south carolina office of regulatory staff and gas...south carolina office of regulatory staff review...
TRANSCRIPT
SouthCarolinaOfficeofRegulatoryStaff
ReviewofSouthCarolinaElectric&GasCompany’s20133rdQuarterReportonV.C.SummerUnits2and3StatusofConstruction
January10,2014
‐ i‐
TableofContents
ExecutiveSummary (1) IntroductionandBackground (3)
ApprovedScheduleReview (5) MilestoneSchedule (5)
HistoricalMilestones (6)FutureMilestones (7)SpecificConstructionActivities (8)CriticalPathActivities (9)Transmission (11)ChangeOrdersandAmendments (13)
LicensingandInspectionActivities (15)
FederalActivities (15) StateActivities (15)
ApprovedBudgetReview (16) CapitalCosts (16) ProjectCashFlow (16) AFUDCandEscalation (18) AnnualRequestforRevisedRates (18)
AdditionalORSMonitoringActivities (19)SummaryofORSVisittoCB&I‐LCFacility (20)ConstructionChallenges (21) StructuralModules (21) ShieldBuildingModules (22) StructuralDesignCompliance (22) InstrumentationandControlDesign (22) OverlappingUnit2&Unit3ConstructionSchedules (23) ManufacturingofMajorEquipment (23)LicenseAmendmentReviews (23)
NotableActivitiesOccurringAfterSeptember30,2013 (24) AccumulatedDeferredIncomeTaxTimingDifference (24) CautionMilestones (24) EquipmentDelivery (25) NRCLicensing (25) SiteFacilities (25) StructuralModules (25) TurbineBuilding (26) Unit3NuclearIsland (26)
‐ ii‐
Appendices
AppendixA: DetailedMilestoneScheduleasofSeptember30,2013
AppendixB: CautionMilestones
AppendixC: ConstructionSitePhotographs
AppendixD: LicenseAmendmentRequests
AppendixE: SCE&GBasematConcretePressRelease
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |1
ExecutiveSummary
On November 8, 2013, SCE&G submitted its 2013 3rd Quarter Report related toconstructionofV.C.SummerUnits2&3.TheReportisfiledinCommissionDocketNo.2008‐196‐E and covers thequarter ending September30, 2013. With reference to theBaseLoadReviewAct,ORS’sreviewoftheCompany’sReportfocusesonSCE&G’sabilitytoadheretotheapprovedscheduleandapprovedbudget.
ApprovedScheduleReviewORS reported in its 2013 2nd Quarter Report that SCE&G announced that its
Engineering,ProcurementandConstructioncontractpartners,WestinghouseElectricCompanyand Chicago Bridge and Iron, had preliminarily indicated to SCE&G that the substantialcompletion date of Unit 2 is expected to be delayed until the 4th quarter of 2017 or the 1stquarter of 2018, with the substantial completion date of Unit 3 expected to be delayedsimilarly1.Thispotentialdelayisprimarilyduetochallengesintheprojectschedulerelatedtodelays in sub‐module fabrication and delivery, specifically the CA01 module. CA01 is astructural module which sits inside the containment vessel and forms the refueling canal,steam generator compartments and pressurizer compartment. SCE&G’sMilestone SchedulereflectsadelayintheUnit2substantialcompletiondatefromMarch15,2017toDecember15,2017, and a delay from May 15, 2018 to December 15, 2018 in the Unit 3 substantialcompletiondate.PertheBaseLoadReviewOrder,overallconstructionisconsideredtobeonschedule if the substantial completion dates are not accelerated more than 24 months ordelayedmorethan18months.Whiledelayed,thesubstantialcompletiondatesfallwithintheparametersallowedbytheBaseLoadReviewOrder.AsofSeptember30,2013,92ofthe146milestoneactivitieshadbeencompleted.Sixteenyettobecompletedmilestoneactivitieshadbeendelayedby10monthsormore,withtwomilestonesindicatingadelayof15months.
ORShasidentifiedseveralongoingconstructionchallengesthatposeapotentialriskto
theon‐timecompletionoftheUnits.ORScontinuestomonitortheseareasclosely.Themostsignificantissueisthecontinueddelayinthedeliveryofthestructuralsub‐modules. Despitecontinuing high‐level management and executive focus from Chicago Bridge and Iron,WestinghouseElectricCompanyandSCE&G,thedeliveryandqualityproblemsassociatedwiththese sub‐modules are still not satisfactorily resolved. Delays in these sub‐modules affectalmostallsubsequentcriticalpathsequencesintheconstructionschedule.
1SCE&GhasnotagreedtoanycontractualchangetotheGuaranteedSubstantialCompletionDatesfortheUnits.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |2
ApprovedBudgetReview
The current approved base project cost in 2007 dollars is $4.548 billion. There has
beennoincreaseinthetotalbaseprojectcost(in2007dollars). Withescalationapplied,thetotalcashflowbudgetedfortheprojectis$5.422billion.ThecumulativeamountspentontheprojectasofDecember31,2012was$1.773billion.Attheendof2013,thecumulativeprojectcash flow is forecasted to be approximately $392 million below the capital cost scheduleapproved in Order No. 2012‐884. Due to escalation, an increased project cash flow ofapproximately $87.824 million is necessary to complete the project in 2018. SCE&G hasestimatedthecostsassociatedwiththedelayinthesubstantialcompletiondatesforUnit2andUnit3tobeapproximately$200million.SinceSCE&Ghasnotacceptedresponsibilityforthesecosts, this report includes no increases to the cash flow attributable to the delay in thesubstantial completion dates. As of September 30, 2013, the SCE&G forecasted grossconstructioncostoftheplantis$5.651billionascomparedtotheapprovedgrossconstructioncostof$5.755billion,whichrepresentsadecreaseofapproximately$104million.
AsreportedinORS’s20132ndQuarterReport,SCE&Gfiledapetitionandnoticeforan
allowableexpartecommunicationbriefingtoaddressaregulatoryaccountingissuerelatedtoaccumulateddeferredincometaxesonSeptember9,2013inDocketNo.2013‐336‐E.Thistaxissue arises as a result of the construction of the Units. In short, traditional accounting taxpracticesascompared toaccounting tax treatmentunder theBaseLoadReviewActcreateatimingdifferencethattemporarilycausesSCE&Gincreasedtaxliabilityexposure.Subsequenttotheendofthequarter,theCompanyconductedabriefingbeforetheCommissiononOctober17, 2013 and the Commission approved the Company’s petition in Order No. 2013‐803 onNovember26,2013.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |3
IntroductionandBackground
On March 2, 2009, the Public Service Commission of South Carolina (“Commission”)approvedSouthCarolinaElectric&GasCompany’s(“SCE&G”orthe“Company”)requestfortheconstructionofV.C.SummerNuclearStationUnits2and3(the“Units”)andtheEngineering,ProcurementandConstruction(“EPC”)ContractwithWestinghouseElectricCompany(“WEC”)and Chicago Bridge and Iron (“CB&I”) (collectively referred to as the “Consortium”). CB&IbecameapartytotheEPCContractvia itsacquisitionoftheShawGroup, Inc(“Shaw”). Thisapproval can be found in the Base Load Review Order No. 2009‐104(A) filed in Docket No.2008‐196‐E. On January 21, 2010, the Commission approved the Company’s request to updatemilestonesandcapitalcostschedulesinOrderNo.2010‐12,whichisfiledinDocketNo.2009‐293‐E.OnMay16,2011,theCommissionapprovedSCE&G’spetitionforrevisionsandupdatestocapitalcostschedulesinOrderNo.2011‐345,whichisfiledinDocketNo.2010‐376‐E. OnMay15,2012,SCE&GfiledanapplicationwiththeCommissioninDocketNo.2012‐203‐Eforupdatesandrevisionstoschedulesrelatedtotheconstructionof theUnits. Theserequestedschedulechanges,alongwithanincreasetothebaseprojectcosttotaling$278.05million,wereapprovedbytheCommissioninOrderNo.2012‐884onNovember15,2012.2
TheanticipateddependablecapacityfromtheUnitsisapproximately2,234megawatts(“MW”),ofwhich55%(1,228MW)willbeavailabletoserveSCE&Gcustomers.SouthCarolinaPublic Service Authority (“Santee Cooper”) is currently contracted to receive the remaining45%(1,006MW)oftheelectricoutputwhentheUnitsareinoperation,andispaying45%ofthecostsoftheconstructionoftheUnits.InOctober2011,SCE&GandSanteeCooperexecutedthepermanentconstructionandoperatingagreements for theproject.TheagreementsgrantSCE&Gprimary responsibility for oversight of the constructionprocess andoperationof theUnitsas theycomeonline. OnMarch30,2012, theNuclearRegulatoryCommission (“NRC”)voted to issue SCE&G a Combined Construction and Operating License (“COL”) for theconstructionandoperationoftheUnits.
In 2010, SCE&G reported that Santee Cooper began reviewing its level of ownershipparticipationintheUnits.Sincethen,SanteeCooperhassoughtpartnersinits45%ownership.Santee Cooper signed a Letter of Intent with Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC in 2011. SanteeCooperandDukeEnergyCarolinas,LLCcontinuetonegotiateregardinganownershipshareintheUnits.
OnNovember8,2013,SCE&Gsubmittedits20133rdQuarterReport(“Report”)related
to construction of theUnits. TheReport is filed in CommissionDocketNo. 2008‐196‐E andcoversthequarterendingSeptember30,2013.TheCompany’sReportissubmittedpursuant 2PetitionsforRehearingorReconsiderationwerefiledonbehalfoftheSierraClubandtheSouthCarolinaEnergyUsersCommittee.BothpetitionsweredeniedviaCommissionOrderNo.2013‐5issuedonFebruary14,2013.TheSierraClubandtheSouthCarolinaEnergyUsersCommitteesubsequentlyfiledappealswiththeSupremeCourtofSouthCarolina.Thoseappealsarenowpending.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |4
to S.C. Code Ann. § 58‐33‐277 (Supp. 2012) of the Base Load Review Act (“BLRA”), whichrequirestheReporttoincludethefollowinginformation:
1. Progressofconstructionoftheplant;2. Updatedconstructionschedules;3. Schedules of the capital costs incurred including updates to the information
requiredinSection58‐33‐270(B)(5);4. Updatedschedulesoftheanticipatedcapitalcosts;and5. OtherinformationastheOfficeofRegulatoryStaffmayrequire.
