tear apart your competition
DESCRIPTION
Competitive Analysis remains an underleveraged - yet - powerful tool in the product strategist's arsenal. Most companies know who their competitors are. Yet competitive analysis is rarely done in an in-depth manner and usually only covers feature checklists of similar products. This presentation will cover how to examine every aspect of your competition so that winning strategic plans can be put in place. This includes a four-step process for developing competitive analysis for both internal and external audiences and topics such as SWOT analysis, Porter's five forces, channel, team/company, product features, funding and others.TRANSCRIPT
How to Tear Apart Your CompetitionBrian Lawley
CEO & Founder
©2010 280 Group LLC
1
CEO & Founder280 Group, LLC
A dAgenda
• About Brian & 280 Group• Special offers• Value of competitive intelligence• Four step process for full analysis• Sources of competitive information• Delivering the results and selling tools• Summary
Slides at:
©2010 280 Group LLC
22
Slides at: www.280group.com/tear.pdf
About Me• 280 Group LLC
President & Founder
About Me
President & Founder
• Whistle CommunicationsDirector of Product Management & Product Marketing
• SymantecSymantec Director of Java and C++ tools
• Apple Computer Senior Product Manager, MacOS
• Claris Corporation (FileMaker, Inc.) Marketing Specialist
• Digidesign, Inc. (division of Avid)Manager of US channel sales and marketingManager of US channel sales and marketing
• Awards, SVPMA, interviews, books, etc.
©2010 280 Group LLC
3
280 GrouppThe Product Marketing & Product Management Experts™
• Consulting & Contractors• Toolkits & PM Office™
(Product Manager’s, Roadmaps, Launches, Beta, Reviews, Competitive Analysis)• Training: public & private
– PM Fast Track™– Agile Excellence for Product Managers™– Customer & Market Research– Effective Decision Making– Interactivity & Communication– Market Value Pricing– Personal Strategic Plans For PMs. – Time Management & Productivity – GREAT Demos!
C tifi ti• Certifications: – Self-Study & In-Person Courses– Agile Certified Product Manager™– Certified Product Manager™
C ifi d P d M k i M ™
©2010 280 Group LLC
4
– Certified Product Marketing Manager™– Blackblot Product Management Professional
Special Offers
• $20 off Competitive Analysis Toolkit• $100 off
– Certified Product Manager (CPM) Self-Study Course & Exam– Agile Certified Product Manager (ACPM) Self-Study Course & Exam
• $300 off – PM Fast Track 4 day course (NY Feb 22nd-26th)– Agile Product Management Excellence & Exam (Feb 27th)
• Email [email protected] for discount codes
©2010 280 Group LLC
5
Value of Competitive Intelligence
• To gain a thorough understanding of your industry
• Identify key competitors and understand how the compete
• Compare your product’s attributes to the competition
• Make informed decisions on product planning and development
©2010 280 Group LLC
66
Four Step Process
• Identify relevant competitors• Do in-depth researchp• Create competitive analysis for internal use• Create competitive analysis & selling tools for p y g
external use
©2010 280 Group LLC
77
Identify your key competitorsIdentify your key competitors
• Only most relevant• Usually only 2 or 3y y• Early markets may have up to 10• 90/10 rule
©2010 280 Group LLC
88
Criteria for Choosing Competitors
• Market share• Press/publicityp y• Mentions by prospects• Strength of solutiong• Appearance in sales deals
©2010 280 Group LLC
99
Four Step Process
• Identify relevant competitors• Do in-depth researchp• Create competitive analysis for internal use• Create competitive analysis & selling tools for p y g
external use
©2010 280 Group LLC
1010
9 Research Components
• External Performance• Funding & Spending• Management• Management• Attitude• Products• Positioning• Marketing• Distribution Channels• Market Share
©2010 280 Group LLC
1111
Sources of Competitive Sources of Competitive Information
• Obviously, publicly held companies will have more information available via newswires and financial statements
• By nature, privately held companies may diffi lt h hi fpose some difficulty when searching for
competitive information
©2010 280 Group LLC
1212
Sources• Product reviews• Product reviews• Press articles• Financial statements “Risks and issues” sections• Press releases• Press releases• Past versions of their website (Wayback Machine http://www.archive.org)• Specific/obscure/advanced searches: http://www.googleguide.com• Information on the sites of theirVCs• Information on the sites of theirVCs• The company’s website: management, board, funding, # customers, • Interview current customers. • Analysts and market research reports: IDC Gartner etc• Analysts and market research reports: IDC, Gartner, etc.• Hoovers http://www.hoovers.com• Silicon Valley startups: www.linksv.com• Company profile at www linkedin com
©2010 280 Group LLC
• Company profile at www.linkedin.com• Dun and Bradstreet http://www.dnb.com.
