strategic leadership in the business school

Upload: lenovoji

Post on 03-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    1/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    B l f ,

    l

    l l . Al

    , l

    k l f l l

    . ll

    - l. I k, F F H

    l ll

    x l l. D

    ll x l l

    l,

    l f j l (IMD, LBS, INSEAD, IAE

    Wk) l x l

    xl ll .

    ernando ragueiro P Gl M

    D ENOVA k, l

    l k, IAE B Sl

    B A. H l D IAE B

    Sl (19952008) V-P Al U

    (19952007).

    howard thomas D LKCSB C S

    M L K C Sl B, S

    M U. Ul l D Wk

    B Sl (20002010), , , D

    Cll C B A

    U Ill UC (19912000).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    2/282

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    3/282

    Strategic Leadership

    in the Business SchoolK O S A

    ernando ragueiro

    howard Thomas

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    4/282

    cambridge university press

    C, N Yk, Ml, M, C ,

    S, S Pl, Dl, k, Mx C

    C U P

    E Bl, C CB2 8RU, UK

    Pl U S A C U P,

    N Yk

    ..

    I l: ../9780521116121

    F F H 2011

    l . Sj x l ll l ,

    k l

    C U P.

    F l 2011

    P U K U P, C

    A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library

    Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data

    F, F.

    S l l : k / F

    F, H .

    . .

    ISBN 978-0-521-11612-1 (k)

    1. B lU SM. 2. MU

    S. I. , H, 1943 II. l.

    HF1111.F724 2011

    650.071173222010051861

    ISBN 978-0-521-11612-1 Hk

    C U P l

    URL xl -

    l, ,

    ll , .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    5/282

    To Lynne and the Thomas family, who are Howards

    foundation and who light up Howards life.

    To Carlos Cavall of IESE, the dean of deans, who has been

    an indispensable mentor to Fernando and a long-standing

    friend to both of us.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    6/282

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    7/282

    vii

    Contents

    List o fgures page viii

    List o tables ix

    Preace xi

    Acknowledgements xiv

    Introduction Global fnancial crisis: uture challengesor strategic leadership, deans and business schools 1

    1 The business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 13

    2 Business schools as proessional organisations

    (proessional service frms) 55

    3 The leadership process in business schools 93

    4 Strategic leadership in practice: leading the

    strategic process in three top business schools 129

    5 Strategic leadership in practice: the role o the dean 173

    6 Learning rom the trenches: personal reections

    on deanship 209

    Reerences 249

    Index 261

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    8/282

    viii

    1.1 Dierentiation actors page 24

    2.1 Dynamic between key eatures in the context

    o proessionals, PSFs and clients 73

    2.2 The main leadership challenges or PSFs within

    the scope o the inner and outer contexts 92

    3.1 Alvessons scheme o leadership tasks 96

    3.2 Business schools core drivers 100

    3.3 SLPs extended contextual ramework 110

    3.4 SLPs core contextual ramework 113

    3.5 A political approach to organisations 118

    3.6 A political approach to SLPs 123

    3.7 Leadership process dynamics 124

    4.1 IMDs revenue growth, 19902004 145

    5.1 A contextual ramework or understanding SLPs

    at business schools 174

    5.2 A political approach to strategic leadership 185

    5.3 A comprehensive and dynamic approach to SLPs 187

    6.1 IAE Business School milestones, 19782008 212

    6.2 Infation rates in Argentina and Latin America,

    19952007 213

    6.3 GDP growth rates in Argentina and Latin

    America, 19952007 214

    6.4 Alignment o university and WBS visions or

    200815 244

    Figures

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    9/282

    x

    1.1 Bun ducn nd un ch c

    cnrucn prc page 22

    1.2 A PEST ny h un ch nvrnmn 27

    1.3 A pr mp Eurpn mngmn ducn 29

    1.4 Brd drnc wn Eurpn nd US un

    ch 34

    1.5 Financial Times rnkng M.B.A. prgrmm,

    19992005 40

    1.6 Rv prrmnc US nd EU un ch 42

    2.1 Cnfgurn rgnn rm nd rgy

    rmn prc 58

    2.2 KIF dfnd y nrn/xrn cu 61

    2.3 Ky ur PSF 63

    2.4 nkg wn ky prc nd ky

    chrcrc PSF 85

    2.5 Dynmc wn mn drhp k nd

    ky chrcrc PSF 90

    4.1 A hr ch n xcuv ducn rnkng,

    pn nrmn prgrmm 134

    4.2 A hr ch n wrdwd M.B.A. rnkng 134

    4.3 IMD vun, 19902004 136

    4.4 INSEAD vun, 19902004 149

    4.5 BS vun, 19902004 162

    5.1 Brkhrugh nd ncrmn rgc nv

    dvd IMD, INSEAD nd BS, 19902004 188

    5.2 Cmmn u gmn prn r

    rkhrugh nv hrd y hr ch 190

    Tables

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    10/282

    x List o tables

    5.3 Cmmn pwr mn prn r

    rkhrugh nv hrd y hr ch 194

    6.1 Ky pyr nd vn n h dvpmn WBS,

    200010 236

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    11/282

    x

    T bk

    : , k H T k v

    p Wk B Sl (WBS), A

    B Sl (ABS), A Av Cll

    Sl B (AACSB) Il, Glbl F

    M E (GFME) b l

    lp; , F F fv

    y lp p pf

    zl x pll ppv l-

    l Ep : IMD, INSEAD L B

    Sl (LBS), ll xp IAE B

    Sl, 1995 2008.

    T l bk, x b l -

    lp p p, xpl ll

    ( by Alx Wl, ll

    WBS).

    Ovll, l l l

    lp b l. D v b v-

    ly b jl, jk ll , b ,

    , v p . Tk ,

    p ll l, p -

    l l l b l vy pl

    p. D l

    CEO, p l. S l,

    G B ( LBS , l, WBS),

    , l y, , f, l,

    lp, f ply l

    pll p lp, bl p

    .. b INSEAD b by

    Preface

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    12/282

    Preacex

    Link: between these US/EU businessschools, there are similarorganisational features: theseposition business schools asprofessional service firms orknowledge-intensive firms.

    However, these PSF characteristicspresent a particularly complexchallenge to the leadership andstrategic management of businessschools.

    Link: leading business schools haveset about becoming international

    (global) leaders (Chapter 1); whatdoes the process of internationalisationlook like in three of the leadingEuropean schools as they attacktop ten places in the rankings?

    Link: given the unique and variednature of business schools and theirtop ten aspirations (Chapters 1 and 2)what is the role of the dean in the

    internationalisation of these threeleading schools?

    Link: provides further insights intostrategic leadership from the personalviewpoint of the authors experiencesas dean; WBS is a strong contrast toIAE as a publicly funded school.

    Link: given the current criticisms of

    business schools and their role, theintroduction identifies potentiallyevolutionary patterns for businessschools and leadership.

    The introduction, Global financial crisis: futurechallenges for strategic leadership, deans

    and business schools, examines the impact ofthe global financial crisis and the opportunity itprovides for deans and university leaders to create

    a new model for business schools and managementeducation.

    Chapter 1, The business school landscape:trends and dilemmas, examines the contrastbetween European and US business schools; eachis seen to be embedded in a different competitivecontext with different competitive advantages.

    Chapter 2, Business schools as professionalorganisations (professional service firms),

    identifies the features of business schools as

    PSFs. There are clear similarities but the model isincomplete as the business school is neither aprofessional partnership (e.g. law firm) nor aconsulting firm. Rather it is a hybrid form of theclass P2 and MPB form seen in studies of PSFs.

