submissions volume 1 coastal marine area - pakiri …

I hereby give notice that a hearing by commissioners will be held on: Date: Monday 1 – Friday 12 March 2021 Time: 9.30 a.m. Meeting Room: Warkworth Town Hall Venue: 2 Alnwick Street, Warkworth

SUBMISSIONS VOLUME 1

COASTAL MARINE AREA - PAKIRI SAND EXTRACTION

KAIPARA LIMITED COMMISSIONERS Chairperson Les Simmons Commissioners Karyn Kurzeja Melean Absolum

Juliane Chetham

Sam Otter SENIOR HEARINGS ADVISOR Telephone: 09 353 9587 or 021 196 2582 Email: [email protected] Website: www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz

Coastal Marine Area - Pakiri Sand Extraction Monday 1 March 2020

SUBMITTERS: Volume 1

Page 19 David Otene Joyce Page 22 Michael Bradford Page 24 Philippa Muller Page 26 Blake Zuill Page 28 Josie Gritten Page 30 Catherine Ryan Page 32 Jess Sodo Page 34 Jack Gordon Page 36 Alex Flavell-Johnson

Page 38 Mangawhai Board Riders / Independent • Tony Baker

Page 40 Brendon van de Lagemaat Page 42 Camilo Martinez Page 44 Freddie Cleverley Page 46 Basil Rademakers Page 48 Nara Mailin Torres Ramirez Page 50 Jude Burton Page 52 Steve Diprose Page 54 Richard Østmo Scott Page 56 Larissa Chelsea Long Page 58 Sinclair Dominikovich-Murray Page 60 Mikaila Anne Hudson Page 62 River Jones Gardner Page 64 Julia Carr Page 66 Anna Victoria Hislop Page 68 Ewa Bednarczyk

Page 70 Te Arai Board Riders

• Peter Richards Page 72 Michael Innes Page 74 James Brunt Page 76 James McGirr Page 78 Dan Redman Page 80 Joseph Hassell Page 82 Oscar Gunn Page 84 Michael Ripley Page 86 Vivien Kennerley Page 88 Geer Iseke Page 98 Matthew Scott Page 100 Gordon Phillip Hosking Page 102 Michael Kevin George Long


Page 104 Andrew Martin Page 106 Ethan Carson-Groom Page 108 Ronen Lahav Page 110 Craig Mathieson Page 112 Michael Guy Cook Page 114 Margaret Estall Page 116 Kate Matheson Page 118 Helen Smith Page 120 Jerem McLay Page 122 Leslie Paul Francois Page 124 & 162

Pakiri Landcare • Nick Molloy and Frankie Hofland

Page 126 Fraser Falconer Page 128 Adriane Swinburn Page 130 Alex McLean Page 132 Tom McCarthy Page 134 Julie Marie Atkinson Page 136 Grace Vujnovich Page 138 Zoe Gimring Page 140 Diane Greenwood Page 142 Megan Browne

Page 144 Williams Whanau Group

• Sammy Eric Dean Williams Page 146 Zak Samuel Smith Page 148 Sharon Amelia Williams Page 150 Grass Esposti Page 152 Holly Stevens Page 154 Xavia Healey-Diaz

Page 156 Pakiri Beach Horse Rides Ltd

• Sharley Haddon Page 158 Lydia Green Page 160 Kelly Norton Page 164 Helen Jamieson Page 166 Helena Cullen Page 168 Greg Askey Page 170 Frankie Hofland Page 172 Fynn Pilkington Page 174 Vanessa Askey Page 176 Chris Jamieson Page 178 Debra Searchfield Page 180 Clifton Hart Page 182 Fi Jamieson


Page 184 Troy Williams Page 186 Jo Ealand Page 188 Sasha Jamieson Page 190 Cherie Williams Page 192 Corinne Callinan Page 194 Megan Bennett Page 196 Alison Baird Page 198 Tim Kidd Page 200 Kirsty Millar Page 202 Lou Dennis Page 204 Emma-Jean Joyce Page 206 Kathryn Williams Page 208 Tangi Holt Page 210 Marama Rawhiti Page 212 Shaun Williams Page 214 Ariana Brown Page 216 Moana Robson Page 218 Kurt Williams Page 220 Lisa Foden Page 222 Teagan Greenwood Page 224 Margaret Fishlock Page 226 Robin Morris Page 228 Glenys McBain Page 230 Vivienne Patricia Martens Page 232 David Reid Page 234 Susan Wiehahn Page 236 Leigh Samuel

Page 238 Aggregate and Quarry Assc. of New Zealand • Wayne Scott

Page 242 Corlene Greenwood Page 244 Svenja Gerth Page 246 Zofia Seymour Page 249 Melanie Scott Page 253 Greg and Davin Bradford Page 255 Marion and David Pilmer Page 257 Olivia Watkins Page 259 Alan Greenwood Page 261 Sue Clayton Page 263 Glenn Pope Page 265 Collin Juneau Page 267 Maxwell Norman Rollo Kidd Page 269 Helen Margaret Parkes


Page 271 Keziah Gallagher Page 273 Matthew Holdsworth Page 275 Tony Enderby Page 277 Nichelle Phillips Page 279 Amanda Tunstall Page 281 Gillian Kaye Cottrell Page 283 Courtney Henley-Smith Page 285 Lorraine Brien Page 287 Myles Williams Page 289 Devon Taylor Page 291 Troy Jordan Williams Page 293 Kathrine Norman Page 295 Damon Clapshaw Page 297 Martin Graham Johanson Page 299 Bridgette Rademakers

Page 302 Surfbreak Protection Society

• Paul Shanks Page 307 Kutumi Lefferts Page 309 Kara Stones Page 311 Vanessa Vujcich Page 313 Ryan Vujcich Page 315 Christopher Patterson Page 317 Thomas Rutherford Page 319 Sherie Wikaira Page 321 Isaac Reid Page 323 Gary Iseke Page 325 Jannine Wilkinson Page 327 Arne Hilke Page 329 Elizabeth Mulligan Page 331 Heugh Kelly Page 333 Hala Nasr Page 335 Lisa Barrington Page 337 Paul and Louise Hendricks Page 339 Philip Faulkner Page 341 Derek Moffat Page 343 Ian Plater Page 345 Rosie Davidson Page 347 Cherry Clements Page 349 Dell Thrasyvoulou Page 351 Kirsty Campbell Page 353 Emily Parker Page 355 Grant Montgomery


Page 357 Sarina Pitkethley Page 359 Tom Bevan Page 361 Michael John Hughes Page 363 Jane Ward Page 365 Scott Rooney Page 367 Ben Parsons Page 369 Robyn Minson Page 371 Jana Harrison Page 373 Catherine Cumming Page 375 Sara Kulins - I speak for the Sea Page 377 Kirstie Hilke Page 379 Kirsty Clapshaw Page 381 Melissa Gunn Page 383 Margie Thomson Page 385 Michael Gerard Sweetman

Page 387 Mackay Management Ltd

• James Mackay Page 389 Maria Collins Page 391 Mitchel Versey Page 393 Donna Marie Flavell Page 395 Ben d'Anvers Page 397 Joseph David Hassell Page 399 Laura Mash Page 401 Seong Min Kim Page 403 Casey King Page 405 Sue Clayton Page 407 Teina Anitini Katipa Nimmo Page 409 John Christopher Lawrence Page 411 John Alexander Bowman

Page 413 Allied Plumbing

• David William Pallett Page 415 Thomas Barker Page 417 Sarah Marie Lindsay Page 419 Maria Gumennaya Page 421 Hugo Clapshaw Page 423 Kim Chamley Page 425 Robert Wade McLean Page 427 Katrina Rose Greenwood Page 429 Gabrielle Buchanan Page 431 Amanda Fenwick Page 433 Jenna Vaughn Page 435 Linda Bowman


Page 437 Charles Clark Page 439 Sally Willis Page 441 Pamela Beattie Page 443 Kyla Covic Page 445 Paul Thomson Page 447 Christine Baines

Page 449 Pakiri G Trust

• Christine Baines Page 451 Hannah Goffeney

Page 453 Hermpac

• Scott Millar Page 455 Clair McEntegart Page 457 Gabrielle Connor Page 459 Alaina George Page 461 Jannene Alexander Page 463 Corrine Callinan Page 465 Rhiannon Morris

Page 467 RJ Riverop

• Peter Nie Page 478 Carley Hammond Page 480 Renata Blair for Evitan Page 482 Tessa Williams Page 484 Heidi Parlane Page 486 Sachith Samaradiwakera Wijesundara Page 488 Gabrielle O'Malley Page 490 Kerry O'Malley Page 492 Darren Mangelsdorf Page 494 Allistair Shepherd Page 496 Erin O'Malley Page 498 Ryan O'Malley Page 500 Rachel O'Malley Page 502 Michael Mackay Page 504 Kyran Gillespie Page 506 Samuel Dale Bradford Page 509 Fiona Gorinas Page 511 Grant Renall Page 513 Susan Jones Page 515 Marcus Robins Page 517 Stephen Mackay Page 519 Vince Moores Page 521 Luke Holliday Page 523 Stefan Marks


Page 525 Ken Marment Page 527 Nick Romanes Page 529 Jane Raybould Page 531 Bryan May Page 533 Sioux Plowman Page 535 J A Baretta Fernandes Page 537 Marina Maccartney Page 539 Sam Bowden Page 541 Dylan Gera Page 543 Susan Barbara Henry Page 545 Vladislav Kholostiakov Page 547 Emma Crowther Page 549 Simon John Walkden Page 551 Alastair Cameron Page 553 Kelly Screen Page 555 Erin Hall Page 557 Karen Ramsay Page 559 Christian Waddingham Page 561 Richard Mayne Page 563 Kate Hewitt Page 565 Andrea Edwards Page 567 Rhiannon Schroder Page 569 Briana Page 571 Nadja Parker Page 573 Maria Glavish Page 575 Clint Lewis Page 577 Julianne de Wet

Page 579 Jardenez Holdings Limited • Jacinta Ryan

Page 581 Katherine Norman Page 583 Winnie Charlesworth Page 585 Marc Warrington Page 587 Tim Parker Page 589 Mark I Perry Page 561 Maureen Perry Page 593 Jeffrey Colin King Page 595 Colin Watts Page 597 Andrew Reid Page 599 Leesa Wright Page 601 Josie Hendry Page 603 Janette Miller Page 605 Adam Minoprio


Page 607 Brendon Lagemaat Page 609 Robert Paul Cameron Page 611 Paul Michael Gledhill Page 613 Tim Merkens Page 615 Stephen Michael McDonald Page 617 Simon Hardley Page 619 Daniel Hawes Page 621 Grainne Tayu Page 623 Michael Harkins Page 625 John Darby Page 627 Arna Newman Page 629 Faisal A Page 631 Chanel Paul Page 633 Olivia Rynne Page 635 Daniel Tohill Page 637 Tobi Muir

Page 639 Taumata B - Tangata Whenua

• Annie Baines Page 641 Christine Hardy Page 643 Christine Bull Page 645 David Henry Page 647 Glenn Altman Page 649 Rhys Gwilliam Page 651 Sharie Sheffield Page 653 KASM Page 657 Fryderyk Kublikowski Page 659 Daniel Gerrard Page 661 Elysia Green Page 663 Robyn Greenwood Page 665 James Hislop Page 667 Ivy Dickson

Page 669 Mackenzie Mayo Limited

• Peter Mayo Page 671 Ben Jackson

Page 673 Omaha Marae Trust

• Annette Moana Baines Page 675 Jessica Bluck Page 677 Melanie Jackson Page 679 Louise Mary Fowler Page 681 Thomas Gibbs Page 683 Moira Adelaide Brown Page 685 David Pilmer


Page 687 Mark Emmett Osborne Page 689 Renay Kung Page 691 Sarah Quinlan Page 693 Simonne Butler Page 695 Dr Mels Barton Page 697 Bridget O'Malley Page 699 Oliver Page 701 Lorraine Tong Page 703 Carolyn Reid Page 705 Ben Green Page 707 Toby Mangelsdorf Page 709 Brent Pascoe Page 711 Arash Barzin

Page 713 SAVE Te Arai

• Aaron McConchie Page 715 Petrus van der Schaaf Page 717 Andrew Turner Page 719 Paul Reid Page 721 Jess Barnett Page 723 Trish Harkins Page 725 Vanessa Mutu Page 727 Juan Miguel Hamber Page 729 Dawson Mutu

Page 731 Protect Aotea

• Kelly Moanna Klink Page 733 Mark Estall Page 735 Kate O'Malley Page 737 Geoffrey MacRae Page 739 Rowan Evan Smiley Page 741 Marina MacRae Page 743 Tommy Foster Gustafsson Page 745 Logan Batts Page 747 Jacob Clarke Smith Page 749 Samantha MacRae Page 751 Jody Greenleaf Page 755 Marie Alpe Page 757 Danielle Norrie Page 759 Richard Stuart Hodder Page 761 Te Maia Pihema Page 763 Kevin Plumpton Page 765 Maria King Page 767 David Reece


Page 769 Marama Gossage Page 771 Star Gossage Page 773 Simon Pengelly Page 775 Elena Keith Page 777 Nicky Spencer Page 779 Louise Garlick

Page 781 Mangawhai Harbour Restoration Society Inc.

• James Carnie Page 786 Sam Whiddett Page 788 Adie Glover Page 790 Katherine Elizabeth Moss Page 792 Martin Charles Greenleaf Page 794 Michelle Gimblett Page 796 Catherine King Page 798 Kelly Dean Page 800 Aroha Gossage Page 802 Juliet Staveley Andrews Page 804 Craig Peirce Page 806 John Andrews

Volume 2 Page 827 Jasmine Channing Page 829 Anita Toi Page 831 Eric Bernard Allan

Page 833 Whangateau Harbour Care Group

• Elizabeth Allen Page 860 Sharnelle Came Page 862 Matt Bennie Page 864 Holly Boyd Page 866 Maria Mugica Page 868 Josephine Miller Page 870 Scarlett Harradine-Stevenson Page 872 Hallam Holloway Page 874 Richard Reid Page 876 Jessie Stanley Page 878 Ross Stanley Page 880 Rebecca ter Borg Page 882 Francesca Purcell Page 884 Esther Herold-Sabbah Page 886 Lulu Stanley Page 888 Nathan Mark Purcell Page 890 Bruno Stanley Page 892 Rania Sabbah


Page 894 Richard Kidd Page 896 Tai Flavell Page 898 Emily Williams Page 900 Rainer Tögel Page 902 Sonya Bloomfield Page 904 Hannah Jensen Page 906 Grace Crawshaw-McLean Page 908 Paul Sprinz Page 910 Jack Halpin Page 912 Ryan Biddulph Page 914 Campbell Ivory Page 916 Gabriel Ritchie Page 918 Shona Brock Page 920 Karl Bayly Page 922 Georgia Warren Page 924 Marco Ermerins Page 926 Mike Forbes Page 928 Francesca Hills Page 930 Veronica Bouchier for Taumata B - Marine and Coastal Act 2011 Application Group Page 932 Sue Williams Warren Page 934 Jamie Piggins Page 936 Sam MacDonald Page 938 Dave Tobeck Page 940 Todd Rice Page 942 Lisa Hopwood Page 944 Wendy Sheffield Page 946 Greg Iremonger Page 948 Ella Rei Mildren-Sheath Page 950 Michael Marris Page 952 George Bradshaw Page 954 Gabrielle Therese Wilson Page 956 Dorothy Power

Page 958 Te Arai Beach Preservation Society Inc

• Marie Alpe Page 960 Louis Sammons Page 962 Olivia Nash Page 964 Wayne Greenwood Page 966 Ashley Best Page 968 Not Stated Page 970 Danielle Warrington Page 972 Hannah Jones Page 974 Silke Rosemarie Pranzetti


Page 976 Phillippa King Page 978 Kourtney Kerr Page 980 Bridget Asmus Page 982 Marty Jones

Page 984 Keith Hay Group

• David Hay Page 986 Jordan Legros Page 990 Ella Carvajal Page 992 Matthew Hay Page 994 Richard Tyler Page 996 Semele Robertson Page 998 Sarah Hamilton Page 1000 Rachel Wood Page 1002 Stu Robertson Page 1004 Julia Helen Tyler Page 1006 Cushla Leonard Page 1008 Tom McGarry

Page 1010 Auckland Conservation Board • Lyn Mayes

Page 1016 Phillida Reid Page 1018 David Lourie Page 1020 Mike Newdick Page 1022 Simon Anderson Page 1024 Andrea Ata Page 1026 Ambrose William OMeagher Page 1028 Lydi Naguib Page 1030 Dana Graham Page 1032 Bjorn Hilke Page 1034 Talen Willox Page 1036 Caitlin Gillespie Page 1038 Thomas Kibblewhite Page 1040 Elizabeth Wright Page 1042 Jayden Hodgson Page 1044 Nicole Barratt Page 1046 Jason Dockery Page 1048 Danielle Peffers Page 1050 Hollie Vesetolu Page 1052 Caspian Smith Page 1054 Hannah Galbraith Page 1056 Ella Kohn-Taylor Page 1058 Emily Cayford Page 1060 Not Stated


Page 1062 Crighton Bone Page 1064 Ramari Heperi Page 1066 Lidya Ke Page 1068 Aria Zhang Page 1070 Kristen Wonch Page 1072 Alexander Morison Page 1074 Andrew Krukziener

Page 1076 Friends of Pakiri Beach

• Louise Ford, Aitkens Hom Majurey Page 1085 Melvin Chong Wei Howe

Page 1087 McCallum Bros. Ltd

• Shayne Elstob Page 1092 Howard Dixon Page 1094 Hayley Gillespie

Page 1100 Ngātiwai Trust Board

• Hayley MacDonald Page 1103 Patrick Cable Page 1105 Lisa Cher Page 1107 Zach Page 1109 Joel Taylor Page 1111 Rolf Hilke Page 1113 Chris Ewart Page 1115 Sophie Journee Page 1117 Arlin Bowmast Page 1119 Petrouchka Steiner-Grierson Page 1121 Daniel Mayer Page 1123 Jonathan Stuart Drucker Page 1125, 1133 Fergus Mcconnell

Page 1127 Keep Wellsford Beautiful • Jerusha

Page 1129 Alya Malcolm-Marx Page 1131 Sophia Hawkins

Page 1135 Te Whanau o Pakiri

• Olivia Haddon Page 1142 Michael Gunson Page 1146 Karthigan Paramananthasivam Page 1148 Liz Eglinton

Page 1150 Kayasand Ltd

• Bram Smith

Page 1152 AML Ltd trading as Allied Concrete

• Lee Skinner Page 1154 Xiuqing Yu


Page 1156 Gysbert William Sieger Denee Page 1158 Ella Louise Fitzgerald Walton Page 1160 Ben Bowden Page 1162 Gabriele Horn-Waldeck Page 1164 Emmylou Wellacott Page 1166 Tamara Bullock Page 1168 Drew Tracey Page 1170 Katy Chamley

Page 1172 Te Arai South Partners Ltd

• Louise Ford, Atkins Holm Majurey

Page 1179 Te Arai Residents’ Assc Inc


Page 1186 Tara Iti Golf Club


Page 1193 Te Arai South Holdings Ltd


Page 1200 Te Arai North Ltd


Page 1207 Te Arai Links

• Louise Ford, Atkins Holm Majurey Page 1214 Nathalie Nasrallah

Page 1216 Manuhiri Kaitiaki Charitable Trust

• Pieter Tuinder Page 1222 Basil Denee Page 1224 Luca Denee Page 1226 Daniel Barbour Page 1228 Rosemarie Hilke Page 1230 Indigo Page 1232 Christine Hardie and Ian Taylor Page 1234 Blake Johns Page 1234 George Mirfin Page 1236 Rupert Denee

Page 1238 Ngāti Manuhiri Settlement Trust • Louise Ford, Atkins Holm Majurey

Page 1245 Magdalena Shaw Page 1247 Dannielle Cripps Page 1249 Katie Ruscoe

Page 1251 Department of Conservation

• Thomas Christie • Kirsty Prior

Page 1258 Greg Jenks MNZM

Page 1260 Bridgeman Concrete Limited

• Timothy Walters


Page 1262 Gabriel Ransom

Page 1264 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Inc.

• Nicholas Beveridge Page 1280 Yasmin Leavins Page 1282 David Kent Page 1284 Linda Lockie Page 1286 Roseanne Hay Page 1288 Daniel Page 1290 Sammy Allan Page 1292 Maximilien Wolf Page 1294 Leonie Vingoe Page 1296 Roxenne Saavedra Montesclaros Page 1298 Marianne Laetitia Bridge nee Denee Page 1300 Imogen Bunting Page 1302 Marion Warrington Page 1304 Marc Warrington Page 1306 Fleur Heaton Page 1308 Jess McCabe Page 1310 Vegas McCarroll Page 1312 Briana Woolnough Page 1314 James Michie Page 1316 Peter Page 1318 Julia Morris Page 1320 Francesca Hofland

Page 1322 New Zealand Underwater Association

• Andrea Macfarlane Page 1327 Keith Warrington Page 1329 Luis Diaz Gutierrez Page 1331 Emma Gilkison Page 1333 Jordan Cormack Page 1335 Adrian Davie Page 1337 Melissa Greene

Page 1339 BLAKE

• Alice Ward-Allen Page 1341 Ohad Peleg Page 1343 Raman Patel Page 1345 Jessica Griffin Page 1347 Alexandria Laurie Page 1349 Anton Matthew John Carter Page 1351 Hayden Swaving Page 1353 Angela Crabb Page 1355 Dan Steel


Page 1357 Rachael Jackson Page 1359 Asher Beagley-Steel Page 1361 Andrew James Mclaren Page 1363 Azar Harley Atkins Page 1365 S M Bayer Page 1367 Jaeshana-Lee Kira Page 1369 Bruce Everard Page 1371 Storm Mckenzie Page 1373 Jayden Gatherer Page 1375 Flynn Rangi Medland Page 1377 Jessie Chapman Page 1379 Alisha Page 1381 Archie Molloy Page 1383 Josh Lambert Page 1385 Lucy van Oosterom Page 1387 Kruz Page 1389 Saskia Wigman

Page 1391 Yogawave NZ

• Rebecca Evans Page 1393 Dillon Patrick John Smith Page 1395 Ryan Stam Page 1397 Treye Liu Page 1933 Rebecca Leathem Page 1401 Toni Mekkelholt Page 1403 Breila Mia Straka Page 1405 Rika Ozaki Page 1407 Lauren Brittain Page 1409 Cushla Salt Page 1411 Claire Hamilton Page 1413 Pim Slagman Page 1415 Nathan Strong Page 1417 Julie Vice Glamuzina Page 1419 Grace Ballinger Page 1421 Dharlia Lynch Page 1427 Nick Pitcher Page 1429 Ingrid Carter Page 1431 Felicity Hopkinson Page 1433 Bradley Thomas Walton Page 1435 Alexander Jack Crook Page 1437 Felice Karuna Page 1439 Sarah Taylor Page 1441 Melissa Crockett-Joyoue


Page 1443 Aaron John Muir Taylor Page 1445 Kiri Binnersley Page 1447 Frances Dickinson Page 1449 Doria Joyoue Page 1451 Arapeta Ashton Page 1455 Matthew Fultz Ashton Page 1457 Melanie Eade Page 1459 Edith Ashton Page 1461 Carl Page 1463 Mervyn Ashton Page 1465 Manda Giddens Page 1467 Sophie Randrup Page 1469 Donald Ashton Page 1471 Frances Magness Page 1473 Albert Ashton Page 1475 Richard Foster Page 1477 Sharleen Greer Page 1479 Tureya Healey-Diaz Page 1481 Caleb Ripley Page 1483 Jacqueline Stevens Page 1485 Michael Tyler Page 1487 Daniel Evan May Page 1489 Katrina Williams Page 1491 Sarah Waller Page 1493 Sam Clark Page 1603 Jonathan Harvey Egdell Page 1607 Brian Tozer Came Page 1615 Olivia Tait Page 1616 Indigo Eade Page 1617 Tommy Ward Page 1618 Stanley Briggis Page 1619 Louis Ward Page 1620 Christine Sheehy and Simon Ward

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Friday, 8 May 2020 7:31 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9433] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: inbound1920016904327532413.pdf

Categories: Jackie

We have received a submission on the notified resource consent for Coastal Marine Area (Off-shore from Pakiri).

Details of submission

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: Coastal Marine Area (Off-shore from Pakiri)

Application number: CST60343373

Applicant name: Kaipara Limited

Applicant email: [email protected]

Application description: To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20 year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit between the 30m and 40m isobaths

Submitter contact details

Full name: David Otene Joyce

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0410750197

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 6 karumba street Warana Sunshine coast 4575

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of sand offshore frim Pākiri has been going on to long and over the years i have seen the dunes fall away into the sea and the marine life dwindle. If this happens for anotje 20 years we may not have a safe beach at Pākiri much longer. Research shows us that dredging and removal of sand effects the fragile ecosystems that live there. Let take 20 years to replenish our oceans.

19

2

What are the reasons for your submission? The Dredging is causing erosion y To Pākiri beach.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop all dredging for at least the next 20 years. Take it from the west coast for a change.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information: inbound1920016904327532413.pdf

20

Story: Marine minerals

Sand dredge, Pākiri Beach

Sand has been dredged from the sea floor off Pākiri Beach, north of Auckland, since the 1950s.The sand is used in Auckland’s building industry. In 2005, two dredging companies wanted tocontinue taking around 80,000 cubic metres of sand from the beach every year for the next 20years. In April that year the Auckland Regional Council recommended that sand dredgingcease, because of concerns that sand extraction had increased beach erosion.

Using this item

NIWA – National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research

This item has been provided for private study purposes (such as school projects, family and localhistory research) and any published reproduction (print or electronic) may infringe copyright law. It isthe responsibility of the user of any material to obtain clearance from the copyright holder.

