the design of a community-led water quality monitoring ... · edina’s fieldtrip gb and esri’s...

1
The design of a community-led water quality monitoring scheme and data collection application for the River Lea through Luton Claire Pook Supervisor: Tim Brewer Cranfield University, College Road, Cranfield, MK43 0AL Email: [email protected] www.cranfield.ac.uk/courses/masters/geographical- information-management.html Objectives 1) Identify what characteristics of the River Lea should be monitored, in which locations, and how often. 2) Consider how local stakeholders might be encouraged to form a network of volunteers, who will carry out the fieldwork. 3) Develop a web based, accessible and engaging tool to collate and present the data, to create a timeline of the health of the River Lea and allow volunteers and general audience to see the value of data being collected. Introduction The River Lea flows from its’ source at Leagrave Park in Bedfordshire to London where it forms one of the main tributaries to the River Thames. The upper reaches of the river pass through the town of Luton, where surface runoff, litter and heavy modification have been identified as sources of contamination in the river channel. This project envisages a ‘citizen science’ approach to monitoring water quality as a way to inform decisions about the future management of the river. Sampling Strategy The Riverfly Partnership train volunteers to record numbers of benthic macroinvertebrates as a measure of pollution in freshwater streams. Thames 21 asks local residents to regularly test pH levels & survey litter in their stretch of river. Repeat sampling of temperature, turbidity, nutrient levels, dissolved oxygen & presence of coliform bacteria at fixed locations on the River Lea will provide a general overview of water quality, and highlight pollution ‘hotspots’. Photography can be used to record pollution incidents as they occur. Potential Sources of Volunteers Survey Design Luton Community Conservation Groups Schools & Colleges Local Businesses Residents Allotment Owners Faith Groups Dog Walkers Scouts / Sea Cadets Samples collected in the vicinity of surface outfalls suspected of introducing contaminants Fixed-point photography used to capture changes in bank structure & riparian vegetation Water to be sampled on a monthly basis, ensuring local weather conditions are recorded Methods & Results Mobile Application Development EDINA’s Fieldtrip GB and ESRI’s Collector for ArcGIS were used to develop 2 data collection applications for capturing survey results. The 2 apps were then reviewed against the following criteria: Background mapping / Appearance Usability in the field Data storage capabilities Multi-user functionality Data export Working offline Ability to display feedback to project volunteers Cost of initial development Ongoing maintenance requirements Additional features Conclusions & Recommendations Citizen science volunteers will require comprehensive training, ongoing support & timely feedback for the duration of the project. Consideration should be given to the additional resourcing requirements (Costs of sampling equipment, data storage, staff etc). Although web technology makes online mapping widely accessible, care should be taken not to alienate certain groups. Many open-source tools exist for creating customisable spatial data collection applications, but the best results are achieved when using a web-based GIS, allowing greater functionality, enhanced presentation and secure data storage. ESRI’s Collector for ArcGIS offers superior customisation & data handling features, but some GIS knowledge is needed to maintain the app.

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The design of a community-led water quality monitoring ... · EDINA’s Fieldtrip GB and ESRI’s Collector for ArcGIS were used to develop 2 data collection applications for capturing

The design of a community-led water qualitymonitoring scheme and datacollection application for theRiver Lea through LutonClaire PookSupervisor: Tim Brewer

Cranfield University, College Road, Cranfield, MK43 0ALEmail: [email protected]

www.cranfield.ac.uk/courses/masters/geographical-information-management.html

Objectives 1) Identify what characteristics of the River Lea should be monitored, in which locations, and how often.

2) Consider how local stakeholders might be encouraged to form a network of volunteers, who will carry out the fieldwork.3) Develop a web based, accessible and engaging tool to collate and present the data, to create a timeline of the health of the River Lea andallow volunteers and general audience to see the value of data being collected.

Introduction The River Lea flows from its’ source at Leagrave Park in Bedfordshire to London where it forms one

of the main tributaries to the River Thames. The upper reaches of the river pass through the town of Luton, wheresurface runoff, litter and heavy modification have been identified as sources of contamination in the river channel.This project envisages a ‘citizen science’ approach to monitoring water quality as a way to inform decisions aboutthe future management of the river.

Sampling StrategyThe Riverfly Partnership train volunteers to recordnumbers of benthic macroinvertebrates as a measure ofpollution in freshwater streams.

Thames 21 asks local residents to regularly testpH levels & survey litter in their stretch of river.

Repeat sampling of temperature, turbidity, nutrient levels, dissolvedoxygen & presence of coliform bacteria at fixed locations on the River Leawill provide a general overview of water quality, and highlight pollution‘hotspots’. Photography can be used to record pollution incidents as they occur.

Potential Sources of Volunteers

Survey Design

LutonCommunity

ConservationGroups

Schools &Colleges

LocalBusinesses

ResidentsAllotment

Owners

FaithGroups

DogWalkers

Scouts / SeaCadets

Samples collected inthe vicinity of

surface outfallssuspected ofintroducing

contaminants

Fixed-pointphotography used to

capture changes inbank structure &

riparian vegetation

Water to be sampledon a monthly basis,

ensuring localweather conditions

are recorded

Methods & Results

Mobile Application DevelopmentEDINA’s Fieldtrip GB and ESRI’s Collector for ArcGIS were used to

develop 2 data collection applications for capturing survey results. The2 apps were then reviewed against the following criteria:

Background mapping / Appearance Usability in the field

Data storage capabilities Multi-user functionality

Data export Working offline

Ability to display feedback to projectvolunteers

Cost of initial development Ongoing maintenance requirements

Additional features

Conclusions & Recommendations• Citizen science volunteers will require comprehensive training, ongoing support & timely feedback for the duration of the project.• Consideration should be given to the additional resourcing requirements (Costs of sampling equipment, data storage, staff etc).• Although web technology makes online mapping widely accessible, care should be taken not to alienate certain groups.• Many open-source tools exist for creating customisable spatial data collection applications, but the best results are achieved

when using a web-based GIS, allowing greater functionality, enhanced presentation and secure data storage.• ESRI’s Collector for ArcGIS offers superior customisation & data handling features, but some GIS knowledge is needed to maintain the app.