the flat federal income tax for the usa

Upload: david-severance

Post on 04-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    1/24

    AmericanFlat FederalIncome Tax

    David M Severance

    [email protected]

    720-392-0420

    ACCT525

    Current Issues in Accounting

    Victoria Marschner

    August 18, 2012

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    2/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 1 of23

    Table of Contents

    Introduction ................................................................................................................................................ 2

    A Brief History of the US Income Tax ....................................................................................................... 3

    Definitions.................................................................................................................................................... 4

    Progressive Income Tax .......................................................................................................................... 4

    Value Added Tax (VAT) ........................................................................................................................... 5

    Flat tax ...................................................................................................................................................... 5

    Flat Tax Proponents .................................................................................................................................. 6

    Rick Perry .................................................................................................................................................. 6

    Newt Gingrich ............................................................................................................................................ 7

    Herman Cain ............................................................................................................................................. 7

    Malcolm S Forbes Jr. ............................................................................................................................... 8

    Rep. Dick Armey ....................................................................................................................................... 8Daniel Mitchell .......................................................................................................................................... 9

    Flat Tax Opponents ................................................................................................................................... 9

    Holley Ulbrich ............................................................................................................................................ 9

    Linda Beale ............................................................................................................................................. 10

    The Popular Flat Tax Plans ..................................................................................................................... 10

    The Forbes Plan ...................................................................................................................................... 11

    The Armey Plan ....................................................................................................................................... 11

    Replace the Income Tax with a Flat 17% Tax ....................................................................................... 11

    Individual Wage Tax ................................................................................................................................ 12

    Business Tax .......................................................................................................................................... 12

    Guards against Higher Taxes ................................................................................................................ 12

    The Rick Perry Plan ................................................................................................................................ 13

    The Gingrich Plan.................................................................................................................................... 13

    The Cain 9-9-9 Plan ................................................................................................................................ 13

    Economics ............................................................................................................................................... 14

    Simplicity ................................................................................................................................................. 14

    Economic Growth .................................................................................................................................... 15

    Eliminate the Tax Lobby ......................................................................................................................... 16

    Global Competitiveness .......................................................................................................................... 16

    Conclusion .............................................................................................................................................. 17

    Works Cited .......................................................................................................................................... 21

    Works Cited Continued...22-23

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    3/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 2 of23

    Introduction

    One might think it would be considered economic suicide for a Tax Accountant

    to write a paper on the concept of the United States(US) changing to a flat income tax.

    The approach will be to balance strong opinion from the author that will be that will be

    backed up by research to support many of these opinions. The main reason for this

    approach is because this Tax Accountant is an American first and has grown sick and

    tired of special interests running our lives.

    As will be discussed further, the idea of why switching to a flat tax and eliminating

    the majority of all tax deductions which have been lobbied by the various special

    interests like the National Association of Realtors (Rohrlich, 2012). Additionally,

    according to a report from the nonpartisan reform group Public Campaign; Thirty large

    American corporations spent more money on lobbying than they paid in federal taxes

    from 2008 to 2010 (Murphy, 2011). Steve Forbes writes in his book, one in six private

    sector employees in Washington DC are employed by the lobbing industry. Half of their

    efforts are directed at wrangling changes to the tax code (Forbes, 2005, p. 8).

    America seems to be is broken; political and corporate corruption and lack of

    ethics in Washington DC and on Wall Street. Read on and you will understand how the

    adoption of the Flat Tax is the road map to taking back our country.

    A Brief History of the US Income Tax

    Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the United States Constitution, reads The

    Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    4/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 3 of23

    pay the Debts and provide for the common defense and general Welfare of the United

    States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United

    States; but is the current progressive Income Tax uniform throughout the United

    States? Assuming the 16th amendment was ratified, does this ratification allow for a

    progressive Income Tax under the US Constitution. Does that change the original

    document calling for uniformity constitutional?