    Chapter 3, The leadership process in businessschools, examines the competitive dynamicsand future challenges in management education(Chapter 1), which, combined with theorganizational nuances of PSFs (Chapter 2),provides a unique challenge to business school

    deans. It argues for examining the strategicleadership process from a political processperspective using the authors SLP model.

    Chapter 4, Strategic leadership in practice:leading the strategic process in three top

    business schools, examines the strategicprocesses of internationalisation at three topbusiness schools: IMD (Lausanne), INSEAD(Fontainebleau) and LBS (London).

    Chapter 5, Strategic leadership in practice:the role of the dean, examines the specific casesof different deans at the three leading Europeanbusiness schools IMD, INSEAD and LBS.

    Chapter 6, Learning from the trenches: personalreflections on deanship, examines the deanshiproles of Fernando Fragueiros tenure as dean ofIAE (a private school in Argentina) and HowardThomas as dean at WBS (a leading publicly fundedschool in the United Kingdon).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    13/282

    Preace x

    l lpl (, , l, b

    v).

    W p vlp l-

    p p l lp p IAE, IMD, INSEAD, LBS WBS ll pv l

    l b l b b l -

    l, , ply, l .

    ernando ragueiro

    howard thomas

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    14/282

    xiv

    This book would not have come into being without the collaboration

    o a number o people. Among key contributors, Andrew Pettigrew

    played an unparalleled role in the shaping o the particular approach

    to leadership presented here that o leadership as a process in a spe-

    cifc organisational context, rom a political perspective. His aca-

    demic work on processual and contextual analysis in organisations

    has enlightened this research since its inception. The empirical

    research that has served as the basis or the core chapters o this

    work was made possible by the generosity and openness o nearly

    100 people: deans, ormer deans, aculty, sta members and busi-

    ness leaders at IMD, INSEAD and London Business School. Our

    special gratitude goes to Peter Lorange, Xavier Gilbert, Juan Rada

    and Jim Ellert at IMD; Gabriel Hawawini, Antonio Borges, Ludo

    Van der Heyden, Claude Rameau, Claude Janssen, Soumitra Dutta

    and Arnoud De Meyer at INSEAD; and George Bain, John Quelch,

    Laura Tyson, Michael Hay and Paul Marsh at LBS. We have also col-

    laborated with, and learnt greatly rom, a number o strategy el-

    lows and doctoral students, including Don Antunes and Xiaoying Li

    (St Andrews), Amanda Goodall (WBS), Julie Davies (ABS and WBS)

    and Alex Wilson (WBS).

    We would also like to thank our colleagues and researchers at

    IAE Business School and Warwick Business School or their support

    and understanding while we devoted the necessary time and eort

    to writing this book. Finally, our sincere appreciation goes to Claire

    New (Howards PA at WBS) and Alex Wilson (WBS), with whom it

    has been our pleasure to work on this endeavour.

    Acknowledgements

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    15/282

    1

    vy y wk w J Dv,

    Wwk P.D. ; Dv T (00).

    introductionGlobal fnancial crisis: uture

    challenges or strategic leadership,deans and business schools

    Globalisation and the global crisis

    T w y v w

    , y y . T f k

    y w w-

    w y f

    k -

    w , j w.

    P v y

    0 y . T , , w v wy w w

    v k.

    T v wy-f y -

    y v, y j ,

    y v wy, w

    w v

    f . Oy

    v v, w

    y w v

    w , w

    .

    E v -

    v f . Hwv,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    16/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School2

    , y w (00),

    , y

    - (T, 00). A y

    v , y. , y k

    -v v v

    , y , w y

    . Hwv, w v-

    w v y

    v

    y w v

    w k w y .

    A - , -

    , , v

    kw -

    w . v

    vy vy

    . j y wy

    v v

    xv.

    Hwv, f

    q , 00

    y y ky , f-

    v

    qy

    y -. , -

    v ky v-

    : .

    , -

    ,

    vy , -k (x, 00).

    qy, q-

    -x vy y v

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    17/282

    Introduction: global inancial crisis 3

    , y w v ,

    k y -

    w y. F x,

    - k kw . A w w

    w w v

    vy k / v. T

    w U/w E

    , v. T

    w w, y,

    w

    ( , z)

    f v -

    v.

    xy, , f

    q y - ,

    k .

    T x y v

    , -

    y q kw k

    w, x, .

    k k v

    y k w

    v

    y w.

    y, w w w ,

    w M A (M..A.) -

    z y w

    . W

    f v ,

    M..A. v vy f w

    . T x

    w y,

    v y w

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    18/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School4

    M..A. xv

    v v.

    W v

    M..A. ( k y, x, The Financial Times) 0

    k j f y

    jy xy ,

    v y w

    w kw j v

    v v . Ov , v

    x , y xv w

    w. A , M..A. xv

    q y -

    jy, v

    wy v ,

    w v w

    .

    A x vy y,

    w k. T v -

    , - -k w -

    ,

    q j -

    v, - v kw

    k.

    A Hv (H) M..A. -

    y, , Jy , J D (H M..A.

    ), xv (EO) JP M

    ,

    w,

    wk, y

    . y, EE M..A. -

    y y , Ny My,

    y T, : []v y y -

    wy k y y.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    19/282

    Introduction: global inancial crisis 5

    .

    y w -

    v-v x v v-

    . , y , y,

    , y y

    w v: - v , -;

    y; y

    - - v ; y-

    v k; v,

    ; w

    y w. F, v v-

    , f-

    y k w

    q w, wy, y y

    .

    , v

    v . R

    v wk w wk v

    y v w y, M..A. j

    y P N K Hv

    (K N,

    00; The Economist, 00). Ry Hv

    -y M..A. -

    v , w y

    v y w w ,

    v (The Economist,

    00: 0).

    , fy w

    y , -

    y vy. T q :

    w w kw,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    20/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School6

    wk w y

    w y.

    Changing models and contingencies

    T y ,

    k j vw v

    . P ,

    F R 0 w

    y ,

    .

    , w- -

    w v w. F x, y

    W, N D U ,

    fy y

    k k -

    (Ak, 00). A T (00) v

    E v -

    U , w wy

    ( P F, 00). F E, D D

    (00) N

    A M y v

    w y.

    U K, ky

    y k -

    , M..A.

    y y , v

    qy, v k, v (ky,

    00). H w w

    x w Ty w -

    v v

    fx f The Financial

    Times y [ v ].

    ( - M..A. ) vy

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    21/282

    Introduction: global inancial crisis 7

    y M..A. w j -

    . v w -

    v, , .

    ky (00) v v k -

    . A D My, J

    , UK-

    vw: W w v k f, w w

    w j

    w. W v w w

    y w w k

    y (w, 00).

    J Py, Y M,

    U :

    y w v;

    - w k;

    qv ;

    k ;

    .

    H w , A k

    , y w v M..A. wk -

    v y w f (Py, 00). y

    F, Mv M (00)

    j

    .

    -

    v y y. w v

    w w,

    x (

    vy),

    w w y x

    , vy, w -

    y. A Hy (00) , v

    y v y wk y

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    22/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School8

    v

    y, v wy y .

    Oy w y y .

    Leadership challenges or deans

    Hwv, w

    y w v y x v-

    v kw y

    y

    wy vy w

    y.

    y y

    v v , -

    y f y-

    . U x y

    , EO, y y

    x

    . T w

    x k, ,

    , . N, y f

    y , ky , v-

    , , y ,

    v v. T vw k

    x

    w x

    (, , y , -

    , .). W w- k ,

    k y, y y

    v w x w

    .

    T ( f

    ) . F x, R,

    J Hk (00: ) v

    : D v

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    23/282

    Introduction: global inancial crisis 9

    vy v v w

    , x y,

    w v wk

    ( Tk y, : x). (00: ) xvy

    U A, J-k

    y: Ty vy

    y y v -

    y [T]y wv w zzy, z-

    , w-. F (: ) x

    .