How to cite this page:

Ian Wright, 'Marine minerals - Phosphates, ironsands and sands', Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand,http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/photograph/5523/sand-dredge-pakiri-beach (accessed 8 May 2020)Story by Ian Wright, published 12 Jun 2006

21

http://www.niwa.co.nz/

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Friday, 8 May 2020 7:46 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9434] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Bradford

Organisation name:



Postal address: 17a Craven St Sockburn Christchurch 8042

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Off shore dredging.

What are the reasons for your submission? I strongly disagree with all aspects of marine sand mining and dredging. Damage to coastal sand deposits I believe will impact the local environment of this area. Just last week Orcas were seen off shore of Parkiri beach. Fish stocks I believe will be affected and upstream predators.

22

2

There is a reason Gist island is a fish sanctuary and nearby sand mining dies not mesh with this area as being one of New Zealand's must see coastal areas. Please do not grant approval for sand mining in the fragile area of inshore coastline, enough is enough.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Prevent any sand mining or dredging now and in the future.


Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

23

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Philippa muller

Organisation name:



Postal address: 15/161 Tara rd mangawhai Northland 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The quantity of sand being removed is too large. The duration is too long.

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand is obviously being depleted over time. The large sand dunes in Mangawhai are much smaller than they were years ago already.

24

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce The quantity significantly to a max of a quarter the amount proposed. Or none at all! Reduce the amount of time in half. Too much damage can happen if a twenty year permit is given. Reassess after ten years.





25

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Blake Zuill

Organisation name:



Postal address: 8 Stanley Avenue Milford Auckland 0632

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Taking quantities of this size or any for that matter are destructive to the marine and land areas. I strongly disagree that there should be any work of this sort happening there.

What are the reasons for your submission? My uncle was a park ranger who dedicated so much of his life to looking after the dunes, projects around coastal protection etc.

26

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not allow dredging as Auckland grows north on these beaches. We will ruin these places.





27

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Josie Gritten

Organisation name:



Postal address: 18a Blackswamp Road Rd5 Wellsford Mangawhai 0875

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Extraction of sand.

What are the reasons for your submission? The huge impact this has on the beaches of Pakiri, Te Ārai etc. and the subsequent effect these land changes have on rare and endangered wildlife species.

28

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop extractng sand from this area.





29

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Catherine Ryan

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +61447160083


Postal address: 17B Craven Street Christchurch Christchurch 8042

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I don't support mining of sand from Parkari beach

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please protect Parkairi beach

30

2





31

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jess Sodo

Organisation name:



Postal address: 272 Scenic Drive Titirangi Auckland 0604

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The extraction of sand and consequential disturbance to & destruction of marine life.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To decline the application.

32

2





33

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Friday, 8 May 2020 12:01 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9440] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jack Gordon

Organisation name:



Postal address: 12a Phillip Parade Forrest Hill Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: In whole I oppose dredging off the Parkiri coastline.

What are the reasons for your submission? Frequent user of the area and have witnessed its degradation over the years resulting from dredging. We need to preserve the natural environment and find alternative locations for dredging if it is a necessary action.

34

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the consent application





35

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Alex flavell-Johnson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 63 lawrence road Mangawhai MANGAWHAI 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I opposed any extraction of coastal/maine sand from the mangawhai-pakiri area

What are the reasons for your submission? I oppose the application because of unmitigatable environmental damage that will be caused. Destruction and Degradation of benthic ecosystems caused by dredging is unmitigatable and unacceptable. The mangawhai-pakiri sand system is a closed system, continued extraction of this finite resource will result in erosion to the coastal system eventually.

36

2

The te arai dunes system are an Significant ecological area (SEA_T_5548a) of high ecological value, and the best example of this habitat in the east coast of auckland/northland. The presence of critically endangered wildlife such as NZ fairy tern should warrant the highest level of environmental protection along this coastline. Dredging also has negative impacts on recreation such as surfing, destroying sand bars, and causes aesthetic impacts by the noise and unsubtle nature of the operation. I strongly oppose any sand extraction along this coastline indefinitely.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to deny the application for consent.





37

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Saturday, 9 May 2020 9:15 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9444] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tony Baker

Organisation name: Mangawhai Board Riders / Independent



Postal address: 11 Spinifex Road Mangawhai Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I strongly oppose the application to extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20 year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit between the 30m and 40m isobaths

What are the reasons for your submission? There are vast array of negative effects associated with undersea open-cast seabed mining including but not limited

38

2

to: - degradation of the marine floor environment; - onshore to offshore sand flow replacement meaning the beach has an unnatural profile (the loss of the large sand dunes surrounding both Pakiri Estuary and the Mangawhai Harbours are examples of this; - decline in surf quality. None of the revenue raised from this industry is invested into the Mangawhai Community. The long term environmental effects are catastrophic for our coastal environment, and therefore will have a negative flow on effect on our coastal communities.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? DECLINE the application in its entirety.





39

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Brendon van de lagemaat

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 insley st mangawhai Mangawhai Mangawhai 0505

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To stop the sand mining

What are the reasons for your submission? If it continues there will be no marine life left or sand dunes left

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To fully stop sand mining in our area

40

2





41

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Camilo martinez

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 cross street Raglan Ragan 3525

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Don’t take more sand fuckers!

What are the reasons for your submission? Don’t destroy nz !

42

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I want you to stop them and also you have a permit to build houses in te arai to some Americans you can go fuck yourselves you don’t love the place you live in fuckers!





43

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Freddie Cleverley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 40 Wanganui Avenue Ponsonby Auckland 1011

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand extraction/dredging

What are the reasons for your submission? Continual degradation of the coast line in Northern Auckland ruins the coastline that the city is lucky to have access to. There aren't many other cities in the world that have access to such healthy marine systems within the world in such close proximity. Further, as a popular surf spot for many Auckland surfers, the dredging impacts the breaks and means this could call for even further travel for surf in future.

44

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce and/or stop the dredging activities undertaken along the coast.





45

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Basil Rademakers

Organisation name:



Postal address: 269 Mahurangi West Road Warkworth Warkworth 0983

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am opposed to sand mining in this area, specifically the mining occurring closer to shore.

What are the reasons for your submission? The reason for my submission is I am an avid surfer and the area is used by many surfers. This recreation could be seen as a real asset for the region and promote tourism and growth.

46

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to deny the application to continue to mine this area





47

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nara Mailin TORRES RAMIREZ

Organisation name:



Postal address: 269 Mahurangi West Road Warkworth Auckland 0983

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am opposed to sand mining in this area, specifically the mining occurring closer to shore.

What are the reasons for your submission? The reason for my submission is I am an avid surfer and the area is used by many surfers. This recreation could be seen as a real asset for the region and promote tourism and growth.

48

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to deny the application to continue to mine this area.





49

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Saturday, 9 May 2020 12:00 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9451] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jude Burton

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 wainoni place Warkworth AUCKLAND 0910

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of sand in the area from pakiri to mangawhai

What are the reasons for your submission? I think the removal of sand is causing problems to the beaches

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Get the sand from somewhere else it’s been going on for too long in that area

50

2





51

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: steve diprose

Organisation name: summit roofing



Postal address: 11 fifth ave, mt albert auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am against taking the sand

What are the reasons for your submission? I believe it may harm the area

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cancelled

52

2





53

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Richard Østmo Scott

Organisation name:



Postal address: 17A Totara road Leigh Warkworth 0947

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The aspect of the proposal is the entirety of the application especially the amount and size of the excavation.

What are the reasons for your submission? Living in the area for 25 years, I have grown up seeing the devastating effect that dredging has had on beach and dunes.

54

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Move back to sand mining inlands rather than dredging.





55

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Larissa Chelsea Long

Organisation name:



Postal address: 28 Amorino Drive Red Beach Auckland 0932

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I wish to oppose the dredging


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would cancel the dredging and encourage a period where the sand dunes can repair or halt the damage that has already been done.

56

2





57

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sinclair Dominikovich-Murray

Organisation name:



Postal address: 22 Bannerman Road Morningside Auckland 1022

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am opposing the dredging and collection of sand from this area in support of the protection of the marine life in the area

What are the reasons for your submission? All the way up this coast, particularly so close to a marine reserve such as Leigh which is already struggling does not need any further disruption of marine habitat

58

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Say no





59

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Mikaila Anne Hudson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 111 Hauiti Drive Warkworth, Auckland Warkworth, Auckland 0910

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am opposing the application in whole.

What are the reasons for your submission? The sand mining at Pakiri Beach is not sustainable, and is widely recognised as such, even being chosen as a case study by an overseas textbook to represent environmental mismanagement. The ecosystem services being provided by Pakiri Beach are irreplaceable, and sand mining is endangering it. Not only is this beach beloved by locals--part of who they are and where they belong-- it's also home to endangered species including the New Zealand dotterel. Even

60

2

if dune degradation was limited, the oxygen-deprived dead zones caused by dust plumes in the ocean would still impact life in the ocean as well as impacting fishing, a local past-time. Allowing sand mining at Pakiri Beach works directly against New Zealand's moral obligations to strive to meet four of the seventeen Sustainable Development Goals: Sustainable Cities and Communities, Responsible Consumption and Production, Life Below Water, and Life on Land. Aren't we supposed to be clean, green New Zealand?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The application for sand mining at Pakari Beach should be declined. A more sustainable off-shore location should be chosen instead.





61

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: River Jones Gardner

Organisation name:



Postal address: POBOX 300275 ALBANY Albany Auckland 0632

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Kaipara Limited seek consent to extract 2 million cubic metres of sand off Te Arai Point over the next 20 years.

What are the reasons for your submission? Overall the area will see irreparable degradation of the marine floor environment; - onshore to offshore sand flow replacement thus the beach will have an unnatural profile (the loss of the large sand dunes surrounding both Pakiri Estuary and the Mangawhai Harbours are examples of this; and an overall decline in surf quality.

62

2

Currently the sand profiles in the foreshore protect and maintain a vital part in the ecosystem in regards to long shore drift and coastal erosion. If the dunes were to be impacted due to larger swells and not enough sand bar protection allowing the waves to crash further out to sea, the dunes will suffer irreparable damage and will damage the local ecosystem and endangered living creatures living within them. Please consider the long term environmental and social effects of approving this application and what the best decision will be for all new Zealanders currently and in the future. Many areas like this coastline are becoming far and few in-between due to current malpractice by many corporations. Thank you for your time.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To abolish the decision to allow access of any corporation to dredge sand and extract from the eastern coastline.





63

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Julia Carr

Organisation name:



Postal address: 23 Devich Rd Mangawhai Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging and mining sand

What are the reasons for your submission? I value the coastal ecosystem and its jntegrity as one of the very attractive aspects of the area, and do not want to see degradation through sand mining.

64

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop sand mining now. There is no need to re-issue permission and if there was widespread communication about this renewal and broad consultation, there would not be community support given the environmental impact. There is much more interest now in restoration and preservation of the ocean ecosystem and the coast than when this practice was started. I would like the Council to make a future focussed, precautionary decision to allow recovery and restoration.





65

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Anna Victoria Hislop

Organisation name:



Postal address: 989 Pakiri road Wellsford Wellsford 0962

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining or drenching at pakiri beach has been going on for many years. A big old dirty boat hovers visable to the beach goers on a daily or twice daily mission to draw the sand.

What are the reasons for your submission? The sand dunes in Pakiri used to be massive. Now the beach is very flat. It is so sad to see such a huge change in the landscape that could have been prevented. Large sand dunes further north have been used to encourage tourism , this is now not possible for Pakiri.

66

2

Sand mining MUST be affecting the natural habitat of the fish that live close by and the rare (near extinct) birds that live on the shore. Sand mining at Pakiri Beach MUST stop. The beach needs time to recover after being raped for capital reasons for so many years. Why do we say take on photographs.. Leave only footprints?? Why can this not apply to our beaches and why has our council not stepped in early to protect our beautiful natural habitat?? This beach will never be the same. Put a stop to the sand mining NOW to prevent further desecration.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Complete ban on sand mining from TODAY.





67

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ewa Bednarczyk

Organisation name:



Postal address: 6A Helvetia Drive Browns Bay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: In whole

What are the reasons for your submission? Due to the negative effects associated with this procedure

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To oppose the application

68

2





69

1

Jackie Lee


Follow Up Flag: Follow upFlag Status: Completed

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Peter Richards

Organisation name: Te Arai Boardriders



Postal address: 6 Charis Lane Wellsford Auckland 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removing sand.

What are the reasons for your submission? Destroying sand dunes and surf sand banks

70

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Denying any mining





71

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Innes

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Otahuri Crescent Auckland Auckland 1051

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Mining sand offshore from Pakiri.

What are the reasons for your submission? Every day, people from all over the Auckland region - as well as many tourists - go to the East Coast beaches north of Auckland to surf. From Pakiri beach through to Forestry beach and Te Arai through to Mangawhai, surfing is a favourite outdoor activity amongst Aucklanders.

72

2

The quality of surf in these specific surf areas (known as beach breaks) strongly depends on the structure of the sand banks on the shore that the waves break on. When sand is allowed to build up on the shoreline, the waves break better. This would not only create a better environment for Aucklanders to enjoy surfing, but would also attract surfing tourists to the region, providing an economic benefit. The quality of the sand banks on Auckland's East Coast has been significantly lowered due to sand mining. Auckland Council should prioritise the thousands of surfers in Auckland that would benefit from a sand mining ban, as well as the economic benefit of increased tourism, over the company applying for consent to limit our playground from realising its potential as a world class surf area.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny consent to any applications to mine sand on between Pakiri and Mangawhai.





73

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: James Brunt

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2/149j Glengarry Road Glen Eden Auckland 0602

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose this!we need to keep our sandbars.

What are the reasons for your submission? I have seen and experienced the change of the bars on pakiri beach.there are dredgers closer than 2km from shore.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the application for sand dredging

74

2





75

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Sunday, 10 May 2020 7:16 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9467] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: James Mcgirr

Organisation name:



Postal address: 29 Cambrae Road Raglan Raglan 3225

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Negative environmental impacts caused by seabed mining to the surrounding surf breaks such as coastal sand depleation

What are the reasons for your submission? I grew up surfing these pristine beaches and I want them protected from industrial seabed mining

76

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny the applicants resource consent applications and refuse all future applications to mine the seabed in New Zealand coastal environment





77

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Dan Redman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 31 Calypso pl Rothesay Bay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This is for the whole application. I do not want consent for sand dredging to be given at all.

What are the reasons for your submission? It is effecting the natural environment of the coastline and the build up of sandbars on the beach

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? A complete stop to all sand dredging around the Pakari and Te Arai coastline.

78

2





79

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Joseph Hassell

Organisation name:



Postal address: 494c Wainui road RR3 Raglan 3297

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining

What are the reasons for your submission? Our sea beds are eroding at rapid rates in the face of rapid sea rises; to remove more sand is reckless. - There is a finite supply of Pakiri Beach’s sand and once it’s gone, it’s gone forever

80

2

- Pakiri Beach is home to the Fairy Tern, New Zealand's rarest bird of which there are only 40 left - There are other non-erosionary sources of sand, so it’s not necessary to mine Pakiri Beach - Sand mining creates dead zones, killing every living thing in the process on the sea bed - The sea bed community is appreciated as ever more important. - Dredging releases carbon stores ("blue carbon"); it is out of step with these times - Science is revealing new effects; underwater noise pollution and sedimentation plume affects water quality - The dredging is by NZ’s oldest marine reserve, with two new Auckland Reserves are at either end of the beach. Can there be a less appropriate place for dredging? - Erosion to dunes is highly likely, the only question is timing - Locals see changes already (to the mid and rear dunes); exotics are choking the former shifting sands - Seeing what the McCallum’s have done to where they operate eg Karamuramu Island; what hope is there for Pakiri? - NZ is going against the position of the rest of the World. In Norfolk, UK, a 2 million cubic meter sand dune is being created, to guard against future erosion. This is the minimum amount that they wish to extract from Pakiri. The position could not be more different. - In a Year 13 UK geography curriculum text book, Pakiri sand mining is a Case Study of environmental mismanagement. NZ’s Green reputation is being diminished internationally by the dredging at Pakiri. We now live in an era of environmental awareness. Single use plastics bags have been banned, we all now think about and mitigate our environmental impact in everything we do. So why in this environmental era, in Green NZ of all places, allow permits to mine sand, in an intensive, primitive way from precious beaches like Pakiri, when there are alternate sustainable sources?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please oppose all sand mining applications for Pakari





81

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Oscar Gunn

Organisation name:



Postal address: 31a park rise Campbell’s bay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The dredging of sand out the Pakiri area


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To deny the resource consent and stop the dredging of sand.

82

2





83

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Ripley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 8 Darroch Slope Omaha Warkworth 0986

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Destroying habitat for marine species. Detrimental effects to sand bars etc on the coast line which affects enjoyment of the beach and surf breaks.

What are the reasons for your submission? I live surf and fish in the area.

84

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not proceed





85

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vivien Kennerley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3 West Glade Crescent Birkenhead Auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Do not muck with nature!! Leave NZ prestine beauty as it is. Enough is enough


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? DONT DO IT

86

2





87

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Sunday, 10 May 2020 12:01 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9473] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: Auckland Unitary Coast Plan - Appendix 4 Surf breaks.pdf; Unitary Plan F2 Coastal Marine

Zone.pdf; Unitary Plan F2 Coastal Marine Zone page 93 and 94 Surfbreaks.pdf

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Geer Iseke

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021 654987


Postal address: PO Box 33928 Takapuna Auckland 0740

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removal of natural sediment and sand from the coastline in the area between Pakiri South and Mangawhai Black Swamp, including Te Arai beach.

What are the reasons for your submission? These beaches and their surfbreaks are specifically protected under the Auckland Unitary Plan - Coastal

88

2

Management, specifically the surfbreaks at Te Arai beach (incl Black Swamp), Pakiri Beach North and South. Removal of sand from the coast will adversely affect the surfbreaks and change the natural wave quality, destroy sand banks structures and change the shape of the sanddunes due to forced movement of sand in and out of the beaches and along the coast.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? 1. Decline the consent. 2. Stop and forbid all sand mining. 3. Protect the surfbreaks from man-made activity. (refer F2 Coastal General Coastal Marine Zone - F2.23.2




Supporting information: Auckland Unitary Coast Plan - Appendix 4 Surf breaks.pdf Unitary Plan F2 Coastal Marine Zone.pdf Unitary Plan F2 Coastal Marine Zone page 93 and 94 Surfbreaks.pdf

89

Appendix 4 Surf breaks


All provisions in this appendix are regional coastal plan [rcp].

ID Name Location Break Type

Seabed Composition

Description

1 Te Arai Beach (including Pacific Road access point 'Black Swamp')

East Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good wave quality suitable to all skill levels. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Good access.

2 Pakiri Beach (North - 'Forestry')

East Coast

Beach break


3 Pakiri Beach (South)

East Coast

Beach break


4 Goat Island East Coast

Reef break

Rock/sand Semi exposed reef break. Relatively inconsistent. Good to high wave quality suitable to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with little development. Good access.

5 Daniels Reef Leigh, East Coast

Reef break

Rock Exposed reef break. Relatively consistent. High wave quality suitable to experienced surfers. Good access.

6 Boulders Leigh, East Coast

Reef breaks

Rock/sand Exposed variable reef breaks. Frequently surfable. Good to high wave quality suitable to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with a lack of development. Difficult access.

Omaha Beach and

East Beach break,

Sand Semi exposed beach, bar and groyne breaks. Provides wave

Auckland Unitary Plan Operative in part 1

90

Geer Iseke

Geer Iseke


7

Bar Coast bar break, groyne breaks

quality suitable to learners relatively consistently. Occasionally provides good wave quality suitable to competent surfers. High amenity values and good facilities. Good access.

8 Tawharanui East Coast

Beach break

Sand/ patches of rocky reef

Exposed beach break. Relatively consistent. Average to good wave quality suitable to all skill levels. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Good access.

9 Orewa Beach and Bar

East Coast

Beach break, bar break

Sand Sheltered beach and bar breaks. Inconsistent. Wave quality highly suitable to and valued by learners and novices. High amenity values and good facilities. Good access.

10 Red Beach East Coast

Beach break

Sand Sheltered beach break. Inconsistent. Wave quality highly suitable to and valued by learners and novices. Good facilities and access.

11 Long Bay Reef

East Coast

Reef breaks

Rock Sheltered reef break. Inconsistent but good wave quality suitable for competent surfers. Difficult access

12 Milford Beach and Reef

East Coast

Reef and beach breaks

Rock and sand Sheltered reef break. Inconsistent. Good wave quality suitable for novice to competent surfers. Highly valued and utilised urban surf break. Good access.

13 O'Neills Reef Takapuna, East Coast

Reef/point break

Rock Sheltered reef break. Inconsistent. Good wave quality suitable for novice to competent surfers. Highly valued and utilised urban surf break. Good access.


91


14 North Reef (Takapuna)

Takapuna, East Coast

Reef break

Volcanic reef Sheltered reef break. Inconsistent. Good wave quality suitable for novice to competent surfers. Highly valued and utilised urban surf break. Good facilities and access.

15 Takapuna Beach and South Reef

Takapuna East Coast

Beach and reef breaks

Sand and rock Sheltered beach and reef breaks. Inconsistent, poor to average wave quality, however highly valued and utilised urban surf break. Suitable for learners to competent surfers. Good facilities and access.

16 Orere Point East Coast

Point break

Boulders/ cobbles

Sheltered point break. Inconsistent. Good wave quality suitable to novice to competent surfers. Good access.

17 Rimmers Road

West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Adequate access.

18 Muriwai Beach (South)

West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable to competent to experienced surfers. High amenity value and good facilities. Good access.

19 Maori Bay West Coast

Beach break, reef break

Sand, rock Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Good facilities and access.


92


20 Te Henga (Bethells Beach)

West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Good facilities and access.

21 O'Neill Bay West Coast

Beach break, rip reform break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Access requires 10-15 minute walk.

22 Anawhata West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Adequate access.

23 Whites Beach

West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. 'Wilderness' experience with lack of development. Difficult access.

24 Piha West Coast

Beach break, bar break

Sand Exposed beach break and bar break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suited for competent to experienced surfers. High amenity values and good facilities. Good access.


93


25 Karekare West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Good access.

26 Whatipu West Coast

Inner harbour, beach break

Sand Sheltered inner harbour beach break. Infrequent. Average wave quality suitable to competent surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with lack of development. Adequate access

27 Kariotahi Beach

West Coast

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Good access.

28 Whangapoua (Okiwi)

Great Barrier Island

Bar break

Sand Exposed bar break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. High wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with low level of development. Access across estuary mouth.

29 Awana Bay Great Barrier Island

Beach break

Sand Exposed beach break that is frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable for competent to experienced surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with low level of development. Good access.

30 Palmers Beach and Kaitoke Beach


Beach break

Sand Exposed beach breaks that are frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high quality wave suitable to competent surfers. Offers a 'wilderness' experience with low level of development. Adequate access.


94


31 Medlands Beach/Shark Alley


Beach break, reef break

Sand/rock Exposed beach and reef breaks that are frequently suitable for wave riding. Good to high wave quality suitable to competent surfers. Good access.

32 Onetangi Beach

Waiheke Island

Beach break

Sand Sheltered beach break. Low to average wave quality suitable for learners to competent surfers. Good access.

33 Palm Beach Waiheke Island

Beach break

Sand Sheltered beach break. Low to average wave quality suitable for learners to competent surfers. Good access.


95

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Sunday, 10 May 2020 2:31 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9475] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Matthew scott

Organisation name:



Postal address: 67 coal hill rd Mangawhai Northland 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stopping the sand mining of Pakiri and north

What are the reasons for your submission? It destroys the sea beds and the erosion it is causing the sandbanks

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop the sea bed mining

98

2





99

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gordon Phillip Hosking

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 169 Mangawhai Mangawhai 0540

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The extraction of a public good to no benefit to the local, or wider community but with the potential to have adverse effects on both the marine and coastal environment.

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand mining in the marine area, supposedly the property of the New Zealand community, for which no return is recieved has a prarallel in the water bottling industry. Taking something at no cost and generating a private return. Construction sand is a limited and valuable resource world wide which is rapidly running out. Why should a private

100

2

company be gifted such a resource for no return to the community which will inevitably bear the costs of environmental degradation.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To refuse the resource consent outright.





101

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Kevin George Long

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1 Darmah Lane Mangawhai Kaipara 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To mine sand off the coast of Pakari to Mangawhai

What are the reasons for your submission? I object due to the significant negative and clearly noticeable impact this has had for years on the shore and seabed close to shore.

102

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The application to continue mining sand here must be rejected outright to give this stretch of coastline a chance to recover.





103

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Andrew Martin

Organisation name:



Postal address: 203a Titirangi Road Titirangi Auckland 0604

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The environmental degradation and negative impacts the sand mining will cause

What are the reasons for your submission? The minim action does and will continue to cause negative environmental impacts to the sea floor and the eco systems that it harbours. It is too close to land.

104

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the application





105

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Monday, 11 May 2020 8:46 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9479] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: ethan carson-groom

Organisation name:



Postal address: 72 island bay road b haven auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: the dredging of sand

What are the reasons for your submission? ecological and enviromental

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? dont let any sand dredging take place, it is a beautiful stretch of coast and would suffer from a large scale operation

106

2

as proposed by kiapra ltd. the marine life in the area would be greatly affected and such effects would be felt up the food train including humans. many shell fish act as pollution filters and the sand its self is important to the integrity of the coast line.





107

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ronen Lahav

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Raleigh Road Northcote Auckland 0627

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Volume of sand removed, lack of protections in place to maintain sea life and coastal integrity and

What are the reasons for your submission? as above

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not allow extraction to occur.

108

2





109

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Craig Mathieson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021 1779 664


Postal address: 20A Vanessa Crescent Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Whole application - dredging of sand off the Mangawhai-Pakiri Embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? Indirect impacts upon surf quality. Detailed impacts on Surf quality not considered in application. Gradual impacts on surf quality cannot be defined or measured.

110

2

Impacts on dunes at Mangawhai that contribute to the sand banks that affect surf quality.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refusal of consent





111

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Monday, 11 May 2020 12:46 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9484] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Guy Cook

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 Aldred Road Auckland Auckland 1050

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The amount of sand they are able to take, and the proximity to highly important environmental features.

