spectral nature of co adsorption on meteorites · 2014-03-17 · spectral nature of co 2 adsorption...

1
Spectral Nature of CO 2 Adsorption on Meteorites Genesis Berlanga 1,3 , Charles A. Hibbitts 1 , Driss Takir 2 , M. Darby Dyar 3 1 Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory, 2 University of Tennessee Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, 3 Mount Holyoke College Department of Astronomy ([email protected]) Reflectance Spectra of Meteorites Introduction (left) Schematic of experimental set-up showing positions of FTIR and external detectors. (right) Sample in place in holder. The powdered sample is held in the copper holder with a MgF 2 window. The reflectance reference standard is below the sample and, being powdered UV-grade MgF 2 material, is also held in place with a MgF 2 window. Conclusions & Future Work We continue to investigate the adsorption of CO 2 by carbonaceous meteorites expanding upon our preliminary work [1]. Because CO 2 has been detected in surfaces of airless bodies too warm to exist as ice, it has been postulated to be held by structural trapping, physisorption, or chemisorption [2]. By investigating the adsorption of CO 2 onto carbonaceous chondrite meteorite material, material thought to reflect regions of the primordial solar nebula that did not undergo significant heating (>200 C) [6], the goal is to understand the potential adsorption processes of CO 2 by non-ice materials on asteroid, comets, and the icy and the irregular satellites orbiting Jupiter and Saturn. Abstract # 2773 Inside the chamber standard sample cryostat System schematic [1] Hibbitts et al., (2000) J. Geophys. Res.; [2] Hibbitts & Szanyi, (2007) Icarus; [3] Hibbitts et al., (2012) 43rd LPSC Abstract #2400; [4] Takir et al., (2013) MAPS; [5] Sandford & Al-lamandola., (1989) ApJ; [6] Norton, (2002). Cam- bridge Encyclo. of Met., Cambridge Uni. Press. p121– 124.; [7] Clark et al., (2005) Nature; [8] Palmer, (2009) U. Arizona., Ph D. diss.; [9] Pearson et al., (2002) 33rd LPSC Abstract #1311; [10] Nave and Jack-son, (2007) J. Chem. Phys; [11] Greenspon et al., (2012) 43rd LPSC Abstract #2490, [12] Bells et al. (2008) Icarus. We would like to acknowledge the support of the NASA Outer Planets Research Program grant # NNX10AB83G. Sample holder Procedures (above) Average spectra of nine meteorite samples after dosing with CO 2 . All were class CM2 excluding Ivuna (CI), QUE 99038 (CV2), and Bells (C2 unassigned). Note: the hydration state (~ 3-micron band) varies dramatically between meteorite as does the amount of CO 2 adsorption ( ~ 4.26 micron band). (below) Same set of spectra. (above left) Trend of CO 2 absorption band depth and shape trend with time after dosing for Bells (top) which remained largely constant with depth and spectrally invariant, and for Ivuna whose band depth increased and shifted after dosing stopped. The presence of the 13 CO 2 band near 4.37 microns is indicative of large amounts of CO 2 , however, the characteristics of the 4.26-micron band is consistent with adsorbed CO 2 (is wider) than CO 2 ice. (above right) The CO 2 band positions for the average meteorite value range between 4.26-4.28 μm. The meteorites with greater CO 2 adsorption fall towards the lower wavelengths (Ivuna being an exception), indicative of a larger number of adsorption sites. References & Acknowledgements 1. Approx. 100 mg of meteorite powder is placed in the sample holder (see figures to right). 2. Sample holder and sample are attached to the end of a cryostat in a vacuum system. 3. Chamber is evacuated to ~ 1E-7 or lower, and usually the system is heated to ~ 80 o C overnight. 4. System is then cooled and sample holder is heated to 475 K for 4 to 6 hours to desiccate. 5. Sample is then cooled to 150 K via liquid nitrogen. 6. CO 2 is dosed directly onto the sample via a 1/4” tube from an external gas supply to a vacuum fitting on the sample holder. 7. Spectra are obtained at 150 K before dosing, during dosing, and after dosing at 150 K. 8. Spectra are obtained at 150K until all CO 2 is desorbed or until ~ 14 hours after dosing. CO 2 adsorbs onto ground carbonaceous meteorite matrix. The lack of correlation with water abundance suggests the CO 2 does not complex with water or OH to form a carbonate complex, but rather adsorbs onto the meteorite material. Ivuna, a CI chondrite, is unique in that its matrix material is dominated by complex clay minerals; these clays, with high microporosity and many available charge compensating cations may explain its particularly strong affinity for CO 2 [1]. The CV chondrite, QUE 99038 adsorbed 10% more CO 2 than the average CM2 chondrite adsorption. CV chondrite parent bodies are suspected to be the K type inner belt asteroids [12]. These asteroids are found ~2.2 AU from the sun and have been exposed to temperatures ranging from 675-875 K. It may be postulated that early solar system CO 2 transport was not only limited to carbonaceous or outer main belt asteroids but to the main and inner asteroid belt as well. (above) CO 2 adsorption/desorption was observed over the span of 6-17 hours, with the sample maintained at 150K. Ivuna continued adsorbing (possibly CO 2 outgassed from the cryostat) the entire time. QUE 99038 reached a maximum band depth near the 4 hour mark and very slowly began to outgas but still retained more CO 2 than the other meteorites 1. CO 2 adsorbs onto carbonaceous meteorite matrix materials at 150K. 2. The amount of CO 2 adsorbing varies between meteorites, though all meteorites but Cold Bokkeveld, LAP 02277, and MET 00639 showed some CO 2 adsorption. 3. There is a weak trend in CO 2 adsorption with meteorite class. 4. CO 2 band position generally shifts to longer wavelengths for deeper CO 2 bands (infer greater CO 2 abundance) implying those meteorites have more adsorption sites. 5. Ivuna (the only CI) adsorbs significantly more CO 2 , and more strongly, than the other samples. 6. CO 2 adsorption trends with Fe 3+ concentration and silicate fraction; and trends inversely with several factors, most notably, Fe 2+. Amount of CO 2 over time after dosing Change in CO 2 band after dosing Change in CO 2 band after dosing Correlations and inverse correlations between CO 2 abundance and composition (far left) Inverse trend between composition and CO 2 adsorption, notably with Fe 2+ . (left) Correlation between composition of adsorption of CO 2 , notably with Fe 3+ and silica content. Trends tend to diminish for CM meteorites. No trend in falls versus finds. Falls include Ivuna, QUE 99038, and Cold Bokkeveld. A high Mineral alteration index (MAI) correlates with no CO 2 adsorption (Cold Bokkeveld, LAP 02277, and MET 00639). CI CV C2 CM2 CI CV C2 CM2 Results

