the classical review

THEC L A S S I C A L

R E V I E W

at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 65.21.228.167, on 05 Jan 2022 at 02:48:15, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available

https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms

https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025

https://www.cambridge.org/core

2Sr,

THE

CLASSICAL

REVIEW.

VOLUME XVIII

DAVID NUTT, 57-59 LONG ACKE.

1904.



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


RICHARD CLAY AK'D SONS, LIMITED,

BREAD STREET HILL, E.C., AND

BUNGAY, SUFFOLK.

I



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


TABLE OF CONTENTS.

No. 1.

Editorial and General:Comments and Communiques. . . .

Original Contributions:Greek Ostraka in the British Museum,

including a Ptolemaic Fragment ofthe Phoenissae. H. R. HALL. . .

On Phaedo 96A-102A, and on the Stv-repos TTAODS 99D (continued). W. J.GOODBICH

Further Notes on Demosthenes. HER-BERT RICHARDS

Aristotle, Ethics I. 6. R. G. BURY .The New Rhetorical Fragment in re-

lation to the Sicilian Rhetoric ofCorax and Tisias. W. RHYS RO-BERTS

Emendations of Julian Misopogon.ARTHUR PLATT

Verbals in -TOS. HERBERT W. GBEENEEmendations of Cicero's Verrines. W.

PETERSON

Contracted forms of the Perfect inLivy. EMORY B. LEASE

- On the Neuter Nominative, some Im-personal Verbs and Three DramaticQuotations. J. P. POSTGATE . . .

The Plural of Res Publica. E. A. SON-NENSCHEIN

The St. John's College (Cambridge)MS. of The TAebaid. H. W. GAR-

PAGE

1

BODThe Manuscript Problem in the Siluae

of Statius. — Addendum. J. P.POSTGATE

Note on Tacitus, Agrieola 33. 2. W.- WARDltJ?OWLER

Note on the Roman Portoria. J. S.REID

The Spelling of the Sixth Century MS.. of Prudentius. E. O. WINSTEDT .TJncialorTJncinali FALCONER MADAN.

Notes:fiavkvTos. HERBERT W. GBEENE . .Aristophanes, Wasps 565. W. F. R.

SHILLETO

Uo\v€nrjs. HEBBEBT W. GREENE . .

1117

18 !

2123

23

27

36

37

38

43

43

44

4548

49

4949

PACK

Notes—continued :Juvenal I. 144-146. J. SARGEAUNT . 49The Source of Dante's Eunoe. J . A.

STEWART 50Reviews:

Gabler's Galen's de Captionibus. T.CLIFFOBD ALLBUTT 50

Boenig's Minucii Octavius. A. J.KBONENBERG 51

Brodribb's Translation of Minucius'Octavius. R. C. SEATON 54

Henderson's Nero. FRANKLIN T. RICH-ARDS 57

John Gower's Latin Poems. J . Gow . 62Briefer Notices :

Housman's Manilius I., Bell and Sons'Pocket-book Odes of Horace, Krum-biegel's Index to Varro's Res Rus-ticae, Gercke's Abriss der Griech-ischen Lautlehre, Moulton's TwoLectures on the Science of Language,Klussmann's Catalogue of School-Programs (J. P. P.) . 6 3

Report:The Classical Association of England

and Wales 64Versions:

I. From William Blake. W. HEAD-LAM 69

II . 'Come, landlord, fill the flowingbowl!' W. HEADLAM 70

Archaeology :Some Account of a Volume of Epi-

graphic Drawings now preserved inthe British Museum. THOMAS ASH-BY, Jun 70

Zeus, Jupiter, and the Oak. ARTHURBERNARD COOK 75

Gardner's Ancient Athens. PAUL BAUB 89Perrot's Art in Antiquity (Vol. VIII.).

W. M. RAMSAY 92Folklore and Classical Studies. FRANK

GEANGEB . 94

Ujfalvy's Portraits of Alexander. D.G . H O G A B T H , 9 4

S u m m a r i e s o f P e r i o d i c a l s . , . . . , 9 5



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


iv THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

No. 2.PAGE

Original Contributions:Herodotus VIII. 2. 1. A. G. LAIRD. 97On Prometheus Desmotes, Lines 980-1.