    T w y--

    w (

    z, 00).

    M y, ky T (00: ) y

    xy v

    : Fy y w

    w k y y

    . Nwy

    w , w q k D y

    k , v , f

    w, w y wy w [T]

    f w y k k

    . y (00) -

    y : T w w

    j w k w

    y. w y, , -

    y x w , -

    , , k j y jy w

    y y . y w, wv,

    vy . O ,

    y f- . , (00) f

    y w, k-

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    24/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School1

    w w k

    .

    y, Dv T

    (00) k w q W ?. y x j w

    vy x w.

    Ty v v , -

    ,

    v f (PF) kw-v

    f (KF), , ,

    . , y y

    v , , , vy,

    y, , , k

    , v k -

    . Ty k y y v

    w y , k v

    y.

    Hwv, x y

    y, v -

    v k w

    w

    . T , k (Financial Times,

    vy, R A Ex (RAE), .)

    y v wy v

    v w

    (DM Pw, : ) w k -

    z w y k -

    , w w y v (K,

    ). Dvy, Dw P-Ajyw (00)

    w Financial Times k f -

    w , w, , y y-

    k,

    y K (00) v yy k.

    F x, y v (w

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    25/282

    Introduction: global inancial crisis 11

    w w) v M..A.

    w v MAT ( M A

    T) x 00 q-

    y k vy. Hwv, v v x,

    jv v

    .

    F, . T

    y y FTE (F T k

    Ex) 00 EO, q -

    y kw-

    v x. T y , -

    v

    (k, 00). T vy y y

    v x -

    w x -

    k

    v y (Mz, ).

    y f

    Dv T (00) y

    xv, -, k -

    , k y -

    . Hwv, w v w

    (00: 0) v (v v -

    ) y q v ( x -

    y w)

    w v . W v

    -qy k. F x, w wk

    w xv y

    vw j y

    y

    - R (z, R, , ) . T x-

    v ky vy x

    EO ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    26/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School12

    y k,

    q ( x)

    v ( x x). T xy -

    x x , ,

    x

    v. , w y

    v x

    y y

    .. .

    T, v, v k,

    -

    , y w

    y w-. T

    w v k w -

    y v

    vy,

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    27/282

    13

    ,

    f A (00) (00).

    1 The business school landscape:trends and dilemmas

    1.1 Introduction

    N j

    . A,

    q , f q (,

    ; H A, 0). x, O

    (00) f

    .

    - j

    , , -

    .

    x

    (G, 00; Z, 00).

    -

    q

    .

    j

    - (P ,

    00). H, , ,

    ,

    , f

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    28/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School14

    x , E U

    P E.

    (, x, H, 00; et al., 00; , 00;Mz, 00; Mz G, 00; P ,

    00; , H , 00).

    . P

    E , E

    A A (NEAD), M-

    D (MD) ()

    x

    (P) , .

    W f

    x .

    x . E

    . , , x

    E

    U ,

    (P , 00).

    E U -

    . -

    . ,

    ,

    , j

    x .

    W .

    1.2 Critical background and historyA , -

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    29/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 15

    P

    .

    . x

    E U , ()

    K j ().

    E

    U ,

    U

    x ,

    x E, A A.

    -

    , , ,

    , ,

    -x -

    - x . H, q

    :

    f -

    ?

    E, U

    . ,

    E. ,

    P- E

    P ,

    q ,

    -

    .

    A, . ,

    V . -

    A (V, ), G (.. A, , , 0,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    30/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School16

    --M, 0, M, 0) z

    ( G, ) ( E Z, ).

    H,

    , E - , .

    U K, x,

    (0) M (0). A (00)

    , E U

    M x , -

    f

    .

    -W-W-

    M, ,

    U K .

    0,

    R,

    R U , -

    ( , ; N

    A , G H, , P,

    ).

    - ,

    M (M)

    , - M..A.

    - - U- M..A. . q,

    , J ( U),

    (), f, H, U M

    (UM), (Ox) W (W),

    x

    ,

    D E [DE] (00) et al. (00).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    31/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 17

    M..A. ,

    -, - .

    U ,

    x E . U

    j

    E , -

    , (00) , G

    H ( 0). -

    (, ).

    U

    , -

    .

    W ( E J x

    G), , H ( E G

    0 G

    ), D

    (G, ). - -

    q. W

    , D f M

    00 H M

    A (M..A. ) 0. A

    ,

    E . A

    U A A

    (AA) f

    q

    .

    U

    0

    , ()

    . , -

    , ( -

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    32/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School18

    ),

    .

    -

    (

    O, 00).

    - -

    f ,

    . , 0

    0 $0

    f ,

    -M, , , H .

    f ,

    -, f

    x

    -

    .

    D

    ,

    ,

    - ,

    R. ,

    : ;

    j ; -;

    ; q; , -

    ,

    , -

    . O

    ,

    -, -

    ( )

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    33/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 19

    ( ).

    ,

    x,

    ( ) - . ,

    , -

    -

    (G, 00; G

    Mz, 00; H, 00; et al., 00; , 00;

    Mz, 00; Mz G, 00;P ,

    00, 00).

    O ,

    q,

    . q

    (00; ), N Y

    U (NYU) , -

    q .

    orward looking backward looking.

    acts

    think. -

    . G (00), ,

    ,

    U ,

    x . A

    , ,

    -

    q,

    E .

    , E q

    , M..A.

    z, (00).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    34/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School2

    , E U-

    q -

    (x -

    A, , - A, 00,K j, , R H, ).

    E

    : f ,

    .. U

    x

    ( E, 000)?

    , -

    . W

    E

    E U

    .

    1.3 Business schools and business education

    as a social construction process

    W

    x

    ( , ; P

    , 00; W, ). W ,

    ,

    , -

    (P , 00). O ,

    -

    , -

    (W, ; W, , )

    .

    K

    . O

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    35/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 21

    ,

    , -

    (DM P, ).

    x , -

    . A f ,

    -

    . A ,

    , W

    W . A

    , (, ),

    , , -

    . -

    -

    ,

    .

    . x

    .

    . , ,

    x ,

    q

    .

    frst level

    ,

    x, q

    -

    .

    , f

    , f

    W (UK ). E

    ( G H) -

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    36/282

    . Business education and business schools as a social

    construction process

    M

    :

    .

    N

    .

    D

    ,

    .

    D

    -

    .

    ();

    E ();

    H

    J

    ();

    P,

    -

    ().

    :

    .

    E

    0.

    U .

    / .

    .

    .

    A

    W, ();

    E

    (000);,

    H

    ();

    DM

    P ().

    :

    U

    .

    .

    0

    .

    /

    .

    f

    ,

    .

    R

    .

    .

    O

    .

    .

    j

    P

    ();

    G (00);

    P et al.

    ();

    ();

    W ().

    Source: Mf A (00).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    37/282

    q

    D

    :

    G H-

    (00),

    (0 ),

    UK (00),

    U (0 ).

    .

    D

    .

    , ,

    .

    z .

    /

    :

    ;

    U K M

    ;

    , H,

    , ;

    U W, H, .

    f

    x

    :;

    ;

    ;

    ;

    ;

    .

    D U- M..A.

    ,

    E

    .

    N .

    R,

    f

    .

    R

    .

    .

    : U, E,

    . ( 0).

    .

    .

    R

    .

    U

    E.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    38/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School24

    Brandloyalty

    Reputation status

    GovernanceFunding and endowment

    International mindsetInnovation

    Knowledge transmissionCorporate linkages

    Language, culture, regulationStandardisation

    Size

    Figure 1.1 D

    ,

    z .

