the future of the nuclear suppliers group
TRANSCRIPT
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 1/70
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 2/70
\MA IQ\QRA JI \MA
EQ@DAKR PQVVDCARP HRJQV
NKRO MCBBP
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 3/70
© 26;; @kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a. Kdd rchmts rasarval.
a @kreahca Aeljwnaet ljas ejt tkoa cestctutcjekd pjsctcjes je pubdc` pjdc`ycssuas? tma vcaws raprasaetal mara kra tma kutmjr–s jwe kel lj ejt ea`asskrcdyrafla`t tma vcaws ji tma Aeljwnaet, cts stk st , jr cts trustaas.
Ej pkrt ji tmcs pubdc`ktcje nky ba raprjlu`al jr trkesncttal ce key ijrn jr by
key nakes wctmjut parncsscje ce wrctceh irjn tma @kreahca Aeljwnaet. Vdaksa
lcra`t cequcrcas tj7
@kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a
Vubdc`ktcjes Lapkrtnaet
;883 Nkssk`musatts Kvaeua, EX Xksmcehtje, L.@. 26609
\ad. +; 262-<=0-8966
Ikx7 +; 262-<=0-;=<6
cs pubdc`ktcje `ke ba ljwedjklal kt ej `jst
kt [email protected]/pubs.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 4/70
@jetaets
Ijrawjrl v
Punnkry ;
\ma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup7@urraet @mkddaehas ce @jetaxt 1
\ma EPH–s Dkst La`kla 8
Ppa`c` @urraet kel Iutura @mkddaehasIk`ceh tma EPH ;0
Lcs`cpdcea kel @ralcbcdcty7 \ma EPH
kel @mcek–s Eu`dakr \rkla Xctm Vkocstke ;0
\ma EPH–s Radktcjesmcp Xctm tma EV\
kel tma [uastcje ji Iutura Nanbarsmcp ;8
EPH La`cscjenkoceh 29
Ravcscje ji tma Hucladceas7 Aerc`mnaet kel Raprj`assceh 23
\ma EPH–s Raspjesa tj ke Avjdvceh Hdjbkd
Eu`dakr \rkla Rahcna 0;
\ma EPH kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa 08
\ma EPH kel Jtmar Axpjrt @jetrjd Krrkehanaets 03
\ma EPH kel tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa <0
Aeijr`anaet kel Aiia`tcvaeass <1
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 5/70
\rkespkrae`y kel Jutrak`m <8
Nudtcdktarkd Eu`dakr Iuad Kssurke`as 16
@je`duscje7 \ma EPH kt tma @rjssrjklsji ke Avjdvceh Eu`dakr \rkla Rahcna 10
Ejtas 18
Kbjut tma Kutmjr 9;
@kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a 92
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 6/70
v
Ijrawjrl
Je Nky 3 kel ;6 tmcs yakr, tma @kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a mjstal kel
`jelu`tal k wjrosmjp kt @kreahca Aurjpa maklqukrtars ce Brussads tctdal —\ma Eu`dakr
Puppdcars Hrjup kel tma Iutura ji Eu`dakr \rkla.„ @kreahca cevctal tj tmcs naatceh kdd
hjvarenaets pkrtc`cpktceh ce tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup (EPH) kel sada`tal eu`dakr
trkla pjdc`y axparts irjn k`klanck, tma Aurjpake Qecje, tma Aurjpake Vkrdcknaet kel
ektcjekd dahcsdktcva bjlcas, celustry, cetarektcjekd jrhkeczktcjes, kel ejehjvarenaetkd
jrhkeczktcjes. Kbjut 81 cevctaas pkrtc`cpktal ce tma wjrosmjp, wctm kbjut mkdi ji tmasa
irjn 06 EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets.
@kreahca jrhkeczal tma wjrosmjp kitar tma Ncecstry ji Ijrache Kiikcrs ji tma
Eatmardkels, wmc`m wks s`maludal tj kssuna tma rjtktceh `mkcrnkesmcp ji tma EPH ijr
jea yakr bahceeceh ce Guea 26;;, prjpjsal tmcs pkst Ejvanbar tmkt wa `jelu`t ke avaet
tj ij`us tma kttaetcje ji EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets kel jtmars `je`areal wctm tma
nkekhanaet ji cetarektcjekd eu`dakr trkla je cssuas tmkt ce ra`aet yakrs mkl `jna tj tma
ijra kel tmkt wjudl ba `rctc`kd tj tma EPH–s iutura wjro.
Pjna ji tma tjpc`s je tma wjrosmjp khaelk mkl kdrakly lrkwe kttaetcje irjn tma
EPH kel cts wjroceh hrjups. Jtmars, mjwavar“parmkps tma njst schec`ket djehar-tarn
cssuas“mkva ejt baae `jdda`tcvady kllrassal by tma hrjup, kel nkey EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets mkva dcoawcsa ejt systanktc`kddy axpdjral tman.
Pjna ji tma tjpc`s wa sjuhmt tj rkcsa kppakral tj as`kpa `je`artal kttaetcje by tma
EPH, ce pkrt ba`kusa cts la`cscjenkoceh kel rjutcea k`tcvctcas kra ij`usal je njra cnna-
lckta prjbdans kel ce pkrt ba`kusa tma EPH–s `jesaesus-bksal la`cscjenkoceh prj`ass
mks pravaetal sjna ctans irjn baceh put je cts khaelk. Ks wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets pjcetal
jut, ke EPH `mkcrnke cs ce ik`t lcs`jurkhal irjn haearktceh njnaetun tj kllrass
nkttars wctm k djeh trkga`tjry ba`kusa mcs tarn ljas ejt axtael tmrjuhm tma eaxt keeukdpdaekry naatceh, wmc`m cs madl jea yakr kitar ma kssunas tma rjtktceh `mkcrnkesmcp.
\ma prjga`t wks kdsj cetaelal tj `jetrcbuta tj tma pjdc`ynkoceh prj`ass ce rakd tcna.
Je tma lky kitar tma Brussads wjrosmjp, tma Ncecstry ji Ijrache Kiikcrs ji tma Eatmardkels
mjstal ke ceijrnkd sancekr ji tma EPH ce \ma Mkhua. Lurceh tmkt sancekr, sjna ji tma
elcehs ji tma @kreahca wjrosmjp wara prasaetal. Jea njetm dktar, kt tma EPH–s 26;;
pdaekry naatceh madl ce Ejjrlwcgo, tma Eatmardkels ijrnkddy kssunal tma `mkcrnkesmcp
ji tma EPH ijr jea yakr.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 7/70
vc | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Ct wks kdsj khraal tmkt @kreahca wjudl pubdcsm ke jpae rapjrt bksal je tma prj`aal-
cehs ji tma wjrosmjp ce tma cetarast ji ceijrnceh tma brjklar pjdc`y ̀ jnnuecty kbjut tma
lcs`usscje madl lurceh tma naatceh. K `jnpaelcun ji suhhastcjes kel ra`jnnaelktcjes
anarhceh irjn tma wjrosmjp cs ce`dulal ce tmcs rapjrt. \ma rapjrt, mjwavar, cs brjklar
ce s`jpa tmke tma wjrosmjp, kel ct `je`ares ctsadi wctm tma mcstjry ji tma EPH irjn cts
ce`aptcje ks wadd ks wctm avaets tmkt trkespcral kitar tma wjrosmjp wks madl. Ce wrctceh tma
rapjrt, C ce`jrpjrktal tma ra`jrl ji tma wjrosmjp lcs`usscje cetj k brjklar prasaetktcje
tmkt cetarpratal tma nktarckd kel pjcetal tj sjna haearkd ̀ je`duscjes, wmc`m kra ny jwe.
Ce jrlar tj ik`cdctkta tj tma hraktast axtaet pjsscbda ke ueae`unbaral lcs`usscje ji sae-
sctcva eu`dakr trkla pjdc`y cssuas, tma wjrosmjp wks madl uelar tma @mktmkn Mjusa Ruda,
wmc`m kdsj hjvareal mjw tma nktarckd cs prasaetal ce tmcs rapjrt. \mcs rapjrt `jvars kdd tma
tjpc`s je tma khaelk ji tma wjrosmjp. Ct raiars tj kel `ctas pkrtc`cpkets– stktanaets kel
cetarvaetcjes, but, ks khraal kt tma jutsat, tma claetctcas ji tma kutmjrs ji tma stktanaets
kel cetarvaetcjes mkva ejt baae lcs`djsal.
K ekd wjrl kbjut wmkt tmcs wjrosmjp wks kel wmkt ct wks ejt.
Ce ;338 kel ;333, tma EPH ctsadi jrhkeczal twj sancekrs je tma EPH kel cts rjda
ce axpjrt `jetrjds kel eu`dakr ejeprjdciarktcje, tma rst jea ce Ycaeek kel tma sa`jel
ce Eaw Sjro.; \masa wara jpae naatcehs kel wara cetaelal tj cestru`t k dkrha kulcae`a
kbjut wmkt tma EPH cs kel mjw ct iue`tcjes.
Eactmar @kreahca ejr tma Ncecstry ji Ijrache Kiikcrs ji tma Eatmardkels kspcral tj lj
tmcs ocel ji jutrak`m ce mjdlceh tma Brussads wjrosmjp. \ma prcna cetaetcje wks cestakl
tj lcs`uss wctm EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh stktas kel k snkdd eunbar ji eu`dakr trkla spa`ckdcsts
sjna `urraet kel iutura `mkddaehas ik`ceh tma EPH, ce tma cetarast ji tma hrjup–s iutura
aiia`tcvaeass, `jmascvaeass, kel `ralcbcdcty.
C wcsm tj tmkeo tma axparts wmj ravcawal tma lrkit taxt ji tmcs rapjrt, aspa`ckddy LnctrcyEcojejv ji tma @aetar ijr Cetarektcjekd \rkla kel Pa`urcty kt tma Qecvarscty ji Hajrhck,
wmj prjvclal nu`m ceschmt. C kdsj wcsm tj mjejr Cke Ketmjey, @mrcstar Kmdstrjn, kel
Yctkdy Ial`maeoj ji tma Ptj`omjdn Cetarektcjekd Vak`a Rasakr`m Cestctuta ijr tmacr pktm-
brakoceh rasakr`m je tma EPH.
C wcsm tj `jnnael tma Ncecstry ji Ijrache Kiikcrs ji tma Eatmardkels ijr cts prasaet
kel pkst `jnnctnaet tj trkespkrae`y ce EPH kiikcrs kel tmkeo Knbksskljr Vcat la
Odaro, tma `urraet EPH `mkcrnke, ks wadd ks mcs `jddakhuas“ce pkrtc`udkr Rkdi vke la
Baao, Gjsapmcea Irketzae, Ektmkdca Gkkrsnk, kel Maeo @jr vke lar Owkst“ijr tmacr
huclke`a kel suppjrt ce `krryceh jut tmcs prjga`t. \ma `jetaets ji tmcs rapjrt, kel tma
vcaws axprassal tmarace, mjwavar, kra ny raspjescbcdcty. \may lj ejt raprasaet key ji`ckdpjsctcje jr vcaw ji tma Eatmardkels hjvarenaet, tma EPH, jr cts `mkcr.
Nkro Mcbbs
Paecjr Kssj`ckta
Eu`dakr Vjdc`y Vrjhrkn
@kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 8/70
;
Punnkry
Kitar tma rst Celcke eu`dakr axpdjscva tast ce ;38<, savae eu`dakr suppdcar hjvarenaets
wara ̀ jevce`al tmkt tma Eu`dakr Eje-Vrjdciarktcje \rakty (EV\) kdjea wjudl ejt mkdt tma
sprakl ji eu`dakr wakpjes“k vcaw tmkt lavadjpnaets ce Crke, Crkq, Ejrtm Ojrak, kel adsa-
wmara wjudl dktar uelars`jra. \ma savae hjvarenaets ijrnal tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
(EPH), kel jvar tma `jursa ji njra tmke tmraa la`klas, ct mks ba`jna tma wjrdl–s daklceh
nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt ̀ jetrjd krrkehanaet, astkbdcsmceh hucladceas tmkt hjvare trkes-
iars ji eu`dakr-radktal nktarckds, aqucpnaet, kel ta`mejdjhy. Sat, ks k vjduetkry kel ̀ jesae-
sus-bksal jrhkeczktcje ji <9 pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, tma EPH tjlky ik`as k mjst ji ̀ mkd-
daehas rkehceh irjn quastcjes kbjut cts ̀ ralcbcdcty kel iutura nanbarsmcp tj cts radktcjesmcp
tj tma EV\ kel jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets.
Ce dchmt ji nkgjr ra`aet lavadjpnaets ce hdjbkdczal eu`dakr trkla“`jnpdax prjdciark-
tcje trkesk`tcjes kel eatwjros tmkt `cr`unvaet nudtcdktarkd trkla `jetrjds, tma ce`raksceh
rjda ijr ejestkta k`tjrs ce prj`uranaet kel prjdciarktcje, jppjrtuecstc` axpjrtceh pjdc`cas
ji suppdcar stktas, kel tma rcsa ji cetarektcjekd aqucty cssuas ce hdjbkd eu`dakr hjvareke`a
kel trkla lcpdjnk`y“nanbar stktas nust kllrass tmasa prassceh cssuas kel rak`m jut tj
eje-EPH stktas. \ma hrjup `keejt iue`tcje ce csjdktcje.
\j ae`jurkha tma EPH tj `jesclar cssuas tmkt mkva k schec`ket cnpk`t je cts iutura
`ralcbcdcty kel aiia`tcvaeass, tma @kreahca Aeljwnaet madl k wjrosmjp ce Brussads, —\ma
Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup kel tma Iutura ji Eu`dakr \rkla,„ irjn Nky 3 tj ;6, 26;;.
\ma wjrosmjp, suppjrtal by tma Ncecstry ji Ijrache Kiikcrs ji tma Eatmardkels, wmc`m
kssunal tma EPH `mkcr ce Guea, wks kttaelal by 81 axparts, ce`dulceh ji`ckds irjn 06
EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets.
Vkrtc`cpkets nkla ct ̀ dakr tmkt tma EPH nust la`cla mjw tj nkekha cts iutura radktcje-
smcp wctm stktas jutscla tma hrjup kel mjw tj laea ctsadi wctm raspa`t tj tma EV\, wmjsa;36 pkrtcas kra `jnncttal tj pravaetceh tma sprakl ji eu`dakr wakpjes, kel prjnjtceh
lcskrnknaet kel tma pak`aiud usa ji eu`dakr ta`mejdjhy. Cetarektcjekd eu`dakr `jnnar`a
cs rkpcldy avjdvceh cetj k systan ji `jnpdax trkesk`tcjes cevjdvceh lastcektcjes kel k`tjrs
tmkt uetcd ejw mkva baae lcs`jeea`tal irjn tma wjrdl ji eu`dakr trkla `jetrjds, ba tmay
hjvarenaets tmkt kra nanbars ji bullceh rahcjekd `ustjns uecjes jr celapaelaet brj-
oars, trklars, kel eke`cars su`m ks tmjsa wmj mkva baae kidcktal wctm Vkocstkec s`caetcst
Kblud [klaar Omke. Ks tma wjrdl–s eu`dakr celustry axpkels, aehkhceh tmjsa `juetrcas
jutscla tma EPH irknawjro wcdd ba ikr njra ̀ rctc`kd tmke kt key tcna ce tma EPH–s mcstjry.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 9/70
2 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Celck cs jea su`m `juetry. Ks k stkta wctm uela`dkral eu`dakr k`tcvctcas jutscla tma
EV\, Celck wks bkrral by tma EPH kel tma EV\ irjn njst cetarektcjekd eu`dakr `jn-
nar`a, but tma hrjup dcital eu`dakr trkla ske`tcjes khkcest Celck ce 266= kt tma raquast
ji tma Qectal Ptktas, suppjrtal by jtmar nkgjr eu`dakr axpjrtceh hjvarenaets, ce`dulceh
Irke`a kel Russck. Xjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets kllrassal tma quastcje ji wmatmar tma Celck
la`cscje wks k —scehudkr ax`aptcje„ tj prce`cpdas sat by tma EV\ pkrtcas kel kljptal by
tma EPH, ks cts nkce klvj`ktas `dkcnal, jr wmatmar ct nkroal k schec`ket `jursa `jr-
ra`tcje by tma EPH tjwkrl tma hjkd ji jbtkceceh tma klmarae`a kel pkrtc`cpktcje ji kdd
eu`dakr suppdcar stktas, ce`dulceh tmjsa jutscla tma EV\ tmkt aerc`m urkecun, raprj`ass
crrklcktal eu`dakr iuad, kel mkva eu`dakr wakpjes. Kttaelaas prasaetal krhunaets ijr
bjtm `ksas but `kna tj ej `jesaesus.
Ejw, tmraa yakrs kitar tma Celck ax`aptcje, @mcek cetaels tj axpjrt njra pjwar rak`tjrs
tj Vkocstke, wmc`m cs, dcoa Celck, k stkta jutscla tma EV\ wctm eu`dakr krns. K``jrlceh
tj EPH hucladceas, Vkocstke wjudl mkva tj `jnnct tj iudd-s`jpa Cetarektcjekd Ktjnc`
Aearhy Khae`y (CKAK) skiahukrls ks k `jelctcje ijr tma trkesk`tcje. \mkt wcdd ejt mkppae,
kel wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets lcs`ussal wmatmar @mcek `ke ba parsuklal ejt tj axpjrt tma
rak`tjrs jr cestakl tj saao k ijrnkd ax`aptcje tj EPH hucladceas. @mcek ̀ dkcns tma axpjrts
kra —hrkeliktmaral„ by k djeh-stkelceh khraanaet wctm Vkocstke. Vrasaetdy tma EPH mks
ejt ijrnudktal k raspjesa tj @mcek–s ̀ mkddaeha, but ci Bacgceh ljas ejt ̀ jna tj sjna khraa-
naet wctm tma EPH, tma hrjup–s ̀ ralcbcdcty wcdd ba lknkhal, wjrosmjp kttaelaas wkreal.
\ma EPH nust ba prapkral tj ce`dula eaw axpjrtars, nkey ji tman lavadjpceh `jue-
trcas pravcjusdy jutscla tma ikbrc` ji eu`dakr trkla ruda nkoceh. Ct wcdd kdsj mkva tj kllrass
`je`ares tmkt tma jrhkeczktcje cs ke ax`duscva `dub tmkt uelar`uts stktas– rchmts tj eu`dakr
`jnnar`a. \ma EPH ce`jrpjrktal @mcek cetj tma hrjup ce 266< kel smjudl `jesclar
tmcs axparcae`a ce key iutura axpkescje. \ma Qectal Ptktas mks ijr`al tma pk`a ji tmcslcs`usscje by klvj`ktceh iudd EPH nanbarsmcp ijr Celck. \mjuhm wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets
irjn Celck, Csrkad, kel Vkocstke prasaetal krhunaets ks tj wmy tmasa `juetrcas smjudl
ba ce`dulal ce tma krrkehanaet, tmara wks ej `jesaesus knjeh tma kttaelaas tmkt tmkt
smjudl mkppae ce tma eakr iutura.
Kdd ji tmcs wcdd kiia`t tma rudas by wmc`m tma EPH jparktas. \ma EPH eaals tj `jesclar
mjw cts vjduetkry pkrtc`cpktcje kel `jesaesus-bksal la`cscjenkoceh wcdd ikra ks njra
stktas gjce tma hrjup. Avae kt tma EPH–s ̀ urraet scza, sjna wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt
tma knjuet ji ̀ jnpdax eahjtcktcje tmkt wjudl ba raqucral tj rak`m k ̀ jesaesus je ̀ rctarck
ijr ke ax`aptcje ijr Vkocstke wjudl ejt ba wjrtm tma `jnpkrktcvady dcnctal baeat ji
mkdtceh k snkdd knjuet ji Pcej-Vkocstkec eu`dakr trkla tmkt cs ce vcjdktcje ji tma hucla-dceas. Yjduetkry `jnnctnaets kra lci`udt tj aeijr`a. But nkey wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets
skw dcttda upscla tj tureceh tma EPH cetj k njra ijrnkd jrhkeczktcje.
\ma ce`raksceh vjduna ji eu`dakr trkla kel tma avjdutcje ji axpjrtceh stktas– prjdciark-
tcje tmrakt kssassnaets mkva prjnptal k ravcaw by tma EPH ji cts ̀ jetrjd dcsts“`jetkceceh
tmjsa ctans tmkt nanbars khraa ̀ judl ba usal tj prjlu`a eu`dakr wakpjes kel tmus wmjsa
axpjrt smjudl ba rastrc`tal. La`cscjes nkla by tma hrjup ce tmcs krak wcdd prjijueldy
cnpk`t tma EPH–s iutura aiia`tcvaeass. \ma jehjceh dcst ravcaw smjudl ba `krrcal jut wctm
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 10/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 0
tma ̀ jjparktcje ji ektcjekd hjvarenaets– aeijr`anaet khae`cas tj kssura tmkt prk`tctcjears
raspjescbda ijr `jetrjddceh trkla uelarstkel kel `ke cnpdanaet tma hrjup–s la`cscjes.
\j iurtmar prjnjta trkespkrae`y kel pkrtc`cpktcje, tma EPH smjudl systanktc`kddy
cevastchkta tma pjsscbcdctcas ijr iutura `jddkbjrktcje wctm jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd
krrkehanaets, aspa`ckddy ce tma kraks ji hjjl prk`tc`as, ai`cae`y, ceijrnktcje nkekha-
naet, tmrakt kssassnaets, hucladcea cnpdanaetktcje, `jesaesus ijrnktcje, aeijr`anaet,
kel jutrak`m. Ce pkrtc`udkr, wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets urhal, tma EPH smjudl cetaesciy
`jjparktcje wctm tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd–s Rasjdutcje ;1<6 @jnncttaa tj astkbdcsm
kel uecvarskdcza k hdjbkd stkelkrl ijr eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds, kel tj bucdl `kpk`cty ce
ektcjekd hjvarenaets tj mkva tmkt stkelkrl kppdcal kel aeijr`al.
Ce k hdjbkdczal aevcrjenaet ce wmc`m eu`dakr hjjls nky ba prjlu`al jr trkesk`tal
keywmara ce tma wjrdl, tma EPH nust rankce ke assaetckd cestrunaet ijr pravaetceh
eu`dakr nktarckd, aqucpnaet, kel ta`mejdjhy irjn hattceh cetj tma mkels ji tmjsa wmj
saao tj lavadjp eu`dakr krns. But ct nust rak`m jut tj celustry, hjvarenaets, kel jtmar
ejeprjdciarktcje stkoamjdlars kel klkpt tj eaw `jelctcjes.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 11/70
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 12/70
1
\ma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup wks
ijrnal by stktas `jevce`al tmkt tma EV\
kdjea wjudl ejt latar prjdciarktjrs.
\ma Eu`dakr PuppdcarsHrjup7 @urraet@mkddaehas ce @jetaxt
\mara kra twj nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets tmkt astkbdcsm hucladceas ijr klncecstarceh eu`dakr
axpjrt `jetrjds7 tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup (EPH) kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa, kdsj
oejwe ks tma Axpjrtars @jnncttaa ji tma Eu`dakr Eje-Vrjdciarktcje \rakty (EV\). Bjtm
krrkehanaets anarhal lurceh tma ;386s, kel bjtm avjdval jvar tcna tj suppdanaet bcdkt-
arkd eu`dakr trkla khraanaets, wmc`m, bahceeceh ce tma yakrs kitar Xjrdl Xkr CC, mkva hjv-
areal eakrdy kdd ji tma wjrdl–s ̀ jnnar`a ce eu`dakr nktarckds, aqucpnaet, kel ta`mejdjhy.
\ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa jrchcektal ce ;38; wmae k hrjup ji itaae eu`dakr suppdcar
stktas bahke naatceh tj `dkrciy mjw tj cetarprat kel cnpdanaet Krtc`da CCC.2 ji tma EV\,
wmc`m raqucras tmkt stkta pkrtcas tj tma EV\ kppdyCetarektcjekd Ktjnc` Aearhy Khae`y (CKAK) skia-
hukrls je tmacr eu`dakr axpjrts. \ma krtc`da stktas
tmkt EV\ pkrtcas uelartkoa ejt tj prjvcla —sjur`a
jr spa`ckd sscjekbda nktarckd, jr aqucpnaet jr
nktarckd aspa`ckddy lascheal jr prapkral _ALV^ ijr
tma prj`assceh, usa, jr prjlu`tcje ji spa`ckd sscje-
kbda nktarckd„ tj eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas uedass
tma sjur`a jr sscjekbda nktarckd cs uelar skiahukrls.
Axpjrt ji ALV ctans wjudl —trchhar„ `artkce `jelctcjes ji suppdy, ce`dulceh CKAK skia-
hukrls ce tma ra`cpcaet stkta ci ct wara k pkrty tj tma EV\, kel kssurke`as ji pak`aiud usa citma ra`cpcaet stkta wara ejt ke EV\ pkrty.2 ALV hjjls wara ejt, mjwavar, laeal by tma
EV\, kel tma ceijrnkd Wkehhar @jnncttaa wks ijrnal tj claetciy tmasa ctans.
\ma EPH wks astkbdcsmal by k hrjup ji savae eu`dakr suppdcar stktas tj iurtmar rastrc`t
eu`dakr `jnnar`a kitar Celck axpdjlal k eu`dakr lavc`a ce ;38< usceh aqucpnaet kel
nktarckd suppdcal by @keklk kel tma Qectal Ptktas uelar bcdktarkd eu`dakr `jjpark-
tcje khraanaets `jnncttceh Celck tj pak`aiud usa ji tma cnpjrtal ctans. \ma EPH wks
axprassdy ijrnal je tma prancsa tmkt tma EV\ kel Krtc`da CCC.2 kdjea lcl ejt sui`a tj pra-
vaet eu`dakr ctans irjn baceh trkesiarral tj pkrtcas tmkt kcnal tj lavadjp eu`dakr wakpjes.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 13/70
9 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Ce cts hucladceas, tma EPH kljptal tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa–s dcst ji hjjls tmkt trchhar
skiahukrls je axpjrts, but ct waet bayjel tma stcpudktcjes ji Krtc`da CCC.2 ce astkbdcsmceh
jtmar `rctarck tmkt ra`cpcaet stktas nust naat tj cnpjrt eu`dakr hjjls irjn suppdcar stktas.
Bahceeceh ce ;381, tma EPH–s nanbars lrkital hucladceas tmkt twj yakrs dktar wara khraal
upje by itaae stktas. \masa hucladceas wara tmae pubdcsmal by tma CKAK ce ;38=. 0 Ce
kllctcje tj tma trchhar dcst, tmay kdsj ce`dulal —@jnnje @rctarck ijr \a`mejdjhy \rkesiars„
ji saesctcva ctans radktal tj urkecun aerc`mnaet kel crrklcktal iuad raprj`assceh, k
raqucranaet ijr pmysc`kd prjta`tcje, k bke je eu`dakr axpdjscva usas kel je prjlu`tcje ji
mchmdy aerc`mal urkecun (MAQ), `jelctcjes dcnctceh ra`cpcaet stktas– ratrkesiars, kel njra
rastrc`tcva —spa`ckd ̀ jetrjds„ je ctans ijr urkecun aerc`mnaet kel spaet iuad raprj`assceh.
Pce`a ;38<, tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa–s trchhar dcst mks baae adkbjrktal kel axpkelal tj
rafla`t tma avjdutcje ji eu`dakr ta`mejdjhy, kel kdsj ba`kusa prjdciarktceh stktas su``aalal
ce axpdjctceh djjpmjdas ce tma hucladceas. Mjwavar, tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa–s nkelkta
rankces bjuel tj cnpdanaetktcje ji EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2.
\ma EPH, mjwavar, mks `jetceual tj axtael tma s`jpa ji cts rudas ijr hdjbkd eu`dakr
trkla bayjel tma nkelkta ji tma EV\.
Kitar pubdcsmceh cts ;38= hucladceas, tma EPH lcl ejt naat khkce uetcd ;33;. Lurceh
tmcs parcjl, savarkd `juetrcas sat up adkbjrkta prj`uranaet jrhkeczktcjes tj suppjrt
eu`dakr wakpjes lavadjpnaet prjhrkns. \may cnpjrtal nkey ctans, aspa`ckddy lukd-usa
hjjls, wmc`m wara ejt subga`t tj tma `jetrjds ji tma twj nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets. Njra
`juetrcas bahke haearktceh eu`dakr pjwar, njra lavadjpal `kpk`ctcas tj prjlu`a eu`dakr
nktarckds kel aqucpnaet, kel tma eunbar ji EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ce`raksal
irjn ;1 tj 28. Xmae tma s`kda ji Crkq–s `dkelastcea prj`uranaet prjhrkn wks ravakdal
ce ;33; kitar tma rst Hudi Xkr, tma EPH nat ijr tma rst tcna ce tmcrtaae yakrs. Ct tmae
uplktal tma trchhar dcst kel `jnpcdal k eaw `jetrjd dcst ijr lukd-usa ctans, wmc`m wkspubdcsmal by tma CKAK ce ;332.< \ma hucladceas ijr lukd-usa trkla ae`jurkhal suppdcars
tj nkoa k subga`tcva gulhnaet kbjut tma ejeprjdciarktcje `ralaetckds ji pjtaetckd ra`cpc-
aet stktas ce tma `jursa ji dc`aesceh axpjrts. Ce ;330, tma EPH ax`aalal tma EV\ nke-
lkta stcdd iurtmar by raqucrceh ks k `jelctcje ijr tma axpjrt ji trchhar dcst ctans, subga`t tj
eaw eu`dakr suppdy `jnnctnaets, tmkt key eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stkta ra`cpcaet–s eu`dakr
k`tcvctcas ba subga`t tj iudd-s`jpa CKAK skiahukrls. Ce ;33<, tma EPH axtaelal tj trch-
har dcst ctans cts stcpudktcje ce tma EPH lukd-usa hucladceas tmkt suppdcar stktas `jesclar
ra`cpcaets– ejeprjdciarktcje `ralaetckds ce dc`aesceh. Ce 2662, tma EPH raspjelal tj tma
avaets ji 3/;; by ce`dulceh ce cts hucladceas tma ra`jnnaelktcje tmkt hraktar aiijrts ba
nkla tj pravaet `jetrjddal ctans irjn baceh jbtkceal by tarrjrcsts. Ce 266<, tma EPH–spkrtc`cpktceh stktas khraal tj kljpt k sj-`kddal `kt`m-kdd na`mkecsn tj latar axpjrts ji
uedcstal ctans sjuhmt by ijrache aetctcas claetcal by suppdcar stktas ks pkrtc`cpktceh ce
eu`dakr wakpjes lavadjpnaet prjhrkns.
Eakrdy k la`kla kitar tma EPH bahke naatceh rahudkrdy tj staklcdy aedkrha tma s`jpa
ji cts `jetrjds, sjna EPH pkrtc`cpkets lurceh jutrak`m k`tcvctcas axprassal `kutcjus jptc-
ncsn tmkt tma nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd rahcna wjudl ijr ke celaecta parcjl su``aal
ce stannceh tma sprakl ji eu`dakr hjjls tj prjdciarktjrs. La`dceceh jcd kel hks prc`as,
ueikvjrkbda a`jejnc`s, kel pubdc` k``aptke`a prjbdans dal nkey `juetrcas tj s`kda bk`o
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 14/70
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 15/70
= | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Lurceh tma pkst la`kla, tma EPH–s
aiia`tcvaeass kel `ralcbcdcty wks lcra`tdy
`mkddaehal by tma wcddceheass ji astkbdcsmal
suppdcars ce tma hrjup tj brako jr bael
cts hucladceas ce tma sarvc`a ji tmacrektcjekd sa`urcty kel a`jejnc` cetarasts.
tj ijrache pjwars aqucpnaet ct cnpjrtal ijr tmkt prjhrkn, sjna cevastchktjrs kssunal
ct ratkceal `jpcas ji saesctcva hks `aetrciuha kel aerc`mnaet pdket lasche ceijrnktcje.8
Vkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ce tma twj nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets
axpjsal tma wkva ji eu`dakr snuhhdceh tmkt as`kdktal lurceh tma dkta ;336s uetcd Omke–s
krrast by Vkocstkec kutmjrctcas ce 266<. K snkdd eunbar ji prj`uranaet khaets, brjoars,
kel prjga`t nkekhars wmj mkl `jddkbjrktal wctm Omke wara subga`t tj gulc`ckd cevastchk-
tcjes kel, ce k iaw `ksas, prjsa`utcje by ektcjekd kutmjrctcas. \ma urkecun aerc`mnaet
ta`mejdjhy prjdciarktal by tmasa k`tjrs, mjwavar, rankces kt dkrha, kel ke cetarektcjekd
kel cetardj`oceh `mkce ji prj`uranaet kssj`cktcjes kel `jetk`ts, k``jrlceh tj ji`ckds
irjn EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, kdsj rankces kt dkrha kel k`tcva. \rklars kel brj-
oars aehkhal ce tmcs busceass lcra`tdy `mkddaeha tma `ralcbcdcty kel aiia`tcvaeass ji tma
EPH ba`kusa tmay, kel ce sjna `ksas hjvarenaets ce `juetrcas wmara tmay kra jparktceh,
kra jutscla tma nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaet.
Ct cs cnpjrtket tj uelars`jra tmkt, uedcoa pravcjus `ksas ce wmc`m ektcjekd hjvare-
naets tchmtdy nkekhal `dkelastcea prj`uranaet k`tcvctcas tj lavadjp eu`dakr wakpjes,
tma k`tcvctcas ji tma Omke eatwjro wara kppkraetdy ejt staaral by k ektcjekd hjvarenaet
but wara `krrcal jut ce pkrkddad wctm Vkocstke–s eu`dakr wakpjes prjhrkn kel cevjdval
s`jras ji ejestkta k`tjrs“aehceaars, nkeuik`turceh `jnpkecas, trklars, brjoars, kel
eke`cars“ejea ji wmjn wara k`tceh je bamkdi ji key ektcjekd hjvarenaet kutmjrcty.
