings ..................................................................................... 29
Data Analysis ...................................................................................................... 30
The Inclusion Criteria ......................................................................................... 31
Research Question One ....................................................................................... 32
Implications for English Language Teachers ...................................................... 35
Research Question Two ...................................................................................... 38
4. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................. 43
My Personal ESL Experience ............................................................................. 47
References ........................................................................................................... 49
x
LIST OF TABLES
Tables Page
1. 3 Networks = 3 UDL Principles……………….……………………………..…. 21
2. Table of Research Question One……………….………………………….……. 32
3. Table of Research Question Two….……..………….………………………….. 39
1
Chapter 1
THE PROBLEM
Introduction
Motivation is a driving force through which human beings attain their goals
(Clement, 2006). Specifically, psychological motivation stimulates people’s desire
and energy to have continued interest and commitment in attaining goals in life
(Weiner, 2000). In a previous study, Gredler (2001) and Broussard and Garrison
(2004) defined motivation as the attribute that moves us to do or not to do something
and can be broken down into two types of motivations: intrinsic and extrinsic
motivation. Intrinsic motivation is manifested in behaviors such as playing,
exploration, and completing challenges without external rewards. Clement (2006)
highlighted that intrinsic motivation rejuvenates and sustains activities through the
spontaneous satisfactions inherent in effective volitional action. On the other hand,
Weiner (2000) and Cherry (2018) stated that extrinsic motivation focuses on
reinforcement contingencies, or external rewards such as grades, praise, money and
fame. Burden (2004) found that both forms of motivation play an active role in the
students learning process and that external stimulus is required to drive or inspire a
person to achieve desired outcomes.
Students can only be motivated through making them have the desire to do
something, especially an activity which calls for hard work and effort (Hajhashemi,
Shakarami, & Caltabiano, 2017). All students, especially those who are studying
2
English as a second language, need techniques to gain motivation from external
factors. English as a Second Language (ESL) students must be motivated to
understand that learning English is useful in their lives. A student’s motivation will
have to be transformed by having the classroom setting transformed into one where
they can be inspired to learn the curriculum.
Statement of the Problem
Understanding the correct form or method of motivation for today’s international
students participating in ESL classes is crucial to their academic success. One of the
pedagogical methods used in learning is the traditional approach of face-to-face
instruction. Arteaga (2006) argued that the environment plays a major role in students’
motivation and participation in learning English. The face-to-face instruction method of
students in the classroom is only applicable to the physical interaction of the teacher and
student in a classroom setting. This classroom environment needs concrete and valid
methodologies in teachers to work cohesively to support students learning English.
According to Hajhashemi et al., today’s generation of third millennium international
students will have harder time to learn the ESL curriculum if “Net-Generation” extrinsic
motivators and strategies are not used by the educators in the classroom. For instance,
international students today tend to use pictures and visual graphics to expressive or
convey their messages and enjoy using newly coined words to help with their interactions
with their peers. Therefore, the main point of this research is to explore the impact of the
right form of extrinsic motivation that is needed for international students to learn
English as a second language.
3
Purpose of the Study
According to Kyiacou and Kobon (2006), intrinsic motivation is linked to the increase
of a student’s increased interest for success or pleasure while extrinsic motivation is
linked to increased performance by initiating the desire to achieve a set goal or objective.
While intrinsic motivation helps students develop and practice positive and desirable
behaviors of learning, extrinsic motivation leads to development of good academic habits
and achieving good academic results. Therefore, the primary aim of this research is to (1)
Explore the role of extrinsic motivation of international students learning English as a
second language, and (2) Examine learning theories utilized by teachers to motivate
international students in learning English as a second language.
Methodology of Research
The qualitative research method was used to perform an extensive review of the
literature and existing information on how extrinsic motivation affects the learning of
English as a second language among international students. This research is designed to
be descriptive in nature as it describes characteristics of the target population.
Definition of Terms
English as a Second Language (ESL)
The study of English by nonnative speakers in an English-speaking environment (ESL,
2012).
4
Extrinsic motivation
Human behaviors psychologically motivated by external rewards such as grades,
money, fame, or praise (Burden, 2004).
Foreign language
A language learned by a student who is not a native of it or a language which
originates from another country and is not spoken in the native country (Dörnyei &
Ushioda, 2009).
Motivation
Something that energizes human activities or gives an individual the desire to achieve
certain goals and objectives (Burden, 2004).
Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages (TESOL)
Emphasizes aspects of teaching English in countries where English is not widely used
in daily life (Rumboll, 2013).
Limitations of Research
The research took a hypothetical approach to analyze how extrinsic motivation affects
the ability for international students to learn English as a second language. Although
primary research would have been preferable for this study, practical constraints such as
access to the research population significantly limited this possibility.
5
Chapter 2
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In today’s globalized world, learning to read and speak multiple languages is a
valuable skillset that allows one to easily blend into other cultures. However, it is
important for people to consider which language they should study and be proficient in.
For individuals who are born in countries where English is not the native language, they
often opt to learn English as a skill to add to their professional portfolio (Barkhuizen,
2011). One of the fundamental reasons why international students learn English is
because English is regarded as the language used for global businesses (Najeeb, 2013).
For those individuals who are interested in working for the top organizations of the
world, English is the language which is commonly used as a medium of communication
(Barkhuizen, 2011). The de facto language for international global business is English,
and many of the companies worldwide require their employees and staff to have some
level of proficiency in English. Moreover, the employment market regards individuals
who can communicate in fluent English as more valuable compared to those that cannot
(Najeeb, 2013). Therefore, learning English will enable one to have a more attractive
career resume and higher potential salary. Speaking the English language enables
individuals to become Global Citizens, with the ability to interact with others in different
parts of the world for work, travel, or business.
6
Theories of Motivation
Many of the theories on motivation and psychology formed in the 1950s and the
1960s questioned the limitations of existing theories formed by behaviorists. Researchers
proposed ways in which they could study the cognitive process of learning and
motivation in students and teachers. Pintrich (2000) studied and analyzed some of the
cognitive theories which had been developed in the 1960s, 70s, 80s, and 90s and
concluded that motivation is the process of sustaining and instigating an activity which is
goal oriented. This conceptualization was then influenced by other researchers such as a
Yao and Mao (2010; as cited in Long, Ming, & Chen, 2013) to conduct further studies to
find parallels between motivation and learning.
Self-determination Theory
The theoretical perspective of motivation must be taken into consideration when
studying the role of extrinsic motivation. Self-determination theory explores the ability
for a person to have personal initiative and regulation over one’s actions (Deci,
Vallerand, Pelletier, & Ryan, 1991). Deci et al. (1991), states that the self-determination
theory distinguishes between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in language learning.
They denote that extrinsic motivation is the ability of the person to have expectations of
external rewards from his or her efforts to achieve certain obligations.
Deci et al. (1991), argued that the self-determination theory explains how people can
create a condition or environment which can increase the level of motivation in the
7
learning process rather than focus on how teachers in a classroom setting can motivate
their students. According to Noels (2001), this theory placed extrinsic motivation in line
with the students’ wants and desires regarding fulfillment of their educational goals and
objectives.
Another theory that is exemplified in the learning of foreign languages is the
regulation argument, which along with the self-determination theory, referred to the
situations where a person has activities based on external stimuli incorporated into his or
her learning activities (Shaikholeslami & Khayyer, 2006). Shaikholeslami and Khayyer
discovered that the external regulation of one’s motivation refers to sources of regulation
outside of the person’s initiatives, and in the case of learning a foreign language, this
cannot be termed as a self-determination activity because it has external factors which
spur an individual to perform an action. An example of the regulation argument is when
a student is encouraged to learn a foreign language due to the fear of not being able to be
converse with it.
Consequently, it can be determined that theories which support extrinsic motivation
are mainly advanced on studying student behavior (Shaikholeslami & Khayyer, 2006).