    ,

    second level ,

    .

    U- ,

    M..A., ,

    , (, ),

    - . D

    , , f

    ,

    q x

    , U-

    (E, 000). , -

    ,

    ,

    . A q,

    , , , , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    39/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 25

    U ( W H)

    .

    A 0 ,

    third level , -

    , -

    . H, , , M

    (M), . U ,

    EE , , .

    E. -

    .. The Financial Times

    (), The Economist, .

    AA ( A A )

    , EQU (E Q ), .

    . , -

    .

    , f-

    , - - -

    , -

    . E , ,

    x E

    U .

    , f

    . W ,

    x ,

    E- U- .

    1.4 The management education environment

    x x - -

    . , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    40/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School26

    .

    O x

    x -

    PE (, , ) (MG, W, 00). A PE

    ..

    A PE

    .

    (, x, - - UK ; Economist, 00). x

    f ,

    . q

    - ,

    f

    . , ,

    ( U K) Q A A (QAA), q, H E

    E (HEE) f- R A

    Ex, q, q

    -q

    -

    .

    G

    , . -q

    E A (, x, M..A.

    The Financial Times

    ), , ,

    q

    ,

    .

    q x

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    41/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 27

    . A PEST analysis o the business school environment

    Political

    E (

    A: ,

    ).

    R

    (EMD, AMA,

    AA).

    R

    q (QAA, RAE)

    / .

    R

    .

    Economic

    (

    : EU, NAA, WO).

    R

    .

    (-

    E, A

    A; A).

    M UK

    .

    G f

    f

    .

    Social

    :

    (.. E);

    (.. N

    A);

    (..

    , ).

    D :

    , , , .

    Technological

    G -

    . .

    .

    K

    .

    W-

    .

    Notes: EMD = E M D, AMA =

    A M..A., NAA = N A A,

    WO = W Oz.

    Sources: G M A (GMA) (00). H (00).

    (00). P (00). V The Financial Times, The Times, The Times Higher

    Education Supplement The Economist. (00).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    42/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School28

    -- -

    - .

    , -

    x,

    .

    ,

    .

    A (00) , [A]

    .

    -

    M..A. ,

    , M..A. (Mz, 00), -

    f j- . Ex

    - M..A.

    , , x,

    --j- .

    ,

    :

    ;

    ;

    ,

    ;

    , - ;

    .. , ;

    ; .

    1.5 The uropean landscape in

    management education

    . -

    E, .

    W E - .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    43/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 29

    . A partial map o European management education

    R

    A W W (V) V G M (, G)

    z R M P (P)

    D

    H E

    NEAD (); HE EE, EP/EAP, EM

    , PO (P); G E M;

    A (N); EM (x); EEM (); E

    G WHU (Kz); EM (); M

    ; M ; GMA (H);

    H z; ;

    G ()

    H U ()

    DA (M)

    f/Q , U D

    N N (, U), R

    M, E U; N

    U ()

    N N M (O)

    P U W P M ;

    K A E M

    (W)

    R M U

    ED/ M ()

    EE , U N (,

    M); EADE, R U ();

    E (M); EADA (M)

    E

    z MD (); H G ( G)

    U K (); W (W); (Ox); J

    (); M (M); UM ();

    (); (); E; ;

    H; f; A

    Sources: The Financial Times ( ); The Economist (W M..A.?);

    EMD; AA; AMA; A (00: ).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    44/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School3

    , x, NEAD,

    , E ,

    j U , HE, EE, EM

    EP/EAP - , .. , , - .

    EM (x), EEM (), G E M,

    A (N) E , , x-

    -f E (,

    - ), -

    -

    ,

    f f .

    G, -

    , G

    . G

    , f- f -

    - D-K -

    . W A ,

    E (

    x M

    ), M..A. G

    Kz ( ), M ( -

    - ) EM ( E M

    ).

    , E ,

    . EE, O D

    ( W H)

    EADE, J, -

    , E M -,

    , .

    U K, A

    (A) (00), 00 M..A. -

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    45/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 31

    (), NEAD , U-

    , j

    U . , H f

    M..A. x , - , (), J (), UM

    (), (Ox) W (W),

    , -x .

    E

    ,

    O, H ,

    xf j ScandinavianJournal o Management Scandinavian Journal o Economics.

    z, , -

    , MD, , G.

    , E -

    f , U W

    P M U W

    K A E M

    P U ,

    G , H

    .

    . ,

    q E -

    . x, U K,

    . , x,

    Ox U ,

    , H, , W N,

    E, . - , A H,

    M..A., D..A. (-

    ) x ,

    . , W,

    ,

    -- . O

    U, H W

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    46/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School32

    M..A., , -

    M..A.,

    .

    ( ) ,

    f - .

    () , f

    , x .

    , ,

    UK

    x U . A , UK , q-U-

    , , -/-

    -

    f , x .

    f E ,

    , NEAD U ,

    ,

    , -

    P D . O

    x, E

    , -

    , ,

    .

    E ,

    -

    E

    , ,

    , U .

    1.6 ierences between uropean and

    S business schools

    .

    U E . f ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    47/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 33

    ,institutional dierences, f

    , -

    x; competitive dierences, , -

    U ,

    U E

    ; , f, social capital

    dierences, -

    ,

    . H x U

    E . .

    ,

    , ,

    (x

    A, , - A, 00, K j,

    , R H, ). - A

    (00) , , []

    , f x

    q .

    Institutional dierences

    , ,

    E U

    ,

    . A , E (

    .) -

    , E .

    E , , -

    languages, cultures regulations

    x E.

    E

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    48/282

    . Broad dierences between European and US business schools

    Europe United States

    Institutional

    differences

    /

    /

    M .

    (E U).

    M.

    H .

    .

    M .

    .

    .

    .

    z z

    (c.0 )

    M z (c.00 )

    Competitive

    differences

    G/

    P .

    .

    P .

    W .

    .

    W .

    .

    .

    .

    /

    .

    , .

    / .

    P, - ., .

    R :

    - M..A.;

    ;

    - .

    - M..A.D- -.

    K

    /

    K

    - j.

    G x

    .

    .

    K -

    - j.

    x .

    Social capital

    differences

    R

    .

    ,

    .

    H .

    , ,

    q.

    R

    , ,

    .

    M

    .

    H .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    49/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School36

    A ( ) E

    .

    f .

    (AA U EQU E), q-

    ,

    E (EQU)

    N A (AA). EQU,

    , x x

    f q

    x . O , AA

    q ,

    , , -

    . A q, EQU E -

    ,

    ,

    U- - -

    .

    A , U , ,

    , -

    standardisation . U ,

    ,

    AA f

    ,

    .

    , , ..

    ... , AA

    AA , A A

    , . ... A AA

    (00).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    50/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 37

    (H, -A W, 00).

    x

    M..A. , q

    , -

    .

    H, E

    ,

    -

    . AA U -

    , ,

    E M D

    E Q .

    E

    . -

    A M..A.

    U K f

    UK M..A.- ,

    . , U-

    , E

    ; ,

    , ,

    q E . -

    , E

    , U -

    .

    size f

    U E (A, 00). z,

    , f

    . z

    f f x EQU f

    E E,

    A, z, , H K, Mx, A U

    . O EMD ...

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    51/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School38

    x

    .. f,

    -q

    , ( P, 0, z ). x,

    q

    M..A. , A .. H,

    K (N) W 00 M..A.

    , -

    , E

    . H,

    , , -q

    . , , MD

    z,

    - - M..A. . , U -

    z -z

    ( , x O ),

    E -z,

    , x

    .