What are the reasons for your submission? I am strongly opposed to the further degradation of such a critical part of New Zealand and our shoreline environment.

112

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like you to reject the application, or put in more restrictions around taking of sand, and better policing around them abiding by the application, and rules set out for them to operate.





113

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Margaret Estall

Organisation name:



Postal address: 48 Lake Rd Te Arai Auckland 4023

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The amount of resource to be removed and the length in years of the consent .


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To ensure this non renewable resource is not taken to the detriment to the marine ecosystem. I would like the council to protect this unique area which is a recreation resource for Auckland and The whole of New Zealand

114

2





115

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kate Matheson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 23 Devich Rd RD5 Mangawhai 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of it

What are the reasons for your submission? I make this submission as a young mother who hopes that's her son will get to grow up spaying in the beautiful environment we have here in Mangawhai and Te Arai. I am extremely concerned about the impact this application will have on the ecosystems including the dune and the surf breaks.

116

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline this application based on the negitive environmental impact





117

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Helen Smith

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1025 Pakiri Block road Tomarata Auckland 1024

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Oppose the dredging if sand


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? No dredging at all

118

2





119

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jerem Mclay

Organisation name:



Postal address: 35 spinifex st Papamoa beach Tauranga 3118

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Fully oppose all aspects of the application. Dredging in these volumes should not be alowed to continue.

What are the reasons for your submission? Have experienced the changes from 20 years ago on that coastline, much of which can be attributed to the sand harvesting. . Do not wish that it should continue.

120

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Drastically reduce the quota and or put a yearly limit on volume of sand to be taken. That it has been done for so long I suspect it will continue in some form. Ideally, there should be no dredging allowed.





121

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Leslie Paul Francois

Organisation name:



Postal address: 76 Simpson Road Ranui Auckland 0612

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The volume of sand the consent allows to be taken.

What are the reasons for your submission? I use the nearby Pakiri Beach for surfing and removing that volume of sand is likely to effect the beach contours and surf quality.

122

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the consent or alternatively reduce the sand quantity to 500,000 tonnes over a reduced period of 10 years to allow environmental effects to be monitored.





123

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Tuesday, 12 May 2020 9:46 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9493] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nick Molloy and Frankie Hofland

Organisation name: Pakiri Landcare



Postal address: 256 Pakiri River Road Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: that the continued sand mining at Pakiri is the cause of the diminution of the beach environment and because it is a closed system this is unsustainable


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? to stop sand mining at Pakiri

124

2





125

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Fraser Falconer

Organisation name:



Postal address: 195 rodney rd leigh auckland Warkworth Auckland 0948

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The sand should stay on the beach


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop mining sand and killing our environment.

126

2





127

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Adriane Swinburn

Organisation name:



Postal address: 121 West End Rd Westmere Auckland 1022

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I totally oppose this activity in its entirety.

What are the reasons for your submission? We have been landowners at Pakiri for 22 years and have watched over the barge activity with horror for years. We have seen the beach change and the sand disappear. I submit that it is a travesty to wreak such damage on a vulnerable coastal environment and far too much damage has been done by this activity already. Times have changed and our communities do not want commercial activity that devastates the environment to continue.

128

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not allow this activity to be permitted once the current permission concludes.





129

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Tuesday, 12 May 2020 12:31 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9496] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Alex McLean

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1024 Mt Eden Auckland 1024

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I do not want this application happening and would like to stop the dredging if sand at parkiri.

What are the reasons for your submission? I would like this to not happen as it will affect the surfing conditions of the area

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Council to stop this from happening

130

2





131

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tom McCarthy

Organisation name:



Postal address: 179 landscape road Mt Eden Auckland 1024

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging which will have a neutral effect on the habitat and leisure pursuits

What are the reasons for your submission? As a keen surfer we will be effected by this practice

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Open to hear alternative options

132

2





133

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Wednesday, 13 May 2020 9:30 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9499] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Julie Marie Atkinson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 798 Matakana Valley Rd, Warkworth Auckland, New Zealand Auckland, New Zealand 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I understand we need sand for products but we need to keep a cery close eye on what the mining is doing to our flora and fauna.

What are the reasons for your submission? I dont see how we can restore any damage onces its done.

134

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Keep a very close eye on the effects the mining will be having on our environment and have measures in place to holt mining.





135

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Grace Vujnovich

Organisation name:



Postal address: 57 Tongue Farm Road, Matakana Matakana Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Please do NOT renew any of the existing sand mining licences off shore at Pakiri Beach.

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand mined from Pakiri Beach is irreplaceable. Yet it is the site of the largest single nearshore sand mining activity in the developed world.

136

2

No other developed country allows nearshore sand mining – we to take back control of this precious resource, which sustains this beautiful coastline.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please do NOT renew any of the existing sand mining licences off shore at Pakiri Beach.





137

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Wednesday, 13 May 2020 12:46 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9501] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Zoe Gimring

Organisation name:



Postal address: 166 Ashton Road Warkworth Warkworth 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The unsustainable practice of mining and its degrading effect on the coastal environment and native species that call it home for monetary gain.


138

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To decline the mining application. It's time for it to end. Leave the land now to recover, the animal species to have peace.





139

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Diane Greenwood

Organisation name:



Postal address: 873 Pakiri Rd RD 2 Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop the sand mining


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? If not stopping altogether to limit the amount of sand taken and for a much lower time frame.

140

2





141

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: megan browne

Organisation name:



Postal address: po box 186 leigh leigh 0947

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose mining the sand from Pakiri beach.

What are the reasons for your submission? We live in Leigh and watch the sand barge go up and down the coast. What a waste of resources and energy to take sand from our beach down to where it doesn't belong naturally.

142

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ban the sand mining from occurring off Pakiri beach coast





143

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sammy Eric Dean Williams

Organisation name: Williams Whanau Group



Postal address: 15 Castledine Crescent Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: We are Pakiri Maori Landowners right on the Shore line

What are the reasons for your submission? I Don't want any more Taken They have already done ,,35 years

144

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do Not Proceed with this Consent. Go Down somewhere else for 35 years





145

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Zak Samuel Smith

Organisation name:



Postal address: 0920 Whangaripo Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop sand mining Pakiri beach and surrounds

What are the reasons for your submission? As I kid I remember the big sand dunes as you entered pakiri beach almost like the ones you see up north, nowadays the big dunes are long gone and the sand banks for surfing are fickle. And it’s sad to imagine what the sea floor would currently be looking like.

146

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop sand mining Mangawhai-Pakiri region





147

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sharon Amelia Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 15 Castledine Crescent Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Too much Sand Dredging had happened at Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? I am A Taumata B Maori Share Holder At Pakiri Beach. I am sick and Tired of the Sand Dredging.

148

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop this Resource Consent





149

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Grass Esposti

Organisation name:



Postal address: 157 Omaha Flats Road Matakana Auckland 0986

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop mining at Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? I want to stand up for the environment

150

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Protect the fragile environment





151

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Thursday, 14 May 2020 10:01 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9511] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Holly Stevens

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2 Laguna Place, Matakatia Whangaparaoa Auckland 0930

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: A lack of assessment has gone into assessing the potential for adverse effects on the surf break at both Te Arai and Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? Despite the activities occurring off the coast of Te Arai/Pakiri, extracting sand from the seabed has the potential to effect two of Auckland's most popular east coast surf breaks. A disruption to the seabed has the potential to effect the way swell approaches the beach and consequently change/disturb the resulting waves which the public has a right to

152

2

enjoy. A detailed assessment should be required to determine the effects sand extraction will have on the surf break of both beaches. Further, I do not support the visual effects the proposal will have as it will permit marine vessel activity in a part of the Hauraki Gulf where minimal commercial marine activity currently takes place. When you compare the effects of the proposal to the current environment, the proposal, which will continue for 20 years, will result in effects on the landscape character and visual amenity of the coastal area. Having surfed both breaks for 10 plus years, the arrival of the consented sand barge off Pakiri Beach last year came as a shock to myself and many others who have not experienced commercial marine vessel activity near the shore. This has affected the way the environment is experienced by users with a large boat frequently seen off the coast during the day and at night with bright lights, effecting the untouched coastal character of the area.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The applicant shall carry out a detailed assessment demonstrating the effects of the proposal on the surf breaks at Te Arai and Pakiri Beach. If this assessment determines minimal effects, I oppose the application on the basis of visual amenity/landscape character effects.





153

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Thursday, 14 May 2020 12:46 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9513] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Xavia Healey-Diaz

Organisation name:



Postal address: 230 Govan Wilson Rd Warkworth Warkworth 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of sand from Pakiri beach

What are the reasons for your submission? I believe that mining of sand from the inshore areas is harmful to the beach. It is damaging to the nesting sites of the critically endangered Fairy Terns, and to at risk dotterils.

154

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not approve this resource consent





155

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sharley Haddon

Organisation name: Pakiri Beach Horse Rides Ltd



Postal address: 317 Rahuikiri Road Pakiri R.D.2 Wellsford Wellsford Auckland Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose to the taking of sand from Pakiri and surrounding beaches in total.

What are the reasons for your submission? For 50 years I have watched Pakiri beach deteriorate from a white sand beach to now a beach that is partially brown and in some places very dark brown. I have seen the sand dunes diminish so that the endangered birds who nest here no longer have their usual nesting grounds and therefore now each year their fledglings get washed away by the big October/November tides.

156

2

I have seen the destruction of the sea bed causing shell fish to abandon the area and some to wash up in large numbers dead and open. It is known that the sand on Pakiri is finite it came from the Waikato via Firth of Thames many years ago and no longer comes from there. This resource is at risk.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The council should follow their fine words about protection of the environment and the health of natural habitats and completely halt this rape of our shores. There are plenty of in land sand deposits within the region which could be used instead.





157

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Lydia Green

Organisation name:



Postal address: 951 Matakana Rd Auckland Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose sand mining


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please do not allow

158

2





159

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kelly Norton

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3 Bathgate Rd Pakiri Wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging sand.

What are the reasons for your submission? Protection of the natural habitat

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not grant this

160

2





161

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nick Molloy and Frankie Hofland

Organisation name: Pakiri Landcare



Postal address: 256 Pakiri River Road Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: sandmining at Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? the Pakiri area is a closed system no more sand is being made. enormous amounts of sand have been taken over the past 40 years. it is having a profound effect on the beach dune system.

162

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? completely stop the taking of sand from the beach





163

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Helen Jamieson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 976 Matakana Valley Road Whangaripo Valley Wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removing sand from the area around Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? I completely oppose it

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like them to reject the submission to continue mining the area. It's been mined enough - further mining is

164

2

detrimental to an area of outstanding natural beauty and the wildlife it supports. As per the information in this petition: https://our.actionstation.org.nz/petitions/save-pakiri-beach-from-sand-mining





165

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Helena Cullen

Organisation name:



Postal address: 960 Whangaripo Valley Road RD2 Wellsford Auckland 0970

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Seabed mining

What are the reasons for your submission? Seabed mining makes no sense. It damages the seabed floor, habitats, marine life and the noise pollution from the mining equipment are harmful to marine life too.

166

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To oppose it all together and deny the application.





167

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Greg Askey

Organisation name:



Postal address: 95 Haverstock Rd Sandringham Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Saying No to this application in whole

What are the reasons for your submission? This beach has already been massively used for the removal of sand. It has to stop. The ecological and wave impact is terrible and it’s time for sand removal to be had elsewhere. Pakiri has paid its due!

168

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To say No , enough is enough from this beautiful pristine area. It’s having a terrible effect on the waves and surfing recreation that many come here for.





169

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Frankie Hofland

Organisation name:



Postal address: 256 pakiri River Road Pakiri Pakiri 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I don't want anymore sand to be taken from Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? To save the environment of the coastline of Pakiri beach

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I want the council to refuse any further resource consents from any applicant to take sand from Pakiri

170

2





171

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Fynn Pilkington

Organisation name:



Postal address: 97 Lawrence rd Mangawhai Kaipara 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand dredging

What are the reasons for your submission? I have watched the massive pakiri sand dunes disappear from 1991 to 2001. Coastal erosion has been exacerbated. Sand bars along the beach have disappeared. Strong dangerous rips that never used to occur now are horrendous and have killed swimmers.

172

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Get the sand from the bottom of the Waitemata harbour.





173

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vanessa Askey

Organisation name:



Postal address: 95 Haverstock rd Sandringham Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Opposing All aspects

What are the reasons for your submission? Dredging companies have been removing huge quantities of sand from Pakiri beach for years, damaging sand dunes, ecological habitats and ruing the sand banks and surf quality. Pakiri has paid its dues and enough is enough.

174

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Dredging at pakari removal of sand





175

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Chris Jamieson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 976 Matakana Valley Road Pakiri Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The entire application. Sand mining should not be allowed at Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? No other country in the developed world allows coastal sand mining and it’s catastrophic to the environment. Pakiri as you already know is a) extremely beautiful and b) the habitat for some of the world’s rarest birds - it’s right next to a marine reserve! And sea bed mining is devastating to the environment.

176

2

It’s REALLY important the licence doesn’t get renewed.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the application for resource consent





177

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Debra Searchfield

Organisation name:



Postal address: 7 Pentland Ave Mt Eden Auckland 1024

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Granting of extraction rights of 2million cubic meters of sand from our local coastal marine area.

What are the reasons for your submission? This is a finite resource that is important for the inter tidal zones on one of the last stretches of undeveloped coast in this region. The continuing sand mining is damaging the environment.

178

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? We would like the application to be denied.





179

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Clifton Hart

Organisation name:



Postal address: 6 Echo Valley Road Mangawhai Mangawhai Heads 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand extraction

What are the reasons for your submission? I believe removing sand from the Pakiri area will alter wave action into the beach and will affect surf conditions

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse the application

180

2





181

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Fi Jamieson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 256 Govan Wilson Road Whangaripo Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The largest single nearshore sand mining activity in the developed world.

What are the reasons for your submission? The damage this will cause to the immediate + surrounding areas

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To NOT renew any of the existing sand mining licences off shore at Pakiri Beach.

182

2





183

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Troy williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 64 kennington park drive ENDEAVOUR HILLS ENDEAVOUR HILLS 3802

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Iwi member

What are the reasons for your submission? Ruined the dunes , taken more than enough, pure greed. If the sand on mission bay etc keeps getting washed out then why keep placing sand there. Its clearly not working . No montioring been put in place for years to watch how the dunes have been decreasing nor have local iwi been consulted if any marine life have been affected. Ships have been spotted serval times docking up close in bay at night time sucking up sand which has ruined the pipi life .

184

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop sand mining altogether. Go see if any other iwi will appreciate it. No good for bird life and marine bio





185

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jo Ealand

Organisation name:



Postal address: 95a Haverstock Road Sandringham Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Don’t touch the sand!


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Oppose the application all together.

186

2





187

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sasha Jamieson

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO BOX 252, MATAKANA WARKWORTH AUCKLAND 0948

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The whole application. The entire ability to mine sand at Pakiri.

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand mining causes major damage to the environment, Pakiri is an area of outstanding natural beauty and is home to many of New Zealand's rare birds. To mine sand there would mean destroying many of these birds' homes, such as dotterels which make their homes on the sand - usually I see Auckland Council signs near the dotterel nests saying to protect them, I don't think you guys should be supporting the destruction of their wider environment. Pakiri is also near

188

2

Goat Island, a large marine reserve home to a huge ecosystem of marine life, there are snapper in the reserve which are 100 years old - dredging the bed for sand would have a devastating impact on Goat Island. Sand has been mined at Pakiri for 20 years already - that's quite enough.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like for the council to not allow sand to be dredged from Pakiri Beach.





189

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Cherie Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 956 Pakiri Rd R.D2 Wellsford Wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of the applications

What are the reasons for your submission? I am Haukainga of Pakiri and our whenua and resource being disrespected

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Think about the future generations instead of greed and money

190

2





191

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: corinne callinan

Organisation name:



Postal address: 12 Moir St Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai Heads 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: do not grant RC for further sand extraction to current or future contractors in the Mangawhai and Pakiri areas, both near and off shore within a 50km radius.

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand has been extracted from this area for decades and it is changing our ecosystem dramatically. The sand hills have significantly decreased in size (much more than natural erosion could account for). This area is also the home to the most endangered bird in NZ (and arguably the World) and locals have worked

192

2

tirelessly to save the Fairy Tern from extinction. All the while, Auckland Council have been allowing contractors to undermine/mine the sand that constitutes the home of these important birds.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop sand mining at Pakiri (and Mangawhai and surrounding areas). Exclusion should be near to shore and also offshore, including within a 50km radius.





193

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Megan Bennett

Organisation name: Astute NZ Ltd



Postal address: 72 Mangawhai Mangawhai 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: removing that amount of sand from our coastline drastically affects not only the sand hills that protect our estuary but the sea and wildlife as well


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? do not grant a 20 year lease for that amount - reduce!

194

2





195

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Alison baird

Organisation name:



Postal address: 39 Old Waipu Road North Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I dont want the barges offshore as they get in the was of recreational fishing. Also the pristine white sand is a huge natural asset for the local community. Sand is a finite resource

What are the reasons for your submission? Protecting out beautiful natural assets.

196

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the mining





197

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tim Kidd

Organisation name:



Postal address: 48b Valley Rd Mount Maunganui Tauranga 3116

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand take opposition

What are the reasons for your submission? It effects the seabed / beach make up, surf on sure, clouds the water and causes loud underwater noises that disrupt the

198

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not approve the consent.





199

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kirsty Millar

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2 Sand Dune Lane Mangawhai Heads Northland 0505

Submission details




What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cease plans to sand mine.

200

2





201

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Lou Dennis

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3/204 Main Highway Ellerslie Auckland 1060

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20 year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit between the 30m and 40m isobaths

What are the reasons for your submission? As a part of the Ngati Wai iwi, who grew up in Pakiri, we have watched the deterioration of Pakiri Beach due to

202

2

previous offshore mining. This has led to erosion, and the dunes have all but disappeared, change the very nature of the beach and affected the wildlife that had been a big part of the beach over time. It is an ecological nightmare.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? For this application to be declined in full.





203

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Emma-jean Joyce

Organisation name:



Postal address: 6 Karumba St Warana Warana 4575

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: 20 years of sand dredging

What are the reasons for your submission? It is damaging our coastline and has been proven in the past

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? 20 years of replenising and take sand from elswhere

204

2





205

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kathryn Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 400 chapel road flatbush Manukau Auckland 2016

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of sand from Pākiri

What are the reasons for your submission? This is damaging our beach and has been going on to long and now is the time to rejuvenate our whenua

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop dreding at the above and replenish for the next 20 years

206

2





207

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tangi Holt

Organisation name:



Postal address: 5 Amanda Place Ingleburn NSW, Australia 2560

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? Alongside other members of the Ngati Manuhiri we oppose this application on the basis of the ecological and environmental impact it has had on our whenua and native wildlife - specifically Pakiri Beach

208

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline the application in full





209

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marama Rawhiti

Organisation name:



Postal address: 28 Snowy Avenue Minto NSW, Australia 2560

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? As a Ngati Wai/Ngati Manuhiri iwi member, we cannot have our whenua destroyed for the profit of others. It is environmentally destructive what has been propsed

210

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline application completely





211

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Shaun Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 15 Castledine Cres Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Consulatation with local hapū ( as a whole) has not been consulted. Auckland Council needs to be considerate that though, dealing with local hapū is appreciated, further understanding of Māori leadership would be expected - especially when considering valuable taonga such as whenua

What are the reasons for your submission? Opposition of dredging and lack of consulatation.

212

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Consulting local hapū properly, through a Te Ao Māori lense. Please do research in regards to who the actual stakeholders are in the area (I.e. Land Owners of Māori land, Marae- where actual mana is held within Te Ao Māori)





213

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ariana Brown

Organisation name:



Postal address: 400 Chapel Road Flat Bush Auckland 2016

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To stop the mining of sand in Pakiri


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop it

214

2





215

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Moana Robson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 24 Coral Crescent Panmure Auckland 1061

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? My family are part of the Ngati Manuhiri iwi in Pakiri - we have watched the decline of our moana whenua from past dredging. This has to stop - we cannot continue to destroy the environment for the sake of profit.

216

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline in full





217

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Williams

Organisation name: Kurt



Postal address: 2 tainui st Onerahi Whangarei 0172

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: No no no the guy sumbmitting this is all about money he is money hungry takes from our people

What are the reasons for your submission? Do not want this to go ahead

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop do not proceed

218

2

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am a trade competitor of the applicant. I am directly affected by an effect of the proposed activity that adversely affects the environment, and that effect does not relate to trade competition or the effects of trade competition




219

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Lisa Foden

Organisation name:



Postal address: 187 Rahuikiri Rd PAKIRI Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of it

What are the reasons for your submission? The beach is being destroyed. The kaimoana is dying. The rips are more dangerous for swimmer. The shorebirds are going extinct.

220

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ban sand mining along the Pakiri and Te Arai coast





221

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Teagan Greenwood

Organisation name:



Postal address: 873 Pakiri Road RD2 Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining has damaged the shore line and should be stopped.

What are the reasons for your submission? I oppose sand mining off Pakiri beach as having been here for 29 years I have seen huge changes in the beach. Including huge reduction of sand dunes, reduced habitat for the coastal birds,, including protected species that nest here, rising tide line and drop offs in the sand where it was once a flat beach. It deeply saddens me to see what has been taken from this sacred land and believe it needs time to recover.

222

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I wish for a ban on sand mining in the area for several years at the very least.





223

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Margaret Fishlock

Organisation name:



Postal address: 356 Ocean View Road RD 4 Wellsford 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removal of sand from coastline

What are the reasons for your submission? I oppose the extraction of any more sand from this area. The damage to the fishing grounds is irreversible also the ecological effects are more than minor. Erosion to the foreshore will continue.

224

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline the application.





225

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Robin Morris

Organisation name:



Postal address: 32 Rustybrook Rd, Wellsford, Wellsford Auckland Auckland 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose creating 2 more golf courses

What are the reasons for your submission? The enviromental impact on the coastal land, the impact on the birdlife of the area and the physical impact on the roads leading to the development. Those roads are appalling now and I don't believe Auckland Council has any intention of changing that, anytime soon

226

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not give consent for any more development in this location.





227

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Glenys McBain

Organisation name:



Postal address: 60 Cotton Lane RD5 Mangawhai Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All aspects of sand removal

What are the reasons for your submission? This is a non renewable resource which is being used to replenish Auckland beaches and make concrete. Over the years this beautiful landmark and wildlife refuge will disappear. Oppose in entirety

228

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse resource consent





229

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vivienne Patricia Martens

Organisation name:



Postal address: 77 Avocado Lane RD 5 Mangawhai Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The application to remove ANY sand off the coast of Pakiri Beach no matter how far from the shore

What are the reasons for your submission? I totally disagree with the mining of sand from our coastline & the detrimental effects it will have on the environment.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? DO NOT grant the application for sand removal at all

230

2





231

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: David Reid

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 303424 North Harbour Auckland 0632

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am totally opposed to this consent for off shore sandmining.

What are the reasons for your submission? The sand in the Pakiri embayment is a finite resource. Once it has been taken it will never replenish. There are alternative sources of sand for Auckland's building / construction market. Off shore sandmining causes significant damage to the sea bed and sea life (fish and shellfish).

232

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the Auckland Council to turn down the application in its entirety.





233

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Susan Wiehahn

Organisation name:



Postal address: 83 Devich Rd Mangawhai Mangawhai 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Mining of area around the dune in mangawhai

What are the reasons for your submission? Do not want the dune disturbed as it has protected birds nesting

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not even consider mining the dune and surrounding areas

234

2





235

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Leigh Samuel

Organisation name:



Postal address: 87 Angelo Ave Howick Auckland 2014

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The ongoing dredging of the sand from Pakiri is devastating the landscape of this beach. It has eroded the natural sand dunes and damaged the natural environment.

What are the reasons for your submission? The environmental damage from continous and further sand dredging is compromising this natural landscape and harming the breeding for native birdlife survival. This has been ongoing for too long and it is time to give this natural resource a much needed reprieve and recovery.

236

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop further sand dredging and allow this beach to recover from the horrendous loss of sand over ongoing and continous years.





237

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Friday, 22 May 2020 3:31 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9618] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: AQA Submission - Auck Council May 2020.pdf

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Wayne Scott

Organisation name: Aggregate and Quarry Association of New Zealand



Postal address: P.O. Box 10-668 Wellington City Wellington 6143

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The need for secure and accessible supply of sand for affordable housing and infrastructure. The value of the aggregates sector to the economic wellbeing of Greater Auckland. Efficient use and development of resources.


238

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Approve the application as submitted




Supporting information: AQA Submission - Auck Council May 2020.pdf

239

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Corlene Greenwood

Organisation name:



Postal address: 71 te henga road rd1 Bethells Henderson 0781

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: As a child i watched this happining and watched our sanddunes wash away

What are the reasons for your submission? Been going on for to long. It is destroying Pākiri beach and kaimoana

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Let Pākiri replenish for the next 20 years for a change

242

2





243

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Svenja Gerth

Organisation name:



Postal address: 15 rona ave 1025 Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: X

What are the reasons for your submission? Enviromental reasons

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not allow the sand mining

244

2





245

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: zofia seymour

Organisation name:



Postal address: 61 waitea road Muriwai Beach Muriwai Beach 0881

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of it; I don't think sand mining should be allowed in this location, and especially not so close to shore. We should be protecting our coastlines and our wildlife.