The physical characteristics of the teacher and the student play a fundamental role in the
advancement of extrinsic motivation. For a researcher to study behaviorist techniques in
a classroom setting, they must evaluate specific actions of a student, the origin of these
actions, and the consequences of these actions. As a result, behaviorists must come up
with specific frameworks to explain the phenomena involving extrinsic motivation such
as self-determination and respondent conditioning (Shaikholeslami & Khayyer, 2006).
8
Respondent conditioning is an alternative theory which advances extrinsic motivation
in the learning of English by international students. Shaikholeslami and Khayyer (2006)
defined respondent conditioning as the use incentives by the instructor to motivate the
learners by requesting the them to complete tasks and measuring how much enthusiasm
they show when trying to complete the task. They found that when the teacher withdraws
incentives and replaces them with less rewards, the students’ level of motivation
decreases because students have associated certain tasks with specific rewards. If the
rewards are no longer available, then the level of motivation will decrease and affect the
concentration and interest of the learners. Therefore, self-determination is a motivational
theory that caters towards non-material factors of extrinsic motivation such as verbal
recognition and feedback, while respondent conditioning deals with material factors of
extrinsic motivation such as rewarding students with a badge, gift, or money.
Burden (2004) pointed out that the extrinsic motivation for students learning English
as a second language can create a better learning environment for everyone but is
dependent on many variables such as the interdependence of second language acquisition,
classroom environment, and social-cultural background. Tseng (2013) claimed that there
are five major factors in language learning: parents, peers, learning situation, teachers,
and ethnicity; however, the same factors do not motivate all students. This is because
while a student may be motivated by his or her parents, another may be motivated by his
or her peers. This research is however fixated on determining the effectiveness of
extrinsic motivation and how it enhances the performance of international students
learning English as a second language (ESL).
9
According to Hajhashemi et al., it is important for a teacher who teach English as a
second language to understand the responsibility on how to use extrinsic motivation to
help his or her ESL students learn English. It is important for teachers to create an
integrative and competitive learning environment for ESL students because traditional
face-to-face learning may be monotonous and boring for students, which may lead to the
students failing their learning objectives. Learning is challenging because it is a process
where both students and teachers may be affected by many internal and external factors.
Also, college students are mature adults who may not always be able to be hand-held
during their learning process; therefore, leveraging extrinsic motivation techniques such
as a positive learning environment is essential to helping ESL students succeed.
Benefits of Extrinsic Motivation
Arteaga (2006) argued that using extrinsic motivation to help students master a
foreign language has several benefits to both teachers and students. One benefit for
students is the mastery of goals orientation, or where the students have the desire to
obtain a better result from the learning process itself. For example, a student gets a high
level of confidence and satisfaction from their mastery of verbal and written English.
Another benefit for students is performance goal orientation, or where students have the
desire to achieve better results than others and can achieve a performance level that that
gives them a personal conviction of success. For example, a student tries to obtain
positive judgment or avoid negative judgment from others so he or she works hard on
mastering a performance-based endeavor. Lastly, another benefit is the social goal
benefit where the student will have the desire to learn so that he or she can develop
10
characteristics that are socially accepted. For example, a student can pursue learning
English as a second language with an objective of achieving academic excellence or to be
accepted in their desired social circle.
The external motivation of students by the teacher recognizing their efforts and
achievements was found to have a tremendous impact on student performance (Kyiacou
& Kobon, 2006). Kyiacou and Kobon found that when students were conditioned by a
teacher whenever they demonstrated good results in the classroom, the students’ morale
decreased over time and education became less meaningful for them when they fail to be
recognized by others. Therefore, while a sense of pride in what students learn may seem
to motivate a student’s performance, a balance between student recognition and extrinsic
motivation must also be kept in mind by the educator.
A student can benefit from extrinsic motivation by having considerable involvement
in the activities they are involved in such as learning a new language (Arteaga, 2006).
Kyiacou and Kobon found that activities such as reading books, presenting in class, and
writing essays are essential for learning English as a second language, and the more
activities the student was involved in, the more interest, self-motivation, and confidence
they developed.
Arteaga (2006) also discovered that extrinsic motivation may be used by educators to
increase competition among students because students motivated by competition have the
desire to learn and feel responsible for their learning process. The main objective of
international students learning English as a second language is to be proficient in both
11
oral and written English. Therefore, motivating students to learn English will incite the
competitive nature of some students to ensure that they attain the highest proficiency
possible compared to their peers. In another previous study, Deci et al. (1991) agreed
that competition is one way to motivate students to achieve higher educational goals,
which is needed to ensure a healthy relationship between teachers and students.
Similarly, Topalov (2011) pointed out that extrinsic motivation will often increase the
competitiveness of international students learning English as a second language.
Extrinsic motivation will also motivate students to create and set goals because they
are convinced that they will be rewarded for it. The setting of educational goals is
fundamental to achieving improved performance and quality grades when learning
English as a second language (Feng & Chen, 2009). As a result, teachers will have a
mechanism to evaluate and quantify academic performance when students achieve their
goals, which in turn further helps students master their curriculum for learning English as
a second language.
Extrinsic motivation can increase confidence in students which is important because
speaking a different language in a foreign country for an English as a second language
student may be very daunting. Arteaga (2006) found that many students do not feel
confident when communicating in a foreign language because they do not have the ability
to command and convince others using the second language. Motivation will therefore
enable students to gain confidence in learning because they are aware of the short-term
and long-term rewards of learning English as a second language.
12
The most common reason why international graduate students never master the
English language is because they lack the motivation to learn English as a second
language. If the students are not motivated extrinsically or intrinsically, they are likely
to lose interest in learning. Extrinsic aspects include how the teacher interacts with the
student, the classroom environment, the student’s peers, how often the student uses the
language, and other factors which arouses the desire of learning as a second language
(Phakiti, Hirsh, & Woodrow, 2013). Phakiti, et al. found that motivation is a critical
aspect of learning, and therefore, its absence often lead students to procrastinate in their
comfort zones, perform poorly, fail their academic goals, or even drop out of school.
Impact of Extrinsic Motivation on the Learning English as a Second Language
Several common issues inhibit extrinsic motivation for international students to master
English as a second language in the classroom. For instance, students are not aware of
the purpose of knowing the language and how to be motivated (Feng & Chen, 2009).
Students often are so focused on the educational and academic purpose of taking the ESL
course that they forget that the primary objective of mastering the language was so they
can actually use the language and communicate with other English speakers, not so they
can pass the class but to be able to pass the class. Papi and Abdollahzadeh (2012)
explained that if the students are aware of the practical reasons for studying the language,
they will be motivated in studying it even if the language does not have a significant
impact in the present community.
13
Extrinsic motivation is also essential for improving English reading literacy if used
properly by teachers. Liu (2007) argued that teachers should follow up with strategies of
motivation to verify whether their students have improved performance or not. For
instance, teachers may instruct the students to read textbooks to test how interested and
motivated are the students are in studying the language. The difficulty in the texts may
also be adjusted from time to time encourage interest in studying the language. Learning
aids may also be used by the teacher to help make the lessons more fun and measure how
engaged students are in the learning process.
Dörnyei and Ushioda’s (2011) study provided evidence that there is a relationship
between the achievements and the positive learning environment of an individual. This is
because they established a significant connection of confidence to a student learning
English as a second language. Wu and Wu (2008) used a research model to measure how
a student’s social environment affected their confidence and ability to learn English as a
second language. For example, Wu and Wu found that a student who does not often
interact with English native speakers have increased self-confidence when using the
second language because he had positive experiences with learning English in the
classroom. Language learning in student clubs, classrooms, and other social activities
may also inspire learners to improve their familiarly, fluency and knowledge of the
second language because it allows the student to envision how the language may be used
once they are fluent and thus changes the attitude of the learner. As a result, Wu and Wu
(2008) concluded that learners are motivated differently and their ability to be more
fluent in English depended on their level of self-confidence and achievement in the
14
learning process. Previous studies by Dörnyei and Ushioda (2011) and Wu and Wu
(2008) suggested that ESL students have different desires, so therefore, flexible methods
are needed trigger these different desires to effectively motivate the ESL students in the
classroom.