    1.7 Competitive dierences

    -

    .

    governance E

    U- . W f

    f

    .

    x

    -

    . ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    52/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 39

    U

    ( f ), -

    , E -

    ( ). ,

    , . , -

    ( U

    E U)

    Financial Times M..A. ,

    . , -

    U

    E .

    unding endowment -

    j .

    U

    U

    - , , ,

    f , .

    , , H ,

    ,

    $ (W, 00).

    U , E

    .

    q ,

    M..A. , -

    (x, 000). E, -

    , M..A.

    . ,

    E

    x

    f

    . x

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    53/282

    . rankings o M.B.A. programmes, 19992005

    G 000 00 00 0

    H (U) P P/W (U) P

    (U) P

    G (U) P

    G (U) P

    NEAD (EU) P

    (EU) P/

    M/ (U) P 0

    N/K (U) P 0

    NYU/ (U) P 0

    D/A (U) P

    MD (EU) P

    Y (U) P 0 0

    D q (U) P

    Notes:

    x : U (H) V (D) [ ];

    f : UA (A) [ ]; : U M [ ];

    : U W O () U N

    : E (J) [ ].

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    54/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 41

    f ,

    M..A.

    . f , -

    , , .

    D f E,

    E

    international mindset (, 00).

    E , ,

    . E

    x ,

    ,

    , , -

    . -

    Financial Times

    E M..A.

    q U

    ( .). A q,

    -

    x -

    .

    Flexibilityinnovation

    E . x , ,

    U . x, H M ,

    O U W U K

    M..A. E x

    - M..A. ( , J, W,

    x) , -

    - - U M..A. . E

    (f -

    ) (z, K,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    55/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School42

    . Relative perormance o US and EU business schools

    D U

    D EU

    EU

    U

    - 0

    V 0

    A

    P

    E

    A

    W

    W

    0

    0

    Notes: A f x .

    ( The Financial Times), 00

    M..A. .

    .. EU ,

    U 00. x, A ,

    U ,

    EU

    . , EU

    U . , , EU

    U .

    V , , W .

    Source: A (00).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    56/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 43

    ). -, j- ,

    f j -

    , ..

    , .

    E transmit knowledge ,

    - j -

    j f, ,

    - . x, j

    M..A. , - U-

    - . E j-

    ; ,

    E, , ,

    f j Scandinavian Journal o Economics

    and Management. M, E G O

    (EGO) ,000 ,

    j Organisation Studies

    f

    E-.

    E x -

    corporate linkages ,

    . W -

    E, E

    -

    . A

    q, E

    ( ) -

    x

    , .

    1.8 Social capital dierences: reputation

    eects and brand loyalty

    , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    57/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School44

    -

    . R

    ,

    , , -

    ( , P, ;

    ,

    R, , MG, W, 00). M,

    , -

    . , DA ()

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    q qf-

    -q

    .

    - ,

    , q -

    . -

    A (00) -

    f.

    W

    -x

    - -

    M..A. The Financial Times. .,

    ,

    - ,

    . O ,

    E (NEAD, MD

    U- ), U

    . .

    ,

    00 .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    58/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 45

    f -

    Business Week. G (00)

    -

    , , f .

    , -

    . ,

    f f

    x.

    O,

    x

    . W -

    E . E

    U

    -

    . A

    , . E

    , -

    ,

    . , , -

    .

    M, -

    q -

    .

    , - -

    . -

    , U z

    f .

    ( .)

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    59/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School46

    , , U- ( -)

    . - , ,

    f -

    -q, - . E

    U .

    E

    U , -

    A (-, Rzz z, 000).

    H, E U-

    . R, R

    (00) , [E]

    , -

    . ,

    ,

    [] -

    ,

    . , E U

    , x

    , x, ,

    (Z,

    00).

    1.9 Summary

    U (

    . .)

    f ..

    (.. M..A.), ,

    - (.. H,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    60/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 47

    W) , , f f

    . , q

    U , -

    U ,

    ( . .).

    A U , U

    .

    E , ,

    ,

    .

    -

    E

    U .

    U K ( M-

    D) ,

    - , /

    U .

    U-, E, P.D. j

    f ,

    , U x. H, q q -

    E

    . A q,

    0

    0 ( . .), -

    , -

    ( . . .).

    f U

    , E q

    , , -

    , q

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    61/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School48

    1.1 merging issues and challenges:

    rethinking the business school

    , H (00) (00)

    f

    x .

    x q .

    - -

    business-as-usual .. x

    U ; takeover -

    / , ; more academic models,

    ..

    ( et al., 00).

    A

    (P,

    ). O , - , , ,

    . q

    :

    f (, 00)?

    M (00)

    , f , . H,

    (G, 00),

    -, ,

    x

    .

    ,

    K (00) K N (00),

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    62/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 49

    , , -

    . A

    f-

    , K .

    P (00) ,

    . ,

    , -

    ,

    M..A., f

    x .

    , x -

    , H (00; )

    , , academic value,

    ;personal value, -

    ; public and social value,

    . ,

    -

    (.. E- -

    ) , ,

    .

    1.11 compelling contet or business

    schools and their leadership

    f. -

    , -

    , -

    . -

    ,

    , -

    ,

    f

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    63/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School5

    .

    ,

    . A x - A ,

    ,

    E , , A

    A j U

    . H,

    -

    x

    .

    , , .

    .

    , j -

    ;

    ;

    .

    . H,

    . A

    -

    ,

    x

    . A ,

    q , -

    , .

    ,

    -

    .

    f

    : x A ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    64/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 51

    x . N M..A. x

    .

    ,

    j ,

    .

    W

    . A ,

    . M

    ,

    . ,

    x - . q

    . ,

    q-

    . ,

    f , -

    -

    q, x

    -

    ,

    , , .

    W z

    ,

    -

    .

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    65/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School52

    . M ,

    From Higher Aims to Hired Hands, K (00) -

    - f

    .

    A M..A.

    , f -

    x

    , q

    -

    M..A. x . A

    f U

    j M..A.

    , , -

    .

    The Financial Times, The Wall Street

    Journal, Forbes BusinessWeek ,

    . R

    q

    , M..A. -

    .

    - , -q

    -

    x .

    , . H, K, -

    ,

    ,

    ..///00/000_..

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    66/282

    Business school landscape: trends and dilemmas 53

    x .

    A

    , , .

    ,

    f ,

    -

    . x, -

    , -

    ,

    .

    . , -

    f .

    O (00)

    . MA

    , ,

    -

    j. ,

    x ,

    x, qf

    , . Mz

    (00) ,

    MA.

    New Vision or Management Education, P

    (00), MD, ,

    , :

    M..A. P.D.

    , ,

    . ,

    . , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    67/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School54

    : -

    .

    R M..A.

    , -

    , , x . ,

    j -

    ,

    -

    : knowing, doing being. ,

    .

    , -

    -

    f . .

    , .

    .

    , f

    .

    .

    .

    .

    Df , .

    .

    R .

    R .

    .

    U .

    .

    .

    -.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    68/282

    55

    2 Business schools asproessional organisations

    (proessional service frms)

    2.1 Introduction

    x

    (D ,00). , (00: )

    .

    N ,

    q . A C ,

    x

    q - ,

    x

    .

    , ,

    (Z, 00)

    (G, 00),

    . ,

    / -

    x

    - (, ; G, 00: ).

    f (D , 00). ,

    x, -

    / ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    69/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School56

    q -

    ..

    / (N G, ).

    x f jf x -

    f - f.

    f

    (Mz, 00) x

    f -

    K.

    2.2 The business school as a proessional

    school

    Mz -

    x -

    .

    , Mz ( )

    , ,

    . f ().

    Adhocracy organisations: x-

    ,

    x j -

    , .

    Proessional organisations: x

    ,

    , j

    , .