With reference to Section 58‐33‐275(A) of the BLRA, the review by the Office of
RegulatoryStaff(“ORS”)oftheCompany’sReportfocusesonSCE&G’sabilitytoadheretotheapprovedconstructionscheduleandtheapprovedcapitalcostschedule.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |5
ApprovedScheduleReview
MilestoneSchedule
AsofSeptember30,2013,ORSverifiedthatoftheMilestoneSchedule’s146activities: 92milestoneactivitieshavebeencompleted(includes91historicaland1future
milestones) 54milestoneactivitiesareyet tobecompleted (includes11delayedhistorical
and43futuremilestones)
ORSalsoverifiedthatduringthe3rdQuarterof2013: Fivemilestoneactivitieswerescheduledtobecompleted
o Threeofthesemilestoneshavebeencompletedo Twoofthesemilestoneshavenotbeencompleted
PertheBaseLoadReviewOrder,overallconstructionisconsideredtobeonscheduleif
the substantial completion dates are not acceleratedmore than24months or delayedmorethan 18 months. As part of its review of the approved schedule, ORS identifies CautionMilestones.CautionMilestonesarethosethathavebeendelayedtenmonthsorlonger.IfanyMilestone is delayed 16 months or longer, ORS may issue a formal notification to theCommission of the delay. As of the end of the 3rd quarter of 2013, ORS identified that theCompany’s notification of the change in Substantial Completion for the Units resulted in 16milestonesbeingdelayedtenmonthsorlonger.
AppendixAshowsdetailsofSCE&G’sMilestoneScheduleasofSeptember30,2013.A
completelistofCautionMilestones,alongwithdetailsregardingthedelaysprovidedbySCE&Gand theConsortium is attached asAppendixB. ORS continues to reviewandmonitor thesemilestonesclosely.
SCE&G’sMilestoneSchedule,attachedtoitsReportasAppendix1,indicatesthatoverallconstruction supports a substantial completion date of December 15, 2017 for Unit 2 andDecember15,2018forUnit3. Thesubstantialcompletiondates fortheUnitsreflectadelayfromthesubstantialcompletiondatesapprovedbytheCommissioninOrderNo.2012‐884ofMarch 15, 2017 andMay 15, 2018, respectively. While delayed, the substantial completiondates fallwithin theparameters allowedby theBase LoadReviewOrder. ORS continues tomonitorthismatterclosely.
ORS reviews all invoices associated with the Milestone Schedule and during the 3rd
quarter of 2013, there were four invoices paid. ORS reviews invoices to ensure that theinvoicesarepaid inaccordancewithCompanypoliciesandpracticesand inaccordancewiththe termsof theEPCcontract. ORSalso reviews theescalationapplied to these invoices forconsistencywiththeappropriateHandy‐Whitmaninflationindices.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |6
Table1showsthestatusofthe102historicalmilestonesandChart1showsthestatusofall146milestonesforthe3rdquarterof2013andprior.3
Table1:
HistoricalMilestones3rdQuarter2013andPrior102of146TotalMilestones
#of
Milestones%ofAll
Milestones4
CompletedonSchedule 65 44.5%
CompletedEarly 10 6.8%
CompletedBehindSchedulebutWithin18MonthsDeviation 16 11.0%
NotCompleted 11 7.5%
Outside18MonthsDeviation 0 0.0%
TotalHistoricalMilestones 102 69.9%
Chart1:
3ThenumbersreportedbyORSandSCE&Gmayvary. Forreportingpurposes,ORSappliesa30‐day thresholdbeforeamilestone isdeemedacceleratedordelayed. SCE&Gusesathresholdlessthan30days. Forinstance,ifamilestoneisscheduledtobecompletedJune2,2013,and theactualcompletiondate isMay29,2013,SCE&Gdeems themilestoneascompletedonemonthearlysince it iscompleted in a prior calendarmonth. ORSwould report thismilestone as being accomplished on schedule since itwas completedwithin30daysofthescheduledcompletiondate.
4Slightvariancesmayoccurduetorounding.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |7
Table2showsthestatusofthe44futuremilestonesandChart2showsthestatusofall146milestonesforthe4thquarter2013andbeyond.
Table2:
FutureMilestones4thQuarter2013andBeyond44of146TotalMilestones
#of
Milestones%ofAll
Milestones5
CompletedEarly 1 0.7%
ProjectedtobeCompletedonSchedule 6 4.1%
ProjectedtobeCompletedEarly 3 2.1%
ProjectedtobeCompletedBehindSchedulebutWithin18MonthsDeviation 34 23.3%
ProjectedtobeOutside18MonthsDeviation 0 0.0%
TotalFutureMilestones 44 30.1%
Chart2:
5Slightvariancesmayoccurduetorounding.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |8
SpecificConstructionActivitiesSiteconstructionactivitiescontinue toprogress. Aworkforceofapproximately2,000
WEC/CB&I (including subcontractors) and330 SCE&Gpersonnel is currently on site. Majorconstructionactivitiesduringthe3rdquarterof2013arelistedbelow:
The Unit 2 CA04 module was set in place in the Containment Vessel Bottom Head
(“CVBH”)onSeptember27,2013.TheCA04willhousethelowerportionoftheReactorVessel(“RV”).
Installation of the plates that make up the Unit 2 Containment Vessel (“CV”) Ringscontinued. Unit 2 CV Ring 1 fabrication and installation of internal stiffeners werelargely complete. Weldingwas completed on the seams of the first three courses ofplatesforUnit2CVRing2.Unit3CVBHworkalsocontinuedthroughthequarter.
SignificantprogresswasmadeontheUnit2TurbineBuilding. OneofthethreelowersectionsoftheUnit2MainCondenserwasinstalledinAugust2013,andCH80,amajorstructural module for the turbine building, was installed in September 2013. Theserepresentmajoradvancements towardthecompletionof theUnit2TurbineBuilding.Additional information on this subject can be found in “Notable Activities OccurringAfterSeptember30,2013”laterinthisreport.
Structural work for Cooling Tower 2Awas substantially completed at the end of 3rdquarterof2013. Approximately60%of theprecastpanels forCoolingTower3Aand50%oftheprecastpanelsforCoolingTower3Bhavebeensetintoplace.Electricalandmechanicalworkcontinuedthroughoutthequarter.Theinitialsectionofthebasematfor Cooling Tower 2B was poured while support work continued on the remainingsectionsinpreparationofconcreteplacement.Additionally,thebasematfortheUnit2circulatingwaterpumphousewascompleted.
Progress continued on the CA20 sub‐modules inside the Module Assembly Building(“MAB”).Atotalof44ofthe72CA20sub‐moduleshadbeendeliveredtothesitefromCB&I Lake Charles (“CB&I‐LC”) as of the end of the 3rd quarter of 2013,with five ofthesearrivingonsiteduring the3rdquarterof2013. During the3rdquarterof2013,CB&Icontractorscontinuedrepairingandre‐weldingthemodulesinsidetheMABusingfull penetrationwelds aspreviously detailed in priorORSReports. Thedelivery andassemblyofallstructuralmodules,includingCA20,isacriticalpathactivity.
CB&I‐LC continues to be the focus of intensemanagement attention. Delays in sub‐module fabricationhavecontributed to theanticipateddelay in theUnit2substantialcompletiondate. CB&IhasimplementedanewleadershipteamanddevelopedanewscheduleforUnit2sub‐moduleproduction.Inanefforttoimprovedeliverytimes,CB&Ishifted work, including the CA04 module, the CA03 module, and Shield Building
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |9
modules, from CB&I‐LC to other fabricators. Further delays in the sub‐modulefabricationschedule,particularlytheCA01module,mayresultinmilestonesexceedingthe18‐monthdelayallowedbytheBaseLoadReviewOrder.ORScontinuestocloselymonitortheimpactmoduledelayshaveoncostandschedule.
ShipmentofthecompletedsquibvalvesfortheUnitsisonholdastheirmanufactureraddresses anomalies uncovered during qualification testing of the valves anddeficienciesidentifiedbytheNRCindocumentpackagesrelatedtoworkperformedbysub‐contractors.
Photographsof3rdquarterconstructionactivitiesareshowninAppendixC.CriticalPathActivities
Critical path activities are those that drive the construction schedule. Theseassessmentsarebasedonpreviouscriticalpathsandprojectedfuturecriticalpaths.
Unit2CA01Module
Fabricationanddeliveryofthesub‐modulesbeingmanufacturedatCB&I‐LCcontinuesto challenge the schedule. Of the sub‐modules required to be assembled, the CA01moduleremainsoneofthemajorcriticalconcernsandchallengestothescheduleoftheproject.Noneofthesesub‐moduleshavebeencompletedorshippedtothesite.Thereare various options being pursued by SCE&G and the Consortium, including work‐aroundsandre‐sequencingoftheinstallation,toreducetheimpactofthedelayofthesesub‐modules.TheCA01moduleiscurrentlythemostcriticalactivityintheassemblyofthenuclearislandbuildingbecauseitmustbeplacedbeforesettingoftheCVringscanprogressbeyondthefirstring. Thiscriticalpathactivityisbehindscheduleandcouldfurtherdelaythecompletiondate.
Unit2CA20Module
Delaysalsocontinuewith the fabricationanddeliveryof theCA20sub‐modules fromCB&I‐LC.Thesub‐modulesneededtoproceedwiththefinalassemblyofmoduleCA20arenotyetonsite.Thismayimpacttheconstructionoftheshieldbuildingandfurtherdelaytheproject.However,theweldrepairsonthesub‐modules,asdiscussedinORS’s20131stQuarterReport,arenearingcompletion.AdditionalinformationontheUnit2CA20Modulecanbefoundin“NotableActivitiesOccurringAfterSeptember30,2013”laterinthisreport.Thiscriticalpathactivityisbehindschedule.
Unit2ShieldBuildingBecauseoftheproductionandqualityissuesassociatedwithCB&I‐LC,fabricationoftheShield Buildingmodules has been reassigned toNewportNews Industries (“NNI”) inVirginia.MobilizationandpreparationforproductioncontinuedatNNIthroughoutthe
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |10
quarter.Althoughfabricationisnowunderway,nosub‐moduleshavebeendeliveredtothesite. Adetailedschedule for theirdelivery isnotyetavailable. Inaddition,workassociated with completing the mock‐ups to field test activities associated with theinstallationoftheshieldbuildingmoduleshasnowbeenscheduledtobecompletedinearly2014.