13
Funding
• Identify key sources of funding your industry• Compare and evaluate your competitors’ p y p
sources of funding• Valuations• Burn rate/runway
©2010 280 Group LLC
1414
Spending
• What are they spending on?– Talent, marketing, facilities, manufacturing, R&D,
etc.• Look for trends in competitors’ spending
h bithabits• A high growth company in a new industry is
going to spend differently than an establishedgoing to spend differently than an established company in a low growth industry
©2010 280 Group LLC
15
External Performance
• Obtain key quantitative performance indicators about your competitorsS l t i (l ) l th fi i l• Sales, net income (loss), annual growth, financial ratios (i.e. assets to liabilities), inventory turnover
• Identify trends about external performanceIdentify trends about external performance • Public company: 10-K or quarterly release Balance
Sheet and Income Statement• Private companies: press release on stage of funding
©2010 280 Group LLC
16
Management
• Importance of identifying leadership within an organization– Example: Is the competitor founded by a group of
engineers that do not have marketing experience?Id tif i th t t t f• Identifying the management structure of a company helps you learn who the decision makers aremakers are
• Find out how well-connected company heads are within the industry/business world
©2010 280 Group LLC
17
are within the industry/business world
17
Attitude• Goal is to find out how your competitors viewGoal is to find out how your competitors view
the market• Aggressively expanding, conservative gg y p g,
actions, risk taking strategies, etc. • Use a performance grid to help identify the p g p y
current state of a company• Plot external performance indicators against
various components of organizational health• Helps provide a sense of the type of company
©2010 280 Group LLC
18
you are competing against18
Th P f G idThe Performance Gridcece
rman
crm
anc
TroubledTroubledCompanyCompany
SuccessfulSuccessfulFirmFirm
Perf
oPe
rfo
tern
al
tern
al
LowLow ComplacentComplacentCompanyCompany
CrisisCrisis
Ext
Ext
LowLow HighHigh
©2010 280 Group LLC
19Organizational HealthOrganizational Health
gg
Products
• Compare key product attributes across the competitive field
• Answer important internal/external questions pertaining to your product
• Identify what is important to the market and how your product compares to competitors
• Use a BCG matrix to communicate product performance in terms of market share and growth rate
©2010 280 Group LLC
20
growth rate20
Example Product Comparison Example Product Comparison Template
Feature Product 1 Product 2
Level of importance to the customer
©2010 280 Group LLC
21
BCG MatrixR
ate
Hig
h
Stars Question Marks
row
th H
rket
Gr
ow
Cash Cows DogsMar Lo
©2010 280 Group LLC
2222
High LowMarket Share
Determine Competitive Determine Competitive Positioning
• Use data from their marketing & website• Brainstorm possible axes for chartp• Try multiple combinations
©2010 280 Group LLC
23
XY Axis Positioning Matrixge
2
Competitor 1 Product
Name
Tag line supporting positioning goes here.
dvan
tag Name
Mai
n A
d
Competitor 3
Competitor 2
M i Ad t 1
Competitor 3
©2010 280 Group LLC
24
Main Advantage 1
Four Quadrant Positioning MatrixFour Quadrant Positioning Matrix
Tag line supporting Competitor 2Tag line supporting positioning goes here.