Upload: others

Post on 16-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Spectral Nature of CO Adsorption on Meteorites · 2014-03-17 · Spectral Nature of CO 2 Adsorption on Meteorites Genesis Berlanga1,3, Charles A. Hibbitts1, Driss Takir2, M. Darby

Spectral Nature of CO2 Adsorption on Meteorites Genesis Berlanga1,3, Charles A. Hibbitts1, Driss Takir2, M. Darby Dyar3

1Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory, 2University of Tennessee Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences,

3Mount Holyoke College Department of Astronomy ([email protected])

Reflectance Spectra of Meteorites Introduction

(left) Schematic of experimental set-up showing positions of FTIR and external detectors. (right) Sample in place in holder. The powdered sample is held in the copper holder with a MgF2 window. The reflectance reference standard is below the sample and, being powdered UV-grade MgF2 material, is also held in place with a MgF2 window.

Conclusions & Future Work

We continue to investigate the adsorption of CO2 by carbonaceous meteorites expanding upon our preliminary work [1]. Because CO2 has been detected in surfaces of airless bodies too warm to exist as ice, it has been postulated to be held by structural trapping, physisorption, or chemisorption [2]. By investigating the adsorption of CO2 onto carbonaceous chondrite meteorite material, material thought to reflect regions of the primordial solar nebula that did not undergo significant heating (>200 C) [6], the goal is to understand the potential adsorption processes of CO2 by non-ice materials on asteroid, comets, and the icy and the irregular satellites orbiting Jupiter and Saturn.

Abstract # 2773

Inside the chamber

standard

sample

cryo

stat

System schematic

[1] Hibbitts et al., (2000) J. Geophys. Res.; [2] Hibbitts & Szanyi, (2007) Icarus; [3] Hibbitts et al., (2012) 43rd LPSC Abstract #2400; [4] Takir et al., (2013) MAPS; [5] Sandford & Al-lamandola., (1989) ApJ; [6] Norton, (2002). Cam-bridge Encyclo. of Met., Cambridge Uni. Press. p121– 124.; [7] Clark et al., (2005) Nature; [8] Palmer, (2009) U. Arizona., Ph D. diss.; [9] Pearson et al., (2002) 33rd LPSC Abstract #1311; [10] Nave and Jack-son, (2007) J. Chem. Phys; [11] Greenspon et al., (2012) 43rd LPSC Abstract #2490, [12] Bells et al. (2008) Icarus. We would like to acknowledge the support of the NASA Outer Planets Research Program grant # NNX10AB83G.

