the office of citizen complaints - sfgovsfgov.org/dpa/ftp/uploadedfiles/occ/occ_3q04.pdf · the...

33
THE OFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTS STATISTICAL REPORT Third Quarter 2004 Included In This Document Comprehensive Statistical Report Comparative Overview of Caseload Complaints and Allegations by Unit Findings in Allegations Closed Presented by: Kevin Allen, Director Compiled by: Chris Wisniewski and Linda Taylor

Upload: doandien

Post on 05-Jun-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

THE OFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTS

STATISTICAL REPORT

Third Quarter 2004

Included In This Document Comprehensive Statistical Report

Comparative Overview of Caseload Complaints and Allegations by Unit

Findings in Allegations Closed

Presented by: Kevin Allen, Director Compiled by: Chris Wisniewski and Linda Taylor

1ST 2ND JUL AUG SEP 4TH YTDCASES OPENEDCases Opened 182 187 72 48 95 -- 584Merged/Voided 10 9 2 0 1 -- 22ADJUSTED TOTAL 172 178 70 48 94 0 562

CASES CLOSED, BY YEAR CASE WAS FILED2002 5 2 4 1 0 -- 122003 129 131 25 34 18 -- 3372004 53 95 56 59 17 -- 280TOTAL 187 228 85 94 35 0 629

CASES PENDING, BY YEAR CASE WAS FILED1998 1 1 1 1 1 -- 12001 1 1 1 1 1 -- 12002 13 11 7 6 6 -- 62003 254 123 98 64 46 -- 462004 130 222 237 226 304 -- 304TOTAL 399 358 344 298 358 0 358

CASES OUTSIDE OCC JURISDICTION19 21 14 12 4 -- 70

CASES SUSTAINED23 16 10 5 8 -- 62

COMPREHENSIVE STATISTICAL REPORTTHIRD QUARTER 2004

2004 2003 2002CASES OPENED1st Quarter 182 325 2232nd Quarter 187 261 273July 72 105 93August 48 95 81September 95 62 714th Quarter -- -- --YTD TOTAL 584 848 741

CASES CLOSED1st Quarter 187 226 2052nd Quarter 228 212 217July 85 98 88August 94 76 69September 35 82 854th Quarter -- -- --YTD TOTAL 629 694 664

CASES PENDINGJanuary 385 308 272February 385 302 261March 402 362 268April 359 384 293May 360 406 293June 358 411 324July 344 419 331August 298 438 343September 358 418 329October -- -- --November -- -- --December -- -- --

CASES SUSTAINED1st Quarter 23 26 192nd Quarter 16 17 28July 10 12 12August 5 8 7September 8 10 94th Quarter -- -- YTD TOTAL 62 73 75

COMPARATIVE OVERVIEW OF CASELOADTHIRD QUARTER 2002 - THIRD QUARTER 2004

MONTH IN PERSON LETTER MAIL OTHER PHONE SFPD TOTALSJanuary 22 1 19 2 9 2 55February 22 4 19 3 5 1 54March 16 7 37 4 8 1 731ST QUARTER 60 12 75 9 22 4 182April 23 4 29 1 9 1 67May 27 5 22 2 5 0 61June 23 1 25 1 8 1 592ND QUARTER 73 10 76 4 22 2 187July 24 1 36 2 9 0 72August 17 8 18 5 0 0 48September 35 5 47 4 4 0 953RD QUARTER 76 14 101 11 13 0 215October -- -- -- -- -- -- --November -- -- -- -- -- -- --December -- -- -- -- -- -- --4TH QUARTER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

YTD TOTAL 209 36 252 24 57 6 584

HOW COMPLAINTS WERE RECEIVEDTHIRD QUARTER 2004

TOTA

L CO

MPL

AINT

S

TOTA

L A

LLEG

ATI

ON

S

OFF

ICER

S IN

VOLV

ED

SFPD UNIT NAME UF UA CRD ND RS SS D PRO POL TF3B SOUTHERN STATION 5 1 5 5 4 0 0 1 0 0 0 16 63C BAYVIEW STATION 1 1 1 1 2 0 1 0 0 0 0 6 23D MISSION STATION 2 0 1 2 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 5 23E NORTHERN STATION 2 1 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 23F PARK STATION 1 1 1 1 3 0 1 0 0 0 0 7 13G RICHMOND STATION 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 13H INGLESIDE STATION 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 13I TARAVAL STATION 2 0 9 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 12 43J TENDERLOIN TASK FORCE 3 4 2 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 54B ENFORCEMENT & INVESTIGATION (SOLOS) 1 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 15N NARCOTICS 1 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 1UK UNKNOWN ASSIGNMENT 19 6 17 14 13 0 0 3 0 0 0 53 13TOTALS 39 14 42 28 27 0 2 6 0 0 0 119 39

DEFINITION OF ALLEGATION TYPESUF Unnecessary ForceUA Unwarranted ActionCRD Conduct Reflecting DiscreditND Neglect of DutyRS Racial SlurSS Sexual SlurD DiscourtesyPRO ProcedurePOL PolicyTF Training Failure

ALLEGATION TYPES

COMPLAINTS AND ALLEGATIONS BY UNITSEPTEMBER 2004

TOTA

L C

OM

PLA

INTS

TOTA

L A

LLEG

ATI

ON

S

OFF

ICER

S IN

VOLV

ED

SFPD UNIT NAME UF UA CRD ND RS SS D PRO POL TF2G PERMITS SECTION 1 1 5 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 23A CENTRAL STATION 6 3 6 6 4 0 0 2 0 0 0 21 83B SOUTHERN STATION 14 1 17 10 17 0 0 3 0 0 0 48 213C BAYVIEW STATION 4 0 10 5 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 133D MISSION STATION 7 3 4 6 7 1 0 3 0 0 0 24 123E NORTHERN STATION 3 1 8 1 5 0 0 1 0 0 0 16 53F PARK STATION 2 0 5 12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 18 53G RICHMOND STATION 1 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 13H INGLESIDE STATION 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 13I TARAVAL STATION 3 1 2 2 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 43J TENDERLOIN TASK FORCE 2 2 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 45N NARCOTICS 3 2 11 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15 6UK UNKNOWN ASSIGNMENT 4 1 1 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 4TOTALS 51 15 77 50 44 1 0 10 0 0 0 197 86

DEFINITION OF ALLEGATION TYPESUF Unnecessary ForceUA Unwarranted ActionCRD Conduct Reflecting DiscreditND Neglect of DutyRS Racial SlurSS Sexual SlurD DiscourtesyPRO ProcedurePOL PolicyTF Training Failure

ALLEGATION TYPES

COMPLAINTS AND ALLEGATIONS BY UNITSEPTEMBER 2003

(FOR COMPARISON)

TOTA

L CO

MPL

AINT

S

TOTA

L A

LLEG

ATI

ON

S

OFF

ICER

S IN

VOLV

ED

SFPD UNIT NAME UF UA CRD ND RS SS D PRO POL TF1A CHIEF'S OFFICE 2 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 22L LEGAL DIVISION 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 13A CENTRAL STATION 15 13 25 6 11 0 0 1 0 0 0 56 243B SOUTHERN STATION 13 6 17 9 18 0 0 6 0 0 0 56 223C BAYVIEW STATION 9 5 22 11 8 0 2 0 0 0 0 48 213D MISSION STATION 9 0 6 7 6 1 1 1 0 0 0 22 113E NORTHERN STATION 14 8 16 6 10 2 0 2 0 0 0 44 213F PARK STATION 4 1 5 4 5 1 1 0 0 0 0 17 53G RICHMOND STATION 2 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 3 23H INGLESIDE STATION 2 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 23I TARAVAL STATION 5 0 9 4 2 0 0 2 0 0 0 17 133J TENDERLOIN TASK FORCE 6 5 4 4 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 104B ENFORCEMENT & INVESTIGATION (SOLOS) 3 0 2 4 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 44X SPECIAL OPERATIONS HQ'S 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 15C AUTO SECTION 2 2 2 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 35G GENERAL WORK SECTION 1 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 35N NARCOTICS 2 0 4 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 6 25S SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS(INCL. GANG TASK FORCE) 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 25V VICE CRIMES DIVISION 2 2 4 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 3UK UNKNOWN ASSIGNMENT 59 24 47 31 41 1 1 10 0 0 0 155 42TOTALS 153 66 165 95 114 5 5 24 0 0 0 474 194

DEFINITION OF ALLEGATION TYPESUF Unnecessary ForceUA Unwarranted ActionCRD Conduct Reflecting DiscreditND Neglect of DutyRS Racial SlurSS Sexual SlurD DiscourtesyPRO ProcedurePOL PolicyTF Training Failure

ALLEGATION TYPES

COMPLAINTS AND ALLEGATIONS BY UNITTHIRD QUARTER 2004

TOTA

L C

OM

PLA

INTS

TOTA

L AL

LEG

ATIO

NS

OFF

ICER

S IN

VOLV

ED

SFPD UNIT NAME UF UA CRD ND RS SS D PRO POL TF2G PERMITS SECTION 1 1 5 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 22N NOISE ABATEMENT UNIT 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 13A CENTRAL STATION 22 18 38 22 21 0 0 8 0 0 0 107 393B SOUTHERN STATION 38 11 52 28 40 0 0 8 0 0 0 139 523C BAYVIEW STATION 22 19 47 32 32 0 1 8 0 0 0 139 533D MISSION STATION 26 10 21 17 26 2 2 9 0 0 0 87 373E NORTHERN STATION 21 10 41 8 27 0 0 1 0 0 0 87 433F PARK STATION 4 1 6 15 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 24 83G RICHMOND STATION 5 1 7 3 9 0 0 3 0 0 0 23 73H INGLESIDE STATION 10 2 10 4 8 0 0 1 0 0 0 25 133I TARAVAL STATION 24 6 34 25 44 0 0 5 0 0 0 114 433J TENDERLOIN TASK FORCE 22 13 34 12 15 1 0 5 0 0 0 80 373M MUNI DIVISION 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 13X PATROL BUREAU HQ'S 1 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 14B ENFORCEMENT & INVESTIGATION (SOLOS) 4 0 7 2 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 12 44T CRIME PREVENTION COMPANY 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 24Z TRAFFIC 10B PROGRAMS (Co. A - J) 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 15D BURGLARY SECTION 1 0 4 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 15E FENCING SECTION 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 15G GENERAL WORK SECTION 3 0 1 3 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 35H HOMICIDE SECTION 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 15J ROBBERY SECTION 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 15N NARCOTICS 5 5 14 3 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 115S SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS(INCL. GANG TASK FORCE) 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 15T JUVENILE DIVISION 2 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 25V VICE CRIMES DIVISION 2 0 2 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 35W DOMESTIC VIOLENCE UNIT 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1AB AIRPORT BUREAU 6 2 2 7 8 0 0 2 0 0 0 22 8UK UNKNOWN ASSIGNMENT 44 10 24 17 34 1 1 5 0 0 0 92 30TOTALS 273 109 353 207 288 4 4 60 0 0 0 1027 407