JANET CASE . 99Two Notes on the Birds of Aristo-

phanes. R. E. WHITE 100The Offensive Weapon in the Pyrrhic.

W. E. D. DOWNES 101Grammatical Notes from the Papyri.

JAMES HOPE MOULTON 106Mavortius' Copy of Prudentius. E. O.

WINSTEDT 112Reviews:

Thalheim's Isaeus. W. WYSE . . .115Shorey's Unity of Plato's Thought. R.

G. BUBT 120Anderson's Asia Minor. RONALD M.

BUBBOWS 122

Reviews—continued:Owen's Persius and Juvenal.—A Re-

joinder. S. G. OWEN 125Report:

Proceedings of the Oxford Philo-logical Society.—Michaelmas Term,1903. LEWIS R. FARNELL . . . . 131

Archaeology :Some Notes on the Ancient Greek j

Sculpture Exhibited at the Bnrling- jton Fine Arts Club. CHABLES iWALDSTEIN 133 .

Recent Excavations in Rome. THOMAS •ASHBY, Jun 137

Monthly Record. F. H. MABSHALL .141Numismatic Summaries. WABWICK

WBOTH 143

No. 3.Original Contributions:

Homeric Notes. I I . JOHN ADAMSSCOTT 145

New Homeric Papyri. T. W. ALLEN. 147Pseudo-Euclid, Introductio Harmonica.

J. COOK WILSON 150Grammatical Notes from the Papyri.

JAMES HOPE MOULTON 151The Citations from Sallust's Histories

in Arusianus Messius. C. M. MAC-DONALD 155

Notes on the Silvae of Statins. W. R.HABDIE 156

Notes:The Vocative of ©tds. W. M. RAMSAY. 158On Juvenal VII. 222. W. M. RAMSAY. 158The Plural of res publica. J. S. REID. 159Latin s(s) from rss. E. H. STUBTEVANT. 159

Reviews :Sidgyrick'sfieptem c. Thebas and Persae

of Aischylos. M. A. BAYFIELD . .159Some Recent Editions of Plays of

Aristophanes. HERBERT RICHARDS. 164The Geographical Study of Homer

(Berard's Les Pheniciens et VOdys-sie). W. M. RAMSAY 165

Vahlen's Ennius. CYBIL BAILEY . .169Merrill's Selections from the Younger

Pliny. WALTEB C. SUMMERS . . .173Roby's Roman Private Law. S. G.

OWEN 174Kromayer's Ancient Battle-grounds.

R O N A L D M . B U B B O W S , , , , . . 1 7 6

I Reviews—continued:| Gardthausen's Greek Manuscripts. T.I W. ALLEN 177

Briefer Notices:Sophocles' Antigone at the Leland

Stanford Junior University (J. E.CASE); Bickel's Stobaeiexcerpta Pla-tonica de Phaedone (R. G. BUBY) ;Solm sen's Inscriptiones Graecae adUlustrandas Dialectos selectae (W.H. D. ROUSE) ; Flickinger's Mean-ing of iiri TT}S aicr]vf)s in writers ofthe fourth century, Capps's Intro-duction of Comedy into the CityDionysia (HEBBEBT RICHABDS) ;Menna's De Infinilivi apud Pliniumminorem usu (WALTEB C. SUM-MERS) ; Winbolt's Latin HexameterVerse (W. H. D. ROUSE) . . . . . 178

Correspondence:Development of Zeus. L. -CAMPBELL. 181

Version:' Shirley's ' No Armour against Fate.'

G. DUNN 181Archaeology :

Dorpf eld's Troy. E. A. GABDNEB . . 181Scott's Portraitures of Julius Caesar. '

KATHARINE A. MCDOWALL . . . .183Besnier's tie Tiberine and De Regione

Paelignorum. THOMAS ASHBY, Jun. 185Monthly Record. F. H. MARSHALL . 188Archaeological Summaries. H. B. W. 190

Summaries of Periodicals , . . . . .191



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


TABLE OF CONTENTS.

