sustainable development 2. sustainable agriculture sustainable agriculture integrates three main...

29
Sustainable development 2

Upload: giles-brown

Post on 25-Dec-2015

220 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

Sustainable development 2

Page 2: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Sustainable agriculture

• Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability, and prosperous farming communities. These goals have been defined by a variety of disciplines and may be looked at from the vantage point of the farmer or the consumer.

Page 3: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Description• Sustainable agriculture refers to the ability of a farm to produce food indefinitely,

without causing irreversible damage to ecosystem health. Two key issues are biophysical (the long-term effects of various practices on soil properties and processes essential for crop productivity) and socio-economic (the long-term ability of farmers to obtain inputs and manage resources such as labor).

• The physical aspects of sustainability are partly understood (Altieri 1995). Practices that can cause long-term damage to soil include excessive tillage (leading to erosion) and irrigation without adequate drainage (leading to accumulation of salt in the soil). Long-term experiments provide some of the best data on how various practices affect soil properties essential to sustainability.

• While air and sunlight are generally available in most geographic locations, crops also depend on soil nutrients and the availability of water. When farmers grow and harvest crops, they remove some of these nutrients from the soil. Without replenishment, the land would suffer from nutrient depletion and be unusable for further farming. Sustainable agriculture depends on replenishing the soil while minimizing the use of non-renewable resources, such as natural gas (used in converting atmospheric nitrogen into synthetic fertilizer), or mineral ores (e.g., phosphate).

Page 4: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Possible sources of nitrogen that would, in principle, be available indefinitely, include:

• recycling crop waste and livestock or human manure • growing legume crops and forages such as, peanuts, or

alfalfa that form symbioses with nitrogen-fixing bacteria called rhizobia

• industrial production of nitrogen by the Haber Process uses hydrogen, which is currently derived from natural gas, but could instead be made by electrolysis of water using electricity (perhaps from solar cells or windmills) or

• genetically engineering (non-legume) crops to form nitrogen-fixing symbioses or fix nitrogen without microbial symbionts.

Page 5: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• The last option was proposed in the 1970s, but would be well beyond the capability of current (2006) technology, even if various concerns about biotechnology were addressed. Sustainable options for replacing other nutrient inputs (phosphorus, potassium, etc.) are more limited.

• In some areas, sufficient rainfall is available for crop growth, but many other areas require irrigation. For irrigation systems to be sustainable they must be managed properly (to avoid salt accumulation) and not use more water from their source than is naturally replenished, otherwise the water source becomes, in effect, a non-renewable resource. Improvements in water well drilling technology and the development of submersible pumps have made it possible for large crops to be regularly grown where reliance on rainfall alone previously made this level of success unpredictable. However, this progress has come at a price, in that in many areas where this has occurred, such as the Ogallala Aquifer, the water is being used at a greater rate than its rate of recharge.

• Socioeconomic aspects of sustainability are also partly understood. Regarding nonindustrialized farming, the best known analysis is Netting's (1993) study on smallholder systems through history.

Page 6: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Economics• Given the finite supply of natural resources, agriculture

that is inefficient may eventually exhaust the available resources or the ability to afford and acquire them. It may also generate negative externality, such as pollution as well as financial and production costs. Agriculture that relies mainly on inputs that are extracted from the earth's crust or produced by society, contributes to the depletion and degradation of the environment. Despite this continuing practice, unsustainable agriculture continues because it is financially more cost-effective than sustainable agriculture in the short term.

Page 7: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• In an economic context, the need for the farm to generate revenue depends on the extent to which it is market oriented and on government subsidy. The way that crops are sold must be accounted for in the sustainability equation. Fresh food sold from a farm stand requires little additional energy, aside from that necessary for cultivation, harvest, and transportation (including consumers). Food sold at a remote location, whether at a farmers' market or the supermarket, incurs a different set of energy cost for materials, labour, and transport.

• To be sold at a remote location requires a complex economic system in which the farm producers form the first link in a chain of processors and handlers to the consumers. This practice allows greater revenue because of efficient transport of a large number of items, but because it produces externalities and relies on the use of non-renewable resources, shipping, processing, and handling, it is not considered sustainable[citation needed]. Moreover, such a system is considered vulnerable to fluctuations, such as strikes, oil prices, and global economic conditions including labour, interest rates, futures markets, and farm product prices[citation needed].