Unit3Basemat
Significantprogresshasbeenmadeinthisarea.Installationofthereinforcingsteelandthe embedded components continued throughout the quarter with an expectedconcretepourofthebasemattooccurinmid‐October2013.Thisisthecurrentcriticalpath activity for Unit 3 and is on schedule. Additional information on the Unit 3basematcanbefoundin“NotableActivitiesOccurringAfterSeptember30,2013”laterinthisreport.
Unit3ModulesModuleassemblyisafuturecriticalpathactivityforUnit3.AsofSeptember30,2013,arevised sub‐module delivery schedule has been not released for Unit 3. These sub‐modules, and therefore the associated modules, are behind schedule. Additionalinformation on the Unit 3 CA01, CA03, and CA20modules can be found in “NotableActivitiesOccurringAfterSeptember30,2013”laterinthisreport.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |11
Transmission
On February 28, 2011, SCE&G entered into a contract with Pike Electric for thepermitting,engineeringanddesign,procurementofmaterial,andtheconstructionoffour(4)230kilovolt(“kV”)transmissionlinesandassociatedfacilitiesrelatedtotheUnits.Thisprojectwillconsistoftwophases.
Phase 1 consists of construction of two new230 kV transmission lines in support of
Unit2:theVCS1–KillianLineandtheVCS2–LakeMurrayLine#2. TheVCS1–KillianLinewillconnect the existing V.C. Summer Switchyard (“Switchyard 1”) to the Company’s existingKillian Road 230 kV Substation. The VCS2–Lake Murray Line #2 will connect the newly‐constructed Switchyard (“Switchyard 2”) to the Company’s existing Lake Murray 230 kVSubstation.Switchyard2willallowtheconnectionofboththeUnit2andUnit3generatorstothe grid. Also, for Phase 1, two new 230 kV interconnections between Switchyard 1 andSwitchyard2havebeenconstructed.ConstructionofthePhase1linescontinuedduringthe3rdquarterof2013.AsofSeptember30,2013,theVCS1–KillianLinewasnearingcompletionandtheVCS2–LakeMurrayLine#2wasapproximately95%complete.
Phase2consistsofconstructionoftwonew230kVtransmissionlinesandassociated
facilities in support of Unit 3. The construction of these lines and associated facilities wasapprovedinOrderNo.2012‐730.FacilitiesinPhase2aretheVCS2–St.GeorgeLine#1,VCS2–St. George Line #2, and St. George 230 kV Switching Station, and Saluda River 230/115 kVSubstation. Preliminary construction activitieshavebegunon theVCS2–St.GeorgeLines#1and #2 including erosion control measures and spotting and framing of structures.Additionally, the overall engineering layout of the St. George 230 kV Switching Station wascompleted.
BoththeVCS2–St.GeorgeLine#1andVCS2–St.GeorgeLine#2willconnectSwitchyard
2totheyet‐to‐beconstructedSt.George230kVSwitchingStation.Constructionontheselinesbeganduringthequarter;however,constructionoftheSt.George230kVSwitchingStationhasnotyetbegun. A thirdnew230kV interconnectionbetweenSwitchyard1andSwitchyard2willbe required forPhase2. SCE&Ghasacquired the land for theSaludaRiver230/115kVSubstation, to be built adjacent to and interconnect with the VCS2‐St. George lines. Thepreliminary environmental assessment of this site has been completed and lay out of thesubstationisprogressing.
Map 1 shows the geographical location of SCE&G’s new transmission lines and other
associatedfacilitiestosupporttheUnits.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |12
Map1:NewSCE>ransmissionLinesandFacilities SupportingV.C.SummerUnits2&3
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |13
ChangeOrdersandAmendments
Duringthe3rdquarterof2013,noChangeOrdersorAmendmentswereexecuted. NoChange Orders or Amendments have been executed since early 2012, despite continuednegotiationsforfourChangeOrders.
ExecutionofChangeOrder#16hasbeendelayedpendingtheresolutionofaquestionregardingtheapplicationoftheHandy‐Whitmaninflationindices.TheCompanyiswithholdingpaymentofdisputedamountsoninvoicesthatareaffectedbytheseindicespendingresolutionofthismatter.
The secondChangeOrder under negotiationwould incorporatePhase II of the cybersecuritychangespreviouslycataloguedinChangeOrder#14.Thethirdincorporatespotentialdesign changes to the offsite water treatment system. The final Change Order undernegotiationwouldaddressWEC’scostsassociatedwithrecentfederalhealthcarelegislation.
Table3detailsallChangeOrdersandAmendments.AlistofdefinitionsforeachtypeofChangeOrderisfoundbelow.
Contractor Convenience: These changes are requested by the contractor.
They are undertaken at the contractor’s own expense, and are both generallyconsistentwiththecontractandreasonablynecessarytomeetthetermsofthecontract.
Entitlement: ThecontractorisentitledtoaChangeOrderintheeventcertainactionsoccur,includingchangesinlaw,uncontrollablecircumstances,andotheractionsasdefinedinthecontract.
OwnerDirected:ThesechangesarerequestedbytheCompany.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |14
Table3:
ChangeOrdersandAmendmentsNo. Summary CostCategories
InvolvedTypeofChange
DateApproved Status
1OperatortrainingforWECRVSystemsandSimulatortraining
FixedPricewith0%escalation6
OwnerDirected
7/22/2009 Approved
2 LimitedScopeSimulator FirmPriceOwnerDirected
9/11/2009 Approved
3 RepairofParrRoad TimeandMaterialsOwnerDirected
1/21/2010 Approved
4TransferofErectionofCA20Module
fromWECtoShawTargetPricework
shiftingtoFirmPriceContractorConvenience N/A
SupersededbyChangeOrder
No.8
5*SupplementsChangeOrderNo.1*
Increasedtrainingbytwo(2)weeksFixedPricewith0%
escalation6OwnerDirected
5/4/2010 Approved
6 HydraulicNuts FixedPrice OwnerDirected
7/13/2010 Approved
7 St.GeorgeLines#1&2 FirmandTargetPriceCategories
Entitlement 7/13/2010 Approved
8 TargettoFirm/FixedShiftTarget,FirmandFixed
PriceCategoriesOwnerDirected
4/29/2011 Approved
9 SwitchyardLinesReconfiguration FirmandTargetPriceCategories
OwnerDirected
11/30/2010 Approved
10 PrimaveraFixedPricewith0%
escalationOwnerDirected
12/16/2010 Approved
11 COLDelayStudyFixedPrice,butwouldbeappliedtoT&MWorkAllowances
OwnerDirected
2/28/2011 Approved
12 2010HealthCareActCosts(Shaw) Firm Entitlement 11/14/2011 Approved
13 OvationWorkstations NoCostOwnerDirected
3/12/2012 Approved
14 CyberSecurityPhaseIFirmPriceandT&MPrice
Entitlement 3/15/2012 Approved
15 LiquidWasteSystemDischargePiping
FirmPrice OwnerDirected
3/15/2012 Approved
16ResolvesWEC/CB&Iclaimsrelated
toCOLDelay&otheritemsTarget&FirmPrice Entitlement N/A Pending
Amendment#1 IncludesChangeOrders1and2Executedon8/2/2010
Amendment#2 IncorporatesChangeOrders3,5‐11Executedon11/15/2011
Amendment#3 Includesmodifiedinsurancewording Executedon4/30/12
6FixedPricewith0%escalation,butwouldbeappliedtoTimeandMaterialsWorkAllowancesbyaddinganewcategoryforSimulatorInstructortrainingandreducingStartupSupportbyacommensurateamount.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |15
LicensingandInspectionActivities
FederalActivities
As of September 30, 2013, SCE&G has identified the need to submit more than 60LicenseAmendmentRequests(“LAR”)totheNRC.TheexactnumberofLARsrequiredvaries,asasingleLARmayaddressmultipleissues.ALARistheprocessbywhichalicenseerequestschanges to theCOL issuedby theNRC. The licenseemayrequestaPreliminaryAmendmentRequest(“PAR”)toaccompanyaLAR.PARsallowthelicenseetocontinuewithconstructionatits own risk while awaiting final dispensation of the LAR. A total of 19 LARs had beensubmittedthroughtheendofthe3rdquarterof2013withsevenofthesesubmittedduringthequarter. A table of LARs submitted to the NRC, and accompanying PARs, if requested, isattachedasAppendixD.IssuessurroundingtheapprovalofLARsarediscussedinmoredetailinthesectionentitled“ConstructionChallenges.”
The NRC conducts monthly site inspections to monitor construction progress. No
additionalissueswereidentifiedduringthe3rdquarterof2013.OnJuly29,2013theNRCissuedaninspectionreportfortheperiodofApril1,2013to
June30,2013withnofindings.On August 1, 2013, the NRC completed an annual inspection of the Company’s
correctiveactionprogram. Thereportdocumenting the inspectionresultswaspublishedonAugust29,2013.Therewerenofindingsidentifiedduringtheinspection.
OnSeptember30,2013,theNRCcompletedaquarterlyinspectioncoveringtheperiod
ofJuly1,2013throughSeptember30,2013.Additionalinformationonthisinspectioncanbefoundin“NotableActivitiesOccurringAfterSeptember30,2013”laterinthisreport.StateActivities
As of September 30, 2013, there are currently no major state construction‐relatedpermitsoutstanding.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |16
7
ApprovedBudgetReview
ORS’sbudgetreviewincludesananalysisofthe3rdQuarter2013capitalcosts,project
cashflow,escalationandAllowanceforFundsUsedDuringConstruction(“AFUDC”).CapitalCosts
To determine how consistently the Company adheres to the budget approved by the
Commission inOrderNo. 2012‐884,ORS evaluates ninemajor cost categories for variances.Thesecostcategoriesare:
FixedwithNoAdjustment FirmwithFixedAdjustmentA FirmwithFixedAdjustmentB FirmwithIndexedAdjustment ActualCraftWages Non‐LaborCost Time&Materials OwnersCosts TransmissionProjects
ORSmonitors variances due to project changes (e.g., shifts inwork scopes, payment
timetables,constructionscheduleadjustments,ChangeOrders).Attheendofthe3rdquarterof2013,SCE&G’stotalbaseprojectcost(in2007dollars)is$4.548billion.ProjectCashFlow
AsshowninAppendix2oftheCompany’sReport,thecumulativeamountspentonthe
projectasofDecember31,2012was$1.773billion.ThecumulativeamountforecastedtobespentontheprojectbyDecember31,2013is$2.453billion.
