sspt issue 17 final

8/21/2019 Sspt Issue 17 Final

1/176

)*

social & political thought

*(& *-&( *

Re)(+- a'd Se%ec-ed Pa)e+,S1//!4 C+*"!.!*c! +* T$!++. W A+.*+ \k]

S"&(' M.,,e%% N"c!(%a, J(%% P!"%") H(! J(,! R(b"',(' C!+", OKa'e

A+-"c%e,

M!a%a* R!"(!c0%+*/ +* 0$! E4%/0!*0%a( A)b%2a(!*c! +" H1)a* S!("$++S"&(' S.,e'

R!c+*/%!.%*# 0$! Ma.4%/0 T$!+.5 +" 0$! Ca,%0a(%/0 S0a0!Fa-&a %$9 Se%6.$

L!+ S0.a1// P+(%0%ca( P$%(+/+,$5 a* M+!.* J1a%/)J C!+",-()!e+ Pa,$e0"c!

B10(!. a* B1$%/) I!*0%05 P!."+.)a0%2%05 a*A'a--aPadd2 McQ.ee'

B(($, Re/"e0edDe++"da A' E2)-"a'b5 P!0!. S(+0!.%&'

L"/"' (' B(++(0ed T"&eb5 Z5#)1*0 Ba1)a*Dec(%('"3"' De/e%()&e'-b5 J+!( Wa%*3.%#$0

Wa%-e+ Be'#a&"' a'd Be+-(%- B+ec!-b5 E.)10 W%6%/(aO'e D"&e',"('a% W(&a'b5 N%*a P+3!.

%* 17 . J* 2010

%* 17 "/"* 2010

SSPT Issue 17 [FINAL]:SSPT 29/06/2010 11:23 Page 1


2/176

studies in social and political thought

S-.d"e, "' S(c"a% a'd P(%"-"ca% T!(.!- %/ a &+1.*a( ,.+1c! b5 ,+/0#.a1a0!/01!*0/ )a*5 +" 3$+) a.! ba/! a0 0$! U*%2!./%05 +" S1//!4 T$! &+1.*a( /!!'/

0+ "+/0!. a* ,.+)+0! %*0!.%/c%,(%*a.%05 %* /+c%a( a* ,+(%0%ca( 0$+1#$0 %*a%0%+* 0+ ,.+2%%*# a ,1b(%/$%*# ,(a0"+.) 0+ &1*%+. aca!)%c/

I'-e+'a-"('a% Ad/",(+2 B(a+dR+b!.0 P%,,%* e A4!( H+**!0$ e S!5(a B!*$ab%b

Ga5a0.% C$a'.a2+.05 S,%2a' e F.!.%c Ja)!/+* e H+)% B$ab$aA(!//a*.+ F!..a.a e W%((%a) O10$3a%0! e S%)+* Ja.2%/

S$a%a D.1.5 e Ma.0%* Ja5 e A.%a*a Ca2a.!.+G+.+* F%*(a5/+* e R+b!.0 G++%* e A*.!3 C$%005

Ed"-(+"a% G+(.)C$.%/ OKa*! e S%)+* M1//!(( e P!0!. K+(a.6

V!.!*a E.(!*b1/c$ e R P$%((%, H+)b1.#A*.!3 M%0c$!(( e Z+! S10$!.(a* e A(a/0a%. K!),

C$.%/ A((/+b.++' e Da*%!( L+*#$1./0

Re/"e0e+,C$.%/ OKa*! S%)+* M1//!(( C$.%/ A((/+b.++' Z+! S10$!.(a*

A*.!3 M%0c$!(( V!.!*a E.(!*b1/c$ Da*%!( L+*#$1./0 A(!4a*!.E((%+0 E((%+0 R+/! A(a/0a%. G.a5 N1..!(% Y!#%* S1*b1(+#1 Rac$!(

W++ Jac' I/$!.3++ L1c5 Ma5b(%* E))a Ba00!(( L+3)a* Pa1(H!b!* A(a/0a%. K!), P!0!. K+(a.6 Da*%!( K1c$(!. R+b L1ca/

G+.+* F%*(a5/+* S5(2a%* F%.!.kB(a!// T%)+ J1!00!* J+*#kS++* A$*D+.+0$!a M1!((!. S0.a0%/ E"0$5)%+1 T+) L!**a. Fab.%6%+ T.%"%.+L!*a Na.! I*!/ Ha//!(b!.# A(+ E$%)%a#$! La.%//a B!#(!5 Na%*!

V+!('*!. L%a) S0a*(!5 A.%/0!a F+0+,+1(+1 Ja)!/ McM1..a5

C()2ed"-"' a'd P+((f+ead"'C$.%/ A((/+b.++' S%)+* M1//!(( A(a/0a%. K!), P!0!. K+(a.6

R P$%((%, H+)b1.# A*.!3 M%0c$!((

De,"' a'd T2)e,e--"'S%)+* M1//!((

S-.d"e, "' S(c"a% a'd P(%"-"ca% T!(.!-F.%/0+* B1%(%*# U*%2!./%05 +" S1//!4

Fa()!. B.%#$0+* BN SP

E%0+.%a( //,0g/1//!4ac1' Sa(!/ //,0/a(!/g/1//!4ac1'

000?,.,,e1?ac?.$c,)-,,)-

T!", ",,.e (f SSPT 0a, &ade )(,,"b%e b2 a c('-+"b.-"(' f+(& -!eCe'-+e f(+ S(c"a% a'd P(%"-"ca% T!(.!- a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (f S.,,e1

i c+,5.%#$0 %/ .!0a%*! b5 0$! a10$+./



3/176

contents

Volume 17 Spring/Summer 2010

S.,,e1 C('fe+e'ce (' T!e(d(+ W? Ad(+'( ;7 Yea+, O'

C+*"!.!*c! R!,+.0S"&(' M.,,e%%

Ga,/ A* I*-1%.5 %*0+ D!"+.)a0%+* a* D!0!.)%*a0%+* %* A+.*+N"c!(%a, J(%%

A F+.c!"%!( b!03!!* Na01.! S+c%!05 a* R!a/+* A,,.+ac$%*# A+.*+/P$%(+/+,$5 +" La*#1a#!P!"%") H(!

A!/0$!0%c P.a4%/J(,! R(b"',('

T!e,e, Aa"',- Occ.%-",& T+a5 T+3a./ Ca,%0a(%/) a/ Occ1(0%/)

C!+", OKa'e

A+-"c%e,

M!a%a* R!"(!c0%+*/ +* 0$! E4%/0!*0%a( A)b%2a(!*c! +" H1)a* S!("$++S"&(' S.,e'

R!c+*/%!.%*# 0$! Ma.4%/0 T$!+.5 +" 0$! Ca,%0a(%/0 S0a0! A* A(0!.*a0%2!

A,,.+ac$Fa-&a %$9 Se%6.$

L!+ S0.a1// P+(%0%ca( P$%(+/+,$5 a* M+!.* J1a%/)J C!+",-()!e+ Pa,$e0"c!

B10(!. a* B1$%/) I!*0%05 P!."+.)a0%2%05 a*A'a--aPadd2 McQ.ee'



4/176

Re/"e0,

`D!..%a A* E#5,0%a* b5 P!0!. S(+0!.%&'

A+-!.+ W"%%e&,e

`L%2%*# +* B+..+3! T%)! b5 Z5#)1*0 Ba1)a*Ma-- Da0,('

`D!c+(+*%6%*# D!2!(+,)!*0 C+(+*%a( P+3!. a* 0$! Ma5a b5 J+!(Wa%*3.%#$0S-+a-",A'd+ea, Ef-!2&"(.

`Wa(0!. B!*&a)%* a* B!.0+(0 B.!c$0 T$! S0+.5 +" a F.%!*/$%, b5 E.)10W%6%/(aR P!"%%") H(&b.+

`O*! D%)!*/%+*a( W+)a* b5 N%*a P+3!.Z(e S.-!e+%a'd

Ed"-(+"a% N(-e

T$! b1.!a1c.ac5 %/ a c%.c(! ".+) 3$%c$ *+ +*! ca* !/ca,!I0/ $%!.a.c$5 %/ a $%!.a.c$5 +" '*+3(!#!\Ma.4 C+"-"*.e (f Hee%, P!"%(,()!2 (f R"!-]

W!(c+)! 0+ 0$! .!k(a1*c$ +" S-.d"e, "' S(c"a% a'd P(%"-"ca% T!(.!- O1. (a/0%//1! .!"(!c0! +* c.%0%-1! a* c.%/%/ %* 0$! c+*0!40 +" 0$! #(+ba( "%*a*c%a(

c.%/%/ T$! c1..!*0 %//1! %/ %* /+)! /!*/! a ,.+1c0 +" 0$! a"0!.)a0$ +" 0$!"%*a*c%a( c.%/%/ a/ 0$! "%*a*c%a( c.%/%/ b!#a0 0$! /+2!.!%#* !b0 c.%/%/ 0$!/+2!.!%#* !b0 c.%/%/ b!#a0 0$! b1#!0 c.%/%/ a* 0$! b1#!0 c.%/%/ b!#a0 0$!c10/ T$%/ .!#.!00ab(! 0.a&!c0+.5 #a2! ,(a1/%b%(%05 0+ 21(#a. Ma.4%/)/c+*0!*0%+* 0$a0 0$! !4!c10%2! +" 0$! )+!.* /0a0! %/ b10 a c+))%00!! "+.)a*a#%*# 0$! c+))+* a""a%./ +" 0$! 3$+(! b+1.#!+%/%! I0 a(/+ /!0 0$! /0a#!"+. a* 1*3$+(!/+)! /5*0$!/%/ 3%0$ 0$! c!*0.a(%6! `)a.'!0%6a0%+*%),!.a0%2!/ +" N!3 Lab+1./ $%#$!. !1ca0%+* ,+(%c5 T$%/ c1()%*a0! %*0$! %*0.a*/%#!*0 1*"+.01*a0! a* 3$+((5 )%/#1%! )a*a#!)!*0 +" 0$!1*%2!./%05'(&e'$%.-.+a3$+ ,.+c!!! 0+ 0.!a0 a/ 0$! c.%0!.%+* "+. H%#$!.

C*2



5/176

E1ca0%+* "1*%*# a ,.%*c%,(! %!*0%"%! b5 A+.*+/ /ca0$%*# .!)a.'A*50$%*# 0$a0 %/ *+0 .!%"%! ca**+0 b! c+1*0! +. )!a/1.! c!a/!/ 0+ !4%/0A/ a .!/1(0 3! $a2! 0$! 1/$!.%*# %* +" /!2!.! c10/ a* a 3a. a#a%*/0 0$!

$1)a*%0%!/ \/!! $00,jj!"!*/1//!43+.,.!//c+)] O" c+1./! 3! a.! *+0a(+*! %* "ac%*# 0$!/! .!#.!//%2! )+2!/ \/!! $00,jj/a2!)43+.,.!//c+)]T$! /$a,! +" 0$! c+a(%0%+* #+2!.*)!*0/ )1c$ 2a1*0! 'e0 )(%"-"c, (++'/1*!"%*! S+ "a. 3! $a2! /!!* a* !)!.#!*c5 b1#!0 (a5%*# +10 +*c! %* a#!*!.a0%+* c10/ a* a *!3 B1/%*!// S!c.!0a.5 /a5%*# 0$a0 0$! "101.! +" 0$!1*%2!./%0%!/ 3%(( b! +*! +" 0$.!! ,.%+.%0%!/ "+. 0$! b1/%*!// !,a.0)!*0 %* 0$!*!40 0$.!! )+*0$/ T$%/ %/ c$%((%*# /01"" F+. !2!* %" 0$!.! )a5 b! /+)!$+,! 0$a0 0$! L%bkC+*/ 3%(( !k%*/0.1)!*0a(%6! $%#$!. !1ca0%+* 3! $a2!0+ $+,! 0$a0 0$%/ )+2! 3%(( *+0 b! 1*!.)%*! b5 "%*a*c%a( %/!)b+3!()!*0

Y!0 !/,%0! 0$!/! ,.!//1.!/ l 3$%c$ (! 0+ )a*5 0!%+1/ b1.!a1c.a0%c)a*+!12.!/ c+*c!.*/ a* !(a5/ l SSPT/0%(( !4%/0/ a* .!/%/0/ /1c$ )5+,%c%),!.a0%2!/ W! .!k(a1*c$ 3%0$ a *!3 !%0+.%a( b+a. a* a .!*!3!a3a.!*!// +" 0$! %),+.0a*c! +" /+c%a( a* ,+(%0%ca( 0$+1#$0 T+ 0$%/ !* 3!$a2! b.+1#$0 0+#!0$!. a* %*0!.*a0%+*a( a2%/+.5 b+a. +" !/0!!)! /c$+(a./a* /1,,+.0!./ W! $a2! a(/+ !c%! 0+ .!+.%!*0 0$! &+1.*a( +,!*%*# %0 1,0+ c.%0%ca((5 )%*! /01!*0/ a* aca!)%c/ ".+) ac.+// 0$! #(+b!

I* 0$%/ +1. .!k(a1*c$ %//1! 3! (++' 0+ 0$! ,a/0 a* 0+ 0$! "101.! F+. 0$! ,a/0

3! c+*/%!. 0$! 3+.' +" T$!++. W A+.*+ 3%0$ a .!,+.0 a* /!(!c0!,a,!./ ".+) 0$!Ad(+'( > Yea+, O'c+*"!.!*c! ".+) A1#1/0 F+. 0$!"101.! 3! ,.!/!*0 a /!.%!/ +" c+),!((%*# a* 0$+1#$0k,.+2+'%*# a.0%c(!/ a*.!2%!3/ 0$a0 /$+3ca/! 0$! /%#*%"%ca*c! .!(!2a*c! a* %2!./%05 +" /+c%a( a*,+(%0%ca( 0$+1#$0

I* 0$! *!40 "!3 )+*0$/ 3! ,(a* 0+ %),(!)!*0 a *1)b!. +" ,(a**!%),.+2!)!*0/ %*c(1%*# a .!!/%#* a* !4,a*/%+* +" +1. +*(%*! ,.!/!*c!a/ 3!(( a/ %*c.!a/%*# +1. %*2+(2!)!*0 3%0$ 0$! C!*0.! "+. S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca(

T$+1#$0 a0 S1//!4 a* ,+/0#.a1a0!/ a0 +0$!. 1*%2!./%0%!/ T$!/! c$a*#!/3%(( /!.2! 0+ /1,,+.0 0$! ,+(%0%ca( a* %*0!((!c01a( #+a(/ +" 0$! &+1.*a( a*/1,,(!)!*0 %0/ b%k5!a.(5 ,1b(%ca0%+*

A/ a "%*a( *+0! 3! 3+1( (%'! 0+ %*2%0! a*5+*! 3$+ %/ %*0!.!/0! %*c+*0.%b10%*# 0+3a./ 0$! .1**%*# +" SSPT0+ #!0 %* 0+1c$ a* #!0 %*2+(2!

T$a*' 5+1

. The Edi"o! of SSPT

F * E) 3



6/176

SPT C('fe+e'ce (' T!e(d(+ W? Ad(+'(;7 Yea+, O'

C('fe+e'ce Re)(+-

b5 S%)+* M1//!((

O* 0$! /%40$ a5 +" A1#1/0 c.%0%ca( 0$!+.%/0/ ac.+// 0$! 3+.(!4,!.%!*c! a !2a/0a0%*# a* )+*1)!*0a( (+// A"0!. a* %((ka2%/!

)+1*0a%* $%'! 1.%*# +*! +" $%/ a**1a( .!0.!a0/ 0+ S3%06!.(a* T$!++.W%!/!*#.1* A+.*+ /1""!.! a $!a.0 a00ac' 0$a0 ,.+2! "a0a( T$.+1#$+100$! ,.!c!%*# !%#$0!!* )+*0$/ +. /+ A+.*+ $a !*1.! *1)!.+1/c(a//.++) %/.1,0%+*/ a* +cc1,a0%+*/ %* a%0%+* 0+ 3%!/,.!a a*%)+/%05a)+*# )!)b!./ +" 0$! (a.#! /01!*0 ,.+0!/0 )+2!)!*0 3$+/! #.+3%*#)%(%0a*c5 $a (!"0 0$! F.a*'"1.0 0$%*'!. ,.+"+1*(5 c+*c!.*! a* %* a /0a0!+" !40.!)! !,.!//%+* W$%(! +0$!. '!5 0$!+.%/0/ l )+/0 *+0ab(5 H!.b!.0Ma.c1/! b10 a(/+ 5+1*#!. )!)b!./ +" 0$! I*/0%010! /1c$ a/ O/'a. N!#0 a*a0 "%./0 J.#!* Hab!.)a/ l !*+./! 0$! /01!*0/ ac0%+*/ A+.*+/ %*%0%a(/1,,+.0 /++* .!c!! a/ $! ca)! 0+ 2%!3 0$! ,.+0!/0/ a/ /1cc1)b%*# 0+%*c.!a/%*#(5 .!#.!//%2! ba.ba.%c a* "a/c%/0%c )!0$+/ .!,.!/!*0%*# ac+),(!0! /1b+.%*a0%+* +" 0$!+.5 0+ b(%* ,.ac0%c! F+. $%/ /0!a"a/0 .!"1/a(0+ b! 0!..+.%6! %*0+ ac0%+* \ ] A+.*+ $a/ b!!* +"0!* ,+.0.a5!1*/5),a0$!0%ca((5 b5 )a*5 a/ ,+(%0%ca((5 %*!""!c01a( a* !(%0%/0 a )a*a.%*a* a!/0$!0! a* +0$!. a((k0++k"a)%(%a. ca.%ca01.!/ S1c$ %/)%//%2!a,,.+ac$!/ 0+ $%/ 3+.' a.! /0.a*#!(5 .!)%*%/c!*0 +" 0$! 0a1*0/ +" )a*5)!)b!./ +" 0$! /01!*0 ,.+0!/0/ 3$+ 3+1( .!#1(a.(5 %/,(a5 ba**!./!4,.!//%*# /!*0%)!*0/ /1c$ a/ B!.(%*/ (!"0k3%*# "a/c%/0/ #.!!0 T!5 0$!C(a//%c%/0 \c%0! %* M((!.kD++$) ] %.+*%ca((5 a* ,1.,+/!"1((5

%*2+'%*# 0$! %*"a)+1/ 01.* +" ,$.a/! a00.%b10! 0+ Hab!.)a/ \%! `(!"0"a/c%/)] I0 %/ )5 2%!3 a* l %0 3+1( /!!) 0$a*'"1((5 l 0$a0 +" +0$!./0$a0 /1c$ +10.%#$0 .!&!c0%+*/ + a #.!a0 %//!.2%c! 0+ +*! +" 0$! )+/0,.+1c0%2! a* c.%0%ca( )%*/ +" 0$! 03!*0%!0$ c!*01.5

I* 0$! c1..!*0 c+*0!40 .%"! a/ %0 %/ 3%0$ 1*.!(!*0%*# %),+/%0%+*/ +" b.10!-1a*0%"%ca0%+* ,(a**! "%*a*c%a( c10/ 0+ !1ca0%+* !*(!// ,!."+.)a*c! a*`%),ac0 )!a/1.!)!*0 !4!.c%/!/ a* /+ +* %0 %/ /+)!3$a0 %/$!a.0!*%*# 0+*+0! 0$! /%)%(a.%0%!/ b!03!!* 0$! %),a0%!*0 a* )5+,%c !)a*/ +" 0$!

/01!*0/ %* 0$! (a0! / a* 0$+/! +" 0+a5/ a)%*%/0.a0+./ )a*a#!./



7/176

5

b1.!a1c.a0/ a* l *+0 0+ b! "+.#+00!* l ,+(%0%c%a*/ O*! #!0/ 0$! %/0%*c0%),.!//%+* 0$a0 0$! ,.+$%b%0%+* +* 0$%*'%*# \A+.*+ ] b.+1#$0ab+10 b5 0$! ac0%+*%/) +" /01!*0 )+2!)!*0/ %* 0$! ,a/0 "%*/ %0/

c+*0!),+.a.5 c+.+((a.5 %* 0$! !4c!//%2! !)a*/ 0$a0 !2!.5 ,!./+* a*!2!.5 ac0%2%05 b! ca%c.%ab%e 0$!%. !""!c0/ a* .!(!2a*c! %))!%a0!(5%/c!.*%b(! (!/0 0$!%. 2a(1! b! !!)! *!#(%#%b(! I* (%#$0 +" 0$!/! c$a((!*#!/a .!01.* 0+ A+.*+ )a5 ,.+2! 0%)!(5 a* %*2a(1ab(! 0+ 0$+/! %*%2%1a(/3%0$ a* 1*%)%*%/$ab(! 3%/$ 0+ .!/%/0 0$! ,+3!."1( c1..!*0/ +" /+c%!05/"+.!b+%*# 0%!