Page 8: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• In Third World agriculture, much of what is known about the social components of sustainability comes from anthropologist Robert Netting's work. In Smallholders, Householders: Farm Families and the Ecology of Intensive, Sustainable Agriculture, he defines an important cross-cultural pattern of high-labor, high-production cultivation exemplified East Asian paddy rice cultivators, African cultivators such as the Kofyar, alpine peasants, and Mesoamrican farmers of raised fields. One key to socio-economic sustainability in such systems is that these farmers systems provide for much of their own subsistence and also participate in the market.

• From a system's view, the gain and loss factors for sustainability can be listed. The most important factors for an individual site are sun, air, soil and water as rainfall. These are naturally present in the system as part of the larger planetary processes and incur no costs. Of the four, soil quality and quantity are most amenable to human intervention through time and labour. (The economic input depends solely on the price of labour and cost of machinery used).

• Natural growth and outputs are also subject to human intervention. What grows and how and where it is grown are a matter of choice. Two of the many possible practices of sustainable agriculture are crop rotation and soil amendment, both designed to ensure that crops being cultivated can obtain the necessary nutrients for healthy growth.

Page 9: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Methods• Monoculture, a method of growing only one crop at a time in a given

field, is a very widespread practice, but there are questions about its sustainability, especially if the same crop is grown every]. Growing a mixture of crops (polyculture) sometimes reduces disease or pest problems (Nature 406:718, Environ. Entomol. 12:625) but polyculture has rarely, if ever, been compared to the more widespread practice of growing different crops in successive years crop rotation with the same overall crop]. For example, how does growing a corn-bean mixture every year compare with growing corn and bean in alternate years? Cropping systems that include a variety of crops (polyculture and/or rotation) may also use replenish nitrogen (if legumes are included) and may also use resources such as sunlight, water, or nutrients more efficiently (Field Crops Res. 34:239)

Page 10: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Some pesticides, though sometimes useful in the short term, can harm the soil food web, a complex ecology of micro-organisms in soil that helps sustain the plant from the roots down[]. Experiments comparing plants grown in soil compared to plants grown through hydroponics have shown a thirty-three percent higher growth rate when there are beneficial soil microorganisms available[citation needed].

• Certain pesticides synthesized by chemical companies can impart a sometimes fatal toxicity to humans[citation needed], livestock and insect pollinators, such as bees and butterflies, which may be necessary for plant success[citation needed]. Without insect pollinators, farm labor must be expended to manually pollinate each plant. Crops such as cacao beans and vanilla are examples of crops requiring highly labor-intensive practices in the absence of natural pollinators.

Page 12: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Many scientists, farmers, and businesses have debated how to make agriculture farming sustainable[citation needed]. One of the many practices includes growing a diverse number of perennial crops in a single field, each of which would grow in separate season so as not to compete with each other for natural resources[citation needed]. This system would replicate the biodiversity already found in a natural environment, resulting in increased resistance to diseases and decreased effects of erosion and loss of nutrients in soil[citation needed]. Nitrogen fixation from legumes, for example, used in conjunction with plants that rely on nitrate from soil for growth, will allow the land to be reused annually[citation needed]. Legumes will grow for a season and replenish the soil with ammonium and nitrate, and the next season other plants can be seeded and grown in the field in preparation for harvest[citation needed]. This method is considered to require a minimal amount of outside resources[citation needed].

Page 13: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• In practice, there is no single approach to sustainable agriculture, as the precise goals and methods must be adapted to each individual case. There may be some techniques of farming that are inherently in conflict with the concept of sustainability, but there is widespread misunderstanding on impacts of some practices. For example, the slash-and-burn techniques that are the characteristic feature of shifting cultivators are often cited as inherently destructive, yet slash-and-burn cultivation has been practiced in the Amazon for at least 6000 years (Sponsel 1986); serious deforestation did not begin until the 1970s, largely as the result of Brazilian government programs and policies (Hecht and Cockburn 1989).

Page 14: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Urban planning• There has been considerable debate about which form of human residential habitat may be a

better social form for sustainable agriculture. Generally, it is thought that village communities can improve sustainability in that such communities tend to provide a cooperative environment that supports farming[citation needed].

