the institutional fragmentation of global environmental...
TRANSCRIPT
LUND UNIVERSITY
PO Box 117221 00 Lund+46 46-222 00 00
The Institutional Fragmentation of Global Environmental Governance
Zelli, Fariborz; van, Harro
2013
Document Version:Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record
Link to publication
Citation for published version (APA):Zelli, F., & van, H. (Eds.) (2013). The Institutional Fragmentation of Global Environmental Governance. (GlobalEnvironmental Politics - Special Issue; Vol. 13). MIT Press.
Total number of authors:2
General rightsUnless other specific re-use rights are stated the following general rights apply:Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authorsand/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by thelegal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private studyor research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal
Read more about Creative commons licenses: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/Take down policyIf you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will removeaccess to the work immediately and investigate your claim.
GlobalEnvironmental
PoliticsIntroduction
The Institutional Fragmentation of Global Environmental Governance:Causes, Consequences, and Responses
Fariborz Zelli and Harro van Asselt
Research Articles
Fragmentation in Global Energy Governance: Explaining the Creation of IRENAThijs Van de Graaf
Multi-Forum Non-State Actors: Navigating the Regime Complexes for Forestry andGenetic Resources
Amandine Orsini
Legitimacy in an Era of Fragmentation: The Case of Global Climate GovernanceSylvia I. Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen and Jeffrey McGee
Fragmented International Governance of Arctic Offshore Oil:Governance Challenges and Institutional Improvement
Christoph Humrich
Managing Institutional Complexity and Fragmentation: The Nagoya Protocol andthe Global Governance of Genetic Resources
Sebastian Oberthür and Justyna Poz.arowska
Commentary
On Fragmentation, Differentiation, and CoordinationMichael Zürn and Benjamin Faude
Book Review Essays
Complex Landscapes and Oil Curse ResearchKen Conca
Assessing Carbon Policy ExperimentsAnita Engels
August 2013
Volume 13 • Number 3
Global Environmental Politics• Editors
Kate O’Neill, University of California at Berkeley, USStacy D. VanDeveer, University of New Hampshire, US
• Associate EditorsAarti Gupta, Wageningen University, The NetherlandsRon Mitchell, University of Oregon, USPeter Newell, University of Sussex, UKErika Weinthal, Duke University, US
• Book Review EditorElizabeth R. DeSombre, Wellesley College, US
• Managing EditorSusan Altman, US
• Editorial BoardLiliana Andonova, Grad. Inst. of Int’l & Devel. Studies,
SwitzerlandSteinar Andresen, Fridtjof Nansen Institute, NorwayGraeme Auld, Carleton University, CanadaJörg Balsiger, University of Geneva, SwitzerlandJ. Samuel Barkin, University of Massachusetts Boston, USJon Barnett, University of Melbourne, AustraliaSteven Bernstein, University of Toronto, CanadaMichele Betsill, Colorado State University, USFrank Biermann, Vrije Universiteit, The NetherlandsHarriet Bulkeley, Durham University, UKPamela Chasek, Int’l Inst. for Sustainable Devel., USJennifer Clapp, University of Waterloo, CanadaKen Conca, American University, USSimon Dalby, Wilfrid Laurier University, CanadaJoanna Depledge, University of Cambridge, UKNavroz K. Dubash, Ctr. for Policy Research, IndiaRobyn Eckersley, University of Melbourne, AustraliaCharlotte Epstein, University of Sydney, AustraliaRobert Falkner, London School of Economics & Pol. Sci., UKMatthias Finger, Swiss Federal Inst. of Tech., SwitzerlandTim Forsyth, London School of Economics & Pol. Sci., UKLars Gulbrandsen, Fridtjof Nansen Institute, NorwayPeter M. Haas, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USPaul G. Harris, Hong Kong Institute of Education, ChinaKathryn Hochstetler, University of Waterloo, CanadaMatt Hoffmann, University of Toronto, CanadaMaria Ivanova, University of Massachusetts Boston, USSikina Jinnah, American University, USTaedong