WithreferencetoAppendix2,ORSevaluatedthetotalrevisedprojectcashflow(Line
37)withrespecttotheannualprojectcashflow,adjustedforchangesinescalation(Line16).ThisevaluationprovidesacomparisonoftheCompany’scurrentprojectcashflowtothecashflow schedule approved by the Commission in OrderNo. 2012‐884. To produce a commonbasisforthecomparison,Line16adjuststheapprovedcashflowscheduletoreflectthecurrentescalationrates.AsofDecember31,2012,thecomparisonshowstheyearlymaximumannualvariancefromtheapprovedcashflowschedulethroughthelifeoftheproject.Thecomparisonalso shows that the cumulative project cash flow is forecasted to be approximately $392.1
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |17
millionunderbudgetattheendof2013.Duetoescalation,atthecompletionoftheprojectin2018 the cumulative project cash flow is forecasted to be approximately $87.8million overbudget.
Table 4 shows the annual and cumulative project cash flows as compared to thoseapprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884.
Table4:
ProjectCashFlowComparison$'sinThousands7
AnnualOver/(Under)
CumulativeOver/(Under)
Actual
2007 ‐ ‐
2008 $0 $0
2009 $0 $0
2010 $0 $0
2011 $0 $0
2012 ($142,003) ($142,003)
Projected
2013 ($250,126) ($392,129)
2014 ($61,220) ($453,349)
2015 $63,947 ($389,402)
2016 $157,237 ($232,165)
2017 $210,969 ($21,196)
2018 $109,019 $87,823
In summary, the Report shows no increase in the total base project cost (in 2007dollars).Duetoescalation,anincreaseinprojectcashflowofapproximately$87.8millionwillbenecessarytocompletetheprojectin2018.TheseforecastsreflecttheupdatedcapitalcostschedulesapprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884,thecurrentconstructionscheduleandtheinflationindicesintheCompany’sAppendix4.Theincreaseinprojectcashflowisduetoanincreaseinescalationresultingfromconstructiondelaysandshort‐termescalationrateincreases.SCE&GhasestimatedthecostsassociatedwiththedelayinthesubstantialcompletiondatesforUnit2andUnit3tobeapproximately$200million.SinceSCE&Ghasnotacceptedresponsibilityfor
7Slightvariancesmayoccurduetorounding.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |18
thesecosts,thisreportincludesnoincreasestotheprojectcashflowattributabletothedelayinthesubstantialcompletiondates.AFUDCandEscalation
The forecastedAFUDC for the totalprojectasof theendof the3rdquarterof2013 is
$229.7millionandiscurrentlybasedonaforecasted6.09%AFUDCrate.Changes in the AFUDC rate, timing changes in project spending due to construction
scheduleshifts,andfive‐yearaverageescalationratesareallfactorsthatimpacttheprojectedproject cash flow. Due to changes in escalation rates, as well as changes to the timing ofpaymentsduetoconstructiondelays,theoverallprojectcosthasdecreased.Morespecifically,asofSeptember30,2013,SCE&G’sforecastgrossconstructioncostoftheplantis$5.651billionas compared to the approved gross construction cost of $5.755 billion, which represents adecreaseofapproximately$104million.AnnualRequestforRevisedRates
PursuanttotheBLRA,SCE&Gmayrequestrevisedratesnoearlierthanoneyearafter
therequestofaBaseLoadReviewOrderoranypriorrevisedratesrequest. SCE&G filed itsAnnualRequestforRevisedRateswiththeCommissioninDocketNo.2013‐150‐EonMay30,2013, the anniversary date of SCE&G’s previous request for revised rates. The Commissionapprovedanincreaseof$67,240,232(2.87%)inOrderNo.2013‐680(A)onOctober2,2013.
Table 5 below shows the requested increases and approved increases from all priorRevisedRateFilingswiththeCommission.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |19
Table5:
Requestedvs.ApprovedIncreasesSCE&GRevisedRateFilings
DocketNo.
OrderNo.
RequestedIncrease
ORSExamination
ApprovedIncrease
RetailIncrease
2008‐196‐E 2009‐104(A) $8,986,000 ($1,183,509) $7,802,491 0.43%
2009‐211‐E 2009‐696 $22,533,000 $0 $22,533,000 1.10%
2010‐157‐E 2010‐625 $54,561,000 ($7,260,000) $47,301,000 2.31%
2011‐207‐E 2011‐738 $58,537,000 ($5,753,658) $52,783,342 2.43%
2012‐186‐E 2012‐761 $56,747,000 ($4,598,087) $52,148,913 2.33%
2013‐150‐E 2013‐680(A) $69,671,000 ($2,430,768) $67,240,232 2.87%
AdditionalORSMonitoringActivities
ORScontinuallyperformsthefollowingactivities,aswellasothermonitoringactivitiesasdeemednecessary:
AuditscapitalcostexpendituresandresultingAFUDCinCWIP
Physicallyobservesconstructionactivities
Bi‐monthlyon‐sitereviewofconstructiondocuments
HoldsmonthlyupdatemeetingswithSCE&G
MeetsquarterlywithrepresentativesofWEC
ParticipatesinNRCPublicMeetingsregardingSCE&GCOLandotherconstructionactivities
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |20
SummaryofORSVisittoCB&I‐LCFacility
OnSeptember25,2013,ORSvisitedtheCB&I‐LCfacility inLakeCharles,Louisianato
review the fabrication and shipping status of theUnits’ structural sub‐modules. SCE&G andCB&I‐LC representatives were also present during this visit. The visit was comprised ofpresentationsbyseveralCB&I‐LCstaffandasitetour.ORStouredtheshopfloorandobservedthework inprogresson several structural sub‐modules, including those for theUnit2CA20andCA01modules.
Since assuming responsibility for the facility fromShaw in late2012,CB&Ihasmadeseveralmanagement changes; increased the staff from 700 in February 2013 to 1,205 as ofSeptember 25, 2013; revamped the shopprocesses andprocedures (including instituting anelectronic tracking system); implemented a planning and scheduling system that tracks allactivities associated with the fabrication process; instituted a program to promote a safetyconsciousworkenvironment;andexpandedthenumberofshiftsandworkhoursofthefacility.These changes are designed to improve the quality and schedule adherence; however, thefacility must demonstrate a sustained record of compliance in order to determine whethertheseeffortshavebeensuccessful.
The expansive shop area was filled with large steel plates and structural steel. Thenumberof“flattables”wherethefinalfabricationactivitieswereunderwayhadrecentlybeenincreased and several more were in various stages of completion. Welding activities wereunderway throughout the facility. However, the overall shop layout appeared to requiremultiplemovements of the large plates by the overhead crane to transfer the plates to theproperwork area. Also, on each sub‐module ORS observed, thereweremultiple “red tags”indicatingnon‐conformances that requiredre‐work. CB&I indicated thatmostof thesewerelegacy issues inherited from Shaw and that CB&I’s new processes and procedures shouldreducethesenon‐conformancesonfuturesub‐modules.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |21
ConstructionChallenges
Based upon the information provided by the Company in its Report, as well as
information obtained via additional ORS monitoring activities, ORS identifies the followingongoingchallengesintheconstructionoftheUnits. StructuralModules
AsidentifiedinpreviousORSquarterlyreports,themostsignificant,currentchallengetotheprojectremainsthecontinuedinabilityofCB&I‐LCtoreliablyandpredictablymeetthequalityandschedulerequirementsoftheproject.ThecriticalpathtocompletionofUnit2runsthroughthecompletionofmodulesCA01andCA20,andisdependentuponthedeliveryofthesub‐modulesthatcomprisethecomponentsofthesemodulesfromCB&I‐LC. TheCVandthestructuresassociatedwith themainNuclear Island(“NI”)buildingcannotbecompleteduntilthesemodules are fabricatedand installed. TheBLRAmilestone (MilestoneActivityNo.97)most closely associated with this activity currently shows a 12‐month delay, and it isconcerning that none of the significant sub‐modules associatedwith the CA01module havebeendeliveredtothesite.Therehasbeenprogressmade,asstatedinthefollowingsummaryandasdiscussed in the “NotableActivitiesOccurringAfterSeptember30,2013” section,butthisarearemainsaprimaryfocusofORS.
CA04sub‐modulesweretransferredtothesiteforfinalfabricationandthecompletedmoduleforUnit2wassetinplaceinsidetheCVBHonSeptember27,2013.
CB&I‐LChasestablishedanon‐siteworkareaatthesitetoperformthefinalinspection,documentationreviewandcompletionofanyadditionalfinalwork.
Allsub‐modulesrequiredfortheassemblyofUnit2moduleCA20forplacementintheNI havebeendelivered to the site for final inspection and fabrication. This freedupshop space at the main CB&I‐LC facility which should permit them to focus on thecompletionofthefabricationoftheUnit2CA01sub‐modules.
CB&I‐LC is nowworking two12‐hour shifts, sevendays aweek to try to recover theschedule for the sub‐modules and reduce the impact on the substantial completiondates.
Fabrication of the sub‐modules for CA03 was transferred to Pegasus Steel in NorthCharleston,SCinordertofurtherreducetheburdenontheCB&I‐LCfacility.
RepairworktoremoveandreplacetheincorrectfilletweldswithfullpenetrationweldsontheUnit2CA20sub‐moduleswasnearlycompleteattheendofthereportingperiod.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |22
ShieldBuildingModules Aspreviouslyreported,shieldbuildingmodulefabricationhasbeenreassignedtoNNI.However,NNI'ssustained,reliableperformancehasnotyetbeendemonstratedandadeliveryschedulehadnotyetbeenprovidedasofSeptember30,2013.ORSremainsconcernedaboutthe significant fabrication and erection challenges that will be presented by the complexconfigurations of the shield building modules. A firm delivery schedule for all the shieldbuilding modules needs to be established in the near future, and NNI needs to begin thedeliveryofhighqualitymodules to the site. In addition, the resultsof testpours associatedwithSouthernCompany’sVogtleandtheUnit#2mock‐upsshouldprovideanindicationofhowtheerectionprocesswillprogress.Thenextfewmonthspresentacriticalchallengetotheprojectinthisarea,andwillbecloselymonitoredbyORS.StructuralDesignCompliance Thedesignreviewsandmodificationsrequiredtoaddressthe issues identifiedbythereviewdiscussedinORS’s20132ndQuarterReporthavenotresultedinanystatedimpacttothe project schedule or cost. However, the construction of the Auxiliary Buildingwalls hasrecentlyfallenbehindschedule.ORScontinuestomonitorthedelayclosely.InstrumentationandControlDesign
During this reporting period, SCE&G announced a 5½ month delay in the deliveryscheduleofthePlantReferenceSimulator(“PRS”)duetoadditionaltimerequiredforWECtocomplete theHuman Factors Engineering/Integrated Systems Validation testing. This delayalsoresultedinadelayintheexaminationdatesforthefirstclassoflicensedreactoroperators.