DEFINITION OF ALLEGATION TYPESUF Unnecessary Force SS Sexual SlurUA Unwarranted Action D DiscourtesyCRD Conduct Reflecting Discredit PRO ProcedureND Neglect of Duty POL PolicyRS Racial Slur TF Training Failure

ALLEGATION TYPES

COMPLAINTS AND ALLEGATIONS BY UNITTHIRD QUARTER 2003

(FOR COMPARISON)

NO FINDING SUBTOTAL TOTALUF UA CRD ND RS SS D POL/PRO TF

1st Quarter 4 4 7 5 0 0 3 23 0 0 232nd Quarter 10 20 5 9 0 0 2 46 0 0 46July 0 7 3 7 0 0 0 17 0 0 17August 4 2 2 6 0 1 0 15 0 0 15September 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 14th Quarter -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --YTD TOTAL 18 33 18 27 0 1 5 102 0 0 102

NO FINDING/WITHDRAWN SUBTOTAL TOTALUF UA CRD ND RS SS D POL/PRO TF

1st Quarter 0 15 2 4 0 0 2 23 0 0 232nd Quarter 6 37 10 4 0 0 4 61 0 0 61July 1 6 2 4 0 0 0 13 0 0 13August 1 4 2 0 0 0 1 8 0 0 8September 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 04th Quarter -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --YTD TOTAL 8 62 16 12 0 0 7 105 0 0 105

NOT SUSTAINED SUBTOTAL TOTALUF UA CRD ND RS SS D POL/PRO TF

1st Quarter 95 180 115 163 3 3 31 590 1 0 5912nd Quarter 101 188 175 173 8 2 33 680 0 0 680July 24 42 47 58 3 7 9 190 0 0 190August 35 49 66 72 5 3 16 246 0 0 246September 8 9 22 33 2 1 9 84 0 0 844th Quarter -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --YTD TOTAL 263 468 425 499 21 16 98 1790 1 0 1791

PROPER CONDUCT SUBTOTAL TOTALUF UA CRD ND RS SS D POL/PRO TF

1st Quarter 5 131 15 27 0 0 0 178 0 0 1782nd Quarter 2 135 16 42 0 0 0 195 1 0 196July 2 29 7 14 0 0 0 52 0 0 52August 2 52 7 18 0 0 0 79 1 0 80September 0 14 0 3 0 0 0 17 0 0 174th Quarter -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --YTD TOTAL 11 361 45 104 0 0 0 521 2 0 523

SUSTAINED SUBTOTAL TOTALUF UA CRD ND RS SS D POL/PRO TF

1st Quarter 2 32 3 16 1 0 1 55 0 0 552nd Quarter 2 11 1 15 0 1 1 31 0 0 31July 0 12 7 12 0 0 1 32 0 0 32August 0 3 1 4 0 0 0 8 0 0 8September 1 1 2 7 0 0 0 11 0 0 114th Quarter -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --YTD TOTAL 5 59 14 54 1 1 3 137 0 0 137

UNFOUNDED SUBTOTAL TOTALUF UA CRD ND RS SS D POL/PRO TF

1st Quarter 3 6 7 2 0 0 2 20 1 0 212nd Quarter 0 5 6 3 0 0 0 14 0 0 14July 1 0 2 3 0 0 0 6 0 0 6August 0 5 1 1 0 0 0 7 0 0 7September 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 04th Quarter -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --YTD TOTAL 4 16 16 9 0 0 2 47 1 0 48

DEFINITION OF ALLEGATION TYPESUF Unnecessary ForceUA Unwarranted ActionCRD Conduct Reflecting DiscreditND Neglect of DutyRS Racial SlurSS Sexual SlurD DiscourtesyPRO ProcedurePOL PolicyTF Training Failure

ALLEGATION TYPES

FINDINGS IN ALLEGATIONS CLOSEDTHIRD QUARTER 2004

ALLEGATION TYPES

ALLEGATION TYPES

ALLEGATION TYPES

ALLEGATION TYPES

ALLEGATION TYPES

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 09/04/1996 08/13/1999 NOT SUSTAINED BY SFPD 05/14/20011 1UF SUS 09/04/1996 08/13/1999 NOT SUSTAINED BY SFPD 05/14/20011 1ND SUS 09/04/1996 08/13/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/14/20011 1UF SUS 09/04/1996 08/13/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/14/20011 1ND SUS 09/04/1996 08/13/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/14/20012 1UA SUS 01/09/1997 12/17/1998 RETRAINING. 05/10/19992 1UA SUS 01/09/1997 12/17/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19993 1ND SUS 01/21/1997 12/23/1998 TRAINING FAILURE BY DEPARTMENT. 05/09/20023 1UF SUS 01/21/1997 12/23/1998 60 DAYS, 30 HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS. 11/07/20013 1UA SUS 01/21/1997 12/23/1998 60 DAYS, 30 HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS. 11/07/20013 1ND SUS 01/21/1997 12/23/1998 60 DAYS, 30 HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS. 11/07/20011 1ND SUS 04/03/1997 03/22/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/19/19991 1ND SUS 04/03/1997 03/22/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/19/19992 1ND SUS 04/11/1997 12/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED.2 1ND SUS 04/11/1997 12/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED.2 1ND SUS 04/11/1997 12/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 05/11/20041 1ND SUS 05/19/1997 09/30/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/20/20009 1UA SUS 05/23/1997 02/05/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 05/09/20019 1UA SUS 05/23/1997 02/05/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 05/09/20019 1UA SUS 05/23/1997 02/05/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 05/09/20012 1ND SUS 05/27/1997 10/14/1999 RETRAINING. 01/11/20002 1ND SUS 05/27/1997 10/14/1999 RETRAINING. 01/11/20002 1UA SUS 06/23/1997 12/23/1998 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/24/20022 1ND SUS 06/23/1997 12/23/1998 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/24/20022 1ND SUS 06/24/1997 12/13/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 03/23/20002 1ND SUS 06/24/1997 12/13/1998 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/23/20004 1UF SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UA SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UA SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UF SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UA SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UF SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UA SUS 07/01/1997 12/10/1998 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1ND SUS 08/15/1997 12/23/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/24/19991 1CRD SUS 08/15/1997 12/23/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/24/19991 1CRD SUS 08/15/1997 12/23/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/24/19991 1ND SUS 08/27/1997 12/11/1998 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/24/19991 1UF SUS 08/27/1997 12/11/1998 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/24/19991 1ND SUS 09/08/1997 11/03/1998 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 03/02/19992 1SS SUS 09/10/1997 08/31/1999 NOT SUSTAINED/LACHES BY THE DEPARTMENT. 08/22/20002 1ND SUS 09/12/1997 06/07/1999 COUNSELING. 06/18/19992 1ND SUS 09/12/1997 06/07/1999 COUNSELING. 06/18/19992 1ND SUS 09/12/1997 06/07/1999 COUNSELING. 06/18/19993 1ND SUS 09/12/1997 06/04/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/22/20013 1UA SUS 09/12/1997 06/04/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/29/20029 1ND SUS 09/19/1997 09/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 12/29/19991 1ND SUS 09/29/1997 08/25/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/01/20001 1ND SUS 09/29/1997 08/25/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/01/20009 1CRD SUS 10/03/1997 10/07/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 07/16/20019 1ND SUS 10/10/1997 12/31/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19999 1UA SUS 10/10/1997 12/31/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19999 1ND SUS 10/10/1997 12/31/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19999 1CRD SUS 10/10/1997 12/31/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19993 1ND SUS 10/14/1997 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/20/20033 1ND SUS 10/14/1997 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/20/20033 1UA SUS 10/14/1997 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/20/20033 1UA SUS 10/14/1997 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/20/20033 1CRD SUS 10/14/1997 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/02/19393 1UA SUS 10/14/1997 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/20/20032 1ND SUS 10/17/1997 12/15/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 12/06/2000

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 10/24/1997 01/29/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/19991 1ND SUS 10/24/1997 01/29/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/19991 1ND SUS 10/24/1997 01/29/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/19991 1ND SUS 10/24/1997 01/29/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/19991 2ND SUS 10/24/1997 01/29/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/19991 1ND SUS 10/24/1997 01/29/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/19991 1ND SUS 10/31/1997 06/25/1999 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. (30 DAYS W/15 HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR 2 YRS) BY POLICE COMMISSION.11/07/2001