    The nation had few taxes in its early history. From 1791 to 1802, the United

    States government was supported by excise taxes on distilled spirits, carriages, refined

    sugar, tobacco and snuff, property sold at auction, corporate bonds, and slaves. The

    high cost of the War of 1812 brought about the nation's first sales taxes on Luxury items

    (gold, silverware, jewelry, and watches) for 5 years but in in 1817, Congress did away

    with all excise taxes in favor of tariffs on imported goods to provide sufficient funds for

    running the government.

    In 1862, in order to support the Civil War effort, Congress enacted the nation's

    first income tax law. This temporarily created the Bureau of Internal Revenue that

    managed tax collection duties. The income tax increasing government coffers by an

    estimated $340 million during the 10 year period it existed (Investopedia US, 2012). The

    Bureau of Internal Revenue is known today as the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The

    name was changed to emphasize a greater focus on serving the public rather than

    merely collecting taxes. Today the IRS is a massive bureau; in 2004 the agency

    collected over $2 trillion in revenue processing more that 224 million tax returns

    (Investopedia US, 2012).

    In 1913, the 16th Amendment to the Constitution made the income tax a

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    5/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 4 of23

    permanent fixture in the U.S. tax system. The amendment gave Congress legal

    authority to tax income and resulted in a revenue law that taxed incomes of both

    individuals and corporations. While Bill Benson makes quite the argument that the

    sixteenth amendment was never ratified (Benson & Beckman, 1985); the fact remains,

    since the ratification of the 16th Amendment to the Constitution, debate has existed

    over the merits of how best to levy the income tax (Teller, 2011).

    Definitions

    Progressive Income Tax

    A tax that takes a larger percentage from the

    income of high-income earners than it does from

    low-income individuals. The United States income

    tax is considered progressive: in 2010, individuals

    who earned up to $8,375 fell into the 10% tax

    bracket, while individuals earning $373,650 or more

    fell into the 35% tax bracket. Basically, taxpayers are broken down into categories

    based on taxable income; the more one earns, the more taxes they will have to pay

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    6/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 5 of23

    once they cross the benchmark cut-off points between the different tax bracket levels

    (Investopedia US, 2012). How is this uniform?

    Value-Added Tax (VAT)

    The VAT is best defined as a consumption tax

    that is placed on a product whenever value is

    added at a stage of production and at final sale;

    it is most often used in the European Union.

    The amount of value-added tax that the user

    pays is the cost of the product, less any of the costs of materials used in the product

    that have already been taxed (Investopedia US, 2012).

    Flat Tax

    In 1962, economist Milton Friedman came up with the idea of a flat tax which

    would erase the tax brackets now in place and tax everyone's income at the same rate.

    Friedmans flat tax would not

    include any deductions

    (DeRose, 1999-2012).

    The Wall Street Journal

    brought the idea of a flat

    income tax into mainstream

    America with an article by Hoover Institution economists Robert Hall and Alvin

    Rabushka (1983, revised1995) titled, "A Proposal to Simplify Our Tax System.

    Businesses are taxed on total sales less labor costs, cost of capital goods, and

    purchase of raw materials, while individuals are taxed on the difference between their

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    7/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 6 of23

    total labor compensation and a personal allowance. There is no tax on savings and

    interest, no double taxation of dividends.

    Herman Cain's 9-9-9 Plan:

    Herman Cain's controversial "9-9-9" tax plan would replace the existing national tax

    code with 9% business taxes, 9% income taxes, and a 9% national sales tax.

    Flat Tax Proponents

    Almost every United States presidential campaign {season} that include a Republican

    primary in the third quarter of an election year since mid-1990s; one or more of the

    candidates include a plan for the flat income tax. The current Republican season {2012}

    was no different. This campaign season brought out three (3).

    Rick Perry

    Rick Perry is proposing letting Americans choose between their

    existing income tax rate or a new flat tax of 20 percent, part of a

    tax and spending reform plan that the Republican presidential

    candidate is dubbing "Cut, Balance and Grow" and lowering the

    corporate tax to 20 percent as well. Eliminate taxes on dividends and capital gains,

    aiming to free up money that presumably would be invested in economic growth

    (Fox News, 2011).

