the holy grail or the alchemists’ stone? - oecd · the holy grail was a well-described object,...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
111111
International rankings of universitiesThe Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone?
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Wissenschaftszentrum, Bonn, 4 December 2006
Andreas SchleicherHead, Indicators and Analysis Division
OECD Directorate for Education
![Page 2: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
222222In the dark all universities the same…
But with a little light….
![Page 3: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
333333
But with a little light….…important differences become apparent….
In the dark all universities look the same…
![Page 4: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
444444
0
10
20
30
Uni
ted
Stat
es
Net
herl
ands
Den
mar
k
Nor
way
Cana
da
Swed
en
Icel
and
Aus
tral
ia
Swit
zerl
and
Uni
ted
King
dom
Finl
and
Germ
any
Japa
n1
Fran
ce
Irel
and
Spai
n
New
Zea
land
Luxe
mbo
urg
Slov
ak R
epub
lic
Kore
a
Gree
ce
Belg
ium
Mex
ico
Aus
tria
OEC
D a
vera
ge
EU19
ave
rage
1940-49 1950-59 1960-69 1970-79
Growth in university-level qualificationsApproximated by the percentage of persons with ISCED 5A/6 qualfication
born in the period shown below (2004)
12
22
3
20
A1.3a
+2.9+3.5+3.7
![Page 5: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
555555 Shifts in countries’ market share of the highly qualifiedNumber of 35-64-year-olds with tertiary type A qualifications
as a percentage of the OECD total
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2
United States Germany
NetherlandsDenmark
SwitzerlandSweden
Hungary Canada
Czech Republic FinlandAustriaNorway
Slovak RepublicNew Zealand
BelgiumGreece
AustraliaIreland
Portugal Italy
United KingdomPolandFranceJapan1
Turkey Spain
MexicoKorea
Lower share of OECD-wide tertiary attainment in 2014
Higher share of OECD-wide tertiaryattainment in 2014
![Page 6: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
666666 Borderless education:Where international students go
Percentage of foreign tertiary students reported to the OECD who are enrolled in each country of destination
Japan; 4%
Canada; 5%
Australia; 6%
France; 9%
Germany; 10%United Kingdom; 11%
United States; 22%
Other non-OECD; 9%
Other OECD; 6%
New Zealand; 3%
Russian Federation; 3%
South Africa; 2%Belgium; 2%
Spain; 2%Italy; 2%
Sweden; 1%Switzerland; 1%
Austria; 1%
Malaysia; 1%
C3.8
![Page 7: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
777777
Know why you are lookingKnow what you are looking forKnow how you’ll recognise it when you find itSearch systematicallyRemember that others are looking too
International rankings of universitiesThe Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’ Stone?
![Page 8: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
888888
Information feeding peer pressure and public accountability has become more powerful than legislation and regulation……and it has made international comparisons
(and some international organisations) indispensable in the field of education that was thus far conceived a largely domestic area
The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’ Stone?
Know why you are looking
![Page 9: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
999999
The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grailOur problem:
The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’ Stone?
Know what you are looking for
<O(to) (with vo), classified by C(tc), f(V (tv))>O there is world of difference in programme types and institutionsV rankings will always remain highly sensitive to the variables that we are measuring, and on many rankings you can do well by changing your inputs, without any impact on resultsvo there is no agreement on comparable properties of programmes and institutions…C …nor on taxonomies to classify them
![Page 10: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
101010101010
The Alchemists’ stone was to be recognised by transforming ordinary metal into gold
Our problem: Rankings need to reflect
– Central and enduring parts of universities that relate to quality of outcomes
– Aspects that can be improved by purposeful actionTrading off breadth and depths
– Not everything that is important needs to be dealt with withexcruciating detail
Seek rankings that are as comparable as possible…… but as specific for universities as necessary
Focus coverage as much as feasible…… but keep as large as necessary to be useful for policy formation
The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’ Stone?
Know how you will know when you find it
![Page 11: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
111111111111 The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’ Stone?
Search systematicallyThe medieval Alchemists’ followed the dictates of a well-established science but that was built on wrong foundationsThe search for the Holy Grail was overburdened by false clues and cryptic symbolsWe need to do better…
Rankings are not absolutes or bright shining objects the very possession of which produces unbounded wealthThey are defined through a process bringing together political, methodological and ethical considerationsGood rankings should reflect what is expected of students and how well those expectations are translated into achieved outcomes
… and there is only one choiceWe do the rankings well or the media will continue to do them poorly
![Page 12: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
121212121212Key questions for an exploratory phaseWhat to assess ?
Baseline transversal competencies– Easy to do, largely invariant across cultural and occupational contexts– Captures only small part of the value universities add to what is learned at
schoolsSpecialist competencies that universities provide
– Challenges comparability across programmes, institutions and countries, new territory in methodological terms
Whom to assess ?Population near end of study or after defined number of years of study
– Difficult to do because of variation in institutional structures, programme lengths and student populations served, both within and across countries
Standardised age cohort– Instruments need to capture wide range in competencies
Units to survey and units of analysis ?Comparison of system performance
– Maximises policy relevance for governments– Difficult to establish comparable samples and to incentivise institutional
participation, variation in participation rates raise questions about interpretation of system performance
Comparison of institutional performance– Maximises relevance for institutions, voluntary participation– Limits system-wide policy insights
![Page 13: The Holy Grail or the Alchemists’ stone? - OECD · The Holy Grail was a well-described object, and there was only one true grail Our problem: The Holy Grail? Or the Alchemists’](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022052009/601e8979d06d6412c8142f5e/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
131313131313
ThankThankThank youyouyou !!!
www.oecd.orgwww.pisa.oecd.org– All national and international publications– The complete micro-level database
email: [email protected]
… and remember:Without data, you are just another person with an opinion