What are the reasons for your submission? This is an area of stunning natural beauty and is an important and beloved destination for many kiwis to visit (as well as those who call it home.) It is also an important refuge for wildlife and delicate coastal area vulnerable to intensive anthropological alterations. There are many reasons it should be protected, such as the following:

246

2

Lifestyle & recreation: The areas of Mangawhai to Pakiri are growing settlements. It is built on the love of natural beauty and lifestyle- the area doesn’t need big industry to sustain & grow population. They are an ever growing popular spot for local tourism (an international) tourism, ranging from beautiful camping spots, batches and luxury offerings. The area is also becoming a hot spot for high value spending because of attractions such as the famous golf course & luxury developments; these can only be adversely effected by dredging activities on their doorstep. Surfing is the fastest growing sport in NZ and this is a central and important area for this activity. For locals, national & international tourism. NZ has already had proposals for ‘surf reserves’ following in the footsteps of the USA, AUS and other countries. We should be a world leader in this, and this area would be worthy of it. It is a hotspot for many other kinds of water based recreation, from fishing to kayaking. Many recreational visitors to the area often make the observation (on local community groups, social media, etc.) of dredging ships being extremely close to shore and being an unwanted presence. Wildlife: Home to the rarest bird in all of NZ- the fairy terns, who are increasingly threatened by loss of habitat (sand dunes) and also their food sources. The sandspit wildlife refuge is also home to other vulnerable birds such as the dotterel. Also it is in the name. SANDspit. We need the sand to be there for there to be a sandspit reserve. Erosion is already effecting the sandspit. Rescue works have already been necessary in the past, when a secondary river outlet burst through the dune, and ongoing projects work on dune restoration and preservation. It is an important feeding ground for transient larger marine mammals- orca in particular feed of the stingray that inhabit this area (the creature from which Mangawhai takes its name), and it is a popular feeding ground for dolphins. It is also a habitat for our shark friends; even hammerheads have been spotted in the area. Although these creatures are not year round residents, they are an important visitors also. We should not just be thinking about our human tourists. Sand dredging is harmful to all marine dwelling life. It creates noise pollution and creates sediment. In the water making conditions adverse to marine creatures of all kinds. Dredging literally destroys habitats and life forms. This area sits directly adjacent to two marine reserves- Tawharanui and Cape Rodney–Ōkakari Point to the south. Pakiri Beach, and the boundaries of the application permit, is right next to the marine reserve at Leigh. This was the first ever marine reserve in NZ- surely the surrounding areas are equally worthy of protection? Te Arai in particular is a haven for fish with its rocky outcrops providing a lovely habitat. COMMON SENSE: The world is running out of resources because of our consumption, and sand is one of them- the global situation is critical. Sand, like oil, is a finite and slow created resource. The sand taken from this area will not be quickly or easily replenished. We do not need to export sand from here to other places (such as Auckland beaches...) when we are also running out of sand in this area, and fighting for dune restoration. We should not be mining sand when we are also desperately trying to save our sand dunes. Erosion is an ever increasing problem nationwide. We need the sand. We KNOW there are risks with rising sea levels due to climate change in our future. Seriously, leave the sand. Allowing this seems extraordinarily short sighted. Bad form: The majority of global offshore mining is not permitted as close to shore or as shallow as this resource consent is asking for. There have been multiple public observations and complaints of the sand mining activities breaching their consent and coming in too close to shore- yet no action has been taken to mitigate or penalise this rule breaking.

247

3

Let’s learn from other countries: Just as we avoided disaster during the covid-19 pandemic by learning from observing disastrous results in other countries terribly and tragically affected, let’s learn from the devastation sand mining has become in other lands such as China, Indonesia, etc. We have the information & data, and we should act upon the risk, the same we we took action against corona virus. It doesn’t matter that this has already been going on for a number of years, it is never too late to stop, and continuing this activity can only be more harmful and destructive. There are other sources of sand for construction, such as crushing rocks, or potentially other more suitable areas for sand mining (if sand mining is really so essential to the wellbeing of New Zealand.) We also need to invest in investigating alternatives to sand or concrete as a construction material for a long term solution. The Green Covid Economic Stimulus Response is a popular and growing movement; and this is most decidedly not a ‘green’ activity. We should be looking to sustainable alternative for our future growth, not depleting our resources until we have nothing left.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To deny the resource consent and not allow offshore sand mining to continue in the area.





248

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Sunday, 24 May 2020 6:30 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:9700] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: Submission Sandmining Kaipara Ltd.doc

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Melanie Scott

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 206 Mangawhai Post Centre Mangawhai Mangawhai 0540

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The entire application to take sand from off the Te Arai, Pakiri coastline for the next twenty years.

What are the reasons for your submission? Sandmining on off the Te Ari / Pakiri beaches has done major damage to the coastline over the years. This coastline is under greater threat than ever before from development and sea level changes. Damage to sea bed, marine life and shore bird survival of critically endangered species such as the NZ Fairy Tern and the threatened NZ Dotterel

249

2

which nest and breed on the Mangawhai Spit are also of major concern. Most sand mined in New Zealand is used for making concrete, and concrete is considered one of the most environmental destructive materials used in construction. Its use is not aligned with international environmental concerns and standards.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I request that the council decline the application in its entirety.




Supporting information: Submission Sandmining Kaipara Ltd.doc

250

Submission on Resource Consent Application by Kaipara Ltd

Application number CST60343373

Sandmining in the Hauraki Gulf to extract 2,000,000 m3 of sand

From the Pakiri/Te Arai coastline over the next 20 years

My name is Melanie Scott. I live at 16 Kohanga Lane, Mangawhai. I oppose the

application to mine sand in the Hauaraki Gulf off the Te Arai/Pakiri coastline.

Environmental Impact and Safety

1. Sandmining on off the Te Ari / Pakiri beaches has done serious damage to the

coastline over many years. The damage is evidenced by the decrease in size

and stability of sand dunes all along the coast in this area. In particular the

iconic Mangawhai Spit Dune which was documented by Captain James Cook as

he sailed down the east coast of the northern north island, has been reduced in

height and volume, quite noticeably over the last two decades.

2. This coastline is under greater threat than ever before from development, climate

change and its consequent sea level changes. Damage to the sea bed, marine

life and the threat to shore bird habitat and survival, in particular critically

endangered species such as the NZ Fairy Tern and the threatened NZ Dotterel

nesting and breeding on the Mangawhai Spit, are of urgent concern.

3. Most sand mined in New Zealand is used for making concrete, and concrete is

considered one of the most environmental destructive materials used in

construction. Its use is not aligned with international environmental concerns

and standards.

4. Shifting and slumping beaches along the Te Arai and Pakiri coastlines are

considered contributing factors to the safety of swimming and surfing. The area

to the north and south of Te Arai Point is part of an Auckland Regional Park,

used by an increasing number of local residents and visitors from Auckland.

There is no life guard support for these beaches and anecdotally there have

been drownings, especially at Pakiri which have been attributed to unstable

sand and beach gradients caused by sandmining.

Compliance

1. Over the past two decades I have spent many hours on these beaches and on the

Mangawhai Spit where I a volunteer observer of NZ Fairy Terns during their

251

breeding season. I have observed sandmining vessels operating inside the

proscribed area close to the shore, practically in the surf line on Te Arai and I

have seen mining vessels moving north beyond the Auckland/Kaipara District

boundary.

I request that the Council decline the resource consent application in its entirety.

I wish to speak in support of my submission.

Melanie Scott

16 Kohanga Lane, Mangawhai

PO Box 206, Mangawhai Post Centre, Mangawhai 0540

Tel 09 431 3237, 0274 521 327

252

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Greg and Davin Bradford

Organisation name:



Postal address: 571 Rahuikiri Rd, Pakiri, RD 4 Wellsford 0900 Pakiri Auckland 0900

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Volume of sand intended to be extracted, damage to coastal marine environment including detrimental effects to Hauraki Park Maritime Park which is contiguous with proposed area to be mined, the intended area is a catchment of the Hauraki Park Maritime Park which is recognised as being of national importance.

What are the reasons for your submission? My reasons for opposing the application are: a): Depletion of a finite resource,

253

2

b): Alternative sand supplies on shore at Kaipara Harbour, c): Marine environment and adverse effects on the same, d): Lack of trust barge operations operating within current limits

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The refusal of the application.





254

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marion And David Pilmer

Organisation name:



Postal address: 32 Cullen Street Mangawhai Heads Kaipara 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand Mining Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? To Stop the sandmining on our beautiful Coast which is having a disastrous effect on The Coastline

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? STOP T H E SANDMINING

255

2

NOW





256

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Olivia Watkins

Organisation name:



Postal address: 873 Whangaripo Valley Road Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The amount of sand proposed to be extracted, and the area to be extracted.

What are the reasons for your submission? The harm already done, to the seabed and marine life, is woefully evident, from previous, and current, dredging. Please stop destroying our natural environment. Give it a chance to replenish itself before granting further consent.

257

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? For the applicant to seek better, more environmentally friendly, options to meet their needs; to leave the sacred environment of Pakiri alone as it has already suffered enough from previous dredging, with none of the replenishment the applicant claims happens.





258

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Alan Greenwood

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Aries Place Shelly Park Auckland 2014

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Against the removal of the quantity of sand

What are the reasons for your submission? This will effect the look of the beach and the plant life as well as the errosion of the sand dunes

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? There must be a decision not the removed sand from Pakiri Beach or off shore

259

2





260

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sue Clayton

Organisation name:



Postal address: 44a Jack Boyd Drive Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: STOP the mining close to our shoreline.

What are the reasons for your submission? No other country allows nearshore sand mining this close to beautiful beaches and coastline. Our sand is precious and this mining is not sustainable. Our seabeds are dead after this type of mining, so our fish and shellfish also die. Our sand dunes and beaches are eroded. In this era of environmental awareness this is lunacy (or money-making at its worst) and we will lose one of the most beautiful areas in New Zealand if the mining is allowed to continue.

261

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not remove the mining/dredging licence.





262

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Glenn Pope

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 Kedge Drive Mangawhai Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose the existing and proposed level of sand mining from the area off Mangawhai, Te Arai and Pakiri.

What are the reasons for your submission? My concerns relate to the removal of sand so close to the coast and the effects this will have on coastal processes, climate change resilience, marine ecology and recreational surfing opportunities in the area. Coastal processes - I oppose any sand mining that will reduce the amount of sand available to replenish sand dunes

263

2

in the area. These dunes form a natural buffer to climate change induced sea level rise and provide habitat for nationally threatened and rare native birds. Climate change resilience - I oppose sand mining that will threaten the ability of the sand dunes and beaches in the area to replenish themselves naturally or where the removal of sand adds to the ongoing erosion problems that will be exacerbated by climate change induced sea level rise. Marine ecology - I oppose sand mining as this removes marine habitat within the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park. It also removes valuable habitat and feeding areas for fish in the area. Recreational surfing - I oppose any sand mining that will continue to change the near shore sand bar and bank systems that provide wave riding opportunities in the area. The subject application does not appear to adequately assess this due to the mining taking place in deeper water. However, it is not clear how that assessment is justified.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? - A third party review of the coastal processes associated with the proposed sand mining in the area, and their effects considering all sand mining operations in the area (including McCullum Brothers). Including effects on surf breaks. - A third party review of the effects on marine ecology as a result of sand mining activity. Review to be undertaken with the requirements of the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park Act (HGMPA) in mind also. - An unbiased, expert assessment of the claims regarding the necessity to mine sand from the marine area rather than from other more easily accessed terrestrial sources (such as on exitsing, cleared farm land around New Zealand) to supply the building and construction industry. Should the Council (or Hearing, or Court) be satisfied that the effects of the proposal are adequately managed or mitigated and that a consent would be issued, the applicant should be bound to monitor the effects of the sand mining operation on the coastal marine area and nearby coastal beaches on an annual basis, and have some form of management regime in place to manage the overall take of sand from the area should adverse effects be generated. Reports should be publically available and provided annually and the applicant should be bound to comply with some form of management response to any issues noted.





264

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Collin Juneau

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1/32 Sydney Street Hauraki Auckland 0622

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Objecting against sand mining as it is ruining the sand banks hence making poor surf condition.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Prohibition of sand mining of the Mangawhai Coast

265

2





266

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Maxwell Norman Rollo Kidd

Organisation name:



Postal address: 56 Red Hill Rd RD5 Wellsford Auckland 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Old technology destroying our environment


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline in total this application

267

2





268

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Helen Margaret Parkes

Organisation name:



Postal address: Po Box 53 Leigh Auckland 0947

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removal of sand from the coastal zone near Pakiri beach

What are the reasons for your submission? The beach scape has changed dramatically from the years of sand dredging. This has reduced the numbers of shorebirds through loss of habitat and protective shelter the dunes provided.

269

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To deny the application for dredging and removal of sand from the shore and seabed in this beach coastal zzz one.





270

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Keziah Gallagher

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2 Tara Road Mangawhai Northland 0573

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? Its ruining our coastline

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop sand mining so close to shire

271

2





272

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Matthew Holdsworth

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Northcoast place Mangawhai heads Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Opposing

What are the reasons for your submission? Added pollution and hurtful to the environment for little gains

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not to do it

273

2





274

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tony Enderby

Organisation name: N/a



Postal address: PO Box 139 Leigh, Rodney District Auckland 0947

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Taking of sand from the Hauraki Gulf. This is a finite resource and needs to be protected.

What are the reasons for your submission? We cannot keep taking what is a finite resource.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop all sand mining in the Hauraki Gulf.

275

2





276

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nichelle Phillips

Organisation name:



Postal address: 5 Cumberland Street Leigh Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Primarily Ecological. The extractions of sand from Pakiri already over the years has had an erosive effect. I don't have the photos myself, but I've seen the photos of other residents in the area (that I know are making submissions) of what the area used to be like before the extractions began.

What are the reasons for your submission? The Council (and wider government) must cease with its "Out of sight, out of mind" approach to our coastal and

277

2

marine environments and halt these damaging practices where the effects not only have long-term consequence, but also subsequently affect other nearby areas. It's shameful given the condition of the Hauraki Gulf already that such exploitative extractions have been allowed in the past to proceed so close to both Goat Island, a historic Marine Reserve, and nesting grounds for endangered coastal birds; Mangawhai, Te Awai, Goat Island and the whole of Parkiri itself. When tourists come to the area and ask about the boats, they are concerned about the proximity to these vulnerable ecosystems, and it's highly damaging to New Zealand's image as a whole.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse the renewal request.





278

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Amanda Tunstall

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 kauri loop road oratia auckland 0604

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am against sand mining at Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? It’s terrible for the critically endangered birds that live there and will have negative consequences for fragile eco systems

279

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop sand mining





280

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gillian Kaye Cottrell

Organisation name:



Postal address: 94 Avocado Lane, RD5, Wellsford wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of sand

What are the reasons for your submission? Detrimental effects on the sea floor and sand dunes

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline the application

281

2





282

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Courtney Henley-Smith

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1281 whangaripo Valley Road Whangaripo Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Opposing the renewal of the sand mining licence for both near shore and offshore sand mining at Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand mining is a direct cause of erosion, and impacts the local wildlife in particular the native fairy tern which inhabits the pakiri area and is in danger of becoming extinct. Removal of physical coastal barriers, such as dunes can also lead to flooding.

283

2

We are therefore opposed to Pakiri being used for sand mining due to the negative environmental effects and unsustainable nature of the mining, particularly the effects of erosion and consider concrete and other building materials for which the sand is currently mined for can be sourced elsewhere from sustainable sources without causing such destruction to the natural habitat at Pakiri. Pakiri is one of Aucklands last pristine beaches and there is no need for unsustainable sand mining to be continued here when there are other sustainable sources available in the Kaipara area Pakiri is the largest near shore sand mine in the world because all other developed countries have put a stop to this, NZ and more particularly Auckland Council need to step up and do the same before its too late.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse the application completely as has been done in all other developed countries- near shore sand mining should not be allowed at all





284

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Lorraine Brien

Organisation name:



Postal address: 307 School Road, RD4 Wellsford Auckland 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose the entire sand mining proposal.

What are the reasons for your submission? The disruption to the natural balance of erosion and accretion on local beaches. The adverse effects to the seabed, the destruction of habitats and marine ecosystems. Damage to shellfish stocks, in turn effecting the entire marine food chain. Disruption to the natural surf break.

285

2

Underwater noise pollution. Pollution from fuel and oil. Light pollution to an untouched natural piece of our dark seascape. Unknown effects to our local fishery. With this proposal, the balance of sustainability leans too heavily on the economic advantages. The likelihood of adverse effects on the environment and social and cultural well-being are just too high.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To oppose the proposal entirely.





286

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Myles Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1 Rahuikiri Road Wellsford Wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The whole thing

What are the reasons for your submission? The beach is losing sand and sand dunes. Protect the beach for the future, our children

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The whole thing. Just don’t do it

287

2





288

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Devon Taylor

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3 Domain Crescent Waitakere Waitakere 0881

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop sandmining our beaches! Leave them alone!


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop this and protect our beaches.

289

2





290

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Troy Jordan Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 260 Pakiri River Rd Pakiri Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I Don't want any more Sand Dredging at all

What are the reasons for your submission? Kaipara and McCullom Sand Badger's have done enough Damage to our Land's as We are Maori Landowners.

291

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I want the Council to Reject this Application because we allowed it once and once only. We are the rightful Maori Landowners.





292

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Katherine norman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 964 Matakana Valley Rd. Rd2 Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: ALL OF IT. This mining is adjacent to one of the only marine reserves in the country.

What are the reasons for your submission? The area for mining is adjacent to a marine reserve.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To reject it.

293

2





294

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Damon Clapshaw

Organisation name:



Postal address: 779 Pakiri Block Road Tomarata Wellsford 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? - causal underwater and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging

295

2

- the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for sole private family profit - offshore sand dredging is out of kilter with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





296

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Martin Graham Johanson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 113 Churchill Road Murrays Bay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Extraction of sand, organisms and damage to the seabed.

What are the reasons for your submission? Damage to the seabed which ultimately affects the fishery and its dependence on the natural resources that are being taken

297

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the rape and pillage of this particular place, why not look at alternatives such as sand bars in the entrances of the harbors etc?





298

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Bridgette Rademakers

Organisation name:



Postal address: 269 Mahurangi West Road Puhoi RD3 Auckland 0983

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To allow the continued dredging of this area in all its aspects.

What are the reasons for your submission? I am a local user of the area for recreational purposes such as surfing, walking, swimming and relaxing, I have also

299

2

worked in the area with the Department of Conservation as a Marine Ranger in the protection of the Cape Rodney- Okakari Point Marine Reserve and monitoring the New Zealand fairy tern population at Pakiri and Te Arai beach. This submission represents my own independent views. I think the application should not be granted for several reasons as indicated below: •The proposed dredging boundaries are essentially abutting Significant Ecological Area (Marine 2) and lie in extreme proximity to Significant Ecological Area (Marine 1) New Zealand’s highest protection awarded sites, as well as Outstanding Natural Landscapes. Given the already recognised value and importance of this ecological area it is vital that this area is awarded the protection that it requires from future adverse activities. While the proposed extraction boundaries currently lie outside of these areas it is important to note that the marine environment is fluid and dynamic, thus any set “boundaries” in real terms will have cross over and flow on effects outside of these areas. Therefore, any impacts within the proposed extraction zone will not be confined to this area but also impact the surrounding Significant Ecological Areas. •Future extensions to the Cape Rodney- Okakari Point (CROP) Marine Reserve should also be taken into consideration when reviewing the application. Given the support of the current Minister of Conservation Eugenie Sage for the extension of CROP Marine Reserve in the coming years it is highly probable that the reserve will be extended to fall within even closer proximity to the proposed extraction boundaries within the next 20-year period. •Continued degradation and disturbances to marine life within the area. This activity will continue to have negative impacts to the benthic environment within the area, with the true extent of the these impacts never to be known given the lack of baseline information prior to the original consent being granted. However, documented adverse impacts to benthic dwelling organisms, such as horse mussels and protected stony corals and the wider benthic community will continue. Which not only impacts these species but also adversely affects the organisms that depend upon them and the ecological services that they provide. Fin fish and marine mammals will also continue to be impacted by suspended sediments and noise pollution, disrupting their natural feeding habitats, communication and foraging techniques. Given the poor state of our Hauraki Gulf Marine Park recently documented in the State of our Gulf 2020 report these impacts should be given the full weight in which they deserve. •Impacted coastal processes and beach and dune morphology. The application indicates that the offshore extraction zone is essential a closed cell unit, largely independent of coastal sediment transport pathways. It is clear that this coastline has seen a reduction in the volume of sand supply to the beach and dunes over the years (you only need to look at photographic evidence to note these extensive changes). However, to state that this offshore sand dredging activity is “not likely to affect nearshore and beach processes” is a stretch. I am aware that there are near shore sand extraction operations in place which are most definitely affecting the sand supply to this coastline, however I am not convinced that this offshore activity is not also contributing to this issue. Any adverse impacts to the sand supply to this area should be avoided, given the critical importance of a healthy supply of sand to this coastline in order to sustain, vital nesting sites for the endangered ‘Category A’ fairy terns, and sand dune systems which also provide important habitat for katipo spiders and offer storm surge protection. Considering the recent and rapid changes the world over has seen to weather patterns and the unpredictability of these patterns in the coming 20-year period, I do not think it is feasible to say with certainty that this activity which operates in a dynamic and fluid environment will not affect nearshore and beach processes over that time period. In an analogy it is like saying licking an ice cream won’t affect the volume on the cone and in this case I think common sense and precaution should prevail. The economic benefits to New Zealanders from allowing the sand extraction to continue should be offset by the long-term economic costs of having to restore this area in generations to come. •Bearing in mind all the above points the flow on affects that these will have to the recreational value, and as a result the economic value, of the area is another reason why this consent should not be granted. This area is becoming increasingly populated with significant housing and services developments that are occurring and is also a highly visited area by the wider Auckland population as well as overseas visitors. With the development of the Stand Up Paddle (SUP) boards and the increasing use of this area by surfers, spear fishermen, fishermen and beach goers it is important that the quality of this area is maintained in term of sand supply, sand bar formation, wave processes etc. The community health benefits and the economic value of maintaining and protecting an asset such as this coastline should be prioritised. It is also important that the safety of water users is taken into consideration. With SUP’s and other water users such as kayak fishermen extending further out to sea in this area there is potential for cross path collisions to occur. I have already witnessed on several occasions where sand dredging barges are so close to Te Arai Point that any surfer/SUP user in the back line or spear fisherman off this point could have easily ended up within the path of these vessels had they not been careful which is very alarming. It is unclear as to whether these vessels were operating on the near or offshore extraction zones however with the increasing use of this area, the potential for these incidents should be eliminated by preventing further consent of these activities.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to not grant this application


300

3




301

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Wednesday, 27 May 2020 4:16 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10085] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: Final SPS submission .docx

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Paul Shanks

Organisation name: Surfbreak Protection Society



Postal address: P.O.Box 2 Whaingaroa Raglan 3265 Whaingaroa Raglan Whaingaroa Raglan 3265

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The application in its entirety, including but not limited to, the assessments of the coastal processes, ecological effects and the economic contribution and impact from seabed mining and cumulative effects.

What are the reasons for your submission? The application has a high potential to create significant adverse impacts to surf breaks, benthic community, marine mammals/fish/birds along with damage to the seafloor and erosion of the coastal margins and dune systems.

302

2

There has been minimal research over any length of time to accurately gauge the recovery of the damaged benthic environment. The dredge discharge destroys bivalves, eradicated/ destroyed the Horse mussel populations and scallop beds. The sediment plume smothers the seabed and the seabed strip -mining extraction will have significant adverse effects on the food chain that starts from the tube worms and benthic organisms. The rare stony corrals are being destroyed and there are significant impacts to marine mammals and fish from noise impacts. Noise travels large distances underwater and the activity from the open cast strip mining has a high potential to damage, alter, disturb or cause marine mammals to change or move their migratory patterns due to the strip-mining operation over several decades. Monitoring reports are based on out of date data. The adaptive management approach and environmental management plan are flawed. Statutory Obligations The application has failed to meet the tests as set out Section 5 of the Resource Management Act 1991. Additionally, it has failed to take into account the provisions of the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010 in Policy 13,15,16 and other relevant planning provisions.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline the application in entirety.




Supporting information: Final SPS submission .docx

303

of 3

P.O.Box 2 Whaingaroa

Raglan 3265 [email protected]

Auckland Council Resource Consents Private Bag 92300 Auckland 1142 Re: Application number CST60343373 Applicant Kaipara Limited [email protected] David Hay Osborne Hay (North) Limited PO Box 16 Warkworth Auckland 0941 27 May 2020 Submission closes 4 June 2020 Application details To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20‐year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit between the 30m and 40m isobaths.

o Surfbreak Protection Society opposes the consent in entirety

o Surfbreak Protection Society wish to be heard at the Hearing

o Decline application in entirety

304

of 3

Introduction

Surfbreak Protection Society (SPS) is a Society dedicated to the conservation of the

"treasures" of the New Zealand Surfing Community ‐ our surf breaks ‐ through the

preservation of their natural characteristics, water quality, marine eco systems and low

impact access for all.

Submission

SPS are opposed to the application in its entirety due to the potential for significant adverse effects as below Application details To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20‐year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit between the 30m and 40m isobaths.

The specific parts of the application to which my/our submission relates to are: The application in its entirety, including but not limited to, the assessments of the coastal processes, ecological effects and the economic contribution and impact from seabed mining and cumulative effects. The reasons for my/our submission are: The application has a high potential to create significant adverse impacts to surf breaks, benthic community, marine mammals/fish/birds along with damage to the seafloor and erosion of the coastal margins and dune systems. There has been minimal research over any length of time to accurately gauge the recovery of

the damaged benthic environment. The dredge discharge destroys bivalves, eradicated/

destroyed the Horse mussel populations and scallop beds. The sediment plume smothers the

seabed and the seabed strip ‐mining extraction will have significant adverse effects on the

food chain that starts from the tube worms and benthic organisms. The rare stony corrals are

being destroyed and there are significant impacts to marine mammals and fish from noise

impacts.

Noise travels large distances underwater and the activity from the open cast strip mining has

a high potential to damage, alter, disturb or cause marine mammals to change or move their

migratory patterns due to the strip‐mining operation over several decades. Monitoring

305

of 3

reports are based on out of date data. The adaptive management approach and

environmental management plan are flawed.

Statutory Obligations

The application has failed to meet the tests as set out Section 5 of the Resource Management

Act 1991. Additionally, it has failed to take into account the provisions of the New Zealand

Coastal Policy Statement 2010 in Policy 13,15,16 and other relevant planning provisions.

The decision I/we would like council to make is Decline the application in entirety.

306

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kutumi Lefferts

Organisation name:



Postal address: 20 Prime Road Grey Lynn Auckland 1021

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Application.