There are several factors of extrinsic motivation in the classroom that impact the
effectiveness for students to learn English as a second language. A learner’s attitude and
anxiety are essential for the extrinsic motivation of students learning English as the
second language (Papi & Abdollahzadeh, 2012). In a previous study, Burden (2004)
observed the effects of various instruction methods on Chinese students taking English as
a second language classes and how these methods affected the motivation, attitude, and
anxiety of the students learning the language over time. Burden (2004) used the Attitude
Motivation Test Battery to gauge social-educational variables such as the desire to learn
English, intensity of motivation, interest in foreign languages, and attitudes towards
learning English. Burden (2004) discovered a correlation between the environment of the
classroom and the attitude of the teacher towards the students. A pleasing attitude inside
the classroom correlated to a pleasing attitude expressed by the teacher, which in turn
encouraged students to learn and achieve their educational goals. Burden also noted in his
study to represent the diverse interests of students learning English as a second language.
Papi and Abdollahzadeh (2012) and Burden’s (2004) recommendations strongly
suggested that teachers should introduce specific instruction strategies to each student if
they desired to gain educational achievements based on extrinsic motivation.
15
The other fundamental aspects are the ability for the learners to learn from the
mistakes of others and have a chance to interact freely with others when learning English
as a second language (ESL). Interactive interaction and good communication between
the teacher and the students are essential features to motivate ESL learners. A study
conducted by Liu (2007) in the Chinese university with students learning English as the
second language was to determine the students’ level of improvement. One of the factors
which came about was the complaint that there was redundancy in the students’ learning
of English as a second language. They did not mind repetition while learning the
language skills, however, many students held the opinion that some of the skills which
are taught in school can be acquired in their job after graduation. They felt that skills
could be taught in less than two weeks and does not require an entire semester in the
school curriculum. Liu recommended that students preferred learning more
communicative approaches by teachers when learning English as a second language as
opposed to dull and repetitive tasks.
An interactive method of studying English as a second language in the classroom
improves the level of communicative competence and comprehension of teaching and
learning English. Studies conducted by Morell (2007) compared interactive methods in
the classroom with non-interactive methods found that students perform better in
interactive classroom environments. Teachers who incorporated interactive methods in
the classroom such as oral presentation, entertainment, and student’s interventions
reported that students were highly motivated in learning English as a second language.
Morell’s findings indicated that teachers must be aware of the needs of their students to
16
able to improve their communicative competence and the involvement of students in the
learning process. Interactive classes are highly favored by students who are studying
English as a second language. Morrell’s research on Strategic Inventory of Language
Learning showed that students embraced the learning process which used the active
naturalistic approach in daily activities. This venture made the students develop an
attachment to the language and peer motivation comes into play as all the students are
actively involved in the learning process. An interactive classroom is highly favored by
students as they gain competence and proficiency in English as a second language.
Impact of Teaching Strategies on Extrinsic Motivation
The strategies of instruction can influence student’s involvement and engagement in
the learning of English as a second language. According to Feng and Chen (2009), the
use of technology and cooperative group learning are factors which can be of importance
in increasing student’s intensity in studying of English as a second language. These
factors shift the learning process from being teacher-centric to learner-centric, providing
the right initiatives for the students to excel in their education. Students consider
teaching strategies which include content in the strategies of delivery to be very relevant
in what they are studying. Therefore, a teacher must create a corrective feedback
between students and the learners should be part of the learning strategies. Development
of teaching and learning process is essential in developing meaningful participation of
students in their classrooms (Feng & Chen, 2009).
17
Theory of Multiple Intelligence
The theory of Multiple Intelligence was introduced in 1983 by Dr. Howard Gardner
with the aim of examining set of skills which makeup intelligence with the aim of
examining a set of skills which make up multiple intelligences (Gardner, 1983). Since
the introduction of multiple intelligences to the field of education, the theory has played a
key role for students learning English as second language. Teachers have the
responsibility to trigger the student’s motivation by acknowledging the diverse
intelligence abilities within them. In situations where students are required to study from
the same content, the teacher must devise strategies in responding to each student in
forms of different activities that meets the students’ needs. The redesigning of the
curriculum in teaching students learning English as a second language ensures that
students will develop an interest and motivation in the subject. In this case, it would
make them have a sense of what they are learning which would result in them
maximizing the time of learning in the classroom (Dörnyei & Ushioda, 2011).
Gardner (1983) makes the point that there is need for the teachers to acknowledge the
diversity and the interests of all students in the classroom. To achieve this objective, it is
important to emulate the theory of multiple intelligence. The theory enhances a
pragmatic approach in the way to define intelligence hence allowing the teachers to use
students’ strengths and help them to learn. According to Gardner (1983), multiple
intelligence strives to motivate student learning English as a second language as it
supports the presentation of information in the best way a student can understand. For
example, if a student is struggling with English learning, the theory upholds that the
18
teacher may emulate suitable teaching approaches such as creating a graphic story which
will eventually blossom into a beautiful and complex narrative helping the student in
grasping tips of learning English.
In addition, the theory challenges the notion of a single intelligence quotient since
human beings have multiple types of human intelligence which represent diverse ways of
processing information. One of the human intelligences in the theory is verbal-linguistic
intelligence which helps an individual to learn, analyze information as well as produce
work related to oral and written language (Gardner, 1983). This aspect makes the theory
suitable for both the teachers and students learning English as a second language.
Gardener's theory argues that a learning style does not have to contain specified criteria
on the way an individual should be taught but to encourage any applicable style hence
acting as a motivator to both teachers and student teaching and learning English as a
second language (Gardner, 1983).
Universal Design and How It Relates to Motivation
Universal Design for Learning (UDL) is a concept which has not only become a norm
in the education sector but also has its roots in the learning environment. As an
application, UDL has made learning of a new language such as English easier as it
provides rich support to student learning and minimizes barriers to the various learning
methods (Feng & Cheng, 2009). For example, teachers are encouraged to deploy
universal design to students with sensory, learning disabilities and language barriers as
the approach makes both teaching and learning easy. Similarly, universal design helps
19
the educators to customize the suitable curriculum to accommodate students’ difference
and learning styles. The main purpose of the universal design for learning is not only to
aid the students in acquiring masterly in knowledge and certain skills but more so to
facilitate them in learning to achieve expertise in learning English (Feng & Cheng, 2009).
The success of the universal design is due to its major components which include
multiple means of representation, expression, and engagement (See Table 1). UDL
encourages the offering of information in more than one format to students (Dörnyei &
Ushioda, 2011). For instance, teachers may opt to use textbooks as their primary visual
teaching method, however, providing audio, text, video as well as hands-on learning kits
as supplemental teaching methods will enhance students’ learning strengths.
In addition, action and expression are part of the second UDL component which
highlights what teachers should emulate when teaching and getting students to
demonstrate what they have learned. For instance, an educator can ask the students to
take a pen and pencil exam, provide an oral presentation or even participate in a group
project as different ways to demonstrate what they have learned (Al-Jarf, 2004). The
students will be motivated in learning as they can choose the mode of expression they
feel comfortable with. Lastly, engagement is the last UDL component that encourages
teachers to find different means to motivate their students in learning English as a second
language. After the students choose their preferred mode of expression, teachers are
encouraged to let students make decisions on choices for different tasks which they feel is
meaningful and significant (Feng & Cheng, 2009).
20
UDL motivates student to learn English as a second language as it expands the
accessibility and effectiveness of general education. This helps the students to learn in
their most compatible learning style or preference, making it easier for them to grasp
what they are taught (Al-Jarf, 2004). Secondly, deploying this teaching mode minimizes
stigma especially when students are given the choice to choose the method of
presentation they feel comfortable with. UDL is also a motivator in students learning
English as a second language as they can interact with different learning materials, thus
having the flexibility to learn more as they engage their strengths more than their
weaknesses.
