taboratories, witnesses for the nrc staff, by ucs/nypirg ... · bley, dr. b. john garrick, dr....

7
iw , -2- s Notice is also hereby given that depositions will be taken of Mr. - . Gregory J. Folb, Mr. Jack W. Hickman, Dr. Alan D. Swain, Dr. Ibbert G. Easterling, Dr. Ihvid C. Aldrich, and Dr. G. Bruce Varnado, of Sandia National , taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG at a time and place to be agreed upon. 'Ihe deposition will concern the testimony they will be . providing on behalf of the NRC Staff in the Indian Ibint fpecial Investigation ' proceeding. In addition, Mr. Folb and Mr. Hickman will be examined about Sandia National Iaboratories' review of the Indian Ibint Probabilistic Safety Study, any Sandia reports docunenting that review, and the meeting held . between Sandia, the NRC Staff, and the Licensees at Sandia National M taboratories to discuss this review; Dr. Swain will be examined about his review of the hunan factors and hunan error rate methods used in the Indian Point Probabilistic Safety Study and about the proper use of NUREG/CR-1278; Dr. Easterling will be examined about the use of Bayesian statistical methodologies in probabilistic risk assessment in general and in the Indian . ,; . Ibint Probabilistic Ehfety Study in particular; Dr. Aldrich will be examined about accident consequence analysis in general, his review (if any) of the accident consequence model used in the Indian Ibint Probabilistic Safety Study (i.e., CRACIT), and the results and implications of the report NUREG/CR-2239 for Indian Ibint and for comparision of risk among various reactors; and Dr. Varnado will be examined about sabotage risks at reactors in general, sabotage risks at Indian Ibint in particular, and the application of probabilistic risk assessment methodology to assess risk from sabotage. DATED: 10 December 1982 RESPECTFULLY SUBMI'ITED, W k / Jef frey M. Blum, D3 . Counsel for UCS 3 8212140400 821210 PDR ADOCK 05000247 G PDR L: %

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

iw ,-2-s

Notice is also hereby given that depositions will be taken of Mr.-

.

Gregory J. Folb, Mr. Jack W. Hickman, Dr. Alan D. Swain, Dr. Ibbert G.

Easterling, Dr. Ihvid C. Aldrich, and Dr. G. Bruce Varnado, of Sandia National

,taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG at a time and place

to be agreed upon. 'Ihe deposition will concern the testimony they will be

. providing on behalf of the NRC Staff in the Indian Ibint fpecial Investigation'

proceeding. In addition, Mr. Folb and Mr. Hickman will be examined about

Sandia National Iaboratories' review of the Indian Ibint Probabilistic Safety

Study, any Sandia reports docunenting that review, and the meeting held

. between Sandia, the NRC Staff, and the Licensees at Sandia NationalM

taboratories to discuss this review; Dr. Swain will be examined about his

review of the hunan factors and hunan error rate methods used in the Indian

Point Probabilistic Safety Study and about the proper use of NUREG/CR-1278;

Dr. Easterling will be examined about the use of Bayesian statistical

methodologies in probabilistic risk assessment in general and in the Indian. ,;.

Ibint Probabilistic Ehfety Study in particular; Dr. Aldrich will be examined

about accident consequence analysis in general, his review (if any) of the

accident consequence model used in the Indian Ibint Probabilistic Safety Study

(i.e., CRACIT), and the results and implications of the report NUREG/CR-2239

for Indian Ibint and for comparision of risk among various reactors; and Dr.

Varnado will be examined about sabotage risks at reactors in general, sabotage

risks at Indian Ibint in particular, and the application of probabilistic risk

assessment methodology to assess risk from sabotage.

DATED: 10 December 1982 RESPECTFULLY SUBMI'ITED,

W k /Jef frey M. Blum, D3 .

Counsel for UCS3 8212140400 821210

PDR ADOCK 05000247G PDR

L:

%

Page 2: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

3

p..

. , .

,

Dxkess== c

3; DEC 1319g> :"

TLNITED STATES OF AMERICA -

NUCLEAR REGUIATORY CCMiISSION 3 Norttwsa, *

\' NN 7BEFORE Tile ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING

NCn N

)Is the matter of )

)CONSOLIDATED EDISON C(MPANY OF NEW YORK, INC. ) Ibcket tbs.