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    8/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 7 of23

    Newt Gingrich

    Gingrich advocates a 15% flat tax, keeping deductions on

    charitable giving and home ownership, and allowing a $12,000

    personal deduction. He also proposes four tax changes to help

    small businesses expand:

    1. Eliminate capital gains taxes.

    2. Lower the corporate income tax to 12.5%

    3. Allow for 100% expensing of new equipment.

    4. End the death tax permanently (because many small businesses are

    passed down to future generations) (Amadeo, Newt Gingrich 2012 Presidential

    Campaign Plan for the Economy, 2012).

    Herman Cain

    2012 Presidential Candidate Herman Cain is the owner of

    Godfather's Pizza. This business experience leads him to believe

    the economy will naturally return to prosperity with less

    government spending and regulation. Cain shares the

    fundamental economic platform of simplifying and reducing taxes to drive economic

    growth, a strategy known as supply-side economics (Amadeo,

    http://useconomy.about.com/od/2012-Campaign/p/Herman-Cain-2012.htm, 2012).

    All of this debate keeps the concept of the Flat Income Tax in the public eye and

    on the water cooler circuit. It is interesting thing is that all three (partially for Cain)

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    9/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 8 of23

    of the current proposals have their roots planted by Dick Army and Steven Forbes,

    and of course Milton Freedman.

    Malcolm S. Forbes, Jr.

    Steve Forbes, Editor of Forbes Magazine, is probably better known

    for the concept of the Flat Income Tax in the US than Milton

    Friedman. Steve Forbes former candidate for the US Presidency

    (1996, 2000) and Author ofFlat Tax Revolution: Using a Postcard to

    Abolish the IRS(Forbes, 2005). The Forbes plan calls for a flat 17% tax on income

    above the first $36,000 and scrapping the tax code. Don't fiddle with it. Throw it out

    (2005). Steve Forbes believed (as many others) it would eliminate the principal source

    of political corruption in Washington, DC.

    Rep. Dick Armey

    The Freedom and Fairness Restoration Act (FFRA) was introduced by

    Congressman Dick Armey of Texas onJune 16, 1994 in a Wall Street

    Journalop-ed piece, and subsequently introduced it as HR4585 in the

    104th Congress. Like the Forbes plan it scraped the 1986 Internal

    Revenue code (as revised) and replaced it with a 17% flat taxso simple Americans can

    file their taxes on a form the size of a postcard(Armey D. , 1994).

    Prior to being elected to Congress in 1985, Dr. Dick Armey was Associate

    Professor of economics at University of North Texas from 1972 to 1977 and Chairman

    of the economics department from 1977 to 1983 (Guttery, 2002). If any politician would

    have a clue about effective tax policy, Dr. Dick Armeywas certainly one of them.

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    10/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 9 of23

    Daniel MitchellDaniel is a senior fellow at the CATO Institute in Washington writes in

    US News and World Report on April12, 2010, It is time to implement a

    simple and fair flat tax. Instead of the hundreds of forms required by the

    IRS, the flat tax uses two simple postcards. Families use the household

    postcard, and all they need to know is their labor income, available on a

    W-2 form. They then subtract an allowance based on family size. The remaining amount

    is taxable income, and the tax bill is based on the flat rate. The business postcard is

    equally simple. All businesses, from Microsoft to a hot dog stand (as well as individuals

    with "Schedule C" income), start with total revenues, and then calculate taxable income

    by subtracting wage costs, input costs, and investment costs. The IRS then gets a flat

    percentage of that remaining amount.

    The special interests hate the flat tax because it means no loopholes, no

    complexity, no shelters, and no special preferences. All income is treated equally. Some

    taxpayers may not like losing various deductions, but treating income equally also

    means that there is no double taxation, so the death tax and capital gains tax are

    abolished (Mitchell, 2010).