Lastly, having a universal design implemented by the teacher gives the students
multiple ways of representation and provides them a better way to be engaged and
express what they have learned. As a result, students are more motivated to access the
content of the curriculum and projects to better ensure they get the academic results they
desire (Dörnyei & Ushioda, 2011). In summary, UDL components provide better ways
in which students learning English as a second language will learn and demonstrate what
they have already learned in class. Therefore, educators must acknowledge that students
all have different learning styles and UDL can ensure that the learning process is
conducive to all students.
21
Table 1.
An explanation of how the UDL component acts as a motivator for learning students.
3 Networks = 3 UDL Principles
Recognition Networks:
The Representation of
Learning
Strategic Networks: The
Action & Expression in
Learning
Affective Networks:
The Engagement in
Learning
How we gather facts and
categorize what we see,
hear and read. Identifying
letters, words or an
author’s style are
recognition tasks.
Planning and performing
tasks. How we organize and
express our ideas. Writing
an essay or solving a math
problem are strategic tasks.
How students get
engaged and stay
motivated. How they
are challenged,
excited, or interested.
These are effective
dimensions.
Present information and
content in different ways
which leads to more ways
of representation.
Differentiate the ways that
students can express what
they know. (Provides
multiple means of action and
expression.
Stimulate interest and
motivation for
learning. (Provides
multiple means of
engagement.
22
Technology and Extrinsic Motivation
The use of technology and other related activities can increase students’ motivation in
learning English as a second language. A study conducted by Al-Jarf (2004) at King
Saud University on students taking foreign languages and the influence of the writing
skills of students learning English as a second language found that use of technology
motivated students. Students were encouraged to use computers and internet at home to
finish their assignments. Al-Jarf found that the students posted high results in the tests
which were given compared to those who used a textbook in learning. These students
had improved motivation, high self-esteem and a purpose for achievement. The use of
technology had tremendous effects in posting of positive results to the students. The
technology was also responsible for students to engage in interactive processes outside of
the classroom and the exchange of ideas. Using and incorporating new technology in the
classroom will encourage the students to learn English as a second language (Dörnyei &
Ushioda, 2009).
Another similar study done by Al-Jarf (2004) with students in elementary and high
schools found that there was a positive influence of students using email talk in learning
English as a second language. The learner’s interaction increased the proficiency in the
oral skills of the students. The ability of students to learn how words are pronounced
motivated students to pursue more involving and complex issues of language learning
and acquisition. In this case, students were encouraged by interacting with other learners,
online learning content, and teachers. The research demonstrated that when students are
using technology in interactions and teachers must seek ways in which they can integrate
23
technology in learning English, the students participated more in the classroom due to
their higher level of motivation.
Motivation and Use of Incentives
In some institutions, teachers use rewards and incentives to develop and promote
motivation to students learning English as a second language. Some scholars have
proposed this as “earn by reading” that students can be given incentives and rewards to
encourage them to learn English (Dörnyei & Ushioda, 2009). This especially targets
students who have low learning abilities. These low achieving students can be rewarded
with attention and other incentives aimed at making them adopt a more progressive
learning process courtesy of extrinsic motivation. Rewarding a student’s increased self-
esteem and thus contributed to developing the student’s motivation to learn (Dörnyei &
Ushioda, 2009). Rewards and incentives vary from one level of education to the other,
and therefore it requires a teacher to use the right incentives to promote motivation to
students. Incentives can vary in the context of gender and age, which requires careful
choosing of the right incentives for different purposes.
The interest of a student to keep learning English, therefore, rests squarely on the
ability of the teacher to keep students interested in the language. The teacher needs to
understand that he or she is the greatest motivational aspect contributor to students. Papi
and Abdollahzadeh (2012) stated that many students are influenced by other factors
outside the classroom, but the teacher must keep the students motivated in learning
English as a second language. The teacher must maintain the initial interests which
24
encourage the students to enroll in learning English as a second language in the first
place. The qualifications, dedication, and personal motivation of the teacher are required
to create a learning environment which can enable learners to achieve their educational
goals in education. Papi and Abdollahzadeh suggested that teachers and learning
institutions need to develop strategies which would promote learning, motivate students
and give them the necessary impetus to pursue their educational goals in learning English
as a second language.
Conclusion
The sections above attempt to review some of the literature that discusses the
correlation between extrinsic motivation and students learning English as a second
language. It can be deduced that there is no single teaching strategy or motivational
program which is better than the other. All of them must be used together or the teacher
must the right strategy for different scenarios to obtain effective teaching results for
English as second language students. Learners’ increased motivation would increase
their desire and ability to learn and chances of achieving their educational goals. All of
this can be attained if the students develop a positive attitude towards learning English as
a second language.
25
Chapter 3
METHODOLOGY
Motivation is a crucial factor in the academic success of international students whose
aim is learning English as a second language. Researchers such as Feng and Chen (2009)
and Karaoglu (2008) attempted to theorize motivation as well as study its different
dimensions with regards to how it affects educational performance of English learners.
Primarily, both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation are crucial for educational success.
Intrinsic motivation is meant to trigger a student’s interest in the learning process while
extrinsic motivation initiates a desire among the learners to set and achieve academic
goals (Feng & Cheng, 2009). Although extrinsic motivation significantly enhances
students’ success, extrinsic has not been significantly studied on how it applies to English
as second language students.
To make a systematic review on the topic of motivation, we will follow five steps. The
first step consists of structuring the research questions. Before that, the researcher must
define the research questions, analyze the existing literature about the topic and
determine the need of a systematic review. A few research questions are needed so the
investigator can find answers to the research problem.
Framing the Research Questions
From the initial literature review, the researcher had established that there is extensive
research on the impact of motivation on academic performance. However, Feng and
Chen (2009) discovered that there are only a few studies which had focused on how
26
motivation influences the achievement of international students in English with second
language classes. The first research question would be framed in a manner that attempts
to contribute to the existing body of knowledge with the purpose of contributing to a
better understanding of how academic performance in English as second language classes
can be enhanced. The researcher asked the first question: What is the role of extrinsic
motivation in learning English as a second language among international students? The
second question on “how are learning theories utilized by teachers to motivate
international studies in learning English as a second language” was based on studies by
Broderick (2016), Lewis (2015), and Belford (2013).
Kozaki and Ross (2011) attributed the frequent failure of students who attend English
as second language classes to the lack of extrinsic motivation. Ideally, although students
may be motivated intrinsically, the absence of extrinsic motivation denies them a chance
to set and achieve goals in the English as second language class. Following the research
methodologies and procedures stipulated in the previous chapter, this section aimed at
analyzing the collected data from key researchers who carried research on the role of
intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in international students learning English as a second
language through answering the two central research questions.
1) What is the role of extrinsic motivation in learning English as a second language
among international students?
2) How are learning theories utilized by teachers to motivate international students in
learning English as a second language?
27
The Investigative Process: The Systematic Review Methodology
The research within this study was predominantly qualitative and only sought to
establish the non-statistical data that explains the role of extrinsic motivation in the
academic achievement of international English as second language students. Therefore,
the researcher focused on desk-based research, which is sometimes referred to as
secondary research to establish information from previous studies about the role of
extrinsic motivation in overall English as second language achievement.
Identifying Relevant Sources
Identifying relevant sources is the most significant process in the research because it
determines the reliability and validity of findings. To establish as many relevant sources
as possible for the study, the researcher searched a wide range of databases including
educational, scientific, psychological, and sociological databases. These multiple
databases provided relevant studies that would facilitate the answering of the research
questions. The researcher focused on establishing both primary studies on the research
topic as well as any other secondary information that would supplement the
understanding of motivation of international students in learning English as a second
language.