T+ c+))!)+.a0! 0$! "+.0%!0$ 5!a. /%*c! A+.*+/ ,a//%*# I l 3%0$ 0$!/1,,+.0 +" )5 ".%!*/ a* c+((!a#1!/ a0 0$! U*%2!./%05 +" S1//!4 l +.#a*%/!a c+*"!.!*c! !%ca0! 0+ 0$! )a* $%/ (%"! a* 3+.'/ a* 0+ .!"(!c0 +* $%/(a/0%*# a* 2a.%! (!#ac5 %* 0$! aca!)%c 3+.( a* b!5+* S01!*0/ a*"ac1(05 ".+) a .a*#! +" %*/0%010%+*/ 3!.! %* a00!*a*c! a(( 3%0$ a* ac0%2!%*0!.!/0 %* a//!//%*# 0$! 2a(1! a* c+*0%*1%*# .!(!2a*c! +" A+.*+//1b/0a*0%a( +10,10 A/ /+)!+*! 3$+ %/ ".!-1!*0(5 %),.!//! ".1/0.a0!,.+2+'! )+2! a)1/! \a* b!)1/!] b5 A+.*+/ 0!40/ 0$! "ac0 0$a0$%/ 3+.' /0%(( $a/ )a.'! a,,!a( 0+ a *1)b!. +" ,!+,(! l +"0!* 3+.'%*# %*%2!.#!*0 /1b&!c0 a.!a/ l +!/ *+0 /1.,.%/! )! %* 0$! (!a/0 F+. 0$! ,a/0 "!3!ca!/ *+3 ,a.0%c1(a.(5 "+((+3%*# 0$! ,.+(%"!.a0%+* +" *!3 +. %),.+2!E*#(%/$ 0.a*/(a0%+*/ +" '!5 0!40/ a %2!./! .a*#! +" 0$!+.%/0/ $a2! '!!*(5

c+*0!/0! A+.*+/ (!#ac5 L!a%*# c+*0!),+.a.5 0$%*'!./ 3$+) +*!c+1( &1/0(5 !4,!c0 0+ b! /5),a0$!0%c 0+ $%/ 3+.' l +* acc+1*0 +" 0$!%.c.%0%ca(k0$!+.!0%ca( c.!!*0%a(/ ,!./+*a( c+**!c0%+* a* %*/0%010%+*a(a""%(%a0%+* l $a2! /%*c! 0$! /+kca((! `(%*#1%/0%c 01.* b!c+)! (a.#!(5 $+/0%(!a* %/)%//%2! +" 3$a0 %/ ,!.c!%2! a/ A+.*+/ 1*)%0%#a0! `,!//%)%/)/0a1*c$ *!#a0%2%05 a!/0$!0%c%/) a* a,,a.!*0 a2!./%+* 0+ ,+(%0%ca( ,.a4%/A0 0$! /a)! 0%)! a* ".+) a %""!.!*0 a*#(! ,+/0/0.1c01.a(%/0/ $a2! ac0%2!(50.%! 0+ a,,.+,.%a0! /+)! +" A+.*+/ )+/0 *+0ab(! %!a/ a/ %),+.0a*0,.!c1./+./ 0+ 0$!%. +3* c.%0%ca( ,.+&!c0/ I* a%0%+* 0+ 0$!/! !2!(+,)!*0/

0$!.! a.! *1)!.+1/ (%0!.a.5 c.%0%c/ )1/%c+(+#%/0/ /+c%+(+#%/0/ c1(01.a(0$!+.%/0/ ,+(%0%ca( 0$!+.%/0/ a* +0$!./ 3$+ c+*0%*1! 0+ !*#a#! 3%0$A+.*+/ 0$+1#$0 %* %2!./! 3a5/

T$!.! a.! #++ .!a/+*/ a/ 0+ 3$5 /1c$ a 2a.%!05 +" 0$!+.%/0/ a,,!a. 0+ .!01.*0+ A+.*+ 0%)! a* a#a%* F+. /0a.0!./ 0$! F.a*'"1.0!. /0!a"a/0(5 .!"10!0$! %),+/%0%+* +" .%#% %/c%,(%*a.5 b+1*a.%!/ /!!%*# %* 0$%/ a .!,(%ca0%+*\a* %*"%(0.a0%+*] +" 0$! ,!.2a/%2! %2%/%+* +" (ab+1. %*0+ 3$a0 /$+1( b! a*a10+*+)+1/ aca!)%c .!a() T$%/ %*0!.%/c%,(%*a.%05 a/a'- %a %e--+e %/.!"(!c0! %* $%/ 3.%0%*#/ 3$%c$ /(%! !""+.0(!//(5 ".+) (%0!.a01.! 0+ )1/%c

M*: C+**(* !*



8/176

6 M*: C+**(* !*

".+) ,/5c$+(+#5 0+ ,$%(+/+,$5 ".+) /+c%+(+#5 0+ (a*#1a#! a)+*#c+1*0(!// +0$!. a.!a/ !4$%b%0%*# +"0!* a /0a.0(%*# !,0$ a* b.!a0$ +"'*+3(!#! O* A+.*+/ 3a0c$ *+0$%*# /$+1( b! c+*/%!.! b!5+*

-1!/0%+* +. +""k(%)%0/ "+. /+c%a( c.%0%-1! a* +*! /!!/ 0$%/ +)*%kc.%0%ca( !5!c+*/%/0!*0(5 a0 3+.' %* $%/ 0!40/ I* 0$! %*%)%0ab(!M"'"&a M(+a%"a+*! "%*/c.%0%ca( %*0!.,.!0a0%+*/ +" *+0 +*(5 ca,%0a(%/0 "+.)/ +" /+c%!05 0!c$*+(+#%ca(+)%*a0%+* %*/0.1)!*0a( .!a/+* 3+.'/ +" a.0 ,+/%0%2%/) a* +0$!. /1c$`1/1a( /1/,!c0/ b10 a(/+ +" *1./!.5 .$5)!/ "+.)/ +" $+1/%*# 0!c$*%-1!/+" ++.kc(+/%*# /a/$ 3%*+3/ /(%,,!./ 0$! %a(!c0%c/ +" 0ac0 0$! 1/! +"%c0a0%+* )ac$%*!/ )a..%a#! a* %2+.c! 0$! 3.%0%*# ,.+c!// $a,,%*!//a* /+ %0 #+!/ +* A+.*+/ 0$%*'%*# %/ /+c%a( 0$.+1#$ a* 0$.+1#$ a* a//1c$ .!"1/!/ 0+ %/+(a0! ,$!*+)!*a ".+) %0/ 3%!. c+*0!40 T$%/ %/ b!ca1/!0$! +b&!c0/ +" /015 + *+0 *!a0(5 "%0 %*0+ 0$! ".a)!3+.' +" `0$%/ ,a.0%c1(a.%/c%,(%*! +. `0$a0 a*a(50%ca( (!4%c+* .a0$!. 0$!5 a.! 0$+.+1#$(5 ,(c"a%%2&ed"a-eda* 0$!.!"+.! .!-1%.! a )!0$+ +" a*a(5/%/ 3$%c$ %/ .!"(!4%2! a**+*k.!1c0%2! %* *a01.! T$%/ 0$!* )%#$0 $%*0 a0 0$! '%* +" d"a%ec-"ca%0$%*'%*# 0$a0 A+.*+ a2+ca0!/ *a)!(5 0$+1#$0 0$a0 ,1/$!/ b!5+* %0/!("

b5 2%.01! +" %0/ c+*0.a%c0%+*/ a* !40a*0 %*a!-1ac5 0+ .!,.!/!*0 .!a(%05ac'*+3(!#%*# 0$! "ac0 0$a0 a(( c+*c!,0/ "a%( 0+ "1((5 ca,01.! 0$! +b&!c0 1*!.0$!%. $!a%*#

S1c$ '!5 0$!)!/ %* A+.*+/ 0$+1#$0 3!.! 3!(( !4,(%ca0! a* !2!(+,!

b5 )a*5 +" 0$! /,!a'!./ a0 0$! c+*"!.!*c! T$!.! 3!.! 03+ c+*c1..!*0/!//%+*/ %* 0$! )+.*%*# I 3a/ ,.!/!*0 a0 0$! "%./0 3$!.! P$%(%, H+#$ \a,0(5!*+1#$ ".+) 0$! G+!0$! U*%2!./%090 %* F.a*'"1.0 a) Ma%*] b!#a*,.+c!!%*#/ 3%0$ a* !4c!((!*0 acc+1*0 +" A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 +" (a*#1a#!F+. A+.*+ (a*#1a#! /0a.0/ +10 a/ a '%* +" /!c+* *a01.! c+)%*# %*0+!4%/0!*c! a0 0$! ,+%*0 %* $%/0+.5 3$!.! $1)a* /1b&!c0/ %/0%*#1%/$0$!)/!(2!/ ".+) *a01.! Y!0 (a*#1a#! %/ *+0 +*(5 a )!a*/ +" /0.%2%*# "+.%*0!./1b&!c0%2! c+))1*%ca0%+* I0 a(/+ 0.a*/"+.)/ 0$! /1b&!c0/ %**!. *a01.!0$!.!b5 .!"10%*# a*5 *a01.a(%/0 .!1c0%+* +" /1b&!c0%2%05 F.+) 0$%/ %*%0%a(

,+%*0 +" !,a.01.! H+#$ #+!/ +* 0+ $%#$(%#$0 0$! 3a5/ %* 3$%c$ "+. A+.*+(a*#1a#! %/ a(/+ a 0++( +" /+c%a( +)%*a0%+* ,a.0%c1(a.(5 3%0$%* (a0! ca,%0a(%/0/+c%!05 3$!.! c!.0a%* ,a00!.*/ +" c+))1*%ca0%+* a* 1/!/ +" (a*#1a#!\`%/c+1./!/ 3! 3+1( /a5 0+a5] /!0 ,a.a)!0!./ +" ac0%+* a* 0$+1#$0T$! "%*a( ,a.0 +" H+#$/ ,.!/!*0a0%+* !2!(+,! 0$! !2!. %*0.%#1%*# a*/+)!3$a0 !(a/0%c c+*c!,0 +" `c+*/0!((a0%+* %* .!(a0%+* 0+ A+.*+/ c.%0%-1!+" (a*#1a#! F+. H+#$ (a*#1a#! .!,.!/!*0/ a "+.c!k"%!( ^K+af-fe%d_ a (+c1/+" 0!*/%+* a* !*!.#5 %* 3$%c$ /1b&!c0 a* +b&!c0 $%/0+.5 a* *a01.! a*

b+5 a* )%* +2!.(a, a* 3$!.! /1b&!c0%2! !4,.!//%+* ca* +cc1. a(+*#3%0$ /+c%a( ac'*+3(!#!)!*0 T$! ,a,!. a,,!a./ %* 0$%/ 2+(1)! a* %/ a



9/176

7

3!(c+)! a%0%+* 0+ 0$! (%0!.a01.! +* 0$! /1b&!c0

R%c$a. S0+,"+. \D1.$a)] #a2! a* %*0!.!/0%*# ,a,!. +* A+.*+ a*

.$!0+.%c 3$%c$ .!3 1,+* a* c.%0%-1! !(!)!*0/ +" J M B!.*/0!%*/a*a(5/%/ +" 0$! %//1! F+. A+.*+ 0$! !4,.!//%2! a* ,!."+.)a0%2! a/,!c0/+" .$!0+.%c b.%*# a00!*0%+* 0+ 0$! &a-e+"a% c('-e'-+" /1b&!c0%2! !4,!.%!*c! a*a.! 0$1/ )1c$ )+.! 0$a* )!.! /05(%/0%c c+*c!.*/ S0+,"+. a.#1!/ 0$a0 0$!c+*0%*1! 1/! +" .$!0+.%c %* ,$%(+/+,$%ca( !*-1%.5 #1a./ a#a%*/0 0$!+.!0%ca(/5/0!)a0%6%*# a*j+. %a(!c0%ca( /0a#*a0%+* %* +0$!. 3+./ .$!0+.%c $a/ a*!//!*0%a( ,a.0 0+ ,(a5 %* )a%*0a%*%*# a 'ea-"/e %a(!c0%c/ S1c$ a*0%k/5/0!)a0%c ,$%(+/+,$%ca( 3+.' %/ a .!c1..!*0 )a*%"!/0a0%+* 0$.+1#$+10A+.*+/ c.%0%ca( 0$%*'%*#

La1.a F%*c$ \S1//!4] !4,!.0(5 .!3 a00!*0%+* 0+ 0$! %),+.0a*c! +" A+.*+/,.+/! /05(! 3$%c$ \!2!* 0$.+1#$ ,.+b(!)a0%c 0.a*/(a0%+*/] .!*!./ "+.) a*c+*0!*0 ab/+(10!(5 %*/!,a.ab(! T$%/ %/ )+/0 c(!a.(5 !4$%b%0! %* A+.*+/,.+2+ca0%2! a* ,1.,+/!(5 1*/!00(%*# 1/! +" !4a##!.a0%+* .!,!0%0%+* a* 0$!a,$+.%/0%c "+.) F%*c$ ,.+2%!/ /+)! !4c!((!*0 !4a),(!/ +" /1c$ 0!c$*%-1!/a0 3+.' 0$.+1#$ c(+/! .!a%*#/ +" '!5 0!40/ ,a.0%c1(a.(5 D"a%ec-"c (fE'%"!-e'&e'- a* M"'"&a M(+a%"a S$! a.#1!/ 0$a0 A+.*+ !),(+5/ a`$+)!+,a0$%c (+#%c %* $%/ /+c%a( c.%0%-1! T$%/ (+#%c %/ *!a0(5 ca,01.! %* 0$!(%*! A+.*+ c%0!/ ".+) Wa#*!./ Pa+,"fa% O*(5 0$! /,!a. 0$a0 /)+0! 5+1 ca*

$!a( 5+1. 3+1* T$.+1#$ %*#!/0%*# 0$! .!%"%ca0%+* %*"(%c0! 1,+* 0$!/1b&!c0 l 0$! a)a#! "+.) +" (%"! %/ a"0!. a(( %*!/ca,ab(! l a* .!,(%ca0%*# %03%0$%* $%/ 1*,.!%c0ab(! a* `a)a#! ,.+/! A+.*+ a00!),0/ 0+ .!!!)/+)! '%* +" )!a*%*# 2a(1! a* ,+//%b%(%05 +10 +" 0$! !4%/0%*# \.!%"%! a*%*a!-1a0!] "+.)/ +" (a*#1a#! a* ,10 %0 0+ 3+.' %* 0$! #1%/! +" /+c%a(c.%0%-1!

Ja)!/ R+3!(( \E//!4] )a%*0a%*! 0$! $%#$ -1a(%05 +" .!/!a.c$ b!%*#,.!/!*0! 3%0$ $%/ ,a,!. (++'%*# a0 A+.*+/ c.%0%-1! +" K%!.'!#aa./ `!0$%c/

+" (+2! R+3!(( /+1#$0 0+ .!2%/%0 A+.*+/ c.%0%c%/)/ %* +.!. 0+ ,.+2+'! a"1((!. .!/,+*/! ".+) K%!.'!#aa.%a* /c$+(a./ 3$+) $! "!!(/ 0+ a0! $a2!+*(5 /1,!."%c%a((5 %/)%//! 0$! c.%0%c%/)/ A+.*+ *+0 +*(5 c.%0%c%6!/ 0$!ab/0.ac0 %*3a.*!// +" K%!.'!#aa./ !0$%c/ b10 $! a(/+ "%*/ /1c$ a* !0$%c/+" (+2! 0+ b! %*a!-1a0! %* (%#$0 +" 0$! /+c%a( c+*%0%+*/ +" 3$%c$ K%!.'!#aa.%/ +0$!.3%/! ac10!(5 a3a.! a* (a.#!(5 c.%0%ca( T$1/ 3$a0 %/ .!-1%.!acc+.%*# 0+ R+3!((/ acc+1*0 %/ a )+.! .+b1/0 .!,(5 0+ A+.*+k%*/,%.!c.%0%c%/)/ *a)!(5 0$a0 0$! %/c.!,a*c5 b!03!!* K%!.'!#aa./ ab/0.ac0!0$%c/ +* 0$! +*! $a* a* $%/ )a0!.%a( /+c%a( c.%0%-1! +* 0$! +0$!. b!,.+,!.(5 a.!//!

M*: C+**(* !*



10/176

8 M*: C+**(* !*

I* 0$! "%./0 +" 0$! !40!*! /!//%+*/ N%c$+(a/ J+(( \O,!* U*%2!./%05],.!/!*0! a c+((!c0%+* +" %!a/ 0$a0 .!,.!/!*0 a /!("k,.+c(a%)! `3+.'k%*k,.+#.!// J+((/ %*0!.!/0 %/ %* 0.5%*# 0+ 1*!./0a* 0$! *+0%+*/ +" de-e+&"'a-"('

a* def(+&a-"('a0 3+.' %* A+.*+ T$!.! a.! )a*5 ,(ac!/ %* A+.*+/3.%0%*# 3$!.! $! /,!a'/ +" /1b&!c0/ a* +b&!c0/ b!%*# !0!.)%*! +.!"+.)! J+(( ,.+2%!/ *1)!.+1/ c%0a0%+*/ 3$%c$ *%c!(5 %((1/0.a0! 0$%/,+%*0 H+3!2!. 0$! )a%* c+*c!.* "+. J+(( %/ 0$a0 %" A+.*+ $+(/ c!.0a%*0$%*#/ 0+ b! %* /+)! 3a5 !0!.)%*! +. !"+.)! 0$!* 1*!. 3$a0c+*%0%+*/ ca* /1c$ c(a%)/ b! )a! O. ,10 %""!.!*0(5 %" 3! acc!,0 0$!c+*c(1/%+* 0$a0 1%/ !"+.)! 0$!* 3$a0 3+1( a* 1*k!"+.)! 1(++' (%'!T$!/! a.! c(!a.(5 c+),(!4 %//1!/ a* %*!! 0$! %/c1//%+* 0$a0 "+((+3!0$! ,.!/!*0a0%+* 3a/ (%2!(5 A* a1#)!*0! 2!./%+* +" 0$%/ !4c!((!*0 ,a,!.a,,!a./ a"0!. 0$%/ .!,+.0

P.+"!//+. Ma4 Pa%/+* \D1.$a)] #a2! a* %*0!.!/0%*# a* 0$+1#$0"1(,!./,!c0%2! +* /+)! +" A+.*+/ '!5 3.%0%*#/ ,a.0%c1(a.(5 %* .!(a0%+* 0+ 0$!0.+1b(! b%+#.a,$%ca( c+*0!40 %* 3$%c$ 0$!5 3!.! 3.%00!* F+. Pa%/+*a"0!. 0$! .%/! +" "a/c%/) %* G!.)a*5 +*! ca* /!! 0$! c+*%0%+* +" !4%(! a/ !2!.k,.!/!*0 %* A+.*+/ 0$%*'%*# T$%/ !4%(%c c+*%0%+* b.%*#/ a /0.+*# /!*/! +")a0!.%a(%/) 0+ 0$! +0$!.3%/! ab/0.ac0 c+*c!,0 +" 0$! *+*k%!*0%ca( 3$%c$

b!ca)! /+ c!*0.a( 0+ A+.*+/ (a0!. ,$%(+/+,$5 3$%c$ c1()%*a0! %* Nea-"/eD"a%ec-"c,

P.+"!//+. A(!4a*!. Ga.;=a D00)a** \G+(/)%0$/] ,.!/!*0! a ,.+2+ca0%2!,a,!. 3$%c$ .!3 1,+* /+)! +" A+.*+/ *+0!/ +* Ka"'a %* +.!. 0+ !4,(+.!0$! %""%c1(0%!/ 0$a0 acc+),a*5 a00!),0/ a0 .!,.!/!*0%*# +. %*0!.,.!0%*#Ka"'a/ 0!40/ F+. A+.*+ 0$! 0!40 %0/!(" %/ %*0!#.a( 0+ 0$! +2!.a(( %/-1%!0%*#!""!c0/ +*! +"0!* "!!(/ 1,+* !*c+1*0!.%*# Ka"'a/ 3+.' A*5 a00!),0 0+.!*!. Ka"'a/ 3+.'/ %* 2%/1a( +. "%#1.a( .!,.!/!*0a0%+*/ %/ +* A+.*+/acc+1*0 a /%#* +" `%((%0!.ac5 D00)a** a.#1!/ a#a%*/0 /1c$ a ,.+$%b%0%2!2%!3 a* !4a)%*!/ O./+* W!((!/ "%() 2!./%+* +" T!e T+"a% W$%(! W!((!/ %/

0+ b! c.!%0! "+. .!/%/0%*# 0$! 1.#! 0+ /(a2%/$(5 1,(%ca0! 3$a0 0$! (%0!.a(3+./ +* 0$! ,a#! c+*2!5 $%/ "%()%c 0!c$*%-1! a* 2%.01+/%05 1(0%)a0!(5/!.2! 0+ .!(!#a0! 0$! 0!40/ (%0!.a( )!a*%*# 0+ a /!c+*a.5 .+(! T$%//1b+.%*a0%+* +" 0$! (%0!.a( %/ a(/+ 0+ b! "+1* %* ,$%(+/+,$%ca(%*0!.,.!0a0%+*/ +" 0$! 0!40 %*a/)1c$ a/ 0$!5 )a'! 1/! +" 0$! !4%/0%*#/!*0!*c!/ )!.!(5 a/ a )!a*/ +" a00a%*%*# )!0a,$+.%ca( %*/%#$0/ l 0$a0 %/ 0+/a5 0$!5 0.a*/,+/! 0$! (%0!.a( )!a*%*# %*0+ a "%#1.a0%2! )!a*%*# A/ .!a!./+" 0$! 0!40 3! ca**+0 %#*+.! 0$! (%0!.a(*!// +" 0$! (!00!. \(!/0 3! .%/' #!00%*#100!.(5 (+/0] 5!0 a0 0$! /a)! 0%)! 3! + *+0 /%),(5 .!/0 c+*0!*0 +*c! 0$!(%0!.a( )!a*%*# +" 0$! /!*0!*c!/ $a/ b!!* c+),.!$!*! F+. D00)a**



11/176

9

!2!* 0$! +,!*%*# /!*0!*c! +" T!e T+"a%%/ a(.!a5 !*+1#$ %* %0/!(" 0+ ,.+2+'!.!"(!c0%+* +* 0$! ,a.0 +" 0$! .!a!. 0$! (%!/ b!%*# 0+( ab+10 J+/!,$ K 0$!,.+0a#+*%/0/ a,,a.!*0 %**+c!*c! 0$! a*+*5)%05j1*c!.0a%*05 +" 0$!

