ssrn-id1867543

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

1/7Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1867543

Journal o the American Oriental Society 130.3 (2010) 445

T Sp F H Lw

Timothy LubinWashington and Lee University

T I c , pc cc Sk c kw H w, c ,k j pc Pck O, wc p c w cc . Nw D D w k H w w ck . Spc w ppc w cp -, w j x p. T S A , H pc, w c w w pc

c w H. L p-p k c H w , cz c (cra) x z p . Dz c k c w . T w c wk w jc, w k cpc . T c , k w- xp p- , w w pp w w .

I p, I w w D , w pp c c- : Lw . M w ,

w p . Lk p, pk . B w , , pp pc?A cc pc c k ( ) xpc, kw, w pc p c w pp . Pp pc cc p- T pc xpc cc.

T, , c w w , wc D c- w k p p. Ik c S. A G, p (k w) kw pp

. D c w p c cz p w w, wc c H . 1 T jpc pc w pcc (p. 6).

A w ( , j Hw) c (.., C) cp-k, pcp c c (.., -w

T w c The Spirit o Hindu Law. B Donald R. Davis, Jr. C: Cambridge UniversityPress, 2010. Pp. xx + 194. $85.

1. D R. D, J., B V: Hk, D, W Lw C C,Law and Con-

temporary Problems 71 (2008): 99.

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

2/7Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1867543

446 Journal o the American Oriental Society 130.3 (2010)

x c w ), wc -ccp . T wcw . B c, pp, pc c.

O pp c c w ckw p : , c c pp c , p c w pw . R w cpc c ; . I p xp c. B c pc , p - ( cc w xcpw , ). D q c-c c k (pp. 17275).

B D , wc cc cp w . D k c w c ccp c , p cp ( ccp pp c). Ec cp c p k: () ccp xp p w , , cx p ww H x; () k H jp H; () c cp p -c, w, (p. 13). W w c c cp p cp- c , pp ww c c c, , I . D H w , []

w . . . dharma p w , w c H ( ) w w w (p. 23).

T c w pc . I , w (pp. 2223), xp Hw ccp c p c pc w w c jpc p D (p. 13). D ckw p- w p: T w c . I c, w, k , wc ccp c, p p, c c k w w kw (pp. 2223). T pc w; p c .

T - cp 1 w ccp prama. Bw M cc Vc , pp w kw w, .., c: veda ( ruti), smti, cra, -, , c (p. 26). I , k c , D cra, c cc pcc, . W c x V , c p V p c dharma (p. 28). T p xp w w: smti x p cc w- Vc jc; cc (cra)

pp V p fc c ppcp D cp Ic pcp ijm(p. 30).

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

3/7

447Lubin: The Spirit and the Flesh o Hindu Law

T c pcc ( c cc pcp) c: p wk . W w xpc w , c c , H w xp c . D

c c w (p. 36), c c . C, Jw w . T Gk c w w oikos (), w wC R p w z p dominus , c p . B c, k p pc .

A c c , p w w xpc : ruti smti pp ammsya q.M k w p . T c p c (pp. 4142). Hw c , pcc, q pp , p cx- fx c c c wk w. AD , p w xp cra w w. T cz c c pc , c , pp jc w, w p ( w c cp pc) c !

A D p , j w w k ( Jw w, S) pcp A-

Ac w c cc c c, z . I w, jc w, c - ( -pc). I pc pc c c w.

T c c cp 2, w D k p c- M Vc c . H xp w c cp 1 w xp zppc cc pc: W p w c c p? I w ?W w jc xp? D cp M c wc x-p p cpx pp. T k - cc M , k IRS , k M- p (.., cc), -pp (ghya) w.

Ex c (karman) w c , cM ppc p Vc jc , x-, smti cra. O w, p c p Vc , c p q. D c p p (pp. 5556). I fc M, , pc, p, c w k ck

p w (p. 63). I c p cfc, M p c cc pp cp c ppc. T,

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

4/7


(rama) w p q, - c p -pp, wp w c w (laukika, pururtha) ( c ), c pq c (vaidika, kratvartha). D p pc w w pp c-

p w w. A , w, c p. Lk , w (p.67), pp c w (pp. 6869).

O p c D , wc p p , c , M cc cq w p c, c w xpc Vc -k. I w, w w - x Vc pcp w p p c- c . T x w -- w c c cz c. I , c , p c fc, w .

Cp 3 w cc ccp (a) ppc p. Tw c : c- ( , ; wp ; p, c), c cc Vc ; cc- , pc w , I cc pc cc. I w ccp, D , c cc c (.., w cc c) (p. 75), x cpc.F, p , cz c, p p pc . D cc

ccp c p p w pc [ E G ] pp p (p. 85). T wc wcz p. A c p c c c , c wk anomie.