    Flat Tax Opponents

    Dr. Holley Ulbrich

    Dr. Ulbrich is an economics professor emeritus and senior fellow at the

    Strom Thurmond Institute at Clemson University; is radically opposed

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    11/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 10 of23

    to the concept of the flat tax. In an op-ed piece in US News, she calls it class warfare

    yet another attempt to reduce the tax obligations of higher-income households in

    exchange for the unenforceable hope or promise that they might use the money to

    invest and create jobs, maybe even jobs in the United States (Ulbrich, 2010).

    Linda Beale

    Ms. Beale is an associate professor at Wayne State University Law School.

    In an article in the New York Times calls the Flat tax regressive, in that they

    place a high tax burden on the most vulnerable at the lower income scales

    (Beale, 2011). Theres a lot wrong with flat taxes. The term is used to

    designate a "flat rate" income tax (often with a zero rate for the poorest) as opposed to

    our current graduated rate structure that imposes slightly higher rates on those who

    have more capacity to pay. She then goes on to sound like a President Obama political

    ad saying and have benefited much more from the various government systems that

    make stable markets, inheritance and the other foundations of great wealth and large

    incomes possible

    The Popular Flat Tax Plans

    The Forbes Plan

    America needs to take a new road, one toward an expansion future that is bigger and

    better than our past (1995)

    The first element is dramatic pro-growth tax cuts.Start by scrapping the tax code. Don't fiddle with it. Junk it. Throw it out. Bury it.

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    12/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 11 of23

    Replace it with a pro-growth, pro-family tax cut that lowers tax rates to 17%

    across the board and expands exemptions for individuals and children so that a

    family of four would pay no taxes on the first $36,000 of income.

    The flat tax would be simple. You could fill it out on a postcard. It would be

    honest. It would eliminate the principal source of political corruption in

    Washington-- trading loopholes for campaign cash.

    There would be no tax on Social Security. No tax on pensions. No tax on

    personal savings. It would zero out capital gains taxes and eliminate estate

    taxes.

    Since 1970 -- in just 25 years -- Washington spending has increased more than seven

    fold. During those same years, family income in America has declined. But the

    politicians say "we" can't afford a tax cut. Maybe we can't afford the politicians (2005).

    The Armey Plan (FFRA)

    Replaces the income tax with a 17 percent flat tax

    The bill repeals today's complicated income tax system in total and replaces it

    with a low, simple flat tax. Under the bill, every dollar of income in the economy is taxed,

    with wage and pension income collected from individuals and all other income collected

    from businesses. Individuals pay 17 percent of wage income calculated on a return so

    simple it can fit on a postcard. Businesses pay 17 percent of business income,

    calculated on an equally simple return (Armey & Shelby, 1995).

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    13/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 12 of23

    Individual Wage Tax

    Individuals pay 17 percent of all wages, salaries, and pensions, after subtracting

    family allowances. The flat tax replaces the current income tax system, but not Social

    Security and Medicare payroll taxes. Social Security benefits would not be taxed.

    Business Tax

    All business income, whatever the source (corporate, partnership, sole

    proprietor, professional, farm, and rental profits and royalties) is taxed at the one low

    rate. Businesses pay 17 percent of the difference, if positive, between revenues and

    expenses. Expenses are defined as purchases of goods and services, capital

    equipment, structures, land, wages and contributions to employee retirement plans. No

    deductions are permitted for fringe benefits, interest, or payments to owners. Collecting

    business income earned by individuals at its source -- the business -- allows for a

    simple, airtight system that ensures all income in the economy is taxed (Armey &

    Shelby, 1995).

    Guards against higher taxes

    To help prevent a future Congress from raising taxes, rewarding a special

    interest, or complicating the tax code, the bill contains a provision which requires a 60

    percent supermajority of the House and Senate to:

    1. Raise the tax rate

    2. Create multiple tax rates

    3. Lower the family allowance

    4. Add a loophole (Armey & Shelby, 1995).

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    14/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 13 of23