*a..a0+./ %!*0%05 a(( /!.2! 0+ )a'! 1/ -1!/0%+* 0$! /!*0!*c!/ (%0!.a()!a*%*# 0.10$ a* acc1.ac5 T$! (%"! +" 0$! (!00!. %* Ka"'a !/0ab%(%6!/ 0$!.!a!./ ,+/%0%+* 0$.+1#$ 0$! (!00!./ !!.%! /!*/! +" "a)%(%a.%05 a* %0/%..!1c%b(! (%0!.a(*!// 0$a0 !)a*/ "1.0$!. %*0!..+#a0%+* a* .!"(!c0%+* 5!03%0$+10 ,.+)%/! +" a /%*#(! !!, )!a*%*# a3a%0%*# 0!401a( !4ca2a0%+* a*,$%(+/+,$%ca( !4,(%ca0%+*

I* 0$! "%*a( '!5*+0! ,.!/!*0a0%+* D.!3 M%(*! \Ca)b.%#!] #a2! a*%),.!//%2! a* +.%#%*a( !4,+/%0%+* +* A+.*+/ 1/! +" #.a))a. %* a.#1)!*0T$.+1#$ a c(+/! .!a%*# +" a "!3 *+0ab(! ,a//a#!/ %* A+.*+/ 3.%0%*# M%(*!%//!c0! 0$! c+),(%ca0! (!4%ca( 1/!/ a* #.a))a0%ca( /0.1c01.!/ !),(+5!

b5 A+.*+ S1c$ c+),(!4 /0.1c01.!/ a* ".a#)!*0! /!*0!*c!/ +"0!*"+.#+%*# !40!*/%2! ,1*c01a0%+* %* a%0%+* 0+ 3%!/,.!a 1/! +" c$%a/)1/a* ,a.a0a4%/ /!.2! 0+ c.!a0! 0$! %)a#! +" a /%*#1(a. /!("k/1/0a%*%*#a10+*+)+1/ 0!401a( +b&!c0 O* acc+1*0 +" 0$!/! )101a((5 /1,,+.0%2! a*/!("k,!.,!01a0%*# "(+3/ a* /0.1c01.!/ A+.*+/ 0!40/ ca* b! /a% 0+ a%)0+3a./ ac$%!2%*# 0$! '%* +" ab/+(10! c+))+%"%ca0%+* 0$a0 $! ,.a%/! %*#!*1%*! 3+.'/ +" a.0 T$! #.a))a0%ca( "+.)/ 0$.+1#$ 3$%c$ A+.*+/ %!a/a.! ,.!/!*0! b!c+)! 0$!)/!(2!/ a* %*2a(1ab(! ,a.0 +" 0$! ,$%(+/+,$%ca(

a.#1)!*0

A0 0$! ,.!/!*0 0%)! %* .!(a0%+* 0+ a 3$+(! $+/0 +" ,.+,+/! "%*a*c%a( c10/a* .!/0.1c01.%*# %* $%#$!. !1ca0%+* 0$!.! %/ a#a%* #.!a0 1*.!/0 a* ,.+0!/0a)+*# /01!*0/ ac.+// 0$! #(+b! 3$+ .%#$0(5 ,!.c!%2! 0$! /$+.0k/%#$0!*!//+" /1c$ ,.+,+/a(/ Y!0 3$%(! 2+%c%*# c+*c!.*/ %.!c0(5 a* "+.#%*# a,$5/%ca( ,.!/!*c! %* ".+*0 +" 0$+/! .!/,+*/%b(! "+. 0$! c10/ %/ 1*!*%ab(5*!c!//a.5 %0 %/ a(/+ (%'!(5 0$a0 *+ )!0$+ +" ,.+0!/0 3%(( b! !""!c0%2! +* %0/+3* 0$a0 %/ %* %/+(a0%+* ".+) +0$!./ B1/%*!// %!+(+#1!/ 3%(( +"0!* #%2!

%*/0.1c0%+*/ 0+ 0ac'(! a ,.+b(!) `$!a +* b10 0$! )+.! ca**5 a,,.+ac$*!!! %* .!/,+*/! 0+ 0$! ,.!/!*0 0$.!a0/ 3%(( c+*/%/0 +" )a*5 %""!.!*0c+*".+*0a0%+*/ a,,.+ac$%*# ".+) )1(0%,(! a*#(!/ a c(',-e%%a-"('+" c.%0%ca(%*0!.2!*0%+*/ +*! )%#$0 /a5 U*"(%*c$%*# c.%0%c%/) a* .%#+.+1/ 0$!+.5 3%((,(a5 a* !//!*0%a( .+(! %* .!/%/0%*# 0$! .!#.!//%2! /(%! %*0+ b.10!-1a*0%"%ca0%+*

O*! +" 0$! #.!a0 /1cc!//!/ +" 0$! c+*"!.!*c! 3a/ 0$a0 %0 !""!c0%2!(5 a*,!."+.)a0%2!(5 %/,(a5! 0$a0 c.%0%ca( 0$!+.5 b5 %0/ 2!.5 *a01.! l %0/`c.%0%ca(*!// l a(3a5/ ,+%*0/ b!5+* %0/!(" T$! *!#a0%2%05 +" 0$%*'%*# %/

M*: C+**(* !*



12/176

M*: C+**(* !*10

.!/0(!// ,a.0%a( a* *!2!. /a0%/"ac0+.5 a* a/ /1c$ 0$+1#$0 "+.!2!.c$a((!*#!/ 0$a0 3$%c$ 3+1( 0.5 0+ /0%"(! +)%*a0! +. !.a%ca0! %0 I*M"'"&a

M(+a%"aA+.*+ 3.+0! 0$a0 T.1! 0$+1#$0/ a.! 0$+/! a(+*! 3$%c$ + *+0

1*!./0a* 0$!)/!(2!/ \ ^_ h] T$%/ a((1!/ 0+ +" c+1./! 0$!105 +" *+0 `"%00%*# %* 3%0$ 0$! !)a*/ +" a ba /+c%!05 *+0 a&1/0%*# +..!1c%*# +*!/!(" a* +*!/ 0$+1#$0 0+ 0$! +)%*a*0 /0a01/ -1+ B10 c.1c%a((5%0 a(/+ 0!/0%"%!/ 0+ 0$! %*!"a0%#ab%(%05 +" 0$+1#$0 %0/!(" A)% 0$! 1*/!00(%*#c+*%0%+*/ 3! ,.!/!*0(5 "%* +1./!(2!/ %* A+.*+/ 0$%*'%*# .!)a%*/ a/%*2%#+.a0%*# ,.!/c%!*0 a* ,.+2+ca0%2! a/ !2!.

S"&(' M.,,e%% ,?)?&.,,e%%,.,,e1?ac?.$ %/ R!2%!3/ a* S,!c%a( I//1!/E%0+. "+. SSPTa* a DP$%( ca*%a0! %* S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca( T$+1#$0 a0 0$!U*%2!./%05 +" S1//!4 H%/ .!/!a.c$ !4,(+.!/ A+.*%a* c.%0%ca( 0$!+.5 a*"%()

E'd'(-e,

T$! $%/0+.5 +" /01!*0 a*%)+/%05 0+3a./ A+.*+ ac01a((5 !40!*/ !2!* "1.0$!.bac' I* Ma5 /01!*0/ %/0.%b10! a `Wa*0! ,+/0!. 0$a0 "!a01.! a )+*0a#!+" A+.*+ -1+0!/ a/ a 3a5 +" .!#%/0!.%*# 0$!%. %/a,,.+2a( +" 3$a0 0$!5 /a3 a/ 0$!%/c.!,a*c5 b!03!!* a*a(5/%/ a* ac0%+* J1/0 )+*0$/ b!"+.! $%/ !a0$ %* a/01!*0 $a 3.%00!* +* 0$! b+a. %* +*! +" A+.*+/ (!c01.! 0$!a0.!/ W!. *1. !*(%!b!* A+.*+ (90 3a(0!* !. 3%. !* Ka,%0a(%/)1/ /!%* L!b!* (a*# b!3a(0!*

^W$+!2!. #%2!/ !a. A+.*+ c+*0.+( 3%(( ,.!/!.2! ca,%0a(%/) "+. 0$! .!/0 +" $%/ (%"!_\L!/(%! ]

L!00!. ".+) A+.*+ 0+ Ma.c1/! a0! J1*! \.!,.+1c! %* L!/(%! ]

F+. %*/0a*c! J.#!* Hab!.)a/ A(b.!c$0 W!(()!. a* A4!( H+**!0$

O* S!,0!)b!. 1,+* .!c!%2%*# 0$! ,.!/0%#%+1/ A+.*+ ,.%6! ".+) F.a*'"1.0Jac-1!/ D!..%a /a% 0$! "+((+3%*# %* $%/ acc!,0a*c! /,!!c$ I $!a. 2+%c!/ a/ %* a.!a) _ T$!5 a(( /!!) 0+ /a5 0+ )! 3$5 +*0 5+1 .!c+#*%/! c(!a.(5 a* ,1b(%c(5

+*c! a* "+. a(( 0$! a""%*%0%!/ +" 5+1. 3+.' 3%0$ 0$a0 +" A+.*+ %* 0.10$ 5+1. !b00+3a./ A+.*+ \ ] La0!. %* 0$! /a)! /,!!c$ D!..%a .!"!./ 0+ A+.*+\a""!c0%+*a0!(5] a/ $%/ )8+e dad()-"(' \%b% ] O*! a(/+ .!ca((/ M%c$!( F+1ca1(0/a)%//%+* 0+ 3%0 ^I_" I $a b!!* "a)%(%a. 3%0$ 0$! F.a*'"1.0 Sc$++( ^ _ I 3+1(*+0 $a2! /a% a *1)b!. +" /01,% 0$%*#/ 0$a0 I % /a5 a* I 3+1( $a2! a2+%!)a*5 +" 0$! !0+1./ 3$%c$ I )a! 3$%(! 0.5%*# 0+ ,1./1! )5 +3* $1)b(! ,a0$\F+1ca1(0 K.%06)a* ]

O" c+1./! 0$! 0!.) `%/c%,(%*! %0/!(" l %* a%0%+* 0+ %0/ )!a*%*# a/ a b.a*c$ +"'*+3(!#! l $a/ a(0!.*a0%2! c+**+0a0%+*/ 0$a0 \,!.$a,/ /+)!3$a0 0!((%*#(5] %*2+'!,+3!. c+))a*)!*0 ,1*%/$)!*0 c$a/0%/!)!*0 0$! %),+/%0%+* +" +.!.



13/176

11

+b!%!*c! a* /+ +* D!.%2%*# ".+) 0$! La0%* d",c")%"'a \.!"!..%*# 0+ 0$! %*/0.1c0%+*+" %/c%,(!/ b5 !(!./] +*! +" %0/ !a.(%!/0 1/!/ %* 0$%/ $%!.a.c$%ca( a* %*/0.1c0%+*a(c+*0!40 ca)! a"0!. 0$! P.+0!/0a*0 R!"+.)a0%+* %* 0$! "+.) +" 0$! `D%/c%,(%*! +" 0$!S!c.!0 3$%c$ !/c.%b! $+3 0$! !a.(5 C$.%/0%a* C$1.c$ .%#%(5 0a1#$0 ,.%*c%,(!/ +"

"a%0$ 0+ c+*2!.0/ 3$%(! !*5%*# 0$!/! 0!ac$%*#/ 0+ 0$! 1*%*%0%a0!j$!a0$!*/ A(+*#Ha.%a*/ Wa(( 0$!.! !4%/0/ a* a(0a. 0+ 0$! R+)a* #+!// D",c")%"'a 0$!,!./+*%"%ca0%+* +" %/c%,(%*! P!.$a,/ +0$!. `a(0a./ 0+ %/c%,(%*! )%#$0 b! "+1* *!a."1*%*# ,a*!(/ "+. .!/!a.c$ c+1*c%(/

I 3+1( (%'! 0+ 0a'! 0$%/ +,,+.01*%05 0+ !40!* )5 $!a.0"!(0 0$a*'/ 0+ !2!.5+*! 3$+a00!*! 0$! A+.*+ c+*"!.!*c! a* $!(,! 0+ )a'! 0$! !2!*0 /1c$ a /1cc!// I a),a.0%c1(a.(5 #.a0!"1( 0+ 0$+/! 3$+ ,.!/!*0! +* 0$! a5 )a*5 +" 3$+) 0.a2!((!".+) "a. a"%!( a* a0 0$!%. +3* !4,!*/! %* +.!. 0+ c+*0.%b10! T$a*' 5+1 0+ A(!4D00)a** Ma4 Pa%/+* D.!3 M%(*! C$.%/ C10.+*! N%c$+(a/ J+(( J+/$ R+b%*/+*

P$%(%, H+#$ R%c$a. S0+,"+. La1.a F%*c$ C$.%/ OKa*! Da*%!( K1c$(!. Ja)!/R+3!(( C$.%/ A((/+b.++' G+.+* F%*(a5/+* K!/0+* S10$!.(a* C$a.(!/Ma/-1!(%!. a* D+1# Ha5*!/

B"b%"(+a)!2

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] R!/%#*a0%+* %* J M B!.*/0!%* \!] T!e C.%-.+e I'd.,-+2Se%ec-ed E,,a2, (' Ma,, C.%-.+e L+*+* R+10(!#! \k]

A+.*+ T$!++. W \ _]M"'"&a M(+a%"a Ref%ec-"(', (' a Da&aed L"fe ^0.a*/

E F N J!,$c+00_ L+*+* V!./+D!..%a Jac-1!/ \] F"c!., Pa.%/ Ga(%(

F+1ca1(0 M%c$!( K.%06)a* La3.!*c! D \!] \] P(%"-"c, P!"%(,()!2 C.%-.+eI'-e+/"e0, a'd O-!e+ W+"-"', ?? L+*+* R+10(!#!

L!/(%! E/0$!. \] I*0.+1c0%+* 0+ A+.*+jMa.c1/! C+..!/,+*!*c! +* 0$!G!.)a* S01!*0 M+2!)!*0 Ne0 Lef- Re/"e0 Ij \Ja*kF!b] k

M((!.kD++$) S0!"a* \]Ad(+'( A B"(+a)!2 ^0.a*/ R L%2%*#/0+*!_ Ca)b.%#!

P+(%05

M*: C+**(* !*



14/176

Ga), A' I'*."+2 "'-( De-e+&"'a-"(' a'dDef(+&a-"(' "' Ad(+'(

b5 N%c$+(a/ J+((

Ab,-+ac-

T$%/ a.0%c(! ,.+,+/!/ a* !4,(+.!/ a $5,+0$!/%/ ab+10 /+)!c(a%)/ )a! b5 A+.*+ T$! c(a%)/ a0 %//1! a,,!a. 0+ a((!#!%* a 3a5 0$a0 %/ $a. 0+ 1*!./0a* 0$a0 b!%*#/ %* )+!.*%05

a.! !"+.)! T$! $5,+0$!/%/ %/ 0$a0 A+.*+/ c+*c!,0%+* +")!%a0%+* %((1)%*a0!/ 0$a0 %!a F+. A+.*%a* )!%a0%+*/!!)/ 0+ b+! a* acc+1*0 +" 0$! !0!.)%*a0%+* +" b!%*#/ l +"$+3 b!%*#/ a.! a/ 0$!5 a.! l 0$a0 3%(( !4,(%ca0! $%/ c(a%)/ ab+10

b!%*#/ !"+.)a0%+* Ac0%*# +* 0$a0 $5,+0$!/%/ 0$! ,a,!.!4,(+.!/ A+.*+/ 2%!3/ ab+10 c+*c!,01a( )!%a0%+* \a*0$!.!b5 0$a0 3$%c$ A+.*+ ca((/ 0$! ,.%+.%05 +" 0$! +b&!c0] a*$%/ 2%!3/ ab+10 /+c%a( )!%a0%+* I "%* 0$a0 0$+/! 2%!3/ +*+0 %* "ac0 !4,(a%* 0$! 05,! +" !"+.)a0%+* a0 %//1! B10 I a.#1!0$a0 0$!.! %/ )+.! 0$a* +*! 3a5 %* 3$%c$ +*! )%#$0 %*0!.,.!0

0$a0 *!#a0%2! .!/1(0

I'-+(d.c-"('

T$%/ ,a,!. %/ ab+10 a ,166(! 3%0$%* A+.*+/ 3+.' T$! ,166(! c+*c!.*/0$! %*0!.,.!0a0%+* +" c!.0a%* c(a%)/ ab+10 !"+.)a0%+* I b!#%* \h] b5,.!/!*0%*# 0$! ,166(! a* b5 +10(%*%*# a ,+//%b(! /+(10%+* 0+ %0 T$a0 /+(10%+*01.*/ 1,+* 0$a0 3$%c$ I /$a(( ca(( `!0!.)%*a0%+* I ,.+c!! \h] 0+ 0.5 0+

)a'! #++ 1,+* 0$! /+(10%+* F%*a((5 \h] I .!"(!c0 1,+* 3$a0 $a/ b!!*ac$%!2! T$a0 .!"(!c0%+* 3%(( !4,(a%* 0$! ,.!/!*c! +" 0$! 3+. `#a,/ %* )50%0(!

8? Ad(+'( a'd def(+&a-"(' a ).33%e a'd a !2)(-!e,",

(+( The p#''le

M5 ,+%*0 +" !,a.01.! %/ a c+((!c0%+* +" c(a%)/ )a! b5 A+.*+ W$a0 0$!c(a%)/ a.! ab+10 %/ %* a /!*/! 0$! 2!.5 -1!/0%+* I /$a(( b! a/'%*# I *+0! a0



15/176

13

0$! +10/!0 0$+1#$ 0$a0 0$!5 a.! c(a%)/ ab+10 )+!.*%05 `M+!.*%05 %* 0$!.!(!2a*0 /!*/! %*c(1!/ 0$+1#$ %/ *+0 (%)%0! 0+ )1c$ +" 0$! 03!*0%!0$c!*01.5 %*1/0.%a(%/! W!/0!.* 3+.( 0+ 3$%c$ A+.*+ 3a/ c+*0!),+.a.5

I $a2! a +6!* c(a%)/ %* )%* \a(0$+1#$ a .a*#! +" +0$!. c(a%)/ %* A+.*+a.! %* 2a.%+1/ 3a5/ c+),a.ab(!] T$+/! 03!(2! c(a%)/ 3$%c$ +3! )+/0(50+ D"a%ec-"c (f E'%"!-e'&e'-a* 0+ Nea-"/e D"a%ec-"c, a.! a/ "+((+3/

^N_a01.! b!c+)!/_ )!.! +b&!c0%2%05 b%(:e Ob#e$-"/"-5-_ \DE j GS ]

Ab/0.ac0%+* 0$! %*/0.1)!*0 +" !*(%#$0!*)!*0 0.!a0/ %0/ +b&!c0/a/ % "a0! 0$! *+0%+* +" 3$%c$ %0 !.a%ca0!/ %0 (%-1%a0!/ 0$!)

\DE j GS ]

T$! !)+*%ca((5 %/0+.0! "+.) ^D5&('e'!af- /e+3e++-eGe,-a%-_ 3$%c$ 0$%*#/ a* $1)a* b!%*#/ $a2! 0a'!* +* %* 0$!c(!a. (%#$0 +" 1*,.!&1%c! '*+3(!#! ^ _ \DE j GS ]

T$!.! %/ a /1b&!c0%+* +" .!a(%05 0+ (+#%ca( "+.)a(%/) \DE jGS ]

B!%*# %/ a,,.!$!*! %* 0!.)/ +" )a*%,1(a0%+* a*a)%*%/0.a0%+* E2!.50$%*#m%*c(1%*# 0$! %*%2%1a( $1)a*b!%*# *+0 0+ )!*0%+* 0$! a*%)a(mb!c+)!/ a .!,!a0ab(!.!,(ac!ab(! ,.+c!// a )!.! !4a),(! +" 0$! c+*c!,01a( )+!(/+" 0$! /5/0!) \DE j GS ]

^T_$! !4c$a*#! .!(a0%+* ^ _ !-1a((5 !"+.)/ def(+&"e+-_ )!*a* 0$%*#/ \MM j GS ]

^O_b&!c0/ $a2! ".+6!* %* 0$! c+( (%#$0 +" .!a/+* \MM j

GS ]

A*5 +*0+(+#5 0+a5 )1/0 b! a* +*0+(+#5 +" 0$! 3.+*# /0a0!+" 0$%*#/ ^d"e O'-(%("e de, fa%,c!e' Z.,-a'de,_ \ND j GS ]

W$a0 %/ %/ )+.! 0$a* %0 %/ T$%/ )+.! %/ *+0 %),+/! 1,+* %0b10 .!)a%*/ %))a*!*0 0+ %0 a/ 0$a0 3$%c$ $a/ b!!* ,1/$! +10+" %0 \ND j GS ]

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



16/176

14 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

T$! 1*%2!./a( +)%*a0%+* +" )a*'%* b5 !4c$a*#! 2a(1! la+)%*a0%+* 3$%c$ a ,.%+.% '!!,/ 0$! /1b&!c0/ ".+) b!%*#/1b&!c0/ a* !#.a!/ /1b&!c0%2%05 %0/!(" 0+ a )!.! +b&!c0 _

\ND j GS ]

T$%*#/ c+*#!a( a/ ".a#)!*0/ +" 0$a0 3$%c$ 3a/ /1b&1#a0!\ND j GS ]

^A_* %!*0%05 0$a0 %* !),%.%ca( .!a(%05 %/ 2%+(!*0(5 "+.c! +*a(( +b&!c0/ a/ %!*0%05 3%0$ 0$! ^$1)a*_ /1b&!c0 a* 0$1/0.a2!/0%! \AT j GS ]

T$! c(a%)/ a//!.0 a !"+.)a0%+* M+.! acc1.a0!(5 a0 (!a/0 )a*5 +" 0$! c(a%)/

a//!.0 !%0$!. /+)!0$%*# (%'! !"+.)a0%+* +. /+)!0$%*# 0$a0 %* /+)! 3a53+1( 3a..a*0 0$! 0!.) `!"+.)a0%+* T.1! +*(5 +*! c(a%) \0$! /%40$]/,!a'/ %.!c0(5 +" !"+.)a0%+* B10 0$! +0$!. c(a%)/ )a'! )!*0%+* +"%/0+.0%+* +" !#.aa0%+* +" `".!!6%*# a* +" +0$!. /%)%(a. 0!.)/ +. %!a/S+ 0$!.! %/ /1""%c%!*0 &1/0%"%ca0%+* I /1b)%0 "+. )5 /0a0!)!*0 0$a0 0$! c(a%)/a//!.0 a !"+.)a0%+* \a* I /$a(( 3.%0! $!*c!"+.0$ +" `0$! !"+.)a0%+*c(a%)/] A/ 0+ 0$! ,(+-+" !"+.)a0%+* 0$a0 0$! c(a%)/ a((!#! I ,.+,+/! 0$!"+((+3%*# T$! c(a%)/ +. a0 (!a/0 /+)! +" 0$!) a((!#! a !"+.)a0%+* 0$a0 %/\]('-"c \]/e+2 e'e+a% a* \]dee)

T$! c(a%)/ a.! ('-"c 0+ 0$! !40!*0 0$a0 0$!5 a((!#! a !"+.)a0%+* *+0 +" +. *+0)!.!(5 +" 0$! a,,.!$!*/%+* +" !*0%0%!/ b10 +" !*0%0%!/ 0$!)/!(2!/ T.1!/+)! +" 0$! c(a%)/ \a* !/,!c%a((5 0$! "%./0 ,a.0 +" 0$! "%"0$ c(a%)] + /!!) 0+

b! ab+10 a,,.!$!*/%+* \+. !4,!.%!*c! +. '*+3(!#!] B10 /+)! +" 0$!c(a%)/ \*a)!(5 0$! 0$%. /%40$ 0!*0$ a* )a5b! 0$! "%"0$] %),10! a!"+.)a0%+* +" ,!./+*/ a* 0$! .!)a%*!. +" 0$! c(a%)/ %),10! a!"+.)a0%+* +" *a01.! +. +b&!c0/ S+ 0$! c(a%)/ l /+)! +" 0$!) a*53a5 la.! +*0%c %* 0$%/ /!*/! 0$!5 ,!.0a%* *+0 0+ +. *+0 )!.!(5 0+ 0$! a,,.!$!*/%+*+" !*0%0%!/ b10 0+ !*0%0%!/ \,!./+*/ a*j+. +b&!c0/] 0$!)/!(2!/ T$! c(a%)/

a.! /e+2 e'e+a%%* 0$a0 0$!5 a//!.0 a 2!.5 3%!/,.!a !"+.)a0%+* +" b!%*#/T$! c(a%)/ ,.!/!*0 0$a0 3$%c$ %/ !"+.)! a/ 2a.%+1/(5 *a01.! )a*'%*`0$%*#/ a* $1)a* b!%*#/ `.!a(%05 `B!%*# `!2!.50$%*# `+b&!c0/ a* `a((+b&!c0/ Ca* +*! )a'! /!*/! +" 0$! %!a +" /1c$ a 3%!/,.!a !"+.)a0%+*P!.$a,/ +*! ca* O*! )%#$0 0.5 0+ + /+ b5 c+)b%*%*# 03+ 0$+1#$0/ 0$a0+" a 2!.5 3%!/,.!a !"+.)a0%+* +" !*2%.+*)!*0/ \b1%(0 a* *a01.a(] a*0$a0 +" a ,!.2a/%2! !"+.)a0%+* +" ,!+,(! C!.0a%*(5 A+.*+ 3a/ )1c$!4!.c%/! b5 0$! /!c+* +" 0$+/! 0$+1#$0/ N+*!0$!(!// 0$! c+*&1*c0%+* +"0$+/! 03+ 0$+1#$0/ +!/ *+0 /!!) 0+ b! 0$! ,.%)a.5 %),+.0 +" 0$!