—Jppjrtuecstc`, Ptkta-Puppjrtal Eu`dakr @jnnar`a„
Lurceh tma pkst la`kla, tma EPH–s aiia`tcvaeass kel `ralcbcdcty wks lcra`tdy `mkddaehal
by tma wcddceheass ji astkbdcsmal suppdcars ce tma hrjup tj brako jr bael cts hucladceas ce
tma sarvc`a ji tmacr ektcjekd sa`urcty kel a`jejnc` cetarasts.
Qetcd tma akrdy ;336s, wmae tma EPH astkbdcsmal tma ̀ jelctcje ji iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls
ijr trchhar dcst axpjrts kel cetrjlu`al `jetrjds je lukd-usa ctans“kel ks tma eunbar
ji EPH nanbars hrklukddy ce`raksal“sjna sup-
pdcar stktas rascstal aiijrts tj `urtkcd tmacr eu`dakr
axpjrts tj `juetrcas wctm bjtm la`dkral kel uela-
`dkral eu`dakr prjhrkns“ce pkrtc`udkr, Krhaetcek,
Brkzcd, Celck, Vkocstke, kel Pjutm Kirc`k. Ejea ji
tma suppdcar stktas, tmjuhm, jvartdy `mkddaehal jr
vcjdktal tma EPH hucladceas ce axpjrtceh ctans tj
tmasa lastcektcjes.
Pce`a ;33=, mjwavar, tma EPH hucladceas mkvabaae `mkddaehal by suppdcar stktas aehkhceh ce wmkt
jea axpart `kddal —jppjrtuecstc`, stkta-suppjrtal
eu`dakr `jnnar`a.„= Russck `je`dulal k pjwar
rak`tjr axpjrt lakd wctm Celck, wmc`m ct `dkcnal lcl
ejt vcjdkta tma EPH–s iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls `jelctcje ba`kusa tma trkesk`tcje wks —hrkel-
iktmaral„ by k bcdktarkd eu`dakr `jjparktcje khraanaet `je`dulal ijur yakrs baijra tma
EPH astkbdcsmal tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls raqucranaet ce ;332. Lurceh tma ;33= EPH
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 16/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 3
pdaekry naatceh, tma Qectal Ptktas jbga`tal tj tmcs krhunaet kel dktar raquastal tmkt
Russck prjvcla lj`unaetktcje tmkt cts ;3== bcdktarkd khraanaet wctm Celck spa`c`kddy
ce`dulal suppdy ji tma pjwar rak`tjrs tj Celck. Russck lcl ejt prjvcla key lj`unaetktcje,
kel tma trkesk`tcje waet ijrwkrl.3
Ce 266;, Russck axpjrtal eu`dakr iuad tj Celck ijr twj pjwar rak`tjrs dj`ktal kt \krkpur
kel cevjoal k `dkusa ce tma EPH hucladceas tmkt parncts k suppdcar tj axpjrt ctans tj k
ra`cpcaet wctmjut iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls —ce ax`aptcjekd `ksas wmae tmay kra laanal assae-
tckd ijr tma skia jparktcje ji axcstceh ik`cdctcas.„;6 Nkey EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets
jbga`tal tmkt tma pdkeeal axpjrt wjudl vcjdkta tma hucladceas, kel ce 266< Russck sus-
paelal iuad suppdy tj tma Celcke rak`tjrs.;; Ce 2669, wmae Russck khkce cevjoal tma skiaty
ax`aptcje, tmara wks dcttda jppjsctcje irjn EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets. Cestakl, tmara
wks ke cetarekd lcs`usscje kbjut mjw tma skiaty ax`aptcje smjudl ba cetarpratal, wctm
sjna pkrtcas, ce`dulceh Russck, krhuceh tmkt tma ax`aptcje `judl ba cevjoal ci k la`cscje
ejt tj suppdy tma ctans ce quastcje wjudl nake tmkt tma rak`tjr wjudl mkva tj ba smut
ljwe.;2 Russck suppdcal tma iuad tj Celck. Ce 266=, Russcke eu`dakr iuad vaeljr \YAD
scheal k $866 ncddcje `jetrk`t wctm tma Eu`dakr Vjwar @jrpjrktcje ji Celck (Ep`cd) ijr
`jetceual suppdy ji urkecun ijr tma rak`tjrs ce \krkpur.;0
\mraa yakrs akrdcar, ce 2661, tma Qectal Ptktas kel Celck mkl keejue`al tmkt tmay
wjudl eahjtckta ke khraanaet ijr pak`aiud eu`dakr `jjparktcje tmkt, tj parnct aetry cetj
ijr`a, wjudl raqucra tma EPH tj nkoa ke ax`aptcje tj tma `jelctcje tmkt axpjrt ji trch-
har dcst ctans tj kdd stktas ax`apt tma EV\–s va eu`dakr wakpje pjwars raqucras iudd-s`jpa
skiahukrls. Xmae tma Q.P.-Celck bcdktarkd khraanaet wks rst `je`acval, Q.P. ji`ckds
mkl `jesclaral prasaetceh tma EPH wctm k dcst ji prjpjsal `rctarck tmkt nchmt sarva ks tma
bkscs ijr kwkrlceh Celck ke ax`aptcje tj tma EPH raqucranaet ijr iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls.
\wj jtmar stktas jutscla tma EV\ wctm eu`dakr krsaekds, Csrkad kel Vkocstke, kt tmkt tcnaprassal tma Qectal Ptktas tj suppjrt tmacr aiijrts tj jbtkce k scncdkr wkcvar irjn EPH
trkla rastrc`tcjes je tma bkscs ji spa`c` `rctarck.;<
\ma Qectal Ptktas, Russck, kel Irke`a, kdd ji wmc`m sjuhmt tj axpjrt eu`dakr aqucpnaet
tj Celck, jppjsal prjvclceh ax`aptcjes ijr Csrkad kel Vkocstke. Cestakl, tmay krhual tmkt
k uecqua ax`aptcje smjudl ba nkla ijr Celck wctmjut raiarae`a tj `rctarck. Ce Paptanbar
266=, tma EPH hrketal tmkt ax`aptcje ijr Celck by ̀ jesaesus, kel Celck nky ejw cnpjrt
`jetrjddal ctans irjn EPH suppdcar stktas.
K @mkehceh Hdjbkd Eu`dakr \rkla Aevcrjenaet
\ma EPH mks kdsj baae `mkddaehal lurceh tma dkst la`kla by k trkesijrnktcje ce tma`jelu`t ji cetarektcjekd eu`dakr trkla.
Pce`a tma haeascs ji bjtm nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets (tma EPH
kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa), tma trchhar dcst mks baae subga`t tj `jesclarkbda njlc`k-
tcje, aemke`anaet, kel aedkrhanaet. \mcs wks ea`assctktal by tma su``ass ji prjdciark-
tjrs ce axpdjctceh djjpmjdas ce tma hucladceas. Ce sjna `ksas, `juetrcas cnpjrtal pkrtckddy
nkeuik`tural ctans je tma dcst, ks wadd ks nktarckds kel aqucpnaet tmkt lcl ejt pra`csady
`jeijrn tj tma ta`mec`kd spa`c`ktcjes je tma dcst but `ke ejeatmadass ba usal ijr eu`dakr
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 17/70
;6 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
wakpjes lavadjpnaet. \may kdsj cnpjrtal lukd-usa aqucpnaet tmkt `judl ba usal tj
prjlu`a tma `jetrjddal ctans tmay sjuhmt.
Ce 266<, tma EPH ce`dulal ce cts hucladceas k —`kt`m-kdd„ ruda urhceh pkrtc`cpktceh
stktas —tj prjvcla k ektcjekd dahkd bkscs tj ̀ jetrjd tma axpjrt ji eu`dakr radktal ctans wmc`m
kra ejt je tma ̀ jetrjd dcsts, wmae su`m ctans kra jr nky ba cetaelal tj ba usal ijr eu`dakr
wakpjes prjhrkns.„;1 Pjna EPH stktas mkl ce`dulal ̀ kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes ce tmacr ektcjekd
axpjrt `jetrjd dkws sce`a tma ncl-;336s. Ce k iaw `ksas tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes parncttal
ektcjekd kutmjrctcas tj mkdt spa`c` axpjrts tj tma Omke eatwjro lurceh tma dkta ;336s
kel ks dkta ks 2662, but ce jtmar `ksas tmay ikcdal tj mkdt trkesk`tcjes ba`kusa latarnceal
axpjrtars wara prapkral tj vcjdkta ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd dkws.;9 Pjna ji`ckds pkrtc`c-
pktceh ce EPH ladcbarktcjes mkva skcl tmkt tma `kt`m-kdd na`mkecsn wks anbrk`al by
tma EPH ks k stjp-hkp naksura ce vcaw ji tma dkrha vjduna ji uedcstal aqucpnaet tmkt
prj`uranaet khaets mkl suppdcal tj eu`dakr prjhrkns ce Dcbyk, Crke, Ejrtm Ojrak, kel
Vkocstke lurceh tma la`kla prcjr tj 266<.
Xmae tma EPH wks ijuelal, eakrdy kdd cetarektcjekd eu`dakr trkla cevjdval pjcet-tj-
pjcet trkesk`tcjes ce wmc`m saddars smcppal ctans tj spa`cal ael usars. Pce`a tma ;3=6s,
mjwavar, prjdciarktjrs mkva ce`rakscehdy trkessmcppal hjjls tj tmacr ekd lastcektcjes vck
cetarnalckta dj`ktcjes ce `juetrcas wctm wako jr ejeaxcstaet axpjrt `jetrjd systans, kel
tmay mkva usal trkla brjoars tj jrhkecza `jnpdax trkesk`tcjes tmkt kra lci`udt ijr axpjrt
`jetrjd kutmjrctcas tj lata`t kel cetarlc`t. \masa trkesk`tcjes kra jitae jrhkeczal tj mkva
nudtcpda cetarnalckry lastcektcjes `kddal —turetkbdas„ kel `jnpdax pkynaet s`manas.;8
\ma Omke eatwjro iraquaetdy usal tma Qectal Krkb Ancrktas kel Nkdkysck ks turetkbdas,
but tma ra`jrls ji ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd kutmjrctcas `ctal ce sjna AQ stktas– cevastchk-
tcjes ji tma Omke eatwjro suhhast tmkt trkla radcal je parmkps tmraa ljzae cetarnalc-
kry smcppceh pjcets wjrdlwcla tj njva hjjls tj tmacr ekd lastcektcjes.;= Ce tmcs wky,ijr axknpda, Ejrtm Ojrak nky mkva aiia`tcvady lcshucsal ksscstke`a tj Pyrck radktal tj
`jestru`tcje ji k `dkelastcea pdutjecun prjlu`tcje rak`tjr batwaae ;338 kel 2669.
Nkdkysck kel Pjutm Kirc`k, irjn kbjut ;33= tmrjuhm 2660, sarval ks nkeuik`turceh ̀ ae-
tars ijr urkecun aerc`mnaet‐radktal aqucpnaet udtcnktady lastceal ijr Dcbyk kel Crke.
Pjna ji tma njst ahrahcjus prjdciarktcje trkesk`tcjes `krrcal jut by tma Omke eat-
wjro lcl ejt cevjdva aqucpnaet jr eu`dakr nktarckds but ta`mejdjhy. Ektcjekd kutmjrctcas
cevastchktceh tma Omke eatwjro lcs`jvaral tmkt lasche ceijrnktcje ce`jrpjrktal cetj
bduaprcets, jrchcekddy stjdae irjn astkbdcsmal eu`dakr prjhrkns ce suppdcar stktas, mkl baae
`jpcal jetj `jnputar lrcvas. Mchmdy saesctcva ceijrnktcje mks baae trkesncttal ce sjna
`ksas vck tma Cetareat kel stjral je `jnpk`t lcsos. Ce 2661, tma kutmjr ji tmcs rapjrtjbtkceal stjdae lasche ceijrnktcje ijr hks `aetrciuha urkecun aerc`mnaet tmkt mkl baae
pmjtj`jpcal kel nky mkva baae ada`trjec`kddy trkesncttal tj uekutmjrczal tmcrl pkrtcas.
Vrjdciarktjrs– ce`raksceh radcke`a je `jnpdax trkesk`tcjes cevjdvceh pkrtc`cpkets jut-
scla astkbdcsmal suppdcar stktas cs k hraktar `mkddaeha ijr tma EPH tmke avar baijra ba`kusa
hdjbkd axpa`tktcjes kbjut tma iutura ji eu`dakr pjwar kra ̀ mkehceh. Kitar yakrs ji stkheket
hrjwtm ce `kpk`cty axpkescje, nkey `juetrcas tmkt `urraetdy haearkta eu`dakr ada`trc`cty
ejw pdke tj schec`ketdy axpkel tmacr eu`dakr ceirkstru`tura, kel `juetrcas tmkt sj ikr
mkva ejt lavadjpal eu`dakr ta`mejdjhy kssats kra pdkeeceh je lapdjyceh pjwar rak`tjrs ce
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 18/70
Nkro Mcbbs | ;;
Pjna `juetrcas ejw cevastceh ce
eu`dakr aearhy ceirkstru`tura, kel ce
pjssasscje ji k sui`caet celustrckd bksa,
wcdd tmansadvas ba`jna suppdcars kel
axpjrtars ji eu`dakr nktarckd ks wadd ks
trchhar dcst kel lukd-usa aqucpnaet.
`jnceh yakrs. Nkey kra lavadjpceh `juetrcas tmkt kra ejt pkrtc`cpktceh ce EPH jutrak`m
k`tcvctcas.;3 Pjna `juetrcas ejw cevastceh ce eu`dakr aearhy ceirkstru`tura, kel ce pjssas-
scje ji k sui`caet celustrckd bksa, wcdd tmansadvas
ba`jna suppdcars kel axpjrtars ji eu`dakr nktarckd
ks wadd ks trchhar dcst kel lukd-usa aqucpnaet.
@mcek, k eu`dakr wakpje stkta sce`a ;39<, sat
up k eu`dakr pjwar ceirkstru`tura vary hrklukddy
bahceeceh ce tma ;3=6s tmrjuhm tma ael ji tma ;336s.
Pce`a tmae, @mcek mks lrknktc`kddy k``adarktal cts
eu`dakr pjwar lavadjpnaet. @mcek ejw jparktas
ijurtaae eu`dakr pjwar rak`tjrs kel nky mkva ks
nkey ks 81 uects jedcea by 2626, kel cts eu`dakr
bucdlup wcdd cevjdva parmkps savarkd muelral
aetarprcsas pkrtc`cpktceh ce eu`dakr `jestru`tcje,
aqucpnaet nkeuik`tura, kel tma aehceaarceh sarvc`as sa`tjr, wmcda @mceasa jvarschmt ji
`jnnar`ckd eu`dakr k`tcvctcas, ce`dulceh cts axpjrt sa`tjr, nky ba `jnpkrktcvady wako.
Celck, iraal irjn njst EPH trkla ske`tcjes ce 266=, ejw mkrbjrs scncdkr knbctcjes.
Ce dkta 26;6, Celck bahke jparktceh cts twaetcatm pjwar rak`tjr, brcehceh cts tjtkd cestkddal
haearktceh `kpk`cty tj kbjut 1 HX 26? Celcke celustry kcns tj ce`raksa tmkt `kpk`cty tj ks
nu`m ks 90 HX by 2602. Kbjut twj-tmcrls ji tmcs `kpk`cty axpkescje wjudl ba `jetrcb-
utal by prjga`ts wctm ijrache suppdcars nkla pjsscbda by tma EPH ax`aptcje ijr Celck.2;
\ma Rcsa ji Cetarektcjekd Eu`dakr Aqucty Cssuas
\ma EPH wks ijuelal by savae suppdcar stktas tmkt wara `jevce`al tmkt tma EV\–s skia-
hukrls prjvcscjes wjudl ejt aiia`tcvady pravaet prjdciarktjrs irjn jbtkceceh nktarckds
kel aqucpnaet ijr eu`dakr wakpjes prjhrkns. But tma EPH cnpjsal ej kllctcjekd trkla
rastrc`tcjes batwaae ;38= kel ;332. Kitar tma rst Hudi Xkr ravakdal tmkt ijr njra tmke
k la`kla Crkq mkl spaet savarkd bcddcje Q.P. ljddkrs je k `dkelastcea eu`dakr wakpjes prj-
hrkn tmkt mkl baae mcllae irjn tma CKAK, tma EPH bahke tj rkt`mat up tma s`jpa ji cts
trkla `jetrjds, bahceeceh wctm tma lukd-usa dcst kel kllctcjekd trchhar dcst ctans tmkt mkl
hural ce Crkq–s eu`dakr wakpjes quast.
Pce`a cts ce`aptcje, tma EPH, tmrjuhm cts k`tcjes, mks prjnptal k``usktcjes irjn
lavadjpceh `juetrcas tmkt ct cs k `krtad ji ta`mejdjhy mjdlars kcnceh tj pravaet jtmars
irjn jbtkceceh eu`dakr ta`mejdjhy, socdds, kel ceirkstru`tura. \masa `dkcns mkva strjehdy
flkvjral EPH lcpdjnk`y ce ra`aet yakrs. Lurceh tma ;3=6s, tmay cemcbctal tma EPH irjniurtmar lavadjpceh kel axpkelceh tma s`jpa ji cts trkla `jetrjds.
Nu`m ji tmcs `rctc`csn mks baae `mkeeadal cetj tma EV\ ravcaw `jeiarae`a prj`ass,
lurceh wmc`m sjna stktas mkva jbga`tal tmkt tma EPH–s k`tcvctcas ax`aal wmkt cs `kddal ijr
uelar EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2. Lurceh tma ;331 EV\ Ravcaw kel Axtaescje @jeiarae`a, pjsc-
tcva raiarae`as tj tma wjro ji tma EPH wara ejt klncttal tj tma ra`jrl ji tma `jeiarae`a,
kel tma EPH wks ̀ rctc`czal ijr dk`o ji trkespkrae`y by sjna nanbars ji tma Eje-Kdcheal
Njvanaet (EKN). EKN `rctc`s, dal by Crke, trcal but ikcdal tj astkbdcsm ks k haearkd
prce`cpda tmkt tma CKAK kdjea smjudl krbctrkta `jnpdcke`a wctm EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2.22
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 19/70
;2 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Lurceh tma ;338 EPH jutrak`m sancekr ce Ycaeek, suppdcar stktas trcal tj `jevce`a
jtmars tmkt tma EPH wks ejt naket tj laey lavadjpceh `juetrcas k``ass tj trkla kel tmkt
tmara kra —ej sa`rat khraanaets„ knjeh EPH nanbars tj tmkt aiia`t, —kel ej sa`rat dcst
ji bkl huy `juetrcas.„20 Pjna lavadjpceh `juetrcas jbga`tal lurceh tma naatceh tmkt tma
EPH hucladceas wara krbctrkrcdy cetarpratal by suppdcars tj laey axpjrts. Puppdcar stkta
ji`ckds jiiaral tma rairkce tmkt eakrdy kdd axpjrt dc`aesa kppdc`ktcjes subncttal tj EPH-
pkrtc`cpktceh stktas kra kpprjval. Crke jbga`tal tmkt —vcrtukddy kdd tma laeckds kra tj stktas
jutscla tma EPH.„2<
Crke, suppjrtal by EKN stktas, ce`rakscehdy jbga`tal tj cetariarae`a ce cts eu`dakr
lavadjpnaet bahceeceh ce 2660, wmae cts skiahukrls `jnpdcke`a ba`kna subga`t tj
ravcaw by tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs, kel EKN jbga`tcjes wara nkhecal by tma
`jetrcbutcje ji tma Qectal Ptktas kel sjna jtmar suppdcar stktas tj tma ikc dura ji tma EV\
Ravcaw @jeiarae`a ce 2661. Jea jbsarvar ji tmkt avaet skcl, —Ijr tma Qectal Ptktas, tma
ij`us ji ejeprjdciarktcje _wks kt tma tcna ji tma Ravcaw @jeiarae`a^ jutscla tma _EV\^7
Ct rasts wctm tma EPH, tma Vrjdciarktcje Pa`urcty Cectcktcva (VPC), QEP@ Rasjdutcje ;1<6,
tma H= Hdjbkd Vkrtearsmcp, kel cts jwe ncdctkry `juetarprjdciarktcje.„21
Q.P. Vrasclaet Bkrk`o Jbknk–s vjws tj ra`jnnct tma Qectal Ptktas tj nudtcdktarkd
lcpdjnk`y bahceeceh ce 2663 `jetrcbutal tj tma jut`jna tmkt tma 26;6 EV\ Ravcaw
@jeiarae`a lcl ejt rue khrjuel je Ejrtm-Pjutm pjdkrczktcje. \ma `jesaesus K`tcje
Vdke rasudtceh irjn tmkt `jeiarae`a ce`dulal K`tcje 09, wmc`m ae`jurkhal stkta pkrtcas
—tj nkoa usa ji nudtcdktarkddy eahjtcktal kel khraal hucladceas kel uelarstkelcehs ce
lavadjpceh tmacr jwe ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjds.„ Jtmar k`tcjes je tma dcst strassal tmkt
stktas– rchmts tj eu`dakr `jnnar`a wara subga`t tj Krtc`das C‐CCC ks wadd ks Krtc`da CY.
K`tcje 16, mjwavar, urhal ta`mejdjhy mjdlars tj —hcva praiaraetckd traktnaet„ tj EV\
eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas kel lavadjpceh `juetrcas.29 Ks mkl baae pralc`tal, ba`kusankey EV\ eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas wara mchmdy `rctc`kd ji tma EPH–s ax`aptcje la`c-
scje ijr Celck ce 266=, tma EPH wks ejt `ctal ce K`tcje 09 ks k njlad raiarae`a ijr tma
lavadjpnaet ji ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjds.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 20/70
;0
Ppa`c` @urraet kel Iutura@mkddaehas Ik`ceh tma EPH
Lcs`cpdcea kel @ralcbcdcty7 \ma EPH kel@mcek–s Eu`dakr \rkla Xctm Vkocstke
\mraa yakrs kitar tma EPH dcital njst trkla ske`tcjes khkcest Celck, ct kppakrs tmkt k eaw
ax`aptcje tj tmcs raqucranaet cs ce tma nkoceh, ks @mcek pdkes tj axpjrt kt dakst twj pjwar
rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke, k stkta tmkt, dcoa Celck, cs eu`dakr-krnal kel jutscla tma EV\.
Lurceh cts rst tmraa la`klas, tma EPH mkl quklrupdal cts nanbarsmcp tj anbrk`a
eakrdy kdd eu`dakr suppdcar stktas. Xmy ct lcl tmcs cs axanpdcal by tma `ksa ji @mcek.
Ijr nkey yakrs kitar @mcek gjceal tma rkeos ji tma wjrdl–s eu`dakr-krnal stktas, ct
ksscstal bjtm `cvcd kel ncdctkry eu`dakr prjhrkns ce Vkocstke kel prjvclal ksscstke`a
tj sjna jtmar uela`dkral eu`dakr prjga`ts, ejtkbdyce Kdharck. Lurceh tma ;336s, mjwavar, ce pkrkd-
dad wctm cts la`cscje tj axpkel cts `cvcdcke eu`dakr
`jjparktcje wctm tma Qectal Ptktas kel jtmar sup-
pdcar `juetrcas, @mcek `aksal ji`ckd ksscstke`a tj
Vkocstke–s ueskiahukrlal eu`dakr prjhrkn kel
gjceal tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa. @mcek lcl `je-
tceua tj axpjrt eu`dakr nktarckd kel aqucpnaet tj
Vkocstke–s `cvcd eu`dakr prjhrkn je tma bkscs tmkt
celcvclukd axpjrts `jnpdy wctm tma skiahukrls raqucranaets ji tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa
trchhar dcst. Ce 266<, @mcek gjceal tma EPH, wmc`m raqucral uelar Vkrkhrkpm < ji cts
hucladceas ijr trchhar dcst ctans tmkt key axpjrts by @mcek uelar eaw suppdy krrkehanaets
batwaae @mcek kel eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas ba `jelctcjeal je iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls
ce tma ra`cpcaet stkta.
Ba`kusa ji @mcek–s ra`jrl ji pravcjus ksscstke`a tj Vkocstke–s uela`dkral eu`dakr prj-
hrkn, tma prjspa`t ji @mcek gjceceh tma EPH uesattdal sjna eu`dakr trkla axparts. But
klvj`ktas ji @mceasa pkrtc`cpktcje krhual tmkt tma ce`duscje ji tma dkst ji tma V-1 `jue-
trcas cetj tma nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets nkla ct njra dcoady tmkt
Lurceh cts rst tmraa la`klas, tma EPH mkl
quklrupdal cts nanbarsmcp tj anbrk`a
eakrdy kdd eu`dakr suppdcar stktas.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 21/70
;< | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
tma vatj pjwars ce tma Qectal Ektcjes Pa`urcty @jue`cd (QEP@) wjudl tmae`aijrtm
`jjparkta ce stannceh tma sprakl ji eu`dakr wakpjes, kel tmkt @mcek wjudl tarncekta
kdd eu`dakr ksscstke`a tj Vkocstke.
@mcek mks ksscstal Vkocstke–s eu`dakr prjhrkn irjn cts ce`aptcje ce tma ;386s. Ct `je-
`dulal skdas ji twj pjwar rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke baijra @mcek gjceal tma EPH ce 266<,
kel ct nky mkva baae `jesclarceh kllctcjekd pjwar rak`tjr axpjrts tj Vkocstke wmae tma
Qectal Ptktas kel Celck keejue`al pdkes ijr bcdktarkd `cvcdcke eu`dakr `jjparktcje ce
2661. Ci sj, @mcek lcl ejt nkoa tmkt la`cscje oejwe. Ce 266<, @mcek spaddal jut tj tma
EPH tmkt ct cetaelal tj `jetceua `cvcdcke eu`dakr `jjparktcje wctm Vkocstke uelar tma
tarns ji k ;33; bcdktarkd eu`dakr ̀ jjparktcje khraanaet. @mcek ceijrnal tma EPH tmkt ct
pdkeeal tj suppdy iuad kel sarvc`as ijr tma @mksmnk-; kel -2 pjwar rak`tjrs axpjrtal tj
Vkocstke baijra 266<, but ce jutdceceh tma s`jpa ji cts ketc`cpktal iutura eu`dakr `jjpark-
tcje wctm Vkocstke, @mcek lcl ejt lcs`djsa tmkt ct pdkeeal tj axpjrt key kllctcjekd pjwar
rak`tjrs tj tmkt `juetry.28
Ce 2669, Vkocstkec kel Xastare nalck bahke rapjrtceh tmkt @mcek kel Vkocstke wara
pdkeeceh njra @mceasa pjwar rak`tjr axpjrts tj tma @mksmnk scta.2= Q.P. ji`ckds tmae
vjwal tmkt tma EPH wjudl ejt prjvcla ke ax`aptcje tj hucladceas ijr Vkocstke parnct-
tceh tmcs tj mkppae.23
Ce Ejvanbar 2669, je j``kscje ji ke ji`ckd stkta vcsct tj Vkocstke by @mceasa
Vrasclaet Mu Gcetkj, k saecjr Vkocstkec ji`ckd tjdl tmcs kutmjr tmkt Vkocstke prassal
@mcek tj khraa tj tma skda ji njra rak`tjrs, but tmkt Bacgceh wks ejt ce`dceal tj lj sj uetcd
ct wks `jelaet tmkt bjtm tma Qectal Ptktas kel Celck wjudl jbtkce raqucral kpprjvkd
ijr tma prjga`tal Q.P.-Celck eu`dakr lakd irjn dkwnkoars ce Xksmcehtje kel Eaw Ladmc,
kel tmkt bjtm tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs kel tma EPH wjudl dcoawcsa parnct tma Q.P.-
Celck lakd tj aetar cetj ijr`a.06 \mkt axpdkektcje ijr @mceasa ji`ckd scdae`a je tma nkt-tar kppakrs `jescstaet wctm tma `jetaets ji k dakoal lcpdjnktc` `kbda irjn Paptanbar ;,
2669, wmc`m stktas tmkt @mcek mkl ejt `jernal Vkocstkec nalck rapjrts `dkcnceh tmkt
Bacgceh mkl khraal tj axpjrt njra rak`tjrs. K``jrlceh tj tma `kbda, Bacgceh spaddal jut
tmkt —@mcek wcdd strc`tdy klmara tj cts cetarektcjekd jbdchktcjes ks k nanbar ji tma EPH.„0;
Ce akrdy 26;6, ct wks `jernal tmkt @mcek cetaelal tj axpjrt twj eaw rak`tjrs tj
Vkocstke ks @mksmnk-0 kel -<.02 EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets kt tma Guea 26;6 pda-
ekry naatceh raquastal k `dkrc`ktcje irjn @mcek, kel ce Ejvanbar @mcek cssual k
stktanaet tj tma hrjup celc`ktceh tmkt ct cetaelal tj axpjrt tma twj rak`tjrs, kllceh
tmkt tma axpjrts wara hrkeliktmaral uelar Bacgceh–s prcjr bcdktarkd eu`dakr trkla pk`t wctm
Vkocstke.00
Ce pkrkddad, @mcek kel Vkocstke nkla krrkehanaets ijr tma CKAK tj skiahukrltwj njra rak`tjrs ce Vkocstke uelar axcstceh skiahukrls krrkehanaets batwaae Vkocstke
kel tma CKAK `jvarceh @mksmnk-; kel -2.0< K``jrlceh tj ceijrnktcje hcvae by Vkocstkec
ji`ckds tmcs pkst Kprcd, Vkocstke mkl bahue ax`kvktcje wjro kt tma scta, ks wadd ks pjurceh
tma `je`rata ijuelktcje ijr tma rst ji tma twj rak`tjrs.01
Pce`a akrdy 26;6, tmara mks baae ej uekecncty knjeh EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh stktas kbjut
mjw tj prj`aal ce raspjesa tj @mcek–s pdkes ijr eaw rak`tjr axpjrts tj Vkocstke.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 22/70
Nkro Mcbbs | ;1
Bahceeceh ce akrdy 26;6 tma Qectal Ptktas axprassal tma pjsctcje tmkt, bksal je tma
ceijrnktcje prjvclal by @mcek ce 266<, @mcek `judl ejt hrkeliktmar tma trkesk`tcje. 09
But ji`ckds irjn sjna EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets cestakl `jesclaral tmkt hrkelik-
tmarceh ji tma axpjrt wjudl ba tma njst axpalcaet sjdutcje tj tma lcdannk, sce`a eunar-
jus EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets mkl baae axpjsal tj lcpdjnktc` prassura by tma
Qectal Ptktas kel Celck tj kpprjva tma ax`aptcje kwkrlal tj Celck ce 266=? tmay lcl ejt
wket tj rapakt tmkt axparcae`a wctm @mcek.08
\ma EPH kel @mcek–s Eu`dakr \rkla Xctm Vkocstke
Ijddjwceh lcs`usscjes wctm pkrtc`cpkets kt tma @kreahca Brussads sancekr, ct wjudl kppakr tmkt tma
ijddjwceh jptcjes kra kvkcdkbda tj tma EPH ce raspjelceh tj @mcek–s rasjdva tj axpjrt kllctcjekd
rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke7
• EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets `judl tk`ctdy parnct @mcek tj axpjrt tma rak`tjrs wctmjut
key lcs`usscje jr `mkddaeha.
• Kbsaet lj`unaetkry vkdclktcje by @mcek ji tma hrkeliktmarceh ji tma axpjrt, EPH-pkrtc`-
cpktceh hjvarenaets `judl ra`jrl jbga`tcjes tmkt tma axpjrt wjudl vcjdkta tma hucladceas
but tkoa ej iurtmar k`tcjes.
• \may `judl axpdc`ctdy khraa tmkt @mcek nky axpjrt tma rak`tjrs wctmjut vcjdktceh tma hucla-
dceas je tma bkscs tmkt @mcek–s prcjr krrkehanaets wctm Vkocstke parnct tma trkesk`tcje tj
ba hrkeliktmaral.
• \may `judl eahjtckta ke khraanaet wctm @mcek tmkt parncts tma axpjrt (la ik`tj hrkelik-
tmarceh) but tmkt `jnncts @mcek tj ladcvarceh ejeprjdciarktcje baeats, ce`dulceh k bke je
iutura rak`tjr axpjrts.
• Puppdcars `judl jbga`t tj hrkeliktmarceh kel rasjdva tmkt @mcek nust ra`acva ke ax`aptcje
tj tma hucladceas tj axpjrt tma rak`tjrs.
• Puppdcars `judl urha @mcek tj suspael cts axpjrt tj eahjtckta `rctarck tmkt Vkocstke nust
naat tj qukdciy tj ra`acva eaw rak`tjrs irjn @mcek.
\mara cs `urraetdy ej `jesaesus ce tma EPH je mjw tj prj`aal. K la`cscje by tma EPH smjudl
rafla`t k `kraiuddy `jesclaral kssassnaet ji tma lknkha tj tma axpjrt `jetrjd rahcna kel tma
EPH–s `ralcbcdcty ijr ak`m jptcje. \ma EPH `mkcrnke `judl `jnncsscje ke cetarekd lcs`usscje pk-
par tj `jesclar tma kvkcdkbda jptcjes? kdtarektcvady, jea jr njra EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets
`judl celapaelaetdy stuly tma nkttar kel rapjrt tma rasudts tj tma `mkcrnke, kitar `jesudtktcjes
wctm stktas jutscla tma hrjup.
