the city of san diego report to the hearing officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 remote radio units, 6...

44
THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer DATE ISSUED: December 7, 2016 REPORT NO. H0-16-080 HEARING DATE : December 14, 2016 SUBJECT: AT&T PARADISE MESA WATER TANK Process Three Decision PROJECT NUMBER: 498903 OWNER/APPLICANT: City of San Diego I AT&T Mobility SUMMARY: Issue: Should the Hearing Officer approve a Wireless Communication Facility (WCF) consisting of the demolition of an existing monopole and relocation of 12 antennas from the monopole to the water tank located at 1521 Statton Court within the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Planning area? Staff Recommendation: APPROVE Neighborhood Development Permit No. 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit No. 1775815. Community Planning Group Recommendation: On September 13, 2016, the Skyline-Paradise Hills Planning Committee voted 9-0 to recommend approval of the project without conditions (Attachment 10). Environmental Review: The project was determined to be exempt pursuant to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15301, Existing Facilities. This project is not pending an appeal of the environmental determination. The environmental exemption determination for this project was made on October 21, 2016, and the opportunity to appeal that determination ended November 4, 2016 (Attachment 8). BACKGROUND The AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank project is located at 1521 Statton Court in the RS-1-7 zone of the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Planning area. The water tank is located on a hillside in the middle of a neighborhood consisting entirely of single-dwelling unit residential land uses, also zoned RS-1-7. The neighborhood is bounded to the west by South Woodman Street, to the south by Paradise Valley Road, to the east by the northern terminus of Briarwood Road, and to the north by Bullock Drive (Attachments 1, 2 and 3) .

Upload: others

Post on 29-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO

Report to the Hearing Officer

DATE ISSUED: December 7, 2016 REPORT NO. H0-16-080

HEARING DATE: December 14, 2016

SUBJECT: AT&T PARADISE MESA WATER TANK Process Three Decision

PROJECT NUMBER: 498903

OWNER/APPLICANT: City of San Diego I AT&T Mobility

SUMMARY:

Issue: Should the Hearing Officer approve a Wireless Communication Facility (WCF) consisting of the demolition of an existing monopole and relocation of 12 antennas from the monopole to the water tank located at 1521 Statton Court within the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Planning area?

Staff Recommendation: APPROVE Neighborhood Development Permit No. 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit No. 1775815.

Community Planning Group Recommendation: On September 13, 2016, the Skyline-Paradise Hills Planning Committee voted 9-0 to recommend approval of the project without conditions (Attachment 10).

Environmental Review: The project was determined to be exempt pursuant to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15301, Existing Facilities. This project is not pending an appeal of the environmental determination. The environmental exemption determination for this project was made on October 21, 2016, and the opportunity to appeal that determination ended November 4, 2016 (Attachment 8).

BACKGROUND

The AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank project is located at 1521 Statton Court in the RS-1-7 zone of the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Planning area. The water tank is located on a hillside in the middle of a neighborhood consisting entirely of single-dwelling unit residential land uses, also zoned RS-1-7. The neighborhood is bounded to the west by South Woodman Street, to the south by Paradise Valley Road, to the east by the northern terminus of Briarwood Road, and to the north by Bullock Drive (Attachments 1, 2 and 3).

Page 2: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

The existing water tank was constructed in 1980 to serve the surrounding community. The monopole currently supporting AT&T antennas on the site was first approved by Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 87-0453 on December 8, 1987 for a period of ten years from lease initiation. This permit allowed the current monopole and equipment building. In 1998, an administrative approval was granted to modify the antennas at the facility. In 1999, Conditional Use Permit 91-0303-62 was granted by the City Council to further modify the facility, approving the relocation of the panel antennas from the monopole to the water tank, removal of the 135-foot-tall monopole and installation of a 67-foot-tall monopole supporting four microwave dish antennas. Although the permit expired March 23, 2009, no records could be located indicating why the 135-foot-tall monopole still exists on the property. Over the past few years, AT&T has submitted applications for new permits for different faux tree designs on the property, but the applications were never pursued past the first review so they were closed by staff due to inactivity. The project is operating without a valid discretionary permit and was referred to Code Enforcement. A Civil Penalty and Notice Order was issued prompting AT&T to negotiate with and obtain authorization from the Public Utilities Department to relocate their antennas on to the water tank. That is the subject of this report.

DISCUSSION

Project Description:

The AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank project proposes the demolition of the existing 135-foot-tall monopole and relocation of 12 panel antennas to the fa~ade of the existing water tank. The project also proposes 24 Remote Radio Units (RRUs) and six surge suppressors, to be mounted to the tank at antenna level (Attachment 12). The antennas, RRUs, surge suppressors, and cabling will be concealed within a cable tray/antenna shroud that will be painted to match the tank. There will be three antenna sectors, each with four antennas, eight RRUs, and two surge suppressors. The existing 302-square-foot equipment area adjacent to the monopole will remain (Attachments 11 and 12). Land Development Code (LDC) Section 141.0420(g)(3) allows equipment enclosures up to 250 square feet and requires a Neighborhood Development Permit for larger enclosures.

Community Plan Analysis:

The Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan does not specifically address Wireless Communication Facilities (WCF). However, the City of San Diego's General Plan Urban Design Element (UD-A.15) requires that the visual impact of wireless facilities be minimized by concealing wireless facilities in existing structures or using screening techniques to hide or blend them into the surrounding area. The plan also calls for these facilities to be designed to be aesthetically pleasing and respectful of the neighborhood context. Furthermore, the plan states that equipment associated with wireless facilities be concealed from view.

Integration into the fa~ade of the existing tank will complement T-Mobile's installation, which is also on the tank and will reduce the visual impact of the facility by eliminating an existing monopole. Existing mature landscaping on the site serves to partially screen the facility, and the cable tray/shroud will conceal the antennas, equipment, and cabling within a unified structure (Attachment 11 ). The proposed project reduces the visual impact of the existing facility while enabling its continued function as a WCF.

2

Page 3: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

Council Policy 600-43:

Council Policy 600-43, Wireless Communication Facilities, encourages wireless providers to locate WCFs away from residential and other sensitive uses by providing lower permit process levels in commercial and industrial zones. For example, WCFs located in commercial and industrial zones are permitted with a Process One (staff-level) approval, whereas WCFs located in a residential zone with a residential use are permitted with a Process Four (Planning Commission) approval. Because the proposed project is located in a residential zone on a site with a non-residential use, a Process Three CUP is required. This location is more preferable than locating the WCF in a residential zone with a residential use, but is less preferable than locating the WCF in a commercial or industrial zone. Wireless carriers are required to provide coverage throughout their license area, which sometimes necessitates locating a WCF in a less preferable area.

Conclusion:

In the 1980's when wireless technology was new to San Diego, antennas were mostly located on higher elevation properties and on monopoles as support structures. As time and technology progressed, new designs were developed to hide these facilities and monopoles began to be phased out. The water tank is an existing community land mark that could be considered a visual impact to some; however the AT&T monopole is an additional visual impact that does not integrate into the single dwelling unit neighborhood and does not comply with the WCF regulations (Attachment 9). Using the 120 foot tall water tank, which is a part of the neighborhood landscape, as a support structure to mount their antennas, reduces the visual impact of the WCF in the neighborhood. Based on its design, the project complies with the WCF Regulations (LDC 141.0420). Staff has prepared draft findings in the affirmative to approve the project and recommends approval of Neighborhood Development Permit 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit 1775815 (Attachment 6).

ALTERNATIVES

1. Approve Neighborhood Development Permit 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit 1775815 with modifications.

2. Deny Neighborhood Development Permit 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit 1775815 ifthe Hearing Officer makes written findings based on substantial evidence that the approval is not authorized by state or local zoning law.

Respectfully submitted,

Attachments:

1. Aerial Photograph 2. Community Plan Land Use Map

3

Page 4: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

3. Project Location Map 4. Project Data Sheet 5. Draft Permit Resolution with Findings 6. Draft Permit with Conditions 7. Coverage Maps 8. Environmental Exemption 9. Photo Survey 10. Community Planning Group Recommendation 11. Photo Simulations 12. Project Plans

4

Page 5: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

Aerial Photo

AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank (Skyline-Paradise Hills Community) 1521 Statton Court

North

w

Page 6: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

Community Plan RESIDENTIAL

D ·Slngl• flll'JUJ

Muln- l•nt.lly

COMMERCIAL

m J M.ftu I NclghborbOOd COmroorcilll· ColftrrtVnlty Rcs'idtntiaf Permi'tted

• ~1~ duslacf

Natghbor•oQ~

PUBLIC FAC1LITIES

0 1Et.menl•J'Y School

c;;l WIGdte 8cl'lo.ol

0 Jv1tlor tnsi·h School

0 Senior 'Hlati School

Designated as "Single Family"

0 llbrory

0 Flr• ·Sr&• lon

SKYLINE• PARADISE HILLS COMMUNITY PLAN MAP

ln tl!e •ire•t 't...lt'" ts Hy .:!here :JtQ b!:l)illft t. ! (..-nit,)' '1H d'.1p ud t h11 oUier ~,s tn t~h Pl•n~ U. CCllnunfl.J flu "ap -ihcl 1 t•k1t i;Jl'•ttivK:4.

SUllll·PJUDISI HlllS ['24E) ,CITY Of SH Dl[CO • PlUllJIG OlPAllTlllllT _____ _______ __,

AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank (Skyline -Paradise Hills Community) 1521 Statton Court

North

w

Page 7: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

...

Project Location Map

South Encantato

••• North Bay eferraces

AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank (Skyline-Paradise Hills Community> 1521 Statton Court

North

w

Page 8: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATIACHMENT4

PROJECT DATA SHEET PROJECT NAME: AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank

Demolition and removal of an exist ing 135-foot-tall monopole and

PROJECT DESCRIPTION: installation of 12 panel antennas, 24 remote radio units and six surge suppressors mounted to the tank and an existing 302-square-foot equipment enclosure.

COMMUNITY PLAN AREA: Skyline-Paradise Hil ls

DISCRETIONARY ACTIONS: Neighborhood Development Permit/Conditional Use Permit

COMMUNITY PLAN LAND Single Family

USE DESIGNATION:

ZONING INFORMATION:

ZONE: RS-1-7 HEIGHT LIMIT: 30 feet

FRONT SETBACK: 15 feet SIDE SETBACK: 238 feet/1 02 feet

STREETSIDE SETBACK: N/A REAR SETBACK: 52 feet

PARKING: N/A

ADJACENT PROPERTIES: LAND USE DESIGNATION & EXISTING LAND USE

ZONE

NORTH: Single Fami ly; RS-1-7 Single Dwelling Residentia l

SOUTH: Single Family; RS-1-7 Single Dwelling Residential

EAST: Single Family; RS-1-7 Single Dwelling Residential

WEST: Single Fami ly; RS-1-7 Single Dwelling Residential

DEVIATION REQUESTED: A 302-square-foot equipment enclosure where 250 square feet is allowed.

COMMUNITY PLANNING On September 13, 2016, the Skyline-Paradise Hills Planning Committee

GROUP RECOMMENDATION:

voted 9-0 to recommend approval without any conditions.

Page 9: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 5

HEARING OFFICER RESOLUTION NO. __ _ NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT PERMIT 1775819 and CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 1775815

AT&T PARADISE MESA WATER TANK- PROJECT NO. 498903

WHEREAS, CITY OF SAN DIEGO, Owner, and AT&T MOBILITY, Permittee, filed an application with the City of San Diego for a permit to demolish and remove an existing 135-foot-tall monopole and install 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water Tank, (as described in and by reference to the approved Exhibits "A" and corresponding conditions of approval for the associated Neighborhood Development Permit 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit 1775815) on portions of a 5.10-acre site

WHEREAS, the project site is located at 1521 Statton Court in the RS-1-7 zone of the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Planning area;

WHEREAS, the project site is legally described as: all that portion of quarter Sections 53 and 54 of Rancho de la Nacion, in the City of San Diego, County of San Diego, State of California, according to Map thereof No. 166, filed in the Office of the San Diego County Recorder;

WHEREAS, on December 14, 2016, the Hearing Officer of the City of San Diego considered Neighborhood Development Permit 1775819 and Conditional Use Permit 1775815 pursuant to the Land Development Code of the City of San Diego;

WHEREAS, on October 21, 2016, the City of San Diego, as Lead Agency, through the Development Services Department, made and issued an Environmental Determination that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Public Resources Code Section 21000 et seq.) under CEQA Guideline Section 15301, Existing Facilities, and there was no appeal of the Environmental Determination filed within the time period provided by San Diego Municipal Code Section 112.0520; NOW, THEREFORE;

BE IT RESOLVED by the Hearing Officer of the City of San Diego as follows:

That the Hearing Officer adopts the following written Findings, dated December 14, 2016.

FINDINGS:

Neighborhood Development Permit Approval - Section §126.0404Cal

1. The proposed development will not adversely affect the applicable land use plan.

The Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan did not contemplate WCFs at the time it was adopted in 1987. However, The City's General Plan addresses WCFs in the Urban Design Element (UD­A.15), which requires that the visual impact of wireless facilities be minimized by concealing wireless facilities in existing structures or using screening techniques to hide or blend them into the surrounding area. The plan also calls for these facilities to be designed to be aesthetically

Page 1 of 6

Page 10: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 5

pleasing and respectful of the neighborhood context. Furthermore, the plan states that equipment associated with wireless facilities be concealed from view.

This project consists of the demolition of a 135-foot-tall monopole and installation of 12 panel antennas on the fa<;:ade of an existing water tank. The project also proposes 24 Remote Radio Units (RRUs) and six surge suppressors, to be mounted to the tank at antenna level. The antennas, RRUs, surge suppressors, and cabling will be concealed within a cable tray/antenna shroud that will be painted to match the tank. There will be three antenna sectors, each with four antennas, eight RRUs, and two surge suppressors. The existing 302-square-foot equipment area adjacent to the monopole will remain.

