sophocles’ antigone 1 “i am no man”. agenda problems (cont’d) … gender, sexuality, values,...

16
Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”

Upload: berenice-richardson

Post on 02-Jan-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

Sophocles’ Antigone 1

“I am no man”

Page 2: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

2

Agenda

Problems (cont’d) …Gender, Sexuality, Values, IdeologyShape of Course

Where, When, What, HowSophocles’ Antigone

Background, Approaches, IssuesDiscussion

Gender, Values, Power

29-Aug

Page 3: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

3

Problems (cont’d) …

Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology

29-Aug

Page 4: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

429-Aug

Issues / Thinkers

Essentialism ConstructionismFoucaultButler

Finnis Nussbaum

Page 5: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

5

Shape of Course

Where, When, What, How

29-Aug

Page 6: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

Mediterranean Sea

Rome

Greek WorldItaly

Athens

Roman Empire ca. 116 CE

29-Aug

Page 7: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

1,000 BCE 1,000 CE

Greece, 550: BCE–CE 200

Rome, 200 BCE–125 CE

Trojan War ca. 1,200 BCE

Rome founded 753 BCE

Athenian democracy 400s–300s B.C.

Roman Republic, Empire510 BCE–CE 476

Periods covered in course

When…

29-Aug

Page 8: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

829-Aug

What (cont.)

Greece v. RomeModernity v. antiquityCONTINUITY V. SINGULARITY

Page 9: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

929-Aug

How? Through Critical…

ReadingThinkingWriting

Papers Journals

Page 10: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

Sophocles’ Antigone

Background, Approaches, Issues

Page 11: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

1129-Aug

Background

Playwright and playHouse of Labdacus

genealogy…Oedipus and aftermath…

Oedipus the King (after 429)Oedipus at Colonus (ca. 406)Antigone (442/1)

Oedipus and Antigone

Page 12: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

13

Ideological Oppositions

29-Aug

ANTIGONEthesis

femaleprivate

insideoikos (family, household, kinship)

lamentationdivine law

CREONantithesismalepublicoutsidepolis (politics, city)

retributionhuman law

Page 13: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

14

Issues

Play as evidence (historically situated?) (ahistorical-universal?)

For …sexualitygender

29-Aug

Page 14: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

1529-Aug

Approaches

Hegelian dialectic thesis, antithesis → synthesis

Lacanian psychoanalysispure desireheroic transgression

Judith Butlernext week…

Page 15: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

16

Discussion

Gender, Values, Power

29-Aug

Page 16: Sophocles’ Antigone 1 “I am no man”. Agenda Problems (cont’d) … Gender, Sexuality, Values, Ideology Shape of Course Where, When, What, How Sophocles’

17

Discussion Focus

29-Aug

Clashing moral imperatives?

Power struggle?

Castration anxiety?

Other?

“I am no man and she the man insteadif she can have this conquest without

pain” (Creon, p. 175).