• Many environmentalists pushing for increased population density to preserve agricultural land point out that urban sprawl is less sustainable and more damaging to the environment than living in the cities where cars are not needed because food and other necessities are within walking distance[citation needed]. However, others have theorized that sustainable ecocities, or ecovillages which combine habitation and farming with close proximity between producers and consumers, may provide greater sustainability[citation needed].

• The use of available city space (e.g., rooftop gardens and community gardens) for cooperative food production is another way to achieve greater sustainability[citation needed].

• One of the latest ideas in achieving sustainable agricultural involves shifting the production of food plants from major factory farming operations to large, urban, technical facilities called vertical farms. The advantages of vertical farming include year-round production, isolation from pests and diseases, controllable resource recycling, and on-site production that eliminates the need for transportation costs[citation needed]. While a vertical farm has yet to become a reality, the idea is gaining momentum among those who believe that current sustainable farming methods will be insufficient to provide for a growing global population[citation needed].

Page 15: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• References• Altieri, Miguel A. (1995) Agroecology: The science of sustainable agriculture.

Westview Press, Boulder, CO. • Jahn, GC, B. Khiev, C. Pol, N. Chhorn, S. Pheng, and V. Preap. 2001. Developing

sustainable pest management for rice in Cambodia. pp. 243-258, In S. Suthipradit, C. Kuntha, S. Lorlowhakarn, and J. Rakngan [eds.] “Sustainable Agriculture: Possibility and Direction” Proceedings of the 2nd Asia-Pacific Conference on Sustainable Agriculture 18-20 October 1999, Phitsanulok, Thailand. Bangkok (Thailand): National Science and Technology Development Agency. 386 p.

• Lindsay Falvey (2004) Sustainability - Elusive or Illusion: Wise Environmental Management. Institute for International Development, Adelaide pp259.

• Hecht, Susanna and Alexander Cockburn (1989) The Fate of the Forest: developers, destroyers and defenders of the Amazon. New York: Verso.

• Netting, Robert McC. (1993) Smallholders, Householders: Farm Families and the Ecology of Intensive, Sustainable Agriculture. Stanford Univ. Press, Palo Alto.

• Sponsel, Leslie E. (1986) Amazon ecology and adaptation. Annual Review of Anthropology 15: 67-97.

Page 16: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Sustainable industries• From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia• Jump to: navigation, search• The earliest mention of the phrase sustainable industries appeared in 1990 in a story about a

Japanese group reforesting a tropical forest to help create sustainable industries for the local populace. (Dietrich, Bill. "Our Troubled Earth – Japan." The Seattle Times. November 13, 1990. Page F-2.) Soon after, a study entitled “Jobs in a Sustainable Economy” by Michael Renner of the Worldwatch Institute was published, using the term sustainable industries. (1991)

• This 1991 report concluded, "Contrary to the jobs-versus-owls rhetoric that blames environmental restrictions for layoffs, the movement toward an environmentally sustainable global economy will create far more jobs than it eliminates. The chief reason: non-polluting, environmentally sustainable industries tend to be intrinsically more labour intensive and less resource intensive than traditional processes." While the conclusion may be subject to some debate, it nevertheless formed an important Among the features of sustainable industry offered in the paper were energy efficiency, resource conservation to meet the needs of future generations, safe and skill-enhancing working conditions, low waste production processes, and the use of safe and environmentally compatible materials. Some of the benefits, however would be offset by higher prices (due to labor costs) and a theoretically larger population needed to perform the same amount of work, increasing the agricultural and other loads on

Page 17: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Sustainable energy sources are energy sources which are not expected to be depleted in a timeframe relevant to the human race, and which therefore contribute to the sustainability of all species. This concept is termed sustainability. An additional criterion for strict sustainability, useful for short- and medium-term decisions is social and political sustainability of an energy technology.

• Sustainable energy sources are most often regarded as including all renewable sources, such as solar power, wind power, wave power, geothermal power, tidal power, and others.

• Fission power and fusion power meet the definition of sustainability, but there is controversy over whether or not they should be regarded as sustainable for social and political reasons

Page 18: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Renewable energy sources• • • Wind power is one of the most environmentally friendly sources of

renewable energy– Main article: renewable energy

• Renewable energy sources are those whose stock is rapidly replenished by natural processes, and which aren't expected to be depleted within the lifetime of the human species. In most cases, these energy sources have technical challenges to overcome before they are economically competitive with conventional methods of electricity generation. Approaches to overcoming these challenges are a field of active research, and are described on the relevant generation method pages.