A Neighborhood Development Permit (NDP) is required per San Diego Municipal Code (SDMC) 141.0420(g)(3) to allow an equipment area larger than 250 square feet. The 302-square-foot enclosure exceeds this limit. To address potential impacts, the project proposes to leave existing mature screening trees to remain, which will serve to reduce the visual impact of the facility.

In addition to the NDP, a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) is required to allow a WCF on a parcel with a non-residential use in a residential zone.

In the 1980's when wireless technology was new to San Diego, antennas were mostly located on higher elevation properties and on monopoles as support structures. As time and technology progressed, new designs were developed to integrate these facilities and monopoles began to be phased out. The water tank is an existing community land mark that could be considered a visual impact to some; however the AT&T monopole is an additional visual impact that does not integrate into the single dwelling unit neighborhood and does not comply with the WCF regulations. Moving the antennas from a monopole to the existing water tank will greatly reduce the visibility of the existing WCF. The antennas, RR Us, surge suppressors, and cabling will be concealed within a cable tray/antenna shroud that will be painted to match the tank. Existing mature landscaping on the site serves to partially screen the facility, and the cable tray/shroud will conceal the antennas, equipment, and cabling within a unified structure. The proposed project reduces the visual impact of the existing facility while enabling its continued function as a WCF.

The proposed WCF complies with SDMC 141.0420, Wireless Communication Facilities, as well as the design and location requirements of the City's General Plan. The proposed WCF will not adversely affect the applicable land use plan or the City's General Plan.

2. The proposed development will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare.

The project is located at 1521 Statton Court in the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan area. The AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank project proposes the demolition of the existing 135 foot tall monopole and installation of 12 panel antennas on to the fa<;:ade of the existing water tank. The project also proposes 24 Remote Radio Units (RRUs) and six surge suppressors, to be mounted to the tank at antenna level. The existing 302 square foot equipment area will remain.

Page 2 of 6

Page 11: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 5

The project was determined to be exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15301 (Existing Facilities). The conditions of approval for the project will require compliance with several operational constraints and development controls intended to assure the continued public health, safety and welfare. Certain of these conditions were based on input received during the public review process. All proposed improvement plans associated with the project will be reviewed prior to issuance of construction permits and inspected during construction to assure the project will meet or exceed all relevant and applicable building, electrical, mechanical, plumbing and fire codes.

The Telecommunication Act of 1996 preempts local governments from regulating the "placement, construction and modification of wireless communication facilities on the basis of the environmental effects of Radio Frequency (RF) emission to the extent that such facilities comply with the Federal Communication Commission's (FCC) standards for such emissions." An Electromagnetic Energy Exposure Report was prepared, which concluded that the project will be in compliance with FCC standards for RF emissions. Therefore, the project will not result in any significant health or safety risks to the surrounding area within matters of the City's jurisdiction.

3. The proposed development will comply with the applicable regulations of the Land Development Code including any allowable deviations pursuant to the Land Development Code.

Because the equipment area is larger than 250 square feet, the project requires an NDP pursuant to SDMC 141.0420(g)(3). The purpose of the NDP, as stated in SDMC 126.0401, is to establish a review process for proposed development that may be desirable but may have some limited physical impacts on the surrounding properties. The intent is to determine if the proposed development complies with the development regulations of the applicable zone, as well as supplemental regulations for the type of development proposed, and to apply limited conditions if necessary to achieve conformance with these regulations.

The equipment area is approximately 302 square feet and is a typical size for WCF in certain configurations. Existing mature landscaping on the site serves to screen the facility. The project is located in the RS-1-7 zone of the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan. The project meets all applicable requirements of this zone.

Because it is proposed on a property containing a non-residential use in a residential zone, this project requires a CUP pursuant to SDMC 141.0420(e)(1 ). This conditional use is allowed by the Land Development Code if findings can be made. These findings are discussed under "Conditional Use Permit Approval" below.

In addition to the NDP and CUP Regulations, the WCF Regulations (SDMC 141.0420) contain design requirements for WCF, which include the requirement to utilize the smallest, least visually intrusive antennas, components and other necessary equipment and to use all reasonable means to conceal or minimize the visual impacts of the wireless communication facilities through integration. Integration with existing structures or among other existing uses shall be accomplished through the use of architecture, landscape and siting solutions.

Page 3 of 6

Page 12: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 5

Removal of the monopole, which is considered a visual impact in this neighborhood of single unit dwellings, will improve the neighborhood visual context. Since the water tank has been in the neighborhood since 1980, using that as a support structure to fa~ade mount the antennas and associated components and paint them to match the tank, will greatly improve the aesthetics. Because the project meets the design requirements of SDMC 141.0420 and findings can be made in the affirmative for all permits required by this project, the project and all deviations will comply with the applicable regulations of the Land Development Code.

Conditional Use Permit Approval - Section §126.0305

1. The proposed development will not adversely affect the applicable land use plan.

Because it was written in 1987, the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan did not contemplate WCFs. However, The City's General Plan addresses WCFs in the Urban Design Element (UD-A.15), which requires that the visual impact of wireless facilities be minimized by concealing wireless facilities in existing structures or using screening techniques to hide or blend them into the surrounding area. The plan also calls for these facilities to be designed to be aesthetically pleasing and respectful of the neighborhood context. Furthermore, the plan states that equipment associated with wireless facilities be concealed from view.

This project consists of the removal of an existing 135-foot-tall monopole and the installation of 12 antennas and associated components onto the fa~ade of the water tank. The associated equipment is located within a 302-square-foot enclosure. A Conditional Use Permit (CUP) is required to allow a WCF on a parcel with a non-residential use in a residential zone within 100 feet of adjacent residential uses because the antennas are 52 feet from an adjacent residential property line. An NDP is required per SDMC 141.0420(g)(3) to allow an equipment area larger than 250 square feet.

The proposed WCF complies with SDMC 141.0420, Wireless Communication Facilities, as well as the design and location requirements of the City's General Plan. The proposed WCF will not adversely affect the applicable land use plan or the City's General Plan.

2. The proposed development will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare.

The project is located at 1521 Statton Court in the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan area. The AT&T Paradise Mesa Water Tank project proposes the demolition of the existing 135-foot­tall monopole and installation of 12 panel antennas on to the fa~ade of the existing water tank. The project also proposes 24 Remote Radio Units (RRUs) and six surge suppressors, to be mounted to the tank at antenna level. The existing 302-square-foot equipment area will remain.

The project was determined to be exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15301 (Existing Facilities). The conditions of approval for the project will require compliance with several operational constraints and development controls intended to assure the continued public health, safety and welfare. Certain of these conditions were based on input received during the public review process. All proposed improvement plans associated with the project will be reviewed prior to issuance of construction permits and inspected during construction to assure

Page 4 of 6

Page 13: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 5

the project will meet or exceed all relevant and applicable building, electrical, mechanical, plumbing and fire codes.

The Telecommunication Act of 1996 preempts local governments from regulating the "placement, construction and modification of wireless communication facilities on the basis of the environmental effects of Radio Frequency (RF) emission to the extent that such facilities comply with the Federal Communication Commission's (FCC) standards for such emissions." An Electromagnetic Energy Exposure Report was prepared, which concluded that the project will be in compliance with FCC standards for RF emissions. Therefore, the project will not result in any significant health or safety risks to the surrounding area within matters of the City's jurisdiction.

3. The proposed development will comply with the regulations of the Land Development Code including any allowable deviations pursuant to the Land Development Code.

Because it is proposed on a property containing a non-residential use in a residential zone with antennas located within 100 feet of the property line of an adjacent residential use, this project requires a CUP pursuant to SDMC 141.0420(e)(1 ). The purpose of the CUP, as stated in SDMC 126.0301, is to establish a review process for the development of uses that may be desirable under appropriate circumstances, but are not permitted by right in the applicable zone. The intent is to review these uses on a case-by-case basis to determine whether and under what conditions the use may be approved at a given site.

The project represents a use that could be considered to have a negative impact on the neighborhood if certain performance and appearance issues aren't addressed. However, the proposed project proposes removal of a 135-foot-tall monopole and installation of antennas and associated components on the neighborhood water tank and will be subject to several performance and appearance-related permit conditions designed to address neighborhood concerns.

Because the equipment area is larger than 250 square feet, the project requires an NDP pursuant to SDMC 141.0420(g)(3). An NDP is allowed by the Land Development Code if findings can be made. These findings are discussed under "Neighborhood Development Permit Approval" above.

The project is located in the RS-1-7 zone of the Skyline-Paradise Hills Community Plan. The project meets all applicable requirements of this zone. The WCF Regulations (SDMC 141.0420) contain design requirements for WCF, which include the requirement to utilize the smallest, least visually intrusive antennas, components and other necessary equipment and to use all reasonable means to conceal or minimize the visual impacts of the wireless communication facilities through integration. Integration with existing structures or among other existing uses shall be accomplished through the use of architecture, landscape and siting solutions.

This project consists of the removal of an existing 135-foot-tall monopole and the installation of 12 antennas and associated components onto the fa~ade of the water tank. The associated

equipment is located within a 302-square-foot enclosure. Because the project meets the design requirements of SDMC 141.0420 and findings can be made in the affirmative for all permits

Page 5 of 6

Page 14: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 5

required by this project, the project and all deviations will comply with the applicable regulations of the Land Development Code.

4. The proposed use is appropriate at the proposed location.

In the 1980's when wireless technology was new to San Diego, antennas were mostly located on higher elevation properties and on monopoles as support structures. This monopole was located on an elevated property above a residential neighborhood next to an existing water tank, where it was assumed it would blend in with the existing visual impact. As time and technology progressed, new designs were developed to integrate these facilities and monopoles began to be phased out. This monopole is one of less than a handful left in the City of San Diego. By using the 120-foot-tall water tank, which is a part of the neighborhood landscape, as a support structure to mount the AT&T antennas, it reduces the visual impact of the WCF in the neighborhood. Additionally, there are mature trees sporadically growing around the perimeter of the water tank, which provides screening for the lower portion of the tank, which also reduces visual impacts.

All proposed improvement plans associated with the project will be reviewed prior to issuance of construction permits and inspected during construction to assure the project will meet or exceed all relevant and applicable building, electrical, mechanical, plumbing and fire codes.

Because the project design and permit conditions address approval and operational concerns, the proposed use is appropriate at the proposed location.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that, based on the findings herein before adopted by the Hearing Officer, NDP No. 1775819 and CUP No. 1775815 is hereby GRANTED by the Hearing Officer to the referenced Owner/Permittee, in the form, exhibits, terms and conditions as set forth in Permit No. 1775819/1775815, a copy of which is attached hereto and made a part hereof.

Karen Lynch Development Project Manager Development Services

Adopted on: December 14, 2016

10#: 24006818

3-3-16

Page 6 of 6

Page 15: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

RECORDING REQUESTED BY CITY OF SAN DIEGO

DEVELOPMENT SERVICES PERMIT INTAKE, MAIL STATION

501

WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO PROJECT MANAGEMENT

PERMIT CLERK MAIL STATION 501

ATTACHMENT 6

INTERNAL ORDER NUMBER: 24006818 .. IS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE

Recorder.

a.

b.

CONDITIONAL USE PERMII~~;;1 NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPM~f'il.b.P'E'RMIT N ·, 75819

' K PROJECT N '/~~~8903 FICER <':f~.

ions set fo ·llin this Permit, permission is granted to . ·· · · y dest~i;~~d and identified by size, dimension, quantity,

it % ·· 't ':;t~rdated December 14, 2016, on file in the

fa 135'.::{~bt-tall monopole;

h the following dimensions: 96" x 14.4" x 8.6") mounted to the ~er tank; 24 Remote Radio Units and six surge suppressors, also f the tank. All associated cables/conduits shall be concealed

c. A 302-square-foot equipment enclosure;

d. Public and private accessory improvements determined by the Development Services Department to be consistent with the land use and development standards for this site in accordance with the adopted community plan, the California Environmental Quality Act [CEQA] and the CEQA Guidelines, the City Engineer's requirements, zoning regulations, conditions of this Permit, and any other applicable regulations of the SDMC.

Page 1 of7

Page 16: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 6

e. Every aspect of this project is considered an element of concealment including (but not limited to) the dimensions, build and scale, color, materials and texture. Any future modifications to this permit/project must not defeat concealment.

STANDARD REQUIREMENTS:

1. This permit must be utilized within thirty-six (36) months after the date on which all rights of appeal have expired. If this permit is not utilized in accordance with Chapter 12, Article 6, Division 1 of the SDMC within the 36 month period, this permit shall be voi . less an Extension of Time has been granted. Any such Extension of Time must meet all SDl\1; / irements and applicable guidelines in effect at the time the extension is considered ·· propriate decision maker. This permit must be utilized by December 29, 2019.

2. This Conditional Use Permit (CUP)/Neighbor _ Developme~f<~fi]r:nit (NDP) and corresponding use of this site shall expire on P er 29, 2026. Up6n~'; iration of this Permit, the facilities and improvements described here1 all be removed from tff and the property shall be restored to its original condition preceding a . Permit.

3. No later than ninety (90) days .he expiratioh: 1s permit, the Permi ee may submit a new application to the City Manager '"t. ~~~~~{~tion wit ~~~wand a decision by the appropriate decision maker at that time:~[;1l,Uure--~·~l4J;bmit prio"tOJhe deadline will be cause.for

~;?>~-· "<:.+;;;f:<?~'":--- -:;'·h~~.

enforcement for noncom pH ce, which ma¥:h!;lclude'P ies ana~•Iif!i;~s.