    The Rick Perry Plan

    The heart of Perry's plan would reduce or eliminate an array of taxes and replace the

    current progressive Income tax a with 20 percent flat tax, end taxes on Social Security

    benefits, estates, dividends and capital gains, which would most help upper-income

    people. He would lower the corporate income tax rate as well as the personal income

    tax rate. Perry's plan would let people exempt $12,500 of their income, plus $12,500 for

    each dependent, from taxation. He would keep popular deductions, such as those for

    mortgage interest, state taxes and charity gifts, for families making less than $500,000 a

    year.The Gingrich Plan

    Gingrich advocates a 15% flat tax, keeping deductions on charitable giving

    and home ownership, and allowing a $12,000 personal deduction. He also

    proposes four tax changes to help small businesses expand:

    1. Eliminate capital gains taxes.

    2. Lower the corporate income tax to 12.5%

    3. Allow for 100% expensing of new equipment.

    4. End the death tax permanently (because many small businesses are

    passed down to future generations) (Amadeo, Newt Gingrich 2012

    Presidential Campaign Plan for the Economy, 2012).

    Herman Cain's 9-9-9 Plan:

    Herman Cain's controversial "9-9-9" tax plan would replace the existing national

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    15/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 14 of23

    tax code with 9% business taxes, 9% income taxes, and a 9% national sales tax.

    Specifically, it would:

    1. Eliminate all payroll taxes.

    2. Remove the double taxation of dividends.

    3. Do away with the Estate Tax and all taxes on capital gains.

    4. Create "Empowerment Zones" in the inner cities which offer business and

    individual tax deductions.

    5. Combine the Fair Tax with the Flat Tax.

    6. Eradicate the IRS and repeal the 15th Amendment (Herman Cain, 2012).

    Economics

    Simplicity

    Because the existing system's maze of

    exemptions, loopholes, depreciation

    schedules, graduated rates, and

    targeted tax breaks is eliminated,

    taxpayers will save countless hours and

    expense in filing their yearly tax returns.

    The Tax Foundation, a Washington,

    D.C.-based nonprofit organization which

    closely monitors federal tax policy,

    estimates the flat tax would reduce

    http://taxes.about.com/od/payroll/qt/payroll_basics.htmhttp://useconomy.about.com/od/fiscalpolicy/p/Fair_Tax.htmhttp://useconomy.about.com/od/usfederaltaxesandtax/p/Flat-Tax.htmhttp://useconomy.about.com/od/usfederaltaxesandtax/p/Flat-Tax.htmhttp://useconomy.about.com/od/fiscalpolicy/p/Fair_Tax.htmhttp://taxes.about.com/od/payroll/qt/payroll_basics.htm
  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    16/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 15 of23

    compliance costs by 94 percent. Complexity is a hidden tax amounting to more than

    $100 billion. This is the cost of tax preparation, lawyers, accountants, and other

    resources used to comply with the Internal Revenue Code. The Internal Revenue

    Service even admits that the current tax code requires taxpayers to devote 6.6 billion

    hours each year to their tax returns (Dalrymple, 2005). Yet even this commitment of

    time is no guarantee of accuracy. The code is so complex that even tax experts and the

    IRS often make mistakes. All taxpayers, from General Motors to a hamburger-flipping

    teenager, would be able to fill out their tax return on a postcard-sized form, and

    compliance costs would drop by tens of billions of dollars.

    Economic Growth

    A flat tax would spur increased work, saving, and investment. By increasing incentives

    to engage in productive economic behavior, it would also boost the economy's long-term growth rate. Even if a flat tax boosted long-term growth by only 0.5 percent, the

    income of the average family of four after 10 years would be as much as $5,000 higher

    than it would be under current tax laws.

    According to Harvard economist Dale Jorgenson, tax reform would boost national

    wealth by nearly $5 trillion (Jorgenson, 2003). It would do this in part because all

    income-producing assets would rise in value since the flat tax would increase the after-

    tax stream of income that they generate.