What are the reasons for your submission? First and foremost, the owner of the business who wishes to extract sand from Pakiri Beach intended in the application document that he would not publicly notify the public. This legally demonstrates he has full knowledge of community opposition to this application to sand mine. And if it was for commercial confidence against known competitors, all the more reason to share it so everyone has a fair knowledge of the market value, instead of trying to

307

2

increase profit through secrecy. This raises question what does the director not want known to the public? What is he hiding? Second, I grew up on Rodney Road. I hold no legal claim to the beach but I believe a decision such as this demands community level involvement and unanimous consent. Pakiri Beach is a public space for all and a long term, maybe even short term mining of the sand bar could change the ecosystem and shape of the beach we've grown up with.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like to see environmental experts review the application, the impacts to the ecosystem and to stop this application from being approved. Has the applicant considered sustainable controls on the extraction of sand to ensure regeneration of the natural environment? Has he explored issues and solutions with the public? What guarantee is there the money generated from this mining will be returned to the local iwi and community? I would like council to set an example that Auckland, and New Zealand beaches, are not commodities for the rich and influential. Thank you for reading my submission.





308

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kara Stones

Organisation name:



Postal address: 39 Kahurangi Lane RD2 Kaiwaka Mangawhai 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Extraction of any sand form the Pakiri Coastal area

What are the reasons for your submission? Environmental impacts, likely consequences of degradation of beautiful beaches and sand hills in the Mangawhai and Pakiri area, impacts on recreation, tourism, and wildlife including rare native birds in the area

309

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To decline this resource consent absolutely and indefinitely in the interests of our community and our future





310

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vanessa Vujcich

Organisation name:



Postal address: 790 Durham Road Upper Inglewood Taranaki 4388

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The unsustainable extraction of sand and its ongoing impacts

What are the reasons for your submission? Our pristine east coast beaches are being impacted negatively by this activity.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse the consent application

311

2





312

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ryan Vujcich

Organisation name:



Postal address: P O Box 213 Kaiwaka Kaiwaka 0542

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Opposing to any seabed sand mining whatsoever.

What are the reasons for your submission? Damage to the coastline, erosion, shellfish beds and as a surfer it affects to sand banks/wave quality

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny the above consent

313

2





314

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Christopher Patterson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 525 Te Arai Point Road Wellsford Auckland 0975

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? - causal, direct and/or indirect offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri and Mangawhai embayments are in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand

315

2

taken out of the system via dredging. - the sand system is in an annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources both locally and beyond - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments - The future cost of restoration will significantly exceed any quantifiable benefits. There is no security that the applicant will be able to meet those costs if required or even exist.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayments and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto.





316

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Thomas Rutherford

Organisation name: N/A



Postal address: P O Box 40 Leigh Auckland 0947

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To totally stop sand extraction from Pakiri Beach and the coast north to Mangawhai

317

2

What are the reasons for your submission? As a regular visitor and walker along the beach I am amazed at the speed the sand above the water line is receding. Old fence lines just hanging in mid air, sand hills reducing.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop applications for the above area and take it from the West Coast and Kaipara harbour.





318

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sherie Wikaira

Organisation name:



Postal address: 40 Line Rd Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: No more Sand Mining from Offshore or Onshore in Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? This has gone on longer enough. This is a beautiful resource and I am sick of see the boats our there dredging. It needs to stop. We need to let nature heal itself and replace what has been stolen by us humans.

319

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop dredging Sand at Pakiri





320

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Isaac Reid

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Salisbury Street Herne Bay Auckland 1011

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are;The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are;- causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system

321

2

for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources- a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit- climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate- offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is;The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





322

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gary Iseke

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 33928 Takapuna Auckland 0740

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging

323

2

- the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






324

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jannine Wilkinsom

Organisation name:



Postal address: 63 Brigantine Drive Auckland Auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The dredging of sand at Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? The dredging of sand at Pakiri Beach is having a significant adverse environment effect offshore and onshore and affects flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity

325

2

It is clearly obvious that the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus the volume of dredging extraction. Only a few years ago the sea was not visible from the estuary, this is no longer the case.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Completely stop sand dredging at Pakiri Beach and reject the current application.





326

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Arne Hilke

Organisation name:



Postal address: 305/85 Daldy Street, Auckland CBD Auckland 1010

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? This sand is non-renewable. There are alternative, sustainable supply sources. Pakiri Beach is a finite, precious resource enjoyed by the greater public and is being depleted for private profit.

327

2

We know how this ends. Dredging has caused significant negative effects to other beaches and disturbs the sea bed and marine ecosystem.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? End all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto.





328

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Elizabeth Mulligan

Organisation name:



Postal address: 12 Peterhouse Place West Harbour Auckland 0618

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Opposing removal of sand on Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? Clearly to preserve nature

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop abusing nature and taking what does not belong to you

329

2





330

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Heugh Kelly

Organisation name: Heugh M Kelly

Contact phone number: 0274-985307


Postal address: PO Box 207 Wellsford Wellsford 0940

Submission details




331

2

- the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments This activity is essentially mining of a limited resource in its location and should be conducted further offshore where it would not have the same potential effects on the coastline






332

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Hala Nasr

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1/8 Knightsbridge Drive, Forrest Hill Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? The damage to the environment is undeniable! It causes offshore and onshore terrible environmental effects e.g. effects flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity. Not only this but the sand is a finite resource - This bothers me so much as someone who is at Pakiri every summer enjoying the beautiful natural golden sand and clear waters.

333

2

Why are we dredging the sand when they are sustainable alternatives? There is literally no good reason to be ruining this beautiful paradise that many of us have spent our summers in for our entire lives (not an exaggeration - if you connected with the Pakiri-goer community, you'd know that!)

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? End ALL dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and do not renew ANY licence/s or amendments thereto





334

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Lisa Barrington

Organisation name:



Postal address: 54 Douglas Street Whakatane Whakatane 3120

Submission details




335

2

- the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments - it is counterproductive to remove a resource (sand) from a pristine beach to prop up beaches in another area, it is a band-aid measure, not a long term nor sustainable solution

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto.





336

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Paul and Louise Hendrickx

Organisation name: AArchitech Design & Draughting



Postal address: 19 Eveline Street Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Taking of any and all sand from all depths along the coast from Cape Rodney in the south to Bream Tail in the north.

What are the reasons for your submission? This sand is the only protection the coast has against erosion. With global warming producing an increase in sea levels and more extreme weather events, taking the coasts natural defences will endanger all coastal property and the people that live and work upon it.

337

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not renew the licence to remove sand from this area.





338

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Philip Faulkner

Organisation name:



Postal address: 6 towbridge pl Howick Auckland 2014

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging Pakiri beach

What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are; - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging

339

2







340

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Derek Moffat

Organisation name:



Postal address: 7 Niccol Ave Auckland Auckland 0624

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity . Goat Island reserve and the whole area is precious. Jeopardizing that for monetary gain for a minority is not acceptable.

341

2






342

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: ian Plater

Organisation name:



Postal address: 16 Waiau Street Torbay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Non complying activity and the form of its exercise, being offshore, to much sand will be taken and the disturbance of the sea bed

What are the reasons for your submission? Offshore dredging is out of step with the regional and national directives on climate change protocols.

343

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to end all dredging in the pakiri mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licences or amendments thereto





344

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Rosie Davidson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 103 Hamilton Road Warkworth Warkworth 0982

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from and disturbance to, the seabed, using a trailing suction pipe in the Pakiri embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? The adverse environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality and biodiversity. A finite and precious resource as enjoyed by the general public is being depleted for private profit.

345

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence or amendments thereto





346

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Cherry Clements

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1 Riverlea Drive Katikati Katikati 3129

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form of its exercise, being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? -Adverse environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity. - The Pakiri embayment is a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging

347

2

- The sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - The licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence. - There are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - A precious resource which is enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit. - Climate change effects have not been properly considered, such as rising sea levels, which are a direct threat to the coast; dredging will further exacerbate this. - Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment to stop immediately and that any licence(s) or amendments to them are not renewed.





348

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Dell Thrasyvoulou

Organisation name:



Postal address: 48 Moir Point rd Mangawhai Mangawhai mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: to stop the extraction of sand close to shore along the whole coast

What are the reasons for your submission? i want the sand to remain where it is. you can never replace once its gone

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To STOP the sand mining

349

2





350

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kirsty Campbell

Organisation name:



Postal address: 16 Mariposa Crescent Birkenhead Auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity i.e. the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? - it's a stunning wilderness area within easy distance of Auckland. Leave it be. - I am concerned about the offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity

351

2

- the Pakiri embayment is a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - it should be left alone - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - apparently the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence (I have not verified this claim) - apparently there are alternative, sustainable sand supply sources - it is a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, which is being depleted for private profit. How is this justifiable? - apparently climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






352

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Emily Parker

Organisation name:



Postal address: 79 Bishop Lane Buckletons Beach Auckland 0968

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging

353

2







354

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Grant Montgomery

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 18485 Glen Innes Auckland 1743

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are; The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? I have witnessed the effects over the last 25 years of the damage created by sand dredging. In the Pakiri areas there has been a noticeable effect on the surf. It has become quite messy as the natural shelves have been altered by the

355

2

dredging. It is far more powerful & dangerous in easterly winds than it ever used to be yet the weather patterns have actually become more stable (the 2020 drought & lack of storm patterns is a good example). However the most noticeable effect is the change to the Mangawhai sand dunes. I would love to have data that proves a massive loss of sand and subsequent reduction in height of the main sand mountain but unfortunately that data does not exist. However I would ask the Council to seek the opinion of any Mangawhai resident over the age of 50. I guarantee that they will swear by visual observation that the sand mountain has reduced in height by approx 5 to 10 metres. It is not self replenishing. Further issues to note are - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






356

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sarina Pitkethley

Organisation name: Billing



Postal address: 69b Bailey st Huntly Huntly 3700

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? For the most parts I oppose due to the negative environmental impact dredging causes. However, I also oppose it because funds are not flowing from the sale of these sands, to whom it should be flowing to-kaitiakitanga.

357

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To end all dredging in the Pakiri and Mangawhai embayment. Also to not renew the licence allowing it.





358

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tom Bevan

Organisation name:



Postal address: 38 Stanmore Road Grey Lynn Auckland 1021

Submission details




359

2







360

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael John Hughes

Organisation name:



Postal address: 23 Bramber St Flagstaff Hamilton 3210

Submission details




361

2







362

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jane Ward

Organisation name:



Postal address: 28 Mariposa Crescent Birkenhead Auckland 0626

Submission details




363

2

- the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment Please!





364

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Scott Rooney

Organisation name: Storprint



Postal address: Dam Holme 11 stenlose stenlose 3660

Submission details




365

2







366

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ben Parsons

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Egremont St Belmont Auckland 0622

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non-complying activity in terms of the offshore extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? A finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit and this will diminish not only the ecology of the area but our community use of a public space

367

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not provide or renew any licences to dredge the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment





368

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Robyn Minson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 40 Jamieson Road RD3 Mahurangi West Warkworth 0983

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The extraction of sand from the Pakiri area.

What are the reasons for your submission? Detrimental environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity. Pakiri is a unique region and should not be used for financial profit.

369

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not allow any applications suggesting removal of sand from Pakiri to go ahead. All current sand dredging to end immediately.





370

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jana Harrison

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Telstar Place Beach Haven Auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging and removal of sand from Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? Unsustainable taking a finite resource which should be owned by the commons. The disruption of habitats. The company has breached previous conditions.

371

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not renew the license for any company in this area.





372

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Catherine Cumming

Organisation name:



Postal address: 43 Melrose Avenue London London 1204

Submission details




373

2







374

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sara Kulins

Organisation name: I Speak for the Sea



Postal address: P.O. Box 404012, 87 Lenzen Road Puhoi Puhoi 0951

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are; - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity

375

2

- the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is; The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





376

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kirstie Hilke

Organisation name:



Postal address: 305/85 Daldy Street Auckland Central Auckland 1010

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? I find it hard to believe that this kind of activity is still permitted, given what we know about the environmental damage it causes to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity. There are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources, so why is this still an option?

377

2

The Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging. The sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes. Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments. We should be preserving this finite and precious resource, and looking after a beautiful New Zealand beach for future generations.






378

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kirsty Clapshaw

Organisation name:



Postal address: 779 Pakiri Block Road Wellsford Auckland 0974

Submission details




379

2







380

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Melissa Gunn

Organisation name:



Postal address: 75 Verbena Road Birkdale Auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are: The activity and the form(s) of its exercise. That is, the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri bay.

What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are it would cause offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity. The Pakiri bay is essentially a closed system. The sand system is in

381

2

annual deficit from sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes. There are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources of sand. A finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit. Climate change effects have not been properly considered e.g. rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate. Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is the ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





382

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Margie Thomson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 175 Richmond Road Auckland Auckland 1021

Submission details




383

2







384

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Gerard Sweetman

Organisation name:



Postal address: P.O. Box 25 Wellsford Auckland 0974

Submission details




385

2







386

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: James Mackay

Organisation name: Mackay Management Limited



Postal address: 310a Glenvar Road Auckland Auckland 0630

Submission details




387

2







388

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Maria Collins

Organisation name:



Postal address: 240 Govan Wilson rd Whangaripo Warkworth 0985

Submission details




389

2







390

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Mitchel Versey

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2b Pohutukawa Avenue Red Beach Auckland 0932

Submission details




391

2







392

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Donna Marie Flavell

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 239 Mangawhai Mangawhai 0540

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the

393

2

system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






394

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ben d'Anvers

Organisation name:



Postal address: 27 Smale Street Point Chevalier Auckland 1022

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? I believe that granting this license in any form will have a less than minor (major in fact) impact on the surrounding natural environment.

395

2

1) Causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity 2) The Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging 3) The sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes 4) The licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence 5) There are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources 6) A finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit 7) Climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate 8) Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






396

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Joseph David Hassell

Organisation name:



Postal address: 494C Wainui Road RD3 RAGLAN 3297

Submission details




397

2







398

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Laura Marsh

Organisation name:



Postal address: 22 Taioma Crescent Te Atatu Peninsula Auckland 0610

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? As a surfer and a swimmer at Pakiri beach, I regularly experience the ocean from within it. As a seafood lover I ingest the bounty of the ocean. The destruction of the seabed undoubtably has a chain reaction that can be measured and simply imagined, potentially effecting the waves and the bio-diversity of the local area, with flow-on effects. The

399

2

applicant has shown they are fine with breeching their current permit, this cannot go on, especially under the light of climate change. Please decide to take a stand against further destruction of our eco-system, we only have one. Further to this: - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






400

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Seong Min Kim

Organisation name:



Postal address: 49 Ellice Road Totara Vale Auckland 0629

Submission details




401

2







402

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: CASEY KING

Organisation name:



Postal address: 68 ferry parade herald island auckland 0618

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non-complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.


403

2

- the sand system is in an annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non-renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





404

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sue Clayton

Organisation name:



Postal address: 44a Jack Boyd Drive Mangawhai Mangawhai Heads 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The extraction of 2million cubic metres of sand every year for the next 20 years must not be allowed.

What are the reasons for your submission? This sand dredging so close to our beautiful beaches and sand dunes is criminal in these more enlightened times. Sandmining removes marine life permanently. We have a duty to protect our environment for future generations. This commercial enterprise destroys the sea bed - it cannot recover in after almost 80 years of continual mining (even if the area was not mined for the next 20). They dredge operates within 25 metres of shore (and I believe breaches this

405

2

limit at times) and no marine life can survive if you overturn the whole sea bed. Mining contributed to the closing off of the Mangawhai harbour entrance, and the breach of the spit over 20 years ago. It is also undermining our iconic sand dunes, and the work of the Mangawhai Harbour Restoration Society volunteers to preserve them, and the work of the community to protect the Sandspit Wildlife Refuge. The application to take more than twice the current annual limit from off-shore Pakiri is exploitation of seacoast for commercial purposes, at the expense of our environment.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? A decision not to renew the sand mining licence any where near the Pakiri beach until such time as adequate research provides a "safe distance" off shore for taking sand. Failing this, a ruling that no mining can take place within 10 miles of the coast or marine parks and reserves.





406

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Teina anitini katipa nimmo

Organisation name:



Postal address: 34 Tarata Crescent Mangere Bridge Auckland 2022

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The taking of sand and damage to the seabed

What are the reasons for your submission? - damage to the environment - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes

407

2

- there are other sustainable sand supply sources - it's for private profit - dredging will further encourage seashore erosion with rising sea levels

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? No more dredging and no license given.





408

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: John Christopher Lawrence

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: (09) 575 5552


Postal address: 7 Dingle Road St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I do not want sand taken from anywhere off the Pakari Coast

What are the reasons for your submission? Research in parts of the world, confirm the devastation of sand islands and the denuding of beaches on the coast where sand mining is active: the evidence is real, that sand is a finate resource and where sand is mined off shore, the sand which replaces it in these hollows comes from denuding the coastal beaches, often leave a rocky shoreline.

409

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not destroy our beautiful coastline by allowing sand mining.There will be an impact on the coastline in time. I have enjoyed Pakari for 55yrs and have observed sand mining in the dunes and offshore dredging. I have also observed the loss of dry sand creating shear sand cliffs at the southern end.





410

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: John Alexander Bowman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 20 Tomas Street Wellsford Auckland 0900

Submission details




411

2

- the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is; The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto.





412

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: David William Pallett

Organisation name: Allied plumbing



Postal address: 26B Verbena road Auckland Auckland 0627

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are; The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment


413

2


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is; The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto Link to the Council submission page;





414

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Thomas barker

Organisation name:



Postal address: 38 will James ave Algies bay Auckland 0910

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To cease all sand removal from the area.

What are the reasons for your submission? It's damaging our environment! I can't believe this even needs people to say no. One guy gets rich and our home suffers because of it.

415

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline any proposal to remove sand from the seabed or beaches.





416

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sarah Marie Lindsay

Organisation name:



Postal address: 22 Worker Road Wellsford Auckland 0900

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dont so it!!!

What are the reasons for your submission? It will ruin the beach for everyone

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Find somewhere else to get the sand

417

2





418

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Maria Gumennaya

Organisation name:



Postal address: 148 Old Onerahi road Onerahi Whangarei 0110

Submission details




419

2







420

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Hugo Clapshaw

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +44 7500903006


Postal address: 779 Pakiri Block Road Wellsford Auckland 0974

Submission details




421

2







422

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kim Chamley

Organisation name: Kim Chamley



Postal address: 279 Konini Road Auckland Auckland 0604

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining...the whole thing.

What are the reasons for your submission? I oppose sandmining in this location in any form. This environment is too precious.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny the whole thing. I strongly oppose any mining.

423

2





424

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Robert Wade McLean

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: (09)4226054


Postal address: 28 Bathgate Road, Pakiri RD2 WELLSFORD 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Coastal Marine Area (off-shore from Pakiri) Application No: CST60343373

What are the reasons for your submission? To oppose the extraction of sand from Pakiri Beach!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop the extraction of sand from Pakiri Beach!

425

2





426

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Katrina Rose Greenwood

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: (09)4226054


Postal address: 28 Bathgate Road, Pakiri RD2 WELLSFORD 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Coastal Marine Area (off-shore from Pakiri Beach) Application No: CST60343373

What are the reasons for your submission? To oppose the extraction of sand from Pakiri Beach!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop extraction of sand from Pakiri Beach!

427

2





428

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gabrielle Buchanan

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2 Eastcliffe Road Castor Bay Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Complete objection of all sand withdrawals from Pakiri Beach.

What are the reasons for your submission? The protection of natural assets supersedes private capital gains.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny all applications and withdraw consent for any further mining to protect further coastal degradation.

429

2





430

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Amanda Fenwick

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Surfdale Road Waiheke Island Waiheke Island 1081

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I'm not supporting dredging the coastline its unsustainable and destroys the environment at beautiful pakari beach


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not let this go ahead to protect future for future generations

431

2





432

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jenna vaughn

Organisation name:



Postal address: 56 school road Wellsford Auckland 0900

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Ruining our land

What are the reasons for your submission? Against this submission as it will ruin the land for our future generations

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not go ahead

433

2





434

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Linda Bowman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 26 Fairleigh Ave Mt Albert Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The taking of a limited resource for private profit.

What are the reasons for your submission? The negative environmental impact it will have on a beautiful piece of coastline.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not allow this to go ahead, now or in the future.

435

2





436

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Charles Clark

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Bell Rd Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details




437

2







438

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sally Wills

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 balmer lane Mount Eden Auckland 1021

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are; - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the

439

2

system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






440

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Pamela Beattie

Organisation name:



Postal address: 98 Avocado Lane Mangawhai RD 5 Wellsford 0705

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Please leave our beautiful natural resources alone

What are the reasons for your submission? Already our beaches have lost their vivid white sand and new shells

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To decline the entire application please.

441

2





442

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kyla Covic

Organisation name:



Postal address: 42 Lloyd Ave Mt Albert Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Damage to the seabed in Parkari & neighbouring beaches

What are the reasons for your submission? It causes irreparable damage to the sea floor, marine ecosystem and the dunes.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Say NO to dredging & damaging our seabed & destroying such an idillic part of the country

443

2





444

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Paul Thomson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 57 Mountain Road Mangere Bridge Auckland 2022

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: We are not going to allow sand mining on our coast


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? No Sand mining

445

2





446

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Christine Baines

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3 Wimbledon Crescent Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Remove of sand from the seabed

What are the reasons for your submission? I would like to give a presentation showing the reasons why I oppose it

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the Sand Removal from Pakiri Seabed

447

2





448

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Christine Baines

Organisation name: Pakiri G Trust



Postal address: 3 Wimbledon Crescent Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop the Sand mining from Pakiri Seabed

What are the reasons for your submission? I would like to speak to this

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the sand mining at Pakiri Seabed

449

2





450

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Hannah Goffeney

Organisation name:



Postal address: 25 Anchorage Road Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai 0505

Submission details




451

2







452

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Scott Millar

Organisation name: Hermpac



Postal address: 2 Sand Dune Lane Mangawhai Heads Northland 0505

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The degradation of the sand dune at Mangawhai would be devastating.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cease sand mining.

453

2





454

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Clair McEntegart

Organisation name: Clair McEntegart



Postal address: 844 Matakana Valley road Matakana Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining at pakiri, I'm totally against it

What are the reasons for your submission? Pakiri is a beautiful untouched beach, it needs to stay that way

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny the submission and protect pakiri

455

2





456

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gabrielle Connor

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 ward road Matakana Warkworth 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging sand

What are the reasons for your submission? Marine protection needed

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline consent

457

2





458

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Alaina George

Organisation name:



Postal address: 57 Hauraki Rd, RD 5 Leigh Warkworth 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removal of any sand. This area should be off limits for any exploitation.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Should be thrown out

459

2





460

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jannene Alexander

Organisation name:



Postal address: 74 Selwyn Road Epsom auckland 1023

Submission details




461

2







462

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: corinne callinan

Organisation name:



Postal address: 12 Moir St Mangawhai Village Mangawhai Village 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri and Mangawhai embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are;- causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from

463

2

effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources- a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit- climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate- offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






464

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Rhiannon Morris

Organisation name:



Postal address: 20 Matheson road Wellsford Auckland 0900

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are;The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.


465

2







466

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Peter Nie

Organisation name: RJ Riverop



Postal address: 1 anich rd massey waitakere city 0614

Submission details

This submission: is neutral regarding the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: as a New Zealand resident, I don't wanna see the environmental damage caused by sand mining，if it is because of economic development，why not we buy from oversea.

What are the reasons for your submission? 1- oversea sand/sea sand is lower cost 2- oversea trade this commodity legally for longtime 3- local supplement reserved for future

467

2

4- beneficial for public people who oppose，and offering this permit applicant to be importer who still can make profits and share the market. 5- I am used to trade this commodity, I know what people and applicant want.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? council should encourage to import sand from oversea, save time and money





468

1

Jackie Lee

From: Peter Nie <[email protected]>Sent: Monday, 8 June 2020 5:41 PMTo: Jackie LeeSubject: Re: FW: s95 Resource Consent CST60343373 - Submission Confirmation, Hearing ProcessAttachments: mmexport1591593913892.jpg; mmexport1591593911637.jpg; mmexport1591593916493.jpg;

mmexport1591593908602.jpg; Screenshot_20200608_173612.jpg; Screenshot_20200608_173523.jpg

Hi Jackie,

Hope your council can guide them purchase from oversea，and provide some convenience in the import process. It is not worth to sacrifice the environment to get benefits. If your council need any support, you are welcome to contact me. Cheers peter

Jackie Lee <[email protected]> 于 2020年6月8日周一下午3:29写道：

Good afternoon,

I confirm receipt of your submission to the above resource consent application.

If your submission was not made online through the online submission facility, Section 96(6) of the Resource Management Act 1991 requires you to serve a copy of your submission on the applicant or the applicant’s agent if that is the address for service as soon as possible, if you have not done so already.

Please note that the recent amendments to the Resource Management Act 1991, have changed the procedures for notified applications and now makes it mandatory for applicants and submitters to provide their evidence prior to the date of the hearing.

These changes now require the council to firstly provide its officers’ reports and any evidence at least 15 working days prior to the date of the hearing. Following this, the applicant must provide all its briefs of evidence at least 10 working days prior to the date of the hearing.

Any submitter wishing to call expert witnesses at the hearing, such as from a professional planner or a traffic engineer, must provide their briefs of expert evidence at least 5 working days prior to the date of the hearing.

Once a hearing date has been set, the council will advise you of the date of the hearing and the date by which your expert evidence must be provided to the council.

475

2

The council will be using its website to make available all the reports and evidences to the applicant and submitters.

The link to the website will be: https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/have‐yoursay/hearings/findhearing/Pages/find‐resource‐consent‐hearing.aspx.

The council will be using email as the address for service for the applicant and submitters unless advised otherwise.

If you have any queries, please contact Jackie Lee on [email protected] in the first instance and quote the application number CST60343373.