4. ' ··approv;~JJto;lhJ: · ermi(~'fhoi:;i~~v~ermittee to utilize this site '•:.·•: .:•· •:·W:g:·: •:· '• . :c.'ii.:r

for wireless comm uni '·ii:t8~ purpose eyond tf\~Apermit expiration date. Use of this permit beyond the expiration date of thlS:4 'ti · hibited. ·- .·

5. descri the pre

a.

b.

J~rmittee sign and <:.c...'.·

- -_·. ~·-·: :-')3""

P®ili:J~.~-··9[ o~f)ation of any facility or improvement any a~fil~iN authorized by this Permit be conducted on

o't;;,<~

Permit to the Development Services Department;

.-·-·,

.~Iii the Office of the San Diego County Recorder.

' --:,,.2.;;'.';$"

6. While this Permit is in~Wect, the subject property shall be used only for the purposes and under the terms and conditions set forth in this Permit unless otherwise authorized by the appropriate City decision maker.

Page 2 of7

Page 17: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 6

7. This Permit is a covenant running with the subject property and all of the requirements and conditions of this Permit and related documents shall be binding upon the Permittee and any successor(s) in interest.

8. The continued use of this Permit shall be subject to the regulations of this and any other applicable governmental agency.

9. Issuance of this Permit by the City of San Diego does not authorize the Permittee for this Permit to violate any Federal, State or City laws, ordinances, regulations or policies including, but not limited to, the Endangered Species Act of 1973 [ESA] and any am ents thereto (16 U.S.C. § 1531

et seq.).

10. The Permittee shall secure all necessary building Permittee is informed that to secure these permits, substantial building modificatipJ1J$ site i ,~)Vements may be required to comply with applicable building, fire, mechanical, ,.~~liJmbing cod~s; State and Federal disability access laws.

11. Construction plans shall be in substantial con alterations to the construction plans ar;e rohibited ur1

·· · it "A." Cha • . , modifications, or ; riate applicatid:~~)~pr

'""'.i! ~:-.'-

amendment(s) to this Permit have b ted.

12. All of the conditions contained int necessary to make the findi.Qg?, required f . pr;~·' . .

'i •,~,(cc,; ~-", ';o' • • _ 'r

to comply with each an ition in o'(tl~r to mqi,t;J ·

this Permit. ~It~';· ·

contained therein.

I challenge«~~'~he Permittee of this Permit, is found or held lid, uil7otorceable, or unreasonable, this Permit shall

P ~hlll;.eiave the right, by paying applicable a new p rt:.without the "invalid" conditions(s) back to the

rmit for a7

determination by that body as to whether all of ance~ .e proposed permit can still be made in the absence of ring shali>'be a hearing de nova, and the discretionary body shall

isapprove, or modify the proposed permit and the condition(s)

13. indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its agents, officers, and employees from any and all ms, actions, proceedings, damages, judgments, or costs, including attorney's fees, against the City or its agents, officers, or employees, relating to the issuance of this permit including, but not limited to, any action to attack, set aside, void, challenge, or annul this development approval and any environmental document or decision. The City will promptly notify Permittee of any claim, action, or proceeding and, if the City should fail to cooperate fully in the defense, the Permittee shall not thereafter be responsible to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless

Page 3 of7

Page 18: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 6

the City or its agents, officers, and employees. The City may elect to conduct its own defense, participate in its own defense, or obtain independent legal counsel in defense of any claim related to this indemnification. In the event of such election, Permittee shall pay all of the costs related thereto, including without limitation reasonable attorney's fees and costs. In the event of a disagreement between the City and Permittee regarding litigation issues, the City shall have the authority to control the litigation and make litigation related decisions, including, but not limited to, settlement or other disposition of the matter. However, the Permittee shall not be required to pay or perform any settlement unless such settlement is approved by Permittee.

ENGINEERING REQUIREMENTS:

14. The project proposes to export 33 cubic yards of mat material listed to be exported, shall be exported to a le Standard Specifications for Public Works Constructio Supplement Amendments adopted by Regional St

.om the project site. All excavated ite in accordance with the

2015 edition and Regional

15. Prior to the issuance of any construction . J::porate any construction Best Management Practices necessa , ~ om ply ,wit~ Chapter 14 jcle 2, Division 1 (Grading Regulations) of the San Dieg9. unicipal Code~ · c5"nstruction pla ··~:5 specifications.

16. Prior to the issuance of any cons Control Plan (WPCP). The WPCP shall be

·tee shall submit a Water Pollution " h the guidelines in Appendix G

of the City's Storm Water S~

17. removed or facility, t Devel "

18.

PLANNING/DESIGN

19.

pined ,Jiisease, weed and litter free condition at all times. is not·~:&rmitted. The trees shall be maintained in a safe its mature height and spread.

20. The WCF shall conform to the approved construction plans.

21. All antennas, Surge Suppressors, RRUs, mounting apparatus, and cable trays shall be painted to match the water tank to the satisfaction of the Development Services Department.

22. Photo simulations shall be printed on the construction plans.

Page 4 of7

Page 19: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 6

23. The Permittee shall install and maintain appropriate warning signage on the WCF as required by State and Federal regulations. The Permittee shall be responsible for complying with all State and Federal regulations.

24. No exposed pipes or mounting apparatus absent antennas shall be present at any time. Mounting pipes shall not be longer than the antennas.

25. Any future modifications to the antennas must be approved by Development Services. The

Permittee shall provide evidence demonstrating compliance with Federal standards for radio

frequency emissions in accordance with the Telecommunicatio ;~of 1996 and any subsequent

amendments.

26. The accuracy and validity of the RF Compliance Re by the Permittee, shall be assured while the WCF is in operation.

27. All equipment, including transformers, e ~ g~ncy generators and ar~' nditioners belonging to the Permittee shall be designed and operated"~ 'stent with the City no . ',rdinance. Ventilation openings shall be baffled and directed a ~St o ential areas:'\tf tion resonance of operating equipment in the equip ,enclosures s

28.

30. such Ii

31. The Permifr Department (PUD) p associated with this pr any such PUDS property public water facility in a man

INFORMATION ONLY:

· .... god working order and free from . ·-"-,_±\

aged equipment shall be .. ·he City of San Diego.

g;1gr transfer of this site to any other h case, the removal and the restoration of this

ible for any damage caused to City of San Diego Public Utilities inity of the project site, due to the construction activities

rdance with Municipal Code section 142.0607. In the event that egrity then, the Permittee shall repair or reconstruct any damaged

r satisfactory to the Director of Public Utilities and the City Engineer.

• Please note that a Telecom Planning Inspection Issue will be placed on the project prior to Final Clearance from the City's Building Inspector to ensure compliance with the approved plans and associated conditions. Prior to calling for your Final Inspection from your building inspection official, please contact the Project Manager listed below at (619) 446-5351 to

Page 5 of7

Page 20: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 6

schedule an inspection of the completed facility. Please schedule this administrative inspection at least five working days ahead of the requested Final Inspection date.

• The issuance of this discretionary use permit alone does not allow the immediate commencement or continued operation of the proposed use on site. The operation allowed by this discretionary use permit may only begin or recommence after all conditions listed on this permit are fully completed and all required ministerial permits have been issued and received final inspection.

• Any party on whom fees, dedications, reservations, or oth conditions of approval of this Permit, may protest the i "· approval of this development permit by filing a writt~f'.!\ California Government Code-section 66020.

• This development may be subject to impac~f

APPROVED by the Hearing Officer of the City al HO-XXX.

Page 6 of7

· ,,actions have been imposed as 'ion within ninety days of the t with the City Clerk pursuant to

permit issuance.

Page 21: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 6

Permit Type/PTS Approval No.: CUP No. 1775815/NDP No. 1775819 Date of Approval: December 14, 2016

AUTHENTICATED BY THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT

Karen Lynch Development Project Manager

NOTE: Notary acknowledgment must be attached per Civil Code section 1189 et seq.

The undersigned Owner/Permittee, this Permit and promises to perform

NOTE: Notary acknowledgments must be attached per Civil Code section 1189 et seq.

AT&T Mobility Permittee

NAME: TITLE:

Page 7 of7

ondition of

Page 22: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

:E --t :I: 0 c -t n 0 < m

~ G'\ m

Page 23: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

~ --I :I: n 0 < m

~ ~ m

Page 24: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 8 NOTICE OF EXEMPTION

(Check one or both)

TO: _X_ Recorder/County Clerk FROM: City of San Diego P.O. Box 1750, MS A-33 1600 Pacific Hwy, Room 260 San Diego, CA 92101-2400

Office of Planning and Research 1400 Tenth Street, Room 121 Sacramento, CA 95814

Project Name: AT&T Paradise Mesa Standpipe

Project Location-Specific: 1521 Statton Court, San Diego, CA 92114

Project Location-City/County: San Diego/San Diego

Development Services Department 1222 First Avenue, MS 501 San Diego, CA 92101

Project No.: 498903

Description of nature and purpose of the Project: The proposed project includes a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) and a Neighborhood Development Permit (NDP) for a Wireless Communications Facility (WCF) consisting of the demolition of an existing monopole and the relocation of 12 antennas from the monopole on to the water tank located at 1521 Statton Court. The associated equipment is located south of the tank in a 319 square-foot enclosure. The site is designated for residential use and zoned RS-1-7.

Name of Public Agency Approving Project: City of San Diego

Name of Person or Agency Carrying Out Project: Caitlyn Kes DePratti Inc. 1171 Veranca Avenue El Cajon, CA 92021 (858) 527- 9938

Exempt Status: (CHECK ONE) ( ) Ministerial (Sec. 21080(b)(1 ); 15268); ( ) Declared Emergency (Sec. 21080(b)(3); 15269(a)); ( ) Emergency Project (Sec. 21 OBO(b)( 4); 15269 (b)(c)) (X ) Categorical Exemption: CEQA Section 15301 (Existing Facilities)

Reasons why project is exempt: The City conducted an environmental review which determined that the proposed project is exempt from CEQA pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, which allows for the operation, repair, maintenance, permitting, leasing, licensing, or minor alteration of existing facilities (public or private), involving negligible or no expansion of use beyond that existing at the time of the determination. The proposed project, a CUP and an NDP for an existing WCF, is not an expansion of use. No environmental impacts were identified for the proposed project. Additionally, none of the exceptions described in CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2 apply.

Lead Agency Contact Person: Anna L. McPherson, AICP Telephone: (619) 446-5276

If filed by applicant: 1. Attach certified document of exemption finding. 2. Has a notice of exemption been filed by the public agency approving the project? ( ) Yes ( ) No

Revised May 2016

Page 25: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 8

It is hereby certified that the City of San Diego has determined the above activity to be exempt from CEQA

°"1uJLL. MUJz~ Signature/Title

Check One: (X) Signed By Lead Agency ( ) Signed by Applicant

Revised May 2016

October 21, 2016 /Senior Planner

Date

Date Received for Filing with County Clerk or QPR:

Page 26: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 9

1. View of North Elevation of site.

2. View of South Elevation of site.

Page 27: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

· ATTACHMENT 9

3. View of East Elevation of site.

4. View of West Elevation of site.

Page 28: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 9

5. View looking North from site. 6. View looking East from site.

Page 29: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 9

7. View looking South from site.

8. View looking West from site.

Page 30: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

~\:11, .. .,llJ'.line -Paradise Hills ,.. ................. g Committee

You can finally make a difference!

Attendees Wayne English William Glover Tim Robinson Cathy Ramsey John Mooney Senta Delgado Guy Preuss

Victor Rivago Frank Von Roenn Cynthia Suero-Gabler

ATTACHMENT 10

Minutes of September 13, 2016

Absent Adrian Chestang Harry Bennett Muriel King Elizabeth Madrid Mildred Hutcherson Tony Villafranca

7:00 p.m. Call to order, Pledge of Allegiance, introductions & procedure review.

7:02 Announcements & Non-agenda Public Conunent

7:08 Motion to accept agenda - W. Glover, 2nd - W. English; approved, 9-0.

7: 10 Motion to approve August, 2016 minutes - G. Preuss, 2"ct - W. English with one correction; approved 9-0.

7:1 l Treasurer's Report: $253.0l on account.

7: 12 p.m. Presentations

I. San Diego Police Community Relations Officer A. Thomas discussed recent crime statistics and other policing topics.

2. Representative for Congressperson Davis presented.

3. Representative for Assemblymember Shirley Weber discussed recent efforts.

4. Luis Natividad and Jimmie Slack discussed recent activities by City Councilmember Myrtle Cole's office.

5. Guy Preuss summarized the most recent Community Planners Conunittee meeting. It was announced that the new Skyline Hills Branch Library would open October 14.

7:28 p.m. Information items I. Cynthia Suero-Gabler discussed the status of the planned Tooma Park Senior Center.

Page 31: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 10

7:35 p.m. Action items

I. Ben Kelso proposed naming the new Skyline Hills Branch Library for fallen San Diego Police Officer Archie Buggs. C. Suero-Gabler moved to approve. C. Ramsey moved that the naming be in the order "Skyline Hills Archie C Buggs Branch Library." 2nd - W. English. Approved 9-1 with F. Von Roenn opposed.

2. W. Glover moved to approve Project No. PTS 498903 AT&T Relocate cellular antenna at 1521 Statton Court. 2nd - G. Preuss; approved 9-0.

3. T. Robinson moved to approve Project No. PTS 426083 Verizon cellular tower at Dusk Drive., 2nd - V. Rivago; approved 9-0.

8:35 p.m. Meeting adjourned.

Minutes submitted by John Mooney.