CompletionofthedesignofthePRSbyWEC,andreviewofthesedesignchangesbytheNRC, are key activities required to support this revised schedule and the substantialcompletiondates.InanefforttoacceleratethereviewofthePRS,theNRChasagreedtoreviewthecompletionofthedesignsofthePRSonapiece‐meal,system‐by‐systembasisratherthantheoriginallyplannedsinglecomprehensivereviewofthecompletedsoftware.However,anyfurtherdelaysinthecompletionofthedesignbyWECoranymajorissuesidentifiedintheNRCreviewcouldjeopardizethecommercialoperationdatesoftheUnits.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |23
OverlappingUnit2&Unit3ConstructionSchedules Thedelays in theprogressonUnit2construction, inparticular thoseassociatedwithsub‐module fabrication and erection, have begun to challenge the ability of SCE&G and theConsortiumtoworkonbothUnitssimultaneouslywhileadheringtotheapprovedschedules.ThiswasrecentlydemonstratedbyshiftingworkcrewsfromthecoolingtowerfoundationstocompletetheUnit3NIbasemat.Thisisanareathatwillbemonitoredcloselyandwillbecomemorerelevantandchallengingoverthecomingmonths.
Adetailedconstructionschedule forUnit3wasdevelopedby theConsortiumduringthis period, and resulted in the approximately 7‐month delay presented as BLRAMilestoneActivityNo.146.However,thisschedulewasnotbasedonfirmcommitmentdatesfromCB&I‐LC for the Unit 3 structural sub‐modules. SCE&G indicated in its Report that the Unit 3substantial completion date may slip further into the first quarter of 2019. CB&I‐LC is topresentafirmscheduleandworkplantotheConsortiumandSCE&Gduringthe4thquarterof2013, and theUnit3 schedulewill thenbe revised to reflect these commitments. Theworkrepresentedonthisrevisedschedulewillchallengetheresourcesavailabletotheproject,andwill require coordinated efforts to ensure the work progresses in accordance with theapprovedschedulesontheUnits.ManufacturingofMajorEquipment Factorssuchasdesignchanges,laborconditions,shippingconditionsandthefinancialstability of foreignmanufacturers due to financialmarket conditions still present significantchallengestotheon‐timedeliveryofequipmenttotheproject.Itisencouragingthatthefinalshipment of major components for the Unit 2 Turbine Generator was received during thisperiod,andseveralmoremajorcomponentsareinthefinalprocessesorenroutetothesite.However, the extensive and expansive supply chains formajor components remain an issuethatrequirescontinuedattention. LicenseAmendmentReviews
ThecurrenttotalnumberofidentifiedLARsbySCE&Gwasover60asofSeptember30,2013,andthisnumbercontinuestoincreaseeachmonth.Ofthetotalnumber,19LARshavebeensubmittedtotheNRCforreview.SCE&GprovidesasummaryoftheLARsthathavebeensubmittedtotheNRCinAppendix5ofitsReport. ThepreparationandreviewoftheseLARsrequiressignificanteffortsbybothSCE&GandtheNRC. Insomecases,theapprovaloftheseLARsisbeginningtochallengetheconstructionscheduleandwillneedtobemonitoredclosely.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |24
NotableActivitiesOccurringafterSeptember30,2013
TheBLRAallowsSCE&G45daysfromtheendofthecurrentquartertofileitsReport.
Items of importance that occurred subsequent to the closing of the 3rd quarter of 2013 arereportedbelow.AccumulatedDeferredIncomeTaxTimingDifference
AsreportedinORS’s20132ndQuarterReport,SCE&GfiledapetitionandnoticeforanallowableexpartecommunicationbriefingtoaddressaregulatoryaccountingissuerelatedtoaccumulateddeferredincometaxesonSeptember9,2013inDocketNo.2013‐336‐E.Thistaxissue arises as a result of the construction of the Units. In short, traditional accounting taxpracticesascompared toaccounting tax treatmentunder theBaseLoadReviewActcreateatimingdifferencethattemporarilycausesSCE&Gincreasedtaxliabilityexposure.Subsequenttotheendofthequarter,theCompanyconductedabriefingbeforetheCommissiononOctober17, 2013, and the Commission approved the Company’s petition in Order No. 2013‐803 onNovember26,2013.CautionMilestones
AlthoughmoduleCA04wasreportedassetinplaceasofSeptember27,2013,issueswiththeallowable tolerances for the final sethavedelayed thecompletionof thismilestone (BLRAMilestoneNo.78).AsofDecember10,2013,non‐conformancesassociatedwiththecompletionofthismilestoneremainunresolved,andthemilestoneisnotcomplete.
As of the end of November 2013, there were 17 BLRA milestones with targeted
completion dates at 10months ormore beyond theOrderNo. 2012‐884 approvedmilestonecompletiondates. Threeofthesehadcompletiondatesdelayedby15monthsormore. TheseareMilestoneNo.88(SetUnit2NIstructuralmoduleCA03)withadelayof16months,MilestoneNo. 92 (Start Unit 2 containment large bore pipe supports) with a delay of 15 months, andMilestoneNo.98(DeliveryofUnit2PassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchangertoPortofEntry)withadelayof15months.ORSpreviouslyfiledaletternotifyingtheCommissionofthedelayinMilestoneNo.88onJuly26,2013. This letter isattachedtoORS’s20132ndQuarterReportasAppendixE.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |25
EquipmentDelivery
TheUnit2CoreMake‐UpTanksweredelivered to the siteonNovember3,2013, andUnit2AccumulatorTanksweredeliveredtothesitefromMangiarottionNovember24,2013.Thesetanksarenowinstorageatthesite. NRCLicensing
OnSeptember30,2013,theNRCcompletedaquarterlyinspectioncoveringtheperiodof July1,2013 throughSeptember30,2013. Thereportdocumenting the inspectionresultswaspublishedafterthequarteronOctober30,2013.Therewerenofindingsidentifiedduringtheinspection. TheNRCconductedaninspectionoftheUnit3NIbasematconcretepour,andhadtwominorfindingswhichhadnoimpactontheconstructionactivities.
AsofDecember11,2013,theCompanyhasidentified72LARsfortheUnits.Ofthese,24have been submitted to the NRC for their review. Nine of these have been approved andincorporated into the license. Currently, one LAR has been identified as critical to theconstructionscheduleandwillrequireaPARinordertomaintainthecurrentprojectschedule.TheLAR,LAR13‐41,wassubmittedbytheCompanytotheNRConNovember26,2013.ThisisLARaddressesthermalconductivityoftheCVcoating.SiteFacilities
TheEmergencyResponseBuildingwasstructurallycompletedandnowhousesthenewfireequipmentpurchasedforthesite.StructuralModules
As reported above, the CA04 module has been set inside the CVBH, but is not yetconsideredtobeinitsfinalpositionbecauseofunresolvednon‐conformanceswithregardtotheallowabletolerancesonitsfinallocationandorientation.
Allsub‐modulesassociatedwithmoduleCA20havebeendeliveredtothesite;however,
manyofthesestillrequirerework/repairandfinalinspectionbytheon‐siteextensionofCB&I‐LCbeforetheyarereleasedtothesiteconstructioncrewforfinalassemblyofthemoduleintheMAB. Allweldrepairworkassociatedwithreplacingthenon‐conforming filletweldswith fullpenetrationwelds has now been completed and is undergoing final inspection. Work on theCA20continuesintheMAB,andthemoduleisscheduledtobeliftedontotheNIduringthe1stquarterof2014.
Q3‐13 Rev iew P a g e |26
TheConsortiumhasproposedtoshiftsub‐modulefabricationfortheUnit3CA01,CA03,and CA20 modules to other vendors to reduce the burden on CB&I‐LC and to improve thedelivery schedule of the sub‐modules to the site. SCE&G has agreed to this proposal and isworkingwiththeConsortiuminvendorselection.
Mock‐uptestpoursfortheshieldbuildingwallshavebeenmadeatSouthernCompany’s
VogtleSiteandarecurrentlyintheprocessofbeingdestructivelytestedtodeterminewhetherthe constructionmethodology andapproach is satisfactory. SCE&G is activelyparticipating inthisactivity,andplanstousetheseresultsinperformingtheirownmock‐uptestpoursduringthe1stquarterof2014.TurbineBuilding
Subsequent to the end of the quarter, significant progress was made on the Unit 2TurbineBuilding. ThemajorturbinebuildingstructuralmoduleCH81AwassetonOctober3,2013,andthelowershellofcondensersectionCwassetonOctober24,2013.AsofDecember12,2013,theuppershellsofcondensersectionsA,BandChavebeenset.CondensateAandBpumpsarealsosetinplaceintheturbinebuilding.TheserepresentmajoractivitiestowardthecompletionoftheUnit2TurbineBuilding.Unit3NuclearIsland
Thepouringof theNIbasemat forUnit3wascompletedonNovember4,2013. ThisrepresentedthecompletionofBLRAMilestone111.ApressreleaseregardingtheplacementofthebasematwasissuedbytheCompanyandisincludedasAppendixE.
SCE&G’s20134thquarterreportisdue45daysafterDecember31,2013. ORSexpectstocontinuepublishingareviewevaluatingSCE&G’squarterlyreports.
