state carcase competition - sa vleismerinosavleismerino.net/publikasies/artikels/wammco...
TRANSCRIPT
State carcase competition
Highlights
• Nation’s largest carcase competition
• Nation’s richest carcase competition
Highlights
• Nation’s largest carcase competition
• Nation’s richest carcase competition
• 30,369 lambs evaluated from 115 entries (69 members)
• 15 members entered 2 or more consignments
• Over $22,000 in cash and prizes to distribute
Highlights
• Nation’s largest carcase competition
• Nation’s richest carcase competition
• 30,369 lambs evaluated from 115 entries (69 members)
• 15 members entered 2 or more consignments
• Over $22,000 in cash and prizes to distribute
• Entries received from all of the state
– Geraldton / Walkaway / Wongan Ballidu / Kalannie
– Northam / Cunderdin / Lake Grace / Newdegate
– Esperance / Ravensthorpe /Jerramungup
– Manjimup / Donnybrook / Kojonup
Competition overview
• 14 August ‘11 – 1 March ‘12
• A minimum consignment of 100 XB lambs
• $50 entry fee
• Same wt & fat grid used since 2006
• Same WAMMCO Select Lean Meat Yield grid used since 2009
• 3 Categories – Overall heavy weight, trade weight, 300+ consignment
• Over $22,000 in cash & prizes
Competition feedback
Diverse range of genetics entered
Competition Feedback
Diverse range of genetics entered
Dams (13): Merino and SAMM – 75% of entries
Greeline, Afrino, Kelso, Dohne, Dorper, Corriedale, Poll Dorset, White
Suffolk, Texel, Border Leicester, Composite
Competition Feedback
Diverse range of genetics entered
Dams (13): Merino and SAMM – 75% of entries
Greeline, Afrino, Kelso, Dohne, Dorper, Corriedale, Poll Dorset, White
Suffolk, Texel, Border Leicester, Composite
Sires (11): Poll Dorset and SAMM – 65% of entries
Ile de France, Afrino, Greeline, Kojak, East Friesian, White Suffolk, Texel,
Suffolk, Dorper
Lamb marking %
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
80% and below
81 - 90% 91 - 100% 101 - 110% 111 - 120% 121%+
% o
f e
ntr
ants
53% achieved
> 100% marking
Ave 105%
lamb marking
Lamb marking %
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
80% and below
81 - 90% 91 - 100% 101 - 110% 111 - 120% 121%+
% o
f e
ntr
ants
38% of Merino dams achieved a lamb marking rate of > 100%
69% of Non pure Merino dams achieved a lamb marking rate of > 100%
53% achieved
> 100% marking
Ave 105%
lamb marking
Point allocation
Each carcase is assigned wt/grade
points ± WAMMCO Select bonus
points
25.1kg fat score 2, W/S Lean meat
yield 31.5%
– Max 100 pts + Bonus 10 pts
– Total 110 x 25.1kg = 2761
Each carcase is assigned wt/grade
points ± WAMMCO Select bonus
points
25.1kg fat score 2, W/S Lean meat
yield 31.5%
– Max 100 pts + Bonus 10 pts
– Total 110 x 25.1kg = 2761
25.1kg fat score 2, W/S Lean meat
yield 29.0%
– Max 100 pts – Discount 10 pts
– Total 90 x 25.1kg = 2259
Point allocation
41
51 52
80
59
96102
76
123
115
30
50
70
90
110
130
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
/08
2008
/09
2009
/10
2010
/11
2011
/12
Year
No. of entries
4000
9000
14000
19000
24000
29000
34000
No. of carcases
Competition participation
23.9 23.9
23.223 22.923.0
24.4
23.223.3
21.2
21
21.5
22
22.5
23
23.5
24
24.5
25
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
/08
2008
/09
2009
/10
2010
/11
2011
/12
Year
Hot carcase
weight (kg)
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
Fat score
(1-5)
Carcase weight vs fat score
Ave carcase weight vs fat score
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
Ave carcase wt = 22.9kg
Ave fat score = 3.0
Ave carcase weight vs fat score
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
Ave carcase wt = 22.9kg
Ave fat score = 3.0
31% of entries 24.1 – 27kg
Ave carcase weight vs fat score
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
Ave carcase wt = 22.9kg
Ave fat score = 3.0
47% of entries > FS 3
Ave carcase weight vs fat score
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
Ave carcase wt = 22.9kg
Ave fat score = 3.0
Ave carcase weight vs fat score
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
Ave carcase wt = 22.9kg
Ave fat score = 3.0