    Mz ()

    MG U, ,

    x MG.

    x , -

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    70/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 57

    Mz MG U -

    , -

    , -

    .

    .

    , j

    ,

    .. A M,

    . M,

    ..

    ,

    .

    . f

    -

    (

    ).

    H,

    , , x,

    j x

    . ,

    j , -

    . N,

    .

    Mz -

    x

    ,

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    71/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School58

    (00) x f

    ,

    x , ()

    x : -

    ; ; -

    ( -

    ); f

    (). H

    . Confgurations o organisational orm and strategy

    ormation process

    Adhocracy

    organisation

    Proessional

    organisation

    Conditions ,

    ,

    ,

    Power vested in j E

    Integration D

    Favoured strategy

    process

    C

    ( )

    Strategies E

    (

    )

    Pattern o change C

    q

    Environment,leadership,

    organisation

    E

    Key strategic

    issue

    C ?

    q

    Source: A Mz (: ).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    72/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 59

    -

    , . , -

    (M, ),

    f Mz (: ) - x

    q

    . R

    (, ) -

    . H

    , x,

    -

    .

    G , , x -

    f

    - f. W f f K

    () .

    -

    x -

    f.

    , ,

    .

    2.3 hat is a proessional service irm

    x -

    K

    (, 000; M, ). O

    . x,

    , , ,

    x

    . O -

    , ,

    f.

    , , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    73/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School6

    .. -

    . M, ,

    x .

    (000) -

    , f

    . A ,

    -

    (). ,

    (00) f x f , -

    f x .

    H

    x, , ,

    [] - -

    x.

    f q

    , , ,

    ( ) (0).

    O , A (00), ()

    (000) f K

    -q .

    A (00) f K -, qf

    j .

    () K

    qf .

    (000) K ..

    , -

    . .

    /x

    K. A , ,

    -/ .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    74/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 61

    Mz () K

    . H

    K: , , f, f

    f, . ,

    , :

    ; j -

    x; -

    ; ;

    .M E () (

    f f, ) K

    , -

    j f

    . W

    K , , - .

    . KIFs defned by internal/external ocus

    Ex

    C

    /

    /

    O

    , -

    -

    C

    z

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    75/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School62

    2.4 The key eatures and characteristics

    o PSFs

    . f

    . -

    .

    Individual proessionals

    A (000: ) , -

    - , x

    j. ,

    f

    . , ,

    .

    j

    f q : () -

    ; () x; ()

    .

    f , autonomy,

    (, ).

    q f -

    , - , (H, ;

    , ).

    proessional expertise -

    . , H, G ()

    x .

    q x, -

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    76/282

    . Key eatures o PSFs

    K

    (000) X X X

    () X X

    () X X

    M () X X

    H () X

    () X

    K, V G

    ()

    X

    H,

    G ()

    X

    R () X

    G (0) X

    H A () X

    E (000) X X X

    (000) X

    (000) X X

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    77/282

    . (cont.)

    K

    M () X X

    A () X

    et al. () X

    Mz () X X

    G, H

    (0)

    X

    M et al. () X XG, H

    ()

    X

    W () X

    () X

    N () X

    M E ()

    ()

    (000)

    ()

    H N ()

    H M ()

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    78/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 65

    , stronger link to their proes-

    sional standards and values than to the PSF that employs them.

    -

    , ( , ). -

    , -

    . (000: ),

    f x,

    x,

    , ,

    ,

    , .

    , x

    f .

    , -

    .

    Proessional competences

    ,

    proessional knowledge, skills attitudes

    q

    j .

    Proessional knowledge j q -

    . K q

    : -

    j, f -

    - x. q,

    j

    . E (000) -

    x,

    . H, j

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    79/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School66

    . ,

    ,

    :

    (Z,). M E ()

    q

    x , j

    . -

    ,

    .

    O ,

    j . -

    ,

    -

    . , ( 000: ) ,

    -

    ()

    f,

    .

    f j .

    f -

    ,

    f j

    .

    , ,

    x

    . A , q -

    .

    j, ,

    . ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    80/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 67

    . ,

    ,

    - , -

    x. .

    Mz (: 0) : , j

    .

    x ,

    . A ,

    x

    . , , -

    ,

    . -

    j ,

    -

    .

    , -

    , (,

    ). - -

    ,

    -q

    .

    Shared power

    A

    , x -

    .

    q

    , , , -

    x ( , ; M, ).

    A f -

    , , ,

    (G, H , 0: ). ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    81/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School68

    ,

    . , :

    x ,

    - j .

    A f

    j

    ( , ). H,

    x -

    . , f x -

    (

    , ). ,

    . -

    , q

    ,

    . x - -

    ,

    q

    .

    Mz () q f

    .

    .

    x ,

    .

    ,

    .

    , / f-

    . -

    f

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    82/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 69

    Intangibility

    , -

    , -

    .

    W ( )

    .

    ,

    , , q (),

    : f,

    -

    ; , .

    (000: ) q

    x

    , f

    . ()

    , -

    . ,

    q -

    .

    Standardisation/customisation

    x , -

    ( ),

    (, , ), -

    ( )

    . O

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    83/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School7

    (000) f

    , x -

    j .

    , , ,

    , -

    ().

    f ,

    q. M E () -

    -

    ,

    ,

    . f-

    j

    . H,

    q ,

    ,

    j

    j,

    .

    M, M E ()

    j . O -

    f Mz () -

    . Mz - q

    , -

    x.

    ,

    .

    N, M E

    ,

    , f -

    . ,

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    84/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 71

    ,

    q , -

    , .

    Trust

    -

    ,

    x,

    . M,

    ( , 000: ).

    : [W] f

    . -

    .

    ,

    . ,

    , , -

    . , -

    q . M,

    q x

    ,

    . ,

    j

    . ,

    j , x

    . , f q f-

    ;

    ,

    f.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    85/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School72

    (000: )

    -

    . ,

    .A, x -

    .

    2.5 Linkages between key eatures and

    characteristics o PSFs, proessionals

    and clients

    f x -

    : , ,

    , , / (

    f x

    ). ., -

    , .

    , ,

    ,

    .

    , , ,

    , -

    ,

    j x.

    qf ,

    ,

    .

    .

    , -

    j .

    q ,

    , , , .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    86/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 73

    -

    Mz , -

    --j

    (Mz, ).

    , -

    , x x.

    H, -

    , f q

    , -

    f. H

    . , ,

    ,

    q

    .

    A , /

    , -

    . H, -

    j

    P

    r

    o

    f

    es

    s

    i

    o

    n

    a

    l

    s

    C

    li

    e

    n

    t

    s

    PSFs

    IntangibilityProfessional Standardisation

    Shared

    Trust

    (solutions)

    Figure 2.1 D x

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    87/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School74

    x,

    j.

    , , -

    x .

    H, ,

    x

    , , q

    x f

    .

    .

    ,

    , ,

    -

    -

    f ( , 000;

    , ).

    , , j -

    , , ,

    ( ) ,

    j x-

    , f, . ,

    --

    . -

    -- .

    W ,

    . q

    ,

    , -

    , -

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    88/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 75

    . , ,

    x , ,

    , x-

    .W x

    -

    . H, x

    -, -

    f x f.

    , j x

    . , x -

    x . -

    , x

    x C .

    2.6 ey processes in proessional service irms

    x

    q , f

    .

    , x x : () ;

    () -; () ; () ; ()

    ; () , ,

    .

    Governance

    A ,

    q

    . , : -

    , . ,

    , ,

    . , ,

    - -. ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    89/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School76

    x

    : x ,

    x ;

    . H, - x .

    H,

    ,

    /

    .

    / ,

    G, H (0) x

    .