(Indian Ibint, thit No. 2) ) 50-247 SP) 50-286 SP

PCMSR AIT1110RITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK }* (Indian Ibint, thit No. 3) ) 10 December 1982)

NCTTICE OF DEPOSITIONS

Notice is hereby given that a deposition will be taken of Dr. Dennis C.

Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson,

witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company of New York, Inc., and the Ibwer

Authority of the State of New York, by (CS/NYIRG at a time and place to be' agreed upon by the parties. 'Ihe deposition will be taken of these witnesses'

as a Innel. 'Ibe deposition will concern the Indian Ibint Probabilistic Safety

Study and other matters upon which the witnesses will be providing testimony

on behalf of the Licensees in the Indian Point Special Investigation

proceeding. In addition, UCS/NYPIRG has requested the witneses to provide all

prior drafts and partial prior drafts of the Indian Ibint Probabilistic Safety

Sttrly for inspection and copying at or prior to the deposition.

b

.

Page 3: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

.

h. -2- -

DATE: 10 December 1982 RESPECTFULLY StBMITTED,'.

'

i

. /. Jeffrey M. Blum, Esq. '

(btmsel for UCS

)

>

!

I

.

J

' " ~ ~ ' - -- . - - - , - - _ _ _ . - r , _ , _

Page 4: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

}- .

a> c).

-s

w,.., -NL:S||C \'}

-- \UNITED STATES T AMERICA DEC 13 igyo f

g{NIELEAR REGUIATORY CCM4ISSION -

e. .. .. u. pBEFORE THE A'lVMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING t gp P, w, gU

- ,!,

)In the matter of )

)CONSOLIDATED EDISON C04PANY T NEW YCRK, INC. ) Ebcket Ws.(Indian Point, thit No. 2) ) 50-247 SP

) 50-286 SPPOVER AlfrHORITY T THE STATE OF NEW YORK )

) (Indian Ibint, thit 2. 3) ) 10 December 1982)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that single copies of "UCS/NYPIRG NTIFICATIGI '1DPARTIES T WI'1NESSES ON C0911SSION QUESTION 'IWO", "NTICE OF DEPOSITIONS" (NRCStaf f Witnesses)", and "NTICE OF DEPOSITIONS" (Licensee Witnesses), wereserved upon the following by deposit in the U.S. mail, first class postageprepaid, this leth day cf December 1982.

F

,

Steven C. Stolly

'Nunzio Palladino, Giairman Victor Gilinsky, CennissionerU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ComissionWashington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

John Nicarne, Comissioner 'Ihomas Roberts, CommissionerU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ComissionWashington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

James Asselstine, Comissioner James P. Gleason, Ehq. , QiairmanU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Adminstrative JudgeWashington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Daard

513 Gilmoure DriveSilver Spring, MD 20901

;

|

,

:

I

Page 5: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

'

-2 -*

,

Dr. Oscar H. Paris Mr. Frederick J. Shon, .

Adminstrative Judge Administrative JudgeAtomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing BoardU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission>

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555,

lbthanne G. Miller, hq. Ibcketing and Service SectionAtomic Safety and Licensing Board Office of the SecretaryU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comunission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ConnissionWashington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

Janice E. More, hq. Atomic Safety and Licensing Board PanelDonald F. Hassell, Esq. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ConnissionHenry J. McGurren, hq. Washington, D.C. 20555Office of the Executive Iagal

Director Atomic Safety and Licensing AppealU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission Board PanelWashington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission

$ Brent L. Brandenburg, Esq.Assistant General G unsel Paul F. Colarulli, Esq.Gnsolidated Edison Company of Joseph J. Ievin, Jr., 2q.New York, Inc. Pamela S. Horowitz, Esq.

4 Irving Place Garles Nrgan, Jr., Ehq.New York, NY 10003 ' Morgan Associates, Cuartered

1899 L Street, N.W.Garles M. Pratt, Ehq. Washington, D.C. 20036Stephen L. Baum, Esq.Power Authority of the State Mayor George V. Begany

of New York Village of Buchananle Columbm Circle 236 Tate AvenueNew York, NY 10019 Buchanan, NY 10511

Jonathon D. Feinberg Stanley B. Klimberg, Esq.New York State Public Service General Gunsel

Commission New York State Ehergy Officeihree Ehpire State Plaza 2 Ibckefeller State PlazaAlbany, NY 12223 Albany, NY 12223

marles J. Nikiah, tsq. Marc L. Parris, Ehq..