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
6,394 lambs
18 consignments
Ave carc wt = 20.3kg
Ave fat score = 2.4
Trade weight category –
weight x fat score
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
18,851 lambs
45 consignments
Ave carc wt = 22.4kg
Ave fat score = 2.9
300+ category – weight x fat score
Top 3 / category
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Fat
score
Ave carcase weight vs points
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Overall
points
Ave carcase wt = 22.9kg
Ave points = 1700
Trade category - points
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Overall
points
Ave carcase wt = 20.3kg
Ave points = 1366
300+ category - points
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Overall
points
Ave carcase wt = 22.4kg
Ave points = 1626
Top 3 / category
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Carcase weight (kg)
Overall
points
Fat score vs carcase yield
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Fat score
Carcase
Yield (%)
Ave carcase yld = 48.9%
Ave fat score = 2.96
Report
Grower Entry No. Overall result &
place (115)
Trade Wt result
& place (18)
300+ lambs result
& place (45)
L. Chop 1 1690.41 (92nd) N/A N/A
L. Chop 2 1347.38 (116th) 1347.38 (15th) N/A
L. Chop 3 1774.22 (79th) 1774.22 (9th) 1774.22 (17th)
Lower rank indicates:
- Final placing in the category
Ability to hit the target
% 24.1 – 27 % Fat score 2 % 24.1 – 27 & FS 2
L. Chop
(rank)
17.9
(75)
52.8
(26)
3.2
(29)
Average
(range)
22.7
(0 – 73.7)
26.2
(0 – 82.0)
2.2
(0 – 37.9)
1st Place 43.2 51.5 25.0
Lower rank indicates:
- more carcases meeting weight and grade specifications
Points & overall result
Wt/grade points Bonus points Overall result
L. Chop
(rank)
78.6
(50)
2.8
(56)
2068.24
(46)
Average
(range)
70.8
(40.5 – 93.5)
2.8
(-15.9 – 23.4)
1700
(830 – 2965)
1st Place 90.9 23.4 2965.49
Lower rank indicates:
- higher weight and grade points
- more bonus points
- finishing position in competition out of 115 entries
Thank you
Competition entrants
WAMMCO Staff
Door Prize
Sliding gate hay feeder Cradle hay feeder
5th
300+ consignment
Trading Name M & E Mincherton
Growers Corey Mincherton
Location Ballidu
Breeding SAMM x F1 SAMM
Numbered entered 321
Carcase Weight 23.57
Fat score 2.96
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.3%
% carcases - bonus pts 78.1%
Competition points 2151.00
4th
300+ consignment
Trading Name PJ & AP Martin
Growers Justin Martin
Location Northam
Breeding Poll Dorset x Merino
Numbered entered 386
Carcase Weight 25.03
Fat score 3.18
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.2%
% carcases - bonus pts 80.6%
Competition points 2327.62
3rd
300+ consignment
Trading Name AJ Orr
Growers Alan Orr
Location Newdegate
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 335
Carcase Weight 26.45
Fat score 3.26
WAMMCO Select LMY 31.8%
% carcases - bonus pts 81.1%
Competition points 2384.61
2nd
300+ consignment
Trading Name Swandale Investments Pty Ltd
Growers Brendon Tyrrell
Location Esperance
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 426
Carcase Weight 25.28
Fat score 2.96
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.4%
% carcases - bonus pts 86.7%
Competition points 2513.97
1st
300+ consignment
Trading Name RW & PM Taylor
Growers Ross & Pauline Taylor
Location Lake Grace
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 337
Carcase Weight 24.84
Fat score 2.62
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.2%
% carcases - bonus pts 81.2%
Competition points 2589.98
5th
Trade weight
Trading Name AJ Orr
Growers Alan Orr
Location Newdegate
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 157
Carcase Weight 20.47
Fat score 2.50
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.4%
% carcases - bonus pts 65.6%
Competition points 1510.51
4th
Trade weight
Trading Name Bunkin Farming Enterprise
Growers Terry & Dale Cronin
Location Dumbleyung
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 106
Carcase Weight 20.14
Fat score 2.42
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.9%