!"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ T$%/ %/ 3$!.! 0$! de)-!+" 0$! c(a%)/ !*0!./ +. %/c(+/!/



17/176

15

%0/!(" L!0 )! !4,(a%*

T$! c(a%)/ a00.%b10! 0$! 3+.' +" !"+.)a0%+* *+0 +*(5 0+ `0$! !4c$a*#!

.!(a0%+* b10 a(/+ 0+ .!a/+* \+. a "+.) +" .!a/+*] a* a* %),+/%0%+* +" %!*0%05B10 $+3 ca* .!a/+* +. /+)! /+.0 +" %),+/%0%+* +" %!*0%05 !"+.) O*!)%#$0 0$%*' 0$a0 A+.*+ $a/ %* )%* /+)! /+.0\/] +" %/0+.0%*# +10(++'H+3!2!. 0$! !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ $a2! +*0%c %),+.0 N+. %/ %0 /!!)%*#(50$a0 a* +10(++' %/ a0 %//1! %* 0$! "+((+3%*# %*%.!c0(5 +*0%c 3a5 a* +10(++',(a5/ a .+(! %* a ca1/a( c$a%* 0$a0 (!a/ 0+ 0$! !"+.)a0%+* +" ac01a( b!%*#/F+. (%00(! %* 0$! c(a%)/ %*%ca0!/ 0$a0 %!a S+ 3$a0 /!!)/ 0+ b! a0 %//1! %/ 0+,10 )a00!./ /(%#$0(5 ,a.a+4%ca((5 /+)! /+.0 +" *+*kca1/a( !""!c0 T$a0 %/3$5 I 3.%0! +" `!!, !"+.)a0%+* I0 %/ 0$%/ !,0$ 0$a0 )a'!/ 0$!!"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ %*0+ a ,166(! T$! ,166(! %/ 0+ !4,(%ca0! 0$! !,0$ a0

%//1!

I + *+0 0$%*' 0$a0 !4%/0%*# 3+.' +* A+.*+ /+(2!/ 0$! ,166(! +" $%/!"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ Ra0$!. %0 a2+%/ +. )%//!/ 0$! ,166(! F+. 0$! (%0!.a01.!c+*/0.1!/ A+.*+/ !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ a/ )!.!(5 0+ + 3%0$ e1)e+"e'ce+.3$!.! 0$! c(a%)/ a.! c+*/0.1! a/ ('-"ca/ ,!.0a%*%*# 0+ +*(5 a %"&"-ed.a*#!+" !*0%0%!/ O. /+ I $a2! #+*! /+)! 3a5 0+3a./ a.#1%*# !(/!3$!.! T$!.!)a%*!. +" 0$! ,.!/!*0 ,a,!. !4,(+.!/ a 3a5 %* 3$%c$ 0$! ,166(! )%#$0

b! /+(2!

(+) A h&po"he!i!

O*! 3a5 0+ /+(2! 0$! ,166(! +. .a0$!. 0+ d",,(%/e%0 3+1( b! 0+ c+*c(1! a/"+((+3/ A+.*+/ c(a%)/ ab+10 !"+.)a0%+* .!,.!/!*0 )!.!(5 0!*!*0%+1/.!!/c.%,0%+* ^ _ a .!!/c.%,0%+* +" .$!0+.%ca( ,+3!. b10 *+ a*a(50%c/%#*%"%ca*c! \A/$c.+"0 ] B10 0$a0 a*/3!. %/ 1b%+1/ %* 0$!"+((+3%*# /!*/! S1.!(5 A+.*+ )!a*/ 0+ 0.a! 1,+* /+)! 1*1/1a( l /+)!

)!"%(,()!"ca%l c+*c!,0%+* +" !"+.)a0%+* F+. 3$a0 !(/! c+1( a !!, *+0%+*+" !"+.)a0%+* b! S+ +1. -1!/0%+* b!c+)!/ 3$!.! +. $+3 %* A+.*+

/$+1( +*! /!!' /1c$ a ,$%(+/+,$%ca( c+*c!,0%+*

I a%) 0+ !4,(%ca0! A+.*+/ !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ b5 ,(ac%*# 0$!) 3%0$%* a3%!. ".a)!3+.' T$! ".a)!3+.' I $a2! %* )%* %/ a* acc+1*0 +" -!ede-e+&"'a-"(' (f be"', B5 a* acc+1*0 +" 0$! !0!.)%*a0%+* +" b!%*#/ I1*!./0a* a ,$%(+/+,$%ca( \a* /+ `!!,] acc+1*0 +" $+3 %0 %/ 0$a0 b!%*#/a/ /1c$ 3$!0$!. !"+.)! +. *+0 a* 3$!0$!. %* )+!.*%05 +. *+0 a.! a/0$!5 a.! W!.! /1c$ a* acc+1*0 ,.!/!*0 3%0$%* A+.*+ 0$!* 0$! !"+.)a0%+*c(a%)/ 3+1( b! )!.!(5 a /,!c%a( ca/! +" %0 S+ )5 $5,+0$!/%/ )a5 b! /0a0!

%* /$+.0 a/ "+((+3/A' Ad(+'"a' acc(.'- (f de-e+&"'a-"(' &"!- &a$e ,e',e (f

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



18/176

16 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

!", c%a"&, ab(.- def(+&a-"(' T$! *!40 /!c0%+* a.#1!/ 0$a0 )a0!.%a( %* A+.*++!/ /!!) 0+ c+),.%/! a* acc+1*0 +" !0!.)%*a0%+* a* %*2!/0%#a0!/ 3$a0(%#$0 0$a0 )a0!.%a( 0$.+3/ 1,+* 0$! ,166(! ab+10 !"+.)a0%+*

9? I'/e,-"a-"' -!e !2)(-!e,",

)+( Media"ion a! de"emina"ion

M!%a0%+* ^Ve+&"--%.'_ %/ +*! +" A+.*+/ c!*0.a( *+0%+*/ \c" OC+**+. ] O*! +" A+.*+/ )+/0 #!*!.a( /0a0!)!*0/ +" )!%a0%+* .1*/ a/"+((+3/

E2!.5 !*0%05 %/ )+.! 0$a* %0 %/ ^ _ S%*c! 0$!.! %/ *+ !*0%05 0$a0 %*

b!%*# !0!.)%*! a* %* %0/!(" !0!.)%*%*# +!/ *+0 *!! a*+0$!./+)!0$%*# +0$!. 0$a* %0/!(" l "+. %0 c+1( *!2!. be!0!.)%*! /+(!(5%* 0!.)/ +" %0/!(" l %0 )1/0 ,+%*0 b!5+* %0/!(" `M!%a0%+* %/ /%),(5a*+0$!. 3+. "+. 0$%/ \ND ]

T$! ,a//a#! #%2!/ #.+1*/ "+. 0$%*'%*# 0$a0 )!%a0%+* c+),.%/!/ a* acc+1*0+" b!%*#/ !0!.)%*a0%+* %* 0$! /!*/! 0$a0 I $a2! #%2!* 0$! (a00!. ,$.a/! H!.!%/ 3$5 I* a//!.0%*# 0$a0 !2!.5 !*0%05 %/ )!%a0! \c" ND ] 0$! ,a//a#!c(a%)/ 0$a0 )!%a0%+* %/ 1*%2!./a( )!%a0%+* ,!.0a%*/ 0+ b!%*#/ a, ,.c!

M+.!+2!. 0$! ,a//a#! .!2!a(/ 0$a0 )!%a0%+* %/ ('-"c "+. %0 %/ be"',0$a0)!%a0! a* a.! )!%a0! F1.0$!. 0$! ,a//a#! a//!.0/ 0$a0 )!%a0%+* %//+)! /+.0 +" !0!.)%*a0%+* F%*a((5 0$! *+0%+* +" )!%a0%+* (++'/ (%'! a

)!"%(,()!"ca%c+*c!,0%+* T$1/ 0$! "+((+3%*# /0a0!)!*0 %/ /1.!(5 a0 (!a/0.+1#$(5 c+..!c0 T$! c+*c!,0 +" )!%a0%+* a*/3!./ A+.*+/ *!! 0+ #%2!c+*c!,01a( !4,.!//%+* 0+ 0$! .!(a0%+*/$%, b!03!!* 0.a*/c!*!*0a( a*!),%.%ca( ,$!*+)!*a \R+/!* ]

T$! .!)a%*!. +" 0$%/ /!c0%+* %*2!/0%#a0!/ 3$!0$!. 0$! ,.+)%/! %/ b+.*! +10I 3%(( %*2!/0%#a0! 0$a0 %/ 3$!0$!. A+.*%a* )!%a0%+* .!a((5 %/ a* acc+1*0

+" !0!.)%*a0%+* 0$a0 )a'!/ /!*/! +" 0$! !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ I* /+ +%*# I0a'! a/ a c1! /+)!0$%*# !(/! 0$a0 %/ %),a.0! +. a0 (!a/0 /1##!/0! b5 0$!,a//a#! -1+0! ab+2! l a* 3$%c$ %* a*5 ca/! %/ 0.1! A+.*%a* )!%a0%+*0a'!/ /!2!.a( "+.)/ +. 2a.%!0%!/ I b!#%* \h] 3%0$ A+.*+/ acc+1*0 +"c('ce)-.a%)!%a0%+* T$!* \h] I 3%(( !4a)%*! 0$+1#$ )+.! b.%!"(5 $%/acc+1*0 +" ,(c"a%)!%a0%+* W! /$a(( /!! 0$a0 b+0$ 2!./%+*/ +" )!%a0%+*acc+))+a0! /+)! %*0!.*a( 2a.%!05



19/176

17

)+) Concep"#al media"ion

@@? T!e c('ce)-.a%"-2 (f -!(.!- a'd (f e1)e+"e'ce

A+.*+/ 3+.' c+*0a%*/ )a*5 .!"!.!*c!/ 0+ 0$! )!%a0+.5 .+(! +" 0$!c+*c!,0 \ ] 0+ )!%a0%*# c+*c!,01a(%05 \SER ] a* /%)%(a.S1c$ ,$.a/!/ %*0!* a 2%!3 0$a0 A+.*+ a//!.0/ .!,!a0!(5 a* !4,(%c%0(5

A%% -!"'$"' "'/(%/e, c('ce)-,\IS ND ND KCPR ] Y!0 A+.*+/0a(' +" )!%a0%*# c+*c!,01a(%05 %*0!*/ /!2!.a( "1.0$!. 0$%*#/ O*! +" 0$!)%/ 0$a0 a(()e+ce)-"('l +. /(%#$0(5 )+.! #!*!.a((5 a(( e1)e+"e'ce\ME ME"] l %*2+(2!/ c+*c!,0/ F+((+3%*# a c+*2!*0%+* %* A*a(50%ca( ,$%(+/+,$5I ca(( 0$a0 0$!/%/ ab+10 ,!.c!,0%+* \+. !4,!.%!*c!] `c+*c!,01a(%/) T$%/c+*c!,01a(%/) %/ )+.! %),+.0a*0 \0$a0 %/ )+.! ,$%(+/+,$%ca((5 c+*0.+2!./%a(

a* )+.! %),+.0a*0 "+. A+.*+] 0$a* 0$! 0$!/%/ ab+10 0$+1#$0 A+.*+/)+/0 !40!*! ca/! "+. c+*c!,01a(%/) +cc1./ 3%0$%* $%/ Me-ac+"-"*.e (fE)",-e&(%(2 L!0 1/ c+*/%!. 0$a0 ca/!

T$!Me-ac+"-"*.e a.#1!/ 0$a0 %* +.!. 0+ $a2! !2!* /+ /!*/+.5 a ,!.c!,0%+*a/ 0$a0 +" c+(+1. +*! .!-1%.!/ /+)!0$%*# b!5+* /$!!. ,.!/!*0 !4,!.%!*c!\ME ] W$5 I* +.!. 0+ /!! 0$a0 a 0$%*# %/ /a5 .! 03+ 0$%*#/ l b!5+*a ba.! ,a00!.* +* +*!/ .!0%*a l a.! *!c!//a.5 \] T$! 0$%*#/ .!*!// )1/0

b! d",-"'.",!ed ".+) 0$! +0$!. "!a01.!/ l "+. %*/0a*c! 0$! /$a,! l +" 0$!

,$!*+)!*+* ,!.c!%2! \ME ] \] T$! .! 0$%*# a* 0$!.!b5 %0/ .!*!//)1/0 b! '*+3* 0+ b! ,)a-"a% a'd -e&)(+a%"+. 0$! .!*!// %/ %* 0$! 0$%*# a*0$! 0$%*# $a/ a (+ca0%+* a* /+)! !#.!! +" ,!.)a*!*c! \ME ] N+3+*! )%#$0 #.a*0 0$+/! 03+ ,+%*0/ "+. c+(+1.! (b#ec-, b10 !*5 0$a0 0$!5a,,(5 0+ )!.! ,e',a-"(', +" .!*!// A+.*+ c+1*0!./ 0$1/ N+ /$!!./!*/a0%+* ca* b! !0ac$! ".+) ,!.c!,0%+* %* 0$! .!a( (%"! +" c+*/c%+1/*!//\ME ] W%(".% S!((a./ l 3$+ (%'! A+.*+ %/ %*/,%.! %* 0$%/ a.!a b5H!#!( l ,.+2%!/ a 3a5 +" #(+//%*# a* !"!*%*# 0$! c(a%) T+ $a2! a/!*/a0%+* +" .!*!// %/ "+. /+)!0$%*# 0+ %(($.! a* /+)!0$%*# ca* (++' .!+*(5 0+ a c.!a01.! 0$a0 $a/ 0$! c+*c!,0 +" a* (b#ec-b!%*# .! \S!((a./

h] A0 a*5 .a0! l 0$a0 %/ 3$!0$!. +. *+0 A+.*+ /$a.!/ 0$a0 0$+1#$0 l $!c+*c(1!/ 0$1/ 0$! c+#*%0%2! /1b&!c0 )1/0 a(3a5/ '*+3 )+.! a* $a2!!4,!.%!*c! )+.! 0$a* &1/0 0$! ,$!*+)!*+* \ME "] 3$!.! 0$! )+.!0$! ,.!/1,,+/%0%+*a( '*+3(!#! +" c+(+1. .!/%!/ %* 0$! c('ce)-+" c+(+1.\ME ]

S0%(( 0$!.! %/ a 3a5 %* 3$%c$ a(( 0$!/! c+*/%!.a0%+*/ /!!) b!/%! 0$! ,+%*0A+.*+/ !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ !40!* b!5+* !4,!.%!*c! 0+ 0$! 0$%*#/!4,!.%!*c! l 3$!.!a/ 0$! "+.!#+%*# %/ *+0 +*0%c b10 !4,!.%!*0%a( +.

!,%/0!)%c B10 0$!.! %/ .!a/+* 0+ 0$%*' 0$a0 A+.*+ a1#)!*0/ $%/

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



20/176

18 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

c+*c!,01a(%/) 3%0$ +. !2!(+,/ %0 %*0+ /+)!0$%*# (!// !,%/0!)%c

@@@ T!e c('ce)-.a%"-2 (f -!"',

T$! "+((+3%*# A+.*%a* %c0a %),10! a c+*c!,01a(%05 0+ b!%*#/S1b&!c0%2%05 ,!.2a!/ 0$! +b&!c0 \ME ] Ob&!c0%2%05 %/ *+0 (!"0 +2!. a/a .!)a%*!. a"0!. 0$! /1b&!c0 %/ /1b0.ac0! \P ] ^W_$a0 %/ %/ *+0%))!%a0! ^b10_ ^ _ a.%/!/ 0$.+1#$ 0$! c+*c!,0 \ND j GS ]^O_b&!c0%2%05 ,.!/1,,+/!/ 0$! /1b&!c0 \ND ] ^S_1b&!c0%2%05 %/ _ 0$!+b&!c0/ "+.) \SO ] I" 0$! +b&!c0 (ac'! 0$! )+)!*0 +" /1b&!c0%2%05 %0/+3* +b&!c0%2%05 3+1( b!c+)! *+*/!*/%ca( \SO ] ^T_+ 0$! 0$%*# 0$!c+*c!,0 %/ *+0 c+*0%*#!*0 a* !40!.*a( Ra0$!. %* H!#!(%a* (a*#1a#! 0$!c+*c!,0 a.0%c1(a0!/ 0$! (%"! +" 0$! 0$%*# %0/!(" \ME j GS ]

O*! )%#$0 /1,,+/! 0$a0 A+.*+/ 2%!3 %/ 0$a0 +" 0$+/! 3$+ $a2! b!!* ca((!`c+*c!,01a( /c$!)!./ T+ 3%0 c+*c!,0/ l c+*c!,01a( .!,!.0+%.!/ +.(a*#1a#!/ +. ,a.0/ +" /1c$ .!,!.0+%.!/ +. (a*#1a#!/ l $a2! +*0+(+#%ca(%),+.0 %* 0$a0 +. %*/+"a. a/ 0$!5 +.#a*%/! a* %*$!.!*0(5 1*+.#a*%/! .!a(%05A+.*+ +!/ $+( b+0$ 0$a0 \] 0$!.! %/ /+)!0$%*# %*!,!*!*0 +" a* #%2!*0+ $1)a* !4,!.%!*c! \/!! KCPR ] a* 0$a0 \] 0$%/ #%2!* %/ %* /+)!%),+.0a*0 3a5 *+0 %.!c0(5 acc!//%b(! \%!) c" ND ] Y!0 add"-"('a%%2A+.*+ c+),(a%*/ 0$a0 Ka*0 l 3%0$ .!"!.!*c! 0+ 3$+) A+.*+ a//!.0/ a*

l !#.a^!/_ ^ _ 0$! 0$%*# 0+ a c$a+0%c ab/0.ac0%+* \ND ]

I*!!A+.*+ c$a.ac0!.%/!/ a* .!&!c0/ )1c$ W!/0!.* )!0a,$5/%c/ a/ a ,!!,$+(!)!0a,$5/%c/ 3$!.!b5 #.!a0 !,%/0!)+(+#%ca( +. )!0a,$5/%ca( ,+3!. %/a00.%b10! 0+ 0$! /1b&!c0 a* 5!0 3$!.!%* 0$a0 /1b&!c0 %/ $!( 0+ $a2! +*(5 a2!.5 %),+2!.%/$! acc!// 0+ .!a(%05 ,.+,!. \ND "] S+ %* "ac0 A+.*+ca**+0 b! a c+*c!,01a( /c$!)!. H+3 0$!* d(e, $! 0$%*' 0$a0 c+*c!,0/!0!.)%*! l a* 5!0 %* /+)! /!*/! +. 0+ /+)! !#.!! + '(-!0!.)%*! l0$! 3+.(

T$! %c01) 0$a0 0$! c+*c!,0 a.0%c1(a0!/ 0$! (%"! +" 0$! 0$%*# %0/!(" %/ a/ A+.*+

$%)/!(" /a5/ H!#!(%a* H!#!( 3.%0!/ 0$%*'%*# %* %0/ %))a*!*0!0!.)%*a0%+*/ a* 0$! 0.1! *a01.! +" 0$%*#/ "+.) +*! a* 0$! /a)! c+*0!*0\ ] B10 3$a0 +!/ -!a-)!a* S+)!0%)!/ 0$! %!a ca* /!!) 0+ b!0$%/ 0$%*#/ .!c!%2! 0$!%. *a01.! ".+) 0$+1#$0 T$1/ +*! )%#$0 0$%*' 0$%/(%*! T$%*'%*# c+*/0%010!/ 0$! /1b/0a*c! +" !40!.*a( 0$%*#/ \H!#!( c" h 0$!.!%*] B10 0$%/ %!a(%/0%c .!a%*# $a/ b!!* c+*0!/0! b5 +0$!..!a!./ +" H!#!( 3$+ 0a'! 0$! %!a 0+ b! %*/0!a 0$! "+((+3%*# )+.!`.!a(%/0%c +*! W! ca* )a'! /!*/! +" +1. acc!// 0+ a* %*!,!*!*0 3+.(+*(5 b5 $+(%*# 0$a0 0$!.! %/ *+ %/0a*c! ".+) 0$! 3+.( %),(%c%0 %* 0$! 2!.5

%!a +" 0$+1#$0 \McD+3!(( c" B!.*/0!%* k] I* 0$%/



21/176

19

a* +0$!. 3a5/ H!#!(/ %!a(%/) .!)a%*/ a* %*2+(2! a* $%#$(5 c+*0!/0!!*0!.,.%/! \/!! S0!.* ] S0%(( 3$a0 )a00!./ "+. +1. ,1.,+/!/ %/ $+3

Ad(+'(1*!./0a*/ \a* a,,.a%/!/] H!#!( T$a0 1*!./0a*%*# )!(/ 0$!

