spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · the role of spectroscopy triplespec...

58
Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems Andrew Tkachenko and IvS team Instituut voor Sterrenkunde, KU Leuven Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems

Andrew Tkachenko and IvS team

Instituut voor Sterrenkunde, KU Leuven

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 2: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Why spectrum analysis?

Because it is important!

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 3: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The role of spectroscopy

TripleSpec [email protected] Hale telescope

2014 Science, 344, 277

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 4: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The role of spectroscopy

The HIRES spectrograph@10m Keck telescope

2013 Nature, 503, 381

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 5: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The role of spectroscopy

The FIES [email protected] NOT telescope

2013 Science, 342, 331

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 6: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The role of spectroscopy

The HRS [email protected] HET telescope +

The Tull Coude [email protected] HJST telescope +

The HIRES spectrograph@10m Keck telescope +

The FIES [email protected] NOT telescope

2012 Nature, 481, 475

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 7: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The role of spectroscopy

The SES [email protected] Otto Struve telescope +

The NARVAL spectrograph@2m TBL telescope +

The FIES [email protected] NOT telescope

2011 Nature, 477, 570

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 8: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The role of spectroscopy

FIES + TLS + DAO + Tull

2011 Science, 332, 216

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 9: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Spectrum analysis

• Precise atmospheric parameters + chemical composition

• Production and evolution of chemical elements, stellar and galactic evolution

• Understanding of various physical processes in stars

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 10: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Spectral disentagling what is it about?

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 11: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Separation of individual spectra + binary parameters

Simon & Sturm (1994, A&A, 281, 286): disentangling in wavelength domain Æ spectrum separation + RV amplitudes

Spectral disentagling what is it about?

Hadrava (1995, A&AS, 114, 393): disentangling in Fourier space Æ spectrum separation + orbital elements.

Page 12: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Spectral disentagling in practice

FDBinary code (Ilijic et al. 2004, ASPC, 318, 11)

Web site: http://sail.zpf.fer.hr/fdbinary

Page 13: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

• Current version 3 (fdb3)

• Disentangling of spectra in the Fourier space.

• The code is written in C and is designed as a command- line utility for a Unix-like operating system.

• Three component hierarchical orbital model.

• AÆB – close pair in a wide (eccentric) Keplerian orbit with tertiary C.

FDBinary

Page 14: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

• demo.in: control file with descriptors to observed spectra, and orbital parameters initial guess with limits for optimization. Times are in days, velocities in km/s, angles in degrees.

FDBinary: input

• demo.obs: observed spectra Æ wavelength (log-scale) normalized flux

Page 15: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Page 16: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Time-series of observations (log-wavelength vs.

normalized flux)

Page 17: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Wavelength range to be disentangled (log-scale)

Page 18: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

(Output) file with the observations in the

wavelength range used for the disentangling

Page 19: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Number of stellar components

Page 20: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Characteristics of the observed

spectra

Page 21: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Julian date of the observation

Page 22: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Heliocentric radial velocity correction

Page 23: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Weight

Page 24: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Light factor (primary)

Page 25: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Light factor (secondary)

Page 26: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Parameters of the outer orbit

Page 27: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Parameters of the inner orbit

Page 28: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

period T0 e Z K1 K2

Page 29: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Optimization runs + iterations + tolerance

Page 30: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Disentangled spectra

Page 31: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Residuals (O-C)

Page 32: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Radial velocities (pixel units)

Page 33: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: input file

Log-file

Page 34: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: output files (*.mod)

Wavelength (log-scale)

Flux1

Flux2

Page 35: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: output files (*.rvs)

RV1 RV2

Page 36: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

FDBinary: example

RV1 RV2

Observations + fit

Disentangled spectra

Page 37: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Spectrum analysis in practice

GSSP code (Tkachenko 2015, in preparation)

Will be available on the IvS web site after the workshop

Page 38: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package

• GSSP_single:

• GSSP_binary:

• GSSP_composite:

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 39: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package: building blocks • The SynthV code (Tsymbal 1996): LTE-based radiative

transfer, individual abundances, stratification, atomic + molecular transitions

• The LLmodels code (Shulyak 2004): LTE-based atmosphere models, line-by-line opacities, individual abundances, stratification

• Bonus: MARCS models (low temperatures), interpolated grid of Kurucz models

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 40: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package: LLmodels grid

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 41: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP_single module: algorithm

Single stars +

Disentangled spectra of binary components

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Valentina
Text
Page 42: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_single: single stars

Application to Vega

(Lehmann et al. 2011)

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 43: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_single: single stars

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 44: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_single: more examples

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 45: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_single: disentnalged spectra

IvS seminar, 10.04.2015

primary secondary

Page 46: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_single: disentangled spectra

IvS seminar, 10.04.2015

KIC 4931738: Papics et al. (2013)

primary secondary

Page 47: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP_binary module: algorithm

Disentangled spectra of binary components

(wavelength-dependent light dilution)

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 48: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_binary: disentangled spectra

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 49: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_binary: disentangled spectra

KIC 4931738: Papics et al. (2013)

primary secondary

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 50: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_binary: disentangled spectra KIC 6352430: Papics et al. (2013)

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 51: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_binary: disentangled spectra KIC 6352430: Papics et al. (2013)

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 52: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP_composite module: algorithm

Composite spectra fitting

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 53: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

GSSP_composite: composite spectra

primary

composite

secondary

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 54: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package: documentation

Appendix

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 55: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package@IvS

Single machine: mpirun –n N executable_name input_file

SLURM: sbatch SLURm_command_file

Best  „documentation“: office 03.32

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 56: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package with SLURM Run time in

minutes Number of

CPUs

Output and log-files

Basic setup, work directory, running

command

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 57: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package: output

Grid of atmosphere models

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

Page 58: Spectroscopic analysis of double-lined binary systems · The role of spectroscopy TripleSpec Spectrograph@5.1m Hale telescope 2014 Science, 344, 277 Binary workshop, 14.04.2015

The GSSP package: output

F2 tables

Binary workshop, 14.04.2015