Assessing the Quality of Studies
The quality assessment of each article was very relevant to every step of the
systematic review. In addition, the framing of the questions and the article selection
criteria defined the minimum acceptable level of research design. To determine the
28
methodological quality of the full text articles that were retrieved, the researcher joins the
findings from the studies highlighted in each article and analyzes the material in line with
the research questions using general evaluation guides and design-based quality check
lists, an organized but flexible methodology aimed to develop the foundation of research
and facilitate the establishment of the acceptability and relevance of different research
designs employed by various researchers (Khan, Kunz, Kleijnen, & Antes, 2003). After
that, the researcher task is to summarize the research results all together as described in
detail below. The researcher can do that through discussion and comparison of the
characteristics, quality, effects and differences of the studies collected. The last step is to
report the outcomes and come up with the conclusions and suggestions in line with the
results (Khan et al., 2003).
The research also deployed a critical appraisal guide, a methodical procedure that is
mainly used to classify the strengths and weakness of the source research with the central
aim of assessing the usefulness and the validity of the study’s findings presented by
researchers. For instance, it was vital to eliminate or lower the priority of articles that
were less than ten years old. Two tables containing the sources relevant to each of the
two central questions were also constructed during this process to demonstrate the use of
the appraisal guide (See Table 2 and Table 3).
Remarkably, Wu and Wu (2008) noted that in any research process the quality
assessment of studies should be aimed at exploring heterogeneity (quality of being
diverse in content) as well as informing the decisions on the appropriateness of meta-
analysis (combined data from multiple studies). The quality assessment can be used to
29
evaluate the strength of inferences and therefore allow the study to make future
recommendations regarding potential additional research.
Summarizing the Documentation
The summarization of evidence from studies which vary in design and quality was not
an easy task and required prudence. The study deployed a systematic review in
summarizing the data as it was confined to a qualitative research design (Wu & Wu,
2008). The research objective anticipated that the findings of the study would help
establish a basis for conducting potential quantitative research. Summarizing the data
related to how motivation enhances the academic success of students involved the
tabulation of student studying attributes, effects, and quality of instruction (Dörnyei &
Ushioda, 2009). A quantitative approach would have required exploring differences
between studies and comparing their impact through meta-analysis. However, given the
qualitative approach, the researcher was only interested in narrative information that
facilitated an understanding of the role of extrinsic motivation in the English as second
language class.
Interpreting the Findings
Before interpreting the findings of the study, the researcher explored all risks of
publication and researcher bias that may be present in the articles. Risk of biases in
publication refer to an organized error or deviation from the genuine truth affecting the
reliability of the study. Bias mainly affects both the reliability and validity of the study
distorting the truth as well as skewing the analysis (Rothstein, Sutton, & Borenstein,
30
2005). Some of the elements of bias in a qualitative study include moderator bias which
involved gathering of data skewed on the moderator’s race, social status and his or her
age. Similarly, the study avoided articles biased of their questions which could affect the
response of result to participants. Lastly, the study avoided articles characterized of
biased answers such as consistency bias, error bias as well as mood bias. For instance,
heterogeneity assessments were conducted to establish whether the overall summation of
the findings could be trusted and relied on. Furthermore, the recommendations made by
the author were graded by reference to both the strengths and weaknesses of the
established evidence.
Data Analysis
Qualitative research involves the use of inferential analysis to compute data and
present the findings. Similarly, qualitative study is also referred as a central exploratory
research whose main aim is to enhance the understanding of specific reasons, views and
motivations. The use of qualitative data collection technique is advantageous as it
enhances the development of ideas for a qualitative research. Therefore, using it will
help in uncovering trends of thoughts and opinions in relation to the research subject.
The purpose of this research was to investigate how extrinsic motivation can be used to
enhance academic achievement in English as a second language classes involving
international students.
31
The Inclusion Criteria
For both primary and secondary sources to be used in this study, the researcher sought
to establish information that was pertinent to the research and could, therefore, help in
answering of the specific research questions (Papi & Abdollahzadeh, 2012). The first
items on the inclusion criteria were the currency of information, data, and evidence. The
researcher sought to establish information that was current and could apply to the present
time. Therefore, only studies conducted within the last ten years were included in the
systematic review so that any source published before 2008 was not eligible to be used in
the research.
The second item on the inclusion criteria was the authoritativeness of the sources.
Authoritativeness can also mean the legitimacy of a source. A reference is only
legitimate or authoritative if its authors are qualified to handle the topic. The researcher
ensured that sources used in the systematic review were authored by qualified
professionals whose ideas, findings, and arguments were viewed credible as trustworthy.
Primarily, the researcher provided that all secondary sources included in the researcher
were published on legitimate websites by qualified authors. The third and most important
item on the inclusion criteria was the relevancy of a source. For a reference relevant to
the research, it had to include at least four keywords generated by the researcher. The
critical research terms included motivation, extrinsic motivation, intrinsic motivation,
English as a Second Language (ESL), Second Language Acquisition (SLA), English as a
Foreign Language (EFL), English Language Learners (ELL), international students,
academic achievement, learning, and student success (Dörnyei & Ushioda, 2009). Given
32
that the research was about international students, the researcher anticipated that studies
to be included in the systematic review should contain an international perspective.
However, during the investigative process, the researcher established that some studies
met all the criterion for inclusion but did not hold a global view.
Research Question One Table 2.
The following articles support the first research question: What is the role of extrinsic
motivation in learning English as a second language among international students?
Table of Research Question One
Author(s) Year Description (Abstract)
Wu, W., &
Wu, P.
2008 The researchers used quantitative methodology to explore the
student perceptions of the physical environment, social
interaction and instructional arrangements and studied the
relationship between the learning context and student
motivation. The three perspectives were found to be
obstacles in English as second language learning and the
learners’ motivation was found to positively correlate with
the learning context.
Karaoglu,
S.,
2008 Discusses the significant role that motivation plays in the
learning of English as a second language. Discusses the
33
different strategies that can be used to motivate learners in an
English as a second language class.
Ebata. M., 2008 The author uses secondary research to identify some of the
factors that influence motivation in an English as a second
language class. The article establishes the environment,
involvement, goals, beliefs, attributes, personal attributes,
self-confidence, teacher-learner relationships, and success, as
some of the factors that influence the motivation.
Feng, R., &
Chen, H.
2009 The study uses observational research to establish the impact
of motivation on English as a second language learning. The
researchers used secondary methods to prove that motivation
plays a significant role in enhancing as well as expediting
learners’ English language learning.
Kozaki, Y.,
& Ross, S.
2011 Longitudinal research design to study the influence of
learning context on the dynamics of individual differences in
language learning were identified. Study conducted among
1682 learners revealed that the mediating impact of learning
context on the relation between individual growth and second
language acquisition exert both positive and negative
influences on the learners’ achievement.
34
Al-
Mahrooqi,
R., Abrar-
Ul-Hassan,
S., &
Asante, C.
C.,
2012 The study sought to replicate the findings of Cheng and
Dörnyei (2007) by analyzing the use of motivational
strategies by English as a second language teachers in Oman.
The main variables included the most important motivational
strategy and the most used motivational strategy. The
teachers in the study region use 48 different motivational
strategies and the most used are associated with the teacher’s
personal performance in class.
Papi, M., &
Abdollahzad
eh, E.
2012 The researchers also used observational research to study the
association between the instructor’s use of motivational
strategies and the learner’s motivated behavior in learning
English as a second language in Iran. The study found out
that the motivational practices of a teacher are related to the
learner’s motivated behavior.
Abrar-Ul-
Hassan, S
2014 Study analyzes the motivational patterns of English for
academic and professional purposes of learners. Types of
motivation established include extrinsic and intrinsic
motivation. Degrees of motivation include low, medium, or
high. Most learners exhibited both types of motivation and
35
the degree of motivation was mostly medium.
Rahman, A.
H., et al.