Page 19: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• The well-known renewable energy options can be classified by the natural process that provides their energy:

• Direct solar energy:• Solar cells use semiconductors to directly convert sunlight into

electricity. Primary challenges with their use are low efficiency, energy-intensive manufacture, and power variability due to weather and nightfall.

• Solar thermal plants use concentrated sunlight as a heat source to power a heat engine which generates electricity. Primary challenges with their use are manufacture and maintenance of large mirror arrays and power variability due to weather and nightfall.

• Solar updraft tower plants use sunlight to heat a contained mass of air, setting up convection currents that cause air to exit through a chimney from which power is tapped. Primary challenges with their use are low efficiency, construction and maintenance of the large structures required, and power variability due to weather (a Solar updraft tower has enough heat capacity to function through night).

Page 20: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Indirect solar energy:• Ocean thermal energy conversion uses the temperature difference between the

warmer surface of the ocean and the cooler lower depths to drive a heat engine. The primary challenges with ocean thermal energy conversion's use are low efficiency and the construction and maintenance of large structures in a sea environment.

• Wind power uses wind turbines to draw energy from large-scale motion of air. The primary challenges with wind power's use are the large areas required to produce useful amounts of electricity, and power variability due to weather.

• Hydroelectricity uses dams to draw energy from the flow of water from high-altitude areas to areas with lower altitudes. Primary challenges with hydroelectricity's use are the environmental damage caused by the construction of dams, and the scarcity of remaining sites for power generation.

• Wave power uses floats to extract mechanical energy from the motion of waves. Primary challenges with wave power's use are the large areas required to produce useful amounts of electricity, and disruption of coastal environments.

• Biofuel uses products of plants, animals, or bacteria to provide fuels that can be used in a manner similar to fossil fuels. The primary challenge with biofuel's use is the availability of suitable feedstock in sufficient quantity for large-scale adoption. The environmental and economic benefits of non-cellulosic ethanol have been heavily critiqued by many, including Brad Ewing of Environmental Economics & Sustainable Development[1] and Lester R. Brown of Earth Policy Institute[2]

Page 21: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Radioactive decay within the Earth:• Geothermal power uses the temperature difference between the earth's surface and

its interior to drive a heat engine, generally at a location such as a hot spring where the heat has been transported most of the way to the surface by natural processes. The primary challenge with geothermal power's use is low power generation efficiency for most sites.

• Rotation of the Earth:• Tidal power uses dams to draw energy from the changes in water height due to tides

produced by the gravitational influences of the moon and sun as Earth rotates. The primary challenges with tidal power's use are the large area required to produce useful amounts of electricity, and disruption of coastal environments.

• Processes powered by solar energy will be renewed for as long as the sun remains on the main sequence (approximately 5 billion years). Processes powered by radioactive decay within the Earth will be renewed for time comparable to the half-life of uranium 238 (4.5 billion years) and thorium 232 (14 billion years). Processes powered by the Earth's rotation will last until the Earth becomes tidally locked to the Sun (though tidal acceleration would eject the moon from Earth orbit earlier). Both of these would take longer than the expected lifetime of the sun to occur.

Page 22: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Sustainable sources not considered renewable

• Sustainable energy sources that aren't renewable are those whose stock is not replenished, but for which the presently available stocks are expected to last for as long as human civilization cares to use them.

• These energy sources are derived from nuclear energy, as other forms of stored energy found on Earth do not have sufficient energy density to supply humanity indefinitely.

Page 23: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Fission power uses the nuclear fission of heavy elements to release energy that drives a heat engine. Primary challenges with the use of fission power are the production of small quantities of highly-radioactive waste in the form of spent fuel, larger quantities of less-radioactive waste in the form of activated structural material, and (for use as a long-term power source) the need to perform intensive processing of highly-radioactive fuel bundles, both to reclaim unused fuel in spent fuel rods, and to reclaim plutonium 239 and uranium 233 that have been bred from uranium 238 and thorium 232, respectively.

• Fusion power uses the nuclear fusion of isotopes of hydrogen to release energy that drives a heat engine. Primary challenges with the use of fusion power are that the technology required to build a useful fusion power plant are still under development, and that substantial quantities of radioactive waste in the form of activated structural material is produced.