1 1UF SUS 10/31/1997 06/25/1999 DISMISSED PER POLICE COMMISSION SETTLEMENT 11/07/20011 1ND SUS 10/31/1997 06/25/1999 DISMISSED PER POLICE COMMISSION SETTLEMENT 11/07/20011 1ND SUS 10/31/1997 06/25/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED.1 1ND SUS 10/31/1997 06/25/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED.1 1UF SUS 10/31/1997 06/25/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED.1 2UA SUS 11/03/1997 10/14/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/01/20011 1D SUS 11/03/1997 10/14/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/01/20011 1ND SUS 11/03/1997 10/14/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/01/20011 1D SUS 11/03/1997 10/14/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 05/01/20015 1ND SUS 11/10/1997 11/02/1998 RETRAINING. 01/07/19993 1D SUS 11/14/1997 10/08/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING.. 11/01/20001 1UA SUS 11/17/1997 01/29/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19991 1ND SUS 11/17/1997 01/29/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19991 1ND SUS 11/17/1997 01/29/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/19994 1D SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 04/06/20024 1ND SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 04/06/20024 1CRD SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 04/06/20024 1ND SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 04/06/20024 1CRD SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 04/06/20024 1ND SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 04/06/20024 1ND SUS 11/26/1997 12/31/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 04/06/20023 1CRD SUS 12/19/1997 03/31/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/08/20013 1UA SUS 12/19/1997 03/31/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/08/20013 1UA SUS 12/23/1997 06/13/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20013 1CRD SUS 12/23/1997 06/13/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20013 1ND SUS 12/23/1997 06/13/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20012 1UF SUS 01/12/1998 06/11/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20012 1D SUS 01/12/1998 06/11/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20012 1ND SUS 01/12/1998 06/11/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20012 1UF SUS 01/12/1998 06/11/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20013 1ND SUS 01/12/1998 12/23/1998 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/12/19991 1ND SUS 01/12/1998 01/29/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 08/19/19991 1D SUS 02/09/1998 08/26/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/01/20011 1CRD SUS 02/09/1998 08/26/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/01/20011 1ND SUS 02/10/1998 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/04/20001 1ND SUS 02/10/1998 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/04/20001 1ND SUS 02/10/1998 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/04/20001 1ND SUS 02/10/1998 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/04/20009 1CRD SUS 02/20/1998 12/30/1998 ADMONISHMENT. 03/24/19999 1D SUS 02/20/1998 12/30/1998 ADMONISHMENT. 03/24/19999 1ND SUS 02/20/1998 12/30/1998 ADMONISHMENT. 03/24/19993 1CRD SUS 02/23/1998 07/31/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/29/19999 1D SUS 03/02/1998 11/30/1998 REFERRAL TO COMMANDING OFFICER. 01/01/20001 1ND SUS 03/02/1998 12/04/1998 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/02/19991 1ND SUS 03/02/1998 12/04/1998 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/02/19991 1D SUS 03/10/1998 10/30/1998 TERMINATION HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR 5 YEARS W/181 DAYS

SUSPENSION IMPOSED. SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION.06/29/2001

1 1CRD SUS 03/10/1998 10/30/1998 TERMINATION HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR 5 YEARS W/181 DAYS SUSPENSION IMPOSED. SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION.

06/29/2001

2 1D SUS 03/10/1998 03/05/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/16/20021 1ND SUS 03/11/1998 10/06/1998 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE BY ASSISTANT CHIEF. 05/24/19993 1ND SUS 03/19/1998 07/07/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 04/29/2002

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

3 1ND SUS 03/19/1998 07/07/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20021 1ND SUS 03/23/1998 12/17/1998 RETRAINING. 06/30/19992 2ND SUS 03/23/1998 08/26/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 04/29/20022 1CRD SUS 03/23/1998 08/26/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 04/29/20022 2ND SUS 03/23/1998 08/26/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 04/29/20029 1D SUS 04/13/1998 10/09/1998 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/31/19981 1UA SUS 04/13/1998 02/23/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 05/24/19992 1ND SUS 04/15/1998 04/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20022 1ND SUS 04/15/1998 04/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20022 1ND SUS 04/15/1998 04/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20021 1ND SUS 04/23/1998 03/09/1999 RETRAINING. 09/15/19993 1CRD SUS 04/27/1998 12/30/1998 ADMONISHMENT. 03/24/19993 1ND SUS 05/04/1998 04/20/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 06/22/19993 1ND SUS 05/04/1998 04/20/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 06/22/19999 1UA SUS 05/08/1998 08/12/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 10/26/20001 1UA SUS 05/22/1998 11/24/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20011 2CRD SUS 05/22/1998 11/24/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20011 1CRD SUS 05/22/1998 11/24/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20011 1UA SUS 05/22/1998 11/24/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20012 1D SUS 05/27/1998 12/13/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/07/20002 1ND SUS 05/27/1998 12/13/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/07/20004 1ND SUS 06/02/1998 04/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/15/19994 1CRD SUS 06/02/1998 04/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/15/19994 1UA SUS 06/02/1998 04/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/15/19994 1UA SUS 06/02/1998 04/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/15/19994 1UA SUS 06/02/1998 04/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/15/19994 1CRD SUS 06/02/1998 04/28/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/15/19999 1UA SUS 06/08/1998 09/30/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/19/20009 1UA SUS 06/08/1998 09/30/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/19/20004 1D SUS 06/08/1998 05/27/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 05/07/20012 1UF SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1CRD SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1CRD SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UF SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1CRD SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1CRD SUS 06/09/1998 03/30/2001 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.1 1UA SUS 06/11/1998 02/17/1999 RETRAINING. 05/11/19991 1UA SUS 06/19/1998 03/15/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 05/16/20021 1UA SUS 06/19/1998 03/15/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 05/16/20021 1CRD SUS 07/13/1998 04/28/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 03/28/20001 1ND SUS 07/13/1998 04/28/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 03/28/20004 1UF SUS 07/16/1998 06/30/1999 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1CRD SUS 07/21/1998 02/25/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/31/20003 1UA SUS 07/21/1998 02/25/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/31/20001 1CRD SUS 07/22/1998 05/13/1999 3 DAYS SUSPENSION. 03/16/20009 1ND SUS 07/22/1998 09/11/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/24/20019 1UA SUS 07/22/1998 09/11/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/24/20015 1CRD SUS 07/24/1998 09/27/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 06/15/20005 1CRD SUS 07/24/1998 09/27/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 06/15/20001 1CRD SUS 07/24/1998 06/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/29/19991 1D SUS 07/24/1998 06/03/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/15/20002 1CRD SUS 07/31/1998 07/13/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 08/15/20006 1UF SUS 08/03/1998 07/22/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/10/20021 1ND SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1ND SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1UA SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1ND SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1UA SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/2000

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1UA SUS 08/12/1998 12/31/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1UA SUS 08/24/1998 09/07/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/18/20001 1UA SUS 08/24/1998 09/07/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/18/20001 2UA SUS 08/24/1998 09/07/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/18/20001 1UA SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1UF SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1CRD SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1ND SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1ND SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1UA SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1CRD SUS 08/31/1998 07/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20014 1UA SUS 09/15/1998 12/28/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20002 1UA SUS 09/30/1998 12/24/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/01/20002 1UA SUS 09/30/1998 12/24/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/01/20001 1UA SUS 10/02/1998 01/10/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1UA SUS 10/02/1998 01/10/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20001 1UA SUS 10/02/1998 01/10/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/29/20002 1ND SUS 10/06/1998 07/29/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 02/26/20012 1ND SUS 10/06/1998 07/29/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 02/26/20012 1CRD SUS 10/09/1998 12/21/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/30/20001 1CRD SUS 10/09/1998 08/31/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 10/26/20009 1CRD SUS 10/14/1998 09/30/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 06/19/20001 1UA SUS 10/15/1998 09/28/1999 RETRAINING. 12/29/19993 1UA SUS 10/16/1998 03/31/1999 RETRAINING. 09/15/19992 1ND SUS 10/26/1998 10/25/1999 RETRAINING. 06/22/20003 1D SUS 11/03/1998 09/28/1999 COUNSELING. 02/02/20005 1ND SUS 11/09/1998 08/27/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND AND RETRAINING. 06/20/20002 1CRD SUS 11/10/1998 05/26/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/19/19991 1CRD SUS 11/17/1998 05/18/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 09/07/19991 1ND SUS 11/17/1998 05/18/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 09/07/19992 1D SUS 11/25/1998 07/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20042 1UF SUS 11/25/1998 07/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20042 1CRD SUS 11/25/1998 07/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20049 1CRD SUS 11/30/1998 08/31/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 03/08/20009 1UA SUS 12/07/1998 11/22/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 11/01/20009 1UA SUS 12/11/1998 07/30/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 04/12/20009 1CRD SUS 12/11/1998 07/30/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 04/12/20004 1ND SUS 12/15/1998 03/31/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 02/02/20009 1CRD SUS 12/15/1998 07/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 06/16/20009 1D SUS 12/15/1998 07/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 06/16/20002 1CRD SUS 12/29/1998 06/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/03/20002 1D SUS 12/29/1998 06/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/03/20002 1ND SUS 12/30/1998 10/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20014 1D SUS 01/04/1999 02/23/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/17/20012 1ND SUS 01/12/1999 12/22/1999 RETRAINING. 11/14/20002 1UA SUS 01/14/1999 09/07/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/09/20021 1UA SUS 01/15/1999 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/27/20001 1UA SUS 01/15/1999 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/27/20001 1UA SUS 01/15/1999 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/27/20001 1UA SUS 01/15/1999 11/30/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/27/20001 1ND SUS 01/20/1999 03/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/08/20021 1ND SUS 01/20/1999 03/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/08/20021 1D SUS 01/27/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. DISMISSED AT HEARING ON

06/26/2001.07/18/2001

1 1CRD SUS 01/27/1999 12/15/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1CRD SUS 01/27/1999 12/15/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20019 3UA SUS 02/02/1999 01/27/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/27/20009 2UA SUS 02/02/1999 01/27/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/27/20009 3UA SUS 02/02/1999 01/27/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/27/2000

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

9 3UA SUS 02/02/1999 01/27/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/27/20001 2ND SUS 03/10/1999 08/26/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/19/20021 1UA SUS 03/10/1999 08/26/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/19/20021 1UF SUS 03/10/1999 08/26/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/19/20021 1D SUS 03/16/1999 02/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20021 2CRD SUS 03/16/1999 02/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20021 1CRD SUS 03/18/1999 12/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20041 1UF SUS 03/18/1999 12/22/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20041 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1UA SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20011 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/11/20013 1ND SUS 03/18/1999 02/29/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/20/20002 1D SUS 03/24/1999 01/24/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE

YEARS.10/26/2001

2 2ND SUS 03/24/1999 01/24/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

10/26/2001

2 1UF SUS 03/24/1999 01/24/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

10/26/2001

2 1ND SUS 03/24/1999 01/24/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/26/20011 1CRD SUS 03/29/1999 12/31/1999 RETRAINING. 06/26/20001 1ND SUS 03/31/1999 04/28/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 04/30/20021 1D SUS 04/19/1999 06/30/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND AND RETRAINING. 01/06/20002 1UA SUS 04/21/1999 11/14/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/22/20012 2UA SUS 04/21/1999 11/14/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/21/1999 11/14/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/21/1999 11/14/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/22/20012 1ND SUS 04/27/1999 12/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/20/20007 1D SUS 04/29/1999 12/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 10/26/20001 1CRD SUS 05/03/1999 08/23/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/20/20001 1D SUS 05/03/1999 08/23/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/20/20009 1ND SUS 05/06/1999 10/08/1999 RETRAINING. 01/05/20009 1ND SUS 05/06/1999 10/08/1999 RETRAINING. 01/05/20009 1D SUS 05/10/1999 03/22/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE. 12/18/20009 1CRD SUS 05/10/1999 03/22/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE. 12/18/20009 1CRD SUS 05/17/1999 08/26/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 02/27/20011 2ND SUS 05/18/1999 01/24/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20041 1UF SUS 05/18/1999 01/24/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/10/20043 1UA SUS 05/18/1999 03/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 10/23/20003 1UA SUS 05/18/1999 03/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 10/23/20001 1ND SUS 05/21/1999 10/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/23/20011 1ND SUS 05/21/1999 10/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/23/20011 1UA SUS 05/21/1999 10/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/23/20011 1ND SUS 05/21/1999 10/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/23/20011 1UA SUS 05/21/1999 10/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/23/20011 1UA SUS 05/21/1999 10/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/23/20012 1ND SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 COUNSELING. 06/11/20032 1UA SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/21/1999 12/28/1999 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 05/24/1999 02/28/2000 RETRAINING. 06/22/20009 1D SUS 05/24/1999 08/30/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/20009 1UA SUS 05/24/1999 08/30/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/29/20003 1ND SUS 05/26/1999 12/29/1999 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/09/20021 1UF SUS 05/30/1999 05/31/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20012 3UF SUS 06/01/1999 05/31/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20012 1D SUS 06/01/1999 05/31/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20012 1CRD SUS 06/01/1999 05/31/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 06/26/20011 1CRD SUS 06/04/1999 12/31/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 06/22/20001 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 03/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/16/20011 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 03/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/16/20011 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 03/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/16/20019 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/1999 06/12/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20022 3UA SUS 06/15/1999 04/28/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/27/20002 2UA SUS 06/15/1999 04/28/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/27/20001 1CRD SUS 06/16/1999 04/28/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 09/19/20001 1SS SUS 06/22/1999 12/30/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/26/20001 1ND SUS 06/25/1999 07/29/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/29/19992 1D SUS 06/25/1999 06/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/07/20036 1ND SUS 06/28/1999 01/07/2000 RETRAINING. 06/30/20009 1ND SUS 07/06/1999 12/22/1999 RETRAINING. 06/26/20009 1ND SUS 07/12/1999 09/28/1999 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 11/16/19992 1ND SUS 07/12/1999 11/30/1999 RETRAINING. 11/28/20002 1ND SUS 07/12/1999 11/30/1999 RETRAINING. 11/28/20002 1ND SUS 07/12/1999 12/24/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/21/20001 1ND SUS 07/20/1999 05/05/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 10/23/20009 1ND SUS 07/26/1999 09/08/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/13/20019 1ND SUS 07/26/1999 09/08/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/13/20013 1ND SUS 07/28/1999 05/31/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/06/20003 1ND SUS 07/28/1999 05/31/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/06/20003 1ND SUS 07/28/1999 05/31/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/06/20003 1ND SUS 07/28/1999 05/31/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/06/20003 1CRD SUS 07/28/1999 05/31/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/06/20001 1ND SUS 07/30/1999 05/24/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 10/23/20002 1ND SUS 07/30/1999 06/26/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/21/20001 1UA SUS 08/02/1999 04/28/2000 COUNSELING. 09/19/20009 1ND SUS 08/06/1999 08/18/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR ONE

YEAR.03/28/2001

9 1CRD SUS 08/06/1999 08/18/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR ONE YEAR.

03/28/2001

9 1CRD SUS 08/06/1999 08/18/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR ONE YEAR.

03/28/2001

9 1ND SUS 08/06/1999 08/18/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR ONE YEAR.

03/28/2001

9 1UA SUS 08/13/1999 04/24/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/16/20002 1CRD SUS 08/16/1999 12/15/1999 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/28/20007 1CRD SUS 08/23/1999 06/30/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 11/17/20012 1UA SUS 08/30/1999 06/01/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/24/20022 1UA SUS 08/30/1999 06/01/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/24/20022 1UA SUS 08/30/1999 06/01/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/24/20022 1UA SUS 08/30/1999 06/01/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/24/20021 1D SUS 08/31/1999 12/24/1999 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/20/20002 1ND SUS 09/15/1999 09/07/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/18/20009 1UA SUS 09/20/1999 04/13/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 10/20/2000

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

9 1CRD SUS 09/20/1999 02/09/2001 TERMINATION HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR 5 YEARS W/181 DAYS SUSPENSION IMPOSED.

06/29/2001

1 1ND SUS 09/22/1999 03/10/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 09/21/20001 1ND SUS 09/27/1999 03/24/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 09/28/1999 01/05/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/06/20011 2D SUS 09/28/1999 01/05/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 02/06/20012 1UF SUS 09/28/1999 05/30/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/17/20022 1ND SUS 09/28/1999 05/30/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/17/20023 1ND SUS 09/28/1999 12/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 06/30/20003 1ND SUS 09/28/1999 12/30/1999 ADMONISHMENT. 06/30/20001 1UA SUS 10/04/1999 04/28/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 10/23/20009 3ND SUS 10/07/1999 01/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/24/20029 1ND SUS 10/07/1999 01/31/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 01/24/20029 2ND SUS 10/07/1999 01/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/24/20023 1UF SUS 10/12/1999 08/04/2000 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, FIVE DAYS TO BE SERVED. FIVE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR ONE YEAR.07/19/2001

9 1UA SUS 10/12/1999 12/22/1999 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/19/20002 1ND SUS 10/15/1999 12/22/1999 RETRAINING. 06/26/20004 1CRD SUS 10/15/1999 01/05/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/15/20013 1ND SUS 11/03/1999 05/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/27/20003 1ND SUS 11/03/1999 05/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/27/20002 1CRD SUS 11/15/1999 10/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 01/26/20011 1UA SUS 12/03/1999 03/10/2000 RETRAINING. 11/01/20002 1UF SUS 12/07/1999 09/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. DISMISSED BY COMMISSION. 09/05/20011 1UA SUS 12/13/1999 09/05/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/18/20002 1CRD SUS 12/20/1999 03/27/2000 COUNSELING. 06/30/20002 1UA SUS 12/20/1999 03/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/18/20002 1ND SUS 12/20/1999 03/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/18/20009 1CRD SUS 12/28/1999 04/04/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 09/18/20002 1ND SUS 12/28/1999 08/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/20/20001 1D SUS 12/30/1999 02/29/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 06/28/20002 1UF SUS 12/31/1999 12/29/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 12/31/1999 12/29/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 2CRD SUS 12/31/1999 12/29/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 12/31/1999 12/29/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.9 1ND SUS 01/04/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/13/20019 1ND SUS 01/04/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/13/20019 1ND SUS 01/04/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/13/20019 1ND SUS 01/04/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/13/20019 1ND SUS 01/04/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/13/20013 1CRD SUS 01/07/2000 12/29/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 02/01/20013 1ND SUS 01/07/2000 12/29/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 11/25/20021 1ND SUS 01/10/2000 08/28/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 12/18/20001 1CRD SUS 01/12/2000 10/04/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/13/20011 1UA SUS 01/12/2000 10/04/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/13/20011 1UA SUS 01/21/2000 10/23/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/07/20011 1ND SUS 01/26/2000 07/27/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 09/28/20009 1UA SUS 01/28/2000 06/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/17/20019 1D SUS 01/28/2000 06/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/17/20019 1ND SUS 01/28/2000 06/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/17/20019 1ND SUS 01/28/2000 06/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/17/20019 1CRD SUS 01/28/2000 06/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/17/20019 1CRD SUS 01/28/2000 06/12/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/17/20011 1ND SUS 02/03/2000 09/22/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 12/20/20004 1CRD SUS 02/04/2000 04/27/2000 COUNSELING. 09/18/20009 1ND SUS 02/07/2000 05/30/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/28/20003 1UA SUS 02/24/2000 08/22/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/18/20003 1UA SUS 02/24/2000 08/22/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/18/20007 1SS SUS 02/25/2000 11/27/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.7 1D SUS 02/25/2000 11/27/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

