sustainable intensification?: implications for the emergence of diseases

1
Sustainable intensifica.on?: Implica.ons for the emergence of diseases Delia Grace, Bernard Be., Fred Unger and Hung Nguyen Currently new diseases are emerging at the rate of one every four months and three out of four of these diseases jump species from other animals. Many of these diseases are associated with agriculture. ILRI led two systema=c reviews of disease emergence and burden to help in priori=sa=on. Pictures Understanding the rela=ons between agricultural intensifica=on and disease emergence has prac=cal implica=ons: Targe=ng hotspots: Iden=fica=on of hot spots for emergence and increasing surveillance in these areas Disease proofing: Iden=fica=on of risk factors and avoiding them as far as possible Cos=ng intensifica=on: Factoring in the costs of emerging disease control and preven=on Delia Grace [email protected] ● P.O. Box 3070900100 Nairobi Kenya ● +254 20 422 3000 hYp://aghealth.wordpress.com ● www.ilri.org Acknowledgements: The CGIAR Research Program on Agriculture for Nutri=on and Health (A4NH) and the Interna=onal Livestock Research Ins=tute (ILRI) Funding: The Department for Interna=onal Development, UK This document is licensed for use under a Crea=ve Commons AYribu=on –Non commercialShare Alike 3.0 Unported License September 2014 There are strong associa=ons with environmental change and disease emergence. Increased disease is associated with habitat fragmenta=on and ecotones, reduced wildlife biodiversity, and encroachment of humans and agriculture into natural ecosystems. There are complex associa=ons with agricultural intensifica=on and disease emergence. Socie=es with intensified agriculture bear a much lower burden of zoono=c disease. Since 1930s most disease emergence has been reported from countries with intensive systems. In the last ten years, propor=onally more emergence events are reported from developing countries. The objec=ve of our studies was to synthesise best available scien=fic knowledge about zoono=c disease transmission through direct or indirect domes=c livestockwildlife interac=on, with emphasis on risk factors, drivers and trajectories of transmission, and promising interven=ons for controlling important zoonoses based on managing livestockwildlife interac=on. A systema=c review was carried out by a mul=disciplinary team with exper=se in zoonoses, epidemiology, socioeconomics and wildlife. Introduc=on Materials and methods Results Research into use Expanded range of JEV in Southeast Asia associated with: Increasing human popula=on increasing irrigated rice produc=on and pig farming Increased habitat for vectors and reservoir hosts increased popula=on density Efficient secondary host – amplifica=on human infec=on (dead end host) Based on Pfeffer and Dobler, 2010, Hurk et al., 2009 Iden=fica=on of themes and search terms Database search; PubMed & CAB Direct, 20062010 Screening by =tle Review of abstracts Review of full papers; evaluate, capture Summary of findings by theme Tsetse fly density and fragmenta=on of natural habitat in eastern Zambia – density lowest where greatest fragmenta=on – likely to disappear (Ducheyne et al., 2009). in tsetseinfested areas of subSaharan Africa, clearance of natural vegeta=on, loss of large wildlife led to neardisappearance of tsetse in some areas (Bossche et al., 2010) Animal suffering from trypanosomosis September 2014

Upload: ilri

Post on 20-Aug-2015

464 views

Category:

Science


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Sustainable  intensifica.on?:    Implica.ons  for  the  emergence  of  diseases  Delia  Grace,  Bernard  Be.,  Fred  Unger  and  Hung  Nguyen    

Currently  new  diseases  are  emerging  at  the  rate  of  one  every  four  months  and  three  out  of  four  of  these  diseases  jump  species  from  other  animals.  Many  of  these  diseases  are  associated  with  agriculture.  ILRI  led  two  systema=c  reviews  of  disease  emergence  and  burden  to  help  in  priori=sa=on.  

Pictures  

Understanding  the  rela=ons  between  agricultural  intensifica=on  and  disease  emergence  has  prac=cal  implica=ons:  •  Targe=ng  hotspots:  Iden=fica=on  of  hot  spots  for  emergence  and  increasing  surveillance  in  these  areas  •  Disease  proofing:  Iden=fica=on  of  risk  factors  and  avoiding  them  as  far  as  possible  •  Cos=ng  intensifica=on:  Factoring  in  the  costs  of  emerging  disease  control  and  preven=on  

Delia  Grace  [email protected]  ●  P.O.  Box  30709-­‐00100  Nairobi    Kenya    ●    +254  20  422  3000    hYp://aghealth.wordpress.com  ●      www.ilri.org          Acknowledgements:  The  CGIAR  Research  Program  on  Agriculture  for  Nutri=on  and  Health  (A4NH)  and  the  Interna=onal  Livestock  Research  Ins=tute  (ILRI)  Funding:  The  Department  for  Interna=onal  Development,  UK  

This  document  is  licensed  for  use  under  a  Crea=ve  Commons  AYribu=on  –Non  commercial-­‐Share  Alike  3.0  Unported  License                                                                                September  2014  

There  are  strong  associa=ons  with  environmental  change  and  disease  emergence.  Increased  disease  is  associated  with  habitat  fragmenta=on  and  ecotones,  reduced  wildlife  biodiversity,  and  encroachment  of  humans  and  agriculture  into  natural  ecosystems.    

There  are  complex  associa=ons  with  agricultural  intensifica=on  and  disease  emergence.  

•  Socie=es  with  intensified  agriculture  bear  a  much  lower  burden  of  zoono=c  disease.  

•  Since  1930s  most  disease  emergence  has  been  reported  from  countries  with  intensive  systems.  

•  In  the  last  ten  years,  propor=onally  more  emergence  events  are  reported  from  developing  countries.    

The  objec=ve  of  our  studies  was  to  synthesise  best  available  scien=fic  knowledge  about  zoono=c  disease  transmission  through  direct  or  indirect  domes=c  livestock-­‐wildlife  interac=on,  with  emphasis  on  risk  factors,  drivers  and  trajectories  of  transmission,  and  promising  interven=ons  for  controlling  important  zoonoses  based  on  managing  livestock-­‐wildlife  interac=on.  

 

 

A  systema=c  review  was  carried  out  by  a  mul=-­‐disciplinary  team  with  exper=se  in  zoonoses,  epidemiology,  socio-­‐economics  and  wildlife.    

 

 

Introduc=on  

Materials  and  methods  

Results  

Research  into  use  

Expanded  range  of  JEV  in  Southeast  Asia  associated  with:  -­‐ Increasing  human  popula=on  -­‐   increasing  irrigated  rice  produc=on  and  pig  farming  

Increased  habitat  for  vectors  and  reservoir  hosts  è        increased  popula=on  density  Efficient  secondary  host  –  amplifica=on    è          human  infec=on  (dead  end  host)  

Based  on  Pfeffer  and  Dobler,  2010,  Hurk  et  al.,  2009  

Iden=fica=on  of  themes  and  search  terms  

Database  search;  PubMed  &  CAB  Direct,  2006-­‐2010  

Screening  by  =tle  

Review  of  abstracts  

Review  of  full  papers;  evaluate,  capture  

Summary  of  findings  by  theme  

Tsetse  fly  density  and  fragmenta=on  of  natural  habitat  in  eastern  Zambia  –  density  lowest  where  greatest  fragmenta=on  –  likely  to  

disappear  (Ducheyne  et  al.,  2009).  in  tsetse-­‐infested  areas  of  sub-­‐Saharan  Africa,  clearance  of  natural  

vegeta=on,  loss  of  large  wildlife    led  to  near-­‐disappearance  of  tsetse  in  some  areas  (Bossche  et  al.,  2010)    

Animal suffering from trypanosomosis

September  2014