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    17/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 16 of23

    General Electric spent more lobbying

    the government than it did in federal

    income taxes between 2008 and 2010

    Eliminate the Tax Lobby

    The report from the nonpartisan reform group Public

    Campaign; Thirty Large American Corporations Spent

    More Money on Lobbying than They Paid in Federal

    Taxes from 2008 to 2010; explains, the 29 companies

    that paid no tax actually received tax rebatesover

    those three years, "ranging from $4 million for Corning

    (GLW) to nearly $5 billion for General Electric (GE)." The amounts spent on lobbying

    added up to $476 million, over three years this amount is further calculated as, roughly

    $400,000 each day, including weekends." The same firms spent an additional $22

    million on donations to federal campaigns (Murphy, 2011).

    A flat tax gets rid of all deductions, loopholes, credits, and exemptions. Politicians

    would lose all ability to pick winners and losers, reward friends and punish enemies, and

    use the tax code to impose their values on the economy. Not only does this end a major

    source of political corruption, but it is also pro-growth since companies would no longer

    squander resources lobbying politicians or making foolish investments just to obtain

    favorable tax treatment (Daniel Mitchell, 2005).

    Global Competitiveness

    In a remarkable development, former communist

    nations are leading a global tax reform revolution. Estonia

    was the first to adopt a flat tax, implementing a 26

    percent rate in 1994, just a few years after the collapse of

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    18/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 17 of23

    the Soviet Union. The other two Baltic republics of the former Soviet Union enacted flat

    taxes in the mid-1990s, with Latvia choosing a 25 percent rate and Lithuania picking 33

    percent. Along with other free-market reforms, the flat tax significantly improved

    economic growth, and the "Baltic Tigers" became role models for the region. Learning

    from its neighbors, Russia stunned the world by adopting a 13 percent flat tax, which

    went into effect in 2001.

    The Russian flat tax quickly yielded positive results: The economy prospered,

    and revenues poured into government coffers since tax evasion and avoidance became

    much less profitable. The flat tax then spread to Serbia, which in 2003 chose a 14

    percent rate. Slovakia hopped on the bandwagon the following year with a 19 percent

    flat tax, as did Ukraine, which chose a 13 percent tax rate. Earlier this year, Romania

    joined the flat tax revolution with a 16 percent tax rate, and Georgia adopted a 12

    percent flat tax rate, which has the honor, at least temporarily, of being the lowest rate

    in the world.

    In a global economy, it is increasingly easy for jobs and capital to escape high-tax

    nations and migrate to low-tax nations. This means that the reward for good tax policy is

    greater than ever before, but it also means that the penalties for bad policy are greater

    than ever before. This is why so many nations are lowering tax rates and reforming their

    tax systems (Daniel J. Mitchell, 2004).[A flat tax will make America a magnet for

    investment and job creation.

    Conclusion

    Toward the end of the introduction of this paper, it was suggested that America seemed

    to be is broken. Every day in the news there is political and corporate corruption in the

    http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2005/07/a-brief-guide-to-the-flat-tax#_ftn13http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2005/07/a-brief-guide-to-the-flat-tax#_ftn13
  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    19/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 18 of23

    newspapers and on television. The lack of ethics that is rampant and for the first time in

    our history our credit rating was downgraded (Krantz & Chu, 2011). We are currently in

    {allegedly ended in 2009) the largest longest recession (CNN Money, 2010) that without

    all the government spending would have been worse than the great depression.

    America need to be repaired, we the people need to take back control of this country

    that one politician after another has sold to some special interest. Shown here in this

    project paper has been a theoretical discussion of how eliminating the current

    progressive income tax system and implementing some rendition of the flat income tax

    written about by Steven Forbes, Dick Armey or Robert Hall and Alvin Rabushka. The

    current tax code doesnt work, American spend billions of hours and millions of dollars

    on lawyers and accountants like us to avoid the progressive income tax as we know it.

    With the Flat tax, saving and investment is encouraged, business will have access to all

    the capital it needs, unemployment as we know it would be non-existent.

    The implementation of a Flat 17%-20% Flat tax on corporations would bring so many

    employment opportunities back to the United States we would need another baby boom

    like after World War II. Without the current tax code and all of the exemptions and

    loopholes companies have no reason to lobby for lower taxes and special benefits.