7 1CRD SUS 02/25/2000 11/27/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.7 1UF SUS 02/25/2000 11/27/2000 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1CRD SUS 02/29/2000 12/22/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/16/20021 1ND SUS 03/03/2000 07/25/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 11/06/20011 1ND SUS 03/09/2000 02/28/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/18/20022 1UA SUS 03/13/2000 12/08/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 07/11/20012 1UA SUS 03/13/2000 12/08/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 07/11/20011 1D SUS 03/13/2000 06/30/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 10/25/20002 1ND SUS 03/15/2000 11/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20012 2CRD SUS 03/15/2000 11/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20012 1D SUS 03/15/2000 11/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20012 2UA SUS 03/15/2000 11/30/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20012 1RS SUS 03/20/2000 08/31/2000 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/16/20022 1SS SUS 03/20/2000 08/31/2000 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/16/20022 2CRD SUS 03/20/2000 08/31/2000 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/16/20021 1ND SUS 03/21/2000 05/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/27/20003 1UF SUS 03/28/2000 04/04/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/07/20023 1UA SUS 03/28/2000 04/04/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/07/20023 1ND SUS 03/28/2000 04/04/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/07/20027 1CRD SUS 04/07/2000 04/10/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/09/20027 1UA SUS 04/07/2000 04/10/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/09/20027 1CRD SUS 04/07/2000 04/10/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/09/20027 1UA SUS 04/07/2000 04/10/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/09/20027 1UA SUS 04/07/2000 04/10/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/09/20027 1ND SUS 04/07/2000 04/10/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/09/20021 1ND SUS 04/10/2000 03/22/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/05/20013 1ND SUS 04/13/2000 09/29/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/20/20002 1UA SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20012 1ND SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20012 1UA SUS 04/14/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/22/20014 1UA SUS 04/18/2000 07/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/09/20024 1CRD SUS 04/18/2000 07/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/09/20021 1D SUS 04/26/2000 05/31/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/23/20002 1ND SUS 04/28/2000 08/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/18/20002 1ND SUS 04/28/2000 08/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/18/20001 1CRD SUS 05/01/2000 03/30/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 08/09/20041 1UA SUS 05/02/2000 09/29/2000 ADMONISHMENT. 12/20/20002 1ND SUS 05/11/2000 12/27/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20012 1ND SUS 05/11/2000 12/27/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20012 1ND SUS 05/12/2000 12/27/2000 3 DAYS SUSPENSION. 1 DAY SERVED AND 2 DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR 2 YEARS.03/22/2002

2 2UA SUS 05/12/2000 12/27/2000 3 DAYS SUSPENSION. 1 DAY SERVED AND 2 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR 2 YEARS.

03/22/2002

2 1CRD SUS 05/12/2000 12/27/2000 3 DAYS SUSPENSION. 1 DAY SERVED AND 2 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR 2 YEARS.

03/22/2002

2 1UA SUS 05/15/2000 03/30/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20012 1UA SUS 05/15/2000 03/30/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20011 2CRD SUS 05/22/2000 09/15/2000 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/12/20029 1UA SUS 05/22/2000 08/31/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 11/16/20001 1ND SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1ND SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1UA SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1RS SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1ND SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1ND SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1UA SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/2001

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1UF SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1ND SUS 05/23/2000 06/15/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/12/20011 1ND SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 08/06/20013 1UA SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20023 1UA SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20023 1CRD SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/25/20023 1UA SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/25/20023 1CRD SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/25/20023 1UA SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20023 1UA SUS 05/25/2000 05/16/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/23/20021 1UF SUS 06/01/2000 09/18/2000 5 DAYS SUSPENSION.TWO DAYS SERVED. THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR A PERIOD OF TWO YEARS.03/11/2003

6 1UA SUS 06/02/2000 05/18/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/27/20029 1ND SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1CRD SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1UA SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1CRD SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1ND SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1UA SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1D SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1UA SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1CRD SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20039 1ND SUS 06/09/2000 11/16/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY POLICE COMMISSION. 02/05/20031 1CRD SUS 06/09/2000 05/18/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.09/17/2001

4 1UA SUS 06/12/2000 05/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/14/20014 1ND SUS 06/12/2000 05/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/14/20014 1ND SUS 06/12/2000 05/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/14/20014 1UA SUS 06/12/2000 05/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 08/14/20011 1ND SUS 06/12/2000 04/04/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 05/15/20011 1ND SUS 06/12/2000 04/04/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 06/12/2000 04/04/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UF SUS 06/12/2000 04/04/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 06/12/2000 04/04/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/15/20012 1UA SUS 06/14/2000 04/27/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/11/20022 1UA SUS 06/14/2000 04/27/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 02/11/20029 1ND SUS 06/15/2000 08/31/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/20/20001 1UA SUS 06/20/2000 11/14/2000 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 01/17/20015 1UA SUS 07/05/2000 12/04/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 01/26/20015 1D SUS 07/05/2000 12/04/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 01/26/20011 1D SUS 07/06/2000 06/29/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20013 1ND SUS 07/10/2000 03/16/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/04/20012 1CRD SUS 07/10/2000 07/05/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1ND SUS 07/14/2000 02/28/2001 COUNSELING. 09/04/20012 1UA SUS 07/14/2000 06/22/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20022 1ND SUS 07/14/2000 06/22/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20022 1SS SUS 07/17/2000 01/31/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RESIGNED. 07/11/20011 1CRD SUS 07/25/2000 10/31/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/11/20032 1UF SUS 07/31/2000 07/25/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/26/20012 2ND SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 07/31/20022 3UA SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/31/20022 2ND SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/31/20022 1CRD SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/31/20022 2ND SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/31/20022 2ND SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/31/20022 3UA SUS 08/01/2000 12/29/2000 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/31/20022 1ND SUS 08/03/2000 02/13/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/16/20011 1ND SUS 08/08/2000 10/10/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/20/20002 1ND SUS 08/09/2000 04/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 10/31/20012 1ND SUS 08/14/2000 06/06/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/17/2001

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

2 1UA SUS 08/14/2000 06/06/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/17/20012 1UA SUS 08/14/2000 06/06/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/17/20012 1ND SUS 08/14/2000 06/06/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/17/20012 1ND SUS 08/14/2000 11/30/2000 COUNSELING. 01/26/20012 1ND SUS 08/14/2000 11/30/2000 COUNSELING. 01/26/20012 1ND SUS 08/14/2000 06/04/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 09/07/20012 1ND SUS 08/14/2000 06/04/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 09/07/20012 1UF SUS 08/23/2000 07/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/26/20012 1UF SUS 08/23/2000 07/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/26/20013 1UA SUS 08/25/2000 07/24/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1ND SUS 09/05/2000 02/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/16/2001

1ND SUS 09/15/2000 08/28/2001 COUNSELING. 12/08/20011 1CRD SUS 09/15/2000 08/31/2001 COUNSELING. 12/08/20011 1ND SUS 09/22/2000 09/28/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/04/20013 1ND SUS 09/25/2000 09/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 01/12/20023 1ND SUS 09/25/2000 09/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 01/12/20023 1CRD SUS 09/25/2000 09/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 01/12/20023 1ND SUS 09/25/2000 09/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/12/20023 1CRD SUS 09/25/2000 09/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/12/20023 1ND SUS 09/25/2000 09/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 01/12/20021 1ND SUS 09/25/2000 04/27/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 09/05/20014 1CRD SUS 09/25/2000 05/18/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 11/25/20034 1ND SUS 09/25/2000 05/18/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 11/25/20031 1CRD SUS 09/25/2000 03/30/2001 COUNSELING. 09/05/20012 1CRD SUS 09/26/2000 04/27/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/05/20012 1D SUS 09/26/2000 04/27/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/05/20012 1UA SUS 09/26/2000 04/27/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/05/20011 1ND SUS 09/26/2000 07/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20011 1UA SUS 09/29/2000 04/16/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/05/20011 1UA SUS 09/29/2000 04/16/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/05/20012 1UA SUS 10/02/2000 08/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1UA SUS 10/02/2000 08/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1CRD SUS 10/05/2000 02/22/2001 COUNSELING. 05/16/20011 1UF SUS 10/05/2000 06/22/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1D SUS 10/05/2000 06/22/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.4 1ND SUS 10/06/2000 09/20/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20014 1ND SUS 10/06/2000 09/20/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20014 1ND SUS 10/06/2000 09/20/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20011 1UA SUS 10/10/2000 08/27/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 09/24/20013 1ND SUS 10/13/2000 12/21/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/07/20013 1CRD SUS 10/17/2000 07/24/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/13/20013 1UA SUS 10/17/2000 07/24/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/13/20012 1CRD SUS 10/20/2000 09/28/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/13/20013 1UF SUS 10/23/2000 01/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 01/12/20023 1UA SUS 10/23/2000 01/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 01/12/20022 1ND SUS 10/23/2000 11/20/2001 TRAINING FAILURE BY DEPARTMENT. 05/10/20029 1ND SUS 10/27/2000 03/30/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/05/20011 1UA SUS 10/31/2000 06/12/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 07/17/20011 1UA SUS 10/31/2000 06/12/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 07/17/20013 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20023 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20023 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20023 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20023 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20023 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20023 1UA SUS 11/06/2000 06/29/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/13/20021 1CRD SUS 11/06/2000 10/18/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20011 1ND SUS 11/07/2000 06/22/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/18/20024 1CRD SUS 11/14/2000 06/29/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/17/20012 1ND SUS 11/14/2000 12/28/2000 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/07/2001

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1CRD SUS 11/17/2000 12/27/2000 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20011 1ND SUS 11/20/2000 04/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/25/20011 1ND SUS 11/20/2000 04/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/25/20011 1ND SUS 11/20/2000 04/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/25/20011 1CRD SUS 11/20/2000 04/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/25/20012 1ND SUS 11/30/2000 07/31/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20022 1ND SUS 11/30/2000 07/31/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20022 1ND SUS 11/30/2000 07/31/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20023 1D SUS 11/30/2000 03/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20012 1UA SUS 12/04/2000 05/11/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/17/20013 1ND SUS 12/04/2000 08/31/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/12/20022 1RS SUS 12/14/2000 05/10/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1RS SUS 12/14/2000 05/10/2001 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 12/15/2000 12/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/19/20022 1CRD SUS 12/15/2000 12/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/19/20022 1UA SUS 12/15/2000 12/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/19/20022 1ND SUS 12/15/2000 12/31/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/19/20021 1ND SUS 12/27/2000 04/11/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 01/14/20012 1ND SUS 01/02/2001 09/28/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 12/17/20029 1D SUS 01/04/2001 03/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/04/20011 1UA SUS 01/04/2001 04/30/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 09/17/20011 1UA SUS 01/04/2001 04/30/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 09/17/20011 1CRD SUS 01/04/2001 04/30/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 09/17/20012 1ND SUS 01/04/2001 11/16/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/08/20021 1CRD SUS 01/05/2001 01/14/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/14/20021 1CRD SUS 01/05/2001 04/11/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/11/20039 1CRD SUS 01/05/2001 04/11/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/11/20031 1ND SUS 01/16/2001 12/19/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 01/31/20021 1ND SUS 01/16/2001 12/19/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 01/31/20022 1CRD SUS 01/19/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.01/29/2002