Yours sincerely,

Jackie.

Jackie Lee | Regulatory Support Officer North/West

Resource Consents

Ph 09 427 3332 | Extn (44) 3332

Auckland Council, 50 Centreway Road, Orewa 0931

As New Zealand remains under COVID‐19 Alert Level 2, Auckland Council is providing services in accordance with the government’s direction. Regulatory Services are continuing to provide some face‐to‐face services, however our Graham Street service centre and reception remains closed at this stage. We are contactable by email or phone.

We apologise for any delay in responding to your inquiry and thank you for your continued patience and support.

You can also visit aucklandcouncil.govt.nz for more information about our response to COVID‐19, as well as access to general information and online services.

476

3

To help protect you r privacy, Micro so ft Office prevented au tomatic download of this pictu re from the Internet.Have your say o n Auckland's Emergency Budget 2020/2021.

CAUTION: This email message and any attachments contain information that may be confidential and may be LEGALLY PRIVILEGED. If you are not the intended recipient, any use, disclosure or copying of this message or attachments is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email message in error please notify us immediately and erase all copies of the message and attachments. We do not accept responsibility for any viruses or similar carried with our email, or any effects our email may have on the recipient computer system or network. Any views expressed in this email may be those of the individual sender and may not necessarily reflect the views of Council.

477

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Carley Hammond

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1683 Mangawhai Road Te Arai Wellsford 0975

Submission details




478

2







479

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Renata Blair

Organisation name: Evitan



Postal address: 45b Kitemoana Street Auckland Auckland 1071

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I full oppose this application. It will have extreme adverse effects on the environment and specifically the Taiao (Māori Environment) of Tangaroa, Ikatere, Hinemoana and Papatuanuku). I object from a Tikanga Viewpoint of the Council and companies not having the authority to be able to extract natural resources from our Atua. I am completely opposed to the greed of the company who are wanting to extract the sand from the ocean at Pakiri. The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are; A trampling of the Mana of Iwi and the Mana of the Maori people of Aotearoa.

480

2

The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed in the Pakiri embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? Auckland Council and the applicant DO NOT have the Mana or authority to be able to do this to our Moana. This applicant will destroy the wairua of the ocean and the wildlife throughout that coast and it must end. It tramples on the mana of Māori when corporates are extracting sand and wildlife from the ocean. This is a trampling of the rights of Maori to protect their properties such as lands, oceanes, forestries and fisheries. The ocean is me and I am the ocean. The identity of iwi is being extracted by the mining companies and it is cruishing to think that Council could allow this in modern day NZ society. It is a pure money grabbing exercise at the expense of Māori. The depletion of our natural resources MUST end. This is unsustainable and unnecessary.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like Council to reject the application based on the Treaty of Waitangi. the Treaty allows for Maori to protect their lands, estates, forestries and fisheries. By granting the applicant the extraction - it is in complete contradiction to the Treaty which I would like to strongly challenge Council and Kaipara Ltd.





481

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tessa Williams

Organisation name:



Postal address: 619B Tara Road RD2 Kaiwaka 0573

Submission details




482

2







483

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Heidi Parlane

Organisation name:



Postal address: 9 Te Ruru Way Stanmore Bay Whangaparaoa 0932

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The whole application. There should be no consent for sand mining at all. Specifically the size and scale, the annual limit is a significant volume and one aspect of the consent has no annual restriction.

What are the reasons for your submission? This area of coastline is of significant natural beauty and the habitat of many seabirds including the protected fairy tern. This mining would severely and irreparably damage this coastline. What are council thinking even allowing such an application to begin with!!!!

484

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the application for the consent in full! If that is not possible legally, then the area of operations and annual limits MUST be significantly reduced along with the duration of the consent.





485

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sachith samaradiwakera wijesundara

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 Jubaea Place Auckland Auckland 0610

Submission details




486

2







487

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gabrielle O'Malley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3-23 Napier Street Freemans Bay Auckland 1011

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non-complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to marine fauna, sea bed, water quality & indigenous biodiversity - the long-term adverse residual effects on the Pakiri embayment, its marine ecosystem and coastal processes, are

488

2

unlikely to ever be adequately mitigated or offset - the Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes, with potential adverse effects on coastal morphology and dune dynamics - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources elsewhere in the region - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered in the application, eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate (noting that healthy dune systems provide a critical natural barrier against the effects of sea level rise and increased storm intensity and frequency) - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






489

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kerry O'Malley

Organisation name:




Submission details




490

2







491

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Darran Mangelsdorf

Organisation name:




Submission details




492

2







493

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Allistair Shepherd

Organisation name:



Postal address: 67 Wakapirau rd Wellsford Wellsford 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: there should be no sand mining in this area

What are the reasons for your submission? there has been sand mining in this area for many years so far, now the sand on the beach is disappearing the sand dunes are moving seaward, this also affects the fish and their habitats as the dredging removes there habitats, also i was led to believe that the actual mining was 2 kilometes from the shore line so that means the mining is also in

494

2

breach as they definitely come closer to the shore than 2 km, there must be other places that actually require sand removal

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to reject new consent i know they need sand for future development but take the sand from where it is a definite problem





495

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Erin O'Malley

Organisation name:




Submission details




496

2







497

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ryan O'Malley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 16 Shearwater Lane Point Wells Auckland 0986

Submission details




498

2







499

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Rachel O'Malley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 16 Shearwater Lane Point Wells Auckland 0986

Submission details




500

2







501

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michael Mackay

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1604 Mangawhai Road Mangawhai Kaipara 0975

Submission details




502

2







503

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kyran Gillespie

Organisation name:



Postal address: 70 Baylys Coast Road Northland Dargaville 0377

Submission details




504

2


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is;The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto. Seek alternative options to sand mining, e.g. offshore. If the amendments are not made, I would like to see active enforcement of the sand mining due to the constant breaches of the company mining outside of their consent during the night.





505

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Samuel Dale Bradford

Organisation name:



Postal address: 571 Rahuikiri Road, Pakiri RD4 Wellsford Auckland 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment. That this application must be considered in the same context and together with the application due to be notified by McCallum Brothers for near shore sand mining at Pakiri.

What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity

506

2

- the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments - the proximity of the non-complying activity in close proximity to multiple regional parks and marine reserves is out of step with the wider context of conservation conveyed by Auckland Council in the Pakiri embayment and the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park/Ko te Pataka kai o Tikapa Moana Te Moananui a Toi - the long standing nature of the current mining activity has undoubtedly caused significant changes to the profile of Pakiri beach, over 28 years of living at Pakiri and spending large amounts of time it is evident that the changes are happening to the negative. - from our family home at 571 Rahuikiri Road, we have observed for the duration of our time in occupation as residents of Pakiri Beach the regularness of the mining, it has been said on our family that you can set your watch by the sand barge arriving, just on dusk, and operating under the cover of darkness out of sight and mind of the many. - that this application must be considered in the same context and together with the application due to be notified by McCallum Brothers for near shore sand mining at Pakiri.






507

1

Jackie Lee

From: Sam Bradford <[email protected]>Sent: Sunday, 31 May 2020 12:56 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: 'Tony Baker'Subject: CST60343373 - request for extension of time for public submission.

Categories: Jackie

To whom it may concern I have made a submission on the above noted application regarding sand extraction off Pakiri Beach – Coastal Marine. I am aware that a further application for renewal/consent has been made by McCallums for nearshore mining at Pakiri Beach, I understand this consent is likely to be publicly notified. I strongly request as follows:

1. That Auckland Council grants an extension to the 4 June deadline in which to make a submission on the above noted application, with the date to coincide with the date for submissions on the McCallum application once it is notified. It is paramount this be done as the potential overlapping or cumulative environmental effects and application information must be considered together to truly comprehend the impact of the non‐complying activity to the Pakiri Embayment.

2. The two applications must also be considered in a joint hearing process so that potential overlapping or cumulative environmental issues can be heard and determined in a single hearing.

I request that my email be acknowledged.

Kind regards Sam Bradford | Solicitor Sellars & Co Lawyers Wellsford Office: 221 Rodney Street, PO Box 8, Wellsford 0940, New Zealand Ph: (09) 423 8022 | Fax: (09) 423 7997 | Email: [email protected] | Mobile: 021 552 735 Helensville Office: 69 Mill Road, PO Box 126, Helensville 0840, New Zealand Ph: (09) 420 9324 | Fax: (09) 420 9325

508

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Fiona Gorinas

Organisation name:



Postal address: 34a Meadowbank Road Meadowbank Auckland 1072

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This is a non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? These activities are harmful to the local flora, fauna and sea bed. It affects water quality and biodiversity. At a time of critical threats to global and national biodiversity and facing mass species extinctions, we should be placing more importance on the needs of nature than humans. There are also alternative and sustainable sand supply sources. I

509

2

should also like to point out that a finite, precious resource that is enjoyed by the greater public, is being exploited for private profit. This plunder of nature is repeatedly happening across the globe and will cause our ecosystems to eventually collapse and threatens our survival on this planet. New Zealand has impressed the world with its handling of the Covid 19 pandemic. We need to now be a global pioneer in building back better. We have an international brand as clean and green. Let's live up to that image.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like an end to all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licences or amendments relating to it.





510

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Gramt Renall

Organisation name:



Postal address: 85 King Road Mangawhai Mangawhai 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: inshore sand mining

What are the reasons for your submission? I used to be on a tug towing a sand barge and over a period of time saw the effects on coastline stability

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? go further of shore

511

2





512

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Susan Jones

Organisation name:



Postal address: 8 Coastview Lane RD5 Wellsford Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The offshore, huge extraction of sand that disturbs the sea bed by using a suction pipe in the Pakiri bay area.

What are the reasons for your submission? -environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - this is a closed system with no effective replenishment of sand taken out via dredging

513

2

- the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs and total dredging extraction volumes decreases the volume of sand build up to the coastal dunes and bays - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments - will the council have to bring sand in to replace and protect the area in the future?






514

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marcus Robins

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1024A Takatu Road Tawharanui Peninsula Matakana 0986

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are;

515

2

- causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality and biodiversity - the proximity of the activity to a unique regional park and marine reserve - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - there is no sound economic case for the activity in the public good - climate change effects have not been properly considered e.g. rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






516

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Stephen Mackay

Organisation name:



Postal address: 206 Cames Road, Wellsford RD5 Mangawhai 0975

Submission details




517

2







518

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vince Moores

Organisation name:



Postal address: Te Arai Lodge 51 Lake Road, Te Arai Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The huge amount of sand extraction and the resultant disturbance of the sea bed caused by this non compliant activity.

What are the reasons for your submission? The detrimental environmental effects to the sea bed, the flora, fauna, biodiversity The surf systems and water quality. The removal of a precious local resource and the enjoyment this offers to the greater public for the benefit of private business profits.

519

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To end all dredging in the Pakiri / Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence or licences nor any other amendments.





520

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Luke Holliday

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2 Marellen Drive Red Beach Auckland 0932

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The mining of sand off the Te Arai coast

What are the reasons for your submission? Disruption of the natural environment and eco system to reward big businesses. The area is one of the last untouched pieces of paradise around Auckland, and is already being exploited with the Tara Iti development.

521

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? refuse the mining operations from taking place





522

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Stefan Marks

Organisation name:



Postal address: 22A Sunnyvale Rd Swanson Auckland 0614

Submission details




523

2







524

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: ken marment

Organisation name:



Postal address: 125 tara Rd Auckland Auckland 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Box 1; The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are; The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? Box 2; The reasons for my submission are; - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity

525

2


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Box 3; The decision I would like council to make is; The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments there





526

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nick Romanes

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2-17 barker rise Northcross Auckland 0632

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Damage to eco systems , Marine life & water sporting activities


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ban all east and west coast sand mining

527

2





528

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: jane raybould

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Burrell Rd Auckland Auckland 1081

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removal of sand from Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? Concerns over erosion. Impact on native bird life and marine life

529

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like council to decline the application . Pakiri is an amazing natural wonder and should be preserved completely for future generationa





530

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Bryan May

Organisation name:



Postal address: P.o Box 401144 Mangawhai heads Kaipara 0541

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand removal

What are the reasons for your submission? Destruction of the beach and dunes

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refusal of the application

531

2





532

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: sioux plowman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 212 staniforth rd wellsford wellsford 0975

Submission details




533

2







534

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: J A Baretta Fernandes

Organisation name:



Postal address: Poplar Rd Stanmore Bay Auckland 0932

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Against the mining


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Don’t allow it to happen protect Pakiri and Te arai land and beaches

535

2





536

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marina Macartney

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO box 175 ruakaka northland 0151

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am against all matters or mining sand near te-arai, this will impact and change the wave formations, damage wildlife and destroy their environment.

What are the reasons for your submission? I believe Te-arai is a famous wildlife and surfing spot, which people all over the world have heard about and come to visit. You can't even have houses along the beach, so how come someone has been allowed to drill sand off the beach?

537

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Say no to the proposal. No more sand drilling. Protect the beach and the wildlife.





538

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sam Bowden

Organisation name:



Postal address: 37 Braemar Rod Castor Bay Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining from pakiri beach

What are the reasons for your submission? They are already destroying the natural coastline the last few years, I have seen them multiple times within the legal 2km allowed range. Ruins the sand banks

539

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? No sand mining





540

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Dylan Gera

Organisation name:



Postal address: 9b Tainui Street Torbay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The mining of Pakiri beach sands


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop any inshore sand mining

541

2





542

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Monday, 1 June 2020 5:16 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10201] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Susan Barbara Henry




Postal address: 63 Athol Place Algies Bay Auckland 0920

Submission details




543

2







544

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vladislav Kholostiakov

Organisation name:



Postal address: 23/4 Rotomahana Terrace Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: New Zealand native wildlife should be preserved for the future generations.


545

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Conservation of the habitat





546

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Emma Crowther

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2 Peacock Street Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity which is taking excessive sand from the seabed which will damage the ecosystem and inhabitants and cause changes to the natural flows of water in the area which will result in damage to the shoreline and the ecosystem there.

What are the reasons for your submission? This area is fragile and pristine and supports our endemic endangered birds (Fairy tern, dotterel) This proposal does not consider the measures or estimated impacts to those endangered birds, or any impacts, short or long term, to the

547

2

area. This proposal is benefitting private investors only and is not in the best interest of the people who live there, the environment or Nee Zealand. This is not a nimby statement, the benefits do not outweigh the damage.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? End all dredging in the Pakiri, Te Arai area and do not renew any licenses or abilities to continue.





548

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Simon John Walkden

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Township Rd Waitakere Auckland 0816

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I vehemently oppose any and all form of sand mining covered by this application

What are the reasons for your submission? Pakiri Beach is of significant cultural significance to both Tangatawhenua and New Zealand Europeans, who both have spent generations building history and memories in this region. Its proximity to the Leigh marine reserve has not been adequately addressed nor have sufficient safeguards been listed to prevent possible harm.

549

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline the application in full.





550

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Alastair cameron

Organisation name:



Postal address: 18 Woodley ave Remuera Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am submitting on the application as a whole.

What are the reasons for your submission? I believe the environmental consequences of the dredging activity by fat outweigh any positives from such activity. This causes irreversible damage to the marine environment, the extent of which short and long term Cannot be accurately estimated, and caution must be taken in rejecting the continuation of such activities and allow the marine environment to heal.

551

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to refuse to renew this resource consent. It is likely to cause irreversible damage that can not be reasoned for a companies private gains.





552

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kelly Screen

Organisation name:



Postal address: Logan Road Buckland Pukekohe 2677

Submission details




553

2







554

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Erin Hall

Organisation name:



Postal address: 48 Ferry Parade Herald Island Auckland 0618

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The proposed sand mining in the Te Arai area. Committing to this environmental degradation for 20 years is absurd. Find another solution in an area not already under pressure from commercial overfishing. This coastline will be barren if this level of interference is allowed.

What are the reasons for your submission? The commercial fishing in this area alone is destroying the sustainability of the local resources and environment in an already strained ecosystem. Further action of mining will only make things worse.

555

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Don’t sand mine in this area. Choose an area where resources aren’t already depleted.





556

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Karen Ramsay

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3/50 Onepoto Road Hauraki Auckland 0622

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non-complying activity and the form(s) of it’s exercise . Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance, to the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? Causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects to flora fauna seabed water quality and biodiversity The Pakiri embayment is on substance a class system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging

557

2

The licence has failed to fulfil and breached many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence There are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources A finite precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public is being depleted for private profit Climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast which the dredging will exacerbate Offshore sand dredging is out of stop with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the job renewal of any licence (S) or amendments thereto





558

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Christian Waddingham

Organisation name:



Postal address: 8 captains close Torbay Auckland 0630

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Mining of sand at pakari beach.

What are the reasons for your submission? I hate to imagine the effects on biodiversity and degradation of environment on a beautiful remote beach.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not mine sand from pakari.

559

2





560

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Richard Mayne

Organisation name:



Postal address: 55 Staniforth Rd TeArai Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of a large portion of our local sea bed and the destruction of marine life that goes with it

What are the reasons for your submission? Local resident who wants this to stop

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject this application

561

2





562

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kate Hewitt

Organisation name:



Postal address: 309/35 albert road Melbourne Melbourne 3004

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The sand dredging from offshore bit.

What are the reasons for your submission? Why, in a country as forward thinking conservationally as New Zealand, are we still allowing our national treasures to be stripped, and the natural flora and fauna destroyed, by private companies for wealth? This does not benefit New Zealand, but destroys it.

563

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decide to not allow offshore dredging in such a fragile and ecologically valuable environment. This same company could easily find a source of sand on land, which would lessen the environmental impact





564

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Monday, 1 June 2020 12:00 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10212] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Andrea Edwards

Organisation name:



Postal address: 44 Onepoto Road Hauraki Auckland 0622

Submission details




565

2







566

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Rhiannon Schroder

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11 quiet st Te Atatu Auckland 0610

Submission details




567

2







568

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Briana

Organisation name:



Postal address: 0910 Managawhai Auckland 1910

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Do not grant this bill! For passing this and destroying peaceful and natural area


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not pass this! I grew up here, it’s a slice of heavens in earth. I live in Canada now and think of this beach daily and is unlike any where any else on earth

569

2





570

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nadja Parker

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 278 Mangwhai Mangawhai 0540

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? o Adverse environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality, biodiversity & recreation o The Mangawhai/Pakiri embayment is a closed system and cannot effectively replenishment the sand taken out of the system by dredging

571

2

o Light pollution as work is done under cover of the night, this disturbs at this point the animals but once the development has started and people move in there will be complaints after complaints for the council to deal with o They are not staying within the distance limits of the current license, so can't be trusted to do so in future o There is an annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes o The licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence o The licencee has had a good old lash at it and enough is enough o There are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources, so please go somewhere else o A finite and precious resource that is enjoyed by Kiwis, is being depleted for private profit o Climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate o Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments, ashamed of the Green Party - where are they?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? End all dredging activity in the Mangwhai/Pakiri embayment and don't renew any licence(s) or amendments of these licence(s). The licenses where refused once before in 2005 by ARC and the then Minister of Conservation but the appeal went through. What a shame. Come on Auckland Council, do the right thing





572

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Maria Glavish

Organisation name:



Postal address: 455 Pakiri block road Tomarata Auckland 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: No sand mining

What are the reasons for your submission? It has taken out the dunes

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny resource consent

573

2





574

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Clint Lewis

Organisation name:



Postal address: 24B Simon Ellice Drive Bayview Auckland 0629

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am NOT okay with sand mining from pakairi.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? NO sand mining from popular nz beaches.

575

2





576

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Julianne de Wet

Organisation name:



Postal address: 32 Stanley Ave Milford Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non-complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.


577

2

- the sand system is in an annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments - In previous years there has been controversy around the research that supported sand dredging being sustainable at Pakiri Beach. However, in the context of a Climate Crisis, if there is contradicting evidence it is essential to err on the side of caution and protect our taonga, rather than risk it for private commercial benefit.






578

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jacinta Ryan

Organisation name: Jardenez Holdings Ltd



Postal address: 15 Lawson Way Weymouth Auckland 2103

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Opposition to removal of sand from Pakiri area

What are the reasons for your submission? It is short sighted and wrong

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Seek alternatives, provide Public rationale as to why this needs to take place and how this will benefit the Pakiri area.

579

2

Who is the driving force behind this sort of decision making ? Who accepts responsibility for this and the outcomes if this proceeds?





580

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Katherine Norman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 0972 Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Mining 2million m3 of sand over 20 years from where the nearly extinct Fairy Terns live. I oppose the entire application.

What are the reasons for your submission? As above

581

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To reject this application





582

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Winnie Charlesworth

Organisation name:



Postal address: 38 Paturoa Rd Totirangi Auckland 0604

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of sand and the changes resulting to water flow.

What are the reasons for your submission? Environmental protection laws in NZ are insufficient.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not grant the consent.

583

2





584

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marc Warrington

Organisation name: Marc Warrington Architects Limited



Postal address: 8 Fairsea Place Lynfield Auckland 1042

Submission details




585

2







586

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: tim parker

Organisation name:



Postal address: Po Box 278 Mangawhai mangawhai 0540

Submission details




587

2







588

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: MARK I PERRY

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 180 Mangawhai Village Mangawhai Village 0540

Submission details




589

2







590

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Maureen Perry

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1482 Mangawhai Road RD 5 Wellsford Auckland 0975

Submission details




591

2







592

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jeffrey Colin King

Organisation name:



Postal address: 7 Simmonds Ave Three Kings Auckland 1041

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of it.

What are the reasons for your submission? The degradation of the coastline, the effects of removing large volumes of sand from the seabed floor, the destruction of biophilia within the catchment zone of removal of sand, the negative effects to the surf breaks and the beach profile. Removal of vast volumes of sand is in effect coastal vandalism and destruction of the environment that has its own natural flows of tides & currents etc.

593

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cancel all permits to take any sand from the coast.





594

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Colin Watts

Organisation name:



Postal address: 3 de luen Ave, Tindalls Beach Auckland Auckland 0930

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The mining of sand will and is creating further environmental problems and on going costs. Leave the sand alone please.

What are the reasons for your submission? Environmental damage and on going cost to the rate payer. Time to stop this damage.

595

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Oppose it. Thanks





596

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Andrew Reid

Organisation name:



Postal address: 9 Sea View Rd Leigh Auckland 0985

Submission details




597

2







598

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Leesa Wright

Organisation name: Land owner



Postal address: 5 Rooseville Mews, Pukekohe Franklin Auckland 2021

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Oppose all application

What are the reasons for your submission? land owner

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? dissolve Kaipara submission to apply

599

2





600

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Josie Hendry

Organisation name:



Postal address: 43/15 Puriri Street Takapuna Auckland 0622

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Leave the beach/sand alone. Its money that gets them through to do what they like.

What are the reasons for your submission? I want NZ to be left as it is. Its been partly ruined already.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Vote to say NO.

601

2





602

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Janette Miller

Organisation name:



Postal address: 6 Clarence Road Northcote Point Auckland 0627

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Removal of sand

What are the reasons for your submission? Why destroy a beautiful beach?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Withhold conscent.

603

2





604

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Adam Minoprio

Organisation name:



Postal address: 25 Lincoln St Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Ban sand mining around Mangawhai and Pakiri

605

2

What are the reasons for your submission? Ruins the beach’s, kills wildlife on the ocean floor, destroys habitats, minimal financial reward for locals and New Zealand.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ban the mining.





606

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Brendon lagemaat

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 insley Mangawhai Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop sand mining!


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Mine way of shore further. It’s just easy for them here in close

607

2





608

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Robert Paul Cameron

Organisation name:



Postal address: 46 De Boer lane Rd2 kaiwaka Whangarei 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining .

What are the reasons for your submission? I'm worried about the environmental effects of taking sand from the ocean floor.its not sustainable and is irreplaceable!

609

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Throw the application out.take no more sand from our shores. especially from parkiri. Too much has already been taken.!!





610

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Paul Michael Gledhill

Organisation name:



Postal address: 4 kingwell st Motorua New plymouth 4310

Submission details




611

2







612

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tim Merkens

Organisation name:



Postal address: 93 Lancaster Rd Beach Haven Auckland 0626

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of it - sand mining here should not have even been entertained as a discussion to this point.

613

2

What are the reasons for your submission? This will drastically change the environment, where I and many others holiday, and take day trips to surf, explore, etc. It is also near the habitat of the critically endangered fairy tern.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the application





614

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Stephen Michael McDonald

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1530 mangawhai road Rodney Auckland 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The mining of the beach

What are the reasons for your submission? I live and have grown up in the area and have seen the damages sand mining has done to our beaches.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the mining

615

2





616

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Simon Hardley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 37 Cheviot St Mangawhai Mangawai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining close to Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? It will cause damage to the sea bed and fisheries. It could negatively impact the beach around Te Arai.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce the area mined by 80%

617

2





618

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Daniel Hawes

Organisation name: Small Kine Ding Repairs



Postal address: 296 molesworth drive Mangawhai Mangawhai 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The indiscriminate taking of sand from our coastlines

What are the reasons for your submission? As a surfer and someone who makes their living fixing surfboards, changes to the sea floor and our noticeable change in surf quality concerns me. The innevitable effect on wildlife and their environment concerns me, both ocean dwelling and land dwelling.

619

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? If sand must be taken, new areas should be looked into. Be it areas with less fragile eco systems and endangered species or extraction from deeper parts of the ocean. Consult with professionals who have no financial gain in the venture.





620

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Grainne Tayu

Organisation name:



Postal address: 17 Atkin Road Kaiwaka Mangawhai 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining is detrimental to the local habitat which could be permanent.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Revoke/ deny this application in it’s entirety. There are other locations that would have less impact such as 90 mile beach.