    Individuals would have true motivation to prosper, save and invest and businesses

    would be encouraged to grow. There would be no need for the current Internal Revenue

    code. No need for Schedules M1-M3 on the current 1120. Whether the US continues

    with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) or something that is merged

    with IFRS, the bottom line will be net profit will be taxed at 17%-20%. No need to worry

    about things like installment sales, tax-free exchanges. Another area would be foreign

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    20/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 19 of23

    taxes; it would simply be an expense item. NO benefit to the US Corporation for

    overseas operations.In actuality, the lower simple tax laws would provide a huge

    reason to bring the factories and jobs back to the USA.

    For those that would argue that charities would suffer; that is likely not true. When is

    the last time you thought about the deduction at Christmas when you dropped money in

    the red kettle. Was a tax deduction the primary motivation behind the recent

    contributions by Kiss and Neil Diamond to the victims of the Century 16 disaster in

    Aurora? No!!! America is the most generous country in the world and we always will be.

    For those that argue the rich should pay more; where does this concept really come

    from? Form a bunch of people that need to address their jealously. America is still the

    land ofopportunity; its just been lobbied to DEATH and is having a hard time coming

    back.

    Lastly, lets look at the revenue that would likely be brought into the US Treasury

    by switching from our current complex tax code to a simple fair Flat Income tax. Initially,

    those revenues will likely decrease, but as the economy grows and becomes strong

    again; Supply Sided Economics has shown that when there is more money in an

    Americans pocket; consumer confidence is higher and suppliers of products and

    service are heavily demanded. In the long run, revenues will surpass what they ARE

    NOW (Tax Policy Center, 2010) which might make it possible to reduce the current $16

    Trillion debt (US Debt Clock, 2012).

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    21/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 20 of23

    Barack Hussein Obama II was right about one thing, we need CHANGE, we

    need to fire the lobbyist by implementing the Flat Income Tax and We the People

    can then TAKE BACK CONTROL OF OUR COUNRY.

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    22/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 21 of23

    Works Cited

    Amadeo, K. (2012). http://useconomy.about.com/od/2012-Campaign/p/Herman-Cain-2012.htm.

    Retrieved August 28, 2012, from http://useconomy.about.com/od/2012-Campaign/p/Herman-

    Cain-2012.htm: http://useconomy.about.com/od/2012-Campaign/p/Herman-Cain-2012.htm

    Amadeo, K. (2012). Newt Gingrich 2012 Presidential Campaign Plan for the Economy. Retrieved August

    28, 2012, from Useconomy.about.com/od/2012-Campaign/p/Newt-Gingrich-And-The-Economy-

    2012-Presidential-Campaign-Plan.htm: http://useconomy.about.com/od/2012-

    Campaign/p/Newt-Gingrich-And-The-Economy-2012-Presidential-Campaign-Plan.htm

    Armey, C. D., & Shelby, S. R. (1995, July). A Comprehensive Plan to Shrink the Government and Grow the

    Economy. Ney Your, New York, United States of America.

    Armey, D. (1994, June 16). Review Merits of Flat Tax. Wall Street Journal.

    Beale, L. (2011, October 13). A Plan for the Uber-Rich. New York Times.

    Benson, B., & Beckman, M. (1985). The Law that Never Was: The Fraud of the 16th Amendment and

    Personal income Tax . South Holland: Constitutional Research Assoc.

    CNN Money. (2010, Novenber 23).An eyeblink glance at the economy, Recession: The longest ever.

    Retrieved August 28, 2012, from

    http://money.cnn.com/galleries/2009/news/0910/gallery.economic_recovery/8.html:

    http://money.cnn.com/galleries/2009/news/0910/gallery.economic_recovery/8.html

    Dalrymple, M. (2005, April 15). Americans Spend 6.6 Billion Hours on Taxes .Associated Press.

    Daniel J. Mitchell, P. (2004). The Economics of Tax Competition: Harmonization vs. Liberalization.

    Washington DC: The Heritage Foundation.