% carcases - bonus pts 82.1%
Competition points 1522.07
3rd
Trade weight
Trading Name WM & ML Leo
Growers Wes and Megan Leo
Location Ravensthorpe
Breeding Poll Dorset x (SAMM x W/Suff)
Numbered entered 105
Carcase Weight 20.97
Fat score 2.38
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.1%
% carcases - bonus pts 56.2%
Competition points 1576.97
2nd
Trade weight
Trading Name GH & CA Barrett
Growers Graham & Wayne Barrett
Location Jerramungup
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 461
Carcase Weight 21.0
Fat score 2.88
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.3%
% carcases - bonus pts 66.2%
Competition points 1584.60
1st
Trade weight
Trading Name Evergreen Farming Co
Growers Craig & Liz Heggaton
Location Kojonup
Breeding (Poll Dorset & Kojak) x composite
Numbered entered 637
Carcase Weight 20.8
Fat score 2.35
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.5%
% carcases - bonus pts 67.7%
Competition points 1622.27
5th
overall
Trading Name RD & LZ Cullam
Growers Simon Cullam
Location Jerramungup
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 167
Carcase Weight 24.7
Fat score 2.55
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.3%
% carcases - bonus pts 84.4%
Competition points 2607.69
4th
overall
Trading Name Bunkin Farming Enterprises
Growers Terry & Dale Cronin
Location Dumbleyung
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 111
Carcase Weight 24.6
Fat score 2.26
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.4%
% carcases - bonus pts 86.5%
Competition points 2709.78
3rd
overall
Trading Name Capemont Farms
Growers Barry, Sheldon & Trent Kowald
Location Katanning
Breeding (Poll Dorset & SAMM) x Merino
Numbered entered 100
Carcase Weight 26.8
Fat score 2.98
WAMMCO Select LMY 31.9%
% carcases - bonus pts 80.0%
Competition points 2730.71
2nd
overall
Trading Name Bunkin Farming Enterprises
Growers Terry & Dale Cronin
Location Dumbleyung
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 103
Carcase Weight 25.3
Fat score 2.35
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.3%
% carcases - bonus pts 83.5%
Competition points 2815.39
State Carcase Comp Winner
Trading Name RW & PM Taylor
Growers Ross & Pauline Taylor
Location Lake Grace
Breeding SAMM x SAMM
Numbered entered 132
Carcase Weight 25.9
Fat score 2.43
WAMMCO Select LMY 32.6%
% carcases - bonus pts 84.2%
Competition points 2965.49
Top 10 overall
Place Trading name Location Breeding Points
1 RW & PM Taylor Lake Grace SAMM x SAMM 2965
2 Bunkin Farming Ent Dumbleyung SAMM x SAMM 2815
3 Capemont Farms Katanning (Poll Dorset & SAMM) X Mo 2730
4 Bunkin Farming Ent Dumbleyung SAMM x SAMM 2709
5 Cullam SAMM Jerramungup SAMM x SAMM 2607
6 RW & PM Taylor Lake Grace SAMM x SAMM 2590
7 Capemont Farms Katanning SAMM x Mo 2551
8 GW & RE Fenwick Wellstead East Friesian x SAMM 2540
9 Swandale Investments Esperance SAMM x SAMM 2514
10 TJ & K Ward Dumbleyung W/Suff x F1 SAMM 2512
Top 10 300+ lambs
Place Trading name Location Breeding Points
1 RW & PM Taylor Lake Grace SAMM x SAMM 2590
2 Swandale Investments Esperance SAMM x SAMM 2514
3 AJ Orr Newdegate SAMM x SAMM 2385
4 PJ & AP Martin Northam PD x Merino 2328
5 M & E Mincherton Ballidu SAMM x F1 SAMM 2151
6 JR & JM Browne Eneabba SAMM x Merino 2103
7 Dutarning Pty Ltd Pingelly (SAMM & Suff) x Merino 2053
8 Evergreen Grazing Co Kojonup (PD & Kojak) x Composite 2034
9 Dutarning Pty Ltd Pingelly (SAMM & Suff) x Merino 1922
10 AH Hall & Co Tenterden PD x Merino 1919
Top 10 trade weight
Place Trading name Location Breeding Points
1 Evergreen Grazing Co Kojonup (PD & Kojak) x Composite 1622
2 GH & CA Barrett Jerramungup SAMM x SAMM 1585
3 WM & ML Leo Ravensthorpe PD x (SAMM x W/Suff) 1577
4 Bunkin Farming Ent Dumbleyung SAMM x SAMM 1522
5 AJ Orr Newdegate SAMM x SAMM 1511
6 PT & IM Jensen & Sons Pingaring SAMM x Merino 1449
7 Evergreen Grazing Co Kojonup (PD & Kojak) x Composite 1444
8 Evergreen Grazing Co Kojonup (PD & Kojak) x Composite 1427
9 TJ & K Ward Dumbleyung W/Suff x F1 SAMM 1391
10 TJR & EG Gorter Kojonup Texel x Composite 1367