Product
Competitor 2
Competitor 3Name
Competitor 1
Competitor 4
©2010 280 Group LLC
25
Marketing
• Is their marketing effective?• How much are they spending?y p g• Do they have a strong brand?• Are they marketing or technology focused?y g gy• What tactics are they using?
– SEO, PPC, white papers, ads, PR, etc., , p p , , ,
©2010 280 Group LLC
2626
Marketing Research
• Research on a competitor’s marketing efforts is different than other types
• Look for marketing activity, financial statements, press releases
• In addition, identify the marketing team, web offers
• Use AdWords and SEO as tools
©2010 280 Group LLC
27
Distribution Channels
• What channels do they use?– Direct, VARs, Web, Distribution, Partners
• How strong is their presence?• Are there flaws in their channels of
distribution?
©2010 280 Group LLC
2828
Market Share
• Identify the market size for your product• Who are the key players in your product’s y p y y p
market?• How do you compare to others within your
industry
©2010 280 Group LLC
29
Four Step Process
• Identify relevant competitors• Do in-depth researchp• Summarize competitive analysis for internal
use• Create competitive analysis & selling tools for
external use
©2010 280 Group LLC
3030
Internal delivery: what’s included
• Industry analysis• Life cycle positiony p• SWOT analysis• Competitive Scope/Differentiationp p• Likely Moves• Market & Strategy ToolsMarket & Strategy Tools• Remember: Added security for sensitive
information about your product/company
©2010 280 Group LLC
31
o a o abou you p oduc /co pa y
31
Industry Specific Analyses
• Use tools that can help communicate important components of your industry
• Porter’s 5-Force Model– Include information on Barriers to Entry,
C tit S li C t dCompetitors, Suppliers, Customers, and Substitutes
• Industry Life-Cycle Model• Industry Life-Cycle Model– Help generalize direction of your industry
©2010 280 Group LLC
32
Porter’s Competitive ForcesPorter s Competitive Forces
©2010 280 Group LLC
33
Industry Life Cycle Model
• Identify where your industry is• Review trends that are consistent with industries in e e t e ds t at a e co s ste t t dust es
your stage
©2010 280 Group LLC
34
SWOTSWOT(Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats)
• Perform a SWOT analysis for each major competitor• Make a list of each of the following:
– Strengths: internal things about your company and its market position that help your chances of success
– Weaknesses: internal things about your company and its market position that weaken your chances of success
– Opportunities: external things that help your chances of success
– Threats: external things that weaken your chances of success
• Fill in the SWOT matrix with strategies based on
©2010 280 Group LLC
35
Fill in the SWOT matrix with strategies based on these factors
SWOT Analysis
Strengths Weaknesses
OpportunitiesStrategies the company
can exploit to take advantage of opportunities
Strategies the company must deal with to take
advantage of t itina
l
advantage of opportunities opportunities
ThreatsStrategies the company can use to defend itself
Strategies the company must deal with to defend Ex
tern
from threats itself from threats
Internal
©2010 280 Group LLC
36
Competitive Scope/Differentiation
• Review scope of the customer base– Broad vs. narrow (focused) scope of customers
• Differentiation scale of the company’s products– Low and High Differentiation
• Compare generic strategies of the products d th i i t iand their owners using a matrix
©2010 280 Group LLC
37
Competitive Scope and Differentiation Matrix
Competitive Advantagep g
Lower Cost Differentiation
BroadTarget 1. Cost Leadership 2. Differentiation
Competitive Scope
NarrowTarget
3A. Cost Focus 3B. DifferentiationFocus
©2010 280 Group LLC
38
g
Likely moves
• Draw conclusions about likely moves competitors will make
• Discover how a product may likely evolve over a period of time
• Use a matrix to compare markets and product development strategies
• Use a roadmap to help visualize the industry landscape in the near to long-term
©2010 280 Group LLC
3939
Market & Strategy Roadmap
Your company