2017 Research investigated the factors that influence motivation
English as second language classrooms among 80 students.
The study employed the quantitative methodology and
established that teacher’s influences, parental influences, and
personal attitude affect the learner’s motivation on English as
a second language.
Implications for English Language Teachers
While extrinsic motivation serves as a dimension which is significant in the learning
of languages, there are many variables which are necessary for a student to have the
necessary ability to embrace and excel in learning a second language. Many researchers
such as Papi and Abdollahzadeh (2012) came up with a large spectrum of variables to
attempt to explain the process of students learning English as a second language. Papi
and Abdollahzedeh considered students that have interests related to native speakers of
the English language and social perceptions that language may result in the interethnic
correlation between the learner and the native speakers. There is a sense in which these
external factors to the motivation of students can imbue a sense of linguistic self-
confidence.
Abrar-Ul-Hassan (2014) and Wu and Wu (2008) conducted research on the role of
motivation and identified that international students who have a goal to English for their
36
professional and future career endeavors are more motivated than those that learn for
general communication purposes at school. Papi and Abdollahzadeh (2012) along with
Karaouglu (2008), Wu and Wu (2008), and Arbor-U1-Hassan (2014) found that English
as a universal language is used in intercultural settings as the primary language that
everyone can learn and understand. From the analysis, the role of motivation in the
English as a second language class cannot be underestimated. Ebata (2008) concluded
that motivation is the crucial determinant of student success and linguistic capability in
the English language learner’s class. Wu and Wu (2008) contends that intrinsic
motivation is internal and may or may not be influenced by external factors. However,
extrinsic motivation is increasingly important because it can be evoked by many triggers
including classroom environment, interaction with the instructors, and other material and
non-material triggers such as material rewards, financial rewards, and recognition.
Furthermore, extrinsic motivation can be tailored to drive or stimulate the learner to
achieve specific educational outcomes.
In studying the significance of motivation in English as a second language classrooms,
most of the researchers tend to focus on the factors that influence extrinsic motivation
and their impact on learning. One element that was recurrent among these studies was
the impact of the classroom environment. Karaouglu (2008) claimed that the learning
environment significantly affected a student’s motivation and how students perceive the
learning environment could have significant implications on how they are stimulated or
willing to achieve the course outcomes. For instance, Ebata (2008) agreed that a friendly
atmosphere characterized by student-centered learning where specific student needs are
37
met sufficiently motivates and encourages the student to learn more. Alternatively,
Kozaki and Ross (2011) argued that if the teacher is authoritative to a hostile level in the
classroom, students are discouraged and their willingness, readiness, and commitment to
achieving educational outcomes become compromised.
The teacher also has a significant role to play when motivating the learners. For
instance, Al-Mahrooqi et al. (2012) established that English Language Learner teachers
in Oman have over 40 different motivational strategies aimed at encouraging their
learners to attain linguistic proficiency in English. Lewis (2015) suggested that these
strategies could be tailored to meet the specific student needs or the needs of the entire
class depending on the teacher. It is imperative to note that the teaching strategy
significantly determines how learners will be motivated to take part in the learning
process. English learning is a complicated process that requires the determination and
full commitment of learners in the class. Kozaki and Ross (2011) concluded that parental
influences also significantly affected how a learner is motivated in the English as a
second language class. Specifically, the authors found that parents who continually
practiced English at home and encouraged their children to learn and use English also
significantly motivated them to attain linguistic proficiency. Kozaki and Ross (2011) and
Wu and Wu (2008) believed it was vital for parents to practice the use of English at home
and continuously support and cheer their children when they endeavor to learn English as
a second language. If a learner finds support in learning the language, they will be
stimulated and inspired to acquire linguistic proficiency in the language to be able to
38
communicate effectively as Rehman, Bilal, Sheikh, Bibi, and Nawaz (2014) outlined in
their study.
Extrinsic motivation could also be influenced by the desire to achieve. Wu and Wu
(2008) found that a student’s success is also a source of motivation. According to the
authors, if a student sees that they are making progress, they are likely to be inspired to
learn more. However, Belford (2013) linked this form of motivation to the role of the
English as a second language teacher. According to Broderick (2016), the teacher should
employ an objective approach in the English as a second language class that vividly
defines error-correction methods and provides a chance for the learners to seek further
clarifications and practice. Karaouglu (2008) outlined that in the learning process,
learners should not be reprimanded for the mistakes they make. Instead, they should be
encouraged to try again and inspire to achieve more. Reprimanding learners only makes
them feel like losers according to the social cognitive theory of learning. Therefore,
motivation should be applied at all levels to enhance linguistic proficiency among the
English Language Learners.
Research Question Two
Table 3.
The following articles support the second research question: How are learning theories
utilized by teachers to motivate international students in learning English as a second
language?
39
Table of Research Question Two
Author(s) Year Description (Abstract)
Digital
Chalkboard
N.d. Website highlights some of the theories and models used in
second language acquisition. The site distinguishes between
outdated/conventional models and contemporary theories that
apply to current English as a second language classrooms.
Anthony,
B. R. A.
2008 Researcher explores the classroom-based teaching strategies for
English as a Second Language. Specifically, the researcher
studies the target output as well as the role of expression in
successful English Language Arts Standard. A theoretical basis
for the study is first established to determine how different
models impact English as a second language learners.
Rao, Z. 2012 Researcher uses two models in the information-processing
theory to investigate the relationship between a learner’s
learning strategies and his/her English proficiency. The author
links five factors to learning strategies in the ACT Model and 3
factors in the 3P Model (personalization, participation and
knowledge-pull).
Belford, E.
R.
2013 “How does language learning occur” In a bid to answer the
question, the author embarks on a review of the different
40
learning theories and how they can be applied in an English as a
second language class. Theories discussed include the
behavioral theory, the social cognitive theory, information
processing theory, and constructivism and their application to
English as as second language learning.
Lewis, M.
B.
2015 This book integrates theory with practice to make important
recommendations for both English Language Learners (ELL)
and teachers. The author combines concepts such as motivation,
error treatment, and autonomy and relates them to existing
learning theories in a bid to establish the right mix for success in
ELL classrooms.
Broderick,
M.
2016 Researcher discusses language acquisition theories by focusing
on their history, application, and suitability for ELL classes.
Some of the theories identified include acquisition/learning
hypothesis, natural order hypothesis, input hypothesis, active
filter hypothesis and the monitor hypothesis.
Andrade,
S. M.
2017 This study elucidates how improved linguistic skill and broader
educational success can be achieved through online ELL courses
based on language acquisition theories, distance education and
other pedagogical approaches. The researcher applies different
learning theories to come up with a theoretical framework that
41
can aid online ELL.
From the systematic review of the literature, it has been established that different
learning theories can be applied to English as a second language classrooms to enhance
outcomes through motivation. The behaviorism learning theory links learning behavior
to environmental influences. According to this theory proposed by Belford (2013), a
learner’s behavioral outcomes are shaped by instruction, and approach to teaching among
other factors in the learning environment. Digital Chalkboard (n.d.) and Andrade (2017)
identified that a teacher needs to be aware of how their style of teaching affects the
learning behavior of learners. If the method of teaching motivates the learners, it should
be reinforced. However, if it discourages active participation and compromises
commitment to educational outcomes, it should be reviewed and possibly changed. On
the other hand, the social cognitive theory sees learning as a result of a change that
happens in the learner’s cognition, thoughts and perceptions about a subject (Andrade,
2017; Anthony, 2008; Lewis, 2015). Unlike behaviorism which sees learning as
conditioning, social cognitive theories push for vicarious learning where students learn
through observation. Thus, Broderick (2016) suggested that teachers could consider
using teaching approaches that allow students to observe and therefore be able to change
their perceptions about aspects of the English language.