    , - -

    - f , operational

    control ,

    f decentralised. H, stra-

    tegic control, x , -

    , f , ,

    centralised.

    Mz ()

    , -

    , j

    . H, x

    , .

    Strategy setting

    x,

    .

    M, x

    . ,

    -

    ,

    .

    H,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    90/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 77

    . ,

    , .

    .

    x, W V 0 , , -

    , (.. ),

    , -, . ,

    -

    -

    (C, ; D , 00; , ).

    x, ,

    .

    (: ) : -

    f, , ,

    . G

    , q

    , , , ,

    .

    ,

    f, q -

    .

    Mz , , -

    ,

    , -

    . W

    , f

    .

    , q

    - x, -

    .

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    91/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School78

    . -

    , H, G

    (), D, Cz (),

    j , - , , x, -

    .

    ,

    : , -

    , , x,

    -

    .

    Staing

    () M ()

    , j

    ,

    . M E ()

    f,

    . W

    , -

    x

    . C -

    ,

    : -

    . , ,

    -

    (AAC, 00: ; , 00). H

    , -

    ,

    ( ) x .

    , ;

    j

    , f

    . V . ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    92/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 79

    j. ,

    ,

    . , , - , ,

    . ,

    -

    f.

    ,

    -

    , -

    j f. C, -

    , ,

    f, .D. -

    (H, 00; et al., 00).

    , -

    -q x,

    x- -

    .

    Service delivery

    M ()

    : -

    --

    .

    () M

    : qf ;

    ; j q . A

    , (000: ), -

    :

    q ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    93/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School8

    x x - .

    , -

    :

    . f

    . C -

    , ,

    . q -

    . ,

    j

    .

    R , q -

    x x. ,

    / -

    f / x ,

    x

    . O

    x q

    .

    C -

    . C f

    , -

    . (000: )

    - ,

    q. j

    f

    -

    f.

    Mz ()

    x

    . A , -

    ,

    , ,

    x. x, ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    94/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 81

    -

    . M,

    - (Mz , ).Cq, x, q

    x x -

    , -

    q .

    Innovation, and learning and knowledge management

    N ()

    - -

    f . H, M ()

    - ,

    j

    j

    . M

    , , x f

    . , x

    j

    , -

    , -

    (M, : ).

    . , ,

    , , -

    -

    . H, f ,

    q

    ,

    , .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    95/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School82

    -

    . H,

    j x .

    Cq,

    .

    Relations, networking, and trust building

    N , -

    produce, deliver improve .

    -

    . M, x

    , .

    .

    , , -

    . Ex, j

    . ,

    f

    ,

    : ,

    .

    2.7 rganising and managing proessional

    service irms: linkage between

    key eatures and key processes

    W j f x -

    : ;

    ; ; ; ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    96/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 83

    ; , -

    . , , x ,

    ? x f

    .

    -

    (C

    et al., ; M, ; , ). , C

    et al. , ,

    ,

    f .

    C et al. f

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    , , , -

    . H, strategic control

    , - -

    , , -

    f. H,

    f.

    jx :

    , , ; , , -

    , - -.

    .

    (M) . A -

    ,

    -

    f. M

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    97/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School84

    , ,

    -

    .

    f, .

    , j ( -

    ) (

    , j, ). H,

    M , -

    , , ,

    . ,

    f q

    .

    W x, . x, -

    -

    f ( .).

    A , governance -

    ,

    .

    f j

    j / -

    . -

    x,

    - M . M ,

    , , ,

    . M

    f

    ,

    - .

    -

    f x.

    f

    f. E

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    98/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 85

    . Linkage between key processes and key characteristics

    o PSFs

    K

    K

    D

    G

    /

    (/x)

    /

    (/x)

    ()

    /

    (x)

    /

    (x)

    ()

    ,

    /

    (/x)

    R,

    (/x)

    /

    z

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    99/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School86

    (000: )

    .

    q f .

    ,

    -

    ,

    x.

    Strategy setting ,

    , -

    .

    f

    . Mz () ,

    ,

    - -, -

    -

    ,

    ,

    . , C et al. (),

    -

    .

    , -

    , ,

    .

    service delivery

    ,

    q.

    innovation,learningknowledge management

    x , , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    100/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 87

    , -

    .

    K ,

    , -

    . -

    q ,

    x.

    networking trust building -

    ,

    . , -

    ( ,

    000). R , -

    . x ,

    -

    ,

    , .

    , M , -

    ,

    , -

    j f

    , .

    , x -

    .

    . , -

    , , , ,

    , -

    . W

    M -

    ,

    ,

    . ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    101/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School88

    M -

    x .

    x

    .

    2.8 Leading and managing proessional

    service irms

    ,

    - f. U -

    K, f

    - ,

    x , -

    -

    x (, 000). H,

    K

    . M

    .

    H ()

    , ,

    -

    .

    .

    ,

    ,

    , .

    , ,

    , -

    .

    j

    j-

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    102/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 89

    (Mz, 00). A D, Cz

    () ,

    - -,

    , , .

    j ,

    f

    .

    ,

    x, -q

    . Cq, -

    ,

    , f ,

    , -

    , , , -

    .

    2.9 hat are the main leadership challengesin proessional service irms

    , , f : -

    ;

    ; , -

    ; ; ,

    f, . E

    f

    K, ,

    . .

    f

    .

    , q x-

    ,

    , , ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    103/282

    . Dynamic between main leadership tasks and key characteristics

    K

    C

    M

    X X X

    X X X

    X X X

    /

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    104/282

    Business schools as proessional service irms 91

    -

    . q .

    () H (, )

    , , x ?

    () H

    f ?

    () H , ,

    , ?

    () H ,

    , ,

    j ?

    () H ,

    ( )

    ?

    () H

    ?

    x q

    . f ( C ) -

    f, , x

    x

    . x

    . . -

    x.

    x

    ,

    .

    ,

    K

    . W

    ,

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    105/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School92

    , x

    , . H

    x

    .

    PSFMain leadership

    skills

    Professionalcompetences

    Sharedpower

    IntangibilityStandardisation

    solutions

    Trust

    Individualprofessionals

    Globalisation

    Hyper-

    competition

    Alliances

    Informationtechnology

    Knowledgeimprovement

    Uncertaintyturbulence

    Demandof customised

    solutions

    Inner context

    Outer context

    Figure 2.2

    x

    Note:

    .

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    106/282

    93

    3 The leadership processin business schools

    f k m

    x k m -

    fm. m

    mx ym, kw-

    - w , w y m

    m y f

    . , w

    m -

    w .

    A f wy-f y w ,

    w w y m y

    mm, y q y

    mk , ,

    m y. A

    w y, y y m-

    , y y

    academic value proposition. A y k ,

    m y w

    .

    3.1 Introduction to the leadership literature

    f ,

    m

    (N, 00; Yk, ). M

    , , m-

    m j

    . Hw, m my -

    x y y y

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    107/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School94

    w w .

    , w

    y q .

    w m . , trait approach, w

    (w k) -

    y m y

    . , style approach xm w

    / j (w wk w ).

    m

    w, m w -

    x ym m.

    w m y x. ,

    situational approach, w f y

    m

    w m m

    m . , contingency

    theory, w m m m

    y m y m.

    A m f,

    k

    y w m / y

    wy , kw-

    m

    w .

    w

    w ym m mm

    (Yk, ; N, 00). y P, Pw

    () D, y Cz () m-

    m , w

    w k

    wk . y -

    m , w w

    , y m

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    108/282

    The leadership process in business schools 95

    w w. , y

    y

    w m y, m y

    .K (0) mm

    y, k

    j m (k )

    . mm w

    , w

    w j k, wk

    . xm

    m ,

    f w , f m-

    . , ,

    m, , k k

    k w . y, -

    m m

    . Hw, w

    mm . w

    m y (Mz,

    00; Yk, ).

    my .

    xm, A (), zk w -

    m k mm,

    y k

    (zk, ). ,institutional leadership

    . , structural leader-

    ship , .

