tax efficient investing - localinstitutes.cii.co.ukaid 6 • vcts / eiss / seiss subject to eu state...
TRANSCRIPT
UNDERSTAND THE RISKS
• Tax legislation can change and depends on
personal circumstances.
• EIS relief depends on companies retaining
their EIS qualifying status for 3 year period
post investment
• You should not invest if you are likely to
require the capital in the near term.
This summary has been approved by Enterprise Investment Partners LLP which is authorised and regulated by
the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 604439). It is not an offer to invest in any of the offers mentioned.
Investment can only be made on the basis of the full Information Memorandums and examination of the risk
factors contained therein. We recommend you seek advice from an independent financial adviser authorised
under the Financial Services & Markets Act 2000 who specialises in investments of this type before investing.
• Past performance is not a reliable indicator of
future performance.
• Any stated returns are for illustrative purposes
only and no forecast (guaranteed or
otherwise) is implied or should be inferred.
• Your capital is at risk and you may not get
back the amount invested.
2
PROGRAMME
3
• Legitimate tax-efficient investing – forget the trial by media!
• A brief history
• What are the available structures?
• Recent Legislative Changes and their impact
• How to choose from the vast array of available products
OVERVIEW
4
Launch DateTotal funds
(Raised to date)Funds raised
(Most recent year)
VCT 1995 Nearly £6 billion £400 million Retail only
EIS 1994 £12.3 billion £1.5 billionIncl. retail and non
retail
SEIS 2012 £250 million £150 millionIncl. retail and non
retail
BPR 2004 £987 millionRetail only. Total market est. £1.8
billion
EU S
TATE
AID
6
• VCTs / EISs / SEISs subject to EU State Aid rules
• All government subsidies for companies subject to rules
• EU Competition Commission is in charge
• HMRC must get State Aid approval for all changes
• “Evidence-based” permissions – do schemes earn their keep?
New companies = employment = increased receipts from corporation tax / income tax / VAT
SUCCESS OF THE EIS
7
22,900 SME’s have received over £12.3bn of funding via
EIS
EIS
2,770 firms raised £1.5bn
in 2013/14
Firms raising funds for the
first time raised £840m
last year
WHAT QUALIFIES?
8
VCT / EIS / SEIS
Most trading businesses, excluding propertyand financial/professional businesses
Can be overseas, provided permanent UKestablishment
BPR
Most UK businesses which carry on a tradebut excluding investment businesses
* Watch out for connected party, joint venture and leasing rules* Watch out for gross assets test / employee test
VCT
9
• Fully quoted vehicle investing in qualifying unquoted companies
• AIM and all non RIEs count as unquoted
The Tax Reliefs - VCT
30% income tax relief
Tax-free dividends
CGT Free on exit
No IHT exemption
No Loss Relief
✔
X
✔
✔
X
VCT
• Generalist, AIM or sector specific
• New Fund or Top Up
• Can invest via equity or debt
• 5 year qualifying period
EIS
10
• Unquoted plc or ltd company carrying on qualifying trade
• Can be funds or single companies
The Tax Reliefs - EIS
30% income tax relief
CGT deferral, liability retriggered on exit
CGT free on exit
IHT exemption after 2 years
Loss relief
No tax-free dividends
✔
✔
✔
X
✔
✔
EIS
• Ordinary shares only, no loans or other share classes
• 3 year qualifying period
• Recent enhancements include 30% income tax relief and relaxation of “carry back”
• Availability of BIR for non-doms
SEIS
11
• ‘Son of EIS – Introduced in 2012 to stimulate start-up economy post-recession
• Maximum of £150,000 can be raised per company
The Tax Reliefs - SEIS
50% income tax relief
CGT write-off of 50%, reduces tax bill from 28% to 14%
CGT free on exit
IHT exemption after 2 years
Loss relief
No tax-free dividends
✔
✔
✔
X
✔
✔
SEIS
• SEIS/EIS funds can now be raised in parallel
• Best approached on fund basis due to higher risk of individual companies
• Not a big retail market, as sums involved are small!