Litigation Division Eric 'lhorsen, Ehq.1he Ibrt Authority of New G unty Attorney

York and New Jersey County of Ibckland' Ole vbrld Trade Center 11 New Hempstead Ibad

New York, NY 10048 New City, NY 10956

lbnorable Ruth Nssinger Alfred B. Del BelloMember of the Council of the Westchester County Executive

City of New York Laurie Vetere, Ehq.

District #4 148 Martine AvenueCity thll N1ite Plains, NY 10601New York, NY 10007

F

,

Page 6: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

-

-3- -

Ezra I. Bialik, Esq. Andrew S. Ibffe, Esq..'

Steve taipsiz, 2q. New York State AssenblyEnvironmental Protection Bureau Albany, NY 12248New York State Attorney

General's Office Honorable Richard L. Brodsky'I%o Wrld Trade Center Member of the (bunty IagislatureNew York, NY 10047 Westchester County

(bunty Office BuildingIbnald Davidoff, Director Mite Plains, NY 19601New York State fiadiological

Dnergency Preparedness Group Spence W. Perry, Esq.Onpire State Plaza Office of General Cbunsel'Ibwer Building, Ibom 1750 Federal Bnergency Management AgencyAlbany, NY 12237 500 C Street, S.W.

Washington, D.C. 20472,

Richard F. Czaja, Esq. Stewart M. Glass, Esq.

Siea and Gould inegional Gunsel330 Madison Avenue Federal Bnergency Management Agency

9 New York, NY 10017 lbom 134926 Federal Plaza

Pat Ibsner, Spokesperson New York, NY 10278Parents Concerned About Indian IbintP.O. Box 125 Garles A. Scheiner, Co-01airpersonCroton-on-Hudson, NY 10520 Westchester People's Action

(balition, Inc.

Richard M. Ibrtman, D3q. P.O. Box 488Iorna Salman White Plains, NY 10602Friends of the Earth, Inc.

208 West 13th Street Alan Latman, Esq.'

thw York, NY 10011 44 Sunset DriveCroton-on-Hudson, NY 10520

Judith Fossler, (bordinator

Rockland Citizens for Safe Diergy Zipporah S. Fleisher300 New Ihmpstead Ibad West Branch (bnservation AssociationNew City, NY 10956 443 Buena Vista Ibad*

i

l New City, NY 10956| Ibnce Schwartz, Esq.

| Paul Gessin, Esq. Melvin Coldberg, Staff Attorney

( Iaurens R. Schwartz, Ehq. Joan Ibit, Project Director| Margaret Oppel, Esq. New York Public Interest! Dotein, Ihys, Sklar & Ibrtzberg Ibsearch Group, Inc.

| 200 Park Avenue 9 Murray Street'

New York, NY 10166 thw York, NY 10007

Ibvid B. Duboff Craig Kaplan, Esq.| Westchester Ibople's Action thtional Dnergency Civil

Coalition, Inc. Liberties Committee'

255 Grove Street 175 Fif th Avenue, Suite 712

White Plains, NY 10601 New York, NY 10010;

il

|,

Page 7: taboratories, witnesses for the NRC Staff, by UCS/NYPIRG ... · Bley, Dr. B. John Garrick, Dr. Stanley Kaplan, and Mr. Dennis C. Richardson, witnesses for (bnsolidated Fdison Company

h* _4_

Ms. Ananda Potterfield, Bq. Jeffrey M. Blta, Bq.,

Johnston & George, Attys-at-Iaw New York thiversity Iaw School528 Iowa Nenue 423 Vanderbilt HallIowa City, IA 52240 40 mshington Square South

New York, NY 19012

Joan MilesIndian R) int Gordinator Greater New York Council on mergyNew York City Audubon Society c/o Dean R. Grren, Director71 West 23rd Street, suite 1828 New York thiversityNew York, NY 10010 26 Stuyvesant Street

New York, NY 10003Ellyn R. Weiss, Bq.William S. Jordan, III, Esq. Steven C. EhollyHarmon and Weiss thion of Gncerned Scientists1725 I Street, N.W., Suite 506 1346 Connecticut N enue, N.W., Suite 1101m shington, D.C. 20006 Washington, D.C. 20036

&

.

b

,

I

||

f

|

f"t

|

!

w