No. 4.Editorial and General:

Comments and Communiques. . . .193Original Contributions:

Further Adversaria upon the Frag-ments of Euripides. T. G. TUCKER. 194

Nuces Thucydideae. T. NICKLIN . .199Platonica I. JOHN BURNET . . . .199Notes on Xenophon. HERBERT RICH-

ARDS 204Grammatical Notes. H. DARNLEY

NAYLOR 206Some Greek Cognates of the Sanskrit

Root tvis-. E. W. FAY 207Emendations of Cicero's Verrines. W.

PETERSON 208Reviews:

Y err all's Agamemnon. J .U.POWELL. 212Stuart Jones's Thucydides. H. RACK-

HAM 216Diels' Pre-Socratics. A. C. PEARSON .217Bornecque's Seneca Rhetor. WALTER

C. SUMMERS 221Boissier's Tacite. T. R. GLOVER . . 223Wessner's Bonatus. J. P. P . . . . 224Chroust's Monumenta Palaeographica.

F. G. KENYON 225

In Reply to a Critique on a recent

Reviews—continued :Greek and Latin Verse Translation.HENRY HAYMAN 226

Owen's Persius and Juvenal.—A Ca-veat. A. E. HOUSMAN 227

Briefer Notices:Wissowa's Pauly's Real-Encyclopadie

der classiscken Altertumswissennchaft(G. F. H I L L ) ; Thomas' Petrone:I'envers de la SociMe Romaine (T.R. GLOVER) 228

Archaeology :The Date of Seilanion. KATHARINE

A. MCDOWALL 229Schreiber's Portraits of Alexander the

Great. P. GARDNER 231Wiegand's Archaic Poros-Architecture

of the Acropolis. G. F. HILL . . . 232Svoronos's National Museum of Ath-

ens. J O H N ff. B A K E R - P E N O Y R E . . 2 3 3

Ronczewski's Roman Vault-Decora-tion. F. H. MARSHALL 234

Hepding's Attis and Ruhl's De Mortu-orum ludicio. JANE E. HARRISON. 234

Monthly Record. F. H. MARSHALL . 235Archaeological and Numismatic

Summaries. H. B. WALTERS andWARWICK WROTH 237

Summaries of Periodicals 238

No. 5.Editorial and General:

The Classical Association at Oxford . 239Original Contributions:

On Iliad E 127 sqq. R. M. HENRY . 240Notes on Aeschylus. W. HEAD-

LAM 241The Parodos of Sophocles' Antigone.

BENJ. IDE WHEELER 243" Further Adversaria upon the Frag-

ments of Sophocles. T. G. TUCKER . 245On the Fragments of Euripides. R.

G. BURY 246On the Platonist Doctrine of the

«rv/tj3XijToi apiOjjLoL J. COOK WIL-- SON 247On a Passage in Xenophon's Memora-

bilia. HENRY JACKSON 260Notes on the Text of Dionysius Hali-

carnassensis: The Three LiteraryLetters. T. NICKLIN 260

Prohibitions in Greek. HENRY JACK-SON 262

Reviews :Nairn's Herodas. W. HEADLAM . . . 263Waltzing's Minucius Felix. ROBIN-

SON ELLIS , . , . , , 269

Reviews—continued:Sandys' History of Classical Scholar-

ship. ALFRED GUDEMAN 271Briefer Notices : -

Simonson's A Greek Grammar: Acci-dence (W. H. D. ROUSE) ; Hardie'sLectures on Classical Subjects (F.M. CORNFORD) 276

Correspondence:Ten Commandments for Classical Stu-

dents. CORA M. PORTERFIELD . . 277Report:

Proceedings of the Oxford Philo-logical Society. — Hilary Term,1904. A. H. J. GREENIDGE . . . 278

Archaeology :" Sauer's Laborde Head mid Parthenon

Pediments. P. GARDNER . . . . 282Walters' Greek Art. C. A. HUTTON . 282Talfourd Ely's Roman Hayling. F. H.

