8/13/2019 Stogner v Case

1/3

STOGNER V. CALIFORNIA (01-1757)93 Cal. App. 4th 1229 114 Cal. Rpt!. 2" 37 !#$#!%#".

Syllabus

NOTE: Where it is feasible, asyllabus (headnote) will bereleased, as is being done inconnection with this case, at thetime the opinion is issued.The syllabus constitutes no partof the opinion of the ourt buthas been prepared by the!eporter of "ecisions for thecon#enience of the reader.$ee %nited $tates #. "etroitTimber & 'umber o., %.$.*+,**.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

STOGNER v.CALIFORNIA

CERTIORARI TO T&E CO'RT OF AEAL OF CALIFORNIA FIRSTAELLATE ISTRICT

No. 011757. Argu! Mar"# $1% &00$'D"(!! )u* &+% &00$

I* 1,,$% Cal(-or*(a *a"! a */ "r((*al sau o-l((a(o*s r((*g ros"u(o* -or s23rla!"#(l! abus /#r # r(or l((a(o*s r(o! #as

2(r! (-%inter alia,# ros"u(o* (s bgu* /(#(*o* yar o- a 4("(s ror o ol(". Asubs6u*ly a!!! ro4(s(o* as "lar #a #(sla/ r4(4s "auss o- a"(o* barr! by r(orl((a(o*s saus. I* 1,,8% ((o*r Sog*r /as(*!("! -or s23rla! "#(l! abus "o(!b/* 1,55 a*! 1,7$. A # ( #os "r(s/r allg!ly "o(!% # l((a(o*s r(o!/as #r yars. Sog*r o4! o !(s(ss #"ola(* o* # grou*! #a # E- ost /actoClaus -orb(!s r4(4al o- a r4(ously (3barr!ros"u(o*. T# r(al "our agr!% bu #Cal(-or*(a Cour o- Aal r4rs!. T# r(al "our!*(! Sog*rs subs6u* !(s(ssal o(o*% (*/#("# # argu! #a #(s ros"u(o* 4(ola! #E- ost /actoa*! Du Pro"ss Clauss. T# Cour o-Aal a--(r!.

http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?200+321http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?200+321http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?200+321http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?200+321http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?200+321

8/13/2019 Stogner v Case

2/3

0eld:A la/ *a"! a-r 2(ra(o* o- a r4(ouslyal("abl l((a(o*s r(o! 4(olas # E- ost/acto Claus /#* ( (s al(! o r4(4 ar4(ously (3barr! ros"u(o*. Cal(-or*(as la/2*!s # ( (* /#("# ros"u(o* (s allo/!%

au#or(9s ros"u(o*s #a # assag o- (#as r4(ously barr!% a*! /as *a"! a-r r(orl((a(o*s r(o!s -or Sog*rs allg! o--*ss#a! 2(r!. Su"# -aurs ro!u" # (*! o-rroa"(4(y #a # Co*s(u(o* -orb(!s. F(rs% #la/ #ra*s # (*!s o- #ar #a # Clausss o a4o(!% -or # Claus ro"s l(bry byr4*(*g go4r**s -ro *a"(*g saus /(#:a*(-sly un1ust and oppressi#e; rroa"(4--"s. alder4. 2ull,$ Dall. $8+% $,1. S"o*!% #la/ -alls l(rally /(#(* # "agor("al !s"r((o*s

o- e- post factola/s #a )us(" C#as s -or#or #a* &00 yars ago (* alder4. 2ull, /#("# #(sCour #as r"og*(9! as a* au#or(a(4 a""ou* o-# Clauss s"o% ollins4. 3oungblood,ar sau rroa"(4ly oll(*g l((a(o*s

http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?497+37http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?497+37http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-const?amendmentvhttp://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?161+591http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?497+37http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?497+37http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-const?amendmentvhttp://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct-cgi/get-us-cite?161+591

8/13/2019 Stogner v Case

3/3

r(o!s !ur(*g # /ar /as 4al(! as a* 2r"(s o-Co*grss /ar o/rs% $tewart4. 5ahn,11 >all.