Page 32: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

AERIAL MAP

COPYRIGHT: GOOGLE MAPS, 20 16

EXISTING

DCI PACIFIC Al E iC WORKS

ARCHITECTURE J ENGINEERING I CONSULTING 32 EXECUTIVE PARK I SUITE 110 I IRVINE I CA 92614

T 949 475. JOOO I 949 475.1001 F

PROPOSED

at&t

PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE SD0371

1521 STATTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 92114

ATTACHMENT 11

PHOTO PROVIDED BY: DEPRATT!, INC.

VIEW SHEET

A 1/3

Page 33: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHMENT 11

AERIAL MAP

PROPOSED

COPYRIGHT: GOOGLE MAPS, 2016

EXISTING

PHOTO PROVIDED BY: DEPRATTl, INC

DCI PACIFIC ' -.. PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE VIEW SHEET ' -'.J .. :-~ SD0371 A l E i C WORKS . - "",)

~ 1521 STATTON COURT B 2/ 3 ARCHITECTURE I ENGINEERING I CONSULTING at&t 32 EXECUTIVE PARK I SUITE 110 I IRVJNE I CA92614 T 949475. 10001949475. 1001 F SAN DIEGO, CA 92114

Page 34: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

AERIAL MAP

COPYRIGHT: GOOGLE MAPS, 20 I 6

EXISTING

DCI PACIFIC A IE IC WORKS

ARCHITECTURE I ENGINEERING I CONSULTING 32 EXECUTIVE PARK I SUITE 110 1IRVINEICA92614

T 949475.10001949475.1001 F

PROPOSED

at&t

PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE SD0371

1521 ST A TTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 92114

ATTACHMENT 11

PHOTO PROVIDED BY: DEPRATTl, INC

VIEW SHEET

c 3/ 3

Page 35: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

ATTACHME NT 12

~

1~~~ at&t ~. ~ Mobility- San Diego

SITE NUMBER: SD0371 SITE NAME: PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE

DRAWING INDEX REV.

TOl TITLE SHEU

A01 sm: Pl.AN. LETTER Of AUTHORIZATION & LESSEE'S cERnFICATE

A

A

A02 PARTIAL ENI.ARCEO Sil£ PWI &: (E) EOUIPl.!ENT LAYOUT Pt.AN A

AOJ AmENNA LAYOUT Pl.AN

A04 ELEVATIONS

AOS ELEVATIONS

001 OETAILS

A

A

A

A

002 AmENNA MOIJHTING DETAILS A

003 ANTENl<A ASSEl.IBUES, RRU, DC SURGE SUPPRESSORS MOUNTlNG ELEVAT!Otl & ADHESIVE NOTES A

CO I STORM WATER REQUIREMENTS APPUCABiUTY CHECKLIST

C02 WPCP {BMP PLAN)

1 1 SH£flS TOTAL

CODE COMPLIANCE

I. 2013 CAllfORNIA AOUINISTRATM: CODE (CAC) 2. 2013 CALIFORNIA BUil.OING CODE (CBC}. llOLUIAES l, ANO 2 (2012 EDITION INlERNAllONAl BUILDING COOf ~nTH :mn CALIFORNIA MIENOl.IENTS) 3. 2013 CALIFORNIA illCTRICAL COO£ (201 1 [OIT!Otl NATIOllAL ELECTRICAL CODE WITH 2013 CALIFORNIA AMENDMENTS) 4. 2013 CALIFORNIA UECHANICAL CODE (CMG)

5. 2013 CALIFORNIA ENERGY COOE

A

A

(2008 EDITION CAL!f{mw. ENERGY COl.L\USSION BUILDING ENERGY EFFICIENCY STANDARDS) 6. 2013 CALIFORNIA FIRE COO£ (CFC) (2012 EOffiON Of llm:RW.TIONAL nRE CODE WITH 201 0 CAllfORNIA A\1£NOMENTS) 7. 201 3 CALIFORNIA GREEN CODE 8. 2013 CAUfORNIA REFERENCES STANDARDS CODE

USID: 13980 FA LOCATION CODE: 10085053

DIRECTIONS

FROM AT&T SAN DIEGO OFFICE

L DEP .. .RT TRl<OE ST TOWARD CAMINO SANTA FE 2. nJRN LEFT ONTO CAMINO SANTA IT 3. TURN RIGHT ONTO MIRAMAR RO 4. TAKE RAMP RIGHT ANO FOLLOW SIGNS FOR 1-805 SOUTH 5. AT EXIT 10, TAKE RAJ.IP RIGHT ANO FOLLOW SIGNS FOR PIAZA 8l VO 6. TURN Lffl ONTO E Pl.A2A Bl..VO 7 _ KEEP STRAIGHT ONTO E 8TH ST 8. ROAO NAME CHANGES TO PARADISE VALLEY RD 9. TURN LEFT OllTO S WOOOl.IAN ST 10. TURN RIGHT ONTO l'ANOWARO ST 11. TURN RIGHT ONTO STATTON CT 12. ARRIVE 1521 STAnON CT, SAN OIEGO. CA 92 114

- '~~ff·: ...... , ~- -igJ !Ver"C d

"""

•'I•·, I

·t.

_..I : ""f t"':

VICINITY MAP

. " ' . . - .r > 2 -.

l ;;, %, ·t ••• ..,.._

• r"'' ~

~ "'~ ··., "=? '> S·

P'.1r1 flj .. \

C I I " )·

.:\•.

gd, e , .. ~_,..,: ~ ...... /).

~.> ' I I :;<

.

"" .

II'{, •

, , 11·:.'r

p , • • l , ,.

_.

·'' ,, Ii'·'

DEVELOPMENT SUMMARY

SCOPE OF WORK:

1/ DEMOLISH AN (E) MONOPOLE 2/ RELOCATE ( 12) (E) ANTENNAS FROM (£) MONOPOLE TO (E) WATER TANK 3/ INSTALL (24) (N) RRU'S ANO (3) (N) (FLAT) DC-6 ANO (3) (N) (FLAT) OC-2,

All MOUNTED AT ANTENNA LE'ltL 4/ INSTALL A PURCELL CABINEI ON THE GROUND ... 1 ABOUT 450" TO BOOST THE DC 5/ (N) CABLE ROUTING FROM {E) EQUIPMENT AREA TO WATER TANK

OOX£0 BELOW IS A UST Of OEVl:LOPMOIT RECU!AT!Otl OE\'IATIONS, AND TM£ REQUIRED P£RlllTS/AFPROVAlS, N/ A IF lffT BLANK:

EXISTING WCFs ON SAME PROPERTY: AT&T AND T-MOBILE

BUILDING CODE INFORMATION: OCCUPANC'I' = U CONSffiUCllON TYPE • V-0

PROPERTY INFORMATION: lfW llfSCBIP!JQ!j·

ASSESSOR PARCEL NUllSER: lf>SE AREA:

OWNER: OWNER: CITY Of SAN OIEGO

592- 321 - 11 EXISTING

ADDRt:S'io 1200 3RD AVE.. MS SIA SUITE 1700 SAN DIEGO. CA 921 01

ZONING INFORMATION:

JURISDICTION: CITY Of SAN OIEGO

EXISllNG PER~dlT: NUP

lATilUDE: 32" 41 ' 35.87' N LONGITUDE: 11 T 02' 46.oo· w

TOP or (() STRUCTURE: 610 FEET (A.ld.S.L) (2012 EDITION IAPMO UNIFORM MECHANICAL CODE WITH 2013 CALIFORNIA AMENDMENTS)

9. APPLICABLE LOCAL CODES BASE or STRUCTURE: 490 FEET (A.IA .SL)

·. ' \'l. ~ i--~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~--.~~-...~~~~~~~~~~--.,..-~~~~-'-~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ..... ~~~~-...~~~~~~~~~~~~ ..... ~~~~~~-4-...~~-...~~~~~~~~-...~~~~~..-..1,.-.....-~~~~~~~~~~--.~-...~~~--l§

:.?--::. at0 -+ ,,,_,..._. J Q(\. ' ~ ; 'J Mot-fit)"· San Ok!go

7337 l!WlE STREET. 3 EASl. ROOM 3684 SAN DIEGO. CA S-212~202

)ePratti irV __J PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE

SD0371

152 1 STATTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 92114

DCI PACIFIC A(EI C WORKS

Al'Cl11TEC11Al£ I ENGINEEJlWG I CONsut.TIHG ll EXECUTT'll:P.NUC: ISUIT£ 1 10

mw« I CA 91614

1-+-~~+-~~~~~~~~~~~~~-+-~~-+-~-...~~-sm:r-...-mu:~~~~~+-~'l!ID~-t«J>l!!~ffi~--l &

~

A 09/ 13/ 16 ISSUfO r OR CO RE'V\EW ANO CO.\tUf.NTS TITLE SHEET T01 NO. t>ATE RE'v\SIOOS

Page 36: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

320" SECTOR 'C'

.-­...-

200" SECTOR'S' ..,.

I I

...- _.\ , ~, ........ -- \ \,;·.J .-- I --~ \

...- ~ I

1.;~ (E) DIRT ROAO "'

\.E) RAW lAN~

I}__ _-.; --#-p_~1-1~1'.

-- ------ 10.) .-- -· . (E) PROPERlY- LlN-E - - - ----- ~

...- I I

I I

\

\ \ I

\ I I

_J

I

/ /

r--- - -1 ,. __

I I f (E) RESIDENTIAL

,- ---' I

I ,L.._ I I

NOTESo

1 / THIS PROJECT PROPOSES NO WORK Yl!THIN lllE PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY.

2/ PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE Of /4NY CONSTRUCTION PERMIT, THE PERMITIEE SHAU INCORPORATE ANY CONSTRUCTION BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES NECESSARY TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER H, ARTICLE 2, DMSJON 1 (GRAOING REGULATIONS) Of THE SAN DIEGO MUNICIPAL CODE, INTO THE CONSTRUCTION PU.NS OR SPECIFICATIONS.

3/ PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE Of AflY CONSTRUCTION PERMIT, THE PERMITIEE SHALL SUBMIT A WATER POLLUTION CONTROL PLAN (WPCP). THE WPCP SHALL BE PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE GUIOEUNES IN APPENDIX G Of THE CITY'S STORM WATER STANDARDS.

4/ THE OWNER/PERMITTEE SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMAGE CAUSED TO CllY Of SAN DIEGO WATER FACILITIES IN THE \/ICINITY OF THE PROJECT SITE, DUE TO THE CONSTRUCTION ACTMflES ASSOClllTEO Wlill THE PROJECT, IN ACCORDANCE WITH MUNICIPAi.. CODE SECTION 142.0607. IN THE EVENT THAT ANY SUCH FACILITY LOSES INTEGRITY THEN, THE DWNER/PERMITIEE SHAU. REPAIR OR RECONSTRUCT ANY Dl\MACED PUBLIC WATER FACllllY IN A MANNER SATISFACTORY TO THE OIRECTO!l OF PUBLIC UTILITIES ANO THE CITY ENGINEER.

5/ THE PROJECT PROPOSES TO EX?ORl JJ CUBIC YARDS OF l.IATERIAL FROM THE PROJECT SITE. All EXCAVATED MATERIAi. LISTED TO BE EXPORTED, SHALL BE EXPORTED TO A LEGAL DISPOSAL SITE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR PUBLIC WORKS CONSlRUCllDN (THE "GREEN BOOK"), 2015 EDITION AND REGIONAL SUPPLEMENT AIJENOMENTS ADOPTED BY REGIONAL STANDARD COMMITTEE.

6/ ANY PARTY ON WHOM FEES, DEDICATIONS, RESERVATIONS, OR OTHER EXACTIONS HAVE BEEN IMPOSED AS CONDmONS Of APPROVAt Of' THIS DEVELOPMENT PERMIT, MAY PROTEST THE IMPOSlllON WITHIN 90 DAYS OF THE Af'PROVAL Of THIS DEVELOPMENT PERMIT BY FlWNG A WRITTEN PROTEST WITH THE CITY CLERK PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE 66020.

TOTAt~33 CUYO.

ATTACHMENT 12

UT!Ol(XA:.JtMOllnSAOO!.

!\0017 1 11.:.TIC,.:.t O H I.:.. l~~l>~I;

.-n't.. t...,.a<u ... 1 1'JUb<1n .:._..~•;-..N'l;OU'>tn~aC4•JIOI

»P!..O-IOl'•fOfllO'tlt..U•U\illl.".Df'°'*G Pf"~aT

-. C'-~li \ t. f'/Lr.fi'.J ... ..tt" .. -:"·"°°" .... :..t>·"ol'.,..,,tJ .,,. \•,,0-~ q,._. .. ~l>ol' .CM d..•Kf~.,.ea.•~· do '-c"~ • .>(- ' :...~.>':;i!r 1..- . .. ( ..... fc11> .a .... _ ., __ .... tt...·. 1<! .... 1 :.0 .l.l!l l \fol:.<.!"J ....... ,tct,hc p..--•.:A• ....... ,,..,....,._,, ... 'l """.tnc:wla\Cprnn.1~-:.a~._.CH._.,to..---t~l&T '•~.., ~~-~~"'°""''tt•,,.. tr't'5Nfl1'- uft o'"4!C1'U ,_~.,, ,~ ... ic ..--u .-11c.au...._.,,._..""""""' b rutv 1 .. ~t.vl( tt.1•ttw1 ""7~or..,.•~:W•..,. __ ,.. q0.• , it q,.a;;r·.....Ju~ 'o ocf. to•=>•rd

t~u~ien:i~O<"i.a ..-.if\u[IQOI""".=~"''''" td..ITft 1;r.qtt> "~""~ et a..,:•~

~-

f!-. -

LETTER OF AUTHORIZATI ON

1 ....... ,.,t.•C:nutkuC' 5'2n.J.m l Wtn:b• Frli1y ~t

f..'f l\ .... 1liiol't11.:~1b!\lf'\

I J ,.,.. rb..• U!\(('1'1~ '1" 1 .... -..l« hh'>t 1h;.• p n pcnpk·-1:nf'C<.I a~

1~z1 Slat1>1nCou1. Snt1 i:lcro,~Oe:Ac_,9"-21'-'1~• - - -----1 ,\Ji.h>.-:-...llfl~~~,1rt1 .. o

11uikt..t.vaJ th.JJ tnJt:toubn1.'- w11h1~ ~' ~ Maui:ipai f '~ I.mi.I 0..'\>.~"1\1 M::.N.Qi: - Si..wni Wattt !iunob.u:k. thk r.n-;....,"11• ~Ill."\! h> -UmtU1 l\.ilh1ta11t"' lm11 lhC' rm.._,, Acr.1- »lU u-..'OIJ'O'al\: -Sitt: lk\t;"- mi.I ""Suma­C..niMt- nr..n .....

l/W,•<'Mtfyulht- A.~-1 0f JnJo· t.nw.k:t,.•. ~;iin:.11i..~.r<lbytbrpt<'P-.;..t

b n..l bl.· .ut"a.fol"""..:

Ol~lf'" D:-1&nJ1ng S11h11:in."' Oil.'fl.Qc.t.1.e tb:t.!n:.'fl.\"111M"!' fblii::hb

M2inbh~1."Clop:t1en1nrr-...;T .. ~"1icoc Mirtimiocin1()n''t0t~fnotf'llnlhy ~lirtf"';dlr."a~.piu.-.I Jri\C'.\.:l)"\ll. ilhjXmll.°lltk•ucfoo.~.