621

2





622

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: MIchael Harkins

Organisation name:



Postal address: 18 kettlewell Drive , Silverdale Auckland 0932

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The mining of sand on Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? This beach is one of the north islands finest and supports many aspects , Surfing , fishing , wildlife , and general recreation , it brings tourism to the area which is a much needed income for a lot of people , damage to the marine ecology that will not be reapairable, and added pollution to the marine area and surrounds turning this into a sand

623

2

mine is suicide , there is already a sand mine near Te Arai , and please consider the fact that you are neigbour to a very valuable marine reserve and marine biology university in Goat Island ,I wholeheartedly object to this proposal

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? protect the marine area by declining this submission , and having no beach or offshore mining in this area





624

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Tuesday, 2 June 2020 12:30 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10250] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: John Darby

Organisation name:



Postal address: 14A Ngatira Rd Muriwai Auckland 0881

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: No sand mining

What are the reasons for your submission? Protect this marine environment

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Hands off

625

2





626

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Arna Newman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 368 settlement road Kaiwaka Northland 0573

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Dredging sand

What are the reasons for your submission? To protect our natural coastline and fauna

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop dredging unnecessarily to make money !

627

2





628

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Faisal A

Organisation name:



Postal address: 25a Cairngrom place, Highland park Auckland Auckland 2010

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: stopping Auckland council to ruin the beach. You guys make enough poor decisions.

What are the reasons for your submission? to help stop Auckland Council from ruining the beach and waste additional tax payers money.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? decline this application.

629

2

A much better plan that is more cost-effective and beneficial; Upgrading the water source and capacity would be a good start. Rather than complaining about low water levels every year and doing bugger-all.





630

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Chanel Paul

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +64 495 8785


Postal address: 353 Tara Road Kaiwaka Northland 0573

Submission details




631

2







632

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Olivia Rynne

Organisation name:



Postal address: 15 Surrey Street Tawa Wellington 5028

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining at Pakari Beach


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not allow this

633

2





634

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Daniel Tohill

Organisation name:



Postal address: 364 Oneriri Rd Kaiwaka Kaiwaka 0537

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Box 1; The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are;The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.


635

2


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Box 3; The decision I would like council to make is;The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





636

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tobi Muir

Organisation name:



Postal address: 152 Bethells rd Henderson Auckland 0781

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All

What are the reasons for your submission? Sand mining can have major negative effect on sand budgets and morphology and therefore damage dune systems and endanger plant and animal that depend on those landscapes . It is absurd and immoral to even consider this application under existing legislation that protects said plants and animals in the vicinity. There are numerous other

637

2

sources of aggregate that don't potentially cause this destruction. There is no need for this extraction other that pursuit of profit

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse the application





638

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: annie baines

Organisation name: Taumata B - Tangata Whenua



Postal address: 74 BEECHDALE CRES pakuranga heights pakuranga heights 2010

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The offshore sand extraction from Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? The effect the dredging thus far has had on our beach . The dunes are being depleted .We the tangata whenua who

639

2

have lived there and whom this coastline belongs to see the change in the beach. Our Sand is a finite resource - being used to top up other beaches and for sand castle competitions for profit .

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The end to ALL dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai area - and the non renewal of any more consents / permits





640

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Christine Hardy

Organisation name:



Postal address: 105 Kohimarama Road Kohi Auckland 1071

Submission details




641

2


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? we have already lost too much sand. In the years I have had a house at mangawhai we have seen our beautiful dunes decrease as sand is stolen from its natural place. Leave it alone The decision I would like council to make is;The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





642

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Christine Bull

Organisation name:



Postal address: 96 Rosetta Road Raumati South Kapiti Coast 5032

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are: The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.


643

2







644

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: david henry

Organisation name:



Postal address: 153 Mangawhai Road Wellsford Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The removal of such a vast quantity of sand from the marine environment offshore Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? The science behind the replenishment of the sand reserves removed from the marine environment have been insufficiently researched. It takes thousands of years to create this amount of sand. Where will the removed sand be replaced from. Without doubt some of the shore sand at Pakiri will be washed and blown into the sea, and sea

645

2

currents will replace a lot of it - but at the expense of the surrounding environment which will have to relinquish this sand.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? There should be further extensive studies into the mechanics of the sand removal and replenishment. The sand mining should only be permitted further from shore where there should be less impact on the shore sands of Pakiri





646

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Glenn Altman

Organisation name:



Postal address: 12 martin cresent Auckland Auckland 0643

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am submitting in severe defense if the sand mining sand mining should not go ahead


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cancel this degredation of a protected spot

647

2





648

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Rhys Gwilliam

Organisation name:



Postal address: 7/38 Kitchener Road Milford Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Pakiri beach mining

What are the reasons for your submission? Keep our coastline beautiful. There are not many surfing spots around Auckland and in summer every beach is packed. People use these spots

649

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Get from elsewhere, somewhere less people attend





650

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sharie Sheffield

Organisation name:



Postal address: 33a Titoki Street Te Atatu Peninsula Auckland 0610

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: It's too much sand taken away!

What are the reasons for your submission? It's wrong, leave the beach alone!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not approving this!

651

2





652

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Tuesday, 2 June 2020 10:30 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10266] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: KASM SUBMISSION 280520 .pdf

Categories: Jackie










Full name: KASM

Organisation name: KASM



Postal address: PO Box 193 Raglan New Zealand Raglan New Zealand 3265

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This submission opposes the matters that are outlined in the AEE including the extraction of sand, disturbance to the seafloor, the associated impacts to the resilience of the benthic community along with ecological effects and impacts to at risk marine mammals.

What are the reasons for your submission? The seafloor supports a wide variety of organisms, including mussels, worms and crustaceans. The adverse effects of

653

2

the “suck and dump” method by trailing arm dredging processes, destroy and damages the seafloor along with the impacts to the benthic zone. The suction dredging will remove the entire top surface of the seabed. The depth of the dredging destroys benthos and the discharge from the dredge then smothers a large area in fine material that prevents regeneration. That process results in the removal of a valuable food source to a range of bottom feeder that make up the food chain. Both marine mammals and fish are impacted by the noise of the dredging operation potentially causing changes to their migratory and feeding habitats. There has been no research on the impacts to fish in the area, nor has there been any analysis of the potential loss to the economic activity in terms of fish catch to the commercial or recreational fishers. Nor has there been any analysis of the loss to natural capital. There has only been a cursory glance over the shoulder in undertaking the assessment in the AEE, and yet, it is stated that it is “expected to be no more than minor” The dredging will also destroy a rare stony coral. The stony coral is protected under the Wild Life Act (1953) and the area they are found; should be excluded from being available for extraction. The damage to the seabed will be substantial and the removal of a finite source of sand may result in beach and dune erosion. The Environmental Monitoring and Management Plan lacks substance and consent conditions are inadequate. Statutory Obligations The application has failed to meet the tests as set out Section 5 of the Resource Management Act 1991. Additionally, it has failed to take into account the provisions of the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010 and other relevant planning provisions.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? KASM seek the committee to decline the application.




Supporting information: KASM SUBMISSION 280520 .pdf

654

of 2

PO Box 193 Raglan

New Zealand [email protected]

Auckland Council Resource Consents Private Bag 92300 Auckland 1142 Re: Application number CST60343373 Applicant Kaipara Limited [email protected] David Hay Osborne Hay (North) Limited PO Box 16 Warkworth Auckland 0941 28 May 2020 Application details To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20-year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit between the 30m and 40m isobaths.

o KASM opposes the consent in its entirety o KASM wishes to be heard at the Hearing o KASM seeks the committee decline the application

The specific parts of the application to which my/our submission relates to are: This submission opposes the matters that are outlined in the AEE including the extraction of sand, disturbance to the seafloor, the associated impacts to the resilience of the benthic community along with ecological effects and impacts to at risk marine mammals.

655

of 2

The reasons for our submission are: The seafloor supports a wide variety of organisms, including mussels, worms and crustaceans. The adverse effects of the “suck and dump” method by trailing arm dredging processes, destroy and damages the seafloor along with the impacts to the benthic zone. The suction dredging will remove the entire top surface of the seabed. The depth of the dredging destroys benthos and the discharge from the dredge then smothers a large area in fine material that prevents regeneration. That process results in the removal of a valuable food source to a range of bottom feeder that make up the food chain. Both marine mammals and fish are impacted by the noise of the dredging operation potentially causing changes to their migratory and feeding habitats. There has been no research on the impacts to fish in the area, nor has there been any analysis of the potential loss to the economic activity in terms of fish catch to the commercial or recreational fishers. Nor has there been any analysis of the loss to natural capital. There has only been a cursory glance over the shoulder in undertaking the assessment in the AEE, and yet, it is stated that it is “expected to be no more than minor” The dredging will also destroy a rare stony coral. The stony coral is protected under the Wild Life Act (1953) and the area they are found; should be excluded from being available for extraction. The damage to the seabed will be substantial and the removal of a finite source of sand may result in beach and dune erosion. The Environmental Monitoring and Management Plan lacks substance and consent conditions are inadequate. Statutory Obligations The application has failed to meet the tests as set out Section 5 of the Resource Management Act 1991. Additionally, it has failed to take into account the provisions of the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010 and other relevant planning provisions. The decision we would like council to make is KASM seek the committee to decline the application.

656

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Fryderyk Kublikowski

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1/225 Ponsonby Road Ponsonby Auckland 1011

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose the offshore mining of sand at Pakiri.

What are the reasons for your submission? The removal of large volumes of sand will destabilise and permanently alter not only the marine environment But also the foreshore. Pakiri is a place of significant coastal beauty and should be protected. It is home to many native bird species and a popular place for locals and visitors. The previous mining operations in the area are still making their impact today with dramatic changes to the shore environment and currents.

657

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like to see this application turned down in its entirety.





658

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Daniel Gerrard

Organisation name:



Postal address: 134 Hobsonville Point Rd Hobsonville Auckland 0616

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: From a moral aspect...I believe that the times have changed and this type of ongoing environmental damage is morally unacceptable.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Withdrawal application

659

2





660

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Tuesday, 2 June 2020 12:00 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10270] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Elysia Green

Organisation name:



Postal address: 9 Kendale Drive Leigh Auckland 0587

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The reasons for my submission are;- causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources- a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit- climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels,

661

2

which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate- offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refuse to renew resource consent.





662

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Robyn Greenwood

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +64 0402436661


Postal address: 116 Thompson St Williamstown Williamstown 3016

Submission details




663

2







664

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: James Hislop

Organisation name:



Postal address: 38 Raymond Bull Rd /P O Box 298 Mangawhai Wellsford 0540

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The dredging of sand from beaches in the Mangawhai Parkari Area


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop any amendments completely

665

2





666

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ivy Dickson

Organisation name: REtired



Postal address: 3/4 Miro Street, Helensville, 0800. Helensville Auckland 0800

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I do not think that the right to take sand should be renewed

What are the reasons for your submission? It will effect the fishing and environment to take the sands

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not renew

667

2





668

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Peter Mayo

Organisation name: Mackenzie Mayo Ltd



Postal address: 24 Moira Street Ponsonby Auckland 1021

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are: Causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects to: flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity.

669

2

The Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes. The licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence. There are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit. Climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate. Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is: The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto.





670

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ben Jackson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 93A Dickson road papamoa beach papamoa beach 3118

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are; The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment


671

2







672

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: ANNETTE MOANA BAINES

Organisation name: OMAHA MARAE TRUST



Postal address: 74 BEECHDALE CRES pakuranga heights pakuranga heights 2010

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The offshore Sandmining - Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? We are opposing the renewal of this consent for Kaipara Ltd . The dredging has had adverse environmental effects to the flora , fauna , kai moana ,and water quality .Omaha Marae is a whanau Marae made up of the tupuna of Rahui Te Kiri and Tenetahi . This coastline still remains in the hands of these tupuna who STILL live there to this day . We see , hear the humming of these sand dredgers day and night . We also see first hand the effects this has had on our

673

2

beach . Omaha Marae is also part of the Ngatiwai Trust Board with whom the current agreement sits with . Kaipara Ltd has failed to fufill and has breached many of the key conditions of the MOU . We do NOT want anymore sand taken from our Foreshore .

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To end ALL dredging on the Pakiri Mangawhai Coastline . To NOT renew anymore consents .





674

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: jessica bluck

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2/225 Ponsonby Rd Ponsonby Auckland 1011

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I object to mining sand in Pakiri

What are the reasons for your submission? I object to mining sand in Pakiri

675

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I object to mining sand in Pakiri





676

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: melanie jackson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 93a Dickson road Papamoa Beach Papamoa Beach 3118

Submission details




677

2







678

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Louise Mary Fowler

Organisation name:



Postal address: 31 Rangiwai Road Titirangi Auckland 0604

Submission details




679

2







680

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Thomas gibbs

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1009 beach Road Torbay Auckland 0630

Submission details




681

2







682

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Moira Adelaide Brown

Organisation name:



Postal address: 301 Pakiri River Rd RD2 Wellsford 0972 pakiri Wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Extraction of Sand using suction pipe on seabed floor and the impact is has of and on shore.

What are the reasons for your submission? Other sustainable sources available. Constant breach of license. Private profit.

683

2

The offshore dredging practices is out of line with national directives and climate change protocols. Rising sea levels along with dredging is threatening our coastline at an increasing rate.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? End all dredging in the Pakiri embayment and the non renewal of the license.





684

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: David Pilmer

Organisation name:



Postal address: 32 Cullen Street, Mangawhai Heads Mangawhai Heads 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sandmining from Pakiri to Mangawhai with 20 year time frame externsion

What are the reasons for your submission? To stop this disastrous catastrophic Disaster happening to our beautiful coastline. The sand removed will never be replaced, leaving the area prone to erosion at a catastrophic rate and the possibility of losing our Harbour including our Distal Spit which is a Bird Sanctuary and Reserve with the possibility of lour Coastline being permanently ruined.

685

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To Ban this Sandmining and extraction of this collossal amoun t of sand from our Coastline permanently. There are other less vulnerable areas such as South Head that could be utilised instead. There are huger amounts of sand to be extracted there with very little opposition or damage foreseen. An open barren area with little foreseable future.





686

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Mark Emmett Osborne

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Bridgens Avenue Te Atatu Peninsula Auckland 0610

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The proximity to the beach, the volume of the sand allowed within the Resource Consent application are both not suitable for this prime coastal area. This coast has been mined for years and it is time to let it rest. Also to note is the close proximity to endangered birds nesting areas, this application is totally unacceptable. As rate payer of Auckland City, I strongly oppose this application.

What are the reasons for your submission? I am a concerned rate payer and support democracy and community input.

687

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not renew this consent application as it is inappropriate. The area has been mined for many years using a consent that is due to expire, There is and never was an ongoing right for the mining company to use this area past the initial consent application and period. That is due to expire and times have changed. Do not renew it.





688

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Renay Kung

Organisation name:



Postal address: 125 Cook Street, Howick Auckland Auckland 2013

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The taking of sand.

What are the reasons for your submission? To stop undermining the offshore ecosystem that is unique to the area.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Just stop it completely. Look for other ways to get the products humans need. Think outside the square.

689

2





690

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sarah Quinlan

Organisation name:



Postal address: 4 Moreton drive Manly Auckland 0930

Submission details




691

2







692

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Simonne Butler

Organisation name:



Postal address: 27 Bathgate Rd RD2 Wellsford Wellsford 0972

Submission details




693

2

for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources- a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit- climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate- offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments.






694

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Dr Mels Barton

Organisation name:



Postal address: PO Box 60203 Titirangi Auckland 0642

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are:- causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system

695

2


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The decision I would like council to make is: The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto





696

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Bridget O'Malley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Salisbury Street Herne Bay Auckland 1011

Submission details




697

2







698

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Oliver

Organisation name:



Postal address: 0985 Rodney Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Why are we mining sand from one of the only pristine places New Zealand and Auckland have left parkiri beach

What are the reasons for your submission? I live here and it’s a beautiful place so why don’t we keep it beautiful

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop mining parkiri beach

699

2





700

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Lorraine Tong

Organisation name:



Postal address: 476 Te Arai Point Rd Wellsford Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are; The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Te Arai, Mangawhai and Pakiri embayment.


701

2







702

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Carolyn Reid

Organisation name:



Postal address: 5 Ryle Street Freemans Bay Auckland 1011

Submission details




703

2







704

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Ben Green

Organisation name:



Postal address: 27 St Albans Ave Mt Eden Auckland 1024

Submission details




705

2







706

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Toby Mangelsdorf

Organisation name:




Submission details




707

2







708

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Brent pascoe

Organisation name:



Postal address: 6 waimiri road Glenbrook Auckland 2681

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Oppose the mining of sand at pakari On the bases that I have watch the environment impact it has had on mining at mangawhai and have seen the change over 30 years and what it has done to the volumes of sand to the sandpit Growing up over looking the big sand dune at mangawhai In 1985 you could not see little barrier or part of port jackson in the coromandal due to the shear size of the big dune Over 25 years looking out over the big dune I watched sea tow and sebritskys come in every day mining sand. Every year the big dune decreased

709

2

The sand spit became narrower and lower 2006 i left mangawhai and from the house i grew up in beyond the big dune Little barrier. Coromandal and pakari were all visible What was known as the biggest sand dune in the southern hemisphere was no longer From 2000 to 2006 rocks at the main surf beach started appearing and the first sign of iron sand started appearing on what had always been crystal white silica beaches for years before Pakari does not have the amount of sand that mangawhai had and will not sustain the shear volume of sand that the will take from this stretch of beach There have been numerous sightings that the dredge has been spotted breaching its northern boundary past pakari and into TeArai zones at night It will have ecological and environmental impacts for future generations if this lease is to be renewed and I would not like to see this go on any further


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Find an alternative location If north port is passed there are tonnes of silica sand to be taken out of one tree point to make way for the port South head has high capacities of silica They dredging needs to stopped along the east coast as the coast line can not sustain what has already been taken from over the last 50 years I do not oppose the mining of sand for nz industries But I do oppose the mining for off shore use and replenishment of beaches that do not naturally have sand I.E mission bay and auckland beaches such as onehunga basin As they can not naturally maintain sandy beaches and have to be constantly topped up and replenished Find an alternative location east coast Auckland to cape Reina is not the answer





710

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Arash Barzin

Organisation name:



Postal address: 31 Taikata Rd Auckland Auckland 0610

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Environmental impact and sustainable development.

What are the reasons for your submission? Preservation of the natural character of the coastal environment, including protection from inappropriate use and development for private commercial means within the coastal marine area. The duration of the consent without consideration for sustainable alternatives materials available with lesser impacts which

711

2

can meet the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Consider sustainable alternatives through research and development to mitigate the cumulative effects of coastal development on Northlands east coast which has already experienced significant detrimental impacts on the natural character of the coast.





712

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Aaron McConchie

Organisation name: SAVE Te Arai



Postal address: 530b Kaiwaka Mangawhai Rd Wellsford kaipara 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? -The area is part of the breeding/foraging ground for the Critically Endangered NZ Fairy Tern and other NZ shorebirds. No consideration has been made or investigation into the affect of these operations on these endangered species. ANY impact to the survival of these birds is unacceptable.

713

2

-The EMMP is whole inadequate and focuses on a heads down approach without monitoring any affects of the surrounding area, fauna/shorebirds and the cumulative affect of both offshore and inshore mining. -There is no regard for the retention of the regionally significant surf breaks of Forestry, Te Arai Point and Mangawhai. These breaks are coastal shore breaks of sand and have been affected over the last 20 years. Analysis in application is of theoretical wave height not quality or ability to hold surf able break over varied swell direction. -The Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging -The sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes -In the application is states that there are alternative sand supply sources -The area is adjacent to Te Arai Regional park and any depletion of natural assets will affect the long term viability of park and the visual and physical amenity of the public - majority of who are from Auckland City. -The period the resource consent applied for is too long to adequately account for climate change effects of which coastal dredging will exacerbate. -The disturbance and destruction of shellfish beds is in direct oppositions to the Hauraki Gulf Forums initiative to restore shellfish beds.






714

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Petrus van der Schaaf

Organisation name:



Postal address: 476 Te Arai Point Road Te Arai Point Wellsford RD5 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose (1) the extraction activity proposed, (2) its excessive volumes, as well as (3) the twenty-year time frame. The nature of the operations threatens the seabed ecology, as well as the natural movements of currents and surf. Furthermore, the defined proposed DEPTHS of operation allow un-monitored incursions in terms of DISTANCE.

What are the reasons for your submission? Kaipara Limited has operated this type of operation for many years, disregarding both the damage to the environment

715

2

as well as violating the restrictions of its consents. Their operations are often so close to shore that it seems highly unlikely that they are operating at the approved depths.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? END ALL DREDGING IN THIS ENTIRE AREA. Given the complexities and threats of global warming and rising sea levels, it is irresponsible to provide 'carte blanche' to such destructive behavior.





716

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Wednesday, 3 June 2020 12:15 AMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10299] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Andrew Turner

Organisation name: A W T



Postal address: Po. Box 62 Leigh North Auckland 0985

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I strongly disagree with the application of having permission to remove ANY more sand from offshore at pakiri beach.

What are the reasons for your submission? Coastal erosion, change in habitual behaviour of the sand sea and wildlife.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not give the concent to take any more sand from offshore at pakiri.

717

2





718

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Paul Reid

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1409D Mangawhai Road Mangawhai Auckland 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The whole thing


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please come up with other ways to get sand but please don’t continue this type of activity off the coast.

719

2





720

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jess Barnett

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1 Amber Glen Albany Auckland 0632

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are;

721

2

- causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - the Pakiri embayment is in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






722

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Trish Harkins

Organisation name:



Postal address: 41 Ashwood Avenue Dairy Flat Dairy Flat 0792

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This beach is one of the north islands finest and supports many aspects , Surfing , fishing , wildlife , and general recreation , it brings tourism to the area which is a much needed income for a lot of people , damage to the marine ecology that will not be repairable, and added pollution to the marine area and surrounds turning this into a sand mine is suicide , there is already a sand mine near Te Arai , and please consider the fact that you are neighbor to a very valuable marine reserve and marine biology university in Goat Island ,I wholeheartedly object to this proposal

723

2

What are the reasons for your submission? This decision will pollute our marine wildlife and will not be repairable

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like it to not go ahead.





724

1

Jackie Lee



Categories: Jackie










Full name: Vanessa Mutu

Organisation name:




Submission details



725

2

What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to marine fauna, sea bed, water quality & indigenous biodiversity - the long-term adverse residual effects on the Pakiri embayment, its marine ecosystem and coastal processes, are unlikely to ever be adequately mitigated or offset - the Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes, with potential adverse effects on coastal morphology and dune dynamics - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources elsewhere in the region - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered in the application, eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate (noting that healthy dune systems provide a critical natural barrier against the effects of sea level rise and increased storm intensity and frequency) - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non-renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto.





726

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Juan Miguel Hamber

Organisation name:



Postal address: 12 Kanuka Place Mangawhai Heads Kaipara 0505

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity, which is bulk extraction of sand offshore from the Pakiri area.

What are the reasons for your submission? - adverse environmental effects - The reducing volume of sand from year to year - the licensee has breached key conditions of the licence and cannot be trusted to adhere to conditions in future - there are alternative & sustainable sources of sand elsewhere

727

2

- a public resource is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered - offshore sand dredging is out of step with climate change commitments

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To end all dredging in the Pakiri / Mangawhai area





728

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Dawson Mutu

Organisation name:




Submission details




729

2







730

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kelly Moanna Klink

Organisation name: Protect Aotea



Postal address: PO Box 25, Port Fitzroy, Aotea, Great Barrier Island Auckland 0990

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The entire application

What are the reasons for your submission? For the protection of the moana

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To stop all dredging

731

2





732

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Mark Estall

Organisation name: Owner



Postal address: 48 Lake Rd Te Arai Point Mangawhai Auckland 0975

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity - The fishery has been disturbed significantly over the past with this extraction - The surf banks are constantly changing when the dredge from time to time gets very close to the shore

733

2







734

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kate O'Malley

Organisation name:



Postal address: 51 Aldersgate Road Hillsborough Auckland 1042

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates are: *the non-complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise * the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to, the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment.

What are the reasons for your submission? It will cause offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects to flora, fauna, sea bed, water quality & biodiversity.

735

2

The Pakiri embayment is a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative & sustainable sand supply sources- a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit- climate change effects have not been properly considered eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate- offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






736

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Geoffrey MacRae

Organisation name:



Postal address: 89 Granville Rd Te Arai Auckland 0974

Submission details




737

2







738

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Rowan Evan Smiley




Postal address: 264 Pakiri Block Road RD4, Wellsford Auckland 0974

Submission details




739

2

unlikely to ever be adequately mitigated or offset - the Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes, with potential adverse effects on coastal morphology and dune dynamics - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources elsewhere in the region - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered in the application, eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate (noting that healthy dune systems provide a critical natural barrier against the effects of sea level rise and increased storm intensity and frequency) - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments - When the wind is in the right direction, the noise of dredging late at night penetrates even our double glazing and interrupts our ability to get to sleep.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? -The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non-renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto. - Should you decide to allow this application, restrict the hours of operation.





740

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marina MacRae

Organisation name: Please Select



Postal address: 29 Muritai Road Auckland Auckland 0620

Submission details




741

2







742

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Tommy foster gustafsson

Organisation name:



Postal address: 21 allenby avenue Devonport Auckland 0624

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Stop te arai sand mining


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Dont renew mining contracts

743

2





744

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Logan Batts

Organisation name:



Postal address: 2/244 Victoria Ave Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details




745

2







746

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jacob Clarke Smith

Organisation name:



Postal address: 182 Station Rd, RD2 Matamata Waikato 3440

Submission details




747

2







748

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Samantha MacRae

Organisation name:



Postal address: 89 Granville rd Te Arai Auckland 0974

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? - causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to marine fauna, sea bed, water quality & indigenous biodiversity

749

2

- the long-term adverse residual effects on the Pakiri embayment, its marine ecosystem and coastal processes, are unlikely to ever be adequately mitigated or offset - the Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes, with potential adverse effects on coastal morphology and dune dynamics - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources elsewhere in the region - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered in the application, eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate (noting that healthy dune systems provide a critical natural barrier against the effects of sea level rise and increased storm intensity and frequency) - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments






750

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Jody Greenleaf

Organisation name:



Postal address: 689 Rahuikiri Rd Tomarata Wellsford RD 4 Auckland 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sandmining off Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? Opposing any sandmining because of the damage caused to the seabed, foreshore, plant and birdlife, shell fish beds, and marine life, Pakiri beach is a precious gem and we MUST protect it. If you take away the sand which is a NON renewable resource, you will destroy everything that lives in it, on it and around it.