Lcs`cpdcea-Radktal Cssuas
• \ma EPH smjudl try tj `dkrciy knjeh pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets mjw hrkeliktmarceh kel
skiaty ax`aptcje prjvcscjes ce tma hucladceas kra tj ba cetarpratal kel kppdcal.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jelu`t k lcs`usscje je mjw tj bast ae`jurkha strc`t klmarae`a ji pkrtc`c-
pktceh stktas kel jutrak`m `juetrcas tj EPH hucladceas.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 23/70
;9 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Kt tma EPH pdaekry naatceh madl ce Guea 26;;, tma nkttar rankceal uerasjdval. Ks
ce 26;6, EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets raquastal kllctcjekd ceijrnktcje irjn @mcek
tj axpdkce cts pdkeeal axpjrt tj Vkocstke kel, ce pkrtc`udkr, tj prjvcla lj`unaetktcje
tmkt tma trkesk`tcje wks `kddal ijr uelar tma ;33; Pcej-Vkocstkec eu`dakr trkla pk`t.
K``jrlceh tj ji`ckds irjn EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, tma EPH mkl khraal by
`jesaesus ce 2669, ce raspjesa tj Russck–s `mkddaeha tj tma EPH hucladceas jvar cts iuad
axpjrt tj Celck, tmkt key iutura `dkcns by k pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet tmkt spa`c` axpjrts
smjudl ba hrkeliktmaral smjudl ba lj`unaetal by avclae`a su`m ks ̀ jnnar`ckd ̀ jetrk`ts
wctm khae`cas ce tma cetaelal ra`cpcaet stkta.0= @mcek sj ikr mks ejt prjvclal key su`m
lj`unaetktcje tj vkdclkta cts kssartcje tmkt tma axpjrt ji tma eaw rak`tjrs wks `kddal ijr
by cts pravcjus krrkehanaet wctm Vkocstke. Xctmjut su`m lj`unaetktcje, k``jrlceh tj
EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet ji`ckds, tma axpjrt ji @mksmnk-0 kel -< by @mcek nust
ba `jesclaral k eaw suppdy krrkehanaet raqucrceh Vkocstke tj `jnnct tj iudd-s`jpa skia-
hukrls ks k `jelctcje ijr tma trkesk`tcje.
Ce ncl-26;;, @mcek ceijrnal EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tmkt ct mkl, ce 266<,
tjdl tma CKAK ji cts cetaelal iutura axpjrts ji pjwar rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke wmae ct prj-
vclal ke axpkelal la`dkrktcje ji cts eu`dakr k`tcvctcas uelar tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd.03
Ba`kusa tma `jnnuec`ktcjes batwaae tma CKAK kel nanbar stktas `je`areceh cnpda-
naetktcje ji tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd kra `jelaetckd, @mceasa stktanaets kbjut tma `je-
taet ji cts la`dkrktcjes tj tma CKAK uelar tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd `keejt ba `jernal
tj tmcrl pkrtcas by tma CKAK.
Kt tma @kreahca wjrosmjp, sjna pkrtc`cpkets ra`kddal tmkt, sj ikr, aiijrts by suppdcar
stktas sce`a 26;6 tj parsukla @mcek ejt tj axpjrt tma rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke mkl ikcdal.
\masa aiijrts ce`dulal k prjpjskd tmkt tma EPH khraa tj parnct tma axpjrts tj ba hrkel-
iktmaral ce ax`mkeha ijr @mcek parsuklceh cts kddy Vkocstke tj kbkelje cts jppjsctcje tjtma eahjtcktcje ji k Icsscda Nktarckd @ut-Jii \rakty kt tma @jeiarae`a je Lcskrnknaet.
K iaw wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets pralc`tal tmkt tma rasjdva axprassal by tma Qectal Ptktas
bahceeceh ce 26;6 tj parsukla @mcek tj saao k ijrnkd ax`aptcje ijr Vkocstke tj tma
EPH iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls `jelctcje ce tma hucladceas wjudl dcoawcsa ejt su``aal. Pjna
EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets wjudl ejt gjce su`m ke cectcktcva, tmay skcl, sce`a tmasa
stktas ketc`cpkta tmkt tmay wjudl ba subga`t tj bcdktarkd prassura irjn @mcek tj quc`ody
khraa tj ke ax`aptcje ijr Vkocstke. Pjna pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp kdsj skcl tmkt
@mcek badcavas tmkt jtmar suppdcars ce tma EPH mkva ej cetarast ce pusmceh tma cssua tj
tma brceo ce vcaw ji tma hrjup–s `dakr uelarstkelceh tmkt klmarae`a tj tma EPH hucla-
dceas cs vjduetkry. Pjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt tma knjuet ji `jnpdax eahjtcktcje tmkt wjudl ba raqucral tj rak`m k `jesaesus knjeh tma EPH–s <9 suppdcars je `rctarck ijr ke
ax`aptcje ijr Vkocstke wjudl ejt ba wjrtm tma `jnpkrktcvady dcnctal baeat ji mkdtceh
k snkdd knjuet ji Pcej-Vkocstkec eu`dakr trkla ce vcjdktcje ji tma hucladceas, pkrtc`u-
dkrdy ba`kusa Vkocstke–s latarcjrktceh pjdctc`kd kel a`jejnc` sctuktcje nchmt pravaet tma
@mceasa axpjrt irjn nktarckdczceh.
Jea Xastare hjvarenaet ji`ckd skcl tmkt @mcek nky ba uewcddceh tj khraa tj key
ce`aetcvas tj laiar eu`dakr `jnnar`a wctm Vkocstke ci tmara cs k bcdktarkd uelarstkel-
ceh batwaae Vkocstke kel @mcek tmkt, ce ax`mkeha ijr eu`dakr `jjparktcje irjn @mcek,
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 24/70
Nkro Mcbbs | ;8
Vkocstke wcdd prjvcla @mcek strktahc` baeats laanal mchmdy vkdukbda by Bacgceh, su`m ks
iraaljn tj lavadjp kel usa pjrt ik`cdctcas je tma Krkbcke Pak.<6
Nkey wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets quarcal jr axprassal k vcaw je tma nkttar, yat, k`oejwd-
alhal tmkt ci @mcek hjas tmrjuhm wctm tma axpjrt ji tma twj rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke wctmjut
lanjestrktceh tmkt tma trkla cs dahctcnktady hrkeliktmaral, tma EPH–s `ralcbcdcty wcdd ba
lknkhal.
\ma EPH–s Radktcjesmcp Xctm tma EV\ keltma [uastcje ji Iutura Nanbarsmcp
Mjw tma EPH raspjels tj tma @mceasa `mkddaeha smjudl ba ceijrnal by cts `jesclarktcje
ji twj brjklar cssuas tmkt mkva `jna tj tma ijra ks k `jesaquae`a ji tma la`cscje by tma
EPH ce 266= tj hrket tma ax`aptcje tj Celck7 mjw tj nkekha tma EPH–s radktcjesmcp
wctm stktas jutscla tma krrkehanaet“ce`dulceh tmjsa wctmjut `jnpramaescva skiahukrlskhraanaets“kel mjw tma EPH laeas ctsadi wctm raspa`t tj tma EV\. \ma EPH–s axparc-
ae`a ce ce`jrpjrktceh @mcek cetj tma hrjup smjudl ba `jesclaral ce key iutura axpkescje
ji tma EPH bayjel tma prasaet pkrtc`cpktcje ji <9 hjvarenaets.
Xcdd tma EV\ ce tma iutura sarva ks k iuelknaetkd ejrn kel pjcet ji raiarae`a ijr
tma EPH–s trkla rudas: Kt tma @kreahca wjrosmjp, ej `dakr `jesaesus wks axprassal je
tmcs quastcje, but ct wks kppkraet tj nkey pkrtc`cpkets tmkt tma Celck ax`aptcje tj tma
iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls raqucranaet mkl raelaral k lcs`usscje ji tmkt cssua by tma EPH–s
pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tcnady kel assaetckd.
Ce Paptanbar 266=, @mcek gjceal tma `jesaesus la`cscje ji EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjv-
arenaets tj hrket Celck tma ax`aptcje irjn tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls raqucranaet. Celadcbarktcjes baijra tmkt la`cscje wks nkla, @mcek mkl urhal tma hrjup tj kllrass Celck–s
raquast ijr tma ax`aptcje ce k ejelcs`rcncektceh
nkeear, cnpdyceh, ce tma vcaw ji sjna pkrtc`cpkt-
ceh hjvarenaets, tmkt Csrkad kel Vkocstke smjudl
kdsj ba `jesclaral ks pjsscbdy adchcbda tj trkla wctm
EPH suppdcars.
CKAK Lcra`tjr Haearkd Njmknnal AdBkrklac
mks jpaedy aeljrsal tma Q.P.-Celck lakd sce`a
2669.<; Ce bcdktarkd naatcehs wctm CKAK nanbar
stktas, AdBkrklac kdsj axprassal tma vcaw tmkt, ce
tma sjnawmkt djehar tarn, ce tma cetarast ji eje-
lcs`rcncektcje, bjtm Csrkad kel Vkocstke smjudl ba ce`dulal by tma EPH ks pkrtears ce
tma eu`dakr trkla rahcna kdjehscla Celck.<2 AdBkrklac kdsj suhhastal ce k 2669 pubdcsmal
alctjrckd tmkt tma eu`dakr suppdy rahcna ba aedkrhal tj ce`dula Vkocstke kel Csrkad, sce`a
—jur trklctcjekd strktahy ji traktceh su`m stktas ks jutsclars cs ej djehar k rakdcstc` natmjl
ji brcehceh tmasa dkst iaw ̀ juetrcas cetj tma ijdl.„<0
But ks savarkd wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets uelardceal, irjn ;331, kdd EV\ pkrtcas“wmc`m
by tmae ce`dulal kdd suppdcar stktas ce tma EPH“khraal tmkt, ks k `jelctcje ijr tma
\ma EPH–s axparcae`a ce ce`jrpjrktceh @mcek
cetj tma hrjup smjudl ba `jesclaral ce key
iutura axpkescje ji tma EPH bayjel tma
prasaet pkrtc`cpktcje ji <9 hjvarenaets.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 25/70
;= | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
celaecta axtaescje ji tma EV\, —Eaw suppdy krrkehanaets … smjudl raqucra, ks k ea`-
asskry pra`jelctcje, k``aptke`a ji CKAK iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls kel cetarektcjekddy dahkddy
bcelceh ̀ jnnctnaets ejt tj k`qucra eu`dakr wakpjes jr jtmar eu`dakr axpdjscva lavc`as.„
\mkt pdalha wks rakirnal by tma suppdcar stktas lurceh EV\ ravcaw `jeiarae`as ce 2666
kel 26;6. Ct wks kbrjhktal ce 266= wmae tma EPH prjvclal tma ax`aptcje ijr Celck.
Ce dcea wctm stktanaets tmkt @mceasa raprasaetktcvas nkla lurceh EPH ladcbarktcjes
ce 2661 (wmae tma Qectal Ptktas ceijrnal EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ji cts cetae-
tcje tj eahjtckta k eu`dakr `jjparktcje khraanaet wctm Celck), Q.P. ji`ckds mkl `jescl-
aral lcs`ussceh ce tma EPH k `rctarck-bksal kpprjk`m ijr ke ax`aptcje tj tma iudd-s`jpa
skiahukrls raqucranaet ce tma hucladceas tmkt, ce prce`cpda, `judl ba kppdcal tj key stkta
jutscla tma EV\ tmkt lascral k``ass tj eu`dakr trkla. \ma Q.P. la`cscje tj saao k —scehudkr
ax`aptcje„ ijr Celck cestakl wks prjnptal by pjdctc`kd axpalcae`y. \ma Qectal Ptktas dcn-
ctal cts suppjrt ijr ke ax`aptcje ijr Celck kdjea ba`kusa ct badcaval tmkt dakvceh jpae tma
pjsscbcdcty tmkt Csrkad kel Vkocstke wjudl kdsj ba hcvae ax`aptcjes wjudl mkva prjvjoal
rn jppjsctcje irjn nkey `juetrcas. Ke ax`aptcje ijr Csrkad aspa`ckddy wjudl hcva rcsa
tj strjeh jbga`tcjes irjn Krkb stktas. Ct wjudl mkva baae pjsscbda, ji`ckds skcl kt tma
tcna, ijr tma Qectal Ptktas kel jtmar EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj lrkit `rctarck
tmkt Celck `judl naat but Vkocstke `judl ejt? mjwavar, Q.P. ji`ckds kssunal tmkt key
`rctarck tmkt Celck nat `judl kdsj ba nat by Csrkad.<< \ma Qectal Ptktas ceijrnal Csrkad kt
tma mchmast davad ji hjvarenaet tmkt ct wjudl ejt suppjrt k bcl by Csrkad ijr ke ax`aptcje
tj EPH trkla rudas, kitar Csrkad mkl parscstaetdy djbbcal je bamkdi ji su`m ke ax`aptcje.<1
\mraa yakrs kitar tma EPH hrketal tma Celck ax`aptcje, @kreahca wketal tj nkoa k
lcs`usscje pjsscbda lurceh tma Brussads wjrosmjp kbjut wmatmar tma hrjup cs prapkral
tj `jesclar ce`dulceh jtmar stktas jutscla tma EV\ tmkt kra `kpkbda ji suppdyceh eu`dakr
nktarckds kel aqucpnaet. @kreahca cevctal wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets irjn Celck, Csrkad, kelVkocstke tj `jesclar tma krhunaets ijr kel khkcest parncttceh tmasa `juetrcas tj pkrtc`c-
pkta ce tma EPH ce tma iutura.
Jea pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt, bahceeceh krjuel 2666, k bcdktarkd Q.P.-Celck prj`ass wks
dkue`mal tj ijrn k bcdktarkd strktahc` pkrtearsmcp. \mcs prj`ass bahke kitar Celck mkl
lanjestrktal cts `jnnctnaet tj `jetrjddceh tma sprakl ji wakpjes ji nkss lastru`tcje
kel mkl straehtmaeal cts axpjrt `jetrjd systan. Celck, ma skcl, cs ejw `jnncttal tj
qukdciyceh ijr nanbarsmcp ce tma EPH kel jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkeha-
naets. Celck cs kdsj `jnncttal tj k ncecnun `ralcbda latarrae`a strktahc` lj`trcea ijr
cts eu`dakr wakpjes kel saaos k``ass tj urkecun, eu`dakr aqucpnaet, kel ta`mejdjhy tj
bucdl up cts eu`dakr pjwar haearktceh ceirkstru`tura ce tma cetarast ji a`jejnc` lavadjp-naet kel `dcnkta `mkeha nctchktcje.
Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt, uedcoa Celck, Csrkad cs `urraetdy ejt prapkral tj anbkro
je k eu`dakr pjwar prjhrkn tmkt wjudl rady je cnpjrts ji `jetrjddal ctans irjn EPH-
pkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas. Csrkad, mjwavar, mks baae kppdyceh tma EPH hucladceas sce`a tma
;336s, kel ce 266< prjnudhktal axpjrt `jetrjd raqucranaets ijr eu`dakr, bcjdjhc`kd, kel
`manc`kd ctans. \ma pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt `urraet kel iutura prjdciarktcje tmrakts ik`al
by EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas bakr ej radktcje tj wmatmar tma tmrakts jrchcektal irjn
EV\ jr eje-EV\ stktas.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 26/70
Nkro Mcbbs | ;3
Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket kdsj radktal tmkt, bjtm ce tma pkst kel tma prasaet, tma EPH ik`al
prjdciarktcje `mkddaehas irjn k eunbar ji EV\ stktas, ce`dulceh Crkq, Crke, Dcbyk, kel
Ejrtm Ojrak. Ce kllctcje, ma skcl, tma Omke eatwjro jparktal je tma tarrctjrcas kel wctm
madp irjn celcvclukds irjn kbjut 06 EV\ `juetrcas. Vkocstke mks baae cevjdval ce tma
EPH–s jutrak`m prjhrkn sce`a 2662, ma skcl, ce`dulceh k vcsct tj Vkocstke by tma EPH ce
2661. Ce 266<, Vkocstke astkbdcsmal k `jnpramaescva axpjrt `jetrjd systan kel, baijra
tmkt, k ektcjekd ̀ jnnkel kutmjrcty raspjescbda ijr ̀ jetrjd ji Vkocstke–s strktahc` kssats. Ci
tma wkcvar ijr Celck wara haearkdczal je tma bkscs ji `rctarck, Vkocstke `judl ba axanptal
irjn tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls raqucranaet kel ba ce`jrpjrktal cetj tma EPH ks k eu`dakr
suppdcar stkta? Vkocstke wjudl ba wcddceh tj eahjtckta tma tarns ji su`m ke ax`aptcje.
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp irjn EPH hjvarenaet ladahktcjes skcl kitar tma
lcs`usscje `je`areceh tma EPH–s radktcjesmcp wctm Celck, Csrkad, kel Vkocstke tmkt tmay
wara ejt `jevce`al tmkt tma EPH smjudl axpkel cts nanbarsmcp tj ce`dula tmasa `jue-
trcas. Jtmars suhhastal lurceh tma naatceh tmkt, ci, ks ketc`cpktal, tma EPH–s 26;; pdaekry
naatceh jea njetm dktar rak`mal k ̀ jesaesus khraanaet je eaw hucladceas ijr aerc`mnaet
kel raprj`assceh (AER) trkesiars, tma eaw `jelctcjes ijr tmcs trkla wjudl raqucra EV\
nanbarsmcp by ra`cpcaet stktas. \mkt jut`jna, tmay skcl, wjudl rafla`t k `juetarrak`tcje
jr raflax by nkey EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ce tma kitarnktm ji tma Q.P.-Celck lakd
kel tma EPH ax`aptcje ijr Celck, tkoceh cetj k``juet `rctc`csn ji tmjsa lavadjpnaets
irjn eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas ce tma EV\. K``jrlceh tj tmcs vcaw, tma raqucranaet
tmkt k ra`cpcaet eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stkta nust ba ke EV\ pkrty wks naket tj —rakssura„
eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas ce tma EV\ tmkt tma EV\ wjudl `jetceua tj ba vcawal by
EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ks ke cnpjrtket cetarektcjekd ejrn, kel tmkt, ce tma
iutura, tma EPH, ks jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket put ct, —wjudl ejt nkoa tma ax`aptcje ijr
Celck cetj k haearkd ruda ijr Csrkad kel Vkocstke.„ Jea axpjrt `jetrjd prk`tctcjear kt tma wjrosmjp skcl tmkt —ke ax`aptcje `ke ba`jna tma ejrn vary, vary quc`ody. \ma EPH mks
tj ba vary `kraiud kbjut tma ejrns, kel C lje–t tmceo tmkt ct cs baceh `kraiud aejuhm.„
Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt, wmae tma EPH tkoas up pjsscbda iutura pkrtc`cpktcje ji
eje-EV\ stktas, tma hrjup —cs hattceh cetj vary iuelknaetkd cssuas,„ sce`a, ci nanbars
tkoa ijr hrketal tmkt EV\ nanbarsmcp cs k `rctarcje ijr EPH nanbarsmcp, tmkt —wjudl
cnpdy tmkt eje-EV\ stktas wjudl mkva tj lcskrn ks k ̀ jelctcje ijr nanbarsmcp„“wmc`m
cs mkrldy k dcoady jut`jna.
But mcstjrc`kddy, pkrtc`cpkets pjcetal jut, tma EPH–s radktcjesmcp wctm tma EV\ mks
baae knbcvkdaet. \ma hrjup wks astkbdcsmal by stktas tmkt badcaval tmkt tma EV\ lcl ejt
sui`a tj pravaet tma sprakl ji eu`dakr wakpjes, kel cts jrchcekd nanbarsmcp ce`dulaltwj `juetrcas tmkt wara ejt EV\ pkrtcas. \ma EPH–s nanbars khraal tj raqucra iudd-
s`jpa skiahukrls ks k suppdy `jelctcje ce tma skna yakr tmkt Irke`a kel @mcek“tma jedy
twj EPH nanbars jutscla tma EV\“k``alal tj tmkt trakty.
Kt tma Brussads wjrosmjp, @kreahca lcstrcbutal k lcs`usscje pkpar tmkt jutdceal pjtae-
tckd baeats kel lci`udtcas smjudl tma EPH pursua k `rctarck-bksal kpprjk`m tj avaetu-
kddy parnct @mcek tj axpjrt pjwar rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke, kel lcs`ussal mjw @mcek nchmt
ba ce`aetcvczal tj khraa tj suspael cts `jnnar`a wctm Vkocstke ijr ks djeh ks ct tkoas tj
eahjtckta kpprjprckta ̀ rctarck tmkt wjudl rasudt ce ̀ dakr baeats ce eu`dakr ejeprjdciarktcje
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 27/70
26 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
kel sa`urcty. Papkrktady, @kreahca dktar pubdcsmal ke axpkelal varscje ji tmcs pkpar jut-
dceceh su`m k pjsscbda kpprjk`m.<9
Lurceh tma wjrosmjp, sjna pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal k dcst ji pjsscbda `rctarck ijr ke
ax`aptcje tj tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls raqucranaet tmkt nchmt kppdy tj key stkta wctm-
jut k `jnpramaescva CKAK skiahukrls khraanaet. Knjeh tma prjpjsal raqucranaets
naetcjeal wara7 ke Ceijrnktcje @cr`udkr (Cei`cr`)/99 skiahukrls khraanaet wctm tma
CKAK aesurceh tmkt CKAK skiahukrls wjudl ba kppdcal ce parpatucty je kdd skiahukrlal
k`tcvctcas ce tma `juetry? ke Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd wctm tma CKAK? rktc`ktcje ji tma
@jnpramaescva Eu`dakr-\ast-Bke \rakty kel, paelceh cts aetry cetj ijr`a, k njrktjrcun
je eu`dakr tasts? klmarae`a tj tma EPH hucladceas kel tj tma ejrns ji jtmar nudtcdktarkd
axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets? rjbust axpjrt `jetrjd dahcsdktcje? rktc`ktcje ji tma 2661
knaelal @jevaetcje je tma Vmysc`kd Vrjta`tcje ji Eu`dakr Nktarckd (Cei`cr`/28</Rav.1)
kel tma @jevaetcje ijr tma Pupprasscje ji K`ts ji Eu`dakr \arrjrcsn? kel `jnnctnaet
tj Ptap 0 ji tma ;0 Ptaps khraal tj by EV\ pkrtcas ce tma ekd lj`unaet ji tma 2666
EV\ ravcaw `jeiarae`a, tjwkrl `je`duscje ji k Icsscda Nktarckd @ut-Jii \rakty. Ijr tma
`ksa ji Vkocstke, tma @kreahca pkpars suhhastal kllctcjekd `jelctcjes ijr k iutura EPH
ax`aptcje, ce`dulceh `juetartarrjrcsn, eu`dakr skiaty kel sa`urcty jbdchktcjes, kel staps
Vkocstke wjudl mkva tj tkoa tj la-as`kdkta cts eu`dakr radktcjesmcp wctm Celck kel pravaet
k rahcjekd eu`dakr krns bucdlup.
\ma @kreahca pkpars bahke wctm tma prancsa tmkt @mcek, ce tma wkoa ji tma savara
k``claet kt tmraa pjwar rak`tjrs kt Iuousmcnk-Lkcc`mc ce Gkpke, `urraetdy nchmt ba pra-
pkral tj ra`jesclar cts axpjrt tj Vkocstke, sce`a ks k `jesaquae`a ji tma k``claet ce Gkpke,
@mcek wcdd dcoady ce 26;2 klgust cts ljnastc` rak`tjr ta`mejdjhy lapdjynaet strktahy tj
bucdl eawar njlads kel ax`dula tma lasche raprasaetal by @mksmnk-0 kel -<. Bacgceh
`judl `jesclar lavadjpceh, tjhatmar wctm jtmar EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, `rctarcktmkt ̀ judl ba sat ks k ykrlstc`o ijr iutura bcdktarkd trkla wctm stktas wctmjut ̀ jnpramaescva
skiahukrls khraanaets. \j ae`jurkha @mcek tj pkrtkoa ce su`m lcs`usscjes, EPH suppdcar
stktas `judl `jnnct tmansadvas tj ik`cdctkta @mcek–s pkrtc`cpktcje ce cetarektcjekd prjg-
a`ts tj axpjrt njlare pjwar rak`tjrs tj nkroats jutscla Vkocstke. @mceasa pkrtc`cpktcje
cs `urraetdy savarady dcnctal by cetadda`tukd prjparty rchmts cssuas, sce`a @mcek cs usceh
ijrache ta`mejdjhy ce njst ji tma rak`tjrs ct cs bucdlceh. Ba`kusa tma EPH irjn ;331
tmrjuhm 26;6 mks `jnncttal kel ra`jnncttal ctsadi tj tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls suppdy
`jelctcje, ct wks kdsj klvcsal tmkt key EPH `jesclarktcje lapkrtceh irjn tmkt uelar-
stkelceh smjudl ba lcs`ussal wctm EV\ eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stkta pkrtcas.
\ma pjtaetckd baeats ji su`m ke kpprjk`m kra7
• astkbdcsmceh k prj`ass ijr tma djeh-tarn cetahrktcje ji eje-EV\ pkrtcas cetj tma
eu`dakr trkla rahcna?
• prjvclceh k wky tj cetahrkta @mcek–s eu`dakr `jnnar`a wctm Vkocstke cetj ke
EPH irknawjro k``aptkbda tj kdd EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets?
• hcvceh kssurke`as tmkt Vkocstke–s iutura eu`dakr lavadjpnaet wjudl tkoa pdk`a
uelar sustkcekbda, skia, kel sa`ura `jelctcjes kel wjudl prjvcla eu`dakr sa`urcty
kel ejeprjdciarktcje baeats? kel
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 28/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 2;
\mara cs `urraetdy ej `jesaesus ce tma EPH
kbjut mjw ct smjudl kpprjk`m tma quastcje
ji iutura radktcjes wctm eje-EV\ pkrtcas.
• ce`aetcvczceh @mcek tj pdky k hraktar kel `jestru`tcva rjda ce tma smkpceh ji tma
eu`dakr trkla rahcna.
\ma pjtaetckd lrkwbk`os ji su`m ke kpprjk`m ce`dula7
• pjsscbda khhrkvktcje ji tma radktcjesmcp batwaae eu`dakr suppdcar stktas kel nkeyeje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas ce tma EV\? kel
• ke ueikvjrkbda `jst-baeat rktcj, su`m tmkt tma nkce lascral jut`jna lrcvceh tma
prj`ass“`cr`uns`rcbceh Pcej-Vkocstkec eu`dakr trkla“nky ba ejt schec`ket
aejuhm ijr EPH pkrtc`cpkets tj cevast ce k `jnpdax kel lcff`udt eahjtcktcje
jvar trkla `jelctcjes wctm Vkocstke.
Cetarvaetcjes by wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmara cs `urraetdy ej ̀ jesaesus ce tma
EPH kbjut mjw ct smjudl kpprjk`m tma quastcje ji iutura radktcjes wctm eje-EV\ pkrtcas.
K iaw pkrtc`cpkets lraw pkrkddads batwaae tma sctuktcje ik`al by tma EPH tjlky kel
tmkt ae`juetaral by @j`jn
<8
bahceeceh ce ;332, smjrtdy kitar `jddkpsa ji tma PjvcatQecje, kel prcjr tj @j`jn–s su``asscje ce ;339 by tma Xkssaekkr Krrkehanaet. Dcoa
Xkssaekkr, jea pkrtc`cpket skcl, tma EPH —mks ej prataetcjes tj uecvarskdcty.„ Ijddjwceh
tma 266= ax`aptcje ijr Celck, ma skcl, tma EPH cs —iraa tj `mjjsa wmc`m rjkl ct smjudl
ijddjw,„ kdchenaet wctm tma EV\, jr cestakl k pktm tmkt ce tma iutura wcdd haearkdcza tma
—scehudkr ax`aptcje„ prjvclal tj Celck tj jtmar eje-
EV\ pkrtcas kel `jesclar tman ks iutura nanbar-
smcp `kelclktas. —Ke EV\ `jnnctnaet kel tma
Celcke ax`aptcje kra ejt `jnpktcbda, sj wmara ljas
tma EPH wket tj hj:„ ma ksoal.
Ejt kdd pkrtc`cpkets ikvjral tma ce`duscje ji
bjtm Vkocstke kel Csrkad cetj tma krrkehanaet. Jea
Aurjpake pkrtc`cpket axprassdy klvj`ktal eahj-
tcktceh ke avaetukd ax`aptcje ijr Vkocstke je tma
hrjuels tmkt ct nchmt prjvcla —tkehcbda baeats„ su`m ks tmjsa pjstudktal by tma @kreahca
pkpar. But ma lcl ejt ikvjr hrketceh su`m ke ax`aptcje tj Csrkad, ce pkrt ba`kusa ct wjudl
—`kusa k djt ji uerast ce tma EKN… . Xara Vkocstke tj ba hrketal ke _ax`aptcje^, C lje–t
tmceo tmara wjudl ba ke uprjkr.„ Kejtmar Aurjpake pkrtc`cpket uelars`jral tma pjsscbcd-
cty tmkt, smjudl staps ba tkoae tj njva `djsar tj k``aptceh eje-EV\ stktas ks nanbars,
ejt kdd ji tmasa wjudl ba traktal aqukddy. —\ma EPH cs k pjdctc`kd kel lcpdjnktc` rahcna.
\mus, ct cs kbjut pjdctc`kd `jesaesus-bucdlceh kel wmkt cs pjsscbda kel ejt ea`asskrcdy
wmkt cs djhc`kd.„
\mcs pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt tma EPH —eaals njra tmke avar k `jesudtktcva na`mkecsn
tmkt jpaes tma wky ijr ce-laptm ̀ jesudtktcjes wctm bjtm kspcrceh EPH pkrtears kel ̀ jue-
trcas jutscla tma EPH. Celaal sjna ji tma daklceh ̀ juetrcas ce tma EKN ̀ judl ikdd wctmce
tmkt `ktahjry. \ma EPH `judl try tj sat up sjna sjrt ji `jesudtktcva ijrnkt„ scncdkr tj
tma Ejrtm Ktdketc` @jjparktcje @jue`cd ijr `juetrcas tmkt kra ejt nanbars ji EK\J.
\mkt bjly, ma skcl, avaetukddy —ba`kna k parnkeaet na`mkecsn ijr ̀ jesudtktcje batwaae
_EK\J^ kel `juetrcas jutscla.„ Xara su`m k na`mkecsn tj ba astkbdcsmal ijr tma EPH,
ma skcl, ct wjudl ba up tj tma pkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas tj la`cla mjw —`djsa„ tj tma EPH
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 29/70
22 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
tmay wcsmal tma jutsclars tj ba, but tma na`mkecsn wjudl kdsj —kddjw _k ejenanbar^ tj
la`cla tj ba`jna ke kspcrceh nanbar ji tma EPH.„
But, skcl kejtmar pkrtc`cpket, ej su`m na`mkecsn ce tma EPH prasaetdy axcsts.
@jesclarktcje by tma EPH ji eaw `kelclktas ijr nanbarsmcp —ljase–t wjro dcoa tmkt.„
Xmkt mkppaes, ma skcl, cs tmkt k `juetry saaoceh nanbarsmcp ce tma EPH —prasaets ke
cectcktcva„ tj tma EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets. —Ci tma cectcktcva cs k``aptal, tma `jue-
try cs ̀ jesclaral. Ci ejt, wa tmkeo tma ̀ juetry kel tadd ct, tmcs cs ejt tma tcna, wa wcdd ̀ jna
bk`o tj yju kt k hjjl tcna. Kel tmkt–s ct.„
\ma ̀ jevaetcjekd krhunaet ikvjrceh k strjeh kdchenaet batwaae tma EPH kel EV\ cs
tmkt tma EPH–s suppdcar stktas“kdd ji tman ejw EV\ pkrtcas“kra ̀ jnncttal tj k —hrkel
bkrhkce„ k``jrlceh tj wmc`m tmay nust prjvcla eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas k``ass tj trkla
kel ta`mejdjhy ce ax`mkeha ijr tmacr `jetceual raeue`cktcje ji eu`dakr wakpjes. Jea
Ksck-Vk`c` pkrtc`cpket suhhastal tmkt k `rctarck-bksal kpprjk`m tj eje-EV\ stktas nchmt
rasudt ce tma EV\–s eje‐eu`dakr wakpje stktas dakvceh tma trakty. —Ci yju kddjw _eje-
EV\ stktas^ ce wctmjut tman hcvceh up tmacr eu`dakr wakpjes prjhrkns … tmara wcdd ba
k tanptktcje ijr `juetrcas tj rst hj eu`dakr kel tmae gjce tma axpjrt `jetrjd rahcnas. Pj
Ejrtm Ojrak wcdd ijddjw Celck kel Vkocstke … kel tmcs `judl sarcjusdy uelarncea tma
EPH rahcna.„ Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket irjn tma skna rahcje ksoal tma skna quastcje, kdbact
irknal by Crke. —Xa sct ce tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs _naatcehs^ kel jitae makr Crke
skyceh tmkt _EV\ nanbarsmcp^ `jnas wctm k wmjda djkl ji jbdchktcjes kel ejt nu`m
baeat. Xjudle–t `mkehceh tma EPH nanbarsmcp `rctarck iaal Crke–s krhunaet:„
But jea pkrtc`cpket vjc`al wmkt ma ̀ kddal k —maratc`kd tmascs„ tmkt tma kssunptcje tmkt tma
EPH–s axtaelceh eu`dakr trkla prcvcdahas tj Celck kel jtmar stktas jutscla tma EV\ wjudl
dakl tj hraktar prjdciarktcje kel laia`tcjes irjn tma EV\ cs —ke ueprjvae jea.„ Dcbyk, Crkq,
Crke, kel Ejrtm Ojrak lcl ejt njva ijrwkrl wctm `dkelastcea eu`dakr prjhrkns ba`kusatma EPH wks lcs`rcncektceh khkcest tman ce ikvjr ji eje-EV\ stktas, ma skcl.