03+ %*0!.,.!0a0%+*/ &1/0 %*0%)a0! \+. /+)!0$%*# (%'! 0$!)]A+.*+ 0!ac$!/ 0$a0 H!#!( $a/ 03+ .a0$!. %""!.!*0 "ac!/ \c" Ha))!. ""] O* 0$! +*! $a* A+.*+ "%*/ %* H!#!( 0$! /+.0 +" `0$+1#$0k(!,+/%0%+* &1/0 %*0%)a0! H!#!(/ ,$%(+/+,$5 a ,$%(+/+,$5 +" /,%.%0 $!( "a/00+ %!a(%/) ^ _ ^0+_ 0$! +c0.%*! +" 0$! %!*0%05 +" /1b&!c0 a* +b&!c0 \H] ^T_$! 0$%*# %0/!(" a* %0/ c+*c!,0 a.! +*! a* 0$! /a)! %* H!#!(_ \H] Â_b/+(10! %!a(%/) _ ,!.)%0/ *+0$%*# 0+ .!)a%* +10/%! 0$! /1b&!c0\H c" LND ] H+3!2!. A+.*+ a(/+ 0$%*'/ 0$a0 H!#!( $a/ a/,!c0/ 0$a0,1(( %* a c+*0.a.5 %.!c0%+* H!#!(/ %a(!c0%c %/ .%2!* b5 0$+1#$0/ "%*%*#

%0/!(" %*a!-1a0! 0+ 0$a0 3$%c$ %0 /!!'/ 0+ #.a/, \H " H ] M+.!+2!.H!#!( 3+1( $a2! 2!$!)!*0(5 .!,1%a0! 0$! %!a +" /,%.%0 a/ a ".!!k"(+a0%*# 0$%*# %/0%*c0 ".+) %0/ +,,+/%0! 0$! )a0!.%a( (%"! +" )a*'%* \HF] I* a 3+. 0$!.! %/ a &a-e+"a%",-/%! +" H!#!( \H " /!! a(/+ !/,!c%a((5H a* H ] N+3 A+.*+ b!(%!2!/ 0$a0 +*c! H!#!(/ "ac! $a/ "1((5a//!)b(! %0/!(" a/ %0 3!.! 0$! %!a(%/0%c "ac! %/ 0$! +*! 0$a0 /0a.!/ +10 I*0$! "%*a( a*a(5/%/ H!#!( ,.+,+1*/ a* !40.!)! \KCPR ] %!a(%/)3$!.!b5 0$! 3+.( %/ )a! )1c$ 0++ !,!*!*0 1,+* /1b&!c0/ \c" ND 44+* 0$! "a((ac5 +" c+*/0%010%2! /1b&!c0%2%05]

W$a0!2!. 0$! !4ac0 !0a%(/ +" A+.*+/ c.%0%-1! +" H!#!( %0 %/ c(!a. 0$a0A+.*+ +!/ *+0 3a*0 /%),(5 0+ %/,!*/! 3%0$ $%) Ra0$!. A+.*+ b!(%!2!/0$a0 +*! /$+1( 0.5 0+ )a'! #++ +* 0$! /5*0$!/%/ 0$a0 $! 0$%*'/ H!#!(

b+0c$! a /5*0$!/%/ b!03!!* %!a(%/) a* )a0!.%a(%/) Î_!a(%/0%c a*)a0!.%a(%/0%c %a(!c0%c/ %*0!./!c0 \ND ] S+ 0$! /%01a0%+* %/ 0$%/ A+.*+/%c0a l ab+10 /1b&!c0%2%05 ,!.2a%*# 0$! +b&!c0 a* /+ "+.0$ l a.! Hee%"a'%c0a B!00!. 5!0 0$!5 !4,.!// l 1, 0+ a ,+%*0 a/(0l 0$! %!a(%/0%c /%! +"H!#!( Ù, 0+ a ,+%*0 b!ca1/! A+.*+ 0$%*'/ 0$a0 0$%/ %!a(%/) )1/0 b!c+1*0!.ba(a*c! +. 0.a*/"+.)! b5 a )a0!.%a(%/) S+ 3! )1/0 c+*/%!.

&1/0 $+3 A+.*+ "%#1.!/ 0$a0 /5*0$!/%/ \%" `/5*0$!/%/ %/ *+0 0++ H!#!(%a* a3+.]

A0 0$%/ ,+%*0 +*! )%#$0 c+*/%!. /+)! /1##!/0%2! .!)a.'/ %* A+.*+/(!c01.!/ +* A.%/0+0(! I a) 0$%*'%*# +" 0$! )+)!*0 3$!.! A+.*+ $%#$(5c+))!*/ 0$! %!a 3$%c$ $! a//+c%a0!/ 3%0$ A.%/0+0(! a* G!.)a*I!a(%/) 0$a0 ,.!%ca0!/ !4,.!//%*# #!*1/ + *+0 /+ )1c$ !*+0! 0$!!//!*c! +" a 0$%*# a/ c(&)+",e0$a0 !//!*c! \M a* ""] B10 A+.*+ +!/*+0 !4,a* +* 0$a0 %!a H+3!2!. $+,! .!)a%*/ "+. A+.*+ %/ )+.!

"+.0$c+)%*# 3$!* $! 0a'!/ $%/ (!a ".+) 0$! .+(! ,(a5! %* c+*c!,01a(

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



22/176

20 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

)!%a0%+* *+0 b5 c+*c!,0/ b10 b5 0$! 0$%*# +. +b&!c0 F+. $!.! 3! "%*A+.*+/ +c0.%*! +" `0$! ,.%+.%05 +" 0$! +b&!c0 ^V(++a' de, Ob#e$-,_

I b!#%* 1,+* 0$! ,.%+.%05 +c0.%*! 3%0$ 0$%/ (%*! D1! 0+ 0$! %*!-1a(%05%*$!.!*0 %* 0$! c+*c!,0 +" )!%a0%+* 0$! /1b&!c0 !*0!./ %*0+ 0$! +b&!c0a(0+#!0$!. %""!.!*0(5 ".+) 0$! 3a5 0$! +b&!c0 !*0!./ %*0+ 0$! /1b&!c0 \ND] H+3 /+ A* +b&!c0 ca* b! c+*c!%2! edac!-_ +*(5 b5 a /1b&!c0 b10a(3a5/ .!)a%*/ /+)!0$%*# +0$!. 0$a* 0$! /1b&!c0 3$!.!a/ a /1b&!c0 b5 %0/2!.5 *a01.! %/ ".+) 0$! +10/!0 a* +b&!c0 a/ 3!(( \%!)] S1c$ %/ 0$!%""!.!*c! %* 3!%#$0%*# \KCPR ] b!03!!* 0$! /1b&!c0/ )!%a0%+* +" a*+b&!c0 +* 0$! +*! $a* a* a* +b&!c0/ )!%a0%+* +" a /1b&!c0 +* 0$! +0$!.T$! %""!.!*c! %* 3!%#$0%*# %/ %* 0$! +b&!c0/ "a2+1. 0$! +b&!c0 $a/ a ,.%+.%05\+. ,.!,+*!.a*c! +. ,.%)ac5 l V(++a'] +2!. 0$! /1b&!c0 H!.! %/ 3$5 T$!

2!.5 *a01.! +. b!%*# +" /1b&!c0/ !,!*/ 1,+* +b&!c0/ \1,+* 0$! +b&!c0/ 0$a00$! /1b&!c0/ a.!] 3$!.!a/ 0$! c+*2!./! %/ *+0 0$! ca/! S0%(( &1/0 3$a0 %/ 0$!)!%a0%+* b5 0$! /1b&!c0 0$a0 %/ a0 %//1! M!.!(5 0$a0 /1b&!c0/ a.! .!-1%.!%" a*5 +b&!c0 %/ 0+ b! c+*c!%2! a,,.!$!*! T$a0 a#a%* 3+1( b! )!.!(5!,%/0!)%c

A+.*+ +!/ #(+// 0$! ,.%+.%05 0$!/%/ H! +!/ /+ "%./0 %* 0$!/! "+.)1(a0%+*/0$+1#$0 $!!/ a ,+0!*0%a( %* 0$! +b&!c0 \ND ] T$! /1b&!c0 %/ 0$! +b&!c0/a#!*0 *+0 %0/ c+*/0%01!*0 \SO ] T$!/! "+.)1(a0%+*/ a.! /1##!/0%2!

T$!5 /1##!/0 0$a0 3%0$+10 /1b&!c0/ +b&!c0/ c+1( *+0 !*&+5 0$!%. "1((+b&!c0%2%05 D+!/ 0$%/ )!a* /%),(5 0$a0 3%0$+10 0$! c+*c!,0 +" /+)! "!a01.!+*! c+1( *+0 a,,.!$!* 0$! "!a01.! N+ F+. 3! $a2! /!!* \h] 0$a0acc+.%*# 0+ A+.*+ 0$! /1b&!c0 )1/0 a(3a5/ '*+3 )+.! a* $a2!!4,!.%!*c! )+.! 0$a* &1/0 0$! ,$!*+)!*+* \ME ] A/ A+.*+ ,10/ %0!(/!3$!.! B!03!!* 0$! 0.1! +b&!c0 a* 0$! %*1b%0ab(! +b&!c0 +" 0$! /!*/!/

b!03!!* 3%0$%* a* 3%0$+10 0$!.! %/ a #1(" _ I* +.!. 0+ .!"(!c0 0$! 0$%*#a/ %0 %/ 0$! /1b&!c0 )1/0 .!01.* 0+ %0 )+.! 0$a* $! .!c!%2!/ ".+) %0 \DE ]S+ !2!.5 +b&!c0 $a/ "!a01.!/ 3$%c$ .!-1%.! "+. 0$!%. !4,.!//%+* c+*c!,0/ 0$a0a.! *+0 !.%2ab(! /+(!(5 ".+) 0$! +b&!c0 %0/!(" T$%/ %/ %*0!.!/0%*# l b10 /+ "a.

a/ I ca* 0!(( 1*!(ab+.a0! T$!.! %/ a*+0$!. #(+// +" 0$! ,.%+.%05 0$!/%/\a*j+. ,!.$a,/ +" 0$! %!a &1/0 ,.!/!*0!] B10 /+ "a. a/ I ca* /!! 0$a0 #(+//%0/!(" a/ (%00(! I a) 0$%*'%*# +" A+.*+/ ca(( "+. a /!c+* C+,!.*%ca*01.* \SO /!! a(/+ ND k] T$! ,.+,+/! 01.* %/ a ,$%(+/+,$%ca(.!+.%!*0a0%+* 3%0$%* a "1*a)!*0a((5 Ka*0%a* +. H!#!(%a* +.%!*0a0%+* a*a4%a( 01.* 0+3a./ 0$! +b&!c0 \ND 44]

)+* Social media"ion

A+.*+ !*2%/a#!/ a /+c%a( "+.) +" )!%a0%+* %* a0 (!a/0 0$! "+((+3%*# 3a5



23/176

21

H! )a%*0a%*/ 0$a0 a(( c+*c!,0/ a.! /+c%a( T$%/ "+.) +" )!%a0%+* %/ -+a',"-"/e%* 0$a0 %0 0a'!/ ,(ac! /"a0$! )!%a0%+* 3+.'! b5 c+*c!,0/ T$1/ 0$!/! (%*!/0$!.! %/ a /+c%!0a( )+)!*0 +" 0$! /5*0$!/%/ +" 0$+1#$0 \ME ] 0$!.! %/

*+0$%*# 1*!. 0$! /1* a* I )!a* ab/+(10!(5 *+0$%*# 3$%c$ %* b!%*#)!%a0! b5 $1)a* %*0!((%#!*c! a* $1)a* 0$+1#$0 %/ *+0 a(/+ /+c%a((5)!%a0! \IS " c" IS KCPR a* H ] T$! 0$!/%/ .+1#$(5 %/0$a0 a(( c+*c!,0/ a.! %*"(1!*c! b5 0$!%. /+c%a( c+*0!40 $!*c! /+c%!05%*"(1!*c!/ 0$! \!,%/0!)%c a*j+. +*0%c] !0!.)%*a0%+* 0$a0 c+*c!,0/ ,!."+.)I 3%(( *+0 "1.0$!. %*2!/0%#a0! 0$a0 0$!/%/ $!.! I*/0!a I /$a(( .!/0.%c0 a00!*0%+*0+ a*+0$!. ,a.0 +" A+.*+/ 0$%*'%*# +* /+c%a( )!%a0%+* +*! 0$a0 %/ )+.!/!,a.ab(! 0$a* 0$! `0.a*/%0%2! "+.) ".+) 0$! c+*c!,01a( "+.) +" )!%a0%+*

I /a5 &(+e/!,a.ab(! a2%/!(5 T$! %!a 3$%c$ I 3%/$ 0+ "+c1/ 1,+* ca* b!

,10 0$%/ 3a5 /+c%!05 )!%a0!/ a, c+*c!,0 +. a'a%((.,%2 0+ c+*c!,0/C+*/%!. +*c! a#a%* /+)! c(a%)/ ".+) A+.*+

^S_+)!0$%*# (%'! a c+*c!,0 %/ %),(%c%0 %* /+c%!05 %* %0/ +b&!c0%2! "+.)^ _ 0$%/ +b&!c0%2%05 +" 0$! c+*c!,0 ^%/_ %*$!.!*0 %* 0$! /1b&!c0 )a00!.%0/!(" \IS c" SER ]

^S_+c%!05 ca* b! ,!.c!%2! a()+/0 ,$5/%+#*+)%ca((5 %* %*%2%1a(,$!*+)!*a \IS ]

^T_+ 1/! H!#!(/ !4,.!//%+* 3$%c$ Ma.4 0++' +2!. ".+) $%)^_ /+c%!05%/ a c+*c.!0!(5 #!*!.a( c+*c!,0 0$a0 )!a*/ 0$a0 3$%(! a(( ,a.0%c1(a./!,!* +* %0 %0 ca**+0 b! (+#%ca((5 ab/0.ac0! ".+) 0$!) \IS ]

^T_$! /+c%a( 1*%2!./a( _ )a*%"!/0/ %0/!(" 0$.+1#$ 0$! %*%2%1a( \IS"]

T$! c+*"(%c0/ 0$a0 0!a. /+c%!05 a,a.0 .!/!)b(! 0$! %/0%*c0%+* b!03!!*0$! c+*c!,0 a* 0$! ,a.0%c1(a. "ac0/ /1b+.%*a0! 0+ %0 \LND ]

La/0(5 a* )+.! (!*#0$%(5

S+c%!05 %/ a((+00! ,.!c%/!(5 3$a0 H!#!( .!/!.2!/ "+. /,%.%0 a/ +,,+/!0+ a(( 0$! %/+(a0! %*%2%1a( )+)!*0/ +" 0$! !),%.%ca( T$+/!)+)!*0/ a.! )!%a0! b5 /+c%!05 c+*/0%010! 0$! 3a5 0$%*#/ a.!c+*/0%010! b5 /,%.%0 "+. a* %!a(%/0 ,.%+. 0+ a*5 ,a.0%c1(a. %*"(1!*c!!4!.0! b5 /+c%!05 +* ,$!*+)!*a /+c%!05 %/ )a*%"!/0! %* ,$!*+)!*a0$! 3a5 "+. H!#!( !//!*c! %/ )a*%"!/0! %* 0$!) S+c%!05 %/ !//!*0%a((5

c+*c!,0 &1/0 a/ /,%.%0 %/ A/ 0$! 1*%05 +" $1)a* /1b&!c0/ 3$+

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



24/176

22 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

.!,.+1c! 0$! (%"! +" 0$! /,!c%!/ 0$.+1#$ 0$!%. (ab+. 0$%*#/ c+)! %*0+b!%*# 3%0$%* /+c%!05 +b&!c0%2!(5 %*!,!*!*0 +" .!"(!c0%+* 3%0$+10.!#a. 0+ 0$! /,!c%"%c -1a(%0%!/ +" 0$+/! 3$+ (ab+. +. +" 0$! ,.+1c0/ +"(ab+. \H k j GS ]

T$!/! c(a%)/ )a5 a//!.0 0$! a"+.!)!*0%+*! /+c%a(%05 +" \`)!%a0%*#]c+*c!,0/ T$!5 )a5 a(/+ a//!.0 0$! !4%/0!*c! +" +. /+)! /+.0 +" %..!1c%b%(%050+ /+c%a( /0.1c01.!/ +. /+c%a( (a3/ B10 0$! c(a%)/ l a0 (!a/0 /+)! +" 0$!)a* c!.0a%*(5 0$! 3$+(! !*/!)b(! l %*0!* )+.! S+)! /+.0 +" d"+ec-a* dee)"+.) +" /+c%a( )!%a0%+* /!!)/ 0+ b! a0 %//1! \3$!.! `%.!c0 )!a*/ *+0 2%ac+*c!,0/ a* 3$!.! `!!, )!a*/ ,$%(+/+,$%ca(] S+ )1c$ %/ /1##!/0! *+0+*(5 b5 0$! c(a%)/ 0$!)/!(2!/ b10 a(/+ b5 0$! a"+.!)!*0%+*! %!a +" a*%*0!./!c0%+* b!03!!* %!a(%/0%c a* )a0!.%a(%/0%c %a(!c0%c/ a* ,!.$a,/ b5

A+.*+/ 3.%0%*# 0$a0 0.a%0%+* %/ -1a/%k0.a*/c!*!*0a( \ND ]

Y!0 I "%* *+0$%*# %* A+.*+ 0$a0 !4,(%ca0!/ 0$! /0.+*#!. "+.) +" /+c%a()!%a0%+* A+.*+/ /+c%+(+#5 (!c01.!/ + #%2! 03+ !4a),(!/ +" )!%a0%+*

b5 /+c%!05 T$! +*! !4a),(! %/ 0$a0 /+c%a( "ac0+./ )a5 b! %),!%*# 0$!%/c+2!.5 +" a c1.! "+. ca*c!. \IS ] T$! +0$!. %/ 0$a0 /+c%a( "ac0+./ +,!.a0!!2!* %* 0$! ,.ac0%c! +" !*0%/0.5 \IS ] T$!/! !4a),(!/ a.! %*!!/+c%+(+#%ca( T$!5 + *+0 !*(%#$0!* a/ 0+ $+3 /+c%!05 %/ a ca0!#+.5 +")!%a0%+* a* 0$!.!b5 c+*c!,01a( \IS ] T$!5 a.! *+0 !!, l *+0 0+ +3%0$ b!%*#/ a0 /+)! 1*1/1a( ,$%(+/+,$%ca( (!2!( P!.$a,/ +*! ca* "%* %*2a.%+1/ 0$%*'!./ 0$a0 A+.*+ %/c1//!/ a* b5 3$+) $! 3a/ %*"(1!*c!/+)! c+*c!,0%+*\/] a*/3!.%*# 0+ 0$! 05,! /+1#$0 F+. %0 )a5 b! 0$a0 /+)!+. a(( +" H!#!( Ma.4 D1.'$!%) a* S%))!( +""!. /1c$ c+*c!,0%+*/H+3!2!. %" A+.*+ +!/ )!a* 0+ b! !*(%/0%*# +. a,,.+,.%a0%*# +*! +" 0$!/!c+*c!,0%+*/ +. /+)!0$%*# (%'! +*! +" 0$!/! c+*c!,0%+*/ %0 %/ 1*c(!a. a0 (!a/0,!*%*# c+*/%!.ab(! "1.0$!. %*2!/0%#a0%+* $+3 $! +!/ /+

:? W!a- !a, bee' ac!"e/ed

M5 $5,+0$!/%/ 3a/ 0$%/ T$! *+0%+* +" )!%a0%+* 3+1( c+),.%/! a* acc+1*0+" b!%*#/ !0!.)%*a0%+* 0$a0 c+1( !4,(a%* A+.*+/ c(a%)/ ab+10 b!%*#/!"+.)a0%+* M+.! ,a.0%c1(a.(5 I $a 0$! "+((+3%*# %!a T$! !"+.)a0%+*c(a%)/ )%#$0 b! !4,(a%*! b5 a* acc+1*0 +" !"+.)a0%+* 0$a0 (%'! 0$!!"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ 3a/ b+0$ +*0%c \0$a0 %/ ab+10 b!%*#/ 0$!)/!(2!/] a*!!, \0$a0 %/ ,$%(+/+,$%ca( +. ,!.0a%*%*# 0+ b!%*#/ a0 /+)! "1*a)!*0a( +./,!c%a( (!2!(] T$a0 $5,+0$!/%/ $a/ b!!* *+ +b2%+1/ /1cc!// I (++'! 0+c+*c!,01a( a* /+c%a( )!%a0%+* 0+ /1,,(5 /+)! )+!(\/] +" a !0!.)%*a0%+*0$a0 %/ \+. %/ %* !ac$ ca/!] b+0$ +*0%c a* !!, B10 A+.*+/ acc+1*0 +" +*0%ca/ a#a%*/0 !4,!.%!*0%a( c+*c!,01a( )!%a0%+* l +. 0$! 3a5 0$a0 0$! +*! %/



25/176

23

)!a*0 0+ /!#1! %*0+ 0$! +0$!. l /!!)/ 2!.5 /'!0c$5 A* $%/ acc+1*0 +" /+c%a()!%a0%+* \/+ "a. a/ %0 3a/ /!,a.ab(! ".+) c+*c!,01a( )!%a0%+*] /!!)!+*0%c b10 b!ca1/! )!.!(5 /+c%+(+#%ca( *+0 !!, C(!a.(5 0$!* %* /+)! /!*/!