• Fission power's long-term sustainability depends on the amount of uranium and thorium that is available to be mined. Estimates for fuel reserves vary widely, but if breeder reactors and fuel reprocessing are assumed, tend to be tens of thousands of years or longer (uranium is approximately as common in Earth's crust as tin or zinc (2 ppm), and thorium as common as lead (6 ppm)).

Page 24: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Fusion power's long-term sustainability depends on the amount of lithium that is available to be mined (for deuterium-tritium fusion), or the amount of deuterium available in seawater (for deuterium-deuterium fusion). Lithium is a reasonably common component of Earth's crust, being about 10 times as common as thorium (65 ppm). Deuterium (a hydrogen isotope) occurs wherever hydrogen is found (principally in water), at about 150 ppm. As it can be extracted easily from seawater, economically viable reserves of deuterium are for practical purposes unlimited.

Page 25: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Technical sustainability of nuclear power• Discussions are re-emerging on proper

classification of nuclear energy under such umbrella terms as "renewable" and "sustainable" These attributes bring moral gains or eligibility for development aid under various jurisdictions.

• The primary argument in favor of "renewable" status is the relatively inexhaustible supply of fuel available (uranium and thorium for fission or hydrogen for fusion). See also: Renewable energy, Nuclear power section.

Page 26: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Proponents, such as environmentalists James Lovelock, Patrick Moore (Greenpeace co-founder), Stewart Brand (creator of The Whole Earth Catalog), and Norris McDonald (president of the AAEA), also claim that nuclear power is at least as environmentally friendly as traditional sources of renewable energy, making it the best future solution to global warming and the world's growing need for energy. They note that nuclear power plants produce little carbon dioxide emissions and claim that the radioactive waste produced is minimal and well-contained, especially compared to fossil fuels. [3]

Page 27: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• In 2001, professors Jan Willem Storm van Leeuwen and Philip Smith released a study which argued that, though nuclear plants don't produce any CO2 directly, the energy required for the rest of the nuclear fuel cycle (uranium mining, enrichment, transportation) and power plant life cycle (construction, maintenance, decommissioning) leads to significant carbon dioxide emissions, especially as usage of lower-grade uranium becomes necessary.[4] In 2000, however, Frans H. Koch of the International Energy Agency reported that, although it is correct that the nuclear life cycle produces greenhouse gases, these emissions are actually less than the life cycle emissions of other renewables, like solar and wind, and drastically less than fossil fuels.[5]

Page 28: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Political sustainability of nuclear power• This section is a stub. You can help by expanding it.Some critics of

nuclear energy argue that deployment of nuclear reactors in many countries would accelerate the proliferation of nuclear weapons technology that has many links with civilian use of nuclear materials. Some nuclear reactors (especially heavy water moderated reactors) create the materials necessary for these weapons.

• The issue of fuel reprocessing and/or long-term repository of nuclear waste materials also remains contentious. Very few coutries have developed waste depositories for high-level radioactive waste (see: Yucca Mountain Repository USA; Gorleben Germany; Forsmark, Sweden).

• Due to opposition to nuclear power many countries (Austria, Italy, Sweden, Germany) have effectively banned further development of nuclear energy showing a clear lack of political sustainability under present conditions.

Page 29: Sustainable development 2. Sustainable agriculture Sustainable agriculture integrates three main goals: environmental stewardship, farm profitability,

• Living machines• From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia• Jump to: navigation, search• • • The living machine at Oberlin College with a settlement tank in the foreground and

filtering tanks in the background• Living Machines are a form of biological wastewater treatment designed to mimic

the cleansing functions of wetlands. They are intensive bioremediation systems that can also produce beneficial by-products such as methane gas, edible and ornamental plants, and fish. Aquatic and wetland plants, bacteria, algae, protozoa, plankton, snails, clams, fish and other organisms are used in the system to provide specific cleansing or trophic functions. In temperate climates, the system of tanks, pipes and filters is housed in a greenhouse to raise the temperature, and thus the rate of biological activity. The initial development of living machines is generally credited to John Todd, and evolved out of the bioshelter concept developed at the now-defunct New Alchemy Institute. Living Machine is a trademarked term held by Living Designs Group, LLC of Taos, New Mexico. Living machines fall within the emerging discipline of ecological engineering, and many similar systems are built in Europe without being dubbed “Living Machines.”