Curt'<f\ca:ztirt:JI~ 11..,..n;i1.,..J<h>nag..· .. r•un ....... ,,.._..ir., 1ic>N, .... k,,.,"''-"~uJ ~ ....... ttTI•• l>t:ltn rmflU(K. u~lllAll)'\.. (131io.·,.. .m:.I t.lri\"•'""-}"' intn ~JXf'lll bno~.,t jlrio.Jt toJi....-1~~ h> lt~ ('tlhh..-.Jni~ ')"'(S' fn..,C'f'.C<'\i•l ini:nat1•·ctr('Oa11J "1.1\ll"" Pt\lft'l.1 Jll•lilf\!>lr\lrn1-r1Non

1\1 Mll1<1tull)'l'11.C''l\iU; \linimiA:th..- u....: ·~~ .. ,..ii.k-. I I~ 1.•ffio1;nt rm~;i.tM1 ')'11.-rtr- ;iitd l..nil>1..~"-' "'"''t" 111>.uqior,.m;: 1a11.i .J\l r.1 ttl" o,!,•\1~-..--.. ~nd 11 ...... ...... b.,.-..-,,

l/"<1 "ill Ul.ll1nam 1hc- ;1h.~\\' •1.m.~J )\'!ll"1n.'fll U~P• f1>r 1h.• •lt1ntt.•1 uf1 ht

k-.l>t

l.cN:c ~inf" 111'\'.~'! IJ•llMIUll!o."I

I M _!l!; 15-L-l>.1 pWt1n."t

2

Page 37: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

\ \

\ \

\ \

\ \

200' SECTOR ·a·

(E) LOCATION FOR SUPPl Y IL DISCHARGE PIPES

\ \.£) l'IAT£R TANK-'

f Ill Ill ill /II Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill /II Ill

PROTECT IN PLACE -----.

3111 ~Il l

<. Ill ;w ~Ill

PARTI AL ENLARGED SITE PLAN

at&t _,,_San Diego

7331 TRADE STREET, 3 EAST, ROOM 3684 SAN OlEGO, CA.92121-420'2

Ill Ill If

Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill Ill

)ePratti )

/

so­SECTOR 'A'

SEE ANTENNA LAYOUT Pl.AN FOR MORE INFO

@

/ / --- (E) ACCESS GATE . /

( /~· . (N) CABLE CONDUIT TRENCH FROM Y ' (E) EQUIPMENT SHELTER / ifl TO {E) CABLE TRAY

/ 111 . · !~~· ~ ~ ~ (E) ACCESS GATE

II V. / ~I · ~ ~ RELOCATE (E) ANTENNA ASSEMBLIES i" -11· MOUNTEO ON (E) MONOPOLE TO / / (E) WATER TANK AND DEMOLISH ,x, .,.. (E) MONOPOLE (li:l .1. ~ \

1111e''. f •

/

(E) AT&T SHELTER@ TO REMAIN (NO CHANGES) --

,.X..-"'~;,,e--, / . / (E) CHAIN LINK FENCE

~~ \ t '- 4 ""'-"·

~ (E) ACCESS GATE

(E) ACCESS DIRT ROAD

\

\ (E)

HVAC

(E) HVAC

I (E)

(E) 24\IOC CABINET . MCPR

(E) CIENA B;.__/X

(E) GPS ANTENNA (E) RRUS- 12 TYP. or 2 TYP. or 3

1 SCALE: 11111 I (E) EQUIPMENT LAYOUT 0 • • 8" 16' PLAN

PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE SD0371

DCI PACIFIC A I EIC WORKS

ATTACHMENT 12

±26'-e·

-(E) CABLE ENTRY PORT

I (E) ROOf LINE

(E) FlF r (E) ARGUS RACKS \ n CABINET

Ru ~(E) 2.}" FIF RACK

--- / ~(E) FIF RACK

[(El-::] / ~~ (E) t==J CABINET

/

-- (E) FIRE ExTINGUISKER

(E) ACCESS DOOR J

(E) CONCRETE STOOD _/

w CJ GJ D

r (E) GENERATOR INTERFACE

- --· (E) TRANSFER

SllEUTnU

S¥~TCH

0

~--- (E) POWER BOX

SCALE:

311"91\0" 0 ,. 2' J'

StElJ' NIJY3£R

2

PARTIAL ENLARGED SITE

~ ~ ~ ~

~ g

1521 STATTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 9211 4

A 09/13/ 16 ISSU(O FOR CO Rlv.EW AND COMMENTS HH SOK A02 PLAN &: (E) EQUIPMENT s OKO :;

AR'CHITfCTURE I f:HGINEEIUNG I CONWlllNG ll EXECUTIVE PNl'IC I SUIT E 110

UMNf I CA 92614 SCALE >S SHOWll

6Y

DRAWN

COil< APP'O LAYOUT PLAN r

~ ~

Page 38: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

---- ----

\

) -----

-----~· ·:.:;: '"·

(N) PURCELL CABINET ,;:· • ' 'I ON THE GROUND l, ,.,:. • . -~'.

'-'l;r TO BOOST THE DC • ... ".~ • ). . ...... ( "'\ . ~ ·""."-i-'

ATTACHMENT 12

·,-~_.. '~<-

· ';'~.:"1..;~ (E) T-MOBILE CJ.RRIER l.EASE

/ AR£A (NOT PART OF PROJECT)

.,oCJ ~

· ~~co "' .~~ '· ;..,<i , ___ - -;-.,.;-__:::-.,;;~, · _,..,..,--- {E) CHAIN UNK FENCE

,.. " .. (E) CHAIN LINK FENCE~ \:?-~:~:f

~ '~·~-==------ , __ / ·-'!:!· ,.,pt· !,. '· -~ \ ? - · ... ,· ,.;:.#I ... •i

# ' l,{.;' ~ 'it , ' -~~

X··.,·\. ,· (E) CONCRETE CURB

ANTENNA LAYOUT PLAN

J2lr SECTOR ·c· ll" .: .~"'' ;f w ~=E/NT (E) LADDER \

:j' ' ~ \ // · ~ (/ (E) T-MOBIL( ', . {N) CABLE CONDUIT TRENCH FROM r ,I ANTENNAS {N) CABLE TRAY TO (E) WAl'ER ' °\, TANK. APPROX. L=JS' ----~r:._ ______ / \ ,~ _ __ .._.. _ _ _ ' ~ \ '·~~·; .:i \

~ ~~' r -"-it----------. ~ {N) CABLE CONDUIT TRENCH FROM ' ~ (N) CABLE TRAY TO (E) WATER TANK.

;

~

~,,,~,-· "--- (N) (4

) AT&:T ANTENNAS. ~ APPROX. L-35'

(B) RRU'S & (1) DC-6 \ ' (I) OC-2. AU MOUWEO \ ON (E) WATER TANK -+

(N) (4) AT&T ANTENNAS.

(8) RRU'S & (1) DC-6 ( . -i1

- - - - - - - \ SEC~ 'A' ( I) OC-2. ALI. MOUNTED I ON (E) WATER TANK ~ \ ~ I

~ (E) CONCRETE / CURB I

\ co •-"°"" /'I \ ANTENNAS~

L.Q .. m-; ' "t I ~:: ='~- - '"'cc-=••}

~-'''~'-' r \\· ~ / I {N) (4) AT&T ANTENNAS, -... (B) RRU'S &: (1) OC-6

\\ ~/ ' (1) OC- 2. All MOUNTED \\ -.. . ON (E) WAlER TANK

(N) CABLE CONDUIT TRENCH rROIA '\, / 1'j"' (N) CABLE TRAY TO {E) WATER " TANK. APPROX. L~Js·-------------4~------ / 1 '

(E) CHAIN LINK FENCE__/ ..

'\ ~~/ \. ,/ 1 ~

1

/ I '~. I ~~.1 ~.~ 1 / 1

-,, / l / '~..1

200' SECTOR .B'

{E) EQUIPMENT

BY OTHERS l

111 I I/ (N) CABLE TRAY ~ ~ I II Ill J

3J .11_..-..--- (E) LOCATION FOR SUPPLY /,f / n & DISCHARGE PIPES ,r,'Y ,!ti I I PROTECT IN PLACE ef'~r

~Ill /

~:: rh'"' I II I ~ ! // I (E) ACCESS I I i //! CATE~

1 I ~ '

r

/// ~ :~ . . Ill 1J:~ Ill 1 ~ 1 ~ . .. _;;, \

!- '. · . $,• 111 111 1> • ·i

111 I I ',>.;;' ~).,~.> ·

·~- (E) CHAIN LINK FENCE

'------- INSTALL (N) CABLE TRAY SUPPORT PIPE DR UTILIZE (E). TYP.

(N) CABLE CONDUIT TRENCH FROM (E) EQUIPMENT SHELTER TO {N) CABLE TRAY. APPROX. L=65'

Page 39: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

D O DO

DODO 0 D

WEST ELEVATION

P£LOCATE ( 12) (E) ANTOINAS MOUrllEO IJN (E) ll0NoPOL£ TO (E) l'IAlER !A.'IK ANO 0£1.HlUSH (E) UONOP<JLE ------

1.0. (£) vmrn TAHK

- - (4) (N) AT&T ANTENNAS IJOU.'lfED ON

II (E) WATER TPJllK, TYP.

T.O. (N) AT&T ANTENNAS

~ ~ ~ ~ _____ Qi_)_~&!__Afi_~-~_£E_~~------- -'j<

(N) CABLE fP.AY CO'll:R IO 0 0 0 Q. CONCEAL ALL CASLE. iYP.

....

"'-·

(8) (N) RRU'5, TYP.

(1) (N) n.Ai OC-6 & (1) (N) OC-2. TYP

'--- (H) CABLE RISER, TYP. PAINIEO TO l.!ATCH (£) WATER TANK

·--....____ (E) T- MOSILE ANTENNAS

-.....__ (£) CABLE RISER

, I Cf ; - I ~ !

(E) FINISHED GRAD£

0 I

i:n ....

0 I

~

~ (E) CHAIN UNK fEllC( (£) AT & T SHELTER TO R[ WJN

)ePratti )

(NO CHANGES) ____ __o

PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE SD0371

1521 STATTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 92 11 4

I

ATTACHMENT 12

RELOCA!f (12) (~) N:TE!l14AS MOIJHTEO ON (E) IJONOPOt[ TO (E) WATER TANK AllO DEIJCLISH (£) !JONOPOLE -----------~

' 0 I

~ +;

'o I

~

(E) WATER I.AN'.~ ----------~

\ T.O. (E) >YATER i#IK

( 4) (N) AT&T NfiEN<<AS l!O\INTED ON (E) WATER TANK. TYP. ---- --+-..

T.0. (N) Af& l Nll[NliAS

-'i<---<!Q. .~!.!.1!1.i.N!l.2.~ -~!1~-- - -----1 (N) CABli TRAY CO\IER TO ! CONCEAL AU CABLE. TYP. ------+---

_/) 00 0 / ..-(]00 0

(8) (N) RRV'S. IYP . ..0 ..{]

(1) (N) f1.Al OC-6 .!: (1} (N) OC-2. flP.

/~--....___ _ _,

/

'o I

(N) CABlf RIS!:R, TYP. PAINTED TO MATCH (E) W~T[R lANK - --

~

_ _ - --'i< (E) Fltl!SHED GRADE

(£) CHAIN LINK fENCE

I 2 a- 12' SOUTH ELEVATION

DCI PACIFIC AIEIC WORKS

(E) Al & l SHELT[R TO R(l.lAJN (NO CHANGES)

/ /

/'

HH SOK ()1(0 ELEVATIONS Alli"IMT(CTlJRC I fNLIN[[1'1N<:o I CONSUi nHG

.l7 VC£CUTIV! PMI( I swn 110 OATE RE'l1SIONS BY CHIC APP'O

I I 1 4' I ' 1T

A04 UfV\11.'E ICA 9lt. t<I

'-----~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~-'----~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~--'-~~~~~----~~~~~~~~-'-~~--~~-Ls_C"1.E~~~~s-HO_n_"~~Lo_ES1C1~•-ED~~~~~-'-o-M_w•_•~~~--''--~~~~~~~~~~-'-~~~~~-'~

Page 40: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

b ' 0

\_ (E) AT&T SHELTER I() R£1AAIN (NO CHANGES)

EAST ELEVATION

;..._.._. ....... :/,.. __ ., at&:t .'(,- •:,

\ , Moblity - Son Oieqo

7337 l RAOE STREET, J W T, ROOM 3684 SAH DIEGO. CA92121...t202

I

RElCCAT[ (I 2) (E) AltTOlllAS UQ\JlliED Olt {E) l!ONOPOL£ TO (E) WA![R TANK ANfl !JE'lOUSH (E) UCNOPOLE

(E) WATER TANK----------~

l .O. (E) VIAlIR IANK

(4) {N) Al &! ~fflEllNAS MO\INTEO Otl (Ej WATER TANK. lYP.