)5 $5,+0$!/%/ $a/ "a%(! T$!.! %/ a (ac' +" "%0 b!03!!* 3$a0 I $a2! )a! +"A+.*%a* !0!.)%*a0%+* a* 3$a0 I $a2! )a! +" A+.*%a* !"+.)a0%+*B10 0$!.! a.! 0$.!! 3a5/ +" %*0!.,.!0%*# 0$%/ .!/1(0 I* ,.!/!*0%*# 0$! 0$.!!a(0!.*a0%2!/ I /$a(( !),(+5 0$! *+0%+* +. 0.+,! +" a `#a, 0$!.!b5 a((1%*#,!.$a,/ a (%00(! /1,!.c%(%+1/(5 0+ 0$! /!c0%+* +" M"'"&a M(+a%"a ca((!Ga,/

\]T!e+e ", a &e+e%2 a))a+e'- a) "' Ad(+'( O* 0$%/ c+*/0.1a( +" )5 .!/1(0/A+.*+/ !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ a.! $5,!.b+(%c T$!5 a.! *!2!. b+0$ +*0%c a*!!, a(0$+1#$ /+)!0%)!/ 0$!5 a))ea+0+ b! /+ T$a0 c+*/0.1a( 3+1( )a'!

)5 $5,+0$!/%/ a "a%(1.! b10 a )%0%#a0! +*! T$! b(a)! "+. 0$! "a%(1.! 3+1(b! )%0%#a0! b5 0$! $5,!.b+(! 3$%c$ +* 0$%/ c+*/0.1a( A+.*+ ,!.,!0.a0!/

\]T!e+e ", a' ac-.a% a) "' Ad(+'( O* 0$%/ c+*/0.1a( 0$! !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/a.! *+0 $5,!.b+(%c T$!5 + %*0!* a0 (!a/0 /+)!0%)!/ 0+ a//!.0 a!"+.)a0%+* 0$a0 %/ b+0$ +*0%c a* !!, B.-0$!.! %/ *+ #++ !4,(a*a0%+*0+ b! "+1* +" !(00$a0 %/ /+ O* 0$%/ %*0!.,.!0a0%+* /+)!0$%*# 0$a0 /$+1(

b! ,.!/!*0 %* A+.*+ %/ )%//%*# I $a2! b!!* /!!'%*# /+)!0$%*# 0$a0 +*!/$+1( (++' "+. %* 0$! /!*/! 0$a0 +*! $a/ a .%#$0 0+ !4,!c0 %0/ ,.!/!*c! B10

!-1a((5 )5 /0.a0!#5 3%(( $a2! b!!* a* !4!.c%/! %* $1*0%*# 0$! W++6(! a/ %03!.! !4c!,0 %*/+"a. a/ %0 %/ 3+.0$ /$+3%*# 0$a0 /+)!0$%*# %/ )%//%*# ".+)A+.*+ l a* /1.!(5 0$a0 3+1( b! 3+.0$ /$+3%*#

\]T!e+e ", a a) "' &2 "'-e+)+e-a-"(' T$! %!a $!.! %/ 0$%/ T$! !"+.)a0%+*c(a%)/ a.! \a/ %* ] *+0 $5,!.b+(%c a* A+.*+ !4,(a%*/ $+3 0$a0 %/ /+ \+.a0 (!a/0 +*! ca* %/c+2!. a* !4,(a*a0%+* +" $+3 0$a0 %/ /+] b10 I $a2! '(-

f(.'d 0$a0 !4,(a*a0%+* O* 0$%/ c+*/0.1a( )5 $5,+0$!/%/ %/ c+..!c0 %*,.%*c%,(! b10 "(a3! %* %0/ !4!c10%+*

I 3%(( *+0 -1%0! 0.5 0+ !c%! 3$%c$ +" 0$! a(0!.*a0%2!/ %/ c+..!c0 B10 I 3%((/a5 /+)!0$%*# 0$a0 /1,,+.0/ +. a0 (!a/0 !(ab+.a0!/ 1,+* 0$! 0$%. a(0!.*a0%2!I $a2! b!!* b.%!" ab+10 +. 3$+((5 *!#(!c0! /+)! %),+.0a*0 0+,%c/ I a)0$%*'%*# !/,!c%a((5 +" 0$! "+((+3%*# /+)!3$a0 +2!.(a,,%*# a.!a/\] A+.*+/ .!(a0%+*/ 0+ Ka*0 H!#!( a* %*!! Ma.4 \] A+.*+/.!(a0%+*/$%,/ 0+ +*0+(+#5 a* 0+ 0.a*/c!*!*0a( ,$%(+/+,$5 \] 0$! ca1/!/0$a0 A+.*+ %!*0%"%!/ "+. 0$! !"+.)a0%+* $! a((!#!/ ca1/!/ 0$a0 a.!/+)!3$a0 2%/%b(! %* 0$! !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/ 0$!)/!(2!/ a* 3$%c$ %*c(1!%!*0%05 0$%*'%*# ^Ide'-"-5-,de'$e'_ !4c$a*#! ^Ta.,c!_ a* .!%"%ca0%+*

^Ve+d"'%"c!.'_ W! )a5 a \] A+.*+/ c+*c!,01a(%/) F+. %0 )a5 b!

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



26/176

24 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

0$a0 "1.0$!. %*2!/0%#a0%+* +" 0$! .+(! 0$a0 c+*c!,0/ ,(a5 %* !4,!.%!*c! 3%((%((1)%*a0! $%/ (!// !,%/0!)%c %!a/ ab+10 c+*c!,01a( !0!.)%*a0%+* O0$!.3+.' +" )%*! +!/ a.!// )1c$ 3%0$%* k B10 %0 +!/ /+ %* a )a**!. 3%0$

3$%c$ I a) /+)!3$a0 1*/a0%/"%!

N"c!(%a, J(%% #(%%?'"c!(%a,&a"%?c(& %/ A//+c%a0! L!c01.!. a0 0$! O,!*U*%2!./%05 H! %/ c1..!*0(5 3+.'%*# +* a)+*# +0$!. 0$%*#/ a )+*+#.a,$+* A+.*+ a* H!%!##!.

E'd'(-e,

T$%/ ,a,!. !2!(+,! ".+) )5 0a(' a0 A+.*+ N+ Ma*/ La* k Y!a./ O* $!(a0 0$! U*%2!./%05 +" S1//!4 +* A1#1/0 0$ I 0$a*' 0$! +.#a*%/!./ +" 0$!

c+*"!.!*c! "+. %*2%0%*# )! a* 0$a*' )5 a1%!*c! "+. 0$!%. -1!/0%+*/ M5 ,a,!..a3/ 1,+* J+(( \] a* J+(( \b] T$! (a00!. %/ %* ,a.0 a /1))a.5 a*.!3+.'%*# +" 0$! \1*,1b(%/$!] ,%!c! T$! /a)! $+(/ +" 0$! ,.!/!*0 ,a,!.0$+1#$ %0/ "+c1/ %/ *+0 0$a0 +" J+(( \b] A(( 0$.!! ,%!c!/ .!,.!/!*0 1*"%*%/$!b1/%*!// I $+,! 0+ 0a'! 0$a0 b1/%*!// "1.0$!. %* a "+.0$c+)%*# b++' 0$a0 3%(( 0.!a0H!%!##!. a/ 3!(( a/ A+.*+

I 3%(( abb.!2%a0! 3+.'/ b5 A+.*+ a/ "+((+3/ DE l D"a%ec-"c (f E'%"!-e'&e'-\c+k3.%00!* 3%0$ Ma4 H+.'$!%)!. J!,$c+00 0.a*/(a0%+*] GS l Ge,a&&e%-e Sc!+"f-e'

\.!"!.!*c!/ b5 2+(1)! a* 0$!* ,a#! *1)b!.] H l Hee% T!+ee S-.d"e, IS lI'-+(d.c-"(' -( S(c"(%(2 KCPR l Ka'-, Ci"iq#e of P#e Rea!on? LND l Lec-.+e, ('Nea-"/e D"a%ec-"c, ME lAa"',- E)",-e&(%(2 A Me-ac+"-"*.e MM lM"'"&a M(+a%"a\.!"!.!*c!/ b5 %0!) *1)b!. !*+0! `h +. ,a#! *1)b!.] ND l Nea-"/e D"a%ec-"c,P l P+",&, SER l S+c%+(+#5 a* E),%.%ca( R!/!a.c$ SO l S1b&!c0 a* Ob&!c0I*0!.,+(a0%+*/ a* ab.%#!)!*0/ a.! a(( )%*! 1*(!// %*%ca0! +0$!.3%/! T$!c+*2!./! $+(/ "+. !),$a/%/ %* -1+0a0%+*/ Pa#! *1)b!./ %))!%a0!(5 "+((+3abb.!2%a0%+*/ !4c!,0 3$!.! c+*0.ak%*%ca0! %* 0$! (%/0 ab+2! I $a2! a)!*! /+)!0.a*/(a0%+*/ I )a.' a* a)!*)!*0 +*(5 3$!* 0$! a)!*)!*0 +3!/ /+)!0$%*# 0+ a0$%. ,a.05 S0%(( 3$!.! I + a)!* a 0.a*/(a0%+* l b10 a(/+ %* /+)! +0$!. ca/!/ l I

3%(( .!"!. 0+ 0$! +.%#%*a( G!.)a* 3%0$ a 2%.#1(! !# DE j GS

T$! .!)a%*!. +" 0$%/ ,a,!. 3%(( .a0$!. *!#(!c0 0$! *+0%+* +" )+!.*%05 \b10 /!! J+(( ] M+.!+2!. I /$a(( /'%) +2!. A+.*+/ acc+1*0 +" 0$! ca.,e,+" 0$!/%01a0%+* 0$a0 $! )!a*/ 0+ %a#*+/! M5 c(+/%*# /!c0%+* 3!%#$/ 0$! %),+.0 +" 0$a0*!#(!c0

I #.+1, 0$! c(a%)/ b5 0!40 a* 0$! 0!40/ 0$!)/!(2!/ b5 +.!. +" c+),+/%0%+* N+0!$!.! 0$a0 I /$a.! 0$! c+))+* 2%!3 +" A+.*+ 0$a0 $%/ !2!(+,)!*0 c+*0a%*/ "!3 %"

a*5 "1*a)!*0a( c$a*#!/ +" )%* N+0! "1.0$!. 0$a0 0$! a0!/ #%2!* %* )5



27/176

25

b%b(%+#.a,$5 a.! +"0!* '(-0$! a0!/ +" 0$!f"+,-,1b(%ca0%+* +" 0$! 0!40 %* -1!/0%+*

I $a2! )+%"%! 0$! 0.a*/(a0%+* %* /1c$ a 3a5 a/ 0+ b.%*# %0 2!.5 c(+/! 0+ 0$! +(!.0.a*/(a0%+* b5 C1))%*# \/!! ]

^D_%! U*0!.3!."1*# a((!/ S!%!*!* 1*0!. !* (+#%/c$!* F+.)a(%/)1/

Da/ S!%* 3%. 1*0!. !) A/,!'0 !. V!.a.b!%01*# 1* V!.3a(01*# a*#!/c$a10A((!/ 3%. 61) 3%!!.$+(ba.!* !./!06ba.!* P.+6! 61) b(+!* B!%/,%!( ". %!b!#.%""(%c$!* M+!((! !/ S5/0!)/ a1c$ !. !%*6!(* M!*/c$ 2+) T%!. 61/c$3!%#!*

Wa/ %/0 %/0 )!$. a(/ !/ %/0 D%!/ M!$. 3%. %$) *%c$0 +'0.+5%!.0 /+*!.* b(!%b0

a(/ a/ a1/ %$) V!..9*#0! %$) %))a*!*0

^ _ %! !* S1b&!'0!* a ,.%+.% 2!./a#0 S1b&!'0! 61 /!%* S1b&!'0%2%090 /!(b!. 61)b(+!* Ob&!'0 !.*%!.%#0

B5 /,!a'/ %.!c0(5 +" !"+.)a0%+* I )!a* 1/!/ a G!.)a* 3+. 0.a*/(a0ab(! 3%0$a c+#*a0! +" 0$! E*#(%/$ 3+. `!"+.)a0%+* M+.!+2!. /1c$ 0!.)/ l Def(+&a-"('a*Def(+&"e+- a*M":b"%d.'l a.! .a.! %* A+.*+/ c+.,1/ a/ a 3$+(!

C+),a.! 0$! "+((+3%*# #(+// b5 A*.!3 F!!*b!.# +" H!%!##!./ c.%0%-1! +")+!.*%05 W$a0 H!%!##!. %/ a((!#%*# %/ a 2%+(a0%+* +" b+0$ $1)a*%05 a* *a01.!a0 a "a. !!,!. (!2!( 0$a* 3a. a* !*2%.+*)!*0a( !/0.1c0%+* \ ] H!.! +*!#(%),/!/ 0$! ,.+/,!c0/ "+. a 3%!. ,.+&!c0 +" 0$! 05,! 0$a0 I )!*0%+* %* )5 "%./0 *+0!

O. a0 (!a/0 0$a0 %/ 0$! (a.#!/0 +. )+/0 %/0%*c0%2! ,166(! 0$! !"+.)a0%+* c(a%)/,+/! F+. 0$! 2!.5 *+0%+* +" !"+.)a0%+* %*2+(2!/ \,a.0(5 +. 3$+((5 2%a 0$! %!a +""+.)] 0$! *+0%+* +" %!*0%05 a* 0$a0 *+0%+* $a/ +" c+1./! #.!a0(5 2!4!,$%(+/+,$!./ T$! %!a/ +" a c$a*#! %* /+)!0$%*#/ %!*0%05 a* +" a *+.)a0%2!%!*0%05 l %!a/ 0$a0 /!!) a(/+ 0+ b! a0 %//1! 3%0$ !"+.)a0%+* l 0$!/! %!a/ a.! 0$+.*5

0++ I c+*/%!. A+.*+/ %!a/ +* *+.)a0%2! %!*0%05 a0 2a.%+1/ ,(ac!/ %* J+(( \]a* %* h +" J+(( \b]

J+(( \ h]

I )a.' 0$a0 A/$c.+"0 $%)/!(" 3$+ %/ c+*/%!.%*# b+0$ A+.*+ a* H!%!##!.)!.!(5 !*0!.0a%*/ l .!)a%*/ a#*+/0%c ab+10 l 0$a0 c+*c(1/%+*

E%* &!#(%c$!/ S!%!*!/ %/0 )!$. a(/ !/ %/0 S!%* %* K+*0.a/0 61) S!%!*!* )a$*0a.a* W!%( *%c$0/ S!%!*!/ %/0 a/ *%c$0 %*!) !/ b!/0%))0 3%. 1* /%c$ /!(b/0

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



28/176

26 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

b!/0%))0 !%*!/ a*!.!* b!."0! a/ *%c$0 !/ /!(b!. %/0 l !** 1.c$ !/ /!(b/0 a((!%*39.! !/ *%c$0 61 b!/0%))!* l 3!%/0 !/ b!. /%c$ $%*a1/ V!.)%00(1*# %/0 a".(!%#(%c$ !%* a*!.!/ W+.0 \GS ] I $a2! )+%"%! 0$! 0.a*/(a0%+* +" 0$%/,a//a#! 3%0$ $!(, ".+) M. N%c$+(a/ Wa('!.

R+/!*/ b++' +!/ *+0 )1c$ #(+// 0$a0 /0a0!)!*0

C+),a.! a(/+ ,!.$a,/ 0$%/ )!%a0%+* %/ !*0a*#(!)!*0 %* c+*0!40 \ND 0.a*/(a0%+* a)!*! 3%0$ Ja.2%/ ]

S!((a./ ,.!/!*0/ $%/ E&)"+"c",& a'd -!e P!"%(,()!2 (f M"'da/ %*c%,%!*0Med"-a-"(',Hee%"8''e, \/!! 0$!.!%* , a* c" a(/+ 0$!.!%* , ] O*! )%#$0 *+0! "1.0$!. 0$a0c+%*c%!*0a((5 S!((a./ b++' a,,!a.! %* 0$! /a)! 5!a. a/ A+.*+/Me-ac+"-"*.e

^D_a/ S!%!*! *%c$0 1*)%00!(ba. /+*!.* *1. 1.c$ !* B!#.%"" a*61$!b!*

^D_!. B!#.%"" *%c$0/ !. Sac$! 1!.(%c$!/ 1* Z1"9((%#!/ /!% ^ _ /+*!.* a!. B!#.%"" H!#!(%/c$ #!/,.+c$!* a/ L!b!* !. Sac$! /!(b!. a1/.c'0

L+14 %/c1//!/ H%(a.5 P10*a) a* W 2 O Q1%*! 1*!. 0$a0 $!a%*# \/!! L+14 c$a,0!. ]

KCPR )+/0 "1((5 %/,(a5/ A+.*+/ %*0!.,.!0a0%+* a,,.a%/a( a* ,a.0%a(a,,.+,.%a0%+* +" Ka*0

T.a*/(a0%+* )+%"%! 3%0$ P%c'"+. \ ]

H!.! A+.*+ %/ #%2%*# a .a0$!. H!#!(%a* .!a%*# +" A.%/0+0(! F+. a c+),a.ab(!acc+1*0 %* 0$! "+.) +" a* A.%/0+0!(%a* .!a%*# +" H!#!( /!! c$a,0!./ a* +" S0!.*\]

A+.*+ ,.!/!*0/ 0$%/ 01.* 0+3a./ 0$! +b&!c0 %* a*+0$!. 3a5 0++ a/ a 01.* 0+

*+*%!*0%05 \/!! ND ] B10 a#a%* l a* !/,%0! 0$! %*0!.!/0 +" A+.*+/ *+0%+*\/]+" *+*%!*0%05 l I ca**+0 /!! 0$a0 %0 )1c$ $!(,/ %* 0$! ,.!/!*0 c+*0!40 I 0.!a0 0$!c+*c!,0%+* +" *+*%!*0%05 %* J+(( \b h]

J+(( \ h !/,!c%a((5 h] %*2!/0%#a0!/ 0$! %!a +" /+c%a( )!%a0%+* 2%ac+*c!,0/

A+.*+ 3a/ '!!* 0+ ,.!// 0$a0 ,+%*0 \/!! IS k A+.*+ ka* A+.*+ ] S+ 0++ %0 /!!)/ 3a/ H!#!( \/!! S0!.* ]



29/176

27

A "1((!. %*2!/0%#a0%+* +" 0$a0 ,$.a/! +" A+.*+/ 3+1( *!! 0+ (++' a0 (!a/0 a0$+3 $! 1*!./0++ 0$! .!(a0%+* b!03!!* $%/0+.5 a* /+c%!05 a* $+3 $! $!( 0$a0 la/ $! ,10/ %0 a0 +*! ,+%*0 l 0.10$ $a/ a 0!),+.a( c+.! \A+.*+ b ]

H!.! %/ 0$! 0!40 I 0$%*' 3! *!! 0+ c+*2%*c! +1./!(2!/ +" 0$%/ ^*a)!(5 0$a0 `0$!.!%/ ^ _ ab/+(10!(5 *+0$%*# 3$%c$ ^ _ %/ *+0 a(/+ /+c%a((5 )!%a0!_ I0 a(/+ a,,(%!/0+ *a01.a( /c%!*c! a* 0!c$*+(+#5 P(!a/! !4c1/! )! %" I #%2! a c.1! !4a),(! 3$%c$I c$++/! +*(5 0+ )a'! c(!a. 0+ 5+1 /+)!0$%*# 3$%c$ !a/%(5 !/ca,!/ +1. a3a.!*!// I0%/ 0$a0 !c%/%2! %/c+2!.%!/ %* )!%c%*! /1c$ a/ 0$a0 +" 0$! ca1/! +" ca*c!. a*0$!.!"+.! a ,+//%b(! c1.! "+. ca*c!. 3+1( ,.+bab(5 $a2! b!!* )a! (+*# a#+ $a*+0 a 3$+((5 !4c!//%2! a)+1*0 +" 0$! /+c%a( ,.+1c0 b!!* /,!*0 "+. /+c%a( .!a/+*/+* a.)a)!*0/ +. 0$! !4,(+.a0%+* +" !),05 /0a./ ^ _ %* a(( ,a.0/ +" 0$! 3+.( ^ _A0 a*5 .a0! 5+1 ca* /!! ".+) 0$%/ c.1! !4a),(! $+3 ,.+b(!)/ 0$a0 $a2! *+0$%*#

%.!c0(5 0+ + 3%0$ /+c%!05 a.! *!2!.0$!(!// /+c%a((5 )!%a0! a/ 3! ,10 %0 a* $+3"a. /+)!0$%*# 3$%c$ %* 0!.)/ +" %0/ c+*0!*0 a/ a ,a.0 +" *a01.! /!!)/ 0+ $a2! *+c+**!c0%+* 3%0$ /+c%!05 %/ %* "ac0 %)b1! 3%0$ %0

Ga,/ \MM h] b!#%*/ 3%0$ a* (a.#!(5 c+*c!.*/ 0$! "+((+3%*# %!a T$!3.%0!. %/ 1.#! 0+ /$+3 !4,(%c%0(5 a(( 0$! /0!,/ 0$a0 $a2! (! $%) 0+ $%/ c+*c(1/%+* /+!*ab(%*# !2!.5 .!a!. 0+ "+((+3 0$! ,.+c!// 0$.+1#$ a* 3$!.! ,+//%b(! l %* 0$!aca!)%c %*1/0.5 l 0+ 1,(%ca0! %0 \MM ] A+.*+ #+!/ +* /0.+*#(5 0+ !*+1*c!0$a0 1.#! H! )%#$0 $a2! .!#a.! 3$a0 I $a2! +*! %* 0$%/ ,a,!. a/ a* a00!),0 0+/1b&!c0 $%) 0+ 0$! aca!)%c %*1/0.5 I a.#1! bac' l a.#1! a#a%*/0 0$! .!(!2a*0 ,a.0/+" A+.*+/ )!0a,$%(+/+,$5 l %* a* !a.(%!. a.0%c(! \ J+(( a]

A+.*+ 0!((/ 1/ $%)/!(" 0$a0 $! !4a##!.a0!/ \/!! R+/! "] B10 0$a0 ca*+1.%/ *+0 %0/!(" )%0%#a0%*# I 0$%*' J+(( \a] a.#1!/ l %* !""!c0 a* a)+*# +0$!. 0$%*#/l 0$a0 !4a##!.a0%+* $a/ (%00(! ,(ac! %* ,$%(+/+,$5

N+0! ab+2! (%/0/ 0$a0 +0$!. 3+.' A *+0ab(! c+*0.%b10%+* 0+ %/ OC+**+. \]A *+0ab(! c+*0.%b10%+* 0+ %/ B!.*/0!%* \] 3$%c$ (%'! Ha))!. \] a* F%*'!\] !4a)%*!/ ,+%*0/ +" %!*0%05 a* %""!.!*c! b!03!!* A+.*+ a* J+$*

McD+3!((

B"b%"(+a)!2

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] I/ Ma.4 Ob/+(!0! D"(e'e, k \0.a*/(a0%+* +"S,90'a,%0a(%/)1/ +!. I*1/0.%!#!/!((/c$a"0 %* 2+( +" A+.*+/ Ge,a&&e%-eSc!+"f-e']

A+.*+ T$!++. W \]M"'"&a M(+a%"a Ref%ec-"(', (' Da&aed L"fe ^0.a*/ E FN J!,$c+00_ L+*+* V!./+

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



30/176

28 J: D**& &) D*+& A)

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] D"a%ec-"c (f E'%"!-e'&e'- ^0.a*/ J C1))%*#_ L+*+*V!./+

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] P+",&, 0.a*/ S a* S W!b!._ Ma//ac$1/!00/ MIT P.!//

A+.*+ T$!++. W \]Aa"',- E)",-e&(%(2 A Me-ac+"-"*.e ^0.a*/ W D+)%*#+_O4"+. B(ac'3!((

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] S+c%!05 0.a*/ F Ja)!/+*_ %* S B.+**!. a* D K!((*!.\!/] C+"-"ca% T!e(+2 a'd S(c"e-2 A Reade+ L+*+* R+10(!#! \k]

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] Nea-"/e D"a%ec-"c, ^0.a*/ E B A/$0+*_ L+*+*R+10(!#!