AppendixADetailedMilestoneScheduleasofSeptember30,2013
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
1ApproveEngineering,Procurementand
ConstructionAgreement5/23/2008 No No 5/23/2008
2IssuePurchaseOrders("P.O.")toNuclearComponentFabricatorsforUnits2and3
ContainmentVessels12/3/2008 No No 12/3/2008
3ContractorIssueP.O.toPassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchangerFabricator–First
Payment‐Unit28/31/2008 No No 8/18/2008
4ContractorIssueP.O.toAccumulatorTank
Fabricator–Unit27/31/2008 No No 7/31/2008
5ContractorIssueP.O.toCoreMakeupTank
Fabricator‐Units2&39/30/2008 No No 9/30/2008
6ContractorIssueP.O.toSquibValveFabricator‐
Units2&33/31/2009 No No 3/31/2009
7ContractorIssueP.O.toSteamGenerator
Fabricator‐Units2&36/30/2008 No No 5/29/2008 1MonthEarly
8ContractorIssueLongLeadMaterialP.O.to
ReactorCoolantPumpFabricator‐Units2&36/30/2008 No No 6/30/2008
9ContractorIssueP.O.toPressurizerFabricator‐
Units2&38/31/2008 No No 8/18/2008
Q3‐13Review Page1of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
10ContractorIssueP.O.toReactorCoolantLoopPipeFabricator‐FirstPayment‐Units2&3
6/30/2008 No No 6/20/2008
11ReactorVesselInternals–IssueLongLeadMaterialP.O.toFabricator‐Units2&3
11/21/2008 No No 11/21/2008
12ContractorIssueLongLeadMaterial‐P.O.to
ReactorVesselFabricator‐Units2&36/30/2008 No No 5/29/2008 1MonthEarly
13ContractorIssueP.O.toIntegratedHeadPackage
Fabricator‐Units2&37/31/2009 No No 7/31/2009
14ControlRodDriveMechanism–IssueP.O.forLongLeadMaterialtoFabricator‐Units2&3‐
FirstPayment6/21/2008 No No 6/21/2008
15IssueP.O.'stoNuclearComponentFabricatorsfor
NuclearIslandStructuralCA20Modules7/31/2009 No No 8/28/2009
16StartSiteSpecificandBalanceofPlantDetailed
Design9/11/2007 No No 9/11/2007
17Instrumentation&ControlSimulator‐Contractor
PlaceNoticetoProceed‐Units2&3
10/31/2008 No No 10/31/2008
18SteamGenerator‐IssueFinalP.O.toFabricator
forUnits2&36/30/2008 No No 6/30/2008
Q3‐13Review Page2of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
19ReactorVesselInternals‐ContractorIssueP.O.forLongLeadMaterial(HeavyPlateandHeavy
Forgings)toFabricator‐Units2&31/31/2010 No No 1/29/2010
20ContractorIssueFinalP.O.toReactorVessel
Fabricator‐Units2&39/30/2008 No No 9/30/2008
21VariableFrequencyDriveFabricatorIssue
TransformerP.O.‐Units2&34/30/2009 No No 4/30/2009
22 StartClearing,GrubbingandGrading 1/26/2009 No No 1/26/2009
23CoreMakeupTankFabricatorIssueLongLead
MaterialP.O.‐Units2&310/31/2008 No No 10/31/2008
24AccumulatorTankFabricatorIssueLongLead
MaterialP.O.‐Units2&310/31/2008 No No 10/31/2008
25PressurizerFabricatorIssueLongLeadMaterial
P.O.‐Units2&310/31/2008 No No 10/31/2008
26ReactorCoolantLoopPipe‐ContractorIssueP.O.
toFabricator‐SecondPayment‐Units2&3
4/30/2009 No No 4/30/2009
27IntegratedHeadPackage‐IssueP.O.toFabricator
‐Units2&3‐SecondPayment7/31/2009 No No 7/31/2009
Q3‐13Review Page3of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
28ControlRodDriveMechanism‐ContractorIssue
P.O.forLongLeadMaterialtoFabricator‐Units2&3
6/30/2008 No No 6/30/2008
29ContractorIssueP.O.toPassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchangerFabricator‐Second
Payment‐Units2&310/31/2008 No No 10/31/2008
30 StartParrRoadIntersectionWork 2/13/2009 No No 2/13/2009
31ReactorCoolantPump‐IssueFinalP.O.to
Fabricator‐Units2&36/30/2008 No No 6/30/2008
32IntegratedHeatPackagesFabricatorIssueLong
LeadMaterialP.O.‐Units2&310/31/2009 No No 10/1/2009 1MonthEarly
33 DesignFinalizationPayment3 1/31/2009 No No 1/30/2009
34 StartSiteDevelopment 6/23/2008 No No 6/23/2008
35ContractorIssueP.O.toTurbineGenerator
Fabricator‐Units2&32/28/2009 No No 2/19/2009
36ContractorIssueP.O.toMainTransformers
Fabricator‐Units2&39/30/2009 No No 9/25/2009
Q3‐13Review Page4of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
37CoreMakeupTankFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorReceiptofLongLeadMaterial‐Units2&3
11/30/2010 No No 12/30/2010 Delayed1Month
38 DesignFinalizationPayment4 4/30/2009 No No 4/30/2009
39TurbineGeneratorFabricatorIssueP.O.for
CondenserMaterial‐Unit28/31/2009 No No 8/28/2009
40ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorIssueLong
LeadMaterialLot2‐Units2&34/30/2009 No No 4/30/2009
41PassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchangerFabricatorReceiptofLongLeadMaterial‐Units2
&35/31/2010 No No 5/27/2010
42 DesignFinalizationPayment5 7/31/2009 No No 7/31/2009
43
StartErectionofConstructionBuildingstoincludeCraftFacilitiesforPersonnel,Tools,
Equipment;FirstAidFacilities;FieldOfficesforSiteManagementandSupportPersonnel;
TemporaryWarehouses;andConstructionHiringOffice
10/9/2009 No No 12/18/2009 Delayed2Months
44ReactorVesselFabricatorNoticetoContractorof
ReceiptofFlangeNozzleShellForging‐Unit2
7/31/2009 No No 8/28/2009
Q3‐13Review Page5of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
45 DesignFinalizationPayment6 10/31/2009 No No 10/7/2009
46InstrumentationandControlSimulator‐ContractorIssueP.O.toSubcontractorforRadiationMonitorSystem‐Units2&3
12/31/2009 No No 12/17/2009
47ReactorVesselInternals‐FabricatorStartFitand
WeldingofCoreShroudAssembly‐Unit26/30/2011 No No 7/29/2011
48TurbineGeneratorFabricatorIssueP.O.for
MoistureSeparatorReheater/FeedwaterHeaterMaterial‐Unit2
4/30/2010 No No 4/30/2010
49ReactorCoolantLoopPipeFabricatorAcceptance
ofRawMaterial‐Unit24/30/2010 No No 2/18/2010 2MonthsEarly
50ReactorVesselInternals‐FabricatorStartWeldNeutronShieldSpacerPadstoAssembly‐Unit2
7/31/2012 No No 8/28/2012
51ControlRodDriveMechanisms‐FabricatortoStartProcurementofLongLeadMaterial‐Unit2
6/30/2009 No No 6/30/2009
52ContractorNotifiedthatPressurizerFabricatorPerformedCladdingonBottomHead‐Unit2
11/30/2010 No No 12/23/2010
53StartExcavationandFoundationWorkforthe
StandardPlantforUnit23/15/2010 No No 3/15/2010
Q3‐13Review Page6of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
54SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofReceiptof2ndSteamGeneratorTubesheet
Forging‐Unit22/28/2010 No No 4/30/2010 Delayed2Months
55ReactorVesselFabricatorNoticetoContractorofOutletNozzleWeldingtoFlangeNozzleShell
Completion‐Unit22/28/2010 No No 12/30/2010 Delayed10Months
56TurbineGeneratorFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorCondenserFabricationStarted‐Unit2
5/31/2010 No No 5/17/2010
57CompletePreparationsforReceivingtheFirst
ModuleOnSiteforUnit28/18/2010 No No 1/22/2010 6MonthsEarly
58SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofReceiptof1stSteamGeneratorTransition
ConeForging‐Unit24/30/2010 No No 4/21/2010
59ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorNoticetoContractorofManufacturingofCasing
Completion‐Unit211/30/2010 No No 11/16/2010
60ReactorCoolantLoopPipeFabricatorNoticetoContractorofMachining,HeatTreating&Non‐
DestructiveTestingCompletion‐Unit212/31/2010 No No 3/20/2012 Delayed14Months
61CoreMakeupTankFabricatorNoticetoContractorofSatisfactoryCompletionof
Hydrotest‐Unit29/30/2012 No No 11/26/2012 Delayed1Month
62PolarCraneFabricatorIssueP.O.forMainHoist
DrumandWireRope‐Units2&32/28/2011 No No 2/1/2011
Q3‐13Review Page7of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
63ControlRodDriveMechanisms‐FabricatortoStartProcurementofLongLeadMaterial‐Unit3
6/30/2011 No No 6/14/2011
64TurbineGeneratorFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorCondenserReadytoShip‐Unit210/31/2011 No No 3/26/2012 Delayed4Months
65 StartPlacementofMudMatforUnit2 6/29/2012 No No 7/20/2012
66SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofReceiptof1stSteamGeneratorTubing‐Unit2
1/31/2011 No No 9/28/2010 4MonthsEarly
67PressurizerFabricatorNoticetoContractorofWeldingofUpperandIntermediateShells
Completion‐Unit210/31/2010 No No 10/28/2011 Delayed12Months
68ReactorVesselFabricatorNoticetoContractorof
ClosureHeadCladdingCompletion‐Unit36/30/2012 No No 6/28/2012
69 BeginUnit2FirstNuclearConcretePlacement 8/24/2012 No No 3/9/2013 Delayed6Months
70ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorNoticetoContractorofStatorCoreCompletion‐Unit2
9/30/2011 No No 12/1/2011 Delayed2Months
71FabricatorStartFitandWeldingofCoreShroud
Assembly‐Unit26/30/2011 No No 7/29/2011
Q3‐13Review Page8of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
72SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofCompletionof1stSteamGeneratorTubing
Installation‐Unit25/31/2011 No No 1/27/2012 Delayed8Months
73ReactorCoolantLoopPipe‐Shipmentof
EquipmenttoSite‐Unit212/31/2012 10/21/2013 No No Delayed9Months
74ControlRodDriveMechanism‐ShipRemainderofEquipment(LatchAssembly&RodTravel
Housing)toHeadSupplier‐Unit26/30/2012 No No 7/16/2012
75PressurizerFabricatorNoticetoContractorof
WeldingofLowerShelltoBottomHeadCompletion‐Unit2
10/31/2010 No No 12/22/2011 Delayed13Months
76SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofCompletionof2ndSteamGeneratorTubing