Ce ;338, ks pkrt ji cts jutrak`m prjhrkn, tma EPH pubdcsmal k lj`unaet tctdal —\ma
Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup7 Cts Jrchces, Rjda, kel K`tcvctcas„ ks Cei`cr`/103.<= \ma jrchc-
ekd varscje ce`dulal k rubrc` `kddal —nanbarsmcp.„ \ma njst ra`aet varscje, Cei`cr`/103/
Rav.<, `kdds tmcs —pkrtc`cpktcje„ cestakl. Jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket cevjdval ce lrkitceh
tmkt lj`unaet skcl tmkt tma ra`aet dkehukha wks naket tj lcs`jurkha `juetrcas jutscla
tma EPH irjn `je`dulceh tmkt tma suppdcars hrjup wks k —`dub„ jr k `krtad. Ce tma iutura,
—pkrtc`cpktcje„ nchmt kdsj cnpdy, uedcoa —nanbarsmcp,„ tmkt `juetrcas nchmt anbrk`a
tma kspcrktcjes kel klmara tj tma hucladceas ji tma EPH wctmjut tkoceh k`tcva pkrt ce
cts la`cscjenkoceh. Ce kdd `jesa`utcva varscjes ji Cei`cr`/103 sce`a ;338, tma lj`unaetaxpdkces tmkt tmara kra —ik`tjrs„“ejt ̀ rctarck“tmkt kra —tkoae cetj k``juet„ ijr nanbar-
smcp/pkrtc`cpktcje. \masa —ce`dula … klmarae`a tj jea jr njra traktcas, su`m ks tma EV\,
tma \raktcas ji \dktadjd`j, Rkrjtjehk, Vadcelkbk, Bkehojo, jr ke aqucvkdaet cetarektcjekd
eu`dakr eje-prjdciarktcje khraanaet _kel^ iudd `jnpdcke`a wctm tma jbdchktcjes ji su`m
khraanaet(s).„
—Xa mkva tj rananbar tmkt _Cei`cr`/103^ stktas tmkt nanbarsmcp ce tma EV\ cs jea ji
tma `ru`ckd ik`tjrs ce la`clceh nanbarsmcp _ce tma EPH^, kel ci _jtmar `rctarck^ kra ejw
tj ba `jesclaral, wa mkva tj `jesclar wmy EV\ nanbarsmcp wks sat ks k ik`tjr ce tma
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 30/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 20
rst pdk`a,„ jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket skcl. Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket, mjwavar, `mkddaehal tma
kssunptcje tmkt tma EPH nust celaectady usa tma EV\ ks k bae`mnkro ijr nanbar-
smcp. —Ce tma bahceeceh, tmara wks ej lcra`t dceo batwaae tma EPH kel tma EV\ ba`kusa
tma suppdcars jrhkeczal tmansadvas tj `jestrkce Irke`a tj k``apt sjna rudas rahkrlceh
axpjrts.„ EPH pkrtc`cpkets smjudl tmaraijra —quastcje wmy tma EPH mks baae sj praj``u-
pcal wctm jea pkrtc`udkr `jelctcje ji suppdy“nanbarsmcp ce tma EV\“aspa`ckddy sce`a
tma _EPH^ jrchcekddy eavar ijrnkddy raiarral tj tma EV\. Xmy lcle–t _tma EPH^ spael
njra tcna laeceh jtmar `jelctcjes ji suppdy:„
Pmjrtdy kitar tma wjrosmjp kel baijra tma 26;; EPH pdaekry naatceh madl jea njetm
dktar, tma Qectal Ptktas ̀ cr`udktal tj EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets k pkpar tctdal —Ijjl
ijr \mjuhmt„<3 ̀ je`areceh tma cssua ji nanbarsmcp. \ma pkpar wks lrkital kitar Vrasclaet
Jbknk keejue`al tmcs pkst Ejvanbar tmkt tma Qectal Ptktas suppjrtal tma ce`duscje
ji Celck ks k iudd nanbar ce tma EPH.16 K``jrlcehdy, tma pkpar lcl ejt prjpjsa tmkt tma
EV\ smjudl ba sat ijrtm ks k `rctarcje ijr iutura EPH nanbarsmcp.
Q.P. klvj`k`y ji Celcke nanbarsmcp ce tma EPH bahceeceh ce dkta 26;6 prjnptal
sjna jtmar EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj jbga`t tj tma Qectal Ptktas tmkt iudd nan-
barsmcp wjudl parnct Celck tj bdj`o `jesaesus la`cscjenkoceh ce tma hrjup ce tma iutura
ba`kusa, ks jea pkrtc`cpket ce tma wjrosmjp skcl, —tmara cs k ̀ je`are, avae k suspc`cje, tmkt
Celck–s khaelk cs tj ravarsa tma trael ji tma EPH sce`a tma ;336s„ tjwkrl tma tchmtaeceh
ji eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds.
Lurceh prapkrktcje ji tma nanbarsmcp pkpar, Q.P. ji`ckds ceijrnal ijrache EPH
`juetarpkrts tmkt tma Qectal Ptktas nchmt kpprjk`m tma cssua ji Celcke nanbarsmcp by
`jesclarceh Celck k —dcoa-ncelal„ stkta tmkt smkral tma EPH–s jvarkdd kspcrktcjes kel
ejrns. Pjna pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp, mjwavar, vjc`al rasarvktcjes kbjut tmcs
kpprjk`m, sce`a tma laectcje ji —dcoa-ncelal„ wjudl ea`asskrcdy ba subga`tcva, kelk la`cscje by EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ks tj wmatmar Celck wks —dcoa-ncelal„
wjudl ba latarnceal k``jrlceh tj tma ektcjekd cetarast ji ak`m pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet.
Lurceh tma eahjtcktcje ji eaw hucladceas ijr aerc`mnaet kel raprj`assceh, ̀ jesaesus wks
ejt pjsscbda uetcd k eunbar ji prjpjsal subga`tcva `jelctcjes wara ladatal irjn tma taxt.
—Xa kra prapkral tj `jetceua tj lcs`uss _prjspa`ts ijr Celcke nanbarsmcp^, but wa
wje–t hj iurtmar uedass Celck prasaets k vary `jevce`ceh krhunaet,„ jea wjrosmjp pkr-
tc`cpket skcl. Nanbarsmcp ijr Csrkad kel Vkocstke wara `urraetdy ejt je tma khaelk ji tma
hrjup kt tma tcna tma wjrosmjp wks madl.
Jea ji tma —ik`tjrs„ `jesclaral ijr pkrtc`cpktcje ce tma EPH uelar Cei`cr`/103 cs
—tma kbcdcty tj suppdy ctans (ce`dulceh ctans ce trkesct) `jvaral by tma keeaxas ji Vkrts ;kel 2 ji tma EPH hucladceas.„ Ks jea pkrtc`cpket tjdl tma EPH sancekr ce ;338, —Key
`juetry wmc`m mks k nk`mcea tjjd smjp `judl ba tma suppdcar ji aspa`ckddy lascheal jr
prapkral `jnpjeaets irjn tma trchhar dcst.„1; Jea pkrtc`cpket ce tma Brussads wjrosmjp
skcl mcs hjvarenaet mks astcnktal tmkt kbjut ;;6 `juetrcas `ke suppdy eu`dakr lukd-usa
aqucpnaet, kel, bksal je wmkt wks ravakdal kbjut tma k`tcvctcas ji tma Omke eatwjro,
—vcrtukddy key ji tmasa ̀ judl ba sat up tj nkeuik`tura kt dakst sjna trchhar dcst ctans.„ \ma
EV\, tmaraijra, —̀ ke–t ba tma udtcnkta ykrlstc`o ijr EPH nanbarsmcp ce tma iutura ci jur
hjkd cs tj `kptura kdd suppdcars ji eu`dakr ctans.„
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 31/70
2< | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Ce tma iutura, tma anarhae`a ji eaw
`ustjns uecjes ce Kirc̀ k, tma Ksck-
Vk`c`, tma Ncllda Akst, kel @aetrkd kel
Pjutm Knarc`k wcdd `mkddaeha tma EPH.
Lurceh tma ;338 kel ;333 EPH jutrak`m sancekrs, sjna pkrtc`cpkets wkreal tmkt
ce`raksceh tma scza ji tma hrjup wjudl raelar ct eakrdy cnpjsscbda tj rak`m `jesaesus je
iutura cssuas, ce`dulceh je tma njst cnpjrtket subga`ts, su`m ks tma `jetaet ji `jetrjd
dcsts kel tma `jelctcjes ijr trkla ce tma hucladceas. K iaw pkrtc`cpkets ce tmjsa naatcehs
prjpjsal tmkt tma EPH astkbdcsm k —twj-tcar„ nanbarsmcp wctm jea hrjup ji `juetrcas
klmarceh tj tma hucladceas kel k sa`jel hrjup k`tcva ce EPH la`cscjenkoceh. But jtmar
pkrtc`cpkets tmae jiiaral tma vcaw tmkt eaw suppdcar `juetrcas wjudl ejt khraa tj upmjdl
tma hucladceas ci tmay wara ejt parncttal tj iuddy tkoa pkrt ce la`cscjenkoceh. \wc`a
ce tma pkst tae yakrs, tma EPH madl k lcs`usscje je —`ktahjrcas ji nanbarsmcp,„ jea
@kreahca wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket skcl. \mcs —wks lcs`ussal ce vary haearkd tarns,„ but ej
k`tcjes wara tkoae ks k `jesaquae`a.
Kscla irjn tma lkehar tmkt axpkelceh tma nanbarsmcp wcdd nkoa ct dass dcoady tmkt stktas
wcdd rak̀ m `jesaesus, pkrtc`cpkets ce tma Brussads wjrosmjp radktal tmkt, ks nanbarsmcp mks
axpkelal, tmara mkva baae hraktar ̀ je`ares kbjut cetarekd lktk sa`urcty, wmc`m wcdd ce`raksa
iurtmar ks tma EPH ij`usas njra kttaetcje kllrassceh tmrakts irjn ejestkta k`tjrs.
Mjw, jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket ksoal, `judl tma EPH gustciy ax`dulceh, je subga`tcva
pjdctc`kd hrjuels, `juetrcas tmkt mkl lanjestrktal tmkt tmay wara suppdcars ji trchhar dcst
ctans, jr avae aetcra eu`dakr ik`cdctcas, wmae tma hrjup mkl ce`dulal k eunbar ji Aurjpake
`juetrcas tmkt lje–t mkva k trk`o ra`jrl ji suppdyceh key eu`dakr nktarckd jr aqucpnaet:
Njra haearkddy, ks jea pkrtc`cpket adsawmara mkl wrcttae ce ke uepubdcsmal pkpar7
Kllceh eaw stktas wctm lcvarhaet cetarasts nky nkoa ct njra lci`udt tj nkcetkce aiia`tcva
eu`dakr axpjrt stkelkrls jr tj uphrkla tmjsa stkelkrls wmae `cr`unstke`as lc`tkta. Je tma
jtmar mkel, ax`dulceh key stkta tmkt mks tma pjtaetckd tj `kusa lknkha tj tma ejeprjdciark-
tcje rahcna nky nake tmkt su`m k stkta wcdd ejt klmara tj raspjescbda axpjrt pjdc`cas. Pu`m
stktas mkva dcttda ce`aetcva tj klmara tj tma hucladceas ci tmay kra ejt parncttal tj pkrtc`cpktace tma la`cscjes ji tma hrjup.
Jea pkrtc`cpket suhhastal tmkt tma kutjnktc` klncsscje ji kdd Aurjpake Qecje nan-
bars tj tma EPH rkcsal iurtmar quastcjes kbjut tma aqucty kel sustkcekbcdcty ji tma EPH–s
prasaet `jursa je lakdceh wctm pjtaetckd eaw pkr-
tc`cpkets. Kdd 28 nanbars ji tma Aurjpake Qecje
kra iudd pkrtc`cpkets ce tma EPH, but —jedy mkdi ji
tmasa mkva key sarcjus eu`dakr ceirkstru`tura, kel
jedy k iaw ji tmasa kra haeucea eu`dakr suppdcars jr
trkessmcppceh stktas ijr eu`dakr ctans,„ k wjrosmjp
pkrtc`cpket irjn celustry skcl. Kdd AQ nanbarskra klncttal ks EPH pkrtc`cpkets ba`kusa tmay kra
nanbars ji k `ustjns uecje wmara nkey dcstal
hjjls kra rjutceady smcppal k`rjss ektcjekd bjuel-
krcas wctmjut ̀ jetrjds.12 Ce tma iutura, tma anarhae`a ji eaw ̀ ustjns uecjes ce Kirc`k, tma
Ksck-Vk`c`, tma Ncllda Akst, kel @aetrkd kel Pjutm Knarc`k wcdd `mkddaeha tma EPH,
savarkd pkrtc`cpkets wkreal. Jea su`m hrjup ce ijrnktcje cs tma @jjparktcje @jue`cd
ijr tma Krkb Ptktas ji tma Hudi (H@@). Jea H@@ nanbar, tma Qectal Krkb Ancrktas
(QKA), cs `jestru`tceh k eu`dakr pjwar pdket, cs `jesclarceh iutura pkrtc`cpktcje ce tma
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 32/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 21
EPH, kel cs k nkgjr trkesct lastcektcje ijr dkrha knjuets ji lukd-usa hjjls, ks tma cevas-
tchktcje ji tma Omke eatwjro–s k`tcvctcas uelars`jral. Pmjudl tma QKA gjce tma EPH,
astkbdcsmnaet ji k `ustjns uecje ce tma H@@ wjudl cnpdy tmkt Bkmrkce, Ouwkct, Jnke,
[ktkr, Pkulc Krkbck, kel parmkps Gjrlke kel Njrj``j wjudl ba`jna EPH pkrtc`cpkets.
Ce kejtmar `ksa, tma Aurkscke A`jejnc` @jnnuecty, jea pkrtc`cpket axpdkceal, va
`juetrcas kra sattceh up k `ustjns uecje, kel, ce tma prj`ass, ijr kbjut achmt yakrs tmay
mkva kdsj baae astkbdcsmceh k `jnnje systan ji axpjrt `jetrjds. \wj nanbar ji tmcs
hrjup, Russck kel Okzkomstke, kra kdrakly pkrtc`cpktceh ce tma EPH. \mraa njra“
Badkrus, Oyrhyzstke, kel \kgcocstke“sj ikr kra ejt. Pjna suppdcar stktas mkl pravc-
jusdy jbga`tal tj tma klncsscje cetj tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa ji jea ji tmasa, Badkrus, je
hrjuels tmkt ct wks ejt —dcoa-ncelal,„ sce`a Badkrus mkl baae `ctal by tmasa suppdcars ks
baceh ce vcjdktcje ji cetarektcjekd ejrns ijr `jevaetcjekd wakpjes trkla `jvaral by tma
Xkssaekkr Krrkehanaet.
Ks jea pkrtc`cpket sunnkrczal7
\ma EPH mks bahue k prj`ass tj ce`dula tma eje-EV\ stktas wmc`m kra eu`dakr suppdcars.
\ma nkttar nust ba kpprjk`mal `kraiuddy ce jrlar ejt tj uelarncea tma jbga`tcvas ji tma
eje-prjdciarktcje rahcna. Celck–s cetaetcje tj kppdy ijr EPH nanbarsmcp wcdd tast mjw tma
EPH raspjels tj klkptceh tj k eaw cetarektcjekd sa`urcty aevcrjenaet… . \mcs cs sjna-
tmceh tmkt cs `jnceh, ct–s ce tma kcr, kel wcdd mkva tj ba lakdt wctm by iutura EPH `mkcrs.
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets klvcsal tmkt, ci tma EPH njvas iurtmar ce tmcs lcra`tcje, tma `mkcr
smjudl klvj`kta k njra k`tcva jutrak`m rjda ijr tma hrjup ce ̀ jnnuec`ktceh cts cetaetcjes
tj `cvcd sj`caty kel ejepkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas by prjvclceh brcaehs kel bk`ohrjuel
nktarckds. Vrcjr tj tma EPH–s la`cscje ce 266= tj hrket tma ax`aptcje tj Celck, tma EPH
lcl ejt axtaescvady brcai jutsclars, ce`dulceh wjroceh hrjups prapkrceh ijr tma 26;6 EV\
Ravcaw @jeiarae`a, je cts prj`aalcehs.
Pjna wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets axprassal `kutcje kbjut laeceh `rctarck ijr iutura EPH
pkrtc`cpktcje ba`kusa kbsae`a ji `rctarck kiijrls tma hrjup pjdctc`kd flaxcbcdcty. —Rchmt ejw
tma EPH ljase–t mkva mkrl kel ikst ̀ rctarck„ kel ijr k —vary hjjl raksje,„ jea skcl. —\mara
kra ”ik`tjrs–“ejt `rctarck“tj ba tkoae cetj k``juet, kel tmara cs narct ce tmcs kpprjk`m.
\ma ik`tjrs kra qucta `dakr, but tmay–ra ejt rn `rctarck? tmara–s daawky, kel ce pjdctc`s
ct–s kdwkys hjjl tj mkva sjna daawky.„ But jtmar pkrtc`cpkets pjcetal jut tmkt flaxcbcdcty
`jnas kt tma prc`a ji dahctcnk`y, sce`a wctmjut rn `rctarck, la`cscjes kbjut iutura pkr-
tc`cpktcje by jtmar stktas `judl ba latarnceal je k subga`tcva bkscs“ce`dulceh pjtaetckd
`ksas ce wmc`m tma EPH laeal ctsadi ks k hrjup ji —dcoa-ncelal stktas.„ Pubga`tcva gulh-
naets pravkcdal wmae tma EPH hrketal Celck ke ax`aptcje, nkey pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal.
Ks jea pkrtc`cpket sunnkrczal eakr tma ael ji tma wjrosmjp7
Rchmt ejw tmara kra ej raquasts irjn key `juetry tj ba`jna k nanbar ji tma EPH, but
tmara nchmt ba raquasts ce tma iutura. Pu`m raquasts eaal tj ba `jesclaral vary `kraiuddy. Xa
`artkcedy eaal k lcs`usscje kbjut `rctarck, kel tma lcs`usscje kbjut pjtaetckd `rctarck _ce tma
@kreahca pkpar `cr`udktal kt tma wjrosmjp^ wks ke cnpjrtket pkrt ji tmcs sancekr. Ct wks k
surprcsa tmkt tmara anarhal sjna khraanaet mara kbjut wmkt saescbda `rctarck nchmt ba …
but tmcs wcdd ba k lcs`usscje tmkt tkoas k djt ji tcna… . \ma wjrosmjp spaddal jut tmkt tma
EPH stkrtal irjn k pkrklchn tmkt wks `jnpdatady lciiaraet irjn tmkt ji tjlky.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 33/70
29 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Ce ;38<, —k bch ̀ juetry, Celck, mkl ̀ rjssal tma tmrasmjdl ji pjssasscje ji eu`dakr wakp-
jes„ by vcjdktceh pak`aiud-usa `jnnctnaets nkla tj suppdcar stktas. Kejtmar suppdcar,
Irke`a, wks prapkrceh tj axpjrt raprj`assceh ta`mejdjhy tj Vkocstke kel Pjutm Ojrak.
Sat kejtmar, Harnkey, mkl `je`dulal ke knbctcjus eu`dakr pdket kel aerc`mnaet ta`m-
ejdjhy axpjrt lakd wctm ke cnpjrtket `juetry, Brkzcd, wmc`m mkrbjral eu`dakr wakpje
knbctcjes. —\jlky–s pkrklchn cs vary lciiaraet, kel tmkt–s tma raksje wmy wa ik`a tma
quastcje ji pjsscbda eje-EV\ stktas ba`jnceh EPH nanbars ce tma iutura.„
EPH Nanbarsmcp kel tma EV\
\ma EV\ cs k trakty tmkt cs `djsa tj uecvarskd, but ct `keejt ba klkptal. \ma EPH wks ijuelal je
tma bkscs tmkt tma EV\ wjudl ejt sui`a tj mkdt eu`dakr prjdciarktcje, kel twj ji cts jrchcekd savae
nanbars wara ejt EV\ pkrtcas. Qedcoa tma EV\, tma EPH ljas ejt kspcra tj ba uecvarskd, but `ur-raetdy kdd cts pkrtc`cpkets kra EV\ pkrtcas, kel ijr tma dkst itaae yakrs EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh stktas
mkva `jnncttal tmansadvas tj upmjdlceh tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls `jelctcje (kdtmjuhm ce 266=
tmay kbrjhktal tmkt `jnnctnaet). Mjwavar, tmara rankce jtmar eu`dakr suppdcars“wmc`m kdsj
pjssass aerc`mnaet kel raprj`assceh ta`mejdjhy kel mkva eu`dakr wakpjes“jutscla tma EV\.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jelu`t k tmjrjuhm kel systanktc` lcs`usscje ji iutura nanbarsmcp, ce-
`dulceh k `jesclarktcje ji tma Q.P. tmjuhmt pkpar, wmc`m ljas ejt ce`dula EV\ nanbarsmcp
ks k `rctarcje.
• Key lcs`usscje ji `rctarck smjudl ce`dula astkbdcsmnaet ji bae`mnkros ijr su`m `rctarck kel
pjsscbda natrc`s tj latarncea `jnpdcke`a wctm tma `rctarck.
• Ct smjudl lcs`uss wmatmar `jaxcstae`a ji —klmarae`a„ tj hucladceas kel —pkrtc`cpktcje„ ks
sapkrkta `ktahjrcas cs sustkcekbda kel iakscbda.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesclar astkbdcsmnaet ji k njra ijrnkd prj`ass tj `jesudt wctm ejepkrtc`-
cpktceh stktas, nkekha tma hrjup–s radktcjesmcp wctm tmasa `juetrcas, kel prapkra tman ijr
nanbarsmcp ks lcstce`t irjn wkctceh je kel rak`tceh tj uesjdc`ctal cectcktcvas ji celcvclukd
stktas.
• \ma EPH smjudl lcs`uss wctm EK\J cts jrhkeczktcje ijr `jjparktcje wctm ejenanbar
`juetrcas kel kppdy key dassjes dakreal.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesclar rjtktceh nanbarsmcp ce tma @jesudtktcva Hrjup ks k pjsscbda
pkrtckd keswar tj tma `mkddaeha ji hraktar klmarae`a kel pkrtc`cpktcje.
• \ma EPH smjudl `krry jut k systanktc` cevastchktcje ji kdd sjur`as ji dcstal hjjls wjrdl-
wcla tj madp prcjrctcza iutura axpkescje ji pkrtc`cpktcje.
EPH La`cscjenkoceh
\ma EPH, wmc`m ce ;38= khraal je k `jnpdata sat ji cetarektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd hucla-
dceas wctmce tma tmraa yakrs ijddjwceh cts rst `jestctutcva naatceh, bahke ks k snkdd hrjup
ji stktas tmkt mkl nu`m ce `jnnje. Kdd wara lavadjpal `juetrcas wctm klvke`al eu`dakr
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 34/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 28
R&L kel iuad prj`assceh ceirkstru`tura, kdd haearktal ada`trc`cty wctm rak`tjrs, kel kdd
`judl prjlu`a trchhar dcst aqucpnaet.
\ma `urraet <9 pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets raprasaet k ikr njra lcvarsa hrjup ji stktas
irjn avary `jetceaet, ce`dulceh va stktas wctm eu`dakr wakpjes, njst ji tma wjrdl–s
eu`dakr pjwar haearktjrs, sjna stktas tmkt kra jppjsal tj eu`dakr pjwar kel mkva njlast
jr ej suppdcar `kpkbcdctcas, kel sjna lavadjpceh `juetrcas.
Pce`a 266;, nanbarsmcp ce tma EPH mks ce`raksal irjn 03 tj <9 by kllceh @mcek,
@rjktck, Astjeck, C`adkel, Okzkomstke, Dctmukeck, kel Nkdtk. Lurceh tmcs parcjl, tma
EPH mks kdsj tkoae k`tcjes tj prapkra tj k``jnnjlkta njra `juetrcas ks pkrtc`cpkets,
ce pkrtc`udkr by axpkelceh jutrak`m aiijrts tj stktas tmkt nky anarha ks eaw eu`dakr sup-
pdcars ce `jnceh yakrs. \ma jutrak`m prjhrkn ce`dulal bcdktarkd aehkhanaets, ce`dulceh
ta`mec`kd ax`mkehas, wctm Celck, Csrkad, kel Vkocstke, kel cetark`tcjes kel vcscts tj oay
trkesctceh stktas su`m ks tma Qectal Krkb Ancrktas, Nkdkysck, kel Pcehkpjra. \ma EPH–s
jvarrclceh kcn bamcel tmasa k`tcvctcas cs tj uecvarskdcza tma kppdc`ktcje ji cts hucladceas.
Irjn tma jutsat, kdd la`cscjes kbjut tma `jetaet ji hucladceas kel jtmar nkttars mkva
baae nkla by `jesaesus. \ma `jesaesus ruda wks ratkceal kel ractarktal ks tma EPH–s
nanbarsmcp staklcdy ce`raksal, njst ra`aetdy ce tma 2663 ravcscje ji Cei`cr`/103.
Lurceh tma wjrosmjp, mjwavar, pkrtc`cpkets radktal tmkt, ks tma nanbarsmcp mks hrjwe,
`jesaesus ijrnktcje je cnpjrtket la`cscjes mks ba`jna ce`rakscehdy lci`udt. Kitar tma
Qectal Ptktas ce 266< `kddal ijr k ratmceo je rudas hjvareceh tma axpjrt ji aerc`mnaet
kel raprj`assceh ctans ce raspjesa tj tma Omke eatwjro kel 3/;;, ct tjjo tma EPH savae
yakrs tj khraa tj eaw dkehukha ce twj pkrkhrkpms ji tma hucladceas.
K iaw pkrtc`cpkets quastcjeal wmatmar tma `jesaesus ruda wjudl jr smjudl `jetceua
tj ba kppdcal ce tma iutura. \may pjcetal jut tmkt, avae wctmce tma Aurjpake Qecje“k
`jnpkrktcvady mjnjhaejus hrjup ji stktas ce tarns ji tmacr jvarkdd pjdctc`kd, a`jejnc`,kel ta`mejdjhc`kd lavadjpnaet“schec`ket lciiarae`as mkva anarhal ce la`cscjenkoceh
je cnpjrtket EPH nkttars.
Vkrtc`cpkets wkreal, mjwavar, tmkt kbkeljeceh tma `jesaesus ruda ijr la`cscjenkoceh
wjudl cnpdy tmkt vjduetkry hucladceas tmkt kra ejt k``aptal by kdd pkrtc`cpktceh stktas
wjudl ba dass vckbda ba`kusa sjna stktas nchmt ejt ba wcddceh tj klmara tj hucladceas
tmay lj ejt khraa wctm. \mkt, tmay skcl, wks aspa`ckddy tma `ksa ijr aiijrts by tma hrjup tj
khraa tmkt tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd smjudl ba k `jelctcje ijr kdd eu`dakr trkla. Ci tmcs wara
la`clal wctmjut k `jesaesus, tmkt `judl dakl sjna stktas tj lavadjp saesctcva `kpkbcdctcas
celchaejusdy jr wctm tma ksscstke`a ji suppdcars ejt kbclceh by EPH hucladceas.
Qdtcnktady, mjwavar, sjna pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp skcl, ct wjudl ba mchmdyuedcoady tmkt tma EPH wjudl kbkelje cts `jesaesus ruda ijr la`cscjenkoceh, ba`kusa
ljceh sj wjudl raqucra kdd pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ce tma hrjup tj khraa tj tkoa tmkt
stap by `jesaesus.
Jea pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt lurceh tma dkst la`kla tma EPH–s cetarekd prj`aluras mkva
baae rktcjekdczal by k wjroceh hrjup je cetarekd raijrn, ce pkrt tj kllrass tma `mkddaeha
ji ce`raksceh pkrtc`cpktcje. Qetcd 266;, ma skcl, tma EPH mkl k pdaekry kel tmraa jtmar
bjlcas“wjroceh hrjups je trkespkrae`y, lukd-usa `jnnar`a, kel ceijrnktcje smkr-
ceh“rueeceh ce pkrkddad. Je tma bkscs ji ra`jnnaelktcjes irjn tma raijrn wjroceh
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 35/70
2= | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
hrjup, ma skcl, tma nkelkta ji tmasa tmraa bjlcas wks trkesiarral tj k eaw @jesudtktcva
Hrjup. —@urraet wjro cs `krrcal jut by tma pdaekry, by tma @jesudtktcva Hrjup kel cts
Ceijrnktcje Ax`mkeha Naatceh. Ce kllctcje tma EPH `ke flaxcbdy `jevaea wjroceh
hrjups jr mjdl lalc`ktal naatcehs tj lakd wctm spa`c` cssuas, kdd ji tman rapjrtceh tj tma
@jesudtktcva Hrjup.„
Qetcd ejw, tma EPH mks jparktal je tma bkscs ji vjduetkry ̀ jnnctnaets ji pkrtc`cpkt-
ceh hjvarenaets kel wctmjut k sa`ratkrckt. Ce dchmt ji tma kbjva-raiarae`al la`cscjes by
nkgjr suppdcar stktas sce`a ;33= ejt tj rchjrjusdy kppdy tma hucladceas, k iaw pkrtc`cpkets ce
tma wjrosmjp klvke`al tma clak ji njvceh tma EPH tjwkrl ba`jnceh k njra ijrnkd jrhk-
eczktcje ce wmc`m nanbar stktas wjudl badjeh tj k bjly mkvceh k parnkeaet sa`ratkrckt
kel nkoa dahkddy bcelceh ̀ jnnctnaets tj cnpdanaet tma hucladceas. Ke aeijr`anaet prj-
`ass nchmt kdsj ba astkbdcsmal, wmc`m ̀ judl axpad stktas tmkt lj ejt kbcla by tma hucladceas.
Cetarvaetcjes by pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tmasa claks wcdd dcoady ejt ba tkoae up
by tma hrjup. Jea pkrtc`cpket axprassal tma vcaw tmkt njvceh tjwkrl ba`jnceh k njra
ijrnkd jrhkeczktcje rafla`tceh tma ijrnkd raspjescbcdctcas, lutcas, kel rchmts ji nanbars
wjudl ae`jurkha tma ijrnktcje ji —sub-`jestctuae`cas„ ce tma EPH, kel ce tma iutura par-
mkps avae tma ijrnktcje ji k EKN `mkptar ce tma EPH. —Lj wa wket kdchenaets ce tma
EPH:„ ma ksoal. —\mcs `judl ba k lcskstar. Ci wa rapdc`kta tma QE atmjs cescla tma EPH,
ct–s jvar.„ K``jrlceh tj kejtmar pkrtc`cpket, tma lkehar ji cetarast-hrjup —bdj`s„ anarh-
ceh cescla tma EPH mkl baae pjcetal jut by sjna pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets kel tmae
lcs`ussal cetarekddy by raprasaetktcvas jvar tma pkst savarkd yakrs, ce stap wctm eahjtcktcjes
madl by tma EPH ijr aerc`mnaet kel raprj`assceh axpjrt hucladceas. Lurceh tmkt eahjtck-
tcje, kejtmar wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt —tmara wks k pjsscbcdcty tmkt ci tma lcs`usscje
hjt jut ji `jetrjd, wa wjudl mkva k iaw `juetrcas khraaceh tj suppjrt k `jnnje pjsctcje
khkcest tma rast.„ Ba`kusa tma eahjtcktcje wks ̀ je`areal wctm ̀ juetrcas– sjvarache rchmts tjnkoa la`cscjes `je`areceh tmacr a`jejnc` lavadjpnaet, ma skcl, tmara wks tma pjtaetckd
tmkt tma eahjtcktcje `judl mkva baae lakldj`oal kdjeh tma hdjbkd Ejrtm-Pjutm lcvcla.
Jea pkrtc`cpket skcl lurceh tma wjrosmjp tmkt ratkceceh k djjsa jrhkeczktcje wctmjut
bcelceh `jnnctnaets wjudl bast aesura tmkt la`cscjenkoceh wjudl tkoa pdk`a je tma
bkscs ji `jnprjncsa batwaae —`jnnje hjkds kel dahctcnkta ektcjekd, ta`mejdjhc`kd, kel
`jnnar`ckd cetarasts„ ji celcvclukd EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets. Ce`rakscehdy daehtmy
eahjtcktcjes je tma `jetaet ji hucladceas, ma skcl, nky ba k radktcvady snkdd prc`a tma EPH
nust pky tj prasarva tma hrjup–s pjdctc`kd flaxcbcdcty.
Dcoawcsa, eunarjus pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp klvcsal tmkt ej klvketkhas wjudl
larcva irjn tma astkbdcsmnaet ji k parnkeaet sa`ratkrckt. Qetcd ejw, sa`ratkrckd kelklncecstrktcva lutcas mkva dkrhady baae `krrcal jut by k sj-`kddal —Vjcet ji @jetk`t,„
`urraetdy kt Gkpke–s Varnkeaet Ncsscje tj tma Cetarektcjekd Jrhkeczktcjes ce Ycaeek.
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tma Gkpkeasa Ncsscje–s rasjur`as ijr EPH wjro“stkii
kddjtnaet kel iuelceh“wjudl mkva tj ce`raksa, smjudl jutrak`m kel tma s`jpa ji EPH
k`tcvctcas ba iurtmar aedkrhal.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 36/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 23
Ravcscje ji tma Hucladceas7Aerc`mnaet kel Raprj`assceh
Ce raspjesa tj tma prjdciarktcje `mkddaehas las`rcbal kbjva, by tma ncllda ji tma dkstla`kla tma EPH mkl anbkroal upje k nkgjr aiijrt tj ravcsct cts rudas ijr eu`dakr trkla.
\ma `mkcrnke ji tma @jesudtktcva Hrjup ce 2663 las`rcbal tma tkso ik`ceh tma EPH
ks ijddjws7
\ma rst quastcje tma EPH nust kllrass cs wmatmar tma `urraet hucladceas kel cetarpratk-
tcjes mkva cnpk`tal tma kbcdcty ji prjdciarkets _sc` ̂ tj k`mcava tmacr eu`dakr knbctcjes7 actmar
by sdjwceh ct ljwe jr nkoceh ct njra lci`udt tj k`qucra eu`dakr hjjls kel ta`mejdjhy.