T c cp 4 p , .., wp (svatva) [] c (p. 89). T c p w w k c, Dc p . V wp w, M N ppp svatva p w w w (svasvmisambandha), c (yatheaviniyogayogyatva), jc (mamedam) (p. 93). F , D w cpx pc wp w H j , c cc w j pp p. T p c w q pp H ( )pp w, c , c wc -c w wp (p. 102). Tk q p pp, w (B, , c) c w pc w svadharma. H, Lck, Mx w p c pp w (pp. 1027).

I cp 5, D c p-c (vyavahra). U k , vyavahra k

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

5/7


x, pcz : c c > c > w p > , pc c w: p, p, c(prama), c (niraya). T c nyya (M), , (, M p: p

x); c jc anyya. Fw w w p, D cfc jc, pc c c (pp. 1089).Lkw, ( pc) c q. B k W w, - . R, c I w cp p w k : c, c, c , p c p, c , c. I q k cz c c, jc w c p,c c pp. I c c, Rw fcq w cc , c c -c cc jc Rc , D H w c, c w - kw jc, c pc. Vyavahra, , p in accordance with dharma to produce dharma, ccp p (pp. 12526).

Cp 6 p c w: c p.D cp w p c: p (daa) k pc (pryacitta), -p. B p p pc c c c (p. 133). H p karman c H

w c w pc w [] , c w c c w p pc c (p. 136). Y pc, wc p , pc cc w pc karman. T, p karman , c cc. M, c p pryacitta c . F p- c pc, pryacitta cc c . F, - p pc ( ) z (Mnavadharmastra 8.318), wc cc cx pc q p. 2

D wc -p p c. T k p c dua-nigraha, c- ( c c), c kaaka-odhanap , p k c. S, w pc p-p cc , daa q , c, ck cc c k. Dc ( pp pp) xpc , daa c pc cq.

2. F c p c, T. L, P Exp: OppD Bc Lw,Indologica Taurinensia 33 (2007): 91120.

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

6/7


I p cp, w D p w jx-p w w c: W Bj w w c B K Sk p - . D Sk cc: daa c , wc

c c ( c ) pc (p. 141).3 A Bj c wc w c j w c, w G . 4 T pc p-c pp p, D, Bj w ccp pc , p pc c p dharma. T cp p pc w, w, : c -p c ( c) w -cp -cc, xp , c H w ( - w).

A ccc c , H w p , - , c p ck. I w, p , wc p xp c cc. B cp 7 D jccra, wc ( ) H w c pcc: dharma , wc H w(p. 148). H c c cra c w cra wk cp pcc, cc cp B w p, , , kw p x, w

(p. 146). I z, z pcc B jcxp c K (, ,V), ckw -p p . A cra cc pcc , B- cra c fc p V, w p w B. T w Vj k B loka-veda-ja, , kw V, w (Mitkar Yjavalkyasmti 2.2). B p cpcc cra p w w-kw xpH jpc p c w w c(p. 149).

T cc p k p c c. F c,D c M w cra w x-Vc cra (p. 150).H w kw M, w x c, w x pc c w c c, G ( sacchdra),w w ccpc c q-Bc p . Ap ccc, k p c pc , Bhaspatismti 1.20.13 [20.8 J ] wk - q wk c sacchdra w

3. Sk, B K, T H T S, Political Science Quarterly 36 (1921): 7990.4. W Bj, Cq Vc,Refections (Nw Yk: Scck, 1978), 280.

7/31/2019 SSRN-id1867543

7/7


(.., Ajitatantra) c j varadharma.

N , D ckw j cc H w , , w I c, p-

p p p c , x- ccc, c c c w .

T p , , k Gestalt, cc, c c c ( , -c). D w w f H w 5 - w wc w pcc, c , w c p p pc c. 6 H c k . W k w pc , w fw, c w k w , D cc . D c k c q . T pc w w w less cp pp p. B c p c, cc , c- w c ppc c.

5. D, M, Lw E B M: Rk W Lw TcRc. Studien zur Indologie und Iranistik23 (2002): 5170; The Boundaries o Hindu Law Tradition, Customand Politics in Medieval Kerala. Cp I Scc, . 5. T: CESMEO, 2004; I R

Lw: Cp Gp R M I,Journal o the Economic and Social History o the Orient48 (2005): 92117.6. A c pp, Rp H Lw, p wkp, R L H,

U Wc, M (24 Sp 2010), U V (21 Oc 2010).

ssrn-id1867543

Documents