Competitor 1
Competitor 2
Competitor 3
Markets
Partner
Build In-HouseAcquire
©2010 280 Group LLC
40
2 Year Competitive, Market p ,& Tech Trends Roadmap
2009 2010
Competitive* Competitor 1 expected release
* Competitor 2 expected release
MarketEarly Adopter Phase
Wid d d tiMarket Widespread adoption
* New technology available to leverage
Tech Trends
gy g
* New technology available to leverage
* New technology available to leverage
©2010 280 Group LLC
41
1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q
4 Year Competitive, Market p ,& Tech Trends Roadmap
Competitive* Competitor 1 expected release
* Competitor 2 expected release
MarketEarly Adopter Phase
Widespread adoption
Tech* New technology available to leverage
* New technology available to leverage
2009 2010 2011 2012
Tech Trends
New technology available to leverage
* New technology available to leverage
©2010 280 Group LLC
42
2009 2010 2011 2012
Delivering the results
• Choose a target audience for your findings• Relevant/sensitive information may be better y
suited for a company executive instead of a potential investor
• Condense your presentations for your target• Use what you learn to develop competitive
selling tools for your sales force
©2010 280 Group LLC
4343
Strategy for success
• Develop an executive summary of your findings
• Based on internal presentation• Convey what you need to do to win• Use this to gain funding & resources
©2010 280 Group LLC
4444
Four Step Process
• Identify relevant competitors• Do in-depth researchp• Summarize competitive analysis for internal
use• Create competitive analysis & selling tools for
external use
©2010 280 Group LLC
4545
External delivery
• Added value for your customer (organize into a matrix)– Identify 7 key added values that your company
can give to a customer Identify 3 sources of the added value– Identify 3 sources of the added value
• Use a side by side Competitive Product Comparison with your most importantComparison with your most important competitor– Include a checklist, most important features listed
©2010 280 Group LLC
46
, pfirst
46
Added Value Comparison Matrix
[Your Industry]
LEGEND [Your■ YES □ NO ■ UNKNOWN
[Your Company] [Competitor 1] [Competitor 2] [Competitor 3]
Added Value Category One
Item 1
Item 2
Item 3
Added Value Category Two
Item 1
Item 2
Item 3
Added Value Category Three
Item 1
Item 2
©2010 280 Group LLC
47
Item 3
Competitive Feature Competitive Feature Checklist/Comparison
[Product name] [Main Competitor]
Feature 1Feature 2Feature 3Feature 4
R b t i l d U i S lli P iti
Feature N
• Remember to include your Unique Selling Proposition• Explain the benefits of your top features• This list can include as many features as you want
©2010 280 Group LLC
48
• This list can include as many features as you want
Deliver Effective Selling Tools
• Competitive comparisons• FAQ for difficult questionsq• White paper(s) on technical superiority• Talking points about each competitorg p p• Success stories/testimonials of customers
who switched to your producty p
©2010 280 Group LLC
4949
Summary
• Value of competitive intelligence• Four step process for full analysis
– Identify relevant competitors– Do in-depth research– Summarize competitive analysis for internal usep y– Create competitive analysis & selling tools for external use
• Sources of competitive information9 h t– 9 research components
• Delivering the results and effective selling tools
©2010 280 Group LLC
50
Special Offers
• $20 off Competitive Analysis Toolkit• $100 off
– Certified Product Manager (CPM) Self-Study Course & Exam– Agile Certified Product Manager (ACPM) Self-Study Course & Exam
• $300 off – PM Fast Track 4 day course (NY Feb 22nd-26th)– Agile Product Management Excellence & Exam (Feb 27th)
• Email [email protected] for discount codes
©2010 280 Group LLC
51
280 Group Resources
• Free templates and white papers • 2009 Product Management Survey Results• PM Job listing sites• PM Job listing sites• 280 Group Product Management 2.0 Newsletter• 280 LinkedIn Group• Product Management 2.0 Blog • Books• PMA listings
Go to www.280group.com in the “Resources” section.
©2010 280 Group LLC
52