Pa`jel, tma EPH nust `jesclar mjw tj straehtmae cts hucladceas kel wmkt `mkehas smjudl
ba nkla tj tma `jetrjd dcsts. Icekddy, tma hrjup nust `jesclar eaxt staps, njst ejtkbdy ce
tarns ji sjna vary ravjdutcjekry claks baceh put ijrtm tj aesura tmkt aerc`mnaet kel raprj-
`assceh ta`mejdjhcas kra ejt ncsusal ijr eje-`cvcdcke purpjsas.10
\ma EPH bahke ravcsceh cts hucladceas ijr aerc`mnaet kel raprj`assceh (AER) ce 266<.
K djeh eahjtcktcje ji eaw tarns ji trkla ijr AER wks `je`dulal jea njetm kitar tma
Brussads sancekr wks madl. Jvar tma eaxt iaw yakrs, tma EPH wcdd `krry jut k systanktc`
ravcaw ji cts `jetrjd dcsts, kel, ks wks tma `ksa ijr AER trkla, ct nky kdsj nkoa `mkehas ce
tma `jelctcjes ijr trchhar dcst kel lukd-usa trkesiars.
\ma hucladceas ijr AER kra ijuel ce pkrkhrkpms 9 kel 8 ji Cei`cr`/21< Vkrt C. \ma
ravcscje ji tmasa hucladceas wks cespcral by ravadktcjes ji tma Omke eatwjro–s k`tcvctcas ce
spraklceh `aetrciuha aerc`mnaet oejw-mjw irjn Vkocstke tj Crke, Dcbyk, Ejrtm Ojrak,
kel pjsscbda jtmar lastcektcjes bahceeceh ce tma ;3=6s kel tmrjuhm 2660. Qetcd ejw,
tma hucladceas urhal AER ta`mejdjhy mjdlars tj —axar`csa rastrkcet„ ce la`cscjes kbjut
axpjrts. \ma eaw hucladceas astkbdcsm ce kllctcje k eunbar ji spa`c` `jelctcjes tmkt k
ra`cpcaet stkta nust naat tj ba adchcbda ijr AER. \masa kra7
• baceh pkrty tj, kel ce iudd `jnpdcke`a wctm, tma EV\?
• ejt baceh subga`t tj la`cscjes by tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs tj ralrass skia-
hukrls `jnpdcke`a jr skiahukrls cnpdanaetktcje la`cae`cas?
• rapjrtceh tj tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd uelar QEP@ Rasjdutcje ;1<6 tmkt tma
ra`cpcaet stkta cs cnpdanaetceh ast a`tcva axpjrt `jetrjds?
• `jnncttceh tj CKAK skiaty stkelkrls kel cetarektcjekd eu`dakr skiaty `jevae-
tcjes? kel
• prjvcscje ji khraanaet batwaae tma ra`cpcaet kel suppdcar stkta kssurceh ej
axpdjscva usa, suppdcar–s ratrkesiar `jesaet rchmts, kel ast a`tcva skiahukrls ce
parpatucty.
\ma eaw hucladceas kdsj `kdd je suppdcars, cetar kdck7
• tj mkva k dahkddy bcelceh khraanaet wctm ra`cpcaets tj dcnct key urkecun aerc`m-
naet tj 26 par`aet Q-201?
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 37/70
06 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
• ejt tj trkesiar key aekbdceh lasche jr nkeuik`turceh ta`mejdjhy? kel
• tj ax`dula rapdc`ktcje by tma ra`cpcaet stkta ji key suppdcal AER ta`mejdjhy jr
aqucpnaet.
Ce pkrtc`udkr, tma eaw hucladceas `kdd upje suppdcars tj raqucra k `jnpramaescva skia-hukrls khraanaet kel ke Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd wctm tma CKAK. \mcs raqucranaet ijr
tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd cs ejt kbsjduta, mjwavar, sce`a tma dkehukha ji tma hucladceas
wjudl parnct k suppdcar tj trkesiar AER tj k ra`cpcaet wctmjut ke Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd
ci tmkt stkta cs —cnpdanaetceh kpprjprckta skiahukrls khraanaets ce `jjparktcje wctm tma
CKAK, ce`dulceh k rahcjekd k``juetceh kel `jetrjd krrkehanaet ijr eu`dakr nktarckds, ks
kpprjval by tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs.„ \mara kra jedy twj su`m rahcjekd krrkeha-
naets7 Aurktjn, ijr tma `juetrcas ji tma Aurjpake Qecje? kel tma Brkzcdcke-Krhaetcea
Khae`y ijr K``juetceh kel @jetrjd ji Eu`dakr Nktarckds (KBK@@). Kdd AQ stktas mkva
ke Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd. Brkzcd kel Krhaetcek lj ejt, kel Brkzcd, aspa`ckddy, cs jppjsal tj
tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd. Eunarjus pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp skcl tmkt Krhaetcek kelBrkzcd wcdd cetarprat tma hucladceas tj nake tmkt tmay lj ejt eaal tj mkva ke Kllctcjekd
Vrjtj`jd tj ba adchcbda ijr AER. Eactmar Brkzcd ejr Krhaetcek nkla k ijrnkd ̀ jnnctnaet
tj mkva ke Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd wmae ct khraal tj tma eaw AER hucladceas, kel sjna
pkrtc`cpkets axprassal tma vcaw tmkt tma dkehukha lcl ejt cnpdy tmkt actmar Krhaetcek
jr Brkzcd mkl nkla k `jnnctnaet tj tkoa pkrt ce k prj`ass tmkt cetaelal tj rasudt ce ke
Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd. \ma dkehukha cs wako, but EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets khraal
tj ct ce jrlar tj rasjdva jbga`tcjes rkcsal by Brkzcd ce tma cetarast ji hattceh khraanaet je
tma jtmar `jelctcjes tmkt kra ejw raqucral ijr AER trkesiars. Ct cs tmajratc`kddy pjsscbda
tmkt twj jr njra stktas wctmjut ke Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd `judl `je`dula ke khraanaet
tj ijrn k rahcjekd skiahukrls khraanaet scncdkr tj KBK@@, but ct cs ue`artkce tmkt tmaCKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs wjudl kpprjva ct.
Bahceeceh ce 2660, tma CKAK kel sjna EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets mkva urhal
tmkt iutura urkecun aerc`mnaet prjga`ts ba jrhkeczal ks nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr iuad `y`da
aetarprcsas wmaraby saesctcva ta`mejdjhy cs ejt trkesiarral tj eaw pkrtcas. Lurceh tma
eahjtcktcje ji tma AER hucladceas, k eunbar ji stktas jbga`tal tj prjpjsal dkehukha tmkt
tmay badcaval wjudl prjmcbct tman irjn jbtkceceh rchmts tj AER by `jnpaddceh tman tj
sat up iutura prjga`ts je tma bkscs ji k —bdk`o bjx„ krrkehanaet, k``jrlceh tj wmc`m tma
stkta lapdjyceh tma aerc`mnaet ta`mejdjhy wjudl ejt jwe but wjudl daksa tma ta`mejdjhy
ijr usa irjn ke astkbdcsmal ta`mejdjhy mjdlar. \ma ekd taxt ji tma eaw hucladceas ljas
ejt raqucra —bdk`o bjxceh„ ji AER ta`mejdjhy ce eaw prjga`ts, but ct strjehdy ae`jur-
khas ta`mejdjhy mjdlars ejt tj smkra AER wctm eaw pkrtears kel prjvclas ijr k va-yakr
ravcaw ji tma AER hucladceas `je`areceh urkecun aerc`mnaet tj k``jnnjlkta `jn-
nar`ckd kel ta`mejdjhy lavadjpnaets, aspa`ckddy key traels tmkt nchmt prjnpt k stkta tj
cetael tj lavadjp ke aerc`mnaet ̀ kpkbcdcty je tma bkscs ji ta`mejdjhy ct sjuhmt tj k`qucra
kel ejt daksa.
Pce`a jbtkceceh tma ax`aptcje irjn tma iudd-s`jpa skiahukrls `jelctcje ce 266=, Celck
ae`jurkhal EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ejt tj kljpt tma raqucranaet tmkt ra`cpcaets
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 38/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 0;
ji AER nust ba EV\ pkrtcas. Pjna pkrtc`cpkets kt tma wjrosmjp suhhastal tmkt, kitar
tma ax`aptcje wks kwkrlal tj Celck“kel kitar ct ba`kna kppkraet tmkt @mcek kcnal tj
axpjrt eu`dakr pjwar rak`tjrs tj Vkocstke“sjna EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets wara
njra ce`dceal tj ikvjr EV\ nanbarsmcp ks k raqucranaet ijr AER, ce pkrt tj lanje-
strkta tmkt tma ax`aptcje tma EPH prjvclal ijr Celck ce 266= wks k scehudkr jea.
\ma EPH–s Raspjesa tj ke AvjdvcehHdjbkd Eu`dakr \rkla Rahcna
Papkrktady irjn tma lcs`usscje ji tma AER hucladceas, tma EPH cs ejw anbkroceh je k
ravcaw ji tma `jetaet ji cts `jetrjd dcsts ijr eu`dakr kel lukd-usa ctans. K``jrlceh tj jea
pkrtc`cpket ce tma wjrosmjp, tma EPH ijrasaas k tmraa-yakr tcnadcea ijr ravcawceh tma dcsts.
\mcs wcdd ejt ba tma rst tcna tmkt tma dcsts mkva baae subga`t tj ravcaw kel kdtarktcje,
but ct wcdd ba tma rst tcna tmkt k `jnpramaescva ravcaw ji tma dcsts wcdd ba uelartkoae.Ce tma pkst, ejeprjdciarktcje ikcduras“su`m ks tma jea wmc`m ce ;38< dal tj tma `raktcje
ji tma EPH ce tma rst pdk`a“prjnptal tma EPH tj knael cts dcsts tj ce`dula kel tj
nkoa njra pra`csa `jetrjds je spa`c` ctans. Qetcd CKAK cespa`tcjes ce Crkq, bahceeceh
ce ;33;, ravakdal tma axtaet tj wmc`m Crkq mkl tkppal ijrache sjur`as ijr lukd-usa hjjls
tj iurtmar cts `dkelastcea eu`dakr prjhrkn, njst `juetrcas, ce`dulceh eakrdy kdd EPH pkr-
tc`cpkets, mkl ej eu`dakr lukd-usa `jetrjd dcsts. \ma EPH `raktal su`m k dcst ce ;332,
pubdcsmal ks Cei`cr` 21</Rav.;/Vkrt CC. Ct jrchcekddy `jetkceal 91 ctans but mks baae sub-
stketckddy axpkelal kel adkbjrktal ce latkcd. \ma njst ra`aet ji achmt su``asscva varscjes
wks `jnpdatal kel pubdcsmal ce 26;6.
Ce pkrkddad wctm tma ̀ raktcje ji tma lukd-usa dcst, tma EPH, kdsj lurceh tma ;336s, uelar-tjjo k ravcscje kel uplkta ji tma trchhar dcst tj brceh tma EPH dcst cetj dcea wctm tma Wkehhar
@jnncttaa trchhar dcst, wmc`m mkl baae ravcsal lurceh tma pravcjus twj la`klas tj ce`dula
eaw ctans kel laea axcstceh ctans njra pra`csady. \ma kllctcjes nkla by tma Wkehhar
@jnncttaa ce`dulal makvy wktar pdkets (ce ;388, ce raspjesa tj tma EPH mkvceh ce`dulal
tmcs ctan je cts trchhar dcst), ijddjwal by `dkrc`ktcjes ijr hks `aetrciuha kel hksajus lciiu-
scje urkecun aerc`mnaet, raprj`assceh, makvy wktar prjlu`tcje, prcnkry `jjdceh punps
ce rak`tjrs, urkecun axpjrts, kel urkecun kel pdutjecun ̀ jevarscje aqucpnaet.
Xmcda ce tma pkst tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa mkl `krrcal jut tma uplktceh ji tma trchhar
dcst, sce`a kbjut 2666, jea pkrtc`cpket skcl, tma EPH mks ba`jna raspjescbda ijr uplktceh
bjtm tma trchhar kel lukd-usa dcsts, dakvceh tj tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa tma tkso ji mkrnj-
eczceh cts trchhar dcst wctm tma jea uplktal by tma EPH. Qetcd ejw, ma skcl, —tmara wara
ncejr njlc`ktcjes ji tma EPH dcst, tmjuhm ct wks eavar `jnpramaescvady uplktal.„ Kt
tma 26;6 EPH pdaekry naatceh, ct wks khraal by pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tmkt tma EPH
dcsts wjudl ba `jnpramaescvady ravcawal. \ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa wcdd mkrnjecza cts dcst
wctm tma uplktal EPH dcst.
\ma EPH dcst ravcaw cs baceh `jjrlcektal by k Lalc`ktal Naatceh ji \a`mec`kd
Axparts (LN\A), `mkcral by ke ji`ckd irjn tma Eatmardkels, wmc`m wcdd rapjrt cts
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 39/70
02 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
rasudts tj tma @jesudtktcva Hrjup. \ma LN\A mks la`clal tj kllrass bjtm tma Vkrt C
kel Vkrt CC hucladceas ks k wmjda kel mks sat up savae tmanktc` hrjups, ak`m ji wmc`m wcdd
mkva k `jjrlcektjr7
•
rak`tjr ta`mejdjhy • csjtjpa sapkrktcje ta`mejdjhy
• raprj`assceh ta`mejdjhy
• wakpjeczktcje ta`mejdjhy
• iuad ikbrc`ktcje ta`mejdjhy
• celustrckd aqucpnaet
• ncs`addkeajus/jtmar
\mcs tmanktc` kpprjk`m, jea pkrtc`cpket skcl, cnpdcas tmkt tma rasudt ji tma ravcaw `judl
ba substketckd, ce`dulceh tma pjsscbcdcty ji k scehda `jetrjd dcst, wmc`m wjudl claetciy spa-`c` ctans tmkt wjudl trchhar CKAK skiahukrls.
\ma `jnpcdktcje ji k scehda EPH dcst wjudl parnct eu`dakr suppdcars tj raqucra iudd-
s`jpa skiahukrls ijr k subhrjup ji hjjls tmkt kra claetcal ks saesctcva kel radavket ijr
prjdciarktjrs– eu`dakr wakpjes prjhrkns. \mkt wjudl ce`dula ctans usal ce k eu`dakr
wakpje“ijr axknpda, ctans ijr prjlu`tcje ji tma dctmcun-9 csjtjpa jr trctcun“tmkt
wjudl ejt ba ce`dulal je tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa–s trchhar dcst ba`kusa tmay kra ejt ALV
ctans kel tmaraijra ejt subga`t tj ̀ jetrjd uelar EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2. Pu`m ctans wjudl kdsj
ce`dula spa`c` ta`mejdjhcas“ijr axknpda, vjrtax ta`mejdjhy ejrnkddy usal ijr prjlu`-
tcje ji scdc`je csjtjpas“dcoawcsa ejt `jesclaral ALV ctans but stcdd saesctcva ba`kusa
tmay `ke ba kppdcal tj aerc`m urkecun.Pjna pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt, ks tma EPH–s ravcaw ji tma dcsts hats uelar wky, tma
hrjup wjudl dcoady ce aiia`t kbkelje tma ALV `ktahjry ks k ykrlstc`o kdtjhatmar. Ljceh
tmkt, tmay skcl, wjudl nkoa k lcs`usscje knjeh EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets kel tma
nanbars ji tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa ̀ je`areceh tma iutura rjda ji tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa
njra ea`asskry, sce`a uelar EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2(b) tma ALV `jelctcje axprassdy trchhars
skiahukrls kel ba`kusa tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa wks axprassdy astkbdcsmal tj claetciy tma
ALV ctans.
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp axprassal tma vcaw tmkt, jvar kel kbjva tma quas-
tcje ji mjw tma EPH rajrhkeczas tma Vkrt C kel Vkrt CC dcsts, ji ikr hraktar schec`ke`a
cs k njra bksc` la`cscje tma EPH nust nkoa kbjut wmatmar tj kspcra tj `jnpramaescva
dcstceh ji hjjls jr cestakl ij`us je aiia`tcva cnpdanaetktcje ji k smjrtar dcst, kt tma skna
tcna radyceh ce`rakscehdy upje pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets– axpjrt `jetrjd dahcsdktcje kel
aeijr`anaet naksuras tj dd ce tma hkps. Pkcl jea pkrtc`cpket, ci tma EPH ijddjws tma dkt-
tar `jursa, ct wjudl ce`rakscehdy rady je aiia`tcva cnpdanaetktcje ji tma `kt`m-kdd ruda tj
pravaet ejedcstal ctans irjn baceh prj`ural by prjdciarktjrs.
Celapaelaet ji aiijrts by tma EPH tj ravcsa cts `jetrjd dcsts, sjna wjrosmjp pkr-
tc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tma EPH smjudl `jjrlcekta kel spjesjr ke aiijrt tj nkoa
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 40/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 00
tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes ji cts pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets njra rchjrjus. Ce pkrtc`udkr,
jea pkrtc`cpket prjpjsal k —laapaeceh„ ji tma EPH–s `kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes by kljptceh
njra adkbjrkta kel `jnpramaescva `kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes ce AQ axpjrt `jetrjd hucladceas.
\mcs pkrtc`cpket kdsj klvcsal tmkt ct wjudl ba njra ai`caet kel ikstar ijr tma EPH tj
straehtmae cts `kt`m-kdd na`mkecsn tmke tj schec`ketdy knael tma dcsts, sce`a `jesclar-
kbda tcna nky ba eaalal ijr pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj khraa je eaw hucladceas kel
tmae tj pkss tman cetj ektcjekd dkw.
Pjna `juetrcas ce tma hrjup ce ra`aet yakrs mkva `krrcal jut k ravcaw ji tmacr `kt`m-kdd
krrkehanaets kel ijuel la`cts, kel knjeh EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tmara cs
k eaal ijr mkrnjeczktcje ji tma krrkehanaets kel, sjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl, ijr ke EPH
khraanaet ijr smkrceh laeckd ceijrnktcje knjeh ektcjekd kutmjrctcas.
K ij`us je aemke`anaet ji tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje wks ikvjral by sjna wjrosmjp pkr-
tc`cpkets ba`kusa, ks jea skcl, ce tma iutura, prjdciarktjrs wcdd ce`rakscehdy `je`aetrkta je
jbtkceceh ctans tmkt kra ejedcstal. \mcs pkrtc`cpket skcl7
Pmjudl tma EPH ce tma iutura spael cts rasjur`as by oaapceh cts dcsts up tj lkta kel `jn-
pramaescva, jr smjudl ct `rakta k na`mkecsn tj njra quc`ody kel aiia`tcvady rak`t: \ma jedy
wky tj lj tmcs cs tj mkva k battar `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje uedass yju mkva sjna ocel ji rak`tcva
na`mkecsn ce tma hucladceas tmkt uplktas dcsts vary ikst. But ce jea `ksa k scehda ctan `judl
mkva k vary mchm prjdciarktcje prjda wmcda ce kejtmar `ksa ct nky ejt. Pjnatcnas ct cs ejt
kdwkys usaiud tj dcst kdd tma ctans ba`kusa tmara cs k pjtaetckd rcso tmkt, ce `artkce sctuktcjes,
ke ctan nchmt ba tmaraby claetcal kel usal by prjdciarktjrs.
\maraijra ci tma EPH `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje wara tj ba adkbjrktal kel ce`rakscehdy radcal
upje, tma hrjup —eaals tj lcs`uss wmatmar `jesudtktcjes smjudl ba raqucral„ `je`areceh
mjw kel wmae tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje cs cnpdanaetal ce spa`c` `ksas.
But kejtmar pkrtc`cpket strjehdy lcskhraal wctm tmcs kssassnaet. —\mara cs k pdk`a ce
tma EPH ijr k `kt`m-kdd `dkusa but ct cs k vary dcnctal pdk`a,„ ma skcl. —\ma dcsts kra tmara
tj `rakta k davad pdkyceh adl kel tma `kt`m-kdd `dkusa cs ejt pkrt ji tmkt davad pdkyceh adl.„
Cestakl, ma skcl, tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje cs ke cestrunaet kt tma lcspjskd ji ektcjekd hjv-
arenaets, kel mjw kel wmae ct cs cevjoal wcdd lapael je k sjvarache stkta–s gulhnaet
je tma bkscs ji k tmrakt kssassnaet. \mcs pkrtc`cpket skcl ma lcl ejt ikvjr axpkelceh tma
`kt`m-kdd prjvcscje.
Xjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets kdsj lcs`ussal tma `mkddaeha ik`al by tma EPH ce lakdceh wctm
tma avjdutcje ji hdjbkd eu`dakr trkla. Ppa`c`kddy, ksoal jea, mjw nu`m aiijrt smjudl
tma EPH kppdy tj kllrass trkla brjoarceh kel trkessmcpnaet cssuas: \ma ik`t tmkt tma
vjduna ji trkla cs `jestketdy hrjwceh cs kejtmar raksje, jea pkrtc`cpket skcl, tj prjba—wmatmar jur dcsts smjudl ba parncttal tj hat djehar kel njra latkcdal.„ Kejtmar pkrtc`c-
pket khraal7 —Xa oejw tmkt _`ustjns kutmjrctcas^ kra kbda tj pmysc`kddy `jetrjd dass tmke
2 par`aet ji wmkt cs hjceh tmrjuhm. Ct–s ejt tmkt tmay kra ceai`caet? ct–s k quastcje ji tma
knjuet ji trkla.„
Celustry pkrtc`cpkets kt tma wjrosmjp skcl tmkt, ce kllctcje tj tma eunbar ji eu`dakr
suppdcars ce`raksceh ce tma iutura, tma eunbar ji dc`aeskbda trkesk`tcjes wcdd kdsj ce`raksa,
ba`kusa tma eu`dakr celustry —nky ba subga`t tj njra typas ji hdjbkdczktcje tmke wmkt wa
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 41/70
0< | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
mkva saae ce jtmar celustrcas,„ ks jea pkrtc`cpket skcl. Ba`kusa eu`dakr prjga`ts kra hattceh
njra kel njra axpaescva kel aetkcd hrakt pjdctc`kd kel a`jejnc` rcso, ce tma iutura tmara
wcdd ba njra kel njra `jnpdax cetarektcjekd jwe-
arsmcp kel jutsjur`ceh ji pkrtc`cpktcje ce prjga`ts.
—\ma ce`raksa ce tma vjduna ji dc`aeskbda trkesk`-
tcjes kel kdsj tma `mkeha ce tma cetarektcjekdczk-
tcje ji tma celustry wjudl ba k sarcjus `mkddaeha
ijr axpjrt `jetrjd gust tmrjuhm tma vjduna ji wjro
tmkt eaals tj ba ljea,„ jea vaeljr axa`utcva skcl.
\ma eunbar ji stkii kt mcs rn ksscheal tj axpjrt
dc`aesa prj`assceh, ma skcl, mks ljubdal lurceh tma
pkst tae yakrs.
Vkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt, kpkrt irjn tma ketc`cpktal
hrjwtm ce vjduna ce eu`dakr trkla kel tma ce`raksceh
`jnpdaxcty ji prjga`t jutsjur`ceh, tma twj njst cnpjrtket ̀ mkddaehas radktal tj tma avjdv-
ceh ektura ji eu`dakr trkla kra trkesct kel brjoarceh, kel cetkehcbda ta`mejdjhy trkesiar.
Qetcd ejw, njst hdjbkd eu`dakr `jnnar`a mks fljwal kdjeh pralc`tkbda trkla rjutas.
Jea pkrtc`cpket axpdkceal7
Xmkt nkttars cs smcppceh laescty, kel tma vkst nkgjrcty ji tmcs trkla cs by sak. Ejt surprcs-
cehdy, tma `juetrcas ji `je`are kra k`tukddy dj`ktal vary `djsa tj tma smcppceh kel trkes-
smcpnaet mubs kel kdsj suppdcar `juetrcas. \mara cs k hajhrkpmc`kd `jrradktcje batwaae tma
`juetrcas mkvceh kel wketceh eu`dakr pjwar, je tma jea mkel, kel tma cetarektcjekd smcp-
pceh dkeas, je tma jtmar. Pj tma suppdy ji tmjsa hjjls, tma njvanaets ji tmjsa hjjls, tma
kbcdcty tj sjur`a tmjsa hjjls, tj lcvart tman, kdsj `jce`clas wctm kdd tma trkesct kel trkes-
smcpnaet mubs, mae`a jur jbsasscje wctm tmjsa pdk`as jvar tma dkst iaw yakrs.
\ma `mkddaeha ji `jpceh wctm brjoarceh kel trkesctceh kra ijrnclkbda, jea pkrtc`cpket
wkreal. Qetcd gust baijra tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd cnpjsal trkla rastrc`tcjes je Crke,
ma skcl,
Xa wjudl saa k vassad daksal by ke Crkecke smcppceh dcea irjn k Hraao khaet tmkt wks
njrthkhal tj k Harnke bkeo kel flkhhal ce tma Csda ji Nke, kel tma vassad cs trkespjrtceh
wakpjes ji nkss lastru`tcje hjjls irjn Ejrtm Ojrak tj Crke. Xmkt `ke yju lj: Xmj cs
raspjescbda: Xmkt kutmjrctcas lj yju mkva: Ce su`m k `ksa ct–s eakrdy cnpjsscbda.
Ma hkva kejtmar axknpda ji mjw tma wjrdl ji cetarektcjekd eu`dakr trkla mks avjdval7
Mjw cs cetarektcjekd trkla `mkehceh tma tmrakt wa ik`a : Irjn kbjut 26;1 jewkrls k XNLprjhrkn wcdd sjur`a uedcstal nktarckd irjn yjur `juetry tj k ircaeldy `juetry? tmara–s actmar
ej eaal ijr k dc`aesa, jr k dc`aesa wc dd ba hcvae vary akscdy. Ct wcdd tmae hj tj kejtmar `juetry,
tj k prj`uranaet jrhkeczktcje? ct wcdd tmae ikbrc`kta sjnatmceh tmkt prjbkbdy wjudl ba
`jetrjddal, but ce tmkt stkta tmay lje–t mkva tma ̀ jetrjds sj ct ljase–t nkttar, kel tmae ct hjas
tj tma ael usar ji `je`are. Ct wcdd ba mkppaeceh k dd tma tcna, avary lky… . Mjw `ke Crke
dkue`m sktaddctas kel mkva tma eu`dakr prjhrkn ct mks: Ba`kusa ji tma dk`o ji `jetrjds wjrdl-
wcla. \mcs cs k hdjbkdczal a`jejny? wmkt yju `ke buy ce tma QO yju `ke buy ce Nkdkysck
jr Celjeasck jr Mjeh Ojeh jr @mcek, ej prjbdan.
Ba`kusa eu`dakr prjga`ts kra hattceh
njra kel njra axpaescva kel aetkcd
hrakt pjdctc`kd kel a`jejnc` rcso, ce tma
iutura tmara wcdd ba njra kel njra
`jnpdax cetarektcjekd jwearsmcp kel
jutsjur`ceh ji pkrtc`cpktcje ce prjga`ts.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 42/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 01
\ma axtaescje ji eu`dakr trkla k`tcvctcas cetj s`jras ji `juetrcas wmc`m tmansadvas kra
ejt pkrtc`cpktceh ce tma EPH kel ce njst `ksas mkva ej trua eu`dakr celustrcas jr avae
axparcae`a wctm `jetrjddceh axpjrts wks cdduncektal by tma ravadktcjes ji tma hdjbkd rak`m
ji tma Omke eatwjro. \mjsa ravadktcjes ce 266< prjnptal tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd
tj pkss k rasjdutcje uelar @mkptar YCC ji tma QE @mkrtar `jnpaddceh kdd ;32 `juetrcas
ce tma QE systan tj njlciy tmacr ektcjekd dahcsdktcje kel klncecstrktcjes tj put cetj
pdk`a kel aeijr`a dahkd naksuras tj pravaet prjdciarktcje ji wakpjes ji nkss lastru`tcje.
QEP@ Rasjdutcje ;1<6 astkbdcsmal ke kl mj` `jnncttaa `jnprcsceh kdd itaae nanbars
ji tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd tj njectjr tma cnpdanaetktcje ji tma rasjdutcje.
Xjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt lktk k``unudktal by tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa, bksal je
ektcjekd hjvarenaet rapjrts je tmacr axpjrt ̀ jetrjd systans kel prk`tc`as, mchmdchmtal tma
schec`ket lciiarae`as batwaae tma stkta ji eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds ce EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh
`juetrcas kel ̀ jelctcjes ce njst ji tma ;<9 stktas ce tma QE systan wmc`m kra ejt pkrtc`c-
pktceh ce tma EPH. EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets mkl, tmay skcl, tkoae nkey naksuras
tj `jnpdy wctm Rasjdutcje ;1<6, but nkey jtmar hjvarenaets mkl ejt.
Pkcl jea pkrtc`cpket, tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa —saas tmkt EPH nanbars k`tukddy lj mkva
`jetrjds ce pdk`a, ce`dulceh `kt`m-kdd kel je cetkehcbda trkesiars. But wmae yju dakva tma
EPH wjrdl, ueijrtuektady, yju saa k tjtkddy lciiaraet pc`tura. Ejt jedy lj k dkrha eunbar
ji stktas mkva ej axpjrt `jetrjds, but tmara–s k stcdd snkddar eunbar ji `juetrcas tmkt k`tu-
kddy mkva `jetrjd dcsts„ ce tmacr rahudktcjes kel dkws. Njrajvar, tmasa `juetrcas —nchmt
mkva sjna sjrt ji axpjrt `jetrjds but ej wky ji claetciyceh wmkt `jnnjlcty tmay–ra sup-
pjsal tj ba djjoceh ijr.„
Pj ikr, pkrtc`cpkets skcl, tma EPH mks ljea dcttda ks k hrjup tj kllrass cssuas rkcsal by
tma hrjwtm ji trkessmcpnaet kel trkla brjoarceh ce tma eu`dakr sa`tjr. Jea pkrtc`cpket
skcl7 —Xa kpprjval ce 2663 k nkelkta tj stkrt tj lakd wctm brjoarceh kel trkesct, buttma wjro cs kt k vary akrdy stkha ji labkta. Pjna lj`unaets kra baceh prasaetal, but wa–ra
ejt tmara yat.„
K sa`jel nkgjr `mkddaeha tj tma hrjup“cetkehcbda ta`mejdjhy trkesiar (C\\)“wks
kdsj uelars`jral by ravadktcjes irjn tma Omke eatwjro, ks wa mkva saae kbjva.
K``jrlceh tj jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket, tma EPH wks tma rst nudtcdktarkd axpjrt
`jetrjd krrkehanaet tj kllrass tma cssuas ji ta`mejdjhy (ks lcstce`t irjn aqucpnaet jr
nktarckd) trkesiar. But ks cs tma `ksa ijr brjoarceh, ma skcl, tma EPH —mks ejt tkoae up
tma `mkddaeha tmrjwe ljwe by tma Omke eatwjro ce ada`trjec`kddy rapdc`ktceh kel trkes-
iarrceh saesctcva lasche ceijrnktcje, kel tma laectcje ji ta`mejdjhy ce bjtm _Vkrt C kel
Vkrt CC^ hucladceas cs jut ji lkta.„Mjw bch k tmrakt C\\ cs tj tma ejeprjdciarktcje rahcna, kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl, cs
lci`udt tj kssass ba`kusa ct cs axtranady lci`udt tj lata`t7
\ma rakdcty ji C\\ cs tmkt yju wcdd lcs`jvar tmcs actmar ba`kusa tma aetctcas kra saaoceh tj
`jnpdy jr ba`kusa tmay _kitar k trkesk`tcje cs `je`dulal^ ijuel tmansadvas tmkt tmay nkla
k ncstkoa kel sj tmay `jna tj yju kel sky, djjo, wa–va ljea tmcs, vary sjrry, sj ejw wa–va
put ce pdk`a `jetrjds je ct tj aesura ct ljase–t mkppae khkce.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 43/70
09 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
\ma EPH, ma skcl, eaals tj la`cla —mjw ikr tj hj ce ce`dulceh C\\ ce cts nkelkta,
ba`kusa wmcda njst ji tma EPH–s wjro mks baae ce tma krak ji `jnnjlcty dcsts, kt tma
njnaet ct cs tma ta`mejdjhy tmkt cs prjbkbdy ce eaal ji tma hraktast `jetrjd.„
But ci tma EPH njvas ce tmcs lcra`tcje, kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl, ct wcdd mkva tj
straehtmae cts `jjparktcje kel ceijrnktcje ax`mkeha wctm aeijr`anaet khae`cas kel
celustry, —ba`kusa tma jedy wky yju `ke `jetrjd C\\ cs tmrjuhm tmjsa aetctcas tmkt mkva
ct, tmay mkva tj mkva cetarekd ̀ jnpdcke`a prj`assas tj aesura tma ta`mejdjhy cs sa`ural kel
tmkt tmay lje–t brak`m ̀ jetrjds, kel tmkt wmjavar mks tma raspjescbcdcty ijr aeijr`anaet“
sjnatcnas ct cs k dc`aesceh kutmjrcty kel sjnatcnas `ustjns“ljas rahudkr kulcts.„ Njra
kttaetcje eaals tj ba lavjtal tj mjw ̀ jnpkecas ra`jrl kel njectjr ta`mejdjhy trkesiars,
aspa`ckddy cetarekddy. —Pj yju mkva k s`aekrcj wmara tma `jnpkey ljas ejt oaap ra`jrls
ba`kusa dahkddy tmay lje–t mkva tj, kel ci tmay lje–t oaap ra`jrls, wmkt `ke ke kulctjr lj:
Ke kulctjr ljase–t oejw wmkt ma `ke–t oejw.„
EPH jutrak`m tj ta`mejdjhy mjdlars ce cts pkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas wjudl ba baea`ckd,
kejtmar wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket skcl. —Yary sadljn lj yju mkva rahudktjrs jr kulctjrs wmj
rakddy oejw wmkt tmay kra djjoceh ijr ce tarns ji ctans wmc`m kra je `jetrjd dcsts, dat
kdjea cetkehcbda trkesiars.„ Pkcl jea celustry raprasaetktcva, —Ijr C\\, pravaetcje cs tma
bast aeijr`anaet, kel je C\\ `jetrjds nkoceh tma `jnpkecas kwkra cs tma oay tj pra-
vaetceh C\\ ba`kusa yju `ke–t rakddy `jetrjd tma trkesiars tmansadvas, jr kt dakst ct–s vary
mkrl tj lj.„ Ci EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets —lj jutrak`m ce tmcs krak, tmay mkva tj
tadd tma `jnpkecas tmkt ct cs ce tmacr cetarast tj hj tmrjuhm tma prjpar `mkeeads, ba`kusa ci
tmay lje–t tmae tmacr hjvarenaet `keejt hukrketaa kel prjta`t tmacr cetadda`tukd prjparty
rchmts ce `ksa tma ta`mejdjhy cs trkesiarral. \mkt cs sjnatmceh tmkt nkoas tma `jnpkecas
saa tma rktcjekda kel tmacr `jnnar`ckd cetarast ce `jnpdcke`a.„
Jutscla tma EPH, k``jrlceh tj QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd lktk, jea pkrtc`cpket skcl, ;06stktas mkva ej `jetrjds je cetkehcbda ta`mejdjhy trkesiar. Ks ijr `jetrjds je brjoarceh,
trkla eke`ceh, kel trkespjrt sarvc`as ijr trkla, ̀ jetrjds kra kdsj dkrhady ncssceh ce tmasa
`juetrcas.