Sample holder

Procedures

(above) Average spectra of nine meteorite samples after dosing with CO2. All were class CM2 excluding Ivuna (CI), QUE 99038 (CV2), and Bells (C2 unassigned). Note: the hydration state (~ 3-micron band) varies dramatically between meteorite as does the amount of CO2 adsorption ( ~ 4.26 micron band). (below) Same set of spectra.

(above left) Trend of CO2 absorption band depth and shape trend with time after dosing for Bells (top) which remained largely constant with depth and spectrally invariant, and for Ivuna whose band depth increased and shifted after dosing stopped. The presence of the 13CO2 band near 4.37 microns is indicative of large amounts of CO2, however, the characteristics of the 4.26-micron band is consistent with adsorbed CO2 (is wider) than CO2 ice. (above right) The CO2 band positions for the average meteorite value range between 4.26-4.28 μm. The meteorites with greater CO2 adsorption fall towards the lower wavelengths (Ivuna being an exception), indicative of a larger number of adsorption sites.

References & Acknowledgements

1. Approx. 100 mg of meteorite powder is placed in the sample holder (see figures to right).

2. Sample holder and sample are attached to the end of a cryostat in a vacuum system.

3. Chamber is evacuated to ~ 1E-7 or lower, and usually the system is heated to ~ 80oC overnight.

4. System is then cooled and sample holder is heated to 475 K for 4 to 6 hours to desiccate.

5. Sample is then cooled to 150 K via liquid nitrogen.

6. CO2 is dosed directly onto the sample via a 1/4” tube from an external gas supply to a vacuum fitting on the sample holder.

7. Spectra are obtained at 150 K before dosing, during dosing, and after dosing at 150 K.

8. Spectra are obtained at 150K until all CO2 is desorbed or until ~ 14 hours after dosing.

CO2 adsorbs onto ground carbonaceous meteorite matrix. The lack of correlation with water abundance suggests the CO2 does not complex with water or OH to form a carbonate complex, but rather adsorbs onto the meteorite material. Ivuna, a CI chondrite, is unique in that its matrix material is dominated by complex clay minerals; these clays, with high microporosity and many available charge compensating cations may explain its particularly strong affinity for CO2 [1]. The CV chondrite, QUE 99038 adsorbed 10% more CO2 than the average CM2 chondrite adsorption. CV chondrite parent bodies are suspected to be the K type inner belt asteroids [12]. These asteroids are found ~2.2 AU from the sun and have been exposed to temperatures ranging from 675-875 K. It may be postulated that early solar system CO2 transport was not only limited to carbonaceous or outer main belt asteroids but to the main and inner asteroid belt as well.

(above) CO2 adsorption/desorption was observed over the span of 6-17 hours, with the sample maintained at 150K. Ivuna continued adsorbing (possibly CO2 outgassed from the cryostat) the entire time. QUE 99038 reached a maximum band depth near the 4 hour mark and very slowly began to outgas but still retained more CO2 than the other meteorites

1. CO2 adsorbs onto carbonaceous meteorite matrix materials at 150K. 2. The amount of CO2 adsorbing varies between meteorites, though all meteorites but

Cold Bokkeveld, LAP 02277, and MET 00639 showed some CO2 adsorption. 3. There is a weak trend in CO2 adsorption with meteorite class. 4. CO2 band position generally shifts to longer wavelengths for deeper CO2 bands (infer

greater CO2 abundance) implying those meteorites have more adsorption sites. 5. Ivuna (the only CI) adsorbs significantly more CO2, and more strongly, than the other

samples. 6. CO2 adsorption trends with Fe3+ concentration and silicate fraction; and trends

inversely with several factors, most notably, Fe2+.

Amount of CO2 over time after dosing

Change in CO2 band after dosing

Change in CO2 band after dosing

Correlations and inverse correlations between CO2 abundance and composition

(far left) Inverse trend between composition and CO2 adsorption, notably with Fe2+. (left) Correlation between composition of adsorption of CO2, notably with Fe3+ and silica content. Trends tend to diminish for CM meteorites. No trend in falls versus finds. Falls include Ivuna, QUE 99038, and Cold Bokkeveld. A high Mineral alteration index (MAI) correlates with no CO2 adsorption (Cold Bokkeveld, LAP 02277, and MET 00639).

CI CV C2 CM2 CI CV C2 CM2

Results