In their research, Rao (2012) and Belford (2013) summarized the information
processing theory that significantly applies to the English Language Learners (ELL)
classroom, which characterizes learning as how an individual acquires, encodes, stores,
42
and retrieves knowledge According to this theory which has been studied extensively in
the literature, there are varied memory models that can be applied in the process of
learning. Some models allow for long-term memory retention while others allow for
short-term memory retention. Each model is tuned to the nature and purpose of the
knowledge acquired. Ebata (2008), Broderick (2016) and Andrade (2017) assumed that
teachers need to be aware of how students retain knowledge in the ELL class.
Conceptually, the knowledge taught in class should be stored for long-term retention and
recall because linguistic proficiency requires the constant retrieval of the gained
knowledge. Another theory that features in literature is constructivism which sees
learning as the contextual cognitive perspective within which individuals construct their
knowledge. Anthony (2008) further outlined that this theory rejects the concept of
“scientific truths.” Teachers should as well identify the appropriate approach and
understand when and how it applies to the ELL classroom.
43
Chapter 4
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
For quite some time, learning of a second language has been under-researched by
many scholars. Researchers such as Rehman, Sheikh, Bibi, and Nawaz (2014) emphasize
that motivation play a fundamental role in the learning of the second language among
students. They have concluded that the motivational level of learning a second language
has the same aptitude as predicting performance levels of students learning a second
language (Kozaki & Ross, 2011). In this case, motivation is a fundamental factor in
influencing the attitude that students will have in their ability to perform in learning the
second language. Therefore, it is prudent for instructors to appreciate the role of
motivation in the learning process especially in the learning of English as a second
language.
Research has shown that international students are likely to perform better if they
engage learning with enthusiasm and commitment. There is a need to help teachers
explore new methods to increase student engagement and participatory activity for their
English as a second language students. A student learning English as a second language
can face many challenges and therefore it is important to initiate the necessary means to
motivate them to achieve their educational goals (Ganjabi, 2011).
Extrinsic motivation is the key factor for which teachers should use to increase
academic performance and promote interactive classroom participation amongst the
students. There are many factors that are essential for the learning of English as a second
44
language. A teacher should be fixated on devising new ways that will increase the desire
of students to learn and achieve their educational goals. By the year 2025, there will be
ten billion people on earth who will be speaking the English language (Kozaki & Ross,
2011). Therefore, it is prudent for international students to find the right motivating
factors that will aid them in gaining proficiency in learning the English language as
efficient as possible.
According to learning theory of Rumboll (2013), several prerequisites must be
employed by English as a second language (ESL) teachers to effectively teach ESL
students. ESL instructors will need quality instructions, interactions, feedback, and
avenues of commendable performance to maintain progress and motivate their students in
learning. A teacher should then seek to tap into the avenues of extrinsic motivation and
thereby tap into the resources of external motivation to create a motivated classroom.
There are different purposes of studying English as a second language and it is important
for teachers to identify the purpose by creating motivational strategies for improving
student learning. Teachers must make students understand why there is a need to try,
how relentless they should pursue the new language skills, and how they should be
motivated towards their pursuits.
Teachers who are experienced can ensure that their students are always motivated.
Motivation has been widely used by schools and institutions as a variable to give students
the impetus to perform better in their education. Researchers Dörnyei and Ushioda
(2009) found out that motivation that is integrative can lessen the anxiety featuring many
students who take English as a second language. Motivation, in this case, is dictated by
45
many factors which are intertwined and have tremendous effects on the motivational
level of the students (Dörnyei & Ushioda, 2009). Learning English requires one to have
the necessary motivating factors to keep them going and providing the right attitude
needed to attain positive educational goals. Extrinsic motivation can influence students
to gain the encouragement necessary for posting good grades.
Researchers such as Papi and Abdollahzadeh (2012) found how a student perceives a
certain language is bound by the way in which they are determined to incorporate the
language being learned. This is a result of the difference between one learning English as
a second language and other subjects in school since language is part of a human identity.
Learning a language involves more than just studying the system of rules or the skills and
grammar of the language. According to Papi and Abdollahzadeh, language is understood
by the student as a recreation of one’s image of him or herself and the restructuring of
new cultural and social behaviors for themselves. Therefore, motivation is wired to the
social nature of the learner.
There are several ways in which educators can provide extrinsic motivation to
students. One of the ways is ensuring that teachers provide students with the usefulness
of the language. Teaching English to Speakers of other Languages (TESOL) teachers can
increase the level of the motivation of students in making sure that students have a way in
which learners can find the usefulness of studying the English language as a second
language (Rumboll, 2013). As a means of motivation, teachers must find ways in which
they can enhance the attitude of learners in studying English through incorporating
extrinsic motivation.
46
Findings from the research recommends that teachers find ways in which they can
make the learning of English personal. Rumboll (2013) argued that teachers must create
a mechanism in which they can create a way for self-expression of students and motivate
them to learn. Students should learn to stay away from information which is not useful
and prevents them from developing accountable performance and success in the
language. To promote extrinsic motivation, research recommends a need for one to have
an education system which is pragmatic and motivation centered, optimal for the
examination, analyzing and applying classroom motivation specific to the students.
In this case, Wu and Wu (2008) state that teachers must have a classroom atmosphere
which is conducive, ample and pleasant. This will then necessitate the learners to be able
to take the tasks as given by the teacher in an open-minded approach. Teachers should
also have a good relationship with the learners as it creates a mutual bond between the
learner and the instructor to create an ample environment for interactions. Wu and Wu
(2008) argued that teachers should also promote the autonomy of the learners and
encourage them to make personal initiatives to ensure that they have engaged positively
with each other and the learning process. They hold the belief that teachers should also
possess the ability to influence the students in having a personalized process of learning
and ensuring that students are familiar with the English culture. Teacher motivation,
therefore, can be termed as a fundamental aspect of learner motivation in learning
English as a second language. Teachers must create rapport for ESL students so that their
motivation is tuned to a personal level. For a teacher, having a real conversation with
students will create a connection between the educator and the students that will then
47
increase the level of motivation to students. This connection can influence students to
learn more as it leads to students experiencing a different culture or language.
My Personal ESL Experience
Just like most students in China, I started to learn English when I was in the 5th and
6th grade 15 years ago. Most of the students back then thought English class was like
any other class we had to take such as music or art class and even assumed it may even
be more fun. In fact, many of us thought this class was an opportunity for us to relax
from a high-pressure class such as math and Chinese writing classes. Our English
teacher was not very strict about our performance because our course performance did
not really impact our ability to graduate to high school. At the time, we did understand
that knowing a bit of English was important for our future careers but that was a bit far
off in the future for us to make it a high priority. By the time I was a senior in high
school and was preparing for college, I finally realized the importance of learning English
because I had to earn a high English score to get into the top universities that were
extremely competitive. I regret not taking English seriously in middle school and
wasting my past eight years not doing anything to improve my English skills. After
studying extremely hard and passing the exams, I was admitted to my university and I
had no reason to use my English anymore, so I forgot much of what I learned in the past
easily. Later when I got my chance to become an international student to attend
university in the United States, my ambition to better learn English once more came back
out as I knew it was extremely helpful for me to adapt into the new environment. As an
ESL international student, I naturally found the research topic about extrinsic motivation
48
very important for learners in the process of learning English like myself. In fact, most
people especially those from countries where English is not compulsory recommended
students to commence learning English as early as when they are in kindergarten. In our
increasingly more globalized world, more schools, teachers, and parents have noticed that
learning English is very important and therefore creating a learning environment that
embraces international students. As a result, a new generation from all over the world
speaks better English than before!
49
REFERENCES
Abrar-Ul-Hassan, S. (2014). A Study of the Motivational Patterns of Learners of English
for Academic and Professional Purposes. TESOL Journal, 5(1), 32-57.
Al-Jarf, R. (2004). The effects of web-based learning on struggling EFL college
writers. Foreign Language Annals, 37(1), 49-57.
Ali, R. & Leeds, E. (2009). The Impact of Face-to-Face Orientation on Online Retention:
A Pilot Development at the intersection of learning, implementation, and design.