Klgustceh tj ke Avjdvceh Eu`dakr \rkla Rahcna
• \ma EPH smjudl strjehdy `jesclar axtaelceh tj kdd eu`dakr trkla spa`c` `jelctcjes tmkt
wara kllal tj tma hucladceas ijr AER `jnnar`a ks kpprjval by tma EPH ce Guea.
• \ma EPH smjudl raqucra ks `jelctcjes ijr key ratrkesiar ji ctans by ra`cpcaet stktas tj k
tmcrl pkrty tma skna `jelctcjes tmkt kppdy ce tma jrchcekd bcdktarkd suppdy khraanaet ba-
twaae tma suppdcar kel tma ra`cpcaet stkta.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesclar astkbdcsmceh `jnnje ejeprjdciarktcje kel axpjrt `jetrjd stke-
lkrls ijr pkrtc`cpktceh suppdcar stktas tmkt wjudl parnct axpalctcjus axpjrt dc`aesceh ji
axpjrtars wctm k ra`jrl ji `jjparktcje kel `jnpdcke`a.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 44/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 08
\ma EPH kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa
\ma vary axcstae`a ji tma EPH rkcsal quastcjes kbjut tma iutura rjda ji tma Wkehhar
@jnncttaa ks akrdy ks ;388, wmae tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa kljptal cetj cts trchhar dcst
ke ctan tmkt mkl pravcjusdy baae ce`dulal je tma EPH–s jwe eaw dcst. Aspa`ckddy bahce-
eceh ce ;332, wmae tma EPH wks rasus`ctktal kitar tma Hudi Xkr, ji`ckds raspjescbda ijr
bjtm hrjups mkva `jesclaral wmatmar, wmy, kel mjw tma twj nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt`jetrjd krrkehanaets wjudl `jetceua tj axcst ce pkrkddad. Lurceh tma ;336s, tma djeh-
sarvceh Wkehhar @jnncttaa `mkcrnke, Irctz P`mnclt ji Kustrck, krhual tmkt tma EPH
smjudl ij`us je lukd-usa axpjrt `jetrjds, dakvceh tj tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa, je bamkdi
ji tma CKAK, tma gjb ji `jetceuceh tj ravcaw tma trchhar dcst. P`mnclt kdsj krhual tmkt tma
CKAK–s rjda ce nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjds wjudl ba ce`raksal ci kdd stktas wjudl klmara tj
tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd.1<
• \ma EPH smjudl astkbdcsm ke cetarekd wjroceh hrjup jr ijrun lurceh tma uplktceh ji tma
dcsts tj `jjrlcekta k raspjesa tj prassura irjn pkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas– celustrcas tj ranjva
spa`c` ctans irjn `jetrjd dcsts.• \ma EPH smjudl mjdl k ijrnkd lcs`usscje knjeh pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets je astkbdcsm-
ceh tma lascral bkdke`a batwaae radcke`a je knaelal `jetrjd dcsts kel radcke`a je ektcjekd
hjvarenaets– cnpdanaetktcje ji tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje.
• \ma EPH smjudl mjdl k `kt`m-kdd wjrosmjp wctm pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets– `ustjns kel
axpjrt `jetrjd kutmjrctcas. \mcs smjudl lj`unaet tmkt, `jnpkral tj tma klncecstrktcje ji
EPH `jetrjd dcsts, tma cnpdanaetktcje ji tma `kt`m-kdd cs `jnpkrktcvady lci`udt, kel subga`t
tj ue`artkcetcas. \ma EPH smjudl aesura tmkt iaalbk`o irjn tmcs lcs`usscje cs prjvclal tj
LN\A ijr usa ce ravcsceh `jetrjd dcsts.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jelu`t k rchjrjus `jnpkrktcva axkncektcje ji tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes ce
kdd nanbar stktas wctm tma hjkd ji mkrnjeczceh kel nkxcnczceh tma aiia`tcvaeass ji tmkt
prjvcscje, tkoceh klvketkha ji `kt`m-kdd ravcaws `krrcal jut by pkrtc`cpktceh stktas.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesclar lrkitceh kel kljptceh k @jla ji @jelu`t ijr suppdcars tj
raceijr`a ejeprjdciarktcje ejrns. \mcs lj`unaet smjudl kdsj rakirn pkrtc`cpktceh hjv-
arenaets– `jnnctnaet tj stktas– rchmts tj aehkha ce cetarektcjekd eu`dakr `jnnar`a ks
axprassal ce bjtm EV\ Krtc`da CY kel ce tma CKAK Ptktuta.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesudt wctm jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets kel aeijr`a-
naet prk`tctcjears tj raelar eaw hucladceas njra aiia`tcva kel usar-ircaeldy.
• \ma EPH smjudl astkbdcsm k ijrun jr na`mkecsn ce tma EPH tj `jjrlcekta kel mkrnjecza
tma cetrjlu`tcje ji tma eaw hucladceas cetj ektcjekd dkw ce pkrtc`cpktceh stktas tj pravaet
—hucladcea smjppceh„ by prjdciarktjrs.
• \ma EPH smjudl axpalcta tma cetarekd lcs`usscje ji ijrnudktceh kel tmae cnpdanaetceh tma
EPH–s raspjesa tj tma `mkddaehas ji trkla-brjoarceh kel C\\.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 45/70
0= | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
\ma EPH kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa
\ma ravcscje ji tma EPH hucladceas kel `jetrjd dcsts nky rasudt ce k iurtmar lapkrtura by tma EPH
irjn tma tarns ji raiarae`a ji EV\ axpjrt `jetrjds. \ma EPH cs `jesclarceh `jnbceceh tma Vkrt
C kel Vkrt CC `jetrjd dcsts kel `jnpcdceh k scehda `jetrjd dcst tmkt wjudl claetciy njra ctans kel
ta`mejdjhcas raqucrceh skiahukrls kel jtmar `jelctcjes ijr axpjrt tmke tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa
trchhar dcst. \ma iutura ji tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa `judl ba prjijueldy kiia`tal, smjudl, ks sjna
pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ketc`cpkta, tma jehjceh ravcaw ji EPH `jetrjd dcsts ce aiia`t kbkeljes
tma ALV `jelctcje ks k ykrlstc`o jr raiarae`a.
• \ma EPH smjudl axpdjra jptcjes ijr iutura `jddkbjrktcje wctm tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa,
wmc`m wcdd `jetceua ks ke cetarpratcva krrkehanaet ijr EV\ skiahukrls sj djeh ks klmar-
ae`a tj tma EPH hucladceas by kdd EV\ pkrtcas cs ejt uecvarskd.
• \ma EPH ce cts ladcbarktcjes smjudl `jesclar tmkt EPH la`cscjenkoceh kel pjdc`cas nky
schec`ketdy `mkddaeha tma `jetceual axcstae`a ji tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa.
• \ma EPH kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa `judl jrhkecza gjcet ksscstke`a tj QE nanbar stktas
tj `jnpdy wctm QEP@ Rasjdutcje ;1<6, nutukd hucladcea `jesudtktcjes, kel `jnnje jut-
rak`m tj celustry.
• \ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa nky ba `jesudtal by tma EPH ce cts wjro radktal tj nkcetkceceh
tma dcsts, but ct wcdd ej djehar mkva dakl raspjescbcdcty ijr tma trchhar dcst.
Ct lcle–t ture jut tmkt wky. Xmkt P`mnclt mkl ketc`cpktal jr mjpal ijr mks ejt trkes-
pcral. Cestakl, ks k pkrtc`cpket kt tma Brussads sancekr axpdkceal, tma ik`t tmkt tma EPH
wcdd ejw uelartkoa k —mjdcstc` kpprjk`m„ ce cts hucladceas ravcaw“`jesclarceh ks jea
bjtm tma lukd-usa kel trchhar dcsts“—ea`assctktas tmkt tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa tkoa k
subjrlcekta rjda tj tma EPH.„
Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket kllal tmkt LN\A, tma wjroceh hrjup `krryceh jut tma `je-
trjd dcst ravcaw, nky kll tj tma EPH–s `jetrjd dcsts saesctcva aqucpnaet kel cestkddktcjes
tmkt lje–t `jeijrn tj tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa–s nkelkta ce EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2, wmc`m
cs dcnctal tj —aspa`ckddy lascheal jr prapkral aqucpnaet jr nktarckd ijr tma prj`assceh,
usa, jr prjlu`tcje ji spa`ckd sscjekbda nktarckd.„ @urraetdy, tma EPH kel tma Wkehhar
@jnncttaa mkva scncdkr nanbarsmcps, tmcs pkrtc`cpket skcl, kel tma nanbars ji bjtm
hrjups —kra uedcoady tj mkva schec`ketdy lcvarhaet vcaws je cssuas dcoa saesctcva eu`dakr
trkla jr tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd.„
But wmkt wcdd tma rjda ji tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa ba ce tma iutura: Irjn tma bahce-
eceh, kel kitar tma `raktcje ji tma EPH, tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa wks cetaelal tj laea
wmc`m axpjrtal ctans trchharal skiahukrls ijr EV\ pkrtcas. \ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa
—rankces lciiaraet irjn tma EPH ce cts radktcjesmcp tj tma EV\ kel pjsscbcdctcas ijr
jutrak`m,„ tmcs pkrtc`cpket skcl. Kllal kejtmar, —\ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa cs stcdd kdcva,
kel tmrjuhm ct _eu`dakr suppdcar stktas^ mkva k lcra`t dceo wctm tma EV\. Xa lje–t mkva
tmkt dceo wctm tma EPH„ ba`kusa ct wks `raktal by eu`dakr suppdcar stktas tj `jetrjd trkla
bayjel tma EV\–s s`jpa.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 46/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 03
\ma EPH kel Jtmar Axpjrt@jetrjd Krrkehanaets
\ma EPH cs ejw tma njst `jnpramaescva nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjd krrkeha-naet, but ct ̀ jaxcsts wctm jtmar krrkehanaets ijr jtmar ta`mejdjhcas radavket tj tma sprakl
ji wakpjes ji nkss lastru`tcje kel `jevaetcjekd wakpjes. Ji pkrtc`udkr radavke`a, jea
wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket axpdkceal, kra tmraa nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd rahcnas7
• tma Kustrkdck Hrjup, ijr `manc`kd kel bcjdjhc`kd nktarckds kel ta`mejdjhcas (pkr-
tcas kra kdsj pkrtcas tj Bcjdjhc`kd kel @manc`kd Xakpjes @jevaetcjes)?
• tma Ncsscda \a`mejdjhy @jetrjd Rahcna (N\@R), ijr ncsscda systans kel pjtae-
tckd XNL ladcvary vamc`das? kel
• tma Xkssaekkr Krrkehanaet, ijr lukd-usa hjjls kel ta`mejdjhcas kel nuectcjes.
\masa krrkehanaets smkra `artkce iakturas ji tma EPH. Kdd but Xkssaekkr mkva ej sa`ra-tkrckt but cestakl dcoa tma EPH mkva ke ceijrnkd pjcet ji `jetk`t tj ik`cdctkta lcs`usscjes
kel tma ax`mkeha ji lj`unaets. Xkssaekkr–s ijrnkd stru`tura wks `kddal ijr ba`kusa ct cs
ejt ke krrkehanaet hjvareceh tarns ijr spa`c` trkesiars but cs cetaelal tj pravaet lastk-
bcdczceh k``unudktcjes ji `jevaetcjekd wakpjes tmrjuhm k `jesudtktcje kel ceijrnktcje-
smkrceh prj`ass bast ik`cdctktal by k ijrnkd sa`ratkrckt.
Pcncdkr tj tma EPH, Xkssaekkr mks k dcst ji nanbarsmcp `rctarck“jea ji wmc`m cs
klmarae`a tj tma hucladceas ji tma jtmar krrkehanaets, ce`dulceh tma EPH kel tma
Wkehhar @jnncttaa“kel cts nanbars smkra bksc` prce`cpdas. Ce 26;6, tma Xkssaekkr
pdaekry naatceh nkelktal ke uplkta ji cts `jetrjd dcst. Ji cetarast tj tma EPH, tmara cs
kdsj ke jehjceh aiijrt ji Xkssaekkr pkrtc`cpkets tj nkoa tma `jetrjd dcst dass ta`mec`kdsj ct `ke ba uelarstjjl by aeijr`anaet parsjeead“ce pkrtc`udkr, `ustjns kel dc`aesceh
ji`ckds wmj nky mkva dcttda axparcae`a wctm tma wakpjes subga`t tj `jetrjds je tma dcst.
Xkssaekkr kdsj mks k wadd-lavadjpal jutrak`m prjhrkn kcnal kt prjnjtceh tma hjkds,
ncsscje, kel k``jnpdcsmnaets ji tma krrkehanaet, ce`dulceh pjst-pdaekry brcaehs ji
ejepkrtc`cpkets kel celustry jutrak`m.
\ma Xkssaekkr krrkehanaet cs kdsj k`tcva ce kljptceh eaw naksuras, hucladceas, kel
bast prk`tc`as ijr spa`c` `jetrjddal ta`mejdjhcas kel klgustceh tj eaw sa`urcty tmrakts.
Ra`aetdy, tma hrjup prjnudhktal eaw lj`unaets je axpjrt ̀ jetrjds ijr kcr-dkue`mal wakp-
jes, bast-prk`tc`a hucladceas ijr tma axpjrt ji snkdd krns kel dchmt wakpjes, k Ptktanaet
ji Qelarstkelceh je Cnpdanaetktcje ji Ael-Qsa @jetrjds ijr Lukd-Qsa Ctans, k lj`u-
naet je bast prk`tc`as ijr C\\, kel kejtmar je brjoarceh, trkesct, kel trkessmcpnaets.
Kdd tmraa ji tmasa krrkehanaets smkra wctm tma EPH `djsal nanbarsmcps kel tma hjkd
ji suppdanaetceh axcstceh ejeprjdciarktcje traktcas kel khraanaets tmkt axprassal haearkd
prce`cpdas but iaw ta`mec`kd spa`c`ktcjes kel tmkt prasaetal djjpmjdas prjdciarktjrs ̀ judl
axpdjct. Dcoa tma EPH, njst jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets mkva ej aeijr`anaet jr
nudtcdktarkd ske`tcjes na`mkecsns, kel ce kdd `ksas aeijr`anaet, ks wadd ks tma dc`aesceh
ji axpjrts, cs tma raspjescbcdcty ji pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 47/70
<6 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Dcoa tma EPH, tmasa tmraa krrkehanaets nkoa la`cscjes by `jesaesus ba`kusa, ks jea
pkrtc`cpket skcl, —tma `jesaesus prce`cpda kddjws ijr k uecal kpprjk`m tj k spa`c`kddy
laeal tmrakt.„ Pjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt, ijr tma EPH ks ijr tma jtmar krrkehanaets,
tma njra spa`c` kel uecqua tma tmrakt, tma njra dcoady tmara wcdd ba ̀ jesaesus kbjut mjw
tj raspjel. Dcoa tma EPH, tma jtmar krrkehanaets kra kdsj `mkddaehal by tma lci`udtcas
ji k`mcavceh `jesaesus knjeh k dkrha eunbar ji pkrtc`cpkets, kdtmjuhm, uedcoa tma EPH,
tma nanbarsmcp ce tmasa krrkehanaets kppakrs tj mkva `urraetdy rak`mal k skturktcje
pjcet, wctm dcttda iutura hrjwtm ketc`cpktal.
Ks cs tma `ksa ijr tma EPH, tma jtmar krrkehanaets kra pjtaetckddy `mkddaehal by tma
sjvarache prarjhktcva ji pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj iraady cetarprat tma hucladceas ks
tmay pdaksa, kel N\@R kel tma Kustrkdck Hrjup mkva axparcae`al lci`udtcas, ce pkrt
ba`kusa ji tma hrjups– ceijrnkd stru`turas, ce latarnceceh wmkt `jestctutas eje`jnpdc-
ke`a wctm hucladceas kel prce`cpdas.
Dcoawcsa ijr tma EPH, tma `djsal nanbarsmcp ji tma jtmar tmraa krrkehanaets mks dal
tj `mkddaehas tj tmacr dahctcnk`y kel tj `rctc`csn tmkt tma krrkehanaets kra ce ik`t `krtads
naket tj smadtar astkbdcsmal ta`mejdjhy mjdlars kel axpjrtars. Kdd tmraa mkva ae`jue-
taral `rctc`csn irjn lavadjpceh `juetrcas kel aspa`ckddy irjn tma EKN? kdd mkva cectc-
ktal trkespkrae`y prjhrkns ce raspjesa? kdd mkva cetrjlu`al `kt`m-kdd prce`cpdas cetj tmacr
hucladceas? kel kdd mkva baae uplktceh tmacr hucladceas tj k``jnnjlkta eaw lavadjp-
naets ce cetarektcjekd trkla su`m ks brjoarceh, trkla eke`ceh, kel C\\.
\mara cs k mchm pjsctcva ̀ jrradktcje batwaae k stkta–s pkrtc`cpktceh ce jea jr njra ji tmasa
tmraa krrkehanaets kel cts pkrtc`cpktceh ce tma EPH. \mcs dal jea pkrtc`cpket tj `jn-
naet tmkt —tmara cs k djt tj dakre irjn jtmar nanbarsmcps kel k mchm baeat pjtaetckd“
aspa`ckddy hcvae tmkt, ijr nkey snkddar ̀ juetrcas, tma skna hjvarenaet ji`ckds raspjescbda
ijr raprasaetceh tmacr hjvarenaets ce tma EPH kra kdsj pkrtc`cpktceh ce tma jtmar krrkeha-naets.„ —Jedy ce dkrha `juetrcas, wctm dkrha buraku`rk`cas, `ke hjvarenaets kiijrl tj
sael lciiaraet ji`ckds tj lciiaraet naatcehs kt tma skna tcna,„ jea pkrtc`cpket skcl. Pce`a
tma bchhar `juetrcas ce tma EPH tael tj ba tmjsa tmkt tkoa njst cectcktcvas ce tma hrjup,
stjvapcpceh ce tmasa `juetrcas– ejeprjdciarktcje kel axpjrt `jetrjd buraku`rk`cas `ke lcs-
`jurkha tma EPH irjn lrkwceh je tma axparcae`a ji tma jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets.
Kitar 3/;;, jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket skcl, k sarcas ji `jeiarae`as wara madl tmkt wara
lascheal tj brceh tjhatmar raprasaetktcvas irjn tma lciiaraet krrkehanaets. But mcstjrc-
`kddy, ma skcl, tmasa hrjups mkva axprassal dcttda eaal ijr `jddkbjrktcje. Celcvclukd `mkcr-
nae mkva trcal tj ae`jurkha ̀ jddkbjrktcje but kt tma hrjup davad tmara mks baae dcttda jr ej
`jnnje k`tcvcty jr cetark`tcje.Lurceh tma EPH jutrak`m `jeiarae`as madl ce tma dkta ;336s, sjna pkrtc`cpkets urhal
tmkt EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets `jesclar stkrtceh kirasm kel eahjtcktceh k hdjbkd
krns `jetrjd trakty wctmce tma Qectal Ektcjes irknawjro. Ce ra`aet yakrs, kel aspa`ckddy
ijddjwceh tma ravadktcjes tmkt sjna prjdciarktjrs mkva baae spraklceh `jevaetcjekd wakp-
jes kel ncsscda-radktal ctans, ks wadd ks eu`dakr wkras, sjna axparts mkva prasaetal ̀ jhaet
krhunaets suhhastceh tmkt tma axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets nchmt ba uecal tmrjuhm tma
astkbdcsmnaet ji ke cetarektcjekd axpjrt ̀ jetrjd trakty tmkt wjudl ba bcelceh je cts nan-
bars kel mkva k ske`tcjes kel aeijr`anaet na`mkecsn.11 Ce 266<, AdBkrklac dcoawcsa
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 48/70
Nkro Mcbbs | <;
prjpjsal tmkt ke cetarektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd trakty ba `jesclaral, kel tma eahjtcktcje ji
su`m k trakty cs `urraetdy klvj`ktal by sjna eu`dakr ejeprjdciarktcje axparts.19
\mcs subga`t wks celcra`tdy rkcsal by savarkd pkrtc`cpkets lurceh tma wjrosmjp? mjw-
avar, k eunbar ji pkrtc`cpkets wmj kra cevjdval ce ji`ckd EPH ladcbarktcjes nkla cetar-
vaetcjes wmc`m krhual tmkt su`m ke kpprjk`m wjudl ejt ba `urraetdy iakscbda jr lascrkbda,
kel tmkt njst pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ce tma EPH wara ejt ce`dceal tj cectckta k prj-
`ass tmkt wjudl dakl tj ke knkdhknktcje ji tma nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd rahcnas cetj
sjnatmceh wmc`m wjudl ba njra ijrnkd kel anpjwaral.
K iaw pkrtc`cpkets klvcsal `kutcje `je`areceh tma EPH–s ijrhceh dceos tj jr `jnpkr-
ceh ejtas wctm tma jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets. Jea skcl tmkt, ijr
ak`m krrkehanaet, tma jparktceh tmrakt kssassnaet uelarpceeceh cts k`tcvctcas nky ba sch-
ec`ketdy lciiaraet. Jea pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd ske`tcjes rasjdutcjes
je Crke kel Ejrtm Ojrak, ijr axknpda, raiar tj tma EPH kel tj tma N\@R but ejt tj
Xkssaekkr. Lurceh Xkssaekkr ceijrnktcje ax`mkehas, ma skcl, —wa j``kscjekddy lakd wctm
cssuas ji tmraktaeceh k``unudktcje ji `jevaetcjekd wakpjes ce Kirc`ke `juetrcas, wmara
tmara cs ej prjbdan wmktsjavar wctm rahkrl tj eu`dakr jr bkddcstc` ncsscda prjdciarktcje… .
\ma spa`c` `jetrjd rahcnas kra tmara ba`kusa tmay ak`m pursua vary spa`c` jbga`tcvas.„
Ijr ektcjekd hjvarenaets tj tkoa k`tcje bksal je Xkssaekkr ladcbarktcjes, tma hjv-
arenaets raqucra flaxcbcdcty, wmc`m `ke ba kiijrlal jedy by k spa`c` tmrakt kssassnaet
hjvareceh tmkt axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaet. —Kt tma ael ji tma lky, _EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets^ ce k eunbar ji `ksas eaal tj hj tj jur ektcjekd pkrdcknaets kel tadd pkrdck-
naetkrckes wmy wa lcl jr lcl ejt hrket k spa`c` axpjrt dc`aesa tj tmkt `juetry ijr tmkt
typa ji ctan. Pj tma EPH kel tma jtmar _nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd^ rahcnas mkva tmacr
spa`c`ctcas wmc`m wa eaal tj raspa`t.„
Njst pkrtc`cpkets `jnnaetceh je tmcs cssua stktal tmkt tmay lcl ejt klvj`kta narhcehkey ji tma krrkehanaets jr tmacr tmrakt kssassnaets, but, ks jea pkrtc`cpket axprassal,
tmay lcl klvj`kta `djsar `jjparktcje kel cetar`mkeha —tj try kel saa wmatmar tma wky tma
rahcnas kra jparktal kel kra iue`tcjeceh `ke nutukddy ceijrn ak`m jtmar kel nkoa tma
jvarkdd systan njra aiia`tcva.„
Kt tma skna tcna, sjna pkrtc`cpkets wkreal tmkt tma EPH smjudl `je`aetrkta je wmkt
ct ljas bast. —\ma EPH eaals tj ij`us je wmara ct klls vkdua, ejt try tj lj tmcehs jtmar
rahcnas kra ljceh battar,„ jea skcl. Buraku`rktc` prassura tjwkrl —ncsscje `raap,„ mjw-
avar, cs ejt ue`jnnje ce tma cetarektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd adl. Jea pkrtc`cpket radktal,
ijr axknpda, tmkt k pkrtc`cpktceh `juetry ce tma Vrjdciarktcje Pa`urcty Cectcktcva (VPC)
mks rapaktaldy klvj`ktal axpkelceh tma cectcktcva–s nkelkta cetj tma krak ji prjdciarktcjeeke`ceh, ejtwctmstkelceh tma ik`t tmkt tma Iceke`ckd K`tcje \kso Ijr`a (IK\I), k `je-
sudtceh hrjup astkbdcsmal by tma H-8 ce ;3=3 jrchcekddy tj `jnbkt njeay dkuelarceh, mkl
ce ra`aet yakrs su``assiuddy kssunal k daklceh rjda ce `jnbktceh prjdciarktcje eke`ceh
je bamkdi ji tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa.18
Ce tma wjrls ji kejtmar pkrtc`cpket, —\mara eaals tj ba njra cestctutcjekd `jjrlcek-
tcje knjeh kdd tma nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets. \mara smjudl ba njra `jjp-
arktcje. Xa smjudle–t try tj rapdc`kta jr, ce sjna `ksas, `jnpata. C mkva axparcae`al tmasa
krrkehanaets `jnpatceh.„ @jjparktcje cs ce tma EPH–s bast cetarast, kejtmar skcl. —Dait
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 49/70
<2 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
tj cts jwe lavc`as, tma EPH `ke hj jii kel ba`jna k wjelariud, `uttceh-alha jrhkeczk-
tcje wmc`m, mjwavar, struhhdas ba`kusa tma jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets mkvae–t oapt
up wctm ct. \mara eaals tj ba wclar avjdutcje kel raijrn.„
Pavarkd pkrtc`cpkets ae`jurkhal tma EPH, but kdsj jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets,
tj `jesclar kljptceh k njra rahcjekd kpprjk`m tj jutrak`m kel cetarekd nkekhanaet ce
tma iutura, ce pkrt ba`kusa tma Aurjpake Qecje mks baae vary su``assiud ce sattceh up ke
axpjrt ̀ jetrjd ejrnktcva kr`mcta`tura ijr ctsadi kel ba`kusa jtmar rahcjekd ̀ ustjns uecjes
kra ejw ce tma nkoceh kel ce tma iutura wcdd dcoady ba astkbdcsmal. Vkrtc`udkrdy ce tma krak
ji lukd-usa `jetrjds, skcl jea pkrtc`cpket, tma Aurjpake Qecje —smjudl sarva ks k njlad
ijr tma H@@, KPAKE, kel jtmars.„ Pj ikr, kejtmar skcl, tma EPH kel jtmar nudtcdktarkd
axpjrt `jetrjd ruda nkoars —mkva ejt baae cetark`tceh„ wctm tma ji`ckds kel khae`cas tmkt
kra ejw jr kra kbjut tj —la`cla je `jnnje `ustjns rudas ijr tmacr `jnnuectcas.„ Jea
pkrtc`cpket suhhastal tmkt tma EPH `jesclar `jesudtceh wctm rahcjekd eu`dakr wakpjes‐
iraa zjea krrkehanaets pursuket tj `krryceh jut rahcjekd jutrak`m.
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tma EPH smjudl iurtmar lavadjp bast prk`tc`as kel
tmae smkra bast prk`tc`as wctm tma jtmar axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets. —Ej bast prk`tc`a
wcdd ba bast ijr key twj spa`c` `juetrcas,„ jea pkrtc`cpket `kutcjeal, —ba`kusa tma ektura
ji trkla, tmacr scza, kel tmacr hjjls-prjlu`ceh a`jejncas wcdd ejt ba claetc`kd.„ Kejtmar
skcl tmkt tma EPH mks k dkw aeijr`anaet huclabjjo ijr cts pkrtc`cpket hjvarenaets, but
tmkt ct wks —axtranady bksc`„ kel wjudl ejt `jetrcbuta tj cnprjvceh tma aiia`tcvaeass ji
EPH hucladcea cnpdanaetktcje? ct smjudl ba cnprjval kel uplktal ce ̀ jddkbjrktcje wctm
axparts ce jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets.
Njra haearkddy, sjna pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tma wjroceh hrjup axparts ce tma
EPH wmj kra raspjescbda ijr nkcetkceceh kel uplktceh tma `jetrjd dcsts smjudl lcs`uss
tmkt wjro wctm `juetarpkrts irjn tma jtmar krrkehanaets.
\ma EPH kel Jtmar Nudtcdktarkd Krrkehanaets
• Njst haearkddy, tma EPH smjudl systanktc`kddy cevastchkta tma pjsscbcdctcas ijr iutura `jd-
dkbjrktcje kel `jjparktcje wctm Xkssaekkr, tma N\@R, tma Kustrkdck Hrjup, VPC, kel jtmar
nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets kel tmae nkoa kpprjk`mas tj tmasa krrkehanaets
ks kpprjprckta.
• \ma EPH `mkcrnke smjudl tkoa tma dakl ce kpprjk`mceh jtmar krrkehanaets kel `jesclar
tma vkdua ji rjutcea naatcehs ji tma `mkcrnae ji tma krrkehanaets.
• Kraks ijr pjtaetckd `jddkbjrktcje tmkt wjudl ba ji nutukd baeat ce`dula7 ai`cae`y kel
ralu`tcje ji raluelke`cas? ceijrnktcje nkekhanaet, ce`dulceh lktk sa`urcty? `jnpkrktcva
tmrakt kssassnaets? hjjl prk`tc`as? `jnpkrktcva cnpdanaetktcje ji `kt`m-kdd prjvcscjes?
laectcje ji eje`jnpdcke`a? `jesaesus ijrnktcje? ektcjekd cetarpratktcjes ji hucladceas?
aeijr`anaet la`cae`cas? kel trust la`cts ae`juetaral lurceh jutrak`m.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesclar sattceh up k parnkeaet wjroceh hrjup knjeh kdd tma krrkeha-
naets tj `jddkbjrkta ce raspjelceh tj `mkddaehas (ce`dulceh tmjsa dcstal kbjva) tmkt kra
`jnnje tj kdd tma krrkehanaets.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 50/70
Nkro Mcbbs | <0
\ma EPH kel tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa
Eunarjus pkrtc`cpkets nkla raiarae`as tj tma wjro ji tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa kel tma pjtae-
tckd ijr ̀ jddkbjrktcje batwaae ct kel tma EPH. Pce`a Rasjdutcje ;1<6–s nkelkta spa`c`kddy
ae`jurkhas cetarektcjekd ̀ jjparktcje ks k nakes ji k`mcavceh cts hjkds, jea pkrtc`cpket suh-
hastal tmkt tmara wjudl ba —k djt ji jvardkps„ wctm jutrak`m wjro `krrcal jut by tma EPH
kel jtmar nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets, aspa`ckddy —ba`kusa tma ;1<6 wjro cs tkrhatal tjwkrl
tma bucdlceh ji ektcjekd `kpk`cty ce cnpdanaetceh _tma rasjdutcje^, wmaraks tma wjro ji
tma _axpjrt ̀ jetrjd krrkehanaets^ cs hakral tjwkrl elceh tma bast prk`tc`as kel `jnnje
hucladceas kel k ̀ jnnje mkrnjeczal kpprjk`m tjwkrl k`mcavceh k ̀ jnpktcbda rasudt.„
Je Kprcd 26, tmraa waaos baijra tma @kreahca wjrosmjp, tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd
pkssal Rasjdutcje ;388, wmc`m axtaelal ijr tae yakrs tma nkelkta ji tma QEP@ ;1<6@jnncttaa ce ksscstceh tma cnpdanaetktcje ji Rasjdutcje ;1<6. Rasjdutcje ;388, pkr-
tc`cpkets suhhastal, wks lcra`tdy radavket tj tma EPH ba`kusa ct nkelktal tmkt tma ;1<6
@jnncttaa cetaesciy cts k`tcvctcas wctm k eunbar ji cetarektcjekd bjlcas ce`dulceh tma
EPH ce jrlar tj prjnjta iudd cnpdanaetktcje ji tma QEP@ rasjdutcje. Vkrtc`cpkets skcl
tmkt savarkd adanaets ji Rasjdutcje ;388 nky ba ji cetarast tj eu`dakr suppdcars7
• tma rasjdutcje–s ra`jhectcje ji tma `jetrcbutcje ji tma Eu`dakr Pa`urcty Punnct
prj`ass?
• cts `kdd je stktas tj —wjro tjhatmar urhaetdy tj pravaet kel supprass k`ts ji
eu`dakr tarrjrcsn ce`dulceh tmrjuhm ce`raksal `jjparktcje kel iudd cnpdanaetk-
tcje ji tma radavket cetarektcjekd `jevaetcjes, kel tmrjuhm kpprjprckta naksuras
tj raceijr`a tma axcstceh dahkd irknawjro„? kel
• cts ce`raksal anpmkscs je claetciyceh kel smkrceh ast a`tcva prk`tc`as.