Lee, Yonsei University, Republic of KoreaRonnie Lipschutz, University of California, Santa Cruz, USEva Lovbrand, Linköping University, SwedenChris Marcoux, DePauw University, USSebastian Oberthür, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, BelgiumChukwumerije Okereke, University of Reading, UKRaul Pacheco-Vega, CIDE, MexicoMatthew Paterson, University of Ottawa, CanadaAseem Prakash, University of Washington, Seattle, USThomas Princen, University of Michigan, USSimone Pulver, University of California, Santa Barbara, USIan Rowlands, University of Waterloo, CanadaMiranda Schreurs, Freie Universität Berlin, GermanyHeike Schroeder, University of East Anglia, UKJeannie Sowers, University of New Hampshire, USDetlef Sprinz, Potsdam Inst. for Climate Impact Res.,
GermanyPaul Steinberg, Harvey Mudd College, USJohannes Stripple, Lund University, SwedenArild Underdal, University of Oslo, NorwayPaul Wapner, American University, USHugh Ward, Essex University, UKD.G. Webster, Dartmouth College, USMarc Williams, University of New South Wales, AustraliaFengshi Wu, Chinese University of Hong Kong, ChinaOran Young, University of California Santa Barbara, US
• Founding EditorPeter Dauvergne, University of British Columbia, Canada
Global Environmental Politics volume 13 number 3,August 2013.Global Environmental Politics (ISSN 1526-3800; E-ISSN1536-0091) is published quarterly (February, May, Au-gust, November) by the MIT Press, 55 Hayward St.,Cambridge, Massachusetts 02142-1315. Subscriptionsand address changes should be addressed to MIT Press,Journals Customer Service, 55 Hayward St., Cambridge,MA 02142-1315; phone: (617) 253-2889 US/Canada(800) 207-8354; fax: (617) 577-1545. An electronic,full-text version of Global Environmental Politics is avail-able from the MIT Press.
Subscription rates: Electronic only—Individuals $55.00,Students/retired $25.00, Institutions $230.00. Canadi-ans add 5% GST. Print and Electronic—Individuals$62.00, Students/retired $29.00, Institutions $268.00.Canadians add 5% GST. Outside the U.S. and Canadaadd $23.00 for postage and handling. Single issues: In-dividuals $15.00, Institutions $67.00. Outside the U.S.and Canada add $6.00 per issue for postage and han-dling. Canadians add 5% GST. Claims for missing is-sues will be honored free of charge if made within threemonths of the publication date of the issue. Claims maybe submitted to: [email protected]. Prices subject tochange without notice.
Postmaster: Send address changes to Global Environ-mental Politics, 55 Hayward St., Cambridge, MA 02142-1315. Periodicals postage paid at Boston, MA and at ad-ditional post ofªces.
For advertising and mailing list information, contactthe Marketing Department, MIT Press Journals,55 Hayward St., Cambridge, MA 02142-1315; phone:(617) 253-2866; fax: (617) 253-1709; e-mail: [email protected].
Permission to photocopy articles for internal or per-sonal use, or the internal or personal use of speciªc cli-ents, is granted by the copyright owner for users regis-tered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC)Transactional Reporting Service, provided that the per-copy fee of $12 per article is paid directly to the CCC,222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. The fee codefor users of the Transactional Reporting Service is ISSN1526-3800/13 $12. Submit all other inquiries to theSubsidiary Rights Manager, MIT Press Journals, 55 Hay-ward St., Cambridge, MA 02142-1315; fax: (617) 253-1709; web: www.mitpressjournals.org/page/copyright_permission.
Global Environmental Politics is abstracted and/or in-dexed by the following: BioBase, CSA Worldwide PoliticalScience Abstracts, Current Contents: Social and BehavioralSciences, Dietrich’s Index Philosophicus, GeoBase, EmBase,Environment Index, Environmental Sciences and PollutionMgmt, International Political Science Abstracts, Journal ofEconomic Literature, Lexis Nexis, PAIS, International UrbanStudies Abstracts, Scopus, Social Science Citation Index, andWorld Affairs Online. For a complete list of abstractingindexing information, see the journal’s homepage.