A+.*+ T$!++. W \a] Ae,-!e-"c T!e(+2 ^0.a*/ R H1((+0kK!*0+._ L+*+*A(0$+*!

A+.*+ T$!++. W \b] Ge,a&&e%-e Sc!+"f-e' F.a*'"1.0k+*kMa%* S1$.'a),

A+.*+ T$!++. W \c] S1b&!c0 a* Ob&!c0 %* A A.a0+ a* E G!b$a.0 \!/]T!e E,,e'-"a% F+a'$f.+- Sc!((% Reade+ N!3 Y+.' C+*0%*11)

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] S+c%+(+#5 a* E),%.%ca( R!/!a.c$ %* B OC+**+. \!]T!e Ad(+'( Reade+ O4"+. B(ac'3!(( \k]

A+.*+ T$!++. W \a] 3%0$ H+.'$!%)!. Ma4 D"a%ec-"c (f E'%"!-e'&e'-P!"%(,()!"ca% F+a&e'-, ^0.a*/ E J!,$c+00_ S0a*"+. S0a*"+. U*%2!./%05 P.!//

A+.*+ T$!++. W \b] Me-a)!2,"c, C('ce)- a'd P+(b%e&, ^0.a*/ E J!,$c+00_Ca)b.%#! P+(%05

A+.*+ T$!++. W \c] Ka'-, Ci"iq#e of P#e Rea!on ^0.a*/ R L%2%*#/0+*!_

Ca)b.%#! P+(%05

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] H",-(+2 a'd F+eed(& Lec-.+e, ?? ^0.a*/ RL%2%*#/0+*!_ Ca)b.%#! P+(%05

A+.*+ T$!++. W \] Lec-.+e, (' Nea-"/e D"a%ec-"c, ^0.a*/ R L%2%*#/0+*!_Ca)b.%#! P+(%05

B!.*/0!%* Ja5 M \] Ad(+'( D",e'c!a'-&e'- a'd E-!"c, Ca)b.%#! Ca)b.%#!U*%2!./%05 P.!//



31/176

29

B!.*/0!%* R%c$a. J \] T!e P+a&a-"c T.+'Ca)b.%#! P+(%05

F%*'! S0:(! \] C+*c!,0/ a* I*01%0%+*/ A+.*+ A"0!. 0$! `L%*#1%/0%c T1.*I'*."+2 k

F!!*b!.# A*.!3 \] Q.e,-"('"' Tec!'(%(2L+*+* R+10(!#!

Ha))!. E/,!* \] M%*%*# 0$! W+.( A+.*+/ C.%0%-1! +" I!a(%/)P!"%(,()!2 a'd S(c"a% C+"-"c",& \] k

Ha))!. E/,!* \]Ad(+'( a'd -!e P(%"-"ca%L+*+* R+10(!#!

H!#!( G W F \] Sc"e'ce (f L("c^0.a*/ A V M%((!._ N!3 J!./!5 H1)a*%0%!/

P.!//

H!#!( G W F \] T!e E'c2c%()aed"a L("c Pa+- I (f -!e E'c2c%()aed"a (f P!"%(,()!"ca%Sc"e'ce, 0"-! -!e Z1/906! ^0.a*/ T F G!.a!0/ W A S1c$0%*# a* H S Ha..%/_Ca)b.%#! Hac'!00

Ja.2%/ S%)+* \]Ad(+'( A C+"-"ca% I'-+(d.c-"(' Ca)b.%#! P+(%05

J+(( N%c$+(a/ \] T$! D!0!.)%*a0%+* a* D!"+.)a0%+* +" B!%*#/ A C.%0%ca(I*0!.,.!0a0%+* +" A+.*+ a* H!%!##!. 1*,1b(%/$! +c0+.a( 0$!/%/ U*%2!./%05 +"E//!4

J+(( N%c$+(a/ \a] H+3 S$+1( P$%(+/+,$5 B! C(!a. L+a! C(a.%05 D!"a1(0C(a.%05 a* A+.*+ Te%(, \S,.%*#] k

J+(( N%c$+(a/ \b] A+.*+/ N!#a0%2! D%a(!c0%c T$!)! P+%*0 a*M!0$++(+#%ca( S0a01/ I'-e+'a-"('a% J(.+'a% (f P!"%(,()!"ca% S-.d"e,\] k

L+14 M%c$a!( J \] Me-a)!2,"c, A C('-e&)(+a+2 I'-+(d.c-"('\/!c+* !%0%+*]

L+*+* R+10(!#!

McD+3!(( J+$* \]M"'d a'd W(+%dMa//ac$1/!00/ Ha.2a. U*%2!./%05 P.!//

OC+**+. B.%a* \] T$! C+*c!,0 +" M!%a0%+* %* H!#!( a* A+.*+ B.%%e-"' (f-!e Hee% S(c"e-2 (f G+ea- B+"-a"'j k

OC+**+. B.%a* \] Ad(+'(, Nea-"/e D"a%ec-"c P!"%(,()!2 a'd -!e P(,,"b"%"-2 (fC+"-"ca% Ra-"('a%"-2 L+*+* MIT P.!//

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



32/176

30

P%c'"+. H!*.5 \] T$! D%a(!c0%c +" T$!+.5 a* P.a4%/ O* La0! A+.*+ %* NG%b/+* a* A R1b%* \!/]Ad(+'( A C+"-"ca% Reade+O4"+. B(ac'3!((

R+/! G%((%a* \] T!e Me%a'c!(%2 Sc"e'ce L+*+* MacM%((a*

R+/!* M%c$a!( \] Hee%, D"a%ec-"c a'd I-, C+"-"c",& Ca)b.%#! Ca)b.%#!U*%2!./%05 P.!//

S!((a./ W%(".% \] E&)"+"c",& a'd -!e P!"%(,()!2 (f M"'dM%**!a,+(%/ U*%2!./%05+" M%**!/+0a P.!//

S0!.* R+b!.0 \] Hee% Ka'- a'd -!e S-+.c-.+e (f -!e Ob#ec-L+*+* R+10(!#!

S0!.* R+b!.0 \] H!#!(/ I!a(%/) %* F C B!%/!. \!] T!e Ca&b+"de C(&)a'"('-( Hee% a'd N"'e-ee'-!Ce'-.+2 P!"%(,()!2\/!c+* !%0%+*] Ca)b.%#! Ca)b.%#!U*%2!./%05 P.!// \k]

J: D**& &) D*+& A)



33/176

A F(+ce6e%d be-0ee' Na-.+e@ S(c"e-2 a'dRea,(' A))+(ac!"' Ad(+'(, P!"%(,()!2 (f

La'.ae

b5 P$%(%, H+#$

I* 0$! !a.(5 / J.#!* Hab!.)a/ c+*0!*! %* $%/ /!)%*a( T!e(+2 (fC(&&.'"ca-"/e Ac-"('0$a0 A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 .!,.!/!*0/ 0$! !4$a1/0%+*+" 0$! ,a.a%#) +" 0$! ,$%(+/+,$5 +" c+*/c%+1/*!// \ ] F.+) 0$%/

,+%*0 +* A+.*+/ a!/0$!0%c/ a* $%/ ,$%(+/+,$5 +" )1/%c .!c!%2! #.!a0!.a!*0%+* %* ,$%(+/+,$%ca( %/c1//%+*/ H%/ !,%/0!)+(+#5 a* /+c%a(,$%(+/+,$5 /!!)! a/ +10a0! a/ $%/ $%/0+.%c+k,$%(+/+,$%ca(c+*/%!.a0%+*/ I 0$%*' 0$!.! a.! 03+ )a%* .!a/+*/ "+. 0$! )a.#%*a(%6a0%+*+" A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 F%./0(5 *+ `(%*#1%/0%c 01.* ca* b! "+1* %* $%/,$%(+/+,$5 +. a0 (!a/0 *+ (%*#1%/0%c 01.* a/ %0 $a/ b!!* ca..%! +10 b5 0$!)a%*/0.!a) +" ,$%(+/+,$5 a* /!c+*(5 A+.*+/ *!#a0%2! c.%0%-1! +"/+c%!05 (+/0 %0/ ,!./1a/%2! ,+3!. a* )a! %0 a,,a.!*0(5 %),+//%b(! 0+ 3+.'3%0$ $%/ 0$+1#$0/ %* a "!.0%(! 3a5 !/,!c%a((5 a"0!. B10 /a5%*# #++b5!

0+ A+.*+ a/ a* !4,+*!*0 +" c+*/c%+1/*!// ,$%(+/+,$5 $a a,.!/1,,+/%0%+* *a)!(5 %#*+.%*# $%/ +3* (%*#1%/0%ck,$%(+/+,$%ca( 3+.'/

T$1/ Hab!.)a/ %*1!*0%a( c.%0%-1! l %! 0$a0 A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 )a.'/0$! 1(0%)a0! "a%(1.! +" 0$! ,$%(+/+,$5 +" c+*/c%+1/*!// ,a.a%#) a* +!/*+0 +!. a*5 (%*#1%/0%ck,$%(+/+,$%ca( +,,+.01*%0%!/ l %* 0$! !* "a((/ /$+.0

b!ca1/! Hab!.)a/ % *+0 !4a)%*! A+.*+/ (%*#1%/0%ck,$%(+/+,$%ca( 3+.'/I + *+0 3a*0 0+ c.%0%c%6! Hab!.)a/ a.#1)!*0 b5 +*(5 ,.!/!*0%*# A+.*+/,$%(+/+,$5 +" (a*#1a#! Ra0$!. 0$! a+,0%+* +" 0$! ,$%(+/+,$5 +"c+*/c%+1/*!// %0/!(" %/ a ,.+b(!) a/ Hab!.)a/ /!!)/ 0+ %!*0%"5c+*/c%+1/*!// ,$%(+/+,$5 a/ /1c$ 3%0$ %0/ %!a(%/0%c 2!./%+* )a%*(5

.!,.!/!*0! b5 D!/ca.0!/ a* G!.)a* I!a(%/) A(0$+1#$ A+.*+ $+(/ +*0+ a )+%! c+*c!,0 +" )!0a,$5/%c/ $%/ 3+.' ca* b5 *+ )!a*/ b! !c(a.!%!a(%/0%c M+/0 +" $%/ !,%/0!)+(+#%ca( 3+.'/ a%) 0+ !*c%.c(! )a0!.%a(%/0%ca((5a(0!.! c+*c!,0/ +" c+*/c%+1/*!// a* /1b&!c0%2%05 0$a0 %*0!#.a0! 0$! Ma.4%a*a* 0$! F.!1%a* c.%0%-1! +" %!a(%/) S+ !2!* %" Hab!.)a/ %/ .%#$0 %*!c(a.%*# A+.*+ a .!,.!/!*0a0%2! +" c+*/c%+1/*!// ,$%(+/+,$5 $! /0%((3+1( $a2! 0+ ,.++" 0$a0 A+.*+ )a'!/ 0$! /a)! )%/0a'!/ %* ca..5%*# +10$%/ c+*/c%+1/*!// ,$%(+/+,$5 a/ $%/ %!a(%/0%c a*c!/0+./ A/ Hab!.)a/ca**+0 /1,,(5 0$! !2%!*c! +" 0$%/ a.#1)!*0 %0 ca* b! +1b0! 3$!0$!. 0$%/



34/176

32

,a.0 +" $%/ c.%0%-1! /0.%'!/ A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 a0 a(( I0 3+1( b!c+)! !2!*)+.! %c1(0 0+ $+( +* 0+ Hab!.)a/ c.%0%-1! %" %0 ca* b! /$+3* 0$a0A+.*+/ c+*c!,0/ +" c+*/c%+1/*!// a* /1b&!c0%2%05 a.! !!,(5 c+**!c0!

3%0$ $%/ c+*c!,0%+* +" (a*#1a#! a* 0$a0 0$! 0$+1#$0 b!$%* a /!*0!*c! /1c$a/ T$! /1b&!c0 b!c+)!/ a /1b&!c0 +*(5 0$.+1#$ (a*#1a#! \ ] %/c.1c%a( "+. A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 W%0$ 0$! a+,0%+* +" c+*/c%+1/*!//,$%(+/+,$5 /+)!0$%*# !(/! 3a/ *!#(!c0! 0$! .!"!.!*c! 0+ 0$! 1*c+*/c%+1/0+ 0$! %*/0%*c0/ a* .%2!/ a* 0+ 3$a0 /0%(( ca* b! ca((! $1)a* *a01.!!/,%0! a(( c.%0%-1! +" !//!*0%a(%/) 0$a0 $a/ b!!* "+.)1(a0! b5,+/0/0.1c01.a(%/0 ,$%(+/+,$5 a* /+c%a( /c%!*c!/ I* c+*0.a/0 0+ Hab!.)a/ %0%/ a* a2a*0a#! %* A+.*+/ ,$%(+/+,$5 +" (a*#1a#! 0$a0 (a*#1a#! %/ /%01a0!a* !0!.)%*! %* a "+.c!!( K+af-fe%d_ b!03!!* %**!. a* !40!.*a( *a01.!.!a/+* a* /+c%!05 .!/,!c0%2!(5

I* 3$a0 "+((+3/ I 3%(( ,1./1! 0$%/ !0!.)%*a0%+* b5 %/c1//%*# 0$.!! ,+%*0/F%./0(5 b5 .!"!..%*# 0+ ,/5c$+a*a(5/%/ I 3%(( 0.5 0+ +10(%*! A+.*+/ 0$!+.5+" 0$! #!*!/%/ +" (a*#1a#! 0$a0 ca* b! "+1* )a%*(5 %* D"a%ec-"c (fE'%"!-e'&e'- I* +%*# /+ I 3%(( 0.5 0+ !)+*/0.a0! 0$a0 0$! #!*!/%/ +" 0$!/1b&!c0 ca**+0 b! 1*!./0++ 3%0$+10 0$! #!*!/%/ +" (a*#1a#! a* 0$a0".!!+) %/ c+**!c0! 3%0$ (a*#1a#! S!c+*(5 I 3%(( !4a)%*! 0$! .+(!(a*#1a#! ,(a5/ %* A+.*+/ /+c%a( 0$!+.5 T$%.(5 I 3%(( c+*c(1! 3%0$ a*a!),0 0+ +10(%*! A+.*+/ )a0!.%a(%/0 0$!+.5 +" )!a*%*# b5 .!"!..%*# 0+ $%/

c+*c!,0 +" `c+*/0!((a0%+* A/ I 3%(( a.#1! 0$%/ 0$!+.5 +" )!a*%*# %/ 0$!"+1*a0%+* "+. A+.*+/ c.%0%-1! +" (a*#1a#! a* "+. $%/ c.%0%ca( 0$!+.5 +"/+c%!05

8? O' -!e Ge'e,", (f La'.ae a'd S.b#ec-"/"-2

O*! +" 0$! c!*0.a( 0$+1#$0/ %* D"a%ec-"c (f E'%"!-e'&e'-%/ 0$a0 0$! /1b&!c0b!ca)! a /1b&!c0 b5 %/0a*c%*# %0/!(" ".+) !40!.*a( *a01.! a* b5 c+*0.+((%*#%0/ %**!. *a01.! %* 0$! /a)! ,.+c!// +!/ *+0 (!a2! a*5 +0$!. ,+//%b%(%05 b10

0+ /%01a0! 0$! #!*!/%/ +" (a*#1a#! %* 0$a0 ,.+c!// +" !)a*c%,a0%+* T$!$%/0+.%ca( ,$!*+)!*+* A+.*+ a* H+.'$!%)!. 1/! 0+ %((1/0.a0! 0$! #!*!/%/+" (a*#1a#! %/ 0$! )a#%c .%01a( I" "+. !a.(5 $1)a* b!%*#/ *a01.! ba/%ca((53a/ a ".%#$0!*%*# a* 0!..%"5%*# ,+3!. 0$!* )a#%c .%01a(/ a.! 0+ b!1*!./0++ a/ a )!0$+ +" $a*(%*# 0$! 0!..+./ a.%/%*# ".+) b.10! *a01.!B5 !*ac0%*# /1c$ .%01a(/ !a.(5 $1)a* b!%*#/ 0.%! 0+ !a/! 0$!%. +2!.k/0%)1(a0! *!.2+1/ /5/0!)/ Acc+.%*# 0+ F.!1 a(( *!.2+1/ /5/0!)/a!),0 0+ '!!, 0$!)/!(2!/ %* a* 1*/0%)1(a0! c+*%0%+* A /0%)1(1/ 0$a0%/ a,,(%! 0+ 0$! *!.2+1/ /5/0!) ".+) 0$! +10/%! ca* b! %/c$a.#! b5ac0%+* 0+ 0$! +10/%! \/!! F.!1 ] T$1/ a /0%)1(1/ ".+) 0$! +10/%!

H: A)? P< + L&&*



35/176

33H: A)? P< + L&&*

+!/ *+0 ,10 0$! *!.2+1/ /5/0!) 1*!. c+*/0a*0 ,.!//1.! A /0%)1(1/ ".+)3%0$%* 0$! +.#a*%/) a* %*/0%*c01a( +. .%2! /0%)1(1/ T+"eb+e"3_ +. a/ F.!1ca((/ %0 0++ a *!! ^Bed9+f'",_ ca**+0 b! %/c$a.#! b5 a /%*#(! ac0%+* 0+ 0$!

+10/%! a/ %0 %/ a c+*/0a*0 %),ac0 0$a0 "+.c!/ 0$! *!.2+1/ /5/0!) 0+ 1*!.0a'!)+.! c+),(!4 ac0%+*/ b5 3$%c$ 0$! !40!.*a( 3+.( %/ /+ c$a*#! a/ 0+a+. /a0%/"ac0%+* 0+ 0$! %*0!.*a( /+1.c! +" /0%)1(a0%+* \%b% ] B10 %"0$! /0%)1(% ".+) 0$! +10/%! a.! a/ ,+3!."1( +)*%,.!/!*0 a* ,!.)a*!*0a/ )1/0 b! ,.!k/1,,+/! +" *a01.a( 0$.!a0/ a* %" 0$! /$+c' 0$a0 %/ ca1/!

b5 0$!/! /0%)1(% +* 0$! *!.2+1/ /5/0!) %/ /+ 2a/0 0$a0 !/ca,%*# %0 %/ *+0!*+1#$ 0+ )a/0!. 0$!/! /0%)1(% 0$! *!.2+1/ /5/0!) 0$!* $a/ 0+ !2!(+,c!.0a%* 0!c$*%-1!/ 0$a0 ,.+)%/! 0!),+.a.5 a* .!(a0%2! .!/0 I* )a#%c .%01a(/0!c$*%-1!/ a* 05,!/ +" b!$a2%+1. 3!.! !2!(+,! a* !/0ab(%/$! 0$a0ca**+0 b! !4,(a%*! a/ )+.! +. (!// %))!%a0! .!ac0%+*/ 0+ %*0!.*a( a*!40!.*a( /0%)1(% 0$a0 3! ca* * %* 0$! a*%)a( 3+.( T$%/ %/ 3$a0 )a'!/)a#%c .%01a(/ /,!c%ca((5 $1)a* Acc+.%*# 0+ A+.*+ a* H+.'$!%)!.(a*#1a#! ,(a5! a c.1c%a( .+(! %* 0$! !2+(10%+*a.5 ,.+c!// %* 3$%c$ $1)a*(%"! !2+(2! +10 +" )!.! a*%)a(%/0%c (%"! T+ !)+*/0.a0! 0$%/ ,+%*0 0$!5%((1/0.a0! 0$! %!.!*c! b!03!!* )a* a* a*%)a( b5 !4,(a%*%*# 0$! "1*c0%+*+" (a*#1a#!

