strategies and considerations for effective p2 planning ... · page 1 of 14 robert g. booze e:mail...

14
Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning and Implementation 9 April 2003 Pollution Prevention Opportunity Assessment (PPOA) Methodology

Upload: others

Post on 15-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page1 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

Strategies and Considerations for EffectiveP2 Planning and Implementation

9 April 2003

Pollution Prevention OpportunityAssessment (PPOA) Methodology

Page 2: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page2 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

Pollution Prevention OpportunityAssessment (PPOA) Methodology

• P2 Planning• Assessing Opportunities• Data Collection and Reporting• Communication• P2 Hierarchy• Targets and Objectives• Aspects and Impacts• Process Flow Diagrams• Recommending Alternatives• Feasibility Analysis• P2 Initiatives• Proactive Approach to Achieving Compliance Through P2

Page 3: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page3 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

P2 Planning

- Assigned Duties and Responsibilities- Based on Management and Environmental Goals- Baseline Assessment of Waste Streams and

Compliance Sites- P2 Opportunity Assessment- Prioritized Plan for Project Implementation- Funding Scheme- Documentation of Performance- Periodic and Frequent Updates- Management and Command Support- Integration Strategy

Page 4: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page4 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

- Prioritize and Screen Efforts to Executethe P2 Program

- Means to Address Compliance Burdenthrough preventive measures

- Facilitates Reporting and Updating- Demonstrates Feasible Alternatives to

Pollution Generation

Page 5: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page5 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

Data Collection and Reporting

• Accurate and Complete Data isEssential to Good Information.

• Good Information is the KeyKnowledge and Wisdom.

• Knowledge and Wisdom are essentialto making good decisions andplanning.

Page 6: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page6 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

Communication

• Sharing Success Stories, LessonsLearned, and Good Ideas

• Websites.• Technology Transfer.• Working Groups.• Documenting Performance.• Reporting.

Page 7: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page7 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

–Disposal

Page 8: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page8 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

- Overall GOALS are based on publishedand otherwise applicable MoMs, agencydirectives, Federal/State regulations.

- Specific OBJECTIVES are based on locallygenerated compliance waste stream data

- Detailed background knowledge:- Installation- Operations- Processes

Page 9: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page9 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

- Compliance Medias- Input- Process & Throughput- Output

- Compliance Site Inventory- Location – Geographically- Process – Pollution Generation- Ownership – Responsible Unit/Activity

- Process/Program Specific Data- Material Inputs – Cost, Quantity- Production – Labor, Time, Cost- Waste – Cost, Quantity

Page 10: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page10 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

ProcessSteps

Throughput

(Medias: industrial and chemicalhygiene, EPCRA, HSMS, etc)

Material Inputs(Media: energy, water, fuel,

hazardous materials,affirmative procurement andenvironmentally preferable

purchases, consumeritems, etc.)

Waste andPollution Output(Medias: HW, CWA, CAA,

etc.)

RECYCLE

Reuse

Page 11: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page11 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

Based on experience, domain knowledge, commandinterest, and professional “hunches.” Requiresvaried and specific expertise:- Organization Personalities- Mission Operations – PM/CM Requirements

- weapon systems- ranges and training

- Installation Management Activities- supply and logistics- facilities, equipment, vehicle, weapons maintenance- medical activities- contracting and administration- energy production and distribution- waste management

- Environmental Media- Financial Analysis- Chemistry and Toxicity- Regulatory Implications- etc…

Page 12: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page12 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

Feasibility Analysis

• Description Targeted Process andDetailed Flow Diagram– Current Waste Generation– Current Operational Parameters– Current Material Consumption Rates

• Narrative Qualification of Alternative(s)• Quantitative Feasibility Analysis

– Technical Feasibility– Environmental Feasibility– Economic Feasibility

Page 13: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page13 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

• Planned• Funded and Resourced• Responsible POC• Data to Document Performance• Evidence of Effectiveness• Future Success Story

Page 14: Strategies and Considerations for Effective P2 Planning ... · Page 1 of 14 Robert G. Booze e:mail Robert.Booze@aec.apgea.army.mil Phone: 410-436-1229 Strategies and Considerations

Page14 of 14

Robert G. Booze e:mail [email protected] Phone: 410-436-1229

ProActive Approach to AchievingCompliance Through P2

P2 Prong - CSI - P/PSI - local goal

Compliance Prong - Regs - MoMs - Rules

Develop Tentative PlanID Suspected

“low-hanging fruit”“Reasons” for Pollution Generation

Feasibility AnalysisDefine “alternatives”

Compare “alternatives”

= ID “Initiatives” and “Efforts”

Present RecommendationsInitiatives vs Processes

Efforts vs Program

PlanningPrioritize

Funding / SchedulingAssign Responsibility

ExecuteMonitor

Document PerformanceReconcileCompareReview

Revise Goals

EMSCTP2

ComplianceManagement

EnvironmentalManagement