Global Environmental Politics is associated with thefollowing: Environmental Studies Section (ESS) of theInternational Studies Association.
http://www.mitpressjournals.org/gep
© 2013 by Massachusetts Institute of Technology
ISSN 1526-3800
Notes for Contributors1. Global Environmental Politics invites submissions on contemporary international and
comparative environmental politics. The journal gives particular attention to theimplications of local-global interactions for environmental management, as well asthe implications of environmental change for world politics. It covers issues such asthe role of states, multilateral institutions and agreements, globalization, trade,consumption patterns, international ªnance, corporations, poverty and inequality,nongovernmental organizations, science and technology, and grassroots move-ments. It also covers particular environmental problems that span two or morecountries, such as climate change, ozone depletion, deforestation, biodiversity, de-sertiªcation, transboundary pollution, waste management, oceans and ªsheries,and endangered species. While articles must focus on contemporary political andpolicy issues, authors and readers will presumably have a range of disciplinary back-grounds, including political science, international relations, sociology, history, hu-man geography, science and technology studies, environmental ethics, law, eco-nomics, and environmental science.
2. The journal is divided into Research Articles and a Forum section. Research Articlesare full-length papers (maximum 8000 words, including footnotes and references)that contain an original contribution to research on global environmental politics.Forum articles comprise short commentaries (2000–3000 words maximum, includ-ing footnotes and references) that should stimulate discussion on salient issues ofinterest to other scholars in the ªeld. The aim of these articles is to provoke thought,discussion, and debate amongst the readership.
3. All articles are refereed. For Research Articles, which go through a rigorous blind re-view process, authors must not explicitly or implicitly reveal their identity on anypage except the title page.
4. All articles must be original. Global Environmental Politics does not review articles al-ready published elsewhere or currently under review by another publisher.
5. Manuscripts should be submitted as a Word document (.doc or .docx) and shouldinclude an abstract of no more than 150 words.
6. For details about GEP style requirements, see the website: http://www.mitpressjournals.org/gep
7. Research and Forum articles should be submitted to our online system, Scholastica:https://scholasticahq.com/login. If you prefer, it may be emailed to: [email protected]. Only if needed, mail can be sent to: Dept. of Political Science, HortonSSC, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH 03824, USA. For matters relatedto book reviews, please contact: Elizabeth DeSombre, Book Review Editor, GlobalEnvironmental Politics, Environmental Studies Program, Wellesley College, 106 Cen-tral Street, Wellesley, MA 02481, USA, [email protected].
Glo
ba
lE
nviro
nm
en
talP
olitic
sVolum
e13,N
umber
3August
2013
iii Contributors
vi Abstracts
Introduction
1 The Institutional Fragmentation of Global Environmental Governance:Causes, Consequences, and ResponsesFariborz Zelli and Harro van Asselt
Research Articles
14 Fragmentation in Global Energy Governance: Explaining the Creationof IRENAThijs Van de Graaf
34 Multi-Forum Non-State Actors: Navigating the Regime Complexes forForestry and Genetic ResourcesAmandine Orsini
56 Legitimacy in an Era of Fragmentation: The Case of GlobalClimate GovernanceSylvia I. Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen and Jeffrey McGee
79 Fragmented International Governance of Arctic Offshore Oil:Governance Challenges and Institutional ImprovementChristoph Humrich
Contents Contents
GlobalEnvironmental
PoliticsVolume 13, Number 3 August 2013
100 Managing Institutional Complexity and Fragmentation: The NagoyaProtocol and the Global Governance of Genetic ResourcesSebastian Oberthür and Justyna Pozarowska
Commentary
119 On Fragmentation, Differentiation, and CoordinationMichael Zürn and Benjamin Faude
Book Review Essays
131 Complex Landscapes and Oil Curse ResearchKen Conca
138 Assessing Carbon Policy ExperimentsAnita Engels
Book Reviews
144 Steinberg, Paul F., and Stacy D. VanDeveer, eds. 2012. ComparativeEnvironmental Politics: Theory, Practice, and Prospects. Cambridge, MA:The MIT Press.Reviewed by Robert V. Bartlett
146 Pamela S. Chasek and Lynn M. Wagner, eds. 2012. The Roads from Rio:Lessons Learned from Twenty Years of Multilateral EnvironmentalNegotiations. New York and London: Routledge.Reviewed by Mark Axelrod
148 Preston, Christopher, ed. 2012. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics ofSolar Radiation Management. Plymouth: Lexington Books.Reviewed by Jonathan Symons
ii • Contents