T.Q. (NJ AT&T MITENNAS

·- ·- ·- - -5':1.~!~~~ ~.~~TI!' ______ . (N) CA!ll[ TRAY CO'lfR TQ CONCE.'L ."1.1. Cl&£. rt?.

. ...{] 0 0 0 ~~ __ --a 0 0 0

(8) (N) RRIJ'S, TYP.-------1· _..-0 ___ .- - 0

~--;:::::::::::.-----.__~~~ (1) (N) FLAT OC- 6 & (1) {N) OC- 2. TIP.

(N) CABLE RIS£R, T'iP. PAJNTEO TO MATCH (E) WAITR TANK ---+--

[ flNISH[O GRADE

(£) CHAIN LINK FENCE

)ePratti ) PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE

SD0371

1521 STATTON COURT SAN DI EGO, CA 92 11 4

ATTACH MENT 12

I I

i" ... - :· " i tihiOJt:ti

(EJ T-IJOBll( ANTENNAS. r!P - ~1n i l

~!Iii: (E) CAIU RISER, TYP. ---·~m

f"l\ ~;H" ·

LJ.i~ill :·

I 'a mi

~! ii Mil:

R[lCCAl( (12) (E) MTEllllAS UOUNlEC ()N ([) MONOPO!£ TO (E) WATER TANK AND ()[llOUSH (E) llONO?Oll

~------- (E) \\'ATER lAllK

I

/

T.Q. (E) l'l;.JtR TANK

r--!---- (4) (N) AT&l ANTENNAS MOUNTED ON (E) WATER TANK, TYP.

T.0. N AT&T ANTENNAS

~ ~ ~ ~- · _ __, ___ (N) CABLE TRAY COVER fO

0 0 0 °'-. CONCEAL ALL CABLE, m>.

0 DD[]...._'::::, . O~ ·-,., ~ --(8) (N) RRU S, JYP

(! ) (N) fl.Al OC- 6 & (I) (N) DC- 2. !YP.

--- (ti} CASlE RISER. TYP. PAINTED TO MATCH (E) WATER JANK

\ ,,

----'-- +-----...U...-'---'-----------_:.---'--->:--'----(E) F!NISHED GRADE

\

,.. a· 12' 2

(EJ Al&! SHELTER T() RE!JAIN (NO CHANGES)

NORTH ELEVATION

DCI PACIFIC A I EIC WORKS

'---- (E) CHAN LINK rENCE

SHffi nn!

0 I

·.o ....

,., 09/IJ/ 16 !SSVEO roR co Rt:.~EW .A.NO COMUENTS HH SOK DKO ELEVATIONS ARCIITTE LIUfn 1 l NCi lNUltlN<i l <OHSutH.o..c;

31 EXECUTIVE PARK I SUITE 110 IRVV..iE I CA92ti•

SCAl.£ AS SHOWN

SY CttK p·o

0£SIG14EO ORAWN

0 I

~

.i1· a· u· 1

A05

Page 41: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

D ~ ' ,~OC-2 SURGE SUPPRESSOR

DC SURGE SUPPRESSOR (OC- 2)

,,

.._ ____ =JI ~ OC SURGE PROTECTOR, SEE TA!!tE BELOW FOR ADO'!. •WO.

EQUIPMENT SPECIFICATIONS

Tl'PE I MODEL NO. I HEIGHT I ll'IOTH I OEPlH I \\'EIGHT

0C SURGE PROTECTOR! OC6-48-60-0-IE I 17.23" I t6.2B" I 6.33" I 35 LBS

l>tOTE: l. ANCHORS Sfl.\U. HAVE HOT-DIPPED GALVA'llZEO FINISH 2. GROUND All EQl!IPMUH TO (E) GROUND BAR WITH #2 A\'iG

DC SURGE SUPPRESSOR (DC-6)

!!QKS;

~---RGS RISER CONDUIT (EXCl:PT AT llCTER BASE)

------Tl!RE}OCO STEEL COUPLING OR INSUlJ,TEO BUSlllNC (NOTE 1)

.---THREADED PIAS!IC TO STE[L A..IW'TER If NECESSARY

, - PVC CONOUll SIZE AS SHO',VN ON PLAN

1. RISER CONDUIT SIW.L BE RIGID STEEL OR INTERMIOIATE Mt.IA!. CONDUll (WHERE COUPth~GS ARE N£CES5"RY THEY SHALl 8[ IHRU!J£D STEEl). IF RlS[R CONDUIT IS NOT TO BE EXTENDED, IT SHALL BE TERIJl,•IAT£0 WITH A IHRfAD[O INSVlAlED BUSHING. RIS[R SH.AU HA'il: A IJINl!IUl.I J6" RADIUS SWEEP. 2. MIN!!!UM 2-1 /2" RlGIO STEEL OR INlERIJEOIAJE !IE!Al CONDUIT RISER. J. METAL CONOUITS INSTAf.lEO UNOERGROO!IO SHi'il BE \IRAPPEQ WITH A Ul APPRO\£D P'.'C TM'( MID IAUST O\/ERIJ\P A U!NIMIJM or 1/2 TltE TAPE WIDTH, TO AT LEAST 6" ABOV£ mtlSHl:O GRADL

CONDUIT RISER

7

8

~: .. t t ! r.;::::.. ;:: a &:

' ·" Moblity~Saneteg;>

7337TRADE StREE'T, J EAST, ROOM 3684 SAN DIEGO. CA92 12t....t202

)ePratti )

\\1DTH

RRU JYPE I HEIGHl I WIOltt OEPfH I VIEIGHl

RRUS-11 I 19.7' I 17.0" 1.r I 50LBS

RRUS-32 I 27.2" I 12.1· 1.0· I 60LBS

NOTE: GC TO REFER TO RFDS fOR EXACT RRU 1 PE

REMOTE RADIO UNIT

' MIN. BENO RADIUS

SIZE 4• OR 6"

' CONOUll I 1/2" 10·

7/8" TB" 1-114· 22·

n=-s%-~-

5 (E) CABLE TRAY PHOTOS

I I

WATER TANK

L3XJX1 / 4 TAB ~

SEE AD HE SI VE

":-;-\ · @~ \.---£.._ l \ TYP. ,r

-~ ) . ~--_J CABLE TRAY. -

l3XJX I / • TAB ---,,

,-FORM B"X&"Xl /4" PLATE TO MATCH (E) TANK RADIUS

~TYP

'r- Al026 90 DEG.

3

(EJ ~HEET IJETA CASI f f RA'' ---

(E) COAX CABLE -­

'

(E) C~BLE TRAY :· SUPPORT PIPE. TYP -------. :, :::

-§ e ... =--.... ..... ,,. ::::: :::: =

..... = = = ; = -

ATTACHMENT 12

(NJ S>-+ECT \!£T>'1 CA3LE TRAY

,--- \~) FIBER

(N) CABLE TRAY SUPPORT PIPE 2

CABLE TRAY SCHECLILE I Cf '8· 1i• CAIRES

t-• ,,. .•. e-10 ,.. , .. Hi -2~ 2•· ,..

·1· 21· .•. ,.. , .. 35• ,.. .•.

" ~1

WIDTH (SEE CABLE TRAY SCHEDULE)

- -COMPACTED BACK!"lll WITH SAl lSFAClORY \ ·1·: j /",,.,- CABLE TRAY 9" • ."°1i . RUNGS, 4• LOADING

2" MIN, (HOR1'!:Rl )

NOTES:

NATIVE OR IMPORTED SOIL

...--UNDISTURBED SOIL

--coMPACTED SAND BED (SEE NOTE 2}

- ~~FIBER&: DC CABLES IN (4) 6° PVC CONDUITS SCHED. 40 OR PER MFR. RECOM.

1. PROVIOC PROPER BENDING RADIUS FOR CONDUITS AS REQ'O BY i HE CABLE MFR. (SEE TABLE ~BOVE)

2. LEAN CONC. W / RED TIN TED TOP MAY BE USED IN PLACE OF COMPAClED SANO.

FIBER & FC CABLE TRENCH

PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE SD0371

T521 STATTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 921 14

\ MOUNT TRAY 10 UNISTRUT VllTH 1/2" - 13 X 1 1/2" LONG C~LV~NIZED BOLiS, SPRING NUTS PIOIO & WASHERS----~

- CABLE VERTICAL TRAY.

EB

6 CABLE TRAY TO WATER TANK

DCI PACIFIC AIEJC WORKS

AR(Htlt.CltJtll I £NGIN(£RWG I CON~Ul..T1NG l2 VfECUTCV'E P'AltK I SUlTE t 10

unnNE I CA'lUH

4 CABLE VERTICAL TRAY

A 09/ll/ 16 1ssurn fOR co REVlE.W AllD CO~!.l[NTS tl"i BOK OKD

DATE RE'ASIONS BY CllK /IP?'

,.S SHOWN 0£SICNEO DRAWN

.Y DEPTH. SUPPORT , CABLES WITH TIE

stm mu:

DETAILS

WRAPS EVERY 4 FT.

CABLE TRAY W/ 18 GA GALV HOLD DOWN CLAMP COVER, PAINTED TO MATCH (E) WATER TANK

001

1

Page 42: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

FORM s- x6 .. Xl/4- ~36 STEEL PLA- [ TO MA-Ch \[) T.A'IK RAGUS

\

0. 1 I

,.,. I I

~- (E) T•NK SHELL

ANTENNA MOUNTING DETAIL

at&t )ePratti

......... Q .......

' '·· - SEE ADHESIVE NO-ES~

~

I NO WELDING ALLOWED ON RESERVOIR I

1/4" lhK. PLAfl -, a··

r-, I !

fT '! - rORM a'"xcx· ; · · PL~rc c•i '!' , TO MA CH (E\, TANK RACIUS ; ' -'- . \, __ L"-'ty:o

; 1: i "'1;4V \1 ; j, I

; '\ \ ANTEhl'A MAST,--· '\ \ ADc\JST •S REQUIRED 1 ~ * i O"X4"X ~ / 8"

N T. S.

\ ThK. PLATE

L 5/8'"0 A307 30LT, TY"'.

1. CONTR ACTOR TO '/[R!FY CLEA'lANCE ANO CONO· TIUNS OF WATER TANK AT LOCATION OF WORK AND RE VIEW DETAILS FOR AN Y REQUIRED .ADJUSTMEN rs.

2. CO'ITRACTOR TO 0 POV![iE COMPLETE SHOO ORAW!NGS '"OR RE'llLW P'llUR ro FABR'CATIOt<.

.5 ~UN TRACTOR fl .. 'H.nFr ENGINEER or Al\, D:SCREPANCIE'.O WITH THE NEW LP.YOUT PRIOR TO PROCEEOl'lG.

4. •\LL PIPES. SRACK ETS A'lD MISC. H,\RDWARE: TO BE GAL '/ANI ZED UNLESS NOTED OTHER'1\ISE.

5 'rlE~NAS, A TTAC"i\lE'lTS MID CONllEC'lONS SH~U. BE DA:NTED .ANO TEXTURE TQ MATCH EXISTING VIA TER TMH

6. CO'l TRACTOR iO PROv10E INSTALL~TION PROCEDURE/ 1,i[THOO OF PROCEOJRE (MOP) PRIOR TO llJSTALLATION

PAINTING NOTES:.

1. \iOliNTll'.G PLATE SHALL BE SHOP PAINTEJ \\ITH A COcOR MATCHING THE EXISTING VIA TER TANK AND "E~ AT&T PROJECT TECHNICf.c SPEC!FICl'T!ON FOR CON3TRUCTION STANDARDS.

2 ~FTER INSTALLATION OF ~·ouN TING PL.•TES ON Tr<E WATER TANK TOUCH-UP/REP AI NT THE TANK SURrACE PEi< WATER TOW::R OWNER'S PAINT SPECIFICftTIONS -\LTrnNATIV(L Y, WITH OWNERS -\PPROVAL.

SD0371 AIEIC WORKS ~~l )

PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE DCI PACIFIC ~ b ~.+0-9/ 1-l/1~6 ~-~-rn -roR-CO-.~-~-· --C-O•"-(m-s ~-t-,H r~;K -:--:-1~

ATTACHMENT 12

Sf!E(J mt.£

ANTENNA MOUNTING DETAIL 002

Page 43: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

FORM Storm Water Requirements 05_560

Applicability Checklist ~~""'" Vn.pu;\Wlrv~ ....

1521 S:TATI"ON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 9.2114.

S&C110N'. 1- Constn1cUoa Storm Water BllP RequirHDe:nb--:: All.._,k'IW'•i.-.n.~lit-itn: ~ll'Pdt.,.i.m,...H'Qlm-'nitlk:"BMP"u•.:t<'Mrrlifir .. wid•tit<> P'!'rti>:rlllmirri •b.ntlnrd.<. : ii. •h• Stvlll WiU!!!J'_St-mtd!inlt-\f-nu•J Sta"" •1WA ~ Nhtiart.'2-r •""t"ir"'ll lo t>bt. •in ~oir"""'- •1t .... r 1a... Sl:-:>1- I {'~rlktiort. f''!_~<'\I ~~ 'CGi.!', •~tlt~~&endh, •h.t Sbt!' \Vat.n Rt-rttsCor.rrol Bo;u.I j For all proje<"l complat& PART A: Jr ~· is required to submit (l S\\'PPP Ot' WPCP. con· I llnue I& PART R.