Educational Researcher, 40(7), 331-337.
Al-Mahrooqi, R., Abrar-Ul-Hassan, S., & Asante, C. C. (2012). Analyzing the Use of
Motivational Strategies by EFL Teachers in Oman. Malaysian Journal of ELT
Research, 8(1), 36-74.
Andrade, S. M. (2017). Online English Language Learning: Theory-Based Course Design
and Pedagogy. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 5(3), 1-10.
Anthony, B. R. A. (2008). Output Strategies for English-Language Learners: Theory to
Practice. The Reading Teacher, 61(6), 474-482.
Arteaga, J. (2006). A Framework to Understanding Motivation in the TESOL
Field. PROFILE 7, 147-159.
Barkhuizen, G. (2011). Narrative Knowledge in TESOL. TESOL Quarterly, 45(3), 391-
414.
Belford, E. R. (2013). Review of Learning Theories: An Educational Perspective.
Journal of Chemical Education, 90(2), 150-151.
50
Broderick, M. (2016). Language Acquisition Theories for Teachers of ELLs. Retrieved
from http://www.hotchalkeducationnetwork.com/language-acquisition-theories/
Broussard, S. C., & Garrison, M. E. B. (2004). The relationship between classroom
motivation and academic achievement in elementary school-aged children.
Family and Consumer Sciences Research Journal, 33(2), 106-120.
Burden, P. (2004). An examination of attitude change towards the use of Japanese in a
university English ‘conversation’ class. Class, 35(1), 21 - 36.
Cherry, K. (2018). What Is Extrinsic Motivation? Retrieved from
https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-extrinsic-motivation-2795164
Clement, R. (2006). Motivation, Self-confidence, and Group Cohesion in the
Foreign Language Classroom. Language Learning, 44(3), 417-448.
Deci, E., Vallerand, R., Pelletier, L., & Ryan, R. (1991). Motivation and education: The
self-determination perspective. Educational Psychologist, 24(3 &4), 325-246.
Digital Chalkboard. (n.d.). Theories/Methods/Strategies/Research for L2 Language
Acquisition. Retrieved from
https://www.mydigitalchalkboard.org/portal/default/Content/Viewer/Content?acti
on=2&scId=100051&sciId=1405
Dörnyei, Z., & Ushioda, E. (2009). Motivation, language identity, and the L2 self.
Bristol: Multilingual Matters.
Dörnyei, Z., & Ushioda, E. (2011). Teaching and researching motivation (2nd ed.).
Harlow: Pearson Education Limited.
51
Ebata. M. (2008). Motivation Factors in Language Learning. The Internet TESL Journal,
14(4). Retrieved from http://iteslj.org/Articles/Ebata-MotivationFactors.html
ESL. (2012). In Dictionary.com. Retrieved from http://www.dictionary.com/browse/esl
Feng, R., & Chen, H. (2009). An analysis of the importance of motivation and
strategy in postgraduates, English acquisition. English Language Teaching, 2(3),
93-97.
Ganjabi, M. (2011). Effective Foreign Language Teaching: a Matter of Iranian Students’
and Teachers’ Beliefs. English Language Teaching, 4(2), 46. Retrieved from
http://dx.doi.org/10.5539/elt.v4n2p46
Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences. New York:
Basic Books.
Gredler, M. E. (2001). Learning and instruction: Theory into practice. (4th ed.). Upper
Saddle River, New Jersey Prentice-Hall, Inc.,.
Hajhashemi, K., Shakarami, A., & Caltabiano, N. (2017). Compensation Still Matters:
Language Learning Strategies for the Third Millennium ESL Learners. Online
Learning, 21(3). Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.24059/olj.v21i3.1055
Karaouglu, S. (2008). Motivating Language Learners to Succeed. Retrieved from
http://www.tesol.org/read-and-publish/journals/other-serial-
publications/compleat-links/compleat-links-volume-5-issue-2-(june-
2008)/motivating-language-learners-to-succeed
Khan, K. S., Kunz, R., Kleijen, J., & Antes, G. (2003). Five steps to conducting a
systematic review. J R Soc Med, 96, 118-121.
52
Kozaki, Y., & Ross, S. (2011). Contextual Dynamics in Foreign Language Learning
Motivation. Language Learning, 61(4), 1328-1354. Retrieved from
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9922.2011.00638.x
Kyiacou, K., & Kobon, M. (2006). Motivation to learn and teach English in
Slovenia. Educational Studies, 24, 345-351. Retrieved from
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0305569980240307
Lewis, M. B. (2015). One-on-One Language Teaching and Learning: Theory and
Practice. ELT Journal, 71(3), 388-389.
Liu, M. (2007). Chinese students’ motivation to learn English at the tertiary level. Asian
EFL Journal, 9(1), 126-146.
Long, C., Ming, Z., & Chen, L. (2013). The study of student motivation on English
learning in junior middle school – A case study of No. 5 Middle School in Gejiu.
English Language Teaching, 6(9), 136-145
Morell, T. (2007). What enhances EFL students’ participation in lecture discourse?
Student, lecturer and discourse perspectives. Journal of English for academic
Purposes, 6(3), 222-237.
Najeeb, S. S. R. (2013). Learner Autonomy in Language Learning. Akdeniz Language
Studies Conference (May, 2012) Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 70,
1238-1242.
53
Noels, K. (2001). Learning Spanish as a second language: learners’ orientations and
perceptions of their teachers’ communication style. Language Learning, 51(1),
107-144.
Papi, M., & Abdollahzadeh, E. (2012). Language Learning. Teacher Motivational
Practice, Student Motivation, and Possible L2 Selves. An Examination in the
Iranian EFL Context, 62(2), 571–594.
Phakiti, A., Hirsh, D., & Woodrow, L. (2013). It’s not only English: Effects of other
individual factors on English language learning and academic learning of ESL
international students in Australia. Journal of Research in International
Education, 12(3), 239-258.
Pintrich, P. R. (2000). An achievement goal theory perspective on issues in motivation
terminology, theory, and research. Contemporary educational psychology, 25(1),
92-104.
Rahman, H. A., Rajab, A., Wahab, S. R. A., Nor, F. M., Zarina, W., Zakaria, W. & Baldi,
M. A.(2017). Factors Affecting Motivation in Language Learning.
International Journal of Information and Education Technology, 7(7), 543-547.
Rao, Z., (2012). Language Learning Strategies and English Proficiency: Interpretations
from Information-Processing Theory. The Language Learning Journal, 44(1), 90-
106.
Rehman, A., Bilal, H., Sheikh, A., Bibi, N., & Nawaz, A. (2014). The role of motivation
in learning English language for Pakistani learners. International Journal of
Humanities and Social Science, 4(1), 254-258.
54
Rothstein, H., Sutton, A. J., & Borenstein, M. (2005). Publication bias in meta-analysis:
prevention, assessment and adjustments. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
Rumboll, A. (2013). Innovative approaches to ESL for young learners: South Africa and
the United States. Per Linguam, 4(1). Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.5785/4-
1-463
Shaikholeslami, R., & Khayyer, M. (2006). Intrinsic Motivation, Extrinsic Motivation,
and Learning English as a Foreign Language. Psychological Reports, 99(3), 813-
818.
Topalov, J. (2011). Motivacija u nastavi stranog jezikai. Novi Sad: Prosveta.
Tseng, M. (2013). The Relationship between Attitudes toward Foreign Culture and
English Proficiency Level in Taiwanese Students of English as a Foreign
Language. Studies in English Language Teaching, 1(2), 264-274.
Weiner, B. (2000). Interpersonal and Intrapersonal theories of motivation from an
attributional perspective. Educational Psychology Review, 12, 1-14.
Wu, W. V., & Wu, P. N. (2008). Creating an authentic EFL
learning environment to enhance student motivation to study English. Asian EFL
Journal, 10(4), 211-226.