Jea pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa cs oaae tj —makr irjn stktas kel irjn
bjlcas dcoa tma EPH kel tma Wkehhar @jnncttaa wmara tmay claetciy ai ia`tcva bast prk`-
tc`as wmc`m tma _;1<6^ @jnncttaa `ke pjcet _QE nanbar stktas^ tj,„ aspa`ckddy sce`a
tma `jnncttaa mks ejt lavadjpal key stkelkrls jr ykrlstc`os ijr eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds
je cts jwe.
• \ma EPH smjudl aspa`ckddy `jeiar wctm jtmar krrkehanaets tj djjo ijr `jnnjekdctcas ce
jutrak`m kel wkys tj kllrass `rctc`csn irjn ejepkrtc`cpkets tmkt tmay kra lcs`rcncektjry.
• \ma EPH smjudl mjdl k lcs`usscje wctm tma Kustrkdck Hrjup `je`areceh cts trkespkrae`yaxar`csas wctm EKN stktas.
• \ma EPH smjudl mjdl k lcs`usscje wctm tma Xkssaekkr Krrkehanaet `je`areceh cts aiijrt tj
nkoa cts hucladceas kel `jetrjd dcst akscar tj usa by axpjrt `jetrjd kutmjrctcas.
• \ma EPH smjudl mjdl k lcs`usscje wctm tma Xkssaekkr Krrkehanaet `je`areceh cts aiijrt tj
`jelu`t paar ravcaws kel axtarekd kulcts tj claetciy wakoeassas.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 51/70
<< | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt lurceh tma pkst scx yakrs, `jetk`t batwaae tma EPH kel
tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa mks ejt kdwkys baae aiia`tcva, rahkrldass ji ax`mkehas ji dattars kel
k iaw brcaehs prjvclal by tma EPH tj tma `jnncttaa.
Vkrtc`cpkets ejtal savarkd pjsscbda ̀ jnnje cetarasts kel adls ji aelakvjr ijr bjtm tma
EPH kel tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa, ce wmc`m tma `jnncttaa cs k`tcva7
• jehjceh kel iutura wjro ji tma `jnncttaa je prjdciarktcje trkla eke`ceh?
• tma `jnncttaa–s `jnpcdktcje ji lcskhhrahktal lktk je axpjrt `jetrjd systans ijr
;83 `juetrcas, bksal je `juetry rapjrts subncttal by ektcjekd hjvarenaets ks
nkelktal by Rasjdutcje ;1<6?
• elcehs ji tma `jnncttaa bksal je ektcjekd cnpdanaetktcje rapjrts celc`ktceh
sjna Rasjdutcje ;1<6 ̀ jnpdcke`a la`cts ce sjna EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh `juetrcas?
• elcehs ji tma `jnncttaa `je`areceh la`cts ce parmkps ks nkey ks twj ljzae
stktas wctm sjna ocel ji eu`dakr ceirkstru`tura but wmc`m kra jutscla tma EPH?• tma nutukd cetarast ji tma EPH kel tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa ce claetciyceh kel
prjvclceh stktas wctm ast a`tcva axpjrt `jetrjd prk`tc`as tj `jnpdy wctm Rasjdutcje
;1<6? kel
• tma `jnncttaa–s knbctcje tj sarva ks k `dakrceh mjusa ijr ksscstke`a tj ektcjekd
hjvarenaets ce `kpk`cty bucdlceh.
Pjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt k `djsar radktcjesmcp batwaae tma EPH kel tma ;1<6
@jnncttaa wjudl ba ik`cdctktal by tma ik`t tmkt tma EPH cs k nudtcdktarkd bjly kel tmkt
tma va parnkeaet nanbars ji tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd kra cnpjrtket EPH pkrtc`c-
pkets. \ma kbsae`a ji sjna V-1 `juetrcas irjn k iaw jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd
krrkehanaets, tmay skcl, nkoas ct njra lci`udt ijr tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa tj ra`jhecza tma
`jetrcbutcjes ji tmjsa krrkehanaets.
Ks k bjly ji tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd, tma k`tcvctcas ji tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa kra ̀ djsady
wkt`mal by QE nanbar stktas tj nkoa sura tmay lj ejt trkeshrass stktas– sjvarache rchmts,
pkrtc`cpkets skcl. Ijr tmkt raksje, tma `jnncttaa cs njst `jnijrtkbda ce lakdceh wctm
ektcjekd hjvarenaets kel cetarektcjekd jrhkeczktcjes dcoa tma CKAK ce ik`cdctktceh tma
cnpdanaetktcje ji Rasjdutcje ;1<6. Vkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt, ijr tmkt raksje, tma akscast wky
ijr tma EPH kel tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa tj `jjparkta je key gjcet axar`csas jr k`tcvctcas
mkvceh ke jutrak`m `mkrk`tar, aspa`ckddy tmjsa cevjdvceh pkrtc`cpktcje irjn `cvcd sj`caty jr
celustry, wjudl ba ijr tma EPH tj tkoa tma cectcktcva, sce`a su`m ke cectcktcva ̀ jnceh irjn
tma `jnncttaa nchmt prjnpt `je`ares jr jbga`tcjes irjn QE nanbar stktas. Pmjudl
tma EPH jr cts pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets wket tj prjvcla `kpk`cty-bucdlceh ksscstke`a
tj stktas ce tma ;1<6 prj`ass, ct wjudl ba pjsscbda ijr tma EPH `mkcrnke tj kpprjk`m tma
;1<6 @jnncttaa sapkrktady irjn key bcdktarkd kpprjk`m tj tma `jnncttaa uelartkoae by
key celcvclukd EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet.
Lurceh cetarekd EPH lcs`usscjes `je`areceh eaw hucladceas ijr AER, ct wks khraal
by pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj kll ks k `rctarcje ijr k ra`cpcaet stkta tmkt cs rapjrtceh tj
tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa tmkt tma stkta cs —cnpdanaetceh aiia`tcva axpjrt ̀ jetrjds ks claetcal
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 52/70
Nkro Mcbbs | <1
by Rasjdutcje ;1<6.„ Jea pkrtc`cpket suhhastal tmkt, smjudl tma `jnncttaa–s wjro lurceh
tma eaxt tae yakrs rasudt ce njra aiia`tcva axpjrt `jetrjds ce kdd stktas, tmcs wjudl ik`cdctkta
tma EPH–s ij`usceh je cts hucladceas kel tmacr cnpdanaetktcje.
\ma EPH kel QEP@ Rasjdutcje ;1<6
Ct cs cnpjrtket tmkt tma EPH uelarstkel tmkt tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa cs k na`mkecsn tmkt `ke madp
tma hrjup uecvarskdcza aiia`tcva kppdc`ktcje ji cts hucladceas kel tj astkbdcsm rjbust axpjrt `jetrjd
systans ce ejepkrtc`cpktceh stktas tj qukdciy tman tj pkrtc`cpkta ce tma EPH prj`ass. Ce `jesclar-
ktcje ji tma dk`o ji pjdctc`kd wcdd kel lci`udtcas tmkt wjudl partkce tj key eahjtcktcje ji k hdjbkd
axpjrt `jetrjd trakty, kel ijr tma la`cts ji tma EV\, wmc`m ljas ejt ce`dula kdd eu`dakr suppdcar
stktas kel ljas ejt nkelkta skiahukrls ijr kdd eu`dakr wakpjes‐`rctc`kd ctans, Rasjdutcje ;1<6
kel tma wjro ji cts `jnncttaa kra cnpjrtket cestrunaets tmkt smjudl ba usal tj k`mcava tma hjkdsji uecvarskd kppdc`ktcje ji `jnnje eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjd stkelkrls7
• \ma EPH smjudl wjro wctm tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa tj `rakta k stkelkrl ijr dahkddy bksal
axpjrt `jetrjds ce kdd QE nanbar stktas. (\ma skna kppdcas tj tma jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt
`jetrjd krrkehanaets.)
• \ma EPH smjudl usa lktk je ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd systans `jnpcdal by tma ;1<6 @jn-
ncttaa ce prapkrceh cts jutrak`m prjhrkns.
• \ma EPH smjudl latarncea tmkt `jnpdcke`a wctm Rasjdutcje ;1<6 cs k `jelctcje ijr kdd
eu`dakr trkla axprassal ce tma ravcsal EPH hucladceas.
• \ma EPH smjudl ba wcddceh tj tkoa tma dakl ce `jjparktcje wctm tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa, hcvae
`je`ares ji QE nanbar stktas kbjut tma dcnctktcjes ji tma QE Pa`urcty @jue`cd nkelkta.
• \ma EPH `mkcrnke smjudl mjdl lcs`usscjes wctm tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa tj kllrass keljvar`jna pjdctc`kd saesctcvctcas cemcbctceh ceijrnktcje-smkrceh by tma EPH wctm QE nanbar
stktas tmkt eaal madp ce bucdlceh ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd `kpk`cty.
• \ma EPH smjudl prjvcla tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa ceijrnktcje je hjjl prk`tc`as jbtkceal irjn
iutura paar ravcaws kel jtmar axar`csas kel cevastchktcjes.
Aeijr`anaet kel Aiia`tcvaeass
Celapaelaet ji ae`jurkhanaet irjn wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets tmkt tma EPH straehtmae
cts radktcjesmcps wctm jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets, sjna pkrtc`cpkets
wkreal tmkt tma EPH smjudl ejt ba lcstrk`tal by tmasa cetark`tcjes. —Xa smjudl put jur
aiijrt cetj aesurceh tmkt axcstceh hucladceas kra prjpardy aeijr`al, kel ci wa _lj tmkt^ wa
wcdd lcs`jvar wmara tmara kra hkps kel wmara tmara smjudl ba kllctcjekd hucladceas.„ Ce
nkey `ksas, kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl, tma hucladceas kra —prjlu`al by ji`ckds ce ijrache
kiikcrs ncecstrcas wmj mkva eavar mkl tj aeijr`a jr `jetrjd k irjetcar.„ Xctm tmkt ce ncel,
ma skcl, tma EPH smjudl `jesudt wctm aeijr`anaet khae`cas ce pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets
lurceh cts jehjceh ravcaw ji tma `jetrjd dcsts tj aesura tmkt tma ekd rasudt cs k —`jetrjd
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 53/70
<9 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
dcst tmkt cs ks usar-ircaeldy ks pjsscbda.„ \ma `jetrjd dcst ravcaw smjudl ba ij`usal je cts
jut`jna ijr axpjrt ̀ jetrjd prk`tctcjears, pkrtc`udkrdy ijr lukd-usa ctans. —\ma kssunptcje
ji avarybjly kdjeh tma ̀ mkce ji raspjescbcdcty ijr ̀ jetrjddceh lukd-usa hjjls mks baae tmkt
`ustjns `judl stjp kdd ji tmasa tmcehs kt tma irjetcar vary akscdy, tmkt tmay mkva paria`t
ceijrnktcje, tmkt tma tcnairknas kra su`m, tma wceljws ji jppjrtuecty kra su`m, tmkt tmay
`ke k`tukddy stjp tmasa hjjls. Ct–s ejt tma `ksa.„
Lurceh tma wjrosmjp lcs`usscje savarkd pkrtc`cpkets uelardceal tmkt tma mcstjrc`kd
ra`jrl smjws tmkt celcvclukd `juetrcas rak`t vary laiaescvady tj kddahktcjes tmkt tmay kra
ejt ̀ jetrjddceh tmacr axpjrts. —Badcava na, jvar 21 yakrs C mkva makrl kdd ji tman. Ct ljase–t
nkttar ci ct cs Harnkey jr Vkocstke? tmay kdd sky ”axpjrt `jetrjds kra ejt k prjbdan ce jur
`juetry,– but ce pjcet ji ik`t tmara mks baae vary dcttda lanjestrktcje tmkt ektcjekd `je-
trjds ce key scehda stkta kra aiia`tcva.„ Ijr tmkt raksje, ma skcl,
\ma EPH kel cts pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets smjudl tmceo mkrl kbjut wmkt tmay `judl lj ce
tmcs krak kel tkdo tj tmacr `jddakhuas ce tma jtmar _nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd^ krrkehanaets.
\mara nky ba sjna pusmbk`o irjn pajpda `je`areal kbjut buraku`rktc` knkdhknktcje ji
tma axpjrt `jetrjd rahcnas, but tmara–s `artkcedy rjjn ijr k lcs`usscje. \mara–s ej raksje
wmy tma `mkcrnke ji ak`m ji tma krrkehanaets `judle–t parcjlc`kddy naat kel lcs`uss tmasa
cssuas ceijrnkddy.
Jea pkrtc`cpket wmj mks tkoae pkrt ce nkey EPH ladcbarktcjes skcl tmkt, tj aiia`tcvady
cnpdanaet axpjrt `jetrjds, tma EPH nust trk`o cts jwe aiia`tcvaeass? mjwavar, tma EPH
cs `urraetdy ejt ljceh tmcs. Kllal kejtmar pkrtc`cpket, —\mara cs ke jbdchktcje tj kbcla
by tma hucladceas, kel yju rapjrt wmkt yju lj, but tmara cs ej na`mkecsn tj trk`o wmkt
spa`c` `juetrcas kra ljceh ce `artkce kraks… . \ma trk`oceh cs k vary `jnpdax nkttar… .
Sju kra pjdctc`kddy bjuel tj ladcvar, but yju kra ejt dahkddy bjuel.„
Ce tma pkst, ma skcl, tma EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets mkva `jesclaral paar ravcaws
ji ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd systans —k vary prc`ody cssua. Ct–s `jesclaral by k djt ji pajpda
ce tma EPH rakdn tj ba pjdctc`kddy tkbjj, lci`udt tj cnpdanaet, but sjnajea ce tma
EPH smjudl ba tmceoceh mkrl kbjut k `raktcva wky tj cnpdanaet k paar ravcaw prj`ass
ce tma hrjup.„ Puhhastcjes ijr `jelu`tceh paar ravcaws mkva baae nkla by axparts irjn
kt dakst twj jrhkeczktcjes7 tma @aetar ijr Cetarektcjekd \rkla kel Pa`urcty (@C\P) kt tma
Qecvarscty ji Hajrhck, kel tma Ptj`omjdn Cetarektcjekd Vak`a Rasakr`m Cestctuta (PCVRC).
@C\P mks lavadjpal k natmjljdjhy ijr parijrnceh ravcaws kel mks `krrcal jut ravcaws
ce njra tmke =6 `juetrcas. Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket suhhastal tmkt tma EPH `judl cectckta k
paar ravcaw prj`ass wctmjut raqucrceh k `jesaesus khraanaet by kdd ji cts pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets. —\mara–s ej raksje wmy tmraa jr ijur EPH nanbars `keejt celapaelaetdyuelartkoa batwaae tman k paar ravcaw, djjoceh kt tma EPH hucladceas kel tmacr cnpda-
naetktcje kel tmacr aeijr`anaet ce ak`m ji tmjsa tmraa jr ijur `juetrcas, kel tmae smkra
tmkt ceijrnktcje wctm tma pdaekry kel tmae cevcta jtmar pdaekry nanbars tj hj tmrjuhm
k scncdkr prj`ass.„ Ce jtmar krrkehanaets, paar ravcaws mkva baae `jelu`tal, axparts
dakreal irjn tma jut`jnas, kel —wa mkva ijuel tmcs tj ba vary aiia`tcva. \mara–s ej eaal
ijr k `jesaesus? tmara wcdd kdwkys ba stktas ce tma _nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets^ wmc`m wcdd
kdwkys bdj`o k paar ravcaw, ej quastcje. But ci yju hat <6 par`aet jr 96 par`aet ji tma
nanbars ji tma EPH uelartkoceh paar ravcaws, parmkps ct wcdd ba`jna k ejrn.„
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 54/70
Nkro Mcbbs | <8
Kllal jea pkrtc`cpket, sattceh up k paar ravcaw prj`ass ejw wjudl madp tma EPH tj
aesura tmkt cts ravcaws ji tma `jetrjd dcsts —lje–t rasudt ce njra adkbjrkta dcsts ci ce ik`t tma
EPH cs ejt aiia`tcvady cnpdanaetceh tma dcsts ct kdrakly mks.„
Aiia`tcvaeass kel Aeijr`anaet
• Aspa`ckddy ba`kusa ce`raksal usa ji tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje wcdd ce`raksa tma raqucranaet ijr
rakd-tcna ceijrnktcje-smkrceh, tma EPH nchmt `rakta k wjroceh hrjup tj cevastchkta mjw tj
axpalcta lktk-smkrceh knjeh pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets kel tj `jddkbjrkta tj prjt irjn
tma axparcae`a ji VPC pkrtc`cpkets kel AQ axpjrt `jetrjd kutmjrctcas ce tmcs krak.
• \ma EPH smjudl ae`jurkha tmraa jr ijur pkrtc`cpktceh stktas tj vjduetaar tj `jelu`t k
paar ravcaw ji ektcjekd cnpdanaetktcje ji tma EPH hucladceas ce tmacr raspa`tcva `juetrcas.
Ct smjudl prasaet tma rasudts kt k pdaekry naatceh ce k wky tmkt ik`cdctktas smjwceh mjw
dassjes dakreal irjn tma ravcaw `judl ba haearkdczal. \mcs prj`ass `judl ba brjklaeal sjtmkt, cescla k la`kla, paar ravcaws `judl ba`jna k ejrn.
• \ma EPH smjudl ae`jurkha savarkd pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, kel tmae kdd ji tman, tj
`krry jut ke kekdyscs ji 1 par`aet ji tmacr EPH-dcstal hjjls tj latarncea wmara axpjrt
`jetrjds wara aiia`tcva kel wmara tmay wara ejt aiia`tcva.
• \ma EPH smjudl claetciy hjjl prk`tc`as lurceh paar ravcaws kel smkra tman wctm jtmar
nudtcdktarkd krrkehanaets kel tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jesudt wctm axpjrt `jetrjd aeijr`anaet parsjeead ce EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets lurceh tma ravcaw ji tma `jetrjd dcsts.
\rkespkrae`y kel Jutrak`m
\ma EPH `jelu`tal jutrak`m sancekrs ce ;338 kel ;333 ce raspjesa tj Vrce`cpda ;8 ji
tma Vk`okha ji La`cscjes `je`dulal wmae tma EV\ wks celaectady axtaelal ce ;331,
wmc`m stktal7 —\rkespkrae`y ce eu`dakr-radktal axpjrt `jetrjds smjudl ba prjnjtal
wctmce tma irknawjro ji lckdjhua kel `jjparktcje knjeh kdd cetarastal stktas pkrty tj
tma _EV\^.„ Pjna pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal lurceh tma @kreahca wjrosmjp tmkt tma EPH
rakirn tmkt `jnnctnaet by tkoceh `je`rata staps tj brjklae cts jutrak`m tj celustry,
`cvcd sj`caty, kel eje-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets.Vkrtc`cpkets kdsj skcl tmkt tmara cs k eaal ijr hraktar trkespkrae`y cescla tma hrjup
`jrraspjelceh tj vkryceh lahraas ji `jnnctnaet tj ceijrnktcje-smkrceh ji celcvclukd
pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets. Gust ks tmara wcdd ba EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tmkt wcdd
bkdo kt pkrtc`cpktceh ce k paar ravcaw prj`ass, tmara kra tmjsa stktas tmkt kra radu`tket tj
smkra ceijrnktcje kt k schec`ket jr laap davad. @mcek (tma jedy EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh stkta
irjn tma hraktar Ksck-Vk`c` rahcje tmkt lcl ejt kttael tma wjrosmjp) wks naetcjeal by
savarkd wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets ce tmcs rahkrl. Jea pkrtc`cpket skcl tmkt ma mkl kttaelal
eunarjus EPH ceijrnktcje-smkrceh naatcehs kel ejtal tmkt —ct cs tma skna va jr scx
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 55/70
<= | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
`juetrcas hcvceh prasaetktcjes kel tma skna `juetrcas prjvclceh `ksa stulcas avary scehda
tcna. Pjna `juetrcas kt tmasa avaets eavar avae spako.„ Pjna pkrtc`cpkets rahrattal tma
dk`o ji k na`mkecsn tj `jnpad jr ae`jurkha radu`tket EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets
tj njra iuddy pkrtc`cpkta but ks`rcbal tmkt stkta ji kiikcrs tj tma vjduetkry ektura ji tma
krrkehanaet. —Ijr sjna pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, pkrtc`cpktcje cs k jea-wky straat,„ jea
skcl. —\may kttael EPH naatcehs sjdady tj el tmcehs jut, ejt tj lcs`djsa.„
Ce tma cetarast ji hraktar trkespkrae`y, sjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt tma EPH smjudl tkoa
k systanktc` djjo kt cts laeckd-smkrceh prj`ass tj try tj `rakta k `jesaesus tjwkrl k hraktar
smkrceh ji laeckd ceijrnktcje.
Xmae tma EPH ̀ rkital cts kpprjk`m tj tma lukd-usa `mkddaeha ce ;332, ct jrlkceal tmkt
ej nanbar smjudl tkoa klvketkha ji tma laeckd ji ke axpjrt by kejtmar nanbar tj par-
nct cts celustry tj axpjrt tma skna ctan tj tma ra`cpcaet subga`t tj k laeckd. \j nkoa tmkt
pjdc`y aiia`tcva, EPH pkrtc`cpkets rjutceady ax`mkeha laeckd lktk vck k Gjcet Ceijrnktcje
Ax`mkeha, wmc`m naats je`a jr njra par yakr. Ba`kusa laeckd ceijrnktcje `ke ba usaiud
tj prjdciarktjrs, mjwavar, tma EPH mks baae radu`tket tj smkra laeckd lktk wctm stktas tmkt
kra ejt nanbars but kra subga`t tj jutrak`m, ce`dulceh Celck, Csrkad, kel Vkocstke. \mara
cs kdsj ej systanktc` laeckd-smkrceh kpprjk`m ce tma EPH radktal tj cnpdanaetktcje ji
tma `kt`m-kdd prjvcscje. \ma EPH kdsj ljas ejt smkra laeckd ceijrnktcje wctm tma CKAK.
Pavarkd pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tma EPH smkra cts laeckd ceijrnktcje wctm tma CKAK
Lapkrtnaet ji Pkiahukrls, sce`a tmkt ceijrnktcje wjudl ksscst tma CKAK ce cnpdanaetceh
tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd ce nanbar stktas kel tmaraby `jetrcbuta tj k njra `jnpramae-
scva tmrakt kssassnaet, wmc`m wjudl ce ture ba vkdukbda tj tma EPH kel cts pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets ce nkoceh la`cscjes kbjut spa`c` eu`dakr trkesiars. But sjna pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets nky ejt suppjrt prjvclceh ceijrnktcje tj tma CKAK, sce`a tmay mkva dcttda
`jelae`a tmkt tma CKAK wjudl pravaet su`m ceijrnktcje irjn baceh dakoal tj key ji cts;16 nanbar stktas. Vkrtc`cpkets kdsj pjcetal jut tmkt, ba`kusa ji tma CKAK–s skiahukrls
`jelaetckdcty prjvcscjes, ceijrnktcje-smkrceh wctm tma EPH `judl akscdy ejt ba ra`cprj-
`kd“tmkt cs, tma CKAK ̀ judl ejt prjvcla tma EPH ceijrnktcje irjn cts lktkbksa je ̀ jue-
try prjdas, wmc`m wjudl lcra`tdy ksscst tma EPH ce cts prjdciarktcje tmrakt kssassnaets.
Vkrtc`cpkets skcl, mjwavar, tmkt, wara tma CKAK hcvae tma laeckd lktk, tma CKAK `judl
ae`jurkha stktas wmjsa ael-usars kra subga`t tj EPH laeckds tj prjvcla hraktar ceijrnk-
tcje kbjut tmacr k`tcvctcas kel tmae prjvcla tmkt lktk tj tma EPH. Aspa`ckddy ce `ksas ce
wmc`m aetctcas subga`t tj laeckds kra ejt prjdciarktjrs, stktas cnpdanaetceh ke Kllctcjekd
Vrjtj`jd smjudl ba wcddceh tj `jjparkta wctm tma CKAK, kel tma rasudts ji `jjparktcje
wjudl baeat tma cnpjrtar, cts stkta kutmjrctcas, tma CKAK, kel tma EPH.Pjna pkrtc`cpkets ce tma wjrosmjp ̀ jnpdkceal tmkt tmara cs ej jparktcjekd laectcje ji
wmkt `jestctutas k laeckd, parncttceh sjna stktas tmkt kra radu`tket tj smkra lktk wctm jtmar
EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets ejt tj ceijrn tman ji laecal trkesk`tcjes je tma hrjuels
tmkt tma stkta, usceh kutmjrcty ejt ijrnkddy ce`jrpjrktal cetj tma axpjrt dc`aesceh prj`ass,
cetarvaeal wctm tma axpjrtar kel parsuklal jr ijr`al ct ejt tj axpjrt tma ctan ce quastcje.
Icekddy, ce tma cetarast ji trkespkrae`y, sjna wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt tma
EPH wabscta ba uphrklal kel iraquaetdy nkcetkceal kel uplktal. Pjna ji tma ceijrnktcje
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 56/70
Nkro Mcbbs | <3
je tma wabscta cs `urraetdy jut ji lkta. \ma scta ̀ judl ba trkesijrnal cetj k usaiud rasjur`a
ijr axpjrt ̀ jetrjd ceijrnktcje, ce`dulceh jpae sjur`a ceijrnktcje irjn pkrtc`cpktceh hjv-
arenaets wmjsa kutmjrctcas kra dceoal tj tma EPH wabscta, kel tma scta `judl sarva ks ke
cetark`tcva sjuelceh bjkrl ijr prjvclceh raquastal ceijrnktcje je mjw tma EPH iue`-
tcjes, wctm uplktal ceijrnktcje irjn pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets, tma @jesudtktcva Hrjup,
wjroceh hrjups je ceijrnktcje ax`mkeha kel trkespkrae`y cssuas, kel tma EPH `mkcrnke.
\rkespkrae`y kel Jutrak`m
• \ma EPH smjudl astkbdcsm `jetk`t wctm, kel prjvcla brcaehs kel bk`ohrjuel ceijrnktcje
tj, tma wjroceh hrjups prapkrceh ijr tma 26;1 EV\ Ravcaw @jeiarae`a kel iutura ravcaw
`jeiarae`as.
•\ma EPH smjudl cetaesciy `jjparktcje wctm ejepkrtc`cpktceh trkessmcppceh stktas, ce`dulcehax`mkehceh ceijrnktcje tj claetciy kel latar k`tcvctcas by prjdciarktceh ael-usars.
• Ke EPH wjroceh hrjup smjudl ik`cdctkta pkrtc`cpktceh stktas aiijrts tj mkrnjecza ektcjekd
rudas ijr smkrceh ceijrnktcje, ce`dulceh prcvk`y kel dahkd lcs`djsura hucladceas.
• \ma EPH smjudl spjesjr kel ik`cdctkta jehjceh lcs`usscje by pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets
tjwkrl k `jnnje kppdc`ktcje ji tma EPH–s ;33< —ejeprjdciarktcje prce`cpda„ ce tma hucla-
dceas, kel ct smjudl lrkit `jnnje `rctarck ijr tmcs prjvcscje ijr usa by ektcjekd hjvarenaet
dc`aesceh kutmjrctcas.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jnnuec`kta tmjsa lrkit `rctarck tj `cvcd sj`caty, tj tma EKN, tj jtmar EV\
`jestctuaets, kel tj tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa ijr cts wjro ce ksscstceh `kpk`cty bucdlceh.
• Dcoawcsa, tma EPH smjudl lavadjp k natmjljdjhy tj raelar laeckds njra jbga`tcva uelar
tma EPH hucladceas. \mcs `judl ba ladahktal tj k wjroceh hrjup.
• \ma EPH smjudl `jelu`t jutrak`m tj celustry tj prjvcla ejeprjdciarktcje bk`ohrjuel cd-
dustrktceh mjw prjdciarktjrs wjro kel wmy axpjrt `jetrjds kra cnpjrtket tj hdjbkd sa`urcty.
• \ma EPH smjudl smkra laeckd kel axpjrt ceijrnktcje“ce k nkeear tmkt ljas ejt vcjdkta
`jnnar`ckd `jelaetckdcty kel lcstjrt jpae trklceh prk`tc`as“wctm tma CKAK ijr cts usa ce
cnpdanaetceh tma Kllctcjekd Vrjtj`jd.
• \ma EPH smjudl mjdl k lcs`usscje tj `je`dula wmkt `jestctutas k laeckd kel hat k `jesae-
sus khraanaet je tma kppdc`ktcje ji tmkt laectcje? ce pkrkddad, ct smjudl sa`ura khraanaet
irjn kdd pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj smkra ceijrnktcje je saczuras ji hjjls by ektcjekd
kutmjrctcas.
• \ma EPH `mkcrnke smjudl bahce k lcs`usscje tj ae`jurkha pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets tj
nkoa uplktal ceijrnktcje kbjut tmacr ektcjekd axpjrt `jetrjd prj`ass kvkcdkbda tj jtmars ce
tma EPH, wctm tma hjkd ji nkoceh tmcs prk`tc`a k ejrn.
• \ma EPH smjudl mcra k `jesudtket tj cnprjva, uphrkla, kel nkxcncza tma aiia`tcvaeass ji
tma EPH wabscta ks k trkespkrae`y kel `jnnuec`ktcjes nalcun.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 57/70
16 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Nudtcdktarkd Eu`dakr Iuad Kssurke`as
Ce La`anbar 26;6, tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs kpprjval tma `raktcje ji k eu`dakr iuad
bkeo tmkt wjudl sarva ks k stjphkp suppdy ji djw-aerc`mal urkecun (DAQ) iuad ijr ke
CKAK nanbar stkta, smjudl suppdy ji iuad tj tmkt stkta irjn jtmar sjur`as ba cetarruptal
ijr eje-`jnnar`ckd raksjes. Okzkomstke mks vjduetaaral tj mjst tma iuad bkeo. \ma DAQ
wjudl ba jweal by tma CKAK.
\ma astkbdcsmnaet ji tma iuad bkeo nky ea`assctkta sjna klgustnaets jr `dkrc`ktcjes
ce EPH hucladceas, skcl jea pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet ji`ckd lurceh tma wjrosmjp. —Ct
nust ba latarnceal wmatmar tma DAQ rasarva kel subsaquaet trkesiars ji iuad tj tma
CKAK kel tmae tmarakitar tj ra`cpcaet stktas kra `jnpktcbda wctm tma EPH hucladceas,„
ma skcl. Ma kdsj skcl tmkt tma EPH hucladceas smjudl ba knaelal tj spadd jut tma EPH–s
ncsscje jr pjsctcje je kssurke`a ji suppdy. Kejtmar pkrtc`cpket, njra haearkddy, urhal
tma EPH tj nkoa k ijrnkd stktanaet ce tma hucladceas kel —kljpt eaw dkehukha wmc`m
raiars tj EV\ Krtc`da CY rchmts kel rahcstars EPH–s ̀ jnnctnaet tj prjnjta cetarektcjekd`jjparktcje kel rakddy rakirn tma cekdcaekbda rchmt ji kdd EV\ pkrtcas tj tma pak`aiud
usas ji eu`dakr aearhy, ks djeh ks tma ra`cpcaets kra `jeijrnceh wctm tmacr EV\ jbdchk-
tcjes. Pcncdkr la`dkrktcjes kra ijuel ce stktanaets ji tma QE Haearkd Kssanbdy, QEP@
Rasjdutcje ;==8, kel ce tma lj`unaets ji tma EV\ Ravcaw @jeiarae`as.„
K``jrlceh tj jea pkrtc`cpket, tmara kra kdsj cssuas ijr tma EPH tj rasjdva `je`are-
ceh tma ael-usar `artc`ktas ijr trkesiar ji eu`dakr nktarckd ce tma iuad bkeo. —Ael-usar
`artc`ktas kra naetcjeal ce tma hucladceas ijr tma trkesiar ji _eu`dakr^ nktarckd… . But
tma prj`alura ijr ael-usar `artc`ktas cs ejt `dakrdy laeal, ejr ljas ct mkva k rahudktjry
irknawjro ijr usceh kel kppdyceh ael-usar `artc`ktas ce prk`tc`a. \mara axcsts ke ue`ar-
tkcety kel tma EPH hucladceas lj ejt klaquktady kllrass tma rudas ijr cssuceh ael-usar`artc`ktas.„ Ma kdsj skcl tmkt tmara cs knbchucty `je`areceh sjna ael-usar-radktal cssuas,
ce`dulceh wmc`m kutmjrcty ce tma cnpjrtceh `juetry mks tma raspjescbcdcty tj cssua ael-
usar `artc`ktas kel wmkt mkppaes ce `ksas ce wmc`m varc`ktcje ji ke ael-usar `artc`kta
cs laanal ea`asskry.
\mara nky ba `ksas, kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl, wmara tma ael-usar `artc`kta wjudl ba
cssual by ke khae`y wmc`m wjudl ejt ba `jnpktcbda wctm tma axpjrt `jetrjd dkw ce ke
EPH suppdcar stkta. \mara kra kdsj quastcjes kbjut tma rchmt ji tma ra`cpcaet tj ra-axpjrt
tma iuad. Ce `ksas ce wmc`m tma iuad wks tj ba ra-axpjrtal wctmjut `jesaet, wmj wjudl ba
madl k``juetkbda: \ma CKAK, jr tma stkta tmkt suppdcal tma urkecun: \mcs pkrtc`cpket
klvcsal tmkt —ke ax`mkeha ji vcaws„ kbjut ael-usar `artc`ktas smjudl tkoa pdk`a wctmcetma @jesudtktcva Hrjup, kel tmkt jea jr njra pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets smjudl prapkra
k lj`unaet jutdceceh k bast prk`tc`a ijr ael-usar `artc`ktas.