PART A: De•~rmin& ConstrlK'tion Pbat.e. StOIW W11tff' Re11uinuaen\f.

i 1S11w ~· M.~-re.cam;n.~-;-~ tt~1tw..&. aeaiiar~"H>Es. r•eiout tor Sl&riA Wa1o.>r Di'l<~~~:b!oOCiat'd w1U1 t"o11,,lr.ttrtiu11 Al'fi-.:il~ nl:oo.~n.M tb,1-!'Jt,-it. ConMrnctM:JJt (if'lll!'r.\I ro1rrmt (C(;pv> tTypi¥1t lly pMj-'<l.<t • itb ~ tfucutbaa\~ glcM"r ~9f~u.ai Je. l ocr~.)

..J Y~SWP11r•N4t11ked.AiJi.f\DeldiottiS2.-t JI K.,-11-at"ll.W'tt-tk>.

!! 0- llw> froi-1 ~~ ra-t ... .:1.ciu nr J-1Si~ .3od ... ·d.v,__ -r • .iJa&- boil IWC luu1 t,,J t...d .. m1~ imJ1u,t:. Jr:11l> b~, f'--'lr11.'l".1olton- ,...3ay otM1 IM1rrity •hi~• •~•tii. iA....,awi d1~~ "n!lu1111.ilw:l wit!r. lill111n• wnl<l'r "'1c:-.1Y?

1 11} 'h•. \Vf'C:P t ff(..U-td. .H.tt: 3-1 Q .S:o;_ M>xt "tlH'AiWO. 1

3 f).-tb"f~P':~"**l.Wlllfll.i .. -1U~llltM11tot'¥i-11Jb""'tln•l\,>ft\o<f ... byd rtt>1)1.:e>tf-tWil1.of '.)l'tg'IO()ll pw:~ ol t}le EM.Wii''" !l'tojt..::b n-u•h :., p.if'.>lihR1ilQy tt>pbrtUlil.'af•

a 16'fl. Wf\"'P ..... lliffd:.,.t iop... a NQ JWU ~1ton. •I Dowtb!l' Jroj..>ct oa~~)..-J.i.111otfvl<lw~tm:~i•i~fut~W~ ----

• fJ.K:trwu l l'.-,n.iu, fu.- 1\larn1 l'....rin11. fl!'\' Srakl~ Prnnsl l'l1t11tbt11' P,•ru1 1t, !-!1i;11 f+1uiu '1 ... t1.11uo·nl f'.-f I un i .~!"' 1\.-rnUt

• fr1th,1tfe .. ! R11(ht ofWa;, P..r111d" };;11 , vlu,.n .. t, m.-hd•· "fll_v U\F'' r 11,,. ~>11/;Wl"'S 'tr11vt lw"' 1t:1h·r..,·n1"' ........ r h1 .. r1l a1: u-hhty•Wl'YH'V

• ~: 1r~U!:i~ ~~:~,1~;:·~;, ~=~:~~a&1~ ~~: .. 1:;.~.!~~:',~;1~~u:..~~r1;.1'ti::~ri!~~~!'::!~ ::a ~~l~t~~ phr•'rtl""'· tnti n·lillnir.~ \lf'alt •11··tU1M'l1•1•t1'-\.

u

0 ~~~~.~~~t;:;;1tl~~k~~:,1 .. w ~\I' l'c\11 1· u

~ VfN~~~ftki~lqtgtti~~ 1P~crtt~•·'fl ~-~:~::~·tr~ ~1~ia~" t~-ti of j(rottnd d~h1rfi. llW"I' .\' D )vs..,. ~ 1~11 1\ • ~t .. r .. \·ah<lfl t.h ~"ii'. .. cn-.,. r thP •'QIK~ ~lare.t..n \{tu.1rWPl'Pto<t,.\. be n-q111Mt int1"-;,td t:o.mtin1ut tv t'.\Jt'r U.

~~iir'r td~~ ~~:;;~~I ~!:i"'~~!::e!i:.=t ~~·;:~~i~:i: ~t!~'i:~~~'-! ~l io •II ~

Prr:-!ltl!O'lra..~t¥"'Vl""o .. -tisr.-lllwtt~.go1.:d11"ll'~M.:.i

-~~~~!!__~~~~-- ~~,~~~· CJ.Y'AJ{lrl•tt!I}

PART ft Determine- Cons1ructioo Sil~ Priorit Th~prioritu1ttioomtatbecowpt('aNf:..tthlrl tblJbno. ltt<lti.'d'>D WJ pllu. Mlill:uhll~ in t !k- ~"-"'PPl"«W'l'CP Tb~nty f-~~"' lh" t 'i'lu te 111l;w.t Uw peklfity ilfpt"OJMb!lhfh bt.tt.ir.and 1till't~'oJD.!>lfUChot1 t'~hudieta P'oj· ~..,. 4"i,ru•d M• in!lfl'Mf~ fr"'!l'"'l>('J"'-1 on irtrw ,.,~1 Ln•11 · tuirb 1hr?n1 lll "1nioo1 <j lthlhy~ '11w- Cit1 h.u lollgu.N '~ lo.:nl dd\uiti-lo. o(•t.!at. lil.N:tt to-.uotr qu.ahl#~ to. tlw n•k d.ttcl'm.u:aruioo. npv'9(\C h ol t ht- Sl."1•

11mtmo•tw.n r,.,.D<-rftl P•-rlllil (COP) Tlt< o:;p d.-t....-rulww.s n3i:. lr.'rtt ln.<lof'd - f'Hlj.;d l' t"-~ i6( &o•,hment Mk ac.d rwd\PU¥ timt¥.r ri..t. Adilitiatml ia,.,.,c.t~ b n.'<tUll.n.J ~f ptuj.:-.. t..,• itli1ia 1b.-Ar..t1~crt-ipttktl Ri<>t•Jt:i••.ul ~iii· m.D.ru (:\8S.'1hraW~ NOT[~ Tli1t i;:nMr.t~ prii.:.my .b.!t.. NOT da.note i:~">Jtnu: t i!J.a. UMP h.'qltiR~w:ell' rlut :ttPly W) projttb : r3tto:r. i1 '"'c-ruU-... the- fft'llU"..:ycr~tiou 1b1 Yill bo! (ow.liter.ti bf <itr llCaft'

Con,p1ete P.ART Band Ct\ntinued to Section i"

I . :J A.~RS :). PlOJK•~lot~\led m t hc-A.":ltlS wn.tff'S~otd.

!. .J llijth Priority

• Proj.!rl!' I ~ '*ff mcm,.i.....:u.is....& la~ft»<k ~,-,.12ot Rnk tM.·.,1 ~p.-r1h" (\m ... "'rtn" l1un <k&rml l\..m11111od ~l krnt\'J ~1111Mo ,\S-ll.'i ••t .. n.bMI

b. ~~~ 1".i.:!.~,·~~~ t~:t.::tz.J&~':,~rJ.:f LUP"frp.I 3 p.•r 1\u• ( '.uumt<'lt()Q

.J "10\'divtllll Prlvril)

ts Prujl'<i.'4. I °'"'re u r IHIWt: bu\ n~ Mtl'.ti·d tom1A.'iUSw bt&h pr-.inl)' <l.~1'0UhNi

b Projctt~ dctcrmirwtl to bi;- ifult ~11 {If Ll'f' 1')-..,• l JW: r lhi':' l"ot!st~uon. G~auttl l'~uml nlld 110.1 b.olNf m th.1'.\."'iR.~t"MJ.•nifl.-d

:l l"* Prtor il)'

.> P1ojo;"(u n"luiftuf .:l W!llo?t l\llhir~ t.°~Uvl (1uu tJ'll llul rn b_t..'i"t \o .~88. [.~ft. N 1Uo.~111ru pr~ytk'>'tg'rwth•m

SEC'lJON 2- Pum111t1.e11t Sio.n:::i Water B:\IP Requiremenb.

Addition:J mform.(ttiolJ for dttrerruirlh1, rh .. N'"lllke~nt!J~ fc.anit ti. tb~ S1crr;1 W!I! ·r !>t;U)<ian,h >.1..iall.lJ

PART C: Determine if Not.Subjed '"~anent S•rn-n1: \Vaie •· lll."q t1h·r.tnenb. rro;...-1a f11.st u •¥ cow.iJf'nd maml,..Sl • M ..._ o r u~~twi!. 11ut cu.t~tHl ~ -~..., .i.,.~<'fopm .. m f'"I"~ L• - vr*eyJ_.,_ r;:,~.;_r,;.•~Jll pi"tljl·tt:t - trtnmhni; tu lh..- tilOOU Wuttr..!ilaruh:u:d;f \foJlloltd llt\' 11o& mlb)l-t l I() I\ r m.t l\l'n l ~lnrnt \\'utrr

~"!~~n~\r;:i~~::'B~\P~wln.:~f;~roceed 10 P.trt F aud ch~k .. :-lo t Subi~• 10

lf"llo" is ch l&C'ke.t fQr" :i.11 of th& nnmben in~ C coolinue to P.\rt D.

~ tlwt proy.-1 onl;~ iach1rt..' ht t"rior r1o'AUd:<b RnliiQr h tltt< proji;>ct l'Cl t irr-ty wt1hio nn C':u:il ing CU(.klec1t !JIT\klUI"\' ttnd !I~ QUI tu aTC u~ .,O:fl'l~ l i>tl lo tQQIDrl 811(H'Ol W.Uft'{? Q Y,-n 'JI No

l>-.1 \ .. ~ pWJWt Ul\l,; 0-tluo.k- \fa,,. CO&Hln,.-t~ u(two!rlw.td ot loll~"~""'ll<I ,;i"Jit t.."" "il li1nd tr.mt in;; nV'tl' iniJ!l.'n kn1B 1Jt1rfac""I Q y.._ 'D No

