sunfest 2004: final presentation€¦ · sunfest 2004: final presentation david jamison, iv dawn...

29
SUNFEST 2004: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade Johannessen: graduate advisor McKay Orthopaedic Surgery Research Laboratory McKay Orthopaedic Surgery Research Laboratory

Upload: others

Post on 31-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

SUNFEST 2004: SUNFEST 2004: Final PresentationFinal Presentation

David Jamison, IVDawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor

Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisorWade Johannessen: graduate advisor

McKay Orthopaedic Surgery Research LaboratoryMcKay Orthopaedic Surgery Research Laboratory

Page 2: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Two Projects♦ Primary: Mouse

Intervertebral Disc (IVD) Imaging and Analysis Protocol Enhancement

♦ Secondary: Compression Testing Device

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 3: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Compression Testing DeviceCompression Testing Device

Wade Johannessen: project advisor

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 4: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Background♦Graduate thesis…

– Disc degeneration begins in the nucleus pulposus

– Direct compressive testing is needed on both healthy and degenerated nucleus samples

♦The Device– Applies a load directly to the sample– Using computer interface, measures and

displays compressive force applied and sample displacement

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 5: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

•Motor

•LVDT

•Sample chamber

•Load sensor

How it works…

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 6: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Procedure

♦Assemble parts♦Calibration

– LVDT– Load sensor

♦Create computer interface♦Test on various samples

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 7: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

LVDT calibrationVoltage vs. Position

y = 0.5515x + 15.927R2 = 1

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

-6.00 -4.00 -2.00 0.00 2.00 4.00 6.00

Voltage (V)

Posi

tion

final relationship: position .5515*V

Page 8: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Currently and Future

♦All parts have arrived– Some remain to be assembled

♦Finish creating interface♦Test

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 9: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Mouse Intervertebral Disc Mouse Intervertebral Disc Imaging and Analysis Imaging and Analysis Protocol EnhancementProtocol Enhancement

Chandra S. Yerramalli: project advisor

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 10: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Background

♦Former senior design project– Premise: Create a mechanical model of the

mouse IVD– Use this information to then model the human

lumbar disc♦Designed a protocol which would:

– Show both the gross disc and nucleus pulposus areas separately

– Calculate area measurements

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 11: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Previous Project

Block / Process Diagram

Mouse Specimen Spine/ tailDissection

Fix spine/tail inFormalin solution

Create IVD cross-section

Stain IVDcross-section

Use microtome to create flat surfacefor measurement

Mount IVDon slide

(optional)

Make digital imageusing light microscope

Input image into software;

extract areas

* Copied from Patrick Antkowiak’s slide presentation

Page 12: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

The Intervertebral Disc

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/imagepages/19469.htm

Page 13: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

My Project♦ Protocol enhancement

– Improving the sectioning, staining and imaging process

– Add more measurements to the MatLab program

♦ Three Steps:1. Understanding the

former protocol2. Devise

improvements/ enhancements

3. Execute new, improved protocol

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 14: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Obstacles/Difficulties

♦Working with soft tissues♦Finding out which methods for staining,

sectioning, etc. worked best♦Working on two projects at once♦No programming experience

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 15: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Improving the sectioning and staining

Page 16: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Improving the MatLab program♦ Original Outputs

– Gross disc area– Nucleus area– Annulus area– Binary image of the

disc and nucleus

♦ Current Outputs– All those mentioned before

plus…– A plot of the major and

minor axes of both the gross disc and nucleus, as well as the centroids of both

– Length of all axes– “offset value”: the distance

between the two centroids– Aspect ratio (maj axis/min

axis)

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 17: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade
Page 18: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade
Page 19: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade
Page 20: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade
Page 21: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade
Page 22: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

But wait…♦These clicks are at random♦How do we know the resulting centroid

plots, major and minor axes, and all the measurements based off them are valid?

♦Short study– 15 trials of random clicks on the same disc– Compiled the function outputs for all trials– Took average and standard deviation

measurements

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 23: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

0.97%

1.83%

1.39% 1.37%

0.00%

0.20%

0.40%

0.60%

0.80%

1.00%

1.20%

1.40%

1.60%

1.80%

2.00%

gross area anulus area nucleus area % nucleus

Percent Deviation vs. Area Measurements

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 24: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

0.66%

0.98%

2.79%

0.76%

0.00%

0.50%

1.00%

1.50%

2.00%

2.50%

3.00%

min axis, gross maj, axis gross min axis, np maj axis, np

Percent Deviation vs Axis Measurements

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 25: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

12.65%

1.06%

2.74%

0.00%

2.00%

4.00%

6.00%

8.00%

10.00%

12.00%

14.00%

centroid seperation aspect ratio, gross aspect ratio, np

Percent Deviation vs. Measurements

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 26: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Next Steps

♦Explore other methods of calculating and plotting the axes

♦Use this protocol in a study– Compare geometric properties and see if a

correlation between that and mechanical properties exists

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 27: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Takeaways♦Programming experience♦Dissection♦Familiarity with lab equipment♦Basic understanding of the spine and

biomechanics in general♦How research is done

– From idea to abstract to journal article♦ Insight into future career path

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 28: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Thank you!

♦Dr. Louis Soslowsky and Dr. Dawn Elliott♦Everyone at McKay Orthopaedic

Laboratory♦Penn Library staff♦My advisors♦SUNFEST♦You!

SUNFEST 2004 U of P McKay Ortho Lab

Page 29: SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation€¦ · SUNFEST 2004: Final Presentation David Jamison, IV Dawn Elliott, Ph.D: faculty advisor Chandra S. Yerramalli, Ph.D: post-doc advisor Wade

Questions?