751

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like to see the area between Goat Island and Mangawhai heads made into a marine reserve and the applications from ALL parties to sand mining this area denied.





752

From: Jackie LeeTo: Jody GreenleafSubject: RE: s95 Resource Consent CST60343373 - Submission Confirmation,Hearing ProcessDate: Tuesday, 9 June 2020 4:01:00 PM

Hello Jody, Not a problem, I’ll put a copy of your email with the submission to show you DO NOT want to attend the hearing ormake a joint submission. Kind regards,Jackie. Jackie Lee | Regulatory Support Officer North/WestResource ConsentsPh 09 427 3332 | Extn (44) 3332Auckland Council, 50 Centreway Road, Orewa 0931

From: Jody Greenleaf <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, 9 June 2020 12:37 PMTo: Jackie Lee <[email protected]>Subject: RE: s95 Resource Consent CST60343373 - Submission Confirmation,Hearing Process Hello Jackie,Thank you for your email. It appears that I have ticked the wrong box on my submission where it asks of I want toattend a hearing and speak in support of my submission, should be a No not a Yes and also the next questionregarding making a joint submission should also read No not Yes.I apologise for this error.Kind regards,Jody Greenleaf Sent from Mail for Windows 10

From: Jackie LeeSent: Monday, 8 June 2020 3:32 PMTo: Jackie LeeSubject: FW: s95 Resource Consent CST60343373 - Submission Confirmation,Hearing Process Good afternoon, I confirm receipt of your submission to the above resource consent application. If your submission was not made online through the online submission facility, Section 96(6) of the ResourceManagement Act 1991 requires you to serve a copy of your submission on the applicant or the applicant’s agent ifthat is the address for service as soon as possible, if you have not done so already. Please note that the recent amendments to the Resource Management Act 1991, have changed the procedures fornotified applications and now makes it mandatory for applicants and submitters to provide their evidence prior tothe date of the hearing. These changes now require the council to firstly provide its officers’ reports and any evidence at least 15 workingdays prior to the date of the hearing. Following this, the applicant must provide all its briefs of evidence at least 10working days prior to the date of the hearing. Any submitter wishing to call expert witnesses at the hearing, such as from a professional planner or a trafficengineer, must provide their briefs of expert evidence at least 5 working days prior to the date of the hearing. Once a hearing date has been set, the council will advise you of the date of the hearing and the date by which yourexpert evidence must be provided to the council.

753

mailto:[email protected]


https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986



The council will be using its website to make available all the reports and evidences to the applicant and submitters. The link to the website will be:https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/have-yoursay/hearings/findhearing/Pages/find-resource-consent-hearing.aspx. The council will be using email as the address for service for the applicant and submitters unless advised otherwise. If you have any queries, please contact Jackie Lee on [email protected] in the first instance andquote the application number CST60343373. Yours sincerely,Jackie. Jackie Lee | Regulatory Support Officer North/WestResource ConsentsPh 09 427 3332 | Extn (44) 3332Auckland Council, 50 Centreway Road, Orewa 0931 As New Zealand remains under COVID-19 Alert Level 2, Auckland Council is providing services in accordance with the government’sdirection. Regulatory Services are continuing to provide some face-to-face services, however our Graham Street service centre andreception remains closed at this stage. We are contactable by email or phone. We apologise for any delay in responding to your inquiry and thank you for your continued patience and support. You can also visit aucklandcouncil.govt.nz for more information about our response to COVID-19, as well as access to generalinformation and online services.

CAUTION: This email message and any attachments contain information that may be confidential and may be LEGALLY PRIVILEGED. If youare not the intended recipient, any use, disclosure or copying of this message or attachments is strictly prohibited. If you have received thisemail message in error please notify us immediately and erase all copies of the message and attachments. We do not accept responsibility forany viruses or similar carried with our email, or any effects our email may have on the recipient computer system or network. Any viewsexpressed in this email may be those of the individual sender and may not necessarily reflect the views of Council.

754

https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/have‐yoursay/hearings/findhearing/Pages/find‐resource‐consent‐hearing.aspx


https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/Pages/default.aspx

https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/have-your-say/topics-you-can-have-your-say-on/emergency-budget/Pages/default.aspx?utm_source=ac_footer&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=EmergencyBudget

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Wednesday, 3 June 2020 12:01 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10317] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marie Alpe

Organisation name:



Postal address: 21 Ocean View Rd R D 4 Wellsford 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The application is opposed in its entirety. More specifically the gross extraction of sand from the sea bed in the defined area off the Te-Arai - Pakiri coastline, and the methods of extraction using a trailing suction pipe.

What are the reasons for your submission? 1. Because of the damage that has been and could be done to the seabed, marine flora and fauna biodiversity and to the Te Arai - Pakiri foreshore. Not enough is known about the effects of sand extraction from the seabed and in particular the long term effects of sand extraction from the seabed. The Te Arai - Pakiri coast the subject of this

755

2

application has been subjected to sand dredging both near shore and offshore for a very long time. I am particularly concerned that the long term effects of this are not well understood or known - it could take decades for adverse effects to materialise and then it is too late. A precautionary approach should be taken and I understand is required by resource management statements and policies relating to the coastal marine area such as the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement. 2.The Pakiri embayment is recognised as a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging. I understand that the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus extraction volumes. This has been going on for years and as already stated I believe that there is insufficient information about the long term effects of sand extraction from the seabed. Under the Resource Management Act 1991 Council is required to consider potential and cumulative effects of an activity on the environment. The community is already concerned about adverse effects such as continual changes to the beach and erosion of the foreshore. For example a memorial seat at Forestry Beach (Te Arai South) has had to be moved back several metres. 3. Over the past 15 years I have actively worked with others and with Council to ensure the protection of the very significant natural, landscape and biodiversity values of the Te Arai - Pakiri coast. North Te Arai in particular is habitat for a number of endangered species including the rare NZ fairy tern and the Northern NZ dotterel. It is most important that habitat is not impacted by adverse effects such as the gradual eroding back of the shoreline, depleting or changes to the biota of the coastal marine area with a consequential effect on these species. There needs to be a very high level of certainty that these adverse effects will be avoided.or the application should not be allowed. 4. It is inappropriate for such destructive activity to be taking place in the coastal marine area adjacent to sensitive habitats - Te Arai Stream and Poutawa Streams are identified as Significant Ecological Areas in the Auckland Unitary Plan Operative in Part. And adjacent to a regional park. This has been designated along the coastal edge of North Te Arai and is soon to be extended to Poutawa Stream. 5. Te Arai - Pakiri coastline is a precious resource to be enjoyed by the species that inhabit it and by the greater public, not depleted for private profit. An alternative and more sustainable supply of sand for Auckland's needs should be utilised. 6. Climate change effects have not been adequately assessed in the application. For example sea level rise which is in itself a direct threat to this significant coastline and will be exacerbated by the sand dredging. 7. Offhsore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National policies and objectives to protect the coastal marine area. It should not continue

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? No renewal of any licence or amendments for dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment. Decline of the application in its entirety.





756

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Danielle Norrie

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Bayfield Road Herne Bay Auckland 1011

Submission details




757

2







758

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Richard Stuart Hodder

Organisation name:



Postal address: 11/14 Fowlds Ave Sandringham Auckland 1025

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose this application completely. No extraction of sand should be carried out with this proximity to the coastline.

What are the reasons for your submission? The environment does not deserve this type of theft. The application for the extraction of sand and the effects on wildlife and inherent effects of water movement around this coastline in question moves me to act and tell you that I oppose this.

759

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the application and put a stop to sand extraction going forward!





760

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Te Maia Pihema

Organisation name:



Postal address: 21 Rushden Terrace Red Beach Auckland 0932

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Increasing the amount of sand mined will have a negative impact on the environment


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To decrease the resource consent for the amount of sand companies are allowed to mine in the Kaipara District

761

2





762

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kevin Plumpton

Organisation name:



Postal address: 644 Rahuikiri Rd Tomarata Auckland 0974

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: non-complying activity and the form(s) of its exercise. Being offshore, gross extraction of sand and disturbance to the sea bed using suction pipe, in the Pakiri area.

What are the reasons for your submission? Erosion of the sand dunes on my property that is clearly visible well over the last 5 years. Shows previous claims of no erosion was incorrect as net effect is erosion without replenishment. More black sand appearing as coast recedes.

763

2

Boat is any eye sore during day and comes in closer to the shoreline some nights which is distracting with the lights and engine noises. If there is a distance limit from shore then I would suggest they are likely breaching it by stealth at night. Rising sea level issues will be further affected causing earlier damage to coastal properties Offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to marine fauna, sea bed, water quality & indigenous biodiversity Long-term adverse residual effects on the Pakiri embayment, its marine ecosystem and coastal processes, are unlikely to ever be adequately mitigated or offset there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources elsewhere in the region precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ending the destruction from dredging with no further licenses being granted





764

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Maria King

Organisation name:



Postal address: 62B Campbell Rd My Maunganui Mt Maunganui 3116

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The region mined should be reduced and extend only as far north as Te Arai Point.

What are the reasons for your submission? The long term impact on the sand dune and sand spit at Mangawhai. Sand that is taken from the area north of Te Arai Pt over the last few decades has had a detrimental effect on the sand dune and sand spit at Mangawhai. Sand that cycles from the Mangawhai harbour/estuary out and pushes back up onto the beach to form the dune is unavailable. Hence the height of the dune is substantially lower now than it was even 20 yrs ago. The outcomes of these mining

765

2

decisions are not realised within a 10yr timeframe, they have significant long term effects. The sand cycle must be preserved.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Limit the northern region boundary so that it ends at Te Arai Pt.





766

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: david reece

Organisation name:



Postal address: po box 4208 shortland street auckland nz auckland auckland 1140

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The specific parts of the application to which my submission relates to are: The non-complying activity and the forms of its exercise. Being the offshore, gross extraction of sand from, and disturbance to the sea bed, using a trailing suction pipe in the Pakiri embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? The reasons for my submission are; -casual offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to flora,fauna , sea bed, water quality and general

767

2

biodiversity. - the Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system by previous dredging. -the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes. - the licencee has failed to fulfill and has breached many of the key conditions of the existing licence and has exercised that licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the existing licence. -there are alternative and more sustainable forms of sand supply sources. -A finite precious resource, as enjoyed by tens of thousands of New Zealanders and overseas visitors, is being depleted and abused for private, commercial profit. -Climate change effects have not been properly considered by the applicant . Continued sand extraction by the applicant will further exacerbate the effect of rising sea levels on the coastline and dune systems . -Off shore sand mining is now completely out of step with regional and national directives, climate change protocols and NZ`s international commitments regarding climate change.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? . I would encourage the council to reject the application referred to herein and, in effect, end all dredging in the Pakiri Management embayment and also put end to the renewal of any sand mining licence(s) or amendments thereto.





768

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Marama Gossage

Organisation name:



Postal address: 362 Rahuikiri Road, RD2 Pakiri Wellsford 0972

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? As a resident of Pakiri Beach, a descendant of Rahui TeKiri and Ngati Wai I am appalled at the detrimental affect the

769

2

current sand dredging has had on our whenua, the sand quality, dunes and shore bird life. It appears that the barges are unmonitored and are operating too close to shore and at unreasonable hours.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the sand dredging.





770

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: star gossage

Organisation name: star gossage



Postal address: 362 rahui kiri rd pakiri wellsford 0972 pakiri rd2 wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I fully opposes the sand mining at pakiri beach , as a tangata whenua who lives on this beach . I am a living desendand of my tupuna who have lived on this beach with unbroken occupation since the canoes arrived .

What are the reasons for your submission? Our dunes have gone , the sand is turning grey , our seafood has gone , our birds have changed habitat , dead sea life washes up on the beach daily , we the people who have lived here in pakiri for hundreds of years know our beach

771

2

better than anyone , you are destroying it very quickly . with no regard of us or our animals and plants we live amount.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Simply to stop the dredging , and if you are too greedy and dumb to not be able to do that , then at least send them out way into deep sea , whales don't come here anymore because of the noise pollution ,i have found dead dolphins and sharks washed up . i see the boat everyday , and it is always breaching the distance from shores .TOO CLOSE.!!





772

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: SIMON PENGELLY

Organisation name:



Postal address: 10 Armadale Road REMUERA Auckland 1050

Submission details




773

2







774

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Elena Keith

Organisation name:



Postal address: 32 Rawene Ave Auckland Auckland 1022

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? Causal offshore and onshore adverse environmental effects; to marine fauna, sea bed, water quality & indigenous biodiversity - the long-term adverse residual effects on the Pakiri embayment, its marine ecosystem and coastal processes, are

775

2

unlikely to ever be adequately mitigated or offset - the Pakiri embayment is, in substance, a closed system for the effective replenishment of sand taken out of the system via dredging - the sand system is in annual deficit from effective sand inputs minus total dredging extraction volumes, with potential adverse effects on coastal morphology and dune dynamics - the licencee has failed to fulfil, and breached, many of the key conditions of the licence and has exercised the licence in ways not envisaged in the grant of the licence - there are alternative and sustainable sand supply sources elsewhere in the region - a finite, precious resource as enjoyed by the greater public, is being depleted for private profit - climate change effects have not been properly considered in the application, eg rising sea levels, which in themselves are a direct threat to the coast, which the dredging will further exacerbate (noting that healthy dune systems provide a critical natural barrier against the effects of sea level rise and increased storm intensity and frequency) - offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives and climate change protocols and commitments. We have been going to Pakiri Beach for over 40 years and have seen the degradation of the marine environment and the beach since the dredging started.






776

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Nicky Spencer

Organisation name:



Postal address: 437a Point Chevalier Road Point Chevalier Auckland 1022

Submission details




777

2







778

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Louise Garlick

Organisation name:



Postal address: 7 Hibiscus Avenue Snells Beach Warkworth 0920

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand Mining @ Pakiri Beach

What are the reasons for your submission? To stop the sand mining at Pakiri Beach

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop Mining

779

2





780

1

Jackie Lee

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nzSent: Wednesday, 3 June 2020 2:46 PMTo: Resource Consent AdminCc: [email protected]: CST60343373 [ID:10330] Submission received on notified resource consent Attachments: MHRS submission - Kaipara Ltd application.pdf


Categories: Jackie










Full name: James Carnie

Organisation name: Mangawhai Harbour Restoration Society Inc.



Postal address: c/- Clendons, PO Box 1305 Auckland City Auckland 1140

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Refer to document attached.


781

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refer to document attached.




Supporting information: MHRS submission - Kaipara Ltd application.pdf

782

of 3

SUBMISSION ON RESOURCE CONSENT APPLICATION

To: Auckland Council Resource Consents Private Bag 92300 Auckland 1142

Submitter Details

Name Mangawhai Harbour Restoration Society Inc.

Address PO Box 401 021, Mangawhai Heads, 0451

Address for service c/o Clendons, PO Box 1305, Auckland, 1140

Phone (09) 306 8000

Email [email protected]

Application Details

Number CST60343373

Name of Applicant Kaipara Limited

Address of proposed activity

Auckland Offshore Sand Extraction Site, Coastal Marine Area

Description of proposed activity

To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20 year period. Extraction between the western boundary of the sand extraction area (being the 25m isobath) and the 30m isobath is limited to 150,000m³ per annum, and there is no annual limit prosposed between the 30m and 40m isobaths.

1. Introduction

1.1. The Mangawhai Harbour Restoration Society Inc (“MHRS”) is a voluntary and charitable

society established for the purpose of the restoration, maintenance and enhancement of the Mangawhai Harbour and surrounding environment. The MHRS represents the interests of the Mangawhai community and its environs. Its objects include:

• Restoring features of the Harbour that have been damaged by pollution or erosion:

• Restoring and maintaining navigable waterways within the Harbour;

• Maintaining and enhancing the quality of water in the Harbour; and

• Assisting the maintenance, preservation and enhancement of the bird sanctuary and sand spit.

The full objects of the MHRS are set out in its Constitution.

1.2. The MHRS successfully opposed near shore sand extraction in the Mangawhai-Pakiri embayment in 2004, and have serious concerns about the environmental impacts of the current sand extraction operations within and surrounding the embayment. Offshore sand extraction can cause adverse effects in the coastline and the near-shore system. The MHRS therefore opposes the application in its entirety.

783

of 3

1.3. The general reasons for this submission are as follows:

• The Mangawhai-Pakiri embayment is a closed sand system, and sand extraction in and around this area is unsustainable;

• Prior studies and decisions have identified the potential for detrimental effects associated with sand extraction in the Mangawhai-Pakiri embayment;

• The applicant’s Assessment of Ecological Effects (“AEE”) is inadequate and unbalanced, and fails to reflect the true environmental and other impacts of sand mining in the area; and

• The applicant has failed to adequately investigate alternative sand sources and methodologies.

These matters are set out more extensively below.

2. The Mangawhai-Pakiri Embayment

2.1. The Mangawhai-Pakiri embayment is a stretch of coastline 30km long approximately 1 hour north-east of Auckland.

2.2. The embayment is the only large ocean beach on the east coast of the region, and Pakiri Beach is the only relatively undisturbed exposed east coast surf beach free of housing and development.

2.3. The dune systems of the Mangawhai-Pakiri coast are recognised as having high conservation values, and are of local, regional and international significance: for example, the Mangawhai-Pakiri dunes were accorded the highest score of any beach in the Auckland Region in the national dune inventory1, and the Department of Conservation has also selected the area as an Area of Significant Conservation Value.

2.4. The endemic threatened sedge, pingao (Ficinia spiralis) ('relict') is found on the dunes along the coast. The foredunes are dominated by spinifex (Spinifex sericeus) and the sand tussock (Austrofestuca littoralis) which are classified as being in decline and are particularly vulnerable to episodes of foredune erosion in storm events. Regionally significant populations of the threatened sand copromsa (Coprosma acerosa), also in decline, are also present on the backdunes.

2.5. Birds in the Pakiri area include the white faced heron, blue reef heron ('nationally endangered’), fairy tern ('nationally critical’), pied stilt and variable oystercatcher (‘recovering’).

2.6. The mouth of the Pakiri River is also a particularly important part of this habitat. The Pakiri River is a tidal stream with a small estuary and bordering saltmarsh that grades into the adjacent natural sand dune plant community. The Pakiri River supports a range of wading, coastal, and secretive threatened coastal fringe birds. Many of the waders and coastal birds roost on the mobile sands at the river mouth, and some, including a range of threatened species nest there. The secretive coastal fringe birds use the saline vegetation and their habitat is enhanced by the presence of adjacent terrestrial vegetation which provides roosts for the birds and potential nesting sites.

3. Adverse Effects on Marine Environment

3.1. Despite the significant conservation value attributed to the Mangawhai-Pakiri embayment, and the designation of the Mangawhai Harbour as Coastal Marine 1 (Protection), Kaipara Limited

1 Partridge T. (1992) The Sand and Dune Beach Vegetation Inventory of New Zealand. I. North Island

784

of 3

seeks resource consents for sand extraction within the embayment, just 3km south of the Coastal Marine 1 (Protection) area at Mangawhai Harbour (where the Minister of Conservation had declined near-shore applications for sand extraction in 2004).

3.2. In August 2004, an independent Hearing Committee was convened to hear applications lodged with the Northland Regional Council (“NRC”) seeking permission to undertake near-shore sand extraction from within the Mangawhai-Pakiri embayment.

3.3. The NRC Hearing Committee recommended that the applications to extract up to 50,000 m3 per year from the coastal marine area at Mangawhai Harbour be declined.2

3.4. The Hearing Committee, having carefully considered all of the evidence, concluded that the proposed sand extraction was not an appropriate and sustainable activity.

3.5. The Commissioners concluded from the evidence that sand extraction contributes to the degradation of the environment, and noted that:

There was no evidence that clearly indicated to the Hearing Committee that sand

extracted was directly replaced by such sand inputs to the system and the Hearing

Committee observed that, even if there was, then the annual extraction would consume

all of it.

Having considered the matter of whether sand extraction was causing erosion of the

Mangawhai Spit, the Hearing Committee considered that sand extraction was a

contributor to erosion.

3.6. As a result, the Commissioners considered that the adverse effects on the environment as a result of continued sand extraction had the potential to cause adverse effects on the coastline, including the conservation values of the Spit (i.e. spit morphology, wildlife habitat and local community) and on natural character. These adverse effects were considered to be more than minor and not capable of being adequately controlled or mitigated through the imposition of conditions.

3.7. These findings were not appealed, and the Minister of Conservation declined the application.3

3.8. Several potential risks and threats to the values of the environment were also identified in evidence. Of particular concern was the potential threat to the habitat of endangered indigenous fauna – the New Zealand Fairy Tern and the New Zealand Dotterel.

3.9. The MHRS disputes the validity and reliability of several assertions made within the application. The application and its associated reports fail to adequately acknowledge the adverse effects of offshore sand extraction.

4. Outcome Sought by MHRS

4.1. The MHRS seeks that the Council declines the application.

4.2. The MHRS wishes to speak in support of this submission at the hearing. If others make a similar submission, the MHRS will consider presenting a joint case with those parties at the hearing.

2 Decision and Recommendation of the Combined Hearing Committee for the consideration of the applications

by Sea Tow Ltd (CON20030620301) and Norsand Ltd (CON20030623601) (August 2004) 3 Prior to the Resource Management (Simplifying and Streamlining) Amendment Act 2009, the Minister of

Conservation was responsible for approving applications for Restricted Coastal Activities.

785

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Sam Whiddett

Organisation name:



Postal address: 54b Aberdeen Road Campbells Bay Auckland 0620

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To prevent the continued destruction of Pakiri Beach through sand mining.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Prevent sand being taken from the Pakiri beach area and other beaches in their jurisdiction.

786

2





787

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Adie Glover

Organisation name: Te Arai Wellness Collective



Postal address: 75 Cemetery Road Te Arai Wellsford 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Sand mining continuing at Te Arai

What are the reasons for your submission? An iconic surf spot that needs to be protected

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stop the sand minibg

788

2





789

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Katherine Elizabeth Moss

Organisation name:



Postal address: 13 Westmere Park Avenue Westmere Auckland 1022

Submission details




790

2







791

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Martin Charles Greenleaf

Organisation name: Birkenhead Health Centre



Postal address: P O Box 34050 Birkenhead Auckland 0746

Submission details



What are the reasons for your submission? *In the 10 years that I have been living in Pakiri beach, I walk along the beach every day. The local fishermen (some living in the area 40 years) tell me that the fishing stocks have declined at an alarming rate. * The sand dredge on many occasions are well within 2 ks of the high tide mark - sometimes just behind the surf

792

2

break. The dredging appears to effect the sand bank formation along Pakiri Beach which causes poor surfing conditions and effecting the shell fish i.e. pippies & tuatua's. * Climate change has not been properly factored in to the sand minning application eg the tides are getting higher and starting to impact on the sand dunes. This will effect coastal property in the future. * Offshore sand dredging is out of step with Regional and National directives, climate change, protocols and commitments.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The ending of all dredging in the Pakiri Mangawhai embayment and the non-renewal of any licence(s) or amendments thereto. As well as enlarge the Goat Island Marine Reserve to include Pakiri & Mangawhai beaches also Little Barrier (Houturu).





793

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Michelle Gimblett

Organisation name:



Postal address: 61 Millennial Way Orewa Auckland 0931

Submission details




794

2







795

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Catherine King

Organisation name:



Postal address: 68 Coal Hill Road, RD5 Wellsford. 0975

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I do not believe the resource is renewable. These arguments have had to be repeated over the years because of the effects on both Pakiri and Mangawhai.


What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To not issue a permit to continue to dredge in this place.

796

2





797

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Kelly Dean

Organisation name:



Postal address: 1013 Great North Road Pt Chevalier Auckland 1022

Submission details




798

2







799

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Aroha Gossage

Organisation name:



Postal address: 17 Arahia Street Northcote Auckland 0627

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: To extract up to a total of 2,000,000m³ of sand from an area of 44km² within the coastal marine area over a 20 year period.

What are the reasons for your submission? I am a descendant of Rahui Te Kiri who was once owner of this entire region, I live on Pakiri Beach. The mining of the unrenewable resource has a direct impact on our lives as over my lifetime I have witnessed the recession of the sandunes which continues to be interfered with.

800

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cease all mining.





801

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Juliet Staveley Andrews

Organisation name:



Postal address: 246 Pakiri River Road RD@ Wellsford Auckland 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The non complying activity and the form (s) of its exercise. Being the offshore,gross extraction of sand from and disturbance to the sea bed, using a (trailing) suction pipe, in the Pakiri embayment

What are the reasons for your submission? I protest at the "head in the sand" attitude in allowing the blatant plundering of a finite and precious resource for private profit.

802

2

Area is between 2 regional parks. Conflict of interest with goals of Hauraki Gulf forum advocating for protection,restoration and enhancement of critical marine values and ecosystems Public consultation by the "miners" has been minimal After so many years, time to explore other avenues.






803

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: Craig Peirce

Organisation name:



Postal address: 16 Fairview Road Mount Eden Mount Eden 1024

Submission details




804

2







805

1

Jackie Lee


Categories: Jackie










Full name: John Andrews

Organisation name: Mr



Postal address: 246 Pakiri River Road Welllsford Wellsford 0972

Submission details


Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The extraction of sand and disturbance of the seabed in the Pakiri embayment,

What are the reasons for your submission? Having lived here on the beachfront at Pakiri for more than 20 years I have witnessed the gradual disappearance of the sand from the dunes and the beach. a lot of the shellfish have also disappeared.

806

2

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? considering the terrible state of the Hauraki Gulf surely the Council should see sense and stop this plundering of this FINITE resource [it cannot be replaced] as pointed out at the last hearing there are mountains of sand moving around the Kaipara that canbe mined for Auckland Industry but no doubt this will cost the miners more so less profit!!





807

submissions volume 1 coastal marine area - pakiri …

Documents