2 1CRD SUS 01/19/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

01/29/2002

2 1CRD SUS 01/19/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

01/29/2002

2 1ND SUS 01/19/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

01/29/2002

2 1UA SUS 01/19/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

01/29/2002

1 1ND SUS 01/22/2001 08/14/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20011 1ND SUS 01/22/2001 08/14/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1ND SUS 01/23/2001 12/19/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/07/20023 1UA SUS 01/31/2001 04/27/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/17/20023 1UA SUS 01/31/2001 04/27/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/17/20023 1UA SUS 01/31/2001 04/27/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/17/20022 1UA SUS 02/02/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20022 1UA SUS 02/02/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1ND SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1UA SUS 02/09/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20022 1ND SUS 02/09/2001 10/22/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20012 1ND SUS 02/09/2001 10/22/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20011 1ND SUS 02/13/2001 12/28/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20022 1ND SUS 02/14/2001 06/22/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20029 1UF SUS 02/20/2001 01/29/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/07/2002

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

2 1ND SUS 02/22/2001 09/28/2001 COUNSELING. 12/26/20011 1ND SUS 03/02/2001 10/09/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/15/20011 1ND SUS 03/05/2001 11/16/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/02/20033 1ND SUS 03/06/2001 11/30/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/02/20043 1ND SUS 03/06/2001 11/30/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/02/20049 1ND SUS 03/07/2001 09/19/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20011 1ND SUS 03/12/2001 10/09/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 12/26/20013 1ND SUS 03/15/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED AND THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR ONE YEAR.04/12/2002

3 1UF SUS 03/15/2001 09/28/2001 5 DAYS SUSPENSION. TWO DAYS SERVED AND THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR ONE YEAR.

04/12/2002

1 1ND SUS 03/21/2001 11/13/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20021 1ND SUS 03/21/2001 11/13/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20022 1ND SUS 03/23/2001 02/27/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/12/20022 1ND SUS 03/23/2001 02/27/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/12/20024 1ND SUS 03/26/2001 06/29/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/17/20012 1ND SUS 03/26/2001 09/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/09/20021 1CRD SUS 04/04/2001 07/24/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 08/19/20019 1UA SUS 04/13/2001 12/28/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, OTHER REASON. 05/07/20021 1D SUS 04/16/2001 03/22/2002 UNFOUNDED 04/30/20031 1ND SUS 04/16/2001 03/22/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 04/30/20031 1ND SUS 04/16/2001 03/22/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 04/30/20031 1ND SUS 04/16/2001 03/22/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 04/30/20032 1ND SUS 04/16/2001 12/27/2001 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/09/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20022 1UA SUS 04/24/2001 10/31/2001 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 04/25/20024 1ND SUS 04/24/2001 06/28/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20011 1D SUS 04/26/2001 08/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1ND SUS 05/02/2001 12/07/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20022 1ND SUS 05/02/2001 12/07/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20021 1UA SUS 05/02/2001 06/29/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20011 1UA SUS 05/07/2001 06/21/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 09/17/20019 1ND SUS 05/17/2001 10/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20022 1UA SUS 05/18/2001 12/14/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/22/20022 1D SUS 05/18/2001 12/14/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 01/22/20022 1ND SUS 05/18/2001 12/28/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 04/04/20032 1ND SUS 05/21/2001 09/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20012 1ND SUS 05/21/2001 09/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/26/20016 1CRD SUS 05/21/2001 08/31/2001 COUNSELING. 12/08/20011 1CRD SUS 05/21/2001 08/31/2001 COUNSELING. 12/08/20014 1CRD SUS 05/21/2001 07/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20011 1UA SUS 05/23/2001 01/08/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 11/20/20031 1ND SUS 06/01/2001 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/02/20021 1ND SUS 06/01/2001 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/02/20021 1UA SUS 06/01/2001 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/02/20021 1UA SUS 06/01/2001 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/02/20021 1UA SUS 06/01/2001 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/02/20021 1ND SUS 06/01/2001 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 10/02/20022 1UA SUS 06/05/2001 05/23/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/27/20022 1D SUS 06/05/2001 05/23/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/27/20022 1UA SUS 06/05/2001 05/23/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/27/20021 1ND SUS 06/06/2001 09/28/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/2002

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 06/06/2001 09/28/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20021 1CRD SUS 06/13/2001 09/18/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/05/20032 1UA SUS 06/19/2001 08/31/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/08/20012 1CRD SUS 06/20/2001 08/31/2001 COUNSELING. 12/08/20014 1UA SUS 06/21/2001 05/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/10/20024 1UA SUS 06/21/2001 05/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 08/10/20022 1ND SUS 06/22/2001 03/29/2002 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE. 04/27/20023 1ND SUS 06/28/2001 12/19/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/31/20023 1ND SUS 06/28/2001 12/19/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/31/20023 1ND SUS 06/28/2001 12/19/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/07/20024 1ND SUS 07/09/2001 10/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 12/26/20012 1ND SUS 07/10/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20022 1ND SUS 07/10/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 03/16/20021 1ND SUS 07/11/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20021 1ND SUS 07/11/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/10/20022 1ND SUS 07/17/2001 11/13/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20022 1ND SUS 07/17/2001 11/13/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20025 1ND SUS 07/20/2001 11/14/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/13/20023 1ND SUS 07/23/2001 11/30/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20022 1UA SUS 07/25/2001 11/30/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 01/08/20022 1UA SUS 08/06/2001 07/24/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/22/20022 1CRD SUS 08/06/2001 07/24/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/22/20022 1CRD SUS 08/06/2001 07/24/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/22/20022 1CRD SUS 08/06/2001 07/24/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/22/20022 1CRD SUS 08/06/2001 07/24/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/22/20023 1ND SUS 08/07/2001 09/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT. 12/08/20013 1UA SUS 08/07/2001 12/18/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20023 1ND SUS 08/07/2001 12/18/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20023 1UA SUS 08/07/2001 12/18/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20022 1ND SUS 08/13/2001 12/28/2001 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20025 1UA SUS 08/20/2001 01/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 07/13/20025 1UA SUS 08/20/2001 01/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 07/13/20021 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/21/2001 06/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.7 1ND SUS 08/23/2001 05/23/2002 UNSPECIFIED DISCIPLINARY ACTION. 07/13/20027 1ND SUS 08/23/2001 05/23/2002 UNSPECIFIED DISCIPLINARY ACTION. 07/13/20021 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR

TWO YEARS.02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1UA SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1UA SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/27/2001 04/30/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION. 15 DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

02/06/2003

1 1ND SUS 09/14/2001 03/22/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20031 1ND SUS 09/14/2001 03/22/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20031 1CRD SUS 09/17/2001 05/23/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION.A NINETY-DAY SUSPENSION

W/FORTY-FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.04/08/2003

1 1UA SUS 09/17/2001 05/23/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION.A NINETY-DAY SUSPENSION W/FORTY-FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

04/08/2003

1 1UA SUS 09/17/2001 05/23/2002 MORE THAN 10 DAYS SUSPENSION.A NINETY-DAY SUSPENSION W/FORTY-FIVE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR TWO YEARS.

04/08/2003

1 1UA SUS 09/19/2001 02/28/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 05/02/20021 1D SUS 09/25/2001 05/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/25/20021 1CRD SUS 09/25/2001 02/28/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 05/09/20021 1CRD SUS 09/25/2001 12/11/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/19/20021 1D SUS 09/25/2001 12/11/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 03/19/20022 1ND SUS 10/16/2001 11/30/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20022 1ND SUS 10/16/2001 11/30/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20023 1ND SUS 10/23/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/18/20023 1CRD SUS 10/23/2001 12/31/2001 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/18/20022 1UF SUS 10/30/2001 07/31/2002 10 DAYS SUSPENSION, 04/27/20043 1D SUS 11/01/2001 10/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 12/30/20023 1CRD SUS 11/01/2001 10/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 12/30/20021 1ND SUS 11/05/2001 03/22/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 05/10/20021 1UA SUS 11/05/2001 12/14/2001 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/13/20022 1UA SUS 11/14/2001 04/30/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/13/20024 1ND SUS 12/06/2001 04/30/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 12/10/2001 11/27/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.9 1CRD SUS 12/18/2001 02/11/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/07/20029 1CRD SUS 12/18/2001 01/28/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 06/01/20029 1ND SUS 12/18/2001 01/28/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 06/01/20021 1UA SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 05/17/20021 1UA SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/02/20021 1UA SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/02/20021 1ND SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/02/20021 1ND SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/02/20021 1UA SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/02/20021 1UA SUS 12/18/2001 04/22/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/02/20024 1ND SUS 12/18/2001 07/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20034 1ND SUS 12/18/2001 07/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20032 1CRD SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1RS SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 12/27/2001 10/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 01/03/2002 02/28/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/14/20021 1UA SUS 01/03/2002 02/28/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/14/20021 1CRD SUS 01/03/2002 02/28/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 05/14/20022 1D SUS 01/03/2002 11/27/2002 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE. 02/11/20039 1ND SUS 01/04/2002 07/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 08/09/20042 1CRD SUS 01/07/2002 10/21/2002 UNFOUNDED 02/11/20033 1D SUS 01/10/2002 09/30/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/16/20033 1CRD SUS 01/10/2002 09/30/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/16/20033 1ND SUS 01/10/2002 09/30/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/16/20033 1ND SUS 01/10/2002 09/30/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/16/20039 1ND SUS 01/14/2002 02/12/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 06/01/20029 1ND SUS 01/14/2002 02/12/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 06/01/20024 1CRD SUS 01/14/2002 07/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 04/30/2003

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

4 1D SUS 01/15/2002 03/25/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/17/20034 1CRD SUS 01/15/2002 03/25/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/17/20034 1CRD SUS 01/15/2002 03/25/2002 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.09/08/2004

4 1CRD SUS 01/15/2002 03/25/2002 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