    , social leadership m , mm-

    , j . zk

    m my x,

    , m

    x / m, w y m

    w m.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    109/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School96

    m A

    f

    k m . : social integrative lead-

    ership, k k; techno-

    visionary leadership, m

    k; , fy, socio-technical leadership, k

    k.

    xm y ., w

    m k y A k w

    m m .

    U A mwk, w w y m

    tasks in the leadership process w.

    3.2 The institutional leadership process

    Setting the direction

    Nmy k x m, -

    mm shared vision.

    m m w m-

    y w , w q W?,W? Hw?.

    Institutionalleadership

    Structuralleadership

    Socialleadership

    Social

    integrative

    Socio-technical

    Techno-

    visionary

    Figure 3.1 A m k

    Source: A (1995: 177).

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    110/282

    The leadership process in business schools 97

    w

    . E m k y m-

    k. w k w

    m . , R E ()

    , my

    , m w w

    m.

    A Yk (), m -

    , mx w q j

    . ,

    mm w

    y. , . A

    m w m

    , w m

    w . M, -

    y , m m

    y w y

    .

    mm y k, -

    y f j, , m

    f

    .

    Creating the sense o a common purpose,and shared values and belies

    m f mm m-

    y m,

    y m my. ( )

    , mm m-

    m y

    , w, m, f. m m m f

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    111/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School98

    y m -

    3.3 The social leadership process

    Motivating and mobilising people

    mm m-

    y m , m y mm-

    fm, m

    w , m-

    m m. m m mm

    y , m, j ,

    m m

    mm (Mz, 00).

    Supporting and empowering people

    kw, k

    P. A Yk () , m w-

    , -m, - w m y

    my m y .

    w

    mm .

    3.4 The structural leadership process

    Coordinating the organisation

    k ym y

    w , , y my.

    y ,

    w ym, , my P K, w

    kw mm ym .

    , P y m

    x

    - m.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    112/282

    The leadership process in business schools 99

    O y P, P MP

    m (C et al., ) y xm . W w

    m mwk .

    xm y w .

    3.5 Governance and strategic leadership

    m

    w my y ,

    w

    m m. R, w y yhow-

    , ,

    ky k mm,

    m m w

    y- . fy,

    w

    m .

    x w -

    m m w, w

    m w shape

    articulate m

    value proposition

    wy. basic keym : m m, -

    m m ( .).

    m, my

    academic model engine x,

    my -

    m m knowing, doing being.

    , y, f, w

    m k q q -

    y mm m -

    my, m

    fm

    m m. fy, y k

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    113/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School1

    , kw m

    m y x q. W k

    w y ? W y x w

    y ? W w m ? Hw

    w y m m m -

    ? W w y ? W

    , mm ; w

    m m ; w y k m-

    w m? y,

    w y ?

    O m m m

    mk , y

    m k w q

    m. Py ky f -

    y. m

    y f, k, k, m

    , f wy , m

    m w m qm. ,

    , y w

    f m

    kw w

    y .

    Academic

    model

    Economicmodel

    Strategicagenda

    Figure 3.2

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    114/282

    The leadership process in business schools 11

    , m ,

    x f economic model

    m m. Hw w y f-

    uel ?, my m y

    x m m m

    m mm m

    m , -

    . , y mm mk

    w w -m w

    y w m .

    , y- , y

    U , wm

    k -m , y

    w m k k. A

    , m x

    wy w m . Hw,

    E k wm -

    w , m,

    m. m y y

    . A, Am , m y,

    A, m -

    wm,

    m m

    . m y

    k ky m mx ,

    m y

    m m, wy .

    A , m m m

    m m

    y. m w -

    , m f (y m-

    x) ,

    mm w w -

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    115/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School12

    w w y

    w- y .

    O m (-

    m m) m w w yf (m m),

    .

    xmy y m m,

    m

    , m m, -

    m m m, -

    y y. strategic agenda road map

    m

    y m, m w

    -mk x. , -

    w m -

    m m x w m y m

    m. A (00: ) , my -

    y w. A

    m m, .. y -

    , m y w y

    m .

    x, w -

    .

    m w:

    m, x m.

    N, kw y w, m f -

    y m

    y y y m,

    w

    fm . w, y (-

    m m ), y m

    y . ,

    m k m

    how wk f

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    116/282

    The leadership process in business schools 13

    . w- E

    , NEAD MD y w

    w

    w x 0 00. m q

    x -

    w m .

    W xm q

    , y -w, m-

    z . m

    -

    m. R

    m. , y,

    , w -

    x -

    y. y ky , f ,

    k, , m w m

    , f

    m ,

    x k.

    3.6 Leadership as a process in contet

    , -

    y y , y m

    x wk y

    wy y . My

    w w w y ,

    w m y -

    m, y wk w

    x. O m, m

    m

    my yy

    y, x -

    w

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    117/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School14

    , , z

    w m mm. Vw -

    , y m

    w w m w. M, w w m, m , w .

    w w w

    w w y j w ,

    . Cy,

    w w.

    N, m

    context, w m. , x-

    m m q-

    : w wy x

    w? q f

    w x

    . M m con-

    textual variables , -

    m f .

    ky m m

    q f (H Ay, ).

    W , -mk y m-

    m x, -

    m, y, ym, ,

    f , m, m, m

    m. w y

    m. w, m

    -

    k , . Ky

    y

    m, m fx

    mmm, w m.

    f ,

    y m w.

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    118/282

    The leadership process in business schools 15

    Wy ? m

    y y :

    ym . P y catch reality in

    fight (Pw, ); x W?, Wy? Hw? k w x,

    m. mx

    k, q m -

    . x

    x, , mm m

    ky w

    x

    (m, 00). k

    my w m ym

    ,

    w y -

    m y m. w w

    w m

    m, j

    .

    y w j

    y

    mm m ym,

    f -

    y . -

    m k w

    y m y

    y m. m , -

    w y y yy -

    y , w y z y

    m. m y

    m w w m y

    x m y .

    kw w y f w

    . , y, m

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    119/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School16

    m k

    x.

    f y

    k w y - x ,

    m x. Vw -

    , y m

    x w mm m

    . , y m x ,

    w m leadership o organisations

    leadership in organisations (ym, , ; H Ay,

    ; H, ). y -

    m . Pm y

    m y mj -

    m w (k Hmk,

    ). m strategic leadership

    m y

    y. ,

    m k y (Hmk,

    ).

    W w -

    , , -

    ky y ,

    , m xy mw -

    y (H, H Am, ).

    y

    m mm , y

    , , m,

    (Pm, ). W f

    strategic leadership process ,

    y w ky -

    , mm m,

    m, m (

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    120/282

    The leadership process in business schools 17

    Hj, 00; C P, ; D, ; , 000;

    H Ay, ; K, 0; Pw, , ; ,

    ). k

    ym , q , w y w

    m.

    y

    ,

    strategic agenda build-

    ing mj w mm-

    strategic agenda executing

    m m. Hw, ,

    y x

    y . , -

    f x,

    y ky k w

    w x

    fm, w x. y

    w x

    f m

    .

    3.7 contetual approach to strategic

    leadership processes in business schools

    k m

    fm, y , w

    m y

    . w-kw

    m . m -

    m fm,

    w , k CEO -

    m m. R, m

    f x xm, m y

  • 7/29/2019 Strategic Leadership in the Business School

    121/282

    Strategic Leadership in the Business School18

    , , k-

    f.

    mm y

    f m q, / y y y y