Installation‐Unit25/31/2012 No No 5/4/2012
77 DesignFinalizationPayment14 10/31/2011 No No 10/31/2011
78 SetModuleCA04ForUnit2 11/6/2012 9/10/2013 No NoDelayed10Months
79PassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchangerFabricatorNoticetoContractorofFinalPost
WeldHeatTreatment‐Unit26/30/2010 No No 5/24/2011 Delayed10Months
80PassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchangerFabricatorNoticetoContractorofCompletionof
Tubing‐Unit25/31/2012 No No 5/29/2012
Q3‐13Review Page9of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
81PolarCraneFabricatorNoticetoContractorof
GirderFabricationCompletion‐Unit210/31/2012 No No 10/23/2012
82TurbineGeneratorFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorCondenserReadytoShip‐Unit38/31/2013 No No 8/26/2013
83 SetContainmentVesselRing#1forUnit2 1/7/2013 1/10/2014 No NoDelayed12Months
84ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorDeliveryof
CasingstoPortofExport‐Unit27/31/2012 No No 7/6/2013
Delayed11Months
85ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorNoticetoContractorofStatorCoreCompletion‐Unit3
8/31/2013 No No 7/18/2013 1MonthEarly
86ReactorVesselFabricatorNoticetoContractorof
ReceiptofCoreShellForging‐Unit39/30/2012 No No 3/29/2012 6MonthsEarly
87ContractorNotifiedthatPressurizerFabricatorPerformedCladdingonBottomHead‐Unit3
1/31/2013 No No 11/9/2011 14MonthsEarly
88SetNuclearIslandStructuralModuleCA03for
Unit26/26/2013 10/5/2014 No No
Delayed15Months
89SquibValveFabricatorNoticetoContractorof
CompletionofAssemblyandTestforSquibValveHardware‐Unit2
5/31/2012 No No 5/10/2012
Q3‐13Review Page10of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
90AccumulatorTankFabricatorNoticetoContractorofSatisfactoryCompletionof
Hydrotest‐Unit33/31/2013 No No 9/16/2013 Delayed5Months
91PolarCraneFabricatorNoticetoContractorofElectricPanelAssemblyCompletion‐Unit2
3/31/2013 No No 3/6/2013
92StartContainmentLargeBorePipeSupportsfor
Unit26/28/2013 9/22/2014 No No
Delayed15Months
93IntegratedHeadPackage‐Shipmentof
EquipmenttoSite‐Unit23/31/2013 2/14/2014 No No
Delayed10Months
94ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorofFinalStatorAssemblyCompletion‐Unit2
5/31/2013 1/21/2014 No No Delayed7Months
95SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofCompletionof2ndSteamGeneratorTubing
Installation‐Unit36/30/2013 10/30/2013 No No Delayed4Months
96SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticetoContractorofSatisfactoryCompletionof1stSteamGenerator
Hydrotest‐Unit21/31/2013 No No 1/14/2013
97StartConcreteFillofNuclearIslandStructural
ModulesCA01andCA02forUnit24/3/2014 4/6/2015 No No
Delayed12Months
98PassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchanger‐DeliveryofEquipmenttoPortofEntry‐Unit2
12/31/2012 1/22/2014 No NoDelayed12Months
Q3‐13Review Page11of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
99RefuelingMachineFabricatorNoticetoContractorofSatisfactoryCompletionof
FactoryAcceptanceTest‐Unit211/30/2013 3/20/2014 No No Delayed3Months
100DeliverReactorVesselInternalstoPortof
Export‐Unit21/31/2014 7/28/2014 No No Delayed5Months
101 SetUnit2ContainmentVessel#3 4/24/2014 4/8/2015 No NoDelayed11Months
102SteamGenerator‐ContractorAcceptanceof
EquipmentatPortofEntry‐Unit27/31/2013 5/26/2014 No No
Delayed10Months
103TurbineGeneratorFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorTurbineGeneratorReadytoShip‐Unit2
4/30/2013 No No 5/28/2013
104PressurizerFabricatorNoticetoContractorofSatisfactoryCompletionofHydrotest‐Unit3
3/31/2014 3/28/2014 No No
105PolarCrane‐ShipmentofEquipmenttoSite‐
Unit21/31/2014 2/6/2015 No No
Delayed12Months
106ReceiveUnit2ReactorVesselOnSiteFrom
Fabricator5/13/2014 No No 7/31/2013 9MonthsEarly
107 SetUnit2ReactorVessel 6/23/2014 5/18/2015 No NoDelayed11Months
Q3‐13Review Page12of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
108SteamGeneratorFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorofCompletionof2ndChannelHeadtoTubesheetAssemblyWelding‐Unit3
12/31/2013 4/30/2014 No No Delayed4Months
109ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorofFinalStatorAssemblyCompletion‐Unit3
8/31/2014 12/1/2014 No No Delayed3Months
110ReactorCoolantPump‐Shipmentof
EquipmenttoSite(2ReactorCoolantPumps)‐Unit2
10/31/2013 6/11/2014 No No Delayed7Months
111 PlaceFirstNuclearConcreteforUnit3 10/9/2013 10/25/2013 No No
112 SetUnit2SteamGenerator 10/23/2014 8/18/2015 No NoDelayed10Months
113 MainTransformersReadytoShip‐Unit2 9/30/2013 No No 7/31/2013 2MonthsEarly
114CompleteUnit3SteamGeneratorHydrotestat
Fabricator2/28/2014 10/30/2014 No No Delayed8Months
115SetUnit2ContainmentVesselBottomHeadon
BasematLegs10/11/2012 No No 5/22/2013 Delayed7Months
116 SetUnit2PressurizerVessel 5/16/2014 5/29/2015 No NoDelayed12Months
Q3‐13Review Page13of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
117ReactorCoolantPumpFabricatorNoticeto
ContractorofSatisfactoryCompletionofFactoryAcceptanceTest‐Unit3
2/28/2015 1/16/2015 No No 1MonthEarly
118DeliverReactorVesselInternalstoPortofExport‐
Unit36/30/2015 6/12/2015 No No
119MainTransformersFabricatorIssueP.O.for
Material‐Unit32/28/2015 2/2/2015 No No
120CompleteWeldingofUnit2PassiveResidualHeat
RemovalSystemPiping2/5/2015 10/30/2015 No No Delayed8Months
121SteamGenerator‐ContractorAcceptanceof
EquipmentAtPortofEntry‐Unit34/30/2015 1/2/2015 No No 3MonthsEarly
122RefuelingMachine‐ShipmentofEquipmentto
Site‐Unit32/28/2015 4/3/2015 No No Delayed1Month
123 SetUnit2PolarCrane 1/9/2015 9/28/2015 No No Delayed8Months
124ReactorCoolantPumps‐ShipmentofEquipment
toSite‐Unit36/30/2015 6/8/2015 No No
125 MainTransformersReadytoShip‐Unit3 7/31/2015 4/13/2015 No No 3MonthsEarly
Q3‐13Review Page14of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
126SpentFuelStorageRack‐ShipmentofLastRack
Module‐Unit37/31/2014 7/4/2014 No No
127StartElectricalCablePullinginUnit2
AuxiliaryBuilding8/14/2013 9/24/2014 No No
Delayed13Months
128CompleteUnit2ReactorCoolantSystemCold
Hydro1/22/2016 10/5/2016 No No Delayed8Months
129ActivateClass1EDCPowerinUnit2Auxiliary
Building3/15/2015 1/12/2016 No No
Delayed10Months
130 CompleteUnit2HotFunctionalTest 5/3/2016 2/8/2017 No No Delayed9Months
131 InstallUnit3Ring3forContainmentVessel 8/25/2015 12/9/2015 No No Delayed3Months
132 LoadUnit2NuclearFuel 9/15/2016 7/25/2017 No NoDelayed10Months
133 Unit2SubstantialCompletion 3/15/2017 12/15/2017 No No Delayed9Months
134 SetUnit3ReactorVessel 10/22/2015 2/16/2016 No No Delayed3Months
Q3‐13Review Page15of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
135 SetUnit3SteamGenerator#2 2/25/2016 5/17/2016 No No Delayed2Months
136 SetUnit3PressurizerVessel 7/16/2015 2/2/2016 No No Delayed6Months
137CompleteWeldingofUnit3PassiveResidual
HeatRemovalSystemPiping6/16/2016 7/27/2016 No No Delayed1Month
138 SetUnit3PolarCrane 5/9/2016 7/11/2016 No No Delayed2Months
139StartUnit3ShieldBuildingRoofSlabRebar
Placement5/26/2016 9/22/2016 No No Delayed4Months
140StartUnit3AuxiliaryBuildingElectricalCable
Pulling11/7/2014 6/2/2015 No No Delayed6Months
141ActivateUnit3AuxiliaryBuildingClass1EDC
Power5/15/2016 11/8/2016 No No Delayed5Months
142CompleteUnit3ReactorCoolantSystemCold
Hydro3/22/2017 8/21/2017 No No Delayed5Months
143 CompleteUnit3HotFunctionalTest 7/3/2017 12/26/2017 No No Delayed5Months
Q3‐13Review Page16of17
AppendixA
Key:MilestonesNotCompleted
CompletedPriortoQ3‐13
CurrentQuarter
ScheduledtoBeCompleted
Q4‐13
ORSCautionMilestone
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
Outside18‐24MonthContingency?
ImpacttoSubstantialCompletionDate?1
ActualCompletion
Date
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
144 CompleteUnit3NuclearFuelLoad 11/15/2017 6/22/2018 No No Delayed7Months
145 BeginUnit3FullPowerOperation 4/8/2018 11/28/2018 No No Delayed7Months
146 Unit3SubstantialCompletion 5/15/2018 12/15/2018 No No Delayed7Months
Notes:
Redhighlightingrepresents"CautionMilestones."CautionMilestonesarethosethataredelayedby10monthsorgreater.
YellowhighlightingrepresentsthoseMilestonesthatarescheduledtobeorhavebeencompletedduringthe3rdQuarter2013.ThisisbasedonthescheduleapprovedbytheCommissioninOrderNo.2012‐884.
WhitehighlightingrepresentsFutureorHistoricalMilestonesthathavenotbeencompleted.
GreyhighlightingrepresentsFutureorHistoricalMilestonesthatwerecompletedpriortothe3rdQuarter2013.
GreenhighlightingrepresentsFutureMilestonesthatarescheduledtobecompletedinthe4thQuarterof2013.ThisisbasedonthescheduleapprovedbytheCommissioninOrderNo.2012‐884.
Q3‐13Review Page17of17
AppendixBCautionMilestones
AppendixB
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
ReasonGivenforDelay
78 SetModuleCA04ForUnit2 11/6/2012 9/10/2013Delayed10Months
Thedelaysareassociatedwiththedelivery,receiptandfabricationoftheCA04module.