MARSHALL 283Monthly Record. F. H. MARSHALL . 284Numismatic Summaries. WARWICK

WROTH 285Summaries of Periodicals 286Addendum to p. 241. W, HEADLAM . . 286.



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


VI THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

No. 6.

PAGE

Original Contributions:Herondas V I I . 96. JOHN I. BEARE . 287On Xenophon, Memorabilia 1. 6. 13.

H . RICHARDS 288The Metrical Division of Compound

"Words in Virgil. A. W. VER-RALL 288

On the Fragments of an Epitome ofLivy Discovered at Oxyrhynchus.J . S. R E I D 290

Some Emendations in Statius' The-laid. H . W. GARROD 300

On Statius, Thebaid IX . 501. J . P .POSTDATE 301

Corruptions of Set in Latin MSS.D. A. SLATER 302

Plato and Minucius Felix. PAULSHOREY ' . . 302

Studies of Latin Words in •cinia-,-cinia-. I.—Luscinia. EDWIN W.FAY 303

PAGE

Original Contributions—continued :Corrections. New Homeric Papyri.

T. W. ALLEN 307Reviews:

Nairn's Herodas(concluded). W. HEAD-LAM 308

Sandys' History of Classical Scholar-ship (concluded). ALFREDGUDEMAN.316

Oakesmith's Religion of Plutarch.W. H. D. ROUSE 322

Gifford's Eusebius. H . F. STEWART . 323Archaeology :

Zeus, Jupiter, and the Oak (continued).ARTHUR BERNARD COOK 325

Recent Excavations in Rome. THOMASASHBY, J u n 328

Short Notices. H . B. WALTERS . . 331Monthly Record. F. H. MARSHALL . 332Archaeological and Numismatic

Summaries. H . B. WALTERS andWARWICK WROTH 332


No. 7.

Editorial and General:Comments and Communiques. . . . 335

Original Contributions:On Alcestis's hruriaptyK, Eur. Ale. 280-

325. MORTIMER LAMSON EARLE. . 330The 'AOrjvaioiv IIoXiTeia and the ijjiiepa.

SiapeiatTpriixevr). F. G. KENYON . . 337A Quantitative Difficulty in the New

Metric. EDWARD BULL CLAPP . . 339Laertiana. HERBERT RICHARDS . . 340Caesar's Movements, Jan . 21 to Feb.

14,49 B.C. MARY BRADFORD PEAKS. 346Studies of Latin Words in -cinio-,

-cinia-. II. -cinium, ' calling,' aPartially Developed Latin Suffix.EDWIN W. FAY 349

Reviews :Cornish's Translation of Catullus.

ROBINSON ELLIS . . . . . . . . 352

Reviews—continued: ;Lindsay's "Nonius Marcellus. MINTON

WARREN 353West's Latin Grammar. ROBERT S.

RADFORD 355Abbott 's From Letter to Spirit. T.

NICKLIN 357Archaeology :

Zeus, Jupiter, and the Oak (Conclu-sion). ARTHUR BERNARD COOK . . 360

Von Mach's Greek Sculpture. JOHNff. BAKER-PENOYRE 375

Collignon's and Couve's Catalogue ofPainted Vases at Athens. H. B.WALTERS 376

Monthly Record. F. H. MARSHALL . 376Archaeological Summaries. H. B. W. 379

Summaries of Periodicals , 380



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


TABLE OF CONTENTS

No. 8.

Original Contributions :Adversaria upon the Fragments of

the Minor Tragedians. T. G.TUCKER 383

On Euripides, Alcestis 96-98. W. A.OLDFATHEE 386

Greek and Eastern Parallels to Hero-dotus, III . 119. W. H. D. ROUSE. 386

Musici Scriptores Graeci. Emenda-tions and Discussions. J. COOKWILSON 387

Notes on Horace. MORTIMER LAMSONEARLE 391

Note on an Unregarded MS. of Livy.W. C. F. WALTERS 392

The Locust-Plague in Africa of 125B.C. : A Modern Parallel. W.WARDE FOWLER 394

Tunica Retiarii. A. E. HOUSMAN . 395Some Notes upon Roman Britain.