T$! a*%)a(/ 3+.( %/ !2+% +" c+*c!,0 I0 (ac'/ a*5 3+. 0+ /!%6! 0$!%!*0%ca( %* 0$! 14 +" ,$!*+)!*a 0+ %/+(a0! 0$! /a)! /,!c%!/ %* 0$!

a(0!.*a0%+* +" /,!c%)!*/ +. 0$! /a)! 0$%*# %* a(0!.! /%01a0%+*/ E2!*0$+1#$ 0$! ,+//%b%(%05 +" .!c+#*%0%+* %/ *+0 (ac'%*# %!*0%ca0%+* %/(%)%0! 0+ 3$a0 $a/ b!!* a(.!a5 !/0ab(%/$! T$!.! %/ *+0$%*# %* 0$!14 +" 0$%*#/ 0$a0 c+1( b! (ab!((! a/ ,!.)a*!*0 Y!0 !2!.50$%*#.!)a%*/ +*! a* 0$! /a)! "+. 0$! (ac' +" a*5 c!.0a%* '*+3(!#! +" 0$!,a/0 a* +" a*5 c(!a. !4,!c0a0%+* +" 0$! "101.! ^ _ T$! (%"! +" a*a*%)a( 1*.!(%!2! b5 0$! (%b!.a0%*# %*1!*c! +" 0$+1#$0 %/ .!a.5 a*$a./$ E/ca,! ".+) 0$! %/)a( !),0%*!// +" !4%/0!*c! ca((/ "+..!/%/0a*c! a* "+. 0$%/ /,!!c$ %/ !//!*0%a( \A+.*+ a* H+.'$!%)!. k]

T$%/ )!a*/ a*%)a(%/0%c (%"! %/ a* !4a),(! +" 3$a0 A+.*+ ca((/ 0$! /0a0! +"1*%!.!*0%a0!*!// \/!! A+.*+ ] T$! ,.+c!//!/ 0$.+1#$ 3$%c$!a.(5 $1)a* b!%*#/ %!.!*0%a0! 0$!)/!(2!/ ".+) )!.! *a01.! a.! c(+/!(5c+**!c0! 3%0$ 0$! ab%(%05 0+ %!*0%"5 c!.0a%* !4,!.%!*c!/ a/ /1c$ 0+ '!!,0$!) %* )%* 0$.+1#$ 0%)! 0+ c+)! bac' 0+ 0$!) .!ca((%*# 0$!) a*%/0%*#1%/$%*# 0$!) ".+) +0$!./ Acc+.%*# 0+ A+.*+ a* H+.'$!%)!.$1)a* b!%*#/ $a2! 0$!/! ab%(%0%!/ +*(5 3$!* 0$!5 a.! ab(! 0+ 1/! %a'.aeO*(5 3$!* a c!.0a%* !4,!.%!*c! %/ *a)! a* %!*0%! 3%0$ a c!.0a%* 3+.ca* 0$! !4,!.%!*c! b! .!)!)b!.! a* ca((! b5 %0/ *a)! c+*/c%+1/(5



36/176

34 H: A)? P< + L&&*

3%0$+10 b!%*# "+.c%b(5 .!,!a0! %* 0$! ,.!/!*0 Acc+.%*# 0+ D"a%ec-"c (fE'%"!-e'&e'- %0 3a/ *a01.!/ ,.!+)%*a*c! 0$! 1*'*+3* a* 0$! 0!..+. %0%),+/! 0$a0 )a! !a.(5 $1)a* b!%*#/ !2!(+, 0$!/! ab%(%0%!/ a/ 0$!5 $a

0+ $a*(! 0$!%. 0!..%"5%*# !4,!.%!*c!/ T$%/ $a,,!*! %* )a#%c .%01a(/ %*3$%c$ *a01.a( 0!..+. 3a/ $+*+1.! %* +.!. 0+ )a/0!. %0

E2!.50$%*# 1*'*+3* a* a(%!* %/ ,.%)a.5 a* 1*%!.!*0%a0! 0$a03$%c$ 0.a*/c!*/ 0$! c+**!/ +" !4,!.%!*c! 3$a0!2!. %* 0$%*#/ %/)+.! 0$a* 0$!%. ,.!2%+1/(5 '*+3* .!a(%05 W$a0 0$! ,.%)%0%2!!4,!.%!*c!/ %* 0$%/ .!#a. %/ *+0 a /,%.%01a( a/ +,,+/! 0+ a )a0!.%a(/1b/0a*c! b10 0$! %*0.%cac5 +" 0$! Na01.a( %* c+*0.a/0 0+ 0$! %*%2%1a(T$! c.5 +" 0!..+. 3$%c$ acc+),a*%!/ 0$! !4,!.%!*c! +" 0$! 1*1/1a(b!c+)!/ %0/ *a)! I0 4!/ 0$! 0.a*/c!*!*c! +" 0$! 1*'*+3* %*.!(a0%+* 0+ 0$! '*+3* a* 0$!.!"+.! 0!..+. a/ /ac.!*!// \A+.*+ a*H+.'$!%)!. ]

T$! c.5 +" 0!..+. %/ !4,.!//! )+.! +. (!// 1*3%((%*#(5 3$%(! 0$! *a01.a(0!..+. %0/!(" %/ !4,!.%!*c! T$%/ %/ 3$5 %0 %/ %c1(0 0+ %/0%*#1%/$ %0 ".+) a)!.! .!!4 B5 !4,.!//%*# 0$! 0!..+. 0$! $%#$(5 /0%)1(a0! *!.2+1/ /5/0!)%/c$a.#!/ %0/!(" B10 0$%/ c.5 +" 0!..+. a/ %0 %/ !4,.!//! %* %))!%a0!!4,!.%!*c! +" 0$! *a01.a( 0!..+. %/ *+0 5!0 0$! *a)! +" 0$! !%05 3$%c$ %/%)a#%*! a/ b!%*# 0$! .!/,+*/%b(! ca1/! "+. 0$! 0!..+. a* #!0/ $+*+1.! %*0$! )a#%c .%01a( A 2+ca( !4,.!//%+* ca* +*(5 b!c+)! 0$! *a)! +" a c!.0a%*

0$%*# %" 0$!.! %/ a c+*/c%+1/ /1b&!c0 0$a0 %*0!*/ 0+ *a)! a* +b&!c0 ".+)3$%c$ %0 %!./ I* a /%01a0%+* %* 3$%c$ 0$! *a01.a( 0!..+. %/ !4,!.%!*c! a*0$! c.5 +" 0!..+. %/ !4,.!//! 0$%/ *!c!//a.5 %!.!*c! +!/ *+0 5!0 !4%/0O*(5 3$!* 0$! !4,!.%!*c! 0!..+. %/ $+*+1.! (a0!. %* 0$! )a#%c .%01a( a*0$! c.5 3%0$ 3$%c$ 0$! 0!..+. 3a/ !4,!.%!*c! %/ !4,.!//! a#a%* +!/ 0$!c.5 +" 0!..+. a/ ,a.0 +" a c+*/c%+1/(5 ,(a**! a* ca..%! +10 ac0%+* /0a.0 0+

b!c+)! a *a)!

A *a01.a( ,$!*+)!*+* ca1/!/ a* !40.!)! 0!..+. 0$a0 $a/ 0+ b! !a(0 3%0$

a"0!.3a./ a#a%* a* a#a%* T$! )!)+.5 +" 0$! !4,!.%!*c! 0!..+. $a1*0/0$! 0!..+.%6! T$! 0!..+. %0/!(" 3a/ acc+),a*%! b5 0$! !4,.!//%+* +" 0$!c.5 +" 0!..+. B+0$ 0$! 0!..+. %0/!(" a* 0$! c.5 (!a2! a* %),.!//%+* %* 0$!*!.2+1/ /5/0!) F.!1 ca((! 0$%/ %),.!//%+* `)!)+.5 0.ac! T$! 0!..+.!4,!.%!*c! #!0/ c+**!c0! 3%0$ a c!.0a%* 2+ca( !4,.!//%+* A/ 0$! 0!..+. 3a/2a/0 a /%*#(! 2+ca( !4,.!//%+* % *+0 /1c! 0+ c+*0.+( %0 3$%c$ %/ 3$5 a/1b/!-1!*0 a* .!,!a0! aa,0a0%+* 3a/ *!c!//a.5 T$%/ aa,0a0%+* 0++',(ac! %* 0$! )a#%c .%01a( b5 $+*+1.%*# 0$! *a01.a( 0!..+. a/ !%05 3$%c$/$+1( /a2! 0$! a.c$a%c c+((!c0%2! T+ $+*+1. 0$! !%05 %0 $a 0+ b! ,.!/!*0T$1/ 0$! !4,!.%!*c! 0!..+. $a 0+ b! .!,.!/!*0! 3$%c$ 3a/ +*! b5



37/176

35H: A)? P< + L&&*

!4,.!//%*# 0$! c.5 0$a0 acc+),a*%! 0$! 0!..+. !4,!.%!*c! T$.+1#$ 0$! c.50$! )!)+.5 0.ac! 0$a0 3a/ (!"0 %* 0$! *!.2+1/ /5/0!) a/ a* %),.!//%+* +" 0$!0!..+. !4,!.%!*c! #!0/ ac01a(%6! T$! +.%#%*a( !4,!.%!*c! %/ .!)!)b!.!

a* .!,.!/!*0! 0$.+1#$ 0$! ac0 +" *a)%*# A%0%+*a((5 0$! *a)! %0/!("%/ a(/+ b!(%!2! 0+ b! ,.!/!*0 3$!* ca((%*# %0 b5 %0/ *a)!

A(0$+1#$ 0$%/ /1,,+/%0%+* %/ %..a0%+*a( a* ,1.! (%*#1a( )a#%c a c.1c%a(a2a*0a#! ca* b! "+1* %* %0 *a)!(5 0$! %)a#%*! ,.!/!*c! +" 0$! 0!..+.0$a0 3a/ ca1/! b5 %!.!*0 )a#%ca( ,.ac0%c!/ %* 3$%c$ (a*#1a#! 3a/ +*(5+*! ,.ac0%c! a)+*#/0 +0$!./ )a! a c+*/c%+1/ aa,0a0%+* ,+//%b(! W$%(!0!..+. %/ /0%(( %*0!*/! %* 0$! .%01a( %0 $a/ *+ %))!%a0! ,.!/!*c! T$! ,.!/!*c!%0 +!/ $a2! %/ a ,.+1c0 +" ,.ac0%ca( )%)!0%c b!$a2%+1. \%)%0a0%+*] a*c+*/c%+1/ %)a#%*a0%+* B10 0$%/ %!.!*c! %/ $%#$(5 %),+.0a*0 I* c+*0.a/00+ 0$! %))!%a0! 0!..+. !4,!.%!*c! 0$! )a#%c .%01a(/ (%)%0! a.!a +!./,+//%b%(%0%!/ 0+ 0.5 +10 %!.!*0 )!0$+/ +" !a(%*# 3%0$ 0$! 0!..+. T$!%.!c0 a* %))!%a0! 0!..+. !4,!.%!*c! (!a/ 0+ ,a*%c .!a"1( c.5%*# a*!/ca,! 3$!.!a/ %* 0$! )a#%c .%01a( 0$!.! a(.!a5 %/ /+)! '%* +" %/0a*c!

b!03!!* 0$! %*2+(2! ,!./+*/ a* 0$! 0!..+. 0$!5 "ac! a* $+*+1. T$!%/0a*c! 0$a0 !4%/0/ %* 0$%/ /1b/!-1!*0 aa,0a0%+* %/ a ./0 /0!, 0+3a./".!!+) 0$a0 %/ %))!%a0!(5 c+**!c0! 3%0$ (a*#1a#! A* !4,!.%!*c! %/ '!,0%* )%* 0$.+1#$ 0%)! b5 c+**!c0%*# %0 3%0$ a (%*#1a( !4,.!//%+* 0$a0 %/ 0+/a5 b5 *a)%*# %0 A/ .!)!)b!.! !4,!.%!*c! 0$! 0!..+. ca* b! aa,0! a*

*!3 "+.)/ +" aa,0a0%+* ca* b! 0.%! +10 N+3 0$!.! %/ a* +,,+.01*%05 0+.!"!. 0+ 0$! !4,!.%!*c! 0!..+. %* %!.!*0 3a5/ b!ca1/! a/ *a)! a*%!*0%! 3%0$ a c!.0a%* 3+. 0$! !4,!.%!*c! ca* b! %)a#%*! %* a c+*/c%+1/ac0 I" 0$! c+*/c%+1/ .!"!.!*c! 0+ /+)!0$%*# %/ ,+//%b(! 0$!* +*! ca* .!"!. 0+0$a0 ,a.0%c1(a. 0$%*# b10 +*! *!! *+0 + /+ D%/0a*c! ".+) 0$! .!a(!4,!.%!*c! +" /+)!0$%*# +0$!. 3a5/ +" ac0%*# ca* b! a!),0! 3$%c$ %/3$5 !a.(5 $1)a* b!%*#/ *+ (+*#!. $a 0+ "ac! 0$! .!a( *a01.a( 0!..+.1*,.!,a.! T$!5 3!.! *+ (+*#!. !"!*c!(!// /1b&!c0 0+ +*(5 0$!%. +3**!.2+1/ .!ac0%+*/ a* 0+ 0$! ".%#$0!*%*# *a01.! 3%0$+10 a*5 ,+//%b%(%05 "+.

%*0!.2!*0%+*/T$! !(!)!*0 +" ".!!+) 0$a0 %/ #%2!* b5 (a*#1a#! 0$!* %/ a(/+ a* !(!)!*0 +"+)%*a0%+* +. c+*0.+( T$%/ %/ /+ b!ca1/! %" 0$.+1#$ %!*0%"5%*#.!)!)b.a*c! +" a* !4,!.%!*c! 0$a0 %/ +*(5 ,+//%b(! 0$.+1#$ (a*#1a#! +0$!.3a5/ +" ac0%*# ca* b! 0.%! +10 0$! !2+(2%*# /1b&!c0 0$!.!b5 #a%*/ 0$!+,,+.01*%05 0+ c+*/c%+1/(5 a(%#* %0/ ac0%+*/ T$1/ %0 %/ *+0 a0 0$! )!.c5 +"%0/ +3* b+%(5 .!ac0%+*/ T+ 0$! /a)! !40!*0 %* 3$%c$ ,$!*+)!*a %* !40!.*a(*a01.! a.! !0!.)%*! a* *a)! \0$%/ )!a*/ 0$! %!*0%ca( %/ /!%6! %* 0$!14 +" ,$!*+)!*a] 0$! /1b&!c0/ %**!. *a01.! %/ !0!.)%*! +. "+.)! b5



38/176

36 H: A)? P< + L&&*

a(%#*%*# %0/ ac0%+*/ 0+ c!.0a%* +b&!c0/ a!-1a0!(5 I0 %/ c.1c%a( %* 0$!!0!.)%*a0%+* +" 0$%/ !(!)!*0 +" +)%*a0%+* 0+ b!a. %* )%* 0$a0 *+ /1b&!c0)a'!/ 0$!/! !4,!.%!*c!/ a/ a* a0+)%6! %*%2%1a( b10 .a0$!. a/ a )!)b!.

+" a* a.c$a%c c+((!c0%2! 3%0$ c!.0a%* (a3/ a* .1(!/ 0+ 3$%c$ %*%2%1a(ac0%+*/ /$+1( a$!.! T$! c+*0.+( +2!. !40!.*a( *a01.! $a/ a(3a5/ b!!*+.#a*%6! c+((!c0%2!(5 T$! /1b&!c0/ c+*0.+( +2!. %0/ +3* %**!. *a01.! %/*!%0$!. 0!),+.a((5 *+. (+#%ca((5 !a.(%!. \+. (a0!.] 0$a* %0/ c+*0.+( +2!. !40!.*a(*a01.! B+0$ "+.)/ +" +)%*a0%+* a* c+*0.+( a.! !-1%,.%)+.%a(%e"c!.+,)+9'%"c!_ O*! /$+1( *+0 "+.#!0 0$a0 )a#%c .%01a(/ 0$!)/!(2!/3!.! a ,a.0 +" 0a)%*# !40!.*a( *a01.! P.a5%*# 0+ 0$! #+/ 3a/ \$!( 0+ b!]

&1/0 a/ )1c$ a ,a.0 +" /1,,(5%*# "++ a/ /+3%*# a* $a.2!/0%*# \T.c'! ] T$! c+*/c%+1/ a(%#*)!*0 +" ac0%+*/ 0$a0 3a/ ,.!/1,,+/! b5 0$!(%*#1%/0%c %!*0%ca0%+* +" 0$! ac01a( /%01a0%+* $a,,!*! 1*!. c+((!c0%2!c+*0.+( H+3 c!.0a%* /%01a0%+*/ 3!.! %!*0%! 3%0$ 3+./ $+3 0$!/!3+./ 3!.! (%*'! 3%0$ !4,!.%!*c!/ 0$! 3a5 0$! /1b&!c0/ (!a.*! 0+ c+*0.+(0$!%. %**!. *a01.! 3!.! /+c%a((5 !0!.)%*! A(0$+1#$ 1*!./0a*%*# a*1/%*# (%*#1%/0%c "+.)/ c+..!c0(5 %/ 0$! c('d"-"( ,"'e *.a '('"+. (%b!.a0%*#$1)a* b!%*#/ ".+) 0$! *a01.a( 0$.a(+)\A+.*+ a* H+.'$!%)!. ] !2!* %* 0$! !a.(%!/0 $%/0+.%ca( "+.)/ +" /+c%a( (%"! (a*#1a#! %/ a(/+ a*%*/0.1)!*0 +" c+*0.+( a* +)%*a0%+* W$!* (a*#1a#! !*0!./ $%/0+.5 %0/)a/0!./ a.! ,.%!/0/ a* /+.c!.!./ W$+!2!. $a.)/ 0$! /5)b+(/ %/ %* 0$!*a)! +" 0$! /1,!.*a01.a( ,+3!./ /1b&!c0 0+ 0$!%. !a.0$(5 c+1*0!.,a.0/

3$+/! .!,.!/!*0a0%2!/ a.! 0$+/! c$+/!* +.#a*/ +" /+c%!05 \%b% ] I* 0$%/,!./,!c0%2! acc+.%*# 0+ D"a%ec-"c (f E'%"!-e'&e'-(a*#1a#! %/ 0$! c+*%0%+*+" 0$! ,+//%b%(%05 +" ".!!+) a* +)%*a0%+* I* +0$!. 3+./ 0$! 1/! +"(%*#1%/0%c /%#*/ b5 $1)a* b!%*#/ %/ a /%#* +" ".!!+) a* +)%*a0%+* J1/0a/ 0$! /1b&!c0 3+1( b! 1*ab(! 0+ c+*0.+( %0/ %**!. *a01.! acc+.%*# 0+ 0$!/+c%a( .!-1%.!)!*0/ 0$a0 a.! (%*#1%/0%ca((5 a,,(%! 0+ %0 3%0$+10 (a*#1a#! /+0++ 3+1( %0 b! 1*ab(! 0+ ac$%!2! ".!!+) ".+) !40!.*a( *a01.! a* /+c%a(.!-1%.!)!*0/ R!#a.%*# (a*#1a#! 0$! '!5 0$+1#$0 +" D"a%ec-"c (fE'%"!-e'&e'-%/ 0$a0 (a*#1a#! b.!a'/ *a01.a( 0$.a(+) a* (!a/ 0+ /+c%a(

c+!.c%+* 5!0 3%0$+10 (a*#1a#! 0$! ,+//%b%(%05 +" /+c%a( (%b!.a0%+* 3+1(c!a/!

9? La'.ae a'd S(c"e-2

Ha2%*# !4a)%*! 0$! #!*!/%/ +" (a*#1a#! a* %0/ .!(a0%+* 0+ 0$! %a(!c0%c +"/1b&!c0%2! ".!!+)j+)%*a0%+* 3$a0 0$!* )a5 b! /a% +" 0$! .!(a0%+*/

b!03!!* (a*#1a#! ".!!+) a* +)%*a0%+* 3%0$%* /+c%!05 )+.!/,!c%ca((5 ca)"-a%",-/+c%!05 A+.*+ a.#1!/ 0$a0 (a*#1a#! %* ca,%0a(%/) %/a /%#* /5/0!) a(0$+1#$ $! a/ 0$a0 (a*#1a#! +!/ *+0 )!.#! %* 0$%/



39/176

37H: A)? P< + L&&*

"1*c0%+* T$%/ /$+1( a(3a5/ b! '!,0 %* )%* H+3 b!/0 ca* 3! 1*!./0a*0$! a//!.0%+* 0$a0 (a*#1a#! %/ a /%#* /5/0!) I0 %/ %c1(0 0+ c(a.%"5 3$%c$(%*#1%/0%c 0$!+.%!/ A+.*+ .!"!./ 0+ %* 0$%/ a//!.0%+* b10 %0 %/ 1*(%'!(5 0+ b!

+0$!./ 0$a* 0$+/! )+/0 ,.!2a(!*0 1.%*# $%/ (%"!0%)! F!.%*a* !Sa1//1.!/ (%*#1%/0%c/ )1/0 b! )!*0%+*! $!.! b10 a(/+ %!.!*0 '%*/ +"a*a(50%c ,$%(+/+,$5 \!/,!c%a((5 0$! !a.(5 W%#!*/0!%*] T+ !)+*/0.a0! 0$!,.+b(!) A+.*+ "ac! %* 0$! .!(a0%+* b!03!!* (a*#1a#! a* ca,%0a(%/) I3%(( b.%!5 .!"!. 0+ Sa1//1.!/ 0$!+.5

I* $%/ C(.+,e "' Ge'e+a% L"'.",-"c,Sa1//1.! a.#1!/ 0$a0 ab+2! a(( /%#*/ a.!a.b%0.a.5 \/!! Sa1//1.! ] T$%/ )!a*/ 0$a0 0$! )!a*%*# +" /%#*/ %/*+0 !/%#*a0! +*c! a* "+. a(( b10 %/ !0!.)%*! b5 (a*#1a#! a/ a /5/0!)a0%c3$+(! l Sa1//1.! ca((/ %0 %a'.el %* a* 0$.+1#$ 3$%c$ a(( /%#*/ a.! %* c(!a.(5!*! .!(a0%+*/ 0+ +*! a*+0$!. T$!%. )!a*%*# %/ *+0 ,.!/1

sspt issue 17 final

Documents