BPR
12
• Business Property Relief originally introduced for Property only, subsequently extended to shares in unquoted companies
The Tax Reliefs - BPR
IHT exemption after 2 years
Can combine holding periods
On death, 5 year ‘look back’
✔
✔
✔
BPR
• Most normal UK companies qualify
• Must be trading and not investment companies
• Huge growth in BPR in recent years
COMPARISON OF TAX RELIEFS
13
Income Tax
CGT Deferral
No CGT on Exit
IHT Exempt
Tax Free Dividends
Loss Relief
VCT ✔ 30% X ✔ X ✔ X
EIS ✔ 30% ✔ ✔ ✔ X ✔
SEIS ✔ 50%✔
(Write-off)✔ ✔ X ✔
BPR X X X ✔ X X
THE PROCESS – HOW DO YOU GET YOUR TAX RELIEF? (EIS/SEIS)
14
“Advanced Assurance” application to HMRC
Clearance granted and tax certificates issued to investors via scheme arranger
Advance clearance granted based on the information disclosed
Raise Money
Commence trade (evidence required)
Submit full application to HMRC (after 4 months of trading)
RECENT CHANGES
15
July 2015 Budget introduced substantial changes to VCT/EIS:
• Lifetime cap of £12m per investee company
• All investments made with intention to “grow and develop” a business (not very clear!)
• Special concessions for “knowledge intensive” businesses
• New funds can not be used to acquire existing trades/shares (incl. Management buyouts for VCTs)
• Reserve power also disqualified (November 2015)
• Any remaining renewable energy schemes (incl. overseas) disqualified from 6 April 2016
EFFECT OF CHANGES
16
• No more renewable energy schemes
• No more schemes with “predictable income” viz reserve power
• Traditional pub EIS model now disqualified
• HMRC forcing focus onto genuine trading businesses
• HMRC also pointing rules towards new/startup businesses at the expense of mature businesses
• Ever lower pension cap driving business to EIS
WHAT TO LOOK FOR: VCT
17
If a new Fund
Track record of managerLook for “total return”, sum of tax relief,tax-free dividends and remaining NAV
If an existing Fund
Quality of portfolio including recent investee company performanceLikelihood of an early exit
If “second-hand” shares
Maturity of underlying businesses – how soon will they exit?No up-front tax relief, but tax-free dividends and CGT free on exit
✔
✔
✔
✔
✔
✔
VCT
WHAT TO LOOK FOR: EIS
18
Track record of manager: How many previous exits? Average return?
Capital preservation or growth? Trades with underlying freeholds?
Fair balance of risk and reward
Commitment of managers: have they invested?
Funds or spread portfolios rather than single companies
✔
✔
✔
✔
✔
EIS
WHAT TO LOOK FOR: SEIS
19
Track record of manager
Any exits yet?
A fund with portfolio spread rather than single company
Generalist or sector specialist?
Technology or non technology?
Capacity for follow on investment
✔
✔
✔
✔
✔
✔
SEIS
WHAT TO LOOK FOR: BPR
20
Balance of yield and security
Solid trades with predictable income streams
Asset-backed
Low fees!
✔
✔
✔
✔
BPR
FUND HIGHLIGHTS
21
TRACK RECORD
ASSET BACKED
NO UP-FRONT FEES
GROWING SECTOR
IMBIBAA Leisure EIS Fund from manager with outstanding track record – average of 35% IRR from 10 previous EIS exits. Most recent exit delivered a 5.7x cash return.
TITANA freehold storage EIS Fund offering capital preservation together with strong projected returns.
GUINNESSA BPR scheme investing in Solar projecting 5% return with no up-front fees.
FINTECH CIRCLEA specialist SEIS Fund investing in FinTech
CONCLUSION
22
“The government’s aim is to make Britain the best place in Europe to do business. The tax-advantaged venture capital schemes continue to be an important part of meeting this
aim, providing valuable support to small and growing businesses seeking finance to develop and grow.”
David GaukeFinancial Secretary
THE TREASURYJuly 2015
SOME USEFUL ADDRESSES
23
EIS Association: www.eisa.org.uk
HMRC: www.hmrc.gov.uk
Enterprise Investment Partners: www.enterprise-ip.com
Martin Sherwood: [email protected] 7843 0472