09/08/2004

4 1D SUS 01/15/2002 03/25/2002 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

09/08/2004

2 1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1RS SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

1ND SUS 01/22/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 08/20/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20021 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 08/20/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20021 1ND SUS 01/22/2002 08/20/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20022 1ND SUS 01/23/2002 04/29/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 07/13/20022 1ND SUS 01/28/2002 08/30/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/03/20032 1ND SUS 01/31/2002 06/28/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/11/20022 1ND SUS 01/31/2002 06/28/2002 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/11/20021 1CRD SUS 02/06/2002 10/29/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/03/20031 1CRD SUS 02/06/2002 10/29/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/03/20032 1ND SUS 02/08/2002 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/31/20032 1CRD SUS 02/08/2002 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/31/20032 1ND SUS 02/08/2002 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/03/20032 1CRD SUS 02/08/2002 04/26/2002 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/03/20034 1ND SUS 02/14/2002 11/11/2002 UNFOUNDED 02/11/20033 1ND SUS 02/19/2002 12/23/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1ND SUS 02/19/2002 12/23/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 06/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 06/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 06/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 06/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 06/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 06/28/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20037 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 09/24/2002 UNFOUNDED 01/17/20037 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 09/24/2002 UNFOUNDED 01/17/20037 1ND SUS 02/20/2002 09/24/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 01/17/20036 1CRD SUS 02/20/2002 08/30/2002 UNFOUNDED 03/02/20046 1CRD SUS 02/20/2002 08/30/2002 UNFOUNDED 03/02/20046 1UA SUS 02/20/2002 08/30/2002 UNFOUNDED 03/02/2004

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 03/01/2002 02/20/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 11/21/20032 1UA SUS 03/05/2002 05/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 03/05/2002 05/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20032 1UA SUS 03/05/2002 05/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 12/04/20031 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 08/30/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20031 1UF SUS 03/05/2002 08/30/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 03/04/20031 1UA SUS 03/05/2002 08/30/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 03/04/20031 1CRD SUS 03/05/2002 08/30/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20031 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 12/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/14/20031 1SS SUS 03/05/2002 12/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/14/20032 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 02/11/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 02/11/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 02/11/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 02/11/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 03/05/2002 02/11/2003 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.09/08/2004

2 1UA SUS 03/05/2002 06/07/2002 COUNSELING. 11/22/20022 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 06/07/2002 COUNSELING. 11/22/20023 1D SUS 03/05/2002 10/28/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/11/20031 1UA SUS 03/05/2002 07/15/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/14/20031 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 07/15/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/14/20031 1CRD SUS 03/05/2002 07/15/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/14/20031 1ND SUS 03/05/2002 07/15/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 06/14/20031 1ND SUS 03/06/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 01/18/20031 1ND SUS 03/06/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 01/18/20031 1ND SUS 03/06/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 01/18/20031 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20041 1ND SUS 03/08/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/26/20042 1ND SUS 03/13/2002 08/28/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20032 1ND SUS 03/13/2002 08/28/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20031 1ND SUS 03/18/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 03/18/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.4 1UA SUS 03/20/2002 06/27/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/24/20034 1UA SUS 03/20/2002 06/27/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/24/20034 1CRD SUS 03/20/2002 06/27/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/24/2003

1ND SUS 03/27/2002 02/05/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1ND SUS 03/27/2002 02/05/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 06/17/2003

2 1ND SUS 04/01/2002 06/19/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/12/20032 1ND SUS 04/01/2002 06/19/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 07/12/20032 1ND SUS 04/03/2002 09/30/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/28/20032 1ND SUS 04/03/2002 09/30/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/28/20032 1D SUS 04/03/2002 12/31/2002 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE. 02/11/20032 1UA SUS 04/03/2002 12/31/2002 UNFOUNDED 02/11/20032 1D SUS 04/03/2002 12/31/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 04/04/2002 12/23/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 04/04/20031 1CRD SUS 04/08/2002 12/20/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/11/20031 1ND SUS 04/09/2002 07/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 12/10/20023 1CRD SUS 04/09/2002 07/24/2002 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE. 10/31/20023 1D SUS 04/09/2002 07/24/2002 INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE. 10/31/20022 1CRD SUS 04/29/2002 06/28/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 04/30/20032 1D SUS 04/29/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20033 1ND SUS 04/29/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/2003

1CRD SUS 05/06/2002 10/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/03/20031ND SUS 05/06/2002 10/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/03/2003

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1ND SUS 05/06/2002 10/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/03/20032 1ND SUS 05/13/2002 04/16/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 05/13/2002 04/16/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 05/13/2002 04/16/2003 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 01/09/20042 1ND SUS 05/15/2002 10/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/03/20031 1ND SUS 05/16/2002 12/31/2002 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 04/04/20032 1ND SUS 05/24/2002 12/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20032 1ND SUS 05/24/2002 12/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20032 1ND SUS 05/24/2002 12/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20032 1ND SUS 05/24/2002 07/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 04/28/20032 1ND SUS 05/24/2002 07/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 04/28/20032 1ND SUS 05/24/2002 07/31/2002 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION. 04/28/20032 1UA SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1UA SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1UA SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1UA SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1RS SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1D SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1UA SUS 06/04/2002 09/26/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED AT CHIEF'S HEARING. 05/11/20042 1ND SUS 06/05/2002 10/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/03/20032 1D SUS 06/13/2002 09/27/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 06/13/2002 09/27/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 06/19/2002 08/28/2002 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 06/21/2002 09/30/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20031 1ND SUS 06/21/2002 11/21/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 03/03/20031 1ND SUS 06/21/2002 11/21/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/03/20036 1UA SUS 06/27/2002 12/20/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/18/20031 1ND SUS 07/01/2002 10/23/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20031 1ND SUS 07/01/2002 10/23/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20031 1ND SUS 07/01/2002 10/23/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/04/20032 1ND SUS 07/15/2002 12/31/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 12/29/20031 1CRD SUS 07/15/2002 02/28/2003 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 02/04/20041 1CRD SUS 07/15/2002 02/28/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 07/15/2002 12/23/20021 1CRD SUS 07/15/2002 12/23/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20031 1CRD SUS 07/15/2002 12/23/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20033 1ND SUS 07/15/2002 10/31/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/11/20033 1D SUS 07/15/2002 10/31/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/11/20032 1ND SUS 07/23/2002 02/27/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/02/20032 1ND SUS 07/23/2002 02/27/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/02/20032 1ND SUS 07/23/2002 02/27/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION. 09/02/20032 1ND SUS 07/23/2002 02/27/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 09/02/20032 1UF SUS 07/29/2002 01/24/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UF SUS 07/29/2002 01/24/2003 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN

ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.09/08/2004

3 1ND SUS 08/05/2002 02/26/2003 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

09/08/2004

3 1UA SUS 08/05/2002 02/26/2003 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

09/08/2004

3 1UA SUS 08/05/2002 02/26/2003 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

09/08/2004

3 1D SUS 08/05/2002 02/26/2003 10 DAYS SUSPENSION,SEVEN DAYS SERVED, THREE DAYS HELD IN ABEYANCE FOR THREE YEARS.

09/08/2004

1UA SUS 08/05/2002 03/26/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 06/27/20031UA SUS 08/05/2002 03/26/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 06/27/20031ND SUS 08/05/2002 03/26/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 06/27/20031UA SUS 08/05/2002 03/26/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 06/27/20031UA SUS 08/05/2002 03/26/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 06/27/20031UA SUS 08/05/2002 03/26/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 06/27/2003

1 1ND SUS 08/05/2002 10/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20031 1CRD SUS 08/09/2002 03/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 08/14/2002 05/31/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 08/26/20031 1ND SUS 08/14/2002 05/31/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 08/26/20031 1UA SUS 08/20/2002 02/28/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 06/16/20032 1ND SUS 08/28/2002 08/31/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 09/13/20041 1CRD SUS 08/28/2002 06/19/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NO FURTHER ACTION BY DEPARTMENT. 07/20/20041 1ND SUS 09/03/2002 03/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 09/03/2002 03/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 09/03/2002 08/31/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/15/20032 1ND SUS 09/03/2002 08/31/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/15/20032 1ND SUS 09/04/2002 07/31/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 09/04/2002 07/31/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 09/17/2002 10/31/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/11/20032 1UA SUS 09/17/2002 03/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 09/17/2002 03/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 09/17/2002 03/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 09/17/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20031 1ND SUS 09/17/2002 11/27/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20033 1UA SUS 09/17/2002 12/23/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/18/20033 1UA SUS 09/17/2002 12/23/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/18/20033 1UA SUS 09/17/2002 12/23/2002 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 02/18/20031 1UA SUS 09/19/2002 02/28/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 08/20/20031 1UA SUS 09/19/2002 02/28/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 08/20/20032 1ND SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1CRD SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1CRD SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1CRD SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 09/20/2002 06/19/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 09/23/2002 12/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20033 1ND SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1ND SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UF SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 09/27/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

1UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION. 03/08/20041UA SUS 10/03/2002 02/10/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/08/20041D SUS 10/15/2002 06/30/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 11/22/2003

2 1UF SUS 10/18/2002 01/23/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 10/18/2002 01/23/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 10/18/2002 01/23/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 06/12/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 06/12/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 12/30/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20031 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 12/30/2002 ADMONISHMENT. 03/10/20035 1UF SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.5 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

5 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1UA SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.5 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.5 1ND SUS 10/21/2002 08/26/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 10/24/2002 09/25/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 10/24/2002 09/25/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 10/24/2002 09/25/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 11/18/2002 08/31/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 11/22/20031 1CRD SUS 11/18/2002 05/23/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 09/30/20032 1UF SUS 11/18/2002 02/28/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 11/18/2002 02/28/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1D SUS 11/18/2002 02/28/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 11/20/2002 12/31/2002 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/10/20031 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/20041 1CRD SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/20041 1CRD SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/20041 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/20041 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1CRD SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/20041 1CRD SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/25/2002 07/14/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1D SUS 11/26/2002 03/20/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 11/27/2002 06/29/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 11/27/2002 06/29/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 11/27/2002 06/29/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 11/27/2002 06/29/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 11/27/2002 06/29/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20032 1ND SUS 11/27/2002 06/29/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 12/30/20031 1CRD SUS 12/02/2002 09/30/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 12/02/2002 07/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING. 10/28/20031 1UF SUS 12/02/2002 10/16/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.1 1CRD SUS 12/02/2002 10/16/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1D SUS 12/02/2002 10/16/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.7 1ND SUS 12/09/2002 11/24/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.7 1ND SUS 12/09/2002 11/24/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 12/13/2002 05/03/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 09/30/20035 1ND SUS 12/18/2002 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1UA SUS 12/18/2002 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1ND SUS 12/18/2002 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1UF SUS 12/18/2002 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1UF SUS 12/18/2002 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.