R. KNOX MCELDERRY {to be con-tinued.) 398

'Indo-European' or 'Indo-Germanic'3CARL DARLING BUCK 399

Notes:On Sophocles, Antigone 259 and 429.

H. DARNLEY NAYLOR 401The Epistolary Tenses in Greek.

JOHN THOMPSON 402The Pronunciation of GN in Latin.

W. M. LINDSAY 402Reviews :

Papyrological Literature. F. G.KENYON 402

PAGE

Reviews—continued :Norden's Aeneid VI. WALTER C.

SUMMERS 403Ramsay's Tacitus. E. HARRISON . . 407Antoine on Modal Attraction. TEN-

NEY FRANK 411Brugmann's Shorter Comparative

Grammar. R. S. CONWAY . . . .412Report:

Proceedings of the Oxford Philo-logical Society.— Easter and TrinityTerms, 1904. A. H. J. GREENIDGE. 415

Version:Cradle Song, from Tennyson. HUGO

H. JOHNSON 416Archaeology:

The Mysteries in the Frogs of Aris-' tophanes. T. G. TUCKER and JANEE. HARRISON . • 416

On the Ancient Sculptures Exhibitedat the Burlington Fine ArtsClub.—A Reply. ADOLF FURT-WANGLER 419

Winter's Types of Terracotta Statuettes.H. B. WALTERS 420

Ausfeld's Prayers of the Greeks. W.H. D. ROUSE 423

Short Notices. W. H. D. ROUSE andH. B. WALTERS 424

Monthly Record. F. H. MARSHALL . 424Archaeological and Numismatic Sum-

maries. H. B. WALTERS andWARWICK WROTH 425


No. 9.

Editorial and General:Comments and Communiques 429Original Contributions:

On Some Tragic Fragments. W.HEADLAM 430

Adversaria upon Fragmenta Tragi-corwm. Adespota. T. G. TUCKER . 431

Platonica.—VI. HERBERT RICHARDS 432Notes on the Scholia to the Aves.

JOHN WILLIAMS WHITE 436The Date of Dionysalexander. W. G.

RUTHERFORD 440The Opening Sentence of the Verrines.

W.PETERSON* 440Horace, Ars Poetica, vv. 125 foil.

H. J. MAIDMBNT 441

Original Contributions—continued:Ad Apuleium. A. J. KRONENBBRG . 442Notes on the Emphatic Neuter. JO&N

GREENE 448The Latin Future Infinitive. J. P.

POSTGATE 450On Secrecy in Voting in the Athenian

Law Courts in the Fifth Century,B.C. JAMES TURNEY ALLEN . _ . 456

Some Notes upon Roman Britain{continued), ft. KNOX MCELDERRY 458

Studies of Latin Words in -cinio-,-cinia-. I I I . EDWIN W. FAY . .461

Reviews:Murray's Euripides. E. H. BLAKE-

NEY 463



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


viii THE ^CLASSICAL REVIEW.

.-"*~ P A O E r

Briefer Notices : I Archaeology :.^fockwood's M. Tvlli Ciceroni* Tuscu- \ Miss Harrison's Greek

PA6B

lanarum Disputatiomim Liber Pri-mus et Somhiwm Scipionis, Mason'sCompositions and Translations

W. H. D. ROUSE . . 465On the Ancient Sculptures Exhibited

at the Burlington Fine Arts Club..(J."P. P.); Meillet's Introduction Corrections in .Professor Furt-d, I'etvde comparative des Langues wangler's Reply 470Tndo-Europeennes (R. S. CON - Professor Furtwangler's Methods.WAY) 464 ; CHARLES WALDSTBIN- 470

i Summaries of Periodicals . . . . . . 474

INDEX ; . 4 7 7

Corrigenda in the December number . . • . . . . . . 492



https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00209025


the classical review

Documents