1\u...-1f;, ;.;;:;--J<';tf;DubJ .. r rUU I~" .;~ai+oDll.;_.;?' E;";1o1t1jJ...-;;._d1t1!":-i;;1-1_.1W; !im1t1.J tu. ruof Q' r d ,. ,Kor 10burhUY111uf11<~ ' " f>l >M;llllJA'"l, rw-1nliac 1"¥' '" fW'Qn fQcu'i:J ,_,111L.i.·" p11 r ki11og

~~~~~~~ ~~;~~=~~,=~~=~e~~~d~:/:;n~~!} ruutiao 0 y,.~ ~No

STORM WATER REQUIREMENTS AP PLI CABILITY CHECKLIST

~ ...... ~ :,.,,__-·,. at0 -·t I/,,_...._. ... I ""'

t ~ ; ~ Mobity . S&n D6eQO

7337 lRAOE SlREET. 3 EAST. ROOM 3084 SAN DIEGO CA92121-..t2C>2

)ePratti ) PARADISE MESA STANDP IPE

SD0371

1521 STATTON COURT SAN DIEGO, CA 921 14

PART D: PDP Exe.apt Ref)"lr@Glent&..

POP K."tflnpt pt'Ojed• are required to imple:•~mt site deritn and &0un:e control JlMPs.

1f "'yeS* was ch ecked f \'H' any tJUMtions in Pa.'t ~continue to Part .F and eh eek the box )a . belP.tl .. PDP Rxe111pt.. ..

If •no" w.:1.s clu~cki!d far All q\teStiOllS Ju P:ttt D. ~ntiaue to Part E..

l . Ooc.-.. t~ ~"iU.'ay UKftuk M':.1.' w ~tmt •i.duYlrolb. b c1"'kr b .... ....,~ r 1f'!ltli that:

• At•~ anJ ..u .... lr\lrloid tn dinod ~ ... ':lt111otr r-tflll-~ut Y"'b~ .. ~ .tr .. 41t..or ueJ ... , ~ltbf,. J'¥fW#3-bJ.!.IU"M~14.Jr.

• :\n- tt-rD¥<1I uo•J t'Ga,.l r~d .... h1 lll' b}'d:racli.-aUy <h. ... -.el'd<"ll lnita ~v..-d &11-• rui.l rnad;o? Or..

· ~~"i:~"~tt='::~b! c\:~r.~=:~:sr:::J~-::.~vc. tWtGfd;m"' .... tth 1iw

~!i:!!:1e~:!~~~!:~"ri:h'!~~~·~::;~~=·::~~Ci:1~8Ri°:~~W'1~~~:~~:'~"'1_, U %>tl;POP.,1n1p.t"'°"tdtt~ftti>App)J i.2;t ~IY:J'NiM • llOf•Hftlf>l PDP ""lt11f\'m.otH~l\flf ly

PART F..: Determine if Projttt is a Prfority DiW~lopoaent Project <PDP). l'rujt'C'u Hu t nto<t tthotw of"1tHodelir11riob!il'>!low :ue-b;«t ID tdthrio~I rl"lflnNrn~ntA il>l:htd!~ r~nop«tttlkm °'" Stnmt \\'nt_,.r ()uulity \lnfl,_,mwnr i>t.- fS\\'•lMP;>.

JI ")•e-s,. ii ebe<:ke-d for ftny number in PART E.. couthnte lo PART F.

Jf .. no" ill checked for ever)· nun~her in PAIIT E. oontinue to PART F and cheek the box fo­OOkd "Sbmdsnl Development Pn)j~".

J N.:w J:k,·dn5>CtH':111ot l b.at """'r""" 10.0UO Ml"";.; kcl ~ Wl •'>rt:: •" hllpef"Tiou~ 11urfio••...,.,,

~'!1'.~!t~~-~v::b~~~~c:~~~p 1~~~~~1~~~;:!::'~ ;:rmal. 1YS1\l\>.J1t i.ll :Jr~ ~ x~ R.-tl~•·doplll.:nl prll-~I th•l Ct t'.al<o'C andfioc' rq•ldi~ ~"'It) "llUaire frel ....- more of \mpe rd»Wo .t\U" fJttW'S ll-U an otJ:l~il?i Nit' of IU.~-~ f<IWU" f~I <"t" aiWf' »f il)(llJooe'n"h•U-" ~urfat.~-11- 111ll'I i11d1111'8 n\JllttM' ~l!ll. 1tio<h1"1:rial, r-.<l1'81nl. cuu:td..e~. ~ud publtr" dOfTdopme-nt i>•i))focu .:.r1.. pu\>.M' 01 iimot,i. l:md. Cl ViM XI :-,i.,

.I .'"'..-w dr.\'d<J.;.;rnl nr rmltwdop~nl ora ,....Mi.un.ot. -.·11r ltllkYi lh&l llf'li p•f'pAN>l (Mil .. :m<I drinb fol' ftlMU1UpUt:111, indnd h1g al11;tiCM»"Jf)'"tu11"h ra•rit..rs l\nd r<l'-6-h.IDf'nl stnncl<t ~Uin.t

s~:~io';=~~ ~~dr~:,..~;1=i~;'":'!:t:.n.:~0~1~.!J!~::,!!fu!.1>11 u v~ ~ ~o .J :'ll<iw J ..,.-e10V,tll9111t o.r r-~•1 f'vduf>s•~bt on ;-hUlirJd~ Tew , ro;;d u11or~ nad/Or r<?Jll.lt'e-'

t!1:;:.!:'!iji~o\::'!:;"=:tl~ ~}!~:}~:~.~:fl!!~tl!~~~r:,whar ;o .J Y" ~ ~.,

~~;;}-:;,:!::;r:~~~~,~~;;:~a~::~:f!i~.~;;;:~~:.h!.';~j!~:·,~:). a~-... ~ ~o ii Nr.w d~~•-•lif''-'-or ,,-Jm- r.h:r;;;·~f.s"i~b<.,. "*• I~ i.1c-;_· ~J"'• rn;r:,,,,ai"" a n ti

~~:;;;:::~~ti:et~z.::: ~h':~:;:t~~.,.)'k«" J.OOOoqu.•no * a.r "'°"' of tm~r.·IUI~ Qr~ ill :\o

DCI PACIFIC AJEIC WORKS

ATTACHMENT 12

P.g•4ot4- CrtyolS.:t'1Die9Q • Clf'lltl~~~laH0.~11fnCtlt•S!0r1nW!lkr~-nu. Af;~lhtyChecW~~----.

7 ~:~1~:!\~:it:~·':d7~~:-:~~~ .. ~~~~t)f!! 5-"~~=.::!11~#-(rullHth~ly ~'<'r<t '"njwt'J:). •tid JU<h~ d m .-ct ly l• ti. E•vir~Ulillt'Mal~ ~~oifrte Ar.-a ([ $_.\>. "Di...-16!1f1lll.it•liretti.1 i." indll<lts tla:w tU.1 lacoat>w~ ~r~ adt<tonc .1200 r~1 W~'t from lh t•J>ffl)f'< l t .. th~ ESA. or~'U}°fdlnApip.r t' r Gp<:-ac~l nayd1.~t·ui.c• i:u~~;d..-.1._.,.1 9- r,.,., i li« p~t t g 1M F.SI\ {i ... n.!)f. ~l'Mfttn...,M w11li ~ '"*" ~nt CJ y""' Cl No

S No1m• d~.-d•'('•o?nt or ".1 ............ .,.W'n t P"'Je'Cf.• "'a r<!tWIH 1puol in<;t 1nnl .. l tRGO~ that .-re111e •nJI•»" n-p\aL- .:;.,~ -auan: re-cl .. r intrel'Ylou" surf .. ~. fif-d. vt-IClf"ll•••

~-:~~~~;:~~O'~~~~·!!'!°T:%1:J!!:: .. •_:,_a.orur \b}Unp1*-ck'd Qy"" 21 Nn

g ~=.::~dt':~· L,':l~;rr= 1!~1:1:..~~i::;:::~:.~'!s'!!::!!!:)P~~~k:r.-rit t~trr.:;32~~:ri~:;~ef~•ibrd lndm.lri•I CIMttlWo.ltr<n t51C)codo>6S(H3. 50 JI , Q y~ !lj No

lO ~~~·~ ~:::'di!~:;h~:<~•:J:~=-~~~!=s~ ~~L~~:;:;; :~~~!~;';di'!:;"ts f:: 1~1~!';!'(~!=:'d::'a~::h~!;: ~"?i!it:d;C:~d!;:~"';=,~:1:~1b1 u.~ of ~ltcidw u 1d f" r1tl1uts. 1wcb - a.,. .aoliHialiM ~•int flllh\'W' pls"la. Caknbil- (If

!~i1~:..'~ .. 0! 1:.:~u=~~:4::.:~:~~~-=:~~1to~i.~1.mt • , . ~ith J'('fT\OU. •urlCk"I):> \){'ii •Mr •hN-1 a.- IO •~rtO\tnthtllr ...... ~ •mf.-.~. Q \ ;:• ::a !\'.9

PART F: ~e-c-t the :.pproprla te ~ftte,ocy hru~ ou the outcomM of PART C lhrou-'1 PART E.

~kt1r,Z::r:i!!?::~~~~~~:,;;::~~::tr.::t'J;'3;.,~,~::t t:::.:.:.~n-. coiirvl- _ 1.l ___ _

:1 ~ ,~;~i~!!:~,:~~~1'i~~~t~utfr~~¥ ~olrvl u~rl• f<'l\ll>f•llht~ l ll uppt_~ a

J.';;JZ~'~!~l~~~-·~~:!J i!W~~~~~~i!'~~(~;_~~b:~o:;J~~~=~~i;Jd fot ~tUtb~""' OR lft'l ... U!Ulllllli! jJ l>fUJKl ~tUU'.f :t &,Y'rumv<f.11) l' .. hOU vl.m llUIUlf""l.l"IUI ':l

Tilt. AS.SOCI:..'!'6 ~!=!INC! PAL INC .

8/t/:!016

11 S-HEO nn£ SHW' rruMOCR

~ ! i;'

• ,

A 09/13/16 1ssuro FOR co R(\'l[W .ANO COMMENTS HH SOK DKO

STORM WATER REQUIREMENTS APPLICABILITY C01 I'·

AACHllECI Un~- I ENGINl[lll-"IG I (QNUA.llNr.; J2 EX ECUTIVE PAllK ( 1UITE I JO

IRWNE I CA 926 1'4

NO. DATE

SCAlE" AS Sl-10'1111 I OCSIGNEO

REVIStCtlS

I DRAWN CHECKLIST BY CH!t APP'C

Page 44: THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Report to the Hearing Officer · 12 panel antennas, 24 Remote Radio Units, 6 surge suppressors, and related equipment and cabling on the Paradise Mesa Water

\

'Y+•

"· ""~ \ ~-~~~'.'~,~~/

-.~. \

WPCP (BMP PLAN)

:~:.· . at&:+ ,,,,...._.·, ~ .. \~ :~ M.:lblty - Sanot9g0

1337 TRADE STREET, 3 EAS T, ROOM 3684 SAN OIEGO, CA 92121""202

\

"

)ePratti ) PARADISE MESA STANDPIPE

SD037 1

152 1 STATTON COURT SAN OIEGO, CA 921 14

DCI PACIFIC A I E IC WORKS

AR<Hllr(lUR( I lNCilNH.JllNG I CONSUlllN!i Jl IEXlClJTlVE l"AltK I :!OUUE I tO

IRVlNE I CA 926H

. _\...-------- -

ATTAC HMENT 12

-, IOl! \ I \\\I l H 1)1 \ I 11 \ '\Cll'I .._

f fl ' " I HI I 110' 11\11'."

lf11, p1ojll-t ,full nu11pl' uith .tl1 tt:•111un111nh. of l)u.· l\1unitif•:tl 1't·J11ti1 ' 'llt·tl ft\ 'au

1h-.;~u f{t:~1ou,d \\ .1r1 r ()11.11!1\ C utt l rol Uo.trd l"llH \\ (H B• ,Hui \lu11i,·ip:•I "wrm \\ .!lu

~.t101ul l'tillut;ua l''·,:J1.ll"'' l.!m:in;.;ti1•U "'''\.111 (.\Pl•J "' 1•,rnut win JJ.n11a1. !·I. _riu 'itfp '' '' \\ ·"" tJ1.ct • .o' n .1h r j,..,ll.t0.J>H• 1r ~ '1~1" . .te::.1· '-nr·,!t th. tion.,h11nl• ;1ntl !ht· (sf"\ •lf :tu lhl'::!t1 I atul lh-,rl11pmt:nl l ~111,

tlt_~1~.,~1ulit.·:!_t>-1 •0' n111111n1tk \Ju~1l1.:<J!!u1t\.-rl_::!_ ( _l1__!_!_l!._1t~!f>1'j'h,nlt.2.p ti

ind '-. lorm \\ ·'"' \I.mu 11 ~\\\_'-~1Hltt 0u. I)\ dc;1,:l~·1rni..·11l-\U\fU'\ ndi JllH ... "'flllll\\~!.l"1""1,!111Ull!.!l!

11., rulJlt;I< 11'1 ,h,ill I>< "''J.l"ll'ihl, , .. , liL"JllUj> nl Jll 'ill Jilli 111utl "" Jtlj:l(l'tll

\fl"ll'fhl. du~ 111 llltl\huc11n11 \ lutlt' 01 arn otht·r 111tt11tfUt:tmn .. u:h\il\ tt 1tu t.·lhf ot t'.'i.Uh \'orl\ d.n. nt offU J ''"' 1U 1•\t~Hr rhil1 l~all'l'' a J. ru:·, h Ill in.,_Lllful lOU ... tru ·d·>n H\11'\ \\ht~.:h m:t\ l"tJtnp1onliH ~torm \\ :1U·r f)u . .llit~ "itl11u an~

"Ut'l'l{"). \ ' t:tlnl!Jt.d lOll't.fnntio11 \\ii 111~1~ IR ft.'t.fllttUI to p1tll'Ul 1.:01nl11h.ti11JJ

'rhich" 01 i·t1uipnu-nt tro111 t1 ,u.·t..ln~ n1t11I llr ... Hr 0 11 1t1 tlu. ,f tt..:t'I.

~\ U '-to..:-1,pih: .. ot 'oil a11d 11r buildilll.! m:11l"riah thJ1 .tH· 1111'..'Mlcd to ht· h.·ft l11r .:.t

pcnm.l g rt:.tfl-1· th.an 't\llt \_aft.ml.•t d.tl' .ut. I•• li t.. to\l J~:d \ II n.IH J\;.thl,· 11 \ tl'

'h \ irt' ... h.111 hi. rn pl..t'"< ~\f tlH uul nl t.~1' h \\.ort.iu:! 11.n \l hot fh\_ <l.1\ r:.i11

proh;ihilih fo1 h.'a't l·\i..'n•th .io • \ t'OIH.Td<: \ \ :1'i l\lml .. h:.tli ht• prn\ 1<h-rl on .ill pruju.·1, uhid1 propi''l tin.

con,tnu:rlno of ,H1! l~ o unt~h 1mp11nt:111c11h ,.,.filth .an fp h'- puuru! 1n pl.1ll u£1

,j(~ .

..& 1 h t.• t·nntral'lu1 1i h.tll 11..·,to11 .di t·nhi1m ·,t·d imulf r1111trol de\ it·l ' tu '' or kh1:.,: ,,, th:r aftu c1d1 nllt·utl 1·rurlth n_ 1.unt 111 '•f ;tfll

I

I

I

I I I

I

... rt\:l·li\ (,I)\....... I \IJ '"~pi·, th;11 n, l"n .. Jlt.d 1 d \f111 httl i., (0U ... tlll\Tl11U .tcthlf\ fllll'f Ii ...

pi ultdtd .1:.:,.\IU"ll, fll''\JllU ;,ttHI \1.:thflJt'lll fl •lfl ' JIHr I :.11 tit l111h' I

i

·-·--- __ (·_ I Ill ~(Ul ~•:O:.f..' of all <:•Hl ... lt'W.: twn Jll;JfCtL.lh u111I i:\) llJ JHUCllt Ul\hl hi pl olc~hti J -- - - .1~:1i11,I ;imp<>•• 11l1;1I rd1·:1><· ol poll111:111h 1111.i !ht'"' 11·u1111h nr

LEGEND BEST MANAGEMENT PROTECTION

DESCRIPTION QUANTITY I SYMBOL

I

~ MATERIAL DELIVERY ANO STORAC( (WI.I - I ) I EA i I ~ SOUO WASTE LlANAGEMENT (WM-5) I EA I

HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT (WM-6) 1 EA ! [4J

CONCRETE WASTE MANAGEMENT (WM-8) I EA I [§] ' [ID SANITARY/SEPTIC WASTE l.IANAGEIJENT {WM - 9) I EA

I -FIBER ROLLS (SC-5) N/A ,- _/

i DIRECllON OF SURFACE FLOW N/ A i /

SCA.LE: 1111 1 I o 4' a· ,,.

SHt.CT mu:

1

A 09/ D / 16 ISSUED fOR CO Rf\ll£W ~O Cot.!tJ£NTS HH SOK CKO

WPCP (BMP PLAN) C02

DATE RE\IS lS BY CHK APP'C