83SetContainmentVesselRing#1for
Unit21/7/2013 1/10/2014
Delayed12Months
TheContainmentVesselRing1sitsatoptheContainmentVesselBottomHead,whichsitsatoptheCR10module.Thedelayshereareduetoengineeringanddesignapprovals,notablydesignapprovalsrelatedtothebasemat
concrete.ThesettingoftheContainmentVesselRing#1previouslyalsodependedonthesettingoftheCA20module,butaworkaroundforthishasbeenestablished.Abulkheadisbeing
installedtoallowconcretetobepouredaroundtheCVBHpriortothesettingoftheCA20
module.
88SetNuclearIslandStructuralModule
CA03forUnit26/26/2013 10/5/2014
Delayed15Months
DelaysareduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module,aswellasscheduleresequencing.Manufacturingofthesub‐modulesfortheCA03modulewasmovedfromCB&I‐LCtoPegasusSteel,LLC
earlierintheyeartoallowCB&I‐LCtofocusontheCA01module.WECalsodiscovereda
probleminthelogicofthepreviousschedule,asthepropersupportfortheCA03modulewillnotbeavailableuntilboththeplacementoftheCA01moduleandtheconcretepourassociated
withthatactivityhavebeencompleted.
Q3‐13Review Page1of3
AppendixB
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
ReasonGivenforDelay
92StartContainmentLargeBorePipe
SupportsforUnit26/28/2013 9/22/2014
Delayed15Months
DelaysareduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module,aswellasscheduleresequencing.WECdiscoveredaprobleminthelogicofthepreviousschedule,astheContainmentVesselLargeBorePipeSupportscannotbeinstalleduntilactivitiesassociatedwiththeplacmentoftheCA01
modulehavebeencompleted.ThereviseddateforthesettingoftheCA03modulestillsupports
atargetsubstantialcompletiondateofDecember14,2017forUnit2.
93IntegratedHeadPackage‐Shipmentof
EquipmenttoSite‐Unit23/31/2013 2/14/2014
Delayed10Months
Thedelayisduetodesignchangestotheradialarmhoisttoresolveissueswithsystem
integration.
97StartConcreteFillofNuclearIsland
StructuralModulesCA01andCA02forUnit2
4/3/2014 4/6/2015Delayed12Months
ThedelayisduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module.
Thismilestoneisalsoimpactedbyaconstructionactivityresequencingthatcallsfor
theweldingofthePressurizerandSteamGeneratorSupportstobeweldedtotheCA01wallpriortotheplacementofconcreteafterthe
settingofCA01.
98PassiveResidualHeatRemovalHeatExchanger‐DeliveryofEquipmentto
PortofEntry‐Unit212/31/2012 1/22/2014
Delayed12Months
Thedelayisduetoschedulerefinementandtheneedforengineeringdesignapprovalpriorto
shipment.
101 SetUnit2ContainmentVessel#3 4/24/2014 4/8/2015Delayed11Months
ThedelayisduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module.
Q3‐13Review Page2of3
AppendixB
ActivityNo.
MilestoneCompletionDateApprovedinOrderNo.2012‐884
ScheduledCompletionDateasofQ3‐13
DeviationfromOrderNo.2012‐884
ReasonGivenforDelay
102SteamGenerator‐Contractor
AcceptanceofEquipmentatPortofEntry‐Unit2
7/31/2013 5/26/2014Delayed10Months
Thedelayisduetooverallscheduleresequencing.
105PolarCrane‐ShipmentofEquipmentto
Site‐Unit21/31/2014 2/6/2015
Delayed12Months
Thedelayisduetooverallscheduleresequencing.
107 SetUnit2ReactorVessel 6/23/2014 5/18/2015Delayed11Months
ThedelayisprimarilyduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module.Aportionofthedelayisalsoduetoaschedulechangerelatedtotheinstallmentofoverlayplatesforthesupportsformajor
components.
112 SetUnit2SteamGenerator 10/23/2014 8/18/2015Delayed10Months
ThedelayisduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module.
116 SetUnit2PressurizerVessel 5/16/2014 5/29/2015Delayed12Months
ThedelayisduetodelaysassociatedwiththefabricationandsettingoftheCA01module.
127StartElectricalCablePullinginUnit2
AuxiliaryBuilding8/14/2013 9/24/2014
Delayed13Months
Thedelayisduetooverallscheduleresequencing.
129ActivateClass1EDCPowerinUnit2
AuxiliaryBuilding3/15/2015 1/12/2016
Delayed10Months
Thedelayisduetooverallscheduleresequencing.
132 LoadUnit2NuclearFuel 9/15/2016 7/25/2017Delayed10Months
Thedelayisduetooverallscheduleresequencing.
Q3‐13Review Page3of3
AppendixCConstructionSitePhotographs
V.C.SummerUnits2&3August,2013
Unit2CH80 andCondenserB
Unit2CA04 Placement
Unit2CVRing1
Unit2CA20
TransmissionLineConstruction
Unit3NuclearIsland
AppendixDLicenseAmendmentRequests
AppendixD
NRCLARNo.
SummaryLAR
SubmittalDate
LARStatus
LARApprovalDate
PARStatus
PARNoObjectionLetterDate
12‐01 StudSpacingaroundElectricalPenetrations 8/29/2012 Approved 7/1/2013
12‐02 DefinitionofWallThicknessinTable3.3.1 9/26/2012 Approved 5/30/2013 Approved 1/16/2013
13‐01 BasematShearReinforcementDesignSpacing 1/15/2013 Approved 2/26/2013 Approved 1/29/2013
13‐02 BasematShearReinforcementDesignDetails 1/18/2013 Approved 3/1/2013 Approved 1/29/2013
13‐03 TurbineBuildingEccentricandConcentricBracing 2/7/2013 Approved 7/1/2013
13‐04 ReconciliationofTier1ValueDifferences 2/7/2013 Pending
13‐05 StructuralModuleShearStudSizeandSpacing 2/14/2013 Approved 5/23/2013
13‐06 PrimarySamplingSystemChanges 2/7/2013 Approved 8/22/2013
13‐07 ChangestoChemicalandVolumeControlSystem 3/13/2013 Pending
13‐08 ModuleObstructionsandDetails 2/28/2013 Withdrawn
13‐10 HumanFactorsEngineeringIntegratedPlan 3/13/2013 Pending
13‐11 NuclearIslandWallsReinforcementCriteria 3/26/2013 Approved 6/6/2013 Approved 4/10/2013
13‐12 FireAreaBoundaryChanges 7/17/2013 Pending
13‐13 TurbineBuildingLayoutChanges 7/30/2013 Pending
Q3‐13Review 1of2
AppendixD
NRCLARNo.
SummaryLAR
SubmittalDate
LARStatus
LARApprovalDate
PARStatus
PARNoObjectionLetterDate
13‐16 HumanFactorsEngineeringVerificationPlan 9/25/2013 Pending
13‐17 HumanFactorsEngineeringVerificationPlan 9/25/2013 Pending
13‐20 Module/StudChannelObstructionsRevisions 7/17/2013 Pending
13‐25 Tier1EditorialandConsistencyChanges 7/2/2013 Pending
13‐32 LiquidWasteSystemChanges 8/30/2013 Pending
Q3‐13Review 2of2
AppendixESCE&GBasematConcretePressRelease
For Immediate Release SCANA Media Contact: SCANA Investor Contact: Rhonda O’Banion Christina Putnam 800-562-9308 803-217-7512 [email protected] [email protected]
SCE&G Completes Nuclear Island Basemat Placement for V.C. Summer Unit 3 CAYCE, S.C., Nov. 4, 2013—South Carolina Electric & Gas Company (SCE&G), principal subsidiary of SCANA Corporation (NYSE:SCG), completed on Nov. 4, 2013 placement of the nuclear island basemat for V.C. Summer Unit 3 in Fairfield County, S.C. This major milestone comes just seven months after SCE&G poured the first new construction nuclear concrete in the U.S. in three decades for its Unit 2 nuclear island. “We are again proud to have accomplished such a significant milestone as our new nuclear construction project progresses,” said Kevin Marsh, chairman and CEO of SCANA. “This is another example of our outstanding collaboration with Santee Cooper, CB&I, Westinghouse Electric Company and the many other stakeholders who play a role in providing South Carolina with the best solution for meeting the long-term need for clean, safe, and reliable power.” “This successful basemat placement is a testament to the hard work by all involved,” said Lonnie Carter, president and CEO of Santee Cooper. “We have come a long way since getting our combined construction and operating licenses in March 2012, and this milestone gets us one step closer to the finish line and the many benefits these units will provide for our state.”
The basemat provides a foundation for the containment and auxiliary buildings that are within the nuclear island. Measuring 6 feet in thickness, the basemat required approximately 7,000 cubic yards of concrete to cover an area about 250 feet long and 160 feet at its widest section. This approximately 43-hour continuous pour of concrete covered a surface totaling 32,000 square feet.
About 2,000 workers are currently involved in constructing two new reactors at V.C. Summer, where Unit 1 has operated safely and reliably for 30 years. The new nuclear project will peak at about 3,000 workers over the course of three to four years. The two 1,117-megawatt units will add 600 to 800 permanent jobs. Once the two units are complete—Unit 2 currently scheduled to be in late 2017 or early 2018, followed by Unit 3—SCE&G anticipates its generation mix will be about 30 percent nuclear, 30 percent natural gas, and 30 percent scrubbed coal, with the balance in hydro, solar and biomass. SCANA and SCE&G post information from time to time regarding developments relating to SCE&G’s new nuclear project on SCANA’s website at www.scana.com. On SCANA’s homepage, there is a yellow box containing a link to the New Nuclear Development section of the website. That section in turn contains a yellow box with a link to project news and updates. Some of the information that is posted from time to time may be deemed to be material information that has not otherwise become public, and investors, media and others interested in SCE&G’s new nuclear project are encouraged to review this information. PROFILE South Carolina Electric & Gas Company is a regulated public utility engaged in the generation, transmission, distribution and sale of electricity to approximately 675,000 customers in 24 counties in the central, southern
and southwestern portions of South Carolina. The company also provides natural gas service to approximately 325,000 customers in 38 counties in the state. More information about SCE&G is available at www.sceg.com. SCANA Corporation, headquartered in Cayce, SC, is an energy-based holding company principally engaged, through subsidiaries, in electric and natural gas utility operations and other energy-related businesses. Information about SCANA is available on the Company’s website at www.scana.com.