1CRD SUS 12/18/2002 07/22/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 11/25/20032 1UA SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1CRD SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1ND SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1CRD SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.2 1UA SUS 12/23/2002 09/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.3 1CRD SUS 12/23/2002 03/31/2003 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 07/10/2003

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

2 1D SUS 01/03/2003 12/31/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 01/27/20042 1ND SUS 01/09/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/09/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/09/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UA SUS 01/13/2003 03/31/2003 1 DAY SUSPENSION. 06/15/20041 1UA SUS 01/13/2003 03/31/2003 1 DAY SUSPENSION. 06/15/20041 1CRD SUS 01/13/2003 03/31/2003 1 DAY SUSPENSION. 06/15/20041 1CRD SUS 01/13/2003 06/29/2003 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 02/23/2004

1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

2 1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 01/14/2003 10/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 01/21/2003 12/31/2003 NO FURTHER ACTION, OFFICER RETIRED. 03/26/20042 1UA SUS 01/21/2003 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 01/21/2003 11/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 01/22/2003 08/19/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

1ND SUS 01/27/2003 10/31/2003 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 02/07/20042 1UF SUS 01/28/2003 07/22/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 03/08/20041 1ND SUS 02/03/2003 11/30/2003 COUNSELING. 03/08/20045 1ND SUS 02/10/2003 01/22/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 03/01/20042 1RS SUS 02/10/2003 10/31/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 04/28/20043 1ND SUS 02/19/2003 09/30/2003 COUNSELING. 12/30/20031 1UA SUS 02/20/2003 08/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 02/20/2003 08/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UF SUS 02/20/2003 08/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 02/20/2003 08/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UA SUS 02/20/2003 08/22/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 02/24/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 02/24/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 02/26/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 02/26/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 02/26/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 02/26/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 02/26/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 02/26/2003 12/17/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 03/11/2003 08/18/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 03/11/2003 08/18/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 03/13/2003 07/23/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1CRD SUS 03/18/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING. 03/15/2004

1CRD SUS 03/21/2003 09/30/2003 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 12/17/20035 1UA SUS 03/24/2003 04/30/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/18/20045 1UA SUS 03/24/2003 04/30/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/18/20041 1UF SUS 03/31/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 03/31/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 03/31/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.

1ND SUS 03/31/2003 02/04/2004 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 03/16/20041ND SUS 03/31/2003 02/04/2004 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/16/2004

1 1ND SUS 04/04/2003 07/23/2003 RETRAINING. 09/30/20031 1UA SUS 04/04/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1UA SUS 04/04/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 04/10/2003 07/31/2003 COUNSELING. 06/30/20041 1ND SUS 04/10/2003 07/31/2003 COUNSELING. 06/30/20043 1ND SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1CRD SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1D SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

3 1ND SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1CRD SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1D SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UF SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UA SUS 04/15/2003 09/30/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 04/21/2003 09/30/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 02/24/20047 1ND SUS 04/28/2003 09/30/2003 POLICY FAILURE BY DEPARTMENT. 04/06/20043 1ND SUS 04/29/2003 12/31/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 04/28/2004

1UF SUS 05/06/2003 04/30/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/05/20041CRD SUS 05/06/2003 04/30/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/05/2004

2 1CRD SUS 05/06/2003 04/30/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/05/20042 1UF SUS 05/06/2003 04/30/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/05/2004

1SS SUS 05/07/2003 07/22/2003 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 11/22/20031ND SUS 05/13/2003 02/05/2004 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 04/28/20041ND SUS 05/13/2003 02/05/2004 ADMONISHMENT AND RETRAINING. 04/28/2004

1 1SS SUS 05/19/2003 05/18/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/26/20041 1ND SUS 05/19/2003 05/18/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 05/26/20041 1UF SUS 05/27/2003 01/29/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UF SUS 05/27/2003 04/10/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.9 1CRD SUS 05/27/2003 11/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.9 1ND SUS 05/27/2003 11/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.9 1CRD SUS 05/27/2003 11/30/2003 CHARGES FILED W/ POLICE COMMISSION.4 1ND SUS 05/27/2003 06/30/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 05/29/2003 12/31/2003 RETRAINING. 06/28/20042 1ND SUS 05/29/2003 12/31/2003 RETRAINING. 06/28/20042 1ND SUS 05/29/2003 12/31/2003 RETRAINING. 06/28/20042 1ND SUS 05/29/2003 12/31/2003 RETRAINING. 06/28/20042 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 05/23/2003 03/05/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 06/02/2003 12/17/2003 COUNSELING. 03/22/20045 1UA SUS 06/03/2003 01/22/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.5 1UA SUS 06/03/2003 01/22/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1ND SUS 06/13/2003 03/15/2004 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 06/30/2004

1CRD SUS 06/17/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1ND SUS 06/17/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1ND SUS 06/17/2003 01/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.

2 1CRD SUS 06/24/2003 09/15/2004 NO FURTHER ACTION, STATUTE LIMIT GCS3304. 10/04/20041ND SUS 06/27/2003 03/08/2004 ADMONISHMENT. 03/01/2004

1 1ND SUS 07/01/2003 12/31/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/28/20041 1ND SUS 07/01/2003 12/31/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/28/20041 1ND SUS 07/01/2003 12/31/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/28/20041 1ND SUS 07/01/2003 12/31/20031 1ND SUS 07/01/2003 12/31/2003 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 07/01/2003 12/31/2003 SUSTAINED BY OCC. NOT SUSTAINED BY DEPARTMENT. 06/28/20041 1CRD SUS 07/11/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 07/15/2003 05/29/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 07/15/2003 05/29/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 07/15/2003 05/29/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 07/15/2003 05/29/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

1 1ND SUS 07/15/2003 05/29/20043 1ND SUS 07/16/2003 09/21/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 07/16/2003 09/21/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 07/16/2003 09/21/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 07/16/2003 01/20/2004 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/08/20041 1ND SUS 07/17/2003 01/30/2004 SUSTAINED BY OCC. PROPER CONDUCT BY DEPARTMENT. 07/21/20041 1RS SUS 07/28/2003 01/22/2004 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/22/20041 1UA SUS 07/28/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 07/28/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 07/28/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 07/28/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 08/06/2003 04/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1D SUS 08/06/2003 04/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 08/12/2003 12/31/2003 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 03/22/20043 1D SUS 08/12/2003 03/05/2004 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/28/20043 1UA SUS 08/12/2003 03/05/2004 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/28/20043 1UA SUS 08/12/2003 03/05/2004 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 06/28/20042 1UA SUS 08/19/2003 12/31/2003 ADMONISHMENT. 03/22/20041 1ND SUS 08/19/2003 02/09/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 08/19/2003 02/09/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 08/20/2003 05/25/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1UA SUS 08/26/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 08/26/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 08/26/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 08/26/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/27/2003 06/25/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 08/27/2003 06/25/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/27/2003 06/25/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1UA SUS 08/27/2003 06/25/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 08/28/2003 05/01/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 08/28/2003 05/01/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UA SUS 08/28/2003 05/10/2004 WRITTEN REPRIMAND. 09/14/20041 1ND SUS 08/28/2003 02/09/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.4 1ND SUS 09/08/2003 12/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.4 1ND SUS 09/08/2003 12/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.4 1CRD SUS 09/08/2003 12/31/2003 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 09/16/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1UA SUS 09/16/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1CRD SUS 09/16/2003 09/15/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 10/03/2003 04/19/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.3 1ND SUS 10/03/2003 04/19/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 10/10/2003 08/31/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.7 1UA SUS 10/14/2003 03/31/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.7 1CRD SUS 10/14/2003 03/31/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.4 1ND SUS 10/17/2003 08/02/2004 COUNSELING AND RETRAINING. 09/29/20045 1UA SUS 10/17/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.5 1ND SUS 10/17/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.5 1CRD SUS 10/17/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 10/17/2003 05/10/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.

1ND SUS 11/14/2003 09/23/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UA SUS 11/17/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UA SUS 11/17/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UA SUS 11/17/2003 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1ND SUS 11/20/2003 08/31/20041 1ND SUS 11/20/2003 08/31/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.1 1CRD SUS 11/20/2003 08/31/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.7 1UA SUS 11/21/2003 08/06/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.7 1UA SUS 11/21/2003 08/06/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.7 1UA SUS 11/21/2003 08/06/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 11/26/2003 07/28/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.

Sustained Case List Report

Eth Alleg Find Received Closed SFPD Action Adjudicated

SUSTAINED CASE LIST THE POLICE COMMISSIONOFFICE OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTSCITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO09/30/200410/01/1998 -

2 1UA SUS 11/26/2003 07/28/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1ND SUS 12/17/2003 09/15/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 12/29/2003 06/24/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING. 07/29/20041 1ND SUS 02/23/2004 07/28/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.1 1ND SUS 02/23/2004 07/28/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING.2 1CRD SUS 02/24/2004 07/09/2004 PENDING CHIEF'S HEARING. 08/18/20043 1D SUS 03/11/2004 07/30/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1UF SUS 03/15/2004 09/13/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.3 1ND SUS 03/15/2004 09/13/20043 1ND SUS 03/15/2004 09/13/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.2 1UA SUS 04/09/2004 09/21/2004 PENDING AT MGMT CONTROL DIVISION.

Sustained Case List Report