Ce EPH ladcbarktcjes sj ikr, kejtmar pkrtc`cpket skcl, sjna pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets
mkva tkoae tma pjsctcje tmkt axpjrt `jetrjd cssuas radktal tj nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr iuad `y`da
na`mkecsns `ke ba kllrassal wctmjut tmacr ce`duscje ce tma EPH hucladceas.
K``jrlceh tj jtmar pkrtc`cpkets, ce `ksas ce wmc`m k stkta raquasts DAQ irjn tma iuad
bkeo, tma CKAK wjudl prjvcla tma ea`asskry lj`unaetktcje ijr tma trkesiar k``jrlceh
tj tma axpjrt `jetrjd raqucranaets ji tma `juetry mjstceh tma iuad bkeo. \ma prjpjskd
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 58/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 1;
ijr tma iuad bkeo na`mkecsn, wmc`m wks kpprjval by tma CKAK bjkrl ji hjvarejrs, sats
`jelctcjes tmkt wjudl mkva tj ba nat by k ra`cpcaet stkta. \masa ce`dula k pak`aiud-usa
`jnnctnaet, CKAK skiahukrls, kel dcnctktcje ji tma usa ji tma urkecun ks iuad ijr ada`-
trc` pjwar haearktcje ce k spa`c` rak`tjr ks claetcal ce tma jrchcekd khraanaet batwaae
tma iuad suppdcar kel tma ra`cpcaet. K``jrlceh tj pkrtc`cpkets, tmasa `jelctcjes kra ejt
claetc`kd wctm tma `jelctcjes ji suppdy ji urkecun iuad axprassal ce tma EPH hucladceas?
tma lciiarae`as nust ba ra`tcal.
\ma EPH kel Nudtcdktarkd Iuad Kssurke`as
\ma EPH smjudl raquast irjn Okzkomstke, kel parmkps k iaw jtmar stktas, lcs`usscje pkpars
je hjjl prk`tc`as ijr nudtcdktarkd iuad bkeos kel aspa`ckddy ael-usa stktanaet kel jbdchktcjes
(—flkh„) nkekhanaet.
Njra haearkddy, tma EPH smjudl `jesclar mjw eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds, uetcd ejw klncecstaral by
ektcjekd hjvarenaets, wjudl ba cnpdanaetal uelar k nudtcdktarkd iuad kssurke`a s`mana.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 59/70
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 60/70
10
@je`duscje7 \ma EPH kt tma@rjssrjkls ji ke AvjdvcehEu`dakr \rkla Rahcna
Jvar tma ̀ jursa ji njra tmke tmraa la`klas, tma EPH, ijr ̀ jnpaddceh raksjes, mks ba`jna
tma daklceh nudtcdktarkd eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaet. Lurceh tma pkst la`kla, tma
lrknktc` avjdutcje ji cetarektcjekd eu`dakr trkla, ks wadd ks ji tma eu`dakr prjdciarktcje
tmrakts k``jnpkeyceh tmkt trkla, mks lanjestrktal tmkt ce tma iutura tma EPH nust
rankce ke assaetckd cestrunaet tj pravaet eu`dakr nktarckd, aqucpnaet, kel ta`mejdjhy
irjn hattceh cetj tma mkels ji tmjsa wmj saao tj lavadjp eu`dakr krns.
\ma wjrosmjp madl by tma @kreahca Aeljwnaet ce Brussads ce Nky axpdjral k eun-
bar ji cssuas tmkt wcdd `jeirjet tma EPH ejw kel ce `jnceh yakrs. Pjna ji tmasa“ijr
axknpda, mjw tma hrjup lakds wctm @mcek–s eu`dakr trkla wctm Vkocstke“wcdd raqucrakeswars vary sjje. Jtmar cssuas“su`m ks mjw tma
EPH kpprjk`mas iutura nanbarsmcp kel mjw ct
klkpts cts trkla rudas“mkva k sjnawmkt djehar trk-
ga`tjry, but tmay nust ba kllrassal ci tma EPH cs tj
ba aiia`tcva kel `ralcbda.
\ma EPH wks ijrnal by k hrjup ji eu`dakr
suppdcar stktas tmkt wara `jevce`al kitar tma rst
Celcke eu`dakr axpdjscva tast tmkt tma EV\ kdjea
wjudl ejt mkdt tma sprakl ji eu`dakr wakpjes. \mkt
kssassnaet prjval tj ba `jrra`t. K eunbar ji EV\pkrtcas bahceeceh ce tma dkta ;386s“Ejrtm Ojrak,
Ahypt, Crkq, Crke, Dcbyk, tma Rapubdc` ji Ojrak, Pyrck, kel parmkps Nykenkr“aehkhal
ce uela`dkral jr `dkelastcea eu`dakr k`tcvctcas. \ma la`cscjes ji hjvarenaets tj `mkddaeha
tma EV\ by aehkhceh ce tmasa k`tcvctcas lcl ejt stan irjn tmacr `je`are tmkt k —`krtad„ ji
eu`dakr suppdcars wks bdj`oceh tmacr k``ass tj pak`aiud eu`dakr lavadjpnaet. \ma uela-
`dkral k`tcvctcas ce tmasa `juetrcas dcoawcsa wara ejt tarncektal jr la`dkral tj tma CKAK
ks k rasudt ji `je`asscjes je eu`dakr trkla nkla tj tmasa `juetrcas by EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh
hjvarenaets.
\ma EPH nust rankce ke assaetckd
cestrunaet tj pravaet eu`dakr nktarckd,
aqucpnaet, kel ta`mejdjhy irjn
hattceh cetj tma mkels ji tmjsa wmj
saao tj lavadjp eu`dakr krns.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 61/70
1< | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
Irjn cts ce`aptcje, tma EPH ax`aalal tma tarns ji EV\ Krtc`da CCC.2 wmae ct sat kllc-
tcjekd `jelctcjes ijr eu`dakr `jnnar`a ce ;38=. \ma lcstke`a batwaae tma kspcrktcjes ji
tma EPH kel tma nkelkta ji Krtc`da CCC.2 mks ba`jna avae hraktar jvar tcna, aspa`ckddy
ks suppdcar stktas– tmrakt kssassnaets avjdval. Irjn tmcs pjcet ji vcaw, tma la`cscje ce
prce`cpda by tma hrjup ce 266= tj dcit eu`dakr trkla ske`tcjes khkcest Celck wks ejt ke
cddjhc`kd lavadjpnaet.
But tmkt la`cscje tmraa yakrs khj mkl tj rkcsa tma quastcje ji wmatmar tmkt stap wks
trudy k —scehudkr ax`aptcje„ tj prce`cpdas sat by ;36 EV\ pkrtcas, ks cts nkce klvj`ktas
`dkcnal, jr wmatmar ct cestakl nkroal k schec`ket
`jursa `jrra`tcje by tma EPH tjwkrl tma hjkd ji
jbtkceceh tma klmarae`a kel pkrtc`cpktcje ji kdd
eu`dakr suppdcar stktas, ce`dulceh tmjsa jutscla tma
EV\ tmkt mkva urkecun aerc`mnaet, raprj`assceh,
kel eu`dakr wakpjes.
@kreahca tmaraijra kcnal tj put tma EPH–s radk-
tcjesmcp tj tma EV\ tj tma tast lurceh tmcs wjro-
smjp. Vkrtc`cpkets irjn Celck, Csrkad, kel Vkocstke
prasaetal krhunaets ks tj wmy tmasa `juetrcas
smjudl ba ce`dulal ce tma krrkehanaet. \mara wks ej `jesaesus knjeh tma pkrtc`cpkets
ce tma wjrosmjp tmkt tmkt smjudl mkppae ce tma eakr iutura.
Celaal, sjna pkrtc`cpkets skcl tmkt tma EPH–s ra`aet kirnktcje tmkt jedy EV\ pkr-
tcas nky jbtkce AER schecal tmkt suppdcar stktas kra ijr ejw radu`tket tj hj ikrtmar ljwe
tma rjkl ce lcvjr`ceh tma hrjup irjn k hdjbkd trakty bcelceh ;=1 stktas ejt tj k`qucra
eu`dakr krns. But sjna pkrtc`cpkets kdsj skcl tmkt tma EPH wjudl ejt udtcnktady su``aal
ce tma iutura uedass kdd eu`dakr-suppdcar kel eu`dakr-krnal stktas klmara tj cts hucladceas,aiia`tcvady smkra ceijrnktcje, kel `jjparkta wctm tma krrkehanaet.
Ce tma naketcna, tma EPH `ke lj njra tj uecvarskdcza klmarae`a tj cts hucladceas.
Vkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt nkey jr parmkps avae njst ji tma QE–s ;30 nanbar stktas
wjudl ejt pkrtc`cpkta ce k hdjbkd axpjrt `jetrjd trakty. But sce`a 266<, kdd tmasa stktas
mkva baae `jnncttal tj `jetrjddceh tmacr axpjrts uelar QEP@ Rasjdutcje ;1<6, kel tma
EPH smjudl wjro `djsady wctm tma ;1<6 @jnncttaa tj astkbdcsm kel uecvarskdcza k hdjbkd
stkelkrl ijr eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds, kel tj bucdl `kpk`cty ce ektcjekd hjvarenaets tj
mkva tmkt stkelkrl kppdcal kel aeijr`al.
Ks pkrt ji tmkt prj`ass, tma EPH `ke tkoa jtmar staps tmkt wcdd lanjestrkta trkespkr-
ae`y tj ejepkrtc`cpkets kel cespcra `jelae`a ce tman tmkt tma krrkehanaet cs `jnnct-tal tj eu`dakr trkla aqucty. Aehkhceh wctm tmjsa `juetrcas ejw kel ce tma iutura wcdd ba
ikr njra ̀ rctc`kd tmke kt key tcna ce tma EPH–s mcstjry, ba`kusa cetarektcjekd eu`dakr ̀ jn-
nar`a cs rkpcldy avjdvceh kwky irjn pjcet-tj-pjcet trkesiars kel cetj k systan ji ̀ jnpdax
trkesk`tcjes cevjdvceh lastcektcjes kel k`tjrs tmkt mkva uetcd ejw baae lcs`jeea`tal
irjn tma wjrdl ji eu`dakr trkla `jetrjds.
Njrajvar, tma vjduna ji eu`dakr trkla kel tma eunbar ji aetctcas tkoceh pkrt ce ct
cs rkpcldy ce`raksceh. Lurceh tma `jnceh twj la`klas, tma eunbar ji pjwar rak`tjrs ce
tma wjrdl“k eunbar wmc`m mks baae stkbda lurceh tma dkst twaety yakrs“nky ljubda.
Ce k hdjbkdczal aevcrjenaet ce wmc`m
eu`dakr hjjls nky ba prjlu`al
jr trkesk`tal keywmara ce tma
wjrdl, tma EPH nust rak`m jut.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 62/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 11
\j aiia`tcvady `jetrjd k bchhar trkla vjduna, tma EPH nust rchjrjusdy `mkddaeha cts jwe
mkbcts kel tmjsa ji cts pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaets? ct nust wjro njra `djsady wctm aeijr`-
ars, `jnpkra ejtas wctm jtmar nudtcdktarkd axpjrt `jetrjd krrkehanaets, kel“lurceh tma
eaxt tmraa yakrs“nkoa wktarsmal la`cscjes kbjut wmkt hjjls ct smjudl `jetrjd ce tma
iutura kel mjw ct smjudl `jetrjd tman.
Lurceh tma wjrosmjp, k iaw pkrtc`cpkets suhhastal tmkt sjna hjvarenaets wcdd rascst
aiijrts tj ijrha radktcjesmcps batwaae tma EPH kel jtmars tmkt smkra tma raspjescbcdcty ji
pravaetceh tma sprakl ji wakpjes ji nkss lastru`tcje, ks wadd ks tmjsa wmjsa trust wcdd ba
assaetckd ci tma EPH cs tj ba `ralcbda. But njra ejw tmke avar baijra, tma EPH `keejt
iue`tcje ce csjdktcje, kel ct ̀ keejt ba k `dub. Ce k hdjbkdczal aevcrjenaet ce wmc`m eu`dakr
hjjls nky ba prjlu`al jr trkesk`tal keywmara ce tma wjrdl, tma EPH nust rak`m jut.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 63/70
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 64/70
18
Ejtas
; Cetarektcjekd Pancekr je tma Rjda ji Axpjrt @jetrjds ce Eu`dakr Ejeprjdciarktcje, Ycaeek,
J`tjbar 8‐= , ;338, www.eu`dakrsuppdcarshrjup.jrh/Daeh/VLI/Pancekr@jetrjd;.pli? Pa`jel
EPH Cetarektcjekd Pancekr je tma Rjda ji Axpjrt @jetrjds ce Eu`dakr Ejeprjdciarktcje, Qectal
Ektcjes Maklqukrtars, Eaw Sjro, Kprcd =‐3, ;333, www.eu`dakrsuppdcarshrjup.jrh/Daeh/VLI/
2 \ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa–s —trchhar dcst„ wks rst pubdcsmal by tma CKAK ce ;38<, www.ckak.jrh/
Vubdc`ktcjes/Lj`unaets/Cei`cr`s/Jtmars/cei263.smtnd.
0 @jnnuec`ktcje Ra`acval irjn @artkce Nanbar Ptktas Rahkrlceh Hucladceas ijr tma Axpjrt
ji Eu`dakr Nktarckd, Aqucpnaet jr \a`mejdjhy, Cetarektcjekd Ktjnc` Aearhy Khae`y, Iabrukry
;38=, www.vartc`.jrh/nalck/kssats/ecnZlj`s/EPH%26kel%26W@/CEI@CR@-21<.pli.
< @jnnuec`ktcje Ra`acval irjn @artkce Nanbar Ptktas Rahkrlceh Hucladceas ijr tma Axpjrt ji
Eu`dakr Nktarckd, Aqucpnaet jr \a`mejdjhy, Cetarektcjekd Ktjnc` Aearhy Khae`y, Gudy ;332,
www.ckak.jrh/Vubdc`ktcjes/Lj`unaets /Cei`cr`s/Jtmars/cei`cr`21<r;p2.pli.
1 Kda` Bkar, —Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup kel cts \cna,„ Pa`jel EPH Cetarektcjekd Pancekr je
tma Rjda ji Axpjrt @jetrjds ce Eu`dakr Ejeprjdciarktcje, Kprcd =‐3, ;333, Qectal Ektcjes
Maklqukrtars, Eaw Sjro, @jeiarae`a Rapjrt, www.eu`dakrsuppdcarshrjup.jrh/Daeh/VLI/
9 Runjrs kbjuel tmkt Vkocstke–s aerc`mnaet oejw-mjw cs ce tma mkels ji Kdharck, Ahypt, Celck,
Crkq, Csrkad, Nykenkr, Pkulc Krkbck, Pyrck, Pulke, kel \uroay, knjeh jtmars. Ejea ji tmasa
runjrs mks baae `jernal, kel ce sjna `ksas hjvarenaets mkva laecal tman. Ce ra`aet yakrs,
prass rapjrts mkva spa`udktal tmkt Omke sarval k —ijurtm `ustjnar„ ce kllctcje tj Crke, Dcbyk,
kel Ejrtm Ojrak. Paa Gaiiray Dawcs, —\ma Ijurtm @ustjnar,„ Krns @jetrjd Xjeo, Kprcd 22,
2661, mttp 7//dawcs.krns`jetrjdwjeo.`jn/kr`mcva/11=/tma-ijurtm-`ustjnar? kel Ljuhdks
Irketz, Cetarvcaw wctm \kvcs Pncday, \kvcs Pncday , VBP, Gkeukry 2;, 26;;, www.pbs.jrh/weat/
tkvcssncday/cetarvcaws/kutmjr-ljuhdks-irketz.
8 Vrcvkta ̀ jnnuec`ktcjes irjn EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet ji`ckds.
= Nc`mkad Orapje, —Cs tma QP-Celck Eu`dakr @jjparktcje Khraanaet Hjjl jr Bkl ijrVrjdciarktcje:„ Ptcnsje @aetar, Kuhust 0;, 2661, www.stcnsje.jrh/asskys/cs-tma-us-celck-
eu`dakr-`jjparktcje-khraanaet-hjjl-jr-bkl-ijr-prjdciarktcje.
3 —Russck 7 Eu`dakr Axpjrt s tj Celck,„ Eu`dakr \mrakt Cectcktcva, @aetar ijr Ejeprjdciarktcje
Ptulcas, 26;6, www.etc.jrh/lb/ecsprjis/russck/axpjrts/ruscel/eu`djvr.mtn.
;6 Vkrkhrkpm <.(b) ji Cei`cr`/21</Vkrt ;.
;; —Russcke Iuad ijr \krkpur Rudal Jut,„ Mcelu, La`anbar 9, 266<.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 65/70
1= | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
;2 [uaetce Nc`mad, —Anarhceh Cetarektcjekd Ptkelkrls7 Ci k Lrakn @judl @jna \rua,„ Qecvarscty
ji Dcíha, Nky 28, 2663, mttp7//dj`kd.lrjct.udh.k`.ba/sk/uaa/klnce/da/pubdc/2663;660681;<6Z
Askrlk[N.pli.
;0 —Russck kel Celck rakly tj trkla,„ Xjrdl Eu`dakr \rkla , La`anbar 1, 266=, www.wjrdl-eu`dakr-
eaws.jrh/eawskrtc`da.kspx:cl>2033<&tarns>celck
;< Hdaee Oassdar, —Csrkad Pubncts Eu`dakr \rkla Vdke,„ Xksmcehtje Vjst , Paptanbar 06, 2668.
;1 EPH Vdaekry Naatceh, Ptraehtmaeceh tma Eu`dakr Eje-Vrjdciarktcje Rahcna, Hjtmaeburh,
Pwalae, Nky 28‐2=, 266<, www.eu`dakrsuppdcarshrjup.jrh/Daeh/VRAPP/266<-61-hjtabjrh.pli.
;9 Nkro Mcbbs, —\ma Qenkoceh ji k Eu`dakr Pnuhhdar,„ Buddatce ji tma Ktjnc` P`caetcsts , vjd. 92,
ej. 9, 01‐<;.
;8 Lkvcl Kdbrchmt, Vkud Brkeeke kel Kelraw P`maad Ptrc`oar, —Lata`tceh kel Lcsruptceh Cddc`ct
Eu`dakr \rkla kitar K. [. Omke,„ Xksmcehtje [ukrtardy , vjd. 00, ej. 2, =1‐;69.
;= Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcje irjn ke AQ axpjrt ̀ jetrjd ji`ckd.
;3 \mkt hrjup ce`dulas Kdharck, Bkehdklasm, @mcda, Ahypt, A`ukljr, Hmkek, Gjrlke, Dcbyk,
Njrj``j, Jnke, [ktkr, Echarck, Vmcdcppceas, Pkulc Krkbck, \mkcdkel, \uecsck, Yaeazuadk, kelYcatekn.
26 —Celck–s 26tm eu`dakr pjwar pdket hjas `rctc`k d,„ Mcelustke \cnas , Ejvanbar 28, 26;6.
2; —Celck ayaceh 90,666 NX eu`dakr pjwar `kpk`cty by 26027 EV@CD,„ A`jejnc` \cnas , J`tjbar
;;, 26;6.
22 Pkvctk Vkela, —EV\, Axpjrt @jetrjds, kel Eu`dakr \rkla,„ Cestctuta ijr Laiae`a Ptulcas kel
Kekdysas, www.clsk-celck.jrh/ke-sap-<.mtnd.
20 Cetarvaetcje by @krdtje \mjrea, Q.P. Lapkrtnaet ji Ptkta, je \uaslky, J`tjbar 8, ;338
_kutmjr–s ejtas irjn tma naatceh^.
2< Cetarvaetcje by Knbksskljr N. P. Kyktjddkmc, je \uaslky, J`tjbar 8, ;338 _kutmjr–s ejtas irjn
tma naatceh^.
21 Mkrkdl Nuaddar, —\ma 2661 EV\ Ravcaw @jeiarae`a7 Raksjes kel @jesaquae`as ji Ikcdura kel
Jptcjes ijr Rapkcr,„ www.bdcxkssj`cktas.`jn/wp-`jetaet/updjkls/26;;/60/Ej0;.pli.
29 26;6 EV\ Ravcaw @jeiarae`a K`tcje Vdke irjn tma Icekd Lj`unaet kljptal by 26;6 Ravcaw
@jeiarae`a ji tma Vkrtcas tj tma \rakty je tma Eje-Vrjdciarktcje ji Eu`dakr Xakpjes, www.
rak`mceh`rctc`kdwcdd.jrh/dahkd/ept/rav̀ je26;6/26;6EV\K`tcjeVdke.pli.
28 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcjes tj tma kutmjr irjn pkrtc`cpkets kt EPH pdaekry naatceh ce
Hjtmaeburh, Pwalae, Nky 28‐2=, 266<.
2= —Vkocstke ce \kdos tj Buy @mceasa Rak`tjrs,„ Iceke`ckd \cnas , Gkeukry 2, 2669? Pmkmcl-ur-
Ramnke, —Vkocstke–s eu`dakr bucdlceh pdke hats @mcek–s `jetceual suppjrt,„ Eu`dajec`s Xaao ,
vjd. <8, ej. ;, Gkeukry 1, 2669, 9? Pmkmcl-ur-Ramnke, —VKA@ skys Vkocstke tkoceh staps tjwkrl
eaw rak`tjr `jestru`tcje,„ Eu`dajec`s Xaao , vjd. <8, ej. 2, Gkeukry ;2, 2669, 0.
23 Nkro Mcbbs, —Vkocstke, @mcek pdkeeceh twj ;,666-NX VXRs,„ Eu`dajec`s Xaao , vjd. <8, ej.
<6, J`tjbar 1, 2669, ;.
06 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcje tj tma kutmjr, Ejvanbar 2669.
0; —Csdknkbkl, Bacgceh mkl lciiarceh vcaws je Pcej-Vko eu`dakr `jjparkt cje,„ Lkwe, Paptanbar ;,
2669.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 66/70
Nkro Mcbbs | 13
02 Nkro Mcbbs, —Vkocstke Lakd Pchekds @mcek–s Hrjwceh Eu`dakr Kssartcvaeass,„ @kreahca Eu`dakr
Aearhy Brcai , Kprcd 28, 26;6, www.`kreahcaaeljwnaet.jrh/26;6/6</28/pkocstke-lakd-schekds-
`mcek-s-hrjwceh-eu`dakr-kssartcvaeass/<su.
00 —NkÚekmnae zur Ptìroueh lar Eje-Vrjdciarktcje uel euodakrae Axpjrtojetrjdda„ (Naksuras
ijr straehtmaeceh ejeprjdciarktcje eu`dakr axpjrt `jetrjds), Harnke Buelastkh, Guea ;<, 26;;,;8/138=, mttp7//lcpbt.buelastkh.la/lcp2;/btl/;8/692/;86922<.pli.
0< Pcllmkrtm Ykrklkrkgke, —CKAK kpprjvas skiahukrls ijr eaw Vkocstkec rak`tjrs,„ Mcelu, Nkr`m
3, 26;;.
01 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcje tj kutmjr, Csdknkbkl, Nky 26;;.
09 —\rkessmcpnaet kel Lcvarscje7 Kra Q.P. \rklceh Vkrtears Ljceh Aejuhm tj Vravaet tma Pprakl
ji Lkeharjus \a`mejdjhcas:„ Makrceh Baijra tma Pub`jnncttaa je \arrjrcsn, Ejeprjdciarktcje
kel \rkla, @jnncttaa je Ijrache Kiikcrs, Mjusa ji Raprasaetktcvas, ;;;tm @jehrass, 2el sas-
scje, Gudy 22, 26;6, Parckd Ej. ;;;-;22, www.hpj.hjv/ilsys/poh/@MRH-;;;mmrh18963/mtnd/
@MRH-;;;mmrh18963.mtn.
08 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcjes tj kutmjr, Guea kel Paptanbar 26;6.
0= Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcje tj kutmjr, Gudy 26;;.
03 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcje ji EPH-pkrtc`cpktceh hjvarenaet ji`ckd tj kutmjr, J`tjbar 26;;.
<6 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcje, J`tjbar 26;;.
<; —CKAK Lcra`tjr Haearkd Xad`jnas Q.P. kel Celck Eu`dakr Lakd,„ CKAK Vrass Radaksa , Nkr`m
2, 2669, www.ckak.jrh/eaws`aetar/prassradaksas/2669/pre266961.mtnd.
<2 Vrcvkta `jnnuec`ktcjes tj tma kutmjr irjn CKAK nanbar stkta kel CKAK sa`ratkrckt ji`ckds.
<0 Njmknal AdBkrklac, —Ratmceoceh Eu`dakr Pkiahukrls,„ Xksmcehtje Vjst, Guea ;<, 2669.
<< Ce pkrtc`udkr, tma Busm klncecstrktcje ax`dulal key `jesclarktcje ji k scncdkr ax`aptcje ijr cts
kddy Csrkad ba`kusa ct iakral tmkt jppjsctcje irjn Krkb stktas nchmt prjva iktkd tj tma pdkeeal
ax`aptcje ijr Celck _prcvkta ̀ jnnuec̀ ktcjes irjn Csrkadc kel Q.P. ji`ckds ce 266=^.
<1 Nkro Mcbbs, —QP rabuiial Csrkadc raquast ijr ax`aptcje irjn EPH trkla ruda,„ Eu`dakr Iuad , vjd.
02, ej. ;, Gkeukry ;, 2668, ;.
<9 \jby Lkdtje, Nkro Mcbbs, kel Hajrha Varojvc`m, —K @rctarck-Bksal Kpprjk`m tj Eu`dakr
@jjparktcje Xctm Vkocstke,„ Vjdc`y Jutdjjo, @kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a,
Guea 26;;, www.`kreahcaaeljwnaet.jrh/26;;/69/22/`rctarck-bksal-kpprjk`m-tj-eu`dakr-
`jjparktcje-wctm-pkocstke/2<d.
<8 @jjrlcektceh @jnncttaa ijr Nudtcdktarkd Axpjrt @jetrjds, astkbdcsmal by wastare stktas lurceh
tma @jdl Xkr tj aeijr`a k trkla anbkrhj khkcest Xkrskw Vk`t ̀ juetrcas. @j`jn wks tarncektal
ce ;33< kel wks su``aalal ce ;339 by tma Xkssaekkr Krrkehanaet, wmc`m `jnprcsas <6 `jue-
trcas, ce`dulceh ijrnar Xkrskw Vk`t `juetrcas.
<= Cetarektcjekd Ktjnc` Aearhy Khae`y Ceijrnktcje @cr`udkr, —@jnnuec`kt cje Ra`acval irjn
tma Varnkeaet Ncsscje ji Kustrkdck je Bamkdi ji tma Nanbar Ptktas ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars
Hrjup,„ CEI@CR@/103, Paptanbar ;9, ;338, www.ckak.jrh/Vubdc`ktcjes/Lj`unaets/
Cei`cr`s/;338/cei103.smtnd.
<3 Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup Vjcet ji @jetk`t Ejta, Qectal Ptktas @jnnuec`ktcje“—Ijjl ijr
\mjuhmt„ Vkpar je Celcke EPH Nanbarsmcp, Nky 20, 26;;, www.krns`jetrjd.jrh/systan/
das/esh;;06.pli.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 67/70
96 | \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup
16 —QP tj suppjrt Celck–s iudd nanbarsmcp ce EPH,„ \cnas ji Celck , Ejvanbar 9, 26;6.
1; @. \mjrea, —Nudtcdktarkd Eu`dakr Axpjrt @jetrjds 7 Vkst, Vrasaet, kel Iutura,„ 0<.
12 Jea wjrosmjp pkrtc`cpket axpdkceal tmkt trkesiar wctmce tma AQ ji ctans dcstal ce tma AQ Keeax
CY (ce`dulceh `ktahjry 6 trchhar dcst ctans) raqucra ke kutmjrczktcje irjn k suppdcar `juetry, but
wmkt ijrn tma kutmjrczkt cje tkoas cs ejt spa`cal. AQ lukd-usa rahudktcje ljas ejt rahudkta jr
stcpudkta ke kutmjrczktcje raqucranaet ijr `juetrcas wmara hjjls kra trkesctal. \mara kra sjna
skiahukrls-radktal (skia trkespjrt, pubdc` makdtm) raqucranaets tmkt nchmt kdsj tkoa tma ijrn ji
ke kutmjrczktcje, but tmasa kra ejt spa`c`kddy axpjrt-`jetrjd-radktal.
10 Rc`mkrl Hjjravc`m, —Lavadjpnaet ji tma EPH kel tma Vmcdjsjpmy ji Axpjrt @jetrjds,„ EPH,
J`tjbar ;1, 2663, www.eu`dakrsuppdcarshrjup.jrh/Daeh/VLI/2663-LavadjpnaetZjiZtmaZ
EPH-AxpjrtZ@jetrjds-RZHjjravc`m.pli.
1< Irctz X. P`mnclt, —\ma Wkehhar @jnncttaa 7 Cts Mcstjry kel Iutura Rjda,„ Gknas Nkrtce
@aetar ijr Ejeprjdciarktcje Ptulcas (@EP), Ejeprjdciarktcje Ravcaw , Ikdd ;33<, mttp7//`es.nccs.
alu/epr/plis/s`mncl2;.pli.
11 Ce pkrtc`udkr Cke Ketmjey, @mrcstar Kmdstrjn, Yctkdy Ial`maeoj, —Raijrnceh Eu`dakr Axpjrt
@jetrjds7 \ma Iutura ji tma Eu`dakr Puppdcars Hrjup,„ Pcprc Rasakr`m Rapjrt ej. 22, Ptj`omjdnCetarektcjekd Vak`a Rasakr`m Cestctuta, 2668. Paa kdsj L. Kdbrchmt kel @. Mcelarstace,
—Qerkvadceh tma K. [. Omke kel iutura prjdciarktcje eatwjros,„ Xksmcehtje [ukrtardy , vjd. 2=,
ej. 2, 2661.
19 N. AdBkrklac, —Pkvceh Jursadvas irjn Lastru`tcje,„ Eaw Sjro \cnas , Iabrukry ;2, 266<.
18 —@jnbktceh Vrjdciarkt cje Iceke`ceh7 K Ptktus Rapjrt je Vjdc`y Lavadjpnaet kel
@jesudtktcje,„ Iceke`ckd K`tcje \kso Ijr`a, Iabrukry 26;6, www.ikti-hk.jrh/
lktkja`l/02/<6/<16<33;;.pli.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 68/70
9;
Kbjut tma Kutmjr
NKRO MCBBP cs k saecjr kssj`ckta ce tma @kreahca Aeljwnaet–s Eu`dakr Vjdc`y
Vrjhrkn. Baijra gjceceh @kreahca, ma wks ke alctjr kel `jrraspjelaet ijr jvar twaety
yakrs ijr eu`dakr aearhy pubdc`ktcjes, ce`dulceh Eu`dajec`s Xaao kel Eu`dakr Iuad , pub-
dcsmal by tma Vdktts lcvcscje ji tma N`Hrkw-Mcdd @jnpkecas.Irjn tma dkta ;3=6s uetcd tma ncl-;336s, ma ̀ jvaral eu`dakr lavadjpnaets ce tma Pjvcat
bdj`, ce`dulceh rasakr`m je tma QPPR–s eu`dakr iuad `y`da ik`cdctcas kel cts eu`dakr nktarc-
kds cevaetjrcas. Pce`a tma ncl-;336s, mcs wjro mks ij`usal je anarhceh eu`dakr prjhrkns
ce Ksck, ce`dulceh @mcek kel Celck.
\mrjuhmjut tma dkst twj la`klas, nkey ji mcs njra tmke 0,666 krtc`das cevastchktal
eu`dakr-prjdciarktcje-radktal lavadjpnaets ce Krhaetcek, Brkzcd, @mcek, Celck, Crke, Crkq,
Csrkad, Gkpke, Dcbyk, Ejrtm kel Pjutm Ojrak, Vkocstke, Pjutm Kirc`k, Pyrck, kel \kcwke.
Pce`a 2660, ma mks nkla nkey latkcdal elcehs kbjut `dkelastcea prj`uranaet ce
Aurjpa radktal tj hks `aetrciuha urkecun aerc`mnaet prjhrkns ce Crke, Dcbyk, Ejrtm
Ojrak, kel Vkocstke.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 69/70
@kreahca Aeljwnaet
ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a
\ma @kreahca Aeljwnaet ijr Cetarektcjekd Vak`a cs k prcvkta, ejeprjt jrhkeczktcje
lalc`ktal tj klvke`ceh `jjparktcje batwaae ektcjes kel prjnjtceh k`tcva cetarektcjekd
aehkhanaet by tma Qectal Ptktas. Ijuelal ce ;3;6, cts wjro cs ejepkrtcske kel lalc`ktal
tj k`mcavceh prk`tc`kd rasudts.
Ks ct `adabrktas cts @aetaeeckd, tma @kreahca Aeljwnaet cs pcjeaarceh tma rst hdjbkd
tmceo tkeo, wctm fljurcsmceh ji`as ejw ce Xksmcehtje, Njs`jw, Bacgceh, Bacrut, kelBrussads. \masa va dj`ktcjes ce`dula tma `aetars ji wjrdl hjvareke`a kel tma pdk`as
wmjsa pjdctc`kd avjdutcje kel cetarektcjekd pjdc`cas wcdd njst latarncea tma eakr-tarn
pjsscbcdctcas ijr cetarektcjekd pak`a kel a`jejnc` klvke`a.
\ma @kreahca Eu`dakr Vjdc`y Vrjhrkn cs ke cetarektcjekddy k``dkcnal sjur`a ji axpar-
tcsa kel pjdc`y tmceoceh je eu`dakr celustry, ejeprjdciarktcje, sa`urcty, kel lcskrnknaet.
Cts nudtcektcjekd stkii stkys kt tma ijrairjet ji eu`dakr pjdc`y cssuas ce tma Qectal Ptktas,
Russck, @mcek, Ejrtmakst Ksck, Pjutm Ksck, kel tma Ncllda Akst.
8/3/2019 The Future of the Nuclear Suppliers Group
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-future-of-the-nuclear-suppliers-group 70/70