    Daniel Mitchell, P. (2005).A Brief Guide to the Flat Tax. Washington, D.C: The Heritage Foundation.

    DeRose, J. L. (1999-2012). Flat Rate Income Tax Definition. Retrieved July 30, 2012, from ehow.com:

    www.ehow.com/about_6715009_flat-rate-income-tax-definition.html#ixzz229cqsSFb

    Forbes, S. (2005). Flat Tax Revolution: Using a Postcard to Abolish the IRS. Washington DC: Regnery

    Publishing .

    Fox News. (2011, October 24). Perry Pitches Scrapping Tax Code, Offering Optional 20 Percent Flat Tax.

    Retrieved August 6, 2012, from foxnews.com/politics/2011/10/24/perry-to-pitch-scrapping-tax-

    code-offering-optional-20-percent-flat-tax/:

    http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/10/24/perry-to-pitch-scrapping-tax-code-offering-

    optional-20-percent-flat-tax/

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    23/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 22 of23

    Works Cited Continued

    Guttery, B. (2002). Representing Texas: A Comprehensive History of the United States and Confederate

    Senators and Representatives from Texas. Woodway: Eakin Press.

    Herman Cain. (2012, April 15). C TV, Something NewEverday;999. Retrieved 28 2012, August, from

    Hermancain.com/999/: http://hermancain.com/999/

    Investopedia US. (2012). investopedia.com. Retrieved July 30, 2012, from Revenue Act Of 1862:

    http://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/revenue-tax-act-1862.asp#ixzz229JvqUVX

    Investopedia US. (2012). Progressive Income Tax. Retrieved July 30, 2012, from Investopedia:

    http://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/progressivetax.asp#axzz229JcBZR8

    Investopedia US. (2012). Value-Added Tax - VAT. Retrieved July 30, 2012, from investopedia.com:

    http://www.investopedia.com/terms/v/valueaddedtax.asp#ixzz229ileEm1

    Jorgenson, D. W. (2003, March-April). Efficient Taxation of Income . Harvard Magazine, pp. 31-33.

    Krantz , M., & Chu, K. (2011, August 8). S&P downgrades U.S. credit rating from AAA. Retrieved August

    28, 2012, from http://usatoday.com/money/economy/2011-08-05-s-and-p-downgrades-

    credit_n.htm: http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/2011-08-05-s-and-p-downgrades-

    credit_n.htm

    Malcolm S. Forbes, J. ". (1995, October 9). Steve Forbes. (R. MACNEIL, Interviewer)

    Mitchell, D. (2010, April 12). Eliminate Tax Brackets and Complicated Forms With a Flat Tax. US News

    and World Report.

    Murphy, E. (2011, December 13). 30 Major U.S. Companies Spent More on Lobbying than Taxes.

    DailyFinance.com.

    Pearson Education, Inc. (2007). History of the Income Tax in the United States. Retrieved July 30, 2012,

    from Infoplease.com: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0005921.html/

    Rohrlich, J. (2012, July 15). Real Estate Lobby Launches Shock and Awe Campaign to Block Tax Reform.

    Retrieved 30 2012, July, from Minyanville.com:

    http://www.minyanville.com/mvpremium/2011/07/21/real-estate-lobby-launches-shock/

    Tax Policy Center. (2010). The Numbers: What are the federal governments sources of revenue?

    Retrieved August 28, 2012, from taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-

    book/background/numbers/revenue.cfm: http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-

    book/background/numbers/revenue.cfm

    Teller, L. B. (2011, Spring ). The Flat Tax:An Analysis of Americas Most Controversial Tax Reform Idea.

    The Public Purpose, pp. 139-157.

  • 7/29/2019 The Flat Federal Income Tax for the USA

    24/24

    American Flat Federal Income Tax

    Page 23 of 23

    Works Cited Continued

    Ulbrich, H. (2010, April 12). Flat Tax Is Class Warfare. US News and World Report.

    US Debt Clock. (2012, August 28). US Debt Clock. Retrieved 28 2012, August